Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Minutes of Meeting
on
Inception Report
on
the Study on Countermessuresfor Sedimentation
in the Wonogiri Multipurpose Dum Reservoir
ugreed upon between
Ministry of Settlement snd Regionul Infrastructure
snd
Japan I nternstionsl Cooperstion Agency
w-
D r . l r . M o c h .B A S U K I H . M . S c Mr. MinoruOUCHI
DirectorGeneral. Leaderof StudyTeam
DirectorateGeneralof Water Resources. JapanInternational
Cooperation
Agency
Ministryof Settlement
and Regional
lnfrastructure
M i n L r t e so l - M e e t i n q
Introduction
The Governmentof Japan.in responseto the ofllcial requestof the Governmentof the Republicof
Indonesia(hereafterref'erredto as "lndonesia"),decidedto conductthe Study on Countermeasures
fbr Sedimentationin the Wonogiri Multipurpose Dam Reservoir(hereafterret-erredto as "the
Study") and the Japan InternationalCooperation Agency (hereafter refbrred to as '"JlCA"')
dispatchedthe PreparatoryStudyTeamto Indonesiafiorn February'
29 to March 9.2004.
JICA has preparedthe Study accordingto the S/W and M/M. and dispatchedthe Study Tearn.
headedby Mr. Minoru OUCHI of Nippon Koei Co., Ltd.. to Indonesiafi'omAugust 29.2004.
At the commencementof the Study.the Study Team explainedthe contentsof the InceptionReport
to Indonesianorganizationsconcerned(hereafterrefbrredto as "lndonesianside") and Indonesian
to as "Both sides") had a seriesof discussionon the
side and the Study Tearn(hereatierref-erred
InceptionReport.The list of attendance
is attachedin Attachrnent.
Indonesianside basically acceptedthe contents of the Inception Report and mentioned some
comments,requests,and agreements
in thosediscussions
as fbllorvs:
l) C o n s i d e ra ti oonf th e S tu d y
2\ Collaborationwith relatedOrganizationsand lJniversitiesin Indonesia
3 ) In fb rma ti o nD i s c l o s u re
4) TechnologyTransf'er
5) CounterpartPersonnel
6) Undertakingof the Governmentof Indonesia
Indonesian
siderequested
theStudyTeamto consider
sustainability
of themanagem
e"t "fl
I
.2#*
Mi nutcsol ' Mectinc.
3. Information Disclosure
4. Technology Transfer
- JICA infbrmed two counterpartswould be invited fbr training in Japan fbr about one
month aroundin February2005 in orderto facilitatetechnologytransf'er.
5. Counterpart Personnel
- Both sides agreed that counterpart organizations are DGWR in Jakarta and Proyek
Bengawan Solo (hereafterref-erredto as "PBS") and Perum JasaTirta I Bengawan Solo
Branch (hereafterreferredto as "PJT I Solo") at the site level.
- in Solo and
PBS agreedto provide two rooms as oflce spacein the PBS headquarters
PBS Wonogiri Dam ofl'ice.respectively.
- The Study Team requestedto provide more rooms in Solo (PJT I Solo Ofhce) when the
ofl'ice space becomes not enough tbr accornmodatingexperts of the Stud;, Teatn and I
counterpartsto be assignedfiom agenciesconcerned
r
b
I
I
--l
..
t/7,,/,1+:
,. ,/
-3-
Minutcs ot' Meeting
Indonesianside
DirectorateGeneral of Water Resources.Ministrv of Settlementand Recional
( K I M PRASWI L ):
Infrastructure
Mr.PrasidanantoNugroho (Directorate of Water
Resources
fbr CentralRegion)
'fechnical
Mr. Eko Subekti (Directorate of
Guidance- WaterResource)
Mr. Bistok S. (Directorateof TechnicalGuidance)
Mr. M. MLrrni(D i rectorate
of Techni calGui dance )
Mr. A . A zi s (D i rectorate
of Techni calGui dance)
Mr. TeguhUngsiadi(Dam SafbtyUnit)
BengawanSolo River Basin DeveloprnentPro.iect
Ofllce (PBS):
Mr. Hetorno
N a ti o n a lD e v e l o p me nPt l a nni ngA gency(B A P E N A S ):
Mr. D onnvA zdan
Mi n i s tryo f F o re s try(D E PH U T) Mr. S aefi rlR achrnan
(K LH ) Ms. Goss-v-
S ta teM i n i s tryo f En v i ro n rnent S uzanna
JICA Expert fbr DirectorateGeneral of Water Resources.Ministry of Settlelnentand
Resional I nfiastructure:
Mr. S huni chiMaeda(W aterR esourceP ol i cy' )
Mr. Masato.fogasaki(SaboPlanning)
Japanese
side
JICA StudvTeam: Mr. Mi noru Ouchi
Mr. Naoki Yarnashita
Ms. H i karLrS ugi rnoto
JICATokyo: Mr. Hideaki Matsurnoto
JICA Indonesia
Representative
Ofltce:
Mr. Shiro Nakasone
Indonesianside
DirectorateGeneral of Water Resources.Ministry of Settlementand Regional
lntiastructure:
Mr. E ko S ubekti (Techni calGui dance)
Mr. TeguhUngsiadi(Dam Safbty
- Unit)
WaterResource
Management
Service
in Central
JavaProvince
, I
Mr.KetutArsa
F
I
-4 .zr7n
Minutes ol' Meeting
side
Japanese
JICA StudyTeam: M r . M i n o r uO u c h i
Mr. Naoki Yamashita
Ms. HikaruSugirnoto
JICATokyo: Mr. Hideaki Matsumoto
-5-
Lampiran 4
Minutes of Meeting on Progress Report (1)
Mi nutes of Mect ins
Minutes of Meeting on
on
AND
Dipl.HE
Mr. Ir. DjokoSubarkah, Mr. MinonrOUCFII
1"
Directorof WaterResources 7 Leaderof the StudyTeam
for CentralRegion JapanlnternationalCoopcrationAgcncy
DirectorateGeneralof WaterResources
Ministryof PublicWorks
The Study on C'ountermeasures for Sedimentalion l v { i n u t c so f M e c t i n g
in the Wonogiri Multipurpose Dam Reservoir
Subject:ProgressReport (1)
Dat e: 19 J a n u a ry2 0 0 5 ,9 :3 0 -1 3 :3 0
The JICA Study Team submitted 20 copies of the ProgressReport ( 1) during the flrst ficld works in
'fhe
Indonesiain accordancewith the Scope of Works of the Study. mccting was chaireclby Ir. Djoko
Subarkah,Dipl.HE, Director of Water Resourcesfor Ccntral Regiorr.Irr the nleeting,the JICA Stucly
Team explained the contents of the ProgressReport ( 1). Thereatter,a scries of disctrssionrvas tnaclc
between both sides. As a result of discussions, the contents of the Progress Report ( I ) werc itt
principle agreedby both sides.The list of participants is attachedhercto.
field works were focused on the technical aspects. Ilnvironmcntal, social, ccotrot'tticantl
2. SWOT analysisis needed in the next stage to solve the problcm statementsidcrrtifieclin this
study properly.
3. The riverbed movement analysisand the verification test of sedintentremoval systctn will bc
4. The trash boom (floating net) in front of intake looks light, so it can ttot stop the gartrageto entcr
into the intake. The modified trash boom shall be consideredin view of easy operatiott antl
maintenance.
5 . The farmersare very poor. This study should find out some altcrnativesto solvc it' It is
suggestedthat farmers participationapproachshould be adopted.Ancl possibility of agrtr
shotrldbc
forestryby plantingof cropslike Jati Emas,mango,jambu mete,ctc for reforestation
with provisionof creditservicesfrom bank.
assessed
U3
The Study on Countermeasuresfor Sedimentation M i n u l e s o 1 'M e c t r n g
in the Wonogiri Multipurpose Dam Reservoir
on the StateForcstryEnterprise;linritcdproductiorr,
7. Therearethreekindsof forestclassification
production,and protectionforests.In the regulation,farmersare not allowedto cultivateall thc
forests,but Ministry of Forestrycan not guard all forestsfrom the farnrer'sactivities.So.
promotionofjoint programis expected.
2t3
The Study on Countermeasuresfor Sedimentation M i n u t e so f M c e t i n g
in the Wonogiri Multipurpose Dam Reservoir
Attachment:List of Participants
Indonesian
side
Institution Name Positiorr
Directorateof WaterResources
for Mr. Dioko Subarkah Director
CentralRegion
Directorateof TechnicalGuidance Mr. Prasidananto Chiel'of SubDircctoratc
Mr. Bistok S C hi ef of S ccti on
Japanese
side
lnstitution Name Position
JICA StudyTeam Mr. Minoru OuCf II T'eaml-eader
Mr. KenjiroONAKA Co-'feaml-eaclcr
Mr. TamotsuSllINGU Civil l3nginecr/
Dan'r& RelateclFacility
Mr. TadahiroFUKUDA ScdimentHvdratrlic
lixpert
Ms. t{ikaruSUGIMOTO Coordinator/
WaterQualityltxpert
3t3
Lampiran 5
Minutes of Meeting on Progress Report (2)
Minutes of Meetins
on
AND
/
I l
,1 I
.l
i ;/' 1
+#
/
Subject:ProgressReport (2)
Dat e: 22 A u g u s t 2 0 0 5 , 1 4 :0 0 -1 8 :0 0
The JICA Study Team submitted 25 copies of the ProgressReport (2) during the second field works
in Indonesia in accordance with the Scope of Works of the Study. The meeting was chaired by Ir.
Dyah Rahayu Pangesti,Dipl.HE, APU Director of Rivers, Lakes and Reservoirs.In the meeting, Ir.
Siswoko, Dipl.HE., Director General of Water Resources also attended. The JICA Study Team
explained the main contents of the Progress Report (2) with the focus on the current condition and
issues on both the Wonogiri dam reservoir sedimentation and its watershed. Thereafter, a series of
discussion was made between both sides. As a result of discussions,the contents of the Progress
Report (2) were agreed by both sides. The list of participant is attached hereto.
1. The Study results seem to focus on structural measures(civil works) in reservoir.The main issue
worries about a dilemma between increasing water demand and decreasing reservoir capacity.
To solve the problem, PU considerserosion control involving poor farmers is key factor. In this
respect, only PIJ can not solve this issue. Therefore PLJ considers to invite and involve relating
2. Sediment bypass from the Keduang River will cause relatively high concentrated sediment flow
to downstream reaches together with the water. The Keduang bypass will cause another
3. The idea of heightening the dam elevation to increase water volume is not recommendable as it
will causea very wide impacts such as stability of dam body, acquisition of reservoir area, social
problems, etc.
4. To deal with the accumulated sedimentation in the Wonogiri Dam, routine clearing of garbage
T-ft
U4
'Ihe
Study on Countermeasuresfbr Sedimentation Minutes of Meetins
in the Wonogiri MultipurposeDam Reservoir
7 . Farmers upstream of Wonogiri Dam especially in steep areas are very poor. Increasing their
income (poverty alleviation) is very crucial.
sedimentation issues are mainly from social problems. Good pattern (method) to solve social
problems shall be established. Of great importance is to implement the method. The Study
aspects.
-brt
2t4
The Study on Countermeasuresfbr Sedimentation Minutes of Meeting
in the Wonogiri Multipurpose Dam Reservoir
Attachment:List of Participants
Indonesian Side:
Institution Name Position
Directorate General of Water Mr. Siswoko Director General
Resources
314
The Study on Countermeasuresfor Sedimentatron Minutes of Meeting
in the Wonogiri Multipurpose Dam Reservoir
JapaneseSide:
D-r7
414
Lampiran 6
Minutes of Meeting on Progress Report (3)
Minutes of Meeting
on
AND
Jakurta, M a r c h 2 , 2 0 0 6
L,'qtr
L ,
Ir. Widagdo Dipl. HE
Subject:ProgressReport (3)
Dat e: M a rc h 2 ,2 0 0 6 ,9 :5 0 -1 3 :0 0
The JICA Study Team submitted 20 copies of the ProgressReport (3) during the second field works
in Indonesia in accordancewith the Scope of Works of the Study. The meeting was chaired by Ir.
Widagdo Dipl. HE, Director of Rivers, Lakes and Reservoirs.The JICA Study Team explained the
main contents of the Progress Report (3) on the progress to date, direction, and strategy of master
planning, urgent countermeasuresfor sedimentation at the intake issues and watershed conservation
as a mid / long term measures for Wonogiri reservoir sedimentation problems. Thereafler, a series of
discussion was made between both sides. As a result of discussions,the contents of the Progress
1 . The Wonogiri reservoir must be sustained as it is an important facility for storing water.
Combination of structural and non-structural countermeasures would be the best solution tbr
a't
The main issues are sediment deposits at the intake and the continuing sediment inflow into the
Wonogiri reservoir. The short term solution that must be highlighted is how to overcome the
blockage of the intake by sediment and garbage. Since dredging of sediment is a temporary
measure, the structural measures to be proposed should be based on the application detail and
operation rules. In addition, the alternative structural measure of the sediment bypass tunnel of
the Keduang River needs to be of further consideration from the aspects of impacts that may
4 . In the future, the sediment entering the Wonogiri reservoir must be reduced significantly. From
the aspect of watershed conservation, changing of lifestyle of local people would be very much
5 . The current operation method of Wonogiri reservoir is risky because of almost no observance of
the existing operation rule. This might come from strong demand of downstream stakeholders
114
The Study on Countermeasures for Sedimentotion ,\linutes of Meeting
in the llonogiri Multipurpose Danr Reservoir
for more water supply. Under the Study, re-allocation of the current remaining reservoir capacity
will be recommendedto securethe current water supply. Howeveq this will require some safety
6. The Study should highlight empowerrnent of community such as how to support people's
7. In view of how to motivate the local people on watershed management and conservation,
sharing of benefits between the upstream and downstream stakeholders shall be an important
factor. This concept for benefit sharing comes from the Integrated Water ResourcesManagement
(rwRM).
8. Conservation of the Wonogiri watershed should involve all the stakeholders concerned. The
214 ,'fu
H
The Study on Countermeasures for Sedimentation Minutes of Meeting
in the Wonogiri Multipurpose Dam Reservoir
314
n
1
The Study on Countermeasures for Sedimentation llinutes ol Meeling
in the Wonogiri Multipurpose Dom Reservoir
JapaneseSide:
414
Lampiran 7
Minutes of Meeting on Interim Report
Minutes oJ' Meeting
Interim Report
on
AND
\
\
\v /t
y', t.
i't';, 'u [\
L . ,
. t /Z
l/
Subject:InterimReport
Date: July I 9, 2006,I 3:00-l 6:30
Place: JatiluhurMeetingroomof Directorateof WaterResources
The JICA StudyTeamsubmitted20 copiesof the Interim Reportto Directorateof River,Lake and
Reservoirat the SteeringCommitteeon July 4,2006 in accordance
with the Scopeof Worksof the
Study.The meetingwaschairedby Ir. WidagdoDipl. HE, Directorof River,Lakeand Reservoir.
The
JICA StudyTeamexplainedmain contentof the InterimReportand exchanged
discussions
with the
Committeemembers.However,conclusionof the SteeringCommitteewas postponed
until the next
SteeringCommitteetwo weekslater for review of the Interim Reportby the Committeemembers,
because
the InterimReportpresentsthe MasterPlanof countermeasures
for sedimentation
problems
in the Wonogiri reservoir,and hence it was of great importanceto decide the direction of
comprehensive
sedimentmanagement
of the Wonogiriwatershedas well as the sedimentation
in the
Wonogirireservoir.
The next SteeringCommitteewas held on July 19,2006chairedby Ir. WidagdoDipl. HE, Director
of River, Lake and Reservoir.The JICA Study Team explainedwith the main focus on selecting
processof the sedimentstoragereservoirwith gateamongalternativestructuralcountermeasures
and
major activitiesof watershedmanagement
and conservation.
Thereafteqa seriesof discussionwas
madebetweenboth sides.As a resultof discussions,
the contentsof InterimReportwereagreedby
bothsides.The list of participantis attachedhereto.
Main pointsandconclusions
of discussions
areasfollows:
t . Participants
understood
with no objectionsthe conceptof MasterPlanby meansof combination
approachof structuraland non-structural
countermeasures
for the sedimentation
problemsin the
Wonogiri reservoir. Structural and non-structural countermeasuresshould be done
simultaneously.
tt4
'fhe ,ll inutes o.f ,lleeting
Study on Countermeasures for Sedimentation
in the Wonogiri lvlultipurpose Dam Reservoir
watershedconservation
4 . Community-based plan shouldbe fbrmulatedbasedon
and management
the participatoryapproach(bottom-upmethod)with the main focus on how to empowerthe
localfarmersandhow to supportthemto increaseagriculturalproductionandtheir income.
7
2t4 4
"7
The Study on Countermeosures for Sedimentation .llinutes of ,\leeting
in lhe Wonogiri Multipurpose Dam Reservoir
3t4
tr7,
'l-he
Study on Countermeasures for Sedimentation lvlinutes of lvteeting
in the Wonogiri Multipurpose Dam Reservoir
J apanes eS id e :
4t4
nft
Lampiran 8
Minutes of Meeting on Draft Final Report
Lampiran 9
Minutes of Meeting on Draft Final Report