Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Technical Report
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The electromechanical behavior of a pressure vessel grade steel A516 has been investigated using poten-
Received 10 March 2011 tiodynamic polarization curves and slow strain rate test (SSRT) in simulated environment of pressurized
Accepted 20 May 2011 water reactor. The anodic polarization behavior shows that the steel remains active in the solution till
Available online 25 May 2011
localized attack (pitting) starts. The cracks initiated at the surface propagate in a trans-granular mode.
These cracks are initiated at the inclusion (MnS) sites and at the interfaces between local anode (ferrite)
and local cathode (pearlite). It seems that the ultimate fracture occurs when the propagating surface
cracks join the subsurface hydrogen induced cracks. The addition of oxygen in the testing chamber to
supersaturation levels shifts the corrosion potential to anodic side and significantly lowers the strength
and ductility. Compared to the room temperature properties, the UTS and tensile elongation in various
simulated conditions are reduced by 10–25% and 25–75%, respectively.
Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction fects of corrosion and corrosion related phenomenon e.g. HIC and
SCC. One such controlling factor is the dissolved gaseous content
Steel is the most commonly used structural metal and has a of the solution [4–7]. Corrosion is an electrochemical process and
wide range of alloys for specific engineering applications. One of proceeds with the formation of local anodes and cathodes at the sur-
the important applications of steels is in the fabrication of pressure face exposed to the corrosive medium. At equilibrium, the rate of
vessels. Because of the high pressures that these vessels retain, the anodic reaction (oxidation) is equal to the rate of cathodic reaction
pressure vessel grade steels must meet the stringent requirements (reduction). In aqueous environments, the reduction reaction con-
of high notch toughness and strict low limits for allowable imper- sists of oxygen reduction reaction. An increase in the dissolved oxy-
fections. One of the widely used pressure grade steel is A516 G-70 gen contents increases the rate of reduction reaction (O2 +
which contains Mn as principal alloying element. Manganese is 2H2O + 4e ? 4OH ) and thereby the corrosion potential of the sys-
normally present in all commercial steels due to its multiple ben- tem. Since, the corrosion potential is decided at the point where the
efits. It deoxidizes the melt and facilitates hot working of the steel current produced by oxidation is totally used by the reduction reac-
by reducing the susceptibility to hot shortness. Mn also contributes tion; an increase in the dissolved oxygen contents increases the cor-
in strength and hardness, and has a strong effect on the hardenabil- rosion potential, which is the driving force for the corrosion reaction.
ity of steel. A516 has the highest strength and ductility among Cáceres et al. observed the presence of a critical dissolved oxygen
other pressure vessel steels (containing slightly lower levels of content which separates the two distinct regions of high and low
Mn but relatively higher levels of S); moreover, it gives the longest corrosion rates. At this critical oxygen content, the corrosion current
time to fracture in corrosive environments [1]. Recent studies on density, corrosion potential and hydrogen evolution rate are signif-
this alloy show strong dependence of mechanical and corrosion icantly increased [8]. The dissolved oxygen contents also affect the
properties on morphology of ferrite [2,3]. composition of the corrosion products that is formed [9]. In pearlitic
The pressure vessel grade steel used in pressurized water reactor steels, depending upon the dissolved oxygen contents, the pseudo-
(PWR) must meet an additional requirement of low susceptibility to passive range may be replaced with the active or passive range
SCC and HIC in the working environment. The fracture toughness [10]. A removal of oxygen from the solution also lowers the suscep-
(KIc) values drop significantly when the material under stress is also tibility to stress corrosion cracking (SCC) [11].
exposed to the aqueous environment in which electro-chemical The air contains about 209 ppm volume oxygen in gaseous
reactions can take place. The water chemistry in such applications form. Due to which, air readily oxidizes the elements in materials
is carefully maintained within the safe regimes to minimize the ef- which have strong thermodynamic affinity to form oxides. The oxi-
dation process is particularly enhanced at higher temperatures.
The amount of oxygen that is dissolved in water or any other liquid
⇑ Corresponding author. Tel.: +92 51 2207 226; fax: +92 51 2207 374.
depends upon the partial pressure of oxygen in equilibrium with
E-mail address: shahzad@pinstech.org.pk (M. Shahzad).
0261-3069/$ - see front matter Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.matdes.2011.05.034
M. Shahzad et al. / Materials and Design 32 (2011) 5154–5158 5155
that liquid, as per the famous Henry’s law. At room temperature Table 1
and atmospheric pressure the saturated dissolved oxygen content The chemical composition of the alloys used in study.
Table 2
The corrosion potentials and corrosion rates (from tafel slopes) measured at room
temperature by electrochemical corrosion cell (i–iii); and the corrosion potentials
measured during slow strain rate tests at 300 °C using an external electrode (iv–vi).
Stress (MPa)
ening rate (curves 3–5 in Fig. 3). In comparison to room tempera- 4
ture properties, the UTS drops by almost 50 MPa (10% drop) and 5 2
300
strain to fracture is reduced to 0.1 (50% drop) under PWR simu- 1 Air, Room temp.
lated conditions. The UTS and elongation values are further 200 2 Air, 300OC
dropped if the testing container is supersaturated with oxygen to 3 Soln (8 ppm), 300OC
45 ppm or 90 ppm levels. In the latter case, the UTS is dropped 100 4 Soln (45 ppm), 300OC
by 175 MPa (35% drop) and strain to fracture is dropped to 0.05 5 Soln (90 ppm), 300OC
(75% drop). All relative drops in percentages are with respect to 0
room temperature properties in air. The corrosion potential mea- 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3
sured at SSRT testing conditions using CORTESTÒ external refer- Strain
ence electrode show that oxygen purging shifts the potential to
Fig. 3. Stress strain curves of the slow strain rate tests conducted in air and solution
anodic side. The potential shifts from 623 mV to 434 mV and under slow strain rate conditions.
322 mV (all potentials against SCE), when the oxygen contents
are increased from saturated level (8 ppm) to 45 ppm and
90 ppm, respectively. exposed to the simulated environment, the rate of strain hardening
The sharp yield point is widely credited to the pinning of mov- at 300 °C is even higher than that of at the room temperature. This
ing dislocations by their environments usually the solute elements. is due to the additional hindrance to the moving dislocations by
An extra amount of stress is required for dislocations to break this the adsorption of H which is produced during cathodic part of
environmental barrier and once the plastic deformation starts the electrochemical corrosion reactions occurring at the surface
there is a little bit drop in stress. At 300 °C, the movements of dis- of the exposed sample [20]. Infact, strain-hardening and an homog-
locations require a lower critical resolved shear stress and the enous or localized strain rate are necessary for environmentally as-
environmental pinning is usually not that effective. Thus, under sisted cracks to initiate and propagate [21]. The addition of oxygen
PWR simulated conditions, the transition from elastic to plastic into the system increases the rate of cathodic reaction, thus pro-
range is a gradual one. Once the plastic deformation starts, the dis- ducing more hydrogen to be absorbed, which raises the rate of
locations pile up at the grain boundaries and further slip on these strain hardening with the increase in oxygen contents. Moreover,
planes requires a higher stress resulting in strain hardening. At the increased corrosion activity increases the rates of initiation
300 °C, the thermal energy allows the piled up dislocations to and propagation of surface crack by enhancing the dissolution of
move to other planes and allow further deformation at lower stress inclusions and other local anodic sites at surface, and the exposed
than that is required at room temperature. However, when surfaces of the propagating cracks, respectively [22,23].
2 200 ppm B
3 1000 ppm B
1.0 -0.50
0.5
0.0
-0.75
-0.5
-1.0
-1.5 -1.00
1E-3 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 1E-5 1E-4 1E-3 0.01 0.1 1 10
Current density (A/m2) Current density (A/m2)
Fig. 2. The electrochemical behavior of the alloy in simulated PWR condition (a) anodic polarization behavior and (b) effect of boron concentration on tafel slope.
M. Shahzad et al. / Materials and Design 32 (2011) 5154–5158 5157
Fig. 4. Secondary cracks analysis of the steel after SSRT test. (a) Optical micrograph showing the longest crack observed, (b) SEM image showing crack propagation along the
parallel ferrite–pearlite bands by connecting the pits formed in SSRT and (c) EDX analysis showing increased levels of Mn and S around the pits visible in SEM image.
Fig. 5. The fractographs of the specimen tested in (a) air at room temperature, (b) solution saturated with oxygen (8 ppm) at 300 °C, (c) solution containing 45 ppm of purged
oxygen at 300 °C and (d) 90 ppm of purged oxygen at 300 °C.
5158 M. Shahzad et al. / Materials and Design 32 (2011) 5154–5158
propagate until they meet the internal (HIC) cracks. A comparison [5] Lou X, Singh PM. Heterogeneous corrosion behaviour of carbon steel in water
contaminated biodiesel. Corros Sci 2010;52:2303–15.
of Fig. 5b–d shows that with the increase in oxygen concentration,
[6] Terachi T, Yamada T, Miyamoto T, Arioka K, Fukuya K. Corrosion behavior of
the depth of surface cracks and the severity of HIC increases. stainless steels in simulated PWR primary water – effect of chromium content
in alloys and dissolved hydrogen. J Nucl Sci Technol 2008;45:975–84.
doi:10.3327/jnst.45.97.
4. Conclusions [7] Skeldon P, Scott PM, Hurst P. Environmentally assisted cracking of alloy X-750
in simulated PWR coolant. Corrosion, vol. 48. NACE International; 1992 [paper
(1) Electrochemical corrosion testing shows that A516 remains no. 92070553].
[8] Cáceres L, Vargas T, Parra M. Study of the variational patterns for corrosion
electrochemically active in the simulated coolant till pitting kinetics of carbon steel as a function of dissolved oxygen and NaCl
occurs at pitting potential. Moreover, the results show slight concentration. Electrochim Acta 2009;54:7435–43.
increase in corrosion rate with the increase in boron [9] Baek W-C, Kang T, Sohn H-J, Kho YT. In situ surface enhanced Raman
spectroscopic study on the effect of dissolved oxygen on the corrosion film on
concentration.
low carbon steel in 001 M NaCl solution. Electrochim Acta 2001;46:2321–5.
(2) Although, the room temperature corrosion rate measured by [10] Prozorov VV. Behavior of pearlitic steels in oxygen containing water. Prot Met
electrochemical corrosion testing in the simulated PWR 2004;40:121–4.
[11] Maeng WY, Choi MS, Kim UC. Effect of dissolved oxygen on PWSCC
coolant is in general low, the SSRT results show a significant
susceptibility of alloy 600 in high temperature water. J Mater Sci
loss of strength and ductility due to hydrogen induced 2004;39:655–7.
embrittlement which leads to environmentally assisted [12] Baranenko VI, Fal’kovskii LN, Kirov VS, Kurnyk LN, Musienko AN, Piontkovskii
cracking (EAC). AI. Solubility of oxygen and carbon dioxide in water. Atom Energy
1990;68:342–6.
(3) Purging the testing chamber with oxygen shifts the corro- [13] Wagner W, Pruss A. International equations for the saturation properties of
sion potential to anodic sides by 300 mV in the tested oxy- ordinary water substance. Revised according to the international temperature
gen level range (8–90 ppm). The increased corrosion scale of 1990. J Phys Chem Ref Data 1993;22:783–7.
[14] Saltykov SN, Tarasova NV. Anodic dissolution of ferrite phases from iron-
activity at this potential produces more hydrogen during carbon ferrite–cementite alloys with different forms of cementite. Prot Met
cathodic reaction which causes increased strain hardening 2006;42:501–6.
and significant loss of ductility (25–75%) in the tested range. [15] Tarasova NV, Saltykov SN. Specifities of forming electrochemical dissolution
zones at ferrite–cementite-structured alloys in sulfuric acid solutions. Prot
In comparison, an increase in boron concentration (100– Met 2007;43:231–4.
1000 ppm) has relatively much smaller effect on the corro- [16] Matsumura M. The possibility for formation of macro-cell corrosion in a liquid
sion potential. with low electrical conductivity. Mater Corros 2011;62:449–53.
[17] Qiao YX, Zheng YG, Okafor PC, Ke W. Electrochemical behaviour of high
(4) The EAC proceeds with the crack initiation at micropits
nitrogen bearing stainless steel in acidic chloride solution: effects of oxygen,
formed at the specimen surface due to the oxidation of acid concentration and surface roughness. Electrochim Acta
MnS inclusions and localized corrosion at the ferrite–pearl- 2009;54:2298–304.
[18] Park J-H, Chopra OK, Natesan K, Shack WJ, Cullen Jr W. Boric acid corrosion of
ite interface. The surface cracks propagate in the transgran-
light water reactor pressure vessel materials. In: Allen TR, King PJ, Nelson L,
ular mode. The ultimate fracture occurs when the editors. Environmental degradation of materials in nuclear power system–
propagating surface cracks meet the subsurface cracks water reactors. TMS (The Minerals, Metals & Materials Society); 2005.
formed by the diffused hydrogen. [19] Janit P. The effects of boric acid on corrosion of steels in simulated pressurized
water reactor primary coolant. PhD dissertation. No. NR49823, University of
New Brunswick; 2007.
[20] Cabrini M, Pastore T. Hydrogen diffusion and EAC of pipeline steels under
Acknowledgments cathodic protection. In: Gdoutos EE, editor. Fracture of nano and engineering
materials and structures. Proceedings of the 16th European conference of
fracture. Alexandroupolis, Greece; July 3–7, 2006. doi:10.1007/1-4020-4972-
The authors acknowledge the support of IAEA in conducting this 2_498.
study through TCP Project PAK/04/046. The authors gratefully [21] Couvant T, Legras L, Vaillant F, Boursier JM, Rouillon Y. Effect of strain-
hardening on stress corrosion cracking of AISI 304L stainless steel in PWR
acknowledge Mr. Muhammad Akram for allowing experiments primary environment at 360 °C. In: Allen TR, King PJ, Nelson L, editors.
on electrochemical corrosion testing instrument. Authors are also Environmental degradation of materials in nuclear power system–water
thankful to Mr. Mohammad Masood and Mr. Amir Alam for reactors. TMS (The Minerals, Metals & Materials Society); 2005.
[22] Chopra OK, Shack WJ. Effects of LWR coolant environments on fatigue design
performing SCC tests and metallography, respectively.
curves of carbon and low alloy steels. NUREG/CR-6583. Argonne National
Laboratory report ANL-97/18.
References [23] Dong Yang. Factors affecting stress assisted corrosion cracking of carbon steel
under industrial boiler conditions. PhD dissertation. Georgia Institute of
[1] Arsenault B, Ghali E. Stress corrosion cracking of pressure vessel welded Technology, Atlanta, GA; 2008.
carbon steels. Int J Pres Ves Pip 1991;45:23–41. [24] Toribio J, Ovejero E. Microstructure-based modelling of localized anodic
[2] Deen KM, Ahmad R, Khan IH, Farahat Z. Microstructural study and dissolution in pearlitic steels. Mater Sci Eng A 2001;319–321:308–11.
electrochemical behavior of low alloy steel weldment. Mater Des [25] Huang H-H, Tsai W-T, Lee J-T. Cracking characteristics of A516 steel weldment
2010;31:3051–5. in H2S containing environments. Mater Sci Eng A 1994;188:219–27.
[3] Lah NAC, Ali A, Ismail N, Chai LP, Mohamed AA. The effect of controlled shot [26] Huang H-H, Tsai W-T, Lee J-T. Corrosion morphology of A516 carbon steel in
peening on fusion welded joints. Mater Des 2010;31:312–24. H2S solution. Scr Metall Mater 1994;31:825–8.
[4] Garcia-Arriaga V, Alvarez-Ramirez J, Amaya M, Sosa E. H2S and O2 influence on
the corrosion of carbon steel immersed in a solution containing 3 M
diethanolamine. Corros Sci 2010;52:2268–79.