You are on page 1of 138

MemoSc

ape
s
Romani
anJ
our
nalofMemor
yandI
dent
it
ySt
udi
es

Vol
.2/No.2/May2018
I
SSN:2558-
8567

Const
ructi
ngt heSocial
(
andIndividual)World:
Myth,Memor y,
andIdent i
ty

Publ
ishe
dbyCSMI
www.
studi
i-
memor
ial
e.r
o
5/1/2018
MemoScapes.
Romanian Journal
of Memory and
Identity Studies

Constructing the Social


(and Individual) World:
Myth, Memory, Identity
Issue 2, No. 2
Editor’s Introduction modulated by a drive to manufacture
ideological unity. It may play an important
part in legitimising new political regimes
and delegitimizing old ones.
The notion of ‘myth’ covers a wide
Myth is a fictional construct, such as
array of meanings and interpretations. A
a narrative or an idea, which puts forth social
sociologist, an anthropologist, a historian, a
and historical explanations that serve the
political scientist, etc. define and understand
needs of the community by building social
this concept in very different ways. Even
consensus3. The crucial point of this
within the boundaries of the same discipline,
definition is that myths are fundamentally
definitions vary from one scholar to another.
rooted in values shared broadly across
Myth, in a narrow sense, represents a
society. It follows from this that myth is not
discursive mode with explicative role, which
simply a matter of truth or falsity. Rather,
defines the fundamental semiological axes of
myths define the aspirations and projects of
a given mythology1. In a broader sense, the
a community and can offer a basis for social
myth may be considered to be an imaginary
mobilisation.
construct which attempts to distil the essence
of cosmic and social phenomena depending
***
on the values of a community, with the aim
of ensuring a certain degree of cohesion
In our long journey through history,
within that particular group. It offers
myths have always been with us. They
individuals and society at large direct access
flourished in ancient Greece as works of
to an interpretative system and a
fiction being later contrasted with logos by
behavioural model2.
the Christians. The Enlightenment seemed to
Myths can be defined as discursive
spell myth’s doom. But even relegated to
practices closely connected to the identity
‘untruth’ status, myth remained important
and memory of a community. Myth may be
in the debates that shaped the ideals of
the result of the perpetual tug-of-war
critical thinking and rationalism.
between remembrance and oblivion, and its
Myths entered a new life once
purpose is generally that of emphasizing the
scientific anthropology was set on firm
shared values of a community. One defining
grounds. Claude Lévi-Strauss defined myth
character of myth is its ability to cut through
as universal – something that can be grasped
the ages while accumulating new meanings,
by people across the world4. Mircea Eliade
transforming and evolving depending on
described myth as narrating an event that
times, situations or places.
took place at the beginning of historical time
Myths represent a key component of
that might explain how a significant element
the social imaginary and are often invoked –
of the world – an island, a plant species, a
and created – in the process of elaborating an
human custom, or an institution – came into
explanatory scheme of national history.
being trough the agency of supernatural
Myth has a powerful simplifying role and is
entities5. Eliade insisted that each time a

1 Dubois (1998), 28. 4 Lévi-Strauss (1958), 232.


2 Boia (1998), 40-41. 5 Eliade (1963), 15.
3 Boia (1998), 39.

I
myth is told, the sacred time of the events model of social conduct10. They build
narrated in the myth is, in a sense, brought creatively on a narrative core so as to meet
back to life6. The act of narrating the myth the demands for making sense of the world,
and thereby ritually re-enacting it has the and buttressing social identities11. They
effect of suspending historical time and provide communities and individuals with
enabling the individual to transcend time interpretive schemes for making sense of
and space7. their microcosm12.
Myths occupied a well-defined place Among the roles filled by myths in
in the life of traditional societies, as modern and postmodern society a few are
anthropologists have shown. By contrast, worth highlighting: as tools for self-
modern societies have banished mythical definition and identity transfer, as agents of
thought as a matter of principle, but proved social cohesion, as vehicles for the
unable to do away with myths completely. transmission of cultural and ideological
Cornelius Castoriadis pointed out that no values, and as legitimizing narratives for
society can survive without symbolic various political movements and regimes13.
constructs that can give meaning to its social Myths truly come to life when they
life. For Castoriadis, Western society, are rooted in a shared collective memory.
modern and postmodern, seems to exhibit to This shared memory of historical events and
an even greater degree the work of the social characters might even be viewed as a
imaginary, at once instituted and instituting precondition for the successful transmission
(that is to say, itself structured by existing and implantation of myths. This living
historical factors while at the same memory of places, characters, and events
structuring the emergence of novel practices plays the key role in the genesis, diffusion,
and ideas)8. Even in the guise of ideological and persistence of myths. Doubtless political
and nationalist narratives, myths preserve and cultural myths are imagined constructs,
their status as fundamental beliefs that can but they start (in most cases) from real
confer meaning upon the imagined destiny historical facts which are reworked and fed
of the community. into a discourse aimed at building social
Scholars have found that the myths of cohesion.
our contemporary world are not Political and national myths are
fundamentally different from the myths of closely tied to the processes of historical
traditional societies. Their content is equally remembrance and historical amnesia, which
fluid, their contours are similarly are vital in the life of any community14.
ambiguous, and they display the same
openness to different cultural influences9. As ***
an integral part of the social imaginary,
political, national, and identity myths give The articles collected in the current
access to a system of interpretation and a issue of MemoScapes. Romanian Journal of

6 Eliade (1994), 70-71. 11 Bottici, Challand (2013), 91.


7 Eliade (1963), 18. 12 Boia (1998).
8 Castoriadis (1975), 174-248. 13 Schöpflin (1997), 22-26.

9 Girardet (1997), 6. 14 Nora (1984), XV-XXIV.

10 Boia (1998), 40-41.

II
Memory and Identity Studies, provide a fresh Castoriadis, C. 1975. L’institution
perspective on various topics related to imaginaire de la société. Paris: Seuil.
myth, memory and identity. The majority of Schöpflin, G. 1997. ‘The functions of
these essays investigate the construction, myths and a taxonomy of myths’, in G.
cultural significance, and socio-political Hosking, G. Schöpflin (eds.). 1997. Myths and
functions of an array of European political Nationhood. New York, London : Routledge.
and cultural myths in the last century. Boia, L. 1998. Pour une histoire de
These contributions analyse the l’imaginaire. Paris: Les Belles Lettres.
complex process whereby myths became Eliade, M. 1963. Aspects du mythe.
part of the cultural memory of a society, as Paris: Gallimard.
well as the role of myths in the political and Eliade, M. 1994. Imagini și simboluri
social life of the region. They focus on a (Images and Symbols). Bucharest:
number of case studies illustrating the Humanitas.
problematic interplay between memory and Nora, P. 1984. Les lieux de memoire.
myths in creating national/local identities. Paris: Gallimard, vol. 1.
They show that myths were often Girardet, R. 1997. Mituri şi mitologii
instrumental in the vast projects of social and politice (Myths and Political Mythologies).
political mobilisation as well as in Iași: Institutul European.
transmitting new ideas and in changing
dominant paradigms.
The articles gathered in this issue CLAUDIA-FLORENTINA DOBRE
emphasize the heuristic value of myths, as
well as their importance in constructing and
deconstructing broad historical, cultural, Claudia-Florentina Dobre has a Ph.D. in History
social or narrative paradigms. They have an from Laval University, Québec. She is the
immediate contribution to the director of the Centre for Memory and Identity
understanding of the imaginary universe in Studies (CSMI) and an associate researcher at
‘Nicolae Iorga’ History Institute of Bucharest.
which communities, societies, nations and
Most recent publications: Claudia-Florentina
even individuals operate at different times
Dobre, Cristian-Emilian Ghiță (eds.). 2017. Quest
and in different cultural areas. for a Suitable Past: Myth and Memory in Eastern and
Central Europe. Budapest-New York: CEU Press;
References: Claudia-Florentina Dobre, Valeriu Antonovici
(eds.). 2016. Prezentul comunismului: memorie
Bottici, Ch., B. Challand. 2013. culturală şi abordări istoriografice (Communism
Imagining Europe. Myth, Memory, Identity. into Present: Cultural Memory and
Historiographical Approaches). Oradea: Ratio et
New York: Cambridge University Press.
Revelatio.
Dubois, Cl. G. 1998. ‘Introduction; II.
Les modes de classification des mythes’, in J.
Thomas (ed.). 1998. Introduction aux
méthodologies de l’imaginaire. Paris: Ellipses.
Lévi-Strauss, Cl. 1958. Anthropologie
structurale. Paris : Plon.

III
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

LUCIAN BOIA

Oldness, Unity and Continuity: Romanian Historical Mythology

Abstract:
Contemporary Romania is unitary, as the patriots who brought about the Unions of 1859 and 1918 desired.
This was the result of a historical process of gradual rapprochement of the various components of the
Romanian people and the creation of a common culture, based on a language which is clearly unitary, the
Romanian language. Post-communist Romania inherited to a large extent the national-communist
ideology. ‘Oldness’, ‘unity’, and ‘continuity’, this historiographic triptych which had become the dogma of
Communist times seems to have grown deep roots, both among professional historians and among the
wider public. This mythology of historical unity and continuity was and still is an obstacle to historical
research, often distorting it.

Keywords: Oldness, Unity, Continuity, Romanian Historical Mythology, Historians, Historical Figures

had been a part of the Hungarian kingdom


Introduction: The Creation of Greater since around 1000; later, they were
incorporated into the Habsburg Empire and,
Romania eventually, after the dualist compromise in
1867, into the Hungarian part of the Austro-
In the early 20th century, two great Hungarian empire.
projects stood before Romanian society: on The start of World War I in 1914
the one hand, the modernisation of the focused the attention of the Romanian
country, whose development was still political class and public opinion on finding
noticeably behind that of Western nations, the best solution for bringing the foreign-
and on the other, the unification of the ruled provinces within the borders of
Romanian nation, by bringing together all Romania. King Carol I (1866-1914) wanted
Romanians in one state. In its 1914 borders, the country to immediately enter the war on
Romania covered less than half of the the side of Germany and Austria-Hungary,
territory where Romanians were the not only due to his German origin (as
majority. Bessarabia – the eastern half of member of the Hohenzollern-Sigmaringen
Moldova – had been annexed by Russia in dynasty), but also due to his conviction that
1812. Earlier still, in 1775, the Habsburg it was in Romania’s interest to remain an ally
Empire had annexed northern Moldova, of the Central Powers. Despite the great
which would thereafter be called Bukovina. prestige he had earned in 48 years of glorious
As for Transylvania, it and its neighbouring reign, he was opposed by most politicians,
regions (Banat, Crişana, and Maramureş) who supported neutrality; shortly after, the

1
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

King died and was followed by his brother’s The Russian Revolution, the anarchy
son, Ferdinand (1914-1927). which took over the country, and its
From 1914 to 1916, Romania eventual withdrawal from the war left the
remained neutral. However, being neutral Romanian front undefended. The
seemed not to be a permanent option. On the Romanians were forced to sign a separate
one side, the ‘Germanophiles’ warned peace of their own, in May 1918, under
against the Russian danger and considered extremely dire conditions: Romania would
that, by fighting against Russia and lose Dobruja and (to Austria-Hungary)
alongside Germany and Austria-Hungary, almost the entire arc of the Carpathian
Romanians could retrieve Bessarabia. The Mountains. However, Russia’s defeat and
‘Ententophiles’ were more numerous and the dissolution of its empire freed
more influential. They relied on the Bessarabia, which was united with Romania
sympathy of public opinion towards France in March 1918. Also, a few months later, the
(for a long time, Romanians were Europe’s defeat of Germany and Austria-Hungary,
most Francophile nation!) and promised to apart from striking the separate peace treaty
obtain Transylvania and Bukovina if their null, allowed Romania to bring the other two
side won – which meant, from all points of provinces, Transylvania and Bukovina,
view, a lot more than Bessarabia. The within its borders. One might say that
Government led by Ion I.C. (Ionel) Brătianu Romania lost the war, but won the peace –
(1864-1927), one of Romania’s most won it twice, in fact, both against Russia and
remarkable statesmen, pushed events in this against Austria-Hungary. It was a stunning
latter direction. Romania signed a treaty stroke of historical luck which opened up a
with the Allies, securing very advantageous future – as far as the national project was
territorial clauses, and, on the 27th of August concerned – beyond the most optimistic
1916, declared war against Austria- expectations.
Hungary. Thus, the pre-war ‘Lesser Romania’
The 1916 campaign ended in disaster. became, at the end of the war, ‘Greater
Romania couldn’t stand against the Romania’. The country more than doubled
combined German and Austro-Hungarian its territory and surface area. The former
attack on the Carpathian front and the Kingdom of 1914 covered 137.000 sq km,
Bulgarian offensive (also supported by while Greater Romania had 295.000 sq km.
Germany) along the Danube and in Dobruja. According to the 1912 census, the country’s
The entire southern part of the country, population at the time exceeded seven
including Bucharest, was occupied, and the million by only a little; by 1930, the number
military, the Government, the royal family had reached eighteen million. Greater
and many other Romanians found refuge in Romania could be considered the complete
Moldova. Reorganised with the help of a fulfilment of the national project, as it
French military mission, the Romanian practically covered the entire territory
army, also supported (without great inhabited by a Romanian majority and, in
enthusiasm) by its Russian ally, succeeded places, even exceeded it: In southern
the performance of holding out on the Dobruja, known as the Cadrilater – annexed
Moldovan front throughout 1917. by Romania from Bulgaria in 1913, after the
Second Balkan War – Romanians were a

2
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

minority by far; the same is true of northern Currently, ethnic Romanians make up about
Bukovina and southern Bessarabia, as well 90% of the country’s population.15
as of eastern Transylvania (the very core of
Greater Romania), where the Hungarian Historical Symbols: The Past as a
Székelys were the majority in several
Foreshadowing of the Future
counties. What is certain is that, with the
almost complete unification of the Romanian
nation, an important percentage of Though Romania, formed in 1859
minorities had also come within the borders through the unification of two principalities
of Greater Romania. In Transylvania (as well – Ţara Românească and Moldova, later
as Banat, Crişana, and Maramureş), in 1930, joined by Dobruja, in 1878, and
Romanians constituted almost 58% of the Transylvania, Bukovina and Bessarabia in
population, Hungarians – over 24%, and 1918 –, is a relatively young state, the
Germans – almost 10%. In Bukovina, Romanian historical consciousness sees the
Romanians made up 44.5% of the contours of the future Greater Romania
population, Ukrainians – 27.7%, Jews – sketched as early as the Antiquity.
10.8%, and Germans – almost 10%. In Greater Romania had first and
Bessarabia, 56.2% of inhabitants were foremost an ethnic justification, as
Romanian, 12.3% – Russian, 11% – Romanians were the majority population in
Ukrainian, 7.2% – Jews... most of the territories which constituted –
On a countrywide average, then and now – the Romanian state.
Romanians made up 71.9% of the Nevertheless, Romanians felt the need, in the
population, and minorities (probably the spirit of the national ideology of the 19th
most varied range of minorities in all of century, to consolidate their ‘natural right’
Europe) accounted for 28.1%. The territorial with the aid of the ‘historical right’, which
losses suffered after World War II (Southern carried equal weight.16 In other words, even
Dobruja, taken back by Bulgaria in 1940, and if ‘Romania’ did not exist before 1859, the
most importantly Bessarabia and the historical Romanian space was considered to
northern half of Bukovina, annexed by the have existed since Antiquity. Over two
U.S.S.R.) reduced the country’s territory thousand years ago, ancient Dacia was
from 295.000 sq km to 238.000 sq km; most of thought to cover the exact same space as
Bessarabia is now, after the fall of the Soviet Greater Romania. The Dacians are
empire, the Republic of Moldova. The considered to be the ancestors of Romanians,
minority population was also reduced, first who left Romania as inheritance to their
by the loss of said territories, then by the Romanian descendants.
extermination of a great number of Jews It is therefore no wonder that around
during the war and, during the following the middle of the 19th century, when
Communist regime, by massive emigration, Romania did not yet exist, Dacia appears
particularly in the case of Jews and Germans. very often in the national discourse of

15 Boia (2016). 16 For the mythological dimension of


Romanian history, see Boia (1997) (2001)
(2017).

3
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Romanian patriots, for example in the titles nevertheless jolly and jesting in times of
of important periodicals, such as Dacia peace, angry and cruel only in war; normally
literară (Literary Dacia), edited in Iași by endowed with common sense and always
Mihail Kogălniceanu in 1840, or Magazin returning to their ancient optimistic belief in
istoric pentru Dacia (Historical Magazine for gods and humans”17.
Dacia), edited in Bucharest by August How did Pârvan know all this? It is,
Treboniu Laurian and Nicolae Bălcescu evidently, a projection on the Dacians of an
between 1845 and 1848. The simple utterance idealised image of the Romanian peasant!
of the word ‘Dacia’ summarised an entire Pârvan continues: “Dacia was a great
national programme, which urged all kingdom, with a perfectly homogenous
Romanians living on the territory of ancient ethnic base, with secular historical
Dacia to unite. traditions, with a well-defined social and
Foreshadowing the unified Romania, economic structure, with an advanced
Dacia itself had to appear as a unified culture influenced at first by Celtic forms
territory, which in point of fact it had never and then, two centuries prior to Trajan, by
been and could not have been: rather, it was the Roman civilisation. Here, there were not
a space populated by tribes, not a national simply a certain number of barbarian tribes
state! The two tribes which occupied the with a greater or lesser population
current territory of Romania and about occupying a vast territory and lacking any
whom we have some information were the sort of political or national cohesion, but
Dacians, centred in Transylvania, and the rather a self-conscious nation.”18
Getae, who lived along the Danube and in I believe no further comment is
Dobrogea. With his claim that the Dacians necessary. Dacia, a national state?! The
and the Getae spoke the same language, the anachronism is obvious.
famous ancient geographer Strabo lent a Alongside Dacia, the second great
hand to the national Romanian mythology. symbol, of Romanian unity and continuity is
As they spoke the same language, they must Mihai Viteazul (Michael the Brave) who
have been the same people. Moreover, their ruled Wallachia between 1593 and 1601.
geographical position is clearly established – Having conquered Transylvania (in 1599)
from the Dniester to the Tisa, the exact same and Moldavia (in 1600), he unified – albeit
extent as Greater Romania. for a very short time – almost the whole of
Even Vasile Pârvan, who was the Romanian territory, or rather leaves us
certainly a first-class historian and an with the impression that he may have
extremely influential personality, allowed unified it. Sometime around the middle of
himself to fall into the trap of identifying the 19th century, the Wallachian ruler became
Dacia with Greater Romania. In his view, the the symbolic figure of national unity.
Geto-Dacians were “a nation of peasants: Nicolae Bălcescu’s book, Istoria românilor sub
settled, steadfast, obedient and respectful of Mihai Vodă Viteazul (The History of
their god, plagued by their neighbours with Romanians under Prince Michael the Brave)
endless wars and pillage; turned wild was written between 1847 and 1852. It was
themselves by their lawless acts, they were left unfinished upon the author’s death, was

17 Pârvan (1926), 173. 18 Pârvan (1972), 150-151.

4
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

published in 1878 and reprinted in more nuanced approach, but even they
numerous editions, being probably the most refrained from identifying a national idea.
widely read Romanian history book. It refers This is what Nicolae Iorga wrote about the
explicitly to the national significance of the relation that Mihai Viteazul had with
actions of the protagonist, who allegedly had Transylvania: “He saw that this too was a
wanted to create “a state spanning the whole Romanian state, with villages inhabited by
of the Romanian land”. This, despite the fact Romanians, even without having clearly in
that Transylvania was a Hungarian rather mind, as we do today, the idea of national
than a Romanian state (the ruling elite was unity, for which that age was not fully
Hungarian, while Romanian peasants, prepared. He thought he could rule as prince
although in all likelihood the majority over the Romanian villages here, just like he
population, mattered little in the context of ruled over the Romanian villages back in his
that age). Moldova was not Romanian either, own principality.” He had this to say about
in the sense that it had its own identity, the Moldovans: ”The conquest of Moldova
separate from Wallachia: the inhabitants happened quickly, but we must not imagine
called themselves Moldovans rather than that the Moldovans were in any sense happy
Romanians. Therefore, at the time, Mihai about it. At the time, as we well know, each
Viteazul couldn’t possibly envisage a country was accustomed to living in
Greater Romania. Nevertheless, he became accordance with its own customs, having its
posthumously, in the historical-political own ancient dynasty... Thus, many of
imaginary of Romanians, an essential Ieremia Movilă’s subjects regarded the
symbol of the fight for unity. In other words, arrival of Mihai, not as that of a braver, more
the prince did not create Greater Romania in capable and more glorious Romanian ruler,
1600, but contributed posthumously to its meaning to accomplish national unity within
creation in 1859 and 1918, through the force the borders of the same political entity, but
of the imaginary. rather as that of a foreign invader, ambitious
When history became and restless, who troubled the countries in
professionalised, at the end of the 19th his vicinity.”19 (It is, however, extraordinary
century and during the interwar period, how much energy was spent to explain, in
national interpretations became far more the most roundabout fashion, that the
nuanced. Even the most fiercely nationalistic inhabitants of Moldova identified as
historians had to concede that during the Moldovans and not as Romanians!).
Middle Ages there could be no C.C. Giurescu’s nationalism cannot
manifestations of an awareness of national be questioned either. Nevertheless, in his
unity among Romanians. In so far as Mihai well-known synthesis Istoria Românilor (The
Viteazul was concerned, during the interwar History of Romanians), the Romanian
years, even school manuals admit the lack of principalities were dealt with separately and
a national unity programme. Some they are not covered equally. Thus, for the
historians, such as Petre P. Panaitescu were period between the 15th and the 16th
clear about this; others, such as Nicolae Iorga centuries, Moldova receives 48% of the total
and Constantin C. Giurescu, embraced a number of pages, Wallachia 41%, while

19 Iorga (1993) (1935), 290-292, 294.

5
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Transylvania only 11%. Why so little about abbreviation stood for Romanian People's
Transylvania? Obviously, the reason (even Republic, the new communist name of the
though not explicitly stated) is that the country). Searching for any Romanian
history of this province is not strictly motivation in Mihai Viteazul’s actions was
speaking Romanian, but rather is shared completely out of the question. Everything
between Romanians and Hungarians. was explained through class struggle and
Nor did Ioan Lupaș, probably the relations with neighbouring powers, most
most important Transylvanian historian of importantly the Habsburgs: ”Mihai Viteazul
the interwar period, believe in the unity of has been used by the Habsburg Empire to
the Romanian space since time immemorial. conquer Transylvania for the Austrians. The
In his opinion, unity was a steady process, voivode [Romanian: ‘prince’ or ‘ruler’] Mihai
each age taking one step further. As for the has become the governor of this province,
year 1600, his conclusion was perfectly clear: and was considered the representative of
“In 1600, when the three Romanian Emperor Rudolf II, who deemed
principalities of Wallachia, Moldavia and Transylvania an Austrian province.”21
Transylvania came to be ruled together by Therefore, the prince who succeeded in
Mihai Viteazul, it was the very lack of a uniting the principalities had allegedly not
common sense of identity that made this fought for Romanians, but rather for the
Romanian rule so short-lived.”20 Austrians.
Even more curious is the fact that in
Romanian Past according to Roller’s vision even the Union of 1859 (the
founding moment of Romania) has no
Communists
national dimension. The interpretation goes
again along the lines of class struggle: “The
In its first phase, ‘internationalist’ idea of uniting Moldavia and Wallachia in a
and anti-national, the Communist regime single state emerged at the same time as
attempted to eliminate completely the capitalism, which needed a well-organised
traditional interpretations of Romanian state, with a larger internal market. The
history. Up until communism, the most developing Romanian bourgeoisie was
important historical factor was deemed to be seeing its interests threatened by the Turkish
the nation; as soon as communism took over, yoke... The highest ranking nobles were
that factor became the ‘class struggle’. The against the union, as they occupied the top
tone was set by the famous manual edited by positions in the state apparatus and feared
Mihail Roller, first published in 1947, that, after the union, these positions would
entitled Istoria României (The History of be taken by the bourgeois. Following the
Romania (up until that point, historians Union,” the manual continues, “it was only
preferred the phrase The History of the bourgeois elements and the commercial
Romanians) while subsequent editions (the nobility who profited, and not the large
last one was in 1957) bore the title Istoria popular masses.”22
R.P.R. (The History of R.P.R.) (The

20 Lupaș (1937), 43. 22 Roller (1952), 367.


21 Roller (1952), 230.

6
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

As for the creation of Greater the advantage of borrowing a lot from pre-
Romania in 1918, it was framed strictly in the communist history. As it were, Romanians
context of Romania’s participation in an were taught to find their country anew. And,
‘imperialist’ war. The union with Bessarabia anyway, it is far more agreeable to feel proud
was described under the title ‘The of one’s past (even at the cost of considerable
imperialist intervention against the socialist distortions) than seeing it in an unfavourable
revolution in Russia’, while Transylvania light.
and the symbolic day of December 1st were From about 1958 until the end of
integrated in a subchapter entitled ‘The 1989, nationalism grew incessantly. Initially,
counter-revolutionary intervention in interpretations were more prudent and
Hungary’ .23 appeared to be no more than a natural
The communist regime in Romania recovery of the national past. Thus on January
had two phases which in certain ways are 24th 1959, the Union of the Principalities – or,
nothing alike. The virulent anti-nationalism more precisely, a century since the
of the first phase was followed by a momentous creation of Romania through the
rehabilitation of the nation and national union in a single state of Moldavia and
culture, ending in extreme nationalism, Wallachia – was celebrated for the first time
every bit as excessive as the nationalism during the communist regime. At this time,
espoused by the extreme right Legion in the the interpretation of the event no longer had
interwar period. This shift from a restrictive connotation: the union was no
‘internationalism’ to ‘nationalism’ can be longer seen as the self-serving act of the
observed everywhere in the communist bourgeoisie, but rather as an act of will of the
world but the range of expressions, from one entire nation.
extreme to the other, as encountered in When Nicolae Ceaușescu took over
Romania is something quite unique in the power (in 1965), nationalist
communist countries (at least in Europe). interpretations amplified and became more
Roller’s posthumous destiny is, in a strident with each passing year. It was no
sense, ironic. He wanted to terminate longer deemed sufficient that the Romanian
Romanian nationalism once and forever, but space had united in recent history, it had to
he only succeeded in exacerbating it. His be portrayed as having been united forever,
radical and absurd anti-nationalism could since the origins. And it could not have
only be annihilated by an equally radical and united in any sort of fashion – the fusion had
absurd nationalism! to be such that not even the slightest regional
Delighted to be rid of Roller and his particularity was tolerated. It is obvious that
theories, Romanians received all the more this absolute unification defines a
easily the brand of nationalism peddled by manipulative strategy, but which eventually
the Ceaușescu regime, considering it a sort of proved efficient and durable. At stake was
normality, without realising that it was just not the past but rather the present.
as deceitful and manipulative as history had Allegedly, Romanians had always been
been in Roller’s interpretation. Moreover, united under their great leaders. Therefore,
this national-communist interpretation had they had to be even more so in the

23 Roller (1952), 525-529.

7
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

communist present, around the Party and shine brightly. Professional historians
particularly around the ‘beloved leader’, remained, nevertheless within the limits of
Ceaușescu (from a certain moment onwards, the traditional view of ethnogenesis, which
also around the dictator’s wife, Elena stated that Romanians emerged from the
Ceaușescu). coalescence of autochthonous Dacians and
This is the rationale behind the great Roman colonists settled in Dacia after its
pomp which marked the 2050th anniversary conquest by the emperor Trajan.
since the foundation of the ‘unitary and At any rate, the story of the formation
centralised’ Dacian state, under the of the Romanian people starts to omit the
leadership of Burebista, celebrated in 1980. Slavic element, which had been given
From the beginning, the timeframe is exceptional importance in Roller’s time, for
laughable: what sort of a milestone is 2050 obvious political reasons, having to do with
years?! Besides, there is no concrete the friendship towards the Soviet Union
information which might have allowed us to (beyond any sort of mythology, the Slavic
pinpoint the year when the Dacian state was component was fairly important, both in the
created. Nevertheless, Ceaușescu needed formation of the Romanian language and in
Burebista, as the Dacian king symbolised the medieval Romanian culture).
beginning of a historical process that the The great test of Romanian unity and
communist dictator allegedly brought to continuity was in the context of the ‘dark
completion. millennium’, the huge historical void
A historian who specialised in the stretching from the Roman withdrawal from
study of Dacians painted an interesting Dacia, towards the end of the 3rd century AD,
portrait of Burebista, seen a leader who was and the creation of the first Romanian
“animated by the burning desire to uplift his political entities around the middle of the
nation. It was to the nation that he dedicated 13th century. As information is totally
his entire activity, both internally and insufficient, this leaves place for any sort of
externally, throughout his life.”24 In order to scenario regarding the formation of the
make any sense of this phrase, one should Romanian language and the Romanian
read ‘Ceaușescu’ instead of Burebista! people, as well as their historical trajectory.
The age of Ceaușescu was, in a sense, The communist regime had
also the golden age of Dacian studies. Under historians and particularly archaeologists
the patronage of Ilie Ceaușescu, the working hard to demonstrate Romanian
dictator’s brother, who was a general and continuity also during the dark millennium.
also a historian, a number of party-affiliated This was in opposition with the migratory
historians attempted to paint the Dacians as theory, which found much support among
the only ancestors of Romanians. One of Hungarians and which postulated that
them even suggested changing the name of Romanians had their origin some place
the country from Romania to Dacia! outside their current territory. However,
Romanians thus became a sort of Dacians ethnic continuity was not considered
and Dacians a sort of Romanians, making the sufficient, and they also needed to
unity and continuity of Romanian history demonstrate political continuity, which tied

24 Crișan (1977), 495.

8
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Dacia to Roman Dacia and to medieval Even for the Middle Ages, there was
Romanian states. an attempt at re-baptising the three
The political manifesto of the principalities: Wallachia became ‘The
Romanian Communist Party (PCR) of 1975 Romanian Principality of Wallachia’,
opens with a substantial historical excursus Moldova was called ‘The Romanian
(which was meant to demonstrate that the Principality of Moldova’, and Transylvania
PCR had inherited and integrated the entire was, obviously, ‘The Romanian Principality
political history of the country). In it, the of Transylvania’. The peak of ridicule was
authors used an astonishing term to bind reached when this forced unification reached
together Romanians throughout the ‘dark the weather forecast as well. Suddenly, it
millennium’. Following the Roman stopped raining in Moldova or snowing in
withdrawal, Romanians allegedly continued Transylvania. Rain and snow now fell over
to live in a ‘disorganised state’. A the North, South, East or West, as the
‘disorganised state’! The phrase is striking, cardinal directions replaced the names of
given that, by definition, the state regions.
presupposes organisation; a disorganised
state is simply a non-existent state. Post-communist Historical Mythology
After 1980, during the last decade of
communism, the discourse about national
unity (always centred on the ‘dear leader’) Post-communist Romania inherited
reached peaks that are hard to imagine in a to a large extent the national-communist
reasonably normal society. Amidst rapidly ideology. ‘Oldness’, ‘unity’, and ‘continuity’,
deteriorating living conditions, what could this historiographic triptych which had
the regime offer people apart from a become the dogma of Communist times
substantial serving of nationalism? seems to have grown deep roots, both
Nationalism was supposed to mitigate both among professional historians and among
the cold and the hunger. the wider public. It is worth noticing that
The unitary treatment of the whole lately, the ‘Dacian-centric’ view has
Romanian past was the mantra of the day. expanded to such a degree that to some it has
Regional history was sacrificed on the altar become a national religion. According to this
of unity – the historical regions were view of things, every European people and
completely disregarded. At most, there were culture originates on the territory of modern
in use phrases such as ‘Romanians in the Romania, in pre-historic Dacia.
South-West of the country’, instead of The vitality of the mythological
‘Romanians from Banat’. When in Budapest triptych was recently demonstrated when
a book appeared about the history of the US Ambassador in Chișinău declared
Transylvania, written obviously from a that the Republic of Moldova has its own
Hungarian perspective, Romanian identity because, at least from a certain
historians could not react, because in moment onwards, its history differed from
Romanian historiography Transylvania did that of Romania. How could the Republic of
not exist (any longer)! The only thing that Moldova, i.e. Bessarabia, have its own
existed was Romania! history, when it is well known (didn’t the
Communists teach us so?) that there is only

9
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

one Romanian history. Only a handful of Russian colonisation and, in general, a


intellectuals dared side with the American process of Russification.
Ambassador. As a matter of fact, the In the imaginary of many Romanians,
diplomat was entirely correct. The South of ‘Bessarabia is Romania’ (a graffito which
Bessarabia was annexed by the Ottoman may be seen written on many walls), in
Empire as early as the 15th-16th centuries and reality Bessarabia is not Romania. It is a
there, Romanians became a minority. Then, country which has a lot in common with
in 1812, the whole of Bessarabia was annexed Romania – first and foremost the Romanian
by the Empire of the Tsars. In 1856, the language - , but which at the same time
southern part was handed back to Moldova exhibits many differences (a substantial
and became a part of Romania but was Russian influence in culture). According to
occupied again by the Russians in 1878. In polls, less than a quarter of the population of
1918, taking advantage of the breaking up of Bessarabia desires to unify with Romania.
the Tsarist Empire, Bessarabia reunited with This is, after all, the result of two centuries of
the Kingdom of Romania. In 1940, it was separate history25.
annexed again by Russia, which had become Also, the other regions which make
in the meantime the Soviet Union. It would up Romania had different histories, starting
gain independence in 1991, when the USSR even with Wallachia and Moldavia, the
collapsed. principalities around which the modern
It is important to clarify that the Romanian state was created. From our
Republic of Moldova we see today is not modern perspective, Stephen the Great was
identical to historical Bessarabia, but a Romanian voivode. However, from his
identical with the Moldovan Soviet Socialist own perspective, he was a Moldavian. There
Republic, as determined following the existed, up until the 19th century, a
annexation of 1940, when the North and the Moldavian identity (and, obviously, a
South were handed to Ukraine and it Wallachian one as well). In the 17th century,
received in compensation a sliver of land the two greatest Moldavian chroniclers,
beyond the river Dniester (Transnistria). Grigore Ureche and Miron Costin, knew full
It is plainly clear that, with the well that Romanians had a common origin
exception of the interwar period, Bessarabia and all spoke the same language, but, as
had a completely different history than the Moldavians, they never speak about ‘the
principality of Moldova, from which it had Romanian language’ or ‘Romanians’, but
been separated in 1812, and after 1859, a rather about the ‘Moldavian language’ and
different history from Romania. Separated the ‘nation of the Moldavians’.
from the Romanian space, it remained until The history of Transylvania was even
1918 outside the space where the Romanian more radically different. It was a province
nation formed. On the contrary, it suffered where the majority of the population was
Romanian, but the ruling elite was

25The most recent poll, from 2017, indicates NATO-c%C3%A2%C8%99tig%C4%83-teren-


that only 24% of the population favours union %C3%AEn-Republica-Moldova.htm,
with Romania: retrieved November 2017.
https://deschide.md/ro/stiri/politic/12145/SO
NDAJ-LRP-IMAS--UNIREA-%C8%99i-

10
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Hungarian. Unlike Wallachia and Moldavia, References:


Ardeal was a multi-ethnic territory, with
three main ethnicities: Romanians, Boia, L. 1997/2017. Istorie și mit în
Hungarians and Germans. As a Principality, conștiința românească. Bucharest: Humanitas;
it was part of Hungary for four centuries and English version History and Myth in Romanian
when Hungary disappeared from the map, Consciousness. 2001. Budapest-New-York:
becoming an Ottoman province, the CEU Press.
autonomous princes of Transylvania Boia, L. 2016. Wie Rumänien rumänisch
considered themselves the continuators of wurde. Berlin: Frank und Timme.
the Crown of Saint Stephen. Crișan, I. H. 1977. Burebista și epoca sa
Finally, Dobrogea had a completely (Burebista and his epoch). 2nd edition.
different history and, with the exception of a Bucharest: Editura Științifică și
period during the rule of Mircea cel Bătrân Enciclopedică.
(1368-1418), was never part of a Romanian Iorga. N. 1993/1935. Istoria românilor
state before 1878. It belonged to the pentru poporul românesc (The History of
Byzantine Empire and later to the Ottoman Romanians for Romanian People). Vol. 1.
Empire. In 1878, Romanians were a minority Bucharest: Minerva.
in Dobrogea, far fewer than Turks and Lupaș, I. 1937. Istoria unirii românilor
Tatars. (The History of the unity of Romanians).
It is plain to see that Romanians do Bucharest: Fundația culturală regală
not have, as mythology would have it, a Principele Carol.
unitary history, but obviously an evolution Pârvan, V. 1972. Dacia. 5th edition.
from fragmentation towards unity. This is Bucharest: Editura Științifică.
not an obstacle for many Romanian Pârvan, V. 1926. Getica. O protoistorie
historians (and many Romanians in general) a Daciei (Getika. A proto-history of Dacia).
to fly in the face of evidence and claim the Bucharest: Romanian Academy Series.
unitary character of the Romanian history. Roller, M. 1952. Istoria R.P.R. (History
Contemporary Romania is, indeed, unitary, of the Romania’s People Republic).
as the patriots who brought about the Bucharest: Editura de stat didactică și
Unions of 1859 and 1918 desired. This was pedagogică.
the result of a historical process of gradual
rapprochement of the various components of
the Romanian people and the creation of a
common culture, based on a language which
is clearly unitary, the Romanian language.

Lucian Boia is the author of numerous works, published in France and Romania (translated in numerous
languages), devoted in particular to the history of ideas and imagination. In Romania, his works have had
a resounding success, especially Istorie şi mit în conştiinţa românească (History and Myth in Romanian
Consciousness) (1997/2017), which offers Romanians a completely new look at their history, and De ce e
România altfel? (Why is Romania different?) (2012), a historical analysis of the Romanian specificity.

11
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

CÉCILE D’ALBIS

Le mythe de Grenade et les fêtes civico-religieuses (xvie-xviiie siècles)

Abstract
Granada, conquered by the Catholic Kings Isabella and Ferdinand in 1492, constructed an image of itself
as the ‘mythical city’. To anchor itself within the Hispanic kingdoms, establish the autochthony of its new
inhabitants, and finally organize its relations to the modern State, the city gradually developed crossed
narratives, in which the oral character challenges the intellectual speech. To understand the background
and the weft of these narratives during the Early-Modern times, we analyse the main elements which
compose the ‘myth’ of Granada over time.

Keywords: Granada, urban myth, civic-religious celebrations, martyrdom, autochthony

Mon propos en évoquant cette


Grenade, tout comme Venise ou perception extérieure et construite de « ville
encore Alexandrie, pour prendre des mythique » à propos de Grenade est
exemples méditerranéens, est ce que l’on justement de situer et de définir les éléments
appelle communément une « ville de cette construction et de tenter d’en
mythique ». La spécificité des villes comprendre la chronologie, les motivations
mythiques réside peut-être en ce que, en les politiques, en examinant de l’intérieur la
arpentant, on ne peut s’empêcher d’avoir la manière dont la ville vit avec le poids de sa
vision troublée par des télescopages entre légende. La succession des célébrations
l’imaginaire des lieux, le présent et une civico-religieuses, étudiées sur les trois
vision globale et stéréotypée des événements siècles des temps dits modernes, les récits
passés. Quelques décennies après la chute de locaux, où les célébrations tiennent un rôle
Constantinople aux mains des Ottomans en majeur, ou les traces iconographiques et
1453, la conquête de Grenade par les Rois architecturales nous offrent autant de
Catholiques Isabelle et Ferdinand en 1492 lectures locales sur la manière dont la ville
représenta en effet un véritable tournant s’est appropriée et a pu faire vivre et évoluer
symbolique et épistémologique dans cette mémoire dans un contexte en
l’histoire européenne. Grenade témoigne de évolution. Ces expressions, forcément
la présence et de la défaite d’un Islam officielles et orientées, se confrontent dans
conquérant et baroque dans les limites de l’espace toujours vivant qu’est la fête, où
l’Europe, dans un autrefois qui nous semble elles sont réinterprétées. Une telle analyse
d’un autre monde. Elle atteste aussi de nous montre aussi que Grenade, comme les
l’existence et de l’achèvement d’un pénible autres villes hispaniques modernes, cherche
conflit intérieur qui a contribué à construire avant tout à se conformer au même grand
l’Europe et la Méditerranée telles que nous schéma politique et mémoriel, qui fonde
les connaissons. l’unité idéologique des royaumes
hispaniques à l’époque moderne.

12
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Je commencerai par expliquer chroniques festives et les histoires locales.


pourquoi il me semble utile d’avoir recours Ces célébrations faites de processions, de
au terme de mythe dans ce contexte, afin fonctions liturgiques et rituelles ou encore de
d’approcher l’histoire de la ville et son jeux allégoriques, mettent en scène et
appropriation locale sur la longue durée et confirment les légendes locales, qui
pourquoi les fêtes civico-religieuses soutiennent elles-mêmes les privilèges de la
constituent une source particulièrement ville confrontée à l’intrusion grandissante de
riche pour entreprendre l’étude des mythes l’administration et des symboles royaux28.
collectifs urbains à l’époque moderne. Je L’étude des célébrations, qui entrecroise les
m’arrêterai ensuite sur les principaux sources et cherche à décrypter les
éléments qui constituent le mythe de motivations des acteurs, le sens du spectacle,
Grenade depuis 1492 jusqu’au XVIIIe siècle, tel qu’il peut échapper à
en insistant sur les points de rupture et l’instrumentalisation politique immédiate,
d’évolution du récit collectif provoqués par nous offre de nombreux renseignements sur
les crises et les bouleversements politiques et l’organisation de la vie urbaine, mais aussi
sociétaux26. sur les raisons et la manière dont la
communauté choisit de se mettre en scène
Les fêtes civico-religieuses et le mythe pour elle-même et pour le monde extérieur29.
urbain à l’époque moderne Lorsque l’on entreprend l’étude de ces
sources festives sur une longue période, il est
possible en effet d’isoler des thèmes
Dans les territoires hispaniques de
récurrents et des références symboliques
l’époque moderne, la vie urbaine s’organise
transmis de génération en génération. On
largement autour des célébrations. Parmi
constate qu’autour de thèmes centraux, qui
elles, les fêtes organisées par les autorités
constituent un noyau dur qui demeure à peu
locales, civiles et ecclésiastiques s’adressent
près inchangé au cours du temps, le récit
à la population à la fois en tant que Civitas
dans son ensemble évolue en fonction du
(communauté des citoyens) et Ecclesia
contexte, et se trouve particulièrement
(assemblée des fidèles). Les fêtes civico-
influencé par les grandes ruptures
religieuses déploient la fierté et la conscience
historiques. Certains thèmes disparaissent,
de l’appartenance civique, les liens de la
d’autres trouvent une vitalité nouvelle,
communauté avec la communitas élargie du
actualisant ainsi un système toujours vivant
royaume et avec l’éternité idéalisée de son
et créateur.
ordre social et politique27. Elles se prolongent
Pour comprendre et replacer les
dans les préoccupations des autorités, les
discours urbains qui transparaissent à
conflits juridiques de préséance, les
travers les célébrations, l’emploi du terme de

26
Cet article a été initialement publié dans 27 Grimes (1976); Kempers (1994), 89-136. Sur
Myth Making and Myth Breaking in History and les liens identitaires entre les villes et le
the Humanities. Proceedings of the Conference royaume à la fin du Moyen-Age, voir Rucquoi
Held at the University of Bucharest, 6-8 (2003), 145-166.
October 2011, edited by Claudia-Florentina 28 Althoff (2003). Pour un état des lieux des

Dobre, Ionuț Epurescu-Pascovici, Cristian débats, voir Moeglin (2007), 393-406.


Emilian Ghiță. 29 Voir Boureau (2006), 25-34.

13
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

mythe a plusieurs avantages dans le cadre Du point de vue historique, le mythe


souvent flou des nombreuses études qui est donc lié aux évolutions politiques et
touchent à la mémoire et à l’identité sociales. Vu qu’il constitue un comportement
collectives30. Alors qu’ils élevaient d’autres de communication, il a un lien spécifique
types de narration, le discours historique en avec la fête qui l’exprime et le transforme. La
particulier, au statut de seul discours dimension locale y est aussi fondamentale et
crédible, les Grecs rejetèrent le mythos, le des contraintes extérieures pèsent autant sur
discours traditionnel et oral, en tant l’un que sur l’autre34. Les fêtes de la
qu’interprétation valide de la société. Les Renaissance et de l’âge baroque font appel à
ethnologues perçurent assez vite toutefois des images sacrées, se réfèrent à une
l’intérêt interprétatif des mythes. Mais cet antiquité idéalisée et réactivent un fonds de
intérêt ne s’est pas appliqué à la culture valeurs partagées. À travers l’étude des fêtes
chrétienne occidentale avant les années 1970 d’une ville moderne, on peut aisément voir
et 198031. Ce n’est donc que tardivement que se formuler et se déconstruire, pour mieux se
le mythe s’est trouvé réintroduit dans les reconstruire, un mythe qui articule les
sciences sociales, plus seulement pour questions de pouvoir, d’identification et de
comprendre les récits collectifs de représentation de la ville.
civilisations lointaines ou de légendes C’est dans ce sens que le terme de
folkloriques dites populaires. Aujourd’hui, mythe, employé dans un contexte urbain
l’analyse du mythe comme un phénomène renaissant pour saisir un cadre idéologique
historique, autrement dit un phénomène fondé sur des images et des références issues
évolutif, que l’on peut étudier en tant que de l’Antiquité, a été employé par les
tel32, cherche à déconstruire l’impasse dans historiens et historiens de l’art anglo-saxons
laquelle nous place le présupposé grec, pour depuis les années 1960. Ces chercheurs
tenter de comprendre comment la mémoire s’emparaient là d’un terme qui désignait un
fabrique la tradition, la préserve et la imaginaire spécifique : lorsque les
transforme en l’acte de transmission, en Britanniques en voyage en Italie au XIXe
fonction de l’évolution du système social. siècle parlent du mythe de Florence ou de
Les travaux sur la construction des Venise, ils font référence à un héritage
mémoires, la transmission symbolique, les idéalisé, qui transforme leur propre manière
rituels ou les idéologies ont permis de d’être Anglais35. Par la suite, la notion de
développer l’emploi du terme de mythe et mythe, reprise dans un sens
d’enrichir son horizon33. anthropologique, servit à déterminer

30 Sur les problèmes posés par l’interprétation pragmatique sur l’action et la prise en compte
des « lieux de mémoire », les identités du rôle des acteurs ont accentué cette
collectives et les débats théoriques actuels, perspective. Voir Breviglieri (2009). Sur la
voir Pakier (2010) ; François (2010). question de l’adéquation rythmique entre
31 Sur la généalogie du mythe en Occident, l’expression discursive de l’action et
voir en particulier Veyne (1983) ; Schmitt l’événement historique, voir Koselleck (1989),
(2001). 308-325.
32 Cardaillac (2001) 107-131 ; Girardet (1986). 34 Détienne (1981). Coulomb (2008).

33 Ces dernières années, les travaux qui 35 Del Vento, Tabet (2006).

insistent dans la lignée de la sociologie

14
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

l’idéologie et les représentations qui C’était la fin de la grande geste de


permettaient de comprendre l’architecture, restauration héroïque de l’Espagne antique,
les soubresauts politiques ou les célébrations qui avait duré des siècles. L’événement,
de villes de la Renaissance, d’abord parce réalisation d’anciennes prédictions, fut
que ces villes se comprenaient elles-mêmes célébré à travers toute l’Europe comme le
en rapport avec la mythologie antique36. signe annonciateur de la Parousie, la victoire
Le terme de mythe implique donc finale de la foi chrétienne dans le monde et le
l’idée d’un discours spécifique sur le passé, retour du Christ. Quelques mois plus tard, le
c’est une sorte de « lieu de mémoire » en lui- succès de l’expédition de Christophe
même, qui se transmet et affecte le présent. Colomb au nom des Rois Catholiques
Autre atout de ce cadre d’analyse, le mythe confirmait l’exceptionnelle faveur divine
conserve encore malgré tout le sens accordée à l’Espagne, chargée de la mission
généralement admis de « faux discours », ce d’unifier le monde sous la bannière de la foi
qui comporte l’avantage de permettre à chrétienne.
l’historien de garder une certaine distance Grenade devint naturellement la
par rapport à son objet et à en questionner le capitale symbolique de ce projet idéologique
sens politique et social à l’intérieur de la dont les rois d’Espagne firent le fondement
communauté envisagée. Enfin, le mythe, ce de leur nouveau pouvoir européen. Cette
« discours sans auteur », contient également situation motiva un grand nombre de projets
l’idée d’inconscient, d’incontrôlable, et par là institutionnels, dévotionnels et artistiques
aussi d’émotion et de normativité prestigieux dans la ville conquise. Les traités
supérieure, qui sont également des de tolérance conclus pour obtenir la
dimensions importantes à considérer dans reddition pacifique de Grenade, les
l’analyse des discours partagés. Capitulations, empêchaient a priori les
Comme les autres villes hispaniques nouveaux colons de s’approprier la plus
conquises avant elle au cours de la grande grande partie de la ville musulmane37, mais
geste médiévale de reprise des territoires Grenade se trouva pourtant parsemée de
anciennement wisigoths, Grenade hérite signes chrétiens et royaux, depuis la plus
d’un ensemble de références associées à la haute tour de la forteresse de l’Alhambra
guerre de conquête. jusqu’aux portes de la ville. Grenade était la
ville promise, la nouvelle Jérusalem à partir
Le mythe royal de laquelle les rois allaient conquérir le reste
des anciennes colonies romaines de
Méditerranée, puis anéantir la menace
Les Rois Catholiques Isabelle et
Ferdinand entrent à Grenade le 6 janvier ottomane et reconquérir les lieux saints.
Surtout, Isabelle et Ferdinand décidèrent
1492. Au bout de dix ans de guerre, le dernier
d’être enterrés dans une chapelle construite
bastion musulman de la péninsule
hispanique disparaissait pour toujours. à côté de la grande mosquée de la ville
transformée en cathédrale. À partir des

36 Sur les modèles antiques des mythes 37 Quesada (1993).


urbains et le lien entre fête, mémoire et
identité locale à la Renaissance, voir Trexler
(1991 [1980]) ; Muir (1981); Fenlon (2007).

15
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

années 1510, les corps des rois victorieux chrétiens, de plus en plus nombreux, et les
tinrent la fonction de saints fondateurs et de autochtones musulmans restés à Grenade se
reliques au pouvoir médiateur au cœur de la révéla rapidement conflictuelle. Au tout
ville où s’enracinent le christianisme et le début du XVIe siècle, à la suite d’une révolte,
pouvoir castillan. les Capitulations furent abrogées et les
L’empereur Charles Quint développa Mudéjares forcés d’accepter les termes d’une
encore la position de Grenade à l’intérieur conversion qui ne leur offrait qu’un statut
d’un empire dilaté à la dimension social inférieur, celui de « Nouveaux-
européenne. Il transforma en particulier la chrétiens », ou Morisques40.
chapelle personnelle des Rois Catholiques en La seconde conséquence était que la
un panthéon destiné à abriter les membres conquête ne pouvait suffire pour jouer le rôle
de la nouvelle dynastie des Habsbourg. Il se de récit fondateur, nécessaire pour
situait ainsi dans une geste à la fois construire une marque identitaire forte pour
patriotique et universelle, confirmait la grâce la nouvelle ville hispanique et ancrer ses
qui était donnée à l’Espagne et à sa lignée, et habitants dans une filiation collective. Alors
soulignait l’importance du rôle accordé à que le critère de noblesse devenait essentiel
Grenade dans le cadre idéologique de la pour défendre les villes contre l’intrusion
monarchie. Jusqu’au milieu du XVIe siècle, croissante de l’administration royale, la prise
les arrivées successives de corps royaux à de Grenade était en elle-même un
Grenade et les célébrations funèbres événement trop récent pour qualifier la
scellèrent l’alliance de la nouvelle noblesse de la ville, principalement fournie
communauté avec ses rois38. par l’antiquité de l’histoire.
Comment ce rôle unique pouvait-il Par ailleurs, les nouveaux habitants
s’accorder avec la réalité ? La conquête de de Grenade ne pouvaient continuer
Grenade avait semblé effacer d’un coup longtemps à s’identifier en priorité au
toute l’histoire des sept siècles passés, opérer groupe restreint des glorieux conquistadors,
une boucle miraculeuse du temps sur lui- car cela soulignait le fait qu’ils étaient des
même, la victoire des Rois oblitérant la nouveaux venus et finalement des occupants
défaite du roi Rodrigue face aux illégitimes. Suivant la tradition médiévale, la
envahisseurs Maures39. Mais ce retour aux guerre contre les Musulmans était une
origines était aussi un tournant. En effet, guerre juste, pour la « restauration de
puisque 1492 ouvrait une nouvelle époque l’Espagne » et les nouveaux arrivants étaient
d’attentes et de valeurs, elle clôturait donc naturellement les premiers habitants
définitivement la précédente. Et cela avait légitimes du territoire. Mais la coexistence
deux conséquences majeures. des communautés sur le mode médiéval,
Tout d’abord, le sens symbolique alors que s’affirmaient de plus en plus les
large de l’événement ne pouvait voiler très notions d’appartenance confessionnelle et
longtemps la réalité complexe dont la ville ethnique de la première modernité, imposait
avait héritée après la conquête. La une redéfinition de la tradition. En d’autres
cohabitation pacifique entre les colons mots, il était nécessaire pour les colons

38 D`Albis (2009), 247-266. 40Sur la coexistence des communautés et le


39 Milhou (1999). destin des Morisques, je renvoie aux travaux
de Vincent et Cardaillac (1977).

16
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

chrétiens de fonder leur autochtonie41, de autorités s’inquiétèrent de plus en plus de ce


s’affirmer comme les premiers habitants royaume périphérique, mal intégré, où
d’un territoire déjà occupé par d’autres, vivent nombre d’anciens Musulmans,
d’accorder leur histoire à celle des autres considérés comme de possibles traîtres. Dès
Castillans. le milieu du XVIe siècle, Grenade n’incarnait
plus la promesse optimiste d’un monde uni
Le mythe martyrial et la quête des prochainement sous la bannière de la croix,
mais une mixité religieuse et ethnique
origines
désormais suspecte et méprisée. De
Nouvelle Jérusalem, Grenade était devenue
Le martyr, dans de multiples
une Nouvelle Babylone43.
composantes et traditions héritées de la
Le fils de l’empereur Charles Quint,
période médiévale, joua un rôle capital dans
Philippe II, le plus puissant souverain ouest-
l’enracinement d’une autochtonie dans la
Européen de la seconde moitié du siècle, fait
Grenade moderne. De nombreux récits de
le choix d’une politique de rationalisation et
martyrs circulaient déjà à Grenade depuis la
d’unification politique et religieuse
période médiévale. À une époque où les
volontariste de ses royaumes. Avec
villes se peuplent de nouveaux lieux de
l’avancée de la Réforme, le souverain est
sociabilité, de marques symboliques et
confronté aux désirs d’indépendance des
sacrées, où les fêtes rassemblent les habitants
marges issus des héritages médiévaux. Dans
dans une communauté élargie, les légendes
ce cadre, la question morisque de Grenade,
locales ou importées contribuèrent à établir
perçue comme une véritable menace
une géographie sacrée dans la ville
géostratégique, devient un objectif
récemment christianisée au début du XVIe 44
prioritaire .
siècle42.
En 1568, poussés à bout par les
Dans le même temps, dans le
vexations et les interdits dont ils sont l’objet
contexte des affrontements directs qui
de la part de la majorité chrétienne, les
opposent l’empire de Charles Quint aux
Morisques de Grenade se soulèvent. Pour le
ambitions d’expansion ottomanes en
pouvoir royal, cette révolte est l’occasion de
Méditerranée et des guerres de religion en
mettre fin à une situation de mixité devenue
Europe, le martyr redevint une figure
intolérable dans une Europe où les États
d’actualité. Les reliques antiques venues des
reflètent de plus en plus une unité culturelle
catacombes romaines envahirent l’Europe
et religieuse. Il en résulte une guerre civile
catholique. La peur d’une nouvelle inversion
violente et traumatique, qui tente de
de l’histoire, soutenue par les prophéties,
résoudre les questionnements identitaires
marque profondément le royaume de
complexes de ce territoire colonial. À l’issue
Grenade soumis aux opérations de piraterie
de leur inévitable défaite, en 1570, des
venues de l’autre côté de la Méditerranée et
dizaines de milliers de morisques sont
incapable de régler la cohabitation de plus en
expulsés dans des conditions terribles du
plus tendue entre les communautés. Les

41 Pour reprendre le titre de l’article de 43 Sur l’imaginaire babylonien de la ville,


Détienne, (2001), 105-110. voir Jacquemier (1999).
42 Harris (2002), 517-543. 44 Torricabras (2001).

17
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

royaume de Grenade45. Quelques années tournant du siècle, Cecilio était en effet un


plus tard, le roi prend la décision de retirer parfait candidat pour se transformer en un
les corps des Habsbourg qui avaient été saint patron : venu d’Orient pour devenir
enterrés à Grenade pour les installer dans un évêque en Occident, il réunissait les canons
nouveau panthéon situé au cœur de la de sainteté anciens et nouveaux, le
Castille, à l’Escorial. merveilleux et l’autorité rationnelle
Cette double disparition confortée par l’Église. C’était également un
traumatique, celle de la population et de la saint syncrétique, colonial, qui réconciliait
culture indigène d’une part, celle des corps implicitement deux religions et deux
royaux d’autre part, entraîna une mondes antagonistes, sous le patronage de la
réorientation forcée de la mémoire et de Vierge et de Saint Jean.
l’identité locale sur lesquelles s’était forgée la En 1595, San Cecilio devient patron
première société grenadine. de la ville par consensus populaire. Et
Alors que les certitudes de la Grenade obtient le titre de siège apostolique
Renaissance s’éloignaient et que le Concile trois ans plus tard. La promotion du culte de
de Trente rationalisait et renforçait la San Cecilio et son intégration rapide dans les
position catholique, le mythe grenadin prit chroniques locales qui se développent au
une tonalité loyaliste et hiérarchique qui début du XVIIe siècle sous l’égide des
tentait de retrouver le lien perdu entre la autorités locales enthousiastes, établirent la
ville, son passé, son environnement réalité des inventions de reliques comme une
hispanique et ses rois. nouvelle version de l’histoire.
En effet, l’éclairage nouveau
Les découvertes du Sacromonte qu’offraient les découvertes sur le passé
permettait de reformuler l’histoire de la ville,
jusque-là obscure et principalement axée
Près de vingt ans après l’expulsion
des Morisques, entre 1588 et 1596, on autour de la rupture engendrée par la
conquête et la christianisation. Suivant la
découvre des reliques sur une colline proche
trame commune fournie par les chroniques
de la ville, rapidement nommée le
médiévales, cette correction faisait de
Sacromonte (le mont saint)46. Des textes qui
Grenade une ville fondamentalement
les accompagnent révèlent opportunément
chrétienne, évangélisée depuis l’antiquité, et
qu’il s’agit des restes d’un arabe, Cecilio,
non plus une ville d’origine musulmane,
converti au christianisme par Jésus et envoyé
naturellement suspecte à cause de sa
par Saint Paul avec ses compagnons pour
fondation récente et de sa diversité ethnique.
évangéliser l’Occident. Ces faux, pensés et
réalisés en réalité par un groupe de Cette poursuite collective d’un passé
glorieux est à la fois le reflet et le cadre de la
morisques lettrés qui souhaitaient conserver
recherche frénétique d’ancêtres
la mémoire de la communauté disparue, ont
un succès inattendu et paradoxal. Au « convenables » qui touche l’ensemble des
Espagnols, confrontés à la diffusion rapide

45Peña, Vincent (1986). élaborations historiques granadines, voir


46Il existe une importante bibliographie sur ce Harris (2007). Sur l’importance des de reliques
cas fascinant. Voir en particulier Manuel dans différents contextes historiques et
Aguilera, García-Arenal (2006). Sur les géographiques, voir Boutry, Fabre (2009).

18
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

des statuts de pureté de sang et, plus Ainsi, bien que le phénomène du
largement, à l’assimilation de l’appartenance Sacromonte soit quelque chose d’éphémère,
idéologique et de l’identité religieuse et largement remis en cause pour son
ethnique. invraisemblance dès la fin du siècle et
Le mythe prend forme grâce au condamné comme hérétique par la papauté
télescopage d’événements anciens et récents, à la fin du siècle suivant, bien que le culte de
du martyr et de la conquête, pris ensemble San Cecilio n’ait jamais bénéficié d’une
sous un halo de providence divine. Pour la importante ferveur populaire48, son
population qui processionne au mont saint, incorporation au mythe de Grenade en fait la
le rapprochement se fait en effet tout clef de la compréhension de l’identification
naturellement entre martyrs anciens et civique grenadine ultérieure. Cette
modernes, entre leurs bourreaux romains et incorporation se produit moins dans les
maures. La notion rénovée de martyr réunit histoires officielles, qui retracent la
les thèmes de la conquête, du conflit de la généalogie de Grenade en employant les
croisade et celle de l’unité religieuse. La découvertes comme preuves scripturaires,
victimisation, qui correspond également aux suivant une conception moderne de
thèmes valorisés par la Contre-réforme, l’interprétation sacrée (comme dans l’œuvre
s’accompagne de l’héroïsation des ancêtres, illustrée du chanoine Francisco Bermúdez de
ce qui permet en retour une perception Pedraza, Historia eclesiastica, principios y
glorieuse de la ville, fondée justement sur ce progressos de la ciudad, y religion catolica de
qui était auparavant considéré comme Granada, 163749) qu’à travers la répétition et
dégradant. Par ce récit, Grenade cesse d’être l’amalgame des thèmes dans les célébrations
stigmatisée et fait évoluer son image. Elle et les trajets processionnels et le
n’est plus le reflet figé d’une conquête passée développement des dévotions mariales, qui
et le rappel de l’existence des Morisques favorisent la transmission orale et les
rebelles. Elle devient la première terre rapprochements sans cesse actualisés.
chrétienne d’Europe et le modèle de la
normalisation religieuse et politique du Les Vierges grenadines et l’adaptation
XVIIe siècle. La découverte des reliques
du mythe au XVIIe siècle
dévoile ainsi l’imaginaire urbain de la ville
en transformation : la ville médiévale, avec
La Vierge et la croix, qui figurent sur
ses bâtiments exotiques, ses inscriptions
les bannières des vainqueurs et représentent
étranges, est éclaircie, idéalisée, sanctifiée47.
les Rois Catholiques, mandataires de Dieu
Par ailleurs, les découvertes libèrent
pour réaliser cette conquête en son nom,
Grenade de l’attache exclusive à ses rois en
occupent une place fondamentale dans la
lui créant un passé. Grâce à elles, la ville
Grenade d’après 1492. Après le départ des
apprend que son histoire n’a pas commencé
Rois, une véritable manufacture est mise en
avec la conquête, mais bien avant, et que
place pour fabriquer des statues mariales
cette histoire est glorieuse.
destinées à peupler les nouvelles églises du

47 Albaladejo (2007). 49 Voir Escobar (2004) 705-726.


48 Sur le culte de San Cecilio, voir Medina

(2001).

19
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

royaume50. C’est l’une de ces statues, placée la communauté civique. C’était au contraire
dans la première cathédrale de Grenade, qui une figure exemplaire et héroïque. Ce qui
devient dans les années 1560 la première implique qu’elle réalise des exploits (des
patronne de la ville, sous le nom de Vierge miracles), en particulier à l’occasion des
de la Antigua. rogations, supplications collectives de plus
Après le Concile de Trente, les en plus fréquentes au XVIIe siècle et qui
dévotions mariales deviennent la principale mêlent indistinctement causes patriotiques
source à la fois de renouveau religieux et et locales. Enfin, l’image était apparue
d’homogénéisation confessionnelle dans le miraculeusement, elle était donc autochtone,
monde hispanique. Les images se tout en manifestant par sa légende un lien
multiplient et se renouvellent. Elles offrent originel aux rois et à la conquête52. Las
des modèles sociaux, imposent une Angustias triomphe donc en intégrant les
hiérarchie et un modèle religieux de principales composantes du mythe de
dévotion, fondé sur la valeur supérieure de Grenade : la conquête, le martyr,
la noblesse, où la monarchie et l’Église se l’autochtonie (en d’autres mots : victoire,
renforcent mutuellement. Puis, lorsque ancienneté et noblesse).
l’issue de la guerre de Trente Ans semble Parallèlement, une Vierge souveraine
marquer la défaite de l’ancien idéal d’empire vient à la fois dominer et réunir l’ensemble
universel de l’Espagne, dans un contexte de des dévotions mariales. L’Immaculée
récession économique et de calamités Conception, Vierge triomphale et
publiques, les Vierges de douleur, qui standardisante, dont le culte est soutenu par
expriment un tragique intériorisé et contenu, la monarchie, offre un modèle à la fois
servent à évoquer un pouvoir royal patriotique et universel qui se diffuse avec
sacrificiel pour un pays de plus en plus un succès inégalé au début du XVIIe siècle53.
conscient de son déclin. Elles justifient la Tenant le rôle de témoin et de gage
survie de l’idéologie espagnole, mais d’orthodoxie dans les livres qui
donnent aussi un sens glorieux à son destin accompagnaient les reliques découvertes à
dramatique51. Grenade, elle jouait déjà un rôle fondamental
À Grenade, une Vierge des douleurs dans les découvertes du Sacromonte. Icône
devient la nouvelle patronne de la ville, royale et invincible, l’Immaculée Conception
officieusement dès le début du XVIIe siècle, se tient depuis le début du XVIIe siècle sur
puis officiellement à la fin du siècle, à travers une colonne à l’entrée de la ville, devant la
plusieurs célébrations spectaculaires et des porte où entrèrent les Rois Catholiques dans
miracles qui imposent son pouvoir la ville en 1492 et les autres rois après eux.
salvateur. Las Angustias bénéficiait en effet Cette Vierge manifeste la continuité de
de plusieurs atouts : il ne s’agissait pas, l’idéologie de la conquête universelle
contrairement à la première patronne, la personnifiée par Grenade, en particulier
Antigua, d’une reine aristocratique dans les fêtes célébrées à l’occasion des
majestueuse et neutre, qui incarne la civitas, victoires ou des défaites de l’armée royale. À

50 À propos de cette étonnante pratique l’Espagne du XVIIe siècle : Carrasco, Bégrand


manufacturière, voir Pereda (2007). (2004).
51 Elliott (1977), 41-61. Et sur l’importance des 52 López-Guadalupe Muñoz (1996).

signes surnaturels et des prophéties dans 53 Bernal (2006), 79-113. Cortés Peña (2001).

20
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

travers une série de miracles, de sacrilèges et politiques et religieuses de son temps. Cet
de célébrations spectaculaires soutenues par événement pousse les nouvelles générations
les autorités en conflit les unes contre les de Grenadins à combler le fossé entre le
autres54, elle devient une sorte de totem qui passé et le présent, faisant ainsi évoluer le
permet à la ville de faire perdurer le mythe récit collectif.
dans un cadre hispanique par ailleurs Le mythe de Grenade ainsi
défaitiste. développé la singularise dans le paysage
hispanique. Mais il sert surtout à insérer la
Conclusions ville dans un environnement hispanique
fortement marqué par un idéal d’unicité et
Au XVIIIe siècle, le mythe achève de d’uniformité. Dans son récit
communautaire, Grenade se veut à la fois
mettre en place une reconstruction du passé
unique et ordinaire, la plus ancienne ville
sous la forme d’un ensemble de récits et
chrétienne de l’Europe occidentale et la
d’images récurrents. Il se fonde sur un triple
dernière conquise. Par ailleurs, célébrations,
paradoxe identitaire : tout en affirmant être
miracles, dévotions communes sont les lieux
les descendants des conquérants de
où ce récit commun se met en scène et se
Grenade, les Grenadins sont des
diversifie progressivement avec le temps.
autochtones. Ils descendent à la fois des
Les jeux de la propagande, la réception
habitants de la ville antique (Illibéris) et des
martyrs du Sacromonte, véritables ancêtres divergente de la population, la complexité
esthétique croissante des célébrations
sacrés. Ils peuvent donc se proclamer à la fois
transforment aussi la perception et le sens du
autochtones (ils étaient là avant les Maures),
purifiés de l’Islam par la mort des martyrs- mythe urbain.
Entre particularité et effort incessant
ancêtres et conquérants de l’ennemi
pour tendre vers une normalité idéale, aux
Musulman.
Ce récit mythique fait de multiples XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles les Grenadins ne
embranchements et de généalogies cessent de rechercher un équilibre qui les
entrecroisées, parfois avortées, reflète les préserve des difficultés contemporaines et
grandes ruptures historiques que la ville a conforte le rôle que la ville ne cesse de
connues, en particulier dans le dernier tiers vouloir assumer dans le concert des
du XVIe siècle. Après la guerre et l’expulsion royaumes hispaniques. Le mythe de
traumatique de la population et de la culture Grenade est donc un outil pour comprendre
des Morisques ; après le départ des corps l’évolution des royaumes hispaniques dans
royaux, qui force à la redéfinition de la raison leur ensemble. Et le modèle du mythe, ce
d’être de la ville des Rois Catholiques, récit à multiples voix, peut nous aider à saisir
symbole de l’achèvement de la conquête ; les modalités de l’intégration des villes
lorsque Grenade, appauvrie et diminuée, se européennes dans leur cadre étatique et
trouve reléguée aux frontières de l’empire l’évolution de la représentation de l’identité
hispanique, la ville fait d’étonnantes urbaine en Europe au cours de l’époque
découvertes qui la replacent au-devant de la moderne.
scène et au cœur des préoccupations

54 Serrano (2002).

21
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Catedra, M. 1997. Un santo para una


Références : ciudad. Ensayo de antropología urbana.
Barcelone : Ariel.
Aguilera, M. B., García-Arenal (eds.). Cortés Peña, A. L., B. Vincent, 1986.
2006. Los plomos del Sacromonte. Invención y Historia de Granada, la época moderna.
tesoro. Valence, Grenade, Saragosse : Grenade : Don Quijote.
Universités. Cortés Peña, A. L. 2001. Religión y
Althoff, G. 2003. Die Macht der Rituale. política durante el Antiguo Régimen. Grenade :
Darmstadt : Primus Verlag. Universidad de Granada.
Albaladejo, P. 2007. Materia de España, Coulomb, Cl. 2008. ‘Les rituels dans
cultura política e identidad en la España les histoires des villes publiées en France
Moderna. Madrid: Marcial Pons. entre les années 1650 et 1780’, in G. Bertrand,
Bégrand, P., 2004. ‘Signes et Il. Taddei (eds.). 2008. Le destin des rituels.
châtiments, monstres et merveilles: Faire corps dans l’espace urbain, Italie-France-
stratégies discursives dans les "relaciones de Allemagne. Il destino dei rituali « faire corps »
milagros’, in Espagne au XVIIe siècle. nello spazio urbano, Italia-Francia-Germania.
Besançon : Presses universitaires franc- Rome : École Française de Rome, p. 281-300.
comtoises. D`Albis, C. 2009. ‘Sacralización real y
Bernal, G. J., J. 2006. ‘Imagen y nacimiento de una ciudad simbólica: los
palabra: el misterio de la Inmaculada y las traslados de cuerpos reales a Granada, 1504-
solemnidades festivas en Andalucía (siglo 1549’, Chronica nova: Revista de historia
XVII)’, in R. M. Recio, M. Peña Díaz (eds.). moderna de la Universidad de Granada 35
2006. Poder y cultura festiva en la Andalucía (2009), p. 247-266.
moderna. Cordoue: Universidad de Cordoba, Del Vento, Ch., X. Tabet (eds.). 2006.
p. 79-113. Le Mythe de Venise au XIXe siècle. Débats
Boureau, A. 2006. ‘How Christian historiographiques et représentations littéraires.
was the Sacralization of Monarchy in Actes du colloque de Caen (19-20 novembre
Western Europe (Twelfth-Fiftenth 2004). Caen : Presses Universitaires de Caen.
Centuries)?’, in J. Deploige, G. Deneckere Détienne, M. 2001. 'L’art de fonder
(eds.). 2006. Mystifying the Monarch. Studies l’autochtonie', Vingtième Siècle. Revue
on Discourse, Power, and History. Amsterdam: d’histoire 69 (2001), p. 105-110.
Amsterdam University Press, p. 25-34. Détienne, M. 1981. L’invention de la
Boutry, Ph., P. A. Fabre, D. Julia (eds.) mythologie. Paris : Gallimard.
2009. Reliques modernes. Cultes et usages Elliott, J. H. 1977. ‘Self-Perception
chrétiens des corps saints des réformes aux and Decline in Early Seventeenth Century
revolutions. Vol. 1-2. Paris : Editions de Spain’, Past and Present 74 (1977), p. 41-61.
l’EHESS. Escobar, J. C. 2004. 'Granada en la
Breviglieri, M. (ed.) 2009. Compétences historiografía religiosa seicentista: la
critiques et sens de la critique. Paris : Historia Eclesiástica de Bermúdez de
Economica. Pedraza (1639)', in M. Barrios Aguilera, Á.
Cardaillac, L., B. Vincent (1977). Galán Sánchez (eds.). 2004. La historia del
Morisques et Chrétiens, un affrontement reino de Granada a debate : viejos y nuevos temas
polémique. Paris : Klincksiek.

22
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

: perspectivas de estudio. Grenade: Editorial Milhou, Al. 1999. Pouvoir royal et


Actas, p. 705-726. absolutisme dans l’Espagne du XVIe siècle.
Fenlon, I. 2007. The Ceremonial City: Toulouse : Presses Universitaires du Mirail.
History, Memory and Myth in Renaissance Moeglin, J.-M. 2007. ‘« Performative
Venice. New Haven: Yale University Press. turn», «communication politique» et rituels
Girardet, R. 1986. Mythes et au Moyen Âge’. À propos de deux ouvrages
mythologies politiques. Paris: Le Seuil. récents’, Le Moyen Age 2 (2007), p. 393-406.
Grimes, R., 1976. Symbol and Conquest: Muir, E. 1981. Ritual in Renaissance
Public Ritual and Drama in Santa Fe, New Venice. Princeton : Princeton University
Mexico. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. Press.
Harris, K. A. 2007. From Muslim to Pakier, M. (ed.) 2010. A European
Christian Granada: inventing a city's past in memory? : Contested histories and politics of
early modern Spain. Baltimore: John Hopkins remembrance. New York: Berghahn Books.
University Press. Pereda, F. 2007. La imágenes de la
Harris, K. A. 2002. ‘The Sacromonte discordia. Política y poética de la imagen sagrada
and the Geography of the Sacred in Early en la España del 400. Madrid : Marcial Pons.
Modern Granada’, Al-Qantara XXIII/2 (2002), Pulido Serrano, J. I., Injurias a Cristo.
p. 517-543. Religión, política y antijudaísmo en el siglo XVII.
Jacquemier, M. 1999. L’âge d'or du Alcalá de Henares: Universidad de Alcalá de
mythe de Babel, 1480-1600: de la conscience de Henares.
l'altérité à la naissance de la modernité. Mont- Puschner, U., E. François. (eds.) 2010.
de-Marsan: Eds interuniversitaires. Erinnerungstage : Wendepunkte der Geschichte
Kempers, B. 1994. ‘Icons, Altarpieces, von der Antike bis zur Gegenwart. Munich:
and Civic Ritual in Siena Cathedral, 1100- Beck.
1530’, in B. A. Hanawalt, K. L. Reyerson Rucquoi, A. 2003. ‘Les villes
(eds.). 1994. City and Spectacle in Medieval d’Espagne : de l’histoire à la généalogie’, in
Europe. University of Minessota Press, p. 89- H. Brand, P. Monnet, M. Staub (eds.). 2003.
136. Memoria, communitas, civitas. Mémoire et
Koselleck, R. 1989. ‘Social history and conscience urbaines en Occident à la fin du
conceptual history’, International Journal of Moyen Age. Herausgegeben vom Deutschen
Politics, Culture and Society II/3 (1989), p. 308- Historischen Institut Paris, Jan Thorbecke
325. Verlag, p. 145-166.
Ladero Quesada, M. A. (ed.) 1993. La Schmitt, J.-Cl. 2001. Le corps, les rites,
incorporación de Granada a la corona de Castilla. les rêves, le temps. Essais d’anthropologie
Grenade : Diputación de Granada. médiévale. Paris : Gallimard.
Lopez-Guadalupe Muñoz, M., L., J. Torricabras, I. F. 2001. Philippe II et la
José. 1996. Nuestra Señora de las Angustias y su Contre-Réforme, l’Église espagnole à l’heure du
hermandad en la época moderna. Grenade : Ed. Concile de Trente. Paris : Publisud.
Comares. Trexler, E. 1991 (1980). Public Life in
Medina, F. M. 2001. San Cecilio y San Renaissance Florence. Ithaca-Londres: Cornell
Gregorio: patronos de Granada. Grenade: University Press.
Editorial Comares.

23
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Veyne, P. 1983. Les Grecs ont-ils cru à


leurs mythes ? Essai sur l’imagination
constituante. Paris : Seuil.

Cécile d’Albis got her Ph.D. in history from Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales (Paris) and the
University of Granada (Spain). She was a Max Weber fellow at the European University Institute in
Florence, between 2010 and 2011, and got a Fernand Braudel fellowship at Institut für Europäische Geschichte
(Mainz) in 2012. She has published Richelieu. L’essor d’un nouvel équilibre européen at Armand Colin, in 2012.
Cécile d’Albis now lives in Strasburg and teaches history and geography.

24
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

LAURENT CAROZZA, ALBANE BURENS

Le Déluge, les savants et la mer Noire : une nouvelle mythologie


scientifique ?

Abstract:

Noah’s Flood is a narrative structure that has cross ages and civilizations. It is above all a deterministic
posture in our perception of the relationship between societies and their environment. We attempt in this
paper to examine the universal character of the Flood myth, and how some scientists call upon this
mythological structure to justify or dress up their studies. Consequently, we try to observe the causal links
established by some researchers between the history of climate and societies, to explain the origin of the
Noah’s Flood. We seek to understand how scientific discourse was built around the research dedicated to
the incarnation of the place, and how today the use of Earth Sciences to unravel the true of the fake is
carried out. Furthermore, it is particularly interesting to pore over the links between archaeologists -
historians of materiality - and environmental scientists. In this article, we will briefly present our
investigations conducted on the populating of the Black Sea coastline during recent Prehistory, and the
way we evidenced a landscape (more than 7000 years old), nowadays largely submerged by the floodplain
of the Danube delta. Those works have led us to many questions about the existence of a flood in the Black
Sea.

Keywords: Myth, Flood, Black Sea, Archaeology, Neolithic period

«L’histoire du déluge étant la chose la plus miraculeuse dont on ait


jamais entendu parler, il serait insensé de l’expliquer : ce sont de
ces mystères que l’on croit par la foi ; et la foi consiste à croire
ce que la raison ne croit pas»

Voltaire (Dictionnaire philosophique, art. Inondations)

Le déluge : du mythe babylonien au dérèglement climatique

Il est de multiples récits du Déluge, ce civilisations. La punition des hommes et de


mythe originel de la re-création du monde et l’ensemble de la création par la puissance
de la renaissance de l’humanité après la divine en réponse aux fautes commises, et
punition divine. Mais ce récit est-il pour l’engloutissement de l’humanité sous les
autant universel ? Il constitue une structure flots, se retrouvent dans de multiples aires
narrative qui traverse les âges et les culturelles, et non pas dans les seules

25
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

religions monothéistes. Si les sociétés justifier ou donner un habillage à leurs


occidentales ont fréquemment recours aux travaux. Le mythe du déluge ne serait-il
symboles du déluge biblique – on en tiendra alors, de manière plus ou moins consciente,
pour preuve l’importante iconographie et qu’une enveloppe ou un slogan
filmographie disponible – le déluge est le publicitaire destiné à manipuler nos
plus souvent mis en exergue pour signifier et imaginaires ?
justifier des fins de cycles historiques en lien
avec des catastrophes naturelles. Le déluge, l’archéologue et la mer
De nombreuses civilisations ont eu
Noire
recours à cette figure où les éléments
déchainés, fruits de l’intervention divine,
Avant d’entrer dans le vif du sujet, il
éprouvent l’humanité pour mieux justifier
nous a semblé nécessaire de préciser la
son sauvetage et sa renaissance. Mais au-
nature et les motivations de notre démarche.
delà de la forme du récit, de ses origines, de
Lorsque, en 2007, nous avons commencé à
ses transpositions multiples, le mythe du
travailler sur le peuplement du littoral de la
déluge relève avant tout d’une posture
mer Noire au cours de la Préhistoire récente
déterministe dans notre perception de la
– entre 6000 et 4000 ans avant notre ère –,
relation qu’entretiennent les sociétés avec
nous étions loin de penser que nos
leur environnement. L’écho immodéré
recherches trouveraient un écho au dehors
donné aux tenants d’hypothèses
de la communauté des archéologues. Mais la
catastrophistes, à l’image des ouvrages
découverte et la fouille d’un établissement
emblématiques de Jared Diamond55, ne fait
chalcolithique situé au cœur de l’actuel du
qu’entretenir le doute quant aux causes et
delta du Danube, occupé durant le 5ème
conséquences des changements sociaux qui
millénaire avant notre ère, nous ont conduit
se sont produits au cours des derniers
à réfléchir au rôle des modifications paléo-
millénaires. À grand renfort d’arguments
géographiques qui se sont produites en mer
scientifiques, dont il convient parfois
Noire durant l’Holocène, et à leur impact
d’évaluer la pertinence ou les limites,
pour les sociétés56. La mise en évidence d’un
certains chercheurs se sont engouffrés dans
paysage vieux de plus de 7000 ans,
cette faille grande ouverte, quitte à ne plus
aujourd’hui en grande partie submergé par
respecter la distance nécessaire entre les faits
la plaine d’inondation du delta du Danube,
et leur interprétation. Dans un monde
nous a valu de nombreuses questions
contemporain, urbain, où la relation à la
relatives à l’existence d’un déluge en mer
nature s’est distendue et altérée, les effets et
Noire et sa datation à la fin du 5ème
conséquences du changement climatique
millénaire avant notre ère. Étant donné nos
global induisent parfois de repenser les
difficultés à répondre autrement que par une
modèles socio-environnementaux. Dans ce
prise de distance par rapport à ce
contexte, on peut s’interroger sur la manière
questionnement, nous nous sommes
dont certains scientifiques font appels à la
intéressés à l’histoire du mythe du Déluge, et
structure mythologique du déluge pour
plus particulièrement à la manière dont

55 Diamond (2009).
56 Carozza et al. (2012).

26
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

scientifiques et chercheurs abordaient cette il les considère comme un ensemble


question. Notre propos n’est pas d’analyser structuré autour d’unités élémentaires (les
la structure du mythe, mais plutôt mythèmes) et de relations internes et leur
d’observer les liens de causalités établis par attribue une fonction plus symbolique
d’aucuns entre l’histoire du climat et des qu’historique. Il s’agit pour lui du récit
sociétés, pour expliquer l’origine du mythe (fondé sur des éléments du quotidien) de
du Déluge. Pour ces chercheurs, le déluge est faits non réels, immémoriaux, inscrits dans
considéré comme l’expression de la mémoire une dimension collective, et proposant une
collective d’un événement cataclysmique explication pour les contradictions majeures
exceptionnel, incarné par la submersion de de l’existence. Il conteste leur caractère
vastes zones littorales à la fin de la période archaïque et démontre au contraire leur
glaciaire. cohérence structurelle, tout en se donnant
Précisons notre posture. Il est de pour but de comprendre la mécanique de la
multiples manières d’aborder la question du transformation du récit, du passage d’une
mythe et de son universalité. Fondateur de la version à l’autre.
psychologie analytique, Carl Gustav Jung57 Certains historiens de l’Antiquité et
considérait certains archétypes (sortes du Moyen Âge, à l’image de Pierre Vidal-
d’images primordiales) comme le fonds Naquet, Jacques Le Goff et Jean-Pierre
commun de toutes les mythologies, de toutes Vernant, ont accepté les modèles
les cultures, à toutes les époques. structuralistes et ont appliqué ce modèle à
L’archétype renvoie à cette tendance des l’histoire des mentalités comme le soulignent
hommes à recourir à une même forme de Patrick Boucheron et Pierre Kalifa59. Mais le
représentation mentale (mobilisant des préhistorien, prisonnier de la matérialité, est
formes symboliques variées de par le relativement démuni face à cette approche.
monde) issue de l’expérience et conditionnée Si les modèles inspirés des travaux de
par la structure même du cerveau. Dans cette Maurice Godelier relatifs à la pensée
acception, le mythe mobiliserait ces symbolique ont trouvé écho auprès de
archétypes unissant un symbole à une certains archéologues, la question du mythe
émotion, et conditionnant l’imaginaire est restée sous-jacente. On doit cependant
comme la représentation. Mais son travail de aux spécialistes de l’art pariétal d’avoir
mythologie comparée – tout comme, plus emprunté cette voie. Pour Jean-Loïc Le
tard, celui de Mircea Eliade – a laissé de côté Quellec, la posture relève davantage de
les récits mythologiques de continents l’idée « d’emprunts ou d’un héritage
entiers tels l’Afrique, l’Australie ou commun » 60. En s’appuyant sur l’hypothèse
l’Antartique. d’une « origine unique de l’humanité », il se
Dès lors, comment poser comme positionne davantage dans une perspective
axiome l’universalité de certains mythes ? historique et diffusionniste des mythes.
Pour Claude Lévi-Strauss58, les mythes En ce qui nous concerne, nous faisons
constituent autant de transformations d’un nôtre, pour les besoins de cet article, la
même récit. Par son approche structuraliste, définition pragmatique que donnent

57 Jung (2014).
58 Levi-Strauss (2009). 60 Le Quellec (2014), D’Huy et al. (2014).
59 Boucheron, Kalifa (2016).

27
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Boucheron et Kalifa du mythe, soit « un récit tradition hébraïque, serait la tradition


fictif, mais fondateur, mettant en scène des mythique mésopotamienne, largement
personnages surhumains dans des temps diffusée dans le Proche-Orient dès le milieu
reculés, voire transcendants »61. du IIIe millénaire, par le biais de récits gravés
en écriture cunéiforme sur des tablettes
Le déluge : un mythe universel d’argile63. La série la plus complète mais
aussi la plus récente de ces tablettes, trouvée
catastrophiste ?
dans les fouilles de la bibliothèque du roi
Assurbanipal à Ninive, daterait des 8e-7e
Le mythe du Déluge trouve écho
siècles av. J.-C. ; elle met en scène le célèbre
dans de nombreuses cultures, inscrites dans
Gilgamesh, descendant d’Ut-Napishtim,
un vaste cadre spatio-temporel62. Cette
homologue de Noé. Dans cette tradition
multitude de récits, qu’ils soient ou non
mésopotamienne, le récit du Déluge est
considérés comme des textes sacrés, donne
évoqué au sein de plusieurs écrits,
un sens souvent moral à ces crises ou
notamment dans une version sumérienne
événements hydro-climatiques majeurs, tout
datée du IIIe millénaire, une version
particulièrement dans les récits de
babylonienne ancienne qui daterait du début
cataclysmes à valeur universelle, où
du IIe millénaire et une version assyro-
l’ancrage géographique outrepasse le cadre
babylonienne du Ier millénaire. D’autres
local et où la puissance divine sanctionne la
récits, moins détaillés, relèvent de ce même
perversité des hommes par la submersion les
fonds. Le mythe du déluge est repris dans
terres habitables et la destruction des
d’abondants textes grecs64 (Ve s. av. J.-C.) et
hommes et des animaux. La précision ou
latins. Mais sa portée véritablement
l’approximation des ancrages tant
universelle devient tangible à la lecture de
géographiques que chronologiques de ces
récits issus notamment des traditions et
narrations, fruits d’un lent processus de
mythologies iraniennes, hindoues, chinoises,
retranscription puis de consolidation
scandinaves ou encore amérindiennes…
graduelle de récits d’un passé lointain, a
Mythographes, archéologues et
conduit nombre de mythographes,
chercheurs ont ainsi cherché à confronter les
archéologues et historiens à poser un cadre
divers récits d’un Déluge retranscrit tantôt
géographique précis autour de ces
sous la forme d’un cataclysme à portée
événements.
universelle, tantôt sous la forme
Le récit biblique du Déluge, que les
d’événements locaux, d’abord sans les
exégètes s’accorderaient à faire remonter au
ancrer dans un contexte environnemental.
Ier millénaire (l’exégèse biblique
Le livre de la Genèse a livré, au fil
traditionnelle faisant remonter Adam aux
des chapitres 6, 7 et 8, le récit détaillé du
alentours de l’an 5000 et le Déluge a minima
Déluge. Le Dictionnaire de la Bible présente
un millénaire plus tard), trouve des
le Déluge comme le châtiment divin des
correspondances dans maints fonds
crimes et de la perversité des hommes mais
culturels, dont le plus ancien, antérieur à la
aussi comme le moyen de préserver et de

61 Boucheron, Kalifa (2016). 63 Babelon (1891).


62 Lenormant (1837-1883). 64 Grimal (1969).

28
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

reconstituer une nouvelle humanité dans la que cet élu sauve l’humanité par la mise à
vraie foi et les bonnes mœurs65. Au vu de la l’abri de quelques proches et de couples
malice des hommes, Yahvé supprime de la d’animaux à l’intérieur d’une embarcation,
surface de la terre tous les êtres qu’il a crées, une arche, capable de résister au
des humains aux animaux. Seul le déluge déchaînement des éléments.
pouvait éradiquer l’expansion de cette La mythologie grecque relate elle
violence en submergeant la surface de la aussi plusieurs épisodes cataclysmiques. Le
Terre sous des eaux purificatrices, plus ancien, sans doute le moins connu,
éradiquant du fait même les hommes et correspond au Déluge du roi Ogygès,
l’ensemble de la création. Seul Noé trouve fondateur de Thèbes69. Le plus fameux
grâce à ses yeux ; il sera chargé, au retrait des d’entre eux, provoqué par Zeus et présenté
eaux (après 40 jours et 40 nuits de pluie), de comme le dernier des déluges, est celui dit de
repeupler le monde. Le courroux de Yahvé Deucalion (ibid.). Il laisse deux survivants :
semble non seulement provoqué par la Deucalion et Pyrrha, à l’origine d’une
violence des hommes et des animaux qui nouvelle race humaine70 … Ce mythe
commencent à s’entredévorer après que les s’inscrit dans la lignée des traditions
fils d’Elohim (veilleurs / anges) prirent mésopotamiennes relatées dans l’Épopée de
femmes chez les hommes, mais également Gilgamesh (texte rédigé autour des XVIIIe-
par le fait que son esprit ne pourrait rester XVIIe s. av. J.-C.) et de celle d’Atrahasis (récit
inaltéré dans des êtres faits de chair66. compilant les mythes mésopotamiens, daté
La version coranique se distingue de aux environs du XVIIIe s. av. J.-C.). La
celle de l’Ancien Testament par ce qu’elle fait légende du déluge de Deucalion (parfois
référence à un événement local, sans portée présenté comme prince crétois de l’âge du
universelle, impliquant la seule Bronze) sera évoquée à de multiples reprises,
communauté du Prophète Noé67. notamment par Strabon, Aristote, Ovide71 et
Dans la tradition mésopotamienne, sera même associée au raz-de-marée
les multiples récits et poèmes mettent en occasionné par l’éruption volcanique du
scène différents acteurs du Déluge : d’Ut- Santorin et, par Platon, au mythe de la
Napishtim, comme nous l’avons déjà disparition de l’Atlantide72 (Le Timée et le
mentionné ci-dessus, à un Noé sumérien, Critias rédigés au cours du IVe s. av. J-C.).
nommé Ziusidu, évoqué dans texte Au Ier siècle av. J.-C., Diodore de Sicile
remontant au IIIe millénaire …68. Les évoque lui aussi ce mythe, ainsi que le
principales versions du récit s’entrecroisent débordement du Pont Euxin (lac de la mer
et présentent maints parallèles avec les récits Noire) dans la mer grecque, suite au
bibliques : le châtiment des Dieux, lassés par déversement des eaux des nombreux fleuves
le tumulte et la sauvagerie des hommes ; et rivières qui s’y écoulent73.
l’annonce du péril à un homme, dans le but

65 Vigouroux (1912), Dhorme (1986). 70 Pindare, Les odes Olympiques, IX (157-158).


66 Parrot (1952). 71 Ovide, Robert (2001).
67 Coran, LXXIX: 11-12. 72 Platon, Brisson (2008).

68 Babelon (1891), Couteneau (1952), Parrot 73 Diodore de Sicile, Livre V.

(1946 et 1953).
69 Babelon (1891).

29
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

On retrouve encore des évocations Henri Maspero quant à lui souligne, dans les
d’un déluge universel dans les traditions légendes remontant à la Haute Antiquité, les
iraniennes, notamment dans le récit du mentions de récits cosmogoniques mettant
mythe de la création du zoroastrisme en scène un déluge ayant nécessité la
(religion monothéiste de l’Iran ancien) au construction de digues et le creusement de
travers du Bundahishn, ou de l’Avesta, texte canaux censés assécher les marais. Selon
sacré retranscrivant un mythe ancien certains mythes, le monde aurait été
relatant un épisode de catastrophe recouvert d’eau ; le Seigneur d’En Haut
climatique (mauvais hivers porteurs d’un aurait mandé un premier puis un second
froid féroce et mortel) et faisant référence à héros dans le but d’aménager la terre et
un homme juste, Yima, qui, alerté du danger d’enseigner l’agriculture aux hommes.
par le dieu Ahura Mazda, put sauver du L’ancienne civilisation
désastre un certain nombre d’hommes, mésoaméricaine Maya ne fait pas exception
d’animaux et de végétaux. et renvoie au Déluge (notamment sous la
Le fonds culturel hindouiste forme d’une pluie de feu suivie par une pluie
comporte lui aussi des références au Déluge, de ténèbre et par la révolte des végétaux,
notamment dans le Veda (texte sacré animaux et objets domestiques) dans un
hindouiste issu d’une longue tradition orale texte sacré, de tradition précolombienne,
transmise de brahmane à brahmane, daté rédigé à l’époque coloniale76 (le Popol Vuh).
autour du XVe siècle av. J.C.), qui met en Cette cosmogonie maya renvoie elle aussi à
scène le premier homme Manu sauvé par le la punition des hommes de bois (deuxième
premier avatar de Vischnou, Matsya74. des trois races d’hommes) en raison de leur
D’autres références sont mentionnées dans impiété, de leur paresse, frivolité et vanité.
des textes sanskrits extraits de l’épopée Ces derniers périrent ou se transformèrent
Mahabharata, datant des derniers siècles en singes.
avant notre ère (la Bhagavadgita et La cosmogonie scandinave, à
l’Anugita). l’origine d’un système religieux polythéiste
En Chine, des évocations de crues ou ayant présidé à la christianisation, remonte
de hautes eaux n’ayant ni valeur punitive ni au Haut Moyen-Âge. Elle fait elle aussi état
dimension universelle ont été consignées, d’un Déluge engendré par le sang d’Ymir
notamment dans Le « Shiji », (ouvrage de (fondateur de la race des Jötnar occis par
130 volumes relatant l’histoire de la Chine Odin, exaspéré par sa brutalité). Les flots de
depuis l’époque mythique de l’Empereur sang tuèrent les géants, à l’exception du
Jaune, rédigé par l’historien Sima Qian et petit-fils de Ymir et de sa femme, qui
achevé par son fils), tout comme dans le repeuplèrent la Terre77.
« Shanhai Jing » (recueil de légendes de Peu d’auteurs mentionnent un mythe
l’Antiquité chinoise, dont la version du Déluge sur les continents africain et
essentielle relève de la dynastie Han) ou australien. J.-P. Lebeuf78 relaie, chez le
encore dans le Huainan Zi (ensemble de 21 peuple Kotoko d’Afrique Centrale,
chapitres rédigés au IIe siècle av. J.-C.)75. l’existence d’une légende, s’originant de

74 Varenne (2003). 76 Raynaud (2000).


75 Mathieu (1989). 77 Boyer (2012), Guelpa (2009).
78 Lebeuf (1976), 98.

30
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

l’Islam et relayée par le Coran, faisant antérieurement à l’apparition de l’écriture,


allusion à un patriarche réputé être un géant, ce qui a permis le foisonnement des
émergeant des eaux du Déluge. Avec transpositions dans la sphère du religieux.
l’assèchement de la Terre, vint le temps pour Lucian Boia a bien montré que le déluge,
lui de faire sortir les hommes et les animaux constitué en récit universel historicisé, était
de l’arche et de les faire se disperser en une construction destinée, dans le jeu subtil
direction du Nord et de l’Est. D’autres des relations avec les avancées scientifiques,
mentions de l’Arche de Salut existent, à légitimer la véracité du discours biblique82.
notamment chez les peuples Dogon, Le même auteur signale, à juste titre, que le
Bambara et Bozo ; mais nulle mention n’est développement des connaissances tend à
faite d’un quelconque déluge. restreindre l’espace disponible pour
La cosmogonie du peuple aborigène expliquer la survenue d’un cataclysme
fait elle aussi allusion à un Déluge à l’origine universel. Ceci explique peut-être pourquoi,
de la destruction d’un monde « d’avant », aujourd’hui, seule l’origine du déluge
provoquée par un serpent géant qui, en se biblique, telle que transcrite dans la Genèse,
jetant dans la mer, aurait provoqué semble donner lieu à discussions.
d’importantes inondations79. Au cours du siècle des Lumières,
Comme on peut le voir dans la philosophes et intellectuels – aspirant à
plupart de ces récits, le Déluge constitue, dépasser l’obscurantisme et à promouvoir la
dans nombre de cultures, ce que Joannès, en science et les connaissances – nourrissaient
référence aux récits babyloniens, qualifiait pourtant un débat passionné entre tenants
de « point d’origine historicisé de du caractère naturel et tenants du caractère
l’humanité »80. Il marque le passage d’un miraculeux du Déluge biblique. Dans son
temps antédiluvien (sorte de période de analyse de la place accordée aux mythes des
cohabitation entre humains et êtres hybrides origines par les scientifiques du XVIIIe
ou monstrueux) à un temps postdiluvien, où siècle, M.S. Seguin s’efforce « de comprendre
les hommes s’inscrivent dans l’histoire et où pourquoi, au moment où les sciences
« il ne leur reste plus qu’à vivre et écrire une semblent avoir réussi à se libérer de
histoire dont ils soient pleinement l’emprise théologique, l’imaginaire
responsables »81. mythique resurgit avec force, comme s’il
était indissociable de la nature humaine elle-
Quand les scientifiques rencontrent le même »83.
Dans L’homme face au climat, Lucian
mythe : ou l’incarnation du lieu
Boia, citant Nicolas-Antoine Boulanger,
montre qu’avec le siècle des Lumières, au
Le large essaimage des récits relatifs
moment où la sécularisation des esprits
au mythe du Déluge sous-tend, du moins en
conduit à délaisser la thèse biblique, naît
apparence, le caractère « universel » de
l’idée d’un déluge sans Dieu, recentrant ainsi
celui-ci. Comme de nombreux mythes, ce
le propos sur l’événement ; soit le
dernier trouve sa source dans le passé,
cataclysme comme vecteur de rupture. Dès

79 Muecke (2002).
80 Joannès (2016). 82 Boia (2004).
81 Joannès (2016). 83 Seguin (2001), 17.

31
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

lors, à l’image du préhistorien Bouchers de historiens de la matérialité – avec les


Perthes, un lien indéfectible va se tisser entre spécialistes des sciences de l’environnement.
le mythe et les avancées scientifiques. Si l’archéologie moderne a rapidement
Avec l’émergence de la « Théorie de abandonné des postures visant à établir la
la Terre » apparaissent les premières véracité des mythes, les relations des
explications scientifiques du Déluge, et des géosciences avec l’histoire des civilisations
auteurs comme Thomas Brunet84, William sont plus complexes. Tel Indiana Jones
Whiston85 ou John Woodward – qui rompt découvrant l’arche de Noé sur le mont
définitivement avec le cartésianisme86 – vont Ararat, certains spécialistes des géosciences
marquer leur époque. Mais c’est Leibniz qui de l’environnement sortent de leur domaine
minimise le rôle du Déluge et préfigure la de compétence et ambitionnent de dissocier
géologie moderne. À sa suite, les adeptes du le « vrai » du « faux », opérant de la sorte un
rationalisme (laïques) tels Fontenelle puis retour depuis les faits scientifiques vers le
Benoit de Maillet ou Nicolas-Antoine récit mythologique. Cette posture n’est
Boulanger, défendront, avec l’aval de toutefois pas propre au mythe du déluge et
l’Académie des Sciences, la posture aux seules géosciences ; comme le souligne
actualiste face aux rationalistes chrétiens qui, Jean-Paul Demoule, « les mythes qui font
en instrumentalisant la science, glisseront rêver les savants sont aussi tenaces que ceux
vers une conception naturaliste du Déluge dont se bercent les ignorants. Mais ils sont
alors que certains iront même jusqu’à nettement plus dangereux »88.
avancer l’hypothèse d’un Déluge restreint
dans une perspective polygéniste. C’est Archéologie du mythe du Déluge
probablement à Buffon que l’on devra
d’affranchir le discours scientifique de toutes Leonard Woolley, archéologue
spéculations diluvionnistes. britannique qui a fouillé entre 1919 et 1934 la
Dans les faits, il importe de voir citée antique de Ur, située dans l’actuel Irak,
comment les discours scientifiques se sont est probablement le premier à avoir tissé un
construits autour de la recherche de lien direct entre données archéologiques,
l’incarnation du lieu, et la manière dont géomorphologiques et le récit du Déluge
s’opère aujourd’hui le recours aux sciences pour expliquer la crise qui a touché la cité
dites « dures » pour démêler le vrai du faux. antique. Lors de ses fouilles, Woolley
Ici encore, Lucian Boia a montré le rôle identifie une couche argileuse qu’il
moteur joué, jusqu’au début du XIXème interprète comme une phase d’inondation
siècle, par les savants et les naturalistes pour massive, et juge, en s’appuyant sur des
maintenir le Déluge dans l’histoire données ponctuelles, que cet événement
universelle87. pourrait constituer un cataclysme. Dans sa
Dans ce processus, il est publication de 1929, Woolley établit un lien
particulièrement intéressant d’observer les direct entre cet événement, dont il évalue la
liens qu’ont entretenus les archéologues –

84 Telluris Tehoria scara, Londres (1684). 87 Boia (2004), 147.


85 A New Theory of the Earth (1696). 88 Demoule (2014).
86 Essay toward a Natural History of the Earth

(1695).

32
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

portée à « 400 miles long and 100 miles sociales s’est imposée, pour justifier
wide ; but for the occupants of the valley that l’effondrement des sociétés de la fin
was the whole world », et le livre de la troisième millénaire avant notre ère en
Genèse. En établissant ce lien de causalité Mésopotamie. Si le débat est aujourd’hui
entre un changement environnemental et dégagé du récit mythologique, pour se
une crise sociale, Woolley s’expose centrer sur la question de la relation entre
davantage, en déclarant dans les médias changement climatique et crise sociale89, il
anglo-américains que « nous avons n’en demeure pas moins que les modèles
découvert les traces du Déluge… ». Cette déterministes réapparaissent fréquemment.
transgression n’est pas anodine, car elle Ainsi, les recherches réalisées par Harvey
marque, pour la première fois peut-être, Weiss90 sur le tell Leilan en Syrie ont-elles
l’instrumentalisation du mythe et le recours permis à ce chercheur de devenir un leader
aux médias pour sensibiliser le grand public, des hypothèses du rôle majeur tenu par les
dans la perspective non avouée de crises climatiques dans l’histoire des
pérenniser les moyens alloués à sa mission. civilisations. Dégagé de la lecture du mythe
Au début des années 1930, les opérations de qui ne ferait qu’obscurcir son discours, il
terrain se poursuivirent à Ur avec incarne pleinement le rôle de la démarche
l’intervention de Max Mallowan - assistant archéo-environnementale, qui vise
de Woolley jusqu’au début des années 30 et à rencontrer sciences sociales et géosciences
anecdotiquement second époux de Agatha de l’environnement, mais dans une
Christie. Mallowan va multiplier dans la perspective qui reste toujours catastrophiste.
région les fouilles pour réfuter les datations
proposées par Woolley ; mais il ne contestera Le géologue et la mer
pas les hypothèses catastrophistes de ce
dernier. En révoquant le caractère Vu qu’il suppose la submersion
exceptionnel de la crise hydro-sédimentaire d’une partie des terres, les géologues marins
mise en avant par Woolley, Mallowan va se sont particulièrement intéressés au mythe
proposer de dater de la fin du 3ème du Déluge et ont tenté de trouver, au travers
millénaire avant notre ère un autre des événements hydro-climatiques, un lien
événement, jugé par lui de plus grande entre récit et faits. On doit à William Ryan
envergure. d’avoir ouvert ce dossier et suscité nombre
Cet exemple illustre bien la manière de travaux sur la question de la connexion
dont certains scientifiques, dont on pourrait entre la Méditerranée et la mer Noire. Entre
penser que les travaux suffisent à justifier 1960 et 1970, Ryan participe à deux
l’ampleur des résultats obtenus, ont éprouvé campagnes de recherches en mer, dans le
le besoin de donner, par le biais de faits Bosphore et en Méditerranée. Il pressent que
matériels, une incarnation historique au récit cette région a connu des modifications paléo-
mythologique. En proposant de lier les deux géographiques majeures, et va intensifier ses
phénomènes, l’idée d’un lien inextricable travaux en mer Noire aux côtés de Walter
entre changements climatiques et crises Pitman, après la publication de l’article de

89 Kuzucuoglu, Marro (2007).


90 Weiss (2000).

33
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Ross, Degen, Mac Ilvaine 197091, qui datent du 6ème millénaire avant notre ère. Si
décrivent la transition entre les phases les auteurs sont tous les deux des
lacustres et marines de la mer Noire, au scientifiques, spécialistes en géologie
moment de sa reconnexion possible avec la marine, et conduisent des recherches
Méditerranée, soit au début de l’Holocène. publiées dans de revues académiques, la
Cette découverte engendre une structure de l’ouvrage publié en 1998
intensification des travaux de recherche et s’éloigne largement de ce que l’on attend
l’organisation des missions d’un tel exercice, puisqu’il prend la forme
océanographiques dans le but de préciser la d’un recueil de nouvelles ou d’un journal de
nature et la chronologie de cet événement bord. Bien que non archéologues, ces
géologique majeur. derniers vont, à grand renfort de données
Dans le sillage de Ryan et Pitman, archéologiques, donner un cadre social au
André et Denise Capart vont mener une grand cataclysme et à la submersion d’une
recherche engagée et hybride – entre partie du littoral de la mer Noire par les eaux
approche scientifique et convictions – dont le salées de la Méditerranée. Ryan et Pitman
but non dissimulé est de donner un cadre élaborent un scénario fondé sur l’analyse de
spatio-temporel à l’existence d’un déluge en données scientifiques - considérées comme
mer Noire. À l’appui de données solides au moment de leur publication – qui
scientifiques et témoignant d’une grande conduit inexorablement à l’hypothèse que le
érudition, l’ouvrage publié en 1986, intitulé processus bien réel de reconnexion entre la
L’homme et les déluges, aboutit à la conclusion mer Noire et la Méditerranée constituerait la
que le mythe du Déluge s’origine dans les source unique du mythe du déluge biblique.
conséquences de l’élévation mondiale du Les auteurs estiment que la remontée
niveau des océans et à son caractère catastrophique du niveau marin se serait
catastrophiste en mer Noire, suite à la produite il y a 8 400 ans. Par le Bosphore, les
reconnexion entre la Méditerranée et la mer eaux de la Méditerranée se seraient
Noire. Les auteurs interrogent différentes déversées en Mer Noire, élevant celle-ci de
sources – archéologie, géologie, paléo- 100 mètres en 33 ans. On notera la précision
climatologie… – les foisonnent, se de l’affirmation. Ils opèrent alors, selon une
contredisent. La démarche souffre posture propre à certains chercheurs anglo-
d’imprécision. Mais l’intérêt de cet ouvrage américains, un rapprochement entre
est de livrer, sans tabou, une revue des l’hypothèse scientifique et son
hypothèses, travail que ne feront pas Ryan et interprétation, en l’occurrence le mythe du
Pitman lorsqu’ils publieront en 2000 Noah’s Déluge, mythe universel, qu’ils interprètent
flood92. comme évocation d'une inondation
Les deux chercheurs américains exceptionnelle ayant provoqué des
centrent leur propos sur la question de la migrations humaines. Poussées à quitter les
reconnexion, par l’intermédiaire de la mer de rives de la mer Noire, les populations
Marmara et du Bosphore, de la mer Noire néolithiques auraient alors entrepris de
avec la Méditerranée à une période qu’ils grandes migrations, à l’origine de la

91 Ross et al. (1970), 163-165. 92 Ryan et Pitman (2000).

34
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

diffusion du récit dans de multiples port turc de Sinop94. Les données recueillies
directions et de sa retranscription au par cette équipe montrent bien la succession
moment de l’apparition des premières entre un plan d’eau douce, lacustre, auquel
écritures. succède un sédiment caractéristique des
L’ouvrage va, dans un premier milieux marins. Les auteurs proposent de
temps, être accueilli avec enthousiasme tant dater cette transition en années
dans une partie de la sphère scientifique radiocarbones calibrées, dans l’intervalle
qu’auprès du grand public, et certains y compris entre 7460 et 6820 BP (Before
verront la preuve « scientifique » de Present). Ces auteurs, largement ouverts aux
l’existence du déluge. théories « pro déluge » de Ryan et Pitman,
À compter de la fin des années 90, vont adopter une posture des plus originales
nous assistons, sur le terrain scientifique et pour justifier le caractère catastrophiste de
médiatique, à une intensification des cette transition. Arguant d’une
recherches et des débats. Les hypothèses de communication personnelle avec F. Hiebert
Ryan et Pitman vont bénéficier des (dont on ignore la fonction et la nature de
recherches menées par Gilles Lericolais lors l’expertise), les auteurs interprètent
de la campagne en mer franco-roumaine l’absence de données archéologiques
« Blason », campagne à laquelle participe relatives au peuplement de la zone, jusqu’à
Ryan en 1998. La cartographie des fonds une période très récente, comme le fruit de
marins, dressée par l’équipe, ne permet pas l’inscription du cataclysme du Déluge dans
de déceler de paléo-rivages, fait qui est jugé l’inconscient collectif, et la peur d’occuper la
concordant avec les hypothèses d’une région durant des millénaires (jusqu’à 5500
submersion rapide de la plateforme av. J.-C.).
continentale au début de l’Holocène. Cette Les auteurs envisagent également
épopée va faire l’objet d’une couverture que les changements environnementaux
médiatique importante, comme en engendrés par l’inondation n’auraient pas
témoignent les nombreuses coupures de permis aux sociétés néolithiques de
presse aux titres éloquents : Dix mille ans s’adapter aux nouvelles conditions. Malgré
sous les mers ; la fertilité du Déluge ; la faiblesse de l’argumentation, les
Plumbing Black Sea for Proof of the Deluge ; hypothèses catastrophistes en lien avec le
il voit le Déluge dans une carotte…93. Si le déluge vont soulever un énorme intérêt, tant
bien fondé de la démarche de l’équipe auprès du grand public que de la
coordonnée par Gilles Lericolais ne peut pas communauté scientifique. La médiatisation
être remis en cause, comme en témoignent s’intensifie dans les médias : la BBC (1996),
les publications parues dans des revues New Scientist (1997, 2003), le New York Times95
scientifiques réputées, le mythe du Déluge (Wilford 1999, 2001), le Washington Post
semble quant à lui mis en scène pour (1999, 2000), Der Spiegel (2000), National
augmenter l’audience du grand public. Geographic (2001), le Frankfurter Allgemeine
En 1999, une nouvelle campagne en Zeitung (2003)… vont donner une visibilité
mer va être menée par R. Balard, au large du aux hypothèses catastrophistes.

93 http://annuaire.ifremer.fr/cv/16316/#top, 94 Balard et al. (2000).


(Accessed December 2017). 95 Wilford (1999, 2001).

35
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Au vu des résultats obtenus, et pour modèles alternatifs. Au début des années


répondre aux questionnements 2000, de nombreux articles sont publiés pour
chronologiques, une autre campagne en mer réfuter l’hypothèse du flooding. Ces
fut réalisée en 2004 dans le cadre du publications scientifiques témoignent de la
programme européen ASSEMBLAGE densité du débat scientifique96. Mais le débat
coordonné par Gilles Lericolais, avec l’appui peut déborder du cadre scientifique si l’on
du navire d’exploration océanographique s’en tient aux déclarations de W. Ryan
Marion Dufresne. L’intérêt de ces recherches lorsqu’il retranscrit97 une déclaration de
de grande qualité est d’avoir contribué à Yanko-Hombach lors d’une présentation
préciser le calage chronologique et à orale à l’occasion de la réunion annuelle de
caractériser le processus de la transgression la Geological Society of America à Seattle en
marine en mer Noire. Ces auteurs placent le 2003 : « Il est impossible qu'un tel événement
niveau de la mer Noire, au moment où ait pu échapper à des décennies de recherche
s’opère la reconnexion, aux alentours de - soviétique ».
80/100 mètres sous le niveau marin actuel. Si On doit à Valentina Yanko-Hombach
l’on devait retenir cette proposition, une d’avoir mobilisé la communauté
grande partie de la plateforme continentale scientifique. La publication, en 2007, d’un
aurait été découverte au début du ouvrage de synthèse The Black Sea Flood
Néolithique, notamment au large de la Question: Changes in Coastline, Climate, and
Bulgarie et de Roumanie, dans la zone de Human Settlement98 dresse une revue des
l’actuel delta du Danube. Les premiers hypothèses et des données disponibles.
colons néolithiques, dans l’hypothèse encore L’intérêt de cet ouvrage est d’utiliser les
non avérée où la région aurait été données archéologiques pour évaluer le bien
« néolithisée » précocement, auraient été fondé historique de l’impact réel ou fictif
impactés par le phénomène de submersion. d’un tel événement pour les sociétés de la
En l’absence de données archéologiques, les Préhistoire récente99.
données chrono-sédimentaires ne C’est avec adresse que Douglas
permettent pas de présumer de la Bailey a su porter le débat dans le champ des
« rapidité » du phénomène ni de son sciences humaines et montrer que les
caractère catastrophique pour les sociétés de données archéologiques ne pouvaient pas
la Préhistoire récente. être manipulées sans précautions. Si Bailey
Dans le même temps, les opposants admet que les changements paléo-
aux thèses catastrophistes vont se réunir environnementaux jouent un rôle dans
autour de Valentina Yanko-Hombach – l’histoire des communautés humaines du
chercheuse d’origine ukrainienne, début de l’Holocène, il rappelle avec justesse
travaillant au Canada – et se saisir des qu’il est inutile de faire appel à des
arguments des partisans de la submersion événements catastrophistes pour expliquer
rapide en mer Noire pour développer des la diffusion du processus de néolithisation.

96 Aksu et al. (2002a, b), Hiscott et Aksu (2002), 98 Yanko-Hombach (2007), Yanko-Hombach et
Hiscott et al. (2002), Yanko-Hombach et al. al. (2007).
(2002), Chepalyga et al. (2003), Kaplin et 99 Dolukhanov (2007), Anthony (2007), Bailey

Selivanov (2004). (2007).


97 Ryan (2007).

36
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

De la même manière, le recours aux modèles delta du Danube vont dans ce sens. L’étude
déterministes, en établissant des liens de de la formation et de l’abandon du tell
causalités entre changements sociaux et chalcolithique de Taraschina, à Maliuc,
environnementaux, constitue une impasse. occupé durant le 5ème millénaire avant
Bailey renchérit en proposant de changer notre ère101, indique que, sous l’actuel delta
d’échelle, et en observant que, si les du Danube, se trouve un paysage
modifications paléo-géographiques néolithique submergé. L’élévation du niveau
survenues en mer Noire ont eu des marin, au début de l’Holocène, va provoquer
conséquences pour les communautés des changements environnementaux
néolithiques, l’impact de ces changements majeurs, avec la formation de vastes zones
demeure ponctuel au vu des échelles dans humides, la modification du tracé des cours
lesquelles sont inscrits les processus socio- d’eau et du trait de côte. Mais ces
culturels. changements se produisent à une échelle de
Si cet ouvrage ne tranche pas sur les temps longue au regard de la vie des sociétés
différentes hypothèses, il montre clairement humaines, ils s’étalent sur une durée que l’on
l’opposition entre les tenants de la remontée peut évaluer de deux à trois siècles. Cette
rapide du niveau marin et ceux d’une durée est, théoriquement, suffisamment
oscillation du niveau de la mer Noire. Mais longue pour permettre aux sociétés de
d’autres chercheurs adoptent une posture s’adapter, de développer des modèles
plus réservée, minorant l’ampleur du économiques alternatifs, de modifier leur
phénomène. Ainsi, pour Liviu Giosan et ses mode de vie et leur économie. Dans le cas qui
collaborateurs100, le niveau de la mer Noire, nous intéresse, la communauté agro-
avant sa reconnexion avec la Méditerranée, pastorale de Taraschina a tenté de pérenniser
n’aurait été inférieur que de 30 m au niveau son modèle jusqu’à ce que le milieu ne lui
marin actuel, au lieu des 80-100 m proposés permette plus d’exercer ses activités
par d’autres chercheurs. Giosan et ses agricoles, et la contraigne à quitter la zone.
collaborateurs proposent de minimiser Elle aurait tout aussi bien pu choisir de
l’impact de la submersion de la plateforme s’adapter aux nouvelles contraintes
continentale, dont la surface serait réduite, environnementales et développer une
mais également de reconsidérer la économie davantage centrée sur
chronologie du phénomène. En se calant sur l’exploitation des ressources halieutiques.
les courbes de remontées globales du niveau Pourquoi n’y a t’il pas eu d’adaptation ? En
des océans et de donnée issues de carottages, choisissant d’abandonner son territoire, et en
Giosan propose de dater le début de la maintenant son mode de vie, la communauté
remontée du niveau marin vers 7400 BC. Le semble avoir opéré un choix culturel, visant
processus se serait produit de manière lente à privilégier la pérennisation de son système
et progressive, à l’instar du reste de la socio-culturel au détriment d’innovations et
Méditerranée. d’adaptations aux nouvelles contraintes
Les données archéologiques tirées environnementales.
des fouilles que nous conduisons dans le

100 Giosan et al. (2006 ; 2009).


101 Carozza et al. (2012 ; 2013).

37
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Dans ce processus, les changements mythes contemporains sont essentiellement


environnementaux ne constituent qu’un scientifiques, et étroitement liés à la question
facteur aggravant, devant l’incapacité des du changement climatique global. Si les
élites sociales à identifier les causes des recherches menées sur le changement
modifications environnementales, trop climatique débouchent irrévocablement sur
impliquées dans le jeu de la reproduction la conclusion que l’humanité exerce une telle
d’un système social fortement hiérarchisé. pression sur son environnement qu’elle en
Tout porte à croire que la rigidité d’un modifie le fonctionnement, ce constat
système social très codifié occupe une place implique un changement de paradigme. Les
tout aussi importante que celle mythes modernes ne mettent plus en scène
communément attribuée aux forçages de punition divine châtiant la vilenie des
environnementaux pour expliquer les causes hommes, mais au contraire une humanité
des ruptures qui se sont produites à l’échelle sanctionnée par les conséquences de ses
des Balkans, à la fin du 5ème millénaire propres erreurs.
avant notre ère. Si, depuis « L’hiver ou le Déluge » de
Les travaux sur les liens des sociétés Nicols Poussin en passant par Gustave Doré
passées avec leur environnement trouvent ou la célèbre « Scène du Déluge » de
aujourd’hui un écho favorable, tant nos Théodore Géricault, l’art pictural nous livre
sociétés contemporaines sont confrontées à une interprétation réaliste du mythe,
des changements globaux. En construisant l’imaginaire contemporain, de par la
des liens entre passé et avenir, nous diversité des supports de création
participons à l’émergence d’un nouvel disponibles, le met en scène et le réinterprète
imaginaire. à l’image d’une fin du monde inachevée. Le
Déluge exerce un extraordinaire pouvoir de
fascination sur le cinéma contemporain102.
Du Déluge au changement climatique Certaines interprétations sont l’œuvre de
réalisateurs intensément captivés par le récit
global : une nouvelle mythologie
mythique, à l’image du réalisateur américain
scientifique Darren Aronofsky dont le film « Noé », sorti
en 2014, met en scène un Noé charismatique
Il n’est point besoin de rappeler que incarné par l’acteur Russell Crowe.
les mythes modernes jouent un rôle Le film de Darren Aronofsky s’inscrit
extrêmement important dans le dans une trame narrative réaliste, d’un
fonctionnement des sociétés ? Si le mythe du monde déliquescent, où Noé et sa famille
Déluge traverse les siècles, les millénaires et reçoivent la mission de sauver le Monde.
les civilisations, nos sociétés contemporaines Dans le film d’animation « La prophétie des
ne sauraient s’extraire de cette construction. grenouilles », le réalisateur Jacques-Rémy
À la différence près, que, si nombre de ces Gired transpose le déluge dans un monde
récits originels ont été retranscrits sous la enfantin, où les grenouilles, incarnations de
forme de textes sacrés, considérés comme les la figure du scientifique, prédisent quarante
canons des religions monothéistes, les

102 Notre propos n’est pas ici de traiter de on pourra citer pour exemple The bible… in
l’ensemble des films qui abordent ce sujet, et the beginning de John Huston sorti en 1966.

38
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

jours de précipitations. Le salut viendra Références:


d’une chambre à air et de pommes de terre
qui assureront la survie des animaux Anthony, D.W. 2007. ‘Pontic-Caspian
réfugiés dans une arche improvisée. Mesolithic and Early Neolithic societies at
D’autres réalisateurs ont donné libre the time of the Black Sea flood: a small
cours à leur imagination, et livré une image audience and small effects’, in V. Yanko-
personnelle de la déferlante ; on renvoie ici à Hombach et al. (eds.). 2007. The Black Sea
la scène de la lame géante qui provoqua la Flood Question: Changes in Coastline, Climate
destruction de New York dans le film and Human Settlement. Dordrecht: Springer,
« Déluge » de F. Feist, sorti en 1933. p. 515-536.
Le cinéma, comme vecteur de Aksu, A.E., Hiscott, R.N., Mudie, P.J.,
l’imaginaire contemporain, a abondamment Rochon, A., Kaminski, M.A., Abrajano, T.,
utilisé le lien unissant le scientifique au Yasar., D. 2002 (a). ‘Persistent Holocene
cataclysme, comme clé du suspens. Dans le outflow from the Black Sea to the Eastern
film « 2012 » de Roland Emmerich, sorti en Mediterranean contradicts Noah’s Flood
2009, le héro n’est autre qu’un scientifique hypothesis’ GSA Today 12 /5 (2002), p. 4-10.
qui, malgré ses erreurs dans l’établissement Aksu A.E., Hiscott, R.N. Yasar, D.
du calendrier du cataclysme, incarne un Noé Isler, F.I. Marsh S. 2002. (b) ‘Seismic
moderne, à la morale infaillible. Au-delà de stratigraphy of Late Quaternary deposits
l’anecdote, dans un contexte où la culture from the southwestern Black Sea shelf:
scientifique se fait idéologie, force est de evidence for non-catastrophic variations in
s’interroger sur le rôle des médias comme sea-level during the last 10000 years’ Marine
vecteurs de transmission de l’information Geology 190 (2002), p. 61-94.
scientifique103, alors même que l’on sait Babelon, E., ‘La tradition phrygienne
combien l’imaginaire des chercheurs du déluge’ Revue de l'histoire des religions 23
détermine, comme l’a montré Holton104, leur (1891), p. 174-183.
représentation de l’objet étudié. Le recours Bailey, D., 2007. ‘Holocene changes in
répété à la figure du Déluge, comme dans le the level of the black sea: consequences at a
film-documentaire « Before the Flood » de human scale’, in V. Yanko-Hombach et al.
Fisher Stevens105, sorti en 2016, participe de (eds.), 2007. The Black Sea Flood Question:
cette idée que le changement climatique Changes in Coastline, Climate and Human
global s’inscrit dans un registre punitif, et Settlement. Dordrecht: Springer, p. 515-536.
que le progrès scientifique en constitue Ballard, R. D., Coleman, D. F.,
l’unique issue. Rosenberg, G.D., ‘Further evidence of abrupt

103 Wolton (1990). film pour sensibiliser le grand public aux


104 Holton (1981). impacts déjà bien réels du phénomène, et à sa
105 « Nous avons pour ambition de reprendre rapidité. … »
le flambeau d’Al Gore. La situation s’est http://alternatives.blog.lemonde.fr/2016/10/16
aggravée depuis ‘Une Vérité qui Dérange’. /avant-le-deluge-leonardo-di-caprio-cherche-
Lors des élections présidentielles de 2012 le a-mobiliser-les-foules-contre-le-changement-
changement climatique n’a jamais été mis sur climatique/ (Accessed November 2017).
la table. Nous avons donc décidé de faire un

39
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Holocene drowning of the Black Sea shelf’ Change and Old World Collapse. NATO ASI
Marine Geology 170 (2000), p. 253-261. Series, Global Environmental Change, vol.
Boia, L. 2004. L’homme face au climat. 49. Berlin : Springer.
Paris : Les Belles Lettres. Dhorme, E. 1986. La Bible, L’ancien
Boucheron, P., D. Kalifa. 2016. Les Testament I. Paris : Gallimard, Bibliothèque
historiens croient-ils aux mythes. Paris : de la Pléiade.
Publications de la Sorbonne. Demoule, J.-P., 2014. Mais où sont
Boyer, R. 2012. Mythes et religions passés les Indo-Européens ? Le mythe d'origine
scandinaves. Paris : Rive neuve éditions. de l'Occident. Paris : Le Seuil, collection
Capart, A., Capart, D. 1986. L’homme science humaines, La librairie du XXIème
et les déluges. Bruxellles : ed. Hayez, la longue siècle.
vue. D'Huy, J., Le Quellec, J.-L. 2014.
Carozza, J.-M., Carozza, L., C. Micu, ‘Comment reconstruire la préhistoire des
F. Mihail, ‘Landscape change and mythes ? Applications d’outils
archaeological settlements in the lower phylogénétiques à une tradition orale’, in P.
Danube valley and delta from Early Charbonnat, M. Ben Hamed, G. Lecointre.
Neolithic to Chalcolithic time. IGCP 521: 2014. Apparenter la pensée ? Saisir l’évolution et
Caspian-Black Sea–Mediterranean Corridors la phylogénie des concepts savants. Paris :
during the last 30 ka: sea level change and Editions Matériologiques, p. 145-186.
human adaptive strategies’, Selected Papers, Diamond, J., 2009, Effondrement.
Quaternary International 261 (2012), p. 21-31. Comment les sociétés décident de leur disparition
Carozza, J.-M., L. Carozza, C. Micu, ou de leur survie. Paris : Gallimard.
M. Danu, V. Radu, G. Opreanu, C. Haita, Diodore de Sicile, Livre V, 47.
‘Après le Déluge : évolution Demoule, J.-P., ‘La préhistoire et ses
géomorphologique du delta du Danube mythes’. Annales. Économies, Sociétés,
après la reconnexion Mer Noire / Civilisations 37/ 5-6, Le document : Éléments
Méditerranée et ses implications sur le critiques (1982), p. 741-759.
peuplement énéolithique’ Quaternaire 24/4 Dolukhanov, P., Shilik, K. 2007.
(2013), p. 503-512. ‘Environment, sea-level changes, and human
Chepalyga, A. L., V. Yanko- migrations in the northern Pontic area
Hombach, ‘The Late Quaternary history of during late Pleistocene and Holocene times’,
the Black Sea and Eurasian basins: a critical in V. Yanko-Hombach et al. (eds.). 2007. The
overview of the Flood hypotheses’, in Black Sea Flood Question: Changes in Coastline,
Program Abstracts of the International Climate and Human Settlement. Dordrecht:
Conference “The Black Sea Flood: Springer, p. 515-536.
Archaeological and Geological Evidence” Genèse 7, 1-12.
(18-20 October 2003, Columbia University, Giosan, L., Donnely, J.P.,
New York), 2003, p. 10-11. Constantinescu, S., Filip, F., Ovejanu, I.,
Coran, LXXIX : 11-12 Vespremeanu-Stroe, A., Vespremeanu, E.,
Couteneau, G., 1952. Le déluge Duller, G.A.T., ‘Young Danube delta
babylonien. Paris: Payot. documents stable Black Sea level since the
Dalfes, H. N., Kukla, G. Weiss, H. middle Holocene: morphodynamic,
(eds.). 2013. Third Millennium BC Climate

40
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

paleogeographic, and archaeological de Lyon, 5-8 déc. 2005. Varia Anatolica XIX.
implications’ Geology 34/9 (2006), p. 757-760. Paris : De Boccard.
Giosan, L., Filip, F., Constantinescu, Labat, R., Caquot, A., 1970. Les
S., ‘Was the Black Sea catastrophically religions du Proche Orient asiatique. Paris :
flooded in the early Holocene?’ Quaternary Fayard-Denoël.
Science Reviews 28/1-2 (2009), p.1-6. Lebeuf, J.-P., 1976. Études Kotoko.
Grimal, P. 1969. Dictionnaire de la Paris : Mouton.
mythologie grecque et romaine. Paris: Presses Lenormant, F., 1837-1883. Les origines
universitaires. de l’histoire d’après la Bible. Tomes I and II.
Guelpa, P. 2009. Dieux & mythes Lericolais, G., Popescu, I., Guichard,
nordiques, Septentrion. F., Popescu, S., Manolakakis, L., 2007.
Hiscott, R.N., Aksu, A.E., ‘Late ‘Water-level fluctuations in the Black Sea
Quaternary history of the Marmara Sea and since the Last Glacial Maximum’, in V.
Black Sea from high-resolution seismic and Yanko-Hombach et al. (eds.). 2007. The Black
gravity-core studies’ Marine Geology 190/1-2 Sea Flood Question: Changes in Coastline,
(2002), p. 261-282. Climate and Human Settlement. Dordrecht:
Hiscott R.N., Aksu A.E., Yaşar, D., Springer, p. 515-536.
Kaminski, M.A., Mudie, P.J., Kostylev, V.E., Le Quellec, J.-L., ‘Existe t-il des
Mac Donald, J.C., Işler, F.I., Lord, A.R., mythes universels ? Entretien avec Nicolas
‘Deltas south of the Bosphorus Strait record Journet’, in Les grands mythes. Origine,
persistent Black Sea outflow to the Marmara Histoire (2014). Éditions Sciences Humaines,
Sea since ∼10 ka’ Marine Geology 190/1-2 p. 9-14.
(2002), p. 95-118. Levy-Strauss, C. 2009. Mythologiques.
Holton, G. 1981. L’imagination Paris : Plon.
scientifique. Paris : Gallimard. Mathieu, R. 1989. Anthologie des
Joannes, F., 2016. ‘Le Déluge mythes et légendes de la Chine ancienne. Paris :
universel est-il le débit de l’histoire ?’, in D. Gallimard.
Kalifa (ed.) 2016. Les historiens croient-ils aux Muecke, S. et coll. 2002. Les Aborigènes
mythes ? Paris : Publications de la Sorbonne, d'Australie. Paris : Gallimard.
p. 65-77. Ovide, (D. Robert traduction). 2001.
Jung, C. G., 2014, Métamorphoses de Les métamorphoses. Paris : Actes Sud,
l’âme et ses symboles, Le livre de poche. collection Thésaurus.
Kaplin, P.A., Selivanov, A.O., Parrot, A. 1946/1953. Manuel
‘Lateglacial and Holocene sea level changes d’archéologie mésopotamienne. vol. 1-2. Paris :
in semi-enclosed seas of North Eurasia: Albin Michel.
examples from the contrasting Black and Parrot, A., Déluge et arche de Noé.
White Seas’. Palaeogeography, Cahiers D’Archéologie Biblique 1 (1952),
Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 209/1-4 Neuchâtel.
(2004), p. 19-36. Pindare. 1922-1930. Les odes
Kuzucuoglu, C., Marro, C. (ed.). 2007. Olympiques, IX-157-158, traduction A. Puech,
Sociétés humaines et changement climatique à la Paris : Les Belles Lettres.
fin du troisième millénaire : une crise a t-elle eu
lieu en Haute Mésopotamie ? Actes du colloque

41
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Platon, Brisson, L. (traducteur). 2008. Vigouroux, F. (dir.). 1912. Dictionnaire


Critias, Platon, Œuvres complètes, de la Bible. Paris : Letouzey et Ané, t. 2, p.
Flammarion. 1343-1344.
Platon, Brisson, L. (traducteur). 2008. Weiss, H. 2000. ‘Beyond the Younger
Le Timée, Platon, Œuvres complètes, Dryas: Collapse as Adaptation to Abrupt
Flammarion. Climate Change in Ancient West Asia and
Raynaud, G. 2000. Le Popol Vuh : Les the Eastern Mediterranean’, in G. Bawden
dieux, les héros et les hommes de l'ancien and R. M. Reycraft (eds.). 2000.
Guatemala d'après le livre du conseil, Librairie Environmental Disaster and the Archaeology of
d'Amérique et d'Orient Jean Maisonneuve, Human Response. Albuquerque: Maxwell
coll. « Classiques d'Amérique et d'Orient ». Museum of Anthropology, p. 63-74.
Ross, D., Degen, E., Mac Ilvaine, J., Weiss, H., Courty, M.-A.,
‘Black sea sedimentary’ History, Science 170/ Wetterstom, W., Guichard, F., Senior, L.
3954 (1970), p. 163-165. Meadow, R., Curnow, A., ‘The Genesis and
Ryan, W., 2007. ‘Status of the Black Collapse of North Mesopotamian
Sea flood hypothesis’, in V. Yanko-Hombach Civilization’ Science 291 (1993), p. 995-2008.
et al. (eds.). 2007. The Black Sea Flood Question: Wolton, D. 1990. L’éloge du grand
Changes in Coastline, Climate and Human public. Paris: Flammarion.
Settlement. Dordrecht: Springer, p. 515-536. Woolley, C. L. 1929. Ur of the Chaldees:
Ryan, W., Pitman, W. 2000. Noah's A Record of Seven Years of Excavation. London:
Flood: The new scientific discoveries about the Ernest Benn Limited.
event that changed history, Simon & Schuster. Yanko-Hombach, V., 2007.
Ryan, W., Pitman, W. C., Major, C.O., ‘Controversy over Noah’s Flood in the Black
‘An Abrupt drowning in the Black Sea’, Sea: geological and foraminiferal evidence
Marine Geology 138/1-2 (1997), p. 119-126. from the shelf’, in Yanko-Hombach, V.,
Seguin, M.S. 2001. Science et religion Gilbert, A. S., Panin, N. and Dolukhanov, P.
dans la pensée française du XVIIIe siècle : le (eds). 2007. The Black Sea Flood Question:
mythe du Déluge universel. Paris : Honoré Changes in Coastline, Climate and Human
Champion. Settlement. Dordrecht: Springer, p. 149-203.
Varenne, J. 2003. Le Véda, éd. Planète,
Les Deux Océans.

Laurent Carozza est chargé de recherche au CNRS, membre de l’UMR 5602 Géographie de l’Environement.
Archéologue de formation, il a soutenu sa thèse de doctorat à l’EHESS en 1997, au sein de l’Ecole Doctorale
« Anthropologie Sociale et Historique de l’Europe ». Il travaille sur les relations société, climat,
environnement dans des terrains aussi diversifiés que la méditerranée occidentale, le Maghreb, l’Amérique
du sud. Il dirige actuellement la mission archéologique franco-roumaine « Archéologie delta du Danube »
du Ministère Français de l’Europe et des Affaires Etrangères.
Albane Burens est ingénieur de recherche au CNRS, membre de l'UMR 5602 Géographie de
l'Environnement à Toulouse. Archéologue et topographe, elle est responsable de la plateforme 3D de
GEODE. Ses thématiques de recherche sont orientées vers les interactions sociétés/environnements,
l’adaptabilité des sociétés anciennes aux changements sociaux et environnementaux et la technologie
céramique. Elle est membre de la mission archéologique « Archéologie delta du Danube ».

42
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

LEONARDO GREGORATTI

Fighting a Dying Enemy: The Struggle between Rome and the Parthians

Abstract

From the mid-first century BC, when Crassus’s legions suffered a disastrous defeat on the open steppes of
northern Mesopotamia, until the early decades of the third century AD, Rome’s expansionist goals in the
East were fiercely opposed by the Parthians. What is now known about the history and structure of the
Parthian kingdom is mainly based on the incomplete and largely stereotyped accounts given by Roman
and Greek writers of the Imperial Era. Influenced by the attitude of the Classical Greek writers towards the
Persians and by the needs of the Imperial propaganda, they depicted the Arsacid Empire as a weak
opponent, lacking strong leadership and permanently on the brink of collapse as a consequence of internal
struggle. Many modern scholars began to question this perspective. Modern research attempts to abandon
the description that Roman writers offered – that of a weak Oriental empire – trying to set aside the myths
and prejudices which the Europeans shared concerning great kingdoms of the Near East in every period.

Keywords: Parthian Kingdom, Achaemenids, Rome, Ottoman Empire, Greek historiography, Roman
propaganda

According to Sir George Hamilton man, a man who has fallen into a state of
Seymour, the British ambassador to St. decrepitude’106.
Petersburg, it was Nicholas I, Tsar of Russia Four centuries after the fall of
in 1853, in the run up to the Crimean War, Constantinople, the Turkish ‘hordes’ no
who first spoke about the Ottoman Empire longer represented a threat for the European
utilizing the well-known expression ‘sick countries. By that time, the fierce and
man of Europe’. More precisely the Russian dreadful warrior who had previously fought
emperor referring to the Sublime Porte, at Mohács and Vienna, the gates of Western
which was increasingly falling under the world, and had threatened to conquer all of
financial control of the European powers and Christian Europe, had come to be perceived
had lost territory in a series of disastrous as a weak and indolent old man, slowly
wars, stated: ‘It is a sick man, a very sick progressing towards the inevitable end107.

106
In a letter from Sir George Hamilton disputed. What is certain, nevertheless, is that
Seymour to Lord John Russell: the reference to Europe appears to have been
Temperley (1936), 272. Source: Parliamentary added later and may very well have been a
Papers. Accounts and Papers: Thirty-Six journalistic misquotation. The first
Volumes: Eastern Papers, V. Session 31 appearance of the phrase as such is in the New
January-12 August 1854, Vol. LXXI (1854), York Times (12 May 1860).
doc. 1, p. 2. The actual use of the expression 107 Cirakman (2002).

‘sick man’ by the Russian monarch is still

43
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

This idea of a once powerful oriental within the framework of Greek historical
empire now depicted as sick and dying was investigation, there arose a series of tales,
not at all new among Western writers and legends, and pseudo-historical episodes,
historians. In the view of most Western some patently fictitious109. These narrations
observers, the empire built by the Ottoman dealt mainly with the exercise of power, the
Turks on the ruins of the Eastern Roman role of the king and the relationship between
Empire had shared, since its inception, most the sovereign and his court, and were
of the characteristics (or topoi, if one is to use fundamental in developing the Western
literary terminology) which Europeans had ‘mythos’ of the Oriental Empire: a stereotype
ascribed in the course of history to any which, due to the scarcity of local sources or,
Oriental state: the vastness of its domains, more often, due to ignorance concerning the
the exotic luxury, the flaunted opulence, the Oriental world, survived until at least the
despotism, the intrinsic weakness, the nineteenth century.
extreme instability of its monarchs (and of Even though many of the accounts
any form of central authority, for that Herodotus records had no historical
matter), the intermingling of private and foundation110, they were used by later
public life in the secret chambers of the authors to prove the superiority of the Greek
harem, where intrigue, seduction and world in comparison to the Oriental one,
murder constituted natural means of particularly underlining the fact that the
political action. democratic solution – the most original
Exploring the origins of this contribution to world politics made by the
characterization based on sheer prejudice Hellenic culture – was the best and most
and applied to any large kingdom in western successful form of government, standing in
Asia, takes us back in time to the work of stark contrast with the despotism of the
none other than the ‘Father of History’, Eastern monarchs111.
Herodotus, who in his Historiai describes to In this regard, it is significant how the
a Greek audience the history, the culture, the Greek historians represented or, indeed,
customs, and the administrative structure of imagined the way in which the king made
the neighbouring kingdom of Persia, ruled his political decisions and in particular the
by the powerful Achaemenids, the first role of women within the Persian court. As
serious threat to Greek cities coming from early as the reign of Xerxes112 (spurred, no
the East, in other words the ‘other’ par doubt, by his unsuccessful attempt to
excellence. conquer Greece), Hellenic historiographers
Discussing the Greek historians’ began to consider the Achaemenid court as
approach to the Achaemenid state, Arnaldo weakened by luxury and wealth. Persian
Momigliano wrote: “There was no effort to policy and royal decisions were, in the eyes
see what kept the empire together behind the of the Greeks, strongly influenced by palace
administrative façade”108. Thus, from the intrigues113. According to Herodotus, for
very beginnings of Western historiography, example, the political influence of Queen

108 Momigliano (1979). 150. Sancisi-Weerdenburg (1989).


112

109 Sancisi-Weerdenburg (1993), 22. Amestris: Hdt. 9.110-112; Ctesias, FGrH 688
113

110 Snodgrass (1980), 168. F 14 (36, 39, 42-43); F 15 (51, 54-55); Deinon
111 Sancisi-Weerdenburg (1993), 32-33.

44
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Atossa114 on her husband, the Great King sort of ‘decadent portrait’ of the Persian
Darius, was so strong that she was able to Empire. Nonetheless, the historical
induce him to make war on the Greeks, information and in particular the references
because she wanted to have Attic, Argive, to luxury, pomp, alcoholism, polygamy, and
and Corinthian maidservants115. court conflicts contained in his work were
In Herodotus, the desire for power of predominantly used by later writers to
the Persian queens was linked to the depict the Persians as a society in full decay,
stereotypical idea which the Greeks had who lost the austerity and the strength they
about Oriental despotism. Those women had when Cyrus had founded the empire118.
could be strong because the kings, their For Plato, the balance between royal power
husbands and sons, were weak. Herodotus’ and slavery on the one hand and freedom on
so called ‘harem tales’, i.e. episodes of court the other, which had been preserved by
life featuring merciless queens as Cyrus, had been gradually lost under his
protagonists, suggested to the Hellenic successors119. The princes of the Persian court
reader that a state where women wielded had been educated in luxury and indolence
such influence on the kings could not be a since Xerxes’ time, that is to say, since the
properly ruled state116. The Persians women of the court had assumed
described by Herodotus and Ctesias (a Greek responsibility for educating the future
physician who lived and worked at the Great leaders120.
King’s court)117 were decadent because they According to Xenophon, a problem of
let their women have a voice in political education was also the basis of the alleged
affairs. A state ruled by women instead of military decadence of the Persians during
men, the Greeks reasoned, could not be a the 4th century BC121. The Achaemenids were
healthy state. This was the main symptom of no longer able to plan a military campaign
the decaying condition in which the without employing Greek mercenaries122.
Achaemenid Empire found itself: a state Preferring to live in the luxury and opulence
once powerful, feared and healthy, was now typical of the ‘Medes’123 they gave up
weak and diseased. training as warriors through hunting and
It would be going too far to ascribe to physical exercises124, resulting in their
Herodotus the intentional invention of this military inferiority, a topic picked up again

FGrH 690 F 15b; D1 105; Plut., Art., 14.10; 16.1; 118 Bichler and Rollinger (2000), 223-227 and
17.1; 19.2-3; 23.1. 269-277; Bichler and Rollinger (2000), 87-90;
114 Hdt., 7.69.2; Hdt., 7.3.2; Schmitt, Atossa, Bichler and Rollinger (2002); Rollinger (2004).
(1987), p. 13-14; Tourraix (1976), 377-380; 119 Plato, Leges, 3.693c – 697e.

Sancisi-Weerdenburg (1993), 25. 120 Plato, Leges, 3.697c – 698a; Briant (1989), 33-

115 Hdt., 3.134.1; Sancisi-Weerdenburg (1993), 34.


24-25; Brosius (1996), 107. 121 An idea already present in Herodotus, for

116 Sancisi-Weerdenburg (1993), 22. example in 5.49-50, where Persian military


117 Ctesias, FGrH 688 F 15 (48-50); Auberger weakness is put in direct relation with their
(1993), 263-267; Brosius (1996), 100-112; legendary wealth; Briant (1989), 38.
Lenfant, (1996), 348-80. 122 Xen., Cyr., 8.8. 22; 24-27; Briant (1989), 35.

123 Xen., Cyr., 8.8. 15.

124 Xen., Cyr., 8.8. 8-12; 16-17.

45
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

by the Athenian rhetorician Isocrates, a great Armenian king had expelled them from their
supporter of pan-Hellenism and a vociferous last Syrian possessions. Rome inherited the
promoter of the war against the Great Seleucid territory and its enemies as well.
King125. These included, beyond the Euphrates, the
It seems clear that the main purpose Parthians, who were forced to abandon their
of Plato, Xenophon and Isocrates was not to plans of conquering Syria and reaching the
provide a reliable historical portrait. Their Mediterranean coast after Rome’s
intentions were, of course, ideological. So intervention127.
their description of the Persian reality was In 53 BC, Crassus’s legions suffered a
conceived in order to better explain and disastrous defeat in northern Mesopotamia.
show their political ideas and their message. From that time until the early decades of the
For these authors, dealing with Achaemenid third century AD, Rome’s expansionist goals
policy was a merely a rhetorical device, an in the East were fiercely opposed by the
instrument they deployed to make more Parthians. The kingdom of the Parthians was
convincing their speeches concerning established a few decades after Alexander’s
contemporary Greek policy. death, in central Asia, close to the remotest
New approaches to Persian history, borders of the Seleucid Empire. Its monarchs
recuperating local, Oriental sources, helped were members of the Arsacid dynasty and
establish that the Achaemenid Empire was were able to gain the best advantages from
not the ‘sick’ state described by many Greek the weakening of the house of Seleucos and
writers at any point in the fourth century, not the consequent disintegration of that huge
even in 334 BC, when Alexander launched Hellenistic state. They managed to spread
his Oriental expedition. their control over large territories of
About five centuries later, another Southern Asia. The Parthian heavy cavalry,
Western power, the Roman Empire, was after overrunning the whole of the Iranian
once again facing a powerful Oriental plateau, Babylonia and Mesopotamia,
enemy: the Parthians126. In the war against stopped on the Eastern bank of the
two of Rome’s most dangerous enemies, Euphrates River, which was to remain the
Mithridates, King of Pontus, and his ally Western limit of Arsacid expansion. For
Tigranes of Armenia, Pompey the Great more than three centuries, the Euphrates
occupied Syria (first century BC), thus constituted the dividing line between two
dealing the coup de grace to the Seleucid superpowers struggling for supremacy in
dynasty, which had been severely weakened western Asia: Rome and Parthia128.
when, just a few years previously, the

125 Isocr., Paneg., 4.141; 150-151; 162; 165; 184; fundamental: Millar (1993); Sartre (2001). Also
Philipp., 5.126 ; followed by Arr., Anab., 3.22.2- useful: Ball (2000); Butcher (2003).
3; Briant (1989), 36-38. 128 As described by Velleius Paterculus,

126 In general on the history of the Parthian witness of the meeting on an island in the
Kingdom: Debevoise (1938); Schippmann middle of the river between Gaius Caesar and
(1980); Bivar (1983), 21-99; Dabrowa (1983); the Parthian Great King Phraates V (1/2 AD);
Frye (1984); Wolski (1993); Wiesehöfer (1994). Velleius Paterculus, 2.101.2-3; Cassius Dio, 55.
127 Plutarh, Pomp., 39.3. In general on the 10.18-19; Suetonius, Tiberius, 12.2; Orosius
Roman presence in the East, see the Adversum Paganos, 7.3.4; Ziegler (1964), 53-54;

46
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Tacitus, Cassius Dio and Plutarch Tiridates, the Arsacid prince who travelled
have dedicated large portions of their works from Parthia to Rome in order to be
to the narrative of Rome’s policy in the East, confirmed on the throne of Armenia by
dealing in detail with the events connected Emperor Nero132, caught the imagination of
with the difficult cohabitation with the the contemporary Romans and found a place
‘barbarians’ beyond the Euphrates and with in the chronicles of later historians.
the struggle for supremacy in Western Asia. Recurring references to Arsacid wealth,
Due to the general scarcity of Parthian (and, luxurious banquets and clothing can be also
in general, Oriental sources), our knowledge found in the works of Pompeius Trogus133,
of the Parthian kingdom and its Tacitus134, Philostratus135, and Herodian136.
administrative structure depends almost Other common features attributed to the
exclusively on the stereotyped accounts Parthians were the despotism of their
drawn up by Roman and Greek writers. kings137, their insatiable sexual appetite138,
Unfortunately, they were interested almost and political instability139: all of these
exclusively in the Arsacid provinces closest elements had already been attributed to the
to the Roman borders and in the historical Persian monarchs by Greek writers.
episodes more closely connected with Roman historians were faced with a
Rome’s policy129. difficult task: having to provide the Western
Charlotte Lerouge’s recent work, public with a representation of the only
L'image des Parthes dans le monde gréco-romain people daring to challenge Rome’s
demonstrated that the Roman concept of the supremacy over the whole known world.
Arsacid kingdom and its inhabitants, its They found that the best solution was to
organization and culture, is a réchauffé provide a moral representation of the
utilising several of those same old elements, Parthians using the same stereotypes which
which had been previously ascribed by the Greeks had conceived and handed down
Classical Greek historians to their Persian with regard to their enemies. A series of
enemies130. In this context, the Parthians, familiar ethnographic topoi were picked up
much like the Achaemenids five centuries and amalgamated in order to create a new
before, were described as a decadent people, artificial model for the Parthian people140.
addicted to luxury and pleasure. Nonetheless, such a model proved useful in
The fabulous retinues of men, describing to the Romans this exotic people,
animals and carriages which accompanied capable of building a kingdom which, unlike
General Surena on the field of Carrhae131 and all the others, Rome was not immediately

Zetzel, (1970), 259-266; Romer, (1974), 171- 135 Philostr., Ap. Tyana, 1.25; 30; 33-34.
173; Luther (2010), 103-127. 136 Herod., 3.4.8; 9.11; 4.10.4; 11.3; 11.6; 15.3;
129 For the sources concerning the history of Lerouge (2007), p. 450.
the Parthian Kingdom: Wiesehöfer (1998) and 137 Just., 41.3.9; Plut., Luc., 21.5-6; Tac., Ann.,

the recent Hack, Jacobs and Weber (2010). 12.10.2.


130 Lerouge (2007), 349-363. 138 Just., 41.3.1; Plut., Crass., 21.7; Joseph.,

131 Plut., Crass., 21.6-9. B.Iud., 7.247.


132 Cassius Dio, 62.1-2. 139 Just., 42.4.1-4; 5.1-2.

133 Just., 41.2.4. 140 Lerouge (2007), 262-267.

134 Tac., Ann., 2.57.

47
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

able to subjugate, a kingdom which forced one hand, the Oriental families were always
the greatest empire of that time to engaged in the struggle against nomadic
compromise. invaders from Central Asia; on the other
Similarly to what happened to the hand, the Mesopotamian families were
Persians after they failed to conquer Greece, connected with the Greek urban aristocracy
the Parthians also began to be described as a and were well-disposed towards a
weak and inconstant people, after the defeat settlement with Rome. Both groups were
the Romans suffered at Carrhae (53 BC), interested in weakening the crown in order
when the leadership of the universal Roman to extend their own power and to
state was forced to admit the existence of consolidate their independence from the
something beyond Rome. The needs of king141.
imperial propaganda thus imposed an ideal The Roman chroniclers failed to
representation of ‘the other’: the Parthian understand the causes of this internal
state could not be allowed to be perceived as struggle, preferring to adopt a more
a viable political alternative. superficial explanation, based on well-
The Parthians, the Oriental enemies, known stereotypes regarding the Oriental
were thus for the Roman historians the ‘New barbarians. Tacitus’ words concerning the
Persians’, heirs of the Achaemenids in the Parthian attitude towards their kings, for
East, while the Roman Empire stood as the example, appear significant in this regard.
defender of the Western culture, much like After the end of the reign of King Phraates (4
the Athenians of old. AD) some Parthian nobles sent envoys to
Unlike the Persian Empire, which Rome in order to ask Augustus to send as
experienced a period of economic prosperity new king Vonones, one of the Arsacid
just after the Greek wars, at the beginning of princes since many years living in Rome (6-8
the first century AD, the Arsacid Empire AD)142. Tacitus states: “The barbarians
reached the peak of a long-lasting condition received him joyfully, as is usual with new
of social and institutional instability. The rulers. Soon they felt shame at Parthians
Parthian aristocracy succeeded in overriding having become degenerate, at having sought
the King’s authority. Monarchs were a king from another realm”143. Great King
maintained with the only intent of providing Artabanus II was well aware of this mental
a formal legitimacy for the power gained by attitude of the Parthians toward their rulers.
one or the other among the aristocratic After being overthrown by a coup d'état
groups. Parthia was torn by the competition supported by Roman authorities (35-36
between the two main noble factions: on the AD)144, he sought refuge by fleeing to the

141 Wolski (1980), 141; Wolski (1981/1984), 13- 45; Frye (1984), 237; Sellwood (1980), typ. 60,
21; Boyce (1994), 241-251. 194-195; Wolski (1993), 150.
142 Joseph., A.Iud., 18.46-47; Suet., Tib., 16.1; Res 143 Tac., Ann., 2.1-2: Et accepere barbari laetantes

Gestae 33; Tac. Ann., 2.1-3; 6.36 and 6.42; Cass. , ut ferme ad nova imperia. mox subiit pudor:
Dio, 40.15.3-4; Debevoise (1938), 151; degeneravisse Parthos; petitum alio ex orbe regem
Kahrstedt (1950), 17-18; Ziegler (1964), 56; […].
Pani (1972), 125; Angeli Bertinelli (1979), 53; 144 Tac., Ann., 6.36-37; Schippmann (1980), 52;

Schippmann (1980), 49; Dąbrowa (1983), 44- Bivar (1983), 73-74; Dąbrowa (1983), 90-91;

48
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

easternmost provinces of the empire hoping treacherous and unable to consolidate a


that “the Parthians, who do not hate the ruler kingdom always on the brink to collapse149.
who is afar, but are ever ready to betray him According to the Romans, the reality could
who is near at hand, might come to regret not be different: the Parthian kingdom was
their previous deeds”145. At a later time, weak because the nature of its monarchs and
Caius Cassius Longinus, governor of Syria, subjects was weak.
was commissioned to escort the young Such a short-sighted approach did
prince Meherdates (49 AD) to the bank of the not allow Western historians to understand
Euphrates146. Having encamped at Zeugma, the transformations which took place within
where the river was most easily fordable, the Parthian society starting from the second
they awaited the arrival of the chief men of half of the first century AD. Vologaeses I,
Parthia and of Acbarus (Abgar), king of the who ruled from 51 AD, was able to
Arabs. There, the governor “reminded strengthen the Crown’s presence across the
Meherdates that the impulsive enthusiasm land and the trade routes, effectively
of barbarians soon flags from delay or even eliminating the overwhelming influence of
changes into treachery, and that therefore he the aristocracy150. By making his two
should urge on his enterprise”147. In fact, in brothers, monarchs in Armenia and in Media
the course of the Eastern campaign, Izates Atropatene, associates to the throne, he
king of the Adiabeni and then Abgar of the conferred stability to the top of the state
Arabs deserted with their troops, “with their structure, setting the foundation for the
countrymen's characteristic fickleness”, writes success of his rule. From this time on, the
Tacitus, “confirming previous experience, royal institution was able to face any
that barbarians prefer to seek a king from situation of international crisis.
Rome rather than to keep him”148. Over the course of the following 170
Tacitus’ point of view demonstrates years of almost incessant confrontation,
that the Roman explanation for the condition Rome tried several times to cross the
of political crisis in Parthia was ascribed to boundary of the Euphrates in order to extend
the very nature of the ‘barbarians’. In the its power and influence over Armenia and
absence of a real historical investigation, the Mesopotamia and deprive its rival of these
temporary weakness of the Arsacids was strategic areas. Vologaeses was able to defeat
seen as a natural consequence of their the Romans after a long war in Armenia and
whimsical and inconstant nature. The his successors managed to oppose all
Parthians were seen to be politically military campaigns which the Emperors
unstable, because they were unfaithful, launched against the heart of the Parthian

Dąbrowa (1989), 317-318; Wolski (1993), 161; 148 Tac., Ann., 12.14: levitate gentili, et quia
Olbrycht (1998), 151-155. exprimentis cognitum est barbaros malle Roma
145 Tac., Ann., 6.36. petere reges quam habere.
146 Tac., Ann., 12.10-14; Bivar (1983), 76-77; 149 Lerouge (2007), 267-270.

Dąbrowa (1983), 121-122. 150 Košelenko (1971), 761-765; Chaumont

147 Tac., Ann., 12.12: Cassius […]monet (1974), 75-81; Keall (1975), 623-624; Chaumont
Meherdaten barbarorum impetus acres (1976), 124; Frye (1984), 227-228; Dąbrowa
cunctatione languescere aut in perfidiam mutari: (1991), 150-153; Olbrycht (1998), 129-130.
ita urguere coepta.

49
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

kingdom. Parthia managed to resist the Bichler, R., R. Rollinger. 2000.


Romans at the maximum of their power Herodot: Eine Einführung. Hildesheim,
without crumbling to pieces. Zurich, and New York.
It seems clear that the long-lived Bichler, R., R. Rollinger, ‘Greece VI.
propagandistic myth of the intrinsic The Image of Persia and Persian in Greek
weakness of all Oriental empires caused the Literature’, Encyclopaedia Iranica, XI/3
Romans to underestimate their oriental (2002)(http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles
adversary's capacity for recovery. The same /greece-v, retrieved 17.02.2012)
mistakes were repeated many centuries later Bivar David A., ‘The Political History
in the years following the First World War, of Iran under the Arsacids’, in E. Yarshater
by European powers eager to share the (ed.). 1983. The Cambridge History of Iran, The
spoils of an Ottoman empire which had been Seleucid, Parthian and Sasanian Periods, III/1.
‘sick’ for a long time, but was perhaps too Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, p.
hastily declared dead151. 21-99.
Boyce, M., ‘The sedentary Arsacids’
Iranica Antiqua 29 (1994), p. 241-251.
References : Briant, P., ‘Histoire et idéologie: Les
Grecs et la ‘décadence perse’, in M.-M.
Angeli Bertinelli, G. 1979. Roma e Mactoux and E. Geny (eds.). Mélange Pierre
l’Oriente. Strategia, economia, società e cultura Lévêque II: Anthropologie et société. 1989.
nelle relazioni politiche fra Roma, la Giudea e Paris : Les Belles Lettres, p. 33-47.
l’Iran. Problemi e Ricerche di Storia Antica 7. Brosius, M. 1996. Women in Ancient
Roma : L'Erma di Bretschneider. Persia (539-331 BC). Oxford: Clarendon
Auberger, J. ‘Ctésias et les femmes’, Press.
Dialogues d’histoire ancienne 19 (1993), p. 253- Butcher, K. 2003. Roman Syria and the
272. Near East. Los Angeles: J. Paul Getty
Ball, W. 2000. Rome in the East. The Museum .
transformation of an empire. London/New Chaumont, M.-L., ‘Études d’histoire
York: Routledge. parthe III. Les villes fondées par les
Bichler, R. 2000. Herodots Welt: Der Vologèse’ Syria 51 (1974), p. 75-89.
Aufbau der Historie am Bild der fremden Länder Chaumont, M.-L., ‘L'Arménie entre
und Völker, ihrer Zivilisation und ihrer Rome et l'Iran I. De l'avènement d'Auguste à
Geschichte, Antike in der Moderne. Berlin: l'avènement de Dioclétien’, in Aufstieg und
Akademie Verlag. Niedergang der römischen Welt, II, 9, 1. 1976.
Berlin-New York: Ed. Temporini, H. &
Haase, p. 71-194.

151
This article was initialy published in Myth Ghi%C5%A3%C4%83-ed-Myth-Making-and-
Making and Myth Breaking in History and the Myth-Breaking-in-History-and-the-
Humanities. … edited by Claudia-Florentina Humanities-pdf (accessed on 1st of May 2018)
Dobre, Ionuț Epurescu-Pascovici, Cristian
Emilian Ghiță.
https://www.scribd.com/document/35911423
2/C-F-Dobre-I-Epurescu-Pascovici-C-E-

50
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Cirakman, A. 2002. From the "Terror of Lenfant, D., ‘Ctésias et Hérodote ou


the World" to the "Sick Man of Europe": les réécritures de l’histoire dans la Perse
European Images of Ottoman Empire and Society achéménide’ Revue des études grecques 109
from the Sixteenth Century to the Ninetenth. (1996), p. 348-380.
New York-Wahington-Bern : Peter Lang. Lerouge, Ch. 2007. L'image des Parthes
Dąbrowa, E. 1983. La politique de l’état dans le monde gréco-romain. Du début du Ier
parthe à l’égard de Rome – d’Artaban II à siècle av. J.-C. jusqu'à la fin du Haut-Empire
Vologèse I (ca 11 – ca 79 de n. è.) et les facteurs romain (Oriens et Occidens 17). Stuttgart:
qui la conditionnaient. Kraków : Uniwersytet Steiner.
Jagiellonski. Luther, A. ‘Zum Orientfeldzug des
Dąbrowa, E., ‘Les héros de luttes Gaius Caesar’, Gymnasium 117 (2010), p. 103-
politiques dans l’état parthe dans la 127.
première moitié du Ier siècle de notre ère’ Millar, F. 1993. The Roman Near East
Iranica Antiqua 24 (1989), p. 311-322 (31 BC – AD 337). Cambridge: Harvard.
Dąbrowa, E., ‘Die Politik der University Press.
Arsakiden auf dem Gebiet des südlichen Momigliano, A., ‘Persian Empire and
Mesopotamiens und im Becken des the Greek Freedom’, in Ryan A. (ed.). The
Persischen Meerbusens in der zweiten Hälfte Idea of Freedom. Essays in Honour of Isaiah
des I. Jahrhunderts n. Chr.’ Mesopotamia Berlin. 1979. Oxford: Oxford University
XXVI (1991), p. 141-153. Press, p. 139-151.
Debevoise, N. C. 1938. A Political Olbrycht, M. ‘Das Arsakidenreich
History of Parthia. Chicago: University zwischen der mediterranen Welt und
of Chicago Press. Innerasien, Bemerkungen zur politischen
Frye, R. N. 1984. The History of Ancient Strategie der Arsakiden von Vologases I. bis
Iran. München: Beck. zum Herrschaftsantritt des Vologases III.
Hackl, U., B. Jacobs, D. Weber (50-147 n. Chr.)’, in E. Dąbrowa (ed.). Ancient
2010. Quellen zur Geschichte des Partherreiches. Iran and the Mediterranean World. Proceedings
Göttingen: Vandenhoeck und Ruprecht. of an international conference in honour of
Kahrstedt, U. 1950. Artabanos III. und Professor J. Wolski held at the Jagiellonian
seine Erben (Dissertationes Bernenses I 2). University, Cracow, in September 1996. 1998.
Bern: A. Francke. Kraków : Uniwersytet Jagiellonski, p. 123-
Keall, E., ‘Parthian Nippur and 159.
Vologases’ Southern Strategy: A Olbrycht, M. 1998. Parthia et ulteriores
Hypothesis’, Journal of the gentes. Die politischen Beziehungen zwischen
American Oriental Society 95 (1975), p. 620- dem arsakidischen Iran und den Nomaden der
632. eurasischen Steppen. München: Quellen und
Košelenko, G. ‘La politique Forschungen zur Antiken Welt.
commerciale des Arsacides et les villes Pani, M. 1972. Roma e i re d’Oriente da
grecques’, in A. Giuffrè (ed.), Studi in onore di Augusto a Tiberio (Cappadocia, Armenia, Media
Edoardo Volterra, I. 1971. Milano : Fac. di Atropatene). Bari: Ariatica.
Giurisprudenza della Univ. Di Roma, p. 761- Rollinger R., ‘Herodotus’,
765. Encyclopaedia Iranica XII/3, (2004), p. 254-288,

51
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

(http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/hero Temperley, H. 1936. England and the


dotus, retrieved 17.02.2012). Near East: The Crimea. London : Longmans
Romer, F. E. 1974. G. and L. Caesar in Green.
the East. Thesis (Ph.D.) - Dept. of Classics. Tourraix, Al. ‘La femme et le pouvoir
Stanford. chez Hérodote’ Dialogues d’histoire ancienne 2
Sancisi-Weerdenburg, H. ‘The (1976), p. 369-386.
Personality of Xerxes, King of Kings’, in L. Wiesehöfer, J. 1994. Das antike Persien.
de Meyer, E. Haerinck, (eds.), Archaeologica Von 550 v. Chr. bis 650 n. Chr. München-
iranica et orientalis: Miscellanea inhonorem Zürich : Albatros.
Louis Vanden Berghe, vol. 1. 1989. Gent: Wiesehöfer, J. 1998. Das Partherreich
Peeters Presse, p. 549-561. und seine Zeugnisse, Beiträge des
Sancisi-Weerdenburg, H., ‘Exit internationalen Colloquiums. Eutin (27.-30. Juni
Atossa: Images of Women in Greek 1996). Stuttgart : Franz Steiner Verlag.
Historiography on Persia’, in A. Cameron Wolski, J., ‘Les sources de l’époque
and A. Kuhrt (eds.). 1993. Women in hellénistique et parthe de l’histoire de l’Iran.
Antiquity. London : Routledge, p. 20-33. Difficultés de leur interprétation et
Sartre, M. 2001. D'Alexandre à Zénobie. problèmes de leur évaluation’ Acta Antiqua
Histoire du Levant antique, IVème siècle av. J.-C. - Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae 28 (1980),
IIIème siècle ap. J.-C. Paris : Fayard. p. 137-145.
Schippmann, K. 1980. Grundzüge der Wolski, J., ‘La périodisation de
parthischen Geschichte. Darmstadt: l’époque parthe en Iran’ Folia Orientalia 22
Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft. (1981/1984), p. 13-21.
Schmitt, R. ‘Atossa’, Encyclopaedia Wolski, J. 1993. L’Empire des Arsacides
Iranica, III/1, New York, (1987), p. 13-14, (Acta Iranica 32). Leuven: Peeters, 1993.
(http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/atoss Zetzel, J. E.G., ‘New Light on Gaius
a-achaemenid-queen retrieved 17.02.2012) Caesar's Eastern Campaign’. Greek, Roman
Sellwood, D. 1980. An Introduction to and Byzantine Studies 11 (1970), p. 259-266.
the Coinage of Parthia. London: Spink & Son. Ziegler, K.-H. 1964. Die Beziehungen
Snodgrass, A. 1980. Archaic Greece, the zwischen Rom und dem Partherreich. Ein Beitrag
Age of Experiment. London: J M Dent & Sons zur Geschichte des Völkerrechts. Wiesbaden:
Ltd. Steiner.

Leonardo Gregoratti was educated at the Universities of Udine (Italy) and Trier (Germany). He has
conducted research in Udine, Trier, Kiel and Bergen. In 2013 he began his collaboration with the
Department of Classics and Ancient History of Durham University as IAS Fellow. His research interests
include Roman History, the history of Western Asia, in particular the Roman Near East, Palmyra, and the
Parthian Kingdom. He collaborated with the archaeological missions conducted by Udine University in
Syria and Iraq.

52
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

ELITSA STOILOVA

Food, Myths and Authenticity

Abstract

This paper aims at tracing the use of myths in the process of authentication of local food and their
promotion by means of food related festivals. To understand the use of food festivals as connected to local
identity, this research explores how particular food items have come to signify an authentic foodstuff, and
how it has come to represent the taste of a particular place, designated as its homeland. ‘Home’ is thus
interpreted as an imagined place, a place that surfaces by means of discourses made up of geographical
indications that imply a process of meaning and myth-making. I am exploring in a critical manner festivals
related to food and drinks, in their Bulgarian context. I am questioning the very process of valuation of
food and food technologies as genuine for a certain region. Another question that the research intends to
answer is how authenticity is powered by mythologized allegations of origin, justifying the connection
food-place-traditions.

Keywords: Festivals, Local Food, Bulgaria, Authenticity, Mythologisation

Introduction152 for regional development. In particular, I


will examine how a food product can be
constructed as typically local, with unique
This paper is based on a case study of characteristics, distinguishing it from other
the annual Festival of Red Peppers, similar food products. I will argue that this
Tomatoes, Traditional Food and Crafts process of food authentication is powered by
organized in the village of Kurtovo re-invented traditions justified trough local
Konare153. The festival in question is myth-making. To explore these issues, this
representative for the study of the strategies article investigates how Kurtovska Kapia
for (re)invention of traditions and their use Pepper and Kurtovo Konare Pink Tomato154

152The research was funded by the Advanced production and canning industry. After the
Academia Programme 2016-2017, launched political and economic changes, Kurtovo
by the Center for Advanced Studies, Sofia, Konare fought for its survival, as did most of
Bulgaria. the Bulgarian rural areas.
153 Kurtovo Konare (in Bulgarian Куртово 154 Kurtovska Kapia Pepper and Kurtovo Konare

Конаре) is a village in Central-Southern Pink Tomato are considered as typical local


Bulgaria, situated 18 kilometres from the food by both local population and botanical
second largest city in Bulgaria, Plovdiv, part experts. In 2015, Slow Food included them in
of Stamboliiski Municipality. The village the Arc of Taste – declaring the two vegetable
dates back to the 18th century (1760). In the late breeds as traditional products belonging to
19th century, it has become an agricultural the community of Kurtovo Konare, who have
centre. During the communist era, Kurtovo preserved the crops and the specific know-
Konare was at the heart of vegetable how for their breeding over time. See the Slow

53
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

came to be perceived as cultural and culinary communicates, and others) offered more
symbols of Kurtovo Konare village. The context and data.
analysis focuses on the use of myths in The article is thematically structured
identity and authenticity construction. The in three parts. The first starts with an
article will argue that food traditions, as introduction of the connection between food,
other collective historical memories, are a authenticity and collective identity. Myth
reconstruction of the past according to the and myth-making are problematised as
needs of the present generation155. The food significant in the establishment of an
festival in question is representative of how emotional bond to a particular locality as
the successors of cultural heritage engage in home, as a place of authenticity. That
a dialogue with the past and use it for local theoretical part is followed by a description
sustainable development. The festival is of the specific local contexts of the food
presented as a new form of public related festivals in Bulgaria. The third part is
celebration, but also as a means that locals dedicated to the particular case study of
use to re-think and re-create their identity, a Kurtovo Konare food festival and to the re-
process in which the mythologisation of invention of tradition and the
existing historical facts and figures plays a mytologisation of the past in order to offer a
significant role. rationale for the authenticity of the local
To answer to the research questions vegetable breeds and to act as justification
set above, various sources were used. The in- for the festival.
depth interview was used as a main source
of information regarding festival specificities Food, Place, Authenticity, and Myth-
and local representation of authenticity.
Making
Organizers of the festivals, local authorities,
local producers, and citizens were
Home and authenticity both refer to
interviewed. As the creation of a particular
a specific place and an emotional bond. Food
image of a product is also part of its
festivals play a significant role in the
authentication, different sources that were
establishment of a particular geographic
connected to the image building were also
region as the home, as the place of
subjected to an analysis. Audio-visual and
authenticity. Moreover, in the same way as
digital materials, as well as documentation
other cultural industries, they produce and
related to the organization of events and to
commercialise contents which are intangible
the promotion and advertisement of the
and cultural in nature156. Food festivals
festival (programs, scenarios, press
might be a critical catalyst for local identity

Food Ark of Taste description for both 155Halbwachs (1992).


vegetables: 156See the definition of cultural industries
https://www.fondazioneslowfood.com/en/ar provided by UNESCO. United Nations
k-of-taste-slow-food/kurtovska-kapia- Organization for Education. 2016. Science and
pepper/ and Culture (UNESCO)
https://www.fondazioneslowfood.com/en/ar http://www.unesco.org/new/en/santiago/cult
k-of-taste-slow-food/kurtovo-konare-pink- ure/creativeindustries (Accessed on 12
tomato/ (Accessed 29 November 2017). January 2018).

54
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

formation as reinforcing the cultural dedicated to the anthropology of food


confidence of the region, a confidence built reflects on the embodied values of food,
on the food authentication, as well as which they present as both constructed and
gastronomic knowledge and traditions. By constructing. Defending food studies, the
investigating the ways in which the concept authors conclude that research on food has
of authenticity is constructed, this article “illuminated broad societal processes such
wishes to tackle its relationship with taste, as political-economic value-creation,
place and identity157. The idea of locality as symbolic value-creation, and the social
home, as the place of authenticity is construction of memory”161. All quoted
especially tangible in relation to food and societal processes of creation of meanings,
taste. The essential role played by symbols and politics might be recognised
homemade and pre-industrial food with also in the creation of local mythology that
their distinctive taste in one's perception of serves local community’s claims of being the
safety, belonging, and rootedness is widely authentic home of a particular food or food
recognized by social scholars158. technology.
Food, as shaped by culture, ethnicity Furthermore, a large number of
and geography, plays an important role in researchers have defined food
the construction of national and local authentication mostly as a result of diverse
identity. Recent food studies pay particular economic and technological efforts, and have
attention to the phenomenon of food identified specific characteristics of authentic
authentication. Pioneers in researching the food, i.e. it must be original, genuine, real,
importance of food in the formation of and true162. It is on these theoretical
collective identity, anthropologist Arjun frameworks that I build my analysis of the
Appadurai and sociologist Erik Cohen relationship between the concept of
demonstrated in the 1980s that authenticity authenticity and the perception of the local
is a modern creation. They related authentic food. The above-mentioned
authenticity to the modernist concepts of researchers have avoided making such
uniqueness and individualism159. In 1981, parallels that, I believe, would broaden the
Appadurai advanced the idea of food as “a understanding of authenticity in connection
highly condensed social fact” that acts as “a to place and community.
marvellously plastic kind of collective The examination of how Kurtovo
representation”160. Konare became considered as peppers’ and
During the 1990s and well into the tomatoes’ homeland reflects on how values
21 century, the relationship between food,
st are embodied in place in order to mark it as
identity, and authenticity became a topic of the authentic home of a specific food. Taste
further discussion. Sidney W. Mintz's and is, after all, connected to a specific place and
Christine M. Du Bois's recent work to technological knowledge. The concept of

157 That set of issues was also developed in 159 Cohen (1988), 371-386; Appadurai (1986), 3-
relation to construction of nationalized foods. 63.
See Stoilova (2015), 14-35. 160 Appadurai (1981), 494.

158 Amelia (2011), 221-237; Johnston and 161 Mintz and. Du Bois (2002), 99.

Longhurst (2011), 325-331; Schach (2008), 10- 162 See Parasecoli (2008), 1-14; Pratt (2007), 53 -

21. 70.

55
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

home refers to a specific locality, both as a study of the community-based festival in


physical structure and as a symbolic Ontario as ‘symbolic representation of the
construction. In the context of the connection asserted, believed and controlled
between authentic products and specific community identity’, designed and
locality, this paper looks at the locality of structured by leading members of the
food as related to homemade, pre-industrial, community167. She defines the crucial role
and genuine. Locality is studied as a place mythology played in place interpretation
with “its own local culinary customs, and in community building.
established through immemorial customs The case study of Kurtovo Konare
and steeped in time”163. Those claims are assesses the role played by food festivals in
often proven by myths and involve a serious place re-contextualisation trough
effort of myth-making. The deconstruction valorisation of traditional food and
of the attributed local specificity to pepper technologies. The justification of food
and tomatoes from Kurtovo Konare is an authenticity is presented as very connected
attempt at tracing the very invention of the with the symbolic construction of the locality
authentic local food based on the as the homeland of the local vegetable
mythologisation of food traditions and breeds.
collective memories.
Studies on the connection between Food Festivals: the Bulgarian Context
festivals and tourism point out that there is
nothing natural about festivals stressing on
Nowadays, Bulgarian food related
the explicit and implicit politics of events as
festivals are very popular and a fast growing
well the processes of symbol creations164. In form of promotion of local culinary
an anthropological research on tourism
traditions and technological know-how.
myths, Bernadette Quinn argues that ‘the
Since the beginning of the 21st century,
political dimension of community events several Bulgarian small cities and villages
manifests itself when researchers begin
initiated celebrations of rural food products
asking which symbols are selected to
and pre-industrial technologies for food
represent the community? Who
production and agriculture. Different
(individuals/institutions) chooses the
festivals dedicated to what the local
symbols and what interests/values are being
community considered as their food heritage
promoted?’165 Bernadette stresses the role
were invented. Bulgarian researchers
festivals play in the construction,
Nikolai Vukov and Miglena Ivanova address
distribution and use of culturally defined
the subject as a ‘new boom of region-related
images and myths that connect the event labels’168. In order to popularize and prevent
with a particular place166.
their local foods, more than 40 small towns
I am incorporating here the
and villages organize such events all over the
understanding of public mythology that the country. Some of them have already gain
anthropologist Carol Farber provides in her

163 Wilk (2009), 189. 166 Ibidem, 333.


164 Farber (1983), Hall (1992), and Quinn 167 Farber (1983), 40
(2003). 168 Vukov and Ivanova (2008), 37.

165 Quinn (2013), 331-332.

56
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

immense importance, becoming a crucial simultaneously traditional and innovative in


part of the regional cultural calendar. their nature. In a way, as they promote the
Organized in villages where farmers preservation of local traditions and products
represent the majority of the population, the in order to guarantee sustainability, they
festivals celebrate different row materials might be considered as anti-global. On the
such as tomatoes, peppers, plums, potatoes, other hand, by attracting alternative,
apricots, watermelons, cabbages, beans, culinary, or rural tourism, they have become
walnuts, pumpkins and others, but also part of the globalization processes. The
processed food products, claimed to be of annual Festival of Red Peppers, Tomatoes,
local specificity. Traditional Food and Crafts organized in the
The diversity of food related festivals village of Kurtovo Konare is a good example
in geographical, cultural, and economic of the interconnection between food,
terms offers a richness of case studies, and memory, myths and local identity formation.
different strategies for (re)invention of food
technologies and their use for sustainable The Festival of Red Peppers,
development. Bulgaria is not an exception in
Tomatoes, Traditional Food and Crafts
that rapid development of locally organized
events honouring food authenticity, but in Kurtovo Konare Village
rather follows the global patterns. Since the
1970s, food-related events have been In 2009, the chitalishe169 ‘Luben
growing rapidly worldwide, and did so at an Karavelov’ from the small village of Kurtovo
even faster rate over the last decades. Konare began collaborating with the Active
The festivals dedicated to diverse Communities for Development Alternatives
food products are appropriating elements (AGORA) Platform. Active Communities
from traditional feasts, combining them with helped the project through the Chitalishte
diverse forms of local and national Community Cultural Centers in Bulgaria,
celebration inherited from the socialist supported by America for Bulgaria
regime (such as the fête of the village), as Foundation170. The chitalishe of Kurtovo
well as new and innovative elements of Konare hosted several community forums
collective celebration and local identity that steered the public discussion towards
promotion. Their specificity is that they are important local community issues. Local
authorities171 and local population identified

169The chitalishte (In Bulgarian читалище) is a Nowadays, the chitalishe fulfils several
specific cultural phenomenon for Bulgaria. It functions at once, such as a community centre,
emerged as а cultural institution in mid- educational institution for youngsters, library,
ninetieth century, when Bulgarians were part theatre, and place for development of amateur
of the Ottoman Empire. Chitalishte played artistic and folklore groups.
crucial role for the development of Bulgarian 170 For more information see http://agora-

national culture and identity and became an bg.org/en/project/abf2.html (Accessed 30


important multi-purpose institution in November 2017)
villages and smaller towns. These institutions 171 The mayor of Kurtovo Konare, Ivan

were local initiatives; they were created and Pirinov, and the secretary of Stamboliiski
functioned entirely by public donations. Municipality, Petya Paldamova, attended the

57
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

economic and social development problems with the festival, raising Kurtovo Konare’s
of the region and outlined several possible profile173. Moreover, the ideologies behind
solutions. In the end, everybody agreed on and the messages sent by the festival have
organizing a food festival in Kurtovo Konare been developed as well. From a touristic
village that should celebrate traditional attraction that should promote the region
crafts and foods, under the name Festival of and its traditions, the message of the festival
Red Peppers, Tomatoes, Traditional Food veered towards the preservation of the
and Crafts. The declared aim was to revive regional biodiversity, and to bio farming.
and promote the traditional local livelihood. Due to the cooperation with the
As reported on the AGORA Platform, the representatives of Slow Food Bulgaria, the
festival “laid the ground for joint efforts of line of sustainable farming has been
local authorities, community, farmers, developed further every year174.
producers and partners for organizing it as From its first edition to the present
an annual event and to be included in the time, the organizers of the festival have not
Stamboliiski Municipality Calendar for changed significantly the highlights of the
promotion of the whole region and tourist programme. Each year, the festival takes
attraction”172. place in the main square of the Kurtovo
The Festival of Red Peppers, Konare village, in front of the chitalishte,
Tomatoes, Traditional Food and Crafts where activities for all ages are organized.
proved its sustainability, using the The festival lasts for three days – from Friday
opportunities given by international and until Sunday. The intention is to offer ‘a
European funds for development of the rural celebration for all ages – for those who love
areas. Since 2009, the manager of the singing, dancing, having fun… and eating!’
chitalishe, Emilia Shusharova, handled the Food plays a central role, as the festival
organisation and day-to-day running of the celebrates pepper, tomatoes, and a
festival, helped by her team and by many traditional Bulgarian homemade product
volunteers from the village. lutenitsa (in Bulgarian лютеница). Lutenitsa
Each year, on the second weekend of is a mixture of mashed boiled tomatoes and
September, there is a three-day celebration of roasted red peppers. Thus, it became the
the local traditions, know-how and logical symbol of the festival and appears on
technologies. Even if the rest of the villagers the festival’s logo. Making lutenitsa at the
were sceptical at first, as time went by, they end of the summer, when tomatoes and red
started to recognise the event as very peppers in Bulgaria are with high yield, is a
important and to proudly connect what they method of preserving vegetables in canned
considered as authentic regional products jars. That is why the festival takes place at the

public discussions, as representatives of local conducted in June 2016 in Kurtovo Konare


and regional authorities. Village.
172 Source: AGORA web page, Kurtovo 174 The official web page of the festival offers

Konare Fest 2010, http://www.agora- reach information about its realization


bg.org/en/news.html?newsid=61 (Accessed through the years.
28 November 2017). http://chitalishtekkonare.com/?cat=47
173 Interview with Emilia Shusharova the (Accessed 29 November 2017).
manager of chitalishe “Luben Karavelov 1897”

58
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

beginning of September. The women of generations, but also to be shown to and


Kurtovo Konare claim that there is shared with outsiders. The festival of
something very particular in the way they peppers and tomatoes preserves and
prepare the lutinitza, as the red peppers are promotes particular traditions considered by
boiled instead being roasted. Kurtovo Konare’s inhabitants as authentic,
Other key elements of the festival connecting traditions to specific territory175.
programme are the farmers’ market; the Besides the different elements of the
bazaar for homemade products and festival’s programme, the organizers, as well
handicraft; the culinary photo and art as the local community developed different
workshops as well as an open fire cooking. stories that are meant to demonstrate there is
The entertainment of the visitors includes a very old connection between local foods,
also a line-up of rock, ethnic, folk, and jazz crops, and food technologies on the one
music. Different competitions that kids hand and the village territory and its
might attend are an interactive way of population, on the other hand. Those stories
learning about local traditions by having tell of the early days of tomato and pepper
fun. In order to raise public awareness of production in Kurtovo Konare and serve as
sustainable agriculture and the preservation historical justifications of what is claimed to
of local biodiversity, discussions dealing be a long standing tradition. That
with those issues are also an integral part of authentication of tomatoes and red peppers
the festival’s programme. as typical for Kurtovo Konare food products
includes two different processes: the
The Festival and the (Re)-Invention of declaration of local traditions and
Traditions technological expertise, and the process of
generating narratives to justify the first. In
the case of the Kurtovo Konare Fest, it is not
The food tasting and the culinary
only the existence of specific local crops that
workshops are the main elements of the
gives peppers and tomatoes such a
festival’s programme and they aim to offer
distinguished taste. What is more important
an experience of the regional gastronomic
is the establishment of a connection between
practices and technology of lutenitsa making.
the community, the food product, and the
Local identity is represented through the
territory.
culinary skills of the villagers from Kurtovo
The first edition of the festival shows
Konare, traditions inherited from the
clearly how organisers used the historical
previous generations and thus re-connecting
events in the justification of why Kurtovo
the present with the past. Moreover, those
Konare should be the right place for a
practices and knowledge which are
festival celebrating tomatoes and red
considered traditional are transformed into
peppers: “We dedicate this first Festival to
an attraction for visitors. Thus, pre-industrial
Grandpa Alexander from Kurtovo Konare,
life and technological and culinary expertise
who was born exactly 150 years ago and who
are valuated as local heritage, significant
was awarded in 1909 with the Governmental
enough to be passed on to the future

175More on those processes in Tregear (2003),


91-108.

59
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Medal for Merits. Do you know why? weeks he became familiar with the
Interestingly, he was the one who brought technology of dried pepper powder making
the tomato seeds in Bulgaria and built the and went back to Bulgaria. ‘Stealing’ the
first Factory for paprika in Bulgaria in 1894, know-how was not the only thing he did –
here in the village of Kurtovo Konare. What he also brought back seeds of Hungarian
else is left for us his successors but to paprika. In his home village of Kurtovo
continue his cause? ...”176 Konare, he adapted a flour mill to grind
That is how the first festival dried red peppers. Thus, in 1888, Alexander
established not only a clear connection Dimitrov produced the first dried red
between the product and the locality, but pepper powder in Bulgaria. Besides the
also told the story of a historical figure that introduction of that technology in Bulgaria,
turned out to be a local hero. The organizers Alexander Dimitrov started pepper
revived Alexander Dimitrov (1854-1928), cultivation. Due to Dimitrov’s
also known as ‘Grandpa Alexander’. That entrepreneurship, Kurtovo Konare became
real historical figure was presented as a local in 1896 the first place in the new country
hero who, with courage and where the cultivation of pepper was
entrepreneurship, introduced red peppers introduced177. Kurtovo Konare villagers also
and early tomatoes to Kurtovo Konare. share the memory that he was the one who
According to the organizers, Dimitrov brought seeds for early tomatoes from
should be remembered as the first Bulgarian Constantinople. The story presents
who brought the ground red pepper Alexander Dimitrov again as an
technology from Sziget (Hungary) and the adventurous and brave trickster. When he
early tomato seed from Constantinople. The visited an agricultural exhibition, he
historical facts are intertwined with legends allegedly stole the tomato seeds hiding them
telling the story of the 34 year old Alexander in his walking stick. Thereby, at the end of
who went to Hungary. There, as a real the 19th century, the first production of early
mythical hero, he tricked the Hungarian tomatoes in Bulgaria started, again in the
owner of a dried pepper mill, who had village of Kurtovo Konare. According to
initially refused to reveal the technology of what locals recall, at first they were grown
the mild paprika. In order to understand only in home gardens in the village, but later
how the mill was functioning, Alexander came to be sold commercially.
started to work as a handyman for the same Consequently, there was a variety of pepper
mill owner. The story tells that after two and tomatoes that were cultivated by the

176 AGORA (2009) “KurtovoKonare Fest 2009 “Дядо Александърот Куртово


was Held”, http://www.agora- Конаревнесъл у нас семето на пипера”
bg.org/en/news.html?newsid=40 (Accessed http://agronovinite.com/dyado-aleksandyr-
30 November 2017). ot-kurtovo-konare-vnesal-u-nas-semeto-na-
177 The histories about Aleksander Dimitrov pipera-i-domatite/. (Accessed 12 January
are disseminated by the chitalishte and 2018); Костова (2015), „Първият килограм
popular newspapers. See Читалище „Любен червен пиперу нас е смлян в Куртово
Каравелов“ (2015), История на фестивала, Конаре“, http://www.desant.net/show-
http://chitalishtekkonare.com/?cat=63. news/34326. (Accessed 12 January 2018).
(Accessed 12 January 2018). Терзиева (2015),

60
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Maritsa Vegetable Crops Research Institute justify to both locals and outsiders why those
in Plovdiv, which was established in 1930 agricultural products are important for the
and was later nationalised, during the region and how locals are connected through
communist era. The laboratories of Maritsa the territory with them. The revived
had a major contribution in further crop memories and history created the hero, but
selection and in the registration of two also his successors.
vegetable breeds that were named after the That common remembrance of the
village: Kurtovska kapia pepper and Kurtovo traditions is very selective. For instance, the
Konare pink tomato. laboratory selection of the crops is not
Through the stories of the brave included in the official festival history, nor in
Alexander, Kurtovo Konare is presented as a the stories narrated by local people.
centre of the innovative agriculture, a home Nevertheless, the crops Kurtovska kapia
of new technologies and local vegetable pepper and Kurtovo Konare pink tomato were
breeds. The mythologised historical events products of additional scientific
connected place and traditions, creating modification. The local soil and climate
authentic local products. The Kurtovo combined with the agricultural traditions of
Konare festival demonstrates how food the Kurtovo Konare’s inhabitants enabled
traditions are a reconstruction of the past the natural selection of the seeds imported
according to the needs of the present from Sziget and Constantinople in late 19th
generation. The stories of Grandpa century. Yet, the laboratory selection several
Alexander are an example of the re- decades later transformed the naturally
invention of traditions. It became part of the selected seeds into entirely new crops. The
collective memories about local food and vegetable breeds named after Kurtovo
agrarian traditions. As the food marketing Konare are unique, but not exactly authentic.
researcher Tregear points out, myths truly In order to prove the connection between
come to life when they are rooted in a shared local people, their territory, traditions, and
collective memory178. The stores of Grandpa specific local product, festival organisers
Alexander, as well as the claim that the selectively used local history and
villagers have developed a unique constructed local mythology to serve the
technology for lutenitsa making functions as claim of authenticity. The festival of red
a collective memory. This shared memory of peppers and tomatoes is an example of how
historical events is a precondition for the food and agrarian traditions, much like other
successful transformation of historical collective memories, are a reconstruction of
events into local myths and their the past according to the needs of the present
implantation to the Kurtovo Konare festival generation.
ideology.
This living memory for Alexander Conclusion
Dimitrov is used to make it clear why the
village should celebrate red peppers and
The food festival at Kurtovo Konare
tomatoes as local products. The real
is an example of patrimonisation of food
historical facts are reworked in order to
products, culinary traditions, and

178 Tregear (2003), 91-108.

61
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

technologies. Organized in a village with a Farber, C. 1983. ‘High, healthy and


predominant farmer population, the festival happy: Ontario mythology on parade’, in F.
celebrates the diversity of tomatoes and E. Manning (ed.). 1983. The Celebration of
peppers, emphasizing the uniqueness of the Society: Perspectives on Contemporary Cultural
local crops Kurtovski Pink Tomato and Performance. Ohio: Bowling Green Popular,
Kurtovska Kapia Pepper. Through those p. 33-49.
celebrations, locals define the place where Halbwachs, M. 1992. On Collective
they live as possessing its own local culinary Memory (Heritage of Sociology Series).
traditions. The mythologisation of the Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
historical past and the creation of a local Hall, C. M. 1992. Hallmark Tourist
heroic figure is part of those processes of Events: Impacts, Management and Planning.
identity and local food creation. The London: Belhaven Press.
mythologised figure of Grandpa Alexander Johnston, L., Longhurst, R.
generates the social imaginary needed by the ‘Embodied Geographies of Food, Belonging
population of Kurtovo Konare to recognise and Hope in Multicultural Hamilton,
their social whole. Thus, the mythologisation Aotearoa New Zealand’ Geoforum 43 (2011),
plays not only the role of argument why the p. 325-331.
village should celebrate red peppers and Masona, M. Ch., A. Paggiarob,
tomatoes, but also plays a particular role in ‘Celebrating Local Products: The Role of
the story of the local community’s creation. Food Events’ Journal of Foodservice Business
The recognition of the shared traditions and Research 4 (2009), p. 364-383.
history established social connection Mintz, S. W., Du Bois, Ch. M. ‘The
between the inhabitants of Kurtovo Konare. Anthropology of Food and Eating’ Annual
Moreover, it made it so that the local Review of Anthropology 31 (2002), p. 99-120.
varieties of vegetables are valued in a new Parasecoli, F. 2008. Bite Me: Food in
way – transforming them from locally Popular Culture. Oxford, New York: Berg
named sorts to a symbol of the locality. Publishers.
Pratt, J. ‘Food Values: The Local and
References: the Authentic’ Critique of Anthropology 27
(2007), p. 53-70.
Appadurai, A. ‘Gastropolitics in Quinn, B. ‘Symbols, practices and
Hindu South Asia’ American Ethnologist 8 myth-making: -cultural perspectives on the
(1981), p. 494-511. Wexford-Festival Opera’ Tourism
Appadurai, A. 1986. ‘Introduction: Geographies: An International Journal of
Commodities and the Politics of Value’, in A. Tourism Space’ Place and Environment 5/3
Appadurai (ed.). 1986. The Social Life of (2003), p. 329-349.
Things: Commodities in Cultural Perspective. Schach, M. H. 2008. Rootedness and
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, p. Mobility in International Indigenous Literatures.
3-63. Ann Arbor: UMI.
Cohen, E. ‘Authenticity and Science and Culture (UNESCO),
Commoditization in Tourism’ Annals of (2005)http://www.unesco.org/new/en/santia
Tourism Research 15/3 (1988), p. 371-386. go/culture/creativeindustries. (Accessed on
12 January 2018).

62
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Stoilova, E. ‘The Bulgarianization of Vukov, N., M. Ivanova. ‘Food Labels,


Yoghurt: Connecting Home, Taste, and Meal Specialties, and Regional Identities:
Authenticity’ Food and Foodways 1-2 The Case of Bulgaria’ Ethnologia Balkanica 12
(2015), p. 14-35. (2008), p. 37-58.
Tregear, A. 'From Stilton to Vimto: Wilk, R. 2009. ‘Difference on the
using food history to re-think typical Menu: Neophilia, Neophobia and
products in rural development' Sociologia Globalization’, in David Inglis and Debra
Ruralis 43 (2003), p. 91-108. Gimn (eds.). 2009. The Globalization of Food.
Viteri, M. A. 2011. ‘Nostalgia, Food New York: Berg, p. 185-196.
and Belonging: Ecuadorians in New York
City’, in Sarah Albiez, Nelly Castro, Lara
Jüssen, Eva Youkhana (eds.). 2011. Ethnicity;
Citizenship and Belonging. Madrid:
Iberoamericana, p. 221-237.

Elitsa Stoilova is an Assistant Professor at Plovdiv University’s Department of Ethnology. Her


research interests are in the field of anthropology of food, cultural institutions, anthropology of
medicine, and identity studies.

63
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

JUSTYNA BUDZIŃSKA, MAŁGORZATA PRACZYK, IZABELA SKÓRZYŃSKA

Performative Motherhood: The Myth of Mother Poland Re-Interpreted


by Women Artists in Contemporary Poland

Abstract
In this article, we analyze the artwork of three contemporary Polish artists, Ewa Wójciak, Marta Frej and
Cecylia Malik, in order to understand the issue of performative motherhood as depicted in their
artwork/performances. The works of art of Polish artists analyzed here touch upon the topic of motherhood
in various ways; all of them, however, deal with a myth deeply rooted in Polish culture: the myth of Mother
Poland. The performative references of the artists to motherhood reconfigure the traditional
comprehension of the roles of mothers, and engage with this myth, not by refusing the role of mother, but
by redefining it.

Keywords: Performative motherhood, Myth of Mother Poland, Performance, Memory

My grandmother was a genuine martyr, which in her case, is honestly what she was. My
mom was a conscious heroine. And she undoubtedly felt worthy of praise, which boosted
her self-esteem.

I made a conscious effort to rehab from martyrdom, but I wasn’t completely successful. I
held a deeply ingrained conviction that children needed to have a warm, home-cooked
dinner. Exhausted after working all week long, I wanted to bravely face the pots and pans,
but luckily my sons would say: ‘Mom, don’t bother! We’ll just eat a roll’. Yet I still kept
hearing a voice deep inside saying: ‘How can you do this? They won’t get any dinner?’ The
truth is that my mom kept to these kinds of old-fashioned routines. I think that such
attitudes were formed back in the days when the role of the man was to go out and get killed,
or at least allow himself to be sent to Siberia. And the woman was supposed to stay behind
with five children and somehow manage to survive. Women developed these strong patterns
of behavior, which are being copied today.179

Anna Giza-Poleszczuk

179‘Najpierw autostrady, potem przedszkola’ (First Highways, then Pre-Schools), A. Giza-Poleszczuk in


conversation with A. Jucewicz, 21.12.2011:
http://www.wysokieobcasy.pl/wysokieobcasy/1,96856,10825277,Najpierw_autostrady__potem_przedszk
ola.html (Accessed 5.10.2017).

64
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Introduction artists/performers are representatives of


Critical Art184, as well as activists and
feminists. Their activism influences their
In this article, we analyze the artwork preference for performative forms of artistic
of three contemporary Polish activity that are socially
artists/performers: Ewa Wójciak 180 Marta engaged/engaging185, while feminist
Frej181 and Cecylia Malik , in order to
182
influences can be seen in aspects of their
understand the issue of performative artistic creation that relate to (but of course,
motherhood183 as depicted in the artwork of
these artist women. The three

180 Ewa Wójciak was born in 1951 in Poznań. A Academy of Fine Arts in Kraków (summa cum
graduate of Adam Mickiewicz University, she is laude) and from curatorial studies at the
an actress, opposition member and activist. Jagiellonian University. She is a laureate of
Together with the members of the Theatre of The numerous awards and the author of many
Eighth Day, she suffered repression for performances and exhibitions.
supporting, and later cooperating with the 183 Performative motherhood refers to Judith

Workers’ Defense Committee (KOR) in 1976. Butler concept of gender performative identity.
Forced into emigration for political reasons in Performativeness means here the visibility and
1985, she returned to Poznań together with the audibility (when we talk about the theater or
team after 1989. She led the Theatre of The Eighth performance) of negotiating gender roles in a
Day as its director. Politically, artistically, and public space as well as the effectiveness of these
socially engaged, she co-authors the negotiations. Butler (2016), 32-33.
performances of the Theatre, carries out artistic, 184 The term ‘critical art’ appeared in the late
social, and discursive projects, is involved in 1990s and describes the activities of Polish artists
actions to help the marginalized and excluded, of the 1990s. The movement must not be
and co-authors theatre productions known understood as consisting of direct expressions of
worldwide, especially in independent, off theatre criticism. Critical art of the 1990s essentially
circles. sought to produce critical descriptions of reality
181 Marta Frej was born in Częstochowa in 1973. and to comment on contemporary life. It
She is a painter, illustrator, cultural animator, and accomplished its critical work by revealing and
the chair of the Kulturoholizm Foundation. In divulging what is hardly obvious, subcutaneous,
2004 she graduated from the Academy of Fine unclear, marginalized. This movement in Polish
Arts in Łódź; between 2005 and 2009 she was an art shared something with trends that developed
assistant of Professor M. Czajkowski in the in USA and Western Europe, including
drawing and painting studio at the Academy. ‘postmodern resistance’, body art, abject art,
She is active in the Center for Promotion of the etc. https://culture.pl/en/article/critical-art-
Youth in Częstochowa (her hometown), where selected-issues (Accessed May 2018)
she organizes, among others, the festival 185 In this context, engagement is understood as a

ART.eria. ‘formal promise’, ‘legal or moral commitment’.


182 Cecylia Malik is a Polish artist with an Kuligowski (2017), 2. Online version:
ecological dash, born in Krakow in 1975. Her http://czaskultury.pl/felietony/pokaz-jak-sie-
interest in social activism and ecology, as well as angazujesz-a-powiem-kim-jestes/ (Accessed
in art first pushed her to undertake artistic 03.10.2017). Mościcki (2007), 16.
education activities. She later graduated from the

65
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

not only) motherhood186. In their choice both their activist interests those women who are
of performative forms of artistic activity and of lower social status, women from small
of motherhood as a motif, we encounter an towns and villages, and those with more
attempt to aesthetically, but also socially, conservative worldviews191. This diagnosis is
work through tensions between the space of important in order to assess the activities of
experience and the horizon of expectations feminists-artists such as Ewa Wójciak, Marta
of contemporary women – daughters, Frej and Cecylia Malik.
mothers, grandmothers, female friends,
etc.187. These horizons of expectations are Mother Poland
determined both by what women remember
from their own past experiences, and by
experiences that are taken over from their The myth of Mother Poland is firmly
ancestors. They are also shaped by the way rooted in the Polish national-Christian
they present to themselves and to the others tradition, where mothers among the gentry
the things that are remembered. The choice (the myth did not refer to burgher women,
of things that are presented and the manner women workers or peasants) are the
in which they are presented (actualized) by heroines of a quotidian life full of devotion,
the three women artists is the main concern sublime in their heroism and the sacrifice for
of the present article. their sons, and in laying their lives on the
The Polish mythology of women altar of motherland. Due to the particular
identifies woman primarily with the myth of circumstances of the creation of the myth of
Mother Poland. For many contemporary Mother Poland in the 19th century (the canon
Polish women, this myth bears all the signs indicates Adam Mickiewicz’s poem “To
of symbolic violence188; on the other hand, Mother Poland” as its source), it was
they do not possess an alternative myth that harmonized with, and in time became
could met their own horizon(s) of identified with, another myth – that of
expectations189. This does not mean, Polonia. However, while Polonia, as
however, that they do not look for such a Mateusz J. Hartwich notices, embodies some
myth, or that they do not attempt to sense of activity, Mother Poland is a
(de)construct the myth of ‘old womanhood’, completely passive figure in the collective
as it was called by Joanna Mizielińska. imagination, condemned to the verdicts of
According to her analysis, however, feminist ‘big history’, the active subjects and
movements, in deconstructing this ‘old beneficiaries of which are men and the
womanhood’, continue to commit the sin of nation192. The myth of Mother Poland
renunciation190. In the Polish context, this corresponds likewise with the religious cult
means that the feminists still exclude from

186 Rynkiewicz (2016), 186. See also: 190 Mizielińska (2004).


Makowska(2012), 180. 191 Similar to the first-wave and second-wave
187 Kosseleck (1999), 143-158. feminism in the West, which were accused of
188 The term ‘symbolic violence’ is understood elitism and reduction of feminist representation
here in terms of the theoretical framework to white middle-class women. Keetley, Pettegrew
proposed by Bourdieu (1998) (2005).
189 Kosseleck (1999). 192 Hartwich (2004), 56-62.

66
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

of Our Lady of Częstochowa193, from where for themselves, and for a new symbolic
it derives its almost mystical power. From presence in the collective memory196.
the point of view of Polish women in the 19th The myth of Mother Poland – shaped
century, the myth of Mother Poland made as it was by history – was assumed in today
them (though, truth be told, only a select few Polish public space, especially by
of them) heroines in the public sphere, a role conservatives, who supported traditionally
previously reserved for nuns, queens, oriented school programs for teaching
princesses and witches194. history197, restrictive abortion laws198, and
Along the years, there have been earlier retirement age for women to increase
several attempts to deconstruct this myth. the protective potential of the family199. This
From the famous series of Tadeusz Boy- myth not only excludes women of lower
Żeleński in the interwar period, entitled social status from narratives of the past, it
“Women’s Hell”195, and Maria Janion’s also corresponds poorly with contemporary
“Women and the Spirit of Otherness”, to the Polish women, their place in the society, the
ever-growing number of contemporary roles they play in the social, political and
publications, debates, discussions and cultural life, and their expectations for the
protests of Polish mothers/feminists who future.
pointed out the inadvertence of the myth of Thus, all the attempts to sustain the
Mother Poland for contemporary women’s myth of Mother Poland today, in conditions
identities, who are searching for a new place significantly different from those which

193 Tieszen (2007), 220-228. Monczka-Ciechomska 198For more on this topic in the context of public
(1992), 96. Imbierowicz (2012), 140-153. debate and women’s protests in Poland see:
194
Kusiak [Kusiak-Brownstein] (2002), 24-38. http://feminoteka.pl/co-sie-zmieni-jezeli-
195 Boy-Żeleński (2013). With a key motif of przeforsowany-zostanie-projekt-ustawy-o-
criminalizing women of low social status charged zakazie-aborcji/ (Accessed 02.10.2017).
with having illegal abortions. 199 For example, such an argument was used in an

196
Graff (2010), 167. Walczewska (1999). Protests interview by the Minister of Family, Labour and
by Polish women began in 2016 to assume an Social Policy, Elżbieta Rafalska, supporting a
organized form. These included the actions “Let’s lowering of the retirement age for women to 60:
Help Women” [ratujmy kobiety.org.pl]; “The “When we talk about the lowering of the
Black Protest” [“Czarny Protest”], symbolized in retirement age for women, we talk also about a
2016 by the black outfits and umbrellas of the chance for restoring the protective potential of
protesters; the “Black Venus Protest”, a the family. This may also have an influence on the
continuation of protests against the radicalization birth rate – women who can count on the support
of the abortion laws in Poland; furthermore, there of their mothers more often make a decision to
were initiatives to maintain the right of families enlarge the family”. E. Rafalska in a conversation
to in vitro therapy and to liberalize existing laws with M. Wójcik, Rafalska: oburza mnie mówienie, że
in this regard. ktoś łoży na emerytów [Rafalska: it appalls me
197 See the analysis of the curriculum for general when one says he or she contributes for retirees],
education and the curricula and textbooks in the in “Fakt” 12.09.2017:
field of history in Poland: Chmura-Rutkowska, http://www.fakt.pl/wydarzenia/polityka/elzbiet
Głowacka – Sobiech, Skórzyńska (2015) and a-rafalska-oburza-mnie-mowienie-ze-ktos-lozy-
Głowacka-Sobiech, Michalski, Napierała, na-emerytow/84sk2ts (Accessed 02.10.2017).
Skórzyńska (2016), 7-40, http://gender-
podreczniki.amu.edu.pl (Accessed 01.10.2017).

67
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

shaped this myth over a century ago, result marginalization in the social, political and
in a rupture between the space of experience professional spheres, and do not have their
and the horizon of expectations of own founding myth, different from the
contemporary Polish women200, inspiring Mother Poland one202.
them, especially feminists, to engage in
active resistance. This resistance concerns Women’s Memory? Performance!
both the domestic sphere and the social,
artistic, political and academic life. It aims at
deconstructing the myth of Mother Poland In 1971, Linda Nochlin wrote an
through various strategies, among which the essay provocatively entitled Why Have There
performative practices play an important Been No Great Women Artists? Her article was
role201. These practices are of paramount analyzed in the pages of the online cultural
importance as women-artists have
experienced the consequences of

200Kosseleck (1999). promoting Polishness, though rarely as defiant


201Rynkiewicz (2016), 186-193. The author makes women, ambassadors of the Polish version of the
an overview of artistic practices deconstructing suffrage movement. On the other hand, two
the myth of Mother Poland, among which she research and documentary projects devoted to
indicates the project of Anna Baumgart, who, in women in theatre have recently been
2005, carried out in the Centre for Contemporary inaugurated, the first one being realized by
Art in Warsaw a project entitled Joanna Krakowska. The project is entitled
‘Bombowniczka’: the figure of a naked pregnant HyPaTia– http://www.hypatia.pl/. The second
woman in an aggressive pose with a fist. Among project, entitled Theatre and Feminism – A New
women writers and performers, she also Research Perspective in the Polish Theatre Studies
indicates Sylwia Chutnik, Manuela Gretkowska, [Teatr I feminizm” – nowa perspektywa
Agnieszka Graff, Grażyna Plebanekand Joanna badawcza w polskiej teatrologii] is being realized
Woźnicka-Czeczot. All of the artists, aside from by Agata Chałupnik. These and other research
their active participation in discussions on and documentary projects are also important to
contemporary versions of motherhood, also take achieving a more nuanced representation of
part in numerous pro-social projects aimed at women and women’s communities and
both women who have children, as well as at initiatives that have undertaken feminist motifs
those who have not chosen motherhood. in their work, among them Izabella Gustowska,
202 The lack of such a myth and the strong Izabela Kowalczyk, Katarzyna Kozyra and Julita
presence of the myth of Mother Poland in the Wójcik. Polish activists, including the leaders of
collective consciousness of Polish women and the women’s protest movement in 2016-2017, in
men is surprising given that, among the Polish turn, benefit from performativity. The journalist
suffragists at the turn of the 19th century, there and writing activities of Polish women on blogs,
were many high-profile artists, including the in radios stations, and in publications carrying
writers Eliza Orzeszkowa, Irena Krzywicka and such slogans as ‘Long Distance Mother Poland’,
Maria Konopnicka, painter Olga Boznańska and ‘Mother Poland on Vacations’ and ‘Mother
actress Helena Modrzejewska. Except for Irena Poland Feminist’, should also be included among
Krzywicka and Olga Boznańska, all of these these subversive practices. See also: Urbańska
artists function in the Polish collective (2015), dealing with the topic of Polish mothers–
consciousness as women-patriots, involved into migrants.
the social projects of Positivism, defending and

68
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

magazine ‘enter the ROOM’203, together with perform/create art is not related to the need
her argument that the limited presence of to have a formal education, but is rather part
women in art is not a result of genius being of an individual path for personal
ascribed solely to male artists, but of the development, such as highlighting the
often hidden social mechanisms for values which are eventually reflected in their
preparing women and men for particular artistic activity, including those values
social roles. The same mechanisms which aimed at achieving equality for women.
deprived women of the possibility of Thus, we question if, and to what
receiving an artistic education, also extent, the social-artistic activity of Polish
determined the social, institutional and women performers, of our three case studies,
aesthetic criteria for being an artist. These is representative of native art, or, more
criteria were formulated in a masculine broadly, of the feminist movement205 as an
world of inherited statuses that predestined artistic movement, and of Critical Art? As
one to becoming an artisan, artist, Katarzyna Zielińska notes: “Talking about
entrepreneur, etc. The lack of women-artists women’s collective identity or about the
in history is therefore less a question of skills identity of the feminist movement, in the
and talents, than a historical product of the light of the ongoing discussions among
criteria used to (not) acknowledge them in a women feminist theoreticians on the subject,
masculine artistic culture and social life204. is a particularly difficult problem. In these
In this context, it is worth paying considerations the subject is described as
attention to contemporary strategies used by multidimensional, accidental, and
women-artists to function on the art market. temporary and constructed by various
This very often involves the individual dimensions of identity. Thus, feminism has
activity of a woman, who operates according to ‘embrace alternative versions of the
to her own rules and systems of values, often subject, the subject understood as
beyond the official institutions of culture. ambivalent, processual, and undetermined,
This activity is thus often undertaken in the always open to a change’. As a result of these
sphere of alternative cultures, where discussions, the utopia of a permanent,
confirmation of women’s right to stable collective has been replaced by an

203 E. Kwiatkowska, Linda Nochlin: Dlaczego nie feminist issues in Polish contemporary
było wielkich artystek? [Why there were no Great art. Izabela Kowalczyk defines it "(...) as an
Artists]: http://www.entertheroom.pl/art- artistic activity committed to women's issues that
design/7330-linda-nochlin-dlaczego-nie-bylo- strives to overcome systems of discrimination
wielkich-artystek, 15.08.2017 (Accessed and oppression. It is closely related to the
17.09.2017). ideology of feminism. The main purpose of this
204Austin (1990) art is to show the deconstruction of previous
205The feminist art movement took shape in the concepts provided to a woman by a patriarchal
West in the ‘70s. However, it appeared in Poland society and the discourse of art.”
only in the 1990s, but rather as a retrospective of Kowalczyk,Wątki feministyczne w sztuce
achievements of Polish artists from previous polskiej [Feminist motifs in Polish art)
years. I. Kowalczyk mentions Natalia LL, Maria at: https://repozytorium.amu.edu.pl/bitstream/1
Pinińska-Bereś, Ewa Partum, Krystyna 0593/9546/1/06_Izabela_Kowalczyk_W_TKI%20
Piotrowska, Izabella Gustowska and Zofia Kulik. FEMINISTYCZNE%20W%20SZTUCE%20POLS
This retrospective constituted the real frame for KIEJ_135-152.pdf (Accessed October 2017).

69
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

ephemeral community, which emphasizes a community for the spectacle. Secondly,


pluralism, difference and variability”206. what pushes the performer (woman or man)
An answer to the above-mentioned to action is always somehow anchored in
problem is, as Zielińska notes, women’s memory, and this action as such, takes place
politics of difference (a non-identity politics) with an intention to share this memory with
and creating a ‘coalition transcending others.
divisions’207. Such a coalition, considering The performative community (of the
our performers, are community-oriented in spectacle), ephemeral in nature, might
character, both in real life and in virtual therefore become a community of memory.
reality. More and more often, they are However, it is not a community in its
characterized by net-based practices, more traditional meaning, but rather – after
or less permanent coalitions of women Jacques Rancière – an ‘ethical community’,
artists, performers, animators, curators and for which a sharing of values by the
their partners in action (both men and actresses/actors is crucial209. In this sense, the
women)208. Performance, especially its performative community of memory may be
contemporary forms, is deeply rooted in interpreted as a pre-political community of
daily life and corresponds perfectly with the being-together210, as a ‘coalition
non-identity politics of women’s Critical Art. transcending divisions’211 calling for the
This is especially evident when we talk about same respect for various different social
performance in the context of actresses/actors.
memory/forgetting of the past. When talking
about performance, we refer to collective Ewa Wójciak, Cecylia Malik and Marta
and direct practices for actualizing the past
Frej case studies
in the present. It is its role to publicly
articulate the identity needs of the
Ewa Wójciak, Cecylia Malik and
community that defines this performance. In
Marta Frej artistic domain is performance.
this sense, performance, even though it is
They undertake artistic actions on the
created at the initiative of the performers,
boundary between art (various forms of
always has a supra-individual, social
visual arts, stage art, often combined) and
character. It also has a community-building
life, between aesthetics and politics212. The
character, in two ways. Firstly, there are no
common denominator of these activities is
shows without an actress/actor (we use the
their critical potential, expressed in a
broader category of woman performer/man
relational approach to the art world and to
performer), and there is also no show
the social world. In his discussions about the
without an audience (co-creators, social
world of the spectacle, Rancière writes that
actors as active subjects), who, as such, create

206 Zielińska (2010), at: 209 Rancière (2009), 21.


http://ruj.uj.edu.pl/xmlui/handle/item/29910 210 Ibidem.
(Accessed October 2017). 211 Zielińska (2010).

207 Zielińska (2010). 212 Skórzyńska. Steiner (2003), 254-276.

208 Women’s Congress [Kongres Kobiet] is an

expression of such net-based practices,


https://www.kongreskobiet.pl.

70
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

there “is an originary and persistent tension world aim at both a (de)construction of the
between the two great politics of aesthetics: myth of Mother Poland and at establishing a
the politics of the becoming-life of art and the new community able to work out an
politics of the resistant form. The first alternative to that myth. At the same time,
identifies the forms of aesthetic experience this work takes place around motherhood,
with the forms of another life”, erasing “itself which, subjected to the creative disposition
as a separate reality”, while the second one of the performers, appears to us as
“by contrast, encloses the political promise something new, as ‘performative
of aesthetic experience in art’s very motherhood’: critical images of women in
separation, in the resistance of its form to the role of mothers, a role they do not have
every transformation into a form of life.” A to give up, but also one that they do not have
relational approach to both the art world and to play, and, above all, one in which they do
the social world appears within these two not have to reproduce a heroic version of
positions, neither of which, as Rancière sanctified suffering.
notes, fulfilled the hopes they aroused213.
Thus, his conception of a relational approach Performative Motherhoods: Time of
to art and life assumes that contemporary art Mothers215
“is modest not only as regards it capacity to
transform the world, but also as regards
claims about the singularity of its objects”; at Ewa Wójciak has been a member of
the same time, they refer to creatively Poznań’s Theatre of the Eighth Day
disposing “the objects and images comprise (Ósemki) since 1971 when she joined the
the common world as it is already given, or group as a student of Polish philology216. The
of creating situations apt to modify our gazes history of the Theatre, once a student theatre,
and attitudes with respect to this collective and later an alternative one, is closely related
environment. Such micro-situations, which with the ethos of the ’68 Generation, mostly
vary only slightly from those of ordinary life via political references to the dramatic events
(…) aim to create or re-create bonds between of 1968 in Paris, Prague, and Warsaw, and
individuals, to give rise to new modes of artistic references to the tradition of the
confrontation and participation”214. theatre-commune. It is also a great example
In the case of our performers, the of the formation on the stage of a new face of
creative dispositions of the objects and polity217.
images co-creating the already existing

213 Rancière, 44. 216 Within the theatre-commune system of the


214 Ibidem. Theatre of the Eight Day, women/actresses co-
215 The Theatre of the Eighth Day, “The Time of author the plays, both at the stage of writing the
The Mothers”. Realization and performance: The script, as well as during the realization of
Theatre of the Eighth Day, Script and direction: performances. The spectacles, happenings and
the members of the Theatre of the Eighth Day, performative actions of the Theatre have
scenography: Jacek Chmaj, music: Arnold continued to be co-authored works of art,
Dąbrowski. Premiere in Poznań (“Wolne Tory”, produced by the entire team.
ul. Spichrzowa) 28 June 2006, 24.00. 217 Raczak (2014), 67-76.

71
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Student theatre in Poland was community in Poland and abroad, and,


marked by its relative creative eventually, also from the political and social
independence, expressed in the choice of opposition in the Polish People’s Republic.
often politically dangerous and artistically The theatre was not only tied to this
unconventional topics, aesthetics, work opposition, but it also suffered the
methods and locations for performances, as consequences of its engagement being
well as by their audiences. The common repressed by the communist authorities,
denominator in this independence was a among this repression acts being forced
social and aesthetic sensitivity, found today emigration in the 1980s219.
in the alternative theatre, which determined An important caesura in the social
its distinct, engaged/engaging presence in functions of the alternative theatre in Poland
both everyday and artistic life. In the case of was 1989 and the period that followed, when
the Theatre of the Eighth Day, this democratic transformations, at least initially,
engaging/engaged presence expressed itself seemed to leave the theatre without a
in the choice of a particular work method: defined opponent, someone or something
collective creation, inspired by real life that inflicted harm and could inspire topics.
experiences, collective performance and The social reality that was only just emerging
interaction. The Theatre of the Eighth Day is from the democratic transformations did not
less a traditional theatre and more a creative seem to need theatrical intervention,
community functioning on the border especially in terms of those questions
between theatre and everyday life. This alternative theatre had commonly debated in
borderline position that the creators of the previous decades, especially the relations
‘Ósemki’ assumed towards the world of art between the authorities and their citizens,
as well as the social world also determined which now seemed to be on the right path. In
their political character, which expressed turn, the economic and institutional
itself in a critical approach to both of these transformations taking place in Poland at
worlds, which intertwined in their theatre- that time forced independent artists to look
commune218. The Theatre of the Eighth Day for new organizational, financial and artistic
was one of the few groups in the student forms for their work, new places for
theatre movement of the 1970s to attain performances, and new audiences.
artistic maturity and find its own unique Many groups joined a growing,
language and aesthetics; this crystallized popular movement focused on festivals,
into a form of artistic expression that was outdoor spectacles and street actions, a
seen as political by both themselves and movement which was also connected with
others. It is also difficult to deny that the the commercialization of their projects.
aesthetic and political choices of ‘Ósemki’ Wójciak recalled that time in a speech at
were the result of discussions, at times very Columbia University: “After the fall of the
heated, conducted not only within the Berlin wall, when freedom and democracy
group, but also with its audience. This came to Poland, we often used to be asked at
audience came from universities, clubs of home and abroad if theatre commitment to
intellectuals, from the alternative theatre political and social issues still had any

218 219
Tyszka (2003). Tyszka (2007), 403-426.

72
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

purpose in the new reality (…) I am not even corner of the world. We gained a new
sure if for a moment I had an illusion and the perspective – the war in the Balkans, the war
theatre that I made had only an in Chechnya – these were our wars, this was
eschatological perspective ahead of us to a part of our world, which we necessarily
portray, and that everyday life from now on wanted to understand, and which we could
would take place without the watchful eye of not have left unsaid”220.
the artist. So, it lasted only for a short time. This was the approach of the Theatre
Conformism, egocentrism, calculation soon of the Eighth Day to the historical events in
defeated empathy and social sensitivity. (…) Poland and Poznań of 1956221. In 1981, when
Artists who believed that art has a duty on the wave of the carnival of Solidarity a
towards those left behind, those suffering monument to the victims of June 1956 was
and weaker, did not have any need for unveiled in Poznań, one of the participants
internal emigration. I can still find no in the celebrations was Ewa Wójciak, reciting
justification for abandoning or even Zbigniew Herbert’s “Mr. Cogito – The
changing the approach and beliefs shaped Return”. A similar situation took place in
three decades ago that an artist as a creator 2006, on the 50th anniversary of the Poznań
and as a human being should serve people, workers’ revolt, when the Theatre of the
illuminate the dark side of existence, and Eighth Day prepared a spectacle entitled
express compassion. (…) We tried to move “Time of Mothers”. The official
people by telling them about refugees, about commemorations in 2006 of the Poznań June
women – the mothers, wives and sisters of 1956 protests were linked to the figure of
men who were dying on the fronts of very Romek Strzałkowski222. As Bogumił
often fratricidal wars breaking out in every Jewsiewicki has noted, celebrations of the

220 E. Wójciak, Kiedy i jak trzeba powiedzieć Nie. Poznań International Fairgrounds, so that the
Historia osobista (When and How to say no. protests were introduced to the world by
Personal Story), the text read at the conference numerous journalists from Western Europe
“Poland as a Text, Poland as a Spectacle” attending the event. This did not stop the
[“Polskajakotekst, Polskajakospektakl”], communist authorities from using force against
December 2010 in Gdańsk and at Columbia the protesters, at the expense of the lives of
University, April 2011 at the conference numerous victims, mostly young workers and
“Nonconformism and the Protest of the Eastern city inhabitants. For more on Poznań’s June 1956
Block: Guiding Legacy or Passing Memory?”. see:
Online presentation in English: http://www.poznan56.pl/wydanie/20151221,w.h
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uJo66OSe4_ tml#p-29000 (Accessed 02.10.2017).
s] (Accessed 11.11.2017) and in Polish: 222 Romek Strzałkowski was 13 years old at the

http://www.hypatia.pl/web/pageFiles/attachme time of his death. He died from a gunshot wound


nts/1816/ewa-wojciak-kiedy-i-jak-trzeba- on ‘Black Thursday’, on 28 June 1956. He was on
powiedziec-nie.pdf (Accessed 02.10.2017). the street on his way shopping for his mother.
221 Due to low salaries, poor organizational and “The next day in the morning, the person on duty
work conditions, as well as shortages of in the hospital’s reception area did not want to
consumer goods, workers from Poznań’s show the body of the child to his father. (…) The
factories and other workplaces initiated a protest, father noticed a bloodstain on the body. The trace
in the streets of Poznań. On 28 June 1956, an of the bullet was small, but distinct, on the left
exhibition-commerce event took place at the side of the shirt. A school ID was lying on the

73
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

anniversary of these protests in 2006 made buildings, and the railway and bus
reference to the Western European stations225. Here also we encounter the figure
revolutionary myth223. Linking the real of Romek Strzałkowski; however, here he is
figure of Romek Strzałkowski to these events recalled not through the prism of his
was a clear attempt to incorporate the events innocent sacrifice or as a victim-patriot, but
in Poznań in 1956 into the Western European through the sacrifice of his mother, like
paradigm of great social revolutions, of many other mothers around the world
which the beneficiaries, but mostly the recalled in the spectacle: Argentine women
victims, were young people, often children, from Plaza de Mayo, mothers of soldiers in
most with plebeian and proletarian Russia, mothers of the victims of the
backgrounds224. “Time of Mothers” also Pinochet regime, Israeli and Palestinian
matched this revolutionary aspect of the women226. This was the first impulse for
Poznań June, with an accent being placed on creating the spectacle, Ewa Wójcik
the working class and its revolt against the explained. A crowd of distraught mothers
injustice of the authorities. This was due to with photographs of their lost children227. On
the choice of the site for the performance. his/her way to the spectacle on 28 June 2006,
The spectacle took place late in the evening a spectator had to walk past a number of
on 28 June 2006, on the fringes of the main photographs of mothers with children. The
anniversary celebrations (held on Adam first photographs depicted Anna
Mickiewicz Square, a central square and the Strzałkowska accompanying her little son
site of the Monument to the Victims of June Romek when he was taking his first steps228.
1956), near the working-class district of “Time of Mothers” appeared as a
Wilda, in the vicinity of what was once one monumental work of art, an outdoor
of the largest factories in Poznań, the Hipolit spectacle using the poetics of street theatre,
Cegielski Factory, on the so-called ‘free with all its exaggerations, the dominance of
tracks’ – a dilapidated post-industrial space image over word, and its stimulating
sprawling between industrial and empty sensory force, and with a grotesque and

chest of the child. (…) Romek died because he serce,186577,art,t,id,tm.html (Accessed


raised a white-and-red flag dropped by a 03.10.2017).
wounded tram driver. According to the family 223 Jewsiewicki (2016), 53-72.

and some witnesses, Romek was taken from 224 The figure of Romek, an innocent victim of the

Kochanowski Street to the building of the June 1956 events, appeared as a central character
Security Office by two men in civilian clothing. in 2006 in Oratorium 1956, composed by Jan A.P.
The 13-year-old may have died standing with his Kaczmarek, a co-founder of the Orchestra of the
arms raised in one of the garages of the building Eighth Day. This presentation preceded “The
of the Security Office. Historians have never Time of The Mothers” and took place at
managed to confirm this version. For half of a Mickiewicz Square in Poznań.
century, the death of Romek Strzałkowski has 225 Kalemba-Kasprzak (2006), 39-40.

been surrounded by many myths, which cannot 226 Ibidem.

be verified based on documents. Cf. M. 227 Drewniak (2006), 68-69.

Rogoziński, 228 One of the author of this article, Izabela

http://wielkopolskie.naszemiasto.pl/artykul/jak- Skorzinska (hereafter I.S.) took part in the


zginal-romek-strzalkowski-kula-w- premiere performance of “The Time of The
Mothers” on 28 June 2006.

74
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

ironic breaking of the sublime of the topic, Less pathetic and sublime (though
and a rhythm built on changing moods and nostalgic) were the ordinary mothers in the
sudden changes in the action. On the spectacle who were fulfilling with
narrative layer, the spectacle combined the tenderness their children’s need for warmth,
personal and local – the story of Anna satiety, security and love. These mothers
Strzałkowska and her son Romek – with the were pushing not strollers, but mini-
universal and global – Argentine, Israeli, armoured-cars.
Palestinian and Russian women stubbornly
searching for answers about what happened
to their children, showing their faces, and
crying for their loss. In this sense, “Time of
Mothers” struck at the core of the myth of
Mother Poland as a heroic victim229. The
mothers in the ‘Ósemki’ spectacle were
neither heroic, nor proud because of the
death of their children. Still, the myth was
present in the show as an archetypal
primeval mother, depicted as an enormous,
beautiful, but insensitive machine for giving Fig. 2 “Time of Mothers” ‘Strollers as mini-armoured-
cars’ (Archive of the Theatre of the Eighth Day).
birth to children.
In the spectacle, the mother’s despair
after losing a son was the same, regardless of
whether he was a hero or a villain. Also
emphasized was the commonness of the evil,
regardless of time and place, which gave
birth to the future victims of revolutions,
revolts, battles and wars. Finally, emphasis
was placed on the non-heroic dimension of
the suffering of ordinary mothers, because in
the spectacle’s final scene, it was these
mothers, not the primeval mother, who were
cleaning the bloody shirts of their sons, and
it is they, not Mother Poland, who were
looking down from the posters that bid
goodbye to spectators: their faces expressed
the lost chance for happiness for their
children. Ewa Wójciak wrote of the
Fig. 1 “Time of Mothers”. ‘Archetypal primeval spectacle: “Women, mothers give birth to
mother’. Photo: Przemysław Graf (Archive of the
life. Their contribution is the miracle of birth,
Theatre of the Eighth Day).
its singularity and uniqueness. The ritually
cheerful, magically lyrical and tender

229 Drewniak (2006).

75
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

beginnings of existence are their creation and her no longer unique life story and suffering
merit. However, later, they are the ones who into the universe of the tragedy of every
suffer the biggest failure – they suffer loss. mother who lost her children, buried their
Life is forcibly taken from their hands. Their remains, looked for traces of them, cursed
one and only leaves, heading into the chaos war while refusing to accept the role of a
of the world. Of an unjust and cruel world. noble victim or a sublime matron, ready to
They realize that completely unaware of the carry on with pride after the evil which was
fact, they gave birth and patiently cared for done to her.
villains and victims. And, in this way, the In “Time of Mothers”, Mother Poland
metaphysics of birth is juxtaposed with the is crazy with pain, removing bloodstains to
overwhelming mundanity and anonymity of make a place for a new life. And to save
death. Women, however, protest this loss, them.
the role of parents of cannon fodder, the
parents of prophets and heroes. Women
want the miracle of normality and continuity
(…) Women stand together on the side of life,
against loss”230.
Asked after the premiere of “Time of
Mothers” if she would send her children “to
the front”, Ewa Wójciak answered without
hesitation that the painful experiences of the
previous generations make sense only if
their successors do not have to fight231.
In this sense, “Time of Mothers” is
definitely a women’s manifesto of respect for
the mother, expressed in respect for the life
of her children. This inversion of the myth of
Mother Poland, tying the action between the
space of experience and the horizon of
expectations, with the accent transferred
from the inevitability of sacrifice to the
expectation that there will no longer be this
sacrifice. This liberation of Mother Poland
Fig. 3. “Time of Mothers” ‘Cleaning the bloody shirts
from the duty of sacrificing her child on the
of the son’. Photo: Przemysław Graf (Archive the
altar of the fatherland came about by making Theatre of the Eighth Day).
her equal with mothers crying upon the
death of their villain–children, by including

230Wójciak (2009), 27. Already in 1992, E. Wójciak however, it is very important due to the
prepared the monodrama “Requiem”, based on introduction of the motif of mothers – victims
Anna Achmatova’s poetry. To I.S., the spectacle onstage standing against any kind of regime (i.e.
seemed overly pathetic and over-aestheticised, the Soviet regime).
referring to the metaphysical experience of a hurt 231 Drewniak (2006), 69.

motherhood. From the perspective of time,

76
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Mother – Pole – Feminist or rehab from thinking, perceiving and qualifying of


martyrdom motherhood, liberated from servitude and
more congruent with reality.
Marta Frej was a winner of the Here, we propose an analysis of three
“Eyeglasses of Equality 2015” prize232 “for of Marta Frej’s memes, in which the central
her artistic work engaged in the defence of character is Mother Poland, but not the
women’s rights and gender equality”233. She martyr with children hanging from her
is also – or maybe first of all – the mother of shoulders, or standing amid the steam rising
a teenage son, and the author of memes from the cooking pot, compatible with the
which critically, at times humorously and at conservative-right-wing vision (which is still
times bitterly, reflect upon and look very much alive). We interpret them using
rebelliously at contemporary Polish women the category of transgressiveness in relation
and men234. to the traditional image of Mother Poland,
Marta Frej’s memes were firstly seen described by Izabela Kowalczyk as a
on the internet, afterwards being exhibited performative of a dutiful womanhood and
during author’s exhibitions in various its transgression into masculine roles237.
galleries, sold on-line printed on various Kowalczyk defines the category of
items, or in the pages of Wysokie Obcasy235. performativity (inspired by Judith Butler) as:
They enjoyed great success for several years “[…] a kind of theatre of social and sexual
in the social media236. While commenting on behavior, in which the community plays
contemporary Polish society, the artist roles assigned to it on the basis of coercion.
focuses a lot of attention on the mythical Here, a problem in the understanding of
Mother Poland, deconstructing its performativity arises [...] it’s not a voluntary
historically, socially and culturally shaped process, dependent on our will. It is rather a
image. Marta Frej’s memes are an attempt to constant repetition of gestures, behaviors,
send us – a society that unthinkingly nurses expression etc., that results in the recreation
this deeply rooted image of mother – to on the surface of the body of a concrete social
rehab, the effect of which would be a new ideal [in our case, the ideal of Mother Poland
as a suffering martyr – JB]. [...] We can talk

232 This is a distinction awarded since 2002 by the rownosci-dla-anny-dryjanskiej-i-marty-frej/


Izabela Jaruga-Nowacka Foundation to both (Accessed 5.10.2017).
individuals and institutions or organizations 234 Marta Frej i jej memy. "Tworzę, żebyśmy my,

working for gender equality and women’s rights, kobiety, nie dygały" [Marta Frej and her Memes. I
So far, the laureates were Maria Janion (a create art so we, women, do not have to curtsy],
scholar), Monika Olejnik (a journalist), the conversation of J. Kowalewska, [in] “Magazyn
Motorola company and the Multikino network. Szczeciński”, 8.09.2016, online version:
More information can be found on the http://szczecin.wyborcza.pl/szczecin/1,150424,20
foundation’s homepage: http://jaruga- 665802,tworze-zebysmy-nie-dygaly-rozmowa-z-
nowacka.pl/default_016.html [access 4.10.2017]. marta-frej.html (Accessed 22.05.2017).
233 Okulary równości dla Anny Dryjańskiej i Marty 235 Weekly addition to Gazeta Wyborcza.

Frej! (Eyeglasses of Equality for Anna Dryjańska 236 For more on memes, including internet-based

and Marta Frej), “Krytyka Polityczna”, ones, see Dawkins (2009) [1976]; Saja (2014), 32-
18.03.2015, online version: 35; Wężowicz-Ziółkowska (2014), 15.
http://krytykapolityczna.pl/kraj/okulary- 237 Kowalczyk (2003), 48.

77
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

here about a copy of an ideal, as Butler arms. Using the strongly fixed (in pop
emphasizes that this ideal or the original culture) figure of the Superheroine (such as
exists solely in the symbolic sphere, it is a Barbarella, Supergirl or Cat-Woman,
phantasm copied again and again by the representing various types of narration) the
subjects undergoing socialization/ artist makes her weapon from an already
culturalization. Simply put, a performative traditional attribute of the mother of a small
act of sexual identity is contained in the child – the diaper.
message: I am a woman! I am a man! [I am a
mother! – JB], however we have to remember
that this message is not only a spoken
utterance, but also an entire repertoire of
gestures, poses, clothes, styles”238.
In the case of the mothers of Marta
Frej, it is not only a question of the
transgression of woman, or rather of her role,
into a man, but of ‘humanizing’ her image,
casting her down (for her own good, but also
for expressing the non-one-dimensionality
of motherhood) from a historically built
pedestal. Frej’s Mothers Poland are just
mothers, women and individuals who are
aware that being a mother is one of the roles
they play, not the only one and not the one
requiring absolute perfection. After reading
Danuta Wałęsa’s Dreams and Secrets,
Agnieszka Graff interprets the memories of
the former First Lady, noticing that Danuta
Wałęsa gave to Poland what was needed, or
even more (and this places her somehow Fig. 4. Marta Frej, „Don’t mess with mother”.
within the traditional figure of Mother Courtesy of the Artist.
Poland), namely her own perspective, not
that of a mother, but of a woman, something The meme (the memes of Marta Frej
new and important in Polish culture (a always use a combination of image and
transgression, not into a man, but rather into words) warns against messing with the
his hitherto domain – of the big-narrator-of- mother. She is not a weak being, but she is
a-great-history): “the comedy of the also not a Supermother, with supernatural
masculine murmur of war, tweaking one’s abilities as the above-mentioned pop
moustache and uhlan megalomania”239. cultural icons. This mother is just ‘super’ for
The first mother – representative of her child, and placing in her hand a weapon
contemporary and critical motherhood in the form of a diaper (instead of a sword,
proposed by Marta Frej – has a child in her laser, etc.) is an indicator that motherhood
may constitute power, the readiness to face

238 Balejko (2001), 136. 239 Graff (2015), 96-97.

78
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

the stereotypes surrounding it. ‘Despite’ The artist confronts herself with
having a child (placed in a wrap), one can another version of the myth of Mother
also be a woman, as superheroines were Poland, this time as a domestic Hestia, the
usually beautiful, in good shape and ‘keeper of the fire’, in a meme using her own
wearing a sexy outfit – which of course does image (a strategy commonly employed by
not limit a vision of womanhood to these Frej) against the background of a fire
attributes; rather, she contrasts the two consuming a building (a home). Here, she
culturally stiff images, that of the super- issues a warning by building upon an idiom
woman and the woman-mother, deeply rooted in the common consciousness
emphasizing the coexistence of these two and signifying care-giving and a
roles, one of which does not necessarily preoccupation with relations, primarily
exclude the other. In fact, she emphasizes emotional ones, between the members (both
their compatible character, clearly women and men) of the family, by stating
communicating the right of women- that ‘I might have exaggerated in tending to
mothers, with an emphasis on the the household hearth’.
individual/subjective character of her ‘self’,
to self-determination. And, at the same time,
she attempts to disenchant
womanhood/women’s sexuality in reference
to the function of being a mother, which is
one of the threads most often appearing in
the memes of the artist: “[…] Everything that
hurts me. […] Firstly, women’s sexuality.
Either it is marginalized or built on a filthy
stereotype – a wife, a virgin and an angel, Fig. 5. Marta Frej, „I might have exaggerated in
versus a lover, a harlot and a devil – or tending to the household hearth…”. Courtesy of the
mythologized in an unbearably pretentious Artist.
way. Secondly – the aim of the women to
reach an idea packed into their heads by This time, Mother Poland,
stupid women’s magazines, which are a completely absorbed with her home and the
perfect vehicle for fashion, cosmetics, members of her household, has crossed a line
interior design, and similar brands. […] between an ordinary, quotidian focus on the
Thirdly: our own vanity (supra-sexual), culturally and socially ascribed role of
connected with laziness and thought mother and wife, and one that is fanatical
patterns and stereotypes. Fourthly: in which inevitably leads to catastrophe. We do
relation to children, very often deprived of not know if there are victims in the ‘home’;
respect and attention. Fifthly: the division of we see, however, (and this is emphasized)
household chores and care duties”240. that the ‘arsonist’ has managed to escape and

240Conversation of M. Frej and A. Graf Część 4 – on culture, pop cultre and (women) celebrities.
erotyczno-feministyczna (czyli o kulturze, And on how they go with Sex, Liberty and
popkulturze I celebryt(k)ach. Oraz o tym, jak się one Feminism), in Graff (2015), 178.
mają do seksu, wolności i feminizmu. A
nakoniecjeszcze o ksiażkach (Part 4 – erotic-feminist

79
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

save herself – not exactly from the fire, but makes them propose a toast to the fact that
from the stereotypically ascribed role of the perfect mothers do not exist.
keeper of the hearth. It is also worth They do not agree to be ‘perfect
remembering that fire/flame can signify mothers’, to house arrest, to tracksuits and
catharsis, in this case, for Mother Poland healthy food. Besides being mothers, they
hitherto imprisoned within the four walls of are also women, colleagues, friends and
the home. sisters – but they are first of all ‘themselves’.

Mother Poland in the search for micro-eco-


utopia

Among the most interesting artworks


of Cecylia Malik is her performance “365
Fig. 6. Marta Frej, „Let’s raise a toast to the fact that trees”, in which for a year, she climbed trees
perfect mothers do not exist…” Courtesy of the Artist. and documented her actions
photographically – creating in this way
In reading various internet forums, evocative portraits of herself, as a fragment
blogs and handbooks dedicated to women of the canvas241. Another important project
and/or mothers, we had a different was “6 rivers” during which she bobbed in
impression about motherhood. On the all the rivers of Kraków in a handmade boat.
internet forums for mothers we can read In both of these projects, Malik plays the
very often the words “Help me...” and “How main role; however, she also collaborates
can I make my child do...” Discussions are with her close friends. In fact, many of her
about “bumps” and “bellies” and advice works engage broader social circles, and
about the consistency of porridge for a six- most of her performances were the results of
month-old; about creams to be used in order collaboration between Malik, those close to
to avoid stretch marks before, during and her (especially her sisters, husband and
after pregnancy, and advice about quickly friends), and other people who were
return to their shape ‘before the pregnancy’. engaged in the actions. Cecylia Malik and
The ‘young mom’ is subjected to a regime of Justyna Koeke even created groups such as
popular, non-reflective obligations, ‘Kolektyw Modraszka’, bringing together
irreconcilable with everyday life, concerning artists and activists who are involved in
what Mother Poland 2.0 should know and several projects. Firstly, they wanted to save
do. the local park located in Zakrzówek,
Frej does not accept this. In her Kraków. The activists adorned theirs habits
memes, she seats her three heroines with handmade blue artificial butterfly
(presumably mothers) alone (!), smiling and wings, a reference to an endangered species
wearing colorful dresses, at a table filled of butterfly called the ‘blue butterfly’ that
with unhealthy, high-calorie products, and inhabited the area. They also encouraged

241 See the artist web-site:


http://www.cecyliamalik.pl/drzewa/d-opis.html
(Accessed 03.10.2017).

80
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

other city inhabitants to take part in the trees in Poland following changes in
action. As a result, hundreds of people took environmental law introduced by the
part in the performance, and thanks to their governing, right-wing, conservative-
actions, a compromise was worked out on Catholic party.
the question of development in this part of The performance consisted of an
the city. Another project that engaged a large action in which Malik was photographed
number of city inhabitants was called the together with her son, whom she was breast
‘Plaits of Białka’ – aimed at saving this small feeding while sitting on tree-stumps left after
river from regulation and dredging. The trees were cut down. Women from around
performance consisted in braiding a plait the country joined her in the action and were
that, by the end of the action, had reached a photographed individually and collectively
length of about 20 km. By this action, Malik breast feeding their children on the stumps
wanted to attract people’s attention to the of newly cut trees243.
problem of the devastation of small rivers in This action was preceded by a
Poland. manifesto: “’Mothers Poland at the cut’ is an
informal civic movement working for the
conservation of the Polish environment. The
change in the law concerning the cutting of
trees is another decision by the current
government aimed at the gradual
devastation of the natural landscape in
Poland. Minister Jan Szyszko, with his
statements and decisions, does not give any
hope for any improvement in this state of
things. Therefore, we demand an immediate
change in the amended law on the protection
Fig. 7. ‘Mother Poland at the Cut’. Malborska Street, of the environment and forests, as well as the
Krakow. Courtesy of the Artist. dismissal of the Minister of the Environment,
Jan Szyszko. Trees play a priority role in the
The last two actions are examples of ecosystem we inhabit; therefore, their
collective community action, an important cutting cannot be a subject of a simple
aspect for Malik. Working with people and understanding of the right of ownership.
focusing on the interaction constitute the Trees are a guarantee of the physical and
core of her artwork, which Michał Pospiszył mental health of successive generations. The
has included in the trend of ‘relational effects of the cutting which is being carried
aesthetics’242. In the spirit of such aesthetics, out will be felt in future decades. The
Malik created a performance entitled movement was initiated in Krakow by
“Mothers Poland at the cut”, which was an Cecylia Malik, with a performance by
expression of protest against the cutting of

242 Pospiszyl (2014). 243See this performance on the artist website:


http://www.matkipolkinawyrebie.pl/ (Accessed
03.10.2017).

81
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

mothers feeding their children at the cut, and into a rational (masculine, cultural) sphere
is spreading to all of Poland”244. and an irrational (feminine, natural and
The manifesto expresses a emotional) one. Such a division results in an
preoccupation with a healthy ecosystem as a opposition between human towards nature
basic value guaranteeing the sustainable and and, at the same time, towards
proper development of societies, while the womanhood”. Referring to Val Plumwood,
performance makes use of the well-known Michałowska notices later that “instead of a
myth of Mother Poland. Malik refers to rational ethics of ‘universal and abstract’
traditional values, namely the women’s role laws, she offers the ethics of preoccupation,
as the feeder of future generations of Polish at the centre of which are such notions as
women and men. She does so, however, in a respect, sympathy, preoccupation and
subversive manner. By making reference to responsibility”245.
traditional women’s role – nurturing the
children – she protests against the
traditional/conservative government. The
myth here is used to launch a strategy of
resistance, using traditional tools as
weapons in an avant-garde fight for
sustainable public space. Men, who at the
behest of minister Szyszko are cutting down
the trees, are a sign of patriarchal culture, in
which public space is governed by men, and
women and children constitute subordinate
Fig. 8. Mothers Poland at the Cut. Polish Aviators’
subjects, confined traditionally to the private
Park, Krakow. Courtesy of the Artist.
sphere. Malik turns public space into an
agora where women with children play an
Being preoccupied by the future of
equal role and can manifest their
the children, understood as the right to live
disagreement.
in an ecologically sustainable space, is very
The second layer of the performance
rational. It constitutes a testimony to a long-
is a discussion about the myth of the woman
term thinking and an understanding of
as an emanation of sensitivity and
development that ensures the comfort of the
irrationality, represented by a preoccupation
lives of all people – not only men, but also
with nature, which contrasts with
women and children.
rationality, which is on the side of
Another action realized as part of the
‘civilizational development’ and economic
performance ‘Mothers Poland at the cut’,
profit. Such an approach is based on eco-
entitled ‘Father Pole plants trees’, deals with
feminist theories which, as is noticed by
the distance from nature taken by men. This
Marianna Michałowska in her article
action engages in discussion with another
devoted to the “365 trees” action, “(…) they
deeply rooted Polish myth about the three
do not agree to a simple division of the world
conditions necessary for a man to prove his

244 Ibidem.
245 Michałowska (2014), 75-76.

82
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

masculinity. To become a man, one has to trunks, playing in a tree house, and a picnic
plant a tree, beget a son and build a house. on a blanket between tree roots. They are a
The planting of trees by a man in order to free nature lesson, a real one, not in a
replace those cut down due to the classroom, but in the bosom of nature. Trees
introduction of the new law constitutes a are a guarantee of the physical and mental
good example of imbuing old myths with health of future generations. Therefore, we
new meanings. The act of planting a tree, demand an immediate change of the current
symbolizing masculinity understood within law that allows for uncontrolled tree cutting.
very patriarchal categories, becomes here an We demand a stop to the process,
act of resistance towards such a culture. The catastrophic in its effects, which directly
man planting trees stands alongside the affect us and our children”246.
women breast-feeding children by fighting Malik’s performance gave a voice in
for the same values and for the right to an the public space to the ‘ordinary people’. Its
eco-friendly common space. He displays the ecologic ethics are, therefore, a polemic with
same preoccupation with nature and with the ideological subsoil of the era of the
the future of his children as women do. Anthropocene, characterized by the
‘Mothers Poland at the cut’ and the men dominance of man over the ecosystem on a
planting trees ironically reverse and ridicule global scale, in which economic factors play
traditional myths that confine women and a major role. This has led some scholars to
men to clearly defined roles with very call this era the ‘Capitalocene’247, due to the
concrete meanings. Breast feeding – a significant role played by capitalism in the
traditional women’s role – in public space ecological devastation of our planet.
and fighting for the right to this space is de Malik’s project grows, however, from
facto a breaking with such a role. Planting the belief that social activities, engaging in
trees by men, in turn, places value in taking collective action, can change the situation
care of Mother Earth, and not in dominating and have an influence on the general
nature. This is also related to an important condition of the people who join the public
topic for Malik: the right to public space, in space. These performances play an
relation to which ecological motifs have a important role in activating the community,
special place. Together with the as the artist points out: “After this appeal,
photographer documenting her girls from Białystok made their own
performance, Tomasz Wiecha, Malik performance of feeding at the cut, and later
published one more manifesto. The in Warsaw, and other cities. Such actions
performance is explained be her in the build community”248. In this way, Malik
following way: “Trees are important for the realizes a micro-utopia that is an emanation
future of our children. They mean clean air, of the belief that art can change reality. She
unpolluted soil, a green view from the uses motherhood to demonstrate universal
window. They are the memory of being social values based on eco-development and
swung in a hammock stretched between tree

246 See on: http://www.matkipolkinawyrebie.pl/ 248 http://przegladdemokratyczny.pl/001519-


(Accessed May 11, 2018) Wywiad-Cecylia-Malik.php (Accessed
247 Malm (2016), 291, 389-394. Chakrabarty (2014), 05.10.2017).
1-23.

83
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

transcending the traditional division womanhood. They make it impossible to


masculine vs. feminine. unequivocally answer the question of what it
means to be a woman and a mother, and,
Conclusions above all, what it means to be Mother
Poland. They show to contemporary Polish
women that their motherhood does not have
The works of art of Polish artists to be reduced to an objectifying stereotype,
analyzed here touch upon the topic of and that they can revalue the traditional and
motherhood in various ways; all of them, historically built model of motherhood.
however, deal with a myth deeply rooted in Being Mother Poland does not need to mean
Polish culture: the myth of Mother Poland. subordination and suffering; it can equip one
Ewa Wójciak is concerned with mothers in with the power to act, with public agency.
the face of the heroic death of their children. The three case studies above show that it is
Marta Frej discusses the traditionally not through collective activity in one place
understood role of the mother and and time, but by means of a community of
motherhood, which is both idealized and values that Rancière called ‘ethical
forced into martyrdom. Cecylia Malik, in community’ is shaping women’s
turn, makes her own motherhood a medium actualizations of the past. These, in turn,
enabling resistance towards a patriarchal derive power from both a resistance towards
system based on dominance over nature, encountered forms (here the myth of Mother
and fighting for sustainable development of Poland), as well as from a critical approach
the public space. to it. Ewa Wójciak, Marta Frej and Cecylia
The myth of Mother Poland is Malik ‘take possession’ of the myth of
imbued here with new meanings, in which Mother Poland, and invite other women to
motherhood is no longer a symbol of re-interpret it and give it new meanings; at
suffering, a sentence locking a woman up in the same time, they put this myth in relation
the house, nor an expression of her to other women’s pasts and to both their own
agreement to give birth and raise young and others’ expectations for the future. Thus,
patriots prepared to give up their lives for through these three artists’ works the
the fatherland. The performers refer to the horizon of expectations inscribed into the
myth of Mother Poland without accepting its myth is not represented anymore by the
traditional content. They re-interpret it in a choice of whether or not to be Mother
positive way, trying to draw from it the Poland, rather it provides various, often
power to transgress traditional stereotypes surprising scenarios for motherhood. The
and clearly marked borders for women’s past is an inspiration, and performance
roles. makes it real.
The roles of women-mothers newly
created by the artists enable the existence of References:
a discursive space with varying
understandings, functions and forms of Austin, G. 1990. Feminist Theories for
motherhood. They stand in contrast to a Dramatic Criticism. Ann Arbor: University of
mummified, one-dimensional model of Michigan Press.
motherhood and the related schematic of

84
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Balejko D. K. 2001. “Teatr ról raport przedmiotowy’ (History – Subject


płciowych. Teorie o performatywnym Report), in I. Chmura-Rutkowska, M. Duda,
charakterze tożsamości płciowej oparte na M. Mazurek, A. Sołtysiak-Łuczak (eds.).
filmie Jennie Livingston ‘Paris Is Burning’ 2016. Gender w podręcznikach. Projekt
oraz tekstach teoretycznych Judith Butler badawczy. Raport (Gender in Scholl
(The Theatre of Gender Roles. Theories on Textbooks. Research Project. Report), vol. 3:
Performative Character of Gender Identity. Raporty przedmiotowe I rekomendacje (Subjects
Based on Jennie Livingston’s movie ‘Paris is Reports and Recommendations). Warsaw:
Burning’ and Theoretical Texts of Judith Fundacja Feminoteka.
Butler), in M. Radkiewicz (ed.). 2001. Gender Graff, A. ‘Polska i Polka’ (Poland and
w humanistyce (Gender in Humanities). Polish Woman), in A. Graff, M. Frej, 2015.
Kraków: Rabid. Memy I Graffy. Dżender, kasaiseks (Memes and
Bourdieu, P. 1998. La domination Graphs. Gender, Cash and Sex), Warsaw:
masculine. Paris: Seuil. Wydawnictwo Krytyki Politycznej.
Boy-Żeleński, T. 2013. Piekło kobiet Graff, F. 2010. ‘Feminizm,
(Women’s Hell).Warszawa: Jirafa Roja. patriotyzm, religia – czyli o kłopotach z
Butler, J. 2016. Zapiski o tożsamością’ (Feminism, Patriotism,
performatywnej teorii zgromadzeń (Notes for a Religion. On Troubles with the Identity), in
Theory of Permormative Identity). Warsaw: A. Ostolski, H. Böll (eds.) 2010. Kościół,
Wyd. Krytyka Polityczna. państwo I polityka płci (Church, State and
Chakrabarty, D. ‘Climate and Gender Politics). Warsaw: Stiftung.
Capital: On Conjoined Histories’ Critical Hartwich, M. J. ‘Męczennicacz y
Inquiry 41 (2014), p. 1-23. imperatorka? ‘Polonia’ a kobiece
Chmura-Rutkowska, I. E. Głowacka – alegorienarodowe w sztuceeuropejskiej XIX
Sobiech, I. Skórzyńska. 2015. “Niegodne i XX wieku’ (Martyr or Emperor? ‘Polonia
historii”? O nieobecności i stereotypowych and Polish Feminin Allegories in the 19th and
wizerunkach kobiet w świetle podręcznikowej 20th Century European Art) Kultura I Historia,
narracji historycznej w gimnazjum (“Unworthy 6 (2004), p. 56-62.
of History?” On the Absence and Imbierowicz, A. ‘The Polish Mother
Stereotypical Images of Women in Light of on the defensive? The transformation of the
the Historical Narrative in Middle School myth and its impact on the motherhood of
Textbooks). 2015. Poznań: Wydawnictwo Polish’ Polish Culture and Society 1 (2012), p.
Naukowe UAM. 140-153.
Dawkins, R. 2009 (1976). The Selfish Jewsiewicki, B. 2016. ‘Kto ustanawia
Gene. Oxford: Oxford University Press. wydarzenie’ (Who Establishes an Event),
Drewniak, Ł. Matczyzna. Nowa transl. M. Heruday-Kiełczewska, in I.
premiera Teatru Ósmego Dnia w rocznicę Skórzyńska, M. Bugajewski, M. Forycki
poznańskiego Czerwca (Motherly. New (eds.). 2016. B. Jewsiewicki, Praca pamięci i
Premiere of the Theatre of the Eight Day in historii. Studia z antropologii historycznej
the Anniversary of Poznan’s June) Przekrój pamięci (The Work of Memory and History.
(2006). Studies in Historical Anthropology of
Głowacka-Sobiech, E., M. Michalski, Memory). Poznan: Wydawnictwo Instytutu
A. Napierała, I. Skórzyńska. 2016. ‘Historia – Historii UAM, p. 53-72.

85
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Kalemba-Kasprzak, E. ‘Matki Makowska, M. ‘Matka Polka –


nadchodza’ [Mothers Approach] Teatr 10 konstrukcja złożona’ (Mother Poland –
(2006). Online at: Complexed Construction), in J. Skoczyński.
http://www.hypatia.pl/web/pageFiles/attac 2012. Mit. Historia. Kultura. Materiały z V
hments/5891/teatr-nr-10-2006.pdf. Seminarium Historii Filozofii Polski (Myth.
Keetley, D., J. Pettegrew. (eds.). 2005. History. Culture. Contents from the 5th
Public Woman. Public Words. A Documentary Seminar of the History of the Polish
History of American Feminism: 1900-1960, vol. Philosophy). Kraków: Księgarnia
2. Oxford: Rowman & Littlefield. Akademicka.
Kosseleck, R. 1999. ‘Vergangene Malm, A. 2016. Fossil Capital. The Rise
Zukunft.ZurSemantikgeschichtlicherZeiten’ of Steam Power and the Roots of Global
quoted by M. Bugajewskri, Tradycja w Warming. London: Verso.
“Temps et récit” Paula Ricoeura (Tradition in Michałowska, M. 2013. Oswajanie
Paul Ricoeur’s “Temps et récit”), in J. drzew. 365 dni z życia Cecylii Malik
Jurkiewicz (ed.). 1999. Krajowość – (Familiarization of Trees. 365 Days from
tradycjezgodynarodów w dobienacjonalizmu Cecylia Malik’s Life), in A. Rostkowska, M.
(Countryness – Traditions of Nation’s Niedośpiał (eds.). 2013. Cecylia Malik +
Consent the Age of the Nationalism). Rezerwat miasto. Krakow: Bunkier Sztuki,
Poznań: Wydawnictwo IH UAM, 143-158. p.68-81.
Kowalczyk, I. 2003. ‘“Dziewica Mizielińska, J. 2004. (De)konstrukcje
Orleańska” Jana Matejki – spektakl niet ylko kobiecości ((De)construction of the
o Joannie’ (Jan Matajkos’s ‘The Maid of Womanhood). Gdansk: Słowo/Obraz
Orleans’ – the Spectacle not only about Joan), Terytoria.
in S. Czekalski (ed.) 2003. “Dziewica Monczka-Ciechomska, M. 1992.
Orleańska” Jana Matejki Materiały II ‘Mitkobiety w polskiej kulturze’ (Myth of the
seminarium Instytutu Historii Sztuki UAM I Women in the Polish Culture), in
Muzeum Narodowego w Poznaniu, Rogalin S. Walczewska (ed.). 1992. Głos maja kobiety
9-10 /2001 (Jan Matejkos’s The Maid of (Voice for Women). Kraków: Convivium.
Orleans’ Contents of the Seminar of Institute Mościcki, P. ‘Zaangażowanie I
of Art. UAM and National Museum in autonomia teatru’ (Engagement and
Poznan. Rogalin 9-10/2001). Poznań: Autonomy of Theatre) Dialog (December
Wydawnictwo Poznańskiego Towarzystwa 2007).
Przyjaciół Nauk. Pospiszyl, M. 2013. ‘Produktywność
Kuligowski, W. sztuki: między biopolitycznym wyzyskiem a
‘Pokażjaksięangażujesz, a powiem ci politycznąwyobraźnią’ (Productivity of Art:
kimjesteś’ (Show me how you engage, and I Between Biopolitical Exploitation and
will tell you, who you are) CzasKultury (3 Political Imagination), in A. Rostkowska, M.
October 2017). Niedośpiał (eds.). 2013. Cecylia Malik +
Kusiak [Kusiak-Brownstein], A. 2002. Rezerwat miasto. Krakow: Bunkier Sztuki,
‘Heroina narodowa’ (National Heroine), in I. 115-122.
Skórzyńska, J. Ostrowska (eds.) 2002. Raczak, L. ‘Madness and Method:
Dialog(i) w kulturze (Dialogue(s) in Culture). Improvisation in the Theatre of the Eighth
Poznań: Wydawnictwo EmPi2, p. 24-38. Day’ Mime Journal (July 2014), p. 67-76.

86
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Rancière, J. 2009. Aesthetics and Its teatru poszukującego na świecie, (Theatre fo the
Discontents. Cambridge: Polity Press. Eight Day – First Decade (1964-1973). In the
Rynkiewicz, B. 2016. ‘Matki Polki – Main Stream of the Student’s Theatre
Feministki, czyli niebezpieczne związki na Transformations in Poland and the
obrzeżach kultury. Wokół doświadczeń Experimental Theatre in the World). Poznan:
współczesnego macierzyństwa’ (Mother Wydawnictwo Kontekst.
Polands – Feminists. Dangerous Liaisons on Urbańska, S. 2015. Matka Polka
the Margins of the Culture), in I. Desperak, I. naodległość (Mother Poland Independence).
B. Kuźma (eds.). 2016. Kobiety Niepokorne. Torun: Wydawnictwo UMK.
Reformatorki – Buntowniczki – Rewolucjonistki Walczewska, S. 1999. Damy, rycerze i
(Disobedient Women. Reformers – Rebels – feministki (Ladies, Knights and Feminists).
Revolutionnaries). Łódz: Wydawnictwo Krakow: Fundacja Kobieca eFKa.
Uniwersytetu Łódzkiego. Wężowicz-Ziółkowska, D. ‘Jednostki
Saja, K. ‘Laboratorium umysłu. pamięci kulturowej.
Próba kulturoznawczej
Maszyna memowa wobec jednostki memu redefinicji i interpretacji hipotezy
kulturowego’ (Laboratory of Mind. Memory memetycznej’ (Units of Cultural Memory.
Machine against the Cultural Memory) An Attempt of the Redefinition and
Refleksje 5 (2014), p. 32-35; Interpretation of the Memetic Hypothesis in
Steiner, M. 2003. Geneza teatru w the field of Cultural Studies) Teksty z Ulicy.
świetle antropologii kulturowej (The Origins of Zeszytmemetyczny 15(2014):
the Theatre in the light of Cultural http://www.memetyka.us.edu.pl/dokument
Anthropology). Wrocław: Wydawnictwo y/pliki/TZU15-2014-01-Ziolkowska.pdf
Uniwersytetu Wrocławskiego. (accessed 11 May 2018)
Tieszen, B. 2007. ‘Matka Polka Wójciak, E. 2009. “Czas Matek”, in P.
(Mother Poland) and the Cult of the Virgin Skorupska (ed.). 2009. Teatr Ósmego Dnia
Mary: Linguistic Analysis of the Social 1964–2009 (The Theatre of the Eight Day
Roles and Expectations of Polish Women’, 1964-1998). Warsaw: Ośrodek KARTA, Dom
in A. Jule (ed.). 2007. Language and Religious Spotkań z Historią, AGORA SA.
Identity. Women in discourse. London: Zielińska, K. 2010. W poszukiwaniu
Palgrave Macmillan. nowej wspólnoty, feministki o narodzie,
Tyszka, J. ‘Characters, Connections, obywatelstwie i demokracji (In the Search of the
Constructing an Action: Forty Years of New Community. Feminists on Nation,
Theatre of the Eighth Day’ New Theatre Citizenships and Democracy). Krakow:
Quarterly 23/4 (November 2007), p. 403-426. Repozytorium Uniwersytetu
Tyszka, J. 2003. TeatrÓsmegoDnia – Jagiellońskiego.
pierwsze dziesięciolecie (1964–1973) głównym
nurcie przemian teatru studenckiego w Polsce i

Justyna Budzińska has a PhD in history and is assistant professor at the Institute of History, ‘Adam
Mickiewicz’ University in Poznań. Her research interests include visualizations of the past (with particular
emphasis on macro and micro history in visual arts); iconographic sources in historical and civic education.

87
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Małgorzata Praczyk has a PhD in history and is assistant professor at the Institute of History, ‘Adam
Mickiewicz’ University in Poznań (from 2012). She has numerous publications on cultural memory,
monuments and memorials, anthropology of the city, bio-humanities.
Izabela Skórzyńska is professor of history at the ‘Adam Mickiewicz’ University of Poznań. She is the
author of two monographs (in Polish), on students’ theater in Poznań, 1953–1989, and on the alternative
politics of memory in post-communist Poland. Her research interests include historical memory, historical
civic education, and multiculturalism.

88
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

VARIA

89
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

SERGIU MUSTEAȚĂ

Soviet Moldova in the Radio Free Europe Broadcasting during the Cold
War. Efim Crimerman’s (Grigore Singurel) contributions

Abstract

Mass media played an important role during the Cold War and Radio broadcast was one of the most
efficient tools deployed by the West against the Socialist block. This phenomenon was called ‘the Battles of
Western Broadcasting’, ‘Waves of Liberty’ or the ‘Voice of Hope’. One of such broadcasts was Radio
Liberation (1949-1964), renamed into Radio Free Europe (RFE) and Radio Liberty (RL) since 1975, which
brought news about the West in various languages to the Socialist countries and to the USSR. Soviet
Moldova did not have its own RFE/RL Service and it was covered by the Romanian Service of RFE and
Russian Services of RL. Between 1970 and 1991 many people had important contributions to disseminating
news about Soviet Moldova: our article focuses on the contributions of Efim Crimerman, who was a RFE/RL
freelancer between 1981 and 1994.

Keywords: Soviet Moldova, Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, the Cold War, Efim Crimerman (Grigore
Singurel)

Introduction249

Radio Free Europe was founded by Radio Liberty and, in this context, the
the Eisenhower administration in 1949 in American Committee for Liberation, Inc.
New York, and the first programs were also changed its name, into Radio Liberty
broadcasted in 1950; the first 30-minute Committee Inc., so as to reflect the new
program was in the Czech language on July reality.
4th (US Independence Day), and, starting on Both projects were initiated by the
July 14th, the Romanian broadcasts were Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). Radio
released as well. Radio Liberation (known by Free Europe mainly addressed the socialist
this name until 1964) was founded in 1951 states, contained five services that
and recorded in Delaware. The first broadcasted in the languages of the
programs, 30 minutes in Russian and 15 respective countries: Bulgaria,
minutes in other languages, were Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Poland, and
transmitted starting with March 1, 1953. In Romania250. Radio Liberty addressed the
1964, Radio Liberation changed its name into public in the USSR and transmitted in 16

249This publication was produced during Fall Carnegie Program, Stanford University and
2016, when I was a fellow of the Carnegie Hoover Institution Library & Archive for this
Research Fellowship Program hosted by the great opportunity, for sharing experiences and
Centre for Russian, East European and Eurasian knowledge on Cold War issues.
Studies (CREEES), Stanford University, USA. I 250 The Romanian service was made up of 50

would like to thank all my colleagues from the employees in 1972 (the total number of

90
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

languages. Within a few years after Liberty, as in the case of other Soviet Union
launching, both radio stations broadcasted Republics. The situation in Soviet Moldova
programs in 28 languages, reaching over 20 was discussed, in particular, in some of the
countries of the world251. programs made by the Russian and
The official relations between the CIA Romanian services of Radio Liberty and Free
and the radio stations Free Europe and Radio Europe. Thus, within the programs of the
Liberty ended on June 30, 1971, when the Romanian Service – ‘The Romanian News’,
administration of these posts temporarily ‘From the Communist World’, ‘Political
passed under the aegis of the State Program’, ‘Panorama’, ‘From Romanian
Department and later became coordinated History’, and during some musical
by a new structure – the Board for programs, Bessarabia or Soviet Moldova
International Broadcasting. After a series of were also discussed. Radio Liberty gave
investigations and debates in several attention to the problems of the SSR
committees created by the US President Moldova in the programs of the Russian
Gerald Ford and led by Milton Service ‘Events and people’, ‘Jewish Culture
Eisenhower252, beginning with 1974, RFE and and Public Life’, ‘Eastern European Radio
RL radio stations became independent, Journal’, ‘The Soviet Union and the national
being funded by the US Congress, breaking question’, ‘The Soviet Union: events,
new ground for these radio stations253. In problems, judgements’, ‘Human rights’,
1976, Radio Free Europe and Radio Liberty ‘Religion in the contemporary world’, ‘Over
were merged and since then known under the barriers’, ‘After the Empire’, ‘Russia in
the logo RFE / RL, Inc. Radio Free Europe the international context’.
and Liberty worked until June 1995, in
Munich, since then its headquarters being
transferred to Prague.
The Soviet Socialist Republic of
Moldova (henceforth SSR Moldova) did not
have a stand-alone service within Radio

employees of RFE in 1972 was 1624, out of which 251 Armenian, Azerbaijani, Belarusian, Bulgarian,
1155 were in the German office), put on the air 13 Estonian, Georgian, Hungarian, Latvian,
hours 34 minutes per day, out of which 6 hours Lithuanian, Polish, Romanian, Russian, Tatar,
and 18 minutes were original programs and the Turkmen, Ukrainian, etc.
rest were retransmissions. The audience, 252 The Hoover Archive contains many papers on

estimated on the basis of the 1971 data, was 8.4 the issue of the situation created around RFE and
million. The annual cost of the Romanian Service RL stations, as well as on the prospects for their
was 2,442,000$, out of which only 814,000$ were development, increasing the annual budget from
direct expenses. The average annual salary of an about 50 million dollars to 70 million dollars, etc.
RFE employee was 8,621$. Hoover Institution See in this respect documents from HIA, RFE /
Library & Archives (henceforth HIA), RFE/RL RL, Inc. Corporate Records, Box no. 65. A
Inc. Corporate Records, box no. 305, file no. 5, detailed report on the history and effectiveness of
RFL/RL General Consolidation 1972-1972. RFE / RL programs, Whelan (1972).
Russian RL service in New York was made by 25 253 Abshire (1975).

people in 1972, out of the total staff of 50 people


and over 20 freelancers.

91
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Since the beginning of its existence, subscribed to five press outlets from
Radio Free Europe developed rules and Chișinău, but initially received only the
regulations on how to organize services, newspaper The Socialist Moldova. As local
program preparation, and broadcasting. newspapers were a source of information for
Right from the beginning, in the activity the Western press, the Munich-based
guide of the Romanian Free Europe Service, RFE/RL administration considered that “it is
a set of rules had been established on how to unlikely that the Soviet regime would allow
develop programs regarding Bessarabia as something disturbing to be published in
well. Thus, guide no. 8 from 18 April 1951 on Moldova”255.
Romania's broadcasts clearly indicates that
“it is very reasonable for the Romanians to
talk with their compatriots about the return
of Bessarabia to Romania”254. However, in
the context of the events that followed,
especially in the states of the socialist camp
in 1956, 1968, RFE / RL policy adapted to new
realities and circumstances. Following the
structural and administrative changes in
RFL/RL in the 1970s and the signing of the
Helsinki Treaty, the administration made
some changes to the policy of the radio
station. Aspects of territorial or national
disputes were addressed much more
carefully, including the Bessarabian issue,
which often falls into the category of
‘irredentism/nationalism’.
As a result of the efforts of Nicolae
Lupan, both in Munich and in Washington
DC, regarding the need to pay more Fig. 1. Efrim Crimerman (Personal Archive)
attention to Soviet Moldova in the RFE/RL
programs, an exchange of letters took place In the second half of the 1970s, the
between RFE/RL leadership and the US programs of the Romanian Free Europe
institutions in Washington DC. In 1978, Service spoke sporadically about various
James Critchlow, the Director of Planning aspects of Bessarabia and Bukovina. Thus,
and Communication of the Council for since 1978, within the ‘Actualitatea
Broadcasting International Programs, asked românească’ program, Nicolae Lupan
the Munich administration for data on the evoked the two regions under the editorials
status of the SSR Moldova. From this ‘Historical Figures of our nation’, ‘The
correspondence, we find out that RFE/RL treasures of our people’ or ‘The Romanian

254Guidance # 8 for Broadcasts to Romania. April 255Letters signed by J. Critchlow (20.10.1978),


18, 1951. HIA, RFE/RL Corporate Records Ralph E. Walter (9.11.1978). HIA, RFE/RL
Collection, Box 280, file 8. Corporate Records Collection.
http://www.hoover.org/library-and-archives.

92
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

spiritual treasures in Bessarabia and focussed on some historical data or events:


Bucovina’. The introduction of the weekly the union of Bessarabia with Romania
segment dedicated to Bessarabia in the (March 27, 1918), the Molotov-Ribbentrop
‘Actualitatea românească’ program had Pact (August 1939), the annexation of
“the intention to provide accurate, balanced Bessarabia by the USSR (June 28, 1940) etc. In
and informative comments on the life in the late 1970s, due to the interventions of
Soviet Moldova to the Bessarabian Nicolae Lupan, within the programs of the
Romanians”. Taking into account the Romanian Free Europe Service, the topics on
transformations in the USSR at the beginning the history and culture of Bessarabia and
of the 1980s, the Romanian Service initiated Bukovina and the problems of the Soviet
a ten minute program devoted to the Moldavia began to be aired more frequently.
Romanian listeners about the political, Towards the end of the 1980s, a special
cultural and economic changes in the SSR program was broadcasted, dedicated to the
Moldova – ‘Echoes between the Prut and the situation in the Soviet Moldavia – ‘Echoes
Dniester’, which was broadcasted three between the Prut and the Dniester’.
times a week on Mondays, Wednesdays and Although in his book Efim
Fridays, starting at 17:10256. Crimerman257 writes about the ‘Moldovan
Radio Free Europe employed both Service’ of Free Europe, such a service did
permanent workers and freelancers. For not exist during the Cold War. The subjects
security reasons, most employees were on Soviet Moldova were presented in two
working under pseudonyms. The first RFE/RL services: Romanian and Russian.
generation of employees were journalists The other services of the RFE/RL
and diplomats, established in the West occasionally addressed the situation in
during the interwar period or who Moldova, especially during the perestroika
emigrated after the Second World War. Later years, national emancipation and the events
on, their profile diversified. that led to the declaration of sovereignty and
The Romanian Service of Radio Free independence.
Europe, from the very beginning of its Alongside the journalists in those
existence, occasionally transmitted certain two services, Nicolae Lupan and Efim
programs or some editorials about Crimerman have brought important
Bessarabia. In most cases, these were contributions to the talks about Bessarabia.
editorials signed by I. Flavius, G. Georgescu, During the 1980s, Vlad Socor also joined the
G. Ciorănescu, V. Georgescu, M. Cazacu, service258, and in the perestroika years and

256 The letter signed by G. Wirzynski, the Director dedicated to Chișinău – ‘Bessarabian Roundup’
of RFE Division, (12.12.1986) and addressed to N. (1988-1989) and ‘Moldavian Report/Echoes
Lupan. Radio Free Europe Memorandum between the Prut and the Dniester’ (1989-1991).
„Romanian BD Program Change”, 8.09.1989. The political analyst spoke for the first time at the
HIA, RFE/RL Corporate Records Collection. microphone of Radio Free Europe about
257 Crimerman (2011), 265-273. Bessarabia and Bucovina on May 12, 1982, within
258 Vlad Socor was employed as a researcher at the the program ‘Romanian News’ (Domestic Bloc,
RFE/RL Institute, but he also made a number of no. 68, 12.05.1982), and a year later he talked
interventions in the Romanian Service about Alexei Mateevich as part of the program
broadcasts, even reaching a special program ‘Historical talk’, no. 15, 20.04.1983.

93
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

shortly after the collapse of the USSR, Victor to immigrate to Israel. Instead of going to
Moroșan (Victor Eskenazy) also addressed Israel, they went to Germany where Efim
issues concerning the Republic of Moldova Crimerman started his collaboration with
in his programs. Since October 23, 1991, Val Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty259.
Butnaru was co-opted as a local journalist
who intervened by phone twice a week from
Chișinău for RFE. Iurie Roșca, Mihai Fusu,
Vasile Năstase also collaborated with RFE,
the office of the Radio station in Chișinău
being opened by Dan Ionescu.

Efim Crimerman and Radio Free


Europe/Radio Liberty (1981-1994)

Efim Crimerman was born in 1923 in


Bălți, at that time in Romania, and lived
during his childhood in Galați and
Bucharest. Due to the antisemitism
encountered in Bucharest, in 1940, his family
moved to Chișinău. During the Second
World War, they went into the Soviet
territories and returned to Chișinău in 1944.
He attended the Faculty of Letters at the
Chișinău State University between 1946 and
1951. During his student years, he published
his first poems. After his graduation, he In his book, Crimerman wrote that,
taught in Nisporeni department, in the while still in Bessarabia, he listened to Radio
Soviet Socialist Republic of Moldova, until Free Europe with an extraordinary pleasure
1960 when he moved to Chișinău and and quite often: “And I envied them ... look,
worked at the State Philharmonic Orchestra. they talked about they have in their hearts.
He wrote more than 200 lyrics, mostly in That is why it is so convincing … about
Romanian, which became hits and brought telling the truth”. Despite Crimerman
him several national and pan-soviet prizes. assertions regarding the easiness of listening,
He also wrote novels and articles. Married in the reception of Western radio programs was
1949 with Șena Pilihova, a physician, quite difficult in SSR Moldova because of
Crimerman has a daughter (Silvia jamming260.
Crimerman). In 1981, they received the right

259Musteață (2017), 20-36. details about the jamming system in the


260 Although jamming created deficiencies in documentary Empire of noise,
receiving Western posts, citizens of the socialist https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXV4nTfGHuI
states and of the Soviet Union republics (Accessed on 20.02.2017). As for jamming on the
continued to listen to their programs. See more territory of the SSR Moldova see the programme

94
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

As soon as he arrived with his family from RFE, highlighting in particular his
in Germany, Efim Crimerman wrote to Lev colleagues whom he had known or worked
Roitman, who was the editor of the with in the Russian Service (Lev Roitman,
‘Sovetskiy Soyuz’ broadcast at Radio Mario Korti, Inna Svetlova, Gleb Rar, Irina
Liberty. While living in Limeshain, he wrote Henkina, Kiril Henkin, Vladimir Tolz, Viktor
the first texts for RFE/RL, and brought them Fedoseev, Evgheni Kusev and others) and
to one meeting with Lev Roitman. the Romanian Service (Nicolae Munteanu,
Crimerman recalls his beginning at RFE/RL: Emil Hurezeanu, Doina Schneider, Şerban
“… I have listened to Free Europe with Orăscu, Mircea Carp, Sorin Cunea, Mircea
extraordinary pleasure. While I still was in Vasiliu, Nicolae Stroescu, George
Chişinău. I did a material with Sulac, with Ciorănescu)263. Although he had met many
these ... And I got a letter from a good friend people during his years in Munich, he does
of mine: ‘Please write to me ... in Russian. not have pictures of his colleagues from the
Write only to me (laughs). Only to me. You radio, nor of those with whom he
do not need to write to the others’. Then I collaborated, nor of friends because: “I
took the car and went to Munich. I went to photographed beautiful places, I have
him, he received me, and called other beautiful memories. This is it, my friends.
journalists”. ‘There you are. That's it’. And We were afraid of each other. They wrote
he introduced us, and, behold, I began to boldly, they were writing, but still, they were
write directly to him. After that, we moved afraid. You see, even the director of the
to Munich”261. Russian section was a KGB operative ... And
The first meeting with Lev Roitman he did not like me at first glance”264.
and Evgheni Kusev took place in the During his time at RFE / RL (1981-
basement cafe of RFE, where they discussed 1994), he wrote about 1200 texts, out of
several issues regarding life in Soviet which 1/4 for the Romanian Free Europe
Moldova, the emigration of the Jews and Service and 3/4 for the Russian Radio Liberty
their further collaboration. So, owing to Lev Service265. While conducting the interviews, I
Roitman's support262, Crimerman began his have discovered an interesting situation:
work as an external collaborator at RFE/RL those who had worked at RFE did not know
in 1981, and moved to Munich. In his book, about Crimerman's talks in Russian to Radio
Crimerman recalled a number of journalists Liberty266. Even though most of his talks

‘Moldova, țară de minune’ with the title ‘War of the collaboration and support relationship with
Radio Waves in the USSR. How the Moldovans Efim Crimerman between 1981 and 1993.
listened to western posts, jammed by the Soviets’, 263 Crimerman (2011), 252-259.

Publika TV, 16.02.2016, 264 Interview with Efim Crimerman, July 12, 2014,

http://www.publika.md/razboiul-undelor-radio- Aachen, Germany.


in-urss-cum-ascultau-moldovenii-posturile- 265 Musteață (2017), 16-17.

occidentale-bruiate-de-sovietici_2534291.html 266 N. C. Munteanu, who signed the vast majority

(Accessed on 20.02.2017). of his scripts for the broadcasts in Romanian, was


261 Interview with Efim Crimerman, July 12, 2014, astonished when I told him that, in fact, most
Aachen, Germany. contributions by Crimerman were made in
262 Lev Roitman lives today in Prague and in my Russian. Talk in Munich, August 2015.
telephone conversation on July 8, 2016 confirmed

95
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

were in Russian for RL, his first aired advised me ... Leva ... Roitman, yes. I also
intervention was in Romanian, with RFE, enjoyed all their rights, and for me, it was
within the ‘Romanian News’ program more ... As for the writing, I wrote at home. I
entitled ‘On Lenin Street’ on July 28, 1981267. wrote in the evening. That's why I used to go
For RFE, in Romanian, he discussed topics to bed late. I came and read during the day.
regarding the situation in Soviet Moldova Not every day. As for the rest, I was free,
and the issue of the Jews; and in Russian, for they had no issue with me. In the morning, I
Radio Liberty, the issue of the Jews, the was at work, at the cafeteria, there was a
situation in SSR Moldova and in Romania: “I special café, we were sitting down and
had started writing about it. Systematically. discussed the news, and we had the right to
Once a week. Once a week, we wrote about take home the newspapers. And I would
Moldova, once a week about Romania and look for something interesting, and if I found
about Romania in Russian. … I did three it, I wrote something, and then I was done
materials on weekly basis...”268. with it”269.
Crimerman believed that the most For ten years, Efim Crimerman
important thing in his work at RFE/RL was contributed to many broadcasts under the
that his talks were aired constantly and, that, aegis of the Romanian Service, which was
through the topics addressed, he contributed located in the left wing on the third floor of
to demolish the communist regime, using the RFE headquarters. Within the Romanian
words as his weapon of choice: “I was not RFE Service, Efim Crimerman mainly
focussing on anyone. Neither did I utter ugly collaborated with Doina Schneider at the
words. I was telling the truth. And I was broadcast ‘From the Communist World’ and
rebuking my conscience if I was wrong”. The with N. C. Munteanu at the ‘The Romanian
position of freelancer did not bother him. On News’ (Domestic Bloc) broadcast, which was
the contrary, he believes that he benefited the most listened to productions of the
from this status, having both full freedom station in the 1980s270. He also do some talks
and an advantageous remuneration: “You to the ‘Human Rights’ program or took part
understand, they offered me such conditions in some roundtables, organized for the
that I, as a freelancer, got more than ... He listeners of RFE271. Every RFE program was

267 Text presented within the programme 268 Interview with Efim Crimerman, July 12,
‘Domestic Bloc’, no. 627 from July 28, 1981. 2014, Aachen, Germany.
Romanian Broadcasting Department, Radio Free 269 Interview with Efim Crimerman, July 12,

Europe. HIA, RFE/RL Broadcast Records 2014, Aachen, Germany.


Collection, Box 3621, file 3, 270 Mircea Morariu, „Europa Liberă – aduceri

http://www.hoover.org/library-and-archives; aminte” (Free Europe – Memories), Adevărul, July


Crimerman (2011), 262. In the weekly Literatura și 2, 2016 (Accessed on 09.02.2017).
arta from December 1987, this date is also marked: 271 For example, the round table on the political

„So, July 28, 1981 can be considered the day of E. legacy of Brezhnev in the ‘Political Program’, no.
Crimerman's debut at the microphone of Free 282 from 15.11.1982. Romanian Broadcasting
Europe”. Sorin Vlaicu, „Ce mai nou e la Europa Department, Radio Free Europe. HIA, RFE/RL
Liberă. (4) Războiul undelor. În prizonieratul Broadcast Records Collection, Box 3965, file 5,
arginților” (What is new at Radio Free Europe. The http://www.hoover.org/library-and-archives
war on waves. Money’s custody), Literatura şi arta (Accessed on 09.02.2017).
2211, no. 51, December 17 (1987).

96
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

composed of several segments. For example, and afterwards handed to the editor on the
the program ‘From the Communist World’, weekly agenda273.
lasted 12-20 minutes, and had from two to Based on a statistical analysis of the
four speakers. In many programs, there were scripts signed by Grigore Singurel (Efim
only the talks of Doina Schneider and Efim Crimerman), found in the Hoover Archive,
Crimerman (speaking under the name for 1983 and 1984, we can infer that about 50-
Grigore Singurel)272. The ‘Romanian News’ 60% of his editorials were written for ‘From
program lasted 30-40 minutes and had the Communist world’, 30-35% for the
between four and six speakers. At the end of ‘Romanian News’ and only a few for the
the broadcast, Efim Crimerman constantly programs ‘Panorama’ and ‘Political
brought about news from Soviet Moldova. program’. Thus, analysing the archive data
The ‘Human Rights’ broadcast, during its 20 and the number of the scripts signed by
minutes, had 3-5 speakers. The editor of the Crimerman, it is very clear that he
program moderated it and had short collaborated most intensively with Doina
introductory comments at the beginning of Schneider and spoke about Soviet Moldova
each speaker's intervention. The news was within the ‘From the Communist World’
broadcasted live, while the other programs broadcast.
were mostly recorded in the studio, edited,

Y
e 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 Total
a
r

Program

Domestic 1 2 10 13 14 12 16 29 23 120
Bloc
Sunday 2 2
Panorama
Panorama 2 1 2 7 12
Communist 12 21 27 23 11 2 12 6 114
World
Political 1 5 6
Program

272Efim Crimerman used several names. He RFE/RL were presented under the name Grigore
signed his article while in Soviet Moldova as Efim Singurel.
Zorin and Efim Ciuntu while his interventions at 273 Crimerman (2011), 251.

97
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Youth 1 1
Program
Human 4 4
Rights
Moldavian 3 2 5
Report
Chronicle 2 2
The World 2 2
of Religion
Article 1 1
of the day
TOTAL 1 2 27 35 43 36 27 35 38 25 269

Table 1. Contributions by Efim Crimerman to RFE programs according to the Hoover Archive.

The collaboration with N. C. documents from the Hoover Archive275.


Munteanu within the ‘Romanian News’ Thus, the relationship between the two
program was both productive and durable. Bessarabians was rather rigid. Although
About N. C. Munteanu, Efim Crimerman they did not collaborate with each other,
recalls that he was a very cheerful, Crimerman and Lupan intersected quite
courageous and exceptional critic, reason for often in the programs ‘Panorama’,
which he was hated and pursued by the ‘Romanian News’ and ‘From the Communist
Romanian Securitate274. With Nicolae Lupan, World’, where each came with his own
the collaboration was limited to a few short intervention. In most cases, they were on
meetings. They had already known each different days, but sometimes they
other from Chișinău, when Nicolae Lupan participated in the same edition, such as the
was the director of the State Moldovan issue of June 24, 1982, about the annexation
Philharmonic. During my interviews, both of of Bessarabia by the USSR276.
them had hostile attitudes towards each
other. Efim Crimerman writes succinctly Topics Addressed by Crimerman
about Lupan in his book, noting that many
of Lupan's texts were not aired because of his
The style in which Efim Crimerman
nationalist approach and his support for wrote and spoke was a special one,
unionism, which is confirmed by a string of
sometimes ironic, often critical and

274 Ibidem, 260. N.C. Munteanu was admired by 276Domestic Bloc no. 99, 24 June 1982. Romanian
more people `for his well documented and Broadcasting Department, Radio Free Europe.
pugnacious shows, but also for his subtle HIA, RFE/RL Broadcast Records Collection, Box
humour and the rich tones of his voice”. Țurcanu 3936, file 4. http://www.hoover.org/library-and-
(2016), 241. archives.
275 Crimerman (2011), 233-234, 268-269.

98
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

humorous, attracting public attention. Three little. I also had a backup in the head. … .
basic topics were discussed by Crimerman in And I would sit down and write”277.
his broadcasts at RFE/RL: the situation in
Soviet Moldova, the problem of the Jews (in Problems of Soviet Moldova
Romanian and Russian) and the situation in
Romania (in Russian). Radio Free Europe /
Radio Liberty had a highly developed Crimerman spoke about various
library and a research institute that received aspects of the Bessarabian realities during
newspapers and magazines from all over the the Soviet regime. One of the most important
world, and since 1978 also from the SSR was the cultural and linguistic situation in
Moldova. Crimerman had full freedom to the country: the dominance of the Russian
choose the topics for his airings in both language, the distortion of the Romanian
Romanian and Russian. language by the Communist authorities and
The vast majority of the texts written the șantist movement, the communist
by Efim Crimerman drew inspiration from censorship in art and science, the abundance
periodicals, both Moldovan newspapers of monuments and names of streets in Soviet
(Sovetskaia Moldova, Socialist Moldova, style at the expense of national traditions
Literature and Art, Moldovan Communist, and culture, the establishment of full control
Moldovan Agriculture) and Soviet Union over all state institutions, including in the
newspapers Sovetskaja kultura, Literaturnaja field of culture by the party and the KGB
gazeta, Pravda, Novyj mir etc.). Knowing the bodies: “Second Lieutenant Constantin
language, history, culture and political Vornicescu has ‘cleaned’ the art of the
realities of Soviet Moldova, with formation Republic for almost a quarter of a century,
and expertise in writing, it was easy for Efim led the network of security agents in this
Crimerman to select and write texts for field. He decided, in essence, who had the
RFE/RL: “I'll tell you. First, I got newspapers. right to sing and to dance on stage, who
The radio did not say anything ... I would could be left abroad. Not the talent, but the
take the newspapers. I would go to the political considerations decided the fate of
library for this, the library was fantastic. It our artists. Not once, in the capacity of a
had all the newspapers that appeared in ‘director’, a ‘literary critic’ etc., he
Chișinău. Political newspapers with political accompanied our artists abroad”278.
tendencies were passing through my hand. Ivan Bodiul's regime and his ‘affairs’
And I would give them back. I would read, I were addressed during several airings at
would choose. ... Look, this is how it was. I RFE, such as Jan Janâci's279 ban on Romanian
took the paper. I looked at it. I found it. books, Romanian music programs,
Something. There was something, it was Romanian artist tours into the SSR Moldova,
etc. Crimerman also approached economic

277 Interview with Efim Crimerman, July 12, 2014, Europe. HIA, RFE/RL Broadcast Records
Aachen, Germany. Collection, Box 3621, file 3.
278 Grigore Singurel, Pe strada Lenin (On the Lenin 279 Jan Janâci is a nickname of Ivan Bodiul, first

street). Text presented within the broadcast secretary of the Central Committee of
‘Domestic Bloc’ no. 627 from July 28, 1981. Communist Party of Moldavia.
Romanian Broadcasting Department, Radio Free

99
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

issues: the problems of the Moldovan is it true that in the era of real socialism
economy, those faced by an ordinary citizen, people die only in cities?”281
namely the access to basic goods, especially Coming from the Moldovan cultural
bread, the quality of service and goods, the environment, Efim Crimerman knew very
quality of roads, bureaucracy, corruption, well the realities and the peculiarities of the
theft, non-fulfilment of the plan or the regime and its attitude towards culture. That
declaration of false data for the is why he often referred to the problems
implementation of annual and five-year faced by the artists, the art having been
plans, the alcoholism, the differences dominated by the communist censorship:
between village and city etc.: “And the first “Out of all this, the editor must exclude any
‘object’ called by the author is bread. Our negative allusion to Soviet reality. The song
daily bread. Namely, in its search, the must reflect the spiritual beauty of the new
Bessarabian peasants now have to waste man, the love for the party, the proletarian
time and take to the road. You might be lead internationalism. Satire should be without
to believe that the locusts attacked the crops teeth, without generalization, to laugh at
in Bessarabia or that the year was droughty? ‘unusual’ phenomena of Soviet society. Only
No. As even the Socialist Moldova writes, in salespeople, locksmiths, small clerks are
1984 the cereal harvest in the Republic was allowed to come under criticism. Those texts
on average of almost 40 quintals per hectare. which do not meet these requirements are
If so, then where is the bread? What do you returned to the authors. From the texts
mean - where? Together with meat, without an author, i.e. folk songs, everything
vegetables, fruit, and grapes - it took the road that reminds of faith, customs and traditions
to Russia”280. of the people, its national heroes, the
Crimerman often addressed the reminders of a prosperous life, wealth (land,
issues living conditions or even the problems horse, cart with oxen, a rich harvest) must be
regarding the funerals: “…In Moldova of eliminated. Folk songs must be sad, full of
real socialism, it is not easy to sleep sorrow. The past has to be hard, the present
somewhere, nor to live, nor to die. In - happy. The past must be deleted, forgotten.
Chișinău, you can still order a coffin, It is much easier to keep in thrall a people
transport, flowers and even music, but in the without a past”282.
Moldavian villages and regional centres, this Simion Grossu's time in power was
is left to the fate. There, no one deals with also debated in the broadcasts of RFE,
funerals. The newspaper Literature and Art highlighting both the servility of Moldovans
gives a passing mention to it. Curious thing: towards Moscow's central power and the

280 Grigore Singurel, Gustul pâinii (The Taste of 31, 1983. Romanian Broadcasting Department,
bread). Text presented within the broadcast Radio Free Europe. HIA, RFE/RL Broadcast
‘Communist World’, no. 456 from March 26, Records Collection, Box 4004-4.
1985. Romanian Broadcasting Department, Radio 282 Grigore Singurel, Artiști cu lacătul la gură

Free Europe. (Artists locked up). Text presented within the


281 Grigore Singurel, Curiozități din lumea broadcast ‘Comunist World’, no. 113 from July
socialismului real (Curiosities from the real 25, 1983. Romanian Broadcasting Department,
socialism world). Text presented within the Radio Free Europe. HIA, RFE/RL Broadcast
broadcast ‘Domestic Bloc’, no. 211 from October Records Collection, Box 3995-4.

100
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

struggle of local bureaucrats and This nomenklatura on the shore of the Bâc
communists with Moldovan citizens and has gotten bogged down in the slump of
traditions: “Simion Grossu, the first stagnation”285.
secretary of the Communists of Soviet Crimerman approached a number of
Moldova, was angry with his party cadres. important issues for the Moldovan society in
Not only do they not understand the new his programs: the famine of 1946/47, the
and complex character of current tasks, but deportations from Bessarabia, the
they are overweight, dealing in distortions, nationalization, the censorship in media and
unjustified increases, fraud, abuse of power, culture, the fate of orphaned children, the
scams, they enjoy a glass and take bribes. He problems of the Moldovan village, the lack
spoke about this from the high platform of of infrastructure, the war in Afghanistan and
the ‘October’ Palace in Chișinău at the last the participation of Moldovan youth in it, the
plenary of the Central Committee (CC) of the Chernobyl catastrophe, the consequences of
Communist Party of Moldova. In his report, the earthquake of 1986, and some ecological
he criticized the nomenklatura in 19 ministries problems, such as the Dniester pollution, etc.
and directorates, as well as 30 Party District Crimerman also spoke of the fact that
Committees out of 39 that the Republic Moscow's new leadership penalized
has”283. Communist leaders in Chişinău for
In the same context, Crimerman also falsifying reality and reporting erroneous
addressed the makeup of Chișinău data: “Soviet Moldova has scored a new
nomenklatura: “... As a rule, the CC's first victory. It took the first place in the Union as
secretary must be of the people's nationality regards fake information. Over the past few
at the head of which he is placed by Moscow. days, Moscow has taken away the diplomas
That is, to be a national in form and a of honour and the prize money it had
socialist in content...”284 Crimerman's received as winnings in the Union Socialist
statements on the democratization of the Contest of the winter of '85-’86. And shortly
Moldovan society during perestroika were before, the Central Committee of the
rather pessimistic: “The year '88 has been Communist Party admonished Simion
illustrative to the utmost that the Grossu, the leader of the Communists of
nomenklatura in Chișinău is in no condition, Moldova, for misinformation and unjustified
is not able and does not want to go through increases of the results”286.
the process of democratization. And it will Another issue of interest for
be an absolute wonder if they do in 1989. Crimerman was Moldovan-Romanian

283 Grigore Singurel, Pe scara ce coboară în jos (On 285 Grigore Singurel, Antitezele lui Matcovschi
the stairways down). Text presented within the (Antithesis of Matcovschi). Text presented within
broadcast ‘Communist World’, no. 436 from the broadcast ‘Domestic Bloc’, no. 482 from
February 19, 1985. Romanian Broadcasting January 3, 1989. Romanian Broadcasting
Department, Radio Free Europe. Department, Radio Free Europe.
284 Grigore Singurel, Schimbări în aparatul de 286 Grigore Singurel, Marele mistificator (The great

conducere (Changes in the top department). Text mystification man). Text presented within the
presented within the broadcast ‘Communist broadcast ‘Communist World’, no. 792 from
World’, no. 504 from June 18, 1985. Romanian November 12, 1986. Romanian Broadcasting
Broadcasting Department, Radio Free Europe. Department, Radio Free Europe.

101
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

relations, which became more active in the in Chișinău declared a strike. Some of their
context of perestroika and glasnost: “…This economic claims were immediately met. Sun
is in reference especially to the villages that rays wrapped in newspaper print. But when
were cut in two parts by the Prut, when the you open the Sovyetskaja Moldova and the
state border was established in 1940, villages Socialist Moldova, heavy clouds and lead,
that have retained their ancestral name on thunder and lightning appear to be wrapped
both banks. According to the new in the same newspaper print”288.
instructions, special crossing points are Taking into account the political
opened for the inhabitants of these transformations in Moldova, still Soviet
communities twice a week. You only have to though, Efim Crimerman presented weekly
provide a written confirmation of the cause the most important events which took place
of the trip, an official invitation from the between 1989 and 1990: the elections in the
relatives, a passport with the stamp that you Soviet Union and the Republican Supreme
have a residence visa in the frontier zone and Soviet, the declaration of sovereignty, the
you can move from Moldova to Moldova. A role of the new political organizations: the
small step, but a step forward. The climate of Popular Front, the Edinstvo and the Gagauz-
trust in cultural contacts is improving …”287 Halky movements, the emergence of self-
The actions of national emancipation proclaimed separatist republics - Gagauzia
were also presented by Efim Crimerman in and Transnistria etc. Crimerman working
the broadcasts of RFE, where he talked about relation with RFE ended in 1990, because the
history, language and democracy, about the post’s roster was filled with new journalists
articles published in the newspaper from Chișinău, while his collaboration with
Literatură și artă and the Nistru magazine, Radio Svoboda continued until 1994.
about the Green Theatre and the Victory
Square etc.: “It seems that the rigid wheel of The Jews Issue
democracy in Moldova has gotten moving.
When you open some issues of the Literature
and Art, you have the impression that the Crimerman spoke about the problem
rays of the sun, wrapped in newspaper print, of the Jews from the USSR in Russian, mostly
come from Chișinău. Moldovan writers and at Radio Svoboda, addressing the issues of
publicists, with an unparalleled boldness so anti-Semitism, prohibitions on leaving the
far, put on top of theirs priorities the most USSR, changing surnames or using the
pressing national issues. In the parks and pseudonyms by cultural workers to hide
other public places of the capital of Soviet their Jewish identity etc. He also touched on
Moldova, the so-called unofficial these issues in some airings in Romanian at
organizations convene rallies and meetings. Radio Free Europe, emphasizing the state of
And not long ago, as it is known, bus drivers affairs in SSR Moldova: the closure of Jewish

287 Grigore Singurel, Climatul de încredere și 288Grigore Singurel, Pe baricadele restructurării


vigilența (The confidence climate and the (On the barricade of the restructuration). Text
vigilance). Text presented within the broadcast presented within the broadcast ‘Domestic Bloc’,
‘Domestic Bloc’, no. 297 From April 19, 1988. no. 382 from August 16, 1988. Romanian
Romanian Broadcasting Department, Radio Broadcasting Department, Radio Free Europe.
Free Europe.

102
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

schools, the state of the Jewish cemetery in citizen of Jewish nationality’ between the
Chișinău, the creation of the anti-Zionist Dniester and the Prut”.
Committee: “Chișinău has 40,000 Jews. At the same time, Crimerman
Many of them have submitted applications pointed out some positive changes in the life
for departure. They are called ‘refuseniks’ of the Bessarabian Jews: “Recently, two
(not allowed to emigrate) because the Soviet synagogues were opened in the Republic
authorities do not let them go. Their number and a Jewish culture society was established.
is kept secret, but the newspaper Sovetskaja Since the beginning of this year, two Jewish
Moldavia has told its readers that the ensembles have been formed in Chișinău,
‘refuseniks’ in Chișinău are doing well and the Russian theatre in the capital of the
are surrounded by parental care”289. Republic has presented the premiere of the
In the context of the perestroika, the show ‘The Last Prayer’ after the novel by
Jews were more easily allowed to leave Şolom-Aleihem, ‘Tevie-lăptarul’. Even the
USSR, a reality that disturbed the party number of Jewish students in higher
authorities in Chișinău and which was education institutions has increased over the
discussed at one of the plenary sessions of past two years from two to three percent.
the Moldovan Communist Party in 1989. Yet, the Jews are leaving.”290
Crimerman commented on these debates in
one of his talks at Radio Free Europe: The Situation of Romania
“Speaking about the complicated social-
political situation in Soviet Moldova at the
plenary session, Lavranciuc states: ‘It must Efim Crimerman spoke about the
be stressed out that, under the influence of situation in Romania only in Russian at
this situation, migratory pressings are Radio Svoboda. In most of his talks, during
increasing. If, in 1987, 1,100 inhabitants of the 1981-1989, he criticized the Ceausescu
Republic left to settle abroad and 1,700 in regime and presented various social,
1988, in the first four months of this year, economic and political realities of socialist
more than 2,000 people received a visa.’ Let's Romania. In the context of the political
look at the figures quoted. In January this changes which took place in Romania in
year, for example, 2800 Jews left the Soviet December 1989, the Moldovan-Romanian
Union, out of which more than 500 were relations were revived, and therefore Efim
from Moldova. As we can see, the percentage Crimerman sometimes mentioned some
of the Bessarabian Jews in this wave of events regarding Romania's attitude
emigration, taking into account the small towards still Soviet Moldova in his
territory of the republic, is very high - about broadcasts at RFE during 1990.
the fifth part. Thus, it can be assumed that in
a decade there will be no so-called ‘Soviet

Grigore Singurel, Antisemitism official (Official


289 290Grigore Singurel, Exodul evreilor basarabeni
Antisemitism). Text presented within the (The Exodus of the Bessarabian Jews). Text
broadcast ‘Communist World’, no. 448 from presented within the broadcast ‘Domestic Bloc’,
March 12, 1985. Romanian Broadcasting no. 608 from June 28, 1989. Romanian
Department, Radio Free Europe. Broadcasting Department, Radio Free Europe.

103
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

and the action rules of RFE/RL. At the same


time, the editor wanted the statements to be
confirmed from two or three sources.
Therefore, in most cases, the sources are
shown at the end of the texts signed by
Crimerman, these being, as a rule, the
newspapers published in the SSR Moldova.
As regards the impact of the
broadcasts, despite the fact that some
surveys and reports had been conducted,
some of them based on letters received from
Socialist countries and USSR292, Crimerman
says that very few letters from the USSR or
SSR Moldova arrived to him. Moreover,
some of them had denigrating content and
Efrim Crimerman and Sergiu Musteață, Aachen, were most likely written by party
2014.
representatives, KGB officers or by persons
affiliated to the Soviet state institutions. The
To my question on censorship and
surveys by RFE/RL were based on a number
textual interventions by the editors of
of criteria with regard to the RFE/RL
RFE/RL, Efim Crimerman stated that they
audience, including the analysis of the
were mainly of orthographic order and
correspondence received from URSS and the
limited to proofreading his texts, both in
socialist states. Thus, in the first semester of
Russian and in Romanian: “He did not
1971, SSR Moldova reached 2% of the total
intervene. I wrote the material. I brought it in
number of letters, so was the situation in
two or three copies. I gave them to Leva,
Estonia and Latvia, while the Ukrainian SSR
Leva Roitman. He read it. He proofread it.
received 30%, and the Georgian SSR only
He knew Russian well, I did it worse. Yes, he
4%293.
did only that. Munteanu. We were friends.
He helped me, he laughed while reading. He
was looking to add. He added. He knew that Efim Crimerman vs. Communist
I was not afraid of ... correction”291. Regime
The traces of these editor’s
interventions can be found in the scripts Efim Crimerman does not consider
discovered in the Hoover Archives. In all himself to be a dissident but someone who
likelihood, the corrections attempted to attempted to show the real face of the
bring the articles in line with the guidelines communist regime, especially the way the

291Interview with Efim Crimerman, July 12, 2014, The Effectiveness of Radio Free Europe.
Aachen, Germany. Audience Research Department, RFE, December
292 RFE/RL, based on a series of surveys and 1965. HIA, RFE/RL Corporate Records
research works, made quarterly and annual Collection, Box 478, file 1.
reports on the impact of its emissions. For 293 Whelan (1972), CRS-265.

instance: Radio Free Europe Audience Research.

104
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Romanian language was destroyed and the bodies, countering any manifestation that
Jews were treated in the USSR: “I did not say: was qualified as ‘antisovietic’ or
‘Down with ...’. I worked, I'm anti-Soviet, yes, ‘unhealthy’ . Thus, in the years of the Soviet
296

that is what I'm convinced of. But I'm not a regime, the Central Committee of the
dissident. What did I do, did I break anything Communist Party of the Soviet Union made
in Moldova? On the contrary, I helped them several decisions to combat ‘hostile radio
get closer to the Romanian language. What propaganda’, such as the decision from July
have you done with this language? That's 19 1960, ‘About the measures of active
what I was fighting with”294. counteraction to hostile radio propaganda’.
His work at Radio Free Europe was Jamming was just one of the technical
disregarded by the party organs and the KGB methods used to prevent citizens from
in the USSR. Soviet authorities conducted an listening to these channels.297
active policy against the Western In 1959, the Soviet authorities
propaganda, especially against radio partially halted Voice of America and BBC
stations. In order to better understand the radio stations298, but RFE/RL still remained
USSR policy towards Western radio stations, forbidden in the USSR. That is why, in the
I will present some examples of documents battle for audience, the USSR radio stations
from the archives of Chișinău295. The protest broadcasted in the languages of the
manifestations in the states of the socialist Republics between 5 p.m.-10 p.m. (taking
camp, GDR (1952), Hungary and Poland into account the time zone differences),
(1956), Czechoslovakia (1968), covered which would have drawn the attention of the
extensively by the Western radio stations, listeners from the programs of the Western
including RFE/RL, were considered radio stations. The Communist authorities
potential sources of grievance in the USSR, considered Radio Free Europe as ‘a weapon
while the access to Western sources of of imperialist propaganda directed against
information could contribute to reduce the socialist states and, above all, against the
people's confidence in the Soviet mass Soviet Union’, led by the Committee of Free
media. That is why the spirit of the SSR Europe in New York, organized with the
Moldova’s population was very closely help of ‘American Zionists’299.
monitored by the party and state security

294 Interview with Efim Crimerman, 12 July, 298 Only broadcasts considered hostile, ranging
Aachen, Germany. from 5-30% to 75-95%, were jammed. Cf. the
295 The archive of the Social-Political Department of Propaganda and Agitation of the
Organizations of the Republic of Moldova Central Committee of the CPSU for Union
(archive of Central Committee of Communist Republics, July 15, 1960.
Party of Moldova) and the Special Deposit of SIS 299 The response of the State Committee of the

(archive of the State Security Committee attached Soviet of Ministers of the SSR Moldova for the
to the Moldovan SSR Ministers' Soviet Union / Television and Radio broadcasting at the request
KGB). of the KGB on Free Europe Radio, signed on May
296 Cașu (2009). 26, 1972. The special deposit of the SIS (KGB), the
297 See more details about jamming techniques Judiciary Files of the Persons subjected to Political
and history in the following articles: Pleikys, Repression during the Communist regime,
(2003) (accessed on 20.02.2017); Król (1992). personal file 017006 (Usatiuc-Ghimpu), volume
10, f. 263-264.

105
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

In 1960, there were about 20 million involvement of the Ministry of


radio sets in the USSR that could receive Communications, the Ministry of Internal
broadcasts from the radio stations of the Affairs, the State Security Committee, the
West, but the authorities could not imagine Republican Committee of the DOSAAF, the
the real picture of the number of listeners. It Prosecutor's Office, the Supreme Court, the
was clear though that people listened to city and district councils in combating this
those stations extensively and adapted their phenomenon, attested in many
radio sets in order to receive ultra-short communities of the SSR Moldova302.
waves. The Department of Propaganda and Following the events in Prague in
Agitation of the Communist Party of the 1968, the Soviet authorities took a number of
USSR reported in July 1960 to the Central steps to monitor the mood of the population
Committee that ‘some disabled war and to prevent access to alternative sources of
veterans, radio-technicians, and especially information. Thus, in May 1972, the State
radio enthusiasts install ultra-short Committee of the Soviet of Ministers of the
diapason, from 10 meters, into the radio sets SSR Moldova for Television and Radio
available to the population for 250-300 broadcasting reported, at the request of the
roubles. Only Western radio stations can be State Security Committee (KGB), that “in
received on these waves. Even in Moscow, 1968-1971 false information on the so-called
in the GUM and other stores, the buyers of ‘Bessarabian problem’ and Romania's claims
radio sets were closely approached by on the territory of Moldova, the rebirth of
people without any occupation, with the nationalist tendencies in the Republic and so
proposal to install ultra-short waves on are included more and more often in the
diapason into the radio’300. Radio Free Europe programs”303.
Unhappy with the way in which the That is why, in 1972, the Central
decisions from 26 February 1960 and 16 July Committee of the Communist Party of
1963 were implemented, the Central Moldova addressed to the Central Committee
Committee of the Communist Party of the of the Communist Party of the USSR the
USSR approved a new decision in 1970 request to dispatch a number of KGB
attempting to prosecute more efficiently operatives in the frontier regions of the
those who used the radio sets illegally 301. Republic of Moldova in order to more
Besides listening to the Western radio effectively combat ‘the work of special
stations, the programmes of these radio services and ideological centers from Western
stations were treated as dangerous, as countries and Israel, that turn up the heat, use
‘hooligan songs, vulgar jokes, and the formations of Jewish Bessarabian
uncensored talks, harmful political and anti- emigration and the Romanian nationalist
Soviet talks are transmitted’. That is why the
party bodies call for a more serious

300 Musteață (2017), 56. of the KGB on Free Europe Radio, signed on May
301 Musteață (2017), 57. 26, 1972. The special deposit of the SIS (KGB), the
302 Ibidem. Judiciary Files of the Persons subjected to Political
303 The response of the State Committee of the Repression during the Communist regime,
Soviet of Ministers of the SSR Moldova for the personal file 017006 (Usatiuc-Ghimpu), volume
Television and Radio broadcasting at the request 10, f. 263-264.

106
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

centers’304. Until 1972, the KGB had offices Russians. Because I was listened to not only
only in 12 districts out of the 33, and therefore by the Romanians, I was listened to by the
the Chişinău leadership requested the Russians, and the Russians were in power
opening of the sections of state security there...” One day he was invited to a meeting
bodies in other districts. First, the opening of in town by two strangers, who, pretending to
sections in the districts along the Romanian be tourists coming from Romania, wishing to
border was requested, where, out of 11 meet Crimerman very much. They claimed
districts, the KGB had offices in only five they had been given his telephone number
districts. by a priest who wrote for Free Europe: ‘It
During the plenary meeting of the CC was dangerous because they were sent from
of the Moldovan Communist Party on Romania, there were two of them. One called
December 1983, Simion Grossu, the First me in the evening’: ‘Mr. Crimerman, we came
Secretary, spoke about the need to intensify to interview you and ...’ but they did not say
counterpropaganda activities against the they were from Romania … and ‘we know
Western information offensive. In March this one, that priest.’ ‘I say I do not know him.
1984, in Chişinău, a scientific-practical I knew one priest, but it was not him. Not this
conference on counterpropaganda took place, one.’ And I went to the Antiquity Exhibition
attended by over 100 specialists in various with my wife. And one of them stopped us.
fields. Historian Ivan Ţaranov said that the (They were not stylishly dressed and they
broadcasts of Free Europe are hostile to the were no longer young.) And he started
Soviet people. After the conference, the pulling my leg: ‘I did, I was ... And I felt he
Scientific Center of Counterpropaganda was was a phony. So I smelled it was’ ... So I told
created, and a similar office was opened in my wife in Russian: ‘It smells like a rat’. He
Chişinău, which co-ordinated the activity of invites me: ‘Come, I have some sweets from
counterpropaganda groups within the Party Bucharest, very, very tasty and very rare’.
Regional Committees.305 ‘Thank you, on another occasion.’ And then,
In spite of the fact they were working it has been confirmed that both of them were
under a pseudonym, the real name of those ... They wanted to finish me, as they killed
who worked at the radio stations was two people from the Romanian editorial
relatively quickly discovered by the staff”306.
communist authorities in the SSR Moldova. Soon after this meeting, an aggressive
We find out that the activity at RFE/RL was campaign against Efim Crimerman started
dangerous from Efim Crimerman's report: in the newspapers of the SSR Moldova with
several times he was called on his phone the title ‘Anti-Sovietism. How is it being
home, most likely by the agents located on formed?’ Thus, on August 29, 1984, the
the territory of the German Federal Republic, newspaper Moldova socialistă (Socialist
and prevented: “Yes, I was told like that: Moldova) published the article “A ‘Knight’
«Заткнись, а то убьем тебя» (Shut up, or of lying and slander” in the ‘Moldavian’
we'll kill you.). Russians… Yes. The language, signed by Fiodor Angheli, the

Secret letter no. 210c addressed to the CC of the


304 Crimerman (2011), 267-268.
305

PCUS, signed by I. Bodiul, first secretary of the Interview with Efim Crimerman, July 12, 2014,
306

CC of the PCM, July 3, 1972. AOSPOM, fond 51, Aachen, Germany.


op. 33, folder 82, files 1-4.

107
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Director of the Moldovan Telegraph Agency In January 1987, the newspaper


(ATEM), and member of the CC of PCM307. Moldova socialistă published another article,
Soon afterwards, the article was published in which stated that “in order to cloud the
several Russian-language newspapers in the minds of the people of our country and of
Sovetskaja Moldavija on 4th of September 1984, other countries of the socialist community,
and in the Večernij Kišinev, on 8th of our ideological opponents largely use the
September308. The article directly targets most unworthy ways and means, including
Efim Crimerman, who, ‘as a CIA agent, is religion and nationalism”310. This article
hiding under the pseudonym Grigore attempted to combat allegations regarding
Singurel, the former inhabitant of the USSR’s ban on the anniversary of a
Chişinău…’309. millennium since the Christianization of
Fiodor Angheli, the author of the Russia, scheduled for 1988, considered to be
article, tries to link the Jewish problem in the ‘hostile attempts’ that have ‘anti-Sovietic
USSR to the situation of the black people and purposes’. Grigore Singurel and Nicolae
the Jews in the USA, considering that Lupan were attacked within the article,
Crimerman makes ‘Zionist propaganda’, being the first time that they were labelled
which was associated by him with ‘the ‘dissidents’ by a Soviet daily: “They were
phrases widely applied by Goebbels's singing to the tune of their masters and the
Chancellery in Hitler's Germany’. dissidents - such as Singurel, who had taken
Crimerman's interventions on the economic hold at Radio Liberty, and Lupan, the
situation in Soviet Moldova were described anointed of Free Europe, who claimed that
as ‘an attempt to discredit socialism as a the baptism of the ‘Romanian’ people, whose
whole and, in particular, the cooperative inseparable part they considered to be the
plan of V.I. Lenin’. Finally, Crimerman was Moldovans, happened long before ‘the
described as a ‘liar’, a ‘knight of slander’ baptism of Russia’311.
associated with Nozdriov, the hero of Gogol. In the same style were the speeches
The content of the article allows us to delivered by the participants in the gathering
notice that Crimerman's talks at RFE/RL of the Republican activists of the party from
were recorded and analysed very carefully, September 29, 1987. The speech given by G.
Grigore Singurel's own words being quoted M. Volkov, the head of the State Security of
very often. So, the Chișinău authorities were the SSR Moldova (KGB), stands out, as it
strongly disturbed by Crimerman's labelled Radio Liberty and Radio Free
performance at RFE. The campaign of Europe as parts of the subversive activity of
denigration continued in the following years special services, centres and organizations
through a series of articles in the Moldovan from abroad against Moldova: “…Our
press. classist opponent regards nationalism and

307In Ion Țurcanu’s view, „the intelligence agency 309 Crimerman (2011), 267.
ATEM, led by a servant of the regime, 310 L. Makarov, „… Cu piatra în sân”, Moldova
exceedingly zealous, a Russophile and socialistă, January 30, 1987.
Russophone Gagauz F. Angheli…” Țurcanu, 144. 311 Ibidem.

308 F. Angheli, „Un «cavaler» al minciunii și

clevetirii” (A knight of the lie and gossip),


Moldova socialistă, August 29, 1984.

108
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

religion as Trojan horse, called upon to break - former inhabitants of Moldova is


down socialism from within. In the considered by the Communist leadership of
organization of ideological diversions, the Chișinău to be ‘subversive’ because they
most active are, as before, the subversive ‘falsify the history of Moldova’, ‘speculate
radio stations Liberty and Free Europe, with the ‘Bessarabian problem’, ‘accuse the
where the father and the son Lupan, Soviet Union of violating the Helsinki
Crimerman and Renata Lisnic located agreements’. The fact that these subjects
themselves, after having left the Republic. were discussed at the party meetings is not
Trying to cope in their vile activity with the new, as it was the participation of KGB
restructuring that takes place in our country, representatives at these meetings. But,
the scum have changed their tactics. Not through the speeches of the President of the
only do they comment in a slanderous form State Security of the SSR Moldova, one can
on the critical articles published in the Union see how carefully the security officers
and the Republican press, but also call on the listened to the broadcasts of the Western
radio listeners in Moldova to anti-Soviet, radio stations, and the qualifications
nationalist actions”312. attributed to them demonstrate their fear
about the ‘negative’ impact on the Soviet
society.
Efim Crimerman laughs at this
statement and ‘how well the Moldovan KGB
was informed’ because there was no such
group, especially ‘coordinated by an
unknown hand’, stating that Victor Lupan
and Renata Lisnic lived in Paris and were not
linked to Radio Free Europe.313 It is true that,
Victor Lupan, as a journalist, has
collaborated with RFE, but mainly on
Oriental issues.
In 1987, the weekly Literatura și Arta
(Literature and Art) launched the "War of the
Waves" column, a series of articles with the
title "What's new in Free Europe or
Comics in the Literatura și Arta, 1987.
reflections on some radiofollies". These were
signed by Sorin Vlaicu, who recognized from
The activity of the emigrants, called
the very beginning that his columns were a
‘Moldavologs’ - bourgeois Romanian and
irect response to Radio Free Europe talks
Moldovan nationalists, originated from
that ‘attacked me several times, commenting
former Bessarabia, as well as the other scum
on some of my articles, robbing the truth

312„Să educăm patrioți internaționaliști. Din party which took place on 29 of September 1987),
cuvântările la adunarea activului republican de Moldova socialistă, October 3, 1987. The article was
partid, care a avut loc în ziua de 29 septembrie also published in a Russian version in Sovetskaja
1987” (Let’s educate international patriotes. Moldavija, 3.10.1987.
Aspects of the talks during the gathering of the 313 Crimerman (2011), 269.

109
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

from its elementary data and calling me


unjustly all sorts of things’. In fact, he wrote
four articles in which he directly attacks
Nicolae Lupan and Efim Crimerman314. Sorin
Vlaicu considers the Western radio stations
(Radio Free Europe, Liberty, Voice of
America) to be ‘in the service of espionage’,
being disturbed mostly by RFE, which
‘programs are prepared exclusively for our
Republic’, through the editorials of Nicolae
Lupan and Grigore Singurel. Vlaicu was
even more disturbed by the fact that,
according to Soviet-American agreements
Literatura și Arta, 1987. Comics by D. Trifan
from 1987, jamming of Western radio
stations stopped, and the messages from the
On the one hand, we can notice the
outside could reach the Moldovan audience
concern of the Chișinău authorities about the
easily: “So, they can reach without a
widespread access of the inhabitants of the
hindrance the ears of listeners, ears of
SSR Moldova to the information from the
various kinds, whose ideological training,
West, following the cessation of the
we recognize, sometimes leaves much to be
jamming316. On the other hand, they
desired, some of them being ‘enchanted’ by
admitted that the public was poorly
the nice phrases of those who always
informed, i.e. unilaterally informed, because
vociferate in front of microphone. And there
of the way the news were presented by the
is also our listener, as I mentioned, poorly
institutions subordinated to the communist
informed”315.
regime.

314 Sorin Vlaicu, „Ce mai nou e la Europa Liberă 316By 1986, in the USSR, there had been 13 radio
sau reflecții pe marginea unor radiobazaconii. (1) centers with wide protection and 61 stations with
Războiul undelor”, Literatura şi arta 2199, no. 39, local protection with a capacity of 40,000 kwt,
September 24, 1987. „Ce mai nou e la Europa jamming the programs of eight Western radio
Liberă sau reflecții pe marginea unor stations: Voice of America, BBC, Liberty, Free
radiobazaconii. (2) Războiul undelor. Calea Europe, Deutsche Welle, Voice of Israel, Radio
lungă a trădării”, Literatura şi arta 2204, no. 44, Beijing, and Radio Korea. The informative note of
October 29, 1987; „Ce mai nou e la Europa Liberă the CC of the PCUS, strictly secret, dated from
sau reflecții pe marginea unor radiobazaconii. (3) 25.09.1986 "Regarding the cease of jamming of
Războiul undelor. Calea lungă a trădării”, the broadcasts by "Voice of America", "BBC",
Literatura şi arta 2205, no. 45, November 5, 1987; „Radio Beijing” and "Radio Korea”, signed by Е.
„Ce mai nou e la Europa Liberă. (4) Războiul Ligachev, V. Chebrikov. Total cease of jamming
undelor. În prizonieratul arginților”, Literatura și of western radio stations was suggested on
arta, 2211, no. 51 (December 17, 1987). November 30, 1988, according to the Order no.
315 Vlaicu, „Ce mai nou e la Europa Liberă sau 38c of the Ministry of the Communications of the
reflecții pe marginea unor radiobazaconii. (1) USSR, from 19.12.1988. Source:
Războiul undelor”. http://www.radiojamming.info/ (Accessed on
20.02.2017).

110
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Vlaicu, in the spirit of the statements authorities resorted to a direct attack on


of the KGB head of Chișinău, claimed that people and the attempt to discredit them in
“due to the directives received from front of the local audience.
Washington, a new detachment of specialists The fourth article in the series
recruited into the espionage centres or from initiated by the Literatura și Arta is devoted
the ranks of the ‘renegades’ has appeared at mainly to Efim Crimerman, who is again
Liberty and Free Europe”317. Thus, in the first labelled with derogatory words:
article of the “War of Waves” series, ‘diversionist, mercantile, outsider, renegade’
members of the ‘Moldovan section’ at Free etc. In this article, Crimerman is compared
Europe were listed as follows: Victor Lupan, both with Jules Verne, and with a monkey.
Nicolae Lupan, Grigore Singurel, Renata With regard to the pseudonym, Vlaicu insists
Lisnic and George Cioranescu, who ‘shed that “the pseudonym Singurel fits well with
crocodile tears, lamenting the bitter fate of this renegade. It is even better than Ciuntu.
the ‘oppressed’ and ‘humiliated’ inhabitants Crimerman is not a defective man. The texts
of our Republic”318. he was making were defective. He is a
The fact that both Lupan and stranger hidden from the eyes of the world.
Crimerman often based their comments on As Victor Hugo said, a lonely person is a
Chișinău's press, especially during the diminutive of a savage accepted by
perestroika, greatly disturbed the Moldovan civilization. E. Crimerman is also a lonely
authorities, which categorized them as savage”320.
subjective and false: “Hiding themselves The author of the article comments on
under the mask of ‘objectivity’, they a series of talks by Crimeman accusing him
manipulate and change the accents in every of taking only “well-known pieces of
piece of information about our country, information, obsolete, outdated and
denying the success of the restructuring in consumed moments” from the Chișinău
every possible way”319. The dilemma of the press, of repeating some texts in the
communist authorities was delicate: the broadcasts of this radio station and so on.
perestroika offered the possibility to criticise Finally, Vlaicu addresses the RFE / RL
the system, but they wanted the critique to be leadership with the suggestion to get rid of
controlled by them. Moreover, when critical Crimerman: “But don’t the gentlemen from
messages about the system or the problems Noah’s team know that before pointing to the
faced by the Soviet society, based on the press garbage in the neighbour’s yard one should
from Chișinău, came from outside, they put one’s own house in order? In other
reacted adversely. words, those ones from Munich must get rid
Lupan and Crimerman had been of mystifications and mystificators first and
speaking for many years at RFE/RL, but the foremost”321. These statements demonstrate
attacks on them intensified in 1987. Along once again that Crimerman's airings were
with the cessation of jamming, communist listened to, recorded and analysed.

317 Vlaicu, „Ce mai nou e la Europa Liberă sau 320 Vlaicu, „Ce mai nou e la Europa Liberă. (4)
reflecții pe marginea unor radiobazaconii. (1) Războiul undelor. În prizonieratul arginților”
Războiul undelor”. (What is new at Radio Free Europe. War on
318 Ibidem. waves. Money’s prisoner).
319 Ibidem. 321 Ibidem.

111
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

The articles in the weekly Literatura și with the mention Munich, is wearing three
Arta are accompanied by a few caricatures, ties with a name written on each: E. Ciuntu,
signed by Dumitru Trifan. The first is a E. Crimerman, G. Singurel, and spitting in
snake wrapped around a microphone. On the direction of a map with the inscription
the snake’s body there is an inscription Free SSR Moldova. As I have mentioned above,
Europe and on the microphone support - the this article attempts to discredit Crimerman,
abbreviation CIA. The second one is a man the caricature being an illustration of the
with black glasses at the microphone, denigrating text.
dressed in cloth, a button on his shirt with a In the context of the perestroika, the
dollar sign, wearing a lambskin hat, with the editorial policy of the weekly Literatura și
inscription Free Europe on the belt and a start Arta changed: it became an opponent of the
key on the back, like the one the mechanical central power, often being criticized at the
clocks have, with the abbreviation DCR on party assemblies, threatened with judicial
it, which might have meant the CIA. In the proceedings or closure. The caricaturist
third issue, the caricature likely represents Dumitru Trifan had already begun to scoff
the same person speaking at the at the Communist authorities. Because of
microphone, this time in a dog booth, on the this, Demidenko, the general prosecutor of
front of which there is the inscription Free the SSR Moldova, threatened him with
Europe, and behind it, inside the booth, one prosecution. Efim Crimerman, who noted
can see the face of a guy wearing black the transformation of Trifan's caricatures,
glasses. The person has a necklace with a wrote and spoke about this subject,
dollar-shaped pendant around the neck, a considering that, in all likelihood, Trifan
knife in the right hand and a piece of bone in understood that not RFE was to blame for
the left. There is one bone in the jacket the situation in Moldova but the Moldovan
pocket and another one beside the booth, nomenklatura322.
with the inscription fee. Next to the bone, These articles were a ‘celebration’ for
there is an open can, with the inscription jom Efim Crimerman, because he saw the
(sugar beet pulp). Taking into account the impact of his work, which disturbed the
fact that Nicolae Lupan was discussed in party organs and the KGB. He believes that
articles two and three, the caricaturist due to his comments, the Chișinău
probably tried to represent him. The leadership took measures to correct the
caricature in the fourth article of the situation, as was the case with his editorials
Literatura și Arta is even more suggestive, about ‘The taste of bread’323 from March 26
because the head of a guy with black glasses, and ‘Bakers from Chișinău’324 from May 16,
who has an earring with the inscription Free 1985, when he talked about the problem of
Europe and a cross bandage on his left cheek cereals assurance in the Moldavian Soviet

322 Grigore Singurel, Caricaturile din ziarul 323 Text presented within the broadcast
„Literatura şi arta” (The caricatures from Literature ‘Communist World’, no. 456 from March 26,
and Art newspaper). Text presented within the 1985. Romanian Broadcasting Department, Radio
broadcast ‘Domestic Bloc’, no. 487 from January Free Europe.
10, 1989. Romanian Broadcasting Department, 324 Text presented within the broadcast ‘Domestic

Radio Free Europe. Bloc’, no. 608 from May 13, 1985. Romanian
Broadcasting Department, Radio Free Europe.

112
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Socialist Republic; at the end of May 1985, Service, in a note addressed to Joel Blocker,
the Central Committee of the Communist noted with satisfaction the impact of the
Party of Moldova approved a decision to issues addressed by Crimerman and Lupan
resolve the issue. His airing, ‘Nothing new on the SSR Moldova: “It is true that the
on the front of drinking’, in which he talked programs issued for the Soviet Moldovans
about the transformation of the Greek are not of the same quality as those for the
Church into a wine tasting room also had an Romanians in Romania... Unfortunately, our
impact: “In Moldova, they began to fight attempts to find Bessarabian professionals
drinking and restore cultural monuments. freely are very limited. I will, however,
On the corner of Kiev and June 28th streets, in speak to those two freelance professionals
the centre of the city, they restored the about the issue and the need to look for
building of the Greek Church, which had some better elements in the future. ... I
been erected long ago by brothers Ion and would like to add that the feedback from
Viktor Sinadino. They re-edified its graceful Bessarabia indicates that the broadcasts are
lines, the stained glass lit up, the stone began very popular and that both people,
to speak. You get into this place of prayer Crimerman and Lupan, have been
and you are stuck. Instead of the altar - the constantly attacked by the Moldovan Soviet
counter with bottles, instead of icons - press for their contributions.”327
barrels of wine. They have restored the Efim Crimerman and Nicolae Lupan,
church and made it a pub ...”325 A few alongside other people working for RFE/RL,
months later, the Chişinău leadership were included on the List no. 1, the list of
transformed the church and its surrounding persons who did not have the right to enter
area into an art exhibition. Thanks to the the USSR for ideological reasons – that was
‘Tigers on arena’ talks in November 1985, the ‘black lists of the KGB’ of the so-called
where they spoke about the dismissal of a ‘anti-Soviet persons’328. In addition to these
driver from Ocniţa district, who dared reactions, letters from listeners came from
criticize his boss in January 1986, the CC the USSR, appreciating and thanking
Bureau of the PCC reinstated him in his RFE/RL collaborators for their performance.
former position, while the respective Crimerman remembers such a message from
superior and the regional secretary of the a Ukrainian citizen living in Moldova who
party were punished326. thanked him: “Although I live in Moldova, I
The issue of the quality and the way do not understand much about what is
of presentation of Soviet Moldova in happening here. I would like to thank
RFE/RL programs remained on the agenda Grigore Singurel for his exceptional analysis
of the administration and was sporadically of this Republic”329.
discussed. In 1986, Vlad Georgescu, the The US Administration of RFE/RL
director of the Romanian Free Europe also sent thankful messages to its

325 Text presented within the broadcast 327 Memorandum. Radio Free Europe Division,
‘Communist World’, no. 556 from September 17, Letter signed by Vlad Georgescu to Joel Blocker,
1985. Romanian Broadcasting Department, Radio August 11, 1986. HIA, RFE/RL Corporate Records
Free Europe. Collection.
326 Crimerman (2011), 270-271. 328 Crimerman (2011), 268.

329 Crimerman (2011), 273.

113
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

collaborators for certain programs or special to return to Free Europe because “I do not
performances. Thus, George Urban noticed want to. Let me repeat - it's a tragedy. It's a
one of Crimerman's editorials regarding tragedy to talk about newspapers...”333
judges in Soviet Moldova: “I would like to Crimerman means the texts based on the SSR
thank you for the exceptional article ‘Who Moldova newspapers. However, he is very
are the judges?’”330 This is a typical radio pleased with his performance at RFE / RL
show that addresses the listeners directly, in and the years spent in Munich because: “I
today’s complicated context. At the same wrote and what I wrote was aired. I
time, your scepticism and humour deserve succeeded. I was listened to. … .”334
attention. Thank you”331. In an interview for the Nezavisimaja
Moldova, during his visit to Chișinău in the
Final Remarks summer of 1993, Efim Crimerman, when
asked about his attitude towards those who
had criticized him during the communist
Efim Crimerman wrote in his book
regime, answered simply: ‘Old habits die
that the time of his pseudonyms had passed
hard’, as most of them have kept their
and nobody knows if they remain in the
functions but turn to nationalism. Only by
memory of the people. With the closure of the
‘ending with nationalism, will we get rid of
RFE/RL office in Munich and its transfer to
communism’. Thus, Crimerman, as a
Prague, many employees and external
collaborators ceased their activity and representative of an ethnic minority in the
Republic of Moldova, believes that with the
collaboration with these radio stations. In this
collapse of the USSR, the political actors have
context, Efim Crimerman left Radio Free
Europe too: “I said good-bye to the radio adopted another extreme – the nationalism.
As to the question about the need for Radio
station, whose voice, during the gloomy
Liberty, he replied that we need liberty all
Soviet era, was a call to another world - the
world of freedom. I said good-bye to the the time, and Radio Liberty should continue
its mission, especially for the states in
English Garden, to my friends, to the studio,
transition, like the Republic of Moldova.
the microphone and my pseudonyms. The
Crimerman, although convinced that
station moved to Prague, and Shena and I
Moldova is a part of Romania, of the
went to my children, in Aachen”332.
Romanian language, culture, past and
During our interviews, Efim
traditions, considers that Moldova should
Crimerman expressed his gratitude for his
take advantage of the chance offered by
years at RFE/RL: “First of all, I am glad to
history to be an independent state335.
have found my voice”, but he did not want

330 Text presented within the broadcast ‘Domestic The article was commented at Radio Svoboda
335

Bloc’, no. 728 from October 28, 1985. Romanian on July 1, 1993. HU OSA 297-0-1-57248; Radio
Broadcasting Department, Radio Free Europe. Liberty (Radio Svoboda) Russian Broadcast
331 Crimerman (2011), 272. Recordings; Open Society Archives at CEU,
332 Ibidem, 273, 278. Budapest,http://catalog.osaarchivum.org/catalog
333 Interview with Efim Crimerman, July 12, 2014, /osa:91d26d1e-09a9-4cfd-8c60-4f8c81df479f#
Aachen, Germany. (Accessed on 23.02.2017).
334 Interview with Efim Crimerman, July 12, 2014,

Aachen, Germany.

114
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

References: Musteață, S. 2017. Basarabeanul bruiat


de KGB. La microfonul Europei Libere ‒ Grigore
Abshire, D. M. „Radio Free Europe Singurel, 1981-1990 (A Bessarabian Jammed
and Radio Liberty – A New Era” NATO by KGB. Speaking at Radio Free Europe ‒
Review 23/2, April 1975. Grigore Singurel, 1981-1990), vol. 1-2.
Cașu, I. „Starea de spirit a populației Chișinău: Arc.
RSSM în contextul destalinizării și revoluției Pleikys, R. 2003. „Radio Jamming in
maghiare (1956)”(The state of mind of the the Soviet Union, Poland and other East
Moldavian population in the context of the European Countries”,
de-Stalinization and the Hungarian http://www.radiojamming.
Revolution of 1956) PONTES. Review of South puslapiai.lt/article_en.htm.
East European Studies 5 (2009). Țurcanu, I. 2016. Din răsărit până în
Crimerman, E. 2011. Голос из-за бугра. amurg. Amintiri (From Dusk till Down.
Ckpunmы u ъocnoмuнaнuя (A voice from Memories). Chișinău: Arc.
behind the hillock. Texts and memories). Whelan, J. G. 1972. „Radio Liberty: A
Gelsen. Study of its Origins. Structure, Policy,
Król, M. „Listening Through the Programming and Effectiveness”, Library of
Jamming” The American Scholar 61/3, Congress. Congressional Research Service,
Summer (1992). Washington, DC.
Mickelson, Sig. 1983. America´s Other
Voice. The Story of Radio Free Europe and Radio
Liberty. New York: Praeger Publishing.

Sergiu Musteaţă is a historian from the Republic of Moldova, professor at the History and Geography
Faculty of the “Ion Creangă” State Pedagogical University of Moldova. He was awarded his Ph.D. at the
History Faculty of “Al. I. Cuza” University, Iași, Romania. He is the author of 7 monographs, more than
300 scientific publications, editor of over 30 books, and two journals. His major academic interests are
history of Eastern Europe, cultural heritage preservation and textbooks analysis.

115
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

REVIEWS

116
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Cristian Vasile (ed.). 2017. „Ne trebuie oameni!” Elite intelectuale și transformări istorice în
România modernă și contemporană („We Need People!” Intellectual Elite and Historical
Transformations in Modern and Contemporary Romania). Târgoviște: Cetatea de Scaun,
442 p.

The Romanian history of the last


century and a half was marked by the need
to create elites not only well trained, but also
fashioned by the dominant modernizing
ideologies. Under the sign of this string, the
historian Cristian Vasile places his scientific
approach in the collective volume of studies,
We Need People!" Intellectual Elite and
Historical Transformations in Modern and
Contemporary Romania, published by Cetatea
de Scaun editing house in Târgoviște in 2017.
Putting together studies of specialists
from several socio-human disciplines, the
volume proposes to the reader an original
approach focused primarily on
understanding the mechanisms of
conversion and reconversion of the elites
from one regime to another and their role in
various modernization projects.
By opting for such a topic, the volume
The formation of a new elite capable contributes to the study of the relationship
to modernize Romania was one of the between the elites, the state and the society,
priorities of the modern Romanian state. while covering a research gap, since the
Starting with the first generation of studies conducted so far have focused
graduates, young people returning from mainly on the formation and elimination
abroad tried to apply the Western model to processes as well as on the process of
the country, establishing new institutions reconversion from the old to the new
and reforming the old ones in a modernizing political regimes (Katherine Verdery (1990),
spirit. After 1945, the Western model was Gheorghe and Luminiţa Iacob (1995), Dennis
abandoned, with Romania copying the Deletant (1999), Bogdan Murgescu (2010),
soviet model. The old elites were eliminated Lucian Boia (2011), Daniel Chirot (2012),
or reconverted, while the new elites were Victor Rizescu (2013)).
formed in the USSR. After the fall of Actually, Cristian Vasile’s edited
communism, the Western model is back to book is not his first as regards the
the forefront of cultural, social and political modernizing role of the Romanian elites, he
life, with the elites relying again on Western has already published several works focused
values. on the relationship between the elite and the

117
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

state, in communism and post-communism distinguished themselves in their fields of


(Vasile, 2011, 2014). The current volume competence.
seems to be a continuation of the Ionuț-Florin Biliuţă analyzes the case
coordinator's scholarly interests, being the of the Orthodox ecclesial elite in the
result of a collective research within the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.
project, ‘Fragmented Modernities: The position of most Orthodox clergy was
Intellectual Elite and Historical ambivalent, alternating between supporting
Transformations in Contemporary the modernizing policies of the state and
Romania’, carried out at the ‘Nicolae Iorga’ opposing to the initiatives aimed at
History Institute and financed by Consiliul abolishing old church rights. At the same
Național al Cercetării Științifice (National time, a new category of bright priests, well
Council of Scientific Research). trained in the teachings and church canons,
The volume emphasizes from its aware of the necessity of the modernization,
introduction, written by the editor, that the showed their support to the process. Due to
adaptation and re-conversion of the their actions, a professionalization of the
intellectual elites from one regime to another Orthodox clergy became possible, which will
is the sign of the resistance to change of the gradually lead to the creation of a
Romanian society as well as a pattern of the modernizing ecclesiastical elite, capable of
inability of various governments to develop dialogue with both the state institutions and
effective mechanisms for implementing the structures of the church.
modernization projects with impact on the Călin Cotoi investigates the role of
masses. Copied or imposed from outside, the physicians and hygienists in the nineteenth
modernization projects ended up in century in producing social modernity, from
Romania by being implemented only the moment of the inauguration of
partially, the 20th century proving to be ‘the quarantine outposts against plague and
age of fragmentary modernities’, which, cholera epidemics. This initial campaign is
however, ‘made their durable mark [on followed by a whole series of ‘failed but
society] until today, through traces left at the productive’ modernization projects (p. 65).
level of cultural, social and mental life’ The stage of nationalization and
(Cristian Vasile, Introduction, p. 13). professionalization of medicine and hygiene
This ‘fragmentary modernity’ through the creation in Romania of some
consists of projects ranging from the specialized organizations, integrated into a
ideological, national to the technical- transnational network, marked by the
reformist, related to the development of personalities of Jacob Felix and Carol Davila,
certain scientific disciplines such as public was followed by the hygiene project crisis,
hygiene, demography, statistics, economics, the proliferation of the ‘racial degeneration
mathematics, cybernetics, social health, of the Romanian element’ idea advanced by
anthropology, sociology, psychology, Constantin I. Istrati, as well as the
human geography. Some of these establishment of the first bacteriological
modernization projects are analyzed in the laboratories led by Victor Babeș.
current volume by historians and Valentin Săndulescu focusses on the
anthropologists who have already professional trajectories of some scholars
such as Vladimir Dumitrescu, Petre P.

118
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Panaitescu and Traian Herseni, from their of development as well as its return, starting
attachment to the legionary movement, with 1960. Without claiming to establish a
during the interwar period, to their ‘radical conceptual history, the article draws,
professionalization’ as an adaptation through the accuracy and force of
strategy during communism. Excessive argumentation, much more than ‘a sketch of
specialization, often in scientific the evolution of terms in a society
subdivisions considered as priority in the profoundly impregnated by ideology’ (p.
process of industrialization, was the strategy 285).
that some intellectuals adopted, abandoning Anca Şincan investigates the
the political guise of the Iron Guard in favor relationship between the state and the
of the communist ideological program. church during communism, starting with the
Traian Herseni, for example, gave up to the case of Gheorghe Nenciu, who was
theory of sociological monograph initiated dismissed in the 1970s by the Department of
by the sociological school of Dimitrie Gusti Cults on the grounds of corruption and
and also to the vision of the peasant collaboration with the Legionary movement.
civilization inspired by the legionary Using as starting point of her investigation
movement in favor of industrial psychology Nenciu's dossier, the author reaches the
and sociology of success adapted to the wider issue of how certain institutional
requirements of the intensive structures come to reproduce themselves
industrialization plans. from one regime to another.
Camelia Zavarache is interested in Narcis Tulbure analyzes the role of
the trajectories of three Romanian some technical elites in areas such as
psychologists: Mihai Ralea, Alexandru economics, statistics and cybernetics in the
Roșca and Mihai Beniuc. The author tries to implementation of development plans in the
capture the ways in which they managed to communist period as well as in the post-
adapt and ultimately serve the political communist society. Specialized in the
regimes in Romania, from the interwar planned economy but knowing both Soviet
period to the establishment of communism. development models and Western models, a
The sympathy manifested in the interwar large part of the technical elites in
and during the Second World War for left- communist Romania ensured the post-1989
wing movements helped the three transition from the planned to the free
psychologists become the specialists of the market economy.
new regime after 1945, contributing fully to The volume coordinated by Cristian
the implementation of the Soviet Vasile carries us on the sinuous paths of
modernization plans. modern and contemporary Romanian
Cristian Vasile's study, focusing on history, focusing on a few concrete cases of
theory, deals with the evolution of concepts several personalities who played an
such as modernity, modernism, and important role in the intellectual and
modernization in Romania. The author scientific fields in which they activated by
points out the beginning of the use in the initiating and implementing certain
political discourse of the concept of modernizing projects. The detailed and
modernization as well as its falling in sophisticated analysis of the relationship of
disgrace and its replacement with the notion these intellectuals with politics, either a

119
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

direct and explicit relationship, or, on the 1948-1965. New York: St. Martin’s Press,
contrary, a ‘camouflaged’ relationship New York;
through radical professionalization is one of Boia, L. 2011. Capcanele istoriei. Elita
the outcomes of this volume. Another intelectuală românească între 1930 și 1950 (The
successful outcome of this volume is the History Traps. Romanian Intellectual Elite
good use of methodology, the studies between 1930-1950). Bucharest: Humanitas;
combining the ‘long duration’ perspective of Chirot, D. 2012. Schimbarea socială
the historical sources analysis with the într-o societate periferică. Formarea unei colonii
biographical method, investigating even the balcanice (The Social Change in a Peripheral
smallest details, relevant to both individual Society. The Formation of a Balkanic
and collective adaptation strategies. Colony). Bucharest: Editura Corint;
Although limited to Romanian space, Iacob, Gh. L. Iacob. 1995. Modernizare-
the volume could be a very good starting europenism. România de la Cuza Vodă la Carol al
point for future comparative researches II-lea (Modernization-Europenization.
between the situation in Romania and that in Romania from Voivode Cuza to Carol II).
other countries with similar or totally vol. I-II. Iași: Editura Universității „Al. Ioan
different developments. Equally interesting Cuza”;
and necessary would be a research that will Murgescu, B. 2010. România și Europa.
compare the issue of the reconversion of the Acumularea decalajelor economice (1500-2010)
elites and the training of new ones with the (Romania and Europe. Accumulation of
issue of the elimination of some of the top Economic Gaps). Iași: Editura Polirom;
Romanian intellectuals under the Rizescu, V. 2013. Ideology, Nation, and
communist regime. Modernization: Romanian Developments in
Cristian Vasile and his collaborators Theoretical Frameworks. Bucharest: Editura
succeed in convincing the reader that the Universității din București;
modernization of Romania, starting with the Vasile, C. 2011. Politicile culturale
creation of the modern state, passing comuniste în timpul regimului Gheorghiu-Dej
through liberal democracy of the interwar (Communist Cultural Politics during
period and the authoritarian regimes, as well Gheorghiu-Dej Regime). Bucharest:
as the current democracy, has been Humanitas.
permanently accompanied not only by Vasile, C. 2014. Viața intelectuală și
various ways of training and selection of artistică în primul deceniu al regimului
new elites, but also by the conversion of Ceaușescu 1965-1974 (The Intellectual and
some personalities of previous regimes. Artistic Life during the First Decade of
Ceausescu’s Regime 1965-1974). Bucharest:
References: Humanitas.
Verdery, K. 1990. National Ideology
Deletant, D. 1999. Communist Terror under Socialism. Identity and Cultural Politics
in Romania: Gheorghiu-Dej and the Police State, in Ceausescu’s Romania. Berkeley: University
of California Press.

MARIA MATEONIU

120
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Alin Ciupală. 2017. Bătălia lor. Femeile din România în Primul Război Mondial (Their
Battle. Women from Romania during WWI). Iași: Editura Polirom, 368 p.

the same time, the opportunity of the topic is


provided by the wider context of the
analysis, since we are now nearing the
centennial of the end of WWI. The book
opens with a double dedication: ‘To
Andreea’, but also ‘To the memory of my
paternal great-grandfather, Constantin P.
Moise, soldier in the Romanian Army during
WWI, prisoner of war in the German lagers
at Tuchel and Lamsdorf’.
The book is structured in five parts,
each with its own subsections, which lay out
clearly all the aspects under discussion. Part
I, ‘The War seen by women’, sets the
framework of the analysis, which
corresponds to the latest directions in the
historiography of the Great War, such as
shining a light upon the emotional
dimension or the cultural history of the war.
The collective imaginary of the 19th
century offered a model structured around
clear gender boundaries: the polar pair man-
Alin Ciupală, professor at the Faculty
woman, where man was the symbol of
of History (University of Bucharest), is a well
reason, force, virility and woman was
known specialist in the modern history of
characterized by frailty, submissiveness,
Romania in general and in the role of women
expressing feelings. The model proved to be
in the society in particular. He has published
enduring and men constantly framed
several studies on this topic such as: Women
women’s role in the war according to their
in 19th century Romanian society. Between the
gender. Women themselves, who were in the
public and the private (2003); Modern studies
midst of their struggle for emancipation,
(2009); About women and their history in
became involved in the public debate about
Romania (2004). Moreover, he has
the war, spoke their minds and adhered to
collaborated with other historians in writing
the Romanian national project, whose
important works and has published many
objective was the creation of a unified
volumes of documents.
Romania. However, when it came to
The volume Their Battle. Women from
concrete action, they too operated with
Romania during WWI is an expression of the
gender boundaries: men were those who
author’s constant preoccupation for gender
engaged in the military and the diplomatic
studies that we have already mentioned. At

121
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

war, whereas women’s duty was to engage separated Romanian women in their actions
in a cultural war, of spiritual emancipation. during the war.
In the second part, entitled ‘Love, In so far as daily life in the two parts
sexuality, eroticism’, the author supports the of Romania was concerned, it can be said
idea that the Great War was a complex that it was equally difficult. Romanian
phenomenon, which upended not only the society, faced with unprecedented conflict
political order of the world, but also the and challenges, became organised, in an
sphere of intimacy, bringing about a effort to support the national project. It had
relaxation of morals and a reframing of no prior experience to fall back on: the brief
relationships between individuals. A experience of the Independence War of 1877-
difference must be emphasized, 1878 had been largely forgotten, while the
nevertheless, between the rural experience of the Second Balkan War of 1913
environment, which was more resistant to had been shared only by a small part of
change, and the urban environment, which society. The efforts of Romanian women
was more permeable to novelties. At the who organised to support orphans, invalids
time, sexuality was present in the public and refugees deserve all the more praise for
discourse about the sanitary issue or about that reason. They formed assistance
sexually transmitted diseases: eroticism was committees and centres for welcoming and
compensated, at least for soldiers who were caring for those in need. Private initiatives of
on the front line for years on end, by a Romanian women proved their efficiency in
‘theoretical erotic’, as solitude was in reality the organisation of campaign hospitals and
their mode of existence. On the front line, but sanitary trains. The National Red Cross
particularly in campaign hospitals or in the Society of Romania played a major part in
areas reserved for recovery and supporting the war effort. In 1916, its budget
recuperation, love stories were in high was over 7.5 million lei, and a territorial
demand, and reading was a coping network of 54 branches, one for every
mechanism. Morals tended to be more county. The efforts of the authorities were
relaxed, rules were being questioned as not only matched, but even surpassed by
much of the country was under the private initiatives. The charitable works in
occupation of the Central Powers and the care of the wounded undertaken by
survival was the primary concern. ladies such as Alexandrina Cantacuzino,
In the third part, ‘The Fighters’, the Nadejda Știrbei, Marta Bibescu, Constanța
author describes the general atmosphere and Argetoianu, Fatma Alice Sturdza were
the state of mind of Romanians on both sides remarkable. Romanian prisoners of war
of the front line – the occupied South and the interned in German, Austro-Hungarian or
free Moldavia –, the organisation of Bulgarian camps, as well as the wounded
women’s aid societies, the organisation of and the sick from campaign hospitals
the service for the aid of Romanian prisoners received the attention of Romanian and
of war and of wounded soldiers, the activity foreign private initiatives. Thus, Romanians
of the National Orthodox Women’s Society living in Paris mobilised and came to their
of Romania (SONFR). The author also points aid, under the coordination of Alexandru
out certain rivalries and fault lines which Em. Lahovary and his wife, Ana Lahovary,
of the Red Cross societies from Paris, Bern

122
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

and Geneva, The London Committee, which World War. The activity and the life of the
was under the control of the Romanian Queen during the years 1916-1918 is
Legation, the New York-based Romanian described along two major coordinates: her
Relief Fund. Aid was also provided from public and her private life. Publicly, she was
Argentina, Brazil or the Netherlands. involved in the effort to organise campaign
Besides the National Red Cross hospitals and to look after the wounded,
Society, there was another society which both near the front and further back. Her
held a national network, both in Wallachia humanity, her ability to understand the
and in Moldavia: the National Orthodox desires of individuals and her empathy for
Women’s Society of Romania (SONFR), their suffering were truly impressive. The
whose president in 1916 was Anastasia queen organised an emergency hospital
Filipescu. SONFR organised kindergartens inside the royal residence in Bucharest,
in Bucharest, offering children care and which quickly turned into a hospital for
education. They also ran a network of major surgical operations. She was helped by
canteens, a hospital for the wounded and a her ladies-in-waiting, but also by her
school for adults. The hospital, run by daughters, who had administrative
Alexandrina Cantacuzino, nursed 2812 activities, but also got involved in all sorts of
wounded, between August 1916 and July activities, depending on the needs. Later, the
1917. The activity of SONFR covered the hospital was evacuated to Moldavia. With
entire territory of Romania and in June 1918 the aid of Jean Chrissoveloni and his wife,
it also created a branch in Bessarabia, under Sybille, the Queen founded the institution
the honorary presidency of Princess which bore her name: The ‘Queen Maria’
Elisabeth. Institution owned three great campaign
Romanian women internalised the hospitals, at Căiuți and Coțofenești in Bacău
Romanian national project and supported County, and in Ghidigeni, in the Covurlui
the Romanian war effort with solidarity. County. Moreover, the Queen organised
Analysing the wartime propaganda and military ambulances, under the authority of
speeches after the war, it would appear that the same institution, as well as a network of
the entire Romanian society acted in unity. canteens for poor children, which covered
Nevertheless, a closer look reveals a different the whole territory of Moldavia.
reality, of rivalries and faction. Thus, the Unhappy with the way in which
historian identifies rivalries between the public institutions operated, Queen Maria
ladies from upper middle class and those was also involved in the political life. In his
coming from the lower middle class. analysis of this involvement, the author
Another fault line was between Liberal followed the Queen’s attitude towards Ion I.
families – generally supportive of the C. Brătianu, the President of the Council of
Entante – and conservative families, which Ministers, her relation with the most
favoured the Germans. There were other important generals in the Romanian Army,
discrepancies as well, for example between the issue of Prince Carol taking on certain
Orthodox and Catholic women. responsibilities, as heir apparent, as well as
The fourth part, ‘The Queen’, is the issue of Romania abandoning the war
entirely dedicated to Queen Maria, who through a separate peace.
played a very important part during the First

123
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Alongside the relation with officer academies, nor the enrolment of a


Romanian officials, the historian also woman-officer. Her acceptance in the Army,
analyses the relation between the Queen and in the 43/59 Infantry Regiment, may have
the representatives of the Allies: the been the result of a direct intervention by
members of the French and Italian missions Prince Carol, who was the leader of the
at first, then the British and the American Romanian Scouts, given that Ecaterina
missions. Besides the face-to-face meetings, Teodoroiu was a former Scout. Nevertheless,
the many letters exchanged by the Queen in her position was honorary and she never
support of the Romanian cause testify to the exercised direct command. King Ferdinand
great efforts she made. In each of these had appointed her Honorary Second
situations, Queen Maria appears as a woman Lieutenant within that regiment. The image
of strong character and intelligence, with of the heroine suffered a process of
clear thinking, capable of making and masculinisation: she became less of a woman
supporting decisions, a person who always and more of a hero/heroine, invested with a
preferred to act and fight rather than to wait non-feminine, warrior nature.
and despair. The historian makes no claims of
The author believed the Queen’s having exhausted the topic of Romanian
private life is also important and he analyses women during the WWI, which he declares
several aspects: the complicated relationship ‘still open’, but does draw some conclusions.
between her and her husband, as the He makes a number of pertinent
mismatch in character was exacerbated by observations about the characteristics of the
events; the relationship between the Queen sources he had used and proposes a list of
and her mother, the Grand Duchess Maria new topics and subjects for future research,
Alexandrovna Romanova; her relationship such as daily life in internment camps for
with her younger sister, Victoria-Melita as Romanian prisoners of war. The brief, but
well as her relationship with her own eloquent conclusion is a justification for the
children. entire work: “World War One did not
Returning to the gender-based model concern men alone, and, as such, its history
of the 19th century, the author writes that must make room for women as well.”
Queen Maria was the ‘Queen Mother’ for the Romanian readers are presented with
wounded in hospitals and for the orphans. a valuable and extremely well documented
Nevertheless, the Chief of the General Staff book. The author added to the various
decorated the Queen in 1918 with the Order published sources several new ones, some
‘Military Virtue’, seeing the Queen as a from his own family’s archive. The 48
faithful soldier of the nation. Thus, gender- illustrations, accompanied by explanations,
based differences seemed to become blurred. add value to this work, which represents a
The fifth part of the book, ‘The significant contribution to the history of the
Heroine’, is dedicated to the personality of Great War.
Ecaterina Teodoroiu, who is the emblem of
Romanian womanly heroism. She died in
combat, during the battle on Secului-Muncel
Hill, on August 22nd 1917. Romanian military ENE LAURA
regulations did not allow women to enrol in

124
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Call for Papers, MemoScapes, No. 3/2019: Regional, National, Local, and
Social Identities in Central Europe and the Black Sea Region in the last 100
years

Deadline: December 15, 2018 community as well as its shared values339.


Discourse is a powerful political tool which
can built but also de-construct national
100 years ago, at the end of the First identities (undrestood as shared and
World War, the world system changed. The assumed discourse)340.
European medieval multi-ethnic empires Although images always played an
vanished for good. New nations emerged on important role in shaping and transmitting
the world scene. Within the new nations, national identities, their power increased
new and old minorities tried to perserve lately due to mass media and the new
and/or develop/transmit their technologies. The new media especially
local/regional/national identities. A Ligue of supports a simplified dominant discourse on
Nations was created in order to help the new nation and national values which is
nations develop and to protect theirs presented as objective and real.341
interests. However, this did not hinder the New media also plays an important
Second World War and the genocide it role in defining social identities understood
brought along. Yet, the world system of as a person’s identification with a social
nations survived the atrocities of WWII group342. „A social group is a set of
being only recently challenged by individuals who share the view that they are
globalization, environmental issues, members of the same category” through
migrations, new technologies as well as by comparison and categorization processes343.
the establishment and developement of Individuals are members of multiple groups
trans-national entities such as the European and „posses multiple identities because they
Union. occupy multiple roles, ... and claim multiple
Benedict Anderson defined nations personal characteristics, yet the meanings of
as „imagined communities”336 whose these identities are shared by members of
traditions were invented337 in order „to society”344.
establish continuity with a suitable historical An identity is a set of meanings that
past”338. These political entities are social define an individual but also a community or
constructed through discourse which points nation which gives to the
out the uniqueness and distinctness of a person/group/community its uniqueness

336 341
Anderson, 1983. Huijser 2009, p. 60
337 342
Hobsbawm, Ranger 1983 Hogg and Abrams, 1988
338 343
Hobsbawm, Ranger 1983, p. 1 Burke, Stets 2009, p. 118
339 344
Wodak 1999, p. 22 Burke, Stets (2009), 3.
340
Wodak et alii. 1999

125
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

within a particular and/or historical context. construction. However, this model was not
National/regional/social/cultural identities implemented as such but adapted to the local
are meant to create consensus and bonds context. This process was best described by
between individuals and society, betweens Popkewitz through its concept of ”Traveling
groups in a given society, but also between Libraries”, a metaphor for „the different sets
nations (see in this context the attempts to of assemblages, flows and networks through
create an European identity). Yet, identities which intelligibility is given to the
contents and shapes are not fixed but changes”345.
flexible, changing over time and in space. Another aspect to be discussed is the
Identity is always (for individual but also for usefulness, the transformation and the new
communities) multiple and versatile meanings of concepts such as, `imagined
depending on the context, social patterns, communities`, `invention of traditions`,
memorial frameworks, but also on the social, `reframed nationalism`346 in our
political, cultural and economic evolutions contemporary world in the BSR and Central
of societies. European region. Another focus of our issue
Our current issue aims at finding will be the analysis of the role of images
answers to the question of identities in (including propaganda images) in shaping
Central Europe and the Black Sea Region and transmitting
(BSR) from different perspectives: national, national/regional/local/cultural identities as
regional, local, and social. Its purpose is their power increased lately due to the new
twofold: on the one hand, to describe and medias.
analyze the construction, adaptation, The issue aims at addressing the
evolution and transmission of the above mentioned topics as well as the
national/local/cultural identities in Central following ones (but not only):
and Eastern Europe and the Caucasus seen  Emerging and evolution of
as processes under Western influences but national identities in Central
bearing local meanings and acquiring special Europe and BSR
shapes and contents, and, on the other, to see  The role of literature, arts,
what is at stake in building an European history, etc. in building
identity and its influence on the national/local/regional
national/regional/local/cultural identities of identities
Central and Eastern Europe as well as the  Minorities within nations
Caucasus.  Redefining national identities
We give a special attention to the in UE
impact of the Western ideas, discourse and  The impact of the new
practices on building/rebuilding national, technologies in forging new
regional and local identities in the Black Sea national, local, and social
Region. The region is set as a case study for identities
our issue topic as most of the countries  New global issues
around Black Sea, if not all of them, adopted (environmental, migration
and assumed a Western model of identity etc.) and their role in

345 346
Popkewitz (2005), 10. Brubaker (1996).

126
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

changing regional, national, editors by 15 of December 2018 for peer


local identities review. For further details, please look at
 Theoretical approaches of the style guide on our website:
identities in Central Europe http://studii-
and BSR347
memoriale.ro/index.php/revista-
memoscapes/info-for-authors-style-
References:
guide/

Anderson, B. 1983. Imagined


communities: Reflections on the origin and
spread of nationalism. London: Verso Books.
Brubaker, R. 1996. Nationalism
reframed. Nationhood and the national question
in the New Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
Burke, P., J. Stets. 2009. Identity
Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hobsbawm, E. T. Ranger (eds.) 1983.
The invention of Tradition. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
Hogg, M. A., D. Abrams. 1988. Social
identifications: A social psychology of intergroup
relations and group processes. London, New
York: Routledge.
Huijser, H. 2009. The multicultural
nation in New Zealand cinema: Production-text-
reception, Saarbrucken: VDM Verlag Dr
Muller.
Popkewitz, Th. (ed.) 2005. The modern
self and John Dewey. Modernities and the
travelling of pragmatism in education. New
York: Palgrave-MacMillan.
Wodak, R., R. De Cillia, M. Reisigl, K.
Liebhart. 1999. The discursive construction of
national identity. Edinburgh: Edinburgh
University Press.

Full article manuscripts of no more than


8000 words must be submitted to the

347
More on our website: http://studii-
memoriale.ro/index.php/revista-memoscapes/

127
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Editor’s Introduction _____________________________________________________________ I


LUCIAN BOIA _______________________________________________________________ 1
Oldness, Unity and Continuity: Romanian Historical Mythology __________________________ 1
Introduction: The Creation of Greater Romania _______________________________________________ 1
Historical Symbols: The Past as a Foreshadowing of the Future __________________________________ 3
Romanian Past according to Communists ____________________________________________________ 6
Post-communist Historical Mythology ______________________________________________________ 9

CÉCILE D’ALBIS ____________________________________________________________ 12


Le mythe de Grenade et les fêtes civico-religieuses (xvie-xviiie siècles) ____________________ 12
Les fêtes civico-religieuses et le mythe urbain à l’époque moderne ______________________________ 13
Le mythe royal ________________________________________________________________________ 15
Le mythe martyrial et la quête des origines _________________________________________________ 17
Les découvertes du Sacromonte __________________________________________________________ 18
Les Vierges grenadines et l’adaptation du mythe au XVIIe siècle _________________________________ 19
Conclusions ___________________________________________________________________________ 21

LAURENT CAROZZA, ALBANE BURENS __________________________________________ 25


Le Déluge, les savants et la mer Noire : une nouvelle mythologie scientifique ? ____________ 25
Le déluge : du mythe babylonien au dérèglement climatique ___________________________________ 25
Le déluge, l’archéologue et la mer Noire ___________________________________________________ 26
Le déluge : un mythe universel catastrophiste ? _____________________________________________ 28
Quand les scientifiques rencontrent le mythe : ou l’incarnation du lieu ___________________________ 31
Archéologie du mythe du Déluge _______________________________________________________ 32
Le géologue et la mer ________________________________________________________________ 33
Du Déluge au changement climatique global : une nouvelle mythologie scientifique ________________ 38

LEONARDO GREGORATTI ____________________________________________________ 43


Fighting a Dying Enemy: The Struggle between Rome and the Parthians __________________ 43
ELITSA STOILOVA __________________________________________________________ 53
Food, Myths and Authenticity ____________________________________________________ 53
Introduction __________________________________________________________________________ 53
Food, Place, Authenticity, and Myth-Making ________________________________________________ 54
Food Festivals: the Bulgarian Context ______________________________________________________ 56
The Festival of Red Peppers, Tomatoes, Traditional Food and Crafts in Kurtovo Konare Village ________ 57
The Festival and the (Re)-Invention of Traditions _____________________________________________ 59
Conclusion ___________________________________________________________________________ 61

JUSTYNA BUDZIŃSKA, MAŁGORZATA PRACZYK, IZABELA SKÓRZYŃSKA _______________ 64


Performative Motherhood: The Myth of Mother Poland Re-Interpreted by Women Artists in
Contemporary Poland __________________________________________________________ 64
Introduction __________________________________________________________________________ 65
Mother Poland ________________________________________________________________________ 66
Women’s Memory? Performance! ________________________________________________________ 68

128
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

Ewa Wójciak, Cecylia Malik and Marta Frej case studies _______________________________________ 70
Performative Motherhoods: Time of Mothers _____________________________________________ 71
Mother – Pole – Feminist or rehab from martyrdom ________________________________________ 77
Mother Poland in the search for micro-eco-utopia _________________________________________ 80
Conclusions ___________________________________________________________________________ 84

SERGIU MUSTEAȚĂ_________________________________________________________ 90
Soviet Moldova in the Radio Free Europe Broadcasting during the Cold War. Efim Crimerman’s
(Grigore Singurel) contributions __________________________________________________ 90
Introduction __________________________________________________________________________ 90
Efim Crimerman and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (1981-1994) ______________________________ 94
Topics Addressed by Crimerman __________________________________________________________ 98
Problems of Soviet Moldova ___________________________________________________________ 99
The Jews Issue _____________________________________________________________________ 102
The Situation of Romania ____________________________________________________________ 103
Efim Crimerman vs. Communist Regime ___________________________________________________ 104
Final Remarks ________________________________________________________________________ 114

REVIEWS ________________________________________________________________ 116


Cristian Vasile (ed.). 2017. „Ne trebuie oameni!” Elite intelectuale și transformări istorice în
România modernă și contemporană („We Need People!” Intellectual Elite and Historical
Transformations in Modern and Contemporary Romania). Târgoviște: Cetatea de Scaun, 442 p.
___________________________________________________________________________ 117
Alin Ciupală. 2017. Bătălia lor. Femeile din România în Primul Război Mondial (Their
Battle. Women from Romania during WWI. Iași: Editura Polirom, 368 p. ________________ 121
Call for Papers, MemoScapes, No. 3/2019: Regional, National, Local, and Social Identities
in Central Europe and the Black Sea Region in the last 100 years ___________________ 125

129
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

This issue of our journal, Constructing the Social (and Individual) World: Myth, Memory,
and Identity, was coordinated by Claudia-Florentina Dobre

Reviewers

Valentin Bottez, Associate Professor, Faculty of History, University of Bucharest;

Cosmin Budeancă, Researcher, Expert at the Institute for the Study of the Communist
Crimes and the Memory of the Romanian Exile (IICCMER), Bucharest;

Sonia Catrina, Associate Researcher, Centre Régional Francophone de Recherches


Avancées en Sciences Sociales (CeReFREA), University of Bucharest;

Keith Hitchins, Professor, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign;

Luciana-Mărioara Jinga, Marie Curie IF Postdoctoral Researcher TEMOS (Temps,


Mondes, Sociétés - CNRS FRE 2015), Universités d'Angers ;

Antal Lukacs, Professor, Faculty of History, University of Bucharest;

Maria Mateoniu, Researcher, National Museum of Romanian Peasant (MȚR),


Bucharest, Romania;

Denisa Oprea, Lecturer, National School of Political and Administrative Studies


(SNSPA), Bucharest;

Susan C. Pearce, Associate Professor, Department of Sociology, East Carolina


University, North Carolina;

Christopher Scarboro, Professor, King’s College, Pennsylvania;

Dorota Skotarczak, Professor, Instytut Historii Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznań;

Cristian Vasile, Senior Researcher, Institute of History ‘Nicolae Iorga’, Bucharest.

130
MEMOSCAPES. ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND IDENTITY STUDIES

MemoScapes is a peer-review, interdisciplinary and yearly journal, which welcomes academic


syntheses, analyses and case studies. It publishes articles from the areas of Humanities and
Social Sciences, as well as empirical research data, reviews and book presentations.

Scientific Committee

Neven Budak (Professor, University of Zagreb)


Liliana Deyanova (Professor Emeritus, St. Kliment Ohridski Sofia University)
Gábor Egry (Senior Research Fellow, Institute of Political History, Budapest)
Bogumil Jewsiewicki (Professor Emeritus, Université Laval de Québec)
Karl Kaser (Professor, University of Graz)
Christine Lavrence (Associate Professor, Department of Sociology, King’s University
College at Western University, London, Ontario)
Sergiu Musteaţă (Professor, ‘Ion Creangă’ Pedagogical State University of Chişinău)
Susan C. Pearce (Associate Professor, Department of Sociology, East Carolina University,
North Carolina)
Cristofer Scarboro (Professor, King’s College, Pennsylvania)
Izabela Skórzyńska (Professor, Institute of History, Adam Mickiewicz University of
Poznań)
Dorota Skotarczak (Professor, Institute of History, Adam Mickiewicz University of
Poznań)
Bogdan Ştefănescu (Professor, University of Bucharest, Faculty of Foreign Languages)
Smaranda Vultur (Associate Professor, West University of Timișoara)
Anna Wachowiak (Professor, Faculty of Social Sciences, Warsaw University of Life
Sciences)

Editorial Board

Director: Claudia-Florentina Dobre


Editor-in-Chief: Cristian Emilian Ghiţă
Editors: Sonia Catrina, Maria Mateoniu, Denisa Oprea
Copy Editor: Valeriu Antonovici

ISSN print: 2558-8567


On-line ISSN: 2559-415X
ISSN-L: 2558-8567

www.studii-memoriale.ro/memoscapes

131
Me
moSc
ape
s
Romani
anJ
our
nalofMemor
yandI
dent
it
ySt
udi
es

Me moSca
pe s
. Roma nianJournalofMe morya ndIdenti
tySt udiesaims
toexploret hec ons t
ructionofmemor ialculturesandt hevar i
-
ousformsofi dent i
ty(indi vi
dual,social,cult
ural,etc.)thatmay
bediscernedi nanys ociety.Itfocusespr imarilyonEur opean
communi ties,butal solookst owardsot herc ontinent s,when
comparativeappr oachess eem promi si
ng.TheJ ournalexpl ores
arangeoft opi c
s ,suchast hec onnecti
onsbet weenc ommuni ca-
ti
ve and c ulturalmemor y;myt hs (as element s ofc ultural
memor y);thec reationofs ocial/cult
ur al/national/l ocaliden-
ti
ti
es;thepr ocessofpat rimoni ali
zati
onandmus ei
fic ationf rom
alonguedur éeper spective.

Publ
ishe
dbyCSMI
ISSN:2559-415X www.
studi
i-
memor
ial
e.r
o
I
SSN-L:2558-8567

Related Interests