Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IN 1
1 Atul Kumar
S/o- Late Sh. Om Prakash Mittal,
R/o-7C, Block-D, Ideal Towers,
57, Diamond Harbour Road,
Kolkata-700023, W.B. ………………. Petitioner No.1
2. Shantanu Guha Ray
S/o-Late Sh. Nripen Guha Ray
R/o-B-385, second Floor,
Chittaranjan Park, New Delhi ……………… Petitioner No.2
…
//Versus//
1. Union of India
Through Ministry of Home Affairs
Through its Secretary
North Block, Cabinet Secretariat, ……………….. Respondent No.1
Raisina Hill, New Delhi - 110 001
2. Ministry of Youth Affairs &
Sports
Through its Secretary
Shastri Bhawan, ……………….. Respondent No.2
Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road,
New Delhi-110001
3. The Board of Control for Cricket
in India (BCCI)
Through its President
Wankhede Stadium,
Church Gate, Mumbai
Maharashtra ……………….. Respondent No.3
To,
The Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India and His Companion Justices of
petitioners above-named
1. That the Petitioners are filing the present writ petition in public
No.919120835957.
WWW.LIVELAW.IN 3
the petitioners which has or could have a legal nexus with the
decade and lying exposed and proven for years. And yet the
fraud continues with all the glory and all the shamelessness.
support this fraud and not only applaud the perpetrators but
treat them as heroes and super heroes. All the law enforcing
WWW.LIVELAW.IN 4
the first time brought out the obscure and intricate relation
27th Jan, 2013, he told the world with absolute clarity that cricket
authorities and media, continuing the same till date. His other
WWW.LIVELAW.IN 5
Matches are Fixed’, and ‘Cricket: The Massive Fraud.’ The latter
also scooped the Delhi airport scam. His cover for Tehelka on
His news report on India’s only female don in Varanasi for New
York Times was among the top trending stories of the daily
WWW.LIVELAW.IN 6
earned him many global awards, so did his work on the dangers
of asbestos.
This book chillingly lays bare the murky world of cricket betting
and fixing over the years that lies hidden from the public eye
under the glare of 4’s and 6’s by its idols. The book brings out
with the blessings of all who matter. His other books ‘Target’ and
7. That the brief facts leading to the filing of the present petition
for two years in its verdict on the 2013 betting and spot fixing
from the matter brought out in this petition that those few
comes as breath of fresh air, but only just! There's more muck fr
report. Banning two IPL teams for two years and two team
few muddy drops out of an ocean full of mud and muddy water,,
9. That Petitioner No.2 has also expressed thus about the Mudgal
in Cricket’:
“I almost fell from the chair. The thought had not struck me
little, skimming just the surface and nabbing the small fry.”
10. That it will not be wrong to say that today cricketing legends,
masses hooked on to it. One will know this for sure after one has
society, many of those selling fake cricket are media and social
media darlings and heroes and super heroes for the masses and
punish the drug peddlers and send them to the prisons, those
already lies in public domain and will get crystal clear to any
11. That many may tend to say what is so big if cricket, after all
and what if they suffer? Why should they bet? People would be
few who are not that ignorant, feel happy to ignore the
12. That years ago, Rashid Latif, the ex Pakistani wicket keeper
batsman and also the captain later on, brought out the link and
ANNEXURE-P/1.
13. That years ago in November, 2011 and years after the match,
team, had alleged through media that the 1996 World Cup
semifinal between India and Sri Lanka was fixed. The news item
others, his team mates, BCCI, and even some cricket journalists
14. That in due course of his life Petitioner No.1 very well
cricket was not sporadic but continuous and total and that
only a drama. The world was largely unaware about that truth.
Line’ to make the world aware. The book dealt with all the
considered mad by his nears and dears but had full confidence in
28/1/2013 to share the truth with the world. Before that he was
self explanatory.
15. That here the petitioners shall try to summarize how cricket
betting is also going on, both in legal and illegal betting markets,
match result, i.e. odds are changing or may change after every
WWW.LIVELAW.IN 11
wickets. People feel elated when their team wins and feel
depressed when it loses, oblivious of the fact that the result was
already fixed between the two teams. They just enjoy the thrills
cricket look very thrilling, ignorant of what all goes behind the
scenes. They don’t know that there was a fixed match behind
Australia’.
could and would lose big money match after match, session after
and bookies would have gone bankrupt long ago and session
Beware’. The petitioners are sure that the Hon’ble Court would
one has done so till date though its existence has been
repeatedly brought to the notice of the world, BCCI and ICC, and
the government agencies for last three long years through press,
that didn’t mean that world should have ignored it, as it seems
signified.
20. That applying mind a little more, how do bookies offer odds for
make one predict how scoring will proceed in next few overs or
the import of such a revelation. The book brings out that Justice
22. That Javed Chutani has been mentioned to be one of the close
appears to have given any heed to it. Chutani, or any one, could
deliberation earlier,
https://www.facebook.com/BettorsBeware/:
While chasing even when Sri Lanka were a promising 30/0 in the
beginning of the 4th over, the odds remained below 1.3 in favour
of Pakistan..
Sure enough, Sri Lanka started losing wickets from there on like
nine pins and were soon out of contest.
It was a sure trap for the bettors. Given match position vis-a-vis
the match odds, the bettors would have been led to bet against
Pakistan to lose all the money put into bets.”
titled ‘IPL betting rates set by Dawood, says charge sheet’, how
years ago.
ANNEXURE-P/7.
24. That totally fixed cricket manifests itself in the plays in the field
in tournaments like IPL, BPL, BBL. PSL. CPL, across the world are
too evident at times to make one see that scripted cricket was
being acted out. When a batsman like Pollard taps a ball for a
single when boundary is required for his team to win, that one
mid-on of a ball he can hit rows behind over the boundary 10 out
of IPL 10 led by larger than life Virat Kohli fails repeatedly and
even gets all out for 49 runs in an innings, fixed and scripted
the lap of lone fielder in the deep and getting out so often when
fixing in IPL 6, must have meant when he said for the 61st match
WWW.LIVELAW.IN 17
the match one could easily know that it was fixed. This was in
girls and house-wives who watch cricket only casually and don’t
25. That Cricket could be a funny game, but players have certain
continuing to play for the team, there is only one explanation for
can be easily seen if one had eyes and an open mind. For
viewers often fail to see that such an act had been facilitated by
26. That once all above is known and understood, the rest follows.
It is not that some odd fixing is taking place in some odd match.
maverick, as reported.
investigation.
open grounds and stares us in the face from our TV sets 24x7. And all
amazing. More amazing is the fact that with this fraud publicly
you give a charlatan power over you, you almost never get it
back.”
in cricket. But that cannot justify the massive fraud and justify
allowing it to continue.
questions arise. Petitioner No.1 has dealt with all such questions
Waugh, a few years ago. Here are the excerpts from Petitioner
news.com.au.
from the prying eyes of the global media and more stringent
match officials.”
The former player said that these matters, apart from wider
Perth in 2010.
leads fully investigated, for fear that more star players might be
will always be there and has to be borne with by the fixers. That
dropped, batsman may get out in next ball or next few balls.
31. Another big question that arises is that if the scripted matches
this puzzling question lies hidden in the question itself. They are
public.
acquitted by the lower court, the Police have gone for appeal in
the High Court. At the time of arrest of Sreesanth then, the Delhi
water tight case and also the players were reported to have
under the chapter ‘Large Scale Fixing Gets Established but All
look the Other Way,’ in the book ‘Bettors Beware’ clearly brought
out how session fixing and hence match fixing did take place and
ANNEXURE-P/.
33. That as per TNN news report dated 12/2/2014 another match
the 12th over, CSK in spite of having a very strong batting line-up
play for India and even captain Indian Team. MS Dhoni is also
ANNEXURE-P/9.
34. That those were the days when IPL 6 scandal and Mudgal
the cricket muck and how with Dawood Ibrahim being behind
bothered a bit.
A true copy of the article ‘The IPL scam and 2014!’ by late
ANNEXURE-P/10.
35. That it was during this scandal three and half years ago that
Manohar had demanded probe into all matches of IPL 6 and even
marked as ANNEXURE-P/11.
Beware’ and his press meet in New Delhi in end February, 2014.
ANNEXURE-P/12.
37. That the Petitioner No.1 even made a detailed submission to the
happened.
ANNEXURE-P/13.
38. That a review of the book ‘Bettors Beware’ by the sports editor
miles-apart places.”
WWW.LIVELAW.IN 25
and sent the copies of his two books Inside the Boundary Line
even such a high profile committee considered the books and the
ANNEXURE-P/16.
41. That not resting in his crusade since his first press conference
42. That the public is mostly unaware of the money and number of
had told Hon’ble Supreme Court that more than Rs 3 lakh crore
lakh crore per year, and in all likelihood in the range of Rs 7-8
spot-fixing probe, said it could just be the tip of the iceberg. The
betting site alone. One could well imagine that the number of
‘UK website got Rs 1.9 lakh crore in cricket bets from India: ED’
ANNEXURE-P/18.
forwarded to Secretary, MHA for action in end July, 2015 vide Sl.
magnitude lied referred to one Sh. A.K. Patro, US (SP-I & III) by
44. That the Petitioner No.1 continued with email interaction with
ANNEXURE-P/21.
through book Bettors Beware is the fact that no one has been
take note and act one day, but unfortunately all ears have been
deaf till date. His email interactions with the Delhi Police
Awaaz on 21/4/2016.
46. That for last few years India and Pakistan have been playing
one such World Cup match in 2011, the script of the match got
match. The match went on more or less as per the leaked script.
47. That fixing in cricket has never been limited to IPL or other
marked as ANNEXURE-P/24.
48. That the Petitioner No.1 had been interacting with ICC and
BCCI also along with others through email without any result.
for necessary comprehension along with the letter, but still not a
has been posting about how matches are scripted to rob the
bettors from time to time for a few years now on facebook page
page is open to public. No one has been able to counter his logic
49. That the Petitioner No.1 has held many press conferences over
the years, the last being held on 1st April, 2017 in Kolkata
security as well.
ANNEXURE-P/27 respectively.
50. That the Petitioner No.1 organized press meets taking pains in
this ongoing massive fraud. But probably media has its own
them did cover his assertions, some of that coverage has been
facilitate this fraud. With BCCI and Union of India failing, even if
the nation, probably there would not have been any need to file
this petition.
51. That Law enforcing agencies are sleeping as they are known to
have slept or failed over the years as far as corrupt and fixed
that acquittal of Sreesanth and others from lower court has in all
Gurunath Meyappan and his links with bookies. This came out in
remarks:
impression that the police are not only ill-equipped to deal with
marked as ANNEXURE-P/28.
ANNEXURE-P/29.
reported to have spilled the beans telling that the match was
happened’.
marked as ANNEXURE-P/30.
54. That quite recently it was reported in media and was all
insider is reported to have told that match was not fixed. There
and make 120 to 130 run and will win, Parthiv Patel will hit
under 10, Polard will hit 1 six. None of such predictions could be
the annexed reports of Zee News and NDTV bringing this fact
out beat about the bush and did not say that it was a clear case
ANNEXURE-P/31.
ANNEXURE-P/32.
55. That since there was no official complaint about this match and
and that fixing was not at the behest of any outside bookies.
56. That in one swift move, all those were silenced for good who led
involved in fixing and that all could not combine to fix. One
why such a self goal was scored by the betting mafia. Anyone
57. That close on the heels of cricket insider proving to the world
“Sarfraz needs to be told that you have not done anything great.
Someone has helped you win the game. There is no reason for
the scenes. Don’t wish to get into the details on who won them
the games. If asked, I will say that the prayers of the fans and
God has won them the games. They have been brought to the
cricket journalists are also likely to know about those? Sohail did
spoken after Pakistan had won. He did not mention that this or
approval.
2017 FN. The time shown on the message indicated it had been
initiated at least a day before, i.e. before the start of the match
came good similar to what was done by Cricket Insider for IPL
59. That the petitioners are sure that anyone would be shocked to
learn how brazen and open the whole business of fixing in cricket
and befooling the gullible bettors has become after the prophetic
for some sessions and correct match result were predicted for 3rd
PLAYERS TO ME?!! NO worries it's all MONEY’. The fraud and the
in cricket and in the country. More than the muck itself, one
return if any information given by him was wrong. For the first T
him, he blocked Petitioner no. 1 and also didn’t furnish him with
one of the mafia were first recorded for IPL 10 final and then
Question arises that did the betting mafia or people on their own
and looting prospective bettors? Clearly it did not have fear and
marked as ANNEXURE-P/38.
far on all that is in public domain for years and on the repeated
support from any quarter in the society, has brought the things
to such a pass that people are today openly telling and showing
make any revelations. Either they had given indications that they
were going to reveal or it was feared that they could and would
reveal. They were those whose word would have carried a lot of
weight. The names that readily come to mind are Hansie Cronje
shashi-tharoor-ipl-isi-link-untold-
story/?utm_medium=onsignal&utm_source=onsignal&utm_camp
aign=onesignal&utm_content=onesignal)
ANNEXURE-P/39.
experts etc.
them would have been taken up and thrown out long back by
respective Boards and ICC, as is done with the few when they
66. That it is hoped that sufficient facts and material have been
that may appear to one. A lot more lies in the public domain
fixed matches are taking place around the globe in a year. The
petitioners are sure that they have been able to bring out
match for last decade or more to the Hon’ble Court or any jury
68. That by now, the Hon’ble Court must have appreciated the pains
continue with the crusade without much support has not been
easy. Yet they have been doing so since they realize it is not
coming generations.
69. That in the context of this petition, it may not be out of place to
"We can easily forgive a child who is afraid of the dark; the real
---- PLATO
WWW.LIVELAW.IN 45
country feel it their duty to bring the aforesaid facts to the notice
71. That the petitioners are preferring the present writ petition on
GROUNDS
https://www.facebook.com/BettorsBeware/ how
matter.
implications.
72. That the Petitioners have not filed any other petition before this
relief.
WWW.LIVELAW.IN 48
petition.
PRAYER
unearth the modus operandi of the on-going fraud & crime and
take appropriate and strict action under the law against all the
like KPL, TNPL etc. and other international matches too from
taking place in the country till culprits are brought to book or the
the facts and the circumstances of the present case in the larger
Filed by
Filed on : -10-2017