Microsoft Excel 14.

0 Answer Report
Worksheet: [AC OPF Trans limit.xls]Datos
Report Created: 11/9/2017 5:42:34 p. m.
Result: Solver found a solution. All Constraints and optimality conditions are satisfied.
Solver Engine
Engine: GRG Nonlinear
Solution Time: 0.297 Seconds.
Iterations: 48 Subproblems: 0
Solver Options
Max Time 100 sec, Iterations 100, Precision 0.00000001, Use Automatic Scaling
Convergence 0.000000001, Population Size 100, Random Seed 0, Derivatives Forward, Require Bounds
Max Subproblems Unlimited, Max Integer Sols Unlimited, Integer Tolerance 0.00000011%, Solve Without Integer Constraint

Objective Cell (Min)

Cell Name Original Value Final Value
$L$16 Objective Function 288.6000 534.9906

Variable Cells
Cell Name Original Value Final Value Integer
$B$14 d1 0 0.0501854796 Contin
$C$14 d2 0 -0.0044490015 Contin
$D$14 d3 0 -0.0011394798 Contin
$E$14 d4 0 -0.0052413929 Contin
$F$14 d5 0 0.0513426069 Contin
$G$14 d6 0 -0.0318851535 Contin
$H$14 d7 0 -0.0260891025 Contin
$B$12 V1 1 1.05 Contin
$C$12 V2 1 1.043594068 Contin
$D$12 V3 1 1.0463758658 Contin
$E$12 V4 1 1.043882797 Contin
$F$12 V5 1 1.0468128793 Contin
$G$12 V6 1 1.0406755072 Contin
$H$12 V7 1 1.0454939423 Contin
$I$12 V8 1 1.0486232669 Contin

Constraints
Cell Name Cell Value Formula Status Slack
$B$19 P1 3.876926584 $B$19>=0 Not Binding 3.876926584
$C$19 P2 3.1974423E-14 $C$19=0 Binding 0
$E$19 P4 5.5067062E-14 $E$19=0 Binding 0
$E$21 Q4 4.968248E-15 $E$21=0 Binding 0
$I$19 P8 2.5670089944 $I$19<=$I$5 Not Binding 0.432991006
$I$19 P8 2.5670089944 $I$19>=0 Not Binding 2.567008994
$C$21 Q2 3.7664316E-14 $C$21=0 Binding 0
$P$60 Q1 Actual -0.3108506683 $P$60>=$O$60 Not Binding 4.689149332
$P$61 Q3 Actual 0.0813654519 $P$61>=$O$61 Not Binding 5.081365452
$P$62 Q5 Actual 1.22E-01 $P$62>=$O$62 Not Binding 5.12E+00
$P$63 Q6 Actual 0.285466996 $P$63>=$O$63 Not Binding 5.285466996
$P$64 Q8 Actual -2.47E-01 $P$64>=$O$64 Not Binding 4.75E+00
$F$19 P5 2.8 $F$19<=$F$5 Binding 0
$G$19 P6 2 $G$19<=$G$5 Binding 0
$F$19 P5 2.8 $F$19>=0 Not Binding 2.8
$G$19 P6 2 $G$19>=0 Not Binding 2
$D$19 P3 3.5 $D$19<=$D$5 Binding 0
$H$19 P7 -9.769963E-15 $H$19=0 Binding 0
$D$19 P3 3.5 $D$19>=0 Not Binding 3.5
$B$19 P1 3.876926584 $B$19<=$B$5 Not Binding 0.123073416
$I$30 Flow-MVA 0.071971314 $I$30<=$K$30 Not Binding 4.928028686
$I$31 Q12 Flow-MVA 1.2143987717 $I$31<=$K$31 Not Binding 3.785601228
$I$32 Q1 Flow-MVA 1.1822180547 $I$32<=$K$32 Not Binding 3.817781945
$I$33 Q25 Flow-MVA 1.531108485 $I$33<=$K$33 Not Binding 3.468891515
$I$34 Q21 Flow-MVA 1.2069898613 $I$34<=$K$34 Not Binding 3.793010139
$I$35 Q23 Flow-MVA 0.0698239693 $I$35<=$K$35 Not Binding 4.930176031
$I$36 Q2 Flow-MVA 0.5425613182 $I$36<=$K$36 Not Binding 4.457438682
$I$37 Q32 Flow-MVA 0.0700100916 $I$37<=$K$37 Not Binding 4.929989908
$I$38 Q34 Flow-MVA 0.2086040108 $I$38<=$K$38 Not Binding 4.791395989
$I$39 Q36 Flow-MVA 0.7195904169 $I$39<=$K$39 Not Binding 4.280409583
$I$40 Q3 Flow-MVA 0.0267599388 $I$40<=$K$40 Not Binding 4.973240061
$I$41 Q47 Flow-MVA 0.6873151536 $I$41<=$K$41 Not Binding 4.312684846
$I$42 Q43 Flow-MVA 0.2081069961 $I$42<=$K$42 Not Binding 4.791893004
$I$43 Q4 Flow-MVA 1.2424269605 $I$43<=$K$43 Not Binding 3.757573039
$I$44 Q51 Flow-MVA 0.0717528556 $I$44<=$K$44 Not Binding 4.928247144
$I$45 Q52 Flow-MVA 1.5358309623 $I$45<=$K$45 Not Binding 3.464169038
$I$46 Q5 Flow-MVA 1.2459143379 $I$46<=$K$46 Not Binding 3.754085662
$I$47 Q62 Flow-MVA 0.5410439675 $I$47<=$K$47 Not Binding 4.458956032
$I$48 Q63 Flow-MVA 0.7156702927 $I$48<=$K$48 Not Binding 4.284329707
$I$49 Q6 Flow-MVA 1.2534490228 $I$49<=$K$49 Not Binding 3.746550977
$I$50 Q71 Flow-MVA 1.1771445854 $I$50<=$K$50 Not Binding 3.822855415
$I$51 Q74 Flow-MVA 0.6883759667 $I$51<=$K$51 Not Binding 4.311624033
$I$52 Q7 Flow-MVA 1.3 $I$52<=$K$52 Binding 0
$I$53 Q83 Flow-MVA 0.0268174136 $I$53<=$K$53 Not Binding 4.973182586
$I$54 Q86 Flow-MVA 1.2630217586 $I$54<=$K$54 Not Binding 3.736978241
$I$55 Q8 Flow-MVA 1.3038911004 $I$55<=$K$55 Not Binding 3.6961089
$I$30 Flow-MVA 0.071971314 $I$30>=$L$30 Not Binding 5.071971314
$I$31 Q12 Flow-MVA 1.2143987717 $I$31>=$L$31 Not Binding 6.214398772
$I$32 Q1 Flow-MVA 1.1822180547 $I$32>=$L$32 Not Binding 6.182218055
$I$33 Q25 Flow-MVA 1.531108485 $I$33>=$L$33 Not Binding 6.531108485
$I$34 Q21 Flow-MVA 1.2069898613 $I$34>=$L$34 Not Binding 6.206989861
$I$35 Q23 Flow-MVA 0.0698239693 $I$35>=$L$35 Not Binding 5.069823969
$I$36 Q2 Flow-MVA 0.5425613182 $I$36>=$L$36 Not Binding 5.542561318
$I$37 Q32 Flow-MVA 0.0700100916 $I$37>=$L$37 Not Binding 5.070010092
$I$38 Q34 Flow-MVA 0.2086040108 $I$38>=$L$38 Not Binding 5.208604011
$I$39 Q36 Flow-MVA 0.7195904169 $I$39>=$L$39 Not Binding 5.719590417
$I$40 Q3 Flow-MVA 0.0267599388 $I$40>=$L$40 Not Binding 5.026759939
$I$41 Q47 Flow-MVA 0.6873151536 $I$41>=$L$41 Not Binding 5.687315154
$I$42 Q43 Flow-MVA 0.2081069961 $I$42>=$L$42 Not Binding 5.208106996
$I$43 Q4 Flow-MVA 1.2424269605 $I$43>=$L$43 Not Binding 6.242426961
$I$44 Q51 Flow-MVA 0.0717528556 $I$44>=$L$44 Not Binding 5.071752856
$I$45 Q52 Flow-MVA 1.5358309623 $I$45>=$L$45 Not Binding 6.535830962
$I$46 Q5 Flow-MVA 1.2459143379 $I$46>=$L$46 Not Binding 6.245914338
$I$47 Q62 Flow-MVA 0.5410439675 $I$47>=$L$47 Not Binding 5.541043968
$I$48 Q63 Flow-MVA 0.7156702927 $I$48>=$L$48 Not Binding 5.715670293
$I$49 Q6 Flow-MVA 1.2534490228 $I$49>=$L$49 Not Binding 6.253449023
$I$50 Q71 Flow-MVA 1.1771445854 $I$50>=$L$50 Not Binding 6.177144585
$I$51 Q74 Flow-MVA 0.6883759667 $I$51>=$L$51 Not Binding 5.688375967
$I$52 Q7 Flow-MVA 1.3 $I$52>=$L$52 Not Binding 2.6
$I$53 Q83 Flow-MVA 0.0268174136 $I$53>=$L$53 Not Binding 5.026817414
$I$54 Q86 Flow-MVA 1.2630217586 $I$54>=$L$54 Not Binding 6.263021759
$I$55 Q8 Flow-MVA 1.3038911004 $I$55>=$L$55 Not Binding 6.3038911
$H$21 Q7 1.8901547E-14 $H$21=0 Binding 0
$P$60 Q1 Actual -0.3108506683 $P$60<=$Q$60 Not Binding 5.310850668
$P$61 Q3 Actual 0.0813654519 $P$61<=$Q$61 Not Binding 4.918634548
$P$62 Q5 Actual 1.22E-01 $P$62<=$Q$62 Not Binding 4.877906645
$P$63 Q6 Actual 0.285466996 $P$63<=$Q$63 Not Binding 4.714533004
$P$64 Q8 Actual -2.47E-01 $P$64<=$Q$64 Not Binding 5.247430939
$B$12 V1 1.05 $B$12<=$K$20 Binding 0
$C$12 V2 1.043594068 $C$12<=$K$20 Not Binding 0.006405932
$D$12 V3 1.0463758658 $D$12<=$K$20 Not Binding 0.003624134
$E$12 V4 1.043882797 $E$12<=$K$20 Not Binding 0.006117203
$F$12 V5 1.0468128793 $F$12<=$K$20 Not Binding 0.003187121
$G$12 V6 1.0406755072 $G$12<=$K$20 Not Binding 0.009324493
$H$12 V7 1.0454939423 $H$12<=$K$20 Not Binding 0.004506058
$I$12 V8 1.0486232669 $I$12<=$K$20 Not Binding 0.001376733
$B$12 V1 1.05 $B$12>=$L$20 Not Binding 0.1
$C$12 V2 1.043594068 $C$12>=$L$20 Not Binding 0.093594068
$D$12 V3 1.0463758658 $D$12>=$L$20 Not Binding 0.096375866
$E$12 V4 1.043882797 $E$12>=$L$20 Not Binding 0.093882797
$F$12 V5 1.0468128793 $F$12>=$L$20 Not Binding 0.096812879
$G$12 V6 1.0406755072 $G$12>=$L$20 Not Binding 0.090675507
$H$12 V7 1.0454939423 $H$12>=$L$20 Not Binding 0.095493942
$I$12 V8 1.0486232669 $I$12>=$L$20 Not Binding 0.098623267
 Require Bounds
%, Solve Without Integer Constraints
Microsoft Excel 14.0 Sensitivity Report
Worksheet: [AC OPF Trans limit.xls]Datos
Report Created: 11/9/2017 5:42:35 p. m.

Variable Cells
Final Reduced
Cell Name Value Gradient
$B$14 d1 0.0501854796 0
$C$14 d2 -0.0044490015 0
$D$14 d3 -0.0011394798 0
$E$14 d4 -0.0052413929 0
$F$14 d5 0.0513426069 0
$G$14 d6 -0.0318851535 0
$H$14 d7 -0.0260891025 0
$B$12 V1 1.05 -3.776006218
$C$12 V2 1.043594068 0
$D$12 V3 1.0463758658 0
$E$12 V4 1.043882797 0
$F$12 V5 1.0468128793 0
$G$12 V6 1.0406755072 0
$H$12 V7 1.0454939423 0
$I$12 V8 1.0486232669 0

Constraints No. Node Generators'USD/Mwh

Final Lagrange 1 50 50
Cell Name Value Multiplier 2 0 46.24568
$B$19 P1 3.876926584 0 3 22 44.77898
$C$19 P2 3.197442E-14 -46.24568386 4 0 50.48704
$E$19 P4 5.506706E-14 -50.48704077 5 40 48.33257
$E$21 Q4 4.968248E-15 0.1463411241 6 35 39.32072
$I$19 P8 2.5670089944 0 7 0 59.31185
$I$19 P8 2.5670089944 0 8 32 32
$C$21 Q2 3.766432E-14 -0.143329504
$P$60 Q1 Actual -0.3108506683 0
$P$61 Q3 Actual 0.0813654519 0
$P$62 Q5 Actual 0.1220933551 0
$P$63 Q6 Actual 0.285466996 0
$P$64 Q8 Actual -0.2474309394 0
$F$19 P5 2.8 -8.332568906
$G$19 P6 2 -4.320719021
$F$19 P5 2.8 0
$G$19 P6 2 0
$D$19 P3 3.5 -22.77898468
$H$19 P7 -9.769963E-15 -59.31185138
$D$19 P3 3.5 0
$B$19 P1 3.876926584 0
$I$30 Flow-MVA 0.071971314 0
$I$31 Q12 Flow-MVA 1.2143987717 0
$I$32 Q1 Flow-MVA 1.1822180547 0
$I$33 Q25 Flow-MVA 1.531108485 0
$I$34 Q21 Flow-MVA 1.2069898613 0
$I$35 Q23 Flow-MVA 0.0698239693 0
$I$36 Q2 Flow-MVA 0.5425613182 0
$I$37 Q32 Flow-MVA 0.0700100916 0
$I$38 Q34 Flow-MVA 0.2086040108 0
$I$39 Q36 Flow-MVA 0.7195904169 0
$I$40 Q3 Flow-MVA 0.0267599388 0
$I$41 Q47 Flow-MVA 0.6873151536 0
$I$42 Q43 Flow-MVA 0.2081069961 0
$I$43 Q4 Flow-MVA 1.2424269605 0
$I$44 Q51 Flow-MVA 0.0717528556 0
$I$45 Q52 Flow-MVA 1.5358309623 0
$I$46 Q5 Flow-MVA 1.2459143379 0
$I$47 Q62 Flow-MVA 0.5410439675 0
$I$48 Q63 Flow-MVA 0.7156702927 0
$I$49 Q6 Flow-MVA 1.2534490228 0
$I$50 Q71 Flow-MVA 1.1771445854 0
$I$51 Q74 Flow-MVA 0.6883759667 0
$I$52 Q7 Flow-MVA 1.3 -35.49005917
$I$53 Q83 Flow-MVA 0.0268174136 0
$I$54 Q86 Flow-MVA 1.2630217586 0
$I$55 Q8 Flow-MVA 1.3038911004 0
$I$30 Flow-MVA 0.071971314 0
$I$31 Q12 Flow-MVA 1.2143987717 0
$I$32 Q1 Flow-MVA 1.1822180547 0
$I$33 Q25 Flow-MVA 1.531108485 0
$I$34 Q21 Flow-MVA 1.2069898613 0
$I$35 Q23 Flow-MVA 0.0698239693 0
$I$36 Q2 Flow-MVA 0.5425613182 0
$I$37 Q32 Flow-MVA 0.0700100916 0
$I$38 Q34 Flow-MVA 0.2086040108 0
$I$39 Q36 Flow-MVA 0.7195904169 0
$I$40 Q3 Flow-MVA 0.0267599388 0
$I$41 Q47 Flow-MVA 0.6873151536 0
$I$42 Q43 Flow-MVA 0.2081069961 0
$I$43 Q4 Flow-MVA 1.2424269605 0
$I$44 Q51 Flow-MVA 0.0717528556 0
$I$45 Q52 Flow-MVA 1.5358309623 0
$I$46 Q5 Flow-MVA 1.2459143379 0
$I$47 Q62 Flow-MVA 0.5410439675 0
$I$48 Q63 Flow-MVA 0.7156702927 0
$I$49 Q6 Flow-MVA 1.2534490228 0
$I$50 Q71 Flow-MVA 1.1771445854 0
$I$51 Q74 Flow-MVA 0.6883759667 0
$I$52 Q7 Flow-MVA 1.3 0
$I$53 Q83 Flow-MVA 0.0268174136 0
$I$54 Q86 Flow-MVA 1.2630217586 0
$I$55 Q8 Flow-MVA 1.3038911004 0
$H$21 Q7 1.890155E-14 0.1112139261
$P$60 Q1 Actual -0.3108506683 0
$P$61 Q3 Actual 0.0813654519 0
$P$62 Q5 Actual 0.1220933551 0
$P$63 Q6 Actual 0.285466996 0
$P$64 Q8 Actual -0.2474309394 0
Microsoft Excel 14.0 Limits Report
Worksheet: [AC OPF Trans limit.xls]Datos
Report Created: 11/9/2017 5:42:35 p. m.

Objective
Cell Name Value
$L$16 Objective Function 534.9906

Variable Lower Objective Upper Objective

Cell Name Value Limit Result Limit Result
$B$14 d1 0.0501854796 0.0501854796 534.990617 0.0501854796 534.990617
$C$14 d2 -0.004449001 -0.004449001 534.990617 -0.004449001 534.990617
$D$14 d3 -0.00113948 -0.00113948 534.990617 -0.00113948 534.990617
$E$14 d4 -0.005241393 -0.005241393 534.990617 -0.005241393 534.990617
$F$14 d5 0.0513426069 0.0513426069 534.990617 0.0513426069 534.990617
$G$14 d6 -0.031885154 -0.031885154 534.990617 -0.031885154 534.990617
$H$14 d7 -0.026089102 -0.026089102 534.990617 -0.026089102 534.990617
$B$12 V1 1.05 1.05 534.990617 1.05 534.990617
$C$12 V2 1.043594068 1.043594068 534.990617 1.043594068 534.990617
$D$12 V3 1.0463758658 1.0463758658 534.990617 1.0463758658 534.990617
$E$12 V4 1.043882797 1.043882797 534.990617 1.043882797 534.990617
$F$12 V5 1.0468128793 1.0468128793 534.990617 1.0468128793 534.990617
$G$12 V6 1.0406755072 1.0406755072 534.990617 1.0406755072 534.990617
$H$12 V7 1.0454939423 1.0454939423 534.990617 1.0454939423 534.990617
$I$12 V8 1.0486232669 1.0486232669 534.990617 1.0486232669 534.990617
 A B C D E F G H I J K L
1 OPF without flow limits
2 nodes 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
3 Generators' Cost of offers - $/MWh
4 $ 50 0 22 0 40 35 0 32
5 P 4 0 3.5 0 2.8 2 0 3 MW Capability
6 11.3
7 Demand at nodes 1.5
8 P 1.5 2.25 2.55 0.75 0 4.5 3.15 0 Specified Load, P
9 Q -0.2 0.1 0.25 -0.1 0 0.1 0.22 0 Specified load,Q
10 Choice Variables
11 V1 V2 V3 V4 V5 V6 V7 V8
12 1.05 1.043594 1.046376 1.043883 1.046813 1.040676 1.045494 1.048623 Selected V
13 d1 d2 d3 d4 d5 d6 d7 d8
14 0.050185 -0.00445 -0.00114 -0.00524 0.051343 -0.03189 -0.02609 0 Selected d
15 .
16 Result Of OPF Solution S Generation Loss S Demand Objective Function 534.9906
17 Generation at nodes 14.74394 0.043936 14.7
18 P1 P2 P3 P4 P5 P6 P7 P8
19 3.876927 3.2E-14 3.5 5.51E-14 2.8 2 0 2.567009 Voltage limits
20 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q5 Q6 Q7 Q8 1.05 0.95
21 -0.31085 3.77E-14 0.081365 4.97E-15 0.122093 0.285467 1.89E-14 -0.24743
22 MVA1 MVA3 MVA5 MVA6 MVA8
23 3.889369 3.500946 2.802661 2.02027 2.578906 MVA output
24 14.7415456 0.04154557
25 15.54253 1.79004 4.883734 9.991345 7.91779 40.12544 Var cost
26
27
28 BRANCH FLOW EQUATIONS Flow limits
29 Branch P Branch Q Flow-MVA
30 P15 -0.01874 Q15 -0.06949 0.071971 5 -5
31 P12 1.213468 Q12 -0.04755 1.214399 5 -5
32 P17 1.182202 P1 2.376927 Q17 0.006187 Q1 -0.11085 1.182218 5 -5
33 P25 -1.52709 Q25 -0.11081 1.531108 5 -5
34 P21 -1.20685 Q21 -0.01867 1.20699 5 -5
35 P23 -0.05856 Q23 0.038035 0.069824 5 -5
36 P26 0.542494 P2 -2.25 Q26 -0.00855 Q2 -0.1 0.542561 5 -5
37 P32 0.058585 Q32 -0.03833 0.07001 5 -5
38 P34 0.189691 Q34 -0.08679 0.208604 5 -5
39 P36 0.716579 Q36 -0.06577 0.71959 5 -5
40 P38 -0.01485 P3 0.95 Q38 0.022259 Q3 -0.16863 0.02676 5 -5
41 P47 0.678195 Q47 0.111594 0.687315 5 -5
42 P43 -0.18959 Q43 0.085809 0.208107 5 -5
43 P45 -1.2386 P4 -0.75 Q45 -0.0974 Q4 0.1 1.242427 5 -5
44 P51 0.018766 Q51 0.069255 0.071753 5 -5
45 P52 1.535618 Q52 0.025562 1.535831 5 -5
46 P54 1.245616 P5 2.8 Q54 0.027276 Q5 0.122093 1.245914 5 -5
47 P62 -0.54101 Q62 -0.00631 0.541044 5 -5
48 P63 -0.71435 Q63 0.043472 0.71567 5 -5
49 P68 -1.24464 P6 -2.5 Q68 0.148309 Q6 0.185467 1.253449 5 -5
50 P71 -1.17324 Q71 -0.09584 1.177145 5 -5
51 P74 -0.67676 Q74 -0.1259 0.688376 5 -5
52 P78 -1.3 P7 -3.15 Q78 0.001742 Q7 -0.22 1.3 1.3 -1.3
53 P83 0.01486 Q83 -0.02232 0.026817 5 -5
54 P86 1.248748 Q86 -0.18935 1.263022 5 -5
55 P87 1.303401 P8 2.567009 Q87 -0.03576 Q8 -0.24743 1.303891 5 -5
56
57
58 Sensitivity
59 Constraints
60
 A B C D E F G H I J K L
61 Node Bid l LMP Final Lagrange
62 1 50 0 50 Cell Name Value Multiplier
63 0 $B$19 P1 8.34E-13 8.8938718
64 0 $F$19 P5 1.99916745 0
65 0 $G$19 P6 2 0
66 0 $I$19 P8 2.31975038 0
67 0 $D$19 P3 3.5 0
68 2 0 -45.8364 45.8364 $H$21 Q7 6.6017E-13 -0.174966
69 3 22 -22.1964 44.19642 $C$19 P2 5.1059E-12 -39.01011
70 4 0 -49.7467 49.74671 $C$21 Q2 -1.399E-12 -0.000942
71 5 40 -7.92867 47.92867 $E$19 P4 1.4579E-12 -40.8879
 M N
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24 14.7
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58 Machine Var Limits
59
60 Q1
 M N
61 Q3
62 Q5
63 Q6
64 Q8
65
66
67
68
69
70
71