Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 STATE OF HAWAII
3
____________________________
4 )
STATE OF HAWAII, )
5 )
Plaintiff, )
6 )
vs. )
7 )
PHILIP BIKLE, ) 3DTC-16-005744
8 )
Defendant. )
9 ____________________________)
10
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
11
before the Honorable Harry Freitas, Judge, Puna at Hilo
12 Division, presiding on Thursday, December 15, 2016.
14
APPEARANCES:
15
EVANS SMITH
16 Deputy Prosecuting Attorney
19
20
21
22
23
24
REPORTED BY: Audrey Tanouye, CSR 225
25 Official Court Reporter, State of Hawaii
Audrey S. Tanouye, CSR 225
Official Court Reporter, State of Hawaii
2
2 --OoO--
19 of the Court.
5 them with me. And the fact that the case file lacks the
11 the Court.
13 the court clerks just erred when they initiated a case as,
20 that.
25 Bikle. I understand you have all the motions, but did you
3 prosecution so --
5 easy question --
1 when you come in and say, "Hey, you know what, I want this
13 not --
16 a policeman.
20 that. I'll be more than glad to look at what you got, but
23 day.
1 proceed.
4 you're not going to deal with that right now? Would you
11 on.
21 a chance to get your sleep. Give you time to get all this
4 that I've been given, and the case file completely lacks
6 defense.
13 it. I don't know what else you want. So until you file
19 a traffic window?
23 paperwork squared away and get it done. Then that way the
3 intelligent response.
11 Tuesday.
18 Because if you file the motion, I'm not going to let you
21 get whatever you want and figure out what you want to do.
23 them, you can always say, "Hey, I don't want your help any
7 decide to have them help you, and then you decide to file
13 that fashion.
18 paperwork, because they won't have it, and try and talk to
19 you also.
1 that the State must prove each and every element of these
11 obligated to do that.
15 do --
17 certain deadlines --
24 law so.
6 you another date to come back. I'm not going to give any
8 When you come back on that date we'll see where you're at.
9 MR. BIKLE: Come back for an actual hearing as to
17 give you a heads up, that I don't have a problem with it,
22 paperwork.
25 right now so --
5 squared away.
14 days.
16 motions; right?
21 when you come back on the 24th I should have the motions
3 Bikle.
6 (9:03 a.m.)
7 --oOo--
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
1 STATE OF HAWAII )
2 COUNTY OF HAWAII )
3 ______________________________)
11
12
14
16
17
20
21
22
23
24
25
3 ________________________
STATE OF HAWAII, )
4 )
)
5 vs. )
)
6 PHILIP BIKLE, )
)
7 Defendant. )
________________________)
8
14 APPEARANCES:
17
MR. PHILIP BIKLE Defendant, Pro Se
18
19
22
23
24
25
2
8 of State.
25 pending an appeal.
3
15 about?
16 MR. BIKLE: The only one that should be on the
22 uh, any --
3 from the very first day that I saw you and it continues --
9 been injured for the past sixteen years. I tore them and
10 I have a lot of scar tissue in a high proximal --
17 MR. BIKLE: I --
18 THE COURT: -- as --
8 follow up on that.
25 longer.
6
9 correct.
10 THE COURT: I would think you -- well let me
11 ask, would you like to wait until we get that one back
4 uh, together.
5 So if you would like to do that, we can do that.
3 the prosecution in the ICA case. Um, uh, what's her name?
8 have to print --
17 the record that he had read the motion in its entirety and
18 then later in that same hearing he inadvertently revealed
3 recuse him?
20 online system.
21 THE COURT: Yeah, 'cause when I -- I --
9 case --
10 THE COURT: Okay.
3 (indiscernible) --
17 prosecution?
18 THE COURT: It usually starts from the -- your
19 appearance in court.
23 Public Defenders?
24 MR. BIKLE: Uh --
23 representation?
24 MR. BIKLE: That sounds correct.
25 Judge Udovic.
15
9 THE COURT: Um --
10 MR. BIKLE: But again the infraction, uh, case
23 ICA --
24 THE COURT: Do you want --
6 MR. BIKLE: Uh --
7 THE COURT: I going tell you why I'm asking. I
8 -- I --
20 Totally up to you.
21 MR. BIKLE: Um, I'm not willing to waive, uh --
20 why.
21 MR. BIKLE: Well I haven't been arraigned so
22 I -- (indiscernible) --
8 Mr. Schlueter?
1 THE COURT: But you can file any motion you want
2 alleging that it's not. Or I should ask, 'cause this
11 back down?
20 that, and the fact that the case that, uh, this relied
21 upon, uh, Baranca [phonetic], I had to locate that and
3 have jurisdiction.
6 down.
7 THE COURT: Okay.
25 violation of statute.
21
9 charge?
10 MR. BIKLE: Um, I would like to have that in a
8 out. 'Cause when your response is, "he may or may not
9 have used any legal terms", what that basically means is,
10 "Everything he said I don't understand. So what I want --
23 have --
24 THE COURT: They're on --
4 your citation?
5 MR. BIKLE: The citation does not have them in
15 you want an attorney. And then when you say, "I don't
16 want an attorney, I wanna do this self [sic] on my own
22 you one attorney for the attorney to help you with that.
11 record?
4 process --
5 THE COURT: So -- so you --
17 of the bar.
18 THE COURT: Okay. So you want --
22 State of Hawaiì?
9 dismiss --
10 MR. BIKLE: I don't initiate anything. They are
11 suppose to initiate --
15 or did you?
16 MR. BIKLE: That's irrelevant.
11 statements.
6 MR. BIKLE: It be --
7 THE COURT: -- as far as the arraignment,
14 statute of limitations.
19 the arraignment --
23 plead.
24 THE COURT: I don't have a problem with --
6 your motions.
7 And then, um, you have a Rule 48 date that
9 set it?
10 MR. SCHLUETER: Um, soon as possible.
1 cannot --
2 MR. BIKLE: You're required to --
19 a --
9 Correct?
10 MR. BIKLE: I would like to stay at the --
15 doing --
16 MR. BIKLE: You're --
15 Mr. Bikle --
16 MR. BIKLE: You're ignoring me.
9 tangents, so --
10 MR. BIKLE: See now you're --
14 stop --
20 want it like the 25th or the 18th? When do you want it?
21 MR. SCHLUETER: 18 -- 18th is fine.
9 without knowing the date that was the final date that you
10 could actually have a trial. And this thing's been
14 not by my request.
15 THE COURT: -- go --
16 MR. BIKLE: -- to --
4 objections.
5 THE COURT: Mr. Bikle --
12 Mister --
13 MR. BIKLE: You don't --
19 hear it.
12 date, too.
13 THE CLERK: Okay.
17 gotta wait for the appeal to come back down, but I don't
18 want to end up giving you all these different dates. I
19 just wanna give you one date at a time. Are you okay with
20 that?
21 MR. BIKLE: You're gonna do what you -- you're
23 then.
24 (Hearing adjourned and next case called at 2:52:02 PM.)
25 ---o0o---
40
1 COUNTY OF HAWAII )
2 STATE OF HAWAII )
3 CERTIFICATE
12 2:52:02 PM.
13 Dated: ___________________________.
14
15
16 ____________________________________
19
20
21
22
23
24
25