Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Wei Fan1, Dan-dan Li2, Jia-lu Li2, Juan-zi Li1, Lin-jia Yuan1,
Li-li Xue1, Run-jun Sun1 and Jia-guang Meng1
Abstract
To investigate the reinforcement architectures effect on the electromagnetic wave properties of carbon fiber reinforced
polymer composites, three-dimensional (3D) interlock woven fabric/epoxy composites, 3D interlock woven fabric with
stuffer warp/epoxy composites, and 3D orthogonal woven fabric/epoxy composites were studied by the free-space
measurement system. The results showed that the three types of 3D woven carbon fiber fabric/epoxy composites had a
slight difference in electromagnetic wave properties and the absorption was their dominant radar absorption mechanism.
The electromagnetic wave absorption properties of the three types of composites were more than 90% (below 10 dB)
over the 11.2–18 GHz bandwidth, and more than 60% (below 4 dB) over the 8–12 GHz bandwidth. Compared with
unidirectional carbon fiber reinforced plastics, the three kinds of 3D woven carbon fiber fabric/epoxy composites
exhibited better electromagnetic wave absorption properties over a broadband frequency range of 8–18 GHz.
Therefore, the three kinds of 3D woven composite are expected to be used as radar absorption structures due to
their excellent mechanical properties and outstanding absorption capacity. The total electromagnetic interference
shielding effectiveness of the three types of 3D carbon fiber woven composites are all larger than 46 dB over the 8–
12 GHz bandwidth, which is evidence that the three types of 3D carbon fiber woven composites can be used as excellent
shielding materials for electromagnetic interference.
Keywords
electromagnetic property, three-dimensional woven composite, reinforcement architecture, free-space method
With the rapid development of the detection power of designing aerospace vehicles. Although the external
today’s radar installation, weapon systems, such as profile might be desirable for stealth considerations, it
fighters, warships and missiles, are under severe may not be acceptable for aerospace vehicle designers.4
threat.1,2 Therefore, stealth technologies for evading RAMs can be achieved by both absorption and
radar detection have attracted considerable attention redirection of incident EM energy, so the development
in many countries in recent years.3 At present, there and application of RAMs has become one of the key
are several techniques to evade radar detection, which factors for the development of stealth technology.5
are broadly classified into two categories: shaping RAMs can be classified into two categories according
of the target and radar absorption materials (RAMs).2
Shaping involves modifying the external features of
the target to reduce the electromagnetic (EM) waves 1
School of Textile and Material, Xi’an Polytechnic University, China
2
backscattered to the direction of the radar source and Ministry of Education Key Laboratory of Advanced Textile Composites,
to redirect them. However, reduction is achieved only Tianjin Polytechnic University, China
in a limited angular region at the expense of an increase
Corresponding author:
in the radar cross-section in other regions. Besides, it is Jia-lu Li, Tinjin Ploytechnic University, No. 399 Binshui West Road, Tianjin
effective only at higher frequencies and frequently con- 300387, China.
flicts with structural and aerodynamics requirements in Email: lijialu@tjpu.edu.cn
2 Textile Research Journal 0(00)
to the molding process and carrying capacity: coating Manufacturing and experimental
on the target and radar absorption structures (RASs). procedures
Coatings or paints have the advantage of low cost and a
Materials
simple process. However, they make the aircrafts
thicker and heavier. Besides, coated absorbing mater- Commercially available raw materials were used in this
ials cannot be used in the wide band of frequencies and study. The T300-3 K, T300-6 K, and T700-12 K carbon
have poor environmental endurance and poor mechan- fibers were supplied by Toray, Japan. The epoxy resin
ical properties. Therefore, coated absorbing materials TDE-86, the hardener PA (tetra hydro phthalic anhyd-
cannot be used for structural purposes.4,6 By contrast, ride), and the accelerant aniline used in the experiment
RASs have the functions of both load-bearing and EM were from Tianjin Resin Plant, China.
energy absorption, and they does not interfere with the
external profiles set by the aircraft designers. Therefore,
Sample preparation
RASs have acquired much attention of scientists in the
field.7–10 We chose three typical 3D woven fabrics (3D interlock
For RASs, the mechanical properties and absorption woven fabric, 3D interlock woven fabric with stuffer
capacity should be considered simultaneously. It is well warp, and 3D orthogonal woven fabric) as the
known that the mechanical properties of carbon fiber reinforcement architectures in this study. The sketch
reinforced polymer composites are excellent, and diagrams of the three fabric structures are shown in
carbon fiber (in continuous or discontinuous forms) Figure 1 to illustrate the specific preform structures.
as electric loss RAMs can absorb some EM waves, in The 3D sheet fabrics with the size of 400 mm
theory.11 In fact, carbon fiber is a strong reflector of (length) 200 mm (width) 4 mm (thickness) were
EM waves due to its high graphitization degree.11–14 To made on the 3D weaving equipment in the Institute
meet the need of RASs, some people added EM for Composite Materials of Tianjin Polytechnic
powders, such as carbon black,10 ferrite,7,15,16 carbon University, China. The matrix was prepared through
nanotubes,17–19 etc., into the matrix of composites, and mixing TDE-86 epoxy resin, methyl tetrahydrophthalic
others changed the machining parameters, the volume anhydride (hardener), and dimethyl benzylamine
fraction of fibers, the processing parameters, and (accelerant) by a weight ratio of 100:85:1, and then
fiber orientation to improve the EM absorption cap- using the RTM (resin transfer molding) process to
acity.14,20,21 To date, however, no studies have focused make the composites. The process involved cutting
on the reinforcement architectures of the EM absorp- the large 3D sheet fabric into testing samples size
tion properties of carbon fiber reinforced polymer (380 mm 180 mm 4 mm) and placing it into the
composites. mold, closing the mold, checking it for leaks, and heat-
Three-dimensional (3D) woven composites can offer ing them to 90 C. Once the mold and the pipeworks
increased resistance to delamination and have the abil- connected to the mold were sufficiently heated, a
ity to contain (localize) the area of damage due to the vacuum of approximately 0.45 MPa was applied to
addition of yarns, known as binders, which interlace the pipeworks, the mold and the resin trap were
through the fabric thickness.22–24 The carbon fiber in allowed to stabilize for 5 min, and then the resin was
the thickness direction of composites can enhance the injected into the mold. The injection process was con-
microwave absorbing properties.11 tinued until a sufficient volume of resin was seen in the
Besides, 3D woven composites can be mass- resin trap, to indicate that the mold had been com-
produced at low cost using automated manufacturing pletely filled with resin. The mold was isolated from
techniques, making them viable in a wide spectrum of the resin pot and the resin trap and then put into an
industrial sectors.23,25 Therefore, in this study, the EM air-circulating oven. The manufacturer recommended
properties of three representative 3D carbon fiber cure cycle was employed27: the first step of the cure
woven fabrics (3D interlock woven fabric, 3D interlock cycle was 2 h at 110 C, with the second step being 2 h
woven fabric with stuffer warp, and 3D orthogonal at 130 C, the third step being 1 h at 150 C, the
woven fabric) reinforced epoxy composites were inves- fourth step being 8 h at 160 C, and the final step
tigated. As the free-space method is known as an ade- being 3 h at 180 C. After curing, ultrasonic C-scans
quate method for measuring anisotropic and (USPC 3040 DAC c-scan system) were performed to
inhomogeneous materials, such as composites,26 the ensure that the samples we selected were free of voids
EM properties of the 3D carbon fiber fabric/epoxy errors. The carbon fiber volume fraction of the three
composites over the 8–18 GHz bandwidth were tested types of 3D woven composites was calculated by the
by the free-space method in this study. A light micro- weighting method.27 The structural parameters of the
scope was used to reveal the structure of the 3D interlock woven fabric/epoxy composites
composites. (3DIWC), 3D interlock woven fabric with stuffer
Fan et al. 3
Figure 1. The structures schematic of three-dimensional (3D) interlock woven fabric (a), 3D interlock woven fabric with stuffer
warp (b), and 3D orthogonal woven fabric (c).
Table 1. Structural parameters of the three-dimensional (3D) interlock woven fabric/epoxy composites (3DIWC), 3D interlock
woven fabric with stuffer warp/epoxy composites (3DISWC), and 3D orthogonal woven fabric/epoxy composites (3DOWC)
3DIWC – 6 6 – 5 8 6 46.3
3DISWC 12 6 3 3 5 3 6 46.2
3DOWC 12 12 3 3 3 3 6 46.5
Characterization methods
A free-space measurement system was used to evaluate
the broadband EM characteristics of the 3D woven
composites studied in this paper. The free-space meas-
urement system was composed of two horn antennas
(transmit and receive antennas) for a broadband fre-
quency range of 8–18GHz, a sample holder, a data
Figure 2. Schematic configuration of the free-space measure-
acquisition system, and a vector network analyzer ment system for characterization of the electromagnetic prop-
(Agilent Technologies, ZNB40). The network analyzer erties of materials.
consisted of a synthesized sweeper and a scattering par-
ameter (S-parameter) test set. The S-parameter test set
in the network analyzer was linked to the broadband
horn antennas through precision coaxial cables and cir- parameter (S12) with the free-space measurement
cular-to-rectangular waveguide adapters. A schematic system. The EM wave perpendicularly struck the com-
of the experimental setup is shown in Figure 2. The two posite surface and the E field was parallel to the weft
identical horn antennas were mounted 80 cm apart. The direction of the composites.
composite under test was mounted in the central plane The measurement system was calibrated for reflec-
of the two antennas on a low loss polystyrene block. tion and transmission with an electronic calibration
The test sample was illuminated with a polarized EM module (ZV-Z54 10 MHz–40 GHz). The vector net-
wave at normal incidence and the reflection and trans- work analyzer calibration process is shown in
mission were investigated by measuring the reflection Figure 3. After calibration, the S-parameter of the com-
scattering parameter (S11) and transmission scattering posite samples can be tested according to the GJB
4 Textile Research Journal 0(00)
Figure 5. Power balance in the X-band and Ku-band frequency range for three-dimensional (3D) interlock woven fabric/epoxy
composites (a), 3D interlock woven fabric with stuffer warp/epoxy composites (b), and 3D orthogonal woven fabric/epoxy com-
posites (c) as a function of frequency.
3DOWC. The carbon fibers in the vertical-arranged modified graphite and polyvinylidene fluoride. J Mater
manner in the 3D composites could be formed into Chem A 2013; 1: 7031–7036.
resin ducts along the z-yarns, so the transmitted 4. Seo IS, Chin WS and Lee DG. Characterization of elec-
power of the 3DOWC was larger than that of the tromagnetic properties of polymeric composite materials
with free space method. Compos Struct 2004; 66: 533–542.
3DISWC.
5. Kim PC and Lee DG. Composite sandwich constructions
The 3DIWC, 3DISWC, and 3DOWC not only had for absorbing the electromagnetic waves. Compos Struct
good EM wave absorbability but also excellent mech- 2009; 87: 161–167.
anical properties; hence, they can be used as a RAS in a 6. Lozano-Castelló D, Raymundo-Piñero E, Cazorla-
weapon system, such as for fighters, warships, and mis- Amorós D, et al. Characterization of pore distribution
siles. Besides, 99.99% of incident radiation is blocked in activated carbon fibers by microbeam small angle
by the 3D carbon fiber woven composite over the X-ray scattering. Carbon 2002; 40: 2727–2735.
8–12 GHz bandwidth, which is evidence that the three 7. Liu PB and Huang Y. Synthesis of reduced graphene
types of 3D carbon fiber woven composites can be used oxide-conducting polymers-Co3O4 composites and their
as excellent shielding materials for EM interference. excellent microwave absorption properties. RSC
These 3D woven structures provide an easy and effect- Advances 2013; 3: 19033–19039.
8. Li CL, Jiang DZ, Zeng JC, et al. The use of cutting
ive way to design and improve the EM wave absorb-
carbon fiber fabric/epoxy composites as band-pass fre-
ability of carbon fiber reinforced polymer composites.
quency selective surfaces. J Compos Mater 2014; 48:
However, we need to further adjust the structure par- 2281–2288.
ameter of reinforcement to make the 3D woven struc- 9. Lee W-J, Lee J-W and Kim C-G. Characteristics of an
tures absorb 90% EM energy over the entire frequency electromagnetic wave absorbing composite structure with
range of radar. Only then can they be the material of a conducting polymer electromagnetic bandgap (EBG) in
choice for military applications. the X-band. Compos Sci Technol 2008; 68: 2485–2489.
10. Chin WS and Lee DG. Development of the composite
Declaration of conflicting interests RAS (radar absorbing structure) for the X-band fre-
quency range. Compos Struct 2007; 77: 457–465.
The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest with 11. Zhao NQ, Zou TC, Shi CS, et al. Microwave absorbing
respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this properties of activated carbon-fiber felt screens (vertical-
article. arranged carbon fibers)/epoxy resin composites. Mater
Sci Eng B 2006; 127: 207–211.
Funding 12. Liu X, Wu ZJ, Wang RG, et al. Experimental study of
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial sup- the electrical resistivity of glass-carbon/epoxy hybrid
port for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this composites. Polym Polym Compos 2014; 22: 289–292.
article: This work was supported by the National Natural 13. Lee SE, Oh KS and Kim CG. Electromagnetic character-
Science Foundation of China (Grant No:51603163), the istics of frequency selective fabric composites. Electron
Science and Technology Project of Shaanxi, China (Grant Lett 2006; 42: 439–441.
No:2017JQ5056), the Science and Technology Project of the 14. Galehdar A, Nicholson KJ, Callus PJ, et al. The strong
China Textile Industry Association (Grant No:2016050), the diamagnetic behaviour of unidirectional carbon fiber
Science and Technology Project of Shaanxi Education reinforced polymer laminates. J Appl Phys 2012; 112:
Department, China (Grant No:16JK1343), the Young 113921-1–113921-6.
Talent Foundation of the University Association for 15. Yang Y, Guo Z, Zhang H, et al. Electrospun magnetic
Science and Technology in Shaanxi, China (Grant carbon composite fibers: synthesis and electromagnetic
No:20160123), the Sanqin Scholar Foundation of Shaanxi wave absorption characteristics. J Appl Polym Sci 2013;
Province, China, the Doctoral Program of Xi’an 127: 4288–4295.
Polytechnic University, China (Grant No:BS1514), and the 16. Tong SY, Tung MJ, Ko WS, et al. Effect of Ni fillers on
Cooperative Innovational Center for Technical Textiles, microwave absorption and effective permeability of
Shaanxi Province, China (Grant No:2015ZX-02). NiCuZn ferrite/Ni/polymer functional composites.
J Alloy Compd 2013; 550: 39–45.
17. Hou CL, Li TH, Zhao TK, et al. Electromagnetic wave
References absorbing properties of carbon nanotubes doped rare
1. Shah A, Ding A, Wang YH, et al. Enhanced microwave metal/pure carbon nanotubes double-layer polymer com-
absorption by arrayed carbon fibers and gradient disper- posites. Mater Des 2012; 33: 413–418.
sion of Fe nanoparticles in epoxy resin composites. Carbon 18. De Rosa IM, Dinescu A, Sarasini F, et al. Effect of short
2016; 96: 987–997. carbon fibers and MWCNTs on microwave absorbing
2. Choi I, Kim JG, Lee DG, et al. Aramid/epoxy composites properties of polyester composites containing nickel-
sandwich structures for low-observable radomes. Compos coated carbon fibers. Compos Sci Technol 2010; 70:
Sci Technol 2011; 71: 1632–1638. 102–109.
3. Wang GS, Zhang XJ, Wei YZ, et al. Polymer composites 19. Hou CL, Li TH, Zhao TK, et al. Microwave absorption
with enhanced wave absorption properties based on properties of rare metal-doped multi-walled carbon
Fan et al. 9
nanotube/polyvinyl chloride composites. J Reinforced 25. Zhang Y, Sun F, Wang Y, et al. Study on intra/inter-ply
Plast Compos 2012; 31: 1526–1531. shear deformation of three dimensional woven preforms
20. Wang DY, Song YC and Jian K. Effect of compos- for composite materials. Mater Des 2013; 49: 151–159.
ition and structure on the specific resistivity of continu- 26. Lee S-E, Park K-Y, Oh K-S, et al. The use of carbon/
ous silicon carbide fibers. J Inorg Mater 2012; 27: dielectric fiber woven fabrics as filters for electromagnetic
162–168. radiation. Carbon 2009; 47: 1896–1904.
21. Kim HG, Shin HJ, Kim G-C, et al. Electromagnetic 27. Qi YX, Li JL and Liu LS. Tensile properties of multi-
interference shielding characteristics for orientation layer-connected biaxial weft knitted fabric reinforced
angle and number of plies of carbon fiber reinforced plas- composites for carbon fibers. Mater Des 2014; 54:
tic. Carbon Lett 2014; 15: 268–276. 678–685.
22. Stig F and Hallstrom S. Influence of crimp on 3D-woven 28. Nayak L, Khastgir D and Chaki TK. A mechanistic
fibre reinforced composites. Compos Struct 2013; 95: study on electromagnetic shielding effectiveness of poly-
114–122. sulfone/carbon nanofibers nanocomposites. J Mater Sci
23. Zhang DY, Waas AM and Yen CF. Progressive damage 2013; 48: 1492–1502.
and failure response of hybrid 3D textile composites sub- 29. Xin L, Rongguo W, Wenbo L, et al. Microwave absorb-
jected to flexural loading, part I: experimental studies. Int ing properties of composites reinforced by irregular car-
Solids Struct 2015; 75–76: 309–320. bon fiber. Acta Materiae Compositae Sinica 2009; 26:
24. Mahadik Y and Hallett SR. Finite element modelling of 94–100.
tow geometry in 3D woven fabrics. Compos Part A 2010; 30. Stonier RA. Stealth aircraft &technology from World
41: 1192–1200. War II to the gulf. Sampe J 1991; 27: 9–18.