Professional Documents
Culture Documents
implementation in generators
Cen Zhang
• Summary
Approach
• SM Lagrangian supplemented with DIM-6 operators (hence SMEFT)
X Ci Oi
LEFT = LSM +
i
⇤2
At https://feynrules.irmp.ucl.ac.be/wiki/ModelDatabaseMainPage
you can find a list of EFT models ready for use.
EFTs with Sherpa
Silvan Kuttimalai
ũ ⌫¯µ
+ +
1 W
M
BS
Sherpa MC
3 /GeV]
5
Full ME
Correlated decays
4 Uncorrelated decays
M
2
PDF PDF
0
2
d2 (corr)+ d2 (full)
MI
1
corr full
0
-1
-2
p
Current Development
BS
tree-level merging
PDF PDF
I First steps towards fixed-order
NLO with OpenLoops
MI
EFT with Whizard
(Thank Jürgen Reuter)
CP-even CP-odd
Multi-vector boson
• Dim-6 TGC: UFO and VBFNLO
CP-even CP-odd
pp>W+W+jj
• Dim-8 QGC: UFO, Whizard, VBFNLO
https://feynrules.irmp.ucl.ac.be/wiki/AnomalousGaugeCoupling
• 33 CP-even + 6 CP-odd
• 34 operators relevant for Higgs
• Flavor-universal
• SILH: hep-ph/0703164, Guildice et al.
• F1: W/Z to ffbar (V/A)
• F2: EW/chromo-dipoles
• G: Gauge-boson self interaction
Current, 300fb-1,3000fb-1
TGC not included
EW sector probed by PEWM+TGC+Higgs: 8+3+8
assuming flavor symmetry
1. PEWM
(-)
• E.g.
• Also check
Rosetta: an operator basis translator for SM EFT
[1508.05895, Falkowski et al.]
(Warsaw, SILH, Higgs basis, …)
Going to NLO in QCD
with EFT
• With MADGRAPH5_AMC@NLO, all we need for EFT @ NLO is the Dim-6 UV
and R2 counterterms.
• Alternatively, there are case studies, not fully automated. For example, can
take UV CTs from [1312.2014 Alonso et al.]
https://feynrules.irmp.ucl.ac.be/wiki/NLOModels
• Higgs Characterisation [P. Artoisenet et al. 2013] [F. Demartin et al. 2014] [F. Demartin et al. 2015]
On going developments:
HEL at NLO
(Degrande, Fuks, Mawatari, Mimasu, Sanz)
Top EFT
Flavor-
conserving
Flavor-
changing
(neutral)
Flavor-
changing
(neutral)
• Decays and FCNC direct t production is available analytically.
[1404.1264 CZ], [1305.7386 F. Maltoni, CZ], [hep-ph/0508016 J.J.Liu et al.]
Flavor-
conserving
Flavor-
changing
(neutral)
• Decays and FCNC direct t production is available analytically.
[1404.1264 CZ], [1305.7386 F. Maltoni, CZ], [hep-ph/0508016 J.J.Liu et al.]
• FCNC associated productions have been implemented.
[1412.5594 Degrande, Maltoni, Wang, CZ] http://feynrules.irmp.ucl.ac.be/wiki/TopFCNC
Flavor-
conserving
Flavor-
changing
(neutral)
Top-FCNC operators
available at
http://feynrules.irmp.ucl.ac.be/wiki/TopFCNC
• Decays and FCNC direct t production is available analytically.
[1404.1264 CZ], [1305.7386 F. Maltoni, CZ], [hep-ph/0508016 J.J.Liu et al.]
• FCNC associated productions have been implemented.
[1412.5594 Degrande, Maltoni, Wang, CZ] http://feynrules.irmp.ucl.ac.be/wiki/TopFCNC
Flavor-
conserving
Flavor-
changing
(neutral)
• Decays and FCNC direct t production is available analytically.
[1404.1264 CZ], [1305.7386 F. Maltoni, CZ], [hep-ph/0508016 J.J.Liu et al.]
• FCNC associated productions have been implemented.
[1412.5594 Degrande, Maltoni, Wang, CZ] http://feynrules.irmp.ucl.ac.be/wiki/TopFCNC
Flavor-
conserving
Flavor-
changing
(neutral)
Flavor-
conserving
Flavor-
changing
(neutral)
ttbar+V
CfQ
H3L
0 0
-1 -1
-2 -2
-3 -3
-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4
CtW H1,3L
CqQ
3 3
NLO
• Operator fit with
2 LO 2 NLO
NLO xsecs:
Decay LO
improved limits 1 1
CfQ
H3L
• Corrections on
0 0
on distributions
-1 -1
can be important
-2 -2
0.25
dσ
σ dy -3t-channel single top 0.012 -3
dσ
σ dp
[GeV-1] t-channel single top
-8 -6 -4 -2
LHC13, (N)LO+PYTHIA LHC13, (N)LO+PYTHIA
t T,j
0 2 4 -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4
H1,3L
(3) (3)
0.2 0.01 OφQ LO OφQ NLO
CtW
0.15 0.008 CqQ
OtW LO OtW NLO
0.006
0.1
(3) (3)
OφQ LO OφQ NLO
0.004
0.05
OtW LO OtW NLO 0.002
0
0
MadGraph5_aMC@NLO
MadGraph5_aMC@NLO
(3) (3)
OφQ NLO LO OφQ NLO LO
1.4
1.2 1.5
1
1
0.8
OtW NLO LO OtW NLO LO
1.4
1.2 1.5
1
1
0.8
−4 −3 −2 −1 0 1 2 3 4 0 50 100 150 200 250 300
y p
t T,j
• Decays and FCNC direct t production is available analytically.
[1404.1264 CZ], [1305.7386 F. Maltoni, CZ], [hep-ph/0508016 J.J.Liu et al.]
• FCNC associated productions have been implemented.
[1412.5594 Degrande, Maltoni, Wang, CZ] http://feynrules.irmp.ucl.ac.be/wiki/TopFCNC
Flavor-
conserving
Flavor-
changing
(neutral)
Flavor-
conserving
Flavor-
changing
(neutral)
pp→t t H at LHC13
0.005 (N)LO (Fixed order)
Λ=1 TeV
SM, LO SM, NLO
0.004 c tG=0.25 LO c tG=0.25 NLO
MadGraph5_aMC@NLO
0.002
0.001
[in fb]
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
pT [GeV]
H
• Decays and FCNC direct t production is available analytically.
[1404.1264 CZ], [1305.7386 F. Maltoni, CZ], [hep-ph/0508016 J.J.Liu et al.]
• FCNC associated productions have been implemented.
[1412.5594 Degrande, Maltoni, Wang, CZ] http://feynrules.irmp.ucl.ac.be/wiki/TopFCNC
Flavor-
conserving
Flavor-
changing
(neutral)
Flavor-
conserving
Flavor-
changing
(neutral)
• SM Lagrangian
supplemented with
DIM-6 operators
(hence SMEFT)
X Ci Oi
LEFT = LSM +
i
⇤2
35
Basis
EW-Higgs operators: a comparison [S. Willenbrock and CZ 2014]
0
⇣ ! ⌘
— — OB = ig2 H † D µ H @ ⌫ Bµ⌫
⇣ ! ⌘2
⇤
O'D = '† Dµ ' '† D µ ' O ,1 = (Dµ )† †
(Dµ ) OT = 12 H † D µ H
O'⇤ = ('† ')⇤('† ') O ,2 = 12 @µ ( † )@ µ ( † ) OH = 12 (@ µ |H|2 )2
1 3
O' = ('† ')3 O ,3 =3 †
O6 = |H|6
— O ,4 = (Dµ )† (Dµ )( † ) —
• EOM can be applied in both directions
In Warsaw/BW basis, only OBW and O3W enters directly. Remaining degree
of freedom comes from shifting input parameters.
t-ch. NLO
10− 1 10−1 t t +Z NLO
t+W LO t t +γ LO
−2
6×10
5×10− 2 t+W NLO 4×10−2 t t +γ NLO
4×10− 2 3×10−2
3×10 −2
s-ch. LO 2×10−2 t t LO
1.4 σ (1)
i (LO)
i
σ NLO =767 pb
σ NLO
s-ch.
=10.1 pb tt
1.2
1.2
1
(3) (1)
1 (3) OtW OtG OφQ OφQ Oφt OtW OtB OtG
OφQ
TGC fit, with W-pair production, plus Higgs data
Signal-strength data
combined with TGC
(Higgs, TGC, combination)
See also [A. Falkowski, F. Riva 2014] [A. Pomarol, F. Riva 2013]
[T. Corbett et al. 2015] [T. Corbett et al. 2013]