Professional Documents
Culture Documents
0(0) 1–8
! The Author(s) 2015
Abstract
China is the only one of the five original nuclear weapon states that is quantitatively increasing the size of its
nuclear arsenal and it now is estimated to have approximately 260 warheads. The arsenalÕs capabilities are also
increasing as older missiles are replaced with newer ones. As China assigns a growing portion of its warheads to
long-range missiles, the US intelligence community predicts that by the mid-2020s the number of warheads on
missiles capable of threatening the United States could increase to well over 100. The nuclear warheads in the
Chinese stockpile are intended for delivery mainly by land-based ballistic missile but also by aircraft and
submarines. The current force has nearly 150 nuclear-capable land-based missiles, half of which are short-
range and medium-range. China has also built two types of submarine-launched ballistic missiles, one devel-
oped for a submarine no longer considered operational and the other in the final stages of development.
Keywords
China, defense, ICBM, nuclear weapon, SLBM, SSBN, United States
e estimate that China has app- quantitatively increasing the size of its
Aircraft
H-6 B-6 ~20 1965 3,100+ 1 x bomb ~20
Fighters? ? ? ? N.A. 1 x bomb ?
Cruise missles
DH-10 CJ-10 ~250 2006? 1,500? 1x? ?
DH-20? CJ-20? ? ? ? 1x? ?
1 The CIA concluded in 1993 that China “almost certainly” had developed a warhead for the DF-15, although it is unclear if the capability was fielded.
2 This table only counts nuclear versions DF-21 (CSS-5 Mod 1) and DF-21A (CSS-5 Mod 2), each of which has fewer than 50 launchers deployed. The conventional DF-21C and
DF-21D are not counted.
3 The missile and warhead inventory may be larger than the number of launchers, some of which can be reused to fire additional missiles.
4 Neither the JL-1 nor the JL-2 SLBM are fully operational, although warheads probably are available. The JL-2 is under development.
5 China is thought to have a small stockpile of nuclear bombs with yields between 10 kilotons and 3 megatons. Figures are for only those aircraft that are estimated to have a second-
ary nuclear mission. Aircraft range is equivalent to combat radius, which for some H-6 bombers can be extended with air refueling. A fighter-bomber was used in a nuclear test in
1972, but it is unknown whether a tactical bomb capability has been fielded.
6 US Air Force intelligence lists the ground-launched DH-10 land-attack cruise missile as “conventional or nuclear.” US Air Force Global Strike Command also lists the air-launched
cruise missile CJ-20 as nuclear-capable, but it is unclear whether that finding comes from a coordinated intelligence assessment.
7 The number in parenthesis includes the 48 warheads produced for the four existing SSBNs. China also possesses an additional 30 warheads, including those produced for the
DF-3A and JL-1 that are awaiting dismantlement, and a small inventory of spare warheads, for a total stockpile of approximately 260 warheads.
Chinese missiles also have strike mis- modernization of ChinaÕs land-based bal-
sions against Russia and India. listic missile force, under which it is repla-
cing older, transportable, liquid-fuel, slow-
launching missiles with longer-range,
Land-based missiles
road-mobile, solid-fuel, quick-launching
Modernization of the Chinese land-based missiles based at new or upgraded
ballistic missile force took an important Second Artillery garrisons. As a result of
new step in 2015 with reports that the coun- this effort, a greater portion of ChinaÕs
try had equipped some of its silo-based future land-based missile force will have
ICBMs with multiple independently- longer ranges and be more maneuverable.
targetable re-entry vehicles (MIRVs). The current force has approximately
The upgrade is part of a broad 160 nuclear-capable land-based missiles
of seven types, half of which are short- for decades without doing so but appar-
range and medium-range; the number of ently has recently decided to equip some
long-range missiles is increasing slowly. of the DF-5 missiles with MIRVs, partly in
The oldest missile in ChinaÕs inventory, response to the US deployment of a bal-
the DF-3A (CSS-2), is a liquid-fueled, listic-missile defense system (Defense
single-stage, maneuverable, intermediate- Department, 2015: 8, 31; Kristensen, 2015;
range ballistic missile that can deliver a 3.3- Sanger and Broad, 2015). We estimate
megaton warhead up to 3,000 kilometers that China has approximately 20 DF-
(km), sufficient to target southeastern 5As, of which perhaps half have been
Russia and Japan. The PentagonÕs annual equipped with MIRVs.
report to Congress on China in 2014 did not ChinaÕs primary regional nuclear mis-
mention the DF-3A but the missile reap- sile is the two-stage, solid-fuel, road-
peared in the 2015 report (Defense Depart- mobile DF-21 (CSS-5) medium-range bal-
ment, 2015). Apparently only one brigade listic missile (MRBM). The DF-21 exists
of perhaps eight transportable DF-3A in two nuclear versions: the DF-21 (CSS-5
launchers remains but China may be in Mod 1) and the newer DF-21A (CSS-5
the process of retiring them and replacing Mod 2). The Mod 1 version has a range
them with the DF-21 (Kristensen, 2014a). of 1,750-plus km but the new version
China also continues to maintain a probably has a longer range of about
single brigade of its second-oldest mis- 2,150 km. The US intelligence community
sile, the DF-4 (CSS-3) intercontinental estimates that ChinaÕs inventory of DF-
ballistic missile (ICBM). The two-stage, 21s increased from 19 to 50 missiles in
liquid-fueled missile can deliver a 3.3- 2006 to 75 to 100 missiles in 2011 (Defense
megaton warhead more than 5,500 km, Department, 2006: 50; 2011: 78). Today
sufficient to target India, part of Russia, there are fewer than 50 launchers of
and Guam. The brigade has approxi- each type deployed, with an estimated
mately 10 transportable launchers, some 80 to 90 launchers in total (US Air
or all of which may be based in caves with Force, National Air and Space Intelli-
a roll-out-to-launch capability. The DF-4 gence Center, 2013: 17). China has also
is being replaced by the DF-31. started deploying conventionally armed
ChinaÕs DF-5A (CSS-4 Mod 2)Ña versions of the DF-21 (the DF-21C and
liquid-fueled, two-stage, silo-based DF-21D, the latter an anti-ship missile).
ICBMÑhas a range that exceeds 13,000 This potentially dangerous mix of
kilometers and has apparently been tar- nuclear and conventional missiles
geted at the United States and Russia increases the risk of misunderstanding,
since the early 1980s. The DF-5A is a miscalculation, and mistaken nuclear
longer-range modified version of the escalation in a crisis.4
DF-5 (CSS-4 Mod 1). The Pentagon Deployment of the new DF-31 (CSS-10
reported in May 2015 that China had Mod 1) ICBM, first introduced in 2006,
equipped some of the DF-5As with mul- appears to have stalled for the time
tiple independently-targetable re-entry being with fewer than 10 launchers (pos-
vehicles (MIRV) (Defense Department, sibly as few as eight) deployed along
2015: 8). The MIRVÕed DF-5A is known with an equal number of missiles. The
as CSS-4 Mod 3. China has had the ability three-stage, road-mobile DF-31 which is
to deploy multiple warheads on the DF-5 transported on a six-axle TEL
Figure 1. Potential Julang-2 SLBM launch areas for targeting continental United States
The Pentagon asserts that the Jin/JL-2 into the Pacific Ocean, through danger-
weapon system Òwill give the PLA [Chin- ous choke points where it would be
ese] Navy its first credible sea-based vulnerable to hostile antisubmarine war-
nuclear deterrentÓ (Defense Depart- fare5 (see Figure 1).
ment, 2013: 6). Yet the Chinese SSBN ChinaÕs main concern is making sure
fleet faces several doctrinal, technical, that its minimum nuclear deterrent would
and operational constraints. Under cur- survive a first strike, and for that reason it
rent doctrine, ChinaÕs Central Military spends considerable resources on moder-
Commission does not allow the military nizing and hiding its land-based missiles.
services to have warheads deployed on This makes its submarine program puz-
missiles under normal circumstances. zling, for it is much riskier to deploy nuclear
Handing over custody of nuclear war- weapons at sea, where submarines can be
heads to deployed submarines in peace- sunk by unfriendly forces, than to hide
time would constitute a significant them in caves or forests deep inside ChinaÕs
change of Chinese doctrine. extensive territory (Kristensen, 2014a).
Moreover, no Chinese ballistic missile
submarine has ever sailed on a deterrent
Cruise missiles
patrol so ChinaÕs navy and the Central
Military Commission have essentially China produces and fields a number of
no experience in operating a submarine cruise missiles, including land-attack
force during realistic military operations. cruise missiles that may have a nuclear cap-
Developing this capability will require ability. The CIA concluded in 1995 that a
development of new command and con- Chinese test scheduled for that year Òmay
trol technologies and procedures. include warhead testing for . . . a cruise mis-
But even if China deployed warheads sileÓ (CIA, 1995) but the evidence for Chin-
on the SSBNs and sent them to sea in a ese nuclear cruise missiles is sketchy and
crisis, where would they sail? For a JL-2 should be viewed with caution.
to reach the continental United States, One potentially nuclear-capable
for example, a Jin SSBN would have to Chinese cruise missile is the DH-10 (CJ-
sail through the East China Sea and well 10) land-attack cruise missile (LACM),
which is thought to have a range of per- 3. The Òcontinental United StatesÓ as used here
haps 1,500 km. US Air Force Intelligence includes only the lower 48 states. US states and
lists the DH-10 as Òconventional or territories outside of the continental United
States include Alaska, Hawaii, Guam, Ameri-
nuclear,Ó indicating that it is a dual-cap-
can Samoa, and many tiny Pacific islands.
able weapon (US Air Force, National Air 4. The Second ArtilleryÕs organization of DF-
and Space Intelligence Center, 2013: 29). 21s is unclear but it is thought that nuclear
The DH-10 is launched from a four-axle and conventional units are kept separate.
triple box launcher. The number of For insightful studies of ChinaÕs missile
deployed DH-10s is uncertain, in part force, see Stokes (2010) and Stokes (2012).
because the Pentagon has stopped 5. Chinese nuclear submarines are apparently
releasing numbers for Chinese missiles. very noisy (Kristensen, 2009b).
In 2011 the estimate was 40 to 55 launch-
ers with 200 to 500 missiles (Defense References
Department, 2011: 78). Burgess RL (2012) Annual threat assessment: Statement
China is also developing an air- before the Senate Armed Services Committee,
launched land-attack cruise missile Defense Intelligence Agency. February 16, p. 19.
known as the CJ-20 for delivery by mod- CIA (1990) China: New nuclear test [Deleted]. Science
and Weapons Review, SW SWR 90-048C, July 31, p. 1.
ified H-6 bombers. An Air Force Global Partially declassified and released to the National
Strike Command briefing in 2013 Security Archive by the CIAÕs Directorate of Intel-
asserted that the CJ-20 is nuclear-cap- ligence, Office of Scientific and Weapons Research,
able (Kristensen, 2013) but the US Air under a Freedom of Information Act request.
CIA (1993) ChinaÕs nuclear weapons: Facing pro-
Force does not list the CJ-20 at all (US spects for a comprehensive test ban. Intelligence
Air Force, National Air and Space Intel- Memorandum 93-20044C M, September 30, p. 5.
ligence Center, 2013: 29). Partially declassified and released to the National
Security Archive by the CIAÕs Office of Scientific
and Weapons Research under a Freedom of Infor-
Funding
mation Act request.
This research was carried out with grant from the CIA (1995) China: Nuclear test [Deleted]. National Intel-
New Land Foundation and the Ploughshares Fund. ligence Digest, CPAS NID 95-053CX, March 7, p. 11.
Partially declassified and released to the National
Notes Security Archive by the National Intelligence Coun-
cil under a Freedom of Information Act request.
1. Given its history of nuclear tests using weap- CIA (2001) Foreign missile defense developments and
ons dropped by short- and medium-range air- the ballistic missile threat through 2015, unclassi-
craft, China is likely to have a small quantity fied summary. National Intelligence Council,
of nuclear bombs that could be delivered by December. Available at: https://www.fas.org/
H-6 bombers. ChinaÕs nuclear bomber cap- spp/starwars/CIA-NIE.htm.
ability is minor and involves secondary mis- Clapper JR (2015) Statement for the Record: Worldwide
sions for only a small number of aircraft. Threat Assessment of the US Intelligence Community,
2. Nuclear weapons are stored in central facil- Senate Armed Services Committee, February 26, p. 7.
ities under the control of the Central Military Available at: http://www.armed-services.senate.gov/
Commission. Should China come under imo/media/doc/Clapper_ 02-26-15.pdf.
Defense Department (2006) Annual Report to Con-
nuclear threat, the weapons would be
gress: Military Power of the PeopleÕs Republic of
released to the Second Artillery Corps to China 2006. Office of the Secretary of Defense,
enable missile brigades to go on alert and May 23. Available at: http://www.defense.gov/
prepare to retaliate. For a description of the pubs/pdfs/china%20report%202006.pdf.
Chinese alerting concept, see Kristensen Defense Department (2011) Annual Report to Congress:
(2009a). For more on warhead storage in Military and Security Developments Involving the
China, see Stokes (2010). PeopleÕs Republic of China 2011. Office of the