Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................................. 3
OVERVIEW ........................................................................................................................................................... 5
RESEARCH QUESTION/HYPOTHESIS ..................................................................................................................... 5
OVERVIEW ........................................................................................................................................................... 8
OVERVIEW ......................................................................................................................................................... 12
POPULATION, STUDY SAMPLE, SAMPLE SIZE, SELECTION OF SAMPLE .............................................................. 14
SOURCES OF DATA ............................................................................................................................................. 14
COLLECTION OF DATA ....................................................................................................................................... 14
DATA ANALYSIS STRATEGIES ............................................................................................................................ 15
ETHICS AND HUMAN SUBJECTS ISSUES .............................................................................................................. 15
TIMEFRAMES ...................................................................................................................................................... 15
REFERENCES ..................................................................................................................................................... 19
APPENDICES ...................................................................................................................................................... 21
APPENDIX 1: ....................................................................................................................................................... 21
QUANTITATIVE QUESTIONNAIRE SAMPLE ............................................................................................................. 21
QUALITATIVE SAMPLE QUESTIONS: ...................................................................................................................... 22
2
INTRODUCTION
Over the past two decades there have been rapid advancements in the computing industry that
have impacted the lifestyle of many around the world. Starting in the late ‘90s the personal
digital assistants allowed for users to have a pocket sized computing system. Later in the early
‘00s, cell phones evolved allowing for communication to be mobilized. Within a few years,
cell phones had the ability to send written forms of communication instantly through a short
message service (SMS), and by 2007, the functionality of a mobile device expanded as the first
iPhone launched with its ability to take pictures, play music, send messages, and access the
internet. In 2003, cell phones were carried for emergency and safety reasons, to actively keep
in contact with people, to manage time efficiently, and purchased to save money (Aoki, 2003).
With the development and expansion of the functionality of mobile devices, cell phones (which
many are now called smartphones) have evolved to the point where users have the ability to
connect with the whole world. Recently “users view smartphones as freeing, connecting,
helpful and usually worth the cost” (Smith, 2015). There is no doubt that smartphone devices
play a pivotal role in our lives today and devices such as the iPhone have become prevalent in
the lives of all Americans. In 2015, two-thirds of Americans owned a smartphone, with 19%
percent of Americans relying on the device to aid in various life tasks (Smith, 2015).
Smartphone users interact with various forms of digital media every time they use their phone.
This allows for exposure to new ideas and knowledge, early learning, access to information, as
well as more opportunities to be in social contact with others (Chassiakos, 2016). However,
there is concern that excessive use may have a negative impact on the user’s health (Chassiakos,
2016). There are also privacy concerns, the ability to access to inaccurate information, or
3
Generation Y and Z have grown up with technological devices and the thought of them being
“addicted” to, or dependent on their smart device has become a rising concern as the
functionality and advancements of the devices continues to grow (Chóliz, 2012). The idea of
dependency, or addiction to the device may be inferred due to the observational phenomenon.
Anywhere you go you will most likely see this age group looking down at their phone in public
venues, even while physically being with someone. Even members of this generation note their
dependency on their device. In 2014, college aged students at Elon University described
“feeling disconnected, naked and stressed when they didn’t carry their phone” (Jones, 2014).
In 2016, out of the three-fourths of teenagers who own a smartphone, 24 percent mentioned
that they feel constantly connected to the internet and 50 percent of them felt addicted to their
phones (Chassiakos, 2016). Most recently, in 2017, an assessment of new technologies found
“a high percentage of young people (ages 12-21 years) felt very uneasy if unable to use their
mobile or if without internet” (Annucibay, 2017). Smartphones in our current society play an
important role allowing users to “access, share and create information and communicate with
With rapid technological advancements it’s important that research stays current. Presently,
there is some research that discusses motives for adolescents using certain applications such as
social networking sites, texting and gaming. These applications can be found within a
smartphone device, but what specifically are adolescent males and females using their
smartphones for and are they becoming dependent on their device? There is limited current
research pertaining to the purpose of specifically using a smartphone in the lives of adolescent
males and females, as well as, limited research on the emotional attachment to the device.
Research is needed to better understand why adolescents are seemingly addicted or dependent
to their phones and what adolescents’ primarily use their smartphone for.
4
PROBLEM STATEMENT
Overview
The purpose of cell phones used to allow a person to verbally get in contact with someone
without being in the same physical space. While cell phones today still serve the same
communicative purpose, there are now a variety of ways in which communication can occur.
Phones are now considered “smart” due to the advancements in their functionality.
Smartphones “reinforce personal autonomy in the context of relationships with peers, offers
major technological innovations, serves as a source of fun and entertainment, and supports the
is less research as to the possible, if any, differences between male and female adolescent use.
(Chassiakos, 2016) research will help to understand the purpose of using a smartphone in the
lives of both male and female adolescents (age 13-19) and provide insight into their attitudes
Research Question/Hypothesis
R1: Does the purpose for using a smartphone differ amongst adolescent males and females
(ages 13-19)?
• H1: There is a significant difference in the purpose for using a smartphone amongst
R2: How does the reason for using a smartphone influence an adolescents psychological
• Subquestion: How does the amount of time an adolescent spends on their smartphone
5
o H2: The purpose for which adolescents use their smartphone, determines the
6
OBJECTIVES AND AIMS
Overall Objective
• To understand if the reasons for which adolescent males and females use their
smartphone affects their psychological dependence on the device.
Specific Aims
7
BACKGROUND AND SIGNIFICANCE
Overview
three main categories: ownership of mobile device, the motives for use, and the possible
negative implications of use. Literature within years 2003 and 2007 discuss trends in ownership
of cell phones, and starts to develop an understanding of how and why mobile devices are being
used. In the next few years, literature continues to discuss the purposes of a cell phone and
multiple functions within a cell phone, social networking, and begins to look into the idea of
device dependency. Literature on the implications and psychological risks associated with cell
phone use does not stay specific to cell phones. There is a gap in literature when it comes to
specifically discussing the purpose and implications of smartphones and an even greater gap
rapidly developing, cell phones, a mobile tool in which one had the ability to communicate
verbally and in limited written form, quickly became another form of digital media that serves
multiple purposes and contains a variety of functionality tools. In 2013, cell phones started to
be called “smart” phones due to certain features it had. A smartphone has the ability to: send
or receive emails, download a software application, access the internet, participate in video
calls, send or receive text messages, and listen to music (Duggan, 2013). With the concept of
smartphones being fairly new, in current literature, smartphones are discussed within the
category of digital media. Research is needed to add to the discussion on the purpose of a
smartphone device in the adolescent age group and the subsequent potential for dependency.
8
Literature Review
Reports from the Pew Research Center provide robust insight in statistical trends throughout
the past few years on teen ownership and purpose for using a mobile device. In order to
understand the growth and development of mobile phones and their uses, it’s important to
understand the trend in ownership of a mobile phone amongst teens. In the early 2000’s, age
was the primary difference amongst mobile phone owners. With small differences in phone
amongst race, ethnicities and gender (Lenhart, 2009). While many teens within the age of
twelve through seventeen had ownership of a mobile phone, it was the older teens who were
more likely to own cell phones (Lenhart, 2009). In 2009, there were still no differences in
ownership with other demographics besides for age and little difference amongst socio
economic status. However, there was a growth in mobile phone ownership, because younger
teens began to obtain phones (Lenhart et.al, 2010). Increase in mobile phone ownership
continues to grow in 2011 as 77 percent of teens had ownership of a mobile phone and nearly
With the rise of mobile phone and even smartphone ownership, literature discusses the uses,
purposes, and motives for use of a device. Annucibay (2017) found that the main use of a
mobile device was to: get in touch with friends and family, play games, be a source of music
media, send written messages, and as a camera. These findings support previous literature that
reports activities done on cell phones include (listed in order from most popular activity to
least): communicating through written text messages, using the internet, communicating
through email, downloading apps, getting directions, listening to music, video chatting, and
sharing location (Duggan, 2013). Chlóliz (2012) adds that the use of mobile phones can be a
source of fun and entertainment for adolescents, and provides adolescents a medium to in which
9
they can establish and maintain interpersonal relationships. Chlóliz’s report supports findings
from Lenhart (2015) who describes how smartphones are used by teenagers as a way to
connect, communicate, and spend time with their friends. Teens are “increasingly connecting
with one another through social media, gaming and the internet” (Lenhart, 2015), all of which
can be done within their smartphone. Smith (2015) adds that young smartphone users may use
their device to combat boredom to which Boyd (2007) noted that specifically social networking
Amongst the variety of uses, the main use with a mobile device has been, and continues to be
for communication (Lenhart, 2012). Communication through a landline phone was still
prevalent in the years 2004-2008 and Lenhart (2009) reports that “a considerable number of
teens with cell phones continue to use landlines daily and at the same rate as their cell phone-
less counterparts”. Communication and the idea of connecting and socializing with close
friends and family is a common theme in the literature, with text messaging now being the most
dominant form of communication (Lenhart, 2012). Statistical trends show that there is an
increase in the use of online social networking sites to communicate, from 55% users in 2006,
to 80% in 2011, as well as an increase in the amount of texts sent (Lenhart, 2012). Lenhart
(2015) reports that “texting is the most common way teens get in touch with closest friends…
[and]…for many teens, phone numbers for texting is the first thing they share with new
friends”. In addition, Reid (2007) adds a different perspective and discusses preferences for
cell phone use specifically amongst people with social anxiety, and loneliness. Reid concludes
that people who are anxious would prefer to communicate through a written text, whereas
people who experience loneliness would rather connect to someone through verbal
communication over a phone call. Furthermore, Chassiakos 2016 points out that “modes of
10
between texts and social media sites” however, it’s also mentioned that there are “blurred lines”
With the wide variety of functionality a smartphone provides, and the increasing number of
users, an area of concern with adolescents is the rise of possible dependency on a smartphone.
Annucibay (2017) performed an assessment on new technologies and found that a “high
percentage of young people (12-21years) felt very uneasy if unable to use their mobile or if
without an internet connection”. There is medical support that describes the negative
implications of too much usage, however, it’s specific to the use of digital media in general
which applies to all screens: TV, cell phone, computer. Risks include: negative effects on sleep,
attention and learning, obesity and depression, exposure to unsafe content, and privacy
concerns (Chassiakos, 2016). Geser (2006) mentions that cell phone usage is not yet an object
in which “much attitudinal commitment is attached”, however a few years later, Jones (2014)
reports that college aged students reported feeling “disconnected, naked, and stressed when
they didn’t carry their cell phone”. In the same report, the 82 percent of the students themselves
agreed that there is some negative psychological impact, especially on one’s self esteem. This
idea of self esteem correlates to the findings of Lenhart, Anderson and Smith (2015) in which
smartphones can be used to put someone down after a relationship break up or spread rumors
about them using the digital platforms within the mobile device. Behaviors that may be
considered reflective of abuse and influence dependency include excessive use of the mobile
device in that it interferes with other daily life activities, changes the “rules for interpersonal
relationships”, and has an effect on the user’s health; physically or mentally (Chlóliz, 2012).
11
RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS
Overview
This study will draw from a social science theoretical framework in which both quantitative
and qualitative components of the study will inform the results and observations. This study
will be framed around an inductive objectivist approach to social science. The overall
theoretical perspective stems from the phenomenological paradigm in which this study is trying
to understand what is the purpose for adolescents (males vs females) of using their smartphone
device. There will be multiple methods in order to obtain a complete understanding. Theories
The method used for this study will be mixed methods so that a complete understanding of the
research questions can be analyzed. Questions in the qualitative and quantitative sections of
research will be similar in content, in that both sections will ask questions pertaining to purpose
of use and dependency. The qualitative interview will allow for participants to further provide
more in-depth thoughts that will help to understand results of the quantitative section. Both
qualitative and quantitative methods will provide data that can be analyzed in a convergent
parallel structure.
A quantitative questionnaire will be used as a method to understand the purpose for which
adolescent males and females are using their device. It may also serve as a way to gauge their
information and data. Questions will be specific and responses will be of ranked nature as
shown in Appendix 1. Empirical data about the uses of smartphone can be analyzed through a
chi squared test that will allow for comparison amongst gender and even ages.
12
The goal of the qualitative section of research is to discuss with participants about their
smartphone usage and their psychological outlook. Information gather through an interview
will provide valuable insight that will help explain the results of the quantitative responses.
Participants will participate in an in-person verbal interview that will later be transcribed and
defensive when asked specific questions, the interview will be conducted by young adults or
people around their age. This may also allow for more communication and dialogue between
the participant and the interviewer and conversations about a specific question may evolve to
provide even more of an understanding. Analysis will be inductive as themes will emerge after
the transcription is coded, analyzed and compared to responses of the quantitative section.
Results of the collected data (qualitative and quantitative) will be combined and merged for
discussion as to whether or not the findings are parallel to each other. In this study, the
quantitative approach will be used to collect ordinal data about the specific use of the
smartphone, as well as to gauge the user’s emotional connection towards their device.
Quantitative data will be used to establish emerging purposes of use based on what participants
say they do on their smartphone. For example, if a participant says they use their smartphone
to text their friends, this can be categorized as a purpose of communicative use. Depending on
what adolescents say they use their smartphones for, the psychological attachment to their
device may differ. For example, if a participant mainly uses their phone for communicative
purposes but specifically to call when needed, that participant would be most likely not as
attached to their phone as one who uses it to communicate socially. The qualitative aspect will
collect information that further explains the participants perspective on the purpose of a
smartphone in their lives and may provide information regarding their dependency. The reason
for collecting both quantitative and qualitative data is to collect a complete understanding and
13
have multiple perspectives on the purpose of a smartphone device in the lives of adolescent
males and females. A mixed method, convergent parallel design will allow for comparison of
gender differences amongst adolescents in regards to what they use their phones for and the
The sampling method would be stratified random sampling so that the study can draw from
many different stratas, in this case, genders and ages. Public schools throughout Ohio will be
used because schools already have the stratas in their own data base from which participants
Sources of Data
Sources of data are adolescent responses to online quantitative survey and responses in verbal
Collection of Data
Data for the quantitative phase will be collected using an instrument such as an online survey
creator. Using an online survey will allow for results to be instantaneously generated and allows
for ability of manipulation and interpretation. Quantitative data can be uploaded into a system
Qualitative data will be collected using a recording device in which the interview will be
14
Data Analysis Strategies
Interpretation of research for the quantitative section will use SPSS or like program so that
results amongst variables such as age and gender can be easily compared and significance can
Interpretation of research for the qualitative section will be coded by hand. The interview will
be recorded and transcribed and the researcher will reread the interview looking for themes and
patterns that provide further insight into the understanding between purpose of use and
psychological dependency.
quantitative and qualitative sections. Wording of the questions need to be carefully considered
so that participants do not feel as if they are doing something wrong if they are addicted or
emotionally attached to their phone. If using a school’s database to select random participants,
confidentiality of information is required and therefore participants can be given a specific code
to identify them. Participation should be voluntary and therefore informed consent is needed,
Timeframes
After research study is approved, it will take about 1-2 months to set up connections for
participation amongst students in schools. After locations are finalized, quantitative data can
be collected over the time span of 1-2 months, followed by about 1 month of analysis and
adjustments for qualitative in person interviews. Coding and analysis of qualitative phase will
take approximately 1 month, and finally a report will be generated and in review for publishing.
Overall, the research should take about 6 months to 1 year, based on limiting factors such as
availability of participants.
15
STRENGTHS AND WEAKNESSES OF THE STUDY
A possible weakness to the study may be due to the nature of the age range of the participants.
The thoughtfulness of responses may differ amongst the different age ranges and genders,
which may result in difficulty generalizing results of the purpose for use and psychological
dependency. Adolescent participants may not take it seriously as they may not see the impact
this study has on their life. Participants may need an external motivation to participate
thoroughly.
A strength to this study is that results will fill the gaps of current literature and provide
information to multiple audiences. Audiences that may find this research helpful include:
parents, medical personnel, educators, mental health professionals, software designers, and
other researchers in the field of social science. Mixed Methods provides more opportunity for
collect valid data because if a participant does not thoughtfully consider the questions in the
quantitative section, they will be asked to further explain their thoughts during the qualitative
interview.
16
SIGNIFICANCE FOR (INFORMATION SCIENCE) (LEARNING
TECHNOLOGIES)
This study will provide current literature to help understand how smartphones play a role in
the lives of adolescents. This study will fill the gap in the literature on digital media usage and
provide specifics about gender differences of use. It will also provide a new age range as most
studies in information communicative technologies focus on adults. This study will augment
the existing studies on the psychological impact smartphone use has on teens.
17
BUDGET AND MOTIVATION
This study will be low in cost, as there will only be need for money to pay for a data collector
18
REFERENCES
Anuncibay, R. de la F. (2017). ICTs and teenage students. problematic usage or dependence. Procedia -
Aoki, K., & Downes, E. J. (2003). An analysis of young people’s use of and attitudes toward cell phones.
boyd, danah. (2007). Why youth (heart) social network sites: The role of networked publics in teenage social
life (SSRN Scholarly Paper No. ID 1518924). Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network.
Chassiakos, Y. (Linda) R., Radesky, J., Christakis, D., Moreno, M. A., Cross, C., & Media, C. on C. A.
(2016). Children and adolescents and digital media. Pediatrics, 138(5), e20162593.
https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2016-2593
Chlóliz, M. (2012). Mobile-phone addiction in adolescence: The test of mobile phone dependence (TMD).
Duggan, M. (2013, September 19). Cell phone activities 2013. Retrieved April 27, 2018, from
http://www.pewinternet.org/2013/09/19/cell-phone-activities-2013/
Geser, H. (2006). Are girls (even) more addicted? Some gender patterns of cell phone usage. Universität
Jones, T. (2014). Students’ cell phone addiction and their opinions. The Elon Journal of Undergraduate
19
Lenhart, A. (2009, August 19). Teens and mobile phones over the past five years: Pew internet
and-mobile-phones-over-the-past-five-years-pew-internet-looks-back/
Lenhart, A. (2012, March 19). What teens do with their phones. Pew Research Center. Retrieved February
Lenhart, A. (2015, August 6). Teens, technology and friendships. Retrieved March 17, 2018, from
http://www.pewinternet.org/2015/08/06/teens-technology-and-friendships/
Lenhart, A., Purcell, K., Smith, A., & Zickuhr, K. (2010). Social media & mobile internet use
among teens and young adults. millennials. Pew Internet & American Life Project. Retrieved
from https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED525056
Lenhart, A., Anderson, M., & Smith, A. (2015, October 1). Teens, technology and romantic relationships.
romantic-relationships/
Reid, D. J., & Reid, F. J. M. (2007). Text or talk? Social anxiety, loneliness, and divergent preferences for
Smith, A. (2015, April 1). U.S. smartphone use in 2015. Retrieved March 17, 2018, from
http://www.pewinternet.org/2015/04/01/us-smartphone-use-in-2015/
20
APPENDICES
Appendix 1:
Dependency Questions:
Sample questions are from the literature of Chlóliz (2012), who stated, “the main objective of
based on the DSM-IV-TR criteria for dependence and similar to the approaches used to
evaluate other behavioural addictions such as addition to gambling” Chlóliz (2012). These
Indicate how frequently the statements that appear below apply to you using the following scale
3. I have gone to bed later or slept less because I was using my smartphone
appropriate to do so (eating, while people are talking to me, stopped at a traffic light).
Indicate to what degree you agree or disagree with the statements presented below: 0-
21
Purpose of use sample questions: *Results of these responses will help identify themes of
purpose such as: using the phone for fun, for communication, to socialize. Questions will be
Indicate how often you use your smartphone for the following statements: 0-never, 1-rarely, 2-
2. Playing games
3. Alleviate boredom
5. Check emails
7. Fitness tracking
8. Shop online
22