ANNARAM BARRAGE - DETAILED COMPARATIVE STATEMENT

AS PER WAPCOS LOCATION AS PER I & CAD Dept LOCATION

Excess/
S.No Description of Item Amount Quantity Amount Remarks
Details Unit Quantity Rate Details Rate Less
(in Crores) (in Crores)

For Diversion of River flow 11.21 For Diversion of River flow - 11.21 0
1 Coffer Dam - -
1)There is no approach road to execute
the work of Right Flank of Annaram
Barrage at WAPCOS proposed location
,since approach road comes under forest
area and could not have started the work
immediately without forest clearance.
2)WAPCOS proposed location is 3kms to
core zone of crocodile wild life santuary
and where as present location is 5.2kms
to crocodile wild life santuary.
3)At WAPCOS Location with 120m
contour 7159Ac and 1.Chintapalli,
2.Mallaram, 3.Damekunta,
4.Laxmipuram, 5.Arinda, 6.Mallaram and
7.Khansaipet colony villages will be
submerged and at present location with
119m contour 6937Ac and
1.Gundrathpalli,2.Chintapalli,3.Dameraku
nta,4.Laxmipuam,5.Pokkur and
6.Khansaipet colony will coming under
submergence.
4)The WAPCOS has not done detailed
sub-soil investigation and sufficient bore
holes.
5)WAPCOS has not done detailed
structural designs.
6)Since length of afflux is not changed ,
length of barrage would have been
1270m against 1119m as proposed in
DPR.
2 Barrage length 1119m 1270m
7)At WAPCOS proposed location HFL
mentioned in DPR is 124.50m where as it
could be 121.970m.
8)At present location HFL is 121.00m
9) At present location after detailed sub-
soil investigation and structural design
and same afflux consided as per WAPCOS
location, the barrage length arrived as
1270m against 1119m.
10)At present location Barrage pond level
reduced from 120m to 119m to minimise
LA and R&R of villages.
11)Medigadda Lift conveyor system
length reduced from 18.85km to
15.05km to minimise forest area and also
to reduce length due to change of
location of barrage.
12)Medigadda Lift System forest area
reduced from 424Ha(1048Ac) to
338Ha(835Ac) i.e, savings in forest area
about 86Ha(213Ac).
13)Barrage Storage capacity increased
from 9.44TMC to 10.87TMC at 119m
pond level.
 AS PER WAPCOS LOCATION AS PER I & CAD Dept LOCATION
Excess/
S.No Description of Item Amount Quantity Amount Remarks
Details Unit Quantity Rate Details Rate Less
(in Crores) (in Crores)

Guide Bund -

3 2 X 1119 m - - 2 X 1905 m -
U/S on both sides
304.48 151.1 -153.38 Guide bund savings amount Rs 153.38Cr
2 X 336 m - - 2 X 572 m -
D/S on both sides

4 Barrage civil works

1)The sufficient provision for Earth work

excavation was not made in WAPCOS DPR.
2)The river training walls were not considered
a) Earthwork Excavation in All in DPR.
Cum 1616912.63 134.11 21.68 4654209.00 134.11 62.42 40.74 3)The depth of foundation is incresed from 2m
Soils
to 3m due to design requirement.
4)Increase in barrage length from 1119m to
Earth work excavation for Earth work excavation for
i) 1270m and decresed raft width from 110m to
Barrage Barrage
100m as per approved drawings.
5)Earth work excavation Quantity increased
due to excavation of river banks for
272m(140M-R/S & 132M-L/S) including both
b) Earthwork Excavation in HDR Cum 1045941.76 171.70 17.96 3102806.00 171.70 53.28 35.32 sides.
6) Increase in width of launching apron from
66.00m to 110.00m asper approved drawing.

Sub - Total 39.64 Sub - Total 115.70 76.06

1)The WAPCOS has not done detailed sub-soil

investigation and sufficient bore holes.
2)The WAPCOS has not done detailed
a) For Main Barrage : structural designs.
M 20 (40 MSA) ; 2.00 m/3.00 3)Based on Detailed Sub-soil Explorations,test
m thick results and based on detailed calculations the
M 25 ( 40 MSA);
Width: 110 m raft thickness arrived as 3m & 4m against 2m &
ii) Raft Cum 321801.43 6915.44 222.54 3.00 M/4.00 M thick 405117.37 7324.25 296.72 74.18
b) For UnderSluice: M 20 (40 3m by WAPCOS.
width: 100 M
MSA) ; 4)As per Latest codal provisions and design
2.00 m/3.00 m thick requirements the grade of raft concrete
width: 110 m adopted M25 instead of M20 as per approved
Drawings
5) Increase in barrage length from 1119m to
1270m as per approved drawing.

1)Since raft concrete grade used M25, hence

wearing coat should be adopted to next grade
M30 as per IS code.
2)Wearing coat thickness increased from 0.15m
iii) Wearing Coat M 25 ; 20MSA, 0.15 m Thick Cum 17604.00 6634.72 11.68 M 30 ; 20MSA, 0.20 m Thick 23067.00 7137.80 16.46 4.78
to 0.20m asper approved drawing.
3)Increase in barrage length from 1119m to
1270m as per approved drawings.

1)The WAPCOS has not done detailed sub-soil

investigation and sufficient bore holes.
5)WAPCOS has not done detailed structural
M 25 ( 20 MSA) ;52 Nos : 4.00 M 25 ( 20 MSA); 70 Nos : designs.
m Thick 4.00 m Thick 2) As per the stability analysis , CBIP manual
iv) Piers 5 Nos Double Pier: 8.00 m Cum 446087.52 7467.91 333.13 5 Nos Double Pier: 448124.00 7467.91 334.65 1.52 and FEM analysis, the length of the Pier is
Thick, 8.00 m Thick, increased from 86.50 m to 100 m i.e.13.5m as
Length:86.50 m Length:100 m per the approved drawing
3) Increase in barrage length from 1119m to
1270m as per the approved drawing

1)Increase in barrage length from 1119m to

M 15; Levelling course under M 15; Levelling course under 1270m
Cum 14121.55 5938.17 8.39 19050.00 5938.17 11.31 2.92
raft raft 2) Increase PCC thickness from 0.10m to
0.15m asper CE,CDO approved drawing.

Training wall,Block protection

5 wall Levelling course under raft M 15; Curtain walls M 15; Curtain walls (3 Nos)
and Curtain walls, Cum - - - 3 x 1270 x 1 x 1.8 9715.50 5938.17 5.77 5.77
+3x1270x1.5x0.5 1)Sufficient Provision for curtain wall,Toe
wall/Block protection wall i.e walls between
C.C blocks on U/s & D/s is not been made in
DPR.
 Training wall,Block protection
AS PER WAPCOS LOCATION AS PER I & CAD Dept LOCATION
5 wall Levelling course under raft Excess/
S.No Description
and Curtainof Item
walls, Amount Quantity Amount Remarks
Details Unit Quantity Rate Details Rate Less
(in Crores) (in Crores) 1)Sufficient Provision for curtain wall,Toe
wall/Block protection wall i.e walls between
M 15; Training walls (2Nos) C.C blocks on U/s & D/s is not been made in
M 15: Training wall Cum - - -
2 X 208 X 8.50 X 20.35 DPR.
71957.60 5938.17 42.73 42.73
M 15; Block protection wall
M 15: Block protection wall Cum - - -

1)Size of CC Blocks provided as per IS code

requirements and Designs
M 15; 40MSA M 20; 40MSA 2) Dimensions of CC blocks increased from
6 CC blocks Cum 53352.45 5938.17 31.68 82328.40 6342.41 52.22 20.54
1.20 X 1.20 X 0.75 1.50 x 1.50 x 0.90 1.20 X 1.20 X 0.75 m to 1.50
X 1.50 X 0.90 m as per Approved Drawings

1)Sufficient provision for Toe walls and

Toe wall, Abutments & Road abutments is not made in the WAPCOS DPR
7 M 20, 20MSA Bridge Cum 2088.00 7573.67 1.58 Road bridge, Fish ladder 10500.30 7573.67 7.95 6.37
Bridge and for fish ladder provision is not made in
WAPCOS DPR.

Z-type or under pier 504.00 141138.00 7.11 -30.88 1)Cut-off Secant piles adopted inview of subsoil
strata metwith,such as boulders/sand
Secant Piles on U/S ( Soft ) 9914.00 21109.00 20.93 20.93 stone/stiff clay.
2) Further the provision for the cross cut-offs at
Z-type sheet piles proposed
8 Cut offs MT 2689.69 141248.00 37.99 Secant Piles on U/S ( Hard) 10514.00 30865.00 32.45 32.45 double piers locations is not provided in the
for U/S & D/S Cut-offs
DPR.
3) Increase in barrage length from 1119m to
Secant Piles on D/S ( Soft ) 12530.00 21224.00 26.59 26.59 1270m as per approved drawing.

Secant Piles on D/S (Hard) 13594.00 28218.00 38.36 38.36

1)The WAPCOS has not done detailed structural

designs.
2T)he Estimated quantities provided in DPR are
not based on detailed structural designs and
drawings. Present quantites of steel are arrived
9 Reinforcement HYSD MT 30656.49 46509.18 142.58 HYSD 47000.00 46509.18 218.59 76.01 based on detailed investigation and Structural
Design based on the Latest codal provisions.
3)Increase in barrage length from 1119m to
1270m as per approved drawing.

300 mm Thick Graded stones 300 mm Thick Graded stones 1)Width of launching apron increased from 66m
10 Launching Apron Cum 98148.00 1493.90 14.66 237490.00 1493.90 35.48 20.82
are proposed are proposed to 110m as per the approved GAD Drawings.

11 Dewatering Kw/hr 4688550.00 23.60 11.06 9169491.53 23.60 21.64 10.58 As per the site conditions

Seignorage charges,
12 69.55 92.90 23.35 1) Due to increase in quantities.
Miscallaneous items

Sub - Total 924.48 Sub - Total 1377.56 453.08

1)Increase in barrage length from 1119m to

a) Under Sluice Gates : 11 Nos
( 15 m x 16.50 m) with Hoist
Capacity 225 T
13 Gates
b) Other Bays : 47 Nos
( 15m x 15.50 m) with Hoist
Capacity 200 T
1270m and decresed size of gates from
15mx16.5 to 15x12m for other bays and
a)Under Sluice Gates : 12 Nos
15mx15.5 to 15mx13 for under sluice bays and
( 15 m x 13 m)
provisions are made accordingly duly following
with Hoist Capacity 225 T
MT 15706.50 237.42 17795.50 297.48 60.06 IS codes.The designs are arrived actual with
b)Other Bays : 54 Nos
detail calculations.
( 15m x 12 m) with Hoist
2.)No of gates increased from 58 to 66 asper
Capacity 200 T
approved drawings.
3)Due to change in specification of steel i.e,
Mild steel to speccial garade steel.

TOTAL (Rs.) In Crores 1477.59 1837.35 359.76 Crores

Net financial implications 24.35% Excess 359.76 Crores

Note: The above details are arrived based on the approved drawings finalisation till today by CE CDO. Further the arrived quantities are subject to variation based on the approved drawings further to
be received which are under process of approval.