You are on page 1of 18

Energy Efficiency

DOI 10.1007/s12053-009-9072-8

Electricity and water consumption for laundry washing


by washing machine worldwide
Christiane Pakula & Rainer Stamminger

Received: 15 January 2009 / Accepted: 7 December 2009


# Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2009

Abstract Washing laundry is one of the most wide- 590,000,000 washing machines in 38 countries with
spread housework in the world. Today, washing about 2.3 billion people, which is about one third of the
machines do this work in many private households, world population. The results of this work show that
using water, electricity, chemical substances, and laundry washing in private households is done with
process time. Although energy efficiency is in the focus quite different amounts of electricity and water in
of many regulations which have already achieved different parts of the world both in absolute and relative
significant improvements, the question remains, how comparison to the overall household consumption. But
relevant these processes are in terms of the absolute due to different consumer habits in dealing with the
impact on resources and whether there are possibilities achieved washing performance in the different global
to improve even further by looking abroad. This survey, regions, the best practice in washing laundry in a
which is based on published data, compares the energy most sustainable way cannot be determined yet.
and water consumption for automatic laundry washing Further research is needed to form a basis for a most
in an average private household with the total energy sustainable development of resource consumption in
and water consumption of private households. Only private households.
little data are available on resource consumption for
laundry washing and reliable figures based on in-use Keywords Energy consumption . Housework
measurements are hard to obtain. But although some of practices . Laundry washing . Washing machine .
the data in this report are poor, this is the first work that Sustainability . Water consumption . Consumer habits .
tries to elucidate the contribution of automatic laundry Global relevance
washing to the total electricity and water consumption
of households in selected countries worldwide. The
report estimates the resource consumption of roughly Introduction

Washing clothes, laundry, and other home textiles is


C. Pakula : R. Stamminger (*) one of the most widespread housework in the world.
Household and Appliance Technology Section, Years ago, it was hard mechanical work, and in some
Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität Bonn,
Nussallee 5,
regions of the world, it still is. Today, washing
53115 Bonn, Germany machines do this work in many private households
e-mail: stamminger@uni-bonn.de worldwide using water, electricity, chemical substances,
C. Pakula and process time as resources. Due to different wash
e-mail: haushaltstechnik@uni-bonn.de habits and practices and different types of washing
Energy Efficiency

machines, the consumption of resources for laundry The main scope of this work is the electricity and
washing by washing machine varies a lot. Figure 1 water consumption for automatic laundry washing per
shows the main washing machine technologies which household, which is not influenced by the market
are in use. penetration of washing machines. But an estimation of
While in horizontal axis machines, only the bottom the total electricity and water consumption for automatic
of the wash tub is filled with water, in vertical axis laundry washing in the different regions covered in our
machines, traditionally, the whole tub is filled with work seems to be interesting and is attempted in
water. Therefore, horizontal axis machines consume the “Electricity and water consumption for automatic
much less water per wash cycle than vertical axis laundry washing by region” section. The variation of
machines, while these are mostly run without heating, ownership rates is shown in Fig. 2.
especially in Asia, and therefore, consume much less The market of washing machines in industrial
electricity per wash cycle than horizontal axis countries is more or less saturated and the worldwide
machines with integrated heating. But indeed, the market penetration is rising steadily. Nevertheless, in
main task of all types of washing machines is to many regions, like China, Turkey, or East Europe, the
provide hygienically clean laundry and to preserve its ownership rate of washing machines is <70% (Fig. 2),
value. This so-called washing performance is not which means that, in about one third of the house-
included in our work and an assessment of the holds in these countries, notable amounts of resources
different washing machine technologies besides the are consumed for manual laundry washing or by
electricity and water consumption is not intended. using manual washers. And although a washing
For several years, the state of the art shown in Fig. 1 machine is available in some households, clothes are
has been changing. Vertical axis machines are still frequently washed manually, e.g., in China (Procter &
most widespread in America, Australia, and Asia. But Gamble, private communication).
the share of horizontal axis machines in those markets Apart from the electricity and water consumption
is rising steadily, e.g., in 2007, 22% of households of washing machines, the efficiency of the washing
used a horizontal axis machine in Australia, while in process is determined by the washing performance. In
2005, it was only 13%. In some areas of the country, some countries where mostly cold wash programs are
horizontal axis machines make already 50% of the new used, e.g., in Japan, a lot of water and energy is spent
sales of washing machines (Australian Bureau of for pre- and post-treatments of laundry in addition to
Statistics 2008). Very often, horizontal axis machines the consumption of the washing machine (Nakaoka
have a minimum program temperature of 30°C which and Sursadana 2002). In our assessment, the con-
means that these machines use electricity to heat up sumptions for manual clothes washing and pre- and
water even in the coldest program selectable. post-treatments of laundry are not taken into consid-

Fig. 1 Global washing


systems (source: WFKRE
2006)

with heating without heating without heating

Horizontal axis Vertical axis Vertical axis


Energy Efficiency

Fig. 2 Ownership rate of

Owner ship rate of washing machines in %.


washing machines. Source: 94 97 100 99
100
Own calculation on the 86
basis of the following 90
sources: Australian Bureau 80
of Statistics (2008); 66 63
70
de Almeida et al. (2007); 61
DEHWA (2008b); GIFAM 60
(2006); Harrel (2003); 50
Nakaoka and Sudarsana 40
(2002); Togay (2002);
30
Yang (2006); ZVEI (2005);
Procter & Gamble, private 20
communication 10
0
West East Turkey North Australia China South Japan
Europe Europe America Korea

eration; therefore, a fair comparison of countries is obtain. Therefore, some of the data in this report are
not possible. But indeed, resource consumption for poor and, in some cases, reasonable guesses had to be
manual laundry washing is an important and interest- made; but nevertheless, this work is the first attempt
ing research area in respect to the global resource to elucidate the contribution of automatic laundry
consumption for laundry washing. washing to the total electricity and water consumption
Although in a lot of vertical axis machines an of households.
internal water heating is not possible, warm washes The main task of this work is the comparison of
can be done by using hot water from external sources. the electricity and water consumption for laundry
The additional energy needed to heat up water from washing by washing machine in relation to the total
the tap is not included in our calculations because it
can be done by other energy sources than electricity,
e.g., gas, coal, oil, or solar power. An assessment of Table 1 Distribution of washing machine technology and con-
the energy consumption for external water heating is sumer behavior
difficult. It does not only depend on the different fuels Region Technology Load size per Most frequently
used but also on the average cold water temperature, in the stock wash cycle (kg) used wash
which in some regions of the world can reach 25°C and temperatures
can make washing with little water heating effective. (°C)
The electricity and water consumption for laundry
West >98% HA 3–4 (75% of 40
washing in private households is determined by the Europe machine capacity)
technology of the washing machines and also by the East >98% HA 3–4 (75% of 40
number of washes, the chosen wash temperature, and Europe machine capacity)
the load size even in one single washing machine Turkey >90% HA 60
model (Table 1, Fig. 3). Washing machine technolo- North >90% VA 3–4 15–48
America
gies are also changing because horizontal axis Australia >75% VA 20–40
washing machine technology is gaining market shares China >90% VA 1.3–2 Cold water
in almost all markets worldwide. But as most markets South >90% VA Cold water
are already saturated, this is changing the stock of Korea
machines only gradually. Wash habits and practices in Japan >97% VA ∼3 Cold water
different countries of the world vary a lot and only
Sources: de Almeida et al. (2007), Togay (2002), Nakaoka and
little reliable data about actual consumer behavior are Sudarsana (2002), Harrel (2003), DEHWA (2008b), Australian
available. Data on water and electricity consumption Bureau of Statistics (2008), Yang (2006), and Procter & Gamble,
for automatic laundry washing are incomplete and private communication
reliable figures from in-use measurements are hard to HA horizontal axis, VA vertical axis
Energy Efficiency
Fig. 3 Yearly number of

Yearly number of wash cycles per household.


600
wash cycles per household.
Source: Own calculation on 520
the basis of the following 500
sources: Australian Bureau
of Statistics (2008);
Harrel (2003); Nakaoka 400
and Sudarsana
(2002); Rüdenauer and 289
300
Grießhammer (2004); 260
Wang (2006); Yang (2006); 211 208
Procter & Gamble, private 200 165 173
communication
100
100

0
West East Turkey North Australia China South Japan
Europe Europe America Korea

electricity and water consumption of households. This for some countries, the share of water consumption for
shall be done on a country by country basis based on laundry washing could not be calculated and some
available data, but extended to the global picture as figures remain uncertain. These are marked clearly in
good as possible using extrapolations and educated the report.
guesses. Figures for 38 countries, which are 31 European
countries, Australia, Canada, China, Japan, South
Korea, Turkey, and USA are included in our calculation.
Material and methods The results are presented in diagrams assorted by typical
regions which are West Europe, East Europe, Turkey,
While the total electricity and water consumption of North America, Australia, China, South Korea, and
the residential sector is mostly published by the Japan. The most interesting figures are drawn up
National Statistical Office of a country, accurate in- alphabetically by country in Table 2. For several
use data on electricity and water consumption for countries, the same values are shown for, e.g., the
laundry washing by washing machine are often hard number of wash cycles, the electricity consumption per
to obtain. Energy efficiency for washing machines is load, and the water consumption per load. Due to
the focus of many regulations locally or regionally similar wash habits and practices, household sizes,
(European Commission 1995; US Federal Register and washing machine technologies in different
2005; DEWHA 2008a). Within 10 years, improve- countries of the same cultural region, these assump-
ments in electricity and water efficiency of about 30% tions seem to be reasonable. And although quite a
have been revealed in the European horizontal axis few values are identical, the figures of these
technology (European Commission 2005). Today, all countries remain interesting because the total elec-
washing machines sold in Europe belong at least to tricity and water consumption and thus the share for
the energy label category A which is undoubtedly due automatic laundry washing vary. Finally, the results
to the forced energy efficiency policy of the European are given as mean values to make figures compara-
Union. ble but it should always be recognized that real
Therefore, the actual water and electricity consump- consumer behavior is a series of distributions rather
tion per wash cycle depend very much on the age of the than means.
washing machine. Accurate in-use data is not available
for all countries and, due to large differences to actual Number of wash cycles per household
measured consumptions per wash cycle, rated or
regulated values should not be used. In order to fill data The calculation of the electricity and water consump-
gaps, some reasonable assumptions had to be made, but tion for clothes washing by washing machine requests
Energy Efficiency

information about laundry washing habits and practi- Requirements of Energy-Using Products (EuP) have
ces, like the number of wash cycles run per year, the investigated among others the consumer behavior
chosen wash temperature, and the average load size. with washing machines. The data were collected with
Only little data are available concerning the actual an online consumer questionnaire in 10 European
load washed per wash cycle. A recent metering study countries and 4.9 wash cycles per household per week
in 100 German households (Berkholz et al. 2006) (254 per year) were reported (Presutto et al. 2007).
reports rising load sizes per wash cycle with rising The report on the European REMODECE project
household sizes. Within the European project “Resi- states 270 wash cycles per year (de Almeida et al.
dential Monitoring to Decrease Energy Use and 2007). The examples show that the available infor-
Carbon Emissions in Europe” (REMODECE), wash mation sometimes is contradictory. The best guess
habits in about 500 households in five European seems to be the adaption of the number of wash
countries have been observed. The report on the project cycles to the household size. Therefore, the number of
states that the vast majority of the households always wash cycles in our work has been calculated on basis
use the washing machine at over 75% of its capacity of the information published by the German Öko-
(de Almeida et al. 2007). More detailed information Institut as presented in Table 3.
about actual load sizes per wash cycle is given in The information used for the calculation of values
the “Water consumption per household” section. for the non-European countries has been taken from
It can be assumed that the total number of wash regional reports about laundry habits and practices
cycles increase with increasing number of persons (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2008; Harrel 2003;
living in a household, while the number of washes per Nakaoka and Sudarsana 2002; Wang 2006; Yang
person living in the household decreases with rising 2006; Procter & Gamble, private communication).
household sizes. This is supported by Berkholz who The number of wash cycles per household per year
has measured the total electricity consumption for is presented in Fig. 3. Obviously, Australia, Japan,
laundry washing in 100 households for 1 month to be and North America run more wash cycles than
at 1,045.5 kWh and the average consumption per households in Europe. This seems to correlate with
cycle at 0.89 kWh (average load, 5 kg). Extrapolated the frequent use of cold washing programs. But cold
to 1 year, this leads to an annual electricity consump- washes are also widespread in China and South
tion of 125 kWh and 141 wash cycles per household. Korea, and in both countries, the number of wash
The report shows a nearly linear increase of wash cycles per household per year is relatively low. While
cycles in dependence of the household size, with a an explanation for South Korea is still missing, the
distribution of 2.1 washes per week in a single low number of wash cycles in Chinese households is
household up to seven washes per week in a six- due to the frequent manual washing of clothes
person household. although a washing machine is available (Wang
The German Öko-Institut has published 164 wash 2006). The leading country regarding the number of
cycles per year for an average household in the region wash cycles with about 10 loads per week is Japan,
Germany, Austria, and Switzerland with a distribution which is obviously caused by the common use of very
of 111 wash cycles per year for a single household up short and cold washing programs and a relatively low
to 211 wash cycles per year for a four-person house- load size (Nakaoka and Sudarsana 2002). The report
hold (Rüdenauer and Grießhammer 2004). The report “Energy Use in the Australian Residential Sector
suggests accepting these figures for all European 1986–2020” publishes 312 wash cycles per year (six
countries as long as reliable figures from in-use washes per week) for Australian households (DEHWA
measurements are not available. 2008b), while the Australian Bureau of Statistics
In contrast to the above-mentioned figures, other reports that about 75% of Australian households run
sources report much more wash cycles per household, five or less wash cycles per week (Australian Bureau
e.g., Stamminger and Goerdeler published 4.5 washes of Statistics 2008). Due to decreasing household sizes
per week (234 per year) in an average household in and a rising number of horizontal axis machines
Germany, based on an online questioning of more in the Australian market, the estimation of five wash
than 2,000 persons (Stamminger and Goerdeler cycles per week (260 cycles per year) seems to be
2007). The Preparatory Studies for Eco-Design reasonable.
Table 2 Most interesting figures by country

Number of Household Owner Wash Electricity Electricity Electricity Electricity Water Water Water Water
households size ship rate cycles consumption consumption consumption consumption consumption consumption consumption consumption
of per per per wash for clothes for clothes per per wash for clothes for clothes
washing year household cyclea washing per washing in household cycle washing per washing in
machines household relation to total household relation to
per year electricity per year water
consumption consumption
per household per
household
b
Unit ×1,000 % MWh kWhb kWhb %b m3 Lb m3 %b

Austria 3,342.3 2.5 95 164 4.5 0.87 142.7 3.2 107.1 60 9.8 9.2
Australia 8,300.0 2.5 97 260 6.9 0.34 88.4 1.3 247.1 106 27.6 11.2
Belgium 4,408.7 2.4 95 165 3.9 0.92 151.8 3.9 89.8 60 9.9 11.0
Bulgaria 2,992.0 2.7 44 165 2.9 0.97 160.1 5.5 89.6 60 9.9 11.0
Canada 11,562.9 2.6 82 289 13.1 0.43 124.3 1.0 283.0 144 41.6 14.7
China 367,617.0 3.4 61 100 1.2c 0.10 10.0 0.8 167.5d 99 9.9 5.9
Croatia 1,478.0 3.0 65 177 4.1 0.97 171.7 4.2 127.2 60 10.6 8.3
e
Cyprus 248.0 3.0 95 177 5.3 1.35 239.0 4.5
Czech Republic 4,216.1 2.4 60 165 3.5 0.97 160.1 4.6 88.6 60 9.9 11.2
Denmark 2,480.8 2.2 79 165 4.2 0.95 156.8 3.8 102.0 60 9.9 9.7
Estonia 582.0 2.3 78 165 2.8 0.97 160.1 5.7 48.8 60 9.9 20.3
Finland 2,295.5 2.2 89 165 9.2 0.89 146.9 1.6 176.0 60 9.9 5.6
France 24,523.0 2.4 97 165 6.0 0.94 155.1 2.6 139.2 60 9.9 7.1
Germany 39,122.0 2.1 95 164 3.6 0.87 142.7 4.0 100.2 60 9.8 9.8
Greece 3,664.0 3.0 95 177 4.6 1.35 239.0 5.2 47.8 60 10.6 22.2
Hungary 3,863.0 2.6 70 165 2.9 0.97 160.1 5.5 101.0 60 9.9 9.8
Iceland 116.2 2.5 95 165 5.8 1.03 170.0 2.9 258.2 60 9.9 3.8
Energy Efficiency
consumption consumption
per household per
household
b
Unit ×1,000 % MWh kWhb kWhb %b m3 Lb m3 %b

e
Ireland 1,288.0 2.9 95 177 5.8 1.13 200.0 3.4
Italy 23,310.6 2.5 95 165 2.8 1.05 173.3 6.1 226.2 60 9.9 4.4
Japan 48,225.0 2.7 99 520 5.4 0.10 52.0 1.0 339.5 120 62.4 18.4
Korea 13,770.0 3.4 100 208 7.5 0.37 77.0 1.0 573.7 140 29.1 5.1
Energy Efficiency

Latvia 803.0 2.9 65 177 1.8 0.97 171.7 9.5 61.0 60 10.6 17.4
Lithuania 1,357.0 2.5 82 165 1.5 0.97 160.1 10.5 31.7 60 9.9 31.2
Luxembourg 172.0 2.6 95 165 4.4 0.93 153.5 3.5 180.2 60 9.9 5.5
e
Malta 128.0 3.1 82 177 4.8 0.97 171.7 3.6
Netherlands 7,049.0 2.3 98 165 3.3 0.88 145.2 4.4 102.9 60 9.9 9.6
Norway 1,962.5 2.3 89 165 17.0f 1.04 171.6 1.0 152.4 60 9.9 6.5
Poland 13,337.0 2.9 76 177 1.7 0.97 171.7 10.1 96.3 60 10.6 11.0
Portugal 3,651.0 2.9 85 177 3.4 0.89 157.5 4.6 201.0 60 10.6 5.3
Romania 7,320.0 3.0 51 177 1.1 0.97 171.7 15.6 97.5 60 10.6 10.9
e
Slovakia 1,900.0 2.8 60 177 2.5 0.97 171.7 6.9
Slovenia 685.0 2.9 98 177 4.4 0.97 171.7 3.9 129.2 60 10.6 8.2
Spain 14,187.0 3.0 95 165 4.1 0.59 97.4 2.4 193.8 60 9.9 5.1
Sweden 4,576.0 1.9 83 140 9.0 0.95 133.0 1.5 114.9 60 8.4 7.3
Switzerland 3,115.0 2.4 95 165 5.2 0.99 163.4 3.1 201.3 60 9.9 4.9
e
Turkey 16,744.0 4.1 63 211 1.7 1.35 284.9 16.8 60
e
UK 25,564.0 2.3 93 165 4.5 1.14 188.1 4.2
USA 112,000.0 2.6 86 289 11.5 0.43 124.3 1.1 534.3 144 41.6 7.8
a
No external resources considered
b
Own calculation based on published data. All sources are mentioned in the “Material and methods” section
c
Uncertain figure calculated on the basis of the nonofficial information (das Zeitbild) that the electricity consumption of Chinese households is about 10% of the US household
consumption
d
Uncertain figure calculated on basis of total water consumption of the domestic sector in China published by US Department of Commerce, International Trade Administration
2005
e
No data available
f
High electricity consumption reported by Eurostat 2005, by Statistics Norway (2005), and by de Almeida et al. (2007)
Energy Efficiency

Table 3 Number of wash cycles per household per year that more than 70% of wash cycles in Australian
Household size (no. of persons) Number of wash cycles households are cold washes (Australian Bureau of
Statistics 2008; DEHWA 2008b).
<2.2 140 The total electricity consumption per household is
2.2–2.7 165 calculated on the basis of figures about the electricity
>2.7 177 consumption of the residential sector published by the
National Statistic Office of the country and region
Source: Own estimation based on Rüdenauer and Grießhammer (Adato Energia Oy 2006; Eurostat 2006a; OECD
(2004)
2005; STATCAN 2006; Statistics Norway 2005;
Statistics Bureau Japan 2006b; Statistisches Bundesamt
Electricity consumption per household Schweiz 2006; Yang 2006).

In 2002, IBM reported data on the average electricity Water consumption per household
consumption per wash cycle. In 16 European countries,
a representative sample of households was questioned While quite topical data regarding the electricity
about their wash habits and practices focussing on dif- consumption of households have been found, topical
ferent wash temperatures (IBM 2002). The average age or even any reliable data about the water consumption
of washing machines in German households is reported of private households are not available for all countries.
to be at about 7 years (Berkholz et al. 2006). This is The lacking information is due to the fact that, in some
close to the information given in the REMODECE countries like Turkey or China, large parts of the
report that about 50% of washing machines in population are not connected to the public water supply
European households are <5 years old, 30% are or the water consumption per household is not
between 6 and 10 years old, and 20% are older than measured like, e.g., in UK. The total water consump-
10 years (de Almeida et al. 2007). Therefore, it seems tion per household is calculated on the basis of figures
to be fair to use the average electricity consumption per about the water consumption of the residential sector
wash cycle published by IBM in 2002. For some published by the National Statistic Office of the
European countries, mainly the New Member States, country and region (Appendix 2; Eurostat 2006b;
no specific information is available; therefore, an OECD 2005; Yang 2006).
electricity consumption of 0.97 kWh has been calcu- The average water consumption per wash cycle
lated on the basis of the IBM figures (Appendix 1). mainly depends on the washing machine technology.
For the non-European countries, information about Vertical axis machines consume about twice as much
the electricity consumption per wash cycle has been as horizontal machines per wash cycle. Modern
taken from published reports about laundry habits and washing machines with horizontal axis technology
practices (Harrel 2003; Nakaoka and Sudarsana 2002; often have an automatic load sensing function in order
Togay 2002; Wang 2006; Yang 2006; Procter & to reduce water and electricity consumption in
Gamble, private communication). These reports do response to consumer loads that are smaller than the
not provide accurate in-use data but consider different rated capacity. Most vertical axis machines also have
wash programs and water temperatures as well as automatic water level settings or the water level can
different machine technologies and refer to the be set manually by the user. Although until today no
existing stock of washing machines. Data for China systematic assessment of part load performance has
and South Korea could be further improved by been carried out, the availability of the function might
personal contact to experts in these countries. Very lead to the expectation that the actual water consump-
recently, in-use measured data for automatic laundry tion per wash cycle is remarkably lower than the rated
washing in Australia have been published, but as such value provided that the consumer does not use the full
information is not available for all countries in this capacity of the washing machine. In 2006, Berkholz
report, all figures are calculated on the basis of the measured the actual load size of 1,265 wash cycles
number of wash cycles and the electricity consump- (Table 4; Berkholz et al. 2006).
tion per load. The value of 0.34 kWh per wash cycle Obviously, for white and colored clothes with hot
is calculated on the basis of the published information wash programs, the capacity of the washing machine
Energy Efficiency

Table 4 Wash load per wash cycle in different wash programs practices (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2008;
Whites/colored, Easy care, Delicates, DEWHA 2008b; Wang 2006; Harrel 2003; Togay
full capacity full capacity full capacity 2002; Nakaoka and Sudarsana 2002; Yang 2006;
4–6 kg 1.5–3 kg 0.5–2 kg Procter & Gamble, private communication), which
consider different machine technologies and refer to
Less capacity 80 25
used (%)
the existing stock of washing machines but no load sizes
Full capacity 20 53 35 and water level settings are considered either. Data for
used (%) China and South Korea could be further improved by
Overloaded (%) 22 65 personal contact to experts in these countries. It is
known that Japanese washing machines are often filled
Source: Berkholz et al. (2006)
with used water from a bath which contains more or less
residual heat. This very special practice can only be
is not fully used, while the load sizes are quite large for mentioned because no reliable quantification of energy
easy care and delicates which are washed with warm or and water taken from this source is available.
cold water temperatures. This is supported by the
report on the European REMODECE project, which Electricity and water consumption per region
states that the vast majority of the consumers observed
in the project always use the washing machine at over The choice of countries included in our calculations is
75% of its capacity (de Almeida et al. 2007). limited by the available information about wash
A survey on the US laundry market published by habits and practices and also by the availability of
Harrel in 2003 reports water level settings of 3,142 reliable data about the electricity and water consump-
wash cycles in American households. The load diary tion of households, whereas demographic figures like
data shows that more than 50% of the cycles were run the population number, the household size, and the
with large and extra large water level, about 30% of number of households are available from reliable
the washes were done with medium/normal water sources for all countries in this survey. The informa-
level, and only 10% with low water level. The options tion is taken from “Statistisches Jahrbuch für das
extra low and mini-basket were not used at all (Harrel Ausland” (Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland 2006)
2003). These observations do only show consumer and, for Japan, from “Household and Household
behavior in Germany and United States, the behavior Members” (Statistics Bureau Japan 2006a). Taking
in other countries might be different. But obviously, the ownership rate of washing machines into consid-
it is too early to confirm that washing machines eration and multiplying the number of households
frequently use less water than rated due to low wash owning a washing machine with the electricity and
loads or low water level settings. water consumption for automatic laundry washing
Stamminger et al. (2005) published an average shown in Figs. 5 (the “Electricity consumption for
water consumption of 59 L per wash cycle with a automatic laundry washing per household” section)
load size of 5 kg for washing machines built in 2000. and 9 (the “Water consumption for automatic laundry
The German Öko-Institut reports 61 L for washing washing per household” section), the total amount of
machines in stock in 2006 (Rüdenauer et al. 2006). electricity and water consumed for automatic laundry
As reliable in-use measurement data are not available washing by region can be estimated.
up to now and part load performance has not yet been
analyzed, the rated values of water consumption per
wash cycle seem to be the best guess. Therefore, an Results
average consumption per wash cycle of 60 L is
estimated for all European countries in this study Electricity consumption for automatic laundry
without taking the actual average load size and water washing per household
setting level into consideration.
For the non-European countries, the value for the The electricity consumption for laundry washing mainly
water consumption per wash cycle has been taken depends on the average washing temperature. Whether a
from published reports about laundry habits and household washes with low temperatures or primarily
Energy Efficiency

chooses high temperature washing programs depends Although 95% of washing machines in North
on one hand on the technical standard of the washing America are vertical axis machines, the average
machine and energy supply and on the other hand on the washing temperature is reported to be at about 30°C
traditional wash habits and practices in the respective (Harrel 2003), which causes an electricity consump-
region. Figure 4 shows that large differences in the tion of about 0.43 kWh per wash cycle. This might
electricity consumption per wash cycle do exist. include warm water from the tap and thus energy
In North America, Australia, China, South Korea, from external resources which cannot be quantified.
and Japan, the electricity consumption per wash cycle In West and East Europe and Turkey, the state of
is low. In these countries, vertical axis machines are the art is horizontal axis washing machines with inte-
widely spread which use cold water or warm water grated heating rods. Turkish households have the
from the tap which is not heated by the washing highest electricity consumption per wash cycle as they
machine furthermore. Due to the methodical basis of are using high wash temperatures more frequently.
this report, the additional energy used to heat up water Following a study about wash habits and practices in
from external sources is not included. Studies about Turkey (Togay 2002), Turkish households wash more
wash habits and practices in these countries show that than 75% of their laundry at water temperatures higher
wash temperatures are significantly lower than in than 50°C and, out of this, 25% at more than 85°C. In
countries with mainly horizontal axis technology Germany, e.g., the average wash temperature is at 46°C
(DEHWA 2008b; Harrel 2003; Togay 2002; Yang and only 6% of the laundry is done at more than 60°C
2006; Procter & Gamble, private communication). A (Stamminger and Goerdeler 2007).
good cleaning performance needs a minimum amount Based on the number of wash cycles and the
of energy input, which is mechanical work, thermal electricity consumption per wash cycle, the yearly
energy, chemicals, and time. Presuming a constant electricity consumption for laundry washing per house-
cleaning performance, the reduction of one of these hold has been calculated as shown in Fig. 5.
four compounds leads to an increase of the others. In Due to the larger household size and thus higher
countries with low electricity consumption per wash number of wash cycles in East European countries,
cycle, a good cleaning performance is often achieved by the electricity consumption is slightly higher than in
an additional input of chemical and mechanical energy West European countries. The high value for Turkey
outside the washing machine. Pre- and post-treatment is caused by the large household size and frequently
processes which are mostly done manually increase the used high washing temperatures and thus high energy
consumption of water and, when done with warm water, consumption per wash cycle. Very recently, a report
energy as well as the time spent on laundry washing. on energy consumption of the residential sector in

Fig. 4 Electricity consump-


tion per wash cycle. Source: West Europe 0,95
Own calculation on the
basis of the following East Europe 0,97
sources: Harrel (2003); IBM
(2002); Nakaoka and Turkey 1,35
Sudarsana (2002); Togay
(2002); Yang (2006); Wang North America 0,43
(2006); Procter & Gamble,
private communication Australia 0,34

China 0,10

South Korea 0,37

Japan 0,10

0,00 0,20 0,40 0,60 0,80 1,00 1,20 1,40


Electricity consumption per wash cycle in kWh
Energy Efficiency

Fig. 5 Yearly electricity


consumption for laundry West Europe 156,2
washing per household.
Source: Own calculation East Europe 167,8
based on the figures shown 284,9
in Figs. 3 and 4 Turkey

North America 124,3

Australia 88,4

China 10,0

South Korea 77,0

Japan 52,0

0,0 50,0 100,0 150,0 200,0 250,0 300,0


Yearly electricity consumption for laundry washing per household in kWh

Australia has been published which estimates 2.58 PJ our calculation, Turkish households spent more than
of energy for automatic clothes washing in Australia 16% of their expenditures for electricity on laundry
in 2008 (DEWHA 2008b). Converted to kilowatt hour washing.2 But as the ownership rate of washing
per year and household, this fits the calculated machines is only 63% and the total electricity
consumption of 88.4 kWh quite well. consumption refers to all households in Turkey, it
Comparing the electricity consumption for laundry might be that this share is too high. Households in
washing with the total electricity consumption, it gets urban areas who own a washing machine probably
obvious that only a small part of the electricity bill of have higher total electricity consumption than the
private households is caused by the washing machine average value published by Eurostat in 2006. In North
(Fig. 6). America, Australia, and Asia, the share for laundry
An average North American household has the washing is only about 1% of the total electricity bill.
highest total electricity consumption among the The rising market penetration of horizontal axis
countries surveyed and also Korean, Japanese, Aus- machines with integrated heating in these countries
tralian, and West European households consume quite might increase the share for automatic laundry washing
a lot of electricity compared to households in China,1 in the near future, especially in countries where energy
Turkey, and East Europe. The relation between the saving projects will be carried out in order to reduce
total electricity consumption and the electricity con- the total electricity consumption of households.
sumption for laundry washing becomes more expressive
by regarding the shares expressed as a percentage which Water consumption for automatic laundry washing
are presented in Fig. 7. per household
The large difference of the share between West
European (3.8%) and East European (9.2%) house- As well as the electricity consumption for laundry
holds is caused by the much lower total electricity washing, the volume of water consumption is influ-
consumption of East European households. Due to the enced by the technical standard of the washing machine
relatively high electricity consumption for laundry and by the behavior of the user, e.g., the number of wash
washing and a low total electricity consumption of cycles run per week.
only 1.7 MWh per household and year, on basis of
2
The Turkish household size is 4.1 persons, which leads to the
high number of 211 wash cycles. The electricity consumption per
1
Uncertain figure calculated on basis of the nonofficial informa- wash cycle is about 1.35 kWh, which is quite high, and in
tion (das Zeitbild) that the electricity consumption of Chinese contrast, the total electricity consumption is only 1.7 MWh/year.
households is about 10% of the US household consumption. This constellation causes the very high share of 16.8%.
Energy Efficiency

Fig. 6 Yearly electricity


West Europe
consumption for laundry
Electricity consumption for
washing and yearly total East Europe
electricity consumption per laundry washing
household. Source: Own Turkey Total electricity
calculation based on the consumption per household
following sources: total North America
electricity consumption:
Australia
Adato Energia Oy (2006);
Eurostat (2006a); OECD China
(2005); STATCAN (2006);
Statistics Norway (2005); South Korea
Statistics Bureau Japan
(2006b); Statistisches Japan
Bundesamt Schweiz (2006);
Yang (2006); electricity 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
consumption for laundry Yearly electricity consumption for laundry washing and yearly total electricity consumption
washing as per Fig. 5
per household in MWh

Figure 8 shows that European washing machines China consume as little water as European households
use less water per wash cycle than washing machines because of their low number of wash cycles. The high
in America, Australia, and Asia, which is caused by water consumption shown for Japan is caused on one
the fact that, in Europe, only horizontal axis machines hand by the high number of wash cycles and on the
are in use. On the basis of the information that about other hand by the high water consumption of the
75% of washing machines in Australia are vertical vertical axis technology. The amount of 62.4 m3 of
axis machines (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2008; water for laundry washing in Japanese households is
DEWHA 2008b) with more than 120 L water con- probably too high if it is presumed that only potable
sumption per wash cycle and only 25% are horizontal water is used for laundry washing. Japanese house-
axis machines with a consumption of about 60 L holds frequently fill used water from a bath into the
per load, an average consumption of 106 L has been washing machine, which cannot be counted as potable
calculated. water but as water which is used for laundry washing.
Due to the economical water consumption of Concerning the total water consumption of house-
European washing machines, households in Europe holds, large differences between the different coun-
use less water for clothes washing per year than most tries do exist. As shown in Fig. 10, South Korean,
other countries as shown in Fig. 9. Households in North American, and Japanese households consume

Fig. 7 Share of electricity


consumption for clothes West Europe 3,8
washing per household.
East Europe 9,2
Source: Own calculation as
per Fig. 6
Turkey 16,8

North America 1,1

Australia 1,3

China 0,8

South Korea 1,0

Japan 1,0

0,0 2,0 4,0 6,0 8,0 10,0 12,0 14,0 16,0 18,0
Share of electricity consumption for laundry washing in percent
Energy Efficiency
Fig. 8 Water consumption
per wash cycle. Source: West Europe 60
Own calculation on the
basis of the following East Europe 60
sources: Harrel (2003);
Nakaoka and Sudarsana North America 144
(2002); Rüdenauer et al.
Australia 106
(2006); Stamminger et al.
(2005); Togay (2002); Yang
China 99
(2006); Wang (2006);
Procter & Gamble, private
South Korea 140
communication
Japan 120

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160


Water consumption per wash cycle in litre

much more water than European,3 Chinese,4 and to the total electricity and water bill of a single
Australian households. The share of water consump- household can be estimated but also the total amount
tion for laundry washing varies between 5% and 19% of electricity and water consumed for automatic
and depends on the water consumption per wash laundry washing in the regions surveyed in our report.
cycle and on the total water consumption of the Table 5 presents an overview about the total number
household. The volume of water used for laundry of households owning a washing machine and the
washing influences the total water consumption of electricity and water consumption for automatic
households in all countries significantly. laundry washing in the different regions and in total.
The relation between the total water consumption Taking the ownership rate into consideration, this
of households and the water consumption for clothes covers roughly 780,000,000 households with about 2.3
washing becomes more expressive by regarding the billion people living in the regions included in this
shares expressed as a percentage which are presented report, which is about one third of the world population.
in Fig. 11. The rising market share of horizontal axis The global electricity and water consumption of washing
machines in Asia, Australia, and North America is machines may be at maximum twice as high (about 100
expected to increase the electricity consumption for TWh electricity and 20 km3=20,000,000,000 m3 water),
laundry washing, but it will probably reduce the water as in most countries outside of our investigation laundry
consumption for automatic laundry washing notably washing is still done by hand.
in the near future.

Electricity and water consumption for automatic Conclusion


laundry washing by region
Summing up the results, it can be said that huge
With the collected data, not only the contribution of differences regarding electricity and water consumption
resources consumed for automatic laundry washing for automatic laundry washing do exist. Reasons for
these variations are different numbers of wash cycles per
year, different wash temperatures, and different technol-
3
The figures for Europe are incomplete. UK does not provide ogies like horizontal and vertical axis washing machines.
information about water consumption of households because,
The quantification of the electricity and water input
in most buildings, water meters are missing. Ireland, Cyprus,
Malta, and Slovakia could also not be considered, but as weighted is difficult as traditional wash habits and practices
averages are calculated, the influence on the result is not vary a lot. Japanese households, for example, need
significant. more water for laundry washing than any other
4
Uncertain figure calculated on the basis of total water consump-
country, but not only potable water is used and the
tion of the domestic sector in China published by the U.S.
Department of Commerce, International Trade Administration amount of reused water from a bath remains un-
2005. known. European households consume the least
Energy Efficiency

Fig. 9 Yearly water con-


sumption for clothes wash- West Europe 9,9
ing per household. Source:
Own calculation based on the East Europe 10,4
figures shown in Figs. 3
and 8 North America 41,6

Australia 27,6

China 9,9

South Korea 29,1

Japan 62,4

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Yearly water consumption for laundry washing per household in m3

Fig. 10 Yearly water con- Water consumption for laundry


sumption for laundry wash- West Europe
washing per household
ing and yearly total water
consumption per household. East Europe Total water consumption per
Source: Own calculation household
North America
based on the following
sources: total water con- Australia
sumption: Eurostat (2006b);
OECD (2005); Yang (2006); China
water consumption for
laundry washing as South Korea
per Fig. 9
Japan

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700


Yearly water consumption for laundry washing and yearly total water consumption per
household in m3

Fig. 11 Share of water con-


sumption for clothes wash- West Europe 7,8
ing per household. Source:
Own calculation as per East Europe 11,8
Fig. 10
North America 8,4

Australia 11,2

China 5,9

South Korea 5,1


18,4
Japan

0 5 10 15 20
Share of water consumption for laundry washing in percent
Energy Efficiency

Table 5 Electricity and water consumption for automatic pre-treatment) should be considered. A selection of
laundry washing by region
those countries as “world champion” which have the
Region Households Electricity Water lowest consumption is too premature, as it lacks the
owning a consumption consumption information on the achieved washing performance
washing for automatic for automatic and additional resources used for washing processes
machine laundry laundry
(×1,000) washing washing of laundry outside the machine. But there are for sure
(TWh) (km3) plenty of opportunities to learn from each other in
having the laundry process done in a most sustainable
West Europe 155,000 24.2 1.5 way. Energy efficiency and water efficiency gains in
East Europe 25,500 4.3 0.3 Europe show that good policies on energy and water
Turkey 10,500 3.0 0.1 consumption can foster sustainable development.
North America 106,000 13.2 4.3 Large parts of the world map remain unconsidered
Australia 7,500 0.7 0.2 in our report, e.g., South and Middle America, Africa,
China 225,000 2.3 2.2 Russia, India, and Indonesia. Investigations about the
South Korea 14,000 1.1 0.4 electricity and water consumption of the residential
Japan 48,000 2.5 3.0 sectors in these regions are incomplete and informa-
Total 590,000 51.1 12.0 tion about laundry habits and practices is rare. Low
living standards in most of those countries and low
Source: Own calculation based on following sources: Statistisches
ownership rates of washing machines can be assumed
Bundesamt Deutschland (2006) and Statistics Bureau Japan
(2006a, b); electricity and water consumption per household as and thus the contribution of automatic laundry washing
per Figs. 5 and 9 multiplied by the number of households owning to the total electricity and water bill of households is
a washing machine probably low. But in some of those countries, the
accelerated economic development will lead to rising
amount of water for laundry washing due to the living standards and thus to a rising number of washing
horizontal axis technology. Because of the very low machines in private households. Research about
number of machine wash cycles in Chinese house- laundry habits and practices is necessary, especially in
holds, the electricity and water consumption for those countries where a rising stock of washing
automatic laundry washing is low. But, as household machines in private households can be expected, in
saturation with washing machines is low and, even order to form a basis for a sustainable development.
when owning a washing machine, manual washing is The example of laundry washing makes clear that
quite common in China, the overall electricity and research, preferably in-use measurement, is needed in
water consumption for all laundry washing may be a order to improve housework in all household processes.
factor of 3 to 4 higher as estimated here for using Learning about different housework and its influence on
washing machines alone. This may be the case also the energy and water consumption of households in all
for other countries, e.g., South Korea and Japan relevant countries is necessary to understand how
where high levels of pre- and post-treatments of resources are used and can be optimized in private
laundry are reported which take off some of the households. Best practices for doing all kinds of
cleaning process from the washing machine. This housework with minimum amount of resources should
leads to the question of the washing performance be identified and disseminated to help in improving
which is achieved by the washing machine and if this housework habits and practices.
is sufficient for consumer needs. High levels of
washing treatments outside the washing machine Acknowledgement This work was supported by Henkel KGaA,
indicate a low level of washing performance provided Germany.
by these machines. These additional processes con-
sume also relevant amounts of water and energy
which are not considered in this investigation. To Appendix 1: calculation of electricity consumption
provide a complete picture on the resources used for
laundry washing, also the use of detergent (inside the The total electricity consumption, the electricity con-
washing machine, but also for manual washing and sumption for automatic laundry washing, and the share
Energy Efficiency

for automatic laundry washing are calculated by the nwci number of wash cycles per household/country,
following equations. As all results refer to the resource ce/wci electricity consumption per wash cycle per
consumption per household per year, the ownership household/country,
rate of washing machines by country is only a r owner ship rate of washing machines,
component of the equations describing weighted ni number of households per country,
averages. NWE number of households in West Europe.
Total electricity consumption per household:
Et
Ce ¼ ð1Þ
nh Appendix 2: calculation of water consumption

Ce total electricity consumption per household, The total water consumption, the water consumption
Et total electricity consumption of residential sector for laundry washing, and the share for laundry washing
per country, have been calculated by the following equations. All
nh number of households. figures refer to the resource consumption per house-
hold per year; therefore, the ownership rate is only a
Electricity consumption for laundry washing by
component of the equations describing weighted
washing machine per household:
averages.
ce ¼ nwc  ce=wc ð2Þ Total water consumption per household:
Wt
ce electricity consumption for laundry washing by Cw ¼ ð5Þ
nh
washing machine per household,
nwc yearly number of wash cycles per household, Cw total water consumption per household,
ce/wc electricity consumption per wash cycle. Wt total water consumption of residential sector per
The share of electricity consumption for laundry country,
nh number of households.
washing in relation to the total electricity consump-
tion per household: Water consumption for laundry washing by wash-
ce ing machine per household:
ze ¼ ð3Þ
Ce
cw ¼ nw  cw=wc ð6Þ
ze share of electricity consumption for laundry
cw water consumption for laundry washing by
washing by washing machine,
ce electricity consumption for laundry washing by washing machine,
nw yearly number of wash cycles per household,
washing machine per household/country,
Ce cw/wc water consumption per wash cycle.
total electricity consumption per household/
country.
Water consumption for laundry washing by wash-
Aggregated figures for West Europe, East Europe, ing machine in relation to the total water consumption
and North America are calculated as weighted averages: per household:
Example: electricity consumption for laundry wash-
cw
ing by washing machine in West Europe: zw ¼ ð7Þ
Cw
P
20
nwci  ce=wci  r  ni
i¼1
ceWE ¼ ð4Þ zw share of water consumption for laundry washing
NWE
by washing machine,
ceWE average electricity consumption for laundry cw water consumption for laundry washing by
washing by washing machine per household in washing machine per household/country,
West European countries, Cw total water consumption per household/country.
Energy Efficiency

Aggregated figures for West Europe, East Europe, IBM. (2002). AISE code of good environmental practice: Final
and North America are calculated as weighted averages: report to the European Commission 1996–2001. Brussels:
IBM.
Example: water consumption for laundry washing Nakaoka, K., & Sudarsana, B. S. (2002). Laundry in Japan.
by washing machine in West Europe: Procter & Gamble communication to IEC SC59D working
groups (private communication).
P
20
Presutto, M., et al. (2007). Preparatory studies for eco-design
nwci  cw=wci  r  ni requirements of EuP's (Tender TREN/D1/40-2005) LOT
i¼1
cwWE ¼ ð8Þ 14, task 3: Washing machines. Retrieved from http://www.
NWE ecowet-domestic.org.
Rüdenauer, I., & Grießhammer, R. (2004). Produkt-Nachhaltig-
cwWE average water consumption for laundry keitsanalyse von Waschmaschinen und Waschprozessen.
washing by washing machine per household Freiburg: PROSA Waschmaschinen.
Rüdenauer, I., et al. (2006). Ökobilanz und Lebenszykluskos-
in West European countries, tenrechnung Wäschewaschen. Vergleich des Waschens bei
nwci number of wash cycles per household/ durchschnittlichen Waschtemperaturen mit Waschen bei
country, niedrigeren Waschtemperaturen. Freiburg: Öko-Institut.
cw/wci water consumption per wash cycle per Stamminger, R., et al. (2005). Old washing machines wash less
efficiently and consume more resources. In: Hauswirtschaft
household/country, und Wissenschaft 3/2005
r owner ship rate of washing machines Stamminger, R., & Goerdeler, G. (2007). Aktionstag Nachhaltiges
ni number of households per country, Waschen—Was macht der Verbraucher? In: SÖFW-Journal
NWE number of households in West Europe. 1/2-2007
Togay, M. (2002). Laundry in CEEMEA. Procter & Gamble
communication to IEC SC59D working groups (private
communication)
US Federal Register (2005). Retrieved January 2008, from http://
frwebgate6.access.gpo.gov/cgi-bin/TEXTgate.cgi?WAISdoc
ID=659635452204+20+1+0&WAISaction=retrieve.
References Wäschereiforschung Krefeld. Retrieved December 2006, from
http://www.wfk.de.
Australian Bureau of Statistics. (2008). Environmental issues: Wang, A. H. (2006). Dr. Alexander H. Wang, Haier Group
Energy use and conservation. Canberra: Australian Bureau Corporation, Qingdao, China (private communication)
of Statistics. Yang, H. (2006). The total energy and water consumption of
Berkholz, P., Stamminger, R., Kruschwitz, A., & Brückner, A. washing machines in Korea. Samsung Electronics (private
(2006). Definition und Ermittlung verhaltensabhängiger communication)
Energiesparpotentiale beim Betrieb elektrischer Haushalts- ZVEI. (2005). Market saturation in Germany in percentage of
waschmaschinen. Bonn. households. Nürnberg: Zentralverband der Elektrotechnik
de Almeida, A., et al. (2007). Residential monitoring to decrease Industrie.
energy use and carbon emissions in Europe. Portugal: ISR-
University of Coimbra, Dep. Electrical Engineering.
DEWHA. (2008a). Equipment energy efficiency program. Aus-
tralia: Department of the Environment, Water, Heritage and Further readings
the Arts.
DEWHA. (2008b). Energy use in the residential sector 1986– Bertoldi, P. (1997). Energy efficiency in household appliances.
2020. Australia: Department of the Environment, Water, Proceedings of the First International Conference on Energy
Heritage and the Arts. Efficiency in Household Appliances. Florence, Italy.
European Commission. (1995). Commission Directive 95/12/EC
of 23 May 1995 implementing Council Directive 92/75/EEC
with regard to energy labelling of household washing
machines.
National Statistics
European Commission. (2005). EuP Studies for Eco-Design
Requirements of EuP's (Tender TREN/D1/40-2005). Re-
trieved from http://www.ecowet-domestic.org/. Adato Energia Oy. (2006). Electricity consumption, statistical
GIFAM. (2005). Le marché franςais des produits. Retrieved yearbook 2006. Helsinki: Adato Energia Oy.
October 27, 2006, from http://www.gifam.fr/pages/ Eurostat (2005). Europe in figures. Yearbook.
lemarché/chriffrescles/gam-lavage-2005-2.html. Eurostat (2006a). Table nrg 105a energy. Retrieved November 2006,
Harrel, C. W. (2003). The US Laundry Market. IEC SC 59D from http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/tgm/table.do?tab=ta-
WG Meeting, Gaithersburg, Oct 13, Procter & Gamble ble&init=1&language=de&pcode=ten00101&plugin=1.
communication to IEC SC59D working groups (private Eurostat (2006b). Table env_watq3 water. Retrieved November
communication). 2006, from http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/tgm/table.
Energy Efficiency

do?tab=table&init=1&language=de&pcode=ten00014& Statistisches Bundesamt Schweiz (2006). Statistisches Jahrbuch


plugin=1. 2006. Neuchâtel.
Retrieved November 2006, from Yearlies_new_environment_ Statistics Bureau Japan. (2006a). Household and household
energy&depth=4 members. Retrieved November 3, 2006, from http://www.
OECD Environmental Data 2004—Compendium 2004, OECD stat.go/jp/english/data/handbook/c02cont.html.
2005 Statistics Bureau Japan. (2006b). Final energy consumption.
STATCAN (2006). Energy supply and demand by fuel type. Retrieved November 3, 2006, from http://www.stat.go/jp/
Retrieved November 2006, from http//www40.statcan.ca/ english/data/handbook/c02cont.html.
101/cst01/prim72.htm. Statistics Norway. (2005). Statistical yearbook of Norway 2005.
Statistisches Bundesamt Deutschland (2006). Statistisches Retrieved October 23, 2006, from http://www.ssb.no/
Jahrbuch für das Ausland. Berlin. english/yearbook/tab/tab-061.html.

You might also like