Professional Documents
Culture Documents
QUESTIONS
[---]
Survey: HCFR Employee Engagement Survey
HCFR Employee Engagement Survey
The survey was developed and is being managed by an independent third party, Dr. Crysta Metcalf who has been contracted by
Local 2294. The survey will be hosted on the Internet and she will collect your responses online. All responses will remain strictly
anonymous. We will not be able to trace individual responses back to any person. Local 2294 will only see combined data for the
total respondents statistically individualized by specific demographic groupings.
The survey will be open for the next 14 days ending on 04/03/18. Local 2294 will be sharing and analyzing the results, once
completed, with both the membership and Hillsborough County officials. The Executive Board will be discussing afterwards the
best way to improve the culture and performance issues identified within the survey.
We would like to get 100% participation in order to ensure that each and every employee's voice is heard. When you receive the
survey request please give it your prompt attention. Thank you very much for your time and support. Please start the survey now
by clicking on the NEXT button below.
-- Select --
* Age:
-- Select --
* Sex:
-- Select --
-- Select --
* Addressing grievances
* Promoting personnel
* Mentoring
I have confidence in the Union's Principal Officers to negotiate in the member's best interest for:
* Wages
I have confidence in the Union's Principal Officers to represent the member’s best interest for:
* Address grievances
I am satisfied with:
* My pay
* My overall benefits
*
I can vote my conscience on all contracts without fear of retaliation from management.
Yes
No
*
If I had an employment opportunity with equal pay and benefits, I would leave HCFR today.
Yes
No
6859(<
[ANSWERED]
EMPLOYEE
ENGAGEMENT
SURVEY
LOCAL 2294
Population Survey
Battalion Chief Battalion Chief
Fire Captain Fire Captain
Driver/Engineer Driver/Engineer
Firefighter Firefighter
Firemedic Firemedic
Lieutenant Lieutenant
Paramedic Paramedic
Dispatch Dispatch
Inspection Inspection
Training Training
DESCRIPTIVE
STATISTICS
Descriptive statistics are simply numbers and percentages.
49.8% of respondents do not believe they can vote their conscience on a contract
without fear of retaliation from management
I believe my fellow firefighters and paramedics have been or would be treated fairly in
disciplinary actions by the department administration:
• 77.6% disagree or strongly disagree
• 17% neither agree nor disagree
• 5.4% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01
ADMINISTRATION
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Appreciation:
• 77.9% of respondents indicated that they disagreed or strongly
disagreed that they were appreciated by the department administration
• 15.6% neither agreed nor disagreed
• 6.5% felt they were appreciated
Correlated with morale. p<.01
Recognition:
• 54.6% were unsatisfied with the department administration recognition
they get for their achievements
• 34% were neutral
• 11.4% were satisfied with the recognition they got from the department
administration
Correlated with morale. p<.01
HEALTH 1
The fire chief and department administration are taking the right
approach to reducing firefighter, paramedic and dispatch fatigue:
• 83.3% disagree or strongly disagree (54.4% strongly disagree)
• 14.2% neither agree nor disagree
• 2.5% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01
The fire chief and department administration are taking the right
approach to increasing Hillsborough County firefighters’, paramedics’
and dispatchers’ mental health and well-being:
• 79.1% disagree or strongly disagree (48.1% strongly disagree)
• 16.5% neither agree nor disagree
• 4.4% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01
HEALTH 2
The issue of PTSD is being addressed in an appropriate fashion by the
department administration:
• 71.6% disagree or strongly disagree
• 17.1% neither agree nor disagree
• 11.3% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01
The fire chief and department administration are taking the right
approach to increasing Hillsborough County firefighters’, paramedics’
and dispatchers’ physical health and well-being:
• 69.1% disagree or strongly disagree
• 23.6% neither agree nor disagree
• 7.3% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01
SPENDING 1
The fire chief and administration are taking the right approach
purchasing additional transport units:
• 86.7% disagree or strongly disagree (60.9% strongly disagree)
• 8.3% neither agree nor disagree
• 5% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01
The fire chief and department administration are taking the right
approach to improving ALS availability:
• 84.2% disagree or strongly disagree (52.9% strongly disagree)
• 10.7% neither agree nor disagree
• 5.1% agree or strongly agree
Correlates with morale. p<.01
SPENDING 2
*The fire chief and administration are taking the right approach to
addressing dispatch system upgrades:
• 72.1% disagree or strongly disagree (50.6% strongly disagree)
• 20.4% neither agree nor disagree
• 7.5% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01
The fire chief and department administration are taking the right
approach to prioritizing the reduction of the department’s spending:
• 63.6% disagree or strongly disagree
• 13.1% neither agree nor disagree
• 23.3% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01
WORKLOAD
STATISTICS 1
The fire chief and administration are taking the right approach to increasing
the number of stations:
• 77.4% disagree or strongly disagree
• 13% neither agree nor disagree
• 9.6% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01 Correlated with managing call load. p<.01
The fire chief and administration are taking the right approach to managing
call load per unit:
• 75.1% disagree or strongly disagree
• 17.8% neither agree nor disagree
• 7.1% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01
WORKLOAD
STATISTICS 2
The fire chief and administration are taking the right approach to
reducing response time:
• 72.7% disagree or strongly disagree
• 17.9% neither agree nor disagree
• 9.4% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01 Correlated with staffing levels. p<.01
Staffing levels for the crew/division are appropriate for the amount of
work:
• 69.9% disagree or strongly disagree
• 12.1% neither agree nor disagree
• 18% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01
MENTORING
The fire chief and administration are taking the right
approach to mentoring:
• 80.3% disagree or strongly disagree
• 16.5% neither agree nor disagree
• 3.2% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01
The fire chief and administration are taking the right approach to
managing communication with the press:
• 82.6% disagree or strongly disagree (55.9% strongly disagree)
• 8.7% neither agree nor disagree
• 8.7% agree or strongly agree
Correlated with morale. p<.01
QUALITATIVE
RESULTS
This is the data from the comments section. It provides
sentiment, but statistics from it are not representative.
But a number were frustrated (and maybe angry) because they still wanted to
convey more:
• “300 characters isn't enough to voice my displeasure”
• “…this section is only 300 characters!? Come on, are you kidding me?! So
much to say, but....”
• “This contract failed because good people have been targeted…[snip]…
belittled, bullied, and harassed by the current administration. The lack of
respect for field personnel has been unprecedented. 300 characters is not
nearly enough. Thank you.”
ADMINISTRATION
88 respondents (38.4%) commented on the department
administration, all but 2 were negative comments
“I have personally seen a great fall in the moral of HCFR in the last two years, and for
the first time in my career have absolutely no confidence with the present
administration. It saddens me to see the department that I love be subjected to the
mistrust that we are experiencing now”
“When it comes to Dispatch: Management is so far out of touch with the needs of the
citizens that access 911. The priority of management is being under budget. That is the
ONLY thing that matters. The priority should be the callers in need of help.”
“From what I've seen I can honestly say that morale is at all time low with this new
administration. It has taken the joy from doing a job we think is important and that gives
us a way to help our community. Reducing the budget has taken priority over our
citizens and personnel.”
ADMINISTRATION
INTIMIDATION
More than one person commented on “vulgar” language and
“profanity” being used by department administration personnel
“when dealing with members.”
“I'm drug free, test whenever. Don’t ask me to work more hours, for less
money in the long run (step increase).”
“Increase our pay and benefits. We are not afraid to be drug tested.”
“Drug testing..bring it on! Just don't like the smear campaign our
administration has been doing to push their agenda in our contract.”
“The drug policy wasn’t the reason I voted down the contract.”
WITH ALL THAT
SAID…
“I don't want to leave HCFR, just want things to get
better.”
“Let's see what The Union, and more importantly The Administration
and The County do with this.”
Thank You.
APPENDICES: POSITIVE
PERCEPTIONS
CLOSE COLLEAGUES
83.3% of respondents believe camaraderie in their firehouse/
division is good.
• 42.9% strongly agree
• 42.6% agree
• 7% neither agree nor disagree
• 7.5% disagree or strongly disagree
Overall satisfaction with the promotion process is not correlated with their
reports on morale. p>.2
Satisfaction with the recognition they get in the press for the department’s
achievements is not correlated with their reports on morale. p>.2
CREDENTIALS
CRYSTA METCALF, Ph.D. crysta.metcalf@gmail.com
PROFILE
Over 20 years in applied social science research for innovation and organizational change, conducting
and overseeing rigorous generative and evaluative research. Deep experience working on and leading
diverse and cross-functional teams, with a proven track record of high productivity and on-time goal
achievement. Highly proficient in nurturing cross-organizational relationships and forging strong public-
private partnerships. Expertise in organizational leadership, goal setting, and strategic planning.
Extensive public speaking experience in national and international forums. Excellent writing and
presentation abilities.
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Conducting meticulous data collection and analysis for organizations interested in product innovation and
data driven design, social media and technology mediated communication, organizational change, and
organizational behavior and leadership.
Layer3TV: Voice of the customer research included overall experience/satisfaction with the device, user
interface, and customer care vehicles (website and call center); assisted with efforts to improve call
center workflow and productivity.
Hillsborough County Fire Fighters Union Local 2294: Morale survey and analysis for organizational
improvement. Achieved 62.2% response rate and confidence interval of 97 +/- 3%.
Senior Manager (E12) and Director (E13) of Interactive Media User Research, Distinguished
Member of the Technical Staff (2008-2013)
Drove the knowledge and technology transfer from the team’s research on human behaviors to the
business groups and strategy and product teams. Led and managed a team of multi-disciplinary
research scientists, aligning team’s strategy with company’s strategy, budgeting, coordinating project
relevance, and communicating research implications to product teams and senior management. Focus
included managing multiple relationships with universities, research institutes and other public partners.
Contributed to larger applied research & technology roadmap, influencing overall product strategy and
technology direction, and collaborating with other managers to facilitate effective joint research across the
organization and encourage wider team-building. Consulted for various business units, conducted market
research for the Chief Technology Office, and developed action plans for dynamically addressing
organizational challenges. Gave presentations and invited talks within and outside enterprise.
Communicated with the media, such as the Chicago Tribune and WTTW public television.
1
Principal Staff Anthropologist (E10) (2006-2008)
Supervised design, execution, and analysis of all naturalistic research in the lab, for exploratory
innovation as well as concept testing. Established and maintained strong and productive university
relationships such as with The University of North Texas. Mentored other research scientists, translating
results into useful and usable products, and communicated the research results within and outside the
enterprise through presentations and publications.
Worked on various multidisciplinary teams, utilizing and teaching ethnographic-style research methods &
analysis techniques to assist in the creation of new technologies and technology
applications/experiences. Led the research on many projects and leveraged a variety of research
methodologies. Within Motorola, pioneered use of grounded-theory affinity techniques for team-based
analysis of large quantities of qualitative data.
Eckerd College, St. Petersburg, FL; University of South Florida, Tampa, FL 1994-2000
Adjunct Faculty
Taught numerous courses at both colleges while finishing doctoral data collection, analysis and
writing of the dissertation.
Contract field research sponsored by Armstrong Laboratories, Wright Patterson AFB, Dayton, OH.
Human Issues in the Implementation of Information Technology: United States Air Force
Collected, analyzed and presented social and cultural data (collected from over 200 individuals in 8 Air
Force organizations) about implementation and use of office automation technology; examined aspects of
organizational culture affecting IT usage levels; project became PhD dissertation.
Teaching Assistant
A complete list of published papers, speaking engagements, and USPTO granted and filed patents can
be provided upon request.
2
VOLUNTEER WORK
• Keep Tampa Bay Beautiful cleanup coordinator for Epps Park, Tampa FL, current.
• 3 year appointment to the Committee on Practicing, Applied and Public Interest Anthropology, a
working committee of the American Anthropological Association, 2012 - 2015
• Board member of W.O.M.E.N. (Women’s Organization for Medical Emergency Needs, a non-
profit 501c3 organization), Tampa, FL, 1994-2010
• Martin Luther King Jr. - Cesar Chavez - Rosa Parks: College Day Mentor Program, Detroit Public
Schools, Detroit, MI, 1992
• Speaker in Detroit City Schools, Detroit, MI - Elementary Education in Anthropology, 1991-1992
EDUCATION
Ph.D., Business and Organizational Anthropology, 1999, Wayne State University, Detroit, MI
Chair: Dr. Marietta Baba
Title: “Cultural influences on the adoption and use of information and communication technologies
in organizations”
M.A., Business and Organizational Anthropology, 1991, Wayne State University, Detroit, MI