Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT: The effects of 5 endpoint temperatures for cooked, internal color were determined for boneless pork
Introduction mal, normal injected, PSE (pale, soft and exudative), and DFD
© 2002 Institute of Food Technologists Vol. 67, Nr. 3, 2002—JOURNAL OF FOOD SCIENCE 1007
cooking, loin chops were sliced through the center perpendicular Table 1—Least square means for raw pork loin chops from
to the flat surfaces. Three panelists scored the cooked color to different qualities d
the nearest one-half point on a 5-point color scale (1 = purplish Treatment Groups
red to pinkish red, 2 = moderately pink, 3 = slightly pink, 4 = very Normal
slightly pink to tannish white, 5=tannish white with no evidence Trait DFD Normal injected PSE SE
of pink). Warm white fluorescent bulbs at 538 lux were used for il- pH 6.6c 5.6b 5.6b 5.2a 0.2
lumination. After visual evaluation, patties were cut parallel to Visual color e 4.3c 2.9b 2.7b 1.8a 0.1
the flat surface. Color was evaluated instrumentally using the L* value 42.4a 54.6b 53.9b 61.9c 1.0
Hunterlab LabScan 6000 (Hunterlab, Reston, Va., U.S.A.) with an a* value 7.7a 10.5b 10.9b 10.7b 0.5
b* value 13.2a 18.3b 18.8bc 19.9c 0.4
aperture of 2.54 cm. CIE L*a*b* values (CIE 1976) for Illuminant
Saturation index f 15.4b 21.1c 11.7a 22.6c 0.6
C and reflectance at 580 and 630 nm were determined on 3 patty Hue angle f 88.3a 89.1b 89.1b 89.3c 0.1
locations. Reflectance ratios (630 nm / 580 nm), hue angle [(b*/ Drip loss, % 0.9a 1.6ab 1.8b 3.3c 0.3
a*) tan-1], and saturation index [(a*2 + b*2) 1/2] were calculated. Myoglobin, mg/g 1.3c 0.9b 0.8ab 0.7a 0.1
Food Chemistry and Toxicology
Table 2—Least square means of pork loin chops of different quality types f cooked to 5 endpoint temperatures
Treatment Endpoint temperature (°C)
Trait group 62.8° 65.6° 71.1° 76.7° 82.2° SE
Visual color g DFD w1.5a w2.1b w2.9c w3.7d w4.3e 0.3
Normal x2.6a x2.8b w3.3c wx3.9cd wx4.7d
SE 0.2
L* value DFD w68.8a w70.0a w69.2a w70.4a w71.0a 1.3
Normal wx70.7a w72.3ab x71.7ab x73.0ab w73.4b
SE 1.2
a* value DFD x4.6c x4.0cb x3.3ab x2.8a w2.3a 0.5
SE 0.5
b* value DFD x18.4b x18.5b x18.5b x17.3ab x16.5a 0.6
Normal w17.0bc x17.4 c x17.4 c w15.9b w14.5a
SE 0.5
Saturation index h DFD x19.1 c y18.9 c y18.8bc x17.5ab x16.7a 0.7
Normal w17.4c x17.7 c x17.6 c w16.1b w14.6a
SE 0.3
Hue angle h DFD w76.1a w77.9a x79.8b w80.8bc w82.1c 7.9
Normal w79.5a w80.9ab x81.5bc w83.1c w84.7c
SE 7.9
Myoglobin DFD w56.3a w56.5a w71.7b w79.8bc w84.1c 6.0
denaturation,% Normal w51.9a w57.9ab w64.1bc w74.4cd w85.3d
SE 6.0
ACP i, units/kg DFD w7.2b w3.5a w1.2a w0.9a w0.6a 1.8
Normal w8.8b x8.5b w1.7a w1.1a w0.7a
SE 1.8
a-e Means in a row with a different superscript letter differ (P<0.05).
w-z Means in a column for each trait with a different superscript differ (P<0.05).
f Pork chops treatment groups: DFD = dark, firm, and dry, PSE = pale, soft and exudative, Normal = chops with normal characteristics, Normal injected =
chops injected at 7% pump.
g Visual color : 1 = purplish red to pinkish red, 2 = moderately pink, 3 = slightly pink, 4 = very slightly pink to tannish white,5= tannish white, no evidence of
pink.
h Saturation index = (a *2 + b* 2 ) 1/2 ; hue angle = (b*/a*)tan -1 .
i ACP = Acid phosphatase.
not affected by pH and factors contributing to PSE. The slightly lower doneness scores than normal muscle cooked to 76 °C,
lower values of ACP in injected loins again may be a dilution ef- which relates to the greater pinkness observed at all tempera-
fect. tures for DFD chops in our study. Howe and others (1982) have
Raw DFD chops had a myoglobin concentration of 1.3 mg/g, shown that the rate of change in visual color of loin chops de-
normal chops had 0.9 mg/g, normal injected chops had 0.8 mg/g, clined with temperature increases beyond 70 °C, which also is
and PSE had a myoglobin concentration of 0.7 mg/g. Our find- consistent with our findings.
ings are consistent with those of Fox and others (1980) who found Overall, the instrumental color values confirmed the visual
0.93 mg of total pigment per gram of normal meat and 0.64 mg/g color changes due to treatment group and endpoint tempera-
in PSE pork chops. ture. L* values (Table 2) for DFD, PSE, and normal-injected meat
did not change significantly as endpoint temperature increased.
Data for cooked pork However, normal loin chops were lighter at 82.2 °C than at
Visual color scores increased (became less pink) as endpoint 62.8 °C. Differences in L* values due to treatment group were
temperature increased (Table 2). However, above 71.1 °C, chops small, but the chops that were DFD tended to have lower values
from normal, normal-injected, and PSE were not visually differ- at the lower endpoint temperatures. Values for a* and b* de-
ent (P > 0.05). DFD chops had lower visual scores (more pink) creased as endpoint temperature increased (Table 2). Howe and
than the other treatment groups at each endpoint temperature. others (1982) also reported decreased a* values for pork at higher
Lewis and others (1987)found that DFD psoas major muscle had endpoint temperatures. Overall, there was a trend for both a*
and b* values to be greater for DFD chops than for other treat- References
ment groups. Antonini E, Brunori M. 1971. Hemoglobin and myoglobin in their reactions with
ligands. Amsterdam: North-Holland Publ Co. 9p.
DFD chops were more saturated and lower in hue angles than Bendall JR, Swatland HJ. 1988. A review of the relationships of pH with physical
the other 3 treatment groups. When a* and b* values were com- aspects of pork quality. Meat Sci 24(2):85-126.
Bernofsky C, Fox JB, Schweigert BS. 1959. Biochemistry of myoglobin. VIII. The
bined into a saturation index (larger values indicate more in- effect of cooking on myoglobin in beef muscle. Food Res 24(2):339-343.
tense pink or red) and hue angle (larger values indicate more- Carlin AF, Mott C, Cash D, Zimmermann W. 1969. Destruction of Trichina larvae
in cooked pork roasts. J Food Sci 34(2):210-212.
gray-brown color for cooked meat), DFD chops were more CIE. 1976. Recommendations on uniform color spaces-color difference equa-
saturated and had lower hue angles. As endpoint temperature tions, psychometric color terms. Supplement No. 2 to CIE publications No. 15 (E-
increased, saturation index decreased and hue angles increased 1.3.1) 1978, 1971/(TC-1-3). Commission Internationale de L’ Eclairage, Paris.
Cornforth DP, Vahabzadeh F, Carpenter CE, Bartholomew DT. 1986. Role of re-
as expected. For all instrumental measurements of color, more duced hemochromes in pink color defect of cooked turkey rolls. J Food Sci
differences were noted at 62.8 °C and 65.8 °C endpoints. Once 51(5):1132-1136.
Davis CE. 1998. Fluorometric determination of acid phosphatase in cooked, bone-
71.1 °C was reached, differences became less apparent. less, nonbreaded broiler breast and thigh meat. J AOAC Internatl 81(4):887-
906.
Food Chemistry and Toxicology
in cooked pork appears to be a good indicator of when chops Authors are with Kansas State Univ., Animal Sciences and Industry, 232
reach 71 °C, but it will not differentiate temperatures below and Weber Hall, Manhattan, KS 66506-0201. Direct inquiries to author Hunt (E-
mail: hhunt@oznet.ksu.edu).
above this point.