TAXATION LAW 2

CASES (2013-2017)

TITLE G.R. NO.

1 Fort Bonifacio Development Corporation vs. CIR 173425
Philacor Credit Corporation vs. CIR 169899
187485, 196113,
2 CIR vs. San Roque Power Corporation
197156
3 Mindanao II Geothermal Partnership vs. CIR 193301 & 194637
4 Philippine Airlines, Inc. vs. Commissioner 198759
5 Applied Food Ingredients Co., Inc. vs. CIR 184266
6 Luzon Hydro Corp. vs. CIR 188260
7 CBK Power Co. Ltd. vs. Commissioner 198729-30
8 CIR v. Toledo Power Company 183880
9 The City of Manila vs. Hon. Caridad H. Grecia-Cuerdo 175723
10 Smart Communications, Inc. vs. Municipality of Malvar 204429
11 CIR vs. Pilipinas Shell Petroleum Corp 188497
12 CIR vs. United Salvage and Towage (Phils), Inc. 197515
13 Nursery Care Corp., et. al. vs. Acevedo 180651
12 Agriex Co. Ltd. vs. Villanueva 158150
13 CIR vs. Pilipinas Shell Petroleum Corp 192398
Commissioner vs. Philippine Associated Smelting and
14 186223
Refining Corporation
15 Duty Free Philippines vs. BIR 197228
AT&T Communications Services Philippines, Inc. vs.
16 185969
Commissioner
17 Fort Bonifacio Development Corporation vs. CIR 175707
18 Philamlife vs. Secretary of Finance and CIR 210987
National Power Corporation vs. Municipal Government of
19 192300
Navotas
20 BIR vs. Court of Appeals 197590
21 Taganito Mining Corporation vs. Commissioner 201195
22 Commissioner vs. BASF Coating + Inks Phils., Inc. 198677
23 Commissioner vs. The Stanley Works Sales (Phils.), Inc. 187589
24 Mindanao II Geothermal Partnership vs. CIR 204745
25 Samar-I Electric Cooperative vs. CIR 193100
26 CBK Power Co. Ltd. vs. CIR 193383-84
27 Winebrenner & Inigo Insurance Brokers, Inc. vs. CIR 206526
28 China Banking Corp. vs. CIR 172509
29 Demaala vs. Commission on Audit 199752
30 Northern Mindanao Power Corp. vs. CIR 185115
31 PNB vs. CIR 206019
32 Eastern Telecommunications Philippines, Inc. vs. CIR 183531
33 Mitsubishi Motors Phils. Corp. vs. BOC 209830
34 CIR vs. CTA and Petron Corp. 183408
35 MV "Don Martin" Voy 047 vs. Secretary of Finance 160206
Manila Electric Company (MERALCO) vs. The City Assessor
36 166102
and City Treasurer of Lucena City
37 Chevron Philippines Inc. vs. CIR 210836
38 Bureau of Customs vs. Devanadera 193253
39 Pilipinas Total Gas, Inc. vs. CIR 207112
40 PAGCOR vs. BIR, et. al. 208731
41 CIR vs. GJM Philippines Manufacturing Inc. 202695
42 Silicon Philippines, Inc. vs. CIR 182737
43 Sps. Pacquiao vs. CTA 213394
44 CIR vs. Liquigaz Philippines Corporation 215557
45 Tridharma Marketing Corporation vs. CTA 215950
46 Coral Bay Nickel Corp. vs. CIR 190506
47 Takenaka Corp.-Philippine Branch vs. CIR 193321
48 CIR vs. Fitness By Design, Inc. 215957
49 CIR vs. De La Salle University, Inc. 198841, 198941
50 CIR vs. Secretary of Justice and PAGCOR 177387
51 Pilipinas Shell Petroleum vs. CIR 195876
52 CIR vs. Asalus Corporation 221590
53 Alcantara vs. Republic 192536
54 CIR vs. Philippine Daily Inquirer, Inc. 213943
55 Medicard Philippines vs. CIR 222743
56 Metropolitan Bank & Trust Company vs. CIR 182582
57 Asia Trust and Development Bank, Inc. vs. CIR 201530/201680-81
58 Visayas Geothermal Power Company vs. CIR 205279
59 Mitsubishi Corporation-Manila Branch vs. CIR 175772
60 Mindanao Shopping Destination Corp. vs. Duterte 211093
61 CIR vs. Lancaster Philippines, Inc. 183408
Power Sector Asset and Liabilities Management
62 198146
Corporation vs. CIR
63 Aichi Forging Company of Asia, Inc. vs. CTA 193625
64 Procter & Gamble Asia Pte Ltd. vs. CIR 205652
65 Mindanao I Geothermal Partnership vs. CIR 197519
66 CIR vs. Transitions Optical Philippines, Inc. 227544
210689-90, 210704 &
67 PAGCOR vs. CIR
210725
W2
17)

YEAR MM/DD PONENTE

2013 January 22 Del Castillo
2013 February 6 Brion
2013 February 12 Carpio
2013 March 11 Carpio
2013 July 1 Perlas-Bernabe
2013 November 11 Sereno CJ
2013 November 13 Bersamin
2014 January 15 Sereno CJ
2014 January 20 Peralta
2014 February 4 Peralta
2014 February 18 Carpio
2014 February 19 Villarama, Jr.
2014 July 2 Peralta
2014 July 30 Bersamin
2014 September 10 Bersamin
2014 Sepember 29 Villarama, Jr.

2014 October 1 Reyes

2014 October 8 Sereno CJ
2014 November 19
2014 November 19
2014 November 24
2014 November 24
2014 November 24
2014 November 26
2014 November 26
2014 December 3
2014 December 8
2014 December 10 Villarama, Jr.
2015 January 14 Perlas-Bernabe
2015 January 28
2015 February 4 Sereno CJ
2015 February 17 Leonen
2015 February 18
2015 March 18
2015 March 25
2015 June 17
2015 July 15
2015 July 15 Bersamin
2015 August 5 Leonardo-De Castro
2015 September 1 Bersamin
2015 September 8 En Banc, Peralta
2015 December 8 En Banc
2016 January 27
2016 February 29
2016 March 2
2016 April 6
2016 April 18
2016 June 8
2016 June 13
2016 October 19
2016 November 9
2016 November 9
2016 November 9 Bersamin
2016 December 5 Velasco, Jr.
2017 February 22
2017 March 15
2017 March 22
2017 April 5 Reyes LOA
2017 April 17
2017 April 19
2017 April 26
2017 June 5
2017 June 6 En Banc, Peralta
2017 July 12
2017 August 8 En Banc
2017 August 30
2017 September 6
2017 November 8
2017 November 22
2017 November 22