VIMAL JYOTHI ENGINEERING COLLEGE, CHEMPERI

DEPARTMENT OF COMPUTER SCIENCE & ENGINEERING

2K6CS806 (P) SEMINAR

EVALUATION RUBRICS

Name of the evaluator :

Designation :

Criteria Amateur Acceptable Admirable Exceptional

Slides seem to
have been cut-
and pasted
Boring slides; Very creative slides;
together
no glaring carefully thought out to
haphazardly at Generally good set
mistakes but no bring out both the main
the last minute; of slides; conveys
Slides real effort made points as well as the
numerous the main points
into creating subtle issues while
mistakes; well.
truly effective keeping the audience
speaker not
slides. interested.
always sure
what is coming
next.
Natural, confident
Low voice,
delivery that does not
occasionally
Audience at the just convey the
inaudible. Clear voice,
back can’t hear message but enhances
Occasional eye generally effective
anything; it; excellent use of
contact with delivery.
Reads most of volume, pace etc.
audience but Generally aware
the presentation
mostly reads the of the audience
Delivery from the slides Keeps the audience
presentation. reactions;
or notes with no engaged throughout the
Some awareness maintains good
eye contact with presentation; modifies
of at least a eye contact when
audience; seems material on-the-fly
portion of the speaking and
unaware of based on audience
audience; only when answering
audience questions and
brief responses questions.
reactions. comments; keenly
to audience
aware of audience
questions.
reaction.
 Good
documentation of
the particular
Reasonably
aspect, tying it to
Minimally complete
the other related Very good
useful document documentation
aspects and to the documentation of the
that simply lists of the particular
topic as a whole; particular aspect as
the basic facts aspect and some
many useful well as the entire topic;
related to the useful pointers
pointers to useful pointers to
particular to resources
resources outside resources and
Quality of aspect; no concerning the
concerning the relevant tools along
documentation attempt made to aspect; no real
aspect in with meaningful
relate it to other attempt to relate
particular as well evaluation of their
aspects of the it to
as the topic as a relative usefulness;
topic; documentation
whole along with useful pointers to
minimal/no concerning the
some guidance on relevant case-studies
pointers to other aspects or
the quality of the and related systems.
useful resources. the topic as a
resources and how
whole.
useful they might
be for the project
teams.
Conclusions
could be Conclusions
Conclusions not Insightful conclusions
supported by supported by
supported supported by evidence;
stronger evidence; some
by evidence; no discussed implications
Conclusions evidence; discussion of
discussion of and application;
minimal implications
implications recommended future
discussion of and future
and future work. directions for research.
implications directions.
and future work
Uncomfortable
No grasp of
with At ease with Demonstration of full
information.
information. content and able knowledge of the
Unable to
Viva Capable only of to elaborate and subject with
answer
answering explain to some explanations and
questions about
rudimentary degree. elaboration.
subject.
questions.

Amateur: 5 marks Acceptable: 10 marks

Admirable: 15 marks Exceptional: 20 marks

Signature of the evaluator: