Gis Comments On KTGT Reply Sheet Crps 26-2-18

ANNUXURE ''A''
DESIGN REVIEW FOR NEW GRID STATION AT GETZ PHARMA AND GIS EXTENSION A
Title: Comments on Schematics Drawings At Getz Pharma and GIS bay extension a
Drawing No.
DESIGN REVIEW LOG
Description Reference
Submission Of Technical Data For Approval.
Comments by K-Electric
S.N KE Comments Status
o
A General Comments
Kindly confirm that the LCC Interlocking Schematics,

LCC Bay to Bay Interfacing, LCC Panel Schematics, Bay
1 RP Panel Schematics, Bay CP Panel Schematics and Open
Metering Panel Schematics for New Bay (=E18) are
same as existing Panels for existing Line Feeders.
2 The Quality of documents should be improved, SLDs Open

are not Clear.
SEL relay is not installed in Ke system so kindly
arrange training of SEL Relays at Manufacturer
premises which includes Air-fare, transportation and
3 allowance for foreign trip with Incidental and Open
accidental insurance, Hotel
accommodation/boarding/lodging charges
allowanace and Daily allowance for two persons.
Kindly arrange witnessing of Type Tests of SEL Relays

at Manufacturer premises which includes Air-fare,
transportation and allowance for foreign trip with
4 Incidental and accidental insurance, Hotel Open
accommodation/boarding/lodging charges
allowanace and Daily allowance for two persons.
All revised drawing and future Submittals must be

5 send after vetting from your consultant along with Open
their comments
6 All Updated area in drawing should be highlighted in Open

red cloud.
B LCC Panel Schematics - SG2L002972:
1 SLD is not clear. (Refer: Sheet A20) Open

Show reference of CT secondary connections for each
2 cores in CT circuit. (Refer: Sheet S10 & S11) Open
Color code of CT wires should be mention in CT
3 circuit. (Refer: Sheet S10 & S11) Open
4 Connected CT ratio should also be mentioned in the Open

CT circuit. (Refer: Sheet S10 & S11)
Shorting provision should be available in the CT
5 circuit. (Refer: Sheet S10 & S11) Open
Interlocking scheme is not clear/complete in the
6 Interlocking circuit. (Refer: Sheet A30, A31, A32 & Open
A33)
7 Interlocking logic loop circuit is not clear/complete in Open
interlocking circuit. (Refer: Sheet A32)
CT/PT trip matrix should be incorporated on SLD
8 Sheet (A15) instead of Overview Sheet (A14). Open
The CT table shows
(Refer:Sheet A14 & Three
A15) (03) metering cores. It
should be only one (01) metering core as decided in
9 meeting dated: 26-10-2017. (Refer:Sheet Closed
A14 & A15)+B49+B74
Panel Dimensions are not shown. Please Incorporate.
10 (Refer:Sheet A16 & A17) Closed
Panel Color is not shown. Kindly confirm that the

11 Panel appearance and size is same as existing Line Closed
Bay LCC Panel. (Refer:Sheet A16 & A17)
Local – Remote Selector switch should be Key
12 Closed
Operated. (Refer:Sheet A16 & A17)
AC 220V supply connection is not correct, as terminal
13 10 & 11 are shorted with terminal 9, kindly justify. Open
14 LED connection of H9 on terminal X3: 9 has shown Open
shorted. (Refer: Sheet R30)
Mention details for terminal block (-125A), (-125B)
15 and (-125C). (Refer: Sheet S11 & S12) Open
Mention terminals of PT automate in the PT circuit
16 (T5_VT_BOX). (Refer: Sheet S22) Open
Component details including ratings (voltage,
17 current, wattage to be mentioned in List of Open
All potential free alarms available on the LCC panel
Apparatus)
18 should be displayed on Control Panel Annunciator as Open
well as Scada HMI
19Sheet# A13/A14. Legends must be clarified. Open
Sheet# A14/A15. Interlocking Logic scheme of E18Q0
20 is incorrect, test, service logic should be segregated Open
and interlock logic table must be corrected.
Sheet# A15/A16. Ratings of each equipment to be
21 given on E18 bay of SLD. Open
22 Sheet# A15/A16. Designation of current Transformer Open

is wrong.
Sheet# A16/A17. Interlocking bypass switch is not
23 included in logic table of all devices, however in DC Open
control A17/A18.
Sheet# wiring it isFunction
used. description of S11 and S12
24 switch for each contact is missing in drawing. Open
References
Looping should
should be be reflected.
done via terminal block instead of
25 inter-MCBs and contactor’ looping. Open
Sheet# D10/D20. There should be interlocking
26 between existing DC and F301 and F302. Open
cross references (Drawing, Sheet, Row, Column,
27 Terminal block and terminal numbers) to be given in Open
Current
details. rating of each and every MCBs to be given on
28 drawing and at least 2 C/O contacts has to be given Open
with
Sheet#each MCB. Separate MCB to be given to Heater
G10/L10,
29 circuit. Open
30 Sheet#L10/L11, another contactor to be given in Open
parallel with K0E.
31 Sheet# L11/L12, Closing coil circuit to be rechecked Open
and ensured
All remote proper
close andinterlocking.
remote open connection
32 drawing to be included and shown in circuit/ cross Open
references ((Drawing,
Sheet# P20/P21, a NC Sheet,
contactRow, Column,toTerminal
of E18Q51 be added
block
beforeand terminal numbers)
interlocking bypass circuit [switch] that
33 prevents closing even after interlocking bypass. And Open
the same for E18Q52, E18Q53 to be added in their
respective
Sheet# circuit include Q51, Q52 and Q53 contact
P20/P21,
34 in logic drawing, and update E18 Logic drawing. Open
Sheet# P21/R10, Cross references (Drawing, Sheet,
35 Row, Column, Terminal block and terminal numbers) Open
to be shown here
36 Open
C Interlocking Schematics - SG2L002970:
Folio A22/A23 : Kindly include DS-Q1 and Q2 of Bay
1 =E18 in the Close Block Diagram of ES-Q35 and Q45 Open
Folio
of BB3A22/A23 : We understand that ES Q35 should
and BB4.
2 not close if DS Q12 & DS Q10 are in Close position. Open
Similarly, ES Q45 should not close if DS Q20 & DS Q22
are in Close
Kindly informposition.
the purpose of Interlocking in wordings
3 in Folio A23/A24. Open
4Kindly confirm what is BC2 (=E10) in Folio A25/A26. Open

Sheet#A24, incorporate synchronization check
5 permissive contact (25M) in service & TCS1 & 2 with Open
OR logic for Breaker Closing operation.
Sheet#A25, incorporate DC cutoff during hand crank
6 manual operation of DS, ES and CBs spring charge. Open
Sheet#A25, E18 Line VT T5 primary (Disconnector)

7 Isolating Link position to be included with AND logic Open
for Q8 close operation.
D GIS Civil Works (KTGT) – SG2A000377:
LCC location to be revised as decided in Joint survey

1 Dated: 30-10-2017 Open
E Relay Panel (=E18) – 17P003P-EBFSR18:
1 SLD is not clear (Refer: Sheet 05) Open
2 Connected CT ratio should be mention in SLD (Refer: Open

Sheet 05)
CT/PT details (CT ratio, class, burden) should be

3 mention in CT/VT circuit (Refer: Sheet 25 & 26) Closed
4 Mention carrier receive signal in logical input circuit Closed

drawing (Refer: Sheet 31)
5 Description/contact detail of logical input is missing Closed

(Refer: Sheet 32)
Reference PLC drawing of carrier send command
6 should be incorporated in permissive signal drawing. Open
(Refer: Sheet 37)
Show reference AR close command/

7 scheme in drawing. (Refer: Sheet 37)CB close block Open
VT fail signal and VT fail status for Line

8 differential/distance Protection should be Open
incorporated in RP3 drawing.
Reference drawing of Existing CBF BI/input should be
9 incorporated in CBF initiation circuit. (Refer: Sheet Open
35)
Sheet 31: Kindly incorporate SDH Panel instead of

10 PLC Panel. Closed
Sheet 31: Auto Re-closer In/Out status to be
11 provided to F87L Relay. Closed
Trip Circuit: Breaker Failure Protection Stage-1 and

12 Stage-2 Tripping to be provided. Open
All Protection signals and alarms should be displayed

13 in HMI. Open
Tripping relay should be used instead of Auxiliary

14 Relays. Open
15Panel View : Panel Color Code to be mentioned. Open
Sheet # 5 (single line diagram) VT disconnector is

16 missing in drawing, VT disconnector has to be Open
provided along with its device number.
Sheet # 100 (General arrangement front view), VT is

17 missing on mimic of control panel. This should be Open
provided.
Specifications of control, AC, DC, CT & VT wires are

not provided. Voltage level, shielded/non shielded,
18 fire resistant and temperature coefficients are Open
required for all cables and make sure that cable
glands has a provision to be grounded.
Sheet # 5, 11kV√3 / 0.10kV√3, 0.10kV√3 is provided,

it is unacceptable to connect 11kV√3 /
19 0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3. Please provide the VT of Open
132kV√3/0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3.
Sheet # 5, short circuit values of devices are
20 mentioned as 40kA without mentioning the Open
temperature. Please confirm the temperature.
Sheet # 5, maintenance earth switch Q53 is

21 grounding line side. It has to be clarified that it is Open
grounding line side or circuit breaker side.
Sheet # 10, value of heater is not mentioned, it

22 should be reflected in drawing. Open
Sheet # 20, DC supply distribution scheme is

unacceptable because both DC sources can be mixed
23 if K14 contacts got damaged. Bi stable relay should Open
be used with set and reset mechanical interlocks.
24 Sheet # 25, CT star point may please grounded Open

through 20A link.
Sheet # 25, cross references (drawing, sheet, row,
25 column, terminal block, terminal numbers) are Open
missing at all drawings.
Sheet # 25, Bus VT neutral should be wired through

26 test plug. Open
Sheet # 31, CB open, Close (52a, 52b) both solid

27 contacts should be wired to binary input of 87L relay. Open
Sheet # 31, cross references (drawing, sheet, row,

column, terminal block, terminal numbers) of all
28 external wiring wired to binary inputs are missing, Open
this should be provided.
Sheet # 31, binary input as VT fail from VT MCB and
29 FFR relay should be provided to 87L to block the Open
function of distance (21) in case of VT fails.
Sheet # 34, 35, Value of R1, R2 and R3 should be

30 reflected on drawings. Open
Sheet # 34, 35. SF6 gas low stage-2 to CB lockout is
31 not provided. Open
Sheet # 34, 35. Save trip coil should be provided from

32 Circuit breaker stage-2 protection. CBF stage-2 has to Open
save the TC-1, 2 otherwise trip coils will damaged.
Sheet # 33, supervision of F94.1 & 94.2 operating coil

33 Open
may please be provided.
Sheet # 90, 91 &92. Function description of Binary

34 input, Binary output and test block fingers in drawing Open
should be reflected.
Sheet# 34, File Reference (=E18+RP3) separate DC
35 source for trip coil #1 and 2 to be ensured. Open
36 Open
37 Open
38 Open
39 Open
F Energy Metering Panel (KTGT) – 17P003P-EBFSO:

As per Joint Survey (Dated:30-10-2017), it was
decided that Energy Meter will be provided on
1 Closed
Control Panel (+CP30). Separate Energy Metering
panel is not required.
2 mention in CT/VT circuit (Refer: Sheet 30 & 31) Open
PT isolation link should be used for PT insulation for

3 PT supply isolation. (Refer: Sheet 30 & 31) Open
Show reference PT supply fail alarm/signal

4 connections in drawing. (Refer: Sheet 30 & 31) Open
5 Separate PT automate should be used for PT supply Open

of energy meter. (Refer: Sheet 30 & 31)
Sheet # 30, VT external wiring shown from =E01+LCC

cross references of drawing number sheet No., Row,
6 Column number and terminal numbers are missing in Open
drawings. These should be reflected.
Sheet # 30, CT External wiring cross references

(drawing number, sheet Number, Row Column,
7 terminal block and terminal numbers) and used Open
Ratios also should be reflected in drawing.
Sheet # 30, Shorting link of CT Terminal block should
8 be removed and parking for shorting screws should Open
be reflected in the drawing.
Sheet # 30, Cross references of K1, K2 and K3

contacts are parallel and wired to external panel
9 without TBs, All external wiring should be connected Open
to Terminal block.
VT LEDs IS INSTALLED BETWEEN PHASE TO PHASE

AND N/O contacts of voltage relays are installed in its
series. Three phase under voltage relays may be
10 installed with its protection (MCB) with at least 2N/C Open
Contacts and LED should be installed between PH-N
whereas, only one N/O contact is used in series
between H1x:1 and VT phase.
Sheet 30, K3 is installed on K3 Neutral i.e. K3 (A1 &

A2) both are connected with neutral. K1 should be
11 connected with Red and neutral, K2 with Yellow and Open
neutral and K3 “Blue with neutral and LED also be
connected accordingly.
Sheet # 4, Supply of Auxiliaries is provided on 230V
12 AC. This should be provided of with AC 230VAC & Open
220V DC.
Sheet # 4, Specification of Lamp and push button is

13 not provided. These should be provided. Open
Ssheet # 4, Specifications of Indicating instruments is

14 not yet provided, these should be provided. Open
Sheet # 10, Cross reference of external wiring of B1

(Thermostat, hygo specific and heaters is missing,
15 Drawing sheet #, terminal # Row & Column Open
references should be provided.
Functional description of F104 is missing in sheet #

16 10. Open
AC & DC cable should laid and terminated in separate

17 runways. Open
Functions description of Device numbers/Terminal

18 number should be mentioned on Steel/Trafo lite Open
engrave Labels.
BusBar Protection Panel Section: (Refer drawing R9-
G Bus Section-B)

1 mention in CT/VT circuit (Refer: Sheet 10) Open
Refer PLC contact detail should be incorporate. (Refer

2 sheet 12) Open
Refer Drawing # 17P003P-EBFSR00, File Ref: +R9

3 Sheet # 12. DTT communication channel fail, Send Open
and received acknowledge for PUTT and BF DTT may
please be provided.

Sheet # 11. Both open/close status of CB =E18+Q0,
4 Disconnectors =E18+Q1 & =E18+Q2DS shall be Open
provided.
5 Sheet # 12. Drawing presentation of sources/ Open
contacts for BFI, DTT Trip send and CBF stage-2
operated is not reflected.

6 Sheet # 20. Function description of test block fingers Open
in drawing should be reflected.
H Line Control Panel (=E18) – 17P003P-FBESM18:
1 Show connected ratio with under line in SLD sheet. Open

(Refer: Sheet 05)
2 CT/PT details (CT ratio, class, burden) should be Open

mention in CT/VT circuit. (Refer: Sheet 50)
Show detail of reference IFC panel in metering circuit

3 drawing (Refer: Sheet 50) Open
4 We recommend that existing Control Panel Open

Schematic for Line Feeder bay should be followed.
Panel View: Frequency and Power Factor Meter to be

5 provided. Open
6Panel View: Panel Color Code to be mentioned. Closed
7Panel View: Floor Opening Details to be provided. Open
All alarms and Equipment status should be looped to

8 Scada Interface Cabinet in order to display on HMI. Open
Panel View: Following Indication lamps to be

9 provided on the control panel: “DC Supply Fail” & Closed
“Synchronization Fail”.
10Local / Scada Selector Switch to be provided. Open
Synchronizing Manual / Auto Selector Switch to be

11 provided. Closed
12Auto Recloser In/Out Switch to be provided. Open

Two separate 220VDC sources should be provided
13 with internal change over scheme. Open
Metering Circuit: CT & VT and Core details to be

14 mentioned on the drawing. Closed
We are used ELAP Annunciator kindly follow the

15 same. Open
Iskara Energy Meter to be provided in Control Panel

16 as per existing scheme. Open
Sheet # 01 is cover sheet, whereas legend of cover

17 sheet on sheet description is missing. These all Open
should be provided.
Please ensure Drop of time delay and P/O voltages of
6Rx12 make (RMS Aux) DC supervision relay. DC
18 Supervision relay shall have 100ms drop off delay to Open
cater the dip of DC voltages.
Refer sheet #4 of 17P003P-EBFSM18, File Ref
19 =E18+CP30, Symbol of O/G should be used as 51N Open
instead of 50/51N.
Sheet #5, CT Ratio for all cover (i.e. Core-1 metering,

Core-2, 21 distance protection, Core-3 (O/C,E/F
20 50/51/50N/51N) and (87BB+50BF) Bus Bar Breaker Open
failure is not mentioned, These should be reflected in
drawings.
Sheet #5, 11kV√3 / 0.10kV√3, 0.10kV√3 is provided, it

is unacceptable to connect 11kV√3 /
21 Open
0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3. Please provide the VT of
132kV√3/0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3.
22 Sheet #5, 87 l/21 AND 50/51/50n/51N should Open

initiate BFI and Block the close.
F101, F103, F201 & F202 has only one 1 C/O these
23 Open
should be supplied with at least 2 C/O
-X2, -X3, -X4, -X5, –X10, -X9, -X17, -X101, - X102, &
24 -x103 Spring loaded Terminal blocks are required and Open
hook type lugs should be used. At least 20% Spare
TBs in each terminal block should be provided.
External references of B1:1&2, Sheet # 10 are

25 missing, these may be provided. Open
External references of B1:1&2 Sheet # 20, DC MCBs –

26 F201 & F202 all terminals 1,2,3&4 should be wired Open
through terminal blocks instead of device to device
(i.e. MCB F201:3 to F202:3 and F201:4 to F202:4
Sheet # 25 External Wires Terminal block, Drawing #,

Sheet #, Row & Column reference numbers are
27 missing, these should be provided. And all drawing Open
open and close circuit presentation should be
mentioned in sheet #30.
Sheet # 25, Auto reclose command should not be
connected after close block, close block should be
28 connected after all closing command except interlock Open
by pass.
Interlock logic table is missing (ILT), the same may
29 please be provided. Open
Single line diagram is mission (SLD), the same may

30 Open
please be provided.
Protection logic diagram (PLD) is mission, the same
31 Open
may please be provided.
32 Single line diagram of Auxiliaries system is missing, Open

the same may please be provided.
Sheet # 25. Cross references of terminal block
number, terminal numbers, drawing, sheet, row and
33 column numbers are missing of SCADA IFC panel, Open
E18+LCC, Existing BB Bay panel etc.
Sheet # 30,31 and 32, K10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 & 17
are used to remote end indication, Remote end
indications should be wired from auxiliary contacts
34 instead of K10, K17 contact and open and close Open
indications should be segregated and description
should be mentioned on sheet NO.32.
Sheet #31, Time setting of flicker circuit (K50) is

35 missing, this may please be reflected in drawing. Open
Sheet # 30,31 and 32, K10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 & 17
are used to remote end indication, Remote end
36 indications should be wired on Annunciation DC (A+, Open
A-).
Sheet # 32, Function of lamp description is not clear,
37 please mention the clear function for which it is used Open
and labels on Panel should be installed accordingly.
Sheet # 32 external cabling should be connected

38 through terminal block instead of directly from Open
contacts.
Sheet #34 external loop of +ve DC loop from
39 +E18+CP30 to =E18+LCC is not supervised and should Open
be supervised.
Sheet #34 NO Contacts of SF6 gas gauges & density

40 switches may be used instead of Normal open. Open
Sheet #34 PT primary disconnector and VT MCB

41 auxiliary contacts may please be provided to Line Open
Protection PT core MCB Trip.
Sheet #40 Terminal blocks should be used for
42 annunciators before and after contacts for Open
annunciation.
Sheet #40 external loop of +ve DC from =E18+CP30

43 to =E18+LCC and =E18+RP3 should be supervised. Open
44 Sheet #40, 42 & 43 annunciator has to work on dual Open

source through auxiliaries contacts of its supervision.
Sheet #44 cross references of drawing, sheet, row

45 Open
and column number is missing is drawing.
Sheet #50 auxiliary supply of transducers (Voltage,

46 Current and power) should be installed on SCADA DC Open
instead of control DC of panel.
Sheet # 50, VT secondary connected from X2:
10,11,12 &13 to EMP panels directly, without
47 protection MCB should be provided in series and Open
MCB terminal has to be wired through terminal
blocks at both ends.
MCB should be installed at front door of control,

48 protection and EMP panels, so that it shall be visible Open
from outside.
D GIS EXTENSION AT KTGTPS
GIS bay extension at KTGTPS(Grid Section)
Date
6-Nov-17 12-Feb-18
PEL Response KE RESPONSE
Noted. Confirmation required
We have already submitted Noted

schematics on A-3
We shall arrange local technical Noted
session for K-Electric for SEL relays
As SEL relay will be used first time in K E network

We shall arrange local technical so please arrange type test witnessing at
session for K-Electric for SEL relays manufacturer premises as per KE specs for two
persons.
There is no sheet A20, but SLD in SLD is still incomplete. Sheet No. A32/D10
sheet A32 has been updated
See sheet S10 & S11 Noted
Updated Noted
Connected CT ratio should be marked/underlined
See sheet S10 & S11
in the CT circuit.
See sheet S10 & S11 Kindlly update
Updated(SG2L002970) Noted
Updated(SG2L002971) Noted
Drawings are not revised, please submit the
Show on SLD Sheet A32 revised drawings as Rev-1 or B.
Updated Noted & Closed
Add operate instruction Please clearify

It is correct Please clearify
Updated Noted
Updated It is not clear, please justify.
Keep the same as the earlier project Kindly incorporate

Signals should be available at both Control Panel
Keep the same as the earlier project Annunciator as well as Station HMI
Updated Its not clear, please justify.
Keep the same as the earlier project Noted
Keep the same as the earlier project Noted
Keep the same as the earlier project Please incorporate
Updated Cross references are missing, kindly clearify.

Updated see SG2L002971 A30 & A31 It is not clear, please justify.
Cancel F301 & F302 in E17, see It is not clear, please justify.
SG2L002971 A30
It is correct Please justify.
It is correct Please justify.

Mention proper CT secondary reference (drawing
number, sheet number, row and column). Sheet
No. S10/S11)
Updated it is not clear
See SG1L002970 folio: A23 pls update BC2 in legend list

Please respond
Comment Complied, Please find

attached the Revised Schematic Noted
Drawings

attached the Revised Schematic please clarify 800A tap is suitable for metering of
12 MW load
Drawings

attached the Revised Schematic Noted & Closed
Drawings
Drawings
Contact detail of logical inputs are Noted & Closed
already mentioned.
PUTT is already incorporated in Line
Relay Panel RP3, while the Carrier
Send Command i.e. DTT send is part Noted
of BF Protection in Busbar Protection
panel Extension.
AR close command is available in Line

Relay Panel RP3, while CB Close Block
scheme is part of LCC Schematic
Drawings. Close block is now through Noted
lockout relays contacts while in circuit
breaker Trip Circuit Z1 trip is now
added in parallel.

Drawings
Already Incorporated in the Drawings are not revised, please submit the
modifications for BB protection Panel revised drawings as Rev-1 or B.

attached the Revised Schematic revised drawings as Rev-1 or B.
Drawings
Drawings
Breaker Failure Protection Stage-1 and Existing trip loop will be extended and revised
Stage-2 Tripping will be part of Busbar drawing of trip circuit has to be submitted.
prot panel.
Reference SCADA & Telecom BOQ item 5.2 - HMI

is required to integrate all bay control and
HMI is not in revised BoQ of K-Electric protection signals. All Control and Protection
signals shall be intergrated via IFC & RTU. No
protection free contact shall be considered.
Auxilary relays are used for the

purpose of Signals multiplication only Noted
not for Tripping . For Tripping we have
used the Trip & Lockout relays.
Drawings the color code is mentioned
on the Sheet # 3 & Sheet # 100 .
SLD on Sheet # 5 is as per Approved Isolator is provided but has to be reflected.

Single Line Diagram for this project.

Drawings
Will be furnished separately Noted

Drawings
As per Specifications Temperature should be mentioned
The Symbol is revised, The Q53 Earth Symbol is still on line side, please update.
Switch is Earhing ciruit breaker side.

attached the Revised Schematic Please mentioned in control drawings too.
Drawings
It is unacceptable, Two DC sources to be

DC Supplies are now being seprated. interlocked with each other
CT Star Point grounding is part of LCC

Schematic Drawing. Please clarify 20A Please submit the CT Calculations for further
review of your response.
link
attached the Revised Schematic noted
Drawings
Drawings
Drawings

Drawings
Comment Complied ,Line VT supply

fail signal is provided on the binary Noted
input.
R1, R2 and R3 are internal parts of Trip Though has to be reflected.

Circuit Suppervision relay.
Point Related to LCC Schematic Its relates with control scheme.
Drawings.
The point relates to Breaker Failure Drawings are not revised, please submit the
protection & will be incorporated. revised drawings
Please eleborate the requirement. References are clearly mentioned in comment.

Drawings
Cross references (Drawing, Sheet, Row, Column,
DC Supplies will be provided from Terminal block and terminal numbers) to be given
existing DC System in details.
Mention text ‘Carrier Receive-I & II’ instead of
‘PUTT Channel-I & II’. Sheet No. 31
Mention existing drawing sheet number and relay
contact details for breaker failure scheme. Sheet
No. 31
Incorporate complete PLC carrier scheme

schematic. Sheet No. 37)
Mention proper reference (drawing number, sheet

number, row and column) for Auto Reclose
function. Sheet no 37
Comment Complied, To Accumudate

the Two energy meters we have Noted & Closed
increased the panel size as
800x800x2200
Comment Complied, Please find Drawings are not revised, please submit the
attached the Revised Schematic revised drawings
Drawings
Isolator link is not used so that no one
can temper the energy meter Please provide same as existing.
readings.
Comment Complied, PT supply fail Drawings are not revised, please submit the
indication is wired up on annunciator. revised drawings
PT supply fail indication is available on

Indication Lamps . Please clarify the References are clearly mentioned.
point
Cross references now mentioned on Drawings are not revised, please submit the
the Drawings. revised drawings
Cross references now mentioned on Drawings are not revised, please submit the
the Drawings. revised drawings
In Drawings all secondary wired are reflected as
shorted, shorting links should not be reflected in
Please eleborate the requirement. drawings and parking for shorting screws has to be
provided.

Drawings
Under voltage relays are not required

as per Technical Specifications for Please Incorporate
Control protection and metering.
Drawings
Comment Complied, As Energy Drawings are not revised, please submit the
metering is now merged with Control revised drawings
Panel .
Drawings
Comment Complied, As Energy Drawings are not revised, please submit the
metering is now merged with Control revised drawings
Panel .
Drawings

Drawings
Noted. Closed
Noted. Closed
attached the Revised Schematic noted and closed
Drawings
Will be incorporated after receiving Reflected in drawings.
the The SDH panel drawings
The required signals are wired up on Response is not clear, please elobrate
the input of Line Diff relay 411L in RP3

We have followed the same schemes Sheet # 11. Both open/close status of CB =E18+Q0,
as per Existing Busbar protection Disconnectors =E18+Q1 & =E18+Q2DS shall be
panel R9 sectoion B provided.
As already mentioned on the drawing
the BFI signal is from Line Relay Panel
RP3, DTT Trip from PLC panel and CBF- Submitted seperately with submital.
Stage-2 indication is from Control
Panel.

Drawings
Drawings
Drawings
Will be incorporated after receiving

the The IFC panel drawings & will Submitted seperately with submital.
update the drawings.
Please provide the drawings of send request through a letter.

Existing control panel.
No power Factor meter is required in Mentioned in KE Specs (Pls. refer to section 3.1
Line Control Panel as per KE Technical (PID/TS/CPM/1.0) Pls incorporate numerical type
Specifications for Control , Protection Frequency and Power factor meters.
& Metering
Drawings
Will be provided after approval of Noted
schematics
There is no HMI in revised BoQ of K- Signals should be available at both Control Panel
Electric Annunciator as well as Station HMI. Futhermore
DC Supply fail indication is available

but Synchronization Fail is not
required as per Technical Noted & Closed
Specifications for Control , Protection
& Metering Clause 13.3 Alarms
MIMIC - LCC - SCADA Selector switch Pls. incorporate in relevant drawings e.g panel
is already available. view (sheet 100).
Comment Complied, Synch Check
selected or Bypass switch is now Noted & Closed
provided.
Auto Recloser In/Out Switch is Need to be provided.
available in relay panel.
Comment Complied, Please find Two separate 220VDC sources should be provided
attached the Revised Schematic with internal change over scheme.
Drawings
Drawings
Comment Complied, Please find comments is still not compiled sheet 100 shows
attached the Revised Schematic Klamsen Annunciator instead of E-Labs
Drawings Annunciator.
Iskara made Energy meters are now

part of Control panels but now there
is no requirement of DPM in this DPM shall aslo be provided as per specs.
panel. Please find attached the
Revised Schematic Drawings
Sheet # 01 is already mentioned in list Noted

of contents with its description.
Ensured. Noted
There is no O/G relay mentioned on This is mentioned as symbol, please follow
Sheet # 4
CT ratios are already mentioned on Noted

the said drawing.

Drawings

please incorporate Block the close in schemetics
attached the Revised Schematic too.
Drawings
Drawings
Standard Terminal blocks will be
provided along with Lugs at each end Noted
of cable

Drawings
There is no purpose of increasing

Terminal connections, It will cause it will provide ease in troubleshooting
more chances of errors.

Drawings
Auto Reclosure command is not
connected after close block. Close Its not clear, please justify.
block scheme is available in LCC
Schematic Drawings.
Interlock Logics are available and are Interlock logic table and diagram is required
part of LCC schematic Drawings. seperately as well.
SLD have already been submitted Noted
Protection SLD have already been Noted

submitted
Auxilary Supplies will be used from The same modification shall be incorporated with
Existing AC DC Panels modifications
Cross reference are already
mentioned on the drawings. For IFC Cross references with drawing number, sheet
panel the drawings will be update number, row and colomn to be provided.
after receiving the IFC panel drawing
K10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 & 17

Auxilary relays are energized in state
of discrepancy between Control Contact and open and close indications should be
segregated and description should be mentioned
Discrepancy Switch and Equipment on sheet NO.32.
Position. They are not for remote end
indications
Please find attached the literature of Sheet #31, Time setting of flicker circuit (K50) is
Time Relay for Time setting missing, this may please be reflected in drawing.
K10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 & 17

Auxilary relays are energized in state
of discrepancy between Control
Its not clear, please justify.
Discrepancy Switch and Equipment
Position. They are not for remote end
indications
The lamps on sheet # 32 are internal
Lamps of Control and Discrepancy Its not clear, please justify.
Switches.
There is no external cabling on Sheet # cable shall be terminated on terminal block.

32
There is no external Loop of DC Supply

From LCC to Control Panel on Sheet # Its not clear, please justify.
34
The indication is available after signal
multiplication by Aux Relay and is Its not clear, please justify.
available as NO contact in LCC
Scheme.
Noted. Please Provide

The terminal blocks are already Terminal block to be provided after annunciator
provided with external panel too.
connections to Annunciator.
There is no external Loop of DC Supply Its not clear, please justify.

From LCC to Control Panel
Not required as per KE Technical

Specifications for Control , Protection Please Provide
& Metering
Comment complied, Please find
attached the revised schematic Noted
drawings.
These transducers are used for
metering purpose and are part of Noted
Control Panel.
The PT Supply MCBs are part of LCC Noted
Schematic Drawings.
Not required as per KE Technical

Specifications for Control , Protection Please justify.
& Metering
PEL Response KE RESPONSE
Noted Noted
Complied Please clarify
Noted Noted
Noted Noted
Noted Noted
Noted Noted
Noted Noted
Noted Noted
Comment Complied, CBF initilization

circuit now also shown on Sheet No. Noted
35
attached the Revised Schematic
Drawings (Refer: Sheet 31)
Noted Noted
Comment Complied, Trip Circuit

revised as discussed in meeting on 7- Noted
3-2018. (Refer: Sheet 34,35)
Noted
Noted Noted
Noted
Complied, Please find Attached the

Revised Schematic Drawings (Refer: It should be mentioned in the list of symbols and
legends
Sheet 5)
Noted Noted
Noted Noted
Noted Noted
its 40kA @ 50° C It should be mentioned on drawing

Revised Schematic Drawings (Refer: Symbol is still on line side
Sheet 5)

Revised Schematic Drawings (Refer: Noted
Sheet 10)
Complied, Please find Attached the Is it K1 or K14? In previous drawing it is K14 and
Revised Schematic Drawings (Refer: in revised drawing it is K1. Relay should have set
Sheet 20).Along with literature of reset mechanical interlock
K14 Contactor.
Same Existing CT is provieded

Noted Noted
Noted Noted
Noted Noted
Noted Noted
Noted Noted

3-2018. (Refer: Sheet 34,35)
3-2018. SF6 Stage-2 now reflected on
drawing (Refer: Sheet 34,35)

3-2018. (Refer: Sheet 34,35)
Lockout Relays are provided, and

Supervision/Testing of Lockout Relays ambiquity in circuit
can be done from Available spare No.
NC contacts.
Noted Fuction description required

Comment Complied, We confirm that
Trip Circuit - 1 & Trip Circuit - 2 have Cross reference to be provided
Seprate DC Supplies

PLC Carrier scheme will be Part of

PLC/SDH panel Schematic Drawings.

Noted Noted
Comment incorporated, Energy
Metering is now part of Control CT/PT details still to be mentioned
Panel. (Refer: Sheet 51,52)
Comment Complied, PT Isolating Link

now Shown on SLD (Refer: Sheet 5)

Metering is now part of Control Noted
Panel. (Refer: Sheet 42)
Comment Dropped in Meeting dated

7-3-2017

Metering is now part of Control

There are no external wiring now,

The indication is wired up on
Annunciator. (Refer: Sheet 42)
Comment incorporated, As Discussed

during meeting on 7-3-2018, LED are
installed Ph-N and Relays are Wired
Ph-Ph.(Refer: Sheet 51,52)
Comment Incorporated, Refer: Sheet

51,52)

F104 was part of Energy Metering

Panel, now it is not in Control Panel ,
Hence Point Dropped.
Noted
Noted
Noted
Noted
As Discussed and Explained in

Meeting Dated 7-3-2018, There is no
provision, No more Binary Inputs are
available in the Existing Busbar
Protection Panel, That’s why they are
wired up on the Binary Inputs of Line
Diff Relay 411L
As Discussed and Explained in

Meeting Dated 7-3-2018, There is no
provision, No more Binary Inputs are
available in the Existing Busbar
Protection Panel, Hence it was
dropped
Comment Complied, CBF initilization
circuit now also shown on Sheet No.
36 of Relay Panel
Noted
Noted
Noted
For SCADA Metering , CT and VT

supply are provided to SCADA
Transducer and Transducer will be
Installed in Control panel, Ref :
Sheet No. 50
Noted
As Discussed and Agreed During a

Meeting on 7-3-2018, DPM will be
provided which will accumudate the
requirement of Numerical Frequency
and Power Factor meters.
Noted
Noted
Noted
Noted

Noted
Noted
Noted
Noted

As Discussed and Agreed During a

Meeting on 7-3-2018, DPM will be
provided.
Noted
Noted
Noted
Noted

Noted
Noted
Noted

Noted

Noted
Noted
AC , DC Supplies Reference are now

shown on Sheet no, 10, 20 of Both
Control and Relay Panel
As discussed in meeting Dated 7-3-

2018, They can not be segregated as
they are only for the purpose of
Flickering cct, moreover can not be
removed as we have only one
position contact of CDS.

Revised Schematic Drawings. (Ref
Sheet no . 31)
They are energized in state of

discrepancy between Control
Discrepancy Switch and Equipment
Position. They are not decoupling
relays
They are the internal Lamps of
Control and Discrepancy Switches,
they will Glow in state of
Discrepancy.
Noted

Drawings

Drawings
Comment Complied and VT supply

fail indication is provided to Line Diff
Relay Binary Input ,(Ref Sheet # 31 in
RELAY PANEL)
Comment Complied, Please Find
Attached revised Schematic Drawing
(Ref Sheet # 40)
Comment Complied, Please Find

Attached revised Schematic Drawing
(Ref Sheet # 40)
As Discussed/Explained in meeting
Dated 7-3-2018, Two DC and one AC
Annunciator is provided
Noted
Noted
Noted
As discussed in meeting Dated 7-3-

2018, As Energy Meters are now part
of control panel, so Due to Space
Constraint , it is not possible and
hence point was dropped.
GSP Commnets 26-1-18
S.no
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
GSP Commnets 26-1-18
Comments
Mention text ‘Carrier Receive-I & II’ instead of ‘PUTT Channel-I & II’. (Ref: Drawing No. 17P003P-EBFSR18, File Ref: E18 + RP3, S
Mention existing drawing sheet number and relay contact details for breaker failure scheme. (Ref: Drawing No. 17P003P-EBFSR
Incorporate complete PLC carrier scheme schematic. (Ref: Drawing No. 17P003P-EBFSR18, File Ref: E18 + RP3, Sheet No. 37)
Mention proper reference (drawing number, sheet number, row and column) for Auto Reclose function. (Ref: Drawing No. 17P0
Mention proper CT secondary reference (drawing number, sheet number, row and column). (Ref: Drawing No. SG2L002972, Sh
Connected CT ratio should be marked/underlined in the CT circuit. (Ref: Drawing No. SG2L002972, Sheet No. S10/S11)
SLD is incomplete. (Ref: Drawing No. SG2L002972, Sheet No. A32/D10)
VT ratio of 11kV√3/0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3 is provided instead of 132kV√3/0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3. (Ref: Drawing No. 17P003P-EBFSM
VT ratio of 11kV√3/0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3 is provided instead of 132kV√3/0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3. (Ref: Drawing No. 17P003P-EBFSR
· Mention text ‘Carrier Receive-I & II’ instead o
· Mention existing drawing sheet number and
· Incorporate complete PLC carrier scheme sch
· Mention proper reference (drawing number,
· Mention proper CT secondary reference (dra
· Connected CT ratio should be marked/under
· SLD is incomplete. (Ref: Drawing No. SG2L00
· VT ratio of 11kV√3/0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3 is pro
· VT ratio of 11kV√3/0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3 is pro
xt ‘Carrier Receive-I & II’ instead of ‘PUTT Channel-I & II’. (Ref: Drawing No. 17P003P-EBFSR18, File Ref: E18 + RP3, Sheet No. 31)
xisting drawing sheet number and relay contact details for breaker failure scheme. (Ref: Drawing No. 17P003P-EBFSR18, File Ref: E18 + RP3
e complete PLC carrier scheme schematic. (Ref: Drawing No. 17P003P-EBFSR18, File Ref: E18 + RP3, Sheet No. 37)
roper reference (drawing number, sheet number, row and column) for Auto Reclose function. (Ref: Drawing No. 17P003P-EBFSR18, File Re
roper CT secondary reference (drawing number, sheet number, row and column). (Ref: Drawing No. SG2L002972, Sheet No. S10/S11)
CT ratio should be marked/underlined in the CT circuit. (Ref: Drawing No. SG2L002972, Sheet No. S10/S11)
mplete. (Ref: Drawing No. SG2L002972, Sheet No. A32/D10)
11kV√3/0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3 is provided instead of 132kV√3/0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3. (Ref: Drawing No. 17P003P-EBFSM18, File Ref: E18 + CP
11kV√3/0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3 is provided instead of 132kV√3/0.10kV√3/0.10kV√3. (Ref: Drawing No. 17P003P-EBFSR18, File Ref: E18 + RP3
18 + RP3, Sheet No. 31)
03P-EBFSR18, File Ref: E18 + RP3, Sheet No. 31)
g No. 17P003P-EBFSR18, File Ref: E18 + RP3, Sheet No. 37)

02972, Sheet No. S10/S11)
03P-EBFSM18, File Ref: E18 + CP30, Sheet No. 5)

03P-EBFSR18, File Ref: E18 + RP3, Sheet No. 5)

Gis Comments On KTGT Reply Sheet Crps 26-2-18

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Gis Comments On KTGT Reply Sheet Crps 26-2-18

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

ANNUXURE ''A''

Kindly confirm that the LCC Interlocking Schematics,

2 The Quality of documents should be improved, SLDs Open

Kindly arrange witnessing of Type Tests of SEL Relays

All revised drawing and future Submittals must be

6 All Updated area in drawing should be highlighted in Open

1 SLD is not clear. (Refer: Sheet A20) Open

4 Connected CT ratio should also be mentioned in the Open

Panel Color is not shown. Kindly confirm that the

22 Sheet# A15/A16. Designation of current Transformer Open

4Kindly confirm what is BC2 (=E10) in Folio A25/A26. Open

Sheet#A25, E18 Line VT T5 primary (Disconnector)

LCC location to be revised as decided in Joint survey

E Relay Panel (=E18) – 17P003P-EBFSR18:

1 SLD is not clear (Refer: Sheet 05) Open

2 Connected CT ratio should be mention in SLD (Refer: Open

CT/PT details (CT ratio, class, burden) should be

4 Mention carrier receive signal in logical input circuit Closed

5 Description/contact detail of logical input is missing Closed

Show reference AR close command/

VT fail signal and VT fail status for Line

Sheet 31: Kindly incorporate SDH Panel instead of

Trip Circuit: Breaker Failure Protection Stage-1 and

All Protection signals and alarms should be displayed

Tripping relay should be used instead of Auxiliary

Sheet # 5 (single line diagram) VT disconnector is

Sheet # 100 (General arrangement front view), VT is

Specifications of control, AC, DC, CT & VT wires are

Sheet # 5, 11kV√3 / 0.10kV√3, 0.10kV√3 is provided,

Sheet # 5, maintenance earth switch Q53 is

Sheet # 10, value of heater is not mentioned, it

Sheet # 20, DC supply distribution scheme is

24 Sheet # 25, CT star point may please grounded Open

Sheet # 25, Bus VT neutral should be wired through

Sheet # 31, CB open, Close (52a, 52b) both solid

Sheet # 31, cross references (drawing, sheet, row,

Sheet # 34, 35, Value of R1, R2 and R3 should be

Sheet # 34, 35. Save trip coil should be provided from

Sheet # 33, supervision of F94.1 & 94.2 operating coil

Sheet # 90, 91 &92. Function description of Binary

F Energy Metering Panel (KTGT) – 17P003P-EBFSO:

PT isolation link should be used for PT insulation for

Show reference PT supply fail alarm/signal

5 Separate PT automate should be used for PT supply Open

Sheet # 30, VT external wiring shown from =E01+LCC

Sheet # 30, CT External wiring cross references

Sheet # 30, Cross references of K1, K2 and K3

VT LEDs IS INSTALLED BETWEEN PHASE TO PHASE

Sheet 30, K3 is installed on K3 Neutral i.e. K3 (A1 &

Sheet # 4, Specification of Lamp and push button is

Ssheet # 4, Specifications of Indicating instruments is

Sheet # 10, Cross reference of external wiring of B1

Functional description of F104 is missing in sheet #

AC & DC cable should laid and terminated in separate

Functions description of Device numbers/Terminal

CT/PT details (CT ratio, class, burden) should be

Refer PLC contact detail should be incorporate. (Refer

Refer Drawing # 17P003P-EBFSR00, File Ref: +R9

Refer Drawing # 17P003P-EBFSR00, File Ref: +R9

Refer Drawing # 17P003P-EBFSR00, File Ref: +R9

1 Show connected ratio with under line in SLD sheet. Open

2 CT/PT details (CT ratio, class, burden) should be Open

Show detail of reference IFC panel in metering circuit