Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Trafficking within and beyond the African continent for the past few years has been largely
ignored for the past several years. Trafficking as an issue area had been relegated to ‘low
politics’ and as such did not warrant prominence or as much attention as a ‘high politics’ issue or
concern would.
Trafficking is regarded as modern day slavery, thus tracing its roots as far back as the slave trade
days. In the West, trafficking, particularly that involving women and girls gained prominence in
“innocent” victims and “immoral” prostitutes (Doezema, 2002, p.22), as a way to fight “white
slavery”.
Despite this early fight by feminists such as Josephine Butler and the adoption of laws as early as
1904 by 16 states in Paris and the 1933 International Convention for the Suppression of the
Traffic in Women, the definition of trafficking was still ambiguous. Thus it was not until
December 2000 that the international community reached a consensus on the definition of
Trafficking in persons according to the Palermo Protocol (UNICEF Innocenti Insight, 2003, p.3)
1
Lately the incidence of trafficking within Eastern Africa has become rife as many citizens of
these nations seek a better life, hence become victims of this illegal trade. Countries within
Eastern Africa are now countries of origin, transit and even destination for those who are
trafficked.
The UNICEF Innocenti Insight (2003, p.10) offers the following definitions for a country of
origin, transit and destination. Thus a country of origin may be defined as “the victim’s home
country or place of residence”; a country of transit is defined as “one or more countries the
traffickers and victims pass through for geographic or logistic reasons to arrive at the final
destination” and a country of destination is defined as “the final point in the trafficking chain”.
One important factor to note is the difference between trafficking and smuggling is that
smuggling involves providing assistance to someone to illegally cross the border for a fee while
trafficking involves the use of means such s deception, coercion and abduction to transport a
person through legal or illegal channels across a border or within the country for exploitation.
Another important fact to note is that with smuggling, a migrant gives their consent to being
This paper shall thus seek to examine, the causes of trafficking, that is, the reasons behind the
trade, countries within Eastern Africa that are affected, with special reference to Kenya, Ethiopia
and Tanzania; the impact of the trade, policy legislation and probable recommendations to help
2
Causes of trafficking
Successful businesses focus on the bottom line, that being of maximizing profit; the principle of
demand and supply is thus the most pertinent to achieving the bottom line as it enables them to
adjust accordingly in order to ensure that profits do not dip, thus adversely affect their venture.
Trafficking is no exception, as like any other form of trade, whether legal or not, the principle of
demand and supply is very pertinent. Trafficking is one of the most profitable illegal trade
$9.5 billion annually while the United Nations places the estimate at $10 billion annually.
Human trafficking as a trade rivals drug trafficking in that a drug can only be sold once for a
certain price, a woman or child can be sold each day, every day, over and over again, thus the
markup is immeasurable (Bolton). Human trafficking is now the world’s third largest criminal
activity according to the United Nations Global Initiative to Fight Human Trafficking
(UN.GIFT).
With regards to trafficking, demand takes the form of “push factors” while the supply side takes
the form of “pull factors” (Innocenti Insight). The “pull factors” are the reasons as to why the
trade flourishes so much, while the “push factors” are the unfortunate circumstances that lure
The “push factors” in the Horn of Africa include but are not limited to: poverty, gender
inequality, conflict, lack of proper awareness and kidnappings in some cases; while on the other
hand the “pull factors” include but are not limited to: sexual exploitation, the need for cheap
3
“Push factors”
As earlier mentioned, these are factors that may unknowingly lure one into a life of misery and
drudgery. The United Nations High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR) estimates that 74.000
people have risked their lives in 2008 to escape desperate situations of civil war, political
Poverty
According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, poverty can be defined as “the state of one who
The United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) estimates that 50% of the population
in the eastern Africa region live under less than $2 a day (UNODC, 2009). Many people are in a
desperate search of a better life for themselves and their families that they are willing to do
anything to improve their stature in society. The modern world has become highly competitive
such that employment opportunities are becoming scarcer, particularly, for those who do not
Families are increasingly being split up as heads of households have to work away from home in
order to provide a sustainable supply of income to take care of their families. The increase in the
number of success stories of those who took gambles with overseas jobs and were handsomely
rewarded for that risk, encourage more and more people to seek opportunities overseas.
Children may be given away by their parents to relatives to raise them and give them a better
future as they are unable to care for them. Parents may unknowingly be leading their children
into lives of forced labour and other forms of exploitation. These children need not leave the
4
country for the “so-called” better opportunities, but merely move to the urban cities within their
Exposure to global markets and access to information, often offer a deceptive view of a better
life abroad, thus increasing the numbers of young people who seek these great fortunes away
from home, and who often fall for traffickers’ fraudulent promises.
In Kenya, for example, every other day, the media reports tales of girls who have been lured by
false promises of jobs in the Middle East and how they were repeatedly and systematically
abused and taken advantage of. Many of these girls have their travel documents confiscated on
arrival to the “promised land” of milk and honey; this prevents them from escaping as they
Conflict
Conflict may be defined as “the situation in which the party (parties) perceive or experience
Conflicts within Eastern Africa have been ongoing for a number of years, the most protracted of
this region, being the Somalia conflict and that of Sudan; other minor conflicts that have arisen
in the past few years but have not displaced as many people as the above mentioned conflicts
have.
Regional conflicts often have an immediate response of refugees and internally displaced persons
who are desperate to get away from the political instability and fighting in the countries.
Traffickers are aware of this and as such often take advantage of those seeking asylum in other
countries as refugees.
5
Those fleeing conflicts often do not have any or proper documentation, that proves, their name,
nationality or even birth registration (Innocenti Insight). Such individuals and children in
particular, are the best kind of commodity for the traffickers as they can easily disappear within
the system.
Many, particularly women and children, may fall into rings that, force them to trade sex for
Gender Inequality
In societies where women and girls are considered to be inferior and weaker, they are more
likely to be trafficked. Young girls are often sold into prostitution rings, particularly, those who
are orphans, or those escaping early marriages; these girls end up in fates much worse or quite
This particular problem has been noted in countries such as Kenya and Ethiopia, where majority
of the runaways end up in poor urban communities and in order to survive may end up in
brothels where they are forced to prostitute themselves, others may end up in forced labour with
Those who end up in these forced labour conditions are often subjected to all sorts of abuse.
6
Kidnappings
Young women, girls and children are often forcibly taken from their homes, schools and villages
by rebels or traffickers. This vulnerable group are often forced into a life that acutely differs
Young boys are often kidnapped to be used as child soldiers in the armies of the rebels, while the
young women and girls are kidnapped in order to provide “wives” for the soldiers in the armies
or in order to provide sexual services to the soldiers in the camps; some of these children are
Within Uganda this is the most prevalent method of trafficking that is being used, particularly in
the Northern part of the country. The Lord’s Resistance Army (LRA) often abducts young girls,
women and children from villages and schools for the purpose of exploitation. According to
IRIN it is estimated that as many as 25,000 northern Ugandan children have been abducted.
Lack of Awareness
This has contributed a major deal to the illicit trade of trafficking of women and children; due to
the fact that many of them, especially, those who live in the rural areas, do not know what they
are getting themselves into. They are lured by false promises of better jobs overseas and believe
Traffickers often exploit their victims’ lack of knowledge of the ‘way of the world’ (African
Woman, pg.77).
7
“Pull factors”
These are the factors that have fuelled and instigated this trade by increasing the demand for
victims of trafficking. The following five factors have been identified as being behind the need
for human slaves: - the need for cheap labour, sexual exploitation, adoption, post conflict
Economic exploitation
This factor contributes to a large percent of the demand for human slaves within and across the
borders of most countries in Africa. Children are often the main victims in this particular trade as
they provide cheap labour and can be mistreated and overworked with little or no pay and would
Many countries within Eastern Africa are guilty of this particular form of exploitation
particularly within their borders, as children are often moved from the rural areas to urban cities
to provide domestic labour in the form or house helps or ayahs for children not that much older
than themselves. They often work more than eighty hours a week and are not given opportunities
In Ethiopia for instance, parents allow their children to be sent to the capital city Addis Ababa, in
the hopes that they shall get good jobs and have an opportunity to be educated, as that is what the
traffickers promise them. Instead these children are employed as weavers in the cottage industry
8
It is estimated that between 20,000 and 25,000 Ethiopians work as domestic workers in Lebanon,
a significant number of whom have been trafficked (Pearson, E., 2003, p.4).
The amount that is their due is never agreed on at the point of origin and many get to know their
Sexual exploitation
The demand for women and girls in countries such as Europe and within the urban centres of a
country has led to an increase in the number of girls and women being trafficked for this
purpose; many are lured under the guise of helping them secure a better job.
Development and economic growth has played a key role in pushing up the demand for sexual
services as men with better jobs are now in a better position to pay for these services and at the
same time give a list of preferences such as age, ethnicity and race and virginity (Wennerholm,
2002, p.13), thus traffickers will seek younger girls and women who are least likely to have
The growing tourism industry in the region has played a contributing factor by increasing the
demand for sexual services and in particular for young girls to offer these services. In Kenya, the
coastal towns of Mombasa and Malindi have seen an increase in the number of young girls who
are trafficked within the area to provide services to the European tourists. Recently it was
reported that tourists have been engaging these young girls in child pornography and selling the
films abroad.
In Ethiopia, young girls are trafficked to the capital and recruited to work in bars by, “balukas”
who are the recruiters who also function as facilitators of the prostitution by linking the victim to
9
a user. The balukas may force them to have sex with more than one partner and often control
10
Traditional practices
Practices such as early marriages have contributed a great deal in increasing the demand for
young girls, thus a high number are trafficked for this purpose. Young, school-age-school-going-
girls are sold off into early marriages at an age as young as eight, due to their “purity” (UNICEF
Innocenti Insight).
Practices such as, traditional medicine and witchcraft, has seen an increase in the number of
people being trafficked, particularly for their body organs. This type of trafficking normally
In recent months there has been an increase in the number of albinos being attacked, both in
Tanzania and Burundi, some victims are ferried across the border from Burundi to Tanzania,
where their organs are then removed for use in black magic.
Adoption
This particular factor tends to be a grey area as not much information is currently available on it.
Out of all the countries on the African continent only three Burundi, Mauritius and Burkina Faso
have signed the Hague Convention on Protection of Children and Co-operation in respect to
In Ethiopia, babies, with live parents, are sold for to foreigners for peanuts, according to a 2004,
report, for as little as $6,700 a black Ethiopia child could be adopted as compared to a child from
These foreigners then leave the country with them and no proper record is kept of this as the
Conflict generates two types of demands for children, an indirect one and a direct one. The direct
form of this demand relates to the use of children as child soldiers, for sexual services and
domestic functions while the indirect demand relates to poor families sending their children off
to be child soldiers in order to supplement the family’s income (UNICEF Innocenti Insight,
pg.8).
There are three important players in this trade: - the Victims, the Traffickers and the Users.
The Victims
These are the vulnerable group who are taken advantage of by both the traffickers and the users.
They may be recruited either by initiating contact with a known trafficker in order to ‘help’ them
to escape a particular situation, mainly poverty or the trafficker may contact the victim’s family,
The Traffickers
These are the middlemen who are responsible for facilitating the trade by providing a constant
stream of supply, that is, victims to the users and using debt-burden to ensure that demand does
not decrease.
12
The Users
They are responsible for providing the demand for the victims and eventually exploiting the
vulnerable group of victims; they are the “engine in the machinery of exploitation” (UNICEF
This group may work individually or within an organised network in order to obtain cheap
labour, have access to easily manageable and underpaid workers by using child labour, and have
access to activities of an illegal nature, such as child prostitution and pornography or to fulfil a
Facilitating contributors
Though the above named actors are the key players in this trade, there are a number of factors
within the countries of origin, transit and destination that enable this unlawful trade to go on
These factors are referred to as facilitating contributors as they inadvertently play a direct role in
the ensuring that this trade has enabling environment to flourish; they may include the following
but are not limited to them: - corruption, weak governments and criminal justice systems, porous
borders and the fact that East Africans can travel freely across the borders of members states of
the EAC, that is, they do not need visas to travel into these countries.
13
Countries affected within Eastern Africa
Most countries within Eastern Africa are affected by this illegal trade and many are culpable for
the suffering that these innocents go through; this paper shall to a large extent focus on Kenya,
These countries are used as either points of origin, transit or even destination.
Kenya
According to a report released by Womankind Kenya, 20 to 50 girls are trafficked from Northern
Kenya to Nairobi every week to work in brothels and onwards to other countries; they are made
to pay upfront in order to secure these “jobs”. They are falsely promised that they are going to be
resettled in America yet they are misused by the men in the vehicles on route.
According to Lucy Oriang, South Asian girls are trafficked into Kenya under the false promise
that they are going to work as dancers yet find themselves subjected to sexual slavery.
Towards the end of last year thirteen young girls, between the ages of 10 and 16 were rescued in
Mombasa after it emerged that they had been lured from Tanzania under the guise of jobs in
Kenya; their host abandoned them after realizing that their guise was cooked. These girls are the
According to the International Organization for Migration (IOM), 6000 to 9000 people are
annually trafficked through the Coast Province, a third of them being children. Mombasa is a
source, transit and destination point for human trafficking as young girls come from as far as
Uganda, DR Congo and Tanzania in the hopes of linking up with rich tourists but instead end up
as “sex slaves”.
14
Ethiopia
Thousands of women and children are trafficked within and across the borders of this country.
Records show that between July 2001 and June 2002, there were 4,896 female labour migrants
(IOM, pg. 56); this number has rapidly increased as of November 2002, the estimate stood as at
between 25,000 and 35,000, in Lebanon alone, with 1,000 migrants arriving each month
Reports currently show that 10,000 Ethiopian female migrants are engaged in prostitution in the
Gulf States.
The main countries of destination for trafficked women and children in the Middle East are the
Lebanon, United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia and Yemen. Within Africa, Ethiopian women and
children are trafficked to Sudan, Kenya, South Africa, Djibouti, Kenya and Egypt (Endeshaw,
Tanzania
Tanzania is mainly used as a country of transit though it often serves as a country of origin, as
girls who are trafficked originate from there. As a transit country, there are two main routes used
to ferry human cargo according to the Tanzania’s Anti-Trafficking Unit: - The first route is
Shimoni in Mombasa to Pemba, Pangani in Tanzania then to Mozambique before going to South
Africa. The other route is Shimoni, Bagamoyo, Mtwara in Tanzania, Mozambique and finally to
South Africa1.
1
http://www.standardmedia.co.ke/InsidePage.php?id=1144030464&catid=459&a=1
15
Impact of trafficking
Trafficking has diverse effects on the people who are most affected by this trade, mainly the
Health effects
Many of the trafficked victims are sexually exploited and do not have much choice in terms of
whether or not their users use protection as they do not have sufficient bargaining power. Thus,
many of these trafficked women and girls are exposed to HIV/AIDS and other Sexually
Unwanted pregnancies may result in the procurement of unsafe abortions, which result in high
rates of maternal deaths or in some cases sterility. The long hours that some of them are forced to
work for, in addition to the backbreaking work that they do takes a toll on their health in the long
term, particularly those who are trafficked for use as cheap labour.
Psychological effects
Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and other disorders such as Dissociative identity
Disorder (DID) may be developed by the victims of trafficking as a result of what they go
Economic effects
16
Children and women who are trafficked for use as cheap labour, often do not receive adequate
pay and do not have the bargaining power to negotiate for better pay or working conditions for
that matter.
They are unable to remit money to their families thus defeating the purpose their being in this
captivity; some are indebted to their traffickers and thus may have to work for years in order to
pay them back, essentially ensuring that they remain captives for years.
Legal effects
Trafficked victims often do not have proper documentation and as such are considered illegal
immigrants. They often face imprisonment or deportation back to their home countries without
Social effects
Trafficked victims are normally transported to other countries that are far from home, where a
different language may be used and they have no idea how to communicate and as of such
Children, who are born to trafficked victims, may be abandoned, placed in orphanages or
adopted (Wennerholm, 2002, p.14); this places a strain on the destination country’s resources.
Those manage to get back home may face stigma, particularly if they come back home whilst
sick.
17
Policy and legislation
Tanzania and Uganda have signed the Palermo Protocol while Kenya and Ethiopia have not
slowing down the counter-trafficking efforts. These countries do not have laws that criminalize
International Organizations are the main players in counter-trafficking; organizations such as the
United Nations Office for Drugs and Crime (UNODC), United Nations High Commission for
Refugees (UNHCR), United Nations Interregional Crime and Research Institute (UNICRI),
United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF), International Committee of the Red Crescent
(ICRC) and International Federation of the Red Cross (IFRC) are actively involved in efforts to
The UNODC has initiated the Blue Heart Campaign in order to raise awareness of human
The African Union has initiated a campaign to assist governments in counter-trafficking efforts
The United Nations Global Initiative to Fight human Trafficking (UN.GIFT) was conceived to
promote the global fight on human trafficking, on the basis of international agreements reached
at the UN.
Recently in Kenya, the Federation of Women Lawyers (FIDA) has partnered with international
18
Recommendations
Though much has been done in light of the laws that have been formulated, more needs to be
done to effectively curb this trade and ensure the protection of vulnerable groups.
Civic awareness campaigns should be increased; the “Kaa Chonjo” campaign that was initiated
by the International Organization for Migration (IOM) in order to sensitize the public on the
dangers of human trafficking. The governments of the concerned countries should work hand in
hand with these agencies to ensure that each citizen knows their rights and know how to go about
securing jobs through legal migration; the governments should encourage legal migration.
Stricter border control to ensure that borders are no longer porous thus enabling the trade to go
on unnoticed and unencumbered. Corruption has to be addressed in the countries, where border
officers are known to collude with traffickers in order to ensure that the human cargo is able to
Tighter laws need to be formulated in order to prosecute those who are guilty of transporting the
victims, that is, the traffickers, those that aid them, such as border officers and the users, for
Ensure that when victims of trafficking are caught, they should be treated with the sensitivity that
they deserve after enduring the horror and trauma of abuse at the hands of their abusers. They
19
Conclusion
Human trafficking is not a region specific problem but a global one; one that needs to be given
the seriousness that it deserves due to the fact that it wreaks irreversible damage to its victims.
This issue needs to be made up from low politics to high politics in order for it to be properly
addressed.
Nations need to work together and cooperate in order to effectively tackle this illicit trade; there
is an urgent need for the formulation of strict laws to counter this trade and ensure that there is a
high level of compliance by setting steep penalties for countries of origin and transit.
Governments need to decentralize their countries and ensure equitable distribution of resources
so that people in the rural areas do not need to migrate to the urban areas in search of a better
life. Education centres should be set up in each part of the country in order to counter illiteracy
and thus reduce the chances of people being taken advantage of as they cannot read the fine
print. Practices such as early marriages that are detrimental to the development and education of
Awareness is the key to combating this vice, if each individual was made aware of the dangers of
Political stability within the Eastern Africa region is the crux, in order to ensure that women and
children are not forced to flee their homes and end up in the hands of those willing to take
20
References
(3)
Bolton, S., (n.d.). Mini-series Explores the Inhumanity of Human Trafficking. Retrieved Feb 12,
2010, from
http://www.un.org/Pubs/chronicle/2005/webArticles/110905_Trafficking.html
http://www.activeforpeace.org/en/peares/peares_conflict.htm
Doezema, J. (2002). Who gets to choose? Coercion, consent and the UN Trafficking Protocol. In
Endeshaw, Y., Gebeyahu, M., & Reta, B., (2006). Assessment of Trafficking in Women and
Human Trafficking is World’s Third Largest Criminal Activity (2010). Retrieved Feb 12, 2010,
from http://www.voxy.co.nz/national/human-trafficking-world039s-third-largest-
criminal-activity/5/36942
In-depth: Life in Northern Uganda: Uganda, LRA Human Rights Abuses (2010). Retrieved Feb
InDepthId=23&ReportId=65776
21
Lundberg, E (2009, May). 21st century slavery: Human Trafficking in East Africa. African
Woman, 1, 76-79.
Miller, C., (2006). Babies for Sale. The New Atlantis: a Journal for Technology and Society,
http://www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/babies-for-sale
Mudi, M., & Oriedo M., (2009, December 16,). Is Kenya turning into a human trafficking hub?
id=1144030464&catid=459&a=1
Oriang, L., (2010, February, 14). A tale of two countries: one free, one in bondage. The Daily
http://www.nation.co.ke/oped/Opinion/-/440808/842176/-/item/1/-/4k5umv/-/index.html
Pearson, E., (2003). Study on Trafficking in women in East Africa. Eschborn, Germany:
Schlein, L., (2009). Record number of people from Horn of Africa flee to Yemen. Retrieved Feb
People-From-Horn-Of-Africa-Flee-to-Yemen-79620302.html
UNICEF Innocenti Insight (2003). Trafficking in Human Beings, especially Women and
22
UNODC (2009). Organised crime and trafficking in Eastern Africa: A Discussion Paper.
Wennerholm, C, J., (2002). Crossing borders and building bridges: the Baltic Region
Oxford: Oxfam GB
23