Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By Paige Rundle
S3567307
This analytical report reflects on the current and complex fashion market situation.
The Cotton on Group has been around since 1988 and has grown enormously since then
consisting of 7 brands.
An analysis of the environment was undertaken by the author using the PESTEL method;
A TOWS (Threat, Opportunity, Weakness, and Strength) Matrix was done on the company.
The industry was looked at with the 5 porter’s forces looking at the impact that each force
A BCG model was done on the group identifying the Stars, Cash Cows, Question Marks, and
Dogs. Rubi shoes were identified as the brand that is a dog and should be harvested.
Strategies implemented by the company was differentiation and cost strategies which the
The general recommendations made for the group were advancing in technology, research
2
Table of Contents
Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 4
5.Strategies .................................................................................................................... 14
6.Recommendations....................................................................................................... 14
6.1 General ........................................................................................................................... 14
7.Appendices.................................................................................................................. 22
3
Introduction
This report was prepared by Paige Rundle, a third year RMIT student undertaking the
Bachelor of Fashion.
Cotton on Group was founded by Nigel Austin selling denim jackets from the boot of his car
in Geelong. The company has massively expanded since 1988 and now has 7 brands in their
Group. The brands consist of Cotton on, Cotton on Body, Supre, Typo, Cotton on kids, Rubi
and Factorie, a wide variety of adults, kids and teen clothing, stationery, shoes, sleepwear,
and undergarments. They have over 1400 stores covering 19 countries and are still rapidly
growing.
The data from this report was obtained from secondary data
4
1.Analysis of environment
The analysis of the environment is done by using the PESTEL system which looks at the
political, economic, social, technological, environmental and legal macro environment. See
Appendix A.
1.1 Political
In 2017 when Donald Trump became one of the most powerful men in the world as president
of the USA, it caused many problems for the country as well as the rest of the world.
Australia has been and will continue to be affected by the Trump government as one of the
first things that they did was abandon the Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement which has still
gone ahead with Australia, Brunei Darussalam, Canada, Chile, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico,
Peru, New Zealand, Singapore and Vietnam (Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade,
2018). With these 11 countries and USA, it comes to about 40% of the world's trade (BBC,
2017). It benefits the nations in the partnership as it extends economic ties by getting rid of
tariffs and helping trade between the countries. Trump government got out of it because they
believe that there will be job loss within America as people are more likely to buy goods that
are in this trade deal if they are cheaper. This could affect Cotton on Group (COG) as it could
now make trading to the USA more expensive as the USA has pulled out. There is still a new
opportunity for COG to enter new markets within the partnership that they have not already
tapped into.
1.2 Economic
Exchange rates can highly affect the Australian retail industry in positive and negative ways.
According to the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA), the exchange rate for the 12 April 2018
was $1 AUD equaled to $0.7751USD and 0.5466 Pounds. This can be seen as a negative for
5
the industry as having a lower exchange rate encourages Australian customers to shop online
from overseas brands as they are getting a cheaper rate instead of buying locally. However,
this can also impact Australian brands positively as getting their products manufactured
overseas is cheaper and most manufacturers use USD to do their transactions. Overall COG
can benefit from having this exchange rate as they save revenue on production but in turn,
could lose customers as they are saving money from buying online internationally.
1.3 Social
Buying behavior can depend on 4 different factors being physiological e.g. perception and
attitudes, personal e.g. age and occupation, social e.g. friends and family, and cultural e.g.
environment and country grown up in. There are many different theories for it which makes it
hard to narrow down on the original theory but they all look into different parts; psychology,
sociology, economics, personal and environmental variables (Stavros et al, 1999). With
generation Z on the rise to be the largest generational group, the industry needs to be aware
that they have completely different buying habits than other previous generations (Australian
College of Marketing, 2014). The current baby boomers are not priced sensitive as they have
the most disposable income and are more likely to be a returning customer if they get the
right service (Eastman and Liu, 2012). Generation X is known to interpret advertisements
differently to any other generation, they are not impressed by designer labels or smart
commercials (Leung & Taylor, 2002). For Generation Y they are more impressed with the
brand, style, and price as well as the social identity that comes with that. Gen Y spend close
to 70% on the fashion retail industry (Valaei & Nikhashemi, 2017). Generation Z are
majority smartphone users for online shopping purposes, they have a lot of time on their
hands so they can research what they are buying e.g. getting the best price. They have no
brand loyalty but still expect to get the very best service (Claveria, 2017). COG is affected by
6
this as they need to make sure they are marketing to each generation correctly for each brand
1.4 Technological
Technology is advancing rapidly which makes staying on top of it extremely difficult for the
technology. Companies like the COG are doing some things that are up to date like using
suppliers who have the newest technology advancements for making garments but this is not
widely known and also not made in Australia (Cotton on, 2018). Technological
advancements are happening all the time around the world, with Virtual Reality and
Augmented Reality being large contributors in the retail industry right now. These two
technologies have not been widely introduced into Australia yet so there is room for COG to
1.5 Ecological
Sustainability has become a huge part of today and what we buy. With more and more people
learning about the consequences of fast fashion on the environment it is making it harder for
the fashion industry to get away with as much especially with annual reports such as the
Baptist Report which gives companies an overall rating on policies, knowledge of suppliers,
auditing the supplier and having a good relationship, and worker empowerment (Baptist
World Aid, 2017). The fashion industry currently contributes negatively to the environment
with so much manufacturing being done in Asian and Indian countries we don’t first handily
see it in Australia. Companies like Reformation are unique in the fact that they focus more on
the sustainability side rather than staying on trend and having fast fashion. They send out a
sustainability report quarterly, in this report, it shows that they use the eco-friendliest
7
materials and also use second-hand materials and give it new life, they have green building
infrastructure and they recycle 75% of all their rubbish. On every product on their website,
they tell the customer how many Carbon dioxide, water and waste savings that product has
used compared to the industry standard. (Reformation, 2018). Currently, COG does hundreds
of audits every year on their suppliers and all of their brands on the Baptist Report scored A-
1.6 Legal
Having stores in many different countries can make it difficult to know all of the laws around
trade and restrictions. This could affect the COG as it can make employment, opening new
stores, shipping produce etc. in a new country. It could delay orders and therefore make the
company behind and miss drops which could be very costly for the company.
2. TOWS Matrix
TOWS meaning threats, opportunities, weaknesses, and strengths and looks at the internal
Currently, COG is in 19 countries around the world with over 1400 stores. This shows that
they have the power to expand internationally already. As they have already got a strong
brand image from being an established Australian brand they are more likely to be accepted
by overseas countries and environments. As they have some stores in the USA already they
could look at expanding more there as that is one of the largest markets. They could also look
at expanding more into Asia and making themselves a well-known international brand. This
8
could be an expensive process as they would have to alter the designs and sizes as it is a
completely different market compared to expanding into USA or UK. (Cotton On, 2018)
A large threat to every company/ brand is the ethical problems you can have with suppliers
and manufacturers. However, COG promotes their ethics very strongly in-store and online,
which gives the impression that they take sustainability and ethics very seriously. On their
website, it states from July- December 2017 there was a 41% improvement on management
practices in their factories and 98% of all their employees are employed full time giving them
By vertically integrating the company COG would be much more aware of what was
happening within the company at all stages and can ensure that the quality is of the standard.
Currently, the perception of the company from the consumers is that it is cheap and good for
basics and not always going to be great quality. By vertically integrating they could have so
much more control over products, environment, ethics, sustainability and possibly have
quicker lead times as well. Although it is difficult to become fully integrated it would make a
As the company is out of date with technology as well as most of the retail industry in
Australia they have an ongoing threat of being outdone by local and international
9
competitors. Currently, each individual brand under the COG is on social media sites such as
Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, YouTube and Twitter, all of these accounts are updated
regularly which is a positive. Other than this they could invest in Augmented reality and
Virtual reality and bring this into their stores as they are big in the industry internationally at
the moment.
3.Industry Analysis
3.Industry Analysis
The porter 5 forces analyse barriers to entry, substitutes, buyer power, supplier power and
rivalry of a company or brand and look at the impact level they will have. (Appendix C)
As the COG already have so many brands under their wing, most startups but also some they
have acquired, they are at an advantage. The Australian fashion industry can be very difficult
to tackle and thrive in for new businesses as there is so much competition already
(Courtenay, 2016). Startups need to look into untapped areas of the market to get them into
‘blue water’. With COG, they already have the experience and expertise for their brands so
won’t make the same mistakes as brands with less capital and less experience. With this
experience, they will be more likely to have high returns on their investment which is why
3.2 Substitutes
The impact level for substitutes is moderate for COG as they already offer such an array of
products that if a customer is looking for another option or replacement they can easily go to
any one of the other stores under the COG group. Although if a customer is wanting quality
and don’t mind paying a bit more than they could go to a more expensive store that offers
10
what they are looking for. This is something that COG can’t compete with as all of their
COG’s buyer power is low as they already know their customer very well from extensive
research. They know that their customer is looking for low cost casual products however the
customer also wants quality for that same low price which could be something they could
have power over as brands are having to listen more and more to what their customer is
As COG has 7 brands they have many different suppliers for all of their brands some of
which they have worked with from the start so have a long-lasting relationship with them.
Everbright Fashion supplier has worked with the group since almost the beginning and
creates around 9 million garments for them every year as they have some of the newest
technology (Cotton on Group, 2018). Suppliers like these would have more power on the
group than some of the new suppliers as they produce so much. Having so many different
3.5 Rivalry
The Australian fashion industry is so competitive making it exceptionally hard to not have a
lot of local and international competitors for all of their brands. As none of their brands are in
the blue water area it means they need to stay up to date on technology, fashion and their
consumers to stay as a primary competitor in the market. A positive for COG is that they are
so well known in Australia and most of the brands are still in the growth stage so they can
still keep innovating and growing with the market. (Kimmorley, 2017)
11
4.Portfolio
In the BCG matrix model, there are 4 squares being Question marks which suggest high
growth and low market share, Cash Cow meaning high market share and low growth, Stars
that are high market share and high growth, Dogs are low market share and low growth. As a
whole group, they have nearly 20% of the market share for fast fashion in Australia only
losing out to H&M who hold 22% according to Forbes. As the COG doesn’t release
information about each of their brands market share this has been done on other secondary
information found.
4.1 Stars
The stars in the group are Cotton on body as they offer so much breadth and depth of
products but still offer them at a low price. By starting off selling just lingerie and then
expanding into sleepwear, active wear and swimwear they cover more than most of their
competitors. They keep growing and bringing in new products like their ‘super soft range’
that has launched and also personalization on products such as dressing gowns, ugg boots and
make up bags (Cotton on, 2018). Cotton on Kids is also a star as they don’t have any major
competitors in their market so they would most likely hold most of the market share and also
have so much room in the market to grow. Cotton on is also a star as they have been around
the longest out of all the separate brands. It may be in a growth/maturity stage but it still has a
high market share as shown from the IBIS World Clothing Retailing in Australia report
where it states that the company has 3.8% of the market share in Australia. They also are the
brand with 700 stores around the world which is the most out of the 7 brands which shows
12
4.2 Question Marks
Question marks in the group are Factorie as they have room for a lot of growth in the industry
as a casual teen brand but they do not hold much market share. At the beginning of this year
all their stores in Asia were closed with no explanation which could show that they tried to
Cash cows are Typo as they have 4.9% of the current market share for stationery. In 2016,
they opened their first store in the UK and have no opened 2 more showing that the
expansion is going successfully. Typo does have competitors who are Officeworks with
46.7% of the market share and Smiggle who have 12.3% (Richardson, 2017). Supre has a
large market share and did grow when it was first acquired by COG in 2013. They turned the
brand around and changed how customers perceived it. Now it is very popular in the teen
market and seen as being fashion forward which was done by understanding their customer
(Whiting, 2018)
4.4 Dogs
The dog in the group is Rubi shoes as they have stopped growing and stores are being closed
and they don’t have much of a market share. This could have been from a few things like
quality, price and fashionability but as a whole the company should look at harvesting it from
their group.
13
5.Strategies
Generic strategies were made as a way of gaining competitive advantage to a brand and
The cost focused strategy is about lowering costs and having ‘no frills’. There are two ways
of doing this, by reducing costs but keeping the same industry standard pricing the company
is likely to increase on their profits. Charging lower prices could increase your market share
as customers are always drawn to lower prices and therefore still making profit on products
as the cost has already been lowered. This can be a hard strategy as it is not enough to just be
the cheapest brand out there as there are so many other low-cost brands that you need to
compete with so the key is to be the leader in this area (Mind Tools, 2018). COG already do
this with Typo as they already have a low cost on their products which isn’t the cheapest in
The differentiation strategy is about making you product or service different to that of your
competitor. It could include product range, functionality, customers values or your brand
image. Large companies that choose to do this strategy need to beware of staying on top of
their product development so that smaller competitors do not take over them. COG could do
more on this strategy as they have no differentiation to their other competitors currently.
6.Recommendations
6.1 General
They could look at advancing in technology by bringing in augmented/ virtual reality to their
stores and online. Other types of technology currently being used successfully are robotics
which are already being used in department stores in areas of the world to direct customers to
certain parts of the store depending on what they are looking for. This could save the
company revenue in the long run if they can use robotics instead of paying staff wages.
Drone delivery is another form of technology that is taking off and has been seen to work by
14
Amazon and 7/11 overseas. This may be a while off for Australia as they have strict laws on
drones at the moment (Oshea, 2017). Looking at technologies that other brands and countries
are using whether they are much larger or way off for Australia is educational for a brand and
Another strategy is starting research into generation Z as there is not a lot known about them
so far there is a lot of unknowns for the whole industry around the world. If COG can get
ahead of other Australian brands and even international brands and find out what exactly it is
this generation are looking for and what their buying habits are going to be then they can be
leaders in this area. This can be done by doing primary research like focus groups and
surveys and can also look at what is already known to form their own marketing scheme.
COG has a massive opportunity to make their supply chain completely transparent. This has
previously been seen to work positively for brands as customers like to see a product and
know exactly where everything has come from, if it is ethically/ sustainably sourced and
know how it has effected the environment. Companies that have done this successfully are
Reformation, Honest By and Maiyet. By looking at these companies they do have a relatively
higher price range than any of COG’s brands as they use sustainable fabrics etc. customers
feel they are doing good for the world even if it is in a small way. With this being such a big
trend in the fashion industry now and for the past couple of years, COG is quite behind.
Another recommendation is for COG to expand to new areas that would suit each of their
brands. As Typo has recently opened in UK and doing well they could look at opening more
stores and also look at opening Cotton On their once they have become more educated in the
market. Supre could be suited to the USA market for expansion once they have fully cracked
15
the Australian market and know what works here and doesn’t although US is a completely
different market and would need a lot of prior information so as to be sure that it succeeds.
Cotton on could expand more into the Asian market as it is already there but only has a few
stores. This could be costly depending what part of Asia they expand to but it is likely they
would need to change things about their brand e.g. size, styles, seasons. As different parts of
the world have different weather to Australia they would need to design different stock for
each part or only send certain styles to certain parts of the world which has been seen by a lot
can be seen by Kit Kat having an advertisement covering a park bench (See appendix E).
This is an effective use of ambient marketing as anyone walking past or sitting down would
think of Kit Kat and likely to buy one or have it on their mind. It stands out as an
advertisement with the red wrapper on half of it. The ad can appeal to any age group or
market as these are all their target market so they have done this very well. Cotton On could
put large mirrors around the city on bus shelters with an item of clothing where potential
customers walking by can stop and see what they would look like in that item of clothing
(See appendix E)
Sensation marketing is one off advertisements that catches people’s attention as they walk by.
Sprite did this is in one of their advertisements seen in Appendix F which worked effectively
as they made it look like the showers on the beach were sprinkling out sprite from a soft
drink machine. This is an example of sensation marketing as they are getting wet by the
16
they are targeting the right market and from the beach the people may have been dehydrated
and gone and brought a sprite. Cotton On could look into doing something like this.
Viral marketing is a technique that a company does to spread around something so fast
through social media. Pokémon Go the app was an example of viral marketing even though
they didn’t outright do much marketing for the release of it, the nature of the game being
augmented reality was enough to get people excited about it and get the word of mouth out.
The app had the most downloads in the first week than any other on the app store (Pilon,
2017) showing that therefore this was viral marketing. Supre could create a slogan that gets
so well known that people can know the brand from hearing the slogan similar to Nike.
Stealth marketing is when a company markets in a way that the customer doesn’t realise they
are being marketed to and therefore are unaware that they are being persuaded to buy
something. This type of marketing often happens on movies where use product placement.
See Appendix G. Apple often product places on tv shows and movies and majority of the
viewers don’t realize that it is purposely being used to market to them. Cotton On could look
Ambush marketing is when a brand will use a big event to market or advertise without legally
paying. This is seen in Appendix H, at an Obama press conference where 3 people working
for Abercrombie and Fitch stood behind Obama and with the Fitch label in clear view for the
camera. This would of likely been a successful technique as millions of people watch the
press conferences and would have seen the label. Typo could put their pens and notepads into
17
References:
ABC News 2018, ‘Donald Trump is exploring re-joining the Trans-Pacific Partnership,
13/donald-trump-reportedly-exploring-rejoining-tpp-trade-deal-talks/9652202>
Australian College of Marketing 2014, ‘Defining Consumer Behaviour & the Decision
<http://www.australiancollegeofmarketing.com.au/marketing/buyer-behaviour.php>
Baptist World Aid Australia, 2018, ‘2017 Ethical Fashion Guide, Baptist World Aid
fashion-guide/>
BBC News 2018, TPP: What is it and why does it matter?, BBC News, viewed on 12 April
2018, <http://www.bbc.com/news/business-32498715>
Cotton on Group 2018, Our History, Cotton On Group, viewed on 10 April 2018,
<http://cottonongroup.com.au/our-story/>
Cotton on Group 2018, Our store foot print, Cotton On Group, viewed on 10 April 2018,
<http://cottonongroup.com.au/our-store-footprint/>
<http://cottonongroup.com.au/sustainability/>
Cotton on Group 2018, ‘Cotton On Body leads the way’, Cotton On Group, viewed on 10
Cotton on Group 2018, ‘Get to know our suppliers’, Cotton On Group, viewed on 10 April
2018, <http://cottonongroup.com.au/sustainability/our-suppliers/get-to-know-our-suppliers/>
18
Cotton on Group 2018, ‘Our Brands, Cotton On Group, viewed on 10 April 2018,
<http://cottonongroup.com.au/our-brands/cotton-on/>
Chung, G 2017, ‘Australias Richest 2017:How this college dropout turned billionaire built a
Courtenay, A 2016, ‘Small Business and startup failure rate: is it a cause for concern?’, The
business/small-business-and-startup-failure-rate-is-it-a-cause-for-concern-20161110-
gsmadd.html>
Claveria, K 2017, ‘When it comes to Gen Z, forget everything you know about brand loyalty’
loyalty>
Cotton on Group 2018, ‘Our achievements’, Cotton On Group, viewed on 10 April 2018,
<http://cottonongroup.com.au/sustainability/our-commitment/our-achievements/>
Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade 2018, Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement
for Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP-11), Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, viewed
pacific-partnership-agreement-tpp.aspx>
Inside Retail, 2018, ‘Cotton On pulling Factorie from two markets’ Inside Retail, viewed 12
from-two-markets/>
Jovey Wai Kwan Leung, Gail Taylor, 2002, "Fashion buying criteria of X Generation
Jacqueline K. Eastman, Jun Liu, 2012, "The impact of generational cohorts on status
19
consumption: an exploratory look at generational cohort and demographics on status
Kimmorley, S 2017, ‘Australian Retialers are pioneers of innovation and Amazon won’t
<https://www.businessinsider.com.au/australian-retailers-are-pioneers-of-innovation-and-
amazon-wont-change-that-2017-4>
Mind Tools 2018, ‘Porter’s generic strategies’, Mind tools, viewed 14 April 2018,
<https://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/newSTR_82.htm>
Magner, L 2017, ‘Clothing Retailing in Australia’, Report no.G4251, industry report, Ibis
World Database
<https://www.forbes.com/sites/gracechung/2017/11/01/australias-richest-2017-cotton-
on/#1a9e5f576621>
O’shea, D 2017, ‘5 technologies reshaping retail in 2017’, Retail Dive, viewed 12 April,
<https://www.retaildive.com/news/5-technologies-reshaping-retail-in-2017/433954/>
Pilon, A 2017, ‘These were the best viral campaigns of 2016’, small business trends, viewed
Pop Sugar 2018, ‘Elle Roseby, the women that turned Supre into a sisterhood’, Pop sugar,
Elle-Roseby-Interview-44542462>
20
Reserve Bank of Australia 2018, ‘Exchange Rates’, viewed 12 April 2018,
<https://www.rba.gov.au/statistics/frequency/exchange-rates.html>
<https://www.thereformation.com/pages/sustainable-practices>
Stavros P. Kalafatis, Michael Pollard, Robert East, Markos H. Tsogas, 1999, "Green
21
7.Appendices
Appendix A
Environmental Trends Is it What is the likely impact?
Factors opportunity
or threat?
Political -Government stability threat High
-GST -Makes it harder to trade with
-Brexit Brexit and Trump trade laws
-Trump Presidency
(TPP)
-Regulation
Economic -Economy Threat and Moderate to high
-Unemployment opportunity -economy is different in all
-Interest Rates countries but if Aus was unstable
-Exchange Rates would cause big problems for
-Inflation COG
Social -Education level Threat and Moderate
-Safety opportunity -Buying habits of each generation
-Buying habits can be very difficult to market to
-Population growth rate each segmentation
-with a bigger population rate
there will be a bigger market in
future
Technological -The Rate of Threat and Moderate
technological change opportunity -Australia is behind in
-Access to the newest technology
and best technology
-Access to internet
Ecological -Weather threat High
22
-Climate change -If the weather is bad then
-Recycling suppliers won’t be able to get
-Sustainability product to where it needs to be
Appendix B
23
-Strong knowledge of have any ethical problems
market with suppliers
Internal Weaknesses -Cotton has become cheaper -As they are not up to date
-Not up to date with and therefore could spend a with technology this could
technology bit extra to get the better- cause them to fall way
-Quality quality cotton behind in terms of their
-On trend design - Acquisition of new brands other competitors
-Brand perception may help to increase the -Having good quality
-Social Media trendiness garments can come back to
-Product line -Trading up would increase ethical problems with the
-Store merchandising the product line supplier and also not being
-Vertical integration could up to date on technology
also help to improve the -Compared to some of COG
quality competitors their stores are
very messy
Appendix C
Forces: Barriers to Substitutes Buyer power Supplier Rivalry
Entry power
Impact Moderate Moderate Low Moderate High
level: high,
moderate or
low
Detailing -High fixed -As COG -COG -They have -COG has so
costs for rent already offer customers so many many
etc. to open a broad want different competitors
new stores range of improvement suppliers for for each of
-High products, in quality but all of the their brands
returns from substitutes still to keep brands so it locally and
experience are not an low price isn’t a high internationally
as they have issue -Customers impact level -As most of
already been -Quality don’t have -The quality their brands
around a could be a much buying of the are still in
long time reason that power as product is their growth
-Being in customers COG knows still very stage of the
Australia substitute their important life cycle they
they have -If the customer and needs to are still
lots of customer very well so be competing
access to doesn’t want are already standardized very hard with
different clothing giving them -Completely their
suppliers then they mostly what transparent competitors
can spend they want supply chain
24
-To start up their money is something
a new brand on a lot of that
under their other things customers
name may are wanting
be difficult now
Appendix D
Market Share
Low
High
Star Question Mark
Cotton on Body
High
Cotton on kids
Market growth rate
Cotton on Factorie
Supre
Low
Rubi Shoes
25
Appendix E
Appendix F
Appendix G
26
Appendix H
27