Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The alfalfa looper (Culifornico uutogruphicu) and the cabbage looper (Trichoplusiu ni) were reared
through the fourth instar on a semidefined artificial diet and for the first 60 hr of the last instar on
fresh leaves of one of their host plants. Microsomes preparedfrom midguts and a carcass segment
which included the fat body were then assayed for aldrin epoxidase activity and cytochrome P-450
content. Epoxidation by midgut microsomes of alfalfa loopers fed peppermint leaves was at a rate
up to eight times that of larvae fed alfalfa, snap beans, or broccoli. The epoxidase activity of the
carcass microsomes was induced about fourfold by the peppermint diet. Midgut microsomes pre-
pared from cabbage looper larvae reared on peppermint leaves were also more active (about four
times) than those reared on alfalfa, broccoli, or cabbage. Although the epoxidase activity of the
carcass microsomes of the cabbage loopers was low, about one-eighth that of the midgut micro-
somes, this enzyme was greatly induced by peppermint leaves. In neither species did the peppermint
leaf diet cause a corresponding increase in the cytochrome P-450 content of the microsomes, the
maximum difference between peppermint and the other plants being about twofold. Bioassays of
cabbage looper larvae reared on broccoli or peppermint and of alfalfa loopers reared on alfalfa or
peppermint indicated that the stimulation of microsomal oxidase activity by the peppermint con-
stituents provided increased tolerance for carbaryl and methomyl but not acephate.
other workers have already established for the mint-fed larvae, these microsomes
these facts (15, 16). were much less active in aldrin epoxidation
The results of the cytochrome P-450 and than those prepared from the midguts. Due
aldrin epoxidase assays of fifth-instar lar- to an oversight, we did not record the larval
vae of alfalfa looper reared on the various weights in these experiments.
diets are presented in Table 1. The midgut We were able to collect third-, fourth-,
epoxidase activity of the peppermint-fed and fifth-instar alfalfa looper larvae from
larvae was five to eight times that of the peppermint plants in the field for a determi-
larvae receiving artificial diet, alfalfa, snap nation of their aldrin epoxidase activity.
bean, or broccoli leaves. The cytochrome The results of these assays were as follows:
P-450 content did not increase to a similar third-instar midgut microsomal epoxidase,
extent in the peppermint-fed larvae, the 1.6 5 0.13; fourth instar, 2.4 + 0.5; and fifth
maximum change being about twofold in instar, 3.0 ? 0.04 nmol dieldrin/min/mg
these larvae compared to those fed alfalfa protein, mean ? SE of two experiments,
leaves. It is evident that the carcass micro- each with two or three assays. Comparing
somal epoxidase, though much lower in ac- these results with those in Table 1, it ap-
tivity than the midgut enzyme, was induced pears that some induction also occurred in
less, up to fourfold, in the peppermint-fed the earlier instars.
larvae while the cytochrome P-450 content
of these microsomes was not affected. Spectral Characteristics of Cytochrome
Similar results were obtained in the P-450
studies of the cabbage looper microsomes, Typical spectral difference curves for the
Table 2. Enhancement in midgut epoxidase CO-P-450 binding complex of midgut mi-
activity due to peppermint was approxi- crosomes from the two species are shown
mately four times that of the other diets and in Figs. 1 and 2. Only curves from larvae
there was no increase in cytochrome P-450 reared on artificial diet and peppermint are
content. One difference between the two shown but these did not vary in spectral
species was the considerable enhancement characteristics from those obtained with the
of carcass epoxidase activity, about 20- other diets. There was little evidence of the
fold, in the peppermint-fed larvae com- presence of cytochrome P-420, and the ab-
pared to those on the other diets. Except sorption maxima was at 450 nm in all cases.
TABLE 1
Effect of Host Plunt on Microsomal Aldrin Epoxiduse Activity und Cytochrome P-450
Content of Alfulfu Looper Larvue
Midgut Carcass”
nmol dld/min/ nmol P-450/ nmol dldlmini nmol P-4501 Larval wt at assay’
Diet” mg protein* mg protein’ mg protein” mg protein’ (mg)
Artificial diet 0.58 + 0.12 0.23 0.10 2 0.01 0.08 426.7 _t 16.7
Alfalfa 0.38 -r- 0.02 0.16 0.09 t 0.01 0.13 109.0 + 6.3
Snap beans 0.43 + 0.05 0.18 0.08 -r- 0.01 0.11 123.0 ? 5.8
Broccoli 0.49 k 0.06 0.26 0.17 + 0.02 0.06 207.4 + 8.7
Peppermint 2.98 k 0.29 0.36 0.39 + 0.11 0.08 185.0 k 9.5
N Newly molted fifth-instar larvae were fed leaves of host plant or continued on the artificial diet for 60 hr prior
to enzyme assay.
b Mean t SE of four experiments, each in duplicate. did, Dieldrin.
’ Average of two experiments, each with single assay.
” See Methods for description.
(’ Mean + SE of two experiments, each in duplicate.
‘Average of 30-40 larvae.
ENZYME INDUCTION IN ALFALFA AND CABBAGE LOOPERS 161
TABLE 2
Effect of Host Plunt on Microsomul Aldrin Epoxiduse Activity und Cytochrame P-450
Content of Cubbuge Looper Lurvue
Midgut Carcass”
nmol dldlmini nmol P-4501 nmol dldlmini nmol P-4501
Diet” mg protein” mg protein” mg protein” mg protein’
Artificial diet 0.39 + 0.01 0.29 0.05 t 0.01 0.05
Alfalfa 0.36 t 0.07 0.17 0.08 -t 0.01 0.16
Broccoli 0.42 + 0.02 0.30 0.04 i- 0.01 0.06
Cabbage 0.27 k 0.01 0.25 0.04 k 0.01 0.06
Peppermint 1.58 2 0.10 0.28 0.84 k 0.21 0.14
” Newly molted fifth-instar larvae were fed leaves of host plant or continued on the artificial diet for 60 hr
prior to enzyme assay.
’ Mean t SE of two experiments, each in duplicate. dld, Dieldrin.
’ Average of two experiments, each with single assays.
” See Methods for description.
Examples of the spectral difference acephate and methomyl with cabbage loop-
curves obtained with the Type II substrate, ers. Alfalfa loopers were much less suscep-
n-octylamine, and microsomes produced by tible to carbaryl after 3 days rearing on
larvae on two of the diets are exhibited in peppermint leaves than after being reared
Figs. 3 and 4. Those shown are typical of all on alfalfa leaves. It can be estimated that
of the diets, exhibiting a trough in the the difference is at least fivefold. A similar
392-nm region. In the case of cytochrome comparison of mortalities indicates an ad-
P-450 of higher animals this characteristic vantage at the lower dose for peppermint-
is thought to be evidence that the micro- fed loopers exposed to methomyl. There
somal P-450 mixture contains a significant was no difference, however, in susceptibil-
amount of the high-spin form (17, 18). ity to the organophosphate compound,
acephate.
Susceptibility to Insecticides
Tables 3 and 4 summarize the results of 0.03
the bioassays of carbaryl, acephate, and
methomyl with alfalfa loopers and of t -Art. duet
---Mint
0.02
t
0.02 -
-Art. diet
-- HIIll
0.01 -
\ .-' ,I
-0.03 I 1
350 400 450
Wowlwpth (nm) Wovelength (nm)
FIG. 1. Cytochrome P-450 curbon monoxide differ- 2. Cytochrome
FIG. P-450 curbon monoxide di&r-
ewe spectru of midgut microsomes from fifth-instur ence spectru of midgut microsomes ,from fifth-instur
u&@ loopers reured on urtijkiul diet or peppermint cubbuge loopers reared on urtijkiul diet or peppermint
Ieuves. Protein concentrution: urtificiul diet. I mgiml; leuves. Protein concentrutions It’ere I mglml jiw both
peppermint. 0.5 mglml. cwws.
162 FARNSWORTH ET AL.
- Art. diet
- Ati.dW
0.01 - --Mint
0.01 -
400 450
Wavelength (nm) 350 400 450
FIG. 3. Type II difference spectra with n-octylumine Wavelength (nm )
of midgut microsomes from fifth-instur alfulfu loopers FIG. 4. Type [Idifference spectru with n-octylumine
reared on urtificiul diet or peppermint leuves. Protein of midgut microsomes from fifth-instur cabbage loop-
concentrution: urtificiul diet, 2.0 mglml; peppermint, ers reured on urtificiul diet or peppermint leaves.
1.1 mglml. Protein concentrations were I mglml for both curves.
As with the alfalfa loopers, the cabbage armyworm, and suggest that induction of
loopers seemed less susceptible to meth- the microsomal oxidases by plant con-
omyl after feeding on peppermint leaves stituents is a common phenomenon. In the
compared to broccoli leaves. Acephate case of herbivores, especially those feeding
toxicity was not affected by the diets. Ap- on a wide variety of plants, induction may
parently the carbamate insecticides are serve as a further mechanism of adaptation.
metabolized more rapidly in looper larvae Another aspect of this phenomenon re-
feeding on peppermint leaves. quires consideration. It is known that the
microsomal oxidase system has an impor-
DISCUSSION tant physiological role in insect develop-
Our results with these two species of ment, namely in the activation of the molt-
lepidoptera support those already reported ing hormone, ecdysterone (19-21), and in
in our work with the variegated cutworm (3, the biosynthesis of the juvenile hormone
5), and by Brattsten (4) with the southern (22). Thus, it would seem that any substan-
TABLE 3
Effect of Host Plant on the Susceptibility of Alfalfa Looper Lurvue to Insecticides
Percentage mortality after feeding oP
Alfalfa leaves Peppermint leaves
Concentration
Insecticide” (%I 24 hr 48 hr 24 hr 48 hr
Carbaryl Control 0 0 0 0
0.05 20 20 0 10
0.10 40 45 10 35
0.50 45 60 20 45
Acephate Control 0 0 0 0
0.05 90 100 90 95
0.15 100 100 90 95
0.30 100 100 100 100
Methomyl Control 0 0 0 0
0.05 65 85 20 55
0.15 65 85 60 80
0.30 85 90 70 95
u Ten larvae were fed bean leaf disks dipped in the insecticide concentration shown.
b Larvae reared through fourth-instar on artificial diet were transferred to treated leaves for 72 hr prior to
assay. Average of two assays, each with a different population.
ENZYME INDUCTION IN ALFALFA AND CABBAGE LOOPERS 163
TABLE 4
Effect of Host Plant on the Susceptibility of Cabbuge Looper Lurvoe to Insecticides
tial stimulation of these enzymes, i.e., the The bioassays, Tables 3 and 4, offer a third
microsomal oxidases, by dietary sub- measure of the effect of the plant constitu-
stances would be disadvantageous if it oc- ents on the metabolic systems.
curred at the wrong time during the insect’s Our finding of a larger relative increase in
growth and development. One question, aldrin epoxidase activity than in the cyto-
therefore, is how has the herbivore adapted chrome P-450 level of the same microsomes
to a host plant such as peppermint so as to is difficult to explain. This may indicate that
avoid any derangement in its physiological the change in enzyme activity brought on
processes brought on by as much as lo-fold by the peppermint allelochemicals is due to
increase in microsomal oxidase activity? a change in the catalytic capacity of the
One possibility is that the insect’s enzyme cytochrome P-450 rather than in the
regulation mechanism does not respond to amount of this important component. Even
the plant stimulus at critical times such as if the epoxidase system does not represent
during hormone biosynthesis or activation. all of the oxidase capacity of the midgut or
Another possibility is that the induction by carcass microsomes, it is evident, at least in
the allelochemicals is highly specific and the case of the cabbage looper (Table 2),
thus without effect on the hormone- that part of the cytochrome P-450 from the
metabolizing system. peppermint-fed loopers must have been ac-
The realization that insects, like higher tivated. This would explain the fourfold in-
animals, probably possess multiple forms of crease in epoxidase activity while there was
cytochrome P-450 raises a difficult problem no change in the P-450 level of the midgut
in experimental design for studies of the microsomes. There is some support for this
type described here. The problem is that no in the Type II binding spectra (Fig. 4). The
single, or even a group of substrates, can be 392-nm trough is more pronounced with the
relied upon to measure the total enzyme microsomes from the peppermint-fed lar-
activity of the microsomal oxidase system. vae, suggesting that relatively more high-
Our solution to the problem has been to use spin P-450 was produced.
aldrin as a model substrate for the micro- In the case of the alfalfa looper (Table 1)
somal oxidase system and to support these this argument is not as strong because there
assays with a measurement of the cyto- was a moderate increase in P-450 content of
chrome P-450 present in the same system. both midgut and carcass microsomes in the
164 FARNSWORTH ET AL.
loopers which had been reared on pepper- 2. P. Blau, P. Feeny, and L. Contardo, Al-
mint leaves. In this case, therefore, a selec- lylglucosinolate and herbivorous caterpillars: A
contrast in toxicity and tolerance, Science 200,
tive and substantial increase in an aldrin- 1296 (1978).
specific cytochrome P-450 could explain 3. S. J. Yu, R. E. Berry, and L. C. Terriere, Host
the eightfold increase in epoxidase activity plant stimulation of detoxifying enzymes in a
along with the twofold increase in cyto- phytophagous insect, Pestic. Biochem. Physiol.
chrome P-450. 12, 280 (1979).
4. L. Brattsten, Ecological significance of mixed-
We considered it possible that methomyl, function oxidations, Drug Metab. Rev. 10(l),
which contains the S-methyl group, might 35 (1979).
have been converted to the more toxic sul- 5. R. E. Berry, S. J. Yu, and L. C. Terriere, Influ-
foxide by microsomal oxidation. The ence of host plants on insecticide metabolism
stimulation of these enzymes by the pep- and management of variegated cutworm, J.
Econ. Entomol., in press.
permint constituents might therefore have 6. R. L. Williamson and M. S. Schechter, Micro-
resulted in increased, rather than decreased somal epoxidation of aldrin in lepidopterous
toxicity in loopers feeding on this plant. As larvae, Biochem. Pharmucol. 19, 1719 (1970).
the bioassay results indicated, however, 7. T. Thongsinthusak and R. I. Krieger, Dihy-
this was not the case. This supports the droisodrin hydroxylation as an indicator of
monooxygenase capability of black cutworm
opinion of Kuhr (16) that the sulfoxide of Agrotis ypsilon and cabbage looper Trichop-
methomyl is not a significant end product in lusio ni larvae, Comp. Biochem. Physiol. MC,
its metabolism by the cabbage looper. (1976).
The practical value of these and other 8. R. I. Krieger, C. F. Wilkinson, L. J. Hicks, and
studies of this type in helping to improve E. F. Taschenberg, Aldrin epoxidation, dihy-
droisodrin hydroxylation, and p-chloro-N-
our present methods of insect control is in- methyl-aniline demethylation in six species of
creasingly apparent. When it can be dem- satumiid larvae, J. Econ. Entomol. 69, l(l976).
onstrated that insects feeding on one crop 9. L. B. Brattsten and C. F. Wilkinson, Induction of
are more or less susceptible to an insec- microsomal enzymes in the southern ar-
ticide than when feeding on another crop, it myworm (Prodeniu eriduniu), Pestic. Biochem.
Physiol. 3, 393 (1973).
is clear that the pest control strategy on the 10. S. J. Yu and L. C. Terriere, Cytochrome P-450 in
two crops could be different, at least in insects: Differences in the forms present in in-
terms of insecticide dose. If it can also be secticide resistant and susceptible house flies,
shown, as seems likely, that both the in- Pestic. Biochem. Physiol. 12, 239 (1979).
sect’s capacity to detoxify insecticides and 11. T. Omura and R. Sato, The carbon monoxide-
its response to plant stimulation of this ca- binding pigment of liver microsomes, J. Biol.
Chem. 239, 2370 (1964).
pacity differs with the developmental stage, 12. M. M. Bradford, A rapid sensitive method for the
then an element of timing could be intro- quantitation of microgram quantities of protein
duced into the pest control strategy. Fi- utilizing the principles of protein-dye binding,
nally, the likelihood that the enzyme- And. Biochem. 72, 248 (1976).
inducing constituents of the plant are 13. C. F. Wilkinson and L. B. Brattsten, Microsomal
drug metabolizing enzymes in insects, Drug
biosynthesized on a growth-dependent Metub. Rev. l(2), 153 (1972).
schedule introduces a second timing factor 14. R. J. Kuhr, Metabolism of carbamate insecticide
worth considering. chemicals in plants and insects, J. Agr. Food
Chem. 18, 1023 (1970).
ACKNOWLEDGMENT 15. R. J. Kuhr, Comparative metabolism of carbaryl
by resistant and susceptible strains of the cab-
This research was supported by USPHS Grant ES bage looper,J. Econ. Entomol. 64, 1373 (1971).
00362-22.
16. R. J. Kuhr, The metabolic fate of methomyl in the
cabbage looper, Pestic. Biochem. Physiol. 3,
REFERENCES
113 (1973).
1. L. B. Brattsten, C. F. Wilkinson, and T. Eisner, 17. C. R. E. Jefcoate, R. L. Calabrese, and J. L.
Herbivore -plant interactions: Mixed-function Gaylor, Ligand interaction with hemoprotein
oxidases and secondary plant substances, Sci- P-450. III. The use of n-octylamine and ethyl
ence 196, 1349 (1977). isocyanide difference spectroscopy in the
ENZYME INDUCTION IN ALFALFA AND CABBAGE LOOPERS 165
quantitative determination of high- and low- and L. 1. Gilbert. Evidence for an a-ecdysone
spin P-450, Mol. Phurmacol. 6, 391 (1970). cytochrome P-450 mixed function oxidase in in-
18. D. W. Nebert, K. Kumai, M. Sato, and H. Kon, sect fat body mitochondria, Nolure (Lond~~n)
Association of type I, type II, and reverse type I 268, 660 (1977).
difference spectra with absolute spin state of 21. S. L. Smith, W. E. Bollenbacher, D. Y. Cooper,
cytochrome P-450 iron, in “Microsomes and H. Schleyer, J. J. Wielgus, and L. I. Gilbert.
Drug Oxidations” (V. Ullrich, Ed.), pp. 224, Ecdysone 20-monooxygenase: Characterization
Pergamon. London, 1977. of an insect cytochrome P-450 dependent
19. R. Feyereisen and F. Durst, Ecdysterone biosyn- steroid hydroxylase, Mol. Cell. Endocrinol. 15,
thesis: A microsomal cytochrome P-450-linked 111 (1979).
ecdysone 20-monooxygenase from tissues of 22. B. D. Hammock, NADPH dependent epoxidation
the African migratory locust, Eur. J. Bidchum. of methyl farnesoati to juvenile hormone in the
88, 37 (1978). cockroach Bluherus giganleus L. Life Sc,i. 17.
20. W. E. Bollenbacher. S. L. Smith, J. J. Wielgus, 323 (1975).