Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This document contains guidelines for the last year of your PhD-trajectory and was written by and for PhD-
students within the EMGO + Institute and William James Graduate School.
First, a timeline is presented for the last 12 months of your appointment. Secondly, important aspects are
explained in detail. In addition there are a number of appendices that might be useful in the end stage of your
project. Finally, sample letters are included which can be adapted to suit your own situation.
NOTE: The guidelines described in this document may vary per candidate depending on:
• The type of contract that you have: PhD student (AIO/OIO)/ junior researcher;
Therefore we recommend you discuss the content of these guidelines with your (co) promoters. Addresses,
web-addresses and phone numbers are given where possible. Relevant addresses and phone numbers can also
be found on the VU and VUmc websites.
If you have any additions, corrections or suggestions for these guidelines, you can send them to Tsjitske
Haanstra: t.haanstra @ vumc.nl
Write letters to grant funds for printing PhD student 4: Letter to grant funds
costs.
Call the Registrar (in dutch: pedel) (020- PhD student
5985309) pedel@vu.nl
The Registrar informs the PhD student on
the application for doctoral graduation, the
regulations and protocols and guides the
PhD student during the procedure
preceding a doctoral graduation. The
Registrar takes care of and checks all
required records.
5 Setting up an ad hoc Doctoral Examination Doctoral supervisor
months Committee (the supervisor or project
to go leader approaches in advance by mail /
phone the proposed Doctoral Examination
Committee and asks them to join the
Doctoral Examination Committee = reading
committee).
4 Letter to the dean with the proposal for the Doctoral 5: Letter with list Doctoral
months Doctoral Examination Committee plus supervisor/Secretary’s Examination Committee
to go details of the Doctoral Examination office
Committee (also by email).
Mail the Doctoral Examination Committee Doctoral supervisor
to notify them when to expect the
manuscript.
Letter plus manuscript to Doctoral Doctoral 6: Letter to send the manuscript to
Examination Committee supervisor/Secretariat the Doctoral Examination
of the dean of the Committee (NL and ENG)
faculty
Wait (30 days) for response Doctoral
Examination Committee
Send a letter to the Dean that the thesis Doctoral supervisor 7: Letter to the Dean
meets the requirements as well as the
requests from the Council of Deans and the
Registrar’s (pedel) office;
Form II is sent by the dean, when the 8: For your information: form II
message of the promoter on the approval
of the reading committee has arrived at the
Dean's Office.
Once a date has been set: send a letter to PhD student/doctoral 11: information for opponents (NL
the opposition supervisor and ENG)
Form for a large postal sending (or ask the PhD student
mailroom VUmc, 42687 or the secretary at
your department).
Discuss the order of opposition and send a Doctoral supervisor/ 10: Letter to Dean with order
letter to Dean (no later than 14 days before Secretary’s office opposition
the doctoral graduation takes place).
You will get a confirmation from the dean.
Send thesis to opponents with defense PhD student/ 11: Information defense to
date, order of opposition and further Secretary’s office opponents (NL en ENG)
details.
To complete your PhD trajectory successfully it is advisable to discuss the status of your thesis with your (co)
supervisor in the last quarter of your third year during your performance appraisal (jaargesprek). Discuss, for
example, whether the completion of the thesis within the contract time is feasible and, if that is not the case,
discuss possible solutions. Also discuss the completion of articles (including revisions) and how you will
approach this if you will be working elsewhere after the end of your contract. This conversation also provides
opportunities to discuss the state of affairs with regard to education and training and to discuss future career
possibilities. At the end of this document we give more attention to the continuation of your career in the
section 'Graduated, and then?’
3. Thesis Committee
In Appendix 1, the Joint guideline of the Graduate Schools of the Dutch University Medical Centres (NFU
guideline) is included. This is a guideline that indicates how many (published) articles are needed to graduate.
NOTE: It is a guideline and may therefore be debated or deviated from. So, determine in consultation with your
(co)supervisor the number of (published) articles in your thesis. Once you have selected the articles for your
thesis, you compose the manuscript for your thesis. Your thesis consists of at least: your articles, general
introduction and general discussion. At this stage you are advised to send the manuscript to your
supervisor(s)/advisor and co-supervisor(s) one more time. From this point it will take about 6 months before
your defense takes place, but this is hard to say precisely because you are dependent on the schedules of your
(co)supervisors and the defensee committee. Please note that there is a summer break from mid-July to late
August.
In principle your supervisors(s) decide in consultation with your co-supervisor(s) who will take seats on the
examination committee (also called thesis committee), but you can also express a preference yourself. Usually
the thesis committee consists of 4 to 6 members. The thesis committee members are generally your opponents
during the defense as well, but sometimes a member is absent and in that case the committee will be
expanded with two or three other members.
At least half of the members of the thesis committee should be professors. Further requirements for the thesis
committee can be found in the VU doctoral regulations. If you are interested, check the Promotion Rules of the
VU University on www.vu.nl -> Research -> PhD -> PhD at the VU -> PhD regulations.
In Appendix 6 an example of a letter for the members of the thesis committee stating when they can expect
the dissertation is included. The thesis manuscript then follows accompanied by a letter stating by which date
they should have assessed the manuscript. Do not only send this version of your thesis manuscript to the thesis
committee, but give your (co-) supervisors a copy of this manuscript as well. The thesis committee has exactly
one month to read and approve the manuscript, but they can ask for 30 days extra time. Often, the outline will
be approved. Small comments can still be processed, but you don’t need to return the adjusted manuscript to
to the thesis committee. It may also happen that chapters have to be rewritten, but your supervisor will try to
avoid this. Substantive suggestions / comments will be given to the supervisor or directly to you.
3.3 TIPS
• Bring your thesis, if possible, to the thesis committee yourself. Most committee members will appreciate this.
• The layout of your manuscript for the thesis committee does not have to be perfect but preferably place the
tables in the right place.
• Close before your defense, make brief visits to meet your opponents (if you do not know them), to make sure
they have received your manuscript in good order. You can use this opportunity to discuss your research with
them and get some idea about what questions they will ask during your defense.
• Your supervisor probably identifies what the opponents are probably going to ask, to prevent overlap in the
questions of your opponents. It is advised to schedule an informal meeting with your supervisors a few days
before the defense to ask whether there are specific things that you should keep in mind or study before your
defense.
4.2 LAYOUT
• Request an ISBN number from the printer or the University Library. The price is about 25 Euros.
• You can do the formatting yourself but you can also outsource it, for example to a graphic designer. The costs
will vary between 500-1500 Euros (incl. formatting the cover). Experienced and relatively inexpensive designers
are for example Esther Ris (www.proefschrifomslag.nl), Menno Hoope (www.mennohoope.nl) or Jeroen van
Wijngaarden (www.proefschrift-opmaken.nl).
• Make sure that you know exactly what program you need to format the thesis in to properly to deliver your
files.
• You often need to format your cover in a special software program (please check with your printing
company!). If you do not have this program and / or are not familiar with it, you need to find someone who can
help, or you can outsource the layout of the cover. Some printers have various software programs files with
default settings for the cover.
• You can place the tables in between in text, but you can also choose to place them after the results and
before the discussion in every chapter.
• You can format your manuscript to the actual size of your thesis or you can deliver it to your printing
company in A4 size (= size of your manuscript for the reading committee) which is then reduced by the printing
company to the proper size. If you opt for the latter, please check if everything is still readable.
• Ask the printer for advice on the width of the margins (or look at their information on thesis printing), have a
look at other theses to see what you like and mirror the margins of the left and right pages. Sometimes the
advice of printing company’s on margins is very spacious (the wider the margin, the more pages you need, the
more they earn!).
• When you are formatting your thesis one chapter at a time, please make sure that the settings of all chapters
are exactly the same (so always insert page numbers in the same way, same margins, etc.).
• Do not make PDF files with the Adobe Writer, but with Adobe Distiller! Procedure is as follows: make a print
file in Word via your own postscript printer / print file and then create a PDF with Adobe Distiller of the print
file. Only then you will be sure that the right settings and font are included For this last step you need a file
from the printing company, so you can use their font and settings. When you are making your thesis one
chapter at a time, make each chapter a PDF with Adobe Distiller, and then add these together using e.g. Adobe
Writer.
• When planning your graduation date you get a date by which the registrar (Pedel) should receive 10 printed
copies of your thesis (approximately 5 weeks before your defense). Take this into account when planning the
preparation and printing of your thesis (ask the printing company to also take this into account).
4.4 PLANNING
Discuss your timeline with the printing company carefully. Most companies need at least 3 weeks to print and
send your thesis. Count on 4 weeks from the moment you send the test files. The timing of printing is generally
very tight. Give your private (email) address for correspondence with the printer; VU-mail sometimes has a few
days delay or if your contract is expired it may be that your VU-mail wil be shut off suddenly. Especially sending
the files with your cover design can cause delays: due to their size and / or the extension of the files they do
not always go through the firewall. Furthermore the upload tool of the printing company may be temporarily
off. Of course you can also send these files on a CD / by post / via dropbox or wetransfer. To be sure, count on
a few extra days in your schedule for the printing. Also make sure you schedule time for proofreading and
correcting proofs. Sometimes you only get 48 hours to do this.
4.5 TIPS
• Ask friends and colleagues to read one chapter each to check lay-out/text/tables etc.
• At the annual ProVU PhD day (usually in December) printers’ representatives are often present They often
give away discount cards.
• Ask for a timeline at the printing company, so that you can make a schedule. Often at least one thing does
not go according to plan, so keep this in mind when you are planning.
5. Sending your thesis
2 A self-specified selection:
All staff involved in the project ;
A selection of the other EMGO academic staff (max. 10);
A selection of national or international experts on the specific topic of the thesis (max. 10);
Also consult with your (co) supervisors about other relevant contacts.
You are in possession of the full copyright of a chapter: there is no obstacle in making this chapter
available through the University Library website (for instance papers published in BMC journals);
You have transferred the copyright of a chapter to a publisher. In this case check with the publisher
whether you are allowed to make the chapter available to a University Library and under what
embargo period. You can find this information in the agreement with the publisher or visit:
www.sherpa.ac.uk/romeo.php (an overview of the policies of many leading publishers regarding
copyright);
The chapter isn’t published yet; you can specify how long you want an embargo period to last. The
license agreement states that you must eventually deal with the publisher on the embargo when your
paper is accepted. A copy of the agreement on the embargo should be sent to the University Library,
because of the embargo duration on your complete dissertation .
5. 3 TIPS
Be prepared: make mailing lists, print invitations for a party, arrange envelopes and get some help to
put everything together. When everything is ready in envelopes, make an appointment with the
transport service to send off your mail items.
Make sure that the invitation for your defense/party is ready to assemble immediately with your
thesis.
Arrange colleagues or your assistants/ paranymphs, for packing the theses and invitations.
Send the dissertations for your reading committee yourself, even though the information you get from
the registrar/pedel states that they will take care of that (this appears not to be case!).
The theses for your opposition members should be accompanied by a standard letter on behalf of you
and your (co) supervisors.
NOTE: some people may be on multiple mailing lists. You can send your dissertation at your own
discretion. Others you may decide not to send it to because the subject of your research really has no
relevance for their own research.
6. 2 FUNDS
Once the manuscript has been sent to the reading committee, you may approach funding agencies to raise
money for the printing costs of your dissertation. If you start at this point in time with raising money, the name
of funders can still be included in your thesis. You might think of the Heart Foundation, Kurt Lewin Institute,
KWF, the Anna-fund, or pharmaceutical companies. Check other theses or nuffic grantfinder to get ideas for
possible funding agencies. In the appendix a sample letter is included which you can use to approach funding
agencies. It is wise to call an agency first to enquire whether you have a chance, because it will save you a lot of
time. Only names of funders can be included in the thesis, logo’s or symbols are not allowed, make sure you
communicate this to the funders.
6.3 VU ARRANGEMENT
Each PhD student will receive € 500, - from the College of Deans as a contribution towards the
costs. Information at:
Registrar’s office VU (pedel), Room 2D-09
De Boelelaan 1105
1081 HV Amsterdam
Tel. 020 – 5985309 / 5985307
Email: pedel@vu.nl
6. 4 PROMOTION BONUS
The collective agreement of academic hospitals states (Article 17.4.4) that PhD students who successfully finish
their thesis within their employment period are entitled to a one-time promotional bonus of 750 euros gross
(at FPP this amount is 2500 euros). This applies only to candidates with a PhD / OiO appointment at the VU
Medical Centre, not to junior researchers. You can claim the money by letting your doctoral supervisor/co-
supervisor fill out a change form and to sign for approval (see P&O intranet VUmc).
6.5 TIPS
Be on time with applying for grants to cover printing costs, this allows you to include names of the
funders in your thesis. Only names of funders can be included in the thesis, logo’s are not allowed,
make sure you communicate this to the funders.
Check the website of VU and VUmc for possible funding agencies.
At the NUFFIC website (almost) all scholarships / funds in the Netherlands are listed. Perhaps there is
also a funding agency that is applicable to you. http://www.nuffic.nl/en/scholarships/grantfinder
7. DEFENSE
7.1 REGISTRAR/PEDEL
The moment you contact the registrar (pedel) you will be sent a folder including information on:
Number of dissertation copies that the registrar expects of you;
Date at which dissertation copies should be delivered;
Example of a title page;
Leaflet with the formula to use at the defense ceremony;
Attire/ clothing rental addresses, addresses photographers;
Forms to order a reception;
Form for the audio-visual services;
Writing a "press release".
You can set a date for your defense at the registrar. Take into account the fact that the completion of the thesis
(layout, abstract, sponsorship, etc.) and preparing your defense are time-consuming.
7.2 PARANYMPHS
The paranymphs are usually (college) friends, colleagues, and sometimes family members. Paranymphs may
also answer questions from the opponents. This never happens, but it is allowed. During the reception and
party the paranymphs are the ones that make sure everything runs smoothly, the can for example label and
secure received gifts.
7.4 SYMPOSIUM
You may choose to organize a symposium. Discuss this with your (co) supervisors. Often, a (co)supervisor
brings it up herself. For any foreign opponents this will make their visit more attractive and they can also give a
presentation themselves. As a PhD student it is usually not necessary to present during the symposium.
7.5 PROMOTION
The committee that will question you during the defense consists of the reading committee (4-5 members),
and 2-3 additional members. Make sure you know your thesis by heart! Every member will probably have
his/her own favourite subject, so you can in advance where everyone’s question will be about.
From about 30 minutes before the ceremony on the day of the defense a preparation room is available for you
and your paranymphs (appropriately called ‘the sweatroom’). About 20 minutes before the ceremony the
registrar (pedel) will come in to tell you about the defense protocol. Often, the professor who chairs during
your defense will contact you in advance for a short interview. Try not to worry too much. According to many
persons that preceded you, it’s easier than it looks.
7.6 RECEPTION
In the information you received from the registrar (pedel) there is a form with four standard reception
packages from the caterer of the VU (Sodexo), but you can also specify your own specific package. In the latter
case you can download a form from the Internet (VU -> facility service -> catering facilities). There is also a pdf
document with the total list of bites and drinks, including pricing.
There are two rates: one with and one without assistance from catering personnel, if you order catering
without personnel you are responsible to clean up yourself and leave the room tidy. Sometimes there is
confusion regarding which pricing is applicable for the reception, therefore it is important to check this in
advance and preferably by e-mail so you won’t get into a discussion afterwards. For more information please
check the caterers website or contact them through email or phone ( vu.sodexoeducation.nl/en/ )
Regarding the quantities: order coffee / tea 'economical' (often there is something more in the can). When it
comes to soft drinks/wine you might count on higher quantities, because you’ll only pay what you used during
the reception. It is not mandatory to have your reception at the VU, you can also have it elsewhere ,The Basket
for example, is a good alternative.
7.7 DINNER
It is a tradition is to treat your project-team and family members to a dinner on the day of the
defense. Obviously this is not mandatory and you can also choose to do things differently. For example, by
inviting a broader selection of people to a buffet-style dinner.
7.8 PARTY
Be on time with searching for a party location, especially when your defense is on a Thursday or Friday. When
you arrange the location before printing your thesis the invitation for dinner/party can be printed at the same
time with the right location on a ‘bookmark’ which you can insert in copies of your thesis.
7.9 TIPS
Organize a symposium for your defense.
Is there an international participant in your committee? Offer to help with finding a hotel, flight, and
recommend nice restaurants, things to do etc. in Amsterdam.
Start early with thinking about who you want to ask as paranymphs during your defense.
Book tip: 'Klaar in vier jaar' by: De Bruin and Hertz.
Consider buying presents for supervisors, research assistants, and possibly opposition members.
Think of music you want to play before, during breaks and after your defense ceremony.
Think about whether you would like to hire a photographer and sound recording/film recordings
(provided by the audio-visual service).
Please note that certain times of the year (just before the summer and Christmas holidays) and
certain days (Friday) are extra popular for defense ceremonies and that there are limited options
available.
Remember that it is not possible to have your defense in July and / or August (summer break).
Think of a reply to the 10 questions that you would not want to get during your defense.
8.1 TAX
The costs for the defense are tax deductible as “training costs”. This is because the defenae leads to an
improvement in the financial position of the candidate. The costs surrounding the ceremony are also tax
deductible, such as the rental of clothing for the occasion for yourself and / or your paranymphs. The costs of
your reception are also included. For more information see the IRS
(http://www.promotiewijzer.nl/financien/belastingen).
Hopefully during your PhD you have thought about and discussed this question extensively. You may already
have taken some concrete actions to secure your career within or outside the scientific community. Possibly
your supervisor helped you here, or maybe not at all, and you now have no idea how to proceed.
To ensure that you do not get disillusioned and end up in unemployment needlessly, we recommend that at
the beginning of your last year of your PhD you reflect on the question of what you want to do after your
promotion. We recommend you to discuss the topic with you (co) supervisors. What opportunities does he /
she see for you? And if there is no scientific career for you, what kind of job fits your interest and skills beyond
the research community? Do you even know what kind of knowledge and skills you have? Which competencies
have you developed during your PhD? And which skills do jobs outside of the scientific community require?
You will usually be able to discuss these topics with your (co) supervisors . In addition, you can discuss this topic
with fellow PhD students. Further, both the VU and VUmc offer various tools for career orientation.
ProVU organizes career days; the Amstel Academy offers trainings especially for PhD students; and career
counselors offered for instance by VUmc can help you finding the answers to a specific question or explore the
possibilities of your future career.
• Career
PhD students are encouraged to think about their career after the PhD program. If you need help you can
contact the career coaches of the VU. If you are interested in career advice, please include contact Leo Miller of
the Study Course and Career.
See also:
http://www.vumc.nl/opleidingen/voor-academici/persoonlijkeontwikkeling/
Do not wait until the last minute to reflect on these career questions, talk about it with others, and especially
make use of the opportunities available to you free of charge.
The appendices contain the letters, forms and regulations you will need to obtain your PhD. We will try to keep
them as up to date as possible, however this doesn’t always succeed. Be aware that these letters and
regulations constantly change, specifically in the process of digitalizing many of the procedures. We would like
to advise you to check intranet regularly for the most recent versions of the documents.
Kijk ook op:
http://intranet/27557/32531/3884087/3884107/4225404/NFU_guidelines_for_PhD_trac1.p
df
for the most recent versions of forms and letters please go to
http://intranet/afdelingen/dienst/sbp/01Bestuur/Decanaat/Promotie/
De hooggeleerde heer
Prof. dr. <naam decaan>
<adres>
Geachte decaan,
Gaarne ontvang ik van u het besluit van instelling van deze commissie, waarvan ik aanneem
dat ook de andere leden een afschrift zullen ontvangen.
………….., suporvisor
Amsterdam, <datum>
«Begroetingsregel»
Op < voorlopige promotiedatum> zal ik promoveren aan de Faculteit der <naam faculteit>
van de VU te Amsterdam, op het proefschrift getiteld: “<titel proefschrift>”.
Dit onderzoek is uitgevoerd onder leiding van de promotoren <naam> en <naam> en co-
promotor <naam>. <Beschrijf kort doel onderzoek en resultaten>
Hierbij wil ik «Naam_Instelling» vragen, mede namens mijn promotoren, om een deel van de
drukkosten van het proefschrift te sponsoren. Als tegenprestatie wordt «Naam_Instelling»
vermeld in het proefschrift en krijgt u twee exemplaren van het proefschrift toegestuurd.
<naam>
<contactgegevens>
De hooggeleerde heer
Prof. dr. <naam decaan>
<adres>
Geachte decaan,
Bijgaand ontvangt u een voorstel voor de ad hoc beoordelingscommissie voor het proef-
schrift van drs. ………... Het voorstel voldoet aan de criteria van de in december 2002
vastgelegde promotieregeling Faculteit <naam faculteit>.
Gaarne ontvang ik van u het besluit van instelling van deze commissie, waarvan ik aanneem
dat ook de andere leden een afschrift zullen ontvangen.
……….. promotor
Cc. …., copromotor
cc. …., promovenda
Geachte XXX,
Als decaan en voorzitter van de promotiecommissie van <Naam faculteit> dank ik u hartelijk
voor uw toezegging om plaats te willen nemen in de leescommissie voor het proefschrift van
…………… . De titel van deze dissertatie is “……………”. De promotor is/De promotoren zijn
professor …………… en copromotor is/de copromotoren zijn …………… . De volledige
samenstelling van de leescommissie is als volgt:
……………….
……………….
……………….
……………….
De leescommissie heeft tot taak het kwalitatief beoordelen van het proefschrift. De
leescommissie bestaat, behalve de promotor die de commissie voorzit, uit ten minste vier
leden. Volgens het promotiereglement van de Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam dient u, bij
aanvaarding van zitting in de leescommissie, binnen 30 dagen na ontvangst van het te
beoordelen proefschrift schriftelijk advies uit te brengen aan de promotiecommissie in de
persoon van de promotor die de leescommissie voorzit. Het staat de leden van de
leescommissie vrij hun oordeel vergezeld te doen gaan van suggesties en/of aanbevelingen.
De promotor zal de promovendus dan in overweging geven zijn proefschrift overeenkomstig
deze aanbevelingen aan te passen. Echter uw toestemming om het proefschrift toe te laten
tot verdediging kan niet afhankelijk worden gesteld van door de promovendus aan te
brengen veranderingen. De promotor zal u over de gang van zaken bij promoties aan de
Vrije Universiteit alle gewenste inlichtingen kunnen verschaffen. U vindt het
Promotiereglement Vrije Universiteit op www.vu.nl -> Onderzoek -> Promoveren ->
Promoveren aan de VU -> promotiereglement.
Ten slotte wordt u uitgenodigd om als lid van de promotiecommissie aanwezig te zijn bij de
verdediging van het proefschrift door de promovendus. Gedurende deze bijeenkomst wordt
u geacht als opponent de promovendus te ondervragen. Datum en tijd van de promotie zal
in overleg met u worden bepaald.
<Naam decaan>
decaan
Appendix 6b: Beoordelingsformulier manuscript per lid leescommissie
Titel proefschrift:
……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..…………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………..
2. Wetenschappelijke kwaliteit:
3. Presentatie/leesbaarheid:
4. Algemeen oordeel:
CONCLUSIE: ondergetekende acht de promovendus wel/niet* toelaatbaar tot de verdediging
van het proefschrift.
…………….. ……………………………………………………..
Dear XXX,
As Dean and Chair of the Doctorate Examination Committee of the <Name of Faculty> of VU
University Amsterdam, I am very grateful that you have indicated your willingness to serve
as a member of the Thesis Committee for the doctoral thesis of ……………. . The title of this
dissertation is “………….”. The supervisor is/The supervisors are Professor ………. and …………….
act(s) as co-supervisor(s). The Thesis Committee comprises the following members:
………………
………………
………………
………………
Your main task as a member of the committee is to read the manuscript and to indicate
whether in your view it makes a sufficient contribution to justify the award of the doctorate.
This can be a very brief, formal statement. The reading committee has at least four members
in addition to the supervisor who chairs the committee. In accordance with the Doctorate
Regulations of VU University Amsterdam, you are asked to inform the supervisor of your
judgement in writing within 30 days of receipt of the manuscript. If the committee approves
the thesis the candidate will be admitted to the public defense. At that stage the award of
the doctorate is in effect already beyond doubt. The supervisor will be able to provide you
with all the relevant information about the course of events for Doctor’s degrees at VU
University Amsterdam. The Doctorate Regulations of VU University Amsterdam are
published on the internet: www.vu.nl -> research -> PhD doctoral -> obtaining a PhD at VU -
>Doctorate Regulations.
The manuscript will be sent to you by the supervisor. If in addition to your judgement on the
quality of the thesis you want to send comments to improve the manuscript this would be
most welcome. The supervisor will encourage the candidate to revise the thesis accordingly
if time permits. I should point out that your approval cannot be conditional on changes to be
made by the candidate.
Finally, as a member of the Doctorate Examination Committee you are also invited to take
part in the public ceremony at which the thesis is defended and the doctorate is conferred.
During that ceremony, you are expected to examine the candidate. Date and time will be
scheduled in consultation.
Yours sincerely,
<Name dean>
dean
Name member reading committee: ……………………………………………………………………………
Form, as a part of the assessment to allow the PhD student to defend his/her thesis.
Title thesis:
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
5. Originality/innovation:
6. Scientific quality:
7. Presentation/legibility:
8. Overall assessment:
CONCLUSION: the undersigned advises to allow/not allow* the PhD student to defend the
thesis.
…………….. ……………………………………………………..
(date) (signature)
De hooggeleerde heer
Geachte decaan,
Het doet mij genoegen dat ik u kan berichten dat de door u voor bovengenoemd
proefschrift ingestelde ad hoc beoordelingscommissie unaniem van oordeel is 'dat het
proefschrift voldoet aan de eisen die gesteld mogen worden voor de toekenning van
het doctoraat'.
Ik verzoek u het College van Decanen en het Bureau van de Pedel van het positieve
oordeel op de hoogte te stellen door middel van Formulier II. Uiterlijk 10 dagen voor
de promotiedatum zal ik u de volgorde van de oppositie en de gegevens over de
opponenten doen toekomen.
<naam promotor>
www.vu.nl
De commissie heeft op advies van de daartoe ingestelde leescommissie besloten de promovendus toe
te laten tot de verdediging van het proefschrift.
Datum
Handtekening
VOORSTEL MET BETREKKING TOT TOEVOEGING ANDERE PERSONEN AAN DE PROMOTIECOMMISSIE EX ART. 13
LID 7 EN UITVOERINGSBESLUIT 6 PROMOTIEREGLEMENT VU
deskundigheid
deskundigheid
deskundigheid
deskundigheid
deskundigheid
deskundigheid
deskundigheid
deskundigheid
Amsterdam, <datum>
Betreft: Proefschrift
Ik wens u veel plezier met het lezen van het proefschrift en hoop u te zien bij mijn promotie
op
<naam>
<contactgegevens>
for the most recent versions of forms and letters please go to
http://intranet/afdelingen/dienst/sbp/01Bestuur/Decanaat/Promotie/
Geachte decaan,
In verband met de verdediging door <naam promovendus> van de dissertatie <titel proefschrift> op
maandag <datum> om <tijdstip> uur, doe ik u de volgende gegevens toekomen:
Volgorde van oppositie:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
De promovendus/a zal eerst een korte inleiding houden over zijn/haar proefschrift van maximaal 10 minuten.
Voor alle leden van de commissie zijn vervolgens ongeveer 10 minuten per opponent beschikbaar. Uiteraard
zijn genoemde tijden inclusief de repliek van de promovendus/a.
<naam>, 1e promotor
e
cc. ………….., 2 promotor
cc. ………….. , copromotor
cc. …………., promovendus
Other example letters can be derived from:
http://intranet/afdelingen/dienst/sbp/01Bestuur/Decanaat/Promotie/
In Nederlands:
Geachte collega,
Bijgaand vindt u een exemplaar van het proefschrift van drs. …..
De titel luidt "……………".
Het doet mij genoegen u te kunnen meedelen dat de beoordelingscommissie unaniem van mening is dat
het proefschrift voldoet aan de eisen die gesteld mogen worden aan de toekenning van een doctoraat.
Wellicht ten overvloede, wil ik u herinneren aan uw deelname aan de oppositie tijdens de promotie op
…………… om ……….. uur in de Vrije Universiteit. De promovendus zal eerst een korte inleiding (max. 10
minuten) houden over haar proefschrift. Vervolgens is voor de oppositie ongeveer 10 minuten
uitgetrokken per lid van de commissie. Uiteraard is genoemde tijd inclusief de repliek van de
promovendus. Met betrekking tot de volgorde van oppositie wil ik het volgende voorstellen:
De promotie zal plaatsvinden in de aula van de Vrije Universiteit. U wordt vriendelijk verzocht om een
half uur voor aanvang (dus om ….. uur) aanwezig te zijn in de Forumzaal, kamernummer 2D-02.
Voor de gasten van buiten de Vrije Universiteit: de Togakamer vindt u rechts in de hal van het
e
Auditorium (1 verdieping). Alle genoemde ruimten bevinden zich in het hoofdgebouw van de Vrije
Universiteit, De Boelelaan 1105, Amsterdam.
Teneinde doublures te voorkomen en waar nodig de vragen op elkaar af te kunnen stemmen, zal ik enkele
dagen voor de promotie nog telefonisch contact met u opnemen.
<naam>, 1e promotor
e
dd. ………….., 2 promotor
dd. ………….. , copromotor
cc. …………., promovendus
In English:
Dear colleague,
I would like to take this opportunity to inform you on the procedures during the official
ceremony, in which you agreed to participate. The ceremony on …..
will start at …
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
The ceremony will take place in the Aula of the main building of the Vrije Universiteit,
De Boelelaan 1117, Amsterdam.
All members of the opposition are requested to be present half an hour before the start of
the ceremony (at 1.15) at the Forum Room, 2D-02.
Looking forward to seeing you,
GOOD LUCK!