You are on page 1of 6

International Journal of Fatigue 75 (2015) 51–56

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

International Journal of Fatigue


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ijfatigue

Fatigue in bamboo
Lauren Keogh, Patrick O’Hanlon, Peter O’Reilly, David Taylor ⇑
Trinity Centre for Bioengineering, Department of Mechanical & Manufacturing Engineering, Trinity College, University of Dublin, Dublin 2, Ireland

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: This paper describes the results of an experimental programme to determine the fatigue behaviour of
Received 9 September 2014 bamboo. Bamboo is subjected to cyclic loading, both in the plant itself and subsequently when the mate-
Received in revised form 28 January 2015 rial is used in load-bearing applications in the construction industry. However, there is currently no data
Accepted 2 February 2015
in the literature describing fatigue in this material. We found that sections of bamboo culm loaded par-
Available online 11 February 2015
allel to the culm axis did not undergo fatigue failure: samples either failed on the first loading cycle, or
not at all. By contrast, fatigue was readily apparent in samples loaded in compression across the diameter
Keywords:
of the culm. The number of cycles to failure increased as the cyclic load range decreased in a manner simi-
Bamboo
Fatigue
lar to that found in many engineering materials: fatigue occurred at applied loads as small as 40% of the
Fracture ultimate strength. Two different species of bamboo were tested and found to have different ultimate
Anisotropy strengths but similar high-cycle fatigue strengths. Finite element analysis was used to help understand
Stress concentration the progression of fatigue damage and the effect of stress concentration features. Some tentative design
rules are proposed to define stress levels for the safe use of bamboo, taking fatigue into account.
Ó 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction Our primary aim for this work was to determine whether fati-
gue failure occurs in bamboo and, if it does, to determine the num-
Bamboo is an important structural material, grown in many ber of cycles to failure for a range of applied cyclic loading
parts of the world. Being very fast growing it provides a renewable conditions. The material is highly anisotropic, being much stronger
resource which is extensively employed in construction work and and stiffer when loaded along the culm axis and much weaker
other load-bearing applications. The literature on this material when loaded perpendicular to the axis, so we aimed to investigate
contains a number of excellent studies reporting static mechanical fatigue behaviour in different orientations. Finally, since fatigue
properties such as Young’s modulus, ultimate strength under var- behaviour is strongly affected by the presence of notches and other
ious different types of loading, and fracture toughness. The bamboo stress concentration features, we planned to carry out a limited
plant grows as a series of hollow, tubular stems known as culms. number of tests to investigate the response of bamboo to such
Static mechanical property data have been published for tests car- features.
ried out on intact lengths of culm [1,2] and also on specimens
machined from the culm wall [3–8].
2. Methods and materials
In the growing plant, cyclic forces will be experienced, princi-
pally in the form of wind loading. When bamboo is used in con-
Most of the testing was carried out using the species of bamboo
struction, for example in scaffolding and space frame structures,
known as Moso (Phyllostachys Pubescens) which is one of the most
cyclic loading can also be expected. So it is surprising that there
commonly used species for structural purposes. The material was
is no data in the published literature recording the fatigue beha-
obtained from a local supplier (Bamboo Suppliers of Ireland,
viour of bamboo. The fibres of the bamboo plant, being relatively
Dublin). A limited number of tests was carried out on a different
stiff and strong, have been used to make fibre composites in com-
species, obtained from the National Botanic Gardens, Dublin, under
bination with various matrix materials, and several of these have
the name Dendrocalamus gigantea. All samples were tested in the
been characterised as regards their fatigue properties (e.g. [9]),
air-dried condition in which they would normally be used for
but these data give no insight into the fatigue behaviour of bamboo
structural applications.
when used in the form of culms.
Mechanical testing was carried out using an Instron 8874 servo-
hydraulic machine. Fig. 1 summarises the experimental pro-
⇑ Corresponding author. Tel.: +353 1 8961703; fax: +353 1 6795554. gramme. Samples were obtained in the form of culms several
E-mail address: dtaylor@tcd.ie (D. Taylor). metres in length. Bamboo culms are hollow tubes in which the

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2015.02.003
0142-1123/Ó 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
52 L. Keogh et al. / International Journal of Fatigue 75 (2015) 51–56

diameter and wall thickness stay fairly constant along the length: tubes obtained by cutting lengths from the culm. These tubes were
we used culms from plants which were 2–3 years old, with dia- loaded in two different ways, as follows.
meters in the range 32–47 mm and wall thicknesses of 2.9– Axial compression tests were carried out on samples cut to a
4.4 mm. Culms also have periodic nodes at branch points: we length equal to twice their diameter; diametral compression tests
avoided taking samples from close to the nodes, using only the were carried out on samples of length 50 mm. In both cases com-
internodal material. pressive load was applied through parallel platens. Because fatigue
Our choice of test specimen was made based on the experience did not occur in axial compression (see below) most of the tests
of ourselves and others in conducting monotonic tests on this were carried out in diametral compression. To reduce the effects
material, and also knowledge of how the material is loaded in of variability in specimen shape and size we used the following
use. Because bamboo is extremely anisotropic (having much approach: one sample was loaded monotonically until failure
greater strength and stiffness in the longitudinal direction) it occurred at a certain force, Fu. Fatigue tests were then carried out
invariably fails during monotonic tests by the initiation and on adjacent samples from the same culm, which had very similar
propagation of longitudinal cracks, irrespective of the specimen dimensions. Each of these samples was loaded with a maximum
shape and applied load [1,4]. Machining of standard test samples force Fmax which was a fixed percentage of Fu. Cyclic loading was
such as waisted tensile specimens or compact tension specimens, carried out at a frequency of 1 Hz and load ratio R (equal to Fmin/
which has been done previously [6,10] is complicated by the need Fmax) of 0.1.
to obtain these from the tubular culms. As a result these samples Testing was continued until complete failure of the sample:
must either be very small, or they must have a curved shape. damage developed in a three-stage process described below. To
Furthermore, the composition and properties of the material vary investigate the effect of stress concentrations, some samples of
through thickness, the outer layers having more fibres and more Moso bamboo had 3 mm diameter holes drilled mid-way along
hardening by lignification, making them stiffer and stronger [10] their lengths at one of the locations where initial failure occurred
but probably less tough [6] than material closer to the centre. For in the plain samples. Some samples had longitudinal grooves
these reasons we decided to test samples in the form of simple machined into them at these same locations (see Fig. 1). Monotonic

Fig. 1. (a) Samples were cut from internodal regions of the bamboo culm and tested in the form of cylinders. Compression was applied in the axial and diametral directions:
some diametral specimens contained stress concentration features (holes or grooves). (b) Diametral compression gives rise to high tensile stresses at four locations around
the circumference: the stress on the inside surface at points N and S is approximately twice as high as the stress on the outside at points W and E.
L. Keogh et al. / International Journal of Fatigue 75 (2015) 51–56 53

loading tests were carried out on these samples, as well as fatigue


tests with cyclic loads of 50%, 60% and 70% of the static failure
loads previously established for plain, unnotched samples.
A stress analysis for the diametral loading test was carried out
using ANSYS finite element software. The sample was modelled
as a tube of diameter 40 mm, wall thickness 4 mm and length
50 mm. Steel platens were modelled, through which a fixed dis-
placement was applied. Frictional contact was modelled at the pla-
ten/sample interfaces. The mesh element size and the number of
iterations were varied until the solution converged. As regards
the mechanical properties of the bamboo material, linear elastic
behaviour was assumed; two different models were created. In
the first model the material was assumed to have a constant
Young’s modulus and Poisson’s ratio. Values of E = 1.85 GPa and
m = 0.3 were found to accurately predict the initial part of the
experimental force/deflection curve: these results are in agreement
previous findings [2]. In our second model we attempted to simu-
late the variation of properties which occurs from outside to inside.
Nogata and Takahashi modelled bamboo as a uniaxial fibre com-
posite in order to predict Young’s modulus in the longitudinal
direction [10]. We used their approach, adapting it to study the
transverse direction. We created a model having five separate lay-
ers through-thickness and varied the Young’s modulus of each lay-
er according to the percentage of fibres as measured by Nogata and
Takahashi. The Young’s modulus values of the individual layers (in
GPa, from outside to inside) were: 4.01; 2.54; 1.86; 1.61 and 1.27.
We found only small differences between these two FE models: the Fig. 2. Examples of cracks forming at Stage A (above) and Stage B (below), for
multi-layer model gave a slightly higher stress (by 14%) at points N diametral compression tests.
and S (as defined in Fig. 1b) and a slightly lower stress (by 3%) at
points W and E. The stress results from these models were also
in agreement with analytical solutions [11–13] to within 10%.
We also modified our model to investigate the effect of introducing
a stress concentration feature and the changes in stress that occur
during the three stages of damage progression (described below).

3. Results

Axial compression specimens of Moso bamboo failed under


monotonic loading by longitudinal splitting. The average stress to
failure (from 11 samples tested) was 65.0 MPa, with a standard
deviation of 5.8 MPa. It was not possible to generate fatigue fail-
ures in these specimens when loaded cyclically, even at a maxi- Fig. 3. A typical force/displacement curve obtained from monotonic loading, with
mum stress as high as 90% of the static strength. Samples that maxima occurring at Stages A, B and C.
did not fail monotonically could be cycled for over 100,000 cycles
to the same Fmax without failing.
The diametral compression samples of Moso bamboo, by con- did not vary one from another by more than 20%. The average value
trast, displayed fatigue failure over a wide range of loading. Failure of the tensile stress at points W and E when monotonic failure
occurred in three separate stages: occurred (defined as the highest of these three peaks) was
Stage A: longitudinal cracking at location W or E (as defined in 10.4 MPa.
Fig. 1b). Cracks initiated on the outside at these points and grew Fig. 4 shows fatigue data for Moso bamboo, plotting the number
very rapidly along the entire length of the sample. These cracks of cycles to failure as a function of the maximum cyclic force, nor-
did not penetrate to the inner surface but arrested when they malised by the static failure force. Failure here is defined as com-
had passed through approximately three quarters of the thickness plete collapse of the sample (i.e. Stage C). There is a significant
(see Fig. 2a). amount of scatter but it is clear that fatigue occurs at applied forces
Stage B: because the crack in Stage A did not cause complete which are considerably less than the static strength. Fig. 5 shows
failure, the test was continued. At a later stage a crack would form results for diametral compression testing of the other bamboo spe-
at the opposite side (point E or W respectively), developing in a cies, which also showed clear evidence of fatigue failure, though
similar manner (Fig. 2b). This also did not cause complete failure. here there is less data available: further testing would be required
Stage C: Final failure occurred when a crack formed on the inner to completely describe the fatigue characteristics.
surface of the sample close to one of the loading points (point N or In Fig. 6 the plain-specimen data for Moso bamboo (from Fig. 4)
S), causing complete collapse of the sample. is reproduced along with data from the tests in which stress con-
These three stages also occurred during monotonic loading, centrations were introduced into the samples. The introduction
where they could be distinguished by load drops giving rise to of holes and grooves tended to reduce both the static strength
three peaks on the force/displacement curves (Fig. 3). There was and the fatigue strength, but there was considerable overlap with
no consistent order to the heights of these peaks, but typically they the plain-specimen data.
54 L. Keogh et al. / International Journal of Fatigue 75 (2015) 51–56

4. Discussion

This work has succeeded in its primary aim: we have demon-


strated that fatigue does occur in bamboo. Our finding that fatigue
failures happen at applied cyclic stresses as low as 40% of static
strength, at cycle numbers of the order of 105, shows that the fati-
gue behaviour of bamboo is similar to that of many engineering
materials. Fatigue is a phenomenon that should be taken into
account when using bamboo for any load-bearing application
where cyclic loads might arise. Our data show considerable scatter,
the number of cycles to failure varying by more than four orders of
magnitude for the same loading conditions. This is not unusual in
brittle materials, for which fatigue life tends to be controlled by
crack initiation from microscopic defects [14]. In this case addi-
tional scatter can be expected due to the natural variations in
material and geometry, though we have attempted to reduce the
effects of geometry as much as possible by testing paired samples
as described above.
Fig. 4. Fatigue data for Moso bamboo tested in diametral loading. The number of
Our finding that fatigue occurs readily in diametral compressive
cycles to failure is plotted against the maximum load in the cycle, normalised by the
load to cause static failure in a sample taken from the same region of the culm. loading but not in axial compressive loading is consistent with pre-
vious work on fibre composite materials [15]. Unidirectional fibre
composites loaded parallel to their fibres tend not to show a large
fatigue range because the applied stress is borne largely by the
fibres, which display very brittle behaviour. In contrast, loading
perpendicular to the fibres leads to fatigue due to the properties
of the matrix material or the fibre/matrix interface.
In use, bamboo culms performing structural functions such as
scaffolding or space-frame structures will experience complex
loading regimes. Whilst they will only rarely be loaded in exactly
the same way as our diametral specimens, they will commonly
experience bending, which causes ovalisation of the cross section
and gives rise to a stress distribution which is very similar to one
created in our tests [13]. Thus our fatigue data should be relevant
for the engineering application of bamboo.
Fig. 7 shows finite element analysis results for the diametral
compression specimens. Stresses arise mainly due to bending of
the tube walls. At points W and E there are regions of locally-high
tensile stress on the outside and compressive stress on the inside.
At points N and S the pattern is reversed, with tension occurring
on the inside. In our tests, whether monotonic or cyclic, the initial
failures always occurred at the W and E positions, with the N and
Fig. 5. Fatigue data for a bamboo species obtained from the National Botanic S locations failing later on. This is surprising because the tensile
Gardens, Dublin, under the name Dendrocalamus gigantea. stress is approximately twice as high at N and S compared to W
and E. The average tensile stress at locations W and E for monotonic
failure was 10.4 MPa: for the same applied load the stress at N and S
is 19.1 MPa.
FEA showed that cracking in one location tends to increase the
stress at other locations (see Fig. 7). In Stage A, the presence of a
crack at point E was estimated to increase the stress at point W
by 17.6% and that at points N and S by 13.7%. In Stage B, the pres-
ence of cracks at both E and W was found to increase the stress at
points N and S by 31.6% (compared to the original values for the
undamaged sample). These results help to understand how fatigue
proceeds in these tests. Initial cracking (Stage A) will occur at one
of two locations, W or E. Due to slight differences in material and
geometry, one side will be weaker than the other and so will fail
first, causing the stress on the stronger side to increase, but only
by a relatively small amount (17.6%). This explains why in most
cases the Stage A failure did not immediately lead to total failure:
rather, a significant number of cycles elapsed between the first and
second failures. The onset of Stage B causes a relatively large
increase in the stresses at points N and S (31%) which were in fact
already much higher that the stresses at W and E as noted above.
Fig. 6. Fatigue data for Moso bamboo samples containing stress concentration Nevertheless further cycles were needed to generate failure at N
features. The plain-specimen data (from Fig. 4) is reproduced for comparison. or S and thus precipitate a total collapse. A possible explanation
L. Keogh et al. / International Journal of Fatigue 75 (2015) 51–56 55

Fig. 7. Results from FEA: (a) maximum principal stress contours for a plain sample; (b) likewise for a sample containing a groove; (c) stress plotted as a function of distance
around the outer circumference starting and finishing at point E, for an intact specimen and also for a groove (3 mm deep notch) at point E.

lies in the variation in material structure through-thickness, which applied load was somewhat flatter. The static strength was smaller
was mentioned above. The material on the outside of the culm is for this material, at 7.7 MPa, however the high-cycle fatigue
relatively hard and strong but it appears to have a lower toughness strengths of the two materials were similar.
than material on the inside [6]. So fatigue cracks may propagate The overall picture is complicated by the existence of a multi-
more easily from small defects at points W and E than at points stage failure process in which the culm can endure considerable
N and S. amounts of damage before final failure occurs. High cycle fatigue
We conducted a relatively small number of tests to investigate failure may be quantified as follows: total failure will occur after
stress concentration features, so these results should be treated 100,000 cycles at R = 0.1 when the stress range (i.e. the difference
with caution until further data are available. When we introduced between the maximum and minimum stress in the cycle) at points
a longitudinal groove at the E location, this had the effect of W and E is approximately 4.5 MPa. For this same loading, the stress
eliminating Stage A. As a result the force needed for a given num- at points N and S rises to approximately 11 MPa in the final stage
ber of cycles decreased (on average) by 21%. FEA predicts this before complete collapse. Further work is needed to characterise
change quite well: the groove essentially creates Stage A at the this material more comprehensively, but these initial results may
start of the test, and increases the stress to cause Stage B by prove useful in indicating a safe working stress for bamboo culms
17.6%. subjected to cyclic loading.
When we introduced a circular hole at E, the effect was very
variable. In some samples a crack propagated very quickly from
the hole, and on average the number of cycles needed for Stage A 5. Conclusions
did reduce (by a factor of 5.5). But on average the total number
of cycles to failure did not decrease, though this was largely due 1. Bamboo culm samples display fatigue failure when loaded in
to the fact that 3 of the 17 samples endured very large numbers compression across their diameters, simulating a type of defor-
of cycles. mation which commonly occurs as a result of culm bending.
In a plain specimen, the initial, Stage A failure, may occur at 2. By contrast, no fatigue behaviour occurs when samples are
point E or point W and (as mentioned above) it will ‘‘choose’’ the loaded in axial compression.
weaker side. The hole is introduced into one side only, which 3. Under diametral loading, failure develops in a series of stages
may be the stronger side or the weaker side. If it’s the stronger side, during which cracks initiate and grow in different locations
then this will have a major effect on the overall life, but if it’s the around the circumference. Failure in the first cycle (i.e. static
weaker side it will have a negligible effect, since both sides must failure) is associated with a tensile stress of 10.4 MPa on the
eventually fail. This will tend to increase the scatter in the number outer surface and 19.1 MPa on the inner surface. High cycle fail-
of cycles to failure. To use a simple analogy, if one throws a die ure at 100,000 cycles requires a stress range of 4.5 MPa on the
then the probably of getting any number from 1 to 6 is equal. outer surface and 11 MPa on the inner surface.
But if one throws two dice and chooses the higher of the two val- 4. The effect of stress concentration features such as grooves and
ues, then the result is weighted towards the higher numbers, and holes is complicated owing to the multi-stage failure process.
scatter is reduced. A similar argument can be made for the groove Initial results suggest that the main effect of such features at
feature: in this case our data did not show increased scatter but points W and E is to increase scatter in the number of cycles
this may be because the number of samples tested was small. to failure. More work is needed to systematically study the
Tests carried out on the other bamboo species showed that fati- effect of feature size, shape and location.
gue failure also occurred, though the dependence of fatigue life on
56 L. Keogh et al. / International Journal of Fatigue 75 (2015) 51–56

Acknowledgements [6] Tan T, Rahbar N, Allameh SM, Kwofie S, Dissmore D, Ghavami K, et al.
Mechanical properties of functionally graded hierarchical bamboo structures.
Acta Biomater 2011;7(10):3796–803.
We are grateful to Martin McNulty of Bamboo Suppliers of [7] Lakkad SC, Patel JM. Mechanical properties of bamboo, a natural composite.
Ireland and to Brendan Sayers of the National Botanic Gardens, Fiber Sci Technol 1981;14(4):319–22.
[8] Jain S, Kumar R, Jindal UC. Mechanical behaviour of bamboo and bamboo
Glasnevin, Dublin, for supplies of bamboo culms and helpful
composite. J Mater Sci 1992;27(17):4598–604.
advice. [9] Phong NT, Gabr MH, Okubo K, Chuong B, Fujii T. Enhancement of mechanical
properties of carbon fabric/epoxy composites using micro/nano-sized bamboo
fibrils. Mater Des 2013;47:624–32.
References
[10] Nogata F, Takahashi H. Intelligent functionally graded material: bamboo.
Compos Eng 1995;5(7):743–51.
[1] Chung KF, Yu WK. Mechanical properties of structural bamboo for bamboo [11] Young WC, Budynas RG. Roark’s formulas for stress–strain. 7th ed. Boston,
scaffoldings. Eng Struct 2002;24(4):429–42. USA: McGraw-Hill; 2002.
[2] Torres LA, Ghavami K, Garcia JJ. A transversely isotropic law for the [12] Batista M, Usenik J. Technical note: stresses in a circular ring under two forces
determination of the circumferential Young’s modulus of bamboo with acting along a diameter. J Strain Anal Eng Des 1996;31(1):75–8.
diametric compression tests. Latin Am Appl Res 2007;37(4):255–60. [13] Wegst UGK, Ashby MF. The structural efficiency of orthotropic stalks, stems
[3] Amada S, Untao S. Fracture properties of bamboo. Compos B Eng and tubes. J Mater Sci 2007;42:9005–14.
2001;32:451–9. [14] Taylor D. Fatigue of bone and bones: an analysis based on stressed volume. J
[4] Shao ZP, Zhou L, Liu YM, Wu ZM, Arnaud C. Differences in structure and Orthop Res 1998;16(2):163–9.
strength between internode and node sections of Moso bamboo. J Trop Forest [15] Hertzberg RW, Manson JA. Fatigue of engineering plastics. London: Academic
Sci 2010;22(2):133–8. Press; 1980.
[5] Lo TY, Cui HZ, Leung HC. The effect of fiber density on strength capacity of
bamboo. Mater Lett 2004;58(21):2595–8.

You might also like