You are on page 1of 11

~

-loqJS 11~1{l UO AnEJ 01 AEP ~uo P~Ul1S~P ~lE OqM SlOSS~jOld ~lmnj pUB 'S1UE1S1SSElnjdl~q
'S1U~pmS IE101JOp IE11U~10d~lE SUlOOl ~lmJ~1 ~q1 U1 Ul~1{l jO moll U1 ~~S
A~q11El{A\ 'SlOSS~jOld:1Eq1SEAI~51J~ld s~AI~SUl~q1W~SJld pUB UEJ A~q11EqM qJE~1
AUEUll~9 U1 SlOSS~jOld ~ql 'Ul~lqOld l~ppES qJnw E w~s~ld S1u~pms ~q1 mg
'>IE~ds 01 os ~llUlEj ~q1 u1 U1EUl~1S1JillUOJ
pUB S~llIEAll ~1{lIIE OS '001 'lOSS~jOld E AluO Sl ~~E~nOJ 51q '~uop pUB P1ESSl nE
u~qM mq 'lOSS~jOld WE~OllE ~q1 10j ~U1f..j1110W
AIPunOjOld 5151q1 ~smOJ jO
'~~~nOJ
S,lOSSJjOld~q1 SEM1Et{1puE-~lqEu~Ew1 ~lmE~lJ sn01po 1S0W~q1 pUB 'P1dms 1S0W~q1
'1S~n~n ~q1 p~1E~lJ pUB ~uOIE ~WEJ 11A~a ~q1 AEP ~WES~q1 jO ~U1U~A~~1{l uo
mg 'w1q l~AO P~I~AlEW pUB ~W1J'J5l~~UE ~q1 puy ~010~1{l jO 10SS~jOld UEUll~9~q1
:jO >IU11{l PlnoJ ~q ~lmE~lJ InJl~pUOM 1S0W~q1 pUB '1S~1~A~IJ~q1 'InJl1nE~q
1S0Ul~q1 Ul~q1 ~UOWE UlOlj p~1E~lJ ~q 'S~U1~quEwnq p~1E~lJ pEq p09 1~1jY
'SMOnOj SEsurn S~IJl1J J1W~pEJE UEUll~9
U11Elndod PU~~~1 y 'UOl1~lJ 1Ep~u~ddEq WEsE~ldun !.l~A ~U11{l~wOS's~AI~sw~q1
~AOqE qJnw 001 ~U111~~UlOlj 1..'l,°10~1{ljO SlOSS~jOldW~A~ld 01 mg :,{U011~U1A1PjO
~~fi;~p E q11M w1q q11M dn S1nd Apu~nb~suoJ pUB 'W1q moqE AES01 SEt{ 10SS~jOld
~q11EqM l~AOJ51P01 snollnJ Sl P09 puy 'JI~SW1qP09 1d~JX~ 1..'l,°10~q1jO 10SS~jOld~q1
UEq11~q~lq 51~uo ON 'SJund1JSW IEJ1~010~1{l~1{l nE jO UM01J ~q1 sll..'l,°10~q1
Jl1EW~1SAS~SnEJ~q ~010~q1 Jl1EW~1SASjO 11EqJ E AlqEl~j~ld 'llEqJ E SEq 1..'l,°10~q1
U1 ~op d011E~1 ~q1 mg ~010~q1 U1 ~1E101JOpE 10 'a'qd E 1SE~11E~AEt{ 1snw pUB
SWEX~IEJ~OIO~1{l ~Sl~A1Pp~ssEd AnnJSS~JJns~AEq 011q~no A~ql 'Ul1'el pUB '>I~~19
~~lq~H MOillf Plnoqs SUE1~010~ql ~010~q1 jO A1lnJEj 10 100qJS A11U1A1P
SnOWEj
E 1E p~wms ~AEq 1snw UE1~olo~1{l l~dold E 1E1p >Iu11{l AEW ~ldo~d JUIOS
NVI90'lO3:HI V 51 "H3:A3:I'l3:g J.."H3:A3:
arly work. But in reality most of the students in their lecture rooms don't want to
take up an academic career at all. They want to be pastors for their congregations
in the church. They want to know what good all the theological theories will do
them later, in their sermons, in their pastoral work, and in the building up of their
congregations. But about that a great many professors haven't a notion, because
they were never congregational pastors themselves, and-at least in Germany-
have an extremely detached relationship with their local churches.
So in the theological faculties a gulf opens up between academic theory on the
one hand and pastoral practice on the other-a broad and repellent ditch. And stu-
dents who then arrive in their congregations proudly equipped with a doctorate in
theology have become strange and alien to normal Christians; they have to make a
painful leap over that broad ditch between the educated and the uneducated, and
have first to learn again that in Christ the difference between "Greeks and barbar-
ians" counts for nothing, but that all are one. After all, the apostles, men and
women both, had no Ph.D.s, and-except perhaps for Paul-none of them would
have passed our theological exams.
I have vivid memories of my first congregation. I had studied theology in
Gottingen, received my doctorate, and came to a little country church near Bremen.
Sixty small farms, 500 souls, and 3,000 cows. So there I stood in the pulpit with all
my learning, feeling pretty much a fool. Fortunately; I had spent more than three
years in the hard "school of life" and had lived with farmers and workers in pris-
oner-of-war camps in Scotland and England. It was from those experiences that
I then preached, not from the lecture notes I had taken in Gottingen. Perhaps I
wasn't a great teacher for my congregation in Wasserhorst, but I did learn something
there: I learned and came to understand the "theology of the people." Every
Christian, man or woman, young or old, who believes and thinks at all about that
belief is a theologian. In those farming families I learned to value the general the-
ology of all believers. I came to understand what Luther meant when he said: We
are all theologians.

Omnes sumus Theologi, that is to say, every Christian.

Omnes dicimur Theologi ut omnesChristiani.


(WA 41,11)
Ever since then I have known that if academic theologians do not go to the people,
picking up and learning the general theology of the people and working for the peo-
ple, they lose their basis. Their theology becomes abstract and sterile and no longer
has much to say to the students who are studying in the theological faculties so that
they can minister to the congregations at the grass roots. But on the other hand,
this means that theology isn't just a task for the theological faculties. It is a task for

-
..6
Lt
~01°'J1{1 Apms 01 UE~'Jq I 'J10j'Jg 'p09 'Jq p09 l'Jl SS'Jl10 'J10UI 01{A'I.Sl'JA'Jl1'Jq
UE1{l .I;'Jll'JqU'JA'J s'JUI1~'JUIOs.-,-ls01 'JAEl{ 10 ~Ul1J'Jr'J1 'J1E A'J1{llE1{A'I. 1l'JA'I.!.l'JA A'l.OU}{
AllEnsn "JJU'Jl51X'J 511{ AU'Jp Apu'Jnb'JsuoJ pUB 'P09 lSU1E~E ~Ul1{l'JUIOS 'JAE1{ 01{A'I.
S1S1'J1{lV tOOl 'UE1~Olo'Jql E UI51'J1{lE 1'J1{ 10 511{ 10j UOSE'J1 'JUIOS SEll 01{A'l.1'JA'Jl1'Jquou!.l'JA'J
1,USl :}{SE 'JUI l'Jl 'SUEPS!l1{] 01 !.'};°1°'J1{111UI11 011dUI'JllE 'J1{1~Ul1nd51P UI
SNVI90'l03H1.. 3g NV::) '001.. 'SISI3HIV
'WS!IBS1JA!UnA1BUO!SS!W01 pUB IJdS09 J1l1
jO UO!1BWBP01d )!Iqnd J1l1 01 PEdI 1,UP!P~OIOJ1l11B1l11ng 'WOqJ1 J1l1'J1B1JUJ~J1
J1l1jO ~OIOJ1l1 B 'I.UruO1~U33'3.l
v!:i°IO31{1 B jO IBJP! J1l1JI!llM B 10j PJllSPJll) WS!1J!d
UBWlJ9 lSPllJ SnSJ[ jO 1J1l1BdJIp 'qO)B[ pUB ')BBSI 'wBllB1qV jO P09 JIp 'UO!1BIJ
-AJ1 )!Iqnd jO P09 JIp 01 UOP)!PBl1UO) U! Jq PInOM 1BIp 1ng 'pJ1B!1!U! J1l1jO dnoii,
JIp I..q I..IuO pO01S1JpUn ~U!Jq jO JIqBdB) ~U!1l)BJ1 JUB)lB ')pJ10SJ UB 'f..1!ImUJWdn01~-U!
UBpm)JS B 'f..1!UnWWO)SnO!~!IJ1 UB!1SPllJ J1l1jO ~OIOJP! SnO~!IJ1 J1l1Jq
PInOM SlJAJ!IJq 10j 1snf ~OIOJ1l1 V (£t:£ MJ1l11BW)'U!B1 J1l1pUB tins J1l1J~!I 'IBS1JA
-!un S! P09 'p09 U! jJ!IJq J~!I '1sPBIro!llBd 10US! p09 'Ip1BJ pUB UJABJlljO 101BJ1J
J1l1S! P09 'SlJAJ!IJq 10j P09 B 1snf 10U S! P09 JSnB)Jq 'SlJAJ!IJq 10j J1J1l11Snf1,US!
~OIOJ1l1 '1B1l1IlB 10j 1ng 'J)UJpJdxJ InjlJpUOM B S! "JdOll ~U!A!I B 01 U!B~B woq"
~U!Jq jO J)UJpJdXJ J1l1 pUB ~OIOJ1l110j J)UJSSJ J1l1 jO S! Ip!Bd l~OIOJ1l1 rums
-lJpUn pUB I..pms liB) "U!B~B woq" J1B10 "SlJAJ!IJq" J1B°llM JIdoJd I..Iuo 1Bl{1UBJW1!
SJOQ l~OIOJ1l1 S!ll JAB~ 1Jll)BWlJ!Jll)S JWIm J1l1J~m 01 ,,'1l1!BjjO Ju!II)OP JIp"
Jq I..Iuo liB) ~OIOJ1l1 UB!1SPllJ 1B1l1UBJW 1B1l1SJOp 1ng 'SdPIroBj IB)!~OIOJ1l1J1l1jO
~OIOJIp I..{lBIOll)S JIp 10j S!SBqB S! 1BIp SlJAJ!IJq IlB jO ~OIOJIp UOWWO) B S! J1Jlll
'UB~OIOJ1l1 B S! jJ!IJq 1B1l11noqB S>{U!Ip pUB SJAJ!IJq °llM JUOA1JAJ1B1l1P!BS I
'PUJ
OU SMOU}{ p09 Jo J~~ld I~J~OIOJq1 Jq1 'MOU}{ JM S~ 'pU~ p09 ll~J 01 J}{ll qll~g S~
,,'P09 SnOJ1Unoq AIJ1~UYU~Jql" JO SJ~OIOXOP I~J~~OIOJql J1~ SJpVul.1'oa IlJ.lnIlJ JqlJO
SJ~~d AU~W Jql '001 ~OIOJql s~q JO SJl1~wwns pU~ SUO~lJnpOl1U~JJl1q Jl0lM
pU~ l~ql MJU}{ q11~g ,,1El{1 S~ ~UOI S~ Jq 1,U~J q1nll" l~ql pJ1JJfqo Apq~l1 JA~q SJ~
-ll1J AIPUJl1J UJAJ lng 'pJqs~u~Jun lIPS J1JMAJql UJql UJAJ pU~ 'SJ11Vul.1'Oa
IlJ.lnIlJ
s~q 10J SJ~~d 000'8 uEtp J10W pJpJJU ql1~g {lE)!1~q1 Jnll S~11 'J~~d JI~U~S~ U~ql
J10WOU J1~nbJ1 WJ1SASI~J~OIOJq11~JfJ AlJAJ JO S~Jp~ IBlUJwEpunJ Jql lInJ~JJ~p
pU~ PJ1~J~IdWOJS~lEl{11.'J°IOJq11~JIJUn AIUO ~ 11 'l~JIJ S~1~JSn~JJq 'JldW~S All~J
-~s~qS~-ql1~g {lE)! pU~ 'lJqJ~WlJ~JlqJS 'lJq1nl 'JU~lSn~nv 'sn~s~u~qlV JO ~U~}{U~ql
w~ 1-I.'J°IOJql PO09 lSl1qJ qllA\ JA~I 01 lU~M pU~ JAJ~IJq AJq1 J~ 'SJAIJSWJql
~U~}{U~ql J1~ SUO~l~~JfJUOJ U~ SU~~lSl1qJ l~qM JO UO~l~u~wnll~ pU~ UO~l~l1JUJd
J~J~lUJ~JS
pU~ ~{l~IoqJS 'I~J~POq1JW U~ql1Jql0 ~U~q10US~I.'J°IOJq1 J~WJp~JV
'~U~pUBlS
-lJpUn S>{JJSql1~J Uo A1~UnWWOJU~pSl1qJ JloqM Jql ~P09 JO JldOJd JloqM Jql
'J1'Jql
wasa time when I wasftill of enthusiasmfor FriedrichNietzsche,who deeplyinflu-
encedmodem atheism,nihilism, and today'spostmodemism. But when I readhis
book The Antichrist,I knew that it was Christianitywith its morality of compassion
that was right, not Nietzschewith his immorality of the superman.The very thing
he condemnedwasfor me the bestof all. Thereis a protestatheismthat deniesthe
existenceof God becauseof the suffering of the innocent that cries out to high
heaven. I just read an interview with Polly Thoynbeein Third Way(August 1998)
whereshecomplained:"How dare [God] createthe suffering? I won'thaveit." And
sheprotested:"Christiansare sadlymistaken." This atheismor antitheismis pro-
foundly theological,for the theodicyquestion-If thereis a God, why all this suf-
fering?-is the fundamentalquestionof everytheblogian,too,fromJob downto the
Christ dying on the crosswith the cry "My God, why haveyou forsakenme?"
Dostoyevskysplendidlydepictedtheology'stwo sides,the believingside and
the doubtingside,in the brothersKaramazov, Alioshaand Ivan. Both of themwres-
tle with God in the face of senseless suffering in the world. But Aliosha believes,
and Ivan protests. One submits,the other rebels.
The story Ivan tells is horrible enough.A Russianlandownersetshis hounds
on a little boy and allows them to tearhim to pieces. The boy'smother is forcedto
look on. "What kind of harmonyis that in which there are hells like this?" Ivan
cries out, and declares:"Is thereanyonein the whole world who could forgiveand
who is permitted to forgive? I don'tlike the harmony. I don'tlike it becauseof my
love for the world. I would rather keepthe unreconciledsuffering It isn't that I
don't acknowledgeGod, but I am respectfullygiving him back my ticket to a world
like this. Understandme, I acceptGod,but I don't acceptthe world God hasmade.
I cannotresolveto acceptit."
And his brotherAliosha answerssoftly: "That is rebellion.Yousay:'Is therea
beingin the whole world who could forgiveandwho is permittedto forgive?'There
is someone,and he can forgive everything,all and everyone,and for everything,
becausehe himselfpoured out his innocentblood for everyoneand everything. You
have forgottenhim. It is on him alone that the building [he meansthe kingdom of
God] will be built. To him we can cry: 1ust art Thou Lord, for all Thy wayshave
beenrevealed.'"
Protestatheismhere,theologyof the crossthere. Dostoyevskyportrayshim-
self in the dissimilarbrothersKaramazov.And I think the samegoesfor theolo-
gians. We are consciousof both sides in ourselves,the rebellion againstthe God
who permits so much meaninglesssuffering,and faith in the crucified God, who
sufferswith the victims and forgivesthe perpetrators. The personwho has never
"contended"with God like Job did doesn'tunderstandthe crucified Christ. And
conversely,the personwho doesn'tbelieve in God and his justice ends up by no

-
48
6
1J~dt[ S,dUOIl~ t[1!M" p09 dAoI AluO U~J dUO 'SA~S PV.lSI VW,1{S dt[1 S~ '1ng "ddot[ InO
pU~ '1UdWl011nO 'uo~ss~d InO S~ P09 "P09 :UldlqOld dUO AIUO Strq ~OIOdt[1
"d~~SSdUlI~dt(1 JO
t[1nl1 dt[1 U~ dAd~ldq Il!M dUO OU 'A1~J~1Udt(1n~l~uosIdd 1nOt[1~M "~U~OP dl~ Adt(11trqM
U~ dq 1SnUl S:tIRdt[ l~dt(110J 'Sld~~U~Ul sno~~~ldl pOO~ U~t[1 dlOUl dl~ SU~~~010dt[1 dnl1
1ng "S~P ~ P~dl 0110 t[JInt[J ~ Unl 01 MOt[-MOU)f dt[1 SPddU Idt[J~d1 pU~ 101S~d f.JdAd
dSInOJ JO -A1d~JOSd1EInd~u~Ul pU~ 'S~U~lddJ 1011UOJ'S~U~t[1 d1BU~UlOp 01 S~ OSdl~nbJ~
dM 1~t[1 Il~)fS ~ ~010Ut[Jd1 JO dIdt[ds dt[1 01 'ldt[1~d '~uoldq 1,USdOP~OIOdt[1
"d)fm 01 dl~ dM t[1~d dt[1 dA~dJIdd 01IdpI0 u~ )fadS dM d~PdIMOU)f dt(1 'S~Ull~dq
sn spudl 1trq1 d~PdIMou)f dt(1 Jo dIdt[ds dt[1 01 s~uoldq OSI~ 11 "UO Aldl U~J dM S~U~t[1
dt[1 1noq~ d~PdIMOU)f s~ 11 "~U!AP u~ UO~1~IOSUOJpu~ dA~1 01 d~~lnOJ sn SdA~~ 1trq1
'dJUd151Xd su~msns 1~t(1 d~PdIMOU)f dt(1 JO dIdt[ds dt[1 01 s~uoldq ~OIOdt[1 "Ul~t[ d1BU
-~UlOp 01IdpI0 u~ 'P09 '1Jdfqo S:t~MOU)f 01 Ul~~ 1,USdOP~OIOdt[1 (UOJ~g S~JU~I:l)
,,"ldMOd 51d~PdIMOU)f" dq 10UU~J d~PdIMOU)f IOJ t[JI~dS S,~OIOdt(1 ~U~IlddUl~ UldJUOJ
dt[1 dSn~Jdq ~010dt[1 01 dlq~J~ldd~ 10U s~ d~PdIMOU)fJO 1ddJUOJ J~JnUd~JS dt[l "dsod
-S~P U~J dM t[J~t[M IdAO d~PdIMOU)f dA~1Jdfqo JO dIdt[ds dt(1 01 ~uoldq 1,USdOP11 "S:tJ~J
dlq~AOld pu~ mEp dlq~u~mldJ~ t[1!M pdUldJUOJ dJUd~JS dA~1Jdfqo U~ 1,US~~OIOdt[1
"St(1ddP l~nud151xd S:t~pu~ ~010dt[1 JO dP~S I~UOSIdd dt[1 dIdt[ U~dUl I "'dnl1,, Ag
lNVI90'lO3:H.1 3:f1"H.1 V 3:WO::)3:g 3:NQ S3:0Q MOH
"WJ1p JAOI pUB SSJlpO~Jq1 MOU}{ OSIB
1Snw AJq1 ~SnO181IJ1
Jq1AluO JAOI 01 pUB 1nOAJp Jq11snf MOU}{ 011J~ 10U 1snw SUB18
-010Jq1 OS "qJnw SB1snf "SlJp151nO" 10j 5111 ~"SlJp1SU1"10j ~U11pJWOS1snf 10U 51
~OIOJ1p 1Bl[! JW 1q~nB1 JWn 1Bq11B JJUJllJdxJ AW "P09 q11A\JJBJd 1B J1JM OqM
sn01d Jq1 pUB pOO~ Jq1 jO AUBdWOJ Jq1 U1 UBq1 'UJAJ 'lJJ1j SJW11JWOS'q11BjpUB
P09 1noqB }{1B101 JJ1j AIJ1JldWOJ 1lJj 1 WJq1 q11A\SBM1 UJl{A\ "P09 1SU1B~B
~U11p
-JWOS pBq AJq1 JSnBJJq '51S1J1pB"pJqJmqJun" Jq1 jO AUBdwOJ J1p PJ}{111 "UJWJ1g
1BlnJJS U1101SBd 1UJpmS B SB~U1q1 JWBSJq1 pJJUJllJdXJ 1 ,,'P09 1noqB ~U1}{1B1
SABMIBJ1BAJql "51S1Jq1B
JSJq1 J}{111,UOPI" iUBWlJ9 1BM1Sod10j 1UB110dW1OSSBM
OqM 'P1BSJJUO lIog qJllU1JH 1J11lA\ J110q1BJJq1 ,,'51S1Jq1BJSJ1p J;}{111,UOP
I"
iuJp AJ1p p09 J1p jO SJAIJSWJq1 JJ1j UBJAJq1 uBl[!
WS1J1pB11Jq1jO SJAIJSWJ1p JJ1j J10W OU UBJ OqM 5151Jq1B
Jq1 PUB1S1JpUnUBJ1 oS
"JWOJlJAO JABq AJ1p ~U11pJWOSSB1nq-WJq1 U11p1A\WS1Jq1B1SJ101dJABq 1SllqJ
PJ1j1Jn.IJ Jq1 jO JJBj J1p u1 p09 JZ1U~OJJ1 OqM JldoJd "51UJWI1BSSBu1 1SBjpuB1S
01 pUB "'SSJIJqUJAJN,, ABS 01 q1~UJJ1SJq1 51 1p1BjIn.Il "POO~51 P09 1nq '11Bj10U
51Jj11 l1WlJd JM 1Bq1 'SU01lIJqJ1 Jq1 pUB 51UJWl01 Jq1 '51qnop J1p pUB SU1BdJq1
jO 1no dn SM01~ 1p1BjpunOj01d ,,]J1IJqun AW noql dlJq 'JAJ1IJq 1 P10l" :jJ1lJqun
pJ1UnOWlns AlIBnU11UOJB 5111 lSn.I1 q51P11qJ'JA1BU B1,us1 P09 u1 1p1Bj In.Il
"lJ1p1J prOM 1snfun 51q11su1B~B~U1lIJqJ11J~UOI
and all one's soul and all one's might" (Deuteronomy 6:4) or not at all. It is impos-
sible to love God if we are half-hearted and divided in mind, or only in passing, as
it were, as if our love kept office hours. A theologian has to invest his own existence
in his theology. Kierkegaard was right when he said that here "subjectivity is truth."
But if we contribute our own existence to the searchfor theological knowledge, we
sense immed~tely that God isn't a philosophical idea or a religious notion. God is
a terrifying and yet fascinating mystery (a mysterium tremendumetfascinosum). We
find ourselves caught up in a personal struggle with God, like Jacob'sstruggle at the
brook Jabbok. It is "terrible to fall into the hands of the living God." We emerge
from these struggles with God not only limping, but also blessed. For a wise old
theological saying tells us that "to know God means to suffer God." We "suffer
God" when we sense his absence, when God "hides his face," as the psalms put it;
we sensefirsthand the God-forsakenness of Jesus on the cross when "the dark night
of the soul" descends on us, and we can find no answers to our questioning: My
God, why? There is only silence. Luther described this out of his own experience
in his second lecture on the Book of Psalms in 1519:

By living-no, much more still by dying and by being damned


to hell-doth a man become a theologian, not by knowing,
reading, or speculation.

(Vivendo,immormoriendo et damnandofit theologus,non


intelligendo, legendoaut speculando)
(WA 5, 163)
By saying this he was not, of course, condemning study; reading, or knowledge. But
he was nevertheless pointing unmistakably to the personal experiences of God out
of which theology springs and from which a theologian emerges. This isn't theol-
ogy as science or technolo~ It is theology as wisdom made wise by life and death
experience: sapientia.
Before people become psychoanalysts, they have to undergo analysis them-
selves. I think the same is true in the case of true theology. A true theologian has
to have addressedand come to terms with his or her personal experiences of God-
his or her fears of God and joys in God. Theologians have to assimilate their per-
sonal experiences as God-forsaken sinners and as God's liberated children,
pardoned and born again to true life. They must be consciously aware of these
things and must not suppress them, especially not the negative experiences of the
self before God. It is good if we can perceive in a person's theology his or her own
self, in the sermon the preacher and in the company of the theologian the human
person. For this, theologians need the courage of their own personal convictions.
They must follow their own consciences first and foremost in all things and must

-
50
It'
N..Elp 'IN..Apms 'Jlq1H jO pU1~ 51ll1 uI (61:Z 'J~nl) ,,11E'Jll l'Jll u1 W'Jlll P'Jl'Jpuod rUE
splON.. 'JS;}lll lIE ld'J~ 'JllS" 'sn SlI'Jl 1.101sSEW1SllllJ 'Jlll SE 'u'JllN..S'JJl1JEld I.1EW lElll
pU1~ 'Jlll 011El1w1S~pms 'Jlq1HjO pu1)f IE1J'JdsE p'Jpu'JWWOJ'Jl 'JH 'UOl1EU1wEx'J-Jl'Js
'IEN..EIPlll1N..PIEN..U1'UOl1El1P'JW IElu'JpU'JJSUEll :AEpOl U011El1P'JWAq pUElSl'Jpun
'IN..lEt[N.. pu'JWWOJ'Jl 1,uP1P l'Jtpnl U011El1P'JWlnoqE ~U1~IEl UI :OPV1!pJJi\[
'l'JpUON..S1'J~P'JIN..OU~IEJ~Olo'Jlll lIE jO IEo~ 'Jlll rUE ~U1uu~'Jq 'Jlll
(}91:91 'J~nl) 'sn jO lUOlj u1 dn su'Jdo llJ1llN.. 'WOP~U1~ s,p09 jO ,,'JJEdspEOlq" 'Jlll
'JA1'JJl'JdrUE 'U1E~Eu'JIPI1llJ 'J~11'JWOJ'Jq 'IN..l'JpUON..UI "JP1Sl.1'JA'J wall sn spunol
-InS °llN.. 'p09 jO Ss;}Ul~U 'JlqElJ'Ju1 'Jlll1'JAO ~U11'JAlEWlE'J~ S,~U1'JquEwnll 'Jlll s1
l'JAEld puy 'P1ESAPll~ll ESSANjO 1.10~'J19 ,,'spU'Jll'JldwOJ l'JpUON..AluO 'Slop1 p'J1E
-'JIJ S1d'JJuoJ" "JA11EI'JIs'JWOJ'Jq ~OI°'JtplS'Jq roo l'JAEld uI ,,'or lI1N..~U1ll1AUE"
lsnf 10U ,,'S'JO~~U1ll1AUE" lsnf 10U 'sn 01 SS'JlppES,P09 01 S'JAI'Jsroo l'JpU'Jllns 'IN..
U'Jl{A\ 1,UON..1EllN..
rUE op lI1N..1EllN..'JsU'JS'IN..'~u1AJ1l01~rUE ~U1~UElll rUE ~U1AEld
UI 'uol1ro~EW1IEJ~01°'Jlll 'Jlll jO U011EU1WEX'J
UE S11'JAEld lEtp 'JA'J11'Jq
I L'Jnl1 51
lEllN.. sn lI'Jl 01 UOll'JlllJ AUE 'Jl'Jlll s11nH i\1'J1SAW'JU1A1P'JtplOj S'JWEUN..'JUlU'JAU1
rUE p09 jO S'J~EW1AUEW U01llSEj UEJ 'IN..ASElUEjsn01~11'Jlroo jO l'JN..od 'Jlll uI
'p09 lnoqE ~U1~IEl rUE
p09 lll1N.. ~U1~IEl :S~U1ll10N..1'Jtpll11s SEN..~ol°'Jtp w1ll lad 'P09 Aq lU'JWU'Jlll~1Iu'J
10j l'JAEld E lll1N.. p09 10j sjoold 'Jtp uo ~ooq 51ll UE~'Jq I.1nql'JluEJ jO wI'Jsuy 'sn
U1 s'Jop 'Jll lEllN..rUE S1p09 °llN.. 'JA1'JJl'JdUEJ 'Juo ou ~U1U'JdoPIEN..U151ll11nOtp1M.
'sn u1 S'JOpP09 lEt[N.. 10j s;}AI'Jsroo u'Jdo 'IN..l'JAEld uI 'S!SJP!d'J :11l1dS'Jlll ll~nOllll
lU'JWU'Jlll~1IU'J rUE U011EI'JA'JIs,p09 10j l'JAEld 'Jlll tp1N..SU1~'JqlJEj U1 p09 jO 'J~p'J
-1N..OU~
lIE AllN..S11Elll (6:9£ wIESd) "lll~11 'J'JS'IN..op lll~11 Atp UI" 'sn Aq UN..OU~'Jq
Jl'Jsw1ll l'JI 01 SEt[ P09 'p09 N..OU~01 sn 10j l'JplO uI lJ'Jfqo UE 10U S1P09 'JsnEJ'Jq
"Jlq1SS'JJJEAI'JAl1J'Jfqo 10U 51 P09 jO 'J~P'JIN..OU~roo lEt[l lJEj 'Jlll UO p'JSEq s1Jl'JS
S,'Juo rUE p09 jO 'J~P'JIN..OU~10j l'JAEld IEJ1~01°'Jlll IE1J'Jds 'Jlll10j p'J'Ju 'Jlll
'~ooquwAll 'Jlll rUE swIEsd 'Jlll U1 punoj 'Jq UEJ S1ll110j
SP1ElS;}q 'Jlll 'p09 lll1N.. 'Jj1l E jO 'Jlmu'JApE 'Jlll UElll1'JtpO ~U1ll10U AlIE'Jl S11'JAEld
'op 'IN..lEllN..U1 P09 01 PUOdS'JlrUE 'S;}A11
roo lno pvJlds 'IN..P09 'JIOj'Jq lnH 'W'Jlll
uo ~10N.. rUE s;}A11roo lno 'JAlEJ 'IN..ppON.. 'Jtp uI "Jj1l jO SU011ElS'Jj1UEW
1'Jlll0 'Jlll
lIE tp1N..rUE '~U1J10f'Jl rUE '~U~U1S '~u1ll51n~uE '~u11qnop '~u1u1qdwOJ '~U1~UEtp
'~U1AEld 'p09 'JIOj'Jq rUE p09 lll1N.. 'Jj1l 'JIOllN..E jO sS;}usn01JSUOJ'Jllllnq 'l'JAEld 10j
S'JW11IE1J'Jdslsnf 10U UE'JW01 'l'JAEld 'ld'JJ'Jld lS11j 'Jlll pUElSl'Jpun I :OPV10
'001 'ppON.. lElnJ'Js 'Jlll U1lnjdl'Jll s1111nq 'U0111pEl1J11sroow wall pE1l1 51ll1
~001 AlqEqOld l'Jlllnl 'OPVU41-GpV1!pJUl -GPV10 :51ll1 10j qnWlOj l'JqW'JW'JI-Ol
-ASE'JrUE 'Jldw1S E UN..OpP1EIl'Jtpnl iUV!3'OjOJ!t1Jnl1 V JUlOJJq JUO SJOpMOH
"Jld1JUlld UE11SllllJ IEsl'JA1un 'lu'J1JUE UE 511Elll
"JJu'J1JSUOJ01 I.1El1UOJ lJE lsnw 'Juo oN 'U011E~'J~UOJ11'JtpU1 A1llofEW 'Jlll tp1N..
'Ju1101u1 lIEj 10 S'J111l0ll1nEllJrollJ 'Jlll jO UOl1J'J11P'Jlll u1 'JA'Jsn01xuE UE lSEJ 10U
the biblical words into our lives and find ourselves in the biblical stories. Here the-
ological exegesis of Scripture and existential, personal self-interpretation belong
together. They complement and deepen one another mutually. They come into
being together and at the same time.
later Rudolf Bultmann called these individual dealings with the Bible, on the
one hand, and personal existence, on the other, "existential interpretation," mean-
ing by that more than a historical-critical exegesis, on the one hand, or a personal
testimony, on the other. In the generation that followed Bultmann we expanded his
"existential hermeneutics" into the "political hermeneutics" of the real, political,
economic, and social situation of human beings. Today the favorite expression in
ecumenical circles is the "contextual interpretation" of biblical texts. This is open
to every woman and to every man, to children and to the old alike. It is not an
advanced skill.
A wonderful example is The Gospel of Solentiname,which Ernesto Cardenal
wrote on an island in lake Nicaragua, with simple peasant farmers and fishermen,
during the Somoza dictatorship. The community does not just contribute personal
opinions to the reading and hearing of the biblical stories and to meditation on
them. The people give expression to their practical, specific situation, too, and take
the biblical texts into their own context.
All biblical exegesis is contextual, but not all exegesis is aware of the fact.
Once we become aware of it, we have to interpret our personal and social context
just as much as we interpret the biblical stories; we must lay bare the links between
the two in our meditation. But, as the word "context" suggests, it is the text of the
Bible that is determining for its present context, not vice versa. If we confront the
biblical stories and messageswith our present personal and political situation, what
emerges are by no means only correspondences and agreements,but rather contra-
dictions and conflicts between what we hear from the Bible and what we see and
experience every dar It is only the will to liberate this life from its humiliations and
oppressions that leads out of these contradictions, so that the contradictions may
turn into correspondences. There are circumstances in our lives that seem to cor-
respond to the biblical message about God's kingdom; but there are far more cir~
cumstances in which we can see only contradictions. "The kingdom of God is not
indifferent toward prices in international trade," writes German Roman Catholic
theologianJ.B. Metz, because on the prices depend the living and dying of the poor
and the children, to whom, according to Jesus' perception, the kingdom of God
belongs.
Tenatio: This brings us to the third factor that makes someone a theologian.
It is the conflict where internal and external enemies emerge.These are not personal
enemies; they are the enemies of the liberating and consoling Word of God. For

-
52
£~
-sw Jp1M AIJ1lUljUl J1{1 'pu~ lJtpO J1{1 UO ~OIoJ1{1lno 1{11M P09 01 pUOdSJllOJ
01 Jdo1{ AlnI1 JM 'pUB1{ JUO Jtp uo ilJSlW 51l pUB JSlWOld 51l JJUO 1B Sl1B1{1 ~O
-IOJ1{11JJj1Jd UMO S,P09 01 PUOdSJllOJ 011dWJ11B 1JJj1JdWl UB Sl ~OIOJ1{1 UBWn1{lno
OS 'unOj pJ1BlpJW Ul pUB ~IJ1OWJl AIUO P09 01 SPUOdSJllOJ 1{Jl1{M 'J3'PJIMOU){
IBPUJlJjUl Sl P09 jO JAB1{ UBJ S3'UlJq pJ1BJlJ 1B1{1 J3'PJIMOU}{ J1{l 'SSJUSnOlJS
-UOJ-jIJS J1BlPJWWl pUB 1JJj1Jd S,P09 Sl JIJSWl1{ jO J3'PJIMOU}{ S,P09 'SOdAl~'J VJ$°lO
-'Jill J1{1 pUOJJS J1{1 'SOdAl'JIlJ1V V13'°1°'Jlll Jtp sl J3'PJIMOU}{ jO PUl}{ 1Sllj J1{l 'p09 jO
JAB1{ UBJ S3'UlJq pJ1BJlJ 1B1{1J3'PJIMOU}{ J1{1 pUB JIJSWl1{ jO SB1{P09 1~1 J3'PJIMOU){
J1{1 UJJA\1Jq PJ1{Sln3'Ul1SlP pUB 01BlcI 01158j PIJ1{ SJl1Bw3'°P 1UB1SJ1°lcl AJlB3
LSJl1BUBj SnOl3'lIJl AZBlJ lO 51SlIB'Jl IBJ~OIOJ1{1 JM JlV LJPlS S,P09 UO 3'Ul1{1JWOS 01
pUOdSJllOJ 1l SJOp lO ~OIOJ1{1lno 1{11M JUOIB JM JlV L3'UlJQ UBWn1{ AlJAJ 01 PJSOIJSl1B1{1
AlJ1SAW JlqBJwroun 'JlqBMOU}{Un Jtp1noqB SJAIJSlnO lOj suOlSnIIl 3'Ul1B
-JlJ AIJlJW JM JlB lO 'P09 Ul JAl1JJfqo 3'UltpAUB 01 pUOdSJllOJ P09 jO J3'PJIMOU}{
JAl1JJfqns lno SJOa :JUO lJdJJp B Sl JlJ1{1 UOl1SJnb Sltp PUl1{Jq 1ng (9:££ 1{BlBSI)
'SABM lno SABM sl1{ lOU '511{3'notplno 10U JlB 511{3'no1{1 s,p09 lOj '001 '3'Ullqwn1{ Jq
UBJ 1JJJjJ J1{11ng 'SJn3'BJIIOJ S,P09 WJtp J}{BW 01 pUB P09 jO IJAJI Jtp 01 SUBl3'°IO
-Jtp J1BAJIJ 01 SWJJS 1l JSnBJJq 'snOmdWnSJld AI3'UlPJJJXJ spunos BJPl Sl1{l
l~'1~SWIH
NVI90'10~Hl. V 009 SI :NOIl.S~flb l.SV"']
1J 1SUJt13't11S~101d
01
PUt1prOM SJq1UJ ~JJ1snrUJ~1f1wall l~JJns 01 SUJ3'~qS~JjJ1snrP09 UlOqM uosl~d ~ql
'prOM SS~I~Jt1ddt1q1JM 1JJUUOJ01UJ S~UlOJP09 q1JM ~Jt1dd punOj S~ OqM uosl~d
~ql 'nOA UJ "p~UMt1p" Ar~dold 10U ApU~PJA~ St1qP09 jO P10M ~q1 U~1f1 'P~IJt1SSt1
10U ~1t1nOA jJ '~UlOJ 1,US~OplJA~a ~q1 jJ ~1~Sl~AUOJ (9t 1 '1 ~l VM) ,,'noA 1JJUJt1
PUt1~WOJ IIJM lJA~a ~1f1'noA UJ SUMt1pp09 jO PloM ~q1 St1uoos St110d" :At1M1q3'Jl~q1
jO sjoold JJSUJl1uJosyt1~1t1A~q11~1f1nllod 'q1JM dn 1nd 01 ~At1q S3'UJ~qUt1Ulnq
U~ ~lOW P09 lt1~j OqM ~ldo~d 1~ S1J~JJ~~PJS ~lqt1:t1~13'~1
10U ~1t1SUOnt1:tdW~1
l~UUJ PUt1S1u~wIJt1S5t1
plt1M:jnO ~ql '~JU~JJSUOJjO ~su~dx~ ~1f11t1l~MOd 1~3'UO11S~q1
q1JM UJ-3'UJllt1jt1AI~1t1UlJ1InPUt1'Jl~S~q1 jO 1noll~s t1'UOJ11m3'JS~1
'1qnop pUt11t1~j
:001 '1lnSJl suont1:tdW~11t1mJlJds plt1MUJ 'prOM ~PJS1no~q1 uJ PUJ){SJq1jO SUOJ1nJ~S
-l~d 011J~rqns sJ q1Jt1jU~l{A\ 1~ds09 ~q1 jO SJJlt1S1~Apt1It1JnSt1JSJIJJ~
PUt1It1JJ1JIod
1t1~1~1f1SUt1~W1~q1nl 'S1u~wIJt15St1
Ag 'l~1f1J~p~1nJ~Sl~d ~q 1,UOM151S~11,uS~Op
OqM
uosl~d ~q1 ~p~1JJPt111UOJ
~q 1,UOM1JJPt111UOJ
1,USJOPOqM uosl~d ~ql 'S~JU~JJSUOJlJ~q1
jO ~){t1S~1f110j PUt1~){t1SS,P09 10j 51q1~){JI S1Ut1W151s~101 ~At1qSl~A~JI~g
i\\t1pno Ut1St1P~AJI1~q1nl ~jJI SJqjO 1S~1~q1 IIV 'p~Mt1pnO ~JU~q PUt1'Ut1q 1t1Jl~dwJ
~q11~pun 1nd St1M1~q1nl 'IZ~1 uJ SUIloM 1t13't1:tsqJJ~~~q11t1MOll){ ~M sV 'P~151s~1
~q 01 ~At1q A~q1 PUt1 ,,'I~ds09 ~1f1jO 1U~Ul~AOUl" ~q1 ss~lddns PUt1l~PUJq A~ql
'Ul~1f1P~Ilt1J ~q St1,,'S1Ut1W" It1JJ1JIodPUt1snO~JI~l ~q1 ~l~M A~q1 '~WJ1 51q uJ l~1f1nl
tance between the finite human being and the infinite God remains. Our theologi-
cal statements about God are at best inadequate analogies and metaphors. All, the-
ological statements about God are no more than "similarities in still greater
dissimilarity," as the Fourth Lateran Council declared in 1215. Human theology is
analogical, metaphorical theology. Consequently; negative theology is always part
of it, too, i.e., the theology that tries to describe or paraphrase the mystery of God
not through analogies but through negations. Orthodox theology knows this as
apophatic theology. So every analogical statement "God is like..." has to be accom-
panied by the negation "God is not like..."-a father or a king, for example.
The positive possibility that finite human beings can talk about the infinite
God in analogies, and are permitted to do so, is based on the presence of God in
what he has created. His special presence is found in the beings he has created to
be in his "image." To be an image implies correspondence, likeness, reflection,
echo, and response. So human reason is created in such a way that with its ideas
and concepts it can correspond to God and can express his eternal presence in its
temporal metaphors. Through his general presence in the created world, the
Creator authenticates the analogical knowledge of God through the beings he has
created; for knowledge of the other presupposed the community of those who are
different.
But this is only general, natural theology. Special Christian theology starts
from a different presence of God in the world: God's incarnation in Jesus Christ.
The distant, detached relationship of the Creator to his creatures is combined with
Christ's inner relationship to God. This is the reciprocal trinitarian knowing of the
Son by the Father, and of the Father by the Son, in the Holy Spirit. That sounds the-
ologically somewhat complicated, but it only means what Matthew 11:27f. says in
different words:
All things have been delivered to me by my Father; and no one
knows the Father except the Son and anyone to whom the Son
chooses to reveal him: Come to me, all who labor and are
heavy-laden, and I will refresh you.

Perfect knowledge of God the Father is possessedby the divine Son,who is of


like nature with him; and vice versa. It is an exclusive knowing of God by God the
Father, of the Father by the Son, and of the Son by the Father. This exclusive circle
is broken through by the Son-become-human, in that he reveals it. How does he
reveal it, and to whom? By calling the weary and heavy-laden to himself, and by
gathering them into his relationship to God, so that they know God as they are
known by God. In the liberating fellowship of Christ we are no longer dealing with
analogical images of God. Here we have to do with God himself, with the knowl-

-
54
~~
0 'dnJl Sl S!l{l
'UdlliV ;\l!Wdld pu~ dllin U! UdA~lOj dl~ Adl{l :ldMSU~ pU~ PUElS~ d~~llsnlli noA
'dlli!l dlli~S dl{ll~ dS{~jpU~ dnJl dq 10UU~J dJUdlUdSAldA3 'dqA~W 'lO ~dlSAlli dU!A!P
UMOill{un dl{l lOj lol{d~dlli ~ pdsn AluO I 'lO 'dq PlnoJ l~l{M jO ~ol~u~ u~ AluO
S~M1! 'l{O 'ldMSU~ 1,U~JnOA 'tdnJl S!l{l sl '~s~ pu~ punol~ wm PlnoM dUO 11 (U:OZ
Ul{OO ,,'UdA~lOj 31V Adl{l ~U~ jO SU!S dl{l dA!~lOj nOA 11" :d~~~U~II~Udlli~lJES
SdlliOJdq d~~~U~1 I~J~OI~U~ pu~ ~OIOdlf1 dA!llmllOJldd pu~ dldlJUOJ SdlliOJdq
~OIOdl{l I~Jpol{dEldlli l~ldUd~ 'lSPl{:) snSd[ l{l!M jdnJl PddPU! Sl Sll{l 'UdlliV
:PUOdSdl dM P09 jO UO!lB!dAdl S!l{ pu~ P09 jO d~PdIMOU~ ,snSd[ ollng jSd~l{ldd
-5!l{1 d~!l dq PlnOJ 1! :slol{d~dlli 01 A~S 01 dA~l{ dM '~U!l{Sdljdl S!l{ pu~ UO!lEl!AU!
S!l{ UO Aldl U~J dM ~lSPl{:) snSd[l{~nOll{l P09 jO UO!l~ldAdl S!l{l UOAldl U~J dM
(£Z: 11 Mdl{ll~W) ,,'udlPI!l{J dPl!1 01llidl{1 Pdl~dAdl
pu~ ~U!PU~Sldpun pu~ dS!A\ dl{l lliOlj S~U!l{l dSdl{l UdPP!l{ 1S1!l{ nOl{l leql 'l{UEd
pu~ UdA~dl{ jO pIal 'ldlf1~d 'ddlf1 ~U~l{l I" :JldS1!AldlSAlli dl{l S! Sll{l 'PPOM U~llinl{
dl~nbdpro! dl{llliOlj UM~lp P09 jO AldlsAlli AIPpOAUdl{10 dlf1l0j slol{dEldlli Aldldlli
ld~UOI OUdl~ dSdl{1 'PPOM S!lf1 U! P09 dunpl dlf1 jO ~U!UdMPU! pu~ UO!l~ldAdl dl{l Sl
prOM Sll{l U! udP~I-M~dl{ pu~ Al~dM dl{l jO ~U!l{Sdljdl dl{l 'p09 jO UdlPI!l{J J!UE!S
-Sdlli dl{l dq 01 snSd[ d~!l sdAldsmo MOU~ dM 'ldl{l~d lEdp '~qqV :P!P JldSlli!l{ snsd[
S11lli!l{ uo U~J pu~ lSPl{:) snsd[ jO ldl{l~d dl{l MOU~ dM ildlSAlli dU!A!P dlf1 u~ dA!1
pu~ 'OlU! pdlddJJ~ pu~ 'OlU!Pdldl~ snSd[l{~nollf11nq ~dlSAlli dU!AW dl{l dlOjdqJJO
l~j pu~s ld~uol ou dM 'ldl{l~d dl{l Aq uos dlf1 jO pu~ UOSdlf1 Aq ldlf1~d dl{l jO d~Pd