Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A.P.A.C. Ltd.
Archaeological Perspectives Analysis Consultancy
REPORT
WB/CAE5/15
Prepared for:
MR J Harris
By: Dr N. Phillips.
A.P.A.C. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent WB/CAE5/15
Summary
An initial watching brief was conducted to a shallow level, which did not
encounter any archaeological resources; however, the resultant ground reduction
was shown to be inadequate for the proposed construction purposes.
After an onsite meeting with GGAT and MCC Planning, an adjustment to the
original condition was agreed allowing a further depth of 450mm to be excavated,
by hand under intensive watching brief conditions.
The work did not impact upon any archaeological resources but did confirm that
the area excavated had already been extensively disturbed by earlier service
installations.
Copyright Notice:
A.P.A.C. Ltd. retains copyright of this report under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988.
The Ordnance Survey has granted A.P.A.C. Ltd a Copyright Licence (No. 100046577) to reproduce map information; Copyright remains
otherwise with the Ordnance Survey.
1
A.P.A.C. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent WB/CAE5/15
Contents
Summary ......................................................................................................................................... 1
Contents ........................................................................................................................................... 2
Figures: ............................................................................................................................................ 3
Plates: .............................................................................................................................................. 3
Appendices ...................................................................................................................................... 3
Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 4
Site Location and Description ......................................................................................................... 4
Brief archaeological and historical background .............................................................................. 4
Aims and Objectives ....................................................................................................................... 6
Watching Brief ................................................................................................................................ 6
Watching Brief Results ................................................................................................................... 7
Interpretation ................................................................................................................................... 9
Staff ................................................................................................................................................. 9
Archive: ......................................................................................................................................... 10
Acknowledgements: ...................................................................................................................... 10
2
A.P.A.C. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent WB/CAE5/15
Figures:
Plates:
Appendices
3
A.P.A.C. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent WB/CAE5/15
Introduction
This Watching Brief Report has been prepared by Dr Neil Phillips, A.P.A.C. Ltd, in response to a proposed
programme of works to replace a demolish an existing wall in order to extend an existing kitchen at Myrtle Cottage,
Caerwent, planning application DC/2013/0000507.
The property is situated within the Roman town of Venta Silurum; the present day town of Caerwent; a designated,
Scheduled Ancient Monument (MM001).
Given the location and known presence of surrounding archaeological resources Glamorgan Gwent Archaeological
Trust, (GGAT); advisors to the planning department, advised that conditions should be imposed on any planning
approval:
1:
No development shall take place until the applicant, or their agents or successors in title,
has secured the implementation of a programme of archaeological work in accordance
with a written scheme of investigation which has been submitted by the applicant and
approved in writing by the local planning authority.
2:
The foundations of the extension will be constructed in accordance with the design
submitted to the LPA as part of the planning application.
MON2057/JBH
…’Edge Beam Detail’… no ground disturbance beyond 150mm D. C. Thomas & Associates
The GGAT conditions required a Written Scheme of Investigation for the required archaeological work, which was
duly submitted and approved in writing before any work began, WB/CA4/15.
The location of the site can be gained from the A448, Chepstow – Newport Rd, fig 01. Approximately 4½ miles
after leaving Chepstow on the A48, turn left at the sign for Caerwent Roman City.
Drive into the town through the old east gate, past the Coach & Horses and continue on to the war memorial where
a right turn leads to Myrtle Cottage; second property on the left at the junction with Pound Lane.
The are to be excavated to a depth not exceeding 150mm below ground surface is shown in fig 02.
The solid geology at the site is Avon Group, mudstones and limestone with a possible superficial deposit of silts,
(BGS), although these have been largely disturbed by building development in the area of the site.
The archaeological record of the Caerwent area is well represented from prehistory to present, with resources from
late prehistoric times to present surrounding the village.
Indeed, a 5km diameter search around Caerwent reveals archaeological resources from the Bronze Age, Iron Age,
Roman, Early Medieval, Medieval, Norman, Post medieval and even Modern WWII.
4
A.P.A.C. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent WB/CAE5/15
However, as the search area is reduced, the resources become more Roman based, which is no surprise, for as stated
above; the site lies adjacent to the area of the Scheduled Ancient Monument of Venta Silurum, SAM MM001, the
Roman civitas of the Iron Age Silures.
The site itself is included within one of Monmouthshire’s 31 designated conservation areas since its designation in
1976, (CCAAMP, p6 2012).
A 500m diameter HER search around the proposed site revealed records for a total of 18 Listed Buildings, appendix
I, 19 sites within the National Monuments record, appendix II, 37 archaeological events, appendix III and 108 Core
listings.
Within the 37 Events list for the 500m search, Appendix III, of specific interest due to close proximity were:
E001345: a watching brief by Monmouth Archaeology in 2009 at Museum Cottage which resulted
in the confirmation of archaeological resources in the form of a large Roman building
with hypocaust structures, walling and drainage. (MA. 209/02).
Originally excavated in 1901-03. (Ashby, Hudd, & Martin 1902).
E001364 A GPR survey carried out by GSB Prospection in 2009 which revealed the presence of a
villa complex with a good potential for surviving flooring and densely packed structural
remains. (GBS 209/03).
Other useful sources of information, not included with the above HER, were:
The Archaeological Evaluation at New House (Pound Cottage) in 2003 by Monmouth Archaeology MA 02/03:
Archaeological Watching Brief Report, Pound Cottage, Pound Lane, Caewent. WB/CAE/15. APAC ltd 2015,
(currently being written).
This will record that no archaeological resources were encountered within the excavation depth restriction of
300mm.
Recent archaeological work on the site itself has been undertaken as part of another planning proposal, within the
site and the information that has been collected has a direct relevance.
1. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent, A report on an Earth Resistance and Ground Penetrating Radar Survey.
Archaeological Surveys Limited J535 2014.
Resistivity data within close proximity to the proposed area for excavation recorded some high resistance
anomalies of uncertain origin and disturbance from services figs: 02, 03, 04.
The GPR survey confirmed the services disturbance and added another high resistance anomaly of
uncertain origin fig 05.
Strong reflections indicative of a discrete feature at the southern end of the survey area
close to the cottage. The feature is located at approximately 0,5m depth and may be
associated with the house or garden, p8.
5
A.P.A.C. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent WB/CAE5/15
2. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent, Archaeological watching brief. Foundations Archaeology. 1015 2014.
At a depth not exceeding 150mm below ground surface on an area to the north west of the same garden:
Later Post medieval/Modern soil deposits (1001), (1002) and (1003) were present to a
minimum depth of 1m below the Modern ground level, 6.1.3.
Later Post medieval/Modern soil deposits (2001) was present to a minimum depth of
1.1m below the Modern ground level, 6.2.3.
In the northern half of trench 3Post medieval/Modern soil deposits (3018) was present
to a minimum depth of 0.18m below the Modern ground level, but in the southern half
this increased to 0.39m, 6.3.8.
Roman features were also recorded at 0.49m and 0.4m below ground level and the
geophysics results of the 2014 survey were found to be incorrect.
The WSI by Foundations Archaeology, preceding their work at the Myrtle Cottage site provided an interesting
assessment of the site:
3.11
Myrtle Cottage and its boundary wall appear to be post-Medieval in date as they
appear on the 1842 Tithe map…
No archaeological features are visible on aerial photographic coverage of the site and
no relevant detail was identified through map regression.
The aim of the watching brief was to preserve by record, within the resources available, any archaeological deposits
uncovered during groundwork.
The watching brief also ensured that: in the event of archaeological resources of significance, being discovered and
requiring treatment beyond the remit of the watching brief, that steps would be implemented to ensure that their
treatment would be undertaken within the standards recommended by the CIFA.
Watching Brief
A site visit was undertaken on the 16th of August and the area for the proposed work was photographed PL01.
6
A.P.A.C. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent WB/CAE5/15
After some discussion with the client, a question as pre-existing ground disturbance became of concern and a brief
measured survey of observable and known service runs was undertaken, fig 02.
The results are shown in figure 03 and reveal that the proposed area had already been considerably disturbed by
service trenching; the depth of which was confirmed to over 400mm by lifting the associated Inspection cover.
A small test pit 200mm x 200mm x 200mm was excavated at the side of a rainwater drain and was able to establish
that the bedding sand on which the patio slabs were placed extended beyond at least 200mm beneath the 70mm of
the slab, PL02.
GGAT were informed of the client’s concerns that the 150mm depth of excavation allowed would not penetrate
through the layer of relatively recent bedding for the patio shown to extend beyond 270mm.
The site had been cleared of obstructions, paving slabs had been removed and the limit of the raft foundation trench
marked prior to hand excavation.
Initial recording
A record of the features and stratigraphy exposed during excavation was kept including written notes and
photographs.
Measurements were taken regularly using Leica Disto 510, laser measurement device.
A limited number of finds were recovered and retained for post excavation processing.
Post Ex
Following the watching brief, the field notes and photographs were digitised to produce the context record of the
stratigraphy; Appendix 1, and an annotated list of the photographs, Appendix II.
The finds which were washed by hand, dried, identified, photographed and packed in sealed and ladled bags were
recorded in Appendix III.
The three appendices; I Context and II Photographs II finds were cross referenced ready for inclusion in the report.
Presentation Notes:
Refer to fig
All contexts are denoted [#] in the text, listed in Appendix V, cross referenced in Appendix VI, to the plates section.
Photographs used in the text are listed Pl # and a complete list of photographs can be found in appendix VI with
contact sheets.
Work began at the site with the removal the bedding sand [100] that underlay the patio, until the required depth of
150mm was reached PL03, fig 02.
Once the depth had been roughly achieved over the majority of the site, PL04, clearance for recording was
undertaken, which in places penetrated into an underlying context of dark grey sandy loam [101] with occasional
stone PL05 and 20th c finds, App III.
The dark grey deposit [101], consistent with service trench fill, had more modern trench fills of sand [102], cut
[103] into it, PL06.
7
A.P.A.C. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent WB/CAE5/15
The western end of the excavation had different context of compacted red sand [104] which is shown in PL04
apparently underlying [101].
Abutting the house, the 150mm deep excavation uncovered an old 6-inch salt glazed, foul pipe [105] which can be
seen to slope down under the excavated surface, supposedly to connect with the pipe at the access chamber known
to be at 400mm below ground surface, fig 03.
The pipe is in trench fill [106] a slightly browner/red gravel/sand which underlies [101].
After the initial watching brief was concluded, it became evident that the depth of the excavation was insufficient
for the proposed lean-to foundations.
An onsite meeting was called with GGAT, and planning at which the client was given permission to amend the
depth for a further 450mm; under strict watching brief conditions, in order for the construction of the new build to
take place.
Below are the results of the further excavation, refer to fig 04.
On the 4th March 2016, work began with the removal of accumulated soil [200] that had collected over the trench of
the initial watching brief [200], PL09.
The clearance to the underlying layer [201], a dark brown sandy clay, revealed a large assemblage of 17th to 19th
century domestic debris and two sherds of Samian Ware {2}.
Context [201]; consistent with the previously excavated context [104] at a depth of 150mm, was found to extend a
further 200mm and produced a variety of finds, {3}, {9} & {10}, however the context was very disturbed with
modern pipe cuts, (see below).
The previously excavated waste pipe [105+202] was exposed, PL10 and fill [107=204] of cut [106=203].
Small finds assemblage {15} was retrieved from the fill [107=204] around [105+202] producing a spread of Roman
to modern ceramics.
Pipe [105+202] was subsequently found to increase in depth towards the north, reaching 400mm and cutting into
[218] from which small find {4} was collected.
A small metal water pipe was also exposed at a shallow depth within [104=201], which lead to the present toilet and
crossed the western return of the trench.
Upon further excavation in [104=201] another 5 waste pipes; leading to manholes previously identified in (fig 2)
where excavated; [215] to the east, [211], [205], [208], [219] centre, with [208] directly underneath [205], PL11.
All except the plastic pipe [215] were salt glazed stoneware and for the most part their associated fills and cuts were
very ephemeral.
The fill [216], for the modern pipe [215] may be somewhat indicative of the sites disturbance as it produced finds
assemblages {7}, {8} & {11}; mostly Roman but definitely modern deposition.
Towards the centre, pipes [205] and [208] where supported on irregular shaped cement columns whilst pipe [211]
lay directly upon [214] red sand, PL12.
Beneath pipe [208], at 380mm depth, was a further salt glazed pipe [219]; this time directly resting on a layer of
roughly squared tumble [222] which appeared to be raised on a supporting mound.
The two plates; PL13 & PL14 show the eastern and western sides of the pipe collection with the raised tumble [222]
seen to be localised to the pipe’s position.
The tumble was cleared of soil and then removed by hand to ascertain if there was any structural component but this
proved not to be the case.
8
A.P.A.C. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent WB/CAE5/15
The void left by removal of the tumble did increase the depth of the trench to 750mm, adjacent to the pipe positions,
revealing a layer of sandy light brown clay [225] and yielding finds assemblage {6} PL12.
A small finds assemblage {13} was collected from the interface between [222] and [225] but may have fallen from
[222] as the stones were being removed.
At the eastern end of the trench, at a depth of 400mm another feature [230], a possible stone construction step or
wall base was uncovered, PL15.
The possible feature was at the limit of the required depth and just on the edge of the trench so after some cleaning
for recording the it was left in situ.
Two pieces of Roman ceramics {14} were retrieved from [230] during cleaning.
At the north western corner of the trench at a depth of around 430mm a further context comprising an area of small
rounded stone in coarse gravel [226] was encountered but again it exceeded the required depth of the trench and so
it was not investigated.
The site provided 18th 19th 20th century finds of earthenware, clay pipes and crockery, with the addition of a small
amount of roman earthenware expected at such a site.
None of the finds were from undisturbed contexts indeed the majority of the Roman ceramics came from later
service fills.
Interpretation
The main sequence of deposition at the site discounting the patio, its bedding and the service pipes is [104=201],
[214], [218], [222], [225].
The lens of gravels to the west [226] were encountered in only a small area and may be localised rather than a main
stratigraphic context.
The possible feature to the east [300] may be Roman in origin as it yielded Roman finds on a Roman site but it is
equally possible that the feature is part of a relatively modern wall which can be identified at the adjacent road side,
PL12.
As so little of [230] was exposed it could also be possible that it was just tumble or another pipe support as with
[222].
The entire excavation showed that at the depth required for building, the site had already been disturbed previously
with various service pipe work between 19th and 20th centuries.
As a result of the extensive disturbance any archaeological resources have already been impacted on.
Although some Roman evidence was found, none of it came from secure contexts.
Staff
Post ex
Mr A. O. Phillips.
9
A.P.A.C. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent WB/CAE5/15
Archive:
The original archive for this project will remain with APAC Ltd.
Acknowledgements:
Thanks to Mr J Harris for allowing access to his site, and his efficient handling of the excavation.
Archaeological Surveys Myrtle Cottage Caerwent Monmouthshire. A Report on an Earth Resistance and
Ltd. Ground Penetrating Radar Survey. REF: J535 March 2014.
Ashby, T.,
& Martin, A.T. Excavations at Caerwent, Monmouthshire on the Site of the Romano-British City
of Venta Silurum 1889-1913. J.B. Nichols Winchester. (Chepstow Library M421)
Cadw Town & County Planning Act 1990. Planning Application No:
DC/2013/00507/New. Proposed Development: Demolish Existing Lean-To Kitchen
and Replace with Larger Single Storey Lean-To Kitchen. 12/08/2013.
Code of Conduct and the Code of Approved Practice for the regulation of
Contractual Arrangements in Field Archaeology. 2008.
10
A.P.A.C. Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent WB/CAE5/15
GGAT. 2014. MON1448.JP. Re: Cross Cottage Caerwent. 1/11/2007.
GGAT HER Enquiry Ref 5043. 500m search area centred on ST 46829065
Monmouth Archaeology New House, Pound Lane, Caerwent. An Archaeological Evaluation for Mr & Mrs
M. Gaskill. MA02.03. 2003.
Monmouthshire County
Council 22/06/2013 pl.app.no DC/2014/00507-NEW.
11
Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent
The Ordnance Survey has granted A.P.A.C. Ltd a Copyright Licence (No. 100046577)
Adapted from
MCC planning Portal DC/2013/00507
Scale 1:500
1k
Map data ©2015 Google
MH
MH
Patio
Patio
Kitchen
House
Existing walls
Proposed walls
0 1 2 3
MH
MH
Patio
3.6m
Patio
Kitchen
House
Existing kitchen
Proposed kitchen
Drain runs
0 1 2 3
N
MH
202 219
MH
224 230
226 224
Kitchen
House
Existing Walls
Trench edge
0 1 2 3
Contractors:
DSC09368, DSC09369,
DSC09371, DSC09372,
DSC09377, DSC09378,
DSC09363, DSC09365,
DSC09368, DSC09369,
213 West Cut Cut for 211
DSC09371, DSC09372,
DSC09377, DSC09378,
DSC09372, DSC09374,
214 West Fill Red sandy clay under 211
DSC09377, DSC09378,
DSC09365, DSC09368,
DSC09369, DSC09371,
215 West Pipe Plastic
DSC09372, DSC09377,
DSC09378,
{6}, {11} DSC09365, DSC09368,
DSC09369, DSC09371,
216 West Fill Sandy clay/surface soil
DSC09372, DSC09377,
DSC09378,
DSC09365, DSC09368,
DSC09369, DSC09371,
217 West Cut Cut for 215
DSC09372, DSC09377,
DSC09378,
{3}, {12} DSC09365, DSC09368,
DSC09369, DSC09371,
218 West Fill Clay sand, dark brown
DSC09372, DSC09377,
DSC09378,
DSC09363, DSC09368,
219 East Pipe Salt glaze DSC09369, DSC09373,
DSC09377, DSC09378,
DSC09363, DSC09368,
220 East fill Clay sand, dark brown DSC09369, DSC09373,
DSC09377, DSC09378,
DSC09363, DSC09368,
221 East Cut Cut for 219 DSC09369, DSC09373,
DSC09377, DSC09378,
{5} {7}, {8} DSC09363, DSC09365,
222 Central Tumble Angular sandstone
DSC09372, DSC09373,
{13} DSC09363, DSC09374,
225 All Deposit Sandy clay, light brown DSC09374, DSC09377,
DSC09378,
226 East Deposit Small rounded stones in coarse sand
227 East Pipe Metal DSC09379
228 East Fill Black surface soil DSC09379
229 East Cut Cut for 227 DSC09379
230 West Stone steps Possible structure, outside trench limit {14} DSC09366, DSC09367,
DSC09368, DSC09369,
DSC09370, DSC09371,
DSC09378,
A.P.A.C. Ltd Appendix V WB/CAE5/15
Contexts
WB/CAE5/15
A.P.A.C. Ltd Appendix VII WB/CAE5/15
Finds Index
WB/CAE5/15
Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent
SAM002
SAM 001
Plate 01: Ground conditions prior to excavation Plate 02: Depth of soil 70mm flag, 200mm sand, soil not reached
DSC08739
DSC08738
Plate 03: Initial excavation depth of 150mm Plate 04: Initial excavation to 150mm
A.P.A.C. Ltd CAE5/15
general view
Myrtle Cottage, Caerwent
DSC08743
DSC08740
Plate 05: General view along excavation to north of kitchen. Areas of Plate 06: Fill [102] for cut [103] into [101]
[101] exposed during clearing for recording
DSC08744
DSC08745
Plate 07: West wall of kitchen showing exposed pipe [105] in fill Plate 08: West wall of kitchen showing
A.P.A.C. Ltd CAE5/15
[106] General showing dip to north exposed pipe [105] in fill [106] detail
MYRTLE COTTAGE, CAERWENT
DSC09376
DSC09362
Plate 09: Ground conditions prior to excavation Plate 10: West corner of trench. Exposed pipe [201] and fill [204]
DSC09372
DSC09373
Plate 11: In-depth, at [225] under tumble [222] and Plate 12: Depth of soil at 700mm,
A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/CAE5/15
exposed pipes [205], [208], and [219] tumble excavated to required depth,
[222] over bottom of trench [225] sandy clay, light brown
MYRTLE COTTAGE, CAERWENT
DSC09364
DSC09363
Plate 13: Tumble at depth of 380mm [200] under exposed pipes Plate 14: Tumble at depth of 380mm [200] under exposed pipes
[208], [219] and fill [210], [220] [202], [206] and fill [204], [207]
DSC09379
DSC09367
Plate 15: Depth of soil 200mm, in-depth shot of possible Plate 16: General view, water pipe
A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/CAE5/15
feature steps, [230] exposed [227]
A.P.A.C. Ltd Appendix III FINDS WB/CAE5/15
DSC08750
101 1
DSC09434
200 2
DSC09435
201 3
DSC09436
218 4
DSC09437
212 5
DSC09438
222 6
DSC09439
216 7
DSC09441
216 8
DSC09442
201 9
DSC09443
201 10
DSC09444
216 11
DSC09445
218 12
DSC09446
225 13
DSC09447
230 14
DSC09448
204 15