IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF NORTH CAROLINA

SOUTHERN DIVISION
No. 7:14-CV-237-BR FILED IN OPEN
ON_f/3 ''rURT
JAMES JACOBS, et al., )
)
~A.~~
a.r-
us D#atrtct Co Jr.,
Plaintiffs, ) Eastem Distr1J'!, Ne
)
v. ) VERDICT
)
MURPHY-BROWN LLC, )
)
Defendant. )

1. "Did the defendant substantially and unreasonably interfere with the plaintiffs use
(
and enjoyment of his or her property?"

James Jacobs Answer:¥S

Jimmy Carr Answer:"'f£--'J

Lucy Sidberry Answer: ¥:£-S

Joyce Messick Answer:~

Willie Messick Answer:~

Edna Allison Answer: '1.f5

2. "What amount of damages, if any, is the plaintiff entitled to recover from the

defendant?"

James Jacobs Answer:$ -

S \ 000,QQO
' 1

Jimmy Carr Answer:$ 5\VOO} ooO

Lucy Sidberry Answer: $ 4 \ 0 00\ o0 C)

Case 7:14-cv-00237-BR Document 221 Filed 08/03/18 Page 1 of 3

....

Joyce Messick Answer:$ 3 l 0001 DOU

Willie Messick Answer: $ ~ I 000 1 00<.J

Edna Allison Answer:$ :3,..s-oo, 0 oc)

3. "Is the defendant liable to the plaintiff for punitive damages?"

James Jacobs Answer: yes

Jimmy Carr Answer: y-l! S

Lucy Sidberry Answer:¥6

Joyce Messick Answer: "f-6

Willie Messick Answer:¥f5

Edna Allison Answer: ye..5

4. "What amount of punitive damages, if any, does the jury in its discretion award to

the plaintiff?"

James Jacobs Answer:$ -7.s, ODO\ 000

Jimmy Carr

Lucy Sidberry Answer:$ 7S100u,ooO

<

Joyce Messi_ck Answer: $ 7.(, 0 00 \ 0 DU

Willie Messick Answer: $ 16'1 c)O() 1 6 c;)()

Edna Allison

Case 7:14-cv-00237-BR Document 221 Filed 08/03/18 Page 2 of 3

, ...

Foreperson

Date

Case 7:14-cv-00237-BR Document 221 Filed 08/03/18 Page 3 of 3