You are on page 1of 259

RPOPERTY OF NATIONAL CONTRACTING CO. LTD.

IF MUST NOT BE USED DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY IN ANY WAY DETERMINAL TO THE INTERST OF THE COMPANY
THE INFORMATION ON THIS DOCUMENT IS THE PRPOPERTY OF NATIONAL CONTRACTING CO. LTD. IF MUST NO

CUSTOMER: KENYA ELECTRICITY


KENYA
FINANCED BY: THE WORLD BANK
IBRD-IDA

CONSULTANT: LAHMEYER INTERNA


TITLE:
400/2
20kV
ISINYA
CONTRACTOR : NATIONAL CONTRACT
SUBST
ATION TRANSMISSION & DIS
P.O.BOX-90, AL-KHOB
KINGDOM OF SAUDI A
PROJECT : EASTERN ELECTRICIT
(SUBCOMPONENT A4
CONSTRUCTION OF IS
ATHI RIVER AND NAI
CONTRACT No: KETRACO/PT/009/2

DOCUMENT 0092013-QH-7401-J-
No:

SHORT CIRCUIT FORC


REVISED AS PER CONSULTANT / BUS AT ISINYA 400/2
CUSTOMER COMMENTS DT 21 &
A 22nd MAY 2015 DURING DESIGN C.L D.G V.T 30.05.15 PREPARED C.L
REVIEW MEETING CHECKED D.G
0 FIRST SUBMISSION C.L D.G V.T 11.02.15 APPROVED V.T
DESCRIPTION PRED. CHK
D. APPD. DATE
REV. NO PASSED V.K
KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LTD.,

THE WORLD BANK

LAHMEYER INTERNATIONAL GMPH

NATIONAL CONTRACTING CO. LTD.


TRANSMISSION & DISTRIBUTION DIVISION
P.O.BOX-90, AL-KHOBAR 31952,
KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA
EASTERN ELECTRICITY HIGHWAY PROJECT
(SUBCOMPONENT A4-SYSTEM REINFORCEMENT)
CONSTRUCTION OF ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION AND
ATHI RIVER AND NAIRO SUBSTATION EXTENSIONS
KETRACO/PT/009/2013

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR 400KV FLEXIBLE


BUS AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION
DATE : 11.02.2015
TOTAL SHEETS
64 SHEETS
REVISION A
INDEX
SL.N0 S/Y SPAN DESCRIPTION

SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION - 400kV FLEXIBLE BUS

1 -- -- SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION INDEX

2 -- -- SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION SUMMARY

3 400KV SWYD S1 52.0m MAIN BUS (QUAD "805 Sq.mm"AAC)


4 400KV SWYD S2 26.0m MAIN BUS (QUAD "805 Sq.mm"AAC)
5 400KV SWYD S3 60.75m JACK BUS (QUAD "805 Sq.mm"AAC)
6 400KV SWYD S4 60.74m JACK BUS (QUAD "805 Sq.mm"AAC)

i
i
INDEX
PAGE NO.

FORCE CALCULATION - 400kV FLEXIBLE BUS

ii

1 to 16

17 to 32

33 to 48

49 to 64

i
i
400/220kV ISINYA SUBSTATION
SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION SUMMARY FOR 400kV FLEXIBLE BUS
S.No. Span Details Span Type Static Tension (kg) SCF (kg)

1 52.0m Main Bus QUAD AAC 4000 4578.8


2 26.0m Main Bus QUAD AAC 4000 4427.9
3 67.4m Jack Bus QUAD AAC 4000 4680.7
4 60.75 Jack Bus QUAD AAC 4000 4646.5

ii
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS

QUAD AAC - 52 Meters

Page 1 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Page 2 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

The following calculations are based on IEC - 865


1 BASIC PARAMETERS
a. System Voltage = 400 kV

b. Highest System Voltage V = 420 kV

c. Short Circuit Rating Ik3'' = 40.0 kA

d. System Frequency f = 50 Hz

e. Duration of Short Circuit current flow Tk1 = 1s

2 CONDUCTOR & ANCHORING DETAILS

a. Details of Main Conductor


(i) Type of conductor = AAC

(ii) Number of sub-conductor per phase n = 4 Nos.

(iii) Mass per unit length of one subconductor m's = 2.221 kg/m

(iv) Cross-section of one sub-conductor AS = 805.00 mm2

(v) Young's Modulus E = 5.5E+05 Kg./Cm2

= 5.39E+10 N/m2

(vi) Diameter of conductor = 36.90 mm

(vii) Centre-line dist. between main conductor mid-points a1 = 6500 mm

a2 = 6500 mm

(viii) Resulting spring constant of both supports of one span S = 100 N/mm

(ix) Minimum Temperature Temp min = 0 °C

(x) Maximum Temperature Temp max = 80 °C


.
(xi) Everyday Temperature Temp o = 40 °C

(xii) Material Constant Cth = 2.7E-19 m4/A2s

(xiii) Co-efficient of thermal expansion a = 2.3E-05 /°C

(xiv) No. of Aluminimum Strand Al strand = 61

(xv) No. of Steel Strand St strand = 0

Conventional value of acceleration of gravity

Page 3 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Page 4 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

b. Details of Anchoring of Main Conductor

(i) Conductor span = 52.00 m

(ii) Initial tension of conductor = 1000 kg


(Tension of conductor x gn) = 1000 × 9.81 N = 9810 N

(iii) Tension of conductor = 9810 × 4 N = 39240 N

(vi) Tension at maximum temperature at 80°C

Tension per conductor = 979.10 kg

then, Fst. Max = 38419.88 N

(v) Tension at minimum temperature at 0°C

Tension per conductor = 1000.00 kg

then, Fst. Min = 39240.00 N

vi) Girder width = 2000 mm

(vii) Length of Insulator Chain = ( 145 x 30 ) li = 5304 mm

a) Distance between centres of disc units = 145 mm

b) No of insulator discs = 30 discs

(viii) No. of Insulator String ni = 2 Nos.

(ix) Weight of Insulator String = 270 kg

(x) Diameter of disc Insulator = 0.280 m

(xi) Length of Hardware = 954 mm

(xii) Weight of Hardware = 45 kg

c. Details of Spacer
(i) Distance between sub-conductors = 450 mm

(ii) Distance between two adjacent spacers = 5000 mm

(iii) Unit Mass of Spacers = 7 kg

(iv) No. of Spacers = 7

Page 5 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
d. Details of Jumper

No. of cond. Length(m) Mass/Unit Length

(i) Jumper - 1 3 x 7 x 2.221 =

(ii) Jumper - 2 3 x 7 x 2.221 =

Page 6 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
3 Effects on Main Conductor

3.1 Characteristic dimensions and parameters


a. Characteristic electromagnetic load per unit length on flexible main conductors in three-phase systems

F' = 0  I " l c 2

 0.75  k 3 
where 2 a l
I''k3 = 3 Ph. initial symmetrical short-circuit current (r.m.s.)

= 40000 A

a = Centre-line distance between main conductor mid points


Equivalent distance is

= (a1+a2)/2

a = 6.5 m

l = Centre-line distance between supports

= 52 m
lc = Cord length of the main conductor in the span

= l – (2 × ( length of one insulator chain + half of the girder width))

= 52 - ( 2 x (5.304+1))

= 39.39 m
μ0 = Permeability of free space, 4 π x 10-7

Hence

F' = ( 2 x 10^-7) x 0.75 x ( 1600000000 / 6.5 ) x ( 39.392 / 52 ) N/m

= 27.971

b. Ratio of electromagnetic force under short-circuit conditions to the gravitational force on a conductor

r = F'
where n  m sc ' g n

n = Number of sub-conductors of a main conductor

= 4 Nos.

Total concentrated mass on conductor


Σm = nsx mS + Σmj

Page 7 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

= 7*7+(46.641+46.641)

= 142.282 kg

Resulting mass per unit length of one sub-conductor:


m'sc = Σm/(n x lc)+m's

= (142.282 / (4x39.392))+2.221

m'sc = 3.12399 kg

gn = Conventional value of acceleration of gravity

= 9.81 m/s2
Hence

r = 27.971/(4 x 3.124 x 9.81)

= 0.228

Page 8 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

c. Direction of resulting force exerted on the conductor


δ1 = arctan (r)

= ATAN(0.228) rad

= 0.22433 rad

= 0.22433 × 180/π °

= 12.853 °

d. Equivalent static conductor sag at midspan


bcmax = n  m sc ' g n  l 2
8 Fst
bcmin = n  m sc ' g n  l 2
8 Fst
where
Fstmax = Static tensile force in flexible main conductor

= 38419.884 N

Fstmin = Static tensile force in flexible main conductor

= 39240 N

Hence
bcmax = 4 x 3.124 x 9.81 x 52^2/(8 x 38419.884) m
= 1.078 m

bcmin = 4 x 3.124 x 9.81 x 52^2/(8 x 39240) m

= 1.056 m

e. Period of conductor oscillations

Tmax bc
= 2 0.8
gn
= 2 x π x √(0.8 x 1.078/9.81) s

= 1.863 s

Page 9 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Tmin = bc
2 0.8
gn

= 2 x π x √(0.8 x 1.056/9.81) s

= 1.844 s

Page 10 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
f. Resulting period of conductor oscillation during short-circuit current flow

Tres.max = T
  2  1 
2

4
1 r 2
1  

 64  0 
 90  

= 1.863/[(1 + 0.228^2)^(1/4) x {1 – π^2/64 x (12.853/90)^2}] s

= 1.846 s

T
Tres.min =  2

 2  1 
4
1 r 2
1  

 64  0 
 90  

= 1.844/[(1 + 0.228^2)^(1/4) x {1 – π^2/64 x (12.853/90)^2}] s

= 1.826 s

g. Actual Young's modulus


Es =   Fst  For Fst
E 0 .3  0.7  sin   90 0   
 
 nAs 
fin

 fin  nAs
E For F st
 fin
where nA s
δfin = Lowest value of δ when Young's modulus becomes constant

= 5E+07 N/m²
Fst.max/(n As) = 38419.884/(4 x 0.000805000) where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

= 1.19E+07 N/m2
≤ δfin

Fst.max/(n As) = 39240.000/(4 x 0.000805000) where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

= 1.22E+07 N/m2

≤ δfin

Hence,
Esmax = 5.4E+10 [0.3 + 0.7 SIN{38419.884/(4 x 0.000805000 x 5.0E+07) x 90°}] N/m²

= 3.00E+10 N/m²

Esmin = 5.4E+10 [0.3 + 0.7 SIN{39240.000/(4 x 0.000805000 x 5.0E+07) x 90°}] N/m²

Page 11 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

= 3.03E+10 N/m²

h. Stiffness norm of an installation with flexible conductors


Nmax = 1 1

where Sl nE s As
S = 100000 N/m , for strained conductors (for slack conductor = 1X10^5 i.e., l=lc)

Nmax = 1/(100000 x 52) + 1/(4 x 1.2E+07 x 0.000805000) 1/N

= 2.03E-07 1/N

Page 12 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Nmin = 1 1

Sl nE s As
Hence
Nmin = 1/(100000 x 52) + 1/(4 x 3.0E+10 x 0.000805000) 1/N

= 2.03E-07 1/N

i. Stress factor ζ of the main conductor

zmax =  ng n msc ' l  2


3
24 f st N
= (4 x 9.81 x 3.12398791632819 x 52)^2 / (24 x 38419.884^3 x 2.03E-07)

= 0.147

zmin
 ng n m sc ' l  2
= 3
24 f st N
= (4 x 9.81 x 3.12398791632819 x 52)^2 / (24 x 39240.000^3 x 2.03E-07)

= 0.138

j. Swing-out angle at the end of the short-circuit current flow


δk =   Tk 1  For 0 ≤ Tk1/Tres ≤ 0.5
 1 1  cos
  360 0 

  Tres 
2 δ1 For Tk1/Tres > 0.5

where
Tk1 = Duration of first short-circuit current flow

= 1.000 s

Tk1/Tres max = 1.000/1.846


= 0.542 > 0.5

Hence
δkmax = 2 x 12.853

= 25.707 °

Tk1/Tres min = 1.000/1.826


= 0.548 > 0.5

Page 13 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
Hence

δkmin = 2 x 12.853

= 25.707 °

k. Quantity for maximum swing-out angle

χ = 1 – r sinδk For 0 ≤ δk ≤ 90°

1–r For δk > 90°

δkmax = 25.7066 °£ 90°

Hence
χmax = 1 – 0.228 · SIN(25.707)

= 0.901

Page 14 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
δkmin = 25.7066 °£ 90°

Hence
χmin = 1 – arctan (r) · SIN(25.707)

= 0.901

l. Maximum swing-out angle


δm = 1.25 arccosχ For 0.766 ≤ χ ≤ 1 (i)

10° + arccosχ For – 0.985 ≤ χ ≤ 0.766 (ii)

180° For χ < – 0.985 (iii)


χmax = 0.9010269983 then Condition (i)

Hence

δm.max = 32.133 °

χmin = 0.9010269983 then Condition (i)

Hence

δm.min = 32.133 °

3.2 Tensile force during short-circuit caused by swing out (short-circuit tensile force)
a. Load parameter φ
φ =

3 1 r 2 1  For Tk 1 
Tres
4
3(rsinδk + cosδk – 1) For T  Tres
k1
4
Tk1 = 1s

Tres.max = 0.46141
4
Tres.min = 0.45656
4

Tk1 is greater than Tres.min


4

Page 15 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
Hence

φmax = 3{√(1 + 0.22817^2) – 1}

= 0.077
Hence

φmin = 3{√(1 + 0.22817^2) – 1}

= 0.077

Page 16 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

b. Load parameter Ψ
The factor Ψ is a function of ζ and φ – it can be calculated as a real solution of the equation:

ϕ2Ψ3 + ϕ(2 + ζ)Ψ2 + (1 + 2ζ)Ψ – ζ(2 + ϕ) = 0


For maximum
Solving the above equation for Ψ (0 ≤ Ψ ≤ 1)
Ψmax = 0.2295
Substituting the value of Ψmax in the above equation,

= 0.077^2×0.230^3+0.077(2+0.147)×0.230^2+(1+2×0.147)×0.230–0.147×(2+0.077)

= 0.000

For minimum
Solving the above equation for Ψ (0 ≤ Ψ ≤ 1)

Ψmin = 0.2190

Substituting the value of Ψmin in the above equation,

= 0.077^2×0.219^3+0.077(2+0.138)×0.219^2+(1+2×0.138)×0.219–0.138×(2+0.077)

= 0.000

c. Tensile force Ft during short circuit caused by swing out (short-circuit tensile force)

Ft = Fst(1 + φΨ) For n = 1, single conductor


1.1 Fst(1 + φΨ) For n ≥ 2, bundled conductor
n = 4 Nos.
Hence
Ftmax = 1.1 x 38419.884 (1 + 0.077 x 0.230) N
Ftmax = 43009.707 N

4384.272 kg

Ftmin = 1.1 x 39240.000 (1 + 0.077 x 0.219) N

Ftmin = 43892.853 N

Page 17 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
4474.297 kg

Page 18 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

3.3 Tensile force Ff after short circuit caused by drop (drop force)
This is significant for r > 0.6 if δm ≥ 70°

r = 0.22817 (not applicable)


δm,max = 32.133260421 °

δm,min = 32.133260421 °

Ff,max = m
1.2 Fst 1  8z
180 0
Ff.max = 1.2 × 38419.884 x √(1 + 8 × 0.147 x 32.13/180°)
Ff.,max = 50722.219 N

= 5170.461 kg

Ff,min = 1.2 F m
st 1  8z
180 0

Ff,min = 1.2 × 39240.000 x √(1 + 8 × 0.138 x 32.13/180°)

Ff,min = 51529.784 N

= 5252.781 kg

3.4 Maximum Horizontal span displacement (bh) and minimum air clearance(amin)
a. Elastic expansion (εela)

εela = Nmax (Ft.max – Fst.max)

= 2.03E-7 *(43010 - 38419.884)

= 9.30E-04
b. Thermal Expansion (εth)
Material constant (Cth ) is 0.27*10-18 m4/A2s for Cross section area of Aluminium/Steel > 6

0.17*10-18 m4/A2s for Cross section area of Aluminium/Steel < 6

0.088*10-18 m4/A2s for Cross section area of Copper

Cth = 2.70E-19 m4/A2s

2
 I "
c th  k 3  Tres / 4
 nAs 
Page 19 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
2
 I k 3 "
Thermal Expansion ε th
= c th   Tres / 4 for Tk1 ≥ Tres/4
 nAs 
2
I 
c th  k 3"  Tk 1 for Tk1 < Tres/4
 nA s 

= 0.27E-18*(40000/(4*0.0008050))²*1.85/4

εth = 1.92E-05

Page 20 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

c. Dilation Factor (CD) 2


3 l 
CD = 1     els   th 
8  bc 

= √(1+3/8*(52/1.08)²*(9.30E-04+1.92E-05))
CD = 1.35

d. Form factor (CF)


CF = 1.05 for r < 0.8
0.97+0.1r for 0.8 < r < 1.8
1.15 for r > 1.8

= 1.05

CF = 1.05000

e. Maximum Horizontal span displacement ( bh)

For slack conductors bh = CF CD bc for δm > 90o


CF CD bc sin δm for δm < 90o

For strained Conductors bh = CF CD bc sin δb1 h for δm > δ1


CF CD bc sin δm for δm < δ1

= 1.05*1.35*1.0784(sin(12.85))
bh = 0.34 m

f. Minimum air clearance (amin)

amin = a - 2bh

= 6.5- 2*0.34
amin = 5.82 m

4 Tensile Force Fpi caused by pinch effect


4.1 Characteristic dimensions and parameters
a. Sub-conductors are considered to clash effectively if either one of following equations are fulfilled
as/ds ≤ 2 and ls ≥ 50 as
as/ds ≤ 2.5 and ls ≥ 70 as
where
as = Distance between sub-conductors

= 0.450 m

Page 21 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
ls = Distance between two adjacent spacers

= 5.000 m
ds = Diameter of flexible conductor

= 0.0369 m
Hence
as/ds = 0.450/0.0369

= 12.195
ls/as = 5.000/0.450

= 11.111

So, sub-conductors shall not clash effectively during short-circuit and Tensile Force caused by pinch effect shall
following the below steps:

Page 22 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
b. Factor k for peak short-circuit current

k = 1.810

c. Time constant of network t

t = 1 For k ≥ 1.1 and if k < 1.1, then k = 1.1


  f    k  1.02  
   2 3   ln  0.98

    

= 1 / [–(2 x π x 50/3) x ln {(1.810 – 1.02) / 0.98}]

= 0.044 s
d. Factor γ

γ = tan-1(2πft)
= ARCTAN(2 x π x 50 x 0.04431)

= 1.499

e. Factor v1

v1 = 1  as  d s  m sc '
f
180 0 0  I k3"  n  1
2
sin  
n 2  n  as

= 50 × {1/SIN(180°/4)} × √[{(0.45–0.0369) × 2.22}/{2E-7 × (40000/4)^2 × (4–1)/0.45}]

= 5.866

f. Time Tpi from short circuit until reaching Fpi

Tpi can be evaluated from the solution of the following equation:

x . √(1 – A + B – C) – v1 = 0

where
sin  4x  2   sin 2
A =
4x
B = y/x · {1 – e–2x/y} sin2γ

C = 8πy sinγ / {1+(2πy)2} M

P = 2πy · cos(2πx – γ)/(2πx)

Q = sin(2πx – γ)/(2πx)

R = (sinγ – 2πycosγ)/(2πx)

M = {(P + Q)e–x/y + R}

Page 23 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
x = fTpi

y = ft
= 50 · 0.04431

= 2.215
Solving the above equation for Tpi,

Tpi = 0.06966 s
.
x = 50 x 0.06966

= 3.483

Page 24 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
A = {SIN(4 x π x 3.48300 – 2 x 1.49908) + SIN(2 x 1.49908)}/(4 x π x 3.48300)

= 0.005

B = 2.21541/3.48300 x {1 – EXP(–2×3.48300/2.21541)} (SIN1.49908)^2

= 0.606

P = 2 x π x 2.21541 x COS(2 x π x 3.48300 – 1.49908)/(2 x π x 3.48300)

= 0.022

Q = SIN(2 x π x 3.48300 – 1.49908)/(2 x π x 3.48300)

= 0.046

R = {SIN(1.49908) – 2 x π x 2.21541 x COS(1.49908)}/(2 x π x 3.48300)

= 6.6E-17

M = {(0.02232 + 0.04567) EXP(–3.48300/2.21541) + 6.60E-17}

= 0.014

C = 8 x π x 2.21541 x SIN(1.49908)/{1 + (2 x π x 2.21541)^2} x 0.01411

= 0.004

Substituting the above values in the above equation,

= 3.48300 x √(1 – 0.00487 + 0.60553 – 0.00402) – 5.86567

= -1.465
g. Factor v2
v2 = √(1 – A + B – C)

= √(1 – 0.00487 + 0.60553 – 0.00402)

= 1.264

h. Factor v3
d s / as  as / d s   1
v3 =
 180 0
sin 
 tan

1
 as / d s   1
 n 
 

= (0.0369/0.45)/SIN(180°/4) x √(0.45/0.0369–1)/ATAN{√(0.45/0.0369–1)}

= 0.303

i. Short-circuit current force, Fv

Fv = 2

 n  1  0  I k 3 "  l s v 2
2  n  a s v 3

Page 25 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
= (4 – 1) x 2E-7 x (40000/4)^2 x (5/0.45) x (1.26358/0.30304)

= 2779.747 N

j. Strain factor of the bundle contraction, εst & εpi

2 2
εst.max = 1.5 Fst l s N  180 0 
 sin 
 a s  d s  2  n 
= 1.5 x 38419.884×5^2×2.03E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^2 x {SIN(180°/4)}^2

= 0.855

Page 26 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

2 2
εst.min = Fst l s N  180 0 
1 .5  sin 
 a s  d s  2  n 
= 1.5 x 39240.000×5^2×2.03E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^2 x {SIN(180°/4)}^2

= 0.873

3
εpi.max = Fv l s N
3
 180 0 
0.375n sin 
 n 

 as  ds 
3
 
= 0.375 x 4 x 2779.747×5^3×2.03E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^3 x {SIN(180°/4)}^3

= 0.530
3 3
Fv l s N  180 0 
0.375n sin 
 n 

εpi.min =  as  ds 
3
 

= 0.375 x 4 x 2779.747×5^3×2.03E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^3 x {SIN(180°/4)}^3

= 0.529

k. Parameter determining the bundle conductor configuration during short-circuit current flow, j
jmax =  pi
1   st
= √{0.52975/(1 + 0.85550)}

= 0.534

jmax 
= pi

1   st

= √{0.52949/(1 + 0.87334)}

= 0.532

j ≥ 1 : The sub-conductors clash.

< 1 : The sub-conductors reduce their distance but do not clash.

Calculation of tensile force caused by pinching effect for non-clashing sub-conductor:

l. ηmax = 0.120 From Figure 11C - IEC60865-1(approx)

for j = 0.534

Page 27 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
& εst = 0.855 ≈ 2^0

ηmin = 0.120 From Figure 11C - IEC60865-1(approx)

for j = 0.532

& εst = 0.873 ≈ 2^0

Page 28 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
m. Fpi =
 ve 
1   
Fst  
2

 st 
where,
ve.max = 1/2 + √ (A1.maxX A2.maxX A3max) - 1/4

2
9   I "
A1.max = n n  1 0  k 3  N
8 2  n 

= 5.5E-05

2
A1.min = 9   I "
n  n  1 0  k 3  N
8 2  n 
= 5.47E-05

4
 180 0 

 sin 
A2.max =  ls 
4
 n 

v2 
a d 

 s s  4

= 32694679.0857517

4
 180 0 

 sin 

A2min =
4
 ls   n 
v2 
a d 

 s s  4

= 32694679.0857517
as  d s

v4.max = as    as  d s 

= 0.124
as  d s

v4.min = as    as  d s 

= 0.124

tan 1 v4
A3.max = 1 v4

= 0.038

tan 1 v4
A3.min = 1
v4

Page 29 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT
tan 1 FORCE
v 4 CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
1  BUS) AT ISINYA
(FLEXIBLE 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
v4

= 0.038

Hence
vemax = 8.779

vemin = 8.777

Page 30 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Now,the tensile force due to pinch effect can be calculated by

 ve 
1   
Fst  
2

Fpi.max = 
 st 

Fpi.max = 44097 N

 ve 
1   
Fst  
2
Fpi.min = 
 st 

Fpi.min = 44918 N

CONCLUSION
Design load for structures, insulators and connectors

Tensile Force at Max. Temperature Ft.max = 4.38 Tonne

Tensile Force at Min. Temperature Ft.min = 4.4743 Tonne

Drop Force at Max. Temperature Ff.max = 0 Tonne

Drop Force at Min. Temperature Ff.min = 0 Tonne

Pinch Force at Max. Temperature Fpi.max = 4.4951 Tonne

Pinch Force at Min. Temperature Fpi.min = 4.5788 Tonne

CONCLUSION
Design load for structures, insulators and connectors

The maximum value of Ft or Ff or Fpi of flexible conductor spans shall be applied to the structure,
the insulators and the connectors as static load.
Maximum of Ft , Ff , Fpi (if applicable):

= Maximum of ( 43893N,00000N,44918N) = 44918.45

= 44.9185

= 4.5788

Page 31 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Page 32 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS

QUAD AAC - 52 Meters

Page 33 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 34 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 1

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 3

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 1

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 3

Page 35 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 36 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

sag value

(T x n x g)

sag value

(T x n x g)

Page 37 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

46.641 kg

46.641 kg

Page 38 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

gth on flexible main conductors in three-phase systems

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

uit conditions to the gravitational force on a conductor

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

Page 39 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 40 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

uctor

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

Page 41 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 42 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A
g short-circuit current flow

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

Page 43 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

onductors

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

(for slack conductor = 1X10^5 i.e., l=lc)

Page 44 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

Page 45 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:43)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

Page 46 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

d by swing out (short-circuit tensile force)


As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

Page 47 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 48 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

Page 49 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 50 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

Page 51 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A
As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

Page 52 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

ly if either one of following equations are fulfilled

Page 53 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

ring short-circuit and Tensile Force caused by pinch effect shall be calculated

Page 54 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

Page 55 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 56 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:109)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:111)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 16

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Page 57 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Page 58 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:97)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 17

Page 59 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 60 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A
As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)
Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:51)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 12

Page 61 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 62 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

conductor spans shall be applied to the structure,

KN

Tonne

Page 63 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 64 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS

QUAD AAC - 26 Meters

Page 17 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Page 18 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

The following calculations are based on IEC - 865


1 BASIC PARAMETERS
a. System Voltage = 400 kV

b. Highest System Voltage V = 420 kV

c. Short Circuit Rating Ik3'' = 40.0 kA

d. System Frequency f = 50 Hz

e. Duration of Short Circuit current flow Tk1 = 1s

2 CONDUCTOR & ANCHORING DETAILS

a. Details of Main Conductor


(i) Type of conductor = AAC

(ii) Number of sub-conductor per phase n = 4 Nos.

(iii) Mass per unit length of one subconductor m's = 2.221 kg/m

(iv) Cross-section of one sub-conductor AS = 805.00 mm2

(v) Young's Modulus E = 5.5E+05 Kg./Cm2

= 5.39E+10 N/m2

(vi) Diameter of conductor = 36.90 mm

(vii) Centre-line dist. between main conductor mid-points a1 = 6500 mm

a2 = 6500 mm

(viii) Resulting spring constant of both supports of one span S = 100 N/mm

(ix) Minimum Temperature Temp min = 0 °C

(x) Maximum Temperature Temp max = 80 °C


.
(xi) Everyday Temperature Temp o = 40 °C

(xii) Material Constant Cth = 2.7E-19 m4/A2s

(xiii) Co-efficient of thermal expansion a = 2.3E-05 /°C

(xiv) No. of Aluminimum Strand Al strand = 61

(xv) No. of Steel Strand St strand = 0

Conventional value of acceleration of gravity

Page 19 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Page 20 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

b. Details of Anchoring of Main Conductor

(i) Conductor span = 26.00 m

(ii) Initial tension of conductor = 1000 kg


(Tension of conductor x gn) = 1000 × 9.81 N = 9810 N

(iii) Tension of conductor = 9810 × 4 N = 39240 N

(vi) Tension at maximum temperature at 80°C

Tension per conductor = 942 kg

then, Fst. Max = 36979.78 N

(v) Tension at minimum temperature at 0°C

Tension per conductor = 1000 kg

then, Fst. Min = 39240.00 N

vi) Girder width = 2000 mm

(vii) Length of Insulator Chain = ( 145 x 30 ) li = 5304 mm

a) Distance between centres of disc units = 145 mm

b) No of insulator discs = 30 discs

(viii) No. of Insulator String ni = 2 Nos.

(ix) Weight of Insulator String = 270 kg

(x) Diameter of disc Insulator = 0.280 m

(xi) Length of Hardware = 954 mm

(xii) Weight of Hardware = 45 kg

c. Details of Spacer
(i) Distance between sub-conductors = 450 mm

(ii) Distance between two adjacent spacers = 5000 mm

(iii) Unit Mass of Spacers = 7 kg

(iv) No. of Spacers = 2

Page 21 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
d. Details of Jumper

No. of cond. Length(m) Mass/Unit Length

(i) Jumper - 1 3 x 7 x 2.221 =

Page 22 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
3 Effects on Main Conductor

3.1 Characteristic dimensions and parameters


a. Characteristic electromagnetic load per unit length on flexible main conductors in three-phase systems

F' = 0  I k 3 " 2 l c
 0.75  
where 2 a l
I''k3 = 3 Ph. initial symmetrical short-circuit current (r.m.s.)

= 40000 A

a = Centre-line distance between main conductor mid points


Equivalent distance is

= (a1+a2)/2

a = 6.5 m

l = Centre-line distance between supports

= 26 m
lc = Cord length of the main conductor in the span

= l – (2 × ( length of one insulator chain + half of the girder width))

= 26 - ( 2 x (5.304+1))

= 13.39 m
μ0 = Permeability of free space, 4 π x 10-7

Hence

F' = ( 2 x 10^-7) x 0.75 x ( 1600000000 / 6.5 ) x ( 13.392 / 26 ) N/m

= 19.018

b. Ratio of electromagnetic force under short-circuit conditions to the gravitational force on a conductor

r = F'
where n  m sc ' g n

n = Number of sub-conductors of a main conductor

= 4 Nos.

Total concentrated mass on conductor


Σm = nsx mS + Σmj

Page 23 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

= 2 x 7+46.641

= 60.641 kg

Resulting mass per unit length of one sub-conductor:


m'sc = Σm/(n x lc)+m's

= (60.641 / (4x13.392))+2.221

m'sc = 3.35304 kg

gn = Conventional value of acceleration of gravity

= 9.81 m/s2
Hence

r = 19.018/(4 x 3.353 x 9.81)

= 0.145

Page 24 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

c. Direction of resulting force exerted on the conductor


δ1 = arctan (r)

= ATAN(0.145) rad

= 0.14355 rad

= 0.14355 × 180/π °

= 8.225 °

d. Equivalent static conductor sag at midspan


bcmax = n  m sc ' g n  l 2
8 Fst
bcmin = n  m sc ' g n  l 2
8 Fst
where
Fstmax = Static tensile force in flexible main conductor

= 36979.776 N

Fstmin = Static tensile force in flexible main conductor

= 39240 N

Hence
bcmax = 4 x 3.353 x 9.81 x 26^2/(8 x 36979.776) m
= 0.301 m

bcmin = 4 x 3.353 x 9.81 x 26^2/(8 x 39240) m

= 0.283 m

e. Period of conductor oscillations

Tmax bc
= 2 0.8
gn
= 2 x π x √(0.8 x 0.301/9.81) s

= 0.984 s

Page 25 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Tmin = bc
2 0.8
gn

= 2 x π x √(0.8 x 0.283/9.81) s

= 0.955 s

Page 26 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
f. Resulting period of conductor oscillation during short-circuit current flow

Tres.max = T
  2  1 
2

4
1 r 2
1  

 64  0 
 90  

= 0.984/[(1 + 0.145^2)^(1/4) x {1 – π^2/64 x (8.225/90)^2}] s

= 0.980 s

T
Tres.min =  2

 2  1 
4
1 r 2
1  

 64  0 
 90  

= 0.955/[(1 + 0.145^2)^(1/4) x {1 – π^2/64 x (8.225/90)^2}] s

= 0.951 s

g. Actual Young's modulus


Es =   Fst  For Fst
E  0.3  0 .7  sin   90 0   
 
 nAs
fin

 fin  nAs
E For F st
  fin
where nA s
δfin = Lowest value of δ when Young's modulus becomes constant

= 5E+07 N/m²
Fst.max/(n As) = 36979.776/(4 x 0.000805000) where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

= 1.15E+07 N/m2
≤ δfin

Fst.max/(n As) = 39240.000/(4 x 0.000805000) where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

= 1.22E+07 N/m2

≤ δfin

Hence,
Esmax = 5.4E+10 [0.3 + 0.7 SIN{36979.776/(4 x 0.000805000 x 5.0E+07) x 90°}] N/m²

= 2.95E+10 N/m²

Esmin = 5.4E+10 [0.3 + 0.7 SIN{39240.000/(4 x 0.000805000 x 5.0E+07) x 90°}] N/m²

Page 27 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
= 3.03E+10 N/m²

h. Stiffness norm of an installation with flexible conductors


Nmax = 1 1

where Sl nE s As
S = 100000 N/m , for strained conductors (for slack conductor = 1X10^5 i.e., l=lc)

Nmax = 1/(100000 x 26) + 1/(4 x 1.1E+07 x 0.000805000) 1/N

= 3.95E-07 1/N

Page 28 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Nmin = 1 1

Sl nE s As
Hence
Nmin = 1/(100000 x 26) + 1/(4 x 3.0E+10 x 0.000805000) 1/N

= 3.95E-07 1/N

i. Stress factor ζ of the main conductor

zmax =  ng n msc ' l  2


3
24 f st N
= (4 x 9.81 x 3.35303778375149 x 26)^2 / (24 x 36979.776^3 x 3.95E-07)

= 0.024

zmin
 ng n m sc ' l  2
= 3
24 f st N
= (4 x 9.81 x 3.35303778375149 x 26)^2 / (24 x 39240.000^3 x 3.95E-07)

= 0.020

j. Swing-out angle at the end of the short-circuit current flow


δk =   Tk 1  For 0 ≤ Tk1/Tres ≤ 0.5
 1 1  cos
  360 0 

  Tres 
2 δ1 For Tk1/Tres > 0.5

where
Tk1 = Duration of first short-circuit current flow

= 1.000 s

Tk1/Tres max = 1.000/0.980


= 1.020 > 0.5

Hence
δkmax = 2 x 8.225

= 16.450 °

Tk1/Tres min = 1.000/0.951


= 1.051 > 0.5

Page 29 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
Hence

δkmin = 2 x 8.225

= 16.450 °

k. Quantity for maximum swing-out angle

χ = 1 – r sinδk For 0 ≤ δk ≤ 90°

1–r For δk > 90°

δkmax = 16.4497 °£ 90°

Hence
χmax = 1 – 0.145 · SIN(16.450)

= 0.959

Page 30 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
δkmin = 16.4497 °£ 90°

Hence
χmin = 1 – arctan (r) · SIN(16.450)

= 0.959

l. Maximum swing-out angle


δm = 1.25 arccosχ For 0.766 ≤ χ ≤ 1 (i)

10° + arccosχ For – 0.985 ≤ χ ≤ 0.766 (ii)

180° For χ < – 0.985 (iii)


χmax = 0.9590687747 then Condition (i)

Hence

δm.max = 20.562 °

χmin = 0.9590687747 then Condition (i)

Hence

δm.min = 20.562 °

3.2 Tensile force during short-circuit caused by swing out (short-circuit tensile force)
a. Load parameter φ
φ =

3 1 r 2 1  For T  Tres
k1
4
3(rsinδk + cosδk – 1) For Tres
Tk1 
4
Tk1 = 1s

Tres.max = 0.245
4
Tres.min = 0.23784
4

Tk1 is greater than Tres.min


4

Page 31 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
Hence

φmax = 3{√(1 + 0.14454^2) – 1}

= 0.031
Hence

φmin = 3{√(1 + 0.14454^2) – 1}

= 0.031

Page 32 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

b. Load parameter Ψ
The factor Ψ is a function of ζ and φ – it can be calculated as a real solution of the equation:

ϕ2Ψ3 + ϕ(2 + ζ)Ψ2 + (1 + 2ζ)Ψ – ζ(2 + ϕ) = 0


For maximum
Solving the above equation for Ψ (0 ≤ Ψ ≤ 1)
Ψmax = 0.0475
Substituting the value of Ψmax in the above equation,

= 0.031^2×0.048^3+0.031(2+0.024)×0.048^2+(1+2×0.024)×0.048–0.024×(2+0.031)

= 0.000

For minimum
Solving the above equation for Ψ (0 ≤ Ψ ≤ 1)

Ψmin = 0.040

Substituting the value of Ψmin in the above equation,

= 0.031^2×0.040^3+0.031(2+0.020)×0.040^2+(1+2×0.020)×0.040–0.020×(2+0.031)

= 0.000

c. Tensile force Ft during short circuit caused by swing out (short-circuit tensile force)

Ft = Fst(1 + φΨ) For n = 1, single conductor


1.1 Fst(1 + φΨ) For n ≥ 2, bundled conductor
n = 4 Nos.
Hence
Ftmax = 1.1 x 36979.776 (1 + 0.031 x 0.048) N
Ftmax = 40737.995 N

4152.701 kg

Ftmin = 1.1 x 39240.000 (1 + 0.031 x 0.040) N

Ftmin = 43217.830 N

Page 33 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
4405.487 kg

Page 34 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

3.3 Tensile force Ff after short circuit caused by drop (drop force)
This is significant for r > 0.6 if δm ≥ 70°

r = 0.14454 (not applicable)


δm,max = 20.5621067702 °

δm,min = 20.5621067702 °

Ff,max = m
1.2 Fst 1  8z
180 0
Ff.max = 1.2 × 36979.776 x √(1 + 8 × 0.024 x 20.56/180°)
Ff.,max = 44867.797 N

= 4573.680 kg

Ff,min = 1.2 F m
st 1  8z
180 0

Ff,min = 1.2 × 39240.000 x √(1 + 8 × 0.020 x 20.56/180°)

Ff,min = 47525.701 N

= 4844.618 kg

3.4 Maximum Horizontal span displacement (bh) and minimum air clearance(amin)
a. Elastic expansion (εela)

εela = Nmax (Ft.max – Fst.max)

= 3.95E-7 *(40738 - 36979.776)

= 1.49E-03
b. Thermal Expansion (εth)
Material constant (Cth ) is 0.27*10-18 m4/A2s for Cross section area of Aluminium/Steel > 6

0.17*10-18 m4/A2s for Cross section area of Aluminium/Steel < 6

0.088*10-18 m4/A2s for Cross section area of Copper

Cth = 2.70E-19 m4/A2s

2
 I "
c th  k 3  Tres / 4
 nAs 
Page 35 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
2
 I k 3 "
Thermal Expansion ε th
= c th   Tres / 4 for Tk1 ≥ Tres/4
 nAs 
2
I 
c th  k 3"  Tk 1 for Tk1 < Tres/4
 nA s 

= 0.27E-18*(40000/(4*0.0008050))²*0.98/4

εth = 1.02E-05

Page 36 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

c. Dilation Factor (CD) 2


3 l 
CD = 1     els   th 
8  bc 

= √(1+3/8*(26/0.30)²*(1.49E-03+1.02E-05))
CD = 2.28

d. Form factor (CF)


CF = 1.05 for r < 0.8
0.97+0.1r for 0.8 < r < 1.8
1.15 for r > 1.8

= 1.05

CF = 1.05000

e. Maximum Horizontal span displacement ( bh)

For slack conductors bh = CF CD bc for δm > 90o


CF CD bc sin δm for δm < 90o

For strained Conductors bh = CF CD bc sin δb1 h for δm > δ1


CF CD bc sin δm for δm < δ1

= 1.05*2.28*0.3006(sin(8.22))
bh = 0.10 m

f. Minimum air clearance (amin)

amin = a - 2bh

= 6.5- 2*0.10
amin = 6.29 m

4 Tensile Force Fpi caused by pinch effect


4.1 Characteristic dimensions and parameters
a. Sub-conductors are considered to clash effectively if either one of following equations are fulfilled
as/ds ≤ 2 and ls ≥ 50 as
as/ds ≤ 2.5 and ls ≥ 70 as
where
as = Distance between sub-conductors

= 0.450 m

Page 37 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
ls = Distance between two adjacent spacers

= 5.000 m
ds = Diameter of flexible conductor

= 0.0369 m
Hence
as/ds = 0.450/0.0369

= 12.195
ls/as = 5.000/0.450

= 11.111

So, sub-conductors shall not clash effectively during short-circuit and Tensile Force caused by pinch effect shall
following the below steps:

Page 38 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
b. Factor k for peak short-circuit current

k = 1.810

c. Time constant of network t

t = 1 For k ≥ 1.1 and if k < 1.1, then k = 1.1


  f    k  1.02   
   2 3   ln  0.98

    

= 1 / [–(2 x π x 50/3) x ln {(1.810 – 1.02) / 0.98}]

= 0.044 s
d. Factor γ

γ = tan-1(2πft)
= ARCTAN(2 x π x 50 x 0.04431)

= 1.499

e. Factor v1

v1 = 1  as  d s  m sc '
f
180 0 0  I k3 "  n  1
2
sin  
n 2  n  as

= 50 × {1/SIN(180°/4)} × √[{(0.45–0.0369) × 2.22}/{2E-7 × (40000/4)^2 × (4–1)/0.45}]

= 5.866

f. Time Tpi from short circuit until reaching Fpi

Tpi can be evaluated from the solution of the following equation:

x . √(1 – A + B – C) – v1 = 0

where
sin  4x  2   sin 2
A =
4x
B = y/x · {1 – e–2x/y} sin2γ

C = 8πy sinγ / {1+(2πy)2} M

P = 2πy · cos(2πx – γ)/(2πx)

Q = sin(2πx – γ)/(2πx)

R = (sinγ – 2πycosγ)/(2πx)

M = {(P + Q)e–x/y + R}

Page 39 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
x = fTpi

y = ft
= 50 · 0.04431

= 2.215
Solving the above equation for Tpi,

Tpi = 0.06966 s
.
x = 50 x 0.06966

= 3.483

Page 40 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
A = {SIN(4 x π x 3.48300 – 2 x 1.49908) + SIN(2 x 1.49908)}/(4 x π x 3.48300)

= 0.005

B = 2.21541/3.48300 x {1 – EXP(–2×3.48300/2.21541)} (SIN1.49908)^2

= 0.606

P = 2 x π x 2.21541 x COS(2 x π x 3.48300 – 1.49908)/(2 x π x 3.48300)

= 0.022

Q = SIN(2 x π x 3.48300 – 1.49908)/(2 x π x 3.48300)

= 0.046

R = {SIN(1.49908) – 2 x π x 2.21541 x COS(1.49908)}/(2 x π x 3.48300)

= 6.6E-17

M = {(0.02232 + 0.04567) EXP(–3.48300/2.21541) + 6.60E-17}

= 0.014

C = 8 x π x 2.21541 x SIN(1.49908)/{1 + (2 x π x 2.21541)^2} x 0.01411

= 0.004

Substituting the above values in the above equation,

= 3.48300 x √(1 – 0.00487 + 0.60553 – 0.00402) – 5.86567

= -1.465
g. Factor v2
v2 = √(1 – A + B – C)

= √(1 – 0.00487 + 0.60553 – 0.00402)

= 1.264

h. Factor v3
d s / as  as / d s   1
v3 =
 180 0
sin 
 tan

1
 as / d s   1
 n 
 

= (0.0369/0.45)/SIN(180°/4) x √(0.45/0.0369–1)/ATAN{√(0.45/0.0369–1)}

= 0.303

i. Short-circuit current force, Fv

Fv = 2

 n  1  0  I k 3 "  l s v 2
2  n  a s v 3

Page 41 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
= (4 – 1) x 2E-7 x (40000/4)^2 x (5/0.45) x (1.26358/0.30304)

= 2779.747 N

j. Strain factor of the bundle contraction, εst & εpi

2 2
εst.max = 1.5 Fst l s N  180 0 
 sin 
 a s  d s  2  n 
= 1.5 x 36979.776×5^2×3.95E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^2 x {SIN(180°/4)}^2

= 1.605

Page 42 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

2 2
εst.min = Fst l s N  180 0 
1 .5  sin 
 a s  d s  2  n 
= 1.5 x 39240.000×5^2×3.95E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^2 x {SIN(180°/4)}^2

= 1.702

3
εpi.max = Fv l s N
3
 180 0 
0.375n sin 
 n 

 as  ds 
3
 
= 0.375 x 4 x 2779.747×5^3×3.95E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^3 x {SIN(180°/4)}^3

= 1.033
3 3
Fv l s N  180 0 
0.375n sin 
 n 

εpi.min =  as  ds 
3
 

= 0.375 x 4 x 2779.747×5^3×3.95E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^3 x {SIN(180°/4)}^3

= 1.032

k. Parameter determining the bundle conductor configuration during short-circuit current flow, j
jmax =  pi
1   st
= √{1.03288/(1 + 1.60550)}

= 0.630

jmax 
= pi

1   st

= √{1.03218/(1 + 1.70246)}

= 0.618

j ≥ 1 : The sub-conductors clash.

< 1 : The sub-conductors reduce their distance but do not clash.

Calculation of tensile force caused by pinching effect for non-clashing sub-conductor:

l. ηmax = 0.140 From Figure 11C - IEC60865-1(approx)

for j = 0.630

Page 43 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
& εst = 1.605 ≈ 2^1

ηmin = 0.130 From Figure 11C - IEC60865-1(approx)

for j = 0.618

& εst = 1.702 ≈ 2^1

Page 44 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
m. Fpi =
 ve 
F st 
1    2


where,  st 
ve.max = 1/2 + √ (A1.maxX A2.maxX A3max) - 1/4

2
9   I "
A1.max = n n  1 0  k 3  N
8 2  n 

= 1.1E-04

2
A1.min = 9   I "
n  n  1 0  k 3  N
8 2  n 
= 1.07E-04

4
 180 0 

 sin 
A2.max =  ls 
4
 n 

v2 
a d 

 s s  4

= 17647773.4673612

4
 180 0 

 sin 

A2min =
4
 ls   n 
v2 
a d 

 s s  4

= 23737154.3546146
as  d s

v4.max = as    as  d s 

= 0.147
as  d s

v4.min = as    as  d s 

= 0.136

tan 1 v4
A3.max = 1 v4

= 0.045

tan 1 v4
A3.min = 1
v4
Page 45 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT
tan 1 FORCE
v 4 CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
ATISINYA 400/220kV
BUS) 1 SUBSTATION CLB
v4

= 0.042

Hence
vemax = 9.714

vemin = 10.775

Page 46 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS (FLEXIBLE
BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Now,the tensile force due to pinch effect can be calculated by

 ve 
Fpi.max = F st 
1    2


 st 
Fpi.max = 40761 N

 ve 
1   
Fst  
2
Fpi.min = 
 st 

Fpi.min = 43437 N

CONCLUSION
Design load for structures, insulators and connectors

Tensile Force at Max. Temperature Ft.max = 4.15 Tonne

Tensile Force at Min. Temperature Ft.min = 4.4054872925 Tonne

Drop Force at Max. Temperature Ff.max = 0 Tonne

Drop Force at Min. Temperature Ff.min = 0 Tonne

Pinch Force at Max. Temperature Fpi.max = 4.1550350791 Tonne

Pinch Force at Min. Temperature Fpi.min = 4.4278640515 Tonne

CONCLUSION
Design load for structures, insulators and connectors

The maximum value of Ft or Ff or Fpi of flexible conductor spans shall be applied to the structure,
the insulators and the connectors as static load.
Maximum of Ft , Ff , Fpi (if applicable):

= Maximum of ( 43218N,00000N,43437N) = 43437.35

= 43.4373

= 4.4279

Page 47 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

FORCE CALCULATION FOR MAIN BUS

QUAD AAC - 26 Meters

Page 48 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 49 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 1

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 3

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 1

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 3

Page 50 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 51 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

sag value

(T x n x g)

sag value

(T x n x g)

Page 52 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

46.641 kg

Page 53 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

gth on flexible main conductors in three-phase systems

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

uit conditions to the gravitational force on a conductor

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

Page 54 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 55 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

uctor

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

Page 56 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 57 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A
g short-circuit current flow

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

Page 58 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

onductors

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

(for slack conductor = 1X10^5 i.e., l=lc)

Page 59 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

Page 60 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:43)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

Page 61 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

d by swing out (short-circuit tensile force)


As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

Page 62 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 63 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

Page 64 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 65 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

Page 66 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A
As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

Page 67 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

ely if either one of following equations are fulfilled

Page 68 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

ring short-circuit and Tensile Force caused by pinch effect shall be calculated

Page 69 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

Page 70 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 71 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:109)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:111)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 16

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Page 72 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Page 73 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:97)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 17

Page 74 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 75 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A
As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)
Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:51)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 12

Page 76 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 77 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

conductor spans shall be applied to the structure,

KN

Tonne

Page 78 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS

QUAD AAC - 67.4 Meters

Page 33 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Page 34 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

The following calculations are based on IEC - 865


1 BASIC PARAMETERS
a. System Voltage = 400 kV

b. Highest System Voltage V = 420 kV

c. Short Circuit Rating Ik3'' = 40.0 kA

d. System Frequency f = 50 Hz

e. Duration of Short Circuit current flow Tk1 = 1s

2 CONDUCTOR & ANCHORING DETAILS

a. Details of Main Conductor


(i) Type of conductor = AAC

(ii) Number of sub-conductor per phase n = 4 Nos.

(iii) Mass per unit length of one subconductor m's = 2.221 kg/m

(iv) Cross-section of one sub-conductor AS = 805.00 mm2

(v) Young's Modulus E = 5.5E+05 Kg./Cm2

= 5.39E+10 N/m2

(vi) Diameter of conductor = 36.90 mm

(vii) Centre-line dist. between main conductor mid-points a1 = 6500 mm

a2 = 6500 mm

(viii) Resulting spring constant of both supports of one span S = 100 N/mm

(ix) Minimum Temperature Temp min = 0 °C

(x) Maximum Temperature Temp max = 80 °C


.
(xi) Everyday Temperature Temp o = 40 °C

(xii) Material Constant Cth = 2.7E-19 m4/A2s

(xiii) Co-efficient of thermal expansion a = 2.3E-05 /°C

(xiv) No. of Aluminimum Strand Al strand = 61

(xv) No. of Steel Strand St strand = 0

Conventional value of acceleration of gravity

Page 35 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Page 36 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

b. Details of Anchoring of Main Conductor

(i) Conductor span = 67.40 m

(ii) Initial tension of conductor = 1000 kg


(Tension of conductor x gn) = 1000 × 9.81 N = 9810 N

(iii) Tension of conductor = 9810 × 4 N = 39240 N

(vi) Tension at maximum temperature at 80°C

Tension per conductor = 988.10 kg

then, Fst. Max = 38773.04 N

(v) Tension at minimum temperature at 0°C

Tension per conductor = 1000 kg

then, Fst. Min = 39240.00 N

vi) Girder width = 2000 mm

(vii) Length of Insulator Chain = ( 145 x 30 ) li = 5304 mm

a) Distance between centres of disc units = 145 mm

b) No of insulator discs = 30 discs

(viii) No. of Insulator String ni = 2 Nos.

(ix) Weight of Insulator String = 270 kg

(x) Diameter of disc Insulator = 0.280 m

(xi) Length of Hardware = 954 mm

(xii) Weight of Hardware = 45 kg

c. Details of Spacer
(i) Distance between sub-conductors = 450 mm

(ii) Distance between two adjacent spacers = 5000 mm

(iii) Unit Mass of Spacers = 7 kg

(iv) No. of Spacers = 10

Page 37 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
d. Details of Jumper

No. of cond. Length Mass/Unit


(m) Length
(i) Jumper - 1 2 x 7 x 2.221 =

(i) Dropper - 1 2 x 15 x 2.221 =

(i) Dropper - 2 2 x 15 x 2.221 =

Page 38 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
3 Effects on Main Conductor

3.1 Characteristic dimensions and parameters


a. Characteristic electromagnetic load per unit length on flexible main conductors in three-phase systems

F' = 0  I " l c 2

 0.75  k 3 
where 2 a l
I''k3 = 3 Ph. initial symmetrical short-circuit current (r.m.s.)

= 40000 A

a = Centre-line distance between main conductor mid points


Equivalent distance is

= (a1+a2)/2

a = 6.5 m

l = Centre-line distance between supports

= 67.4 m
lc = Cord length of the main conductor in the span

= l – (2 × ( length of one insulator chain + half of the girder width))

= 67.4 - ( 2 x (5.304+1))

= 54.79 m
μ0 = Permeability of free space, 4 π x 10-7

Hence

F' = ( 2 x 10^-7) x 0.75 x ( 1600000000 / 6.5 ) x ( 54.792 / 67.4 ) N/m

= 30.016

b. Ratio of electromagnetic force under short-circuit conditions to the gravitational force on a conductor

r = F'
where n  m sc ' g n

n = Number of sub-conductors of a main conductor

= 4 Nos.

Total concentrated mass on conductor


Σm = nsx mS + Σmj

Page 39 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

= 10 x 7+31.094

= 234.354 kg

Resulting mass per unit length of one sub-conductor:


m'sc = Σm/(n x lc)+m's

= (234.354 / (4x54.792))+2.221

m'sc = 3.29029 kg

gn = Conventional value of acceleration of gravity

= 9.81 m/s2
Hence

r = 30.016/(4 x 3.290 x 9.81)

= 0.232

Page 40 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

c. Direction of resulting force exerted on the conductor


δ1 = arctan (r)

= ATAN(0.232) rad

= 0.22843 rad

= 0.22843 × 180/π °

= 13.088 °

d. Equivalent static conductor sag at midspan


bcmax = n  m sc ' g n  l 2
8 Fst
bcmin = n  m sc ' g n  l 2
8 Fst
where
Fstmax = Static tensile force in flexible main conductor

= 38773.044 N

Fstmin = Static tensile force in flexible main conductor

= 39240 N

Hence
bcmax = 4 x 3.290 x 9.81 x 67.4^2/(8 x 38773.044) m
= 1.891 m

bcmin = 4 x 3.290 x 9.81 x 67.4^2/(8 x 39240) m

= 1.868 m

e. Period of conductor oscillations

Tmax bc
= 2 0.8
gn
= 2 x π x √(0.8 x 1.891/9.81) s

= 2.467 s

Page 41 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Tmin = bc
2 0.8
gn

= 2 x π x √(0.8 x 1.868/9.81) s

= 2.453 s

Page 42 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
f. Resulting period of conductor oscillation during short-circuit current flow

Tres.max = T
  2  1 
2

4
1 r 2
1  

 64  0 
 90  

= 2.467/[(1 + 0.232^2)^(1/4) x {1 – π^2/64 x (13.088/90)^2}] s

= 2.443 s

T
Tres.min =  2

 2  1 
4
1 r 2
1  

 64  0 
 90  

= 2.453/[(1 + 0.232^2)^(1/4) x {1 – π^2/64 x (13.088/90)^2}] s

= 2.428 s

g. Actual Young's modulus


Es =   Fst  For Fst
E  0.3  0.7  sin   90 0     fin
 

  nAs  fin  nAs
E For F st
  fin
where nA s
δfin = Lowest value of δ when Young's modulus becomes constant

= 5E+07 N/m²
Fst.max/(n As) = 38773.044/(4 x 0.000805000) where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

= 1.20E+07 N/m2
≤ δfin

Fst.max/(n As) = 39240.000/(4 x 0.000805000) where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

= 1.22E+07 N/m2

≤ δfin

Hence,
Esmax = 5.4E+10 [0.3 + 0.7 SIN{38773.044/(4 x 0.000805000 x 5.0E+07) x 90°}] N/m²

= 3.01E+10 N/m²

Esmin = 5.4E+10 [0.3 + 0.7 SIN{39240.000/(4 x 0.000805000 x 5.0E+07) x 90°}] N/m²

Page 43 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
= 3.03E+10 N/m²

h. Stiffness norm of an installation with flexible conductors


Nmax = 1 1

where Sl nE s As
S = 100000 N/m , for strained conductors (for slack conductor = 1X10^5 i.e., l=lc

Nmax = 1/(100000 x 67.4) + 1/(4 x 1.2E+07 x 0.000805000) 1/N

= 1.59E-07 1/N

Page 44 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Nmin = 1 1

Sl nE s As
Hence
Nmin = 1/(100000 x 67.4) + 1/(4 x 3.0E+10 x 0.000805000) 1/N

= 1.59E-07 1/N

i. Stress factor ζ of the main conductor

zmax =  ng n msc ' l  2


3
24 f st N
= (4 x 9.81 x 3.29028931230837 x 67.4)^2 / (24 x 38773.044^3 x 1.59E-07)

= 0.341

zmin
 ng n m sc ' l  2
= 3
24 f st N
= (4 x 9.81 x 3.29028931230837 x 67.4)^2 / (24 x 39240.000^3 x 1.59E-07)

= 0.329

j. Swing-out angle at the end of the short-circuit current flow


δk =   Tk 1  For 0 ≤ Tk1/Tres ≤ 0.5
 1 1  cos
  360 0 

  Tres 
2 δ1 For Tk1/Tres > 0.5

where
Tk1 = Duration of first short-circuit current flow

= 1.000 s

Tk1/Tres max = 1.000/2.443


= 0.409 ≤ 0.5

Hence
δkmax = 13.088{1 – COS(360° x 1.000/2.443)} °

= 24.109 °

Tk1/Tres min = 1.000/2.428


= 0.412 ≤ 0.5

Page 45 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
Hence

δkmin = 13.088{1 – COS(360° x 1.000/2.428)} °

= 24.216 °

k. Quantity for maximum swing-out angle

χ = 1 – r sinδk For 0 ≤ δk ≤ 90°

1–r For δk > 90°

δkmax = 24.1087 °£ 90°

Hence
χmax = 1 – 0.232 · SIN(24.109)

= 0.905

Page 46 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
δkmin = 24.2164 °£ 90°

Hence
χmin = 1 – arctan (r) · SIN(24.216)

= 0.905

l. Maximum swing-out angle


δm = 1.25 arccosχ For 0.766 ≤ χ ≤ 1 (i)

10° + arccosχ For – 0.985 ≤ χ ≤ 0.766 (ii)

180° For χ < – 0.985 (iii)


χmax = 0.9050377606 then Condition (i)

Hence

δm.max = 31.465 °

χmin = 0.9046391128 then Condition (i)

Hence

δm.min = 31.532 °

3.2 Tensile force during short-circuit caused by swing out (short-circuit tensile force)
a. Load parameter φ
φ =

3 1 r 2 1  For Tk 1 
Tres
4
Tres
3(rsinδk + cosδk – 1) For Tk 1 
4

Tk1 = 1s

Tres.max = 0.61075
4
Tres.min = 0.60711
4

Tk1 is greater than Tres.min


4

Page 47 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
Hence

φmax = 3{√(1 + 0.23248^2) – 1}

= 0.080
Hence

φmin = 3{√(1 + 0.23248^2) – 1}

= 0.080

Page 48 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

b. Load parameter Ψ
The factor Ψ is a function of ζ and φ – it can be calculated as a real solution of the equation:

ϕ2Ψ3 + ϕ(2 + ζ)Ψ2 + (1 + 2ζ)Ψ – ζ(2 + ϕ) = 0


For maximum
Solving the above equation for Ψ (0 ≤ Ψ ≤ 1)
Ψmax = 0.4035
Substituting the value of Ψmax in the above equation,

= 0.080^2×0.404^3+0.080(2+0.341)×0.404^2+(1+2×0.341)×0.404–0.341×(2+0.080)

= 0.000

For minimum
Solving the above equation for Ψ (0 ≤ Ψ ≤ 1)

Ψmin = 0.3950

Substituting the value of Ψmin in the above equation,

= 0.080^2×0.395^3+0.080(2+0.329)×0.395^2+(1+2×0.329)×0.395–0.329×(2+0.080)

= 0.000

c. Tensile force Ft during short circuit caused by swing out (short-circuit tensile force)

Ft = Fst(1 + φΨ) For n = 1, single conductor


1.1 Fst(1 + φΨ) For n ≥ 2, bundled conductor
n = 4 Nos.
Hence
Ftmax = 1.1 x 38773.044 (1 + 0.080 x 0.404) N
Ftmax = 44027.205 N

4487.992 kg

Ftmin = 1.1 x 39240.000 (1 + 0.080 x 0.395) N

Ftmin = 44528.085 N

Page 49 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
4539.050 kg

Page 50 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

3.3 Tensile force Ff after short circuit caused by drop (drop force)
This is significant for r > 0.6 if δm ≥ 70°

r = 0.23248 (not applicable)


δm,max = 31.4645384314 °

δm,min = 31.5315982497 °

Ff,max = m
1.2 Fst 1  8z
180 0
Ff.max = 1.2 × 38773.044 x √(1 + 8 × 0.341 x 31.46/180°)
Ff.,max = 56546.844 N

= 5764.204 kg

Ff,min = 1.2 F m
st 1  8z
180 0

Ff,min = 1.2 × 39240.000 x √(1 + 8 × 0.329 x 31.53/180°)

Ff,min = 56923.096 N

= 5802.558 kg

3.4 Maximum Horizontal span displacement (bh) and minimum air clearance(amin)
a. Elastic expansion (εela)

εela = Nmax (Ft.max – Fst.max)

= 1.59E-7 *(44027 - 38773.044)

= 8.34E-04
b. Thermal Expansion (εth)
Material constant (Cth ) is 0.27*10-18 m4/A2s for Cross section area of Aluminium/Steel > 6

0.17*10-18 m4/A2s for Cross section area of Aluminium/Steel < 6

0.088*10-18 m4/A2s for Cross section area of Copper

Cth = 2.70E-19 m4/A2s

2
 I "
c th  k 3  Tres / 4
 nAs 
Page 51 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
2
 I k 3 "
Thermal Expansion ε th
= c th   Tres / 4 for Tk1 ≥ Tres/4
 nAs 
2
I 
c th  k 3"  Tk 1 for Tk1 < Tres/4
 nA s 

= 0.27E-18*(40000/(4*0.0008050))²*2.44/4

εth = 2.54E-05

Page 52 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

c. Dilation Factor (CD) 2


3 l 
CD = 1     els   th 
8  bc 

= √(1+3/8*(67.4/1.89)²*(8.34E-04+2.54E-05))
CD = 1.19

d. Form factor (CF)


CF = 1.05 for r < 0.8
0.97+0.1r for 0.8 < r < 1.8
1.15 for r > 1.8

= 1.05

CF = 1.05000

e. Maximum Horizontal span displacement ( bh)

For slack conductors bh = CF CD bc for δm > 90o


CF CD bc sin δm for δm < 90o

For strained Conductors bh = CF CD bc sin δb1 h for δm > δ1


CF CD bc sin δm for δm < δ1

= 1.05*1.19*1.8909(sin(13.09))
bh = 0.53 m

f. Minimum air clearance (amin)

amin = a - 2bh

= 6.5- 2*0.53
amin = 5.43 m

4 Tensile Force Fpi caused by pinch effect


4.1 Characteristic dimensions and parameters
a. Sub-conductors are considered to clash effectively if either one of following equations are fulfilled
as/ds ≤ 2 and ls ≥ 50 as
as/ds ≤ 2.5 and ls ≥ 70 as
where
as = Distance between sub-conductors

= 0.450 m

Page 53 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
ls = Distance between two adjacent spacers

= 5.000 m
ds = Diameter of flexible conductor

= 0.0369 m
Hence
as/ds = 0.450/0.0369

= 12.195
ls/as = 5.000/0.450

= 11.111

So, sub-conductors shall not clash effectively during short-circuit and Tensile Force caused by pinch effect shall
following the below steps:

Page 54 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
b. Factor k for peak short-circuit current

k = 1.810

c. Time constant of network t

t = 1 For k ≥ 1.1 and if k < 1.1, then k = 1.1


  f    k  1.02  
   2 3   ln  0.98

    

= 1 / [–(2 x π x 50/3) x ln {(1.810 – 1.02) / 0.98}]

= 0.044 s
d. Factor γ

γ = tan-1(2πft)
= ARCTAN(2 x π x 50 x 0.04431)

= 1.499

e. Factor v1

v1 = 1  as  d s  m sc '
f
180 0 0  I k3"  n  1
2
sin  
n 2  n  as

= 50 × {1/SIN(180°/4)} × √[{(0.45–0.0369) × 2.22}/{2E-7 × (40000/4)^2 × (4–1)/0.45}]

= 5.866

f. Time Tpi from short circuit until reaching Fpi

Tpi can be evaluated from the solution of the following equation:

x . √(1 – A + B – C) – v1 = 0

where
sin  4x  2   sin 2
A =
4x
B = y/x · {1 – e–2x/y} sin2γ

C = 8πy sinγ / {1+(2πy)2} M

P = 2πy · cos(2πx – γ)/(2πx)

Q = sin(2πx – γ)/(2πx)

R = (sinγ – 2πycosγ)/(2πx)

M = {(P + Q)e–x/y + R}

Page 55 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
x = fTpi

y = ft
= 50 · 0.04431

= 2.215
Solving the above equation for Tpi,

Tpi = 0.05304 s
.
x = 50 x 0.05304

= 2.652

Page 56 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
A = {SIN(4 x π x 2.65200 – 2 x 1.49908) + SIN(2 x 1.49908)}/(4 x π x 2.65200)

= -0.022

B = 2.21541/2.65200 x {1 – EXP(–2×2.65200/2.21541)} (SIN1.49908)^2

= 0.755

P = 2 x π x 2.21541 x COS(2 x π x 2.65200 – 1.49908)/(2 x π x 2.65200)

= -0.715

Q = SIN(2 x π x 2.65200 – 1.49908)/(2 x π x 2.65200)

= 0.031

R = {SIN(1.49908) – 2 x π x 2.21541 x COS(1.49908)}/(2 x π x 2.65200)

= 8.7E-17

M = {(-0.71477 + 0.03106) EXP(–2.65200/2.21541) + 8.66E-17}

= -0.207

C = 8 x π x 2.21541 x SIN(1.49908)/{1 + (2 x π x 2.21541)^2} x -0.20653

= -0.059

Substituting the above values in the above equation,

= 2.65200 x √(1 – -0.02229 + 0.75525 – -0.05889) – 5.86567

= -2.272
g. Factor v2
v2 = √(1 – A + B – C)

= √(1 – -0.02229 + 0.75525 – -0.05889)

= 1.355

h. Factor v3
d s / as  as / d s   1
v3 =
 180 0
sin 
 tan

1
 as / d s   1
 n 
 

= (0.0369/0.45)/SIN(180°/4) x √(0.45/0.0369–1)/ATAN{√(0.45/0.0369–1)}

= 0.303

i. Short-circuit current force, Fv

Fv = 2

 n  1  0  I k 3 "  l s v 2
2  n  a s v3

Page 57 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
= (4 – 1) x 2E-7 x (40000/4)^2 x (5/0.45) x (1.35515/0.30304)

= 2981.189 N

j. Strain factor of the bundle contraction, εst & εpi

2 2
εst.max = 1.5 Fst l s N  180 0 
 sin 
 a s  d s  2  n 
= 1.5 x 38773.044×5^2×1.59E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^2 x {SIN(180°/4)}^2

= 0.676

Page 58 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

2 2
εst.min = Fst l s N  180 0 
1 .5  sin 
 a s  d s  2  n 
= 1.5 x 39240.000×5^2×1.59E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^2 x {SIN(180°/4)}^2

= 0.684

3
εpi.max = Fv l s N
3
 180 0 
0.375n sin 
 n 

 as  ds 
3
 
= 0.375 x 4 x 2981.189×5^3×1.59E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^3 x {SIN(180°/4)}^3

= 0.445
3 3
Fv l s N  180 0 
0.375n sin 
 n 

εpi.min =  as  ds 
3
 

= 0.375 x 4 x 2981.189×5^3×1.59E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^3 x {SIN(180°/4)}^3

= 0.445

k. Parameter determining the bundle conductor configuration during short-circuit current flow, j
jmax =  pi
1   st
= √{0.44484/(1 + 0.67599)}

= 0.515

jmax 
= pi

1   st

= √{0.44469/(1 + 0.68390)}

= 0.514

j ≥ 1 : The sub-conductors clash.

< 1 : The sub-conductors reduce their distance but do not clash.

Calculation of tensile force caused by pinching effect for non-clashing sub-conductor:

l. ηmax = 0.120 From Figure 11C - IEC60865-1(approx)

for j = 0.515

Page 59 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
& εst = 0.676 ≈ 2^0

ηmin = 0.120 From Figure 11C - IEC60865-1(approx)

for j = 0.514

& εst = 0.684 ≈ 2^0

Page 60 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
m. Fpi =
 ve 
1   
Fst  
2

 st 
where,
ve.max = 1/2 + √ (A1.maxX A2.maxX A3max) - 1/4

2
9   I "
A1.max = n n  1 0  k 3  N
8 2  n 

= 4.3E-05

2
A1.min = 9  0  I k3" 
n  n  1   N
8 2  n 
= 4.28E-05

4
 180 0 

 sin 
A2.max =  ls 
4
 n 

v2 
a d 

 s s  4

= 35063986.2370546

4
 180 0 

 sin 

A2min =
4
 ls   n 
v2 
a d 

 s s  4

= 35063986.2370546
as  d s

v4.max = as    as  d s 

= 0.124
as  d s

v4.min = as    as  d s 

= 0.124

tan 1 v4
A3.max = 1 v4

= 0.038

tan 1 v4
A3.min = 1
v4

Page 61 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT
tan 1 FORCE
v 4 CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
1  BUS) AT ISINYA
(FLEXIBLE 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
v4

= 0.038

Hence
vemax = 8.083

vemin = 8.082

Page 62 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Now,the tensile force due to pinch effect can be calculated by

 ve 
1   
Fst  
2

Fpi.max = 
 st 

Fpi.max = 45450 N

 ve 
1   
Fst  
2
Fpi.min = 
 st 

Fpi.min = 45918 N

CONCLUSION
Design load for structures, insulators and connectors

Tensile Force at Max. Temperature Ft.max = 4.49 Tonne

Tensile Force at Min. Temperature Ft.min = 4.53905045 Tonne

Drop Force at Max. Temperature Ff.max = 0 Tonne

Drop Force at Min. Temperature Ff.min = 0 Tonne

Pinch Force at Max. Temperature Fpi.max = 4.63297948 Tonne

Pinch Force at Min. Temperature Fpi.min = 4.68070287 Tonne

CONCLUSION
Design load for structures, insulators and connectors

The maximum value of Ft or Ff or Fpi of flexible conductor spans shall be applied to the structure,
the insulators and the connectors as static load.
Maximum of Ft , Ff , Fpi (if applicable):

= Maximum of ( 44528N,00000N,45918N) = 45917.70

= 45.9177

= 4.6807

Page 63 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

ORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS

QUAD AAC - 67.4 Meters

Page 64 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 65 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 1

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 3

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 1

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 3

Page 66 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 67 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

sag value

(T x n x g)

sag value

(T x n x g)

Page 68 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

31.094 kg

66.63 kg

66.63 kg

Page 69 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

ngth on flexible main conductors in three-phase systems

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

uit conditions to the gravitational force on a conductor

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

Page 70 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 71 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

uctor

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

Page 72 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 73 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A
ng short-circuit current flow

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

Page 74 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

conductors

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

(for slack conductor = 1X10^5 i.e., l=lc)

Page 75 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

Page 76 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:43)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

Page 77 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

d by swing out (short-circuit tensile force)


As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

Page 78 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 79 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

Page 80 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 81 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

Page 82 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A
As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

Page 83 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

ely if either one of following equations are fulfilled

Page 84 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

uring short-circuit and Tensile Force caused by pinch effect shall be calculated

Page 85 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

For k ≥ 1.1 and if k < 1.1, then k = 1.1

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

Page 86 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 87 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:109)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:111)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 16

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Page 88 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Page 89 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:97)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 17

Page 90 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 91 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A
As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)
Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:51)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 12

Page 92 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 93 of 64
any Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

conductor spans shall be applied to the structure,

KN

Tonne

Page 94 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS

QUAD AAC - 60.75 Meters

Page 49 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Page 50 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

The following calculations are based on IEC - 865


1 BASIC PARAMETERS
a. System Voltage = 400 kV

b. Highest System Voltage V = 420 kV

c. Short Circuit Rating Ik3'' = 40.0 kA

d. System Frequency f = 50 Hz

e. Duration of Short Circuit current flow Tk1 = 1s

2 CONDUCTOR & ANCHORING DETAILS

a. Details of Main Conductor


(i) Type of conductor = AAC

(ii) Number of sub-conductor per phase n = 4 Nos.

(iii) Mass per unit length of one subconductor m's = 2.221 kg/m

(iv) Cross-section of one sub-conductor AS = 805.00 mm2

(v) Young's Modulus E = 5.5E+05 Kg./Cm2

= 5.39E+10 N/m2

(vi) Diameter of conductor = 36.90 mm

(vii) Centre-line dist. between main conductor mid-points a1 = 6500 mm

a2 = 6500 mm

(viii) Resulting spring constant of both supports of one span S = 100 N/mm

(ix) Minimum Temperature Temp min = 0 °C

(x) Maximum Temperature Temp max = 80 °C


.
(xi) Everyday Temperature Temp o = 40 °C

(xii) Material Constant Cth = 2.7E-19 m4/A2s

(xiii) Co-efficient of thermal expansion a = 2.3E-05 /°C

(xiv) No. of Aluminimum Strand Al strand = 61

(xv) No. of Steel Strand St strand = 0

Conventional value of acceleration of gravity

Page 51 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Page 52 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

b. Details of Anchoring of Main Conductor

(i) Conductor span = 60.75 m

(ii) Initial tension of conductor = 1000 kg


(Tension of conductor x gn) = 1000 × 9.81 N = 9810 N

(iii) Tension of conductor = 9810 × 4 N = 39240 N

(vi) Tension at maximum temperature at 80°C

Tension per conductor = 985.00 kg

then, Fst. Max = 38651.40 N

(v) Tension at minimum temperature at 0°C

Tension per conductor = 1000.00 kg

then, Fst. Min = 39240.00 N

vi) Girder width = 2000 mm

(vii) Length of Insulator Chain = ( 145 x 30 ) li = 5304 mm

a) Distance between centres of disc units = 145 mm

b) No of insulator discs = 30 discs

(viii) No. of Insulator String ni = 2 Nos.

(ix) Weight of Insulator String = 270 kg

(x) Diameter of disc Insulator = 0.280 m

(xi) Length of Hardware = 954 mm

(xii) Weight of Hardware = 45 kg

c. Details of Spacer
(i) Distance between sub-conductors = 450 mm

(ii) Distance between two adjacent spacers = 5000 mm

(iii) Unit Mass of Spacers = 7 kg

(iv) No. of Spacers = 9

Page 53 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
d. Details of Jumper
No. of cond. Length(m) Mass/Unit Length

(i) Jumper - 1 3 x 7 x 2.221 =

(ii) Jumper - 2 3 x 7 x 2.221 =

Page 54 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
3 Effects on Main Conductor

3.1 Characteristic dimensions and parameters


a. Characteristic electromagnetic load per unit length on flexible main conductors in three-phase systems

F' = 0  I " l c 2

 0.75  k 3 
where 2 a l
I''k3 = 3 Ph. initial symmetrical short-circuit current (r.m.s.)

= 40000 A

a = Centre-line distance between main conductor mid points


Equivalent distance is

= (a1+a2)/2

a = 6.5 m

l = Centre-line distance between supports

= 60.75 m
lc = Cord length of the main conductor in the span

= l – (2 × ( length of one insulator chain + half of the girder width))

= 60.75 - ( 2 x (5.304+1))

= 48.14 m
μ0 = Permeability of free space, 4 π x 10-7

Hence

F' = ( 2 x 10^-7) x 0.75 x ( 1600000000 / 6.5 ) x ( 48.142 / 60.75 ) N/m

= 29.260

b. Ratio of electromagnetic force under short-circuit conditions to the gravitational force on a conductor

r = F'
where n  m sc ' g n

n = Number of sub-conductors of a main conductor

= 4 Nos.

Total concentrated mass on conductor


Σm = nsx mS + Σmj

Page 55 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

= 7*9+(46.641+46.641)

= 156.282 kg

Resulting mass per unit length of one sub-conductor:


m'sc = Σm/(n x lc)+m's

= (156.282 / (4x48.142))+2.221

m'sc = 3.03257 kg

gn = Conventional value of acceleration of gravity

= 9.81 m/s2
Hence

r = 29.260/(4 x 3.033 x 9.81)

= 0.246

Page 56 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

c. Direction of resulting force exerted on the conductor


δ1 = arctan (r)

= ATAN(0.246) rad

= 0.24110 rad

= 0.24110 × 180/π °

= 13.814 °

d. Equivalent static conductor sag at midspan


bcmax = n  m sc ' g n  l 2
8 Fst
bcmin = n  m sc ' g n  l 2
8 Fst
where
Fstmax = Static tensile force in flexible main conductor

= 38651.4 N

Fstmin = Static tensile force in flexible main conductor

= 39240 N

Hence
bcmax = 4 x 3.033 x 9.81 x 60.75^2/(8 x 38651.4) m
= 1.420 m

bcmin = 4 x 3.033 x 9.81 x 60.75^2/(8 x 39240) m

= 1.399 m

e. Period of conductor oscillations

Tmax bc
= 2 0.8
gn
= 2 x π x √(0.8 x 1.420/9.81) s

= 2.138 s

Page 57 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Tmin = bc
2 0.8
gn

= 2 x π x √(0.8 x 1.399/9.81) s

= 2.122 s

Page 58 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
f. Resulting period of conductor oscillation during short-circuit current flow

Tres.max = T
  2  1 
2

4
1 r 2
1  

 64  0 
 90  

= 2.138/[(1 + 0.246^2)^(1/4) x {1 – π^2/64 x (13.814/90)^2}] s

= 2.115 s

T
Tres.min =  2

 2  1 
4
1 r 2
1  

 64  0 
 90  

= 2.122/[(1 + 0.246^2)^(1/4) x {1 – π^2/64 x (13.814/90)^2}] s

= 2.099 s

g. Actual Young's modulus


Es =   Fst  For Fst
E  0 .3  0 .7  sin   90 0    fin
 nA  

  s fin  nAs
E For F st
  fin
where nA s
δfin = Lowest value of δ when Young's modulus becomes constant

= 5E+07 N/m²
Fst.max/(n As) = 38651.400/(4 x 0.000805000) where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

= 1.20E+07 N/m2
≤ δfin

Fst.max/(n As) = 39240.000/(4 x 0.000805000) where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

= 1.22E+07 N/m2

≤ δfin

Hence,
Esmax = 5.4E+10 [0.3 + 0.7 SIN{38651.400/(4 x 0.000805000 x 5.0E+07) x 90°}] N/m²

= 3.01E+10 N/m²

Esmin = 5.4E+10 [0.3 + 0.7 SIN{39240.000/(4 x 0.000805000 x 5.0E+07) x 90°}] N/m²

Page 59 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
= 3.03E+10 N/m²

h. Stiffness norm of an installation with flexible conductors


Nmax = 1 1

where Sl nE s As
S = 100000 N/m , for strained conductors (for slack conductor = 1X10^5 i.e., l=l

Nmax = 1/(100000 x 60.75) + 1/(4 x 1.2E+07 x 0.000805000) 1/N

= 1.75E-07 1/N

Page 60 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Nmin = 1 1

Sl nE s As
Hence
Nmin = 1/(100000 x 60.75) + 1/(4 x 3.0E+10 x 0.000805000) 1/N

= 1.75E-07 1/N

i. Stress factor ζ of the main conductor

zmax =  ng n msc ' l  2


3
24 f st N
= (4 x 9.81 x 3.03256786174235 x 60.75)^2 / (24 x 38651.400^3 x 1.75E-07)

= 0.216

zmin
 ng n m sc ' l  2
= 3
24 f st N
= (4 x 9.81 x 3.03256786174235 x 60.75)^2 / (24 x 39240.000^3 x 1.75E-07)

= 0.206

j. Swing-out angle at the end of the short-circuit current flow


δk =   Tk 1  For 0 ≤ Tk1/Tres ≤ 0.5
 1 1  cos
  360 0 

  Tres 
2 δ1 For Tk1/Tres > 0.5

where
Tk1 = Duration of first short-circuit current flow

= 1.000 s

Tk1/Tres max = 1.000/2.115


= 0.473 ≤ 0.5

Hence
δkmax = 13.814{1 – COS(360° x 1.000/2.115)} °

= 27.428 °

Tk1/Tres min = 1.000/2.099


= 0.476 ≤ 0.5

Page 61 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
Hence

δkmin = 13.814{1 – COS(360° x 1.000/2.099)} °

= 27.477 °

k. Quantity for maximum swing-out angle

χ = 1 – r sinδk For 0 ≤ δk ≤ 90°

1–r For δk > 90°

δkmax = 27.4278 °£ 90°

Hence
χmax = 1 – 0.246 · SIN(27.428)

= 0.887

Page 62 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
δkmin = 27.4773 °£ 90°

Hence
χmin = 1 – arctan (r) · SIN(27.477)

= 0.887

l. Maximum swing-out angle


δm = 1.25 arccosχ For 0.766 ≤ χ ≤ 1 (i)

10° + arccosχ For – 0.985 ≤ χ ≤ 0.766 (ii)

180° For χ < – 0.985 (iii)


χmax = 0.8867366111 then Condition (i)

Hence

δm.max = 34.418 °

χmin = 0.886548451 then Condition (i)

Hence

δm.min = 34.447 °

3.2 Tensile force during short-circuit caused by swing out (short-circuit tensile force)
a. Load parameter φ
φ =

3 1 r 2 1  For Tk 1 
Tres
4
Tres
3(rsinδk + cosδk – 1) For Tk 1 
4

Tk1 = 1s

Tres.max = 0.52872
4
Tres.min = 0.52474
4

Tk1 is greater than Tres.min


4

Page 63 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
Hence

φmax = 3{√(1 + 0.24589^2) – 1}

= 0.089
Hence

φmin = 3{√(1 + 0.24589^2) – 1}

= 0.089

Page 64 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

b. Load parameter Ψ
The factor Ψ is a function of ζ and φ – it can be calculated as a real solution of the equation:

ϕ2Ψ3 + ϕ(2 + ζ)Ψ2 + (1 + 2ζ)Ψ – ζ(2 + ϕ) = 0


For maximum
Solving the above equation for Ψ (0 ≤ Ψ ≤ 1)
Ψmax = 0.3020
Substituting the value of Ψmax in the above equation,

= 0.089^2×0.302^3+0.089(2+0.216)×0.302^2+(1+2×0.216)×0.302–0.216×(2+0.089)

= 0.000

For minimum
Solving the above equation for Ψ (0 ≤ Ψ ≤ 1)

Ψmin = 0.293

Substituting the value of Ψmin in the above equation,

= 0.089^2×0.293^3+0.089(2+0.206)×0.293^2+(1+2×0.206)×0.293–0.206×(2+0.089)

= 0.000

c. Tensile force Ft during short circuit caused by swing out (short-circuit tensile force)

Ft = Fst(1 + φΨ) For n = 1, single conductor


1.1 Fst(1 + φΨ) For n ≥ 2, bundled conductor
n = 4 Nos.
Hence
Ftmax = 1.1 x 38651.400 (1 + 0.089 x 0.302) N
Ftmax = 43663.922 N

4450.960 kg

Ftmin = 1.1 x 39240.000 (1 + 0.089 x 0.293) N

Ftmin = 44292.212 N

Page 65 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
4515.006 kg

Page 66 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

3.3 Tensile force Ff after short circuit caused by drop (drop force)
This is significant for r > 0.6 if δm ≥ 70°

r = 0.24589 (not applicable)


δm,max = 34.417509101 °

δm,min = 34.4466491644 °

Ff,max = m
1.2 Fst 1  8z
180 0
Ff.max = 1.2 × 38651.400 x √(1 + 8 × 0.216 x 34.42/180°)
Ff.,max = 53484.921 N

= 5452.082 kg

Ff,min = 1.2 F m
st 1  8z
180 0

Ff,min = 1.2 × 39240.000 x √(1 + 8 × 0.206 x 34.45/180°)

Ff,min = 54008.164 N

= 5505.419 kg

3.4 Maximum Horizontal span displacement (bh) and minimum air clearance(amin)
a. Elastic expansion (εela)

εela = Nmax (Ft.max – Fst.max)

= 1.75E-7 *(43664 - 38651.4)

= 8.77E-04
b. Thermal Expansion (εth)
Material constant (Cth ) is 0.27*10-18 m4/A2s for Cross section area of Aluminium/Steel > 6

0.17*10-18 m4/A2s for Cross section area of Aluminium/Steel < 6

0.088*10-18 m4/A2s for Cross section area of Copper

Cth = 2.70E-19 m4/A2s

2
 I "
cth  k 3  Tres / 4
 nAs 
Page 67 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
2
 I k 3 "
Thermal Expansion ε th
= c th   Tres / 4 for Tk1 ≥ Tres/4
 nAs 
2
I 
c th  k 3"  Tk 1 for Tk1 < Tres/4
 nA s 

= 0.27E-18*(40000/(4*0.0008050))²*2.11/4

εth = 2.20E-05

Page 68 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

c. Dilation Factor (CD) 2


3 l 
CD = 1     els   th 
8  bc 

= √(1+3/8*(60.75/1.42)²*(8.77E-04+2.20E-05))
CD = 1.27

d. Form factor (CF)


CF = 1.05 for r < 0.8
0.97+0.1r for 0.8 < r < 1.8
1.15 for r > 1.8

= 1.05

CF = 1.05000

e. Maximum Horizontal span displacement ( bh)

For slack conductors bh = CF CD bc for δm > 90o


CF CD bc sin δm for δm < 90o

For strained Conductors bh = CF CD bc sin δb1 h for δm > δ1


CF CD bc sin δm for δm < δ1

= 1.05*1.27*1.4203(sin(13.81))
bh = 0.45 m

f. Minimum air clearance (amin)

amin = a - 2bh

= 6.5- 2*0.45
amin = 5.59 m

4 Tensile Force Fpi caused by pinch effect


4.1 Characteristic dimensions and parameters
a. Sub-conductors are considered to clash effectively if either one of following equations are fulfilled
as/ds ≤ 2 and ls ≥ 50 as
as/ds ≤ 2.5 and ls ≥ 70 as
where
as = Distance between sub-conductors

= 0.450 m

Page 69 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
ls = Distance between two adjacent spacers

= 5.000 m
ds = Diameter of flexible conductor

= 0.0369 m
Hence
as/ds = 0.450/0.0369

= 12.195
ls/as = 5.000/0.450

= 11.111

So, sub-conductors shall not clash effectively during short-circuit and Tensile Force caused by pinch effect shall b
following the below steps:

Page 70 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
b. Factor k for peak short-circuit current

k = 1.810

c. Time constant of network t

t = 1 For k ≥ 1.1 and if k < 1.1, then k = 1.1


  f    k  1.02  
   2 3   ln  0.98

    

= 1 / [–(2 x π x 50/3) x ln {(1.810 – 1.02) / 0.98}]

= 0.044 s
d. Factor γ

γ = tan-1(2πft)
= ARCTAN(2 x π x 50 x 0.04431)

= 1.499

e. Factor v1

v1 = 1  as  d s  m sc '
f
180 0 0  I k3"  n  1
2
sin  
n 2  n  as

= 50 × {1/SIN(180°/4)} × √[{(0.45–0.0369) × 2.22}/{2E-7 × (40000/4)^2 × (4–1)/0.45}]

= 5.866

f. Time Tpi from short circuit until reaching Fpi

Tpi can be evaluated from the solution of the following equation:

x . √(1 – A + B – C) – v1 = 0

where
sin  4x  2   sin 2
A =
4x
B = y/x · {1 – e–2x/y} sin2γ

C = 8πy sinγ / {1+(2πy)2} M

P = 2πy · cos(2πx – γ)/(2πx)

Q = sin(2πx – γ)/(2πx)

R = (sinγ – 2πycosγ)/(2πx)

M = {(P + Q)e–x/y + R}

Page 71 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
x = fTpi

y = ft
= 50 · 0.04431

= 2.215
Solving the above equation for Tpi,

Tpi = 0.05304 s
.
x = 50 x 0.05304

= 2.652

Page 72 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
A = {SIN(4 x π x 2.65200 – 2 x 1.49908) + SIN(2 x 1.49908)}/(4 x π x 2.65200)

= -0.022

B = 2.21541/2.65200 x {1 – EXP(–2×2.65200/2.21541)} (SIN1.49908)^2

= 0.755

P = 2 x π x 2.21541 x COS(2 x π x 2.65200 – 1.49908)/(2 x π x 2.65200)

= -0.715

Q = SIN(2 x π x 2.65200 – 1.49908)/(2 x π x 2.65200)

= 0.031

R = {SIN(1.49908) – 2 x π x 2.21541 x COS(1.49908)}/(2 x π x 2.65200)

= 8.7E-17

M = {(-0.71477 + 0.03106) EXP(–2.65200/2.21541) + 8.66E-17}

= -0.207

C = 8 x π x 2.21541 x SIN(1.49908)/{1 + (2 x π x 2.21541)^2} x -0.20653

= -0.059

Substituting the above values in the above equation,

= 2.65200 x √(1 – -0.02229 + 0.75525 – -0.05889) – 5.86567

= -2.272
g. Factor v2
v2 = √(1 – A + B – C)

= √(1 – -0.02229 + 0.75525 – -0.05889)

= 1.355

h. Factor v3
d s / as  as / d s   1
v3 =
 180 0
sin 
 tan

1
 as / d s   1
 n 
 

= (0.0369/0.45)/SIN(180°/4) x √(0.45/0.0369–1)/ATAN{√(0.45/0.0369–1)}

= 0.303

i. Short-circuit current force, Fv

Fv = 2

 n  1  0  I k 3 "  l s v 2
2  n  a s v3

Page 73 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
= (4 – 1) x 2E-7 x (40000/4)^2 x (5/0.45) x (1.35515/0.30304)

= 2981.189 N

j. Strain factor of the bundle contraction, εst & εpi

2 2
εst.max = 1.5 Fst l s N  180 0 
 sin 
 a s  d s  2  n 
= 1.5 x 38651.400×5^2×1.75E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^2 x {SIN(180°/4)}^2

= 0.743

Page 74 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

2 2
εst.min = Fst l s N  180 0 
1 .5  sin 
 a s  d s  2  n 
= 1.5 x 39240.000×5^2×1.75E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^2 x {SIN(180°/4)}^2

= 0.754

3
εpi.max = Fv l s N
3
 180 0 
0.375n sin 
 n 

 as  ds 
3
 
= 0.375 x 4 x 2981.189×5^3×1.75E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^3 x {SIN(180°/4)}^3

= 0.490
3 3
Fv l s N  180 0 
0.375n sin 
 n 

εpi.min =  as  ds 
3
 

= 0.375 x 4 x 2981.189×5^3×1.75E-07/(0.45 – 0.0369)^3 x {SIN(180°/4)}^3

= 0.490

k. Parameter determining the bundle conductor configuration during short-circuit current flow, j
jmax =  pi
1   st
= √{0.49041/(1 + 0.74291)}

= 0.530

jmax 
= pi

1   st

= √{0.49022/(1 + 0.75392)}

= 0.529

j ≥ 1 : The sub-conductors clash.

< 1 : The sub-conductors reduce their distance but do not clash.

Calculation of tensile force caused by pinching effect for non-clashing sub-conductor:

l. ηmax = 0.120 From Figure 11C - IEC60865-1(approx)

for j = 0.530

Page 75 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
& εst = 0.743 ≈ 2^0

ηmin = 0.120 From Figure 11C - IEC60865-1(approx)

for j = 0.529

& εst = 0.754 ≈ 2^0

Page 76 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
m. Fpi =
 ve 
1   
Fst  
2

 st 
where,
ve.max = 1/2 + √ (A1.maxX A2.maxX A3max) - 1/4

2
9   I "
A1.max = n n  1 0  k 3  N
8 2  n 

= 4.7E-05

2
A1.min = 9   I "
n  n  1 0  k 3  N
8 2  n 
= 4.72E-05

4
 180 0 

 sin 
A2.max =  ls 
4
 n 

v2 
 a  d 

 s s  4

= 35063986.2370546

4
 180 0 

 sin 

A2min =
4
 ls   n 
v2 
 a  d 

 s s  4

= 35063986.2370546
as  d s

v4.max = as    as  d s 

= 0.124
as  d s

v4.min = as    as  d s 

= 0.124

tan 1 v4
A3.max = 1 v4

= 0.038

tan 1 v4
A3.min = 1
v4

Page 77 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT
tan 1 FORCE
v 4 CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
1  BUS) AT ISINYA
(FLEXIBLE 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB
v4

= 0.038

Hence
vemax = 8.464

vemin = 8.462

Page 78 of 64
National Contracting Company Limited

DOCUMENT No.
PROJECT: KENYA ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION COMPANY LIMITED
(KETRACO) 0092013-QH-7401-J-1107

DESIGNED
TITLE: SHORT CIRCUIT FORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS
(FLEXIBLE BUS) AT ISINYA 400/220kV SUBSTATION CLB

Now,the tensile force due to pinch effect can be calculated by

 ve 
1   
Fst  
2

Fpi.max = 
 st 

Fpi.max = 44993 N

 ve 
1   
Fst  
2
Fpi.min = 
 st 

Fpi.min = 45583 N

CONCLUSION
Design load for structures, insulators and connectors

Tensile Force at Max. Temperature Ft.max = 4.45 Tonne

Tensile Force at Min. Temperature Ft.min = 4.51500635 Tonne

Drop Force at Max. Temperature Ff.max = 0 Tonne

Drop Force at Min. Temperature Ff.min = 0 Tonne

Pinch Force at Max. Temperature Fpi.max = 4.58640283 Tonne

Pinch Force at Min. Temperature Fpi.min = 4.64653674 Tonne

CONCLUSION
Design load for structures, insulators and connectors

The maximum value of Ft or Ff or Fpi of flexible conductor spans shall be applied to the structure,
the insulators and the connectors as static load.
Maximum of Ft , Ff , Fpi (if applicable):

= Maximum of ( 44292N,00000N,45583N) = 45582.53

= 45.5825

= 4.6465

Page 79 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

ORCE CALCULATION FOR STRUNG BUS

UAD AAC - 60.75 Meters

Page 80 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 81 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 1

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 3

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 1

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 3

Page 82 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 83 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

sag value

(T x n x g)

sag value

(T x n x g)

Page 84 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

46.641 kg

46.641 kg

Page 85 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

th on flexible main conductors in three-phase systems

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

t conditions to the gravitational force on a conductor

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

Page 86 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 87 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

ctor

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:39)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

Page 88 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 89 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A
short-circuit current flow

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 6

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

where As is cross-section of one sub-conductor

Page 90 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

nductors

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

(for slack conductor = 1X10^5 i.e., l=lc)

Page 91 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 7

Page 92 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:43)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

Page 93 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

Page 94 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 95 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:41)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 8

Page 96 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 97 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

Page 98 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A
As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

Page 99 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:45)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 9

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

y if either one of following equations are fulfilled

Page 100 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:47)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 10

ing short-circuit and Tensile Force caused by pinch effect shall be calculated

Page 101 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

Page 102 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 103 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:109)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 15

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:111)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 16

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Page 104 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Page 105 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:97)

Refer Annexure Pg.No: 17

Page 106 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 107 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A
As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:49)
Refer Annexure Pg.No: 11

As per IEC - 865 (Pg No:51)


Refer Annexure Pg.No: 12

Page 108 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

Page 109 of 64
ny Limited

DOCUMENT No. DATE

0092013-QH-7401-J-1107 5/30/2015

CHECKED APPROVED REV

DG VT A

KN

Tonne

Page 110 of 64

You might also like