Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Discipline Civil Project stage Detailed Design Review (Design Development) Job number
239476
Client Maynilad (MWSI) Attendance Angelo Landicho File reference
06-03-02
Circulation Attendees Theresa Deyto, Adrian Marsden, Benjamin John Liney
Scope of Review
Control Document Number Document Title DISCIPLINE Rev Comment Date of Reviewer Record of items reviewed / Reviewers’ comments / Actions arising / Review Response Date of Corrective action completed Construction risk?
Number from Review conclusions Response
Contractor's response / Action proposed Yes/No By Action verified (PM) Yes/No Actioned?
Sign and Date
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Please present document in standard letterhead / frontpage 05-May-2018: Noted. 09-May-18 Yes AL
11025 of Structural Steelworks
9-May-2018 Arup: We note the changes made by the JV. Issue closed out.
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Sec. 3.0 Scope: 05-May-2018: Noted, please see revised document. 09-May-18 Yes AL
11026 of Structural Steelworks Chemical Building 1 is also included.
9-May-2018 Arup: We note the changes made by the JV. Issue closed out.
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Sec. 4.0 References: 05-May-2018: Noted, please see revised document. 09-May-18 No AL
11027 of Structural Steelworks Please provide reference document (i.e. standard, code and year released) - for item d
9-May-2018 Arup: What is this code? AASHTO?
18-May-2018: If you are pertaining to the Item d of Sec. 4,
this refers to the Code of Standard Practice for Steel Buildings
and Bridges.
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Please attach welder's certification and welding inspector's accreditations 05-May-2018: Noted, please see revised document. 09-May-18 Yes AL
11028 of Structural Steelworks (certifications).
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Sec. 6.1 Material Reception: 05-May-2018: Noted. 09-May-18 No AL
11029 of Structural Steelworks Please list acceptance criteria of materials.
9-May-2018 Arup: Complete documentation of testing conducted shall also be 18-May-2018: Please see revised document.
included as part of the acceptance criteria.
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Sec. 6.2. Steel Traceability: 05-May-2018: Please see revised document. 09-May-18 Yes AL
11030 of Structural Steelworks Why S275? Has there been a proposal to change the design material from ASTM A36
to S275?
9-May-2018 Arup: We note that the design material is ASTM A36, as mentioned in the
revised document.
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Sec. 6.5 Verification: 05-May-2018: Noted, please see revised document. 09-May-18 Yes AL
11031 of Structural Steelworks What about coating requirements?
9-May-2018 Arup: We note the inclusion of the coating requirements as part of the
product verification.
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Sec. 7.0 Fabrication: 05-May-2018: Noted, please see revised document. 09-May-18 Yes AL
11032 of Structural Steelworks Please show fabrication procedures as flowchart to verify how non-compliant materials
are rejected, and how it is processed.
9-May-2018 Arup: We note the inclusion of the process flowchart in the document.
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Sec. 7.0 Fabrication: 05-May-2018: Noted, please see revised document. 09-May-18 Yes AL
11033 of Structural Steelworks Include organizational flowchart showing persons-in-charge for each process,
especially the plant's QA/QC in-charge responsible for checking the correctness of
fabrication.
9-May-2018 Arup: We note the from the organizational flowchart that the plant
manager and engineer-in-charge is not involved? Please clarify.
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Sec. 7.1 Surface Cleaning: 05-May-2018: Yes, it is sand blasting. 09-May-18 Yes AL
11034 of Structural Steelworks Sand-Blasting?
9-May-2018 Arup: This is noted.
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Sec. 7.7 Protective Treatment: 05-May-2018: Noted, please see revised document. 09-May-18 No AL
11035 of Structural Steelworks Mention the approved paint material, and list painting methodology.
9-May-2018 Arup: Please mention the document reference number of the approved 18-May-2018: Noted.
paint material for referencing.
Page 1 of 1
Project title Putatan WTP 2 Detailed Design Review Discipline Civil Project stage Detailed Design Review (Design Development) Job number
239476
Client Maynilad (MWSI) Attendance Angelo Landicho File reference
06-03-02
Circulation Attendees Theresa Deyto, Adrian Marsden, Benjamin John Liney
Scope of Review
Control Document Number Document Title DISCIPLINE Rev Comment Date of Reviewer Record of items reviewed / Reviewers’ comments / Actions arising / Review Response Date of Corrective action completed Construction risk?
Number from Review conclusions Response
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Sec. 8.0 Weld Procedure: 05-May-2018: They are the third party testing center who 09-May-18 Yes AL
11036 of Structural Steelworks Who is in-charge of this "Inspection Center"? will conduct the testing and inspection on weld location.
9-May-2018 Arup: We note AJF's response. Please refer to the accepted company
profile of the third-party inspectors for compliance.
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Sec. 8.2 NDT: 05-May-2018: All welded location will be tested using this 09-May-18 Yes AL
11037 of Structural Steelworks How many percentage of total weld locations will be tested through DPI? method, please refer to Table 2.0.
9-May-2018 Arup: We note from AJF's response that all weld locations shall be tested
for DPT.
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Table 1.0 to 3.0: 05-May-2018: Noted, please see revised document. 09-May-18 Yes AL
11038 of Structural Steelworks Please indicate reference standard.
9-May-2018 Arup: We note from the document that the reference document is Sec 6
of Inspection of AWS D1.1 23rd edition 2015.
DDR- PWTP2-QA-CR-CON-ARU-0392 Quality Control System for the Plant Fabrication Civil A Arup 24-Apr-18 AL Sec. 12.3: NCR: 05-May-2018: Noted, please see revised document. 09-May-18 No AL
11039 of Structural Steelworks Photo records shall also be secured to document NC.
9-May-2018 Arup: The attached sample of the internal NC form does not include 18-May-2018: Noted.
provision for photo recording.
Page 2 of 1