You are on page 1of 13

Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013 www.seipub.

org/acer

Production of Biodiesel from Rapeseed Oil in


Greece
Mingyen Yu*1, Seyed Ali Hosseini 2, Nikolaos Spiliopoulos
Department of Chemical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering and Physical Sciences
University of Surrey, Guildford GU2 7XH, UK
*1M.Yu@surrey.ac.uk; 2S.Hosseini@surrey.ac.uk

Abstract biodiesel was patented in South Africa in 1983 (Bisen


This work provides a detailed technoeconomical, political et al., 2010). Lateron, Austrian company Gaskoks
and environmental review of current Biodiesel production managed to erect the first biodiesel plant in 1987.
trends in Europe and Greece. Furthurmore, detailed design Currently, based on the sourcing of feedstock, there
of a biodiesel plant in Greece with a production capacity of are four generations of biodiesel, which are described
60,000 tonnes per year, using rapeseed as the raw material, is in Table 1.
developed. The analysis includes finding a suitable region in
TABLE 1 DIFFERENT GENERATIONS OF BIODIESEL BASED ON FEEDSTOCK
Greece and determining the best process for the plant that
TYPES AND MODE OF PRODUCTION
minimises the overall cost. Detailed mathematical
computations for design and costing of all equipment using Generation Feedstock and mode of production
the transesterification process are developed, which is then Relies on crops giving sugars, starches and oil as
used to determine the financial costs of equipment, utilities, their feedstock, such as rapeseed, cotton, corn, palm
First etc. The production of biodiesel is obtained by
labour and the final product. By considering the price of
fermenting the sugars or with transesterification of
rapeseed oil to be around 0.7 €/kg, the cost price (before
fatty oils.
taxation) for the proposed biodiesel comes to 0.715 €/litre, Uses lignocellulosic biomass as feedstock and is
and the entire investment is able to break-even in three years. Second produced through thermochemical routes or by
The analysis has also indicated that the cost price of breaking down cellulose with enzymes biodiesel.
biodiesel is lower than the current Greek market price of Produced from algae. Algae is produced from
diesel. Moreover, recent Greek legislation (Law 3908/2011) is photosynthetic organisms and grown in the water by
Third
likely to improve the profit margin even further. Overall, taking up light, CO2 and other nutrients. The algae
based on the current economic downturn in Greece, such a oil can be used for producing biodiesel (alkyl esters)
Either created using petroleum-like hydroprocessing,
project will have positive social and economic influences on
Fourth advanced bio-chemistry, or revolutionary processes
society, in addition to its environmental advantages. The
like Joule’s "solar-to-fuel" method.
results of this research can provide a basis for political and
industrial decision making. Biodiesel has a golden or dark brown colour
(depending on the feedstock). It is immiscible in water,
Keywords
has a high boiling point with low vapour pressure and
Biomass Technology; Renewable Energy; Cost-even Analysis is non-flammable under ambient pressure. It is even
claimed that biodiesel contains 3.2 times the amount of
Introduction energy it takes to produce (US Department of Energy.,
Although the first “compression-ignition” engine fully 2012). Generally, biodiesel can be legally blended with
powered by peanut oil in 1900, however, during the petroleum diesel and the most popular blends are
20th century, the relative high price of biofuels to fossil shown in Fig. 1 (US Department of Energy., 2012).
fuels has resulted in the “disappearance” of vegetable
oils as a fuel alternative. Due to resource depletion and
the oil crisis in 1973 and 1979, interest in renewable
energy sources has returned to the limelight again
(Regnier., 2007). The first attempt at biodiesel
production after the Arab oil embargo was in 1977, by FIG. 1 MOST POPULAR BIODIESEL BLENDS a
the Brazilian scientist Expedito Parente, who managed
The higher the amount of biodiesel in the blend is, the
to produce biodiesel through transesterification with
ethanol. Following the same technique, engine-tested
a US Department of Energy, 2012

79
www.seipub.org/acer Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013

lower the emissions in the air with the exception of Directive 2003/30/EC or the ‘Biofuel Directive’ was
NOx is, which increases as the ratio of biodiesel adopted in 2003 by the European Parliament in order
increases. Although B100 provides the best emission to promote biofuels for transport issues, and it set
reductions compared with petroleum diesel, lower targets of 2% and 5.75% market share of biofuels by
blends are also environmentally beneficial; for 2005 and 2010 respectively. The European
instance, B20 is able to reduce PM emissions by 10%, Commission, in order to promote the cultivation of
CO by 11%, and unburned HC by 21% (US energy crops, introduced a 45€ per hectare programme
Environmental Protection Agency, 2002; U.S. for farmers in 2003, providing them with the
Department of energy, 2012). motivation to grow the raw materials for biofuels
production. All of the European countries have
adopted the EU Directives, where tax exemptions and
biofuel obligations are the basic principles for the
European countries to implement with the legal
framework objectives (Karagiannidis et al., 2007).
Greece is one of the first EU countries that provided
tax exemptions policy for biofuels. According to the
the Hellenic Republic Ministry of Development in 2006,
Greece’s most popular biomass raw materials for the
FIG 2. AVERAGE EMISSIONS IMPACT OF BIODIESEL FOR industrial sector were waste wood, straw and cotton
HEAVY-DUTY HIGHWAY ENGINES b residues. The total annual consumption was estimated
Moreover, compared to petroleum diesel, using at around 150k tonnes of oil equivalent (toe), whereas
biodiesel in a conventional petroleum diesel engine Greek households used to use a total of 0.7 M toe of
substantially reduces tailpipe emissions of unburned wood annually for heating and cooking purposes.
hydrocarbons (HC), carbon monoxide (CO), sulphates, Table 2 provides a typical summary of Greece’s energy
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, nitrated polycyclic profile.
aromatic hydrocarbons, and particulate matter (PM) TABLE 2 GREECE COUNTRY AND ELECTRICITY PRODUCTION
(US Department of Energy., 2012). PROFILE IN 2012 de

Europe is a powerful biodiesel producer, providing a Electricity Production


Country Profile
Profile (2001)
total of 9.5 million tonnes of biodiesel in 2010. The
Population 10.8 Million(2011) Fossil Fuel 94.5%
European Union supports biofuels in order to reduce
Area 131,957 km2 Hydro 3.8%
carbon footprint, replace fossil fuels, decrease imports
Total Primary
of foreign fuels and boost rural areas. Top three EU Energy 29M toe (2009) Nuclear 0%
biodiesel producers are Germany, France and Spain Supply
(shown in Fig. 3). From this figure, it is evident that Electricity 58.79 billion kWh Other
1.7%
Production (2011) renewables
there has been a rapid increase in annual production
of Europe (Skarlis et al., 2007; Karagiannidis et al., On December 13th 2005, the Greek constitution voted
2007, EBB.Stastics, 2010). through and adopted Act 3423/2005 for the
“Introduction of biofuels and other renewable fuels in the
Greek market”. Next, a programme for the allocation of
biofuel quantities was set up and linked with the
establishment of the Biofuels Distribution License.
This was for companies that wished to be involved in
the production and selling of biofuels in Greece.
Finally, the national target of 5.75% for 2010 was set
for national biofuel usage, as shown in Table 3.
(Myrsini Christou., 2011). Under Act 3423/2005, each
participant has the right and the obligation to
FIG. 3 BIODIESEL PRODUCTION IN EU 2002-2010 c
distribute specific quantities of pure biofuels and

b US Environmental Protection Agency, 2002 d Central Intelligence Agency World Factbook, 2012
c European Biodiesel Board, 2010 e International Energy Agency, 2012

80
Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013 www.seipub.org/acer

blends on the Greek market. A provision incorporated Ekkokistiria-klostiria


Voreiou Komotini 6,600
in Article 34 of Act 3340/2005 provides full excise
VertOil S.A.
duties exemption from the following quantities of Mil Oil Hellas S.A. Kilkis 10,450
pure biodiesel: First call: 51,000 m³ (in 2005), second NEWENERGY S.A. Thessaloniki 9,900
call: 91,000 m³ (published by the end of 2005) and third GF ENERGY S.A. Serres 21,000
ΜΑΝΟS S.A. Korinthos 99,000
call: 114,000 m³ (published in December 2006). Under
Volos 33,000
the 1st call, 2,500 tonnes of pure biodiesel were
allocated to Hellenic Biopetroleum S.A. Under the 2nd
call, 16 companies submitted applications for tender.
The quantities were allocated to 12 biodiesel
producers and 2 biodiesel traders. The last call for
114,000 tonnes biodiesel was published in 2006 by the
Greek Ministry of Development.
TABLE 3 ESTIMATION OF BIODIESEL REQUIRED FROM 2005 TO 2010 f

Estimated Automotive Biodiesel


Year Diesel Consumption Biodiesel used (%) Required
(thousands of tonnes) (tonnes)
2005 3,707 2.00 120,442
2006 3,800 2.50 154,329
2007 3,892 3.00 189,678 FIG. 5 BIODIESEL PLANTS ALLOCATION h
2008 3,984 4.00 258,883
2009 4,077 5.00 331,157 Rapeseed is considered the third most important oil
2010 4,169 5.75 389,424 producing plant after soybeans and palm oil in Greece.
According to National Reports on the promotion of Table 5 compares the efficiency of the five most
the use of biofuels or other renewable fuels for popular energy crops in Greece. It can be concluded
transport in Greece for the period 2005-2010, Greece’s that rapeseed and sunflower have the highest
most promising future investments will be biodiesel efficiency in biodiesel production which is between 50
and bioethanol. The first attempt at the production to 100 kg/stremma (unit for measuring the land area in
and distribution of biodiesel in Greece was made in Greece; equal to 0.1 hectare) (Intelligent Energy
December 2005 and no biofuels had been distributed Europe a).
or consumed before this time (Hellenic Republic TABLE 5 FEEDSTOCK FOR PRODUCING BIODIESEL PER YEAR i

Ministry of Development, 2006b). During this trial, Crop Biodiesel Biodiesel


Raw
biodiesel was blended with automotive diesel from Efficiency Efficiency Efficiency
Material
refineries and industries to produce petroleum kg/stremma* kg/stremma litres/stremma
Sunflower 150 – 300 50 – 100 58 – 116
products. The biodiesel produced was around 3000
Rapeseed 150 – 300 50 – 100 58 – 116
tonnes and by 2007 this had increased to 100,000 Cynara 100 – 150 24 – 36 28 – 41
tonnes. Currently, there are thirteen biodiesel plants in Cardunculus
Greece (shown in Table 4 and Fig 5). Soy-bean 120 – 160 17 – 23 20 – 27
Cotton 160 - 240 27 – 41 32 – 48
TABLE 4 BIODIESEL COMPANIES IN GREECE 2010 g
* 10 stremma = 1 hectre
Origin of quantity of pure Capacity
Company
biodiesel (tonnes)
Cultivation of the rapeseed plant generates two
Pavlos N. Pettas S.A. Patra Industrial Area 99,000 products: rapeseed oil (from the seed) and rapeseed
Biodiesel Ltd. Mygdonia Park Municipal 21,000 flour (from the residue). The rapeseed oil is the only
District, Thessaloniki type of oil that meets 100% EU specifications for
Agroinvest S.A. Achladi Municipal District, 230,000
Fthiotida
biodiesel production. Rapeseed flour is a product rich
ELVI Kilkis 79,000 in proteins (34%) and can be used as an animal food as
Staff Colour Energy S.A. Larissa Industrial Area 11,000 well, partial replacing soybeans, and hence reducing
ELIN Biofuels S.A. the cost of animal food production. On average 30-37
Vioenergeia Papantoniou Volos Industrial Area 73,300
S.A. Chalkidiki 9,000
kg of rapeseed can be produced by cultivating one

f Myrsini Christous, 2011 h Myrsini Christous, 2011


g Hellenic Republic, Ministry of Development, 2010 i Greece Centre for Renewable Energy Sources, 2000-2006

81
www.seipub.org/acer Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013

hectare of land, which corresponds to the production Location Allocation


of 10-13 kg of biodiesel (Intelligent Energy Europe a;
Traditionally, the location-allocation problem has been
CRES, 2000-2006; Rigalos et al., 2008).
a well-established research area within the field of
In this paper, we will analyse a 60,000 tonnes per year Operation Research (OR). Melo et al. (2009) conducted
biodiesel production plant in Greece assuming local an extensive review of the role of facility location
production of raw material. The analysis includes models within the supply chain. The authors divided
detailed mathematical computations on the technical the investigation into two objectives: namely, facility
equipment of the industrial plant and also contains location and supply chain management. There are
cost analyses for the technical equipment, utilities, by- many papers found addressing the topic of single
products and the final product. The results of this location layer with single commodity. (Sahin and Süral,
research can provide a basis for political and industrial 2007; Melkote and Daskin, 2001; Barahona and Jensen,
decision making. 1998). Thus for this research, we will start by finding a
suitable area in Greece for the installation of the
Methodology biodiesel plant.
The first step for this research is to find a suitable area Large (around 45,000 ha) and easily accessible
for the plant’s facilities. One of the most critical factors quantities of raw materials are important requirements
we consider at this point is the accessibility of the for this area, as this will reduce the cost of
arable land for the cultivation of rapeseed, which is transportation from the cultivation site to the plant.
the raw material. The capacity of the biodiesel plant, Similarly, other raw materials such as methanol, acid
the amounts of utilities and raw materials used and and base catalysts should be readily available near the
any other quantities such as the catalyst were site of the plant as well. Finally, the biodiesel
calculated using the commercial software package, produced should be accessible for distribution, and
Aspen Hysys. The production process through lack of competition in the area is essential for
transesterification was studied and explained in this establishing this new industry. Taking all these criteria
work. The total cost of the installation was calculated. into account, the region of Southwest Greece (shown
For the purpose of the computations, data will be in Fig.6) is the most suitable region for the investment.
extracted from Aspen Hysys. Distillation columns will This part of Greece is called Aitoloacarnania and it
be examined separately by using the McCabe-Thiele consists of mountains (Acarnanian Mountains), rivers
method in order to calculate the number of trays. Due (Acheloos, Evinos and Ermitsa etc.) and rich fertile
to the presence of the highly polar components, valley for cultivation. According to the national
methanol and glycerol, both the non-random two Statistic Department of Greece around 500,000
liquid (NRTL) and universal quasi-chemical stremma of unused land is readily and easily available
(UNIQUAC) thermodynamic/activity models were for rapeseed cultivation in Aitolia-Acarnania.
recommended to predict the activity coefficients of the
components in a liquid phase (Hyprotech Ltd., 2000).
Detailed descriptions of these models were provided
by Gess et al. (1991). The total cost of the installation
and the payback periods will be evaluated to
determine if this is going to be a good and lucrative
investment in general.

Modelling and Design


The modelling section was divided into three sub-
sections: location-allocation, the chemical process and FIG. 6 GREECE, AITOLOACARNANIA
the production process of biodiesel. In the first sub-
Based on land availability, in this research it was
section the region of Greece that is most suitable for
assumed that the capacity of the biodiesel plant will be
the cultivation of the required rapeseeds was allocated.
60,000 tonnes per yea, that the average number of
In the second sub-section, the chemical process for
working days for any industry in Greece is 344 days
producing biodiesel was studied. Finally, the
and that the plant operates for 24 hours a day. Thus,
simulation results were presented.
the total number of hours is 8,256 hours per year.

82
Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013 www.seipub.org/acer

Qbiodiesel = 7.267 tonnes /hour = 7,267 kg/hour (1) RCOOH + R’OH  RCOOR’ + H2O

Using the average biodiesel efficiency of 70 Since base catalysts are much more efficient for
kg/stremma summarised in Table 5 above, it can be transesterification than acids, they are the natural
computed that: choice when no esterification reaction is required to
convert FFA.
Required stremma = 85,714.3 ha/year (2)
Since rapeseed produces double crops per year, the Free fatty acids and water always produce negative
required hectares are divided into 42,857.14 ha or impacts during the process as both of them together
428,571.4 stremma, which is a bit less than the can cause soap formation (increase viscosity,
available 500,000 stermma; it is reasonable to use a difficulties in glycerol separation etc.). There are three
number less than 500,000 stermma to account for any known base catalysts which can be used in the
error in the assumptions. transesterification: Sodium Hydroxide, Potassium
Hydroxide and Sodium Methoxide (also known as
Chemistry of Biodiesel Production Sodium Methylate). Sodium Hydroxide (NaOH) has
Transesterification is the main chemical reaction for much slower dissolution in Methanol compared to
the production of biodiesel. Currently, it is considered Potassium Hydroxide and Sodium Methoxide.
to be the most efficient process because of the low Potassium Hydroxide (KOH) is more expensive than
temperature (65oC) and pressure (20psi) requirements NaOH due to its higher potential yields for biodiesel
for the process, as well as the high and direct with lower waste disposal cost. Sodium Methoxide
conversion rate (98%) of methyl ester (Skarlis et al., (NaOCH3) is more expensive than the hydroxides but
2007). The overall process is made up of a sequence of a lower concentration of NaOCH3 is required to
three consecutive and reversible reactions. During the achieve a good reaction. It is estimated that 70% of US
first reaction, a triglyceride which is the main content biodiesel production relies on Sodium Methoxide
of the vegetable oil and animal fats, reacts with an (Thane., 2008).
alcohol in the presence of a catalyst, producing a An acid catalyst can be used in the pre-treatment stage
mixture of fatty alkyl esters and glycerol. for esterification of FFA and then followed by
CH2-OOC-R1 R1-OOC-R’ CH2-OH transesterification (with base catalyst). There are two
| | | common acid catalysts for esterification: Hydrochloric
CH2-OOC-R2 + 3R’OH  R2-OOC-R’ + CH2-OH acid (HCl) which has the ability to access the sugar of
| | | multiple feedstocks with little water use, and
CH2-OOC-R3 R3-OOC-R’ CH2-OH Sulphuric acid (H2SO4) which is much cheaper than
Triglyceride Alcohol Fatty Acid Glycerol
the first one; HCL currently costs around 100€/ton (U.S.
Alkyl Esters
Department of energy, 2012).

Triglyceride is also known as triacylglycerol, Process Description


triacylglyceride, or TAG. It is an ester composed of a
At the beginning of the process, both methanol and
glycerol bound to three fatty acids with R1, R2, and R3
NaCOH3 are mixed together, and put with the
denoting long hydrocarbon chains. Methanol or
rapeseed oil to the reactor so the transesterification
ethanol can be used as alcohols in the reaction but
reaction takes place. After the transesterification, the
methanol is predominant in commercial applications
biodiesel and glycerol should be separated and
because it is cheaper and offers greater ease of
methanol should be recovered. In this work Sodium
downstream recovery of the unreacted alcohol. The
Methoxide (NaOCH3) and Hydrochloric acid (HCL)
catalyst can be either acid or base depending on the
(instead of H2SO4 and KOH) are used as catalysts. The
content of the feedstock. In the case where waste
system produces biodiesel from an alcohol (methanol
cooking oils are going to be used as feedstock, high in
or ethanol) and one or several different oil feedstocks.
free fatty acids (FFA), the reaction of esterification will
H2SO4 is used to convert any FFA by esterification.
take place in the presence of an acid catalyst in order
Such a commercial scale process can either operate in a
for the conversion into biodiesel to take place, as
continuous mode or a semi-continuous mode.
shown.

83
www.seipub.org/acer Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013

Methanol
Mixer Methanol
recycle
NaOCH3

Oil Transesterification Wash Methanol Quality


recovery control
Biodiesel

Methanol
Crude Glycerol recycle

Neutralization with Phase Reneutralization with Methanol


HCL HCL NaOH
separation recovery

Fatty Glycerol
acids Glycerol
purification

FIG. 7 GENERAL PROCESS STEPS FOR THE BIODIESEL PRODUCTION

Overall, the process consists of six major components. a continuous centrifuge, FF-101, in order for the
1. The Acid-alcohol esterification pre-treatment glycerol to be removed and sent to the mixing tank, M-
and water/acid removal units: Esterification 101. Methanol, sodium methoxide and unreacted
(complete conversion of FFA) where the molar substances coming from FF-101(stream 7) are the feed
ratio of alcohol to oil is 6:1, catalyst to oil ratio for the second reactor. The mixture of methyl esters,
is 1 wt%, temperature is around 60-70°C, glycerol, unreacted substrates and catalyst coming out
reaction lasts up to 1.5 hours and water and of the bottom of R502 (stream 9) enters a second
acid are to be removed-by washing with continuous centrifuge FF-102. The glycerol-rich
glycerol-before entering the next step. bottom product from FF-102 goes to the glycerol
recovery section, whereas the top product is sent to
2. Base alcohol transesterification units:
the biodiesel refining section in order to be purified
Transesterification (90-98% conversion of TAG)
and dehydrated. The top product of FF-102 is washed
where the molar ratio of alcohol to oil is 6:1,
with water to neutralise the catalyst and convert any
catalyst to oil ratio is 1 wt%, temperature is
soap to free fatty acids. Another centrifuge, FF-103, is
around 45-60°C, reaction lasts up to 1 hour.
then employed to separate the biodiesel from the rest
3. Biodiesel drying unit: for the product to meet of the liquid phase. The bottom output of FF-103 is
the quality standards, crude biodiesel needs to sent to the mixing tank, M-101. The top product,
be washed with water to remove the catalyst which contains mostly water and biodiesel, enters a
and finally purified by distillation and drying. vacuum dryer, VD-101, where water and biodiesel are
4. Catalyst recovery unit: Catalyst has to be separated. The glycerol from the reactors and the
neutralised by acid in this stage. biodiesel wash are gathered in the process tank, V-202,
5. Alcohol recovery unit: Unreacted alcohol is and treated with HCL to convert soaps to free fatty
separated by distillation and then recycled. acids; these are then removed with the centrifuge, FF-
6. Glycerol unit: Glycerol may be recovered at 104.
different grades of purity depending on the This fatty acid is disposed of as sewage for the whole
intended use and the accepted level of costs. industry. The remaining glycerol is neutralisd with
As can be seen from the process flowsheet (Fig. 8), sodium hydroxide (NaOH) and then distilled in
there are two sequential transesterification reactors, R- alcohol recovery distillation, T-101, in order to reduce
501 and R-502. The reactions are both conducted at its water content. Methanol is recovered by another
60oC. The first one is continuously fed with rapeseed alcohol recovery distillation, and T-102, is recycled in
oil, methanol and sodium methoxide. the transesterification process. The fraction of water in
the glycerol process is recycled in the wash operations
The glycerol- rich product from the first reactor enters (Haas et al., 2006).

84
Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013 www.seipub.org/acer

FIG. 8 FLOWSHEET FOR THE PRODUCTION OF BIODIESEL FROM RAPESEED OIL

From Table 4.1 (stream 2), the necessary amount of


Result and Discussion
rapeseed oil for production is 7,083 kg/h. As the
The result of the process simulation is presented in industry runs for 344 days per year and 24 hours per
Table 6 with details of stream characteristics which day, the total cost of the rapeseed is 40,934,073.6€
enable a precise calculation of the operational annually. The base catalyst (NaOCH3) to oil ratio is 1
requirement. Again, due to the presence of the highly wt% (Haas et al., 2006). Thus 70.83 kg per hour of
polar components, methanol and glycerol, both the NaOCH3, is required by the plant. That gives a total
non-random two liquid (NRTL) and universal quasi- annual cost of 3,192,695.97€ per year based on the cost
chemical (UNIQUAC) thermodynamic/activity models of the base catalyst being $6.71/kg. An acid catalyst
were recommended to predict the activity coefficients (HCL) is used to neutralise the base catalyst and to
of the components in a liquid phase (Zhang et al., 2003; breakdown fatty acids. HCL is added into the system
Hyprotech Ltd., 2000). Some unavailable interaction in streams 22 and 32. In stream 22, there is 1.11 kg-
parameter coefficients, such as those for methanol/ mole HCL per hour, which gives rise to 19.98 kg and
methyl-oleate, glycerol/methyl-oleate and sulphuric 70.83 kg per hour of HCL being needed for streams 22
acid with any other component, were estimated using and 32 respectively. Assuming the cost of HCL is 0.107
the UNIQAC liquid–liquid equilibrium module in €/kg, the total cost of the acid catalyst required is
HYSYS. 80,220.83€ per year.

Cost Analysis Steam and Electricity Costs

A provision of the biodiesel production cost is Steam is required mainly in the reactors and
presented in this section. The costs are broken down distillation columns. It is known from our simulation
into capital costs, which consists of the equipments to that 1.4 GJ steam is needed to produce 1 tonne of
be used in the plant (e.g. biodiesel tank, rapeseed tank, biodiesel. Thus 81,527.6 GJ of steam is required per
methanol tank, centrifugal, mixer etc.), as well as year for the plant. This comes to 403,317.04€ based on
operation costs which are the raw material, catalyst, a unit cost of 4.947€ per GJ of steam. Similarly,
steam, electricity and labour costs. electricity is required in the reactors and centrifugal
vessels. Again, it is known from process simulation
Raw Material and Catalyst Costs that 30 kW electricity is required to produce 1 tonne of
In Europe, over the last decade, the price of rapeseed biodiesel, which gives a total amount of 1,747,020 kW
oil decade has ranged from 0.4 €/kg to 1.1 €/kg per year for electricity needs, which in turn costs
(International Monetary Fund, 2012). Thus for this 142,207.43€ per year, based on 0.0814€ per kW of unit
research, the price of rapeseed oil is set at 0.7 €/kg. electricity cost.

85
www.seipub.org/acer Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013

TABLE 6 STREAM CHARACTERISTICS

Temperature Pressure Mass flow Molar flow Waste


Stream Oil MeOH Biodiesel Glycerol H2 O HCL
(oC) (kPa) (kg/h) (kgmole/h) (Fatty acid)
1 60 140 1,538 48 48
2 60 140 7,083 8 8
3 60 140 1,230 38.4 38.4
5 60 140 308 9.6 9.6
6 60 140 8,314 46.4 0.8 16.8 21.6 7.2
7 60 140 7,429 32.5 0.8 10.1 21.6
9 60 140 7,737 42.1 0.1 17.5 23.7 0.7
10 60 140 7,439 34.3 0.1 10.5 23.7
12 60 140 8,560 104.3 0.1 1.1 23.7 79.4
13 60 140 8,870 113.7 0.1 10.5 23.7 79.4
14 11.5 1 8,560 104.3 0.1 1.1 23.7 79.4
15
100 1 7,083 23.8 0.1 0.0009 23.5 0.2
(biodiesel)
16 100 1 1,527 80.5 1.1 0.2 79.2
17 75 140 1,527 80.5 1.1 0.2 79.2
18 60 140 310 9.5 9.5 0.02
19 60 140 298 7.8 7 0.02 0.7
20 60 140 885 13.9 6.7 0.02 7.2
21 60 140 1,493 31.2 23.2 0.1 7.9
22 60 140 60 3.4 2.3 1.1
23 60 140 1,554 34.6 23.2 0.07 7.9 2.3 1.1 0.07
24 60 140 1,526 34.1 23.2 7.9 3
25 60 140 28 0.5 0.4 0.07
26 74 140 770 24.7 23.2 1.5
27 198 140 756 9.4 0.0046 7.9 1.5
28 36 30 742 23.2 23.2 0.0015
30 60 70 28 1.5 0.023 1.5
31 (H2O) 75 140 100 5.6 5.6
32 (HCL) 75 140 71 3.9 3.9
33
60 140 71 1.7
(NaCOH3)
However, the volume for the process tank needs to be
Storage Tank and Process Tank Costs
5 m3 ≤ Vtank ≤ 80 m3. Since the calculated volume is
According to the simulation results, stream 15 which lower than this constraint, we will use the lower limit
ends at the biodiesel storage tank has a Standard Ideal of 5 m3 instead. Using the correction factor for stainless
Liquid Volume Flow of 8.0148 m3 per hour. The tank steel of 2.4, the cost of the installed tank comes to be
must be able to store the produced biodiesel for four 22,546.98€. We calculate the costs of the other process
weeks, so the necessary volume of the individual tank tank, V-201 similarly (Koukous, 2008-2009).
is 5,770.66 m3. In order to avoid overflow, an extra 20%
is added to this volume. The new volume of the Centrifugal and Pressure Viessel (Mixer) Costs
individual biodiesel tank therefore comes to 6,924.79 Stream 6 which ends at the continuous centrifuge, FF-
m3. Based on the new volume, the total cost comes to 101, has a Standard Ideal Liquid Volume Flow of
717,092.49€. This is the cost of the installed equipment 8.6090 m2/h and, similar to the process tank, the
as of 2012, with the correction factor for stainless steel centrifuges must comply with the restriction of 1 m3 ≤
being 2.4. In the same way, the costs of the oil, Q ≤ 50 m3. Thus the cost for the continuous centrifuge,
methanol, glycerol, catalyst and HCL tanks have been FF-101 comes to 75,049€. Using the same methodology,
calculated (Koukous, 2008-2009). the costs of FF-102, FF-103, FF-104 are calculated
The stream which ends at the process tank, V-202, has respectively (Koukous, 2008-2009). According to the
a Standard Ideal Liquid Volume Flow of 1.7718 m3/h. result from the simulation, the flow rate in mixer, M-
Thus the volume is 1.7718 m3, if the resident time in 101 is 1.65814 m3/h and because the resident time in
the tank is an hour. Again, in order to avoid the risk of the tank is 1 hour, the volume of the vessel is
overflow, the volume of the tank is increased by 20%. calculated to be 1.65814 m3. To avoid the risk of
The new volume of the tank comes to 2.13 m3. overflow, the volume of the tank is increased by 20%.

86
Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013 www.seipub.org/acer

Thus the new volume is 1.9897 m3. Based on this, the Table 8. Based on the calculation, the real number of
diameter of the vessel is 1.082 m and the height is trays needed for the distillation column is 11, the
2.164 m. However, the diameter and height should distance between the trays is 0.6 m and the height of
comply with the restrictions where 0.305 m ≤ D ≤ 3.05 the column is 6.6 m. The weight of the column comes
m and 1.22 m ≤ H ≤ 30.5 m respectively. The cost of the to 1,374.5 kg. Using the above result, the cost of the
vessel comes to 7,525€. The cost of the installed installed equipment without trays is 85,240€ as of 2012,
equipment is 31,830€, using FBM=4.23, FM=1, FP=1. where FBM=4.23, FM=1, FP=1. The cost of the tray is
15,880€. Thus the final total cost for the distillation
Vaccum Dryer Costs column T-101 is 101,120€. The same principle is
The result of the simulation for the stream applied to calculate T-102 as well.
characteristics of the vacuum dryer is shown in Table 7. TABLE 8 DISTALLATION COLUMN DATA
For the design of the vacuum dryer, which contains
Parameter Value
gas and liquid, the required volume of the retained Steam flow rate (V) 8,324 kg/h
liquid VL will be 1.44 m3, assuming the resident time t Density of gas (ρV) 1.5091 kg/m3
equal to 10 minutes. Then the required diameter, Speed of gas (μV) 1.63 m/s
according to the speed of the gas and since the vessel λ 0.88

operates without a filter, uv is 11.14 m/s and the


Reactor and Heat Exchanger Costs
diameter of the vacuum dryer is 2.28 m. The height of
the liquid, HL will be 0.23 m. Based on this result, the The flow rate for the sequential transesterification
height of the segment which is available for gas, HV, is reactor, R-501 is 8.7350 m2/h. With a conservative
calculated taking into account the following assumption of the resident time in the reactor being 1
constraints. hour; the volume comes to 8.7350 m3. In order to avoid
the risk of overflow, the volume of the tank is
HV > 1.67m
increased by 20%, giving a new volume of 10.482 m3.
3 ≤ (HL+HV)/D ≤ 5
Putting these values together, the cost of the reactor
In this case study, since the ratio is less than 3, it is itself is 40,844€, and the cost of the installed equipment
assumed that Hv is increased until the ratio is equal to is 169,900€ as of 2012, where FBM=4.16, FM=1, FP=1.
3. Thus the value of Hv = 8.5 m is used. This will satisfy Based on the simulation results, the exchanged heat in
both of the constraints in (3). The total height of the the heat exchanger, HE-402, is equal to Q = 958.1 kW,
vessel turns out to be 8.73 m, and the cost of the vessel and ∆TLM = 55.6oC , where Th,i = 100oC, Th,o = 75oC, Tc,i =
is 63,658€. Finally, the cost of the installed equipment 25oC and Tc,o = 40oC. The rotation surface is calculated
is 269,270€, where FBM=4.23, FM=1 and FP=1 as 12.58 m2 and the cost of the reactor alone is 9,799€
TABLE 7 VACCUM DRYER DATA
as of 2012. Finally, the cost of the installed equipment
is 32,239€, where FBM=3.29, FM=1, FP=0, Fd=1.
Parameter Value
Liquid flow rate (L) 7,033 kg/h Labour Costs
Density of liquid (ρL) 815.26 kg/m3
Steam flow rate (V) 1,527 kg/h Koukous, (2008-2009) provided an extensive list of the
Density of gas (ρV) 0.006115 kg/m3 workforce needed in a plant based on the type and
quantity of every unit of operation, using the same
Distallation Column Costs principle. In total, 16 workers are required per shift,
and the total labour costs comes to 260,000€ per year
The number of trays corresponding to the second for the overall project (including maintenance). The
distillation column is calculated by using the McCabe- detail is listed in Table 9.
Thiele method. From simulations, the following data is
TABLE 9 WORKFORACE NEEDED FOR EACH UNIT OF
obtained: (1) mole fraction of water in bottom product,
OPERATION
XR = 0.0153; (2) mole fraction of feed, XF = 0.9397; and (3)
1 heat exchanger 1 x 0.1 = 0.1
mole fraction of methanol in distillate, XD=0.9999. The
2 distillation columns 2 x 0.5 = 1.0
minimum reflux ratio required to achieve the product 4 centrifugal viessels 4 x 0.2 = 0.8
specification is 0.6665 and the real reflux ratio is 1mixer 1 x 0.3 = 0.3
calculated as 0.54. Based on this result, we calculate 1 vaccum dryer 1 x 0.2 = 0.2
2 reactors 2 x 0.5 = 1.0
the surface area of the tray to be 0.9399 m2, and the
diameter of the column to be 1.17 m, using the data in Table 10 shows the summary of annual cost of

87
www.seipub.org/acer Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013

materials, utilities and workforce. (Law 3299/2004). Under the new incentive scheme, the
TABLE 10 TOTAL ANNUAL COST OF RAW MATERIALS,
following incentives are available (Greece Ministry of
UTILITIES, AND WORKFORCE Development, 2012; KPMG, 2011):
Material Required Quantity Annual Cost € • Tax relief: Exemption from payment of income tax
Raw Materials on pre-tax profits.
Rapeseed Oil 58,477.3 ton/year 40,934,073
Methanol 6,571.8 ton/year 1,504,942 • Cash grants provided by the State that cover part of
Base Catalyst (NaOCH3) 584.8 ton/year 3,192,696 the expenses of the investment project.
Acid Catalyst (HCL) 753.2 ton/year 80,221
Water 11,095.4 ton/year 594.7
• Leasing subsidies provided by the State that cover
Total Cost: 45,712,526.7€ part of the payable instalments related to the leasing
Utilities of new equipment. However, the leasing subsidies
Steam 81,500 GJ/y 403,317 do not exceed a seven-year period.
Electricity 1,747,000 kW 142,208 Since there is no income tax on pre-tax profits, no
Total Cost: 545,525€ other costs (e.g. income tax) will be considered in the
Workforce break-even analysis. In this research, it is assumed that
Workers 16 260,000 the break-even periods are three years(i.e. the
Total Cost: 260,000€ biodiesel plant will start to make profit after three
years).
Break-even Analysis
Biodiesel Price vs. Diesel Price in Greece
In order to assess the economic feasibility of investing
in a 60,000 tonnes biodiesel plant, a break-even In order to compare the biodiesel price of the
analysis is conducted. This is a technique used to find proposed plant against the diesel price in Greece, the
cost price of the biodiesel is first calculated. The total
the break-even point (BEP), at which costs or expenses
cost for the first three years of operation is
are equal to revenue. A profit or a loss has not been
142,768,689€, and the proposed biodiesel plant is able
made, although opportunity costs have been “paid”,
to produce 199,728,061.5 litres of biodiesel (1 tonne
and capital has received the risk-adjusted, expected
biodiesel = 1,143.25 litres) during this period. Based on
return (David and Boldrin., 2008). The objective of the
the above results, the cost price for producing the
analysis is to compare the cost price (before taxation)
biodiesel in our proposed plant is 0.715 €/litre.
of the biodiesel produced by the plant against the cost
price of diesel sold in Greece, to see the profitability of Fig. 9 shows the average Greece diesel cost price for
our biodiesel plant in the long run. The cost price of the period of 10 years (01/2002 – 12/2012). (European
the biodiesel is also compared against the WTI crude Comission, Statistics and Market observatory, 2012)
oil price, to see if the crude oil price gives availability The cost price of diesel in Greece is between 0.25€ to
for the investment of the biodiesel technology. 0.93€. Based on Fig. 9, the cost price of diesel has risen
above our proposed biodiesel price (0.715 €/litre) since
Currently in Greece, a number of taxes are imposed on the beginning of 2011. The price of diesel in Greece is
diesel that is to be sold in the market, and they are rising with respect to time. Thus it can be concluded
applied as follows (Greece Ministry of Development, that the use of biodiesel has great potential in Greece,
2012): and the deployment of such a biodiesel plant is
1. 412€ per 1000 litres of diesel fuel. profitable based on the proposed biodiesel cost price
and the incentives given by the government and the
2. Additional 0.5% of tax on the total amount in step 1. states.
3. 0.20 €/m3 of fuel tax on top of the total amount in
step 2.
4. 1.2% of the initial diesel cost (i.e. before step 1).
5. Finally, 23% of VAT is added to the total sum of
steps 3 and 4 before diesel is sold in the Greece
market.
In 2011, Greece passed the Investment Incentives (Law
3908/2011), which replaces the previous incentive Fig 9. UNIT COST PRICE vs. DATE FOR BIODIESEL IN GREECE

88
Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013 www.seipub.org/acer

Fig. 10 shows the relationship between Greece diesel analysis of 92.21 $/barrel for crude oil price,
cost price and the WTI crude oil price over the period investment in the biodiesel plant is still profitable in
of 10 years (01/2002 – 12/2012). From the figure, it can the last two years (01/2011 – 12/2012), as the average
be concluded that the price of the diesel in Greece is cost of crude oil is 94.49 $/barrel. However, looking at
linearly proportional to the WTI crude oil price. Using the immediate future, the crude oil price is close to our
the proposed biodiesel cost price of 0.715 €/litre as break-even point. With the incentives given by the
calculated in 5.1, we try to find the break-even point of government and the state, investment in the biodiesel
the crude oil price, which comes to 92.21 $/barrel. plant will still be profitable in Greece.

FIG 10. CORRELATION BETWEEN DIESEL COST PRICE, CRUDE FIG 12. CORRELATION BETWEEN WTI CRUDE OIL PRICE AND
OIL PRICE IN GREECE AND TIME j TIME l

However, assuming that tax is implemented for


Conclusions
regular diesel but not biodiesel, the profit for biodiesel
can be further improved. Fig. 11 shows the In this research, we looked closely at the EU policies
relationship between the Greece diesel market price regarding biofuel production, and more specifically,
and the WTI crude oil price from 2005 to 2012. Based Greece’s potential in investing in a biodiesel plant.
on the plot, it can be concluded that the market prices Based on Greece’s geographical characteristics and its
for diesel and crude oil are correlated. Using our feedstock production capability, we have investigated
proposed biodiesel price, the break-even point of the a technoeconomic feasibility of a biodiesel plant with
crude oil comes to 29.74 $/barrel. tha capacity of 60,000 tonnes per year using rapeseed
oil as the feedstock. Based on the overall results, it can
be concluded that Greece has very good potential for
investing in rapeseed to produce biodiesel in the long
run. Although the expenses of the investment are high,
it is still profitable to invest in biodiesel technology in
Greece. Based on our simulation and calculation, the
current diesel as well as the crude oil market, the
proposed biodiesel plant is able to break-even in three
years. With the help of government and state
incentives, this investment is definitely profitable in
FIG 11. CORRELATION BETWEEN DIESEL MARKET PRICE,
CRUDE OIL MARKET PRICE IN GREECE AND TIME k
the long run, as the price of both diesel in Greece and
crude oil will be more expensive in future. The
Fig. 12 below shows how the WTI crude oil price has
investment also brings social benefits such as job
changed over time, for the same period of 10 years (US
opportunities, directly and indirectly, economic
Energy Information Administration, 2012). From this
benefits based on the current correlation between the
plot, it can be concluded that the crude oil price has
diesel price in Greece and the crude oil price
risen gradually since 2002. Based on the break-even
internationally, and environment benefits, based on
the reduction in greenhouse gases .
j Adopted from: European Comission, Statstic and Market

Observatory, 2012; US Energy Information Administration, At the same time, although rapeseed oil is the
2012
k Adapted from: European Comission, Statstic and Market

Observatory, 2012; US Energy Information Administration, lAdapted from: US Energy Information Administration,
2012 2012

89
www.seipub.org/acer Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013

preferred energy crop in Greece, even higher biodiesel Production of Solid and Liquid Biofuels for Greece, 2006.
yields can be achieved if cultivation of different seeds Centre For Renewable Energy Sources. National Report on
such as sunflowers, cotton, etc. can be used. Since
Biodiesel Use in Greece, n.d.
waste cooking oils are generated by households every
day, it will further improve the biodiesel production Centre For Renewable Energy Sources. Promoting Favourable
rate and quantity if these are used as well. Such Conditions to Establish Biodiesel Market Actions, 2007.
investments can be planned by multiple parties, with Christou, Myrsini. “Biodiesel in Greece” no. January (2007).
the government and state as the promoters. EBB Stastics. “The EU Biodiesel Industry,” 2012.
Due to the current economic status of the country, http://www.ebb-eu.org/stats.php.
such an investment may be withheld until the Edition, Fourth. “Biodiesel Handling and Use Guide” no.
situation improves. Government and policy are also
January (2009).
factors which will significantly influence the biodiesel
European Comission. “Statistics & Market Observatory,”
industry, to the extent that such an industry in Greece
will be policy driven. However, an industry project of 2012.
such scale will provide opportunities for improvement European Renewable Energy Council. Renewable Energy
for the nation as a whole. Policy Review, 2004.
The development of such industries requires major European Renewable Energy Council. Renewable Energy
breakthroughs in technologies, successful Policy Review - Greece, 2007.
commercialisation, and the development of Gess, M.A., Danner, R.P., Nagvekar, M. Thermodynamic
infrastructure. On the other hand, its clean emissions
Analysis of Vapor–Liquid Equilibria: Recommended Models
profile and ease of use make biodiesel one of the
and a Standard Data Base. New York: American Institute
fastest growing alternative fuels in the world. With the
subsidies given by the government and the state, the of Chemical Engineers, 1991.
cost of biodiesel is competitive with that of petroleum Greece Ministry of Development. “Daily Statistic on Fuel
diesel in Greece. The future of biodiesel lies in the Prices,” 2012.
world’s ability to produce renewable feedstocks such
Haas, Michael J, Andrew J McAloon, Winnie C Yee, and
as vegetable oils and fats to keep the cost of biodiesel
Thomas a Foglia. “A Process Model to Estimate Biodiesel
competitive with petroleum, without supplanting land
necessary for food production, or destroying natural Production Costs.” Bioresource Technology 97, no. 4
ecosystems in the process. Creating biodiesel in such a (March 2006): 671–8. doi:10.1016/j.biortech.2005.03.039.
manner will allow this clean, renewable, and cost Hellenic Republic Ministry of Development. 2nd National
effective fuel to help ease the world through Report on the Promotion and Use of Biofuels and Other
increasing shortages of petroleum, while providing
Renewable Fuels for Transport in Greece (2005-2010). Athens,
economic and environmental benefits well into the 21st
century. 2006.
Hellenic Republic Ministry of Development. 3rd National
REFERENCES Report on the Promotion and Use of Biofuels and Other

Barahona, F and Jensen, D. “Plant location with minimum Renewable Fuels for Transport in Greece (2005-2010), 2006.

inventory.” Mathematical Programming 83, (1998): 101-111. Hellenic Republic Ministry of Development. 6th National

Bisen, Prakash S, Bhagwan S Sanodiya, Gulab S Thakur, Report on the Promotion and Use of Biofuels and Other

Rakesh K Baghel, and G B K S Prasad. “Biodiesel Renewable Fuels for Transport in Greece (2005-2010), 2010.

Production with Special Emphasis on Lipase-catalyzed Hellenic Statistical Authority. Distribution of Utilized

Transesterification.” Biotechnology Letters 32, no. 8 Agricultural Area by Basic Categories of Land Use and by

(August 2010): 1019–30. doi:10.1007/s10529-010-0275-z. Region and Department, 2005.

Central Intelligence Agency. “The World Factbook,” 2012. International Energy Agency Stastics. Share of Total Primary

https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world- Energy Supply in 2009, 2011.

factbook/. International Monetary Fund. “IMF Primary Commodity

Centre for Renewable Energy Sources. Energy Crops for the Prices,” 2012.

90
Advanced Chemical Engineering Research Vol. 2 Iss. 4, December 2013 www.seipub.org/acer

Karagiannidis, A, M Theodoseli, and Z Samaras. “Biofuels US Energy Information Administration. “WTI Crude Oil
Market in Greece and the Potential Role of Captive Spot Price Chart,” 2012.
Fleets” (2007): 1973–1978. Zhang, Y. “Biodiesel Production from Waste Cooking Oil: 1.
Koukous, I. Industrial Design. 1st ed. University of Patra, Process Design and Technological Assessment.”
2008. Bioresource Technology 89, no. 1 (August 2003): 1–16.
Levine, D. and Boldrin, M. Against Intellectual Monopoly. doi:10.1016/S0960-8524(03)00040-3.
New York: Cambridge University Press, 2008.
Mingyen Yu earned his BSc degree in Electrical Engineering
Melkote, S. and Daskin M.S. “Capacitated facility
in 2006 from Purdue University (Indiana, USA). He then
location/network design problems”. European Journal of moved to UK to continue his postgraduate study and
Operation Reaseach 129, (2001): 481-495. obtained his MSc in Information and Business Systems
Engineering from University of Surrey in 2007. In 2008, he
Melo, M.T., S. Nickel, and F. Saldanha-da-Gama. “Facility
started working as an academic staff in Republic
Location and Supply Chain Management – A Review.” Polytechnic, Singapore, specialising in supply chain and
European Journal of Operational Research 196, no. 2 (July logistics, unitil 2010.
2009): 401–412. doi:10.1016/j.ejor.2008.05.007. Mingyen is now a PhD research student at Department of
Reeds Business Information Limited. ISIC Pricing Hydrocloric Chemical Engineering, University of Surrey. His current
research interests include biomass supply chain modeling,
Acid, 2012.
distribution and transportation optimization, as well as
Regnier, Eva. “Oil and Energy Price Volatility.” Energy sustainable systems design in terms of life cycle analysis.
Economics 29, no. 3 (May 2007): 405–427.
doi:10.1016/j.eneco.2005.11.003.
Seyed Ali Hosseini earned his BSc in Chemical Engineering
Rigalos, C., Moiragia, A., Tsoumani, A. and Papadopoulou, in 2005 from Sharif University of Technology (Tehran, Iran).
C. Production of Biodiesel, Greece, 2008. After graduating, he worked as a market analysis for
pharmaceutical products of Akzo Nobel in Iran. He then
Sahin, G and Süral, H. “A review of hierarchical facility
moved to UK to continue his postgraduate studies. In 2007,
location models.” Computer & Operation Research 34, he was awarded his master’s in Advanced Chemical
(2007): 2310-2331. Engineering from the University of Birmingham.
Immediately following, Ali joined the Centre for Process
Skarlis, Str, E Kondili, and J K Kaldellis. “Design and
Systems Engineering (CPSE) at Imperial College London to
Feasibility Analysis of a New Biodiesel Plant in Greece” complete his PhD. He attained a PhD in two years and
(n.d.): 1–11. continued his research at Imperial College London as an
States, United. “Analysis of Biodiesel Impacts on Exhaust associate research fellow. At the same time, he did a master’s
in Finance at the London School of Economics (LSE).
Emissions Draft Technical Report” no. October (2002).
Ali is now a lecturer at Department of Chemical
Thane, Phil. “Breaking Away from Potassium Hydroxide”
Engineering, University of Surrey. His current research
no. november (2008): 53–57. interests cover a variety of topics relevant to mathematical
US Department of Energy. “Biodiesel Benefits and modeling, including design and analysis of energy and
bioenergy systems, supply chain modeling and
Consideration,” 2012.
optimization, design of sustainable systems for water and
US Department of Energy. “Biodiesel Blends,” 2012. resources recovery, and energy finance.
http://www.afdc.energy.gov/fuels/biodiesel_blends.html.

91

You might also like