Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AND AQUACULTURE
has been labeled by some as "zeo-agriculture." shown in figure 1. This arrangement of silicate
Most of the past activities in zeo-agricuhure tetrahedra reduces the overall Si:0 ratio to 2:1,
have taken pierce in Japan where farmers have and if each tetrahedron in the framework
used zeolite rock for years to control the contains silicon as the cation, the structures
moisture content and malodor of manure and are electrically neutral, as is quartz (Si02). In
to increase the pH of acidic volcanic soils. The zeolite structures, however, some of the quadri-
growing awareness of the abundance and avail- valent silicon is replaced by trivalent alumi-
ability of inexpensive natural zeolites in the num, giving rise to a deficiency of positive
United States has prompted considerable inter- charge. This charge is balanced by the presence
est, and zeolites are becoming the subject of of mono- and divalent cations, such as Na +,
serious agricultural experimentation around the Ca ++, and K +, elsewhere in the structure. Thus,
country. Some of the ways in which zeolite the oxide empirical formula of a zeolite is of
minerals can contribute to more efficient live- the type:
stock and crop production are discussed here,
M2/n0"A1203"xSi02"yH20
along with their role in the rapidly expanding
areas of fish breeding and aquaculture. At this where M is any alkali or alkaline earth cation, n
stage in its development, the number of papers is the valence of that cation, x is a number from
on "zeo-agricuhure" in the literature is small, 2 to 10, and y is a number from 2 to 7. The
and hard data are few; however, despite these oxide and unit-cell formulae of clinoptilolite,
drawbacks, the potential of zeolite raw mate- the most common of the natural zeolites,
rials seems apparent, and may be of intcrest to follow:
many in the field of agricultural technology. (Na,K)20. A1203 910Si02 96H20
or
N A T U R A L ZEOLITES
(Na4K 4) (A18Si40)096.24H20.
Zeolites are crystalline, hydrated aluminosili- Ions within the first set of parentheses in the
cates of alkali and alkaline earth cations, having unit-ceil formula are known as exchangeable
infinate, three-dimensional structures. They are cations; those within the second set of paren-
further characterized by an ability to lose and theses are called structural cations, because
gain water reversibly and to exchange constitu- with oxygen they make up the tetrahedral
ent cations without major change of structure. framework of the structure. Loosely bound
Zeolites were discovered in 1756 as well-formed molecular water is also present in the structures
crystals in cavities of basal rock by Baron Axel of all natural zeolites.
Fredrick Cronstedt, a Swedish mineralogist, Whereas the framework structures of quartz
who named them from the Greek words ~ew
and Xt0oo, meaning "boiling stones," in allusion
to their peculiar frothing characteristics when
heated before the blowpipe. Since that time,
nearly 40 natural species have been recognized,
and an equal number have been synthesized in
the laboratory. Synthetic zeolites are the main-
stays of the muhimillion dollar molecular sieve
businesses that have blossomed in the last 15
years in this and other countries. The potential
applications of both synthetic and natural
zeolites stem, of course, from their fundamen- 0
tal physical and chemical properties, which in
Si
turn are related directly to their individual
crystal structures and chemical compositions.
Crystal Structure of Zeolites. Along with
quartz and feldspar minerals, zeolites are tekto-
Silicates, that is, they consist of three-dimen-
sional frameworks of Si04 a tetrahedra, where- Figure 1. Three-dimensional arrangement of silicate
in all four corner oxygen ions of each tetra- tetrahedra in tektosilicates. Crystal structure of the
hedra are shared with adjacent tetrahedra, as beta-tridymite form of SiO 2 .
1190 MUMPTON AND FISHMAN
Representative Ion-
unit-cell Void Channel Thermal exchange
Zeolite formula a volume a dimensions a stability capacity b
Analcime Nal e (All 6 Si3 ~ O96.16HaO 18% 2.6 /~ High 4.54 meq/g
Chabazite (Na2 ,Ca)e (All 2 Si24 O~ ~).4OH20 47 3.7 X 4.2 High 3.81
Clinoptilolite (Na, K4 )(AlsSi 40 096 )'2411a O 39? 3.9 X 5.4 High 2.54
Erionite (Na, Ca.s,K)9 (AIgSia ~O~ 2)~ 35 3.6 X 5.2 High 3.12
Faujasite Nas s(AIs aSit ~40~ 84)'2711aO 47 7.4 High 3.39
Ferrierite (Na2Mg2)(Ale Si3 oOr 2) ~ aO 4.3 x 5.5 High 2.33
3.4 X 4.8
Heulandite Ca4 (AIs Si: s O~ 2 )" 24112 O 39 4.0 • 5.5 Low 2.91
4.4X 7.2
4.1 • 4.7
Laumontite Ca4 (Als Sit 6 04 s)'161120 4.6 X 6.3 Low 4.25
Mordenite NaB (AIs Si4 o 096 )" 24112 O 28 2.9 • 5.7 High 2.29
6.7 X 7.0
Phillipsite (Na,K)1 o(AIt 0Si22064)'201t20 31 4.2 X 4.4 Low 3.87
2.8 X 4.8
3.3
l.inde A Na t 2(A112Si~ 204 s ) . 2 7 H 2 0 47 4.2 High 5.48
Linde X Nas6 (A186 Six 06 0384 )" 264Ha O 50 7.4 High 4.73
aTaken mainly from Breck, 1974; Meier and Olson, 1971. Void volume is determined from water content.
bCalculated from unit-cell formula.
2 2b
Figure 2. Simple polyhedron of silicate and aluminate tetrahedra. (a) Ball and peg model of truncated cubo-
octahedron. (b) Line drawing of truncated cubo-octahedron;lines connect centers of tetrahedra.
ZEOLITES IN ANIMAL SCIENCE AND AQUACULTURE 1191
zeolites over CHa, providing a means by which its cation selectivity is:
impure natural gas or methane streams can be Cs > Rb > K > NH4 > Ba > Sr >
upgraded to high-BTU products. In addition,
the small, but finite, quadripole moment of N2 Na > Ca > Fe > Al > Mg > Li (Ames, 1960)
allows it to be adsorbed selectively from air, Thus, clinoptilolite has a decided preference for
producing oxygen-enriched streams at relatively larger cations, and its selectivity for NH4 + ions
low costs. Both of the above processes may find was exploited by Ames (1967) and Mercer et al.
application in agricultural technology (vide (1970) in the development of an ion-exchange
infra). process for the removal of ammoniacal nitrogen
lon-Exchange Properties. The exchangeable from municipal sewage. This same affinity of
cations of a zeolite are also only loosely bonded clinoptilolite for NH4 +, of course, is the basis
to the tetrahedral framework and can be of many of the uses of this zeolite that are
removed or exchanged easily by washing with a being developed in the agricultural field.
strong solution of another ion. As such, crystal-
line zeolites are some of the most effective ion ANIMAL-HUSBANDRY APPLICATIONS
exchangers known to man, with capacities of 3
to 4 meq per gram being common. Ion-ex-
Animal Nutrition
change capacity is basically a function of the
degree of substitution of aluminum for silicon Since 1965, experiments have been in pro-
in the framework structures; the greater the gress in Japan on the use of natural zeolites as
substitution, the greater the charge deficiency, dietary supplements for poultry, swine and
and the greater the number of alkali or alkaline cattle. Based on the successful use of montmo-
earth cations required for electrical neutrality. rillonite clay in slowing down the passage of
In practice, however, the ion-exchange capacity nutrients in the digestive system of chickens
is dependent on a number of other factors as and the resultant improvement in caloric effi-
well. In certain species, cations can be trapped ciency, as reported by Quisenberry (1968),
in structural positions that are relatively inac- clinoptilolite and mordenite have been added to
cessible, thereby reducing the effective ex- the normal protein diets of pigs, chickens, and
change capacity of that species for that ion. ruminants at several agricultural stations and
Also, ion-sieving may take place if the size of livestock farms in Japan. Significant increases in
the exchanging cation is too large to pass the gain of body weight per unit of feed
through the entry channels into the central consumed (feed efficiency) and in the "general
cavities of the structure. Analcime, for exam- health" of the animals have been achieved
ple, will exchange almost completely its Na + (Minato, 1968).
for Rb + (ionic radius = 1.49/~), but not at all Poultry. Using clinoptilolite from the Itaya
for Cs+ (ionic radius -- 1.65 A) (Breck, 1974). mine, Yamagata Prefecture, and mordenite
Unlike most non-crystalline ion exchangers, from Karawago, Miyagi Prefecture, Onagi
such as organic resins or inorganic aluminosili- (1966) found that Leghorn chickens required
cate gels (mislabeled in the trade as 'zeolites'), less food and water and still gained as much
the framework of a crystalline zeolite dictates weight in a 2-week trial as birds receiving a
its selectivity towards competing ions. The control diet. Feed efficiency ratios (weight
hydration sphercs of high field-strength ions gain/feed intake) 4 were markedly higher at all
prevent their close approach to the seat of levels of zeolite substitution; feedstuffs contain-
charge in the framework; therefore ions with ing 10% zeolite giving rise to efficiencies more
low field strengths are more tightly held and than 20% greater than those of normal rations
selectively exchanged than other ions. The (table 2). Adverse effects on the health or
small amount of aluminum in clinoptilolite, for vitality of the birds were not noted, and the
example, results in a relatively low ion-ex- droppings of groups receiving zeolite diets
change capacity (about 2.3 meq/g); however, contained up to 25% less moisture than those
of control groups, after a 12-day drying period,
making them considerably easier to handle.
Arscott s found that broiler chickens fed a
4 Excluding zeolite.
SArscott, G. H. 1975, 1976. Dept. Poul. Sci., diet of 5% clinoptilolite from the Hector,
Oregon State Univ., Corvallis, (Personal communica- California, deposit gained slightly less weight
tion). over a 2-month period than birds receiving a
ZEOLITES IN ANIMAL SCIENCE AND AQUACULTURE 1193
Feed
Zeolite Avg Avg Avg Avg effi-
Group content starting final weight feed ciency
no. of rations wt wt gain intake b ratio c
aonagi (1966). Tests carried out on 48-day-old Leghorns over a 14-day period, 30 birds/group. Normal
rations consisted of 16.5% crude protein and 66% digestible nutrients.
bExcluding zeolite.
CFeed efficiency = weight gain/feed intake (excluding zeolite).
dcp = clinoptilolite ; Mo = mordenite.
Avg Survivors
Treatment Avg consump- Avg of
data weight tion b F.E.V. c 48 birds
4-week data d
Control diet 730g 1175g .622 46
Control diet + zntibiotic f 708g 1116g .634 47
Control diet with 5% clinoptilolite 703g 1070g .657 48
8-week data e
Control diet 1869g 3978g .470 45
Control diet + antibiotics f 1882g 3869g .486 46
Control diet with 5% clinoptilolite 1783g 3647g .489 48
Avgb Zeolite
Age of pigs Average weight Avg feed AvgC improve-
Group Start Finish Start Finish wt. gain intake F.E.V. ment
aKondo and Wagai (1968). Tests carried out using 5% clinoptilolite in rations of experimental groups.
bExcluded zeolite.
C
Feed efficiency value = weight gain/feed intake.
dEight Yorkshire pigs.
e . .
Twenty Yorkshire pigs.
to young pigs, but only about 6% greater when showed that the death rate and incidence of
given to older animals. All pigs on the zeolite disease among animals fed a diet containing 6%
diet displayed polished hair and slightly reddish clinoptilolite was markedly lower than for
skin. In addition, the particle size of the feces control animals in experiments conducted over
of the control group was noticeably coarser a 12-month period. As shown in table 5, the
than that of the experiment group, suggesting decrease in the number of cases of gastric
that the digestive process was more thorough ulcers, pneumonia, heart dilation, and in the
when zeolites were added to the diet. The feces overall mortality rate is remarkable. The savings
of animals in the control group were also richer in medicine alone amounted to about 75~ per
in all forms of nitrogen than zeolite-fed ani- animal, to say nothing of the increased value of
mals, indicating that the zeolites contributed a larger number of healthy pigs. Although no
towards a more efficient conversion of feed- control groups were monitored, Morita (1967)
stuff nitrogen to animal protein. Han e t al. reported that the addition of zeolite to the diet
(1975, 1976) found that the digestibility of of piglets severely afflicted with scours marked-
crude protein and nitrogen-free extracts tended ly reversed the progress of this disease within a
to be improved as zeolite was substituted for few days. Four underdeveloped Laundry pigs
wheat bran in swine diets at levels from 1 to 6% were fed a diet containing 30% zeolite for the
over a 12-week period. first 15 days and 10% zeolite for the remaining
Toxic or other adverse effects were not part of a month-long experiment. The severity
noted for any of the test animals described of the disease decreased almost at once, and
above. On the contrary, the presence of zeolites feces of all pigs were hard and normal after
in swine rations appears to contribute mea- only 7 days. Although the pigs consumed an
surably to the well-being of the animals. Ac- average of 1.75 kg of zeolite/head/day, no ill
cording to Torii (1977), tests carried out at the effects were noted, and once they had recov-
Keai Farm near Moioka, Iwate Prefecture, ered from diarrhetic ailments, the pigs regained
Japan, where 4,000 head of swine are bred, healthy appetites and became vital.
aTest carried out on 4,000 swine at Keai Farm, Morioka, Iwate Prefecture, Japan (Torii, 1974).
ZEOLITES IN ANIMAL SCIENCE AND AQUACULTURE 1 195
Apparently the vitalizing effect of a zeolite lectivity of clinoptilolite suggests that in rumi-
diet can be transferred from mother to off- nants it acts as a nitrogen reservoir in the
spring. Experiments at the Ichikawa Livestock animals' digestive systems, resulting in a slower
Experiment Station, where 400g of clinoptilo- release and more efficient use of ammonium
lite was fed each day to pregnant sows and ions produced by the breakdown of ingested
continued through the 35-day weaning period protein-containing rations. Zeolite particles
of their offspring, showed substantial increase might also stimulate the lining of the stomach
in the growth rate of the young pigs. As shown and intestinal tract, causing the animal to
in table 6, test animals weighed from 65 to 85% produce more antibodies and thereby inhibit
more than control-group animals at the end of diseases such as scours, et cetera.
the weaning period (Buto and Takehashi, Ruminants. In an attempt to reduce the
1967). The authors reported that young pigs toxic effects of high NH4 + content of ruminal
whose dams received the zeolite diet also fluids when non-protein nitrogen (NPN) com-
suffered almost no attacks of diarrhea, while pounds, such as urea and diuret, are added to
those in control groups were severely afflicted the diets of cattle, sheep, and goats, White and
with scours, greatly inhibiting their normal Ohlrogge (1974) introduced both natural and
growth. synthetic zeolites into the rumen of test ani-
Similar studies were conducted at Oregon mals. A m m o n i u m ions formed by the enzyme
State University (England, 1975) with young decomposition of NPN were immediately ion
swine using rations containing 5% clinoptilolite exchanged into the zeolite structure and held
from the Hector deposit. Although lesser in- there for several hours until released by the
creases in growth rates were found than in the regenerative action of Na + entering the rumen
Japanese studies, the incidence of scours was in saliva during the after-feeding fermentation
significantly reduced for animals receiving the period. From both in vivo and in vitro experi-
zeolite diet. Currently, heavy doses of prophy- ments, they found that up to 15% of the NH4 +
lactic antibiotics are used to control such in the rumen could be taken up by the zeolite.
intestinal diseases, which, left unchecked, result Thus, the gradual release of NH4 + allowed
in high mortality rates among young swine after rumen microorganisms to synthesize ccllular
they are weaned. Federal regulations are be- protein continuously for easy assimulation into
coming increasingly stringent in this area, and if the animal's digestive system. The zeolite's
antibiotics are prohibited, other means must be ability to act as a rcservior for NH4 § " . . .
found to control such diseases. Natural zeolites permits the addition of supplemental nitrogen
may be the answer. to the animal feed while protecting the animal
The exact functions of the zeolites in both against the production of toxic levels of ammo-
dietary and antibiotic phenomena are not well nia" in the rumen (White and Ohlrogge, 1974).
understood and await serious physiological and The amount of zeolite used in these experi-
biochemical examination. The ammonium se- ments depended on the size of the animal, the
Weight-
No. Average weight (kg) gain
of New- 21- 35- improve-
Species pigs Group born days days ment
aTests carried out at lchikawa Livestock Experiment Station, Japan. Four hundred grams of clinoptilolite
given to sows in experimental group per day and continued to end of weaning period (Buto and Takenashi,
1967).
bweight-gain of experimental animals + weight-gain of control animals • I00.
1196 MUMPTON AND FISHMAN
expected concentration of ammonium ions, and No deleterous effects were noted, and the feces
the NH4+-exchange capacity and selectivity, of of the test animals contained slightly less water
the zeolite. Approximately 500 g of a synthetic and fewer particles of undigested solids in the
zeolite w ~ introduced into the 50-liter rumen >5 mm size-range. The incidence of diarrhea
of a cow; lesser amounts sufficed for sheep. The and soft-feces was markedly less in zeolite-fed
zeolite was added in the form of a foraminous calves than in control animals (table 7).
bolus or as a finely divided powder with the Watanabe e t al. (1971) raised six young
normal rations, the latter method requiring bullocks for 329 days on a diet containing 2%
periodic replenishment. Although natural chab- clinoptilolite, along with 72% digestible nutri-
azite and clinoptilolite were found to be effec- ents and 11% crude protein. Although little
tive in this application, synthetic F zeolite difference in the final weights of test and
(Milton, 1961) appeared to work best of all. control animals was noted, test steers showed
Synthetic F and W zeolites both have superior slightly larger body dimensions and reportedly
ion selectivities and total NH4+-exchange ca- dressed out to give slightly higher quality meat.
pacities. Considering the current non-availabil- These differences were reflected in the overall
ity of these products, however, and their higher prices obtained for the test animals and a
probable high price when they become avail- 20% greater profit. In addition, diarrhea and
able, it is apparent that certain NHa+-selective other intestinal ailments were noticeably less
n a t u r a l zeolites, such as clinoptilolite or phillip- prevalent in the animals on the zeolite diet, and
site, may find definite application in ruminant the excrement from these animals was signifi-
feeding, especially if powdered zeolite can be cantly less odoriferous, again testifying to the
mixed directly with the normal rations of the retentivity of clinoptilolite for ammonia. It is
animals. The price would be only a few cents unfortunate that a much higher level of zeolite
per kilogram. was not used in these experiments; earlier
In this same area, Kondo e t al. (1969) found studies in the United States showed that as
that clinoptilolite added to the feed of young much as 40% clay could be added to animal
calves improved their growth rate by stimulat- rations without adverse effects (Ousterhout,
ing appetite and decreased the incidence of 1970).
diarrhea and soft-feces. Five percent zeolite was
added to the normal grass and hay diets of lO-
Excrement Treatment
and 184-day-old heifer calves over a 180-day
period. The animals on the zeolite-supple- The rising demand for animal protein in
mented diets gained approximately 20% more worldwide diets is attcnded by several on-going
weight than those in control groups, and problems, not the least of which is what to do
although the test calves consumed more feed, with the mountains of animal wastes produced
the feeding costs per kilogram of weight gained each day on farms and in feedlots. In the
were significantly less than for control animals. United States alone, livestock production cre-
30 0 0 4 0 0 4
36~0 0 1 2 9 4 13
61-90 0 0 2 1 1 13
91-120 1 0 1 2 0 13
121-150 0 0 4 4 0 8
151-184 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 1 1 13 16 5 51
ates more than one billion metric tons of solid result is reported to be an overall increase in egg
wastes and nearly 400,000,000 tons of liquid production and healthier birds.
wastes each year (Laporte, 1975, p. 365). Ac- Using clinoptilolite from Itaya, Onagi (1965)
cumulations of such magnitude pose serious noted that the water content, maggot popula-
problems to the health of man and beast alike tion, and ammonia production were all mini-
and are the source of pollution of nearby mized when chicken droppings were routinely
streams and rivers. In addition, the large amount mixed with one-third zeolite (table 8). He
of undigested protein remaining in the excre- found that similar results could be obtained if
ment represents a valuable resource that for the powdered zeolite was added directly to the
most part is being wasted, due to our growing rations of the birds, all without affecting the
dependence on chemical fertilizers. The physi- vitality or growth rate of the chickens (Onagi,
cal and chemical properties of many natural 1966). Apparently, gaseous ammonia reacts
zeolites lend themselves to a wide variety o f with the hydrous zeolite to form ammonium
applications in the treatment of animal wastes, ions which are selectively ion-exchanged and
including (1) the reduction of malodor and held in the zeolite structure. Onagi (1965)
associated pollution, (2) the creation of health- suggested from these experiments that the
ier environments for confined livestock, (3) the addition of zeolites to poultry wastes would
control of the viscosity and nutrient retentivity substantially reduce labor costs associated with
of the manure, and (4) the purification of air-drying or the high energy costs of thermal
methane gas produced by anaerobic digestion treatments, while at the same time retain
of the excrement. valuable fertilizer components and meet ecolog-
Malodor and Moisture Control. The semi- ical standards. Similar studies are in progress in
fluid droppings in large poultry houses com~ the Department of Poultry Science, Oregon
monly emit a stench that is discomforting to State University (Arscott 6 ).
farm workers and to the chickens themselves. In swine raising, Kondo and Wagai (1968)
The noxious fumes of ammonia and hydrogen found that the feces of pigs fed a diet contain-
sulfide contribute to decreased resistance to ing 10% clinoptilolite were richer in all forms of
respiratory diseases resulting in smaller and less nitrogen after drying than those from control
healthy birds (Ernst, 1968; Kling and Quarles, groups (vide supra). As a result of this study
1974). Japanese farmers with access to local and of other investigations, about 25 tons of
deposits of zeolitic tuff have sprinkled zeolite clinoptilolite per month are spread on the
on farmyards and manure piles for years to floors o f a Sapporo swine-raising facility to
control both the odor and the moisture content adsorb urine and other liquid wastes (Torii,
(Minato, 1968, 1971). Torii (1974) reported 1974). The buildings are said to be dry, clean,
that in many areas of Japan, clinoptilolite is and considerably less odoriferous. Nishimura
now being mixed with the droppings directly or (1973) reported that mordenite was used in
packed in boxes suspended from ceilings to treating liquid swine-wastes. Not only was 90%
remove ammonia and thereby improve the of the suspended solids removed, b u t significant
general atmosphere in chicken houses. The net reductions in the NH4 +, B.O.D., and C.O.D.
contents were also achieved, as shown in t a b l e
9. In Akita Prefecture, Japan, a zeolitic mud-
stone is used to treat offensive odors and to
6 Ibid, 1976. reduce moisture content of swine excrement
Droppings/zeolite ratio
Property 2:1 3:1 5:1 10:1 Control
aOnagi (1965). Clinoptilolite was spread on droppings of Leghorn chickens every third day for a 15-day
per!od. The total amount of droppings is the same in all tests, including the control.
1198 MUMPTON AND FISHMAN
TABLE 9. EFFECT OF ZEOLITE TREATMENT the process is still an attractive one, and Goep-
ON LIQUID SWINE WASTESa pner and Hasselmann (1974) estimated that a
billion cubic feet of 700 BTU/ft 3 of methane
Trans- gas could be produced by treating the 250,000
N COD BOD parency
(ppm) (pprn) (ppm) (%) tons of manure produced each day by the
12,000,000 cattle penned in feedlots of the
Original United States. Jewell (1974)also suggested that
solution 554 1907 3600 0 the methane produced by the anaerobic diges-
Zeolite- tion of the organic wastes of a typical New
treated York State dairy farm of 60 head would be
effluent 19 24 21 24
equivalent to the farm's entire fossil fuel
requirements.
aNishimura (1973).
A recent development by Reserve Synthetic
Fuels, Inc., utilizing the adsorption properties
of natural zeolites, suggests that such methane
(ttonda and Koizumi, 1976). The dried manure streams can be economically upgraded to high-
is then sold as an inexpensive fertilizer for the BTU products. In 1975 this company opened a
cultivation of rice. methane-recovery and purification plant to
An innovative application of zeolites in treat methane gas produced by decaying or-
excrement treatment was recently patented in ganic matter in the Palos Verde sanitary landfill
the United States by Komakine (1974) and near Los Angeles. Raw gas containing about
involves the addition of natural zeolites and 50% CH4 and 40% CO2 is fed to 2 pre-treat-
ferrous sulfate to chicken droppings. The fer- ment vessels to remove moisture, H 2 S, mercap-
rous sulfate inhibits zymosis and decomposition tans, et cetera. The dry gas is then routed
of the droppings, and the zeolite stabilizes the through three parallel adsorption columns
hygroscopic nature of this compound and packed with pellets of dehydrated chabazite/
captures NH4 + produced in the manure. The erionite from a deposit near Bowie, Arizona,
mixture is dried at 120 to 150 C and used as an and CO2 is removed by pressure-swing adsorp-
odorless, organic fertilizer. It is also used as a tion on the zeolite. Approximately one million
protein-rich feedstuff for fish, fowl, and domes- cubic feet of methane meeting pipeline specifi-
tic animals. The zeolite-, ferrous sulfate-treated cation is produced each day and delivered to
droppings contain 4.5% N, 4.5% P2Os, 2.4% utility company pipelines (NRG, 1975). Such a
K20, and 22% useable protein and have been zeolite-adsorption process to upgrade impure
successfully substituted for as much as 20% of methane streams produced by the digestion of
the normal rations of swine, poultry and edible animal manure appears to be technically feasi-
carp. ble and awaits detailed economic and engineer-
Metbane Purification. Although it is well ing evaluation.
known that anaerobic digestion of animal ex-
crement and other organic wastes produces an AQUACULTURAL APPLICATIONS
impure methane-gas product, this source of In recent years, more and more fish products
energy has generally been ignored for anything have found their way to the dinner tables and
except local or in-house use (Jewell, 1974). feeding troughs of every country, and the
Automobiles that run on chicken droppings and commercial breeding and raising of fish as a
lamps that burn manure-pile gases are common source of protein and for hobby and recreation-
in the popular science magazines, to be sure, al purposes is becoming a major business in the
but commercial operations based on the utiliza- United States. Many varieties of fish, however,
tion of such gases face both technical difficul- are extremely sensitive to minor fluctuations in
ties and economic hurdles that have not yet such factors as water temperature, pH, O2,
been resolved. One major drawback is the fact 1-12S, and NH4 +, and the chemical and biologi-
that in addition to methane, copious quantities cal environment of aquacultural systems must
of carbon dioxide and sulfur compounds are be carefully maintained within close limits at all
also produced during the digestion process, times. Processes based on the selective adsorp-
giving rise to Iow-BTU products that are ex- tion and ion-exchange properties of several
tremely corrosive to pumps, valves, and other natural zeolites for the oxygen aeration of
hardware needed in the operation. Nevertheless, hatchery and transport waters and for the
ZEOLITES IN ANIMAL SCIENCE AND AQUACULTURE 1199
removal of toxic nitrogen from tanks and in the development of a nitrogen purification
breeding ponds may contribute significantly to unit for trout and salmon hatcheries using
increased fish production for human and animal clinoptilolite from a New Mexico deposit. Here
consumption. NH4 + is reduced from about 5 ppm to less than
Nitrogen Removal. In closed or recirculating .1 ppm, at flow rates of 2.2 to 4.5 Mgd. The
aquacultural systems, NH4 + produced by the system is said to be economically superior to
decomposition of excrement and unused food biofiltration and much more reliable under
is one of the leading causes of disease and colder climatic conditions.
mortality in fish. In oxygen-poor environments, Jungle Laboratories of Comfort, Texas, is
even a few ppm NH4 + can lead to gill damage, working on a similar ammonium~ion removal
hyperplasia, and substantial reduction in system using zeolite ion-exchange for fish haul-
growth rates (Larmoyeux and Piper, 1973). age applications, where brain damage due to
Biological nitrification is a principal means of excess NH 4 + ions commonly results in sterility,
removing NH4 + from culture waters; however, stunted growth, and high mortality (Nichols) 9.
processes similar to those used in municipal Throw-away cartridges and filters containing
sewage-treatment plants based on zeolite ion- granular clinoptilolite will also be available for
exchange have been found to be effective in the removal of NH4 + from home aquaria and
controlling the nitrogen content of hatchery are expected to come onto the market shortly.
waters (Konikoff, 1973). Johnson and Sieburth The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service of the
(1974) proposed that zeolite ion-exchange Department of the Interior is investigating
might be a useful backup and/or alternative to zeolite ion-exchange processes for the treat-
bio-filtration for NH4 + removal and have the ment of recirculating waters in tank trucks used
advantages of low cost and high tolerance to to transport channel catfish from Texas to the
changing temperatures and chemical conditions. Colorado River in Arizona (McCraren 1~ Cur-
Unpublished tests conducted in 1973 at a rently, about 2,000 kg of 20 to 25 cm fish are
working hatchery near Newport, Oregon, indi- carried in 45,000 liters of water (about .04
cated that 97 to 99% of the NH4 + produced in a kg/L or 35 kg of fish per cubic meter). If NH4 +
recirculating system was removed by clinoptilo- can be removed, the number of fish hauled in
lite ion-exchange columns from waters contain- such trucks can be nearly tripled. Slone et al.
ing .34 to 1.43 mg NH3-N/liter (KapranosT). (1975) were able to achieve biomass concentra-
Peters and Bose (1975) substantiated these tions of more than.112 kg/L (or 35 kg/rn 3) for
results and found that trout remained healthy catfish (Ictalurus punctatus) after 7 months in a
during a 4-week trial when zeolite ion-exchange vertical raceway using recycled water and a
was used to regulate the NH4 + content of tank zeolite ion-exchange process to remove ammo-
waters. Becker Industries of Newport, Oregon, nium ions after biofiltration. Ammoniacal ni-
in conjunction with the U.S. Army Corps of trogen concentrations of less than 5 mg/liter
Engineers, is developing a single unit, purifica- were easily maintained.
tion facility for hatchery-water reuse. The Aeration Oxygen Production. As mentioned
system will incorporate a zeolite ion-exchange above, oxygen-enriched air can be produced by
circuit for nitrogen removal and is designed to the selective adsorption of nitrogen by acti-
handle concentrations of 20 to 30 ppm NH3-N vated zeolites. A pressure-swing adsorption
at flow rates of 10 to 15 Mgd, typical of the process (p.s.a) capable of producing up to 500
conditions encountered at most of the 200 fish m 3 of 90% 02 per hour was developed in Japan
hatcheries now operating in the Pacific North- (Tamura, 1970) for secondary smelting opera-
west (Kapranos) 7. Piper s also reports progress tions. Smaller generators with outputs of as
little as 15 liters of 50% 02 per hour are also
manufactured by the Koyo Development Com-
pany, Ltd. and used to aerate fish breeding
7Kapranos, W. 1976. Becker Industries, Pordand,
OR. (Personal communication). tanks and in the transportation of live fish.
8Piper, R. G. 1976. Fish Cultural Development Carp and goldfish raised in such environments
Center, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Bozeman, MT. are said to be livelier and to have greater
(Personal communication). appetites (Koyo Kaihatsu, 1974). It is obvious
9Nichols, R. A. 1976. Jungle Laboratories, Com- that in closed tanks and stagnant ponds, oxygen
fort, TX. (Personal communication).
lOMeCraren, J. 1976. U.S. Fish and Wildlife aeration might markedly increase the number
Service, San Marcos, TX. (Personal communication). of fish that can be raised per unit volume.
1200 MUMPTON AND FISHMAN
Ousterhout, L. E. 1970. Nutritional effects of clays in in Japan. u.s.-Japan Cooperative Science Program
feed. Feedstuffs 42: 34. Seminar on Occurrence, Origin, and Utilization of
Peters, M. D. and R. J. Bose. 1975. Clinoptilolite-a Sedimentary Zeolites in the Circum-Pacific Region,
physiochemical approach to ammonia removal in Menlo Park, CA, July, 1974 (Abstr.).
hatchery and aquacuitural water reuse systems. Torii, Kazuo. 1977. Utilization of natural zeolites in
Fish and Marine Tech. Rep. 535, 12 p. Japan. In L. B. Sand and F. A. Mumpton (Ed.)
Quisenberry, J. H. 1968. The use of clay in poultry Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Use. Per-
feed. Clays & Clay Minerals 16: 267. gamon Press, Elmsford, NY.
Slone, W. J., P. R. Turner and D. B. Jester. 1975. A Watanabe, S., Y. Yanaka and A. Juroda. 1971. Report
new vertical raceway fish culture system containing on the experimental use of zeolite-tuff as dietary
clinoptilolite as an ammonia stripper. Proc. 54th supplement for cattle. Rep. Okayama Prefecture
Conf. West. Ass. Game Fish Conserv. Commis- Feder. Agr. Coop. Ass., April, 1971, 18 p.
sioners, July, 1974, Albuquerque, N.M., 381-94. White, J. L. and A. J. Ohlrogge. 1974. Ion exchange
Tamura, Takaaki. 1970. Oxygen concentration proc- materials to increase consumption of non-protein
ess. U.S. Patent 3,533,221, Oct. 13, 1970, 10 p. nitrogen in ruminants. Can. Patent 939186, Jan. 2,
Torii, Kazuo. 1974. Utilization of sedimentary zeolites 1974. 30 p.