Professional Documents
Culture Documents
From the gold rush to the rise of the film industry, from the free speech
movement of the 1960s to the emergence of Silicon Valley as an engine of
innovation, California has reinvented itself time and again.
Perhaps this is why many of us find ourselves asking: Can California do it again? Today the state is facing
some of its toughest challenges. And its future will be crafted from our responses to these challenges—as
individuals, as organizations, as communities. We can already see signals of some of these responses as
we scan the California landscape. They point to very divergent futures, to alternative scenarios in which we
come face-to-face with what we value.
Will California become the leading Smart State? Or will it evolve as a vibrant Culture Commons? Will we
reinvent the state to embody 21st Century Superstructures? Or will we retreat into an Enclave Economy?
These are four strikingly different visions of how the state could look in 2020. But in reality, California will
be—and perhaps already is—some combination of all four of these scenarios.
This map is an invitation to explore the future worlds that are already emerging today in California. It’s a
tool to tackle, head on, the big questions facing the state. It’s a chance to think about the alternatives, to
compare and contrast scenarios that provoke us to think in new ways, to ask better questions and engage
in important conversations with our neighbors, our colleagues, and our community leaders. Perhaps most
important, it’s a way to reinvent ourselves as 21st century Californians.
Take a tour of California’s landscape-in-the-making. Grapple with one or more of the big questions. Imagine
your day in one of the future scenarios. And then take your next step—it may be the first step toward
building the new California dream.
You can build this vision for yourself, or you can work with colleagues in your workplace to think about
how your organization can help build a different kind of California. Or you can engage your community
in imagining the kind of difference it can make. Fill in the blanks together or individually. Add some
photographs or your own charts to the California landscape. Remember, the future isn’t complete without
your contributions!
A b o u t T h i s Ma p
This map was developed by Institute for the Future (IFTF) in
collaboration with California Institute for Telecommunications and
Information Technology (Calit2) and the Center for Information
Technology Research in the Interest of Society (CITRIS). The map
emerged from a workshop led by Marina Gorbis and Rod Falcon, with
a group of experts in a variety of fields. For more information on the
workshop and a list of experts, visit www.iftf.org/FutureofCalifornia.
The ideas expressed on this map are the sole responsibility of IFTF.
IFTF’s 2010 California Dreaming is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0.
For more information, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/. All other brands and trademarks cc
remain the property of their respective owners. SR-1313
Four Visions of California
G r oW t h
S m a r t S tat e
A growth scenario is both about business-as-usual and innovation-as-business. Economic growth
continues to define success for corporations, institutions, and even communities. And in a state where
technical know-how and entrepreneurship have been a winning formula for growth for several decades,
the state is investing in systems that expand that advantage. At the heart of this investment is a new
digital backbone of automated systems aimed especially at solutions for climate, energy, water, and
waste problems. The state is also cultivating a design advantage, in both of its traditional areas of
leadership—aerospace and electronics—and in new approaches to industries such as food, fashion,
and even the automotive industry. But the real platform for growth is urban data, as smart systems
keep a finger on the pulse of California cities and entrepreneurs spin this data into marketplace gold.
Sadly, the continued emphasis on research leadership in the public university system does little to
expand opportunities for those who can’t afford the high cost of a college education, and the rich-poor
gap continues to widen.
E d u c at i o n
The educational system—and the UC system in particular—is streamlined as an engine of economic
growth. Result? Research becomes a priority for all institutions of higher learning, with even stronger
links between industry leaders, startups, and university research labs. R&D accounts for a growing
percentage of the state’s GDP.
W ATER & ENER GY + Wo r k
Smart meters, smart grids, and community-scale power and waste technologies drive both
resource conservation and new wealth, with new green jobs for skilled technicians. Still, the state
can’t quite keep ahead of demand for energy and water.
G OVERNANCE & EQUIT Y + MI GRATION
Even as migration from Asia and Latin America continues to slow, the large Asian and Latino
populations in California create strong social and economic ties with these regions—so much so
that together they function as an integrated economy in many ways.
Co n s t r a i n t
C u lt u r e Co m m o n s
In a constraint scenario, California abandons growth for growth’s sake as it tries to rein in demand
for natural resources. The state turns its attention to a combination of cultural norms (focused
on conservation) and cultural expression (focused on expanding support for the creative arts).
Underpinning this new social consensus is the growth of a variety of commons that leverage new social
media for everything from supporting small-scale food distribution to community health to building
the creative infrastructure. But perhaps the most significant shift is a redefinition of freedom: citizens
accept cultural norms and taxes as a platform for freedom. Taxes generate revenue that assures
access to education, health, and public infrastructures.
F OOD + h e a lt h
Driven by health costs and health concerns, the state reorganizes its food systems around the concept
of the urban foodshed. Urban planning takes into account the demand for food, leveraging local
production capacity to sustain city populations and integrating urban, peri-urban, and rural farming.
The state imposes a fast food tax as well as food-mile incentives.
Work
While all the scenarios see some growth in green jobs, the constraint scenario sees investment in
honing a green labor economy—redefining all jobs as green jobs and using green development to
create income opportunities for even the poorest citizens.
W ATER & ENER G Y + HEALTH
Using a combination of carbon markets, personal carbon quotas, and steep gasoline taxes,
California aims to be the national leader in reduction of carbon emissions. Beyond conservation,
the state targets a variety of toxic wastes to improve community health—and even works with China to
craft independent agreements aimed at reducing trans-Pacific pollution.
G O V ERNANCE & E Q UIT Y
Leveraging its new social consensus, the state finds the political will to repeal Proposition 13,
providing the financial resources needed to address the most extreme disparities in health,
education, and income.
Four Visions of California
T r a n s f o r m at i o n
Co ll a p s e
E n c l ave Eco n o m y
In California, a collapse scenario begins with a catalytic natural disaster, like an earthquake or
wildfire—or both. Loss of resources plus high costs of recovery drain wealth from the public sector.
The private sector moves to protect its own resources, with increased privatization of water, security,
and education. The result is the emergence of a couple wealthy, walled metropolitan areas (such
as San Diego-Orange County and the San Francisco Bay Area) that control access to most of the
state’s resources. Meanwhile, other parts of the state slip into slum-like conditions. The exception are
places where large Latino populations exploit the so-called “Latino Paradox”—leveraging family and
community values as well as traditional food and health practices. In 2020, they provide the only hint of
a possible path out of collapse.
Education + Work
Public education becomes increasingly privatized. Most UC campuses are privatized and refocused
on producing research scientists and technologists. K-12 is also increasingly privatized; a growing
segment of the young population drops out to help support their families in low-skill labor jobs.
FOOD
With pressures on the state’s water infrastructure and lockdown of certain farm regions by wealthy urban
communities, the food system begins to fail. Without coordinated protection, the state’s fisheries also fail.
Work + MI G RA T ION
As privatization of education, health, and security continue, the gap between rich and poor
becomes extreme. The wealthy aggregate in secure urban enclaves or walled suburban communities,
tapping the poor for resources needed from outside.
G O V E RNANC E & E Q UI T Y
Crime and security risks increase in the state, and prisons and police/fire services are privatized in the
hands of a few large corporations. Cities buy these services directly, without significant state oversight.
HE A LTH
How will we How will we learn in a How will we reinvent How will we build How will we thrive How will our systems How will we redefine
create healthy century of vast information our food systems a strong economic with less water and of governance assure our borders, spaces, and
lifestyles in a world and increased complexity? to foster sustainable foundation with 21st century more expensive energy? responsive leadership, places to support robust
of new health risks? bodies and ecosystems? industries and jobs? justice, and equitable and resilient communities?
›› Privatization of public college education ›› Unsustainable growth in demand for water access to state resources?
Unhealthy built and natural environments ›› 2025: 1 million fewer college grads than needed Climate change impact on crops More green jobs ›› Declining Sierra snowpack: –52% by 2090
›› ›› ›› ›› Growth of suburban and exurban poverty
Greater burden of chronic disease ›› Lower college enrollment, more research funding Food for export vs. distributed local production Design leadership ›› Modest gains in desalination, gray water conversion
›› ›› ›› ›› Continued growth of rich-poor gap ›› Children of immigrants = drivers of
›› Increasing health disparities ›› Second-generation Latino educational lead ›› Growth of urban farming ›› Growth of robotics and local manufacturing ›› Urban vs. agricultural water conflicts population growth
›› Coastal wealth, inland poverty
›› New borders, new infections ›› Shift from printed textbooks to digital resources ›› Growth of urban and suburban food deserts ›› More entrepreneurs from Mexico ›› Increased demand for smaller, sustainable housing ›› Ages 30 to 50: large migration out of state
›› Rising prison population, older inmates
›› Diminishing Latino health advantage ›› School lunch reform ›› Rising Chinese labor costs = more California jobs? ›› Growth of electric vehicle economy ›› New kinds of borders and boundaries:
›› Rise of Latino independent voter
walled communities
›› Gerrymandered districts = fragmentation
›› New cross-border virtual communities
›› Growing secessionist demands
Response e d u c ation a l rethin k
Response
Response foo d u p g r a d e Response resour c e for m u l a m i g r ation
Response w or k re d esi g n
re d irec t
Response g overnM E N T R E FO R M
e
o ns I ntervention
sp
Re lth
H ea
2010
who are
you today?
2020
who will you be
in the future?
GROWTH CO LL A P S E
CO N S T R A I N T T R A N S F O R M AT I O N
S m art S tat e Enc l av e Econo m y
C u lt u r e 21 st C e nt u ry
In the face of large-scale disaster, a highly privatized society loses its cohesiveness.
California enters a new era of growth, built on the backbone of smart systems.
These systems support innovation across a host of sectors and industries—
Co m m ons Superstructures Wealth is concentrated in a few highly-connected urban areas that lock in basic
from ubiquitous online learning to city governance to new models for the resources from their periphery. Beyond the boundaries of these secure enclaves—
A sober-minded assessment of risks and A new kind of citizenship emerges as people build
aerospace, biomedical, and alternative energy industries. The rewards of growth and isolated from them—less well-off populations struggle to maintain any
resources in the face of water and energy shortages parallel institutions that leverage social media for their core
are not equally distributed, however. The rich and young thrive. Poor Gen-Xers have advantages of community. In the most successful example of adaptation, the
leads to a new focus on communities and commons— infrastructure. Communities—not all geographically defined—
the hardest path. Latino population leverages its culture to rebuild socially, economically,
with a new partnership across sectors to reinvent culture replace sectors as the organizational substrate for learning,
and environmentally devastated areas.
in California. A combination of strong policy and creative innovation, wealth generation, and governance. Neuroscience
›› University of California: platform for economic growth innovation yields a lifestyle blueprint that emphasizes the provides the design paradigm for this institutional transformation,
R&D spending: growing percentage of GDP ›› Catalytic natural disasters: earthquakes, wildfires, floods
›› creative arts, community health, and conservative consumption. with new capacities to engage, inspire, and learn.
›› Smart water and waste systems ›› Walled cities: secure connections to food, health, and learning
Digital license Digital food Distributed earthquake Recycled products, Strong environmental Community eco-mapping Alternative New food Disaster Failure of Public-private educational
plates—with ads tracking sensing re-invented workers regulations and monitoring currencies networks planning inland suburbs collaborations