You are on page 1of 9

Traumatic Asphyxia-Reappraised

JAMES S. WILLIAMS, M.D., STANLEY L. MINKEN, M.D.


JAMES T. ADAMS, M.D.
From the Department of Surgery, University of Rochester Medical Center,
260 Crittenden Boulevard, Rochester, New York 14620

OLLIVIER,14 in 1837, found at autopsy of of the compressed chest into the valveless
persons who had been trampled by crowds veins of the head and neck producing venu-
in Paris, craniocervical cyanosis, subcon- lar and capillary atony and stasis cyanosis.
junctival hemorrhage, and cerebral vascu- The second was that contusion of abdomi-
lar engorgement. He applied the term nal sympathetic nerves produced reflex
masque ecchymotic. Similar reports subse- vasodilatation in head and neck vessels.
quently appeared in the French and Ger- Support for this was offered by Beach and
man literature," 12, 16, 24 but without expla- Cobb 2 who demonstrated small vessel en-
nation. In 1900, Perthes 16 observed mental gorgement by skin biopsy. Bolt 3 felt that
dullness, hyperpyrexia, hemoptysis, tachyp- four factors were involved in the genesis of
nea, and contusion pneumonia, and, since traumatic asphyxia: 1) deep inspiration; 2)
then, petechial hemorrhages of the mucus closure of the glottis; 3) thoraco-abdominal
membranes, epistaxis, hematemesis, rectal effort (splinting of thoracic and abdominal
bleeding, hematoma of the esophagus, albu- musculature); and 4) thoracic or abdomi-
minuria, microscopic hematuria, paraplegia, nal compression which forces blood into
peripheral nerve damage, amnesia, and con- the cervico-facial region producing venular
vulsions have been described in what is now and capillary stasis.
known as traumatic asphyxia.7-11'17, 23, 26 Alexander 1 observed that the clinical
The first explanation for the develop- signs of traumatic asphyxia developed in
ment of the syndrome was offered by Tar- patients following an epileptic seizure. In
dieu 25 in 1866, when he stated "the puncti- 1946, Dwek5 reviewed 170 cases and re-
form ecchymosis of the face, neck, and emphasized that the syndrome could be
chest are caused by the effort in which re- produced by vomiting, deep sea diving,
sistance to suffocation manifested itself." and whooping cough and did occur with-
Lejars 13 and later Ryerson 21 in 1907, re- out chest compression.
affirmed Tardieu's contention that the pa- Fred and Chandler 6 reviewed 178 cases
tient plays an active role in the develop- from the literature and reported a case of
ment of the syndrome by his panic strug- traumatic asphyxia in 1960. Since then,
gling. They felt that the victim made a Quigley18 reported two cases and Sham-
"forcible thoraco-abdominal effort" leading blin and McGoon 22 added five more. This
to a marked increase in the craniocervical brings the total number of reported cases
intravascular pressure. to 186.
Hueter 12 postulated two mechanisms for Recent experiments to define the basic
the development of the bluish discoloration pathophysiology of traumatic asphyxia have
localized to the craniocervical area. The been inconclusive. Reichert and Martin 19
first was a mechanical reflux of blood out produced acute thoracic compression by
dropping weights on the chest of experi-
Submitted for publication September 11, 1967. mental animals. Two to five minutes of
384
Volume 167
Number 3
TRAUMATIC ASPHYXIA-REAPPRAISAL 385
TABLE 1. Summary of Fatal Cases
Nature of Injury Physical Findings Pathological Findings
Warn- Conjunc-
Case Age* History ing Death Mask tiva Chest Abdomen Brain

A826 40 Chest crushed when + Immediate + Hemor- Congested Congested Negative


bulldozer rolled rhage lungs liver and
over spleen
A262 50 Chest and abdomen + Immediate + Hemor- Congested Congested Negative
crushed when car rhage lungs and lacer-
slipped from jack ated
spleen
A126 36 Chest crushed when + Immediate + None Acute con- Congested Multiple
car slipped off gestion spleen petechiae
jack of'lungs; and in-
vessels testine
engorged;
medias-
tinal
petechiae
A217 28 Chest and abdomen + Immediate + None Acute con- None None
compressed in an gestion;
underground medias-
cave in tinal
petechiae
AIOO 39 Chest crushed when + Immediate + Hemor- Acute con- None Meninges
tractor he was rhage gestion had
driving fell over of lungs petechiae
on him

Al 16 64 Chest crushed by + 13 hours - Hemor- Acute con- Congested Multiple


2,000 pounds rhage gestion; spleen petechiae
sheet metal; multiple and in-
pinned face down medias- testine
tinal
petechiae
A338 31 Head on collision - Immediate - Hemor- Ruptured None None
after falling rhage aorta
asleep; chest
crushed between
seat and engine
A765 58 Chest and abdomen - Immediate - None Acute con- Lacerated None
compressed when gestion liver and
hit by steel girder of lungs spleen
from rear while
on scaffold

* All were male patients.

such compression produced venous stasis result of venous obstruction alone or were
and capillary dilatation. In other experi- due to tissue anoxia.
ments, the superior vena cava was ob- The pathogenesis of the traumatic as-
structed by direct clamping for 10 minutes. phyxia syndrome remains obscure. It ap-
Again, venous stasis and capillary dilata- pears related to a voluntary or involuntary
tion occurred. They were unable to con- abdominal muscular contraction against a
clude that stasis and dilatation were the closed glottis after deep inspiration.
386 WILLIAMS, MINKEN AND ADAMS Annals of Surgery
March 1968
of cyanosis and petechiae, clinical signs
and symptoms in surviving patients, and
autopsy findings in fatal cases.
Case Reports
Surviving Patients
Case 1. A five-year-old boy was hospitalized
after falling from a moving tractor. An automobile
trailing the tractor squeezed his chest and upper
abdomen against a rear tire for several minutes.
750 mm When first seen, he was irritable and responded
poorly to command. Generalized facial edema,
multiple fascial, cervical, and shoulder petechiae,
and subconjunctival hemorrhage were present.
The abdomen was firm and tender to palpation.
Abdominal paracentesis aspirated free blood. Uri-
nalysis showed two plus albumin and three to
five red blood cells per high powered field.
A lacerated liver was found at laparotomy
and treated by segmental resection. Irritability
continued for 12 hours postoperatively but cere-
bration became normal 24 hours after the injury.
Cervico-facial cyanosis cleared in 3 days and re-
FIG. 1. Experimental preparation. Cuffed endo- covery was complete.
tracheal tube allows control of airway. Hemo-
dynamic parameters measured include carotid ar- Case 2. A 15-year-old girl slipped off the tail-
tery and jugular vein flow, brachial and femoral gate of a slowly moving jeep as it tipped over on
artery pressures and jugular and inferior vena a side hill pinning her chest to the ground. She
caval pressures. was incarcerated for 2 minutes, during one minute
of which she was unconscious. When seen, she
Whether increased venous pressure in the was drowsy but oriented, and her face was swollen
and cyanotic. Multiple petechiae of the face and
head and neck is related to functional neck were observed. Bilateral subconjunctival
obstruction of the superior cava or to retro- hemorrhages were present. The abdomen was un-
grade ejection of venous blood from the
thoracic cavity is unclear.
150 4 DOGS
The present study was undertaken to EXHIBITED
cZ:, REVERSED
evaluate the possibility of a pre-impact FLOW
fear response in patients who develop trau-
matic asphyxia, and to examine experi- t 100 -

mentally the role of the airway on the


hemodynamic alterations thought to occur.
K50~
Case Material
Case histories of four surviving patients
with traumatic asphyxia treated at Strong CONTROL NON OBSTCONTROL NON OBST
Memorial Hospital and eight fatal cases OBST OBST.
of thoraco-abdominal crush injuries on JUGULAR CAROTID
record at the Monroe County Medical Ex- VEIN ARTERY
aminer's Office, Rochester, New York were FiG. 2. Per cent change in mean blood flow
reviewed. Analysis included the nature of in the jugular vein and carotid artery without
and with airway obstruction and acute thoracic
the injury, pre-impact warning, presence compression.
Volume 167
Number 3
TRAUMATIC ASPHYXIA-REAPPRAISAL 387
TABLE 2. Carotid Artery and Jugular Vein Flow
Control Non-Obstructed Obstructed
Mean Range Mean Range Mean Range

Carotid artery* 160.6 90-250 145 60-268 22.3 0-50


Jugular vein* 121.5 50-193 98.4 43-176 -5.5 -22-11
* cc. per minute

remarkable, but the left humerus was fractured and right posterior hemithorax. Rales were heard
and the arm was lacerated. Neurological examina- over the right base. Urinalysis showed one plus
tion was normal, urinalysis revealed positive albu- albumin and many red blood cells. Twenty-four
min and microscopic hematuria. hours after admission the child was no longer ir-
The left arm wound was debrided under local ritable but had an elevated temperature. A right
anesthesia and a cast applied. The patient was lower lobe infiltration was found and appropriate
drowsy for several hours after admission and her therapy was instituted. Three days after admis-
pupils were unequal but reactive. Twenty-four sion there was no evidence of petechiae or cyano-
hours later her somnolescence cleared and the sis. The child was discharged 7 days after admis-
pupils were normal. Facial edema and petechiae sion fully recovered.
cleared in 72 hours, but subconjunctival hemor-
rhages persisted for one week. Recovery was Fatal Cases
uneventful.
Case 3. A 41-year-old man stopped his flat-bed The case histories and findings of the
truck abruptly at a red light and a shifting load fatal cases are summarized in Table 1. All
of steel pipe jumped the barrier of the trailer were severe thoracic or thoraco-abdominal
compressing his chest between the back wall of crushing injuries.
the cab and the steering wheel. He was incar-
cerated for 10 miinutes and unconscious when Clinical Results. The postmortem cases
freed. and three of the four survivors were sub-
When first seen he was unreactive and respira- jected to prolonged compression. Two fatal
tions were labored. Pulse and blood pressure were cases had no period of preimpact warning
normal; his face and neck were "swollen and cya- and had no ecchymotic masks. Another
notic." He had multiple petechiae over both
shoulders. The chest was normal except for mul- fatal case, in which there was no warning,
tiple anterior and posterior contusions. Bilateral was pressed face down and did not have
ankle clonus and a positive Babinski on the right craniocervical cyanosis. Subconjunctival
were present. Urinalysis revealed three to five red hemorrhage was present in three surviving
blood cells per high powered field. Twenty min- patients and in five autopsy subjects. Facial
utes after admission he was aphasic and demon-
strated marked cerebral irritability requiring re- edema was seen only in survivors and
straints. Twenty-four hours after admission, apha- cleared within 12 hours. Cutaneous pe-
sia cleared but his speech was slurred. A right techiae and cyanosis were limited to the
seventh cranial nerve weakness was noted. Ba- head, neck and upper thorax and lasted up
binski reflexes could no longer be elicited. Forty- to 72 hours. Microscopic hematuria or al-
eight hours after injury the cervico-facial cyanosis buminuria were present in all surviving
and petechiae had disappeared and he was read-
ing a newspaper. His facial weakness was still patients.
present when last seen 3 months after the accident. Varying degrees of cerebral dysfunction
Case 4. A 19-month-old boy ran into the front were noted in the surviving cases, however,
of a moving automobile. When admitted, he was these symptoms cleared in 48 hours.
sleepy but could be aroused. His face was swollen, Associated injuries in surviving patients
cyanotic and multiple petechiae were seen. La- were treated and did not influence the
bored grunting respirations were 50/minute.
There were subconjunctival hemorrhages on the course of traumatic asphyxia or eventual
left and a large abrasion over the right shoulder recovery.
388 WN'ILLIAMS, MIIN KEN AN-D ADAMS Annals of Surgery
March 196S
Postmicortemn examination of the tlhoracic chleal tube. Continuots direct arterial blood
x ities shoxwed acute pulinonarx colnges- presstres xwrc recordled 1)N- idxw ellir
tioIi in seven cases anId the abdomllinal x is- polycthylncue cannulae in the bracliial anid
cera shoxved varxying degrees of acuite coIn- fem)oral.arteries. Similarly, venous pres-
gestioin throughoutt. N europathologic find- suires xere recorded bx cainnulation of a
ings were limited to the brain. In one case branclh of the external jugular vein and the
there 'were diffuse intracerebral petechial iniferior vena. cava via the femoral vein.
lhemorrlhages aind meninigeal congestioni Blood flox7 was measured by noncannilulat-
wvas seen in another. The cause of death ing, electromagnetic square wave floxv
xw as listed as acute pulmonary congestion probes placed oIn the opposite external
in six case instances, trainsected thoracic juguilar vein and common carotid artery.
aorta in one. aindI lacerated brain stem in A pneumiiiatic tourrniquet wvas placed arouilnd
one. the tlhorax to produce acute thoracic com-
pressioni. To simulate the pre-impact fear
Experimental Study response, a girdle wvas w\rapped around the
Methods. Twenty-three experiments wvere abdcomen to produce muscular splinting
performed under sodium pentothal anes- (Fig. 1). All pressures were recorded
thesia on seven fasted adult moingrel dogs throuiglh transducers oIn a Sanborn direct
weighing betw-eeni 15 and 25 Kg. The air- writing poly-graph. Flow data was similarlyr
wav was controlled by a cuffed endotra- measurecl.
After a control period, two series of ex-
periimenits w7ere carried out on each dog.
886 690 The toutrniquet x\ as inflated to 750 mim.
Jig for 30 secoinds durinig each acute phase.
The first series inclu(ded two experiments
in wlhiclh carotid aind jugular blood flowx
wx as m onitored xx ithout airway obstruiction.
In the second series, these flows were re-
c_z corde(d after the lungs xxcre fully inflated
Kz)
1b anI Amnbu bag anid the airx\-ay occluded
K2 utist priior to compression. Continuous pres-
K~ sure recorclings x7ere obtained througlhout
all acute and recovery periods wxith record-
K)3 inlgs made at 30 second intervals for 2 min-
utes and then at 5 minute intervals until
control levels xere regained.
Experimental Results. Acute thoracic
coiimpressioii produced a uiniform series of
clhanlges in the airxvay obstructed and non-
airxva- obstructed groups. Alterations in
jugular venous and carotid arterial blood
CONTROL NON OBST CONTROL flow in both groups are shoxvn in Table 2.
OBST. OBST Clhaniges in arterial and venous pressures
JUGULAR INFERIOR ar-e seen in Table 3. The mean jugular ve-
VEI N VENA CAVA nous floxy xvas 81 of control value xwith
Fl(;. 3. Per cent chainge in mean venous pres- a p)atenit airxx7av, xvhile xvith obstruction
sure in the jugular vein and inferior vena cava flox fell to 6% of normal anid in fotur dogs
without and with airwxay obstruction and acute
thoracic compression. xvas actually reversed to a mean rexversed
lr E--
Volunme 167
Number 3
TRAUMATIC ASPHYXIA-REAPPRAISAL 389
flow of 13.6 cc. per minute (Fig. 2). Caro- 150-
tid flow was 90%o of control value without K_

airway obstruction and 14%o of control 112


flow when the airway was obstructed 106
(Z o00o--
(Fig. 2).
Animals with airway obstruction showed
an average increase in jugular pressure of 50
886%o of control value during the acute 50-
compressive period (Fig. 3). In one ani-
mal, an increase of 1,500% occurred. The
nonobstructed group showed an increase
to only 145%o of control. Inferior vena caval CONTROL NON OBST. CONTROL NON OBST.
OBST. OBST.
pressures showed a similar trend, increas-
ing 690%o of control in the airway ob- FE MORAL BRACHIAL
ARTERY ARTERY
structed group and 300% in the non-
obstructed group (Fig. 3). FIG. 4. Per cent change in mean arterial pres-
sure in the femoral and brachial arteries without
Mean brachial artery pressures in- and with airway obstruction and acute thoracic
compression.
creased 6%o over control during compres-
sion in the nonobstructed group but de-
creased to 50.3%o with airway occlusion warning was violently pressed face down
(Fig. 4). Similarly, femoral artery pres- in the ground and had neither a mask nor
sures increased 12% over the control val- subconjunctival hemorrhage, the face and
ues in the open airway group and de- chest were subjected to a high counter-
creased to 52%o with obstruction. pressure which prevented venular conges-
A representative pressure and flow trac- tion and petechial hemorrhage.20
ing in a dog with airway obstruction is The increase in intrathoracic pressure
shown in Fig. 5. associated with a closed glottis and its
Although petechial hemorrhages were pathophysiologic effect is dependent upon
not seen in the skin or mucous membranes the force of thoracic or thoraco-abdominal
of any animals, conjunctival injection did compression and its duration. The exact
occur. force of compression was 2,000 pounds in
Discussion one fatal case. Forces up to 16,000 pounds
have been previously reported.15 The one
The results of the clinical study indicate surviving patient who was compressed for
that development of traumatic asphyxia is 10 minutes showed early severe neurologi-
associated with a fear response in the acci- cal derangement, but only a mild seventh
dent victim just prior to injury. In this nerve weakness remains. In all but one of
"moment of impending disaster," the indi- the fatal cases, compression was prolonged.
vidual reflexly takes a deep breath, holds A great force, applied instantaneously, is
it, and braces himself. All the surviving
patients in this series and six fatal cases,
likely to produce pulmonary contusion in
by the nature of the accidents, had warn- addition to facial cyanosis, as in the five-
ing of impending injury. On the other year-old boy who was struck by an auto-
hand, in two fatal instances, one fell asleep mobile. If the compression is prolonged
at the wheel and the other was struck from death may result from suffocation. It is dif-
behind, neither had warning and did not ficult to say whether or not the pulmonary
develop the characteristic craniocervical congestion seen in the fatal cases was re-
cyanosis. One fatal case who did have lated to the force of compression or was
WILLIAMS, MINKEN AND ADAMS Annals of Surgery
390 March 1968
TABLE 3. Arterial and Venous Pressure

Control NonObstructed Obstructed


Vessel Mean Range Mean Range Mean Range
Brachial artery* 141 125-155 150 120-175 71 35-100
Femoral artery* 124 120-150 150 115-175 70 35-100
Jugular vein** 4.0 2-5 5.1 3-10 35.4 17-60
Inferior vena cava** 5.5 4-10 16.4 3-38 37.9 17-70
* mm. Hg.

** mm. H20.

secondary to acute heart failure prior to inflow should be initially unimpaired. Our
death. experiments in which the airway was
Since air cannot escape from the thoracic not obstructed during chest compression,
cavity during compression in the face of a showed carotid artery flow only slightly
closed glottis, the increased pressure is reduced and arterial pressure actually in-
transmitted centrally to mediastinal veins, creased in some animals. However, with
superior and inferior vena cavae, and right airway obstruction and compression, caro-
atrium. The blood in these structures is tid artery inflow was drastically reduced
squeezed from the chest into the valveless and arterial pressure dropped markedly.
vein of the head, neck, and abdomen. The Furthermore, the fact that jugular flow
cephalad regurgitation of venous blood was reversed in four animals with airway
was sufficient in nine of twelve cases to obstruction during compression is addi-
produce characteristic facial discoloration, tional evidence that mechanical venous ob-
subconjunctival hemorrhage and, in sur- struction does not occur in traumatic
vivors, cerebral dysfunction. In addition, asphyxia.
one fatal case demonstrated meningeal The experimental evidence supports the
vascular congestion and another diffuse clinical hypothesis that airway obstruction
petechial brain hemorrhage. after deep inspiration and just prior to
The effects of increased venous pressure compression produces a marked and rapid
and reversed flow are transmitted to the rise in jugular pressure and a reversal of
intra-peritoneal viscera as well. Evidence venous flow. Chest compression alone has
in survivors of transient hematuria, albu- little influence.
minuria, or both, and in the fatal cases of Increased intrathoracic pressure produces
varying degrees of organ congestion may a rise in intra-abdominal venous pressure
be explained on the basis of this pressure as well. Elevation of caval pressure in un-
increase. The augmented intra-abdominal obstructed animals is most likely related
venous pressure may be of sufficient mag- to impingement on the inferior vena cava
nitude to produce gastrointestinal bleed- by the overlying liver or diaphragm at the
ing.8, 14
time of chest compression. In the airway
Previous investigators have shown that obstructed animals, however, venous pres-
obstruction of the vena cava above the sure rose considerably above control values
azygos vein for 10 minutes will produce in the face of falling arterial pressure.
marked venous congestion and petechial Although no petechiae developed in mu-
hemorrhage.19 If the rise in jugular pres- cous membranes or skin of experimental
sure is related to functional obstruction of animals, vascular engorgement did occur.
the superior vena cava alone, then arterial Since the total pressure exacted on the
Volume 167 TRAUMATIC ASPHYXIA-REAPPRAISAL
Number 3 391
dogs' thorax was 1,200 pounds (14 pounds
per square inch), sufficient to produce
clinical traumatic asphyxia, it appears that
either the canine capillary is more resistant
to increased pressure or that the animals
coat offers some degree of counterpressure.

Summary
A clinical and experimental appraisal
of traumatic asphyxia has been presented.
Four surviving patients with traumatic
asphyxia and the records of eight fatal
cases of blunt thoraco-abdominal trauma
were analyzed. All patients who developed
the craniocervical cyanosis characteristic of
the syndrome had accidents in which there
was warning of impending trauma. Sur-
viving patients had varying degrees of
transient cerebral dysfunction and hema-
turia or albuminuria. The ecchymotic rash
in these patients cleared within 5 days.
Fatal cases showed varying degrees of pul-
monary and intra-abdominal congestion at
autopsy. One had diffuse intra-cortical pe-
techial hemorrhages and another acute
meningeal congestion.
FIG. 5. Representative pressure and flow trac-
In experiments on dogs acute thoracic ings. With acute chest compression and airway
compression was produced with a pneu- obstruction, brachial artery pressure fell from a
control level of 150 mm. Hg to 35 mm. Hg.
matic tourniquet placed around the chest Upon release of the airway obstruction and with
and inflated to 750 mm. Hg. Airways were continued chest compression, the brachial pressure
rebounded to 200 mm. Hg. A similar pattern was
controlled with cuffed endotracheal tubes seen in the femoral arterial pressure. Jugular ve-
and hemodynamic alterations were re- nous peressure increased rapidly from a control
value of 5 mm. Hg to 35 mm. Hg (600% in-
corded. With chest compression for 30 sec- crease) with compression and airway obstruction
onds and airway obstruction in full inspira- and then fell rapidly to slightly below the control
level when the airway obstruction was relieved.
tion, jugular and inferior vena caval pres- Jugular flow, with the airway obstructed and the
sure was markedly increased above normal chest acutely compressed, decreased from a con-
trol value of 110 ml./minute to a reversed flowv
and jugular flow was rapidly diminished of 17 ml./minute and then rebounded to 400
or actually reversed. Carotid artery flow ml./minute with release of the airway obstruction
while maintaining chest compression.
and brachial and femoral artery pressures
also decreased significantly. When the air- vidual performs a Valsalva maneuver,
way was unobstructed during chest com- which if prolonged, as with a seizure, vom-
pression, pressures and flows were only iting, or accompanied by thoraco-abdomi-
slightly different from controls. nal compression, results in a marked eleva-
On the basis of this clinical and labora- tion of venous pressure and reversal of
tory study, it is evident that airway occlu- venous flow with capillary stasis or rupture
sion plays an integral role in the patho- producing the typical ecchymotic rash that
physiology of traumatic asphyxia. The indi- characterizes the syndrome.
392 WILLIAMS, MINKENWILLIAMS,
AND ADAMS Annals of Surgery
~~~~~~~~~~~~March
1968
References 14. Ollivier, d-A.: Relation medicale des evene-
ments survenus au Champ-de-Mars le 14
1. Alexander, E. G.: A Case of Stasis Cyanosis juin, 1837. Ann. d'hyg., 18:485, 1837.
Following an Epileptic Seizure, Stimulating 15. Parker, F. I.: Optic Atrophy from Traumatic
Traumatic Asphyxia. Ann. Surg., 49:762, Asphyxia with a Report of a Case. Arch.
1909. Ophth., 40:159, 1911.
2. Beach, H. H. A. and Cobb, F.: Traumatic 16. Perthes, G.: Ueber "Druckstauung." Deutsche
Asphyxia. Ann. Surg., 39:481, 1904. Ztschr. f. Chir., LV, 384, 1900.
3. Bolt, R. A.: Traumatic Asphyxia, Report of a 17. Pierce, F. E.: Traumatic Asphyxia with Re-
Case. Cleveland Med. J., 7:647, 1908. port of Two Cases. Quart. Bull. Northwest-
4. Braun, H.: Extravasation sanguine etendue a ern Un. Med. School, 12:39, 1910.
la tete, au cou at au bras gauche, consecu- 18. Quigley, W. F.: Acute Superior Vena Caval
tive a une compression del l'abdomen. Se- Compression. Hawaii Med. J., 20:337, 1961.
maine med., 383, 1899; Deutsch Ztschr. f. 19. Reichert, F. L. and Martin, J. W.: Traumatic
Chir., li:599, 1899. Asphyxia; Experimental and Clinical Ob-
5. Dwek, J.: Ecchymotic Mask. J. Int. Coll. servations with a Report of a Case with
Surg., 9:257, 1946. Concomitant Paralegia. Ann. Surg., 134:361,
6. Fred, H. L. and Chandler, F. W.: Traumatic 1951.
Asphyxia. Amer. J. Med., 29:508, 1960. 20. Robertson, L. B.: Traumatic Asphyxia with
7. Gardner, E. K.: Traumatic Asphyxia. Brit. Report of Six Cases. Canadian Med. Ass.
Med. J., 2:545, 1941. J., 4:501, 1914.
8. Gordon, W. I. and Thomson, A. M. W.: Trau- 21. Ryerson, E. S.: A Case of Traumatic Asphyxia
matic Asphyxia: With Illustrating Cases. with Recovery. Canadian Prac. Rev., 32:195,
Glasgow Med. J., 130:180, 1938. 1907.
9. Green, T. M.: Traumatic Asphyxia. Surg., 22. Shamblin, J. R. and McGoon, D. C.: Acute
Gynec. Obstet., 35:129, 1922. Thoracic Compression with Traumatic As-
10. Hamilton, J. B.: Note on Traumatic Asphyxia phyxia; Report of Six Cases. Arch. Surg.,
with Ocular Complications. Brit. J. Ophth., 87:967, 1963.
14:22, 1930. 23. Stickney, J. M. and Hagedorn, A. B.: Chest
11. Heuer, G. J.: Traumatic Asphyxia; With Espe- Injuries and Traumatic Asphyxia. Proc.
cial Reference to its Ocular and Visual Dis- Mayo Clin., 19:207, 1944.
turbances. Surg. Gynec. Obstet., 36:686, 24. Tardieu, A.: Memoire sur la mort par suffo-
1923. cation. Ann. d'hyg., 4:371, 1855.
12. Hueter, C.: Ueber die Dilatation der Blutge- 25. Tardieu, A.: Relation medico-legale de l'acci-
faesse der Kopfes bei schweren Verlet- dent survenu au pont de la concorde, a
zungen des Unterleibes. Deutsche Ztschr. Paris, le 15 aout 1866, pour servir a l'his-
f. Chir., 4:382, 1874. (Case included in toire de la mort par suffocation. Ann. d'hyg.,
article with listed title.) 2:338, 1866.
13. Lejars, F.: L'infiltration ecchymotique diffuse 26. Winslow, R.: A Case of So-Called Traumatic
de la face, a la suite des compressions du Asphyxia. Med. News of N. Y., 86:207,
tronc. La Semaine Medicale, 182, 1905. 1905.

You might also like