Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Book Review
Hope for Law: Narrative
Therapy and Intimate
Abuse Practice
Linda G. Mills, Ph.D., L.C.S.W., J.D.*
Leila is a 24 year old Maori1 woman who had been hospitalized by Dr. Glen
Simblett, a psychiatrist, in New Zealand. Leila had been hallucinating. Dr. Simblett
felt that her psychotic episodes had become so life threatening that she needed
hospitalization. While hospitalized, she stopped talking, eating, and drinking.
Against medical advice, she refused treatment. Ultimately, she checked herself
out of the hospital to see a tohunga (a Maori healer). Leila described her story as
follows:
Tigers have 9 lives. It lost its ®rst life in the family it was born in because of their
abuse and punishment. It lost its second life to drugs and alcohol. She [sic] lost her
third life in a marriage where there was no room for her hopes and ideas. She lost her
last life when she was admitted to a psychiatric unit. She hasn't got many lives left now
(p. 122).
Dr. Simblett is a psychiatrist practising Narrative Therapy in New Zealand. Leila
was, in part, the inspiration for Dr. Simblett's commitment to Narrative Therapy
and to a psychiatric practice that is sensitive to the cultural, ®nancial, and gendered
subtexts of emotional breakdown and to their narratives, as the clients themselves
embrace them.
Leila's story is part of an edited volume titled Narrative Therapy in Practice:
The Archaeology of Hope. The book is a fascinating collection of therapy practice-
based essays written by New Zealand counselors engaged in a form of therapeutic
practice called Narrative Therapy. Narrative Therapy develops a postmodern
method of counseling which relies on both therapist and client narratives for
de®ning the presenting problem and for proposing solutions. The book presents
essays on both the theory and practice of Narrative Therapy, a method which has
now been adopted by postmodern therapists who practice in all parts of the world.
The ®rst four chapters of the book describe the theory and method of Narrative
Therapy, and the last six chapters present its application in a number of practice
* Correspondence to: Linda G. Mills, Department of Social Welfare, School of Public Policy and Social
Research, 3250 Public Policy Bldg., Los Angeles, CA 90095-1656, USA. Email: lmills@ucla.edu
1
The Maori people are a Polynesian group that inhabited New Zealand before European colonists
arrived 300 years ago.
CCC 0735±3936/98/040525±09$17.50
# 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
526 Book Review
settings including psychiatry, alcohol treatment, therapy with male sexual abuse
survivors, school counseling, group counseling using indigenous knowledge, and
mediation. While the speci®c application of Narrative Therapy as therapeutic
practice may have only marginal interest to the readership of an interdisciplinary
journal involving law and behavioral science, the method of Narrative Therapy has
much to teach advocates who are interested in an engaged legal practice, one that
provides more than a typical legal solution. This review essay presents the method
of Narrative Therapy as it is described in the text and explores Narrative Therapy's
application to an intimate abuse legal practice.
Lawyers, more speci®cally, and the legal system in general, rob clients of their
lives every day. Fighting for one's Social Security bene®ts can involve several
appeals and numerous rejections. Getting a worker's compensation settlement can
take seven years. Suing for medical malpractice involves depositions, court appear-
ances, and testimony from hostile doctors. Often, lawyers themselves exacerbate
the suering of their clients by misdirecting them or by failing to nurture them
through the treacherous legal process (Durston & Mills, 1996). Indeed, in Robert
Cover's prophetic words ``[T]he relationship between legal interpretation and the
in¯iction of pain remains operative even in the most routine of legal acts'' (Cover,
1986).
Recently, a number of scholars have attempted to construct a more hospitable
and caring legal system (Goodrich, 1996; Littleton, 1993; Margulies, 1995; Mills,
1998; Wexler & Winick, 1996). Using principles from psychology, psychoanalysis,
philosophy and critical and feminist studies, these scholars struggle to create a
more empowering space from which clients can engage the law.
Narrative Therapy in Practice: The Archaeology of Hope oers a number of con-
crete methods by which emotionally minded lawyers can help clients work through
their legal problems in ways that ®nd satisfactory resolutionsÐresolutions that
actually help the client heal from the trauma that evoked legal intervention in the ®rst
place. Those practitioners who ®nd themselves hostile to the idea that the legal
system can and should be therapeutic and healing should avoid this text. This book,
and the work of narrative therapists in general, is only for the psychologically
sympathetic lawyer, for the advocate who believes that the legal system has an ethical
or even legal mandate to respond in ways that do not rob Leila of her nine lives.
Several chapters in the book explore the theoretical underpinnings of the Narrative
Therapy approach. Chapter 3 most clearly outlines a method. It is helpful to
understand the method and to explore how it might be applied in a legal context.
Narrative Therapy, described in some detail below, grows out of postmodernism,
a philosophy which rejects notions of ``certainty'', ``truth'', and the idea that
we can ever really know anything. Postmodernism recognizes that there is no
``essence'' or essential being. Language or speech, as it is interpreted by post-
modernists, is not an expression of knowing beings but rather a re¯ection of the
larger social, political, and cultural conditions in which it is created. Meaning then
is both tentative and uncertain. Postmodernism is fundamentally political in nature,
# 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Behav. Sci. Law, 16, 525±533 (1998)
Book Review 527
The Terms
``Preferred Descriptions'' give therapists an opportunity to explore their own
stories and to rediscover their preferred descriptions of themselves as counselors.
Professional training often renders even the therapist's previous life experience
invisible.2 Key to eective Narrative Therapy practice is the assumption that if
helpers are to learn more about their client's stories, they must be familiar with
their own. Lawyers, as I have previously argued could bene®t tremendously from
such self-re¯exivity and from learning more about how their own stories permeate
the choices they oer clients.3
``Persistent and Genuine Curiosity'' is key to the practice of Narrative Therapy.
The idea is that the helper's curiosity should encourage the client to reveal both
their negative and positive storyÐtheir suerings and their competencies. To guard
against abusive interrogations and to achieve a more respectful curiosity, Narrative
Therapy suggests that helpers ask clients whether they are willing to proceed with a
line of questioning and that helpers ``check in'' as the questioning persists. This
ensures, as is key to Narrative Therapy, that clients are willing participants in
presenting their stories. It seems obvious that lawyers could bene®t from taking a
2
Similarly, law training often represses the student's personal experiences and renders them invisible or
irrelevant. Students are taught to eliminate the ``I'' from their arguments, to repress their feelings about
the facts of a case, and to present their arguments in a gender neutral manner. See, for example,
Goodrich, 1986; Guinier et al., 1997; Kennedy, 1992.
3
For a discussion of countertransference as technique for insight-oriented lawyering, see Mills, 1996,
1997, 1998.
# 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Behav. Sci. Law, 16, 525±533 (1998)
528 Book Review
more tentative posture when questioning clients about their legal stories; and while
this may be controversial, it might also be bene®cial if lawyers considered both their
client's suerings and competencies when exploring how to proceed in a given case,
especially when the client involved is likely to be marginalized or rendered invisible
by the legal process.4
According to Narrative Therapy in Practice: The Archaeology of Hope, discourse,
positioning, deconstruction, and reconstruction are the methods or tools around
which a client's narratives are assembled. Discourse is a ``cluster of ideas produced
within the wider culture'' (p. 93). ``Discourses'' are stories which embody cultural
norms and which reveal, when examined closely, the power dynamics in both
intimate and social relations. ``Positioning'' is integral to discourses insofar as the
discourses themselves position us in relationship to others. In other words, where
we are situated in a given story line, or position, is dictated by the discourse.
The inevitable interplay of these concepts is best illustrated through an example.
A battered woman and her abusive partner share a certain discourse about their
dynamic which positions them in relation to each other. The batterer, for example,
may believe that he is ``king of his castle''. Without re¯ection, the battered woman
may capitulate to this version of what is expected of her.
The discourse which underlies their story probably takes various forms. For
example, the batterer may feel entitled to a warm cooked meal because he is the
primary breadwinner. The battered woman may unre¯exively agree and ``buy into''
this discourse. This discourse positions them in con¯ict, and quite possibly in
danger, when the battered woman fails to prepare dinner according to his speci®-
cations. No excuse is adequate to counteract the ``I am king'' discourse. A colicky
3-month-old, a job obligation, or a dying mother only rei®es the ``king'' discourse
and her position in it. Together they have unwittingly agreed to the story which
takes precedence over all others: that he is king.
``Deconstruction'' disassembles the discourses, the assumptions which underpin
a dynamic. Indeed, in the example, deconstruction inverts the binary opposition
between ``king'' and ``cook'', and prepares the client for the possibility of rejecting
the destructive dynamic. Deconstruction provides an opportunity for the battered
woman to see what she has agreed to and to re¯ect on her position within that
discourse. The purpose of deconstruction is to pull the curtain away, to reveal the
power dynamics which lie behind the discourse. ``Deconstruction is a process in
which discourses are exposed and people's positions within them are revealed''
(p. 95).
``Reconstruction'' is the space of possibility, the opportunity revealed from the
deconstruction process. Reconstruction occurs when the client has revealed the
discourses and the positioning and is now ready (and able) to reconstruct her story
in ways she chooses. Reconstruction allows the client to reject the cultural and
social norms and other assumptions embedded in the discourse she has unwittingly
adopted and enables her deliberately to reposition herself in ways that are
constructive and ful®lling. Reconstruction creates the possibility of reversing the
hierarchical opposition. In the case of the battered woman, reconstruction enables
her to reorder the discourses, and to reposition herself within them. It enables her,
at least emotionally speaking, to choose a story she prefers. The law, in whatever
4
For an insightful method for hearing the client's strengths, See Al®eri, 1991.
# 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Behav. Sci. Law, 16, 525±533 (1998)
Book Review 529
form it takes, such as a restraining order or arrest, may or may not ®gure in to her
new story. Lawyers, strictly speaking, may or may not be instrumental in helping
this battered woman move on with her life.
For the psychologically minded lawyer, Narrative Therapy should be viewed as
an exciting new development in the theoretics of legal practice. It has promise both
for client interviewing and for assisting clients in resolving their problems in ways
that move beyond the law, and which envision a more meaningful and ful®lling
resolution.5
# 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Behav. Sci. Law, 16, 525±533 (1998)
530 Book Review
the population of New Zealand, while representing 99% of the prison population
(Shulman, 1996).
Given my work in domestic violence, and more particularly my interest in the
cross-cultural dimensions of intimate abuse, for me the movie centers on Beth
Heke. Beth Heke, a Maori woman, played by actress Rena Owen, has been married
to Jake Heke (Temuera Morrison), a Maori man, for 18 years and has ®ve children
with him. The movie is a portrait of Jake's violent outbursts (he is nicknamed
``Jake the Mus'' for muscle), both in bars and at home, and his inability to control
his violent temper.
Moreover, the movie is about the eect of that violence on their children. Their
oldest son, Nig, joins a gang (distinguished by body tattoos in the Maori tradition),
and his younger brother, Boogy, is placed in a state foster-care institution. Their
daughter, Grace, who ultimately commits suicide, is raped by her father's uncle.
While the movie is only marginally about the legal system (Boogy is sent to a
state institution after a brief court hearing), it is possible to imagine that in this day
and age Beth Heke, as a battered woman, might have been exposed to the legal
system, should she have needed or wanted it following a violent episode. Indeed,
one domestic violence program in New Zealand called the Hamilton Abuse Inter-
vention Project is speci®cally designed to address the unique legal and other needs
of battered Maori women and their children. How might Narrative Therapy help
these emerging legal and therapeutic programs address battered women's needs?
What we learn from the movie is that Beth Heke ultimately ®nds her strength by
rediscovering her cultural roots. What is revealed is that she left her Maori village
18 years earlier to marry Jake. At the time she left, her father, a traditional Maori,
disapproved of her marriage and prophesied that ``she would return''. In her
stubbornness, as the movie portrays her, she saved face by never returning. What
she ultimately realizes, is that it is in her cultural heritage that she can rediscover
her strength and identity. Can the law be eective in helping a battered woman like
Beth Heke ®nd this healing path?
United States legal narratives in domestic violence are all too often undimen-
sional. The legal system only knows the law; it does not have the tools or capacity to
help women ®nd their ways to safety through other means. This, I argue, is the
promise of Narrative Therapy. It can oer lawyers and their clients tools which can
facilitate long-lasting change, with or without legal intervention.
Battered women, in general, hesitate to seek assistance. When they do, their
interactions are often dissatisfying, all too often sending them toward, rather than
away from, the abusive relationship (see Mills, 1998). Had Beth Heke approached
the legal system and been faced with a lawyer trained in Narrative Therapy, that
lawyer might have been able to help her see that the most healing path for her in
relation to the violence in her life is a cultural one. Using principles of Narrative
Therapy, how might such an interaction unfold?
Critical to a dialogue with a woman like Beth Heke is a lawyer's re¯ection
on her own ``preferred description''. As I have previously argued, knowing one's
countertransferences (what the lawyer brings in terms of a psychological history to
the legal interaction) is critical to ensuring that those issues are not transferred in
terms of an emotional history onto the client (Mills, 1996, 1997, 1998). For
example, an advocate who has not re¯ected on her own issues may project her own
interpretation of a situation onto her client. One battered woman may prefer legal
# 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Behav. Sci. Law, 16, 525±533 (1998)
Book Review 531
# 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Behav. Sci. Law, 16, 525±533 (1998)
532 Book Review
with pride, spirit. If my spirit can survive living with you for 18 years, then I can
survive anything''.
While Beth came to these realizations on her own, it is critical to wonder
whether the legal system might not have helped her ®nd this reconstruction sooner.
The legal system is often the ®rst point of contact for battered women. I am
suggesting that the tools of Narrative Therapy, including persistent and genuine
curiosity, discourse and positioning, and deconstruction and reconstruction, might
have helped a legal advocate working with Beth Heke ®nd a life free from violence
through her cultural reconnection. Indeed, these realizations may have occurred
before Grace's death and before Beth experienced the loss of her sons.
Drawing on Beth's history, a lawyer using Narrative Therapy techniques might
have elicited discourses about her past, both positive and negative, in which Beth
revealed her suering and her strength. When Beth could see her strength in these
negative and positive narratives, she might then be poised to care of herself and her
children, and she might then be positioned to reject Jake's violence. In the movie,
these deconstructions and reconstructions ultimately enable Beth to create a
narrative which is free from Jake's violence.
Legal intervention in Beth Heke's case may or may not have assisted her in
keeping her and her children safe. No doubt her resolve to change her life went well
beyond the typical legal response which oers restraining orders, arrest, and even a
few referrals. Indeed, Beth Heke changed her life without the law. However, given
the law's more recent propensity to intervene, it seems reasonable to suggest
alternative methods or tools for advocates who become involved in these cases.8
What seems clear is that a lawyer may have been in a position, had she been trained
in Narrative Therapy, to become involved earlier and to have helped women like
Beth Heke to take therapeutic journeys in realizing paths to healing. In this case, it
was not the law Beth needed, but rather a helper who could see, along with her,
that cultural reconnection was her most likely salvation. What Narrative Therapy
oers the lawyer is a method for looking beyond the law, if necessary, and for
helping women like Beth Heke to see that tigers' lives can be re-claimed in the
strength that lie sleeping in their suering.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
REFERENCES
Al®eri, A. V. (1991). Reconstructive poverty law practice: learning lessons of client narrative,
Yale Law Journal 100, 2107.
Cover, R. M. (1986). Violence and the word, Yale Law Journal 95, 1601.
8
Many of the United States' eorts in the last 20 years have been aimed at encouraging law enforcement
to take domestic violence seriously. While I agree that such intervention is necessary, I believe it should
be tempered according to the wishes of the battered woman, assuming that she is in a position to make
such decisions.
# 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Behav. Sci. Law, 16, 525±533 (1998)
Book Review 533
Durston, L., & Mills, L. (1996). Toward a new dynamic in poverty client empowerment: The
rhetoric, politics, and therapeutics of opening statements in social security disability hearings, Yale
Jornal of Law & Feminism, 8, 119.
Goodrich, P. (1996). Law in the courts of love: Andreas Capellanus and the judgements of love,
Stanford Law Review, 48, 633.
Goodrich, P. (1986). Reading the law: a critical introduction to legal method and technique, Blackwell
Publishers.
Guinier, L., Fine, M., & Balin, J. (1997). Becoming gentlemen: women, law school, and institutional
change, Beacon Press.
Kennedy, D. (1992). Legal education as training for hierarchy. In (David Kairys (Ed.), 1992).
The politics of law (p. 38), Pantheon.
Lopez, G. (1992). Rebellious lawyering: one chicano's vision of progressive law practice. Westview Press.
Littleton, C. Women's experience and the problem of transition. In (Martha Minow (Ed.), 1993).
Family matters: readings on family lives and the law p. 261.
Margulies, P. (1995). Representation of domestic violence survivors as a new paradigm of poverty law:
In search of access, connection, and voice, George Washington Law Review, 63 1971.
Mills, L. G. (1996). On the other side of silence: eective lawyering for intimate abuse, Cornell Law
Review 86, 1225.
Mills, L. G. (1997). Instituition and insight: a new job description for the battered woman's
prosecutor and other more modest proposals, UCLA Women's Law Journal, 7 169.
Mills, L. G. (1998). The heart of intimate abuse: new interventions in child welfare, criminal justice, and
health settings, Springer Publishing Co.
Sherman, L. W. et al. (1992). The variable eects of arrest on criminal careers: the Milwaukee
domestic violence experiment, Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 83, 137.
Shulman, K. For Actress Rena Owen, `Warriors' is more than a role in movies: the 34-year-old Maori
has personal experience with the cultural subjugation portrayed in the ®lm About New Zealand's
indigenous people, (1995, March 10). Los Angeles Times F. 10.
Wexler, D. B. & Winick B. J. (Eds.). (1996) Law in a therapeutic key: developments in therapeutic
jurisprudence. Carolina Academic.
White, L. (1992). Theoretics of practice: the integration of progressive thought and action: paradox,
piece-work, and patience, Hastings Law Journal 43, 853.
# 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. Behav. Sci. Law, 16, 525±533 (1998)