Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevier.com/locate/ces
Abstract
A dynamic mechanistic model of a multi-phase heterogeneous batch reactor processing a non-catalytic 2uid–solid reaction is developed
and numerically solved. The model takes into account both intra-particular convection and di5usion phenomena, as well as chemical
reaction between the 2uid and the solid. By addressing the until now ignored case of convection originated by the continuous increase of
the particle porosity, this work enables a more realistic modeling of many non-catalytic 2uid–solid reaction systems. The dependency of
the convective term on the chemical reaction rates gives rise to a space and time dependency of the intra-particle velocity thus increasing
the mathematical complexity of the problem. The model is characterized by a set of PDEs coupled with adequate boundary conditions that
are solved by the method of lines. An example of application of great importance to the chemical pulping of wood is used, emphasizing
the di5erences with the typical situation where only di5usion is considered.
? 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Simulation; Mathematical modeling; Multi-phase reactor; Intra-particle convection; Variable porosity; Pulping digester
0009-2509/02/$ - see front matter ? 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 0 0 9 - 2 5 0 9 ( 0 2 ) 0 0 4 2 9 - 3
448 N. C. P. Fernandes, J. A. A. M. Castro / Chemical Engineering Science 58 (2003) 447 – 456
where Cp; k denotes the concentration of the species k in the c (x; t) = 1 − (1 − c; i )(x; t); (8)
phase or 2ow p and L is the particle thickness. Coupling
Eq. (1) with Eq. (2) it is possible to reach where c; i is the initial average porosity of the chips and
the yield (x; t) is the sum of the local mass fractions of
dCf ; k Qin (Cin; k − Cf ; k ) + Kk afe (Ce; k |x=L=2 − Cf ; k ) all organic compounds in the solid matrix and is given
= :
dt Vf by
(3) no
(x; t) = Cs; k (x; t): (9)
As the reaction proceeds, the volume of free liquid, Vf , de- k=1
creases with time, while the e5ective inter-facial area be-
tween the free and entrapped liquids, afe , increases due to Porosity change: The model also requires the partial
the increase in porosity. derivative of porosity with time. From Eq. (8) and heeding
To determine the time evolution of the concentration to Eqs. (7) and (9) it is possible to reach, after simpli-
of a generic substance k dissolved in the entrapped liquid >cation
phase inside the particle, a partial microscopic mass balance
o n
is used @c
= (1 − c; i ) |Rk |: (10)
@t
@ @ @Ce; k @ k=1
(c Ce; k ) = Dk − (c vCe; k ) + k |Rk |
@t @x @x @x
Interface area: According to Dupuit’s law it is possi-
(4) ble to prove that, for a random distribution of pores, the
450 N. C. P. Fernandes, J. A. A. M. Castro / Chemical Engineering Science 58 (2003) 447 – 456
ratio between the porous cross-sectional area and the to- Thus, the >nal form of Eq. (1) is
tal cross-sectional area is the same as the ratio between
dVf
the porous volume and the total volume, i.e., the porosity = Qin − Qout − |vx=L=2 afe : (17)
(Froment & Bisho5, 1990). Therefore, dt
E9ective di9usion coe6cients: Dk depends on the molec-
ae (x; t) = c (x; t)ac ; (11)
ular di5usivity of species k and on the porosity and tortuosity
where the porosity is given by Eq. (8) and both ae and ac of the solid matrix (Froment & Bisho5, 1990). In this work,
refer to the total number of particles in the reactor rather than the tortuosity is considered constant. Thus, the e5ective dif-
to a single chip. The area of interface between the free and fusion coeKcient is updated with the porosity according to
entrapped liquids is the e5ective capillary cross-sectional
Dk (x; t) = Dm; k c (x; t) (18)
area at the chip edge (x = L=2):
afe = c |x=L=2 ac : (12) with the constant Dm; k de>ned as
Dm; k
Intra-particle velocity: Since the intra-particle convection Dm; k = ; (19)
is originated by the change of porosity and not by a forced
motion of the free liquid through the chip, the “2ow” of where Dm; k is the molecular di5usivity of species k.
liquid across the slab decreases from the chip edge to the chip
center (where it is zero). As it has been already mentioned 2.3. Boundary conditions
above, this leads to symmetric velocity pro>les relatively to
the chip center. The velocity of the 2uid at a given point To solve the set of PDEs de>ned by Eqs. (1), (3), (6),
inside the chip can be computed from and (7) a consistent set of boundary conditions has to be
Q(x; t) selected and this should re2ect the physical characteristics
v(x; t) = : (13) of the system:
ae (x; t)
The liquid 2ow at a generic point xj of the x-axis (spatial • Both sides of the chip contact the free liquid, which means
coordinate along the chip thickness) represents all the liquid that they are exposed to the same external concentrations.
needed to >ll up the new inner volume generated by the Therefore, di5usion will induce symmetric pro>les along
chemical dissolution of the solid matrix between x = 0 (chip the slab thickness.
center) and the point xj . Thus, the convective liquid 2ow at • Since convection results from an increase in chip poros-
a generic position xj inside the chip is given by ity due to chemical reaction and admitting that the ini-
xj tial conditions are the same along the chip thickness, the
@ convective 2ows are symmetric relatively to the particle
Q(xj ; t) = − c (x; t)ac d x : (14)
@t 0 center.
Substituting Eqs. (11) and (14) into Eq. (13) it is possible Therefore, at the particle center (x = 0), for each species in
to obtain, after simpli>cation phase p (either solid or entrapped liquid) one can consider
xj
1 @c (x; t) that
v(xj ; t) = − d x; (15)
c (xj ; t) 0 @t @Cp; k
= 0: (20)
where the partial derivative of the chip porosity with time @x x=0
is given by Eq. (10). This velocity depends on the reaction
extent in two antagonistic ways: The speci>cations at chip edge are the result of assuming
equal mass 2uxes at the chip surface (x = L=2):
• On one hand, if the chemical reaction rate increases the
@Ce; k
change in porosity will be faster, leading to an increase a c Dk + Qfe Ce; k |x=L=2
@x x=L=2
in the intra-particle velocity pro>le;
• On the other hand, as the reaction proceeds the porosity =Kk afe (Cf ; k − Ce; k |x=L=2 ) + Qfe Cf ; k : (21)
increases, thus increasing the porous cross-sectional area.
This promotes a decrease in the intra-particle velocity. Attending to Eqs. (12) and (16) it is possible to transform
Eq. (21) into
Volume of free liquid: The total 2ow of 2uid from the
free liquid into the chip, Qfe (Eq. (1)) is equal to the 2ow Dk @Ce; k
= (Kk − v|x=L=2 )
of liquid crossing the chip edge, Q|x=L=2 , i.e., c @x x=L=2
The model equations are solved by the method of lines that A relevant application of the model developed here is in
transforms the problem into a system of ODEs. The partial the chemical pulping of wood, a heterogeneous non-catalytic
di5erential equations were discretized using a constant step reaction process of upmost importance in the pulp and paper
along the spatial coordinate of the particle, x, and the space industry. A particular operational problem in this process is
derivatives were approximated by centered >nite di5erences. the non-uniformity of the >nal pulp that arises as a result of
The number of resulting ODEs, neq is strong concentration gradients that are built up within the
chip during the reactor operation. Therefore, the ability to
neq = nf + (n + 1)(ne + ns ); (23) predict such gradients is of great importance for the under-
standing and handling of the factors that a5ect this undesir-
where nf , ne , ns and n designate the number of equations able non-uniformity. In order to illustrate the model capa-
for the free liquid, for the entrapped liquid (at each chip bilities, the kinetic laws proposed by Mirams and Nguyen
position), for the solid phase (at each chip position) and (1996) were used to compute the reaction rates of the or-
the number of discretization intervals used between the chip ganic species in the wood. It is noteworthy that this kinetic
center and the chip edge, respectively. The number of equa- model was developed based on average solid matrix con-
tions for each phase is given by centration measurements and on the concentrations of inor-
ganic species in the free liquid. Since the work of Mirams
ni + no for free liquid; and Nguyen (1996) does not include a law for the consump-
np = ni + no for entrapped liquid; (24) tion rate of inorganic chemicals, the model employed by
Fernandes and Castro (2000) was used after proper tuning
no for solid matrix: with industrial data from a pulp mill. A “heterogeneous” ki-
netic model, based on concentrations inside the chip does not
Due to limitations related to the adopted numerical approx-
exist yet and, therefore, the model of Mirams and Nguyen
imation of the derivatives, the equations corresponding to
(1996) is employed here for exemplifying purposes. Such
the physical boundaries (chip center and chip edge) require
approximation of using a “homogeneous” kinetic model to
the use of a >ctitious point. The state variables correspond-
compute the reaction rates of a heterogeneous global model
ing to the solid and to the entrapped liquid in the particle
has been adopted in previous works taking into account the
can be computed at the >ctitious point j = −1 using the dis-
di5usion inside the chip (for example, Gustafson, Shelder,
cretized form of Eq. (20). In what concerns the >ctitious
McKean, & Finlayson, 1983; Jim'enez, Gustafson, &
point at j = n + 1, the state variables corresponding to the
McKean, 1989; Agarwal, 1993).
entrapped liquid can be computed from Eq. (22). However,
This kinetics implies a number of concentrations as state
for the variables characterizing the solid matrix a linear ap-
variables that include six organic compounds in the solid
proximation was assumed in the vicinity of the chip edge,
matrix
that is,
c, −
0.75
• the liquid (including both free and entrapped) to wood
ratio is approximately 6:13 dm3 kg−1 ,
0.70
• both Qin and Qout are set to zero,
• the initial free liquid concentration of hydroxide x = 0.0 mm
x = 0.9 mm
ion is 1:20 mol dm−3 and of hydro-sul>de ion is 0.65
x = 2.1 mm
The industrial purpose of the cooking is to decrease the Fig. 3. Porosity pro>les at di5erent spatial positions in the wood particles.
amount of lignin in the solid structure of wood in order
to release the cellulosic >bers, while preserving the chemi-
cal properties of their main components, i.e., cellulose and 0.012
hemicellulose. For a given operating scenario, the tradeo5
x = 0.0 mm
x = 0.9 mm
between high deligni>cation and low carbohydrate attack 0.010
x = 2.1 mm
x = 3.0 mm
determines the industrial reaction time. Simulations were
performed to cover 250 min (≈ 4:2 h), a typical cooking 0.008
time.
v, mm min−1
The two inorganic chemicals in the free liquor are trans- 0.006
ferred to the chips and react with the six organic compounds
of the solid matrix, dissolving them into the entrapped liq- 0.004
uid. The chemical degradation and dissolution of the solid
structure of the wood is responsible for the increase of the 0.002
porosity of the chips. This has been ignored in previous
attempts to describe the intra-particle process heterogene- 0.000
ity (Johnsson, 1970; Tyler, 1982; Gustafson et al., 1983;
0 50 100 150 200 250
Gustafson, 1988; Agarwal, 1993; Agarwal, Gustafson, &
t, min
Arasakesari, 1994; Agarwal & Gustafson, 1997; Li, Phoenix,
& Macleod, 1997). In these works a considerable discrep- Fig. 4. Absolute values of interstitial velocity pro>les inside the wood
ancy between the experimental values and the predicted chips.
space averaged pro>les does exist and the range of values
anticipated for non-uniformity is far from reality. This in-
accuracy subsists even when di5erent parameters for dif- rapid increase of porosity seen at the chip surface in the
ferent data sets are employed in the simulation (Gustafson beginning of the operation, despite the relatively low tem-
et al., 1983; Agarwal, 1993; Agarwal et al., 1994; Agarwal perature. After this initial phase the porosity changes are at-
& Gustafson, 1997). The thicker the chips, the more evident tributable almost exclusively to the dissolution of the three
is the weakness of these models. Agarwal (1993) (see also less reactive organic components whose behavior, though,
Agarwal et al., 1994; Agarwal & Gustafson, 1997) tries to is strongly in2uenced by the progressive increase in the re-
overcome the diKculties described in Gustafson et al. (1983) actor temperature. At t = 60 min, the time derivative of the
by introducing the concept of an “equivalent sphere” with porosity starts to diminish, due to the progressive lowering
the same speci>c surface area as the chip but the results, of concentrations in wood and of the inorganic reactants.
although better, are still unsatisfactory. As a result of the porosity evolution highlighted in
The porosity of the chips varies signi>cantly during the Fig. 3, the wood particles soak free liquid to >ll up the
cooking as it is portrayed in Fig. 3, where it is also possible dissolved volume of solid matrix, giving rise to an inward
to see that its evolution is di5erent from point to point along 2ow of liquid. The absolute values of the velocity pro>les
the chip thickness, since it is the result of the local rates of associated to such a 2ow are presented in Fig. 4 for several
the reactions involved. chip positions.
Three of the six organic chemicals that form the solid The absolute value of the velocity attains its maxi-
matrix are very reactive. Their fast dissolution explains the mum once the highest temperature is reached (t = 1 h).
N. C. P. Fernandes, J. A. A. M. Castro / Chemical Engineering Science 58 (2003) 447 – 456 453
for the liquid 2ow (see Eq. (15)). It can also be seen that
0
the module of the velocity, at a certain time, always de-
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
creases from the external surface (dotted line) to the center
of the chip (solid line). This means that the increase of the x, mm
interstitial area (bigger in the outer zones of the particle)
Fig. 5. Concentration pro>les of OH− along the spatial particle coordinate
plays a less signi>cant role on the velocity than the spatial (Cf ; OH− |t=0 = 1200 mol m−3 ).
cumulative changes of porosity from the chip center up to
the point under consideration.
An interesting comparison that can be made is between the
0.25
convective 2ux associated to this intra-particle velocity and conv, x = 0 mm
the total (convective and di5usive) 2ux. The average ratio conv, x = 3.0 mm
conv, average
between the convective and the total 2uxes for the species 0.20 no conv x = 0.0 mm
0.8
0.7
ODW
0.6
Ce, C+H, kg kg−1
0.5
0.4
conv, x = 0 mm
conv, x = 3.0 mm
conv, average
0.3
no conv x = 0.0 mm
no conv x = 3.0 mm
no conv, average
0.2
0 50 100 150 200 250
t, min
Fig. 7. Solid matrix carbohydrates pro>les with and without convection. Fig. 8. Yield predictions with and without convection.
concentration and above all the particle non-uniformity, rel- systems, none until now has addressed this problem when
atively to the model proposed here. The discrepancy be- it is caused by chemical reaction of the particles structure.
tween the two averaged values begins at t ≈ 50 min, has Usually, these are seen as inert materials where the catalyst
a maximum at t ≈ 100–150 min and decreases slightly at is supported and the convection origin lies on the fact that
the end of the operation. This mismatch is remarkably co- there is a pressure drop along the reactor, that leads to a
incident with that veri>ed between the di5usion model used constant intra-particle velocity. Here, a wider methodology
by Gustafson et al. (1983) and the data used in its valida- is taken, with a time and space variable velocity, since it
tion. This anticipates a strong predictive potential for the depends on time and spatial evolutions of the reaction rates.
model with intra-particle convection. As it has been pointed The approaches for intra-particular convection developed
out above, the results presented in this paper are qualitative until now are not suitable for the case of variable porosity of
and have demonstrative purposes only. Quantitative results the particles. The modeling approach adopted here was ap-
require a convenient choice of parameters, namely of the plied to the heterogeneous process of kraft pulping of wood.
di5usion coeKcients (now functions of the porosity only). The inclusion of convection induced by the increase of the
The concentration pro>les of the carbohydrates in the chip porosity enables a more realistic and potentially accu-
wood predicted by the two models can be seen in Fig 7. rate description of this process. Such a tool is important at
Once more the model taking into account the intra-particle a industrial level because it can be used to achieve higher
mass transport by convection forecasts less inhomogeneity production rates and pulp of higher quality. In spite of the
than that where this phenomenon is ignored. The consider- preliminary nature of the values used for the mass trans-
able disparity between the average values in Fig. 7 again fer coeKcients across the >lm and the di5usion coeKcients
suggests that the correcting key for the inability of the 1-D (now simple functions of the chip porosity), the model ex-
slab model to reproduce the experimental data lies on the hibits promising features in overcoming signi>cant predic-
accounting of the important porosity changes and the con- tion inaccuracies of previous investigations where the di5u-
sequent intra-particle convection transport mechanism. sion is the only transport mechanism that is accounted for.
Finally, Fig. 8 reveals the di5erences between the pre- The model developed here provides a better understanding
dictions of the two models under analysis in what con- of the heterogeneous nature of the cooking process and is a
cerns the yield of the pulping process. The pro>les along step ahead towards the e5ective control of the undesirable
the chip thickness, especially those corresponding to the non-uniformity of the pulp.
end of the cooking, corroborate the overestimation of pulp
non-uniformity by the di5usion model relatively to that pro-
posed here that accounts for both di5usion and intra-particle Notation
convection.
Cs; k mass fraction of the species k in the solid phase Agarwal, N., & Gustafson, R. (1997). A contribution to the modeling of
based on oven dry wood, dimensionless kraft pulping. The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, 75(2),
Dk e5ective di5usion coeKcient for species k, m2 s−1 8–15.
Agarwal, N., Gustafson, R., & Arasakesari, S. (1994). Modeling the e5ect
Dm; k molecular di5usivity for species k, m2 s−1
of chip size in kraft pulping. Paperi ja Puu, 76(6 –7), 410–416.
Dm; k ratio between the molecular di5usivity for species Aris, R., & Kehoe, J. P. G. (1973). Communications on the theory
k and the tortuosity, m2 s−1 of di5usion and reaction-IX. Internal pressure and forced 2ow for
Kk mass transfer coeKcient for the species k, m s−1 reactions with volume change. Chemical Engineering Science, 28,
L particle thickness, m 2094–2098.
Brown, P. N., Hindmarsh, A. C., & Petzold, L. (1998). Consistent initial
n number of discretization intervals along x, dimen-
condition calculation for di5erential-algebraic systems. SIAM Journal
sionless of Science Computing, 19, 1495–1512.
ne number of equations for the entrapped liquid at each Brown, P. N., Hindmarsh, A. C., & Petzold, L. R. (1994). Using Krylov
chip position, dimensionless methods in the solution of large-scale di5erential-algebraic systems.
neq total number of ODEs which constitute the dis- SIAM Journal of Science Computing, 15, 1467–1488.
Costa, I. M. M., Francisco, S. C. P., Simão, J. P. F., Egas, A. P., & Castro,
cretized model, dimensionless
J. A. A. M. (2001). The nature of mass transfer of alkali to wood chips
nf number of equations for the free liquid, dimension- during kraft pulping. In CHEMPOR’2001, Aveiro, Portugal, in press.
less Fernandes, N. C. P., & Castro, J. A. A. M. (2000). Steady-state simulation
ni number of inorganic species, dimensionless of a continuous moving bed reactor in the pulp and paper industry.
no number of organic species, dimensionless Chemical Engineering Science, 55(18), 3729–3738.
Ferreira, R. M. Q. (1988). ContribuicBão para o estudo de reactores
ns number of equations for the solid phase at each
catalcBãticos de leito Dxo: Efeito da convecFo em catalisadores de poros
chip position, dimensionless largos e casos de catalisadores bidispersos. Ph.D. thesis, Universidade
Q 2ow of liquid at a generic point inside the chip do Porto.
relatively to x axes, m3 s−1 Ferreira, R. M. Q., Costa, A. C. A., & Rodrigues, A. E. (1996). E5ect of
Qfe 2ow from free to entrapped phase, m3 s−1 intraparticle convection on the transient behavior of >xed-bed reactors:
Finite di5erences and collocation methods for solving unidimensional
Qin inlet 2ow in the reactor, m3 s−1
models. Computers and Chemical Engineering, 20(10), 1201–1225.
Qout outlet 2ow from the reactor, m3 s−1 Froment, G. F., & Bisho5, K. B. (1990). Chemical reactor analysis and
Q intra-particular 2ow of liquid at a generic x point design (2nd ed.). New York: Wiley.
of the chip, m3 s−1 Gustafson, R. R. (1988). The role of di5usion during initial deligni>cation
Rk reaction rate for species k, kg kg−1
ODW s
−1 of alkaline pulping. Tappi Journal, 71(4), 145–147.
Gustafson, R. R., Shelder, C. A., McKean, W. T., & Finlayson, B. A.
t time, s
(1983). Theoretical model of the kraft pulping process. Industrial and
v intra-particular velocity, m s−1 Engineering Chemistry, Processing Design and Development, 22(1),
Vf volume of free liquid, m3 87–96.
x spatial coordinate along the thickness of the Jim'enez, G., Gustafson, R. R., & McKean, W. T. (1989). Modelling
chip, m incomplete penetration of kraft pulping liquor. Journal of Pulp and
Paper Science, 15(3), J110–J115.
Johnsson, L. (1970). Mathematical models of the kraft cooking process.
Greek letters Technical report 11, Department of Control Engineering, Chalmers
University of Technology, Gothenburg, Sweden.
c chip porosity, dimensionless Komiyama, H., & Inoue, H. (1974). E5ects of intraparticle 2ow on
c; i initial chip porosity, dimensionless catalytic reactions. Journal of Chemical Engineering of Japan, 7(4),
281–286.
yield, dimensionless
Leitão, A., & Rodrigues, A. E. (1996). Modeling of biodegradation/
c; OD speci>c mass of an oven dry chip, kg m−3 adsorption combined process in >xed-bed bio>lm reactors: E5ects
tortuosity factor, dimensionless of the intraparticle convection 2ow. Chemical Engineering Science,
51(20), 4595–4604.
Li, S., & Petzold, L. R. (1999). Design of new DASPK for sensitivity
analysis. Technical report TRCS99-28, University of California at
Acknowledgements Santa Barbara.
Li, J., Phoenix, A., & Macleod, J. M. (1997). Di5usion of lignin
Financial support granted by Ministry of Science and macromolecules within the >bre walls of kraft pulp. Part I:
Technology under Project Praxis 3/3.2/PAPEL/2327/95 Determination of the di5usion coeKcient under alkaline conditions.
The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering, 75(2), 16–22.
is gratefully acknowledged. The >rst author also wishes
Lopes, J. C. B., Dias, M. M., Mata, V. G., & Rodrigues, A. E. (1995).
to thank Program Praxis for her scholarship PRAXIS/4/ Flow >eld and non-isothermal e5ects on di5usion, convection and
4.1/BD/3338. reaction in permeable catalysts. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry
Research, 34(1), 148–157.
Mirams, S., & Nguyen, K. L. (1996). Kinetics of kraft pulping of
Eucalyptus globulus. AIChE Symposium Series, 92(311), 1–9.
References Nan, H. S., Dias, M. M., Lopes, J. C. B., & Rodrigues, A. E. (1996).
Di5usion, convection and reaction in catalyst particles: Analogy
Agarwal, N. (1993). Modeling of continuous pulping. Ph.D. thesis, between slab and cylinder geometries. The Chemical Engineering
University of Washington. Journal, 61, 113–122.
456 N. C. P. Fernandes, J. A. A. M. Castro / Chemical Engineering Science 58 (2003) 447 – 456
Nir, A., & Pismen, L. M. (1977). Simultaneous intraparticle forced Sun, W., Costa, A. V., & Rodrigues, A. E. (1995). Determination of
convection, di5usion and reaction in a porous catalyst. Chemical e5ective di5usivities and convective coeKcients of pure gases in single
Engineering Science, 32, 35–41. pellets. The Chemical Engineering Journal, 57, 285–294.
Pfei5er, J. F., Chen, J. C., & Hsu, J. T. (1996). Permeability of gigaporous Tyler, D. B. (1982). Predicting rejects from kraft cooking of overthick
particles. A.I.Ch.E. Journal, 42(4), 932–936. chips. Svensk Papperstidning, 85(18), R180–R184.
Pismen, L. M. (1976). Convective currents induced by chemical reactions
in partially->lled porous media. Chemical Engineering Science, 31,
693–699.