Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Guide
The purpose of this document is to provide a “how to" reference for the implementation and
management of a successful Rebuild Option program. The elements of a complete program are
presented in the following sections of this guide:
I. Introduction – Definition of the Rebuild Option concept and customer needs addressed,
customer / dealer benefits and the critical elements of a successful Rebuild Option program.
II. Rebuild Option Implementation - This guide breaks the program into four easy steps:
Create – Which rebuild options to offer and how to create and price rebuild
options.
Sell – How to promote and sell Rebuild Options.
Deliver – Coding rebuild options, parts reusability, remanufactured products,
dealer exchange program and managing impact on parts inventory.
Measure – Monitoring performance of your rebuild options program.
-2-
Rebuild Option Guide
Introduction................................................................................................................................................... 4
Customer Needs .......................................................................................................................... 4
Rebuild Option Concept ............................................................................................................. 5
Critical Elements of a Successful Program................................................................................. 6
Create .......................................................................................................................................................... 10
RO Coverage Plan..................................................................................................................... 10
Option Definitions .................................................................................................................... 11
Recommended Rebuild Options: .............................................................................................. 12
Core Acceptance Criteria.......................................................................................................... 16
Determining Cost ...................................................................................................................... 16
Option Pricing........................................................................................................................... 17
Sell .............................................................................................................................................................. 18
Sales Training ........................................................................................................................... 18
Selling Tools ............................................................................................................................. 19
Sales Goals................................................................................................................................ 19
Target Customer List ................................................................................................................ 20
Tracking Target Opportunity .................................................................................................... 20
Promotion.................................................................................................................................. 20
Sales Incentive .......................................................................................................................... 21
Inspection Program ................................................................................................................... 21
Deliver ........................................................................................................................................................ 23
Service Capability.................................................................................................................... 23
Option Coding........................................................................................................................... 23
Parts Reusability ....................................................................................................................... 24
Managing Exchange Program................................................................................................... 24
Caterpillar Remanufactured Products ....................................................................................... 25
Keeping RO’s current ............................................................................................................... 25
Measure....................................................................................................................................................... 26
KPI’s – Customer facing........................................................................................................... 26
KPI’s – Operational .................................................................................................................. 26
Variance Monitoring................................................................................................................. 26
-3-
Introduction
The service business for Caterpillar Equipment can be broken into preventive maintenance (PM), and
unscheduled and scheduled repairs and rebuilds. The strategies for maximizing the Caterpillar dealers’
participation in these areas are:
Preventive Maintenance – provide customers with Customer Support Agreements that meet all of the
customer’s maintenance needs (PM CSA’s), and identify additional repair opportunities with machine
inspections built into the CSA.
Unscheduled repairs – First, help customers minimize unscheduled rebuilds through good equipment
management practices including PM CSAs, advanced product monitoring techniques (SOS, Product Link,
etc.) and CSA’s that cover unscheduled rebuilds.
Scheduled repairs & rebuilds – this type of rebuild can also be covered by a CSA. These agreements are
typically called Total Maintenance and Repair (TM&Rs). Without a CSA, a proven strategy is to offer
customers Rebuild Options for individual components or even the entire engine or machine.
Customer Needs
Surveys of Caterpillar customers indicate that the top criteria for selecting a service provider to rebuild
components are:
1. Turnaround Time
2. Technical Expertise
3. Promise Date Matching Completion Date
4. Up Front Fixed Price
-4-
Surveys of Caterpillar customers confirm that the majority of customers want firm price quotes for
rebuilds and component rebuilds.
Source: 2005 MPSD Customer Segmentation Study – NACD, UK France, Australia (729 Earthmoving data points)
The remaining customer preferences are split between time and material rebuilds and inclusion in CSA
Contracts. These surveys also indicate that complete descriptions of rebuilds, complete control of the
rebuilds, short turnarounds, and a good warranty are important purchasing factors. For these reasons, if
you offer only time and material rebuilds and/or flat-rate labor plus parts, you may not be addressing
the needs of the majority of your customers.
We recommend surveying your customers to verify their preference for fixed price rebuilds and help
build your marketing strategy/plan.
-5-
Customer Benefits
Reduce operating costs - before failure rebuilds are less
costly.
Reduce downtime – Because parts and labor resources
are planned, components can often be reconditioned
faster before failure.
Ease of doing business – customers can schedule
downtime and budget for rebuilds because the price is
known in advance.
Dealer Benefits
Ease of doing business – provides sales force with tools to sell service and reduces time settling invoice
disputes.
Increase service differentiation - provides competitively priced services that other workshops can rarely
match.
Increase service profitability by making better use of your service capabilities and improving efficiency.
Create: Deliver:
- RO Coverage Plan - Service Capability
- Option Descriptions & criteria - Standard Jobs
- Determining Cost - Option Coding
- Option Pricing - Parts Reusability
- Exchange Program
Sell: - Remanufactured Products
- Sales Training - Parts Inventory
- Selling Tools - Keeping ROs Current
- Target Customer List
- Sales Goals Measure:
- Promotion - Variance Monitoring
- Sales Incentive - Identifying and Tracking Target Opportunity
- Inspection Program
-6-
Rebuild Option Strategy & Plan
Each dealership needs an overall Rebuild Option strategy that defines how Rebuild Options fit with
their overall service offerings. This will be a guiding light for decisions that will be made during
implementation. This should be a written document outlining the following essential elements:
Who the competition is and what they offer.
Key models and key components that will be covered.
An expectation of the sales volume and % of rebuild business that will be done through Rebuild Options.
Key differentiators of the dealer’s RO program (ie, warranty, turnaround time, exchange components).
Type of Customer that will be targeted to gain incremental business
Measurable targets should be included with a schedule for completion. Targets include:
- Rebuild Option unit sales
- Parts & Service DCAL
- Service Efficiency
- Overall Profitability
- Customer Satisfaction
It is important the dealer plan becomes a “living document” that is maintained so that at any point in
time it can be referenced to determine if the program is meeting expectations.
-7-
Project Team - A Rebuild Option project team is highly recommended to ensure alignment to the
overall strategy, and buy-in from the Parts & Service teams to deliver as promised and track results.
This team should consist of representatives from Parts, Service (both Marketing & Operations) from
dealer HQ & Branches.
-8-
Service Department Buy-in
In most cases, the packaging of service and parts products into a defined Rebuild Option will represent
a significant change from traditional service marketing methods (Time and Material). Therefore, the
Service Department Management in conjunction with the program coordinator must complete the
definitions and development of the dealership’s Rebuild Options.
When Centralized rebuilding is not utilized, all branch service managers performing a rebuilding
function must be involved to ensure the program is acceptable at the branch level.
Additionally, precise service operations procedures must be established, i.e., work order opening,
coding, rebuild controls/standards, customer follow-up and contacts (see Communications section) in
order to ensure that ROs meet Customer expectations, and the dealer can track their effectiveness and
profitability in performing the RO.
-9-
Create
RO Coverage Plan
Target models can be determined by considering:
- Products with significant population in your territory
- Products with components that are economically rebuildable, ie, they have
adequate market value to justify investment when component rebuilds are
required (generally Heavy Construction machines and larger)
- 10 -
Option Definitions
Rebuild option definitions should be driven by analyzing customer needs to determine the level of rebuild
they want (for example, do your customers need a transmission rebearing/reseal, or a full recondition?)
The rebuild option should include the parts required for the majority of rebuilds, in order to minimize
invoice add-ons after the initial quote.
- 11 -
Following are recommended Rebuild Options for:
1. Engines
2. Transmissions
3. Torque Converters
4. Hydraulic Cylinders
5. Hydraulic Piston Pumps & Motors
1. Engines
- 12 -
2. Transmissions
Inspection
Option Included Excluded Meets Customer Need To
Criteria
Level 1 Component • All Level 1 Parts: bearings, • Friction plates and discs, clutch • Address leaks in an
Transmis meets Reman piston rings, gaskets, seals, locks, pistons otherwise problem-free
sion Full Core filters • Gears, shafts & carriers transmission
Rebuild Criteria • Transmission pump (if integral) • Transmission Control Group • Extend transmission life
• Torque Converter (if integral) • Transmission pump (if
separate)
• Torque Converter (if separate)
• Cases or Housings
Level 2 Component • All Level 1 Parts: bearings, • Replacement of Transmission • Restore to like-new
Transmis meets Reman piston rings, gaskets, seals, locks, Control Group performance
sion Full Core filters • Cases or Housings • Maximize next component
Rebuild Criteria • Friction plates and discs, clutch life
pistons
• Gears, shafts & carriers
• Reseal Transmission Control Gp
• Transmission Pump
• Torque Converter (if integral)
- 13 -
3. Torque Converters
Inspection
Option Included Excluded Meets Customer Need To
Criteria
Level 1 Component • All Level 1 Parts: bearings, • Friction plates and discs, clutch • Address leaks in an
Torque meets Reman piston rings, gaskets, seals, pistons otherwise problem-free
Converter Full Core locks, filters • Gears, shafts, turbine, stator, torque converter
Rebuild Criteria impeller • Extend torque converter
• Case or Housings life
Level 2 Component • All Level 1 Parts: bearings, • Turbine, stator, impeller • Restore to like-new
Torque meets Reman piston rings, gaskets, seals, • Cases or Housings performance
Converter Full Core locks, filters • Maximize next component
Rebuild Criteria • Friction plates and discs, clutch life
pistons
• Gears, shafts
- 14 -
4. Hydraulic Cylinders
Level 2 (Reseal • Component meets • Seals, O-rings, piston, • Tube, head • Address leaks and likely or
& Light Hone reman full core piston nut known rod damage
& Re-rod) criteria • Rod • Bring machine back to
100% productivity
Level 2 (Reseal • Component still • Seals, O-rings, piston, • Rod, head • Address leaks and likely or
& Light Hone meets reman full piston nut known tube damage
& Re-tube) core criteria • Tube • Bring machine back to
100% productivity
- 15 -
Core Acceptance Criteria
It is critical to have a simple standard for PSSR's to use to determine if a condition meets “before
failure” criteria. Because earthmoving customers are unlikely to remove a component that is running
perfectly with no symptoms, it is recommended to use Reman Core Acceptance Criteria to judge the
condition of components. They are simple and allow for a component to have some symptoms.
Determining Cost
This data has been used to determine the cost relationships and labor hour ranges you will find in the
EAME RO matrices. The cost relationship determines the average parts cost required to rebuild each
- 16 -
component. Using this along with the labor hour ranges gives you information required to determine
your target costs for major component rebuilds.
Option Pricing
Cost is not the only item to consider when establishing the
option price. You must also consider the market situation
and the dealer definition of the product. The cost must be
developed from standard labor times and a specific parts
list that may be factored for reusability or for the use of
remanufactured components
Once a price has been established, it should be compared
with competitive offerings in your territory to determine if
good value is represented to the customer. Be sure to
identify exactly what the competitive product includes (degree of rebuild, quality of parts, paint, dyno-
test, etc.) to guarantee a valid comparison is prepared. Ensure that consistency is achieved across the
product line, for example, alignment between 3306 powered machines. Target margins should be
established and improvement goals should be set to improve reusability or reduce labor hours. This
should allow dealers to meet or beat the margin targets. For those components with unacceptable
margin, determine if rebuild process improvements are needed.
The standards (parts, labor and miscellaneous) must be accessible to the individual performing the
rebuild. This individual must understand the job is an option sale and what parts are normally
replaced/salvaged during the rebuild. This not only contributes to a consistent high quality product but
also insures achievement of target profitability.
- 17 -
Sell
Sales Training
There are a number of people who have contact with your customers and
influence their purchase decisions. Some of these people are:
Parts and Service Sales Rep General Parts and Service Managers
Field Servicemen Inside Sales Reps
Shop Supervisors, Foremen, and Service Parts
Countermen
Parts and Service Sales Reps are the most important customer contact group. Parts and Service Sales
Reps will be the primary vehicles to present and explain rebuild options to your customers. To do this,
they need to know and understand the rebuild options themselves. As new rebuild options are
developed and offered, your reps should be updated
regarding:
- Rebuild option definitions: inclusions and exclusions,
and how components qualify for each rebuild option.
- Guaranteed prices, potential add charges, and how prices
were developed.
Additional training is also available specific to Rebuild
Options:
-
- “When to Sell RO”, includes:
- Cat Equipment Management Philosophy
- Repair Economics
- Repair Indicators & Tools
- “How to Sell RO”, includes:
- Customer Needs
- Risk & Cost Analysis
- Our Differentiation
- Positioning Our Differentiation As Customer Advantages
- Handling Objections
-
Field Servicemen should also be kept informed with respect to your rebuild option program. In some
instances they will be performing these rebuilds. In other cases,
customers may ask them about the options. In either case, they
are in a good position to influence customers and therefore need
to have a full understanding of the program.
Shop People and Parts Counter Reps have a lot of customer
contact. It is always possible that a customer might ask them
about your service products. For example, if a customer calls to
order turbocharger bearings and seals, your parts countermen
- 18 -
should take that opportunity to explain the before failure rebuild concept and how it can prevent
surprises and extra costs.
Selling Tools
RO Price List
PSSR’s agree that the ability to quote a firm price during the sales call greatly
improves the probability of making the sale. Here is a sample price list format.
This price list is recommended for anyone that touches the customer…
PSSR's, Parts Counter Staff and Field Technicians.
You will notice that target rebuild interval ranges are provided by model for
each component, this helps less experienced PSSR's identify the right time to
propose a Fixed Price Component Rebuild. It is also recommend that each
dealership look at their Work Order history to determine a realistic After
Failure cost to rebuild your most important major components. In some cases,
you may also want to list the price of a new component here.
Sales Goals
Short and long-term sales goals should be established prior to the launch of the program based on
machine population and target models selected.
Based on the targets, a forecast should be created for expected sales gains and incremental profits to the
dealership. This will help place a value on the program that will assist in the justification of the initial
start-up costs. Items which must be considered are training, developmental time, promotion, and sales
incentives.
Each salesman should have his/her own set of goals for the program. Commission structures should act
as an incentive for selling before failure rebuild options. Incentives need not only apply to salesmen.
Leads programs dealership-wide has been found to be well worth the small investment in time and
awards.
- 19 -
Target Customer List
A target customer list will be beneficial to winning incremental RO business. This list should be
populated with customers that have low service DCAL (Do It Myself and Work With Me customers)
and high opportunity for the rebuilds on product models identified by the RO coverage plan described
earlier in the guide. This list will help bring focus to business you don’t have today and provides that
greatest opportunity to sell ROs.
Promotion
There are several "tools" dealers have effectively used to
promote rebuild options. A few of these include:
Full Brochure – Click on the image to the right to see a
customized brochure for PSSR’s or Parts Counter Reps to
give to Customers, highlights the key messages of:
Extend machine life & Rebuild Before Failure
Get a fixed price and agreed schedule
Cat Dealer expertise and Cat parts quality
Work with your Cat dealer to determine when you need a rebuild
• Spec sheet Inserts provide what is included and the criteria to qualify
for a fixed price, for each major component:
-
- Engine
- Transmission - Hydraulic Piston Pumps & Motors
- Final Drive or Complete Axle - Hydraulic Cylinders
- 20 -
Cat Care Meetings, Maintenance Management Seminars and Branch Open Houses are good ways to
promote Rebuild Options. Customer meetings allow you to reach a large group of customers at the same
time. These meetings can be used to illustrate and discuss the advantages of rebuild before failure,
introduce new Rebuild Options, and to showcase your service differentiation
Sales Incentive
This is used in the early stages of the program to focus the PSSR on the Options Program. This may
also be used to focus the PSSR on selling the individual machine inspection leading to any revenue
work that results in conventional compensation.
Some form of an incentive program must continue to keep the PSSR focused on the Option Products as
in many cases the options may result in a higher margin than the equivalent time and material rebuild.
Inspection Program
An Inspection Program is intended to provide the
PSSR with adequate documentation of the
machine condition and to aid the PSSR in the
process of offering rebuilds/options to the
customer. Inspections come in forms as simple as
a walk around to a TA2 using complete
diagnostic equipment performed by a field
service technician.
The critical element of the inspection process is
the communication to the customer, utilizing a
standard machine condition report.
Communication must be transmitted from the
technician to the PSSR of any potential repairs to
be made to the customer’s machine in order for
the PSSR to offer repair options to the customer.
Types of physical inspections depending on the market or customer:
Continuous - dealer continuously involved in the maintenance of the machine (MCS, PMP)
Scheduled - dealer is involved in the scheduled machine maintenance (PM, TA1 or TA2)
Will Call - dealer performs demanded; i.e., Field Call, Shop Rebuild, TA-1, or TA-2
The ultimate inspection program is achieved when the dealer is an integral part of the machine
maintenance. In this situation the dealer is beyond any selling and just alerts the customer of the needed
rebuilds and gains approval. Other types of inspections can evolve into this level.
- 21 -
With the other forms of inspections the inspector; service department and PSSR need to continually
interface to understand:
- 22 -
Deliver
Service Capability
The Customer’s second most important buying criteria when selecting a
rebuild service provider is technical expertise. While a fixed price RO and
fast turnaround time can differentiate your service, a rebuilt component that
performs flawlessly will ensure
repeat business.
Standard Jobs
Standard Jobs are the foundation of any Rebuild Option
program. A standard job identifies the parts needed to do the rebuild, parts reuse percentages, labor
hours, miscellaneous charges. The entire process of building, selling, delivering and measuring rebuild
options is linked together through the use of standard jobs. Creating standard jobs requires the
involvement of the Service Department, which also aids in the level of Service Department buy-in.
Building a standard job can be done manually (which is very time-consuming) or performed using the
Repair Option BUILDER software. BUILDER is used to develop rebuild options and maintain rebuild
option prices.
Option Coding
All options must be coded correctly to ensure an accurate history can be retrieved to evaluate the
rebuild option program. At dealerships, this will involve the use of specific SMCS job codes assigned
to standard jobs used for your rebuild options. The mechanic and foreman should also be aware that
any work outside of the option consists must be placed on a separate segment. This not only is required
for job tracking but also to ensure proper invoicing for the rebuild.
Without standard jobs you will not be able to:
- Measure operational performance
- Measure financial performance
- Track and drive service efficiency
- 23 -
The following is a list of recommended Component Codes (match these to your RO’s):
Component Code Description Component Code Description
1000 Engine 5058 Piston Motor
3030 Transmission 5070 Piston Pump
3101 Torque Converter 5084 Implement Pump
3159 Transfer Gears 5456 Boom Cylinder
3258 Differential 5457 Bucket Cylinder
4050 Final Drive 5458 Stick Cylinder
4351 Hydraulic 5473 Swing Pump
Propel/Drive
Motor
Parts Reusability
Parts reusability is essential to take full advantage of genuine Caterpillar parts quality. Reusability
guidelines have been published to assist your Service Department. See "Index of Reusability and
Salvage Publications” (SEBF8029) for a complete listing of the available publications.
- 24 -
Caterpillar Remanufactured Products
With more than 700 product lines, high-quality, lower-cost Reman options are available for nearly the
entire Caterpillar product line.
Cat Remanufactured Products offers two types of products to support your RO program:
- Complete “Drop-In” major components, such as engine, transmissions, etc. to satisfy fast turnaround,
peak shaving or components, which are not covered in your RO program.
- Minor components, such as water pumps, turbochargers, etc, to support your dealer rebuild program.
This allows you to choose between your own rebuild product, Caterpillar Remanufactured Products, or
new.
- 25 -
Measure
For a rebuild option program to be successful, it is essential that a system
be in place to monitor the results. First of all, establish a system to keep
service shops and PSSR's informed of rebuild options sold and key
Customer facing and Operational KPI’s. Also, be very clear of what your
targets and performance are.
Here are recommended KPI’s, formulas, and targets specific to rebuild options.
KPI’s – Operational
Metric Measure Target
Standard Job utilization SJ Hours/Total Invoiced Hours 35%
Parts cost variance (Parts cost – Target parts cost) +/- 5%
Target parts cost
Variance Monitoring
Service work orders for rebuilds must be segmented and
coded correctly so that rebuild option history can be
retrieved and evaluated using the process flow chart
below. It is important that any additional work performed
outside the rebuild option scope be separated from the
job so that it does not influence your evaluation.
A regular report should be established that compares the
actual parts and labor on the job to the target amounts. It
is important to remember that individual variances are
not as important as the average variance over several
work orders. If necessary, cost targets can be adjusted based on this information.
- 26 -
The report is equally useful to the service shop. By knowing the target cost amounts and the
profitability of each job; the service departments are often able to increase efficiencies to make the
program more profitable. The report should allow you to assess to following for each rebuild option
(such as "D8R Engine Level 1" or "966G Level 2 Transmission ").
- Quantity of sales (number)
- Identify each work order for each option
- Compare target labor hours vs. actual (all rebuilds for one particular option)
- Compare target parts cost vs. actual (all rebuilds for one particular option)
- Compare target miscellaneous cost vs. actual (all rebuilds for one particular option)
This recap report should identify problem areas such as:
- No sales for a particular option, due to limited population or a price/value relationship
out of line with the market.
- An option not meeting profitability goals due to insufficient parts reusability, labor
inefficiency, etc
The variance monitoring system should identify problem areas and if further investigation is necessary to
determine the cause and a subsequent correction. For example, it may occasionally be necessary to adjust
option prices if profitability is not acceptable.
- 27 -