Professional Documents
Culture Documents
OF BIRMINGHAM
Department of English
Centre for English Language Studies
DECLARATION
I declare:
a) that this submission is my own work;
b) that this is written in my own words; and
c) that all quotations from published or unpublished work are acknowledged with
quotation marks and references to the work in question.
d) that this dissertation consists of approximately 13,000 words, excluding footnotes,
references, figures, tables appendices & long quotations.
by
NOOR BALFAQEEH
Master of Arts
in
Translation Studies
September 2009
ABSTRACT
As a result of their openness to other cultures, Arab readers have become more interested
in reading translated books within the sub-genre of personal and professional
development. This type of genre is full of idioms and culturally-bound expressions that
need to be carefully translated into Arabic. This research aims to investigate which
translation strategies are more acceptable to the readers: domesticated or foreignized
strategies.
Following the holy command of Allah in the verse, ―And remember, when your Lord
proclaimed, ‗If you will be grateful, then I shall give you more, and if you are thankless,
then My torment is severe.‘‖ (Ibrahim Chapter: verse 7) and the sacred guidance of
Prophet Mohammed (peace be upon him) represented in his saying, ―Whoever does not
thank people (for their favours) has not thanked Allah (properly), Mighty and Glorious is
He!‖ (Musnad Ahmad, Sunan At-Tirmidhî), I would like to express my sincere gratitude
to a group of people who contributed to the accomplishment of this dissertation.
My sincere thanks go to my supervisor Theron Muller, whose guidance and advice were
the assets upon which the dissertation was developed to reach its current status. I also
would like to thank my friend, Dr Jannat Al-Abbasi, who has been a great contributor to
my development, both academically and intellectually. Her keen advice and close
supervision yielded a firm determination on my side to do my best.
On this occasion, I would never forget to thank my friend, Dr Siddiga Al-Ghalib, the
research methods specialist who was my reliable reference when facing problems with
research reliability. She was a generous advisor who spent long hours teaching me how to
implement several quantitative techniques to achieve the objectives of my research.
Above all, my soul mate, my husband Abdullah Al-Bar, is the one who deserves the most
gratitude and appreciation for his support and encouragement along with my parents, who
never stop praying for my best.
CONTENTS
ABSTRACT ..........................................................................................................................
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ....................................................................................................
CONTENTS ..........................................................................................................................
APPENDICES .................................................................................................................. 47
BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................................. 71
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: Dissertation Outline .........................................................................................................................15
Table 2: Subject Classification and Distribution ..........................................................................................22
Table 3: Sample of the First Questionnaire's Questions on Idioms ...............................................................23
Table 4: Sample of the First Questionnaire‘s Questions on Culturally-bound Expressions ..........................24
Table 5: Sample of Second Questionnaire's Questions on Idioms ................................................................24
Table 6: Sample of the Second Questionnaire's Questions on Culturally-bound Expressions ......................25
Table 7: Sample of the Final Questionnaire's Questions on Idioms ..............................................................25
Table 8: Sample of the Final Questionnaire‘s Questions on Culturally-bound Expressions .........................25
Table 9: Question 2 .......................................................................................................................................33
Table 10: Question 9 .....................................................................................................................................33
Table 11: Question 7 .....................................................................................................................................33
Table 12: Question 8 .....................................................................................................................................34
Table 13: A Breakdown of the Questions‘ Results According to Idiom Type ..............................................36
Table 14: Question 19 ...................................................................................................................................38
Table 15: Question 21 ...................................................................................................................................38
Table 16: the Breakdown of the questions‘ results according to Culturally-bound Expressions ...................39
Table 17: A Sample of Deletion Questions ...................................................................................................40
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1: Total Score for Idioms ...................................................................................................................42
Figure 2: Total Score for Culturally-Bound Expressions ..............................................................................43
Figure 3: Total Score for Deletion .................................................................................................................44
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
Applying different translation strategies is one of the tools translators use to overcome
translation problems. Idioms and culturally-bound expressions are among prominent
translation problems, especially when translation occurs between two distinct languages like
English and Arabic which diverge both linguistically and culturally. This research aims to
investigate which translation strategies are most acceptable from the point of view of Arab
readers, when translating idioms and culturally-bound expressions within the sub-genre of
professional and personal development literature. The paper starts with a brief examination
of the linguistic and cultural features of English and Arabic, in addition to a concise
background of the status of translation in Saudi Arabia, the target culture. The literature
review explores what makes idioms and cultural expressions problems in translation and
what kinds of strategies are used to conquer these problems. It also presents different
classifications of translation strategies that will be used in the discussion, along with a
succinct summary of the research genre. Before commencing the methodology of the
research, a short presentation about methodologies that are commonly used to investigate
translation problems is provided, followed by a chapter introducing the hypotheses and an
outline of the research.
For the methodology, Basil Hatim‘s (2001) schematic representation for action research is
followed to include several steps starting with the problem definition and data collection
from two books within the research genre. Then the subjects of the research are
characterized to preface the practical method that is followed. Qualitative and quantitative
methods are designated so that the research can accomplish its objectives, among which is to
develop the measuring tool of the research, the questionnaire. The outcomes of both stages
are discussed intensively in Chapter 5, covering all translation strategies that were tested.
Finally, the results are presented in Chapter 6 along with the research restrictions and
recommendations. Throughout the paper, there are some abbreviations used. These
1
abbreviations are ST, TT, SL and TL which stand for source text, target text, source
language and target language respectively.
2
speakers view the world determines language use; and 3) when the relationship between
language and culture is neutral.
In addition, the geographical nature of Middle East countries is very much reflected in
Arabic vocabulary because ―the physical and cultural environment in which it develops
influences the vocabulary and the grammar of a language‖ (Holmes 2001:337). To describe
hot weather, for example, there are tens of adjectives that do not have direct English
equivalents. Conversely, English vocabulary describing wet and rainy weather is rich and
hard to be fully translated into Arabic.
English, meanwhile, is the lingua franca of international academic, political and economic
summits and conferences. It is the official language of many countries around the world and
it is spoken as the second/foreign language in many countries, including Saudi Arabia. In
Saudi Arabia, English is obligatory throughout the education system – elementary,
intermediate, and secondary and university – yet it is taught with varying intensities (Al-
Khatib in Harbi 2007:108).
3
access that knowledge. However most of these texts are written in languages other than
Arabic, so translation into Arabic has flourished, particularly from English. English to
Arabic translation is popular for two reasons. First, as mentioned earlier, as the second
language in Saudi Arabia, English is more accessible to many professionals, such as
bankers, airline employees, and medical professionals (Al-Khatib cited in Harbi 2007:103).
Second, knowledgeable leaders within emergent fields are writing in English, raising interest
in reading translations of those texts.
Nevertheless, the performance of the translation industry in Saudi Arabia can be evaluated
as modest for several reasons. Economic factors play a major role in reducing the quality of
translation. Al-Khatib (in Harbi 2007:108) notes that ―the high costs of printing and
publishing in Saudi Arabia compared to the competitive costs in the other Arab countries
accentuates also the inflow of the imported Arabic translated books.‖ The cost of translation
has led the Saudi private sector to turn to other Arab countries, such as Egypt and Syria, for
their translation needs. Nonetheless, the number of books translated into Arabic and
introduced into the local market has increased between 1994 and 2004; the social sciences
and humanities have had the highest share of the translations in response to the demands of
the market (ibid). Private publishers like Jarir and Obaikan are among the top private
translation centres in Saudi Arabia in terms of cultural, political and literature translations
that target non-specialized readers. All the above factors, along with the translation
industry‘s negligible contribution to the Saudi economy, somehow results in modest national
interest to regulate translations for their quality (ibid).
4
CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW
Baker (1992:63), on the other hand, considers idioms and fixed expression as two different
categories under the multi-word units; she refers to them as ―frozen patterns of language
which allow little or no variation in form, and in the case of idioms, often carry meanings
which cannot be deduced from their individual components.‖ Also she adds some
constraints on idiom usage, which include the inability to change word order or structure and
the inability to delete, substitute or add words. On the other hand, Carter (1998:66) classifies
idioms as a type of fixed expression that include proverbs, stock phrases, catchphrases,
allusions, idiomatic similes and discoursal expressions. However, this classification does not
have defined boundaries and a structural overlap is very much expected (ibid). He also
identifies different sets of fixed expression characteristics: 1) non-substitutable, 2) more than
a single word and 3) semantically frozen.
5
The semantic and syntactic variation in frozenness results in different types of fixed
expressions. In this research, some of the fixed expressions other than idioms are included
for their idiomatic function because ‗idiomacity‘ (Cowie and Mackin (1975) and Cowie
(1983) cited in Abu-Ssaydeh 2004) is the common feature shared by all types of fixed
expressions.
Idioms are difficult to translate. It is sometimes hard to find the right equivalent for a single
word without finding equivalence for a sequence of words that convey one specific meaning.
Idiom translation difficulties fall into different types. First, there is a lack of sense
equivalence in the TL; idioms are culturally specific, which means that they may express a
sense that doesn‘t occur in the TL. Baker stresses this point when she says:
Idioms and fixed expressions which contain culture-specific items are not necessarily untranslatable.
It is not the specific items an expression contains but rather the meaning it conveys and its
association with culture-specific context which can make it untranslatable or difficult to translate.
(1992:68).
Thus translating the idiom mostly depends on the context in which it has occurred. Second,
there may be equivalence for the idiom in the TL, but the situation in which it has been used
differs from the SL to the TL. In other words, an idiom may have the same sense in the TL
but a different connotation. For example, ‗to sing a different tune‘ means in English to say or
do something that contradicts what has been said or done before. The Arabic equivalence for
that idiom is ‗yuGanni 'la laylah‘ (literal: ‗sing to his own Layla‘) and is used to refer to
situations in which a person only cares about his/her own benefit. Both idioms share the
surface meaning but are used differently. Third, the frequency and the formality of idioms
differ from one language to another. Baker (1992) demonstrates this point by giving Arabic
and Chinese as examples of languages that allow limited use of idioms in formal written
texts.
6
because ―multiculturalism, which is a present-day phenomenon, plays a role here, because it
has had an impact on almost all peoples worldwide, as well as on the international relations
emerging from the current new world order‖ (Karamanian, 2002). Therefore, due to
globalization, some cultural aspects and notions are widespread across cultures, regardless
of linguistic, ethnic, and religious background. In this paper, culturally-bound expressions
may relate to some of these universal cultural phenomena, but the focus is on cultural-
specific notions.
Carter (1998:34) differentiates between core vocabulary – which is the basic domain of lexis
that a language user needs to communicate in a simple context with foreigners or children –
and non-core vocabulary by several criteria, including being culture-free. He pointed out that
―the more core the word is, the less likely it is to be restricted to culture-specific uses‖
(1998:41). Based on that theory, there is core vocabulary that is independent from culture
and can be interpreted similarly in all contexts and cultures, and non-core, or culturally-
bound, vocabulary that must be interpreted differently from one culture to another. On the
other hand, within Sapir-Whorf‘s linguistic relativity, which is that ―language influences
perceptions, thought, and, at least potentially, behaviour‖ (Holmes 2001:324), Homeidi
points out that culture determines language: ―Words only have meaning in terms of the
culture in which they are used‖ (2004:14). Therefore, there are two schools of thought
regarding the level of culture involvement in vocabulary interpretation.
Based on the first school, words or expressions can be classified into two categories:
cultural-free, like eat, walk, chair, etc., and cultural-bound, like Independence Day,
godfather, Christmas, family reunion, etc. Although the second school states that no word
can be understood without its cultural context, there are some words that have universal
semantic elements that can be found in all languages. In this paper, culturally-bound
expressions are the ones that are specific to a given culture and do not necessarily have
equivalents in other cultures.
7
language equivalents for terms conveying culture-sensitive notions in the source language as
a result of the fact that the two languages have different meaning subsystems and cultures‖
(2007:16). Some core vocabulary is not perceived as core by all language users (Carter
1998:46), so finding equivalents for these words would be problematic. If this is true for
core vocabulary, which are basic and simple words, finding equivalents for non-core
vocabulary would be even more challenging. It is harder because every language has
different semantic features, classifications, and prototypes. Furthermore, the level of
translatability of culturally-bound expressions depends on the feasibility of the TL
equivalents at both the denotative and connotative meaning levels (Teilanyo 2007:16). For
example, the denotative meaning of ‗hand‘ is the physiological part of the human, but at the
connotative level, there are many meanings of the word that may either relate to the
denotative meaning, like the metaphorical use of ‗give a hand,‘ or may not relate to it, like
the collocation of ‗second-hand.‘ It is also important to consider that ―[t]he process of
transfer, i.e., re-coding across cultures, should consequently allocate corresponding
attributes vis-a-vis the target culture to ensure credibility in the eyes of the target reader‖
(Karamanian 2002).
1 All examples mentioned are taken from the data collected for this research.
2
It is important to mention that 70% of the C2 class were located in Jeddah, which justifies the similar
8
impact (Abu-Ssaydeh, 2006:117-120). Abu-Ssaydeh takes the view that the choice of a
particular strategy will depend on the ―closeness between the two languages, the translator‘s
experience, the adequacy of dictionaries, and the nature of the idiom in question‖ (2006:
117).
Culturally-Bound Expressions
Cultural expressions, on the other hand, are a salient translation problem, especially when
translating between two distinct languages that are spoken by two distant nations. To
translate the culturally-bound expressions, translators may use six different strategies
depending on the type of the culturally-bound expression itself. When translating culturally-
bound expressions, the translator may first provide the literal equivalents only without
adding any more information, as with ‗ إرا-ٙ اىَْضه ٍش ة أخشَٚنْل اىشج٘ع إىٞ ف. فقذ حٍ٘بط ٗىف ٍخطئ
ْت ٗ صحبت غبىبتَٞ‘ مبُ ٍْضىل ػببسة ػِ ػالقت رas a TT for ‗Thomas Wolf was wrong. You can go
home again – if your home is a treasured relationship, a precious companionship.‘ This
strategy can be used when the ―translator knows that the TT reader will be familiar with the
cultural background reflected in the ST‖ (Sanchez 2007:129). Secondly, the translator may
literally translate and provide some addition information like ‗ دػبءAlcoholics Anonymous
ُغؼُ٘ ىيخخيص ٍِ ٕزا اإلدٍبٝ ِٝ اىنح٘ه اىزٍْٜت ٍذٞ ‘ٕ٘ دػبء اشخٖش ػِ جَؼas a TT for ‗Alcoholics
Anonymous prayer.‘ In this strategy, the translator intervenes depending on his/her
knowledge, and ―if he does not intervene, the purpose of translation as an act of cross-
cultural communication is not respected, and we can be sure that the reader in the target
language will not get the message expressed in the source text‖ (Homeidi 2004:24).
Thirdly, paraphrasing the expression is another strategy, with ‗ ٗ اىَقبػذٌٜ اىنشاعٞاالٓ حَبً بخْظ
اىغشقْٚت أٗشنج ػيٞ ظٖش عفٚ ‘ػيas a TT for ‗like straightening deck chairs on the Titanic.‘
Fourthly, translating using the TL equivalent if available is another strategy, like ‗ فتٞٗص
‘اىؼشٗطfor ‗bridesmaid.‘ Fifth, the translator may borrow the expression from the TL
culture, like ' دػبءAlcoholics Anonymous.‘ To support this strategy, Teilanyo says:
While philosophical concepts may not be translatable using the basic code of the TL, and some
lexical items may have to be translocated to the TT as loans or borrowings, others may be subjected
to some form of translation by resorting to ―loan translations,‖ ―calques,‖ ―neologisms,‖
9
―circumlocutions,‖ and some other forms of literalism (Jakobson 1992: 147; Mokwenye 1997: 11;
Okeogu 1997: 4). (2007:6)
Finally, the translator may delete the expression; which is what most translators choose
when faced with concepts that are considered taboo for the target culture. Sexual concepts
and purely Christian notions, for example, are among those concepts for Saudi culture.
In some cases a combination of more than one strategy is needed to convey the meaning
because, ―in many cases the social environment which underlies the SL will require an
adaptation, an explanation or a paraphrasing rather than, strictly speaking, a translation‖
(Sanchez 2007:129).
The dilemma between producing foreignized texts and completely avoiding any foreign
features in the TT can be resolved by looking at Toury‘s notion of acceptability vs. adequacy
(1995:56-7). For Toury, on the one hand, producing adequate translation implicates some
departure from the target norms and abiding by the target norms to reach acceptability which
undertakes ―shifts from the source text‖ (1995:56). On the other hand, obligatory shifts in
the translation field universally occur, as the process of translation involves two languages
and two cultures (ibid). Manipulating non-obligatory shifts can help the translator produce
an acceptable TT that mainly communicates the intended message of the ST while
respecting the TL norms.
However, the pro TL translation is the free translation of Hasan Ghazala, who considers it
appropriate for specific genres like literary, political, journalistic, and cultural texts; these do
not require translation of details, but rather are concerned with conveying the general
10
message (2008:16). This leads to the notion of domesticating translation, which aims to
―allow the translation to work as a literary text in its own right, excreting its force within
native traditions‖ (Venuti 2000:16). For Ghazala, the translator of this kind of translation is
not committed to translate every single word of the ST, nor does he/she feel tied to the
constraints of individual words and phrases (2008:12). Using translation strategies that are
pro-TL, such as paraphrasing, deletion and translation using TL equivalents, can result in
domesticated TT. Domesticated texts match the TL norms linguistically and functionally,
whereas the translator manipulates the non-obligatory shifts abiding by the TL norms to
produce an acceptable TT.
Therefore, the translator is the centre around whom the whole process of translation
revolves. His/her knowledge, experience and ideology play a major role in selecting the kind
of strategy that will be used. Sanchez stressed this point when he stated,
It is not unusual, unfortunately, to come across lack of sufficient knowledge on the part of the
translator, and not just in relation to the SL, but also in relation to his or her own language. This has
a negative effect on the translation, sometimes to an extent that can be defined as foreignization
(2007:125).
However the visibility of translators‘ knowledge and ideology varies according to the level
of translator mediation, which is ―the extents to which translators intervene in the transfer
process, feeding their own knowledge and beliefs into their processing of a text‖ (Hatim and
Mayson 1997:147). Accordingly his/her choice of translation strategies will vary.
11
this field this equals to 491 books.‖ (Al-Khatib in Harbi 2007:113). It has also been noticed
that the target audience tends to believe that what is written originally in the target language
within this genre is built on Western literature and knowledge. As a result, the translation
industry has flourished; this has caused the domination of commercial translation by the
private sector.
To wrap up, translation strategies can be pro-SL or TL depending on many factors, among
which are the genre of the text, the translator‘s ideology, the communicative purpose of the
translation itself and the distance between the two cultures involved.
Therefore, this research matches the first way of Toury‘s phase 1 because it studies the ST
and its synchronic TT. It also works within the second phase, since it compares the idioms
and culturally-bound expressions of the ST and the TT in parallel. In addition, phase 4 is
reflected in this research because socio-cultural dimensions are extensively elaborated to
analyze the implication behind the translation strategies used.
12
2.5.2. Experimental vs. Action
In terms of descriptive research framework, this research can be categorized as action
research, since it mainly focuses on proposing the best translation strategies by examining
the translation process and observing the translator‘s tendencies when translating idioms and
culturally-bound expressions. However, proposing the most effective strategies to translate
idioms and culturally-bound expressions is measured through investigating the feedback of
Arabic readers, which is where the quantitative components of the research emerge. In
addition, since it is quite difficult to have access to the translators themselves (since the
translation is anonymous in both books of the study), an analysis of the process of
translation is achieved through comparing the ST and the TT in parallel. In other words, the
results are achieved through analyzing the translation product, which can be seen as an
experimental model. On the other hand, looking at the linguistic items that are culturally
bound and investigating them within the sub-genre of self- and professional development,
which is highly loaded with socio-cultural features, there is a need to adopt some techniques
of the ethnographic model of research. Ethnographic parts of this research include the field
study via the observation of the readers‘ feedback and the qualitative interpretative analysis
of the interviews.
To summarise, in order to explore the most effective strategies in translating idioms and
culturally-bound expressions, several steps were followed that functioned within the
schematic representation of action research proposed by Basil Hatim (2001), which is laid
out in Chapter 4.
13
CHAPTER 3 HYPOTHESES AND OUTLINE
To collect the data for this research two books were scanned for idioms and culturally-bound
expressions: The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People by Steven Covey and Love Smart
by Phil McGraw. Both books were translated by Jarir Bookstore, one of the leading
translation centres in the target country, as mentioned above.
14
3.2. Dissertation Outline
This research will consider the issues discussed so far by analyzing translation strategies
employed by English to Arabic translators of popular mass-market self- and professional
development books. Table 1 demonstrates how the translation strategies of idiomatic and
cultural expressions are classified, tested and analyzed. More information about the
methodology of this research is included in Chapter 4.
Stage Function
Data Collection Scanning the two books for idioms and culturally-bound expressions
Prior to Implementation
Analysis & Discussion The outcome of the previous stages will be interpreted within the cultural
Implementation
For easy reference to the translation strategies that are the focus of this study, some
abbreviations are used. PM, AE and LT stand for paraphrased meaning, Arabic equivalent
and literal translation, respectively. SC and TC are abbreviations for source culture and
target culture.
15
CHAPTER 4 METHODOLOGY
For Hatim, action and practitioner research within translation studies are implemented to
achieve different purposes, one of which is the aim to ―upgrade the general quality of
performance among teachers and learners, novices and professionals‖ (2001:189). From
identifying and investigating the problem, through evaluating and consolidating the data and
listing the possible course of actions, to predicting the outcomes, and finally, to
implementing and evaluating the action, Hatim suggested a schematic representation of
action and practitioner research. The steps of Hatim‘s schematic representation are
implemented in this research as follows.
16
In addition, there is another issue that needs to be tackled. When translating this sub-genre
of self- and professional development literature, would it be more effective to foreignize or
domesticate the TT? In other words, the choice of translation strategy depends on the type
of translation that is implemented, either domesticated or foreignized. Knowing what Arab
readers prefer when reading this kind of book would help the translator to decide which
translation strategy to use.
Phase I
The first book, The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People, was chosen for several reasons.
This book represents both sub-genres, personal development and professional development,
because it presents a range of communication skills that can be applicable and effective in
the context of one‘s personal, social, and professional life. It is also considered to be one of
the leading books in the Saudi market within the field of human development. In addition,
this book is rich in terms of idioms and culturally-bound expressions. Thus, the book was
scanned to locate the idioms and culturally-bound expressions, and then the Arabic version
was scanned to locate the parallel expressions. All data were organized in a table (refer to
Appendix 7) according to the type of expression found and the translation strategy that was
used. Idioms and culturally-bound expressions are classified as follows:
Idioms
The idiom categorization of Carter (1998), which includes idioms that are originally
metaphors, idioms that are semantically opaque, and idioms whose sense has been lost, is
followed, in addition to proverbs (i.e., ‗a thousand mile journey begins with the first step‘),
discoursal expressions (i.e., ‗sooner or later‘), and allusions and quotations (i.e., ‗do unto
others as you want others to do unto you‘). Fixed collocations (i.e., ‗dead drunk‘), similes
(i.e., ‗as old as the hills‘) and phrasal verbs (i.e., ‗hang out‘) are excluded from the scope of
this paper. However, there is an overlap between the idiom categories, and one idiom can be
17
classified under more than one category. For example, ‗to trample on the sacred ground of
another's heart‘ can be classified as an idiom or as allusion, because it is derived from the
words of Thornton Wilder: ―trampling on the feelings of those about you‖ (The Free
Dictionary). As a result, the idioms were re-categorized based on the translation strategies
used.
Based on the data collected, there are six translation strategies: 1) literal translation of
idioms that have a TL equivalent, 2) literal translation of idioms that have no TL equivalent,
3) literal translation of idioms that have the potential to be TL idioms eventually, 4)
paraphrasing, 5) translation using the TL equivalent, 6) incorrect translation and 7) deletion.
Culturally-Bound Expressions
Following Armellino‘s (2008) classification, culturally-bound expressions are divided into
three categories: 1) historical, 2) social and 3) religious. Historical expressions consist of
several sub-categories including literary expressions like (Aesop‘s fable of the goose and the
golden egg), historical incidents (like straightening deck chairs on the Titanic) and allusions
(e.g. ‗In the words of Abraham Maslow, ―He that is good with a hammer tends to think
everything is a nail‖‘). It is true that allusions are included in the idioms above, but allusion
exists in the grey area between idioms and culturally-bound expressions. In other words,
some allusions, like the Golden Rule‘s ―do unto to others as you want others to do unto
you,‖ are quoted idiomatically; over time, they become part of the language‘s idioms. Social
expressions include environmental expressions like ‗a place that served liquor would violate
his parole‘. Religious expressions include expressions related to any religion other than
Islam like ‗servant of Potiphar‘ and ‗Jeez Louise‘.
These culturally-bound expressions are classified according to the translation strategy that
was used: 1) literal translation without any attempt of domestication, 2) literal translation
with some features of domestication, 3) borrowing, 4) foreignized paraphrasing without any
attempt of domestication, 5) domesticated paraphrasing, 6) translation using the TL
equivalent, and 7) deletion.
18
Phase II
After sorting out the data collected from the first book and classifying the translation
strategies used while translating into Arabic, it was decided to include another book as
another data source for the following reasons. When all types of idioms and culturally-bound
expressions were sorted, a pattern of translation strategy in handling some types of idioms
and culturally-bound expressions was observed. For example, the translator of The Seven
Habits of Highly Effective People tends to delete religious quotes and literally translate
allusions and idioms. Thus, in order to raise the external validity of the research, analyzing
what another translator may do was necessary. Another justification is that the first book
does not include many social expressions that are considered taboo in the target culture, such
as sex and dating. For this reason, the second book was selected because it is a social book
and talks about daily social practices of Western culture at a personal level using informal,
speech-like language. The second book included is Love Smart, by Phil McGraw.
The effective strategy presumably could be the strategy that results in an acceptable TT.
Therefore, the acceptability of the TT can be considered as a measuring criterion for the
effectiveness of the translation strategy that has been used. At this point, the need for field
work to collect the feedback of local readers and investigate their satisfaction with available
translated books was brought to the surface. Two investigation techniques were
implemented to survey the acceptability of translated idioms and culturally-bound
19
expressions by local Arab readers. All were carried out after summarizing the translation
strategies that are commonly used by the translators of the two books mentioned above.
Another way to reach the best strategies in translating idioms and culturally-bound
expressions is to investigate how translators make their decisions about strategies that
should be used. This approach concerns the process of translation itself rather than the
product and requires access to local translators.
It would be better if both approaches were combined to come up with the best translation
strategies within the genre of human development because that would likely result in an
integrated outcome that is convenient for translators and acceptable to the target audience.
However, due to the limited size and time-frame of this research, only the first approach was
applied: to present the most acceptable strategies from the point of view of the readers,
regardless of what translators may experience while translating.
4.4.1. Subjects
Generally speaking, the subjects of this research are Arab readers, males and females, who
tend to read books translated into Arabic because they either lack the English language skills
that would enable them to read English books, or they are bilingual but feel more
comfortable reading books in their mother tongue. Subjects are also interested in reading
translated books in the human development genre, specifically those involving personal and
professional development.
20
The subjects‘ demographic description includes the following qualities: aged between 22-55,
Saudi or Arab expatriate, and holders of at least a Bachelor‘s degree. As an exception to the
last demographic criterion, some senior undergraduate student respondents were accepted.
For the age criterion, Arab readers below age 22 were excluded for two reasons. First, the
under-22 age group barely find time to read about personal and professional development
because their time is extremely occupied with studying and reading within the area of their
studies. Secondly, people who are truly interested in cultivating their personal and
professional skills tend to be those who work and are married, or about to marry, both of
which are qualities usually found in the over-22 age group.
Arab expats are included in this study to see if their feedback is different than that of the
Saudis. Generally speaking, it is quite common to think that Saudis are more conservative
and close-minded than other Arabs, so we might expect they would be biased toward
strategies that are pro-TL. Another reason was that the aim of this research is to recommend
the most effective strategies while translating into Arabic English idioms and culture-bound
expressions to all Arab readers regardless of their nationality. In addition Arab expats
represent a considerable percentage of the Saudi Arabia population, so including them will
add to the diversity of research coverage.
In addition to the rationale behind age criterion, a Bachelor‘s degree was the minimum
educational level of the respondents for the following reasons. Bachelor‘s degree holders
appear to have fair language capabilities and reading skills that will enable them to judge
texts for acceptability. They also tend to have an interest in reading books on personal and
professional development to enhance their skills.
Table 2 below illustrates the number and distribution of the respondents throughout the
methodology stages of the research.
21
Qualitative Subjects
Paired-in-depth 6 2 females 12
Paired-in-depth 6 2 males 12
Subtotal of Qualitative Respondents 30
Quantitative Subjects
Location No/Group Gender Number
Jeddah 60 30 males and 30 females 60
The second phase consisted of six pair-in-depth interviews with three males and three
females. The initial plan was to conduct three mini focus groups consisting of four
respondents, two females and two males. However, it was not convenient to accommodate
females and males in one location because of the culturally-sanctioned segregation system
followed in Saudi Arabia. Specifically, some respondents would not agree to participate in
the research, if they knew that the interviews would be mixed-gender.
22
Questionnaire
The body of the questionnaire was built upon the completion of the data consolidating stage.
After studying the data collected from the two books selected for this research, the vision of
the questionnaire body became clear. Having envisioned a profound background about type
of idioms and culturally-bound expressions along with the most frequently used strategies in
translating into Arabic, the structure of questions was developed gradually to reach its final
version, which is attached in Appendices 3 and 4. For easy reference, the questions of the
questionnaire will be referred to as Q plus the number of the questions, as in Q1, Q2, etc.
Draft 1
The first draft was tested with the focus group mentioned above to validate its structure and
content. It consisted of two sections: one for idioms and the other for cultural expressions. In
the idiom section, the respondents were asked to choose the most correct meaning for the
underlined expression, and they were also given the choice to rank the three choices based
on most correct and least correct. The first section consisted of 13 questions, each of which
included text cited from one of the two books. The idiom in every question was underlined
as it was translated, and the respondent had to choose one of the three meanings provided.
The three choices represented a TL equivalent, paraphrasing, and an incorrect translation,
respectively (refer to Table 3 below). Q13 was a repetition of Q2 to validate the seriousness
of the respondents while filling in the questionnaire.
التقٌٌم المعنى العبارة
ٌنفقون معظم وقتهم فً القال و القٌل ؼٌر أنً ال أشعر بؤي والء من ناحٌتهم وأظن أننً لو تؽٌبت ٌوما واحدا
ٌنفقون معظم وقتهم فً ما ال ٌنفع فسوؾ ٌنفقون معظم وقتهم فً الثرثرة حول نافورة المٌاه،ًلمرض ب
ٌضٌعون وقتهم فً التنزه و الحدٌث حول لماذا ال أستطٌع تدرٌبهم على أن ٌكونوا نتحملٌن للمسإولٌة؟
نافورة المٌاه
Table 3: Sample of the First Questionnaire's Questions on Idioms
Section 2 regarding cultural expressions was similarly organized, but the request was to
choose the most acceptable choice rather than the most correct meaning to fill in the gap.
There were 12 questions and four choices: the TL equivalents, one paraphrased expression,
and two literal translations of the ST expression, one of which had additional information. In
23
some of the questions where the cultural expression was deleted in the TT, the expressions
were retrieved in the text of the question (refer to Table 4 below).
التقٌٌم التعبٌر البدٌل العبارة
دعاء المدم نٌن على الكحول المجهولٌن و بهذه الطرٌقة فإننا ال نعطً هذه المشاكل
" دعاءAlcoholics Anonymous القوة لتسٌطر علٌنا و نتشرب بالروح التً " (و هو دعاء اشتهر عن جمعٌة
)مدمنً الكحول الذٌن ٌسعون للتخلص من هذا اإلدمان ً" إلهً هبن.................." تنبعث من دعاء
دعاء الخمر المجهول الشجاعة ألاؼٌر من األشٌاء التً ٌجب أن
تتؽٌرو السكٌنة ألقبل األشٌاء التً ال ٌمكن
"Alcoholics Anonymous "
.تؽٌٌرها
Table 4: Sample of the First Questionnaire’s Questions on Culturally-Bound
Expressions
Draft 2
After discussing the first draft with the respondents in the focus group, some major
modifications took place. In the idiom section, the respondents were requested to fill in gaps
instead of choosing the meaning of the idiom; the three choices stood for TL equivalent,
paraphrased meaning, and literal translation. The wrong choice was deleted for being a
leading option that would definitely not be chosen (refer to Table 5). The repeated question
was deleted because there was no need for it; the questionnaire demanded focus and
concentration from the respondents, who easily figured out the repetition in the first draft.
التقٌٌم المعنى العبارة
ٌنفقون معظم وقتهم فً القال و القٌل
ؼٌر أنً ال أشعر بؤي والء من ناحٌتهم وأظن أننً لو تؽٌبت ٌوما واحدا
ٌنفقون معظم وقتهم فً ما ال ٌنفع
لماذا ال أستطٌع تدرٌبهم................................ فسوؾ،لمرض بي
ٌنفقون معظم وقتهم فً الثرثرة حول
على أن ٌكونوا متحملٌن للمسإولٌة؟
نافورة المٌاه
Table 5: Sample of Second Questionnaire's Questions on Idioms
For the culturally-bound expression section, the choices were reduced to three choices to
reduce the ambiguity and the similarity of some options. In addition some of the literal
translations of the expressions, especially those that talked about historical and literary
incidents were accompanied by a note of explanation between parentheses (refer to Table 6).
التقٌٌم التعبٌر البدٌل العبارة
دعاء المدمنٌن على الكحول المجهولٌن و بهذه الطرٌقة فإننا ال نعطً هذه المشاكل القوة لتسٌطر
" دعاءAlcoholics Anonymous " (و هو دعاء علٌنا و نتشرب بالروح التً تنبعث من دعاء
24
" إلهً هبنً الشجاعة ألاؼٌر من األشٌاء اشتهر عن جمعٌة مدمنً الكحول الذٌن ٌسعون للتخلص.................."
)من هذا اإلدمان التً ٌجب أن تتؽٌرو السكٌنة ألقبل األشٌاء التً ال ٌمكن
.تؽٌٌرها
"Alcoholics Anonymous "
The second draft of the questionnaire was shared with the respondents of the six pair-in-
depths interviews after the core discussion. The comments and the feedback of the 12
interviewees were used to produce the final draft of the questionnaire that was sent out for
the quantitative stage.
Final Draft
One major section was added to this draft. Its importance was discovered based on the
insightful feedback received from the pair-in-depth interviews. When discussing the
translation of some religious expressions and some sensitive social practices, there was
diversity in the feedback of respondents as to whether these elements should be literally
translated or totally deleted. Therefore, the third section of the questionnaire was composed
of close-ended direct questions that asked the respondents about their preferences when
translating these sensitive social and religious expressions (refer to Table 7).
األمثال العبارة
ْفغٝ ٍب الْٜفقُ٘ ٍؼظٌ ٗقخٌٖ فٝ 01 ٍ٘بٝ بجٞ ى٘ حغّْٜخٌٖ ٗأظِ أٞ ٗالء ٍِ ّبحٛ ال أشؼش بأّٜش أٞغ
ٓبَٞ اىزشرشة ح٘ه ّبف٘سة اىْٜفقُ٘ ٍؼظٌ ٗقخٌٖ فٝ 02 ىَبرا ال................................ فغ٘ف،ٜٗاحذا ىَشض ب 1ط
وٞ اىقبه ٗ اىقْٜفقُ٘ ٍؼظٌ ٗقخٌٖ فٝ 03 ت؟ِٞ ىيَغؤٗىٞنّ٘٘ا ٍخحَيٝ ُ أٚبٌٖ ػيٝغ حذسٞأعخط
In addition, the second section was reduced to ten questions, and some of the questions now
offered only two choices—literal translation and paraphrasing; paraphrasing stands for the
TL equivalent, since there was no TL equivalent for those expressions (refer to Table 8).
التعبيراث الثقافيت العبارة
ت مبّج حقذً بشّبٍجبٞنٝت أٍشٍٞ إػالٜٕٗ( ٜت ٗ اّفخبح اىؼَت بٞحٝقيِ بنو أسٝ لٝ ششٚ "اىؼز٘س ػي............ ِأػشف أُ بؼضن
01
) ْبثٞ اىغخٜب فّٞ٘ٝحفض ٛظ عٖال مأٞبة ً ُ أجو ػالقت حخ٘س ببىضٗاس ىٞ اىح1ط
ِقيٝ ٗ َبٝشا قذٞفنشُ حفنٝ 02 " اإلطالقٚىؼبت ػي
25
As a result, the questionnaire ultimately consisted of twenty-six questions, twelve for
idioms, ten for culturally-bound expressions, and four for culture and deletion. Upon
completion of this stage of the qualitative field work, the quantitative work followed.
The questionnaire was distributed in the two main cities in Saudi Arabia, Jeddah and
Riyadh. These cities were chosen for several reasons. First, the community of Riyadh is
known for its conservative disposition. It represents the religious ideology of the Saudi
people more than the Jeddah community, which is known for its ideological diversity and
multiculturalism. For its low multiculturalism and high localism, Riyadh is a rich
environment in which to meet the criteria of the research‘s subjects who tend to read
translated books rather than reading English books. In addition, Riyadh includes a higher
percentage of Saudis than does Jeddah. Furthermore, the questionnaire targeted both males
and females to ensure that its conclusions pertained to both genders. To address the target
respondents directly, this stage was specifically conducted next to/in two main bookstores in
Saudi Arabia: Jarir and Obaikan which are among the top translation centres locally.
26
the pair-in-depth interviews was to test the questionnaire and its readability and validity.
Second, the repeated question that was added to the first draft of questionnaire and which
was later deleted was another trial to raise the reliability of the questionnaire through testing
the respondents‘ seriousness. Furthermore, having more than one question for every type of
idiom and culturally-bound expression was meant to lead to reliable results. Most
importantly, the test and re-test technique was implemented to verify the reliability of every
question on the questionnaire.
The test and re-test reliability check was conducted as follows. After one month of the first
round of the quantitative stage, in which 121 respondents took the questionnaire, the second
round took place, during which the questionnaire was re-administered to 15 respondents out
of the initial 121 respondents. Afterwards, the results of these 15 respondents in both rounds
were compared. The comparison showed that 3 questions scored less than 10 on the scale of
15 which stands for the 15 respondents. These low reliable questions are Q8 (the proverb),
Q9 and Q11 which are metaphorical idioms. For detailed information about the statistical
results of the test and re-test technique, refer to Appendix 6.
27
CHAPTER 5 ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION
As mentioned before, this stage was conducted in two phases. Phase 1 consisted of one
focus group. This phase aimed to test the first draft of questionnaire, and the outcome was
incorporated in Draft 2 in Chapter 4.
Twelve respondents were interviewed for the second phase; half of them were men, and half
were women. All of the interviewees matched the criteria of the research sample. The
interviews were conducted in Arabic and mainly focused on four topics: 1) reading
translated books generally, and personal and professional development books specifically, 2)
opinions about the language of the translated books and participants‘ reactions towards it, 3)
how they prefer Western idioms and culture-bound expressions to be translated; and 4) a
discussion about the questionnaire. A sample of the questions raised during the interviews is
in Appendix 8.
The discussion for this stage is categorized based on gender because the interviews were
conducted in separate pairs to adhere to the segregation and social restrictions of the TC.
28
behind buying translated books in general. In addition, what they like most about Western
authors within professional and personal development is that they are globally addressing
human minds and raising issues that relate to humanity in general. They also think that those
authors are simple and direct in their approach, presenting applicable ideas and useful
advice.
Regarding the language of the available translated books, most of the female interviewees
think that the language is weak and sometimes difficult to understand, which makes them
read the paragraph more than once to grasp the idea. Nevertheless, this low language quality
does not matter to them as long as they can understand the general message. They also think
that sometimes the difficulty of understanding is not because of the incompetence of the
translator, but rather out of the oddness of the original notion of the ST; one of the
respondents mentioned an experience in which the author advises readers to burn hair ends
in order to encourage the hair to grow. She found the sentence difficult to understand for the
innovativeness of the thought rather than the lack of proper translation.
On the other hand, they give different feedback about translating religious notions, like
alcohol drinking and celebrating Christmas and sexual notions like dating and having sexual
relationships outside marriage. Some of them are pro translating the religious notions, but
the others are pro replacing those notions with Islamic ones. The former group thinks that
everything should be translated as it is, since the target audience is mature and has the ability
to filter and judge. Also they believe that they need to learn more about the Western culture
29
to avoid its faults and at the same time to build on their success. The latter group thinks that
religious and sexual notions should be domesticated in order not to harm the
conservativeness of the TC. For them, quotes from the Bible should be replaced by verses
from Quran and ‗girlfriend‘ should be replaced by ‗wife.‘ However, both groups agree that
notions that attack or harm Islam or Muslims either directly or indirectly should be deleted.
Although male respondents‘ feedback about the language of translated books varies, they all
agree that the language, most of the time, is weak and difficult to understand. This weak
language may stop them from completing the book. They think that sometimes the translator
has no knowledge about the topic and consequently fails to convey the intended message.
However, when they are asked to choose between reading an Arabic book and reading a
translated book within the same topic, they give different answers. One-third of the
respondents would read the translated books because they trust translators who tend to
domesticate the ST and present the TT in a layout that suits the target culture. The rest
would choose the original Arabic book to avoid the weak language of translation and out of
trust in the Arab author, who would be more effective in reflecting the TC.
All male respondents agreed that culturally-bound expressions should be wholly translated,
though those expressions are unrelated to the TC and accordingly difficult to be applied.
Similarly, they react to religious and sexual notions, but they advised that the translator may
generalize the notions to avoid translating sensitive expressions. They also refer to the fact
that they live in a global village and know a lot about Western society, so there is no harm in
translating everything about Western culture, including religious and sexual notions.
30
5.1.3. From Hypothetical to Actuality: Testing the Questionnaire
After discussing their preferences, the questionnaire was given to the respondents, and the
results are discussed in this section.
For idioms, most female respondents choose either the AE or the PM. One-third of the
women choose some LT because they are affected by the translation language that is
available on the market. For Ghazala (2008:7), literal translation is frequently used in Arab
countries not only by novice translators, but by professional practitioners, which is the
reason why some respondents choose the LT. They get used to this type of translation
available on the market, as was mentioned by some of the respondents in the qualitative
stage. For those who pick the LT, the AE is the second choice for them, since they are
interested in reading literary books and accordingly appreciate the beauty of language. The
other two-thirds either pick the AE or the PM equally. Likewise, one-third of the female
respondents choose several LT for culturally-bound expressions, and the rest alternate
between AE and PM.
For idioms, most male respondents choose either the AE or the PM. They never chose the
LT. It was also noticed that the respondents who are good readers and tend to read literary
book prefer the AE because they really care about the beauty of language. In addition, these
respondents pick the original Arabic books in the previous section because the language type
and cultural reflection matter to them.
For culturally-bound expressions, men respondents choose either the AE or the PM. It seems
that there is a contradiction in the men‘s answers regarding cultural notions. In the previous
section, they theoretically wanted all of the cultural notions to be translated without change
and to generalize the sensitive (religious and sexual) notions. Nonetheless, in actuality, when
they were given the questionnaire, they never choose the LT. On the contrary, they pick the
AE more, which shows that they really care about the values and notion of their cultures,
especially where there is an equivalent that can be used. Except for one case, they choose the
LT that is accompanied with an explanation between parentheses.
31
Regarding the layout and the items of the questionnaire, most of the respondents‘ feedback
was positive, and their comments were taken into consideration when developing the final
form of the questionnaire.
32
the AE is the favourite as a translation strategy for the idiom ‗you miss the bus‘ and in Q12,
the AE is the favourite for the discoursal expression ‗sooner or later.‘
LT is the second most popular choice for females in Q2 and Q9; both idioms are
metaphorical. LT in these questions is similar to AE, whereas both share the same words and
the same structure. To elaborate, in Q2, LT and PM have the same score of 28%; both
choices share the same structure with the AE. In addition, this score supports the work of
Ghazala (2008: 129) who recommends literal translation for metaphorical idioms.
AE was like an alarm knock on a sensitive string
fortunately the situation came up when we
PM was like an alarm stimulating a sensitive topic
Q2 purchased an appliance. But when it did come
was like a stimulus that triggered off a hot button
up, it …….. LT
response
Table 9: Question 2
Males
For male respondents, PM gets the highest score in five of the 12 questions. The second-
highest scorer is the AE, which was the preferred answer for four questions. Among them is
the biggest percentage, 82%, scored for Q12, the discoursal expression. Both AE and PM
scored 34% equally for Q3. However, LT got the highest score for two questions, Q7 and
Q10. Although the phrase of Q7 was literally translated, it stresses a strong meaning using
the words ‗knees‘ and ‗kneel down.‘ Both words draw an image that illustrates the situation
and at the same time forms a phrase that can be used as a potential Arabic idiom in the
future.
During the five years I have lived in UK, I saw AE was rushed madly upon by misfortunes twice
that country………. because train conductors PM live crises twice
Q7
were maliciously obedient in following all the
LT brought twice to its knees
rules and procedures written on paper.
33
In Q10, the LT holds the word ‗back‘, which has a connotation of support in both languages.
Therefore, the LT is a potential equivalent to complete the sentences, though it perhaps does
not make sense in Arabic, generally speaking. In contrast to the women, LT is either the
men‘s first or second choice in six of the questions. In addition, wherever the LT is the first
choice, PM is the second choice for men.
Age group
A (22-35)
The highest score strategy for age group A is AE, repeated six times. LT was the favourite
for Q7, which was discussed in the previous section. PM is the second most popular
strategy, and was repeated in five questions. LT was the second highest strategy once for
Q2, as discussed earlier.
B (36-55)
The most popular strategy for age group B is PM, repeated eight times. The second highest
percentage, 57%, was scored for PM of Q4.
In Riyadh, PM is the highest strategy in 6 questions. It also shares the highest score with AE
in two questions, 7 and 11. LT is neither the first nor the second choice for the Riyadh
34
community. This means that PM is the Riyadh‘s community‘s first choice, and AE is its
second.
For Saudi respondents, PM is the highest strategy, repeated seven times out of ten questions.
LT is the highest for Q2 and shared the same percentage with AE. By contrast, AE is the
non-Saudi respondents‘ preference for seven questions and LT is neither the first nor the
second choice for them.
Social Class
PM is the highest favourite for Bs, repeated seven times out of 12 questions. The second
choice for them is AE, and they prefer the LT only in Q7 for the phrasal reason mentioned
previously. For C1s, LT and PM equally share the position of first choice across the 12
questions
The result of the C2 class is quite different. The highest score is PM, repeated in six
questions, but they also choose the LT in three questions: Q3, 6, and 8, with a score above
50%. In addition, LT is not chosen for these questions by any classification of the sample
except for Q8, where the LT version is the favourite of the Jeddah community. What also
adds to the strangeness of this result is that the LT of Q6 has no apparent significance and
cannot be interpreted from the context of the question.
35
Group B PM PM PM AE PM PM PM AE AE PM PM AE
PM/
Jeddah PM LT PM LT AE PM AE PM LT LT AE
AE
Riyadh PM AE PM AE PM AE PM PM AE PM PM AE
Saudi AE LT/AE PM AE PM AE PM PM PM PM PM AE
Non-Saudi PM PM PM AE PM AE PM AE AE AE PM AE
B PM AE PM AE PM AE/PM PM PM PM LT PM AE
C1 PM PM AE AE PM AE PM AE AE PM/AE PM AE
C2 PM PM LT AE PM AE PM PM/AE/LT LT PM LT PM
The majority of the sample prefers PM for translating four of the metaphorical idioms. In
addition, for most of the respondents, PM is the best strategy to translate the two idioms that
have the potential to be TL idioms in Q4 and 5, which eliminate their potential of being part
of the TL idioms. PM also is chosen for the proverb in Q8 and the opaque idiom in Q7.
Having revealed that PM is preferred by most of the respondents, the claim of Baker (1992),
which states that Arabic is among the languages that allow limited use of idioms in writing,
is supported. However, AE is preferred for the opaque idiom of Q6 and the discoursal
expression in Q12.
Female respondents pick PM for the two potentially transferable idioms, the proverb and
two of the metaphorical idioms, Q3 and Q10. AE is their preference for four metaphorical
idioms and the discoursal idiom. For the two opaque idioms, the female respondents are
divided between PM and AE. By contrast, male respondents choose PM for four
metaphorical idioms and the proverb in Q8. Opaque idioms for men are divided between AE
and LT, and the potential idioms between AE and PM.
Age group A is consistent in choosing AE for all metaphorical idioms, and PM is its choice
for the potentially transferable idioms, the proverb and one opaque idiom. Meanwhile, age
group B chooses PM for almost all the metaphorical idioms, the proverb, one opaque idiom
and one potentially transferable idiom.
36
For the Jeddah community, there is no consistency in their choices. All idiom types are
distributed between the three translation strategies. However, the Riyadh community prefers
PM for potentially transferable idioms and the proverb, and AE for opaque and half of the
metaphorical idioms.
Saudi respondents choose AE for most of the metaphorical idioms and PM for the rest,
except for one metaphorical in Q2, for which LT scored the highest. Metaphorical and
potentially transferable idioms are divided equally between AE and PM for non-Saudis; PM
is their choice for the proverb and AE for the opaque idioms.
In Q19, LT is the favourite strategy for all categories except the Riyadh community and
social classes B and C2. The Riyadh community and social class B choose AE, while class
C2 chooses PM. As mentioned before, the LT includes an explanation about the background
of the Titanic. This background might be irrelevant or unnecessary for Riyadh respondents;
they appear to be more conservative and close-minded, which makes them choose the AE.
The AE of the culturally-bound expression of this question, ‗like straightening deck chairs
on the Titanic,‘ is a rhetoric idiom that has a historical connotation.
37
AE The one who cries after Malta‘s destruction
It is like straightening chairs on the deck of a
Efficient management without effective LT sinking ship (like what happened on the great
Q19
leadership is, as one individual had Titanic)
phrased it, ―…………….‖ It is like straightening chairs on the deck of a
PM
sinking ship
For class B, who are described as highly educated, the expressive and stylistic effect of the
AE is more privileged than the LT. On the other hand, it could be argued that the simplicity
of class C2 in terms of education and income was behind choosing the PM that is simple,
short and straightforward.
In Q21, the highest strategy across all categories is AE, except for the Jeddah community
and class C2,2 who both prefer PM. The Jeddah community may prefer the PM version
because they think that the original author would not write the AE ‗the love of Allah‘ while
the original is ‗the love of Christ.‘ This is the case for some respondents in the pair-in-depth
interviews. Also the wording and structure of the choices may lead the respondents to
choose this specific strategy. Thus, the Muslim community will never choose the LT.
AE My love of Allah
……… is visible through my actions toward
Q21 PM My faith
others.
LT My love of Christ
Q# Q13 Q14 Q15 Q16 Q17 Q22 Q18 Q19 Q20 Q21
Whole PM PM PM/AE PM PM PM PM LT PM AE
2
It is important to mention that 70% of the C2 class were located in Jeddah, which justifies the similar
score.
38
Sample
Female PM PM PM/AE PM PM PM PM LT PM AE
Male PM PM PM/AE PM PM PM PM LT PM AE
Group A PM PM PM/AE PM PM PM PM LT PM AE
Group B PM PM PM/AE PM PM PM PM LT PM AE
Jeddah PM PM PM/AE PM PM PM PM LT PM PM
Riyadh PM PM PM/AE PM PM PM PM AE PM AE
Saudi PM PM PM/AE PM PM PM PM LT PM AE
Non-Saudi PM PM PM/AE PM PM PM PM LT PM AE
B PM PM PM PM PM PM PM AE PM AE
C1 PM PM PM PM PM PM PM LT PM AE
C2 PM PM LT PM PM PM PM PM PM/LT PM
The results for culturally-bound expressions are consistent. For the historical-social, social-
environmental and social expressions, the whole sample and the different classifications
choose PM. For historical-literal, PM is the choice except for Q19. The whole sample
chooses LT, which provided an explanation, except for the Riyadh community and the B
class, both of whom pick the AE. On the other hand, the Jeddah community picks the PM
for the religious expression in Q21, which reflects the tendency of this community towards
multiculturalism.
Here, the results are quite unexpected. Although deletion is the highest in Q25 for the
sample, with a non-significant score of 36%, LT is second with a score of 35% of the whole
39
sample. Q25 asks about the best strategy for translating religious practices, and it is
surprising to get the two most extreme strategies, LT and deletion, close in their score. In
addition, deletion got the lowest score in the other three questions, which indicates that
respondents do not prefer deletion at all levels. This result agrees with the feedback of the
majority of the interviewees in the qualitative stage.
Another surprising result is in Q23, where LT and AE scored the same, 40%, for the whole
sample. The question asks about how to translate sensitive social practices – mainly sexual
practices. However, when revising the questions in the culturally-bound section, particularly
Q22, which contains a sensitive sexual notion, the result was similar; here 60% of the
sample chose PM, and the rest chose LT.
Q26 asks the respondents about their preferred strategy for translating literary and historical
quotes and incidents (refer to Table 17). Most of the respondents prefer LT, which
corresponds to Q19 that asks about translating a literary expression and where LT is the
most frequent strategy.
Q26 Sentences that contain some literary and To be deleted as long as deletion will not
01
historical incidents that belong to affect the general meaning
western society like historical stories 02 To be literally translated
and quoting the literary works. To be replaced by quotes from Arabic
03
literature and History
Table 17: A Sample of Deletion Questions
40
CHAPTER 6 FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION
For the other classifications of the research sample, age group B, the Riyadh community,
Saudis, and the B social class all chose PM most across all idiom questions, while AE
was chosen most by age group A and non-Saudi respondents. However, in the answers of
those classifications, a minor percentage opted for the LT, except for the Riyadh
community, who are described as being more conservative and close-minded.
Across the whole sample, PM ended up in first place as the most popular answer for eight
questions, and AE was the second most popular as repeated for four questions. However,
statistically, AE took first place, with 40% of the total answers of the 121 respondents;
PM came in second with 38% (refer to Figure 1). Therefore, we can conclude that AE
and PM are the most acceptable strategies for translating idioms within the genre of
professional and personal development. This conclusion is supported by Ghazala‘s point
about translating proverbs; this can be generalized and applied to all other types of
idioms. Ghazala (2008:143) states that literal translation is not recommended for
proverbs, because it might distort the meaning, while paraphrasing or ―translating by
sense‖ can be the last resort when the equivalent or near equivalent is not available.
41
Total Score for Idioms
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
Total
15%
10%
5%
0%
Arabic Meaning Literal
equivalent Paraphrased Translation
For culturally-bound expressions, the interviewees at the qualitative stage chose LT for
social practices; for religious notions, however, men chose PM or generalization, and
women chose LT or AE. Yet when given the questionnaire, they chose either AE or PM,
with more opting for AE.
42
Total Score for Culturally-Bound Expressions
50%
40%
30%
Total
20%
10%
0%
Arabic Meaning Literal
equivalent Paraphrased Translation
Regarding deletion, the results, either in the qualitative or quantitative stages, do not
support deletion at all levels of culturally-bound expressions, though deletion non-
43
significantly scored high in one of the third section‘s questions relating to religious
practices (refer to Figure 3 which shows the total score for deletion at the quantitative
stage).
50%
40%
30%
20% Total
10%
0%
Deletion Literal Arabic EQ
Translation
To synthesize, literal translation might be acceptable and sound familiar to Arab readers
who frequently read translated books and who are oriented to Western culture and
practices. On the contrary, deletion is not preferred as it is presumably received by Arab
readers as a dishonest practice on the part of the translator, and this supposition is
supported by much of interviewees‘ feedback in the qualitative stage. It can also be taken
as an indication of how keen Arab readers are to learn about Western cultures.
44
Arab readers are seeking self-development in their exploration of personal and
professional development books. Therefore, translating books within the genre of
professional and personal development using paraphrasing and generalization, i.e. pro-TL
strategies, is communicatively effective and at the same time acceptable, since the readers
are hungry for information and knowledge. This conclusion is applicable in the case of
idioms and culturally-bound expressions. In other words, if direct equivalents for idioms
or cultural expressions are not available, paraphrasing would be sufficient and acceptable
to the target audience.
Furthermore, it can be inferred from the results of this research that translating books that
address women more than men, using more polished language, and translating idioms and
cultural expressions using equivalents from the target language would be more effective
and acceptable. On the other hand, men care about the message more and prefer
generalized translation, which means that books that are purely addressed to men can be
translated using paraphrased meaning and generalized notions that convey the message
directly without any attempt towards using stylish language.
Future research can ascertain from this study the importance of conducting a range of
research on this topic. For one thing, research that investigates how translators tend to
translate idioms and cultural expressions and the reasons behind choosing one strategy
45
rather than the other would contribute to any kind of research that is meant to measure the
feedback of readers. Likewise, obtaining accurate feedback from the readers can be
conducted in stages; in each stage, one strategy could be tested to verify the significant
effectiveness of it in comparison to the other strategies.
Finally, more researches on the demands of the local market in terms of translated
material would contribute to any linguistic or cultural translation research that aims to
explore the best practices and the effective strategies in dealing with translation
problems. This kind of market research would also serve as an informative platform that
would pave the way for any national attempt towards regulating and developing
translation industry.
46
APPENDICES
******************************************************************************************
الرجاء قراءة التعلٌمات قبل البدء فً تعبئة االستبٌان
هذا االستبٌان ٌتألف من قسمٌن:
.1القسم األول ٌقٌس مدى فهم القارئ العربً لبعض التعبٌرات اللؽوٌة المترجمة من اللؽة االنجلٌزٌة إلى العربٌة
.2القسم الثانً ٌقٌس مدى قبول القارئ العربً لبعض التعبٌرات الثقافٌة المترجمة من اللؽة االنجلٌزٌة إلى العربٌة.
*****************************************************************************************
أوال :التعبٌرات اللغوٌة
التعلٌمات:
.1الرجاء اختٌار المعنى األصح للعبارات التً تحتها خط بوضع الرقم 1فً المربع المقابل
ٌ .2مكنك ترتٌب المعانً (بحٌث ٌمثل رقم 1المعنى األكثر صحة و ٌمثل الرقم 3الرقم األقل صحة).
كان كمنبه دق على وتر حساس لحسن الحظ أصبح األمر على ما ٌرام فقط عندما اشترٌنا الجهاز .و لكن عندما .2
عرضنا هذا األمر للمناقشة كان كمنبه ضغط بشدة على زر استجابة حادة ،وبدا لً
كان كمنبه أثار موضوعا حساسا هذا االمر كرمز لكل التفكٌر ؼٌر العقبلنً و قد ولّد داخلً سلسلة من األحاسٌس
السلبٌة.
كان كمنبه أٌقظنً من ؼفلتً
و أصبح المشروع أشبه باألرض الخربة كان المشروع ٌتهاوى ،و بدت الشوارع اشبه ما تكون بساحة من األعشاب البرٌة ،أما .3
مالكوا المنازل القلٌلة التً كانت قد شٌدت فقد تكاتفوا سوٌا فً مواجهة تدهور قٌمة
وتحوله إلى منظر بشع ٌإذي العٌون ممتلكاته م ،و على مستوى المدٌنة ساد جو من االضطراب بشؤن تاخر مشروع أرض
النخبة عن موعده المحدد و تحوله لقذى العٌون
و تحوله إلى مصدر تعاسة
ال تسمن و ال تؽنً من جوع كم هو فرق حقٌقً ذلك الذي ٌصنعه التفهم .إن جمٌع النصائح الحسنة فً العالم لن .4
تساوي حتى مجرد صفقة من البقول ما لم تكن معنٌة بالمشكلة الحقٌقٌة و لن تستطٌع
ال فابدة منها
أن تصل إلى المشكلة إذا ما كنا مسلمٌن أنفسنا لهذه الدرجة من الذاتٌة الشخصٌة
ال تباع و تشترى
كل من كان جٌدا فً الطرق ٌمٌل إلى الظن ٌؤن إال ان الناس تمٌل إلى البقاء فً منطقة الراحة مع نصؾ الدماغ المسٌطر و تجري .5
كل األشٌاء مسامٌر التعامل مع كل موقؾ طبقا للجانب المفضل فً المخ .وكما ٌقول إبراهام ماسلو :إن
أن كل من برع فً أمر ما قاس جمٌع االمور الذي فً ٌده مطرقة ٌمٌل إلى الظن بأن كل ما حوله مسامٌر
علٌه
تعامل مع األشٌاء كؤنها مسامٌر
تمطرنً باألسبلة وفً كل مرة أكون فٌها مسافرا إلى الخارج ،تنتزع منً االعترافات و تسؤلنً أٌن .6
تستجوبنً استجوابا حادا تناولت إفطاري؟ و من كان معً؟
تعطٌنً الدرجة الثالثة
إما إن ٌتحسنوا و إال فالباب ٌفوت جمل كنت ذات مرة مع مجموعة من األشخاص حٌث سؤل أحدهم "كٌؾ تطور موظفٌك .7
الكسالى أو ؼٌر األكفاء؟" و بادرواحد من المجموعة باإلجابة "أقذفهم بالقنابل الٌدوٌة"
إن لم ٌتحسن األداء فسٌفقدون عملهم و قد ابتهج العدٌدون لهذا النهج البتار فً اإلشراؾ اإلداري وهو نهج "أصلحهم أو
أغرقهم"
إن لم تحسن مظهرهم فسنشوههم
ؼٌر أنً آكل قلبً من الؽٌظ .8إننً ارقب أصدقابً و أقربابً و هم ٌحققون بعض النجاح أو ٌنالون بعض التقدٌر و
ابتسم لهم و اهنبهم فً حماس غٌر أنه فً داخلً تتملكنً
ؼٌر أنً فً قمة الحزن و القهر التعاسة
تكون ما بٌن شد و رد و بٌنما اإلنسان ٌتقلب من عامل آلخر فإن النسبٌة الناجمة مثل البكرة المعلقة التً .9
47
ال تبقى على حال بل تتارجح من القمة إلى القاع تدور فً حٌاة اإلنسان قد تصل إلى القمة فً إحدى اللحظات ثم تنخفض فً اللحظة
مثل الحٌاة و اإلنسان التالٌة
دست على أحزانً .10عندما تحققت أخٌرا من اننً أمتلك هذه القوة ،و حٌنما ابتلعت مرارتً و أدركت أننً
قد اخترت أال أكون بابسة -فً تلك اللحظة هببت واقفة لقد شعرت أنً كالمارد الذي
تجاوزت أزمتً انطلق من القمقم
نفضوا الػبار عن أنفسهم .11و كنتٌجة لذلك فقد اعرض الكثٌر من الناس عن برامج ادارة الوقت و عن المخططٌن
لذا تخلوا عن كل ما بٌن أٌدٌهم الذٌن ٌجعلونهم ٌشعرون بؤنهم مجدولون اكثر مما ٌجب ،و مقٌدون إلى حد بعٌد ،ولذا
لذا أطاحوا بالصؽٌر و حوض االستحمام إلى فقد أطاحوا بكل شٌئ وراء ظهورهم عابدٌن إلى تقنٌات الجٌلٌن األول و الثانً من
الخارج اجل الحفاظ على العبلقات
و بعد أن ضربنا بمدركاتنا القدٌمة عرض .12وبعد أن ارخٌنا العنان لمدركاتنا القدٌمة عن ابننا و اعتمدنا على دوافع مستندة إلى
الحابط القٌم بدأت مشاعر جدٌدة فً االنبثاق ،لقد وجدنا أنفسنا نستمتع بما ٌحدث بدال من
وبعد أن تخلٌنا عن مدركاتنا القدٌمة وضعه موضع المقارنة و االتهام
و بعد أن وسّعنا مدركاتنا القدٌمة
كان كمنبه دق على وتر حساس .13و كان هذا األمر ٌعد إشارة بالنسبة لً ،و لحسن الحظ أصبح األمر على ما ٌرام فقط
و كان كمنبه أثار موضوعا حساسا عندما اشترٌنا الجهاز .و لكن عندما عرضنا هذا األمر للمناقشة كان كمنبه ضغط بشدة
كمنبه أٌقظنً من ؼفلتً على زر استجابة حادة ،وبدا لً هذا االمر كرمز لكل التفكٌر ؼٌر العقبلنً
******************************************************************************************
ثانٌا :التعبٌرات الثقافٌة
التعلٌمات
.1الرجاء اختٌار التعبٌر األكثر مالءمة لملئ المكان الخالً و ذلك بوضع الرقم 1فً المربع المقابل
ٌ .2مكنك ترتٌب الخٌارات (بحٌث ٌمثل الرقم 1التعبٌراألكثر قبوال و ٌمثل الرقم 4التعبٌر األقل قبوال).
المدٌنة الكبٌرة
أن تنزل من أبراجك العاجٌة لتواجه الواقع إن األمر ٌقتضً قدرا هاببل من األمن الداخلً حتى ٌمكن البدء بروح من .2
أن تترك ما اعتدت علٌه لتكتشؾ و تعٌش عالما جدٌدا المؽامرة ،بروح من ارتٌاد المجهول ،بروح من اإلبداع و بدون شك ،فإن
أن تترك الراحة و تبدأ فً العمل فً البراري علٌك............................... .
أن تهجر عالم الراحة فً مستقرك الربٌسً لتواجه عالما
كامبل جدٌدا و مجهوال فً قفار البرٌة
البحر المٌت فً األردن و لكن لو ألقٌنا نظرة من قرب نحو كثٌر من التوجهات المطلوبة للنمو و .3
تحقٌق الذات ،فإننا سوؾ نجد فً لبها أو جوهرها التمركز حول الذات.
البحر المٌت ولكن ٌوجد فً مركز الذات القلٌل من االمان و التوجٌه و الحكمة و القوة
ألنه مثل ..................الذي ٌؤخذ و لكنه ال ٌعطً و ٌصبح بذلك راكدا
البحر الؽدار
عشٌقته و كان جدوله حافل بالمهمات بما فً ذلك شراء بعض الكتب و ؼسل .4
سٌارته و توصٌل .................و ؼٌر ذلك
خطٌبته
زوجته
دعاء المدمنٌن على الكحول المجهولٌن و بهذه الطرٌقة فإننا ال نعطً هذه المشاكل القوة .5
لتسٌطر علٌنا و نتشرب بالروح التً تنبعث من دعاء
" "..................إلهً هبنً الشجاعة ألاؼٌر من
دعاء " ( "Alcoholics Anonymousو هو دعاء اشتهر عن جمعٌة مدمنً األشٌاء التً ٌجب أن تتؽٌرو السكٌنة ألقبل األشٌاء
الكحول الذٌن ٌسعون للتخلص من هذا اإلدمان) التً ال ٌمكن تؽٌٌرها.
سلطة المتحدث و استعطاؾ الجمهور و المنطق لقد كان لقدماء اإلؼرٌق فلسفة رابعة تضمنتها ثبلث .6
48
إٌثوز(و ٌعنً إخبلص و سلطة المتحدث) و باثوز(ٌعنً استعطاؾ الجمهور ) و كلمات مرتبة فً تتابع منهجً و هً ..........و
لوقوز (و ٌعنً المنطق و الحقابق التً تدعم حجة المتحدث) أزعم أن تلك الكلمات تحتوي على جوهر مبدأ السعً
إٌثوز و باثوز و لوقوز أوال للفهم و تقدٌم صورة مإثرة
Ethos, Pathos, and Logos
من ٌبكً بعد خراب مالطا إن اإلدارة دون القًادة المإثرة هً أقرب ما تكون .7
عدم جدوى االهتمام بتنظٌم الكراسً و المقاعد على ظهر سفٌنة أوشكت على إلى ، ................ .و لن تستطٌع اإلدارة الناجحة أن
الؽرق (كما حدث على ظهر سفٌنة تاٌتنك العظٌمة و هً تؽرق) تعوض فشل القٌادة و ٌعود سبب صعوبة القٌادة إلى
من مسإلٌته تنظٌم الكراسً فوق ظهر السفن أننا ننحرؾ بها و ننؽمس فً تصور ذهنً لئلدارة
عدم جدوى االهتمام بتنظٌم الكراسً و المقاعد على ظهر سفٌنة أوشكت على
الؽرق
فؤنت ستحب العودة إلى المنزل ما دام ٌنتظرك فٌه أناس تربطك بهم عبلقة قوٌة و و شعرنا بؤن أساس استمرار حبنا هو أن نتحدث و .8
متٌنة خاصة عن المشاعر وأن نحاول التحدث مع بعصنا
فٌمكنك الرجوع إلى المنزل مرة أخرى(-و ذلك على عكس رواٌة توماس وولؾ البعض كل ٌوم حتى و إن كنت على سفر ألن ذلك
التً بعنوان "ال ٌمكنك العودة إلى المنزل") -إذا كان منزلك عبارة عن عبلقة هو أساس السعادة واألمان التً ستعم أرجاء المنزل.
يثمٌنة و صحبة ؼالة ..................
ال ٌمكنك العودة إلى المنزل الملٌا بالعبلقات الثمٌنة
فٌمكنك الرجوع إلى المنزل مرة أخرى -إذا كان منزلك عبارة عن عبلقة ثمٌنة و
ي
صحبة ؼالة
مسجد الحً أم ا المتحدث الثالث فسوؾ ٌكون من زمبلء العمل و .9
دار عبادتك المهنة على حٌن سوؾ ٌكون الرابع من ...........أو
الجمعٌة إحدى الجمعٌات فً المنطقة
كنٌستك
ألن محبتً هلل .10أسعى ألن أكون خٌّرا كجار .............ستظهر فً
ألن إٌمانً و اعتقادي سلوكٌاتً تجاه اآلخرٌن
ألن محبتً لؤلنبٌاء
ألن محبتً لٌسوع
بالمبادئ األخبلقٌة السماوٌة األساسٌة .11ومن ناحٌة أخرى هناك أشخاص أقل فً ترددهم
بقٌم األدٌان السماوٌة األساسٌة لدور العبادة و مع هذا ٌظهر فً سلوكهم و مواقفهم
بالقٌم تمسكا حقٌقٌا ......................
بالقٌم المسٌحٌة الٌهودٌة األساسٌة
أحب ألخٌك ما تحب لنفسك .12تقول القاعدة الذهبٌة "................." :فً حٌن أن
المعنى الظاهر لهذه القاعدة قد ٌعنً أن تقدم لهم ما
عامل الناس بمثل ما تحب أن ٌعاملوك به تحب أن ٌقدموه لك لكنً أعتقد أن المعنى الجوهري
هو أن تفهم اآلخرٌن بعمق كؤشخاص و بالطرٌقة التً
ترٌد أن ُتؾ
هم أنت بها.
كن طٌبا مع الناس
******************************************************************************************
الرجاء قراءة التعلٌمات قبل البدء فً تعبئة االستبٌان
هذا االستبٌان ٌتألف من قسمٌن:
.3القسم األول ٌقٌس مدى مالءمة بعض التعبٌرات اللؽوٌة المترجمة من اللؽة االنجلٌزٌة إلى العربٌة
.4القسم الثانً ٌقٌس مدى قبول القارئ العربً لبعض التعبٌرات الثقافٌة المترجمة من اللؽة االنجلٌزٌة إلى العربٌة.
*****************************************************************************************
أوال :التعبٌرات المجازٌة و األمثال
الرجاء اختٌار العبارة األكثر مالءمة لملئ المكان الخالً بوضع دائرة حول الحرف المقابل.
المعنى العبارة
ٌنفقون معظم وقتهم فً القال و القٌل أ) .14ؼٌر أنً ال أشعر بؤي والء من ناحٌتهم وأظن أننً لو تؽٌبت ٌوما واحدا لمرض بً،
49
المعنى العبارة
ٌنفقون معظم وقتهم فً ما ال ٌنفع ب) فسوؾ ................................لماذا ال أستطٌع تدرٌبهم على أن ٌكونوا متحملٌن
للمسإولٌة؟
ٌنفقون معظم وقتهم فً الثرثرة حول نافورة المٌاه ج)
كان كمنبه دق على وتر حساس أ) .15لحسن الحظ أصبح األمر على ما ٌرام فقط عندما اشترٌنا الجهاز .و لكن عندما
عرضنا هذا األمر للمناقشة ،..........................وبدا لً هذا االمر كرمز لكل
كان كمنبه أثار موضوعا حساسا ب) التفكٌر ؼٌر العقبلنً و قد ولّد داخلً سلسلة من األحاسٌس السلبٌة.
برباطة جؤش أ) .16العملٌة كلها أشبه باللعبة و التً ٌجب أن تمارسٌها ،..........................و إال لن
تحصلً أبدا على ما تبحثٌن عنه
بدون قلق و توتر ب)
ال تسمن و ال تؽنً من جوع أ) .17كم هو فرق حقٌقً ذلك الذي ٌصنعه التفهم .إن جمٌع النصابح الحسنة فً العالم
...................ما لم تكن معنٌة بالمشكلة الحقٌقٌة و لن تستطٌع أن تصل إلى
ال فابدة منها ب)
المشكلة إذا ما كنا مسلمٌن أنفسنا لهذه الدرجة من الذاتٌة الشخصٌة
لن تساوي حتى مجرد صفقة من البقول ج)
تؽٌٌر الحال من المحال أ) .18إال ان الناس تمٌل إلى البقاء فً منطقة الراحة مع نصؾ الدماغ المسٌطر و تجري
أن كل من برع فً أمر ما قاس جمٌع االمور علٌه ب) التعامل مع كل موقؾ طبقا للجانب المفضل فً المخ .وكما ٌقول إبراهام ماسلو:
كل من كان جٌدا فً الطرق ٌمٌل إلى الظن بؤن كل األشٌاء ج) .................................
مسامٌر
تمطرنً باألسبلة أ) .19وفً كل مرة أكون فٌها مسافرا إلى الخارج .................... ،و تسؤلنً أٌن تناولت
تستجوبنً استجوابا حادا ب) إفطاري؟ و من كان معً؟
تعطٌنً الدرجة الثالثة ج)
تتكالب علٌه المصابب مرتٌن أ) .20خبلل السنوات الخمس التً عشتها فً برٌطانٌا العظمى رأٌت هذا البلد
...........................و ذلك ألن محصلً تذاكر القطارات كانوا بتبعون
ٌمر بؤزمتٌن حقٌقٌتٌن ب) االجراءات و القواعد المكتوبة بمكر و دهاء
بؤنه قد فاتك قطار الزواج أ) .22ال أرٌدٌك أن تصابً بالذعر أو أن تشعري .................... .و لكن حان الوقت
أنك قد أصبحت عانس ب) للتوقؾ عن إهدار أٌامك
بؤنه قد فاتتك الحافلة ج)
تنالٌن بها أقصى المنى أ) ٌ .23مكنك إٌجاد فارس األحبلم الذي تعرفٌن أنه مناسب لك ،ستحصلٌن على عبلقة
، ........................... .و تحقق أحبلمك التً طالما حلمت بها منذ الطفولة
تشبع كل احتٌاجاتك ب)
لقد تسلل الملل و الرتابة إلى زواجنا أ) ...... …….إننا ال نتشاجر أو نفعل أي شٌا لقد كففنا عن حب بعضنا البعض. .24
لقد فقد زواجنا كل معانً اإلثارة ب)
لقد أصبح زواجنا أملسًا ج)
عاجبل أم آجبل أ) .25ؼٌر أنك ستجد نفسك مضطرا إلى مواجهة الحقابق ......................
سواء اآلن أو بعد حٌن ب)
قرٌبا أو الحقا ج)
الرجاء اختٌارالتعبٌر األكثر مالءمة لملئ المكان الخالً و ذلك بوضع عالمة فً المربع المقابل
ٌقلن بكل أرٌحٌة و انفتاح العمة بً (وهً إعبلمٌة أمرٌكٌة كانت تقدم برنامجا تفزٌونٌا فً ج)
الستٌنات)
البحر المٌت فً األردن أ) .14و لكن لو ألقٌنا نظرة من قرب نحو كثٌر من التوجهات
50
التعبٌر البدٌل العبارة
البحر المٌت ب) المطلوبة للنمو و تحقٌق الذات ،فإننا سوؾ نجد فً لبها
البحر المٌت فً إسرابٌل ج) أو جوهرها التمركز حول الذات .ولكن ٌوجد فً مركز
الذات القلٌل من االمان و التوجٌه و الحكمة و القوة ألنه
مثل ..................الذي ٌؤخذ و لكنه ال ٌعطً و ٌصبح
بذلك راكدا
نصاب ساعات العمل أ) .15إنك تتعلم حٌن تصمت ،كما أنك تعطً من ٌعمل معك
ٌهم الوالء الذي ٌتجاوز كثٌرا
التنفٌس المعنوي ،إنك تبث ؾ
الثمان ساعات الٌومٌة ب) .....................البلزمة للوظٌفة (أو البلزم للوظٌفة).
ما هو برجك؟ الجو شدٌد الحرارة ألٌس كذلك؟ هل قرأت العدد االخٌر من مجلة سٌدتً؟ أ) .16لقاء التعارؾ ببساطة من أكثر الطرق العشوابٌة و الؽٌر
منتجة فعادة تؤخذ الحوارات أشكاال مثل:
اضاعة الوقت فً السإال عن آخر المستجدات االجتماعٌة و السٌاسٌة و أحوال الطقس ب) ................................
إلى أي برج تنتمً ؟ هل ترى كل هذه االمطار الؽزٌرة؟ هل طالعت م جلة" بٌبول "هذا األسبوع؟" ج)
دعاء المدمنٌن على الكحول المجهولٌن أ) .17و بهذه الطرٌقة فإننا ال نعطً هذه المشاكل القوة لتسٌطر
علٌنا و نتشرب بالروح التً تنبعث من دعاء
" "..................إلهً هبنً الشجاعة ألاؼٌر من
دعاء " ( "Alcoholics Anonymousو هو دعاء اشتهر عن جمعٌة مدمنً الكحول الذٌن ب) األشٌاء التً ٌجب أن تتؽٌرو السكٌنة ألقبل األشٌاء التً
ٌسعون للتخلص من هذا اإلدمان) ال ٌمكن تؽٌٌرها.
سلطة المتحدث و استعطاؾ الجمهور و المنطق أ) .18لقد كان لقدماء اإلؼرٌق فلسفة رابعة تضمنتها ثبلث
كلمات مرتبة فً تتابع منهجً و هً ..........و أزعم
إٌثوز(و ٌعنً إخبلص و سلطة المتحدث) و باثوز(ٌعنً استعطاؾ الجمهور ) و لوقوز (و ٌعنً ب)
أن تلك الكلمات تحتوي على جوهر مبدأ السعً أوال للفهم
المنطق و الحقابق التً تدعم حجة المتحدث)
و تقدٌم صورة مإثرة
Ethos, Pathos, and Logos ج)
من ٌبكً بعد خراب مالطا أ) .19إن اإلدارة دون القٌادة المإثرة هً أقرب ما تكون
عدم جدوى االهتمام بتنظٌم الكراسً و المقاعد على ظهر سفٌنة أوشكت على الؽرق (كما حدث ب) إلى ، .................و لن تستطٌع اإلدارة الناجحة أن
على ظهر سفٌنة تاٌتنك العظٌمة و هً تؽرق) تعوض فشل القٌادة و ٌعود سبب صعوبة القٌادة إلى أننا
عدم جدوى االهتمام بتنظٌم الكراسً و المقاعد على ظهر سفٌنة أوشكت على الؽرق ج) ننحرؾ بها و ننؽمس فً تصور ذهنً لئلدارة
فؤنت ستحب العودة إلى المنزل ما دام ٌنتظرك فٌه أناس تربطك بهم عبلقة قوٌة و متٌنة أ) .20و شعرنا بؤن أساس استمرار حبنا هو أن نتحدث و
عنوان "ال
فٌمكنك الرجوع إلى المنزل مرة أخرى(-و ذلك على عكس رواٌة توماس وولؾ التً ب ب) خاصة عن المشاعر وأن نحاول التحدث مع بعصنا
ي
ٌمكنك العودة إلى المنزل") -إذا كان منزلك عبارة عن عبلقة ثمٌنة و صحبة ؼالة البعض كل ٌوم حتى و إن كنت على سفر ألن ذلك هو
يفٌمكنك الرجوع إلى المنزل مرة أخرى -إذا كان منزلك عبارة عن عبلقة ثمٌنة و صحبة ؼالة ج) أساس السعادة واألمان التً ستعم أرجاء المنزل
..................
أقنعة المهرجٌن أ) .21و من ٌحاولن اللجوء إلى عملٌات التجمٌل ٌنتهً بهن
أقنعة عٌد الهاالوٌن ب) الحال إلى شكل مزٌؾ و صناعً أكثر من ...............
أقنعة عٌد رأس السنة ج)
ألن محبتً هلل أ) .22أسعى ألن أكون خٌّرا كجار .............ستظهر فً
ألن إٌمانً و اعتقادي ب) سلوكٌاتً تجاه اآلخرٌن
ألن محبتً لٌسوع ج)
بالمبادئ األخبلقٌة السماوٌة األساسٌة أ) .23ومن ناحٌة أخرى هناك أشخاص أقل فً ترددهم لدور
بقٌم األدٌان السماوٌة األساسٌة ب) العبادة و مع هذا ٌظهر فً سلوكهم و مواقفهم تمسكا
بالقٌم المسٌحٌة الٌهودٌة األساسٌة ج) حقٌقٌا ......................
لٌس هدفه من الزواج الجانب الحسً فقط أ) .24أنا أستحق الزوج المناسب الذي سٌكمل عمره معً ،و
نعٌش معا فً تجربة جمٌلة ،و ٌتعرؾ على شخصٌتً و
و لٌس هدفه االستمتاع بجسدي فقط ب) نكمل بعضنا البعض و ..................................
لفقٌه
نور علوي ب
طالبة ماجستٌر الترجمة بجامعة برمنجهام فً المملكة المتحدة
مارس 2009
51
Appendix 3 Final Draft of the Questionnaire (Arabic)
. تابع المقابلة إذا قبل المشاركة، انهى المقابلة إذا لم ٌقبل المجٌب المشاركة فً المقابلة
تعاونك مهم جداً فً التطور الجٌد لهذه الدراسة. شكراً لمشاركتك فً هذه الدراسة
S4. How many English translated books have you read? كم كتاب مترجم قرأت حىت اآلن؟
S5. In what kind of topics you like to read? يف أي املوضوعات حتة أن تقرأ؟
If Self Development (S5 = Code #02) was not chosen, TERMINATE interview.
52
األمثال العبارة
ٌنفقون معظم وقتهم فً ما ال ٌنفع 01 ؼٌر أنً ال أشعر بؤي والء من ناحٌتهم وأظن أننً لو تؽٌبت ٌوما واحدا لمرض بً،
فسوؾ ................................لماذا ال أستطٌع تدرٌبهم على أن ٌكونوا متحملٌن
ٌنفقون معظم وقتهم فً الثرثرة حول نافورة المٌاه 02 للمسإولٌة؟ س1
53
that is appropriate for you. There is no right or wrong
answer but rather what you would feel best suits to finish
the sentence.
نصاب ساعات العمل 01 إنك تتعلم حٌن تصمت ،كما أنك تعطً من ٌعمل معك التنفٌس
المعنوي ،إنك تبث فٌهم الوالء الذي ٌتجاوز كثٌرا 1س5
المتطلبات المادٌة ( 8ساعات فً خمسة أٌام) 02 .....................البلزمة للوظٌفة (أو البلزم للوظٌفة).
"هذا األسبوع؟ "بٌبول" إلى أي برج تنتمً ؟ هل ترى كل هذه االمطار الؽزٌرة؟ هل طالعت مجلة 01 لقاء التعارؾ ببساطة من أكثر الطرق العشوابٌة و الؽٌر منتجة
فعادة تؤخذ الحوارات أشكاال مثل................................ : 1س6
اضاعة الوقت فً السإال عن آخر المستجدات االجتماعٌة و السٌاسٌة و أحوال الطقس 02
ما هو برجك؟ الجو شدٌد الحرارة ألٌس كذلك؟ هل قرأت العدد االخٌر من مجلة سٌدتً؟ 03
سٌطر علٌنا وو بهذه الطرٌقة فإننا ال نعطً هذه المشاكل القوة لت
" (و هو دعاء اشتهر عن جمعٌة مدمنً الكحول الذٌن ٌسعون Alcoholics Anonymousدعاء " نتشرب بالروح التً تنبعث من دعاء " "..................إلهً
01
للتخلص م ن هذا اإلدمان) هبنً الشجاعة ألاؼٌر من األشٌاء التً ٌجب أن تتؽٌرو السكٌنة 1س7
ألقبل األشٌاء التً ال ٌمكن تؽٌٌرها.
المتضرعٌن الملهوفٌن 02
إٌثوز(و ٌعنً إخبلص و سلطة المتحدث) و باثوز(ٌعنً استعطاؾ الجمهور ) و لوقوز (و ٌعنً المنطق لقد كان لقدماء اإلؼرٌق فلسفة رابعة تضمنتها ثبلث كلمات مرتبة
01
و الحقابق التً تدعم حجة المتحدث) فً تتابع منهجً و هً ..........و أزعم أن تلك الكلمات تحتوي 1س8
استعطاؾ الجمهور و المنطق سلطة المتحدث و 02 على جوهر مبدأ السعً أوال للفهم و تقدٌم صورة مإثرة
من ٌبكً بعد خراب مالطا 01 إن اإلدارة دون القٌادة المإثرة هً أقرب ما تكون
إلى ، .................و لن تستطٌع اإلدارة الناجحة أن تعوض
(كما حدث على عدم جدوى االهتمام بتنظٌم الكراسً و المقاعد على ظهر سفٌنة أوشكت على الؽرق فشل القٌادة و ٌعود سبب صعوبة القٌادة إلى أننا ننحرؾ بها و
02 1س9
ظهر سفٌنة تاٌتنك العظٌمة و هً تؽرق) ننؽمس فً تصور ذهنً لئلدارة
عدم جدوى االهتمام بتنظٌم الكراسً و المقاعد على ظهر سفٌنة أوشكت على الؽرق 03
فٌم كنك الرجوع إلى المنزل مرة أخرى(-و ذلك على عكس رواٌة توماس وولؾ التً بعنوان "ال ٌمكنك و شعرنا بؤن أساس استمرار حبنا هو أن نتحدث و خاصة عن
01
ي
العودة إلى المنزل") -إذا كان منزلك عبارة عن عبلقة ثمٌنة و صحبة ؼالة المشاعر وأن نحاول التحدث مع بعصنا البعض كل ٌوم حتى و
20س
إن كنت على سفر ألن ذلك هو أساس السعادة واألمان التً ستعم
فؤنت ستحب العودة إلى المنزل ما دام ٌنتظرك فٌه أناس تربطك بهم عبلقة قوٌة و متٌنة 02
أرجاء المنزل ..................
ألن محبتً لٌسوع 01 أسعى ألن أكون خٌّرا كجار .............ستظهر فً سلوكٌاتً
تجاه اآلخرٌن
ألن إٌمانً و اعتقادي 02 س21
ألن محبتً هلل 03
لٌس هدفه الحصول على جسدي فقط 01 أنا أستحق الزوج المناسب الذي سٌكمل عمره معً ،و نعٌش معا
فً تجربة جمٌلة ،و ٌتعرؾ على شخصٌتً و نكمل بعضنا س22
لٌس هدفه من الزواج الجانب الحسً فقط 02 البعض و..................................
54
التعبٌر األفضل العبارة
.أن تحذؾ تماما من النص عند الترجمة طالما الحذؾ ال ٌخل بالمعنى العام 03
.أن تحذؾ تماما من النص عند الترجمة طالما الحذؾ ال ٌخل بالمعنى العام 01 العبارات التً تحوي بعض االقتباسات من االنجٌل و مقدسات األدٌان األخري
كاالستشهاد بؤقوال القسسٌسٌن و األحبار
.ًأن تستبدل باقتباسات و استشهادات من الدٌن اإلسبلم 02 4س2
.أن تترجم ترجمة حرفٌة 03
.أن تترجم ترجمة حرفٌة 01 ًالعبارات التً تعكس عادات و ممارسات دٌنٌة ؼٌر إسبلمٌة مثل التردد عل
الكنٌسة أو االحتفال بالكرٌسمٌس
.أن تحذؾ تماما من النص عند الترجمة طالما الحذؾ ال ٌخل بالمعنى العام 02 25س
.أن تستبدل باقتباسات و استشهادات من الممارسات و العادات االسبلمٌة إن وجد 03
.أن تحذؾ تماما من النص عند الترجمة طالما الحذؾ ال ٌخل بالمعنى العام 01 ًالعبارات التً تضم أحداث و اقتباسات تارٌخٌة و أدبٌة تخص المجتمع الؽرب
:مثل االستشهاد ببعض القصص التارٌخٌة أو االقتباس من األعمال األدبٌة
.أن تترجم ترجمة حرفٌة 02 26س
.أن تستبدل باقتباسات و استشهادات من التارٌخ و األدب العربً إن وجد 03
Thank you for your time in participating in our research. With your opinion, we continue to progress.
Expression Meaning
01 spend most of their time chatting
But I do not feel any loyalty from them. I think if 02 spend most of their time on useless stuff
Q1
I were home sick for a day, they would……..
03 spend most of their time gabbing at the water fountain
But the process that gets you there is a game, 01 with self-possession
a game that has to be played loose and fun if
Q3 02 without worries and tension
you want to win. You have got to play the
game …….. 03 without sweaty palms
What a difference real understanding can 01 does not fatten and substitute hunger
make! All the well-meaning advice in the
Q4 02 is useless
world ………….. if it does not even address the
real problem. 03 won't amount to a hill of beans
01 “Changing the case is impossible.”
“If somebody is good at one thing, he/she deals with
02
Q5 In the words of Abraham Maslow, …….. other things in the same way.”
“He that is good with a hammer tends to think
03
everything is a nail.”
01 rains me with questions
She ……….. every time I am away. Where did I
Q6 02 interrogates me severely
eat my breakfast? And who else was there?
03 gives me the third degree
55
During the five years I lived in UK, I saw that 01 rushed madly upon by misfortunes twice
country………. Because train conductors were
Q7 02 live crises twice
maliciously obedient in following all the rules
and procedures written on paper. 03 brought twice to its knees
01 „If you want the honey, bear the bees‟ stings‟
……. has validity in some circumstances, but it
„The one who wants to achieve results has to bear the
Q8 is not the essence of an effective exercise 02
difficulties‟
program.
03 „No pain, no gain‟
I do not want you to panic or to feel 01 you missed the marriage train
Q9 that……… but it is time to stop wasting your 02 you have become an old maid
days. 03 you missed the bus
You can create a relationship that 01 help you reach the highest wishes
Q10 will…………..and fulfil the dream you had since 02 fulfil your ambitions
you were a little girl. 03 scratches every itch you have
01 Boredom and routine have sneaked into our marriage.
………… We do not fight or anything. We just
Q11 02 My marriage has lost all excitement.
do not love each other anymore.
03 My marriage has gone flat.
01 hastily or lately
But you will find yourself forced to face the
Q12 02 either now or after a while
reality…..
03 sooner or later
Expression Meaning
I know that some of you ………….. .., “I do not 01 who think old thinking would say
think a life partner to enter into the sanctity of
Q13 marriage is any kind of game.” would say with the Progressiveness of Aunt Bee (who is
02 an American Media personality who presented a TV
show in the 60s)
But if look closely at many of the popular 01 the Dead Sea in Jordan
approaches to growth and self-fulfillment, we 02 the Dead Sea
often find self-centering at their core. There is the Dead Sea in Israel
Q14
a little security, guidance, wisdom, or power in
03
the limited center of self. Like …….. it accepts
but never gives.
When you listen, you learn. And you also give the work load
the people who work for you and with you 01
Q15
the psychological air. You inspire loyalty that
goes well beyond………….. 02 the eight-to-five physical demands of the job
I mean, give me a break, how lame is typical “What is your sign? The weather is hot today, isn‟t it?
01
date rhetoric:…………………………… Have you read the last edition of Sayidati Magazine?”
Wasting time asking about the last political and social
Q16 02
updates and about weather.
"So, what is your sign? Can you believe all this rain? Did
03
you see People magazine this week?"
In this way, we do not empower those 01 the prayer of Unknown Alcoholic addicts
problems to control us. We share in the spirit “The Alcoholic Anonymous prayer,” which is a famous
Q17
embodied in………. “Lord, give me the 02 prayer of the Alcoholic Addicts Society.
courage to change.
The early Greeks had a magnificent ethos (Personal credibility), pathos (emphatic side), and
philosophy which is embedded in three 01 logos (the logic)
Q18
sequential words:…… Personal credibility, emphatic side, and logic
02
56
Efficient management without effective 01 The one who cries after Malta‟s destruction
leadership is, as one individual had phrased it,
It is like straightening chairs on the deck of a sinking ship
Q19 “…………….” 02
(like what happened on the great Titanic)
03 It is like straightening chairs on the deck of a sinking ship
We feel the key to staying in love is to talk You can go home again if it contains people with whom
01
particularly about feelings. We try to you have strong relationships.
Q20 communicate with each other several times You can go home again (opposite to Thomas Wolfe‟s
every day, even when I am traveling. …… 02 novel You Cannot Go Home Again) if it contains people
with whom you have strong relationships.
……… is visible through my actions toward 01 My love of Allah
Q21 others.
02 My faith
03 My love of Christ
I deserve somebody to spend time with me, 01 not to target from marriage the physical side
Q22 share experiences with me, and get to know 02 not to enjoy my body only
me……… 03 not to grab my ass
Expression Meaning
Q23 Sentences that reflect social and ethical To be replaced by our traditions and
01
practices that belong to Western society, customs
like going to night clubs and sexual 02 To be literally translated
relations outside marriage
To be deleted as long as deletion will not
03
affect the general meaning
Q24 Sentences that contain some quotes from To be deleted as long as deletion will not
01
the Bible and holy books of other religions, affect the general meaning
like quoting priests and popes. 02 To be replaced by quotes from Islam
03 To be literally translated
Thank you for your time in participating in our research. With your opinion, we continue to progress.
57
2 - City
Jeddah 50% 100% 0% 49% 50% 51% 48% 37% 58% 33% 50% 49%
Riyadh 50% 0% 100% 51% 50% 49% 52% 63% 42% 67% 50% 51%
3 - Gender
100
50% 50% 51% 0% 46% 55% 51% 49% 67% 55% 46%
Male %
Female 50% 50% 49% 0% 100% 54% 45% 49% 51% 33% 45% 54%
4 - Age
22 – 35 54% 55% 52% 49% 58% 100% 0% 65% 47% 50% 64% 44%
36 – 55 46% 45% 48% 51% 42% 0% 100% 35% 53% 50% 36% 56%
5 - Social Class
100
36% 27% 44% 36% 35% 43% 27% 0% 0% 45% 27%
B %
100
60% 70% 49% 57% 62% 52% 68% 0% 0% 53% 65%
C1 %
100
5% 3% 7% 7% 3% 5% 5% 0% 0% 2% 8%
C2 %
6 - Nationality
100
48% 48% 48% 52% 43% 57% 38% 60% 43% 17% 0%
Saudi %
Exp Arab 52% 52% 52% 48% 57% 43% 63% 40% 57% 83% 0% 100%
7 - Location
Jarir 45% 38% 52% 56% 35% 51% 39% 44% 49% 17% 57% 35%
Obekon 55% 62% 48% 44% 65% 49% 61% 56% 51% 83% 43% 65%
S3 - Educational
Degree
High School 67% 70% 64% 51% 83% 72% 61% 65% 67% 83% 67% 67%
Bachelors 26% 25% 28% 44% 8% 26% 27% 28% 28% 0% 28% 25%
Masters 7% 5% 8% 5% 8% 2% 13% 7% 6% 17% 5% 8%
S5.1 - Type of Novel
Read
Literary 75% 60% 90% 85% 65% 72% 79% 81% 72% 67% 71% 79%
Self & Professional 100 100 100 100 100
100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Development % % % % %
Others 73% 58% 87% 82% 63% 69% 77% 70% 74% 83% 69% 76%
Main Questions
1-
2 - City 3 - Gender 4 - Age 5 - Social Class 6 - Nationality
Total
Jedda Riyad Mal Femal 22 – 36 – Saud Exp
Total B C1 C2
h h e e 35 55 i Arab
BASE: All
121 60 61 61 60 65 56 43 72 6 58 63
Respondents
First Part - Q1
37 36 33
36% 33% 39% 26% 47% 45% 27% 40% 33%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 42 39 50
40% 37% 44% 41% 40% 35% 46% 36% 44%
Paraphrased % % %
21 25 17
23% 30% 16% 33% 13% 20% 27% 24% 22%
Literal Translation % % %
First Part - Q2
42 33 17
36% 25% 46% 28% 43% 40% 30% 34% 37%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 23 38 67
34% 27% 41% 39% 28% 23% 46% 31% 37%
Paraphrased % % %
58
35 29 17
31% 48% 13% 33% 28% 37% 23% 34% 27%
Literal Translation % % %
First Part - Q3
26 43 17
36% 37% 34% 34% 37% 38% 32% 33% 38%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 49 39 17
41% 37% 46% 34% 48% 37% 46% 40% 43%
Paraphrased % % %
26 18 67
23% 27% 20% 31% 15% 25% 21% 28% 19%
Literal Translation % % %
First Part - Q4
28 44 33
38% 42% 34% 43% 33% 43% 32% 41% 35%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 60 49 50
53% 48% 57% 46% 60% 49% 57% 52% 54%
Paraphrased % % %
12 17
9% 10% 8% 11% 7% 8% 11% 7% 7% 11%
Literal Translation % %
First Part - Q5
40 43 33
41% 58% 25% 46% 37% 38% 45% 31% 51%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 53 38 33
43% 28% 57% 28% 58% 46% 39% 52% 35%
Paraphrased % % %
19 33
16% 13% 18% 26% 5% 15% 16% 7% 17% 14%
Literal Translation % %
First Part - Q6
40 46 17
42% 37% 48% 46% 38% 42% 43% 36% 48%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 47 38 33
40% 40% 41% 31% 50% 45% 36% 38% 43%
Paraphrased % % %
14 17 50
17% 23% 11% 23% 12% 14% 21% 26% 10%
Literal Translation % % %
First Part - Q7
30 35 17
32% 28% 36% 25% 40% 31% 34% 29% 35%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 30 35 50
34% 32% 36% 33% 35% 32% 36% 36% 32%
Paraphrased % % %
40 31 33
34% 40% 28% 43% 25% 37% 30% 34% 33%
Literal Translation % % %
First Part - Q8
35 26 33
30% 25% 34% 31% 28% 32% 27% 33% 27%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 47 44 17
44% 33% 54% 36% 52% 45% 43% 41% 46%
Paraphrased % % %
19 29 50
26% 42% 11% 33% 20% 23% 30% 26% 27%
Literal Translation % % %
First Part - Q9
47 40 67
44% 30% 57% 36% 52% 37% 52% 45% 43%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 33 35 33
34% 47% 21% 46% 22% 32% 36% 31% 37%
Paraphrased % % %
21 25
22% 23% 21% 18% 27% 31% 13% 0% 24% 21%
Literal Translation % %
First Part - Q10
35 31 17
31% 30% 33% 26% 37% 35% 27% 29% 33%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 40 40 50
40% 25% 56% 30% 52% 34% 48% 43% 38%
Paraphrased % % %
26 29 33
28% 45% 11% 44% 12% 31% 25% 28% 29%
Literal Translation % % %
First Part - Q11
37 42 67
41% 45% 38% 34% 48% 48% 34% 41% 41%
Arabic equivalent % % %
59
Meaning 37 33 17
34% 30% 38% 33% 35% 29% 39% 31% 37%
Paraphrased % % %
26 25 17
25% 25% 25% 33% 17% 23% 27% 28% 22%
Literal Translation % % %
First Part - Q12
72 67 33
67% 70% 64% 82% 52% 62% 73% 66% 68%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 23 22 50
24% 18% 30% 11% 37% 29% 18% 31% 17%
Paraphrased % % %
11 17
9% 12% 7% 7% 12% 9% 9% 5% 3% 14%
Literal Translation % %
Second Part – Q13
Meaning 65 69 67
68% 80% 56% 61% 75% 71% 64% 60% 75%
Paraphrased % % %
35 31 33
32% 20% 44% 39% 25% 29% 36% 40% 25%
Literal Translation % % %
Second Part – Q14
26 33 67
32% 20% 44% 48% 17% 28% 38% 38% 27%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 74 67 33
68% 80% 56% 52% 83% 72% 63% 62% 73%
Paraphrased % % %
Literal Translation 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Second Part – Q15
77 72 33
72% 75% 69% 56% 88% 78% 64% 71% 73%
Arabic equivalent % % %
23 28 67
28% 25% 31% 44% 12% 22% 36% 29% 27%
Literal Translation % % %
Second Part – Q16
26 26
25% 22% 28% 26% 23% 22% 29% 0% 24% 25%
Arabic equivalent % %
Meaning 60 57 67
59% 62% 56% 56% 62% 65% 52% 57% 60%
Paraphrased % % %
14 17 33
17% 17% 16% 18% 15% 14% 20% 19% 14%
Literal Translation % % %
Second Part – Q17
Meaning 74 74 67
74% 72% 75% 67% 80% 75% 71% 72% 75%
Paraphrased % % %
26 26 33
26% 28% 25% 33% 20% 25% 29% 28% 25%
Literal Translation % % %
Second Part – Q18
Meaning 67 69 67
69% 75% 62% 62% 75% 72% 64% 60% 76%
Paraphrased % % %
33 31 33
31% 25% 38% 38% 25% 28% 36% 40% 24%
Literal Translation % % %
Second Part – Q19
42 33 33
36% 33% 39% 34% 38% 35% 38% 38% 35%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 21 22 50
23% 20% 26% 25% 22% 23% 23% 17% 29%
Paraphrased % % %
37 44 17
40% 47% 34% 41% 40% 42% 39% 45% 37%
Literal Translation % % %
Second Part – Q20
Meaning 70 67 50
67% 68% 66% 51% 83% 72% 61% 59% 75%
Paraphrased % % %
30 33 50
33% 32% 34% 49% 17% 28% 39% 41% 25%
Literal Translation % % %
Second Part – Q21
51 56 17
52% 42% 62% 44% 60% 52% 52% 47% 57%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Meaning 40 33 50
36% 47% 26% 39% 33% 40% 32% 45% 29%
Paraphrased % % %
60
11 33
12% 12% 11% 16% 7% 8% 16% 9% 9% 14%
Literal Translation % %
Second Part – Q22
Meaning 60 58 67
60% 57% 62% 57% 62% 54% 66% 59% 60%
Paraphrased % % %
40 42 33
40% 43% 38% 43% 38% 46% 34% 41% 40%
Literal Translation % % %
Third Part – Q23
16 22 17
20% 20% 20% 3% 37% 23% 16% 26% 14%
Deletion % % %
35 43 33
40% 52% 28% 62% 17% 34% 46% 34% 44%
Literal Translation % % %
49 35 50
40% 28% 52% 34% 47% 43% 38% 40% 41%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Third Part – Q24
28 21
22% 25% 20% 13% 32% 28% 16% 0% 21% 24%
Deletion % %
33 39 67
38% 35% 41% 48% 28% 37% 39% 36% 40%
Literal Translation % % %
40 40 33
40% 40% 39% 39% 40% 35% 45% 43% 37%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Third Part – Q25
40 35 17
36% 43% 28% 26% 45% 43% 27% 38% 33%
Deletion % % %
40 29 67
35% 30% 39% 44% 25% 31% 39% 33% 37%
Literal Translation % % %
21 36 17
30% 27% 33% 30% 30% 26% 34% 29% 30%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Third Part – Q26
21 10
13% 25% 2% 20% 7% 15% 11% 0% 17% 10%
Deletion % %
51 58 67
56% 52% 61% 52% 60% 54% 59% 55% 57%
Literal Translation % % %
28 32 33
31% 23% 38% 28% 33% 31% 30% 28% 33%
Arabic equivalent % % %
Total Scores for the three Strategies
Section 1
Total
Arabic equivalent 40%
Meaning Paraphrased 38%
Literal Translation 22%
Section 2
Total
Arabic equivalent 29%
Meaning Paraphrased 45%
Literal Translation 26%
Section 3
Total
Deletion 23%
Literal Translation 42%
Arabic EQ 35%
61
Appendix 6 Statistical Analysis of the Test and Re-Test Check
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q5 Q6
% Counts % Counts % Counts % Counts % Counts % Counts
73% 11 67% 10 67% 10 80% 12 93% 14 73% 11
Q25_C Q26_C
% Counts % Counts
67% 10 73% 11
33% 5 27% 4
action
Literal Translation the has a TL Equivalent
62
To inflict injury as if by treading
heavily: "trampling on the
to trample on the sacred
feelings of those about you" أن تخوض فً منطقة مقدسة ترعى حول حمى الماكن
ground of another's Page 314 Page 450
Thornton Wilder فً قلب شخص آخر الحساسة
heart
http://www.thefreedictionary.com
/trampling)
to play the game without بدون ٌد مبتلة من العرق و
Page 6 with firm grib and determinism Page 17 بعزٌمة قوٌة
Smart
القلق
Love
sweaty palms
لٌس هذا وقت تجربة األداء
this is no dress rehearsal Page 10 Page 20
أو التدرٌب على العرض
Translatio
ST location intended meaning TT location TL evident
n Strategy
leave him alone and do not
get off his back Page 17 ال تقفوا خلؾ ظهره Page 20 اتركوه و شؤنه
bother him
shake things up, make ٌقلب األشٌاء راسا على
Page 41 Page 56
heads roll ٌدٌر الرإوس،عقب
shape up lazy and كٌؾ تطور موظفٌك
Page 58 improve and turn out Page 82
incompetent employees الكسالى و ؼٌر االكفاء؟
drop hand grenades Page 58 metaphorically أقذفهم بالقنابل الٌدوٌة Page 82
something that you say in order
to tell someone that if their
shape up or ship out Page 58 أصلحهم أو أؼرقهم Page 82
behaviour does not improve,
they will have to leave
(slang: go for) an employee who
gofers page 86 runs errand in addition to regular سعاة Page 121
duties
an original description of a plan
تنتقل باألمر إلى صورة
reduce it to the blueprint Page 99 or idea that explains how it is Page 138
التصمٌم المعماري
expected to work
قم بقٌاساتك مرتٌن لتقطع
measure twice, cut once Page 99 think deeply before acting Page 138
أخشابك مرة واحدة
The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People
marching orders for the give someone their marching و تعطً األوامر الخاصة
Page 99 Page 139
Translatio
ST location intended meaning TT location TL evident
n Strategy
سفح ًاذا عجز الحمار ف
Literal Translation that are Potential to
you can't have the fruit فبل ٌمكنك جنً الثمار دون
Page 186 Page 261 الجبل لم ٌنقل الحمل إلى
without the roots الجذور
أعبله
he that is good with a think in the same pattern and إن الذي فً ٌده مطرقة ٌمٌل
hammer tends to think Page 130 deal with all things in the same إلى الظن بؤن كل ما حوله Page 181
be TL Equivalent
63
Translatio
ST location intended meaning TT location TL evident
n Strategy
you should be sorry for the ًؼٌر أنه فً داخلً تتملكن أعض اصابع الندم و
I'm eating my heart out Page 16 Page 19
choices you have made التعاسة الحسرة
literal meaning but the
get rich quick Page 35 كن ثرٌا حاال Page 48 الثراء السرٌع
expression has a sound effect
more than his pride
Page 37 more than what he can stand أكبر مما ٌتحمله كبرٌاإه Page 50
could swallow
ٌبدو مستعصٌا على
too good to be true Page 54 it is very perfect to be realistic Page 73
التصدٌق
The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People
use control levers Page 55 using control tools استخدام وسابل التحكم Page 77 بٌده مقالٌد األمور
to say that you agree with and
more than giving lip بدال من مجرد الر كون إلى
Page 169 support an idea or plan but not Page 239
service ًالتؤٌٌد اللفظ
do anything to help it to succeed
ترتفع األرباح إلى عنان
Profits skyrocket Page 57 profits rised rapidly Page 80
السماء
التكالٌؾ هً الً ارتفعت
costs skyrocket; profits إلى عنان السماء فً حٌن
Page 57 rise rapidly and fell rapidly Page 81
nose-dive ؼاصت األر باح إلى
األعماق
to actually perform what you
"walk our talk" Page 148 ٌطابق فعلنا كبلمنا Page 207
say you can do
she gives me the third a situation in which someone
degree every time I'm Page 185 tries to find out information by تنزع منً االعترافات Page 260 تحقٌق و استجواب
away asking you a lot of questions.
to upset someone, esp. by
"step on me again. تخطانً مرة أخرى كل
Page 209 getting involved in something Page 294
Everyone does" واحد ٌفعل
that is their responsibility
the managers were المدراء هم الذٌن كانوا
Page 231 get the best Page 327
creaming ٌجنون الثمار
if your performance
Paraphrasing
إذا لم ٌتطابق سلوكك
doesn't square with your Page 238 to agree with something Page 337
الخاص مع سلوكك العام
public performance
our differences are no
a problem which prevents
longer stumbling blocks لن تستمر كؤحجار تعٌق
Page 259 someone from achieving Page 371
to communication and التقدم و التدفق
something
progress
inside-out page 15 and attitudes first then to work on من الباطن إلى الظاهر page 17 من الداخل إلى الخارج
the external
you always reap what you always gain the result of
Page 22 إنك دابما تحصد ما تزرع Page 27
you saw what you have done
a thousand mile journey the long journey needs an إن رحلة األلؾ مٌل تبدأ
Page 37 Page 50 رحلة األلؾ مٌل تبدأ بخطوة
begins with the first step initiative movement بالخطوة األولى
TL Equivalent
doing their own things Page 50 do what they want ٌفعلون ما ٌحلو لهم Page 69
sooner or later Page 77 at some time in the future عاجبل أم آجبل Page 109
to be very involved at the busiest
I get caught up in the و تمسك بتبلبٌبً أمور أؼرق فً تفاصٌل أمور
Page 105 or most active stage of a Page 146
thick of thin things بسٌطة تافهة
situation or activity
تختلط مشاعر الحب و
love-hate over reaction Page 112 mixed opposite feelings Page 155
الكراهٌة معًا
throw more light on brain focus on the wrong aspect while لتلقً مزٌدا من الضوء على
Page 130 Page 182
functioning being in a dangerous status وظابؾ المخ
64
إن المدرسة ال تساوي
schools are for birds Page 246 cultural expression Page 351
شروى نقٌر
we're beating around the ًإننا نضرب أخماسا ف
Page 247 Trying with no sucess Page 352
bush أسداس
you're already miles تكون قد قطعت بالفعل
Page 253 proceed in the future Page 361
down the road شوطا طوببل فً طريقك
to prevent a small problem from الذي ٌقضً على المشكبلت
potential problems can
Page 259 getting worse by stopping it soon ًالكامنة و هً مازالت ف Page 371
be nipped in the bud
after it starts مهدها
on the very edge of
Page 265 على شفا هارٌة الفوضى Page 378
chaos
an idea which shows a lot of
imagination but which is not
a flight of fancy Page 266 مجرد سباحة فً الخٌال Page 379
practical or useful in real
situations
create wedges in the
Page 272 Affect the relationship badly ٌدق إسفٌنا فً عبلقتهما Page 391
relationship
everyone else is buried كل شخص آخر ٌنؽمس
Page 277 Too much busy with details Page 398
by the minutia حتى أذنٌه فً التفاصٌل
إذا أردت جنً العسل تحمل
No pain no gain Page 291 No reward without efforts Page 419
لسع النحل
we can't live without
إننا ال نعٌش كً نؤكل بل "نحن قوم ال نؤكل حتى
eating but we don't live Page 302 Page 435
نؤكل لنعٌش "نجوع و إذا أكلنا ال نشبع
to eat
to expect something to be
we have blindly taken for
Page 315 available all the time and forget أخذناها كؤمر مسلم به Page 452
granted
that you are lucky to have it
pull me out off the lonely Take me out of the bad ٌنتشلنً من الؽرق فً المٌاه
page 2 page 12
water situation الراكدة
وكؤن قطار الزواج أو
missed the bus Page 10 Too old or too late Page 21
Love Smart
االرتباط قد فاتك
walking hand in hand page 45 Happy and accompanied تسٌر و هً متؤبطة ذراع page 60
a dog-eat-dog dating
page 46 Very brutal world عالم الزواج شرس و عنٌؾ page 60
world
خارج مضمار العبلقات
off the hook page 64 page 78
الزوجٌة
Translatio
ST location intended meaning TT location TL evident
n Strategy
my marriage has gone
Page 16 unexciting ًلقد أخفق زواج Page 19
flat
loosened up our old gradually changing our old ومع ارخاء العنان لمعتقداتنا
Page 20 Page 24
perception of our son perception about our son القدٌمة عن ابننا
to improve your situation by your
up-by-the-bootstraps
Page 148 own efforts without any help from و القرٌب من شراك النعل Page 207
efforts
other people
To arrive in a place or situation
wind up sick Page 59 after or because of a course of تعود أدراجك مرٌضا Page 83 تسقط مرٌضا
action
you're wiped out Page 152 to be destroyed ثم تشل قدرتك Page 212 قضً علٌك
The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People
let go Page 169 do not bother yourself with it دعه ٌعمل Page 240 ال تلقً له باال
someone who behaves as if they
or playing little tin god in
Page 188 are more important or powerful و ألعب معك لعبة الكذب Page 264
your life
than they really are
Incorrect Translation
an organized father and كانت نزهة مارسوا فٌها
son outing, complete بعض األلعاب الرٌاضٌة
with gymnastics, مثل المصارعة و تناولوا
Page 192 cultural aspects Page 270
wrestling matches, بعض شطابر السجق و
hotdogs, orangeade, and المشروبات و شاهدوا فٌلما
a movie- the works اسمه العمل- سٌنمابٌا
I carry my battle scars
ربما ساقوم خبلل مفاوضات
with me into any future Page 212 Page 299
المستقٌل بإنزال األذى بك
negotiations
to create an agreement or
let's really hammer it out Page 213 و دعنا نتطبلق إلٌها Page 302
solution to a problem
inwardly they were you should be sorry for the إال أنهم من الداخل تتآكل تحترق قلوبهم حسرة و
Page 219 Page 310
eating their hearts out choices you have made قلوبهم من الؽٌظ ؼٌظا
brought twice to its to destroy or defeat someone or
Page 223 رأٌت هذا البلد ملتزما Page 315
knees something
the ordinary people in a society
we involved people at
Page 230 or political organization and not أن ٌطوروا من األساس Page 325
grass root level
the leaders
would give all the dirty to do the unpleasant or difficult ٌوفرون كل الوظابؾ األقل
Page 231 Page 327
job things شؤنا
that had been built were
Page 282 to be very angry تكاتفوا سوٌا فً مواجهة Page 405
up in arms
becoming an eyesore Page 287 something very ugly و تحوله إلى قذى العٌون Page 405
65
Culturally-Bound Expressions
Translation
ST location intended meaning TT location classification
Strategy
Aesop's fable of the
خرافة عٌسوب حول األوزة (Historical/Liter
goose and the golden Page 52 cultural expression Page 73
و البٌضة الذهبٌة ary)
egg
Well quite literally it is one who
studies forever. You might say
that everyone is in fact an eternal
student. But I am referring to that
type of person who is a
permanent resident in a
university. The perks of staying
in college are numerous--
namely you don't have to pay for
the eternal student your life. Some of the lucky are
Page 59 نموذج الدارس األبدي Page 83 Social
syndrome able to con parents into paying
for their stay at institutes of
higher education, but one can
occasionally trick the
government and other
scholarship organizations into
paying. There are several types
of eternal students ranging from
the truly dedicated to the wild
partier.
Page (Social/Environ
to the "big city" "إلى "المدٌنة الكبٌرة Page 448
312 mental)
Thomas Wolf was wrong. . فقد توماس ولؾ مخطا
The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People
Hollywood scripts Page 80 cultural expression السٌنارٌو الهولٌودي Page 113 social
االهتمام بتنظٌم الكراسً و
like straightening deck Page taking care of something after historical/literar
Literal Translation
المقاعد على ظهر سفٌنة Page 143
chairs on the Titanic 102 being destroyed- uselessness y
أوشكت على الؽرق
a puppet pulled by
Page ًالقٌام بدور الدمٌة الت social/Environm
someone else's strings to Page 154
111 ٌتبلعب بها شخص ental
high proactively
going to and fro in the
world and up and down و التجول فً العالم
in it like Satan, explaining Page كالشبطان و شرح و تجربة
religious concept Page 160 religious
and experiencing 115 كل ما ٌمنحه الؽرور و
whatever Vanity Fair has التباهً من لذة
to offer
terms of active, inactive, وصؾ اآلخرٌن بعبارات
Page
liberal, orthodox or religious expression نشٌط كسول متحرر سلٌم Page 163 religious
117
conservative العقٌدة محافظ
look at the program in تنظر إلى ورقة فً ٌدٌك
Page 96 cultural and religious practice Page 135 social
you hands ...تضم أسماء
like the Dead Sea in Page مثل البحر المٌت الذي ٌاخذ social/environm
cultural aspect Page 164
Israel 118 ًو لكنه ال ٌعط ental
The Pareto principle (also
known as the 80-20 rule, the law
of the vital few and the
principle of factor sparsely)
Page ٌطلق على هذا األمر "مبدأ cultural
The Pareto Principle states that, for many events, Page 218
156 "بارٌتو expression
80% of the effects comes from
20% of the causes. e.g., "80% of
your sales comes from 20% of
your clients."
Page
Sunday to work on it cultural aspect ٌوم األحد النجازه Page 229 social
163
complete with high Page
cultural فرق طلبة المدارس العلٌا Page 325 social
school bands 230
an organized father and كانت نزهة م ارسوا فٌها
son outing, complete with بعض األلعاب الرٌاضٌة
gymnastics, wrestling Page مثل المصارعة و تناولوا
cultural aspects Page 270 social
matches, hotdogs, 192 بعض شطابر السجق و
orangeade, and a movie- المشروبات و شاهدوا فٌلما
the works اسمه العمل- سٌنمابٌا
(Cultural) A usually high-
performance automobile that
Page leads a group of competing cars دور ٌشبه سٌارة تقوم بتعٌٌن
a pace car in the race Page 322 social
227 through the pace lap of a race سرعة العداد فً سباق
but does not participate in the
race.
beyond the eight-to five (ثمانٌة المتطلبات المادٌة
Page
physical demands of the cultural working hours البلزمة ) مقابل خمس ة Page 371 social
259
job للوظٌفة
66
you have to leave the
فإن علٌك أن تهجر عالم
comfort zone of base
Page الراحة فً مستقرك لتواجه social/Environm
camp and confront an cultural concept Page 375
263 ًعالما جدٌدا و مجهوال ف ental
entirely new and
قفار البرٌة
unknown wilderness
Page
daily prayerful meditation cultural religious expression التؤمل و الصلوات الٌومٌة Page 420 religious
292
Christ takes the slums Page ٌخرج هللا األحٌاء الفقٌرة من
religious expression Page 443 religious
out of people 309 الناس
as though there were
مع أنه ٌوجد فطٌرة واحدة
only one pie out there
و إذا أراد شخص،فحسب
and if someone get a big Page
ما الحصول على قطعة Page 309 social
piece of the pie, it would 219
سٌكون ذلك،كبٌرة منها
mean less for everybody
على حساب اآلخرٌن
else
in a place the served فً مكان ٌقدم الخمور لن
liquor would violate his Page 2 social ex ٌجعله ٌتمكن من الحدٌث page 12
parole معً كما ٌجب social
ًو أصبح كالن ساء البلت
those women who dress
ٌجعلن الحٌوانات األلٌفة
up her pets and calls Page 3 social exp. Page 13
ترتدي المبلبس و ٌطلقن
them her "children"
ًعلٌها لقب أطفال social
و بصدد الحصول على
you are about to get your
Page 5 social exp. الحزام األسود فً فن إقامة Page 154
relationship "black belt"
العبلقات الناجحة المثٌرة social
she needs to spend a إنها تحتاج لقضاء المزٌد من
little more time at the Page 7 social exp. ًالوقت فً تناول الطعام ف Page 18
buffet البوفٌه social
Love Smart
Strategy
cultural and religious (is a
alcoholic anonymous worldwide organization of people alcoholic دعاء
page 86 Page 120 social -religious
prayer who share a desire to stop anonymous
drinking alcohol.[1])
The modes of persuasion are
devices in rhetoric that classify
the speaker's appeal to the
Borrowing
audience. They are: ethos,
pathos and logos. Ethos is an
appeal to the authority or
Page honesty of the speaker, Pathos ethos, pathos, and
ethos, pathos, and logos Page 365 Historical
255 is an appeal to the audience’s logos
emotions, Logos is logical
appeal, and the term logic is
derived from it. It is normally
used to describe facts and
figures that support the
speaker's topic.
Translation
ST location intended meaning TT location classification
Strategy
in September and June- -فً شهري سبتمبر و ٌونٌو
Page
the beginning of school cultural expression موعد بدء و انتهاء السنة Page 193 social
139
and the end of school- -الدراسٌة
The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People
67
spiritual beings having a "بشرٌة
human experience."
they had been dating for Page كانا مخطوب ٌن منذ مدة cultural
cultural expression Page 237
a long dating 169 طوٌلة expression
امرأة كبٌرة و مرعبة
"crazy cat woman" that مهووسة بالرجال و ٌخٌم
scares the Page 3 social exp. علٌها شبح العنوسة و Page 13
neighbourhood kids. تخٌؾ أطفال الجٌران و ال
تفعل سوى تربٌة القطط social
زوج أو صدٌق من الجنس
a boyfriend or husband Page 4 social exp. page 15
اآلخر social
getting married is not الزواج لٌس شٌبا حتمٌا
Page 4 social exp. page 15
something you must do ٌنبؽً أن تقومً به social
Love Smart
instead of a bride maid Page 7 social exp. و لٌس وصٌفة العروس Page 17
social
to play the dating game Page 9 social exp. لممارسة لعبة االرتباط Page 20
social
Jeez Louise Page 11 religious expression ! ًٌا إله Page 21
religious
آخر أربع عطبلت نهاٌة
the last four Fridays Page 46 social exp. page 61
األسبوع social
و عضو فً أنشطة دور
a member of my church Page 47 religious and cultural expression page 61
العبادة religious
و هناك نوع آخر من
Angelina Jolie sexpot
Page 54 social exp. الفاتنات مثل الممثلة أنجٌلٌنا page 68
types
ًجول social
Translation
ST location intended meaning TT location classification
Strategy
The basic Judeo-
Page
Christian ethic honours religious expression deleted Page 226 religious
The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People
161
the Sabbath
Handel's Messiah might
Page
rate higher priority than a cultural concept deleted Page 176 social
127
rock concert
Page
good church member religious expression deleted Page 176 religious
127
service or seeking after Page
deleted Page 176 social
material wealth 127
Deletion
of the Judeo-Christian
tradition
the musical Man of La Page
deleted Page 432 social/literary
Mancha 300
servant of Potiphar Page 89 religious concept deleted Page 125 religious
سواء كان المكان أحد
at a nightclub, gym, النوادي أو صالة لؤللعاب
Page 11 social-religious Page 22 religious/social
church or online dating الرٌاضٌة أو المواعدة عبر
االنترنت
الفتٌات الشابات الجمٌبلت و
Love Smart
hot, young, single girls page 45 social-religious ؼٌر المتزوجات أو لسن page 59 religious/social
مخطوبات
trendy nightclubs or new
page 45 social-religious deleted page 59 social
restaurant bars
a Christian page 53 religious concept deleted page 67 religious
you are not Ms. Potato
social-literary page 73 social
Head
Translation
ST location intended meaning TT location classification
Strategy
Page
church centeredness مركز المإسسات الدٌنٌة Page 163 religious
117
The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People
church but inactive in its ًالعبادة و لكنه ال ٌنشط ف Page 163 religious
117 Apostles, which is the central
gospel تطبٌق تعالٌم الدٌن
content of Christian revelation
(slang: go for) an employee who
Page
gofer delegation runs errand in addition to regular التفوٌض اآلمر Page 242 social
173
duties
The term continues to be used in
these specific ways, but it is also
Page used in a more general way to
stewardship delegation التفوٌض بالمسبولٌة Page 242 social
173 refer to a responsibility to take
care of something one does not
own
Page لسنا على إحاطة تامة بكل
we're not omniscient omniscient Page 171 social
123 العلوم
Page ًلقضاء وقت معها مع باق
Christmas family reunion cultural expression Page 389 religious
272 العابلة بمناسبة رأس السنة
Page
Christian religious expression رجل الدٌن Page 189 religious
136
68
a loving Heavenly Father
Page
and that every Goliath religious expression deleted Page 189 religious
136
can be overcome
Page
the love of Christ religious expression محبتً هلل Page 189 religious
136
to share the two little Page لدٌه توجه نخو تقدٌم روح
linguistic-social exp Page 12
words "we" and "us" 136 الجماعة على النزعة الفردٌة social
I am planning on getting
سنتا من ثمن40 سؤوفر
forty cents off a can of Page 3 social exp. Page 14
عبوة سابل التنظٌؾ
Pledge social
your "friend at the و كؤننً الجاسوس ا لخاص
Page 12 Page 23
factory" بك social
little girls who march their
سمعنا كلنا عن الفتٌات
Babies down the "aisle"
Page 13 الصؽٌرات ٌلعبن بدمٌتهن و Page 24
so they can marry their
ٌجعانها تتزوج دمٌة األخ
brothers' G.I. Joes social
if your goal is to get to "I إذا كان هدفك هو أن ٌوافق
do", then you have a ،أي رجل على الزواج منك
different set of standards Page 14 linguistic-social exp سٌكون هناك معاٌٌر مختلفة Page 25
from what you have if عما إذا كان هدفك هو
your goal is "I am" السعادة الزوجٌة social
Jude Law's younger رجل فً قمة الوسامة و
page 45 social exp. page 60
brother األناقة
a dog-eat-dog dating
page 46 social-religious عالم الزواج شرس و عنٌؾ page 60
world social
with all the
progressiveness of Aunt Page 46 history-social ٌفكرن تفكٌرا قدٌما page 60
Bee social/historical
playing the game and ٌمارسون لعبة التعارؾ و
page 46 social-religious page 60
Love Smart
69
9. Which bookstore you prefer, Jarir or Obaikan? Why?
10. Are you happy with the quality of translation? Why or why not?
11. Do you like to read books that are full of cultural concepts that do not relate to
our Saudi and Islamic culture? Example: boyfriend, Christmas, historical
characters, and incidents.
70
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books
Baker, M. 1992. In Other Words: A Coursebook on Translation. Routledge, London and
New York.
Bell, R. 1991. Translation and Translating. Longman. London and New York
Dickins, J, Harvey, S & Hihhins, I. 2002. Thinking Arabic Translation. Routledge,
London and New York.
Carter, R. 1998. Vocabulary: Applied Linguistics Perspectives. 2nd Edition. Routledge,
London and New York.
Catford, J C. 1965. A Linguistic Theory of Translation, London: OUP; Uma Teoria
linguistica da Traducao, Sao Paulo: Cultrix 1980
Coulthard, M. (ed). 1994. Advances in Written Text Analysis. Routledge, London and
New York.
Covey, S. 1989. The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People. Franklin Covey Co. New
York.
Covey, S. 1989. (2006 Trans. Jarir Bookstore). تٞ اىؼبداث اىغبغ ىيْبط األمزش فؼبى. Jarir
Bookstore. Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.
Ghazala, H. 2008. Translation as Problems and Solutions. Dar El-Ilm Lilmalayin.
Lebanon.
Harbi, N. (ed). 2007. Performance of the Arabic Book Translation Industry in Selected
Arab Countries: Egypt, Lebanon, Morocco, Saudi-Arabia and Syria. MPRA
Paper No. 6707, posted 12. January 2008 / 12:44 at http://mpra.ub.uni-
muenchen.de/6707/m
Hatim, B. 2001. Teaching and Researching Translation. Longman. London.
Hatim, B. and Mayson, I. 1997. The Translator as Communicator. Routledge.
Holmes, J. 2001. An Introduction to Sociolinguistics. 2nd Edition. Longman.
McGraw, P. 2005. Love Smart. Free Press.
Newmark, P. 1988. A Textbook of Translation. New York: Prentice Hall International.
Toury, G. 1995. Descriptive Translation Studies and Beyond. John Benjamin Publishing
Company.
71
Venuti, L. (ed) 2000. The Translation Studies Reader. Routledge. New York and London.
Articles
Abu-Risha, M. 2008. ‗Investigating Ethnolinguistic Theory across Language‘ in The
Journal of Specialized Translation. Issue:9, January 2008.
Abu-Ssaydeh, A. 2004. ‗Translation of English Idioms into Arabic‘ in Babel, Vol:50,
Issue:2.
Al-Dammad, A. 1999-2008. ‗Domestication vs. Foreignization in English-Arabic
Translation‘. ProZ.com Translation Article Knowledgebase at
http://www.proz.com/doc/1643 visited on July 25, 2008.
Armellino, E. 2008. ‗Translating Culture-Bound Elements in Subtitling—An Example of
Interlinguistic Analysis: A Scene from Scent of a Woman‘ in TranslationJournal,
Vol:12, No:2. Available at http://accurapid.com/Journal/44culturebound.htm
Gahzala, H. 2004. ‗Stylistic-semantic and Grammatical Functions of Punctuation in
English-Arabic Translation‘ in Babel, Vol:50, Issue:3 (2004), pp. 230–245. ISSN:
0521–9744.
Hale, S & Campbell, S. 2006. ‗The Interaction between Text Difficulty and Translation
Accuracy‘ in Babel, Vol:48, Issue:1, pp. 14-33.
Homeidi, M. A. 2004. ‗Arabic Translation Across Cultures‘ in Babel, Vol:50, Issue:1,
pp.13–27.
Jaber, A. 2001. ‗Arab Translators‘ Problems at the Discourse Level‘ in Babel, Vol:47
Issue:4, pp.304–322.
Karamanian, A P. 2002. ‗Translation and Culture‘ in Translation Journal, Vol:6, No. 1.
Available at http://accurapid.com/journal/19culture2.htm
Mohammed, A H. and Omer, M R. 2000. ‗Texture and Culture: Cohesion as a Marker of
Rhetorical Organization in Arabic and English Narrative Texts‘ in RELC Journal,
Vo:.31, 45.
Mahmoud, A. 2002. ‗Interlingual Transfer of Idioms by Arab Learners of English‘ in
Internet TESL Journal, Vol:viii, No:12, December 2002.
72
Sa‘Addin, M. 1999. ‗Towards a Viable Applied Linguistic Theory of Translation: An
Ethnolinguistic Point of View‖. Translation in Performance. Department of
Modern Languages, University of Bradford. Bradford, West Yorkshire.
Sánchez, M T. 2007. ‗Translation and Sociolinguistics: Can Language Translate
Society?‖ in Babel, Vol:53, Issue:2, pp.123–131.
Teilanyo, D I. 2007. ‗Culture in Translation: The Example of J. P. Clark‘s The Ozidi
Saga‘ in Babel, Vol:53, Issue:1, pp.1–21.
Dictionaries
Trrefry, D. ed. 2006. Collins English Dictionary. HarperCollins Publishers. Glasgow,
UK.
Al-Mawrid Arabic-English Dictionary. 2004. Dar Al-Elm Lilmalayin, Lebanon.
Al-Mawrid English-Arabic Dictionary. 2004. Dar Al-Elm Lilmalayin, Lebanon
http://www.dictionary.com
Longman Idioms Dictionary. 1998. UK: Longman, England.
Oxford Idioms Dictionary. 2000. Oxford University Press
Oxford Wordpower English-English-Arabic Dictionary. 2004. Oxford University Press
The American Heritage Dictionary. 1985. Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston.
www.thefreedictionary.com
73