Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Prepared By:
Ahmed Almulla, Matt Arnold, Hope Blanchette, Travis Blake, Joanna Grab, Melissa Goldfarb,
Sarah Laliberte, Andrea Leveille, Brad Mckinney, Luke Palma, Sara Rosenthal, John Stoddard
Introduction Statement
This book was written by twelve graduate students of
architecture (M. Arch.) at Northeastern University in the
fall of 2010 as part of our Master’s Research Studio. This
book will explore issues related to pre-constructed
building strategies in urban environments, thus the title,
Prefab City. As a result of this exploration and analysis,
we hope to uncover potential design opportunities in an
area that seems to be less well documented and
researched in the field. This book is intended to be used
by our studio, and could be useful to peers, professors or
professionals wanting an integrated understanding of an
approach to prefabricated building in a urban context.
Table of Contents
Introduction Determinants Deployment Tactics
Purpose ...............................................1 Transportation ..................................10 Density on Demand...........................68
by Ground: Rail ..........................................11 Definition, Factors ...................................69
Definitions .......................................... 2 by Ground: Road ........................................13 Mobility and Adaptability .........................70
by Water .....................................................21 Construction .............................................71
Research Methodology + Scope ......4 by Air ..........................................................23 Connections .............................................73
Process.....................................................77
Site Access + Assembly....................26
Site Access ...............................................27 Parasite + Barnacle............................80
Crane Operation and Extents ...................29 Urban Infill Sites ......................................81
Cranes and Obstacles .............................31 Definitions ................................................83
Off Frame Assembly ................................33 Parasite Precedents ................................85
Barnacle Precedents ...............................89
Modular Strategies ............................38
Logistics ...................................................39 Instant Utopia ..................................98
Site Placement Strategies .......................43 Introduction..............................................96
Aggregation Techniques .........................45 The Plug-In Tower .................................100
Mechanical Systems.................................47 The Expanding Monolith .......................106
The Artificial Hill town ............................110
Component Strategies .....................49
Definitions ..................................................51 Extreme Prefab................................118
On-Site Labor ...........................................53 Launching Gantry Game .......................120
Fabricated Unit .........................................55 Incremental Launching System ............124
Panel System ............................................57 Extra-Large Prefab ...............................128
Precast Concrete ......................................59
Kit-of-Parts ................................................61
Non Physical Contexts Precedents
Building Code..................................136 Rating Precedents .........................168
Regular....................................................137 Rating Systems ......................................169
HUD Code ..............................................138 Matrix Chart ............................................170
Prefab Scale ...........................................171
Zoning Code ...................................144 Enchridion................................................173
Boston ..................................................145
Charlottesville, VA ................................147 Precedents .....................................176
Little Rock, AK .....................................148
Economics ......................................150
Overview ...................................................151
HUD Code ................................................153
Single Family Modular .............................155
Stick Built Modular....................................156
Multi Family Modular ................................157
Multi Family Stick Built .............................158
Policy...............................................160
Purpose and Definitions
• How elements are prefabricated in a factory (not part of the construction or delivery
process), unless it is significant in terms of time/labor/quality issues.
INTRODUCTION
DETERMINANTS
Urban
Relating to, or belonging to, a city. Examples of prefabricated architecture are disproportionally located
in rural or suburban settings. Therefore, our aim is to focus on researching prefabrication in a more
dense urban fabric. Although the ‘density’ factor is loosely defined, the context should be clearly
understood as urban.
Prefab
DEPLOYMENT
Definitions for this word vary slightly but are all common in the sense that they are too broad and
general (factory-built, factory-made, pre-cut, panelized, manufactured, modular, mobile). For our
purposes, we are defining prefab as a building or structure that is manufactured in standard parts off-
site to be shipped and assembled elsewhere.
To be even more rigid in our definition of prefab, we have developed a matrix and identified projects or
methods of construction just outside the matrix to define the borders of our research zone. The
projects within the matrix re-enforce our definition of prefab.
CONTEXT
Delivery Method
‘Delivery method’ has different meanings in different fields and even within the field of architecture, it
can have various implications. Since it is an important factor in Prefab City, a precise definition, for our
purposes, is required. By delivery methods, we mean the mode of transportation and route from
factory where a prefab element was made to the actual construction site, and everything in between.
PRECEDENTS
Introduction • 2
Research Methodology and Scope
To make our research and findings more effective Asphalt Road Drop House
and useful, we have devised a strategy to
calculate or ‘rate’ the degree or ‘prefabness’ for
each of the examples presented. Firstly, the
matrix helps us define our boundaries on what
constitutes prefab. In other words, the limits of
degree of ‘prefabness’ are defined by the projects
around the border of the matrix, and everything
within falls in our realm of study.
Puma City
DETERMINANTS
Drop House Nomadic
Museum
Precast Concrete
Metastadt Segmented Bridges
Pierson Court
Nakagin Tower
DEPLOYMENT
Use Kim House Elemental Box City Bailey Use
Residential Bridge Infrastructure
Hong Kong
Tower
Habitat 67
CONTEXT
2 x 4 Res. Elemental Permanent
Infill
Zollverein Temporary
PRECEDENTS
Keetwonen Asphalt
Road
Custom
Adobe Hut/ On-site
Igloo Construction Standard
Introduction • 4
Determinants
INTRODUCTION
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
de·ter·mi·nant
[dih-tur-muh-nuhnt]
–noun
1. a determining agent or factor.
PRECEDENTS
delivery of a prefabricated element. Prefab
delivery must be carefully thought through to
ensure smooth transition from factory to site.
Factors to pay special attention to include method
of transportation, site restrictions, and the
construction strategy.
Determinants • 6
Transportation
Transportation •
8
PRECEDENTS
when using a barge, port locations in relation to operate the device and the cost associated with from this mode of transportation.
site are critical factors that limit the use of water delivery.
transport.
Transportation • 10
by Ground: Rail
Rail transportation provides an economical
alternative to truck transport for longer shipping Seattle
distances (over 250 miles). In the United States,
there is an existing network of freight railways
that serve the major metropolitan areas.
Boston
Chicago
Cities that are located close to water most often New York
have the greatest convergence of railroads. Philadelphia
Waterways offer the greatest capabilities for Los Angeles Washington D.C.
intermodal transport.
US System of Railways
DETERMINANTS
environment.
DEPLOYMENT
Typical Railcar dimension is set by
container container dimension so that
dimension two containers can fit on
one car
Trailer lengths also
accomodate container
dimensions
CONTEXT
req’d clearance 18’-9” req’d clearance 20’-9”
Worcester Boston
20’ -3”
18’ -3”
PRECEDENTS
< 19’-6”
Other Railway
Dump Truck
Advantages: Large freight weight compacity
Disadvantages: Width could be problematic
when trying to traverse complex sites.
Flatdeck Trailer
11’-0”
37’-0”
8’-6”
a b 10’-0”
10’-0”
52’-6” 29’-0”
8’-6” 9’-0”
11’-6”
9’-2” 10’-0”
* maximizes height
8’-6”
DETERMINANTS
8’-6” 14’-0”
45,000 lbs. 48,000 lbs.
Oversized Load
10’-0”
48’-0”
DEPLOYMENT
63’-0”
8’-6”
8’-6”
10’-0”
16’-0”
48,000 lbs.
CONTEXT
10’-0”
50’-0”
8’-6”
11’-6”
9’-0”
PRECEDENTS
10’-0”
40,000 lbs.
a1 b1 c b2 a2
INTRODUCTION
DETERMINANTS
Landscape Street Furniture Signage Pedestrian Utilities
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
Truck Turning Obstacles
PRECEDENTS
‘Making the turn’ is one of the challeneges of
truck transport when building in an urban
environment. The many obstacles the city
presents (parked cars, telephone poles, stop
signs, etc.) make routing a truck to site one of the
City Utilities Lighting Parallel Parking
most important parts of the process.
Transportation • 18
Truck Turning Radii
The swept path a truck takes as it makes a right Swept path of truck
60°
turn is a critical moment. To the right is a diagram
that explains the logics of how a truck makes a
turn.
60°
60°
90° 90°
a
a
b
b
180° 180°
a: 53’-0” a: 53’-0”
b: 8’-6” b: 8’-6”
critical swept path critical swept path
CONTEXT
90° 90°
90°
a a
a
b
*cannot make a 180° b
PRECEDENTS
b with a 60’ radius
180°
a: up to 80’-0” a: 48’-0” a: 75’-0” or 1/3 truck bed length
180°
b: 8’-6” b: 16’-0” b: 8’-6”
critical swept path critical swept path critical swept path
Stretch Semi-Truck Oversized Load (Width) Oversized Load (Length)
Transportation • 20
by Water
Vessels used for transport range in size based on
the depth of water being traveled. The prefab
component’s size, if only traveling by water, is
restricted by the smallest body of water it travels
through.
DETERMINANTS
World’s largest container ship, Emma Maersk:
1,302 feet long, 184 feet wide
11,000 full TEU 14-ton containers
Football field:
DEPLOYMENT
300 feet long
CONTEXT
RO-RO Roll-on/Roll-Off varies by size subdivided into multiple types, many carry vehicles and containers
Sto-Ro off wheel cargo, brought on board by a ramp at stern or side entry
Container/Ro-Ro flexibile storage- containers on + under deck forward, ramps at stern for aft
underdeck. Ro-Ro cargo is often construction equipment
Ferry Shallow transport distance less than 300miles, often personal vehicles and rail cars
Heavy Lift Deep capable of unloading/loading heavy/bulky components - typical single lift of 100 tons
Crane Ship off-load containers from non self-sustaining ships offshore or underdeveloped ports
PRECEDENTS
FLO-FLO Float-On/Float-Off submerges open deck entirely under water surface, smaller cargo ship is
floated over, water is pumped out of ballast tanks
Barge Carrier Ships Shallow very long length compared to width, hard to handle and off-load to
Container Ships Deep containers stack 5 or 6 high, twelve across and interlocked with fittings- typically rely
on shore cargo handling gear for unloading/loading
Transportation • 22
by Air
It may be cost effective to transport by air using a
freight aircraft if the elements are small enough
and light enough to fit inside a cargo hold.
Utilizing an air crane, despite its hourly cost, may
container /
palette
be necessary if the urban site is particularly
difficult to access by truck and standard cranes.
The boom height necessary to place a prefab
large main-deck
component may require too large of a crane for
cargo door
the adjacent street size. In this instance lifting a
prefab unit as large as many typical single family
homes may be the efficient option for transport.
DETERMINANTS
23
0m
im
DEPLOYMENT
ax
im
um
dis
t
an
ce
Air Crane / Skycrane Specs:
CONTEXT
Length: 70 feet
Height: 18ft 7 inches
Empty Weight: 19,234 lb
Max takeoff weight: 42,000 lb
PRECEDENTS
truck/rail/water transport
Rate of climb: 1,3330 ft/min
vessel
Ceiling: 9,000 ft
http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/ship/sealift-ships.htm
http://earthpulse.nationalgeographic.com/earthpulse/earthpulse-map
http://www.massfreightandrailplan.com/documents/rail_plan/Draft%20MA%20State%20Rail%20
Plan090910.pdf
http://www.stevenswest.com/trailer_selector.shtml
http://www.dot.ca.gov/hq/traffops/trucks/trucksize/height.htm
Image Credits:
http://crcyc.railfan.net/wall/other/frye-beacon.jpg
http://www.hankstruckpictures.com/pix/trucks/george_fiebe/2008/08-12/file002.jpg
http://www.billemory.com/blogimg02/k639b4-semi-franklin.jpg
http://www.flickr.com/photos/36722129@N06/4168030601/
Site Access + Assembly
courtyard
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
corner site narrow site full access to site
Jog Reset
The jib is very useful to hold the modular unit in
an almost upright position. It has the potential to
resolve design issues thanks to its ability to
Crane cab controls
suspend the module in a way different from the
way a crane typically does.
143' 80°
DETERMINANTS
jib
122' 44°
95' 20°
80°
DEPLOYMENT
42' 72' 101' 130' 170'
56'
CONTEXT
24'-7"
340'-0"
outrigger
190'-0"
20'-0"
outrigger
PRECEDENTS
360°
360° work area
work area
Site Access + Assembly • 30
Crane + Obstacles
Hand signals
INTRODUCTION
Obstacles on a construction site
There are a variety of existing physical barriers
that must be worked around. These can lead to
interesting, even fruitful design moves. They
includew but are not limited to:
Utility poles
DETERMINANTS
Power lines
Lamp posts
Trees
Fire hyrdants
Subterranian utilities
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Site Access + Assembly • 32
Off Frame Assembly
Module Site 43 %
INTRODUCTION
41' 25' 17'
DETERMINANTS
6' 6' 6'
DEPLOYMENT
Stretch Semi Truck Oversized Load (Width) Oversized Load (Length)
minimum site dimensions minimum site dimensions minimum site dimensions
41’ wide x 80’ deep 25’ wide x 48’ deep 17’ wide x 63’ deep
module dimensions module dimensions module dimensions
8’-6” wide x 80’ deep 16’ wide x 48’ deep 16’ wide x 48’ deep
CONTEXT
21 % 64 % 50 %
PRECEDENTS
Site Access + Assembly • 34
Off Frame Assembly
PRECEDENTS
Site Access + Assembly • 36
Site Access + Assembly
Sources
Modular Strategies • 38
12’-0” standard
construction process. The use of modules greatly
reduces time for the construction schedule (see
12’-0” standard
below) by allowing builders to work
simultaneously on and off site. In working
primarily off-site, negative impacts on the
environment 8’-6” no permitting
and post-construction site revival required (standard)
12’-0” permit required (wide)
are greatly reduced.
14’-0” escort required (wide)
special route required (oversize) 8’-6” no permitting required (standard)
16’-0”
Module dimensions are determined by the 12’-0” permit required (wide)
14’-0” escort required (wide)
Massachusetts Department of Transportation. special route required (oversize)
16’-0”
MassDOT codes restrict travel of certain trucks
and load sizes during high volume traffic hours.
standard
12’-0”
standard oversize maximum
40’-0”
53’-0” standard oversize
76’-0”
40’-0”
53’-0”
Site Built Construction Schedule 76’-0”
DESIGN PERMITING ON-SITE ON-SITE ON-SITE
schematics + documents submission + approvals preparation + foundation building construction site restoration
DETERMINANTS
HSS frame
steel form deck
3” concrete
HSS frame
steel studs
gwb
cladding
DEPLOYMENT
Steel framed modules are constructed with a
hollow structural steel frame that is infilled with
light gague steel studs. The modules arrive on
site with interior and exterior finish materials
installed, are fastened to one another and
finishing touches are made. The steel module
shown to the right allows for the construction of a
maximum twelve story building.
CONTEXT
exploded axonometric
mate-line
concrete floor
mate-line
PRECEDENTS
gwb ceiling
2 layers type x gwb
mineral wool fire stop
firesafing
marriage wall section
Modular Strategies • 40
Logistics
gwb ceiling
2 x 6 ceiling joists
gwb finish wall
(2) 2 x 12 beam
floor sheathing
2x4 studs (2) 2 x 10 beam
2x10 floor joists
2x6 studs
sheathing
cladding
DETERMINANTS
steel post
steel channel
1” plywood floor
steel joists
rubber gasket
securing bars
Shipping container modules can come from
steel doors
actual recycled shipping containers, or can be
custom constructed for specific projects.
DEPLOYMENT
Shipping containers are intended to be stacked
for the transportation of goods, and therefore
stack easily as well to form buildings. The
corrugated side walls provide a lot of the
containers strucural capacity, and need to be
reinforced with columns if sections are removed
as shown above exploded axonometric
CONTEXT
steel angle below
steel channel at plywood seam
corrugated side wall
steel joists below
corrugated end wall
steel permieter beam
1” plywood floor
PRECEDENTS
steel bottom block
steel vertical support
On-Frame Modular
There are two main strategies for placing modular Off-frame construction (see below) is commonly
buildings on to a site. On-frame construction (see used for multi-story buildings. The module is
above), also known as mobile homes, is limited to placed onto the back of a flat-bed truck for
single story structures. Modules are placed on a shipment, and is craned into its site upon arrival.
chassis, hitched to a truck, and brought to site. The modules can be stacked according to local
The chassis is lowered onto a set of piers and zoning and codes, as well as the structural
detached from the truck. The chassis and wheels integrity of the system. Off-frame systems are
are left beneath the module, making the structure typically viewed as permanant.
temporary in nature
Off-Frame Modular
DEPLOYMENT
craning sequence
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
anchor module to foundation
Modular Strategies • 44
Aggregation Techniques
There are several ways modules can be Non-attached Semi-attached
aggregated to form a building. Modules can be
not attached, semi attached, or attached as seen
in the diagrams to the right. Here are several
examples of how modules can be aggregated
within the different levels of attachment. The
examples listed are existing aggregation
techniques in their simplest form.
DETERMINANTS
Mate Stack Void : Bridge
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
Mate : Shift Stack : Shift Void: Bridge
PRECEDENTS
Mate : Turn Stack : Turn
Modular Strategies • 46
Mechanical Systems
DETERMINANTS
shaft space mechanical systems
DEPLOYMENT
electrical connection
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
shipping container mechanical units
2010.http://www.modular.org/documents/document_publication/permanent2010.
pdf (accessed Oct. 2010).
Images
Melissa Goldfarb
John Wilde
http://www.lot-ek.com
http://www.kullman.com
Component Strategies
Component Strategies • 50
PRECEDENTS
package is used as a portion of the finished
product. It can include any number and
combination of the fabricated unit, the panel
system, or precast components. Coordination of
products is done off-site then delivered.
Component Strategies • 52
On-Site Labor
The benefit of prefabricated systems is mostly
realized in the reduction of construction on-site
labor. Prefabricating components, panels, or
modules can significantly reduce the amount of
time workers are present at the site. The
reduction of on-site time obviously reduces
construction labor cost but also has the potential
to reduce the amount of errors experienced at the
construction site.
51 lbs 2” H × 4” W x 8’-0” L
DETERMINANTS
150 lbs 10’-0” H x 4’-0” W x 6” L
DEPLOYMENT
< 2,000 lbs 4’ H x 4’ W x 3’-4” L
CONTEXT
20,000 lbs 11’-6” H x 8’-0” W x 48’-0” L
PRECEDENTS
25,000 lbs 15’-0” H x 60’-0” W x 9’-0” L
Component Strategies • 54
Fabricated Units
Fabricated units have the advantage of being
constructed in a controlled environment.
Compared to stick-built methodology, fabrication
groups the individual studs, beams and joists
within a factory setting. Instead of installing and
connecting each stud to the foundation through
the footer of a wall, the framing is made into a
component that includes the header, footer and
all the studs for a predetermined length of wall.
Degrees of Prefabrication
Stud Stud Panel Bridge Truss
elevation
plan
INTRODUCTION
Roof Structure
Interior Finish
DETERMINANTS
Framing
Column-Beam Connection
DEPLOYMENT
Cladding
Apetures
CONTEXT
Foundation
Fabricated Unit Logic
PRECEDENTS
Steel Frame Construction
Component Strategies • 56
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT PRODUCT
Panel System
3
4
Last Panel
Initial Panel
Panel Installation Sequence
Component Strategies • 58
Structural Components 1 2 3 4
Slabs
length factor by function of service
width by transportation restriction
5 6 7
Beams
depth is dependent on length 10
length is function of capacity load
Columns
1. Solid
height is dependent on the width
2. Hollow Core
8 9 3. Single Tee
Precast concrete construction is most readily 4. Double Tee
seen within the city as infrastructure. It is a 5. Rectangular
versitile construction type. Any shape and size is 6. Inverted Tee
possible as long as the overall component 7. L-shaped
conforms to the smallest restrictions on size 8. Round|Rectangle
based on transportation used to get from 9. Square
precaster to the job site. Refer to the 10. Double Height
Transportation Sub-Chapter for restraints, per
transport type.
DETERMINANTS
Bulkhead
New Segment
Older Segment
Older Segment
Soffit adjustable formwork for precast segments
DEPLOYMENT
Carriage
New Old
Outside Formwork
CONTEXT
Long Line Casting System
PRECEDENTS
Inside Formwork
Plan
Component Strategies • 60
Kit-of-Parts
Examples
Container End Product
Sunshower Kit
doors
windows
DETERMINANTS
container
casework
fasteners
panels
DEPLOYMENT
plumbing
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Contained in the Kit
Component Strategies • 62
Component Strategies
Sources
Precast Concrete by NEU School of Architecture Graduate Students Fall 2009 (Michelle Callinan, Daniel Riggs, Chris Kuczynski with Matthew Littell)
US Department of Housing and Urban Development “Design, Fabrication and Installation of Engineered Panelized Walls: Two Case Studies”
http://www.huduser.org/Publications/PDF/panelized_walls.pdf
Images:
http://www.enlisted.info/field-manuals/fm-5-277-bailey-bridge.shtml
http://www.usace.army.mil/History/hv/Pages/098-Role_of_US_Army_Corps.aspx
http://www.flickr.com/photos/42108746@N00/30019541/
http://tinyhouseblog.com/galapagos.html
http://www.steelworksnz.co.nz/projects/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/nycstreets/4831935944/
http://www.kozialconstruction.com/
http://tulane.edu/news/newwave/081710_sunshower.cfm
http://www.metamere.com/images/segmentalbridgeunderconstruction4.jpg
http://www.mtc.ca.gov/images/ta02-0307/skyway.jpg
http://www.gautrain.co.za/web_images/_2S22gQ.jpg
http://www.djc.com/stories/images/20090716/DSCN1968_big.jpg
Component Strategies • 64
CONTEXT
helps to create subtle links between the urban
Tactics: any mode of procedure for gaining context and each precedent to foster design
success. discoveries. Overall, projects were selected
based upon the following criteria:
• Clarity of the deployment method
Deployment Tactics takes an in-depth look at • Unique prefab implementation
PRECEDENTS
current techniques to rapidly deliver prefab • Relationship to the urban condition
architecture and infrastructure. This chapter • Success of the conceptual approach
studies projects with unique construction • Scale: S - XXL
solutions, which can be useful in the urban
context.
Deployment Tactics • 66
Density on Demand
Density on Demand • 68
Factors
• Mobility
• Adaptability
• Quick On-Site Installation
• Light Footprint
INTRODUCTION
Mobility + Adaptability
The ability to be transported to a site fully
constructed, with minimal site work, creates
opportunities for a potential site, regardless of
location, for instant urbanism. The fact these
mobile shelters can be erected on site then
DETERMINANTS
moved whenever needed adds a unique aspect to
their designs. In the case of the Quonset hut,
since it was developed for multiple regions
around the world, it incorporated sleds, wheels,
chassis or even empty oil drums as pontoons to
be transported. Mobile or HUD code homes
maintain the chassis used in transport while
DEPLOYMENT
occupying a site which can be reused in order to
move the building to a different location.
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Density on Demand • 70
Construction
On-Site Installation
The amount of time spent with on-site
construction has a significant effect on
implemention strategies. Instant urbanism is
automatically tied to its connection with the earth,
the amount of on-site earthwork involved and the
permanence of those connections. The Quonset
Hut and Fema Trailers are two examples that
minimize sitework and on-site construction to Wood Frame House
create efficient instant urbanism. Sitework is able
to proceed in parallel with the prefabrication
process so when the materials arrive on site there
is a minimum amount of work to prepare in order
to receive the structure. The Quonset Hut has all
of its pieces prefabricated on-site and utilizes
simple connections in the field for quick
installation. HUD code and mobile homes in
general are completely prefabricated, the chassis
being reused on-site as supports and remaining
attached to the unit. Mobile/HUD Code Home
Installation Time
Wood Frame House + foundation - One Month
Quonset Hut - One Day Quonset Hut
Mobile Home - Six Hours (approx.)
Density on Demand • 72
Quonset Hut
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
Quonset Hut
Slab on Grade
PRECEDENTS
Earth Displaced
320 ft3
Density on Demand • 74
Connections
Semi-Permanent Construction
Mobile Home
Concrete Piers
Footings
Earth Displaced
37.3 ft3
INTRODUCTION
Permanent Conventional Construction
Wood Frame
House
DETERMINANTS
Basement
DEPLOYMENT
Displacement
9600ft3
Wood Frame
House
CONTEXT
Crawlspace
PRECEDENTS
Displacement
3840ft3
Density on Demand • 76
Process
Delivery
INTRODUCTION
Recycled +
Quonset Hut Relocated
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
Erection Military Base Military Base
CONTEXT
Disaster Relief
Trailer Park Trailer Park
PRECEDENTS
Recylced +
Mobile Home Unit Relocated
Density on Demand • 78
Density on Demand
Sources
Cotsalas, Valerie. “Standoff at Nassau’s Last Trailer Park.” The New York Times - Breaking News,
World News & Multimedia. 13 Jan. 2008. Web. 08 Nov. 2010. <http://www.nytimes.com/>.
Decker, Julie, and Chris Chiei. Quonset Hut: Metal Living for a Modern Age. New York: Princeton
Architectural, 2005.
“Excel Home Factory Photos.” Modular Homes Consumer Guide Manufactured Home Floorplans and
Prices. Web. 08 Nov. 2010. <http://www.modulartoday.com/gallery-excelfactory.html>.
Parasite + Barnacle
Parasite + Barnacle • 80
DEPLOYMENT
“Typical Infill”
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
“Below” “Above”
Parasite + Barnacle • 82
Definitions
Parasite
DEPLOYMENT
Barnacle prefab is a similar type of prefabricated barnacles attached to a rock
architecture to parasite prefab, as it responds to
infill site possibilities within the urban
environment in a similar way. Barnacle prefab
does attach itself to an existing structure, but the
main difference is that it can survive on its own.
CONTEXT
Barnacle prefab is self-sufficient, with separate
independent systems from its host. Primarily, the
barnacle prefab would only utilize the host for
structural or real estate purposes. It is more
permanent than parasite prefab.
PRECEDENTS
barnacle architecture precedent
Parasite + Barnacle • 84
Parasite Precedents
DETERMINANTS
Interstitial Space
g
tio
ce
in
di
pa
ild
Ad
Bu
lS
er
ia
g
in
t it
t in
ta
rs
Existing Building
is
on
te
Ex
In
DEPLOYMENT
C
Unoccupiable Space
CONTEXT
acts as parasite prefab because the containers
are attached to and feed on the systems of the
existing building. The structural system of
concrete beams and columns is directly
connected to the structural system existent in the
host building. These containers can not exist on
their own; they rely on the host building to
PRECEDENTS
efficiently function. The containers were designed
to be added to the existing building, yet this
additional structural system causes a large
percentage in loss of usable or functional space
of the 900 square meter addition. Unoccupiable Space
Parasite + Barnacle • 86
Parasite Precedents
Existing Systems
DEPLOYMENT
Crane Transport
CONTEXT
Parasite Circulation
Water Transport
Existing Circulation
PRECEDENTS
Crane Site Assembly Assembly Section
Parasite + Barnacle • 88
Barnacle Precedents
DEPLOYMENT
Independent Barnacle Circulation
Circulation Section
CONTEXT
Services Shaft
PRECEDENTS
Independent Barnacle Circulation
Assembly Section
Parasite + Barnacle • 90
3 Barnacle Precedents
Just the Facts:
Date: 1998
Location: Sevilla, Spain
Typology: Temporary Scaffolding / Residential
INTRODUCTION
and the scaffolding project must be approved by
an architect. The scaffolding, composed of 60 x
60 x 3 mm beams and 100 x 10 mm collars of
galvanized steel, was assembled with a group of
welders who helped to form the steel ribs. The
structure was then covered by flexible sheets of
PVC foam. Storage space was added to give the
DETERMINANTS
structure more function. The last step was to add
a movable staircase and the project was ready to
go as a temporary shelter.
DEPLOYMENT
Independent BarnacleCirculation
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Assembly Section
Parasite + Barnacle • 92
Parasite + Barnacle
Sources
Brayer, Marie-Ange, and Béatrice Simonot. ArchiLab’s Futurehouse: Radical Experiments in Living
Space. New York: Thames & Hudson, 2002.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infill
http://www.collagecityfilm.com/archives/category/musings
http://www.remoratrade.com/
http://www.kortekniestuhlmacher.nl/laspalmas.html
http://www.kortekniestuhlmacher.nl/laspalmas.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parasitism
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnacle
http://www.calderflower.com.au/
http://www.designboom.com/weblog/cat/9/view/7625/lara-calder-architects-parasite-prefab.html
http://www.recetasurbanas.net/index.php
Instant Utopia
Instant Utopia • 94
The idea of creating an utopian architecture or the utopian theme. Ultimately, adaptability to
urban fabric has often been a romanticized con- specificities that site conditions present is what
cept rather than realistic one. While it is not new, gives prefabricated architecture an advantage
the idea still intrigues architects today for various over the traditional stick built type.
reasons: control, efficiency, master planning, etc.
During the renaissance, designers and artists Instant Utopia consists of three precedents that
such as Johannes Andreae and Bartolomeo were selected due to the clarity of the type for
Andreae’s Christianopolis , 1619 which they represent. Those buildings are as
flirted with the concept of the perfect world, the
Garden of Eden, and published catalogues of follows:
their engraving and writings on the subject. 1. Nakagin Capsule Tower, Kisho K. 1972
2. Habitat ‘67, Moshe Safdie, 1967
Today, there is a limited number of actual built 3. Metastadt, Richard Dietrich, 1972
projects that fall within the realm of utopia. An identifying name is given to each building type
Instant Utopia attempts to identify the key fea- that clearly addresses the unique attributes of the
tures of this architecture in regards to deploy- type. The following page goes into further detail,
ment. Prefabricated architecture, whether in the identifying the key features of this type and creat-
form of modular/capsule living environments, or ing a usable language for the precedents.
DETERMINANTS
unaffected by its context. It starts as an initial
growth and slowly, or rapidly, metastasizes into
an endlessly adaptable system, creating city out
of density.
The Artificial Hilltown explores the idea of making Dense Urban Fabric Plug-In Capsule
Ascending Armature
urbanism on a site, regardless of the contextual
environment. Flipping and re-aggregating the The Expanding Monolith
“blocks” to make a picturesque environment is
DEPLOYMENT
what gives the type its fake variety.
CONTEXT
Dense Urban Fabric Initial Monolith Expanding Effect
PRECEDENTS
The Armature The Single Block Mirrored Blocks
Instant Utopia • 96
Nakagin Capsule Tower
DETERMINANTS
1
DEPLOYMENT
3
CONTEXT
4
PRECEDENTS
Exploded Axonometric Armature: n. a framework to support the clay or
7
Capsule Axonometric
8 1. Plumbing, Electrical, & Waste Lines
2. Vertical Plug-In Service Fin
3. Air Conditioning Duct
4. Air Conditioning Register
5. Prefabricated Bathroom
6. Built-In Desk
7. Moveable Chair
8. Built-In Bed
INTRODUCTION
DETERMINANTS
1
DEPLOYMENT
4
CONTEXT
7
Typical Capsule Plan
1. Capsule Entrance
8
2. Prefabricated Bathroom
PRECEDENTS
3. Air Conditioning Chase
4. Interior Finish Surface
5. Welded Light-Weight Steel Truss Member “A”
6. Welded Light-Weight Steel Truss Member “B”
7. Built-In Bed
8. Circular Window
Instant Utopia • 100
The Aggregation & Capsule Delivery
1 1
1
2
4
3 3
DETERMINANTS
6. Construction - 7-8 Months
DEPLOYMENT
1 2 3
CONTEXT
4 5 6
PRECEDENTS
Instant Utopia • 102
Metastadt
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Richard Dietrich’s Model, 1969 Concept Image 2
Instant Utopia • 104
The Construction Components
DEPLOYMENT
1
Stage 2
CONTEXT
3
PRECEDENTS
Steel Framing Assembly
Steel Framing Axonometric
1. Void Module for Elevator Shaft
2. Typical Steel Framing Module
Stage 3 3. Second Floor Void Module
Instant Utopia • 106
Habitat ‘67
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
1 2
Horizontal Circulation
CONTEXT
Armature Components
PRECEDENTS
1. Horizontal Walkway every 4th Floor
3 4 5
2. Parking Garage Vertical Circulation
3. Typical Core Staircase
4. Typical Elevator Shaft
5. Typical Intermediate Staircase
Instant Utopia • 108
Constructing the Module
DETERMINANTS
Stage 1 5
Stage 5
DEPLOYMENT
Stage 2
Stage 6
CONTEXT
3
PRECEDENTS
2. Positioning the Formwork
3. Positioning the Steel Container
Stage 7 4. Closing the Steel Container
4 5. After Curing, Exposing the Module Walls
6. Positioning the Module Walls & Base
Stage 4 7. Post Tensioning the Module Walls & Base
Instant Utopia • 110
Unit 4
1
5
6
Stage 1 Stage 5
9
2
Stage 2 Stage 6
3
10
Unit 4 Assembly
1. Precast Concrete Module “A”
2. Precast Concrete Module “B”
DETERMINANTS
2
DEPLOYMENT
4
CONTEXT
5
PRECEDENTS
1. Precast Concrete Roof
2. Fenestration
3. Interior Walls, Prefab Bathrooms, & Millwork
4. Wood Flooring
5. Precast Concrete Modules
6. Precast Concrete Deck
Instant Utopia • 112
The Aggregation
Unit 1
1 Bedroom
Unit 2
2 Bedroom
Unit 1 Unit 7
Unit 3
2 Bedroom
Unit 4
2 Bedroom Unit 2 Unit 8
Unit 5
3 Bedroom
Unit 6
Unit 3
3 Bedroom Unit 9
Unit 7
3 Bedroom
Unit 8 Unit 4
3 Bedroom Unit 10
Unit 9
3 Bedroom
Unit 5
Unit 10
Unit 11
3 Bedroom
Unit 11
4 Bedroom
DEPLOYMENT
Mirrored & Replicated Aggregation at Front
CONTEXT
3
Armature Components
PRECEDENTS
1. Type A
2. Type B 5
3. Type C - End Condition
4. Type D
Replicated Aggregation at Rear
5. Type E - End Condition
Bergdoll, and Peter Christensen. Home delivery: Fabricating the Modern Dwelling. New York: MOMA, 2008
Campi, Mario. Skyscrapers: An Architectural Type of Modern Urbanism. Michigan: Birkhäuser, 2000
Förster, Wolfgang. Housing in the 20th and 21st Centuries. Michigan: Prestel, 2006
Safdie, Moshe. Moshe Safdie, Volume 1. Australia: The Images Publishing Group, 2009
Images:
Utopias Illustrated.
http://www.santa-coloma.net/voynich_drebbel/utopias/utopias.html
Disadvantages
Undisturbed
Staging Area
assembled off site and transported to the
construction site on an as needed basis. This
reduces the need for large staging areas at the
Construction
construction site and reduces the impact on the Staging Area
area below the bridge spans.
This type of construction can be attributed to
vertical skyscraper construction, in where the
launching system uses the substructure to
support the crane. The superstructure is
incrementally built using the already assembled
superstructure as a counter balance for the
sections of the bride that are being erected.
DETERMINANTS
Substructure
Superstructure
Main Truss
Superstructure
Cross Beams
DEPLOYMENT
Substructure
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Extreme Prefab • 118
Launching Gantry Crane
Construction Sequence
The launching gantry allows work to commence on two fronts. The crane Once one side of the structure is connected back to the remainder of the
spans between two substructures allowing superstructure components to superstructure it creates a back span for the forward components
be assembled on either side of the substructure creating a double balanced cantilevering half way to the next substructure.
cantilever.
INTRODUCTION
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
With the reach of the crane being limited to half the distance of the most The previous process is repeated as many times as needed to span the
forward span, the crane needs to be move forward to start the next span obstacle.
CONTEXT
and complete the previous segment.
PRECEDENTS
Extreme Prefab • 120
Incremental Launching
The theory of the incrementally launched bridge
consists of building the superstructure segments
Site Disturbance
in a assembly area located behind the bridge
abutment. Each segment is prestressed to the
Undisturbed
section of superstructure already built. The entire
superstructure is then jacked forward a distance
equal to the length of the segment. This process Construction
is repeated until the bridge is in its final position. Staging Area
The bridge is launched along temporary bearings
which allows the bridge to roll over the
substructure elements. Once the bridge is
complete the temporary bearings are replaced
with permanent bearings.
DETERMINANTS
Superstructure
Substructure Launching Jack Process
Temporary Roller Bearings
Lifting Pushing
DEPLOYMENT
Returning Lowering
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Extreme Prefab • 122
Incremental Launching
Construction Sequence
Once the substructures are set the launching nose and first segments of the The launching nose and first bridge section is jacked forward a distance
superstructure are constructed in the assembly area. equal to the length of the bridge segment. With the additional length of the
launching segment due to the launching nose, stress is reduced on the
bridge segment.
INTRODUCTION
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
Additional bridge sections are assembled in the assembly area and the The process is repeated as many times as needed to cross the obstacle.
launching sequence is repeated. The roller bearings attached to the top of The launching nose is disassembled when the bridge is in its final location.
CONTEXT
the substructure allow the superstructure to roll over the substructure. the roller bearings are replaced with permanent bearings.
PRECEDENTS
Extreme Prefab • 124
Extra-Large Prefab
With prefabricated components being limited in
size by transportation restrictions extreme prefab Site Disturbance
pieces need to turn to other modes of
transportation. Urban water ways could allow
supersized prefabricated components to be 99%
complete upon delivery to the site.
Construction
Staging Area
Extra-Large Prefab
INTRODUCTION
Transportation Logistics
195’
1500
40 Tons Clearances
Tons 35’
DETERMINANTS
Bardge Limitations
975’
105’
Collection of bardges allowed
above St. Louis river due to locks
15 Bardges and restricted water ways.
DEPLOYMENT
Collection of bardges allowed
280’
Assembly Location
40 Bardges
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Extreme Prefab • 126
Extra-Large Prefab
Construction Sequence
Extreme prefab components are too large for vehicle transportation so The large bridge section is assembled on the barges to alleviate the need to
water transportation is typically used. The staging area or assembly area crane the bridge section onto the barge. An adjacent staging area can
needs to be adjacent to a water way that is connected to the final locations receive deliveries preferably from a local factory location.
of the bridge.
INTRODUCTION
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
The water route must be planned ahead of time to make sure the bridge Once the bridge section arrives at its final location, the section is floated
section can clear all obstacles. into place and jacked up into its final location. Finally, on site assembly
CONTEXT
occurs and the bridge is complete.
PRECEDENTS
Extreme Prefab • 128
Extreme Prefab • 888
VSL International Ltd. | Post-tensioning | Structural Engineering. Web. 02 Nov. 2010. <http://www.vsl.
com/>.
Topic, By. Federal Highway Administration: Home. Web. 02 Nov. 2010. <www.fhwa.dot.gov/>.
“TRB 2005, Session 628: The Future Is Now... Successes in Bridge Construction - Highways for LIFE -
FHWA.” Federal Highway Administration: Home. Web. 02 Nov. 2010. <http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/hfl/
ralls.cfm>.
“PCI Journal Magazine Archives.” Site Introduction - Welcome to PCI. Web. 02 Nov. 2010. <http://
www.pci.org/publications/journal/archive.cfm>.
Extreme Prefab • 132
PRECEDENTS
needed in prefabrication that does not consist of
physical design attributes. This information
includes building codes, zoning laws, economics,
and policy. All of these aspects determine how
prefabrication operates in different urban areas
throughout the United States.
Non-Physical Contexts • 134
Building
Modular Code
PATH
http://www.pathnet.org/
New Colony
http://articles.baltimoresun.com/keyword/new-colony
Zoning
ModularCode
Economics • 150
Meetings with commercial and residential loan officers at Chelsea Groton Bank & One West Bank
Refabricating Architecture by Stephen Kieran & James Timberlake
Policy
Modular
Policy • 160
Policy Analysis
http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa132.html
Precedents
INTRODUCTION
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
In the pages ahead, you will find precedents
PRECEDENTS
collected in our research that hold qualities of
prefabrication that we would like to showcase.
These examples have been categorized
according to principles and methods we have
designed in order to best display their features
and components.
Precedents • 166
Modular
Precedent Ratings
Precedent Ratings • 168
65 j ec
t
Prefab Score
on-site/off-site ratio
p ro
modular
(+)
panelized
kit of parts
use use precast
residential infrastructure prefab steel
degree of prefabrication
temporary
hud/mobile
(-)
grid
infill/parasite
permanent
temporary infrastructure
custom density
standard
page number
INTRODUCTION
Off-site
Prefabrication
Melrose II
Metastadt
Puma City
Citizen M
DETERMINANTS
Drop House Nomadic
Museum
Precast Concrete
Pierson Court Segmented Bridges
Loft House Nomiya
System 3 Kiem & Sill Honk Kong Bank
Stelco
Nakagin Tower
South Side
Metasdadt Studio East
Kim House
DEPLOYMENT
Elemental Urban Shelter
Use Box City Bailey Use
Residential Bridge Infrastructure
Moduli 225
Parcel 12 + 18 Hong Kong
Tower
Habitat 67
Baukasten
CONTEXT
Yacht House
PRECEDENTS
Keetwonen Asphalt
Road
Custom
Adobe Hut/ On-site
Igloo Construction Standard
DETERMINANTS
Bluff Homes Melrose II
Precast Bridge 65 Metastadt 81
Parasite Prefab 64 Sill and Kem 80
Parcel 12 and 18 64 Drop House 78
Pinchin St Studios 64 Kim House 78
Keetwoven 63 Urban Shelter Building 78
Park Row Terrace 63 The Nomadic Museum 77
DEPLOYMENT
Honk Kong Bank 61 Stelco Catalogue Housing 77
Habitat ‘67 58 Puma City 76
Elemental 49 Studio East Dining 76
Nomiya Restaurant 75
South Side Row Houses 75
74
CONTEXT
Rue De Meaux
Las Palmas 73
Rucksack House 73
Box City 71
Loft House 70
69
PRECEDENTS
Moduli 225
Rastipuisto 69
Moho Manchester 68
er
al
w
ci
te
To
en mer
si
ra
le
nk
om
su
Pa
Ba
ge
ap
C
es
em se
as
id
ng
se
67
se
25
en
C
&
om
II
l
dt
Br
ou
ta
lm
Ko
ou
nM
on
ou
t‘
i2
ity
t
in
ng
se
ta
as
en
H
Pa
O
fH
y
ita
ag
Contents
H
w
C
as
H
ul
ro
ile
si
ze
g
uk
H
p
et
ab
od
on
uf
ou
ft
ak
x
el
et
ro
O
Ba
iti
Ba
Bo
Lo
Ke
La
Bl
M
El
Ki
M
H
M
H
D
N
C
H
Prefab Score 65 66 65 71 83 78 49 58 61 80 63 78 73 70 81 81 69 68 83
Modular
Panelized
Kit of Parts
Precast Concrete
Prefab Steel
Temporary
Hud / Mobile
Grid Environment
Infill / Parasite
Infrastructure
Density on Demand
77
N
om
ad
75
ic
N M
om us
iy eu
a
64
Pa R m
ra es
si ta
te ur
64
an
Pa
rc
Pr
ef t
el ab
63
12
Pa
rk &
18
82 R
ow
Pi Te
er
so ra r
n
64
ce
C
Pi
nc o ur
hi t
n
76
Pu St
m St
a ud
io
C
69
R ity s
as
tip
73
ui
R st
o
uc
ks
74
ac
R k
ue H
D ou
e se
67
Sa M
ea
te ux
rin
75
in
So ne
ut
h
66
Si
Sp de
ac R
eb ow
77
St o x H
el ou
co se
s
76
C
St at
ud al
io og
85
ue
Ea
Sy st H
st ou
em Din si
78
in ng
U 3 g
rb
an
67
Sh
Ya el
ch te
tH rB
ou ui
ld
se in
g
Precedent Ratings • 174
Sources 279
Precedents • 178
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
Alternative Uses
A single unit with typical provisions and site work
would cost about $130,000. As many as thirty
units could be arranged and stacked to create a
ten-story, 11,000 square-foot office tower.
DETERMINANTS
Planner
prefabricated. The material used is an unpainted
Solid elements
4 3/4 inches thick regional wood, with a skin that producer
is removable, changeable and washable.
Serving units
producer
Window producer
DEPLOYMENT
Building
site
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Large Scale Stacked Assemblies
Precedents • 182
Citizen M
Concrete Architectural Associates | Amesterdam, Netherlands | 2008 | Hotel
Prefab Score
83
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom Entrance to Lobby Pod (Hotel Room)
standard
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
Capsule Steel Structure Capsule Bolting
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
in Tsuruga clearance 11 ft
permanent 400 km (250 mi) 50 km (30 mi)
temporary
custom Site
standard
Isometric Plan
of Capsule
INTRODUCTION
The precast concrete floor slabs that were part of
the core’s structure were erected at a rate of one
every two days, alternating with the construction
of the steel frame, affording a full operational core
to facilitate the periodic construction of the
framework without an external scaffold. 144
DETERMINANTS
capsules were attached to the building in less
than a month. Interestingly, the podium, which is
the most under-looked part of the project, had
more traditional construction techniques and also
responsible for much of the on-site construction
time.
DEPLOYMENT
attaching capsules to structure
Modern Alternative pre-fabrication of capsules
core structure and mechanical system
on-site construction
pre-fabrication of steel frame and re-enforced concrete floor slabs
design process
CONTEXT
1968 1969 1970 1971 1972
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 188
Pierson Court
Kieran Timberlake | New Haven, CT | 2006 | Dormitory
Prefab Score
82
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
Precedents • 190
Prefab Score
83
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
INTRODUCTION
The diagram to the left shows securing the
modules to each other on site. The light gray
portion indicate horizontal brick layers layed on
site. The dark gray indicates the datum line
which was a layer of bricks left out to show its
modular structure. The pink bricks were insterted
DETERMINANTS
to vertically lock the modules together and are
also pronounced to show structural honesty of
the building’s modular unit construction.
DEPLOYMENT
Modular Construction
This construction method is clearly documented
through photographs. The modular arrives on
CONTEXT
site on a truck. A crane lifts the module onto the
site. A construction worker guides the module
into the proper spot. The images of the process
show how stacking the modules act as a way
increasing efficiency in both time and cost.
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 192
Melrose II
Danois Architects | South Bronx New York, NY | 2002 | Low-income Housing
Prefab Score
81
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
Street Perspective
Methodology: Construction time was minimized
with large precast concrete modules and precast
structural frame.
DETERMINANTS
Melrose II was able to significantly reduce
construction costs with precast concrete building
methods. Assemblers can construct the entire
building from six factory made modules. As
illustrated in the building sequence axonomoetric,
Cornice Module
the structural frame and floor planks are
assembled first, then the precast window facade
panels are hung from the structure. After, a three-
DEPLOYMENT
Lot Plan
story entrance bay module is attached, along with
the precast concrete stairs and projecting
cornice.
CONTEXT
Facade Module
Delivery Route
PRECEDENTS
Factory Assembly
Precedents • 194
Metastadt-Bausystem
Richard J. Dietrich | Wulfen, Germany | 1972 | Multi-family residential/commercial
Prefab Score
81
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
DETERMINANTS
adapted to specific spatial needs. The absence of
diagonal bracing created the maximum of space
and permitted the greatest possible flexibility.
DEPLOYMENT
Construction Concept
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Entrance
Precedents • 198
Housing + Commercial Block
Keim + Sill | Rathenow, Germany | 1997 | Housing + Commercial
Prefab Score
80
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
Precedents • 202
Open Terrace
permanent
temporary
custom Extruded Entrance
standard
Exterior Terrace
Methodology: Cargo containers are efficient, but South Oriented
South-East Facing Bris-Soleil
people feel uncomfortable in metal boxes, so this
Retractable in Winter
is a wood house that fits in a container.
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
DETERMINANTS
trusses to cover the museum. There is flexibility
in the stacking of the shipping containers to
conform to each site. For example, the site in
Santa Monica was shorter than that of New York,
so the gallery was split into two 100m length
buildings, rather than the original 200m length.
The innovation behind the nomadic museum is
that museum can be placed anywhere a cargo
DEPLOYMENT
ship can pull up.
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 210
Stelco Catalogue Housing
Barton Myers Associates | 1969 | Steel housing prototype
Prefab Score Axonometric View of Cluster
77
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
Unit Components
(-)
permanent
temporary Exterior Panels
custom
standard
Methodology: Using a structure of steel columns, Opening Fixed Fixed Fixed Fixed
modules based on a 3-foot-sqaure dimension Ceiling
Connectors
could be filled in. Interior Panels Floor
on-site/off-site ratio
once at the site another crane is used to
assemble the building. This process is done
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
Panel System
INTRODUCTION
The concept behind Puma City is a pulling apart
and shifting of shipping containers to create
indoor/outdoor spaces, and outdoor spaces.
These cantilevers become roof decks for people
to use.
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 216
Studio East Dining
Carmody Groarke | 2010 | London, England | Temporary Pavilion / Restaurant
Prefab Score
76
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 222
Rue de Meaux
Renzo Piano | Paris, France | 1988 | Multi-family Housing
Prefab Score
74
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Section through courtyard
Precedents • 224
Las Palmas Parasite
Kortknie Stuhnmacher Architecten | Rotterdam, Netherlands | 2001 | Housing
Prefab Score
73
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
on-site/off-site ratio
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
Off-site
On-site
connected through the use of sky bridges. The
shipping containers used for this project
presented opportunities for interesting and
DETERMINANTS
innovative design solutions throughout.
DEPLOYMENT
2-3 Months
Stacking
CONTEXT
4 Days
Iron Work
Remove Walls
6 Weeks
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 230
Box Office
Distill Studio | Providence, RI | 2010 | Offices
The use of shipping containers created several
issues that required creative solutions. For
example, each unit is mechanically independent
from one another. There are 12 units total, and
each unit has a condensor outside. This modular
HVAC system made installing the systems much
easier, and far less complicated.
DETERMINANTS
distance apart.
DEPLOYMENT
Shipping container structure diagram
CONTEXT
Column grid layout digrams
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 232
Loft House
Studio Aisslinger | 2009 | Berlin, Germany | Housing
Prefab Score
70
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
on-site/off-site ratio 18
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
15
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
3
Delivery: No foundation required, assembly could
take as little as two days. All materials available
within 200 miles.
Module configurations
1
Precedents • 236
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
Methodology:
DETERMINANTS
precast panel that encloses two different
apartments need not be on fixed positions, nor do
they have to run in vertical alignment between
floors. The storey-high precast panels stretch the
full width of these vertical segments and this
makes some precast units as long as 8m and
keeps the number of units to a minimum, thereby
reducing construction cost. Where the front
DEPLOYMENT
elevation is punctuated by the staircases they are
detailed a little differently from
the repeating rhythm of the precast panels that
enclose the apartment zones.
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 238
Rastipuisto Apartment Block
Helamaa and Pulkkinen Architects| Helsinki, Finland | 2009 | Multi-family Housing
The standard design of the windows are of
composite aluminium and hardwood construction.
The exterior frame is a durable aluminium with a
powder-coated finish while the interior ‘warm
frame’ is a hardwood.
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
DETERMINANTS
and work crew to provide affordable housing.
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 242
Saterininne Housing Development
Brunow and Manula Architects | Helsinki, Finland | 2009 | Multi-family Housing
Prefab Score
67
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
DETERMINANTS
to increase the strength of the sandwich panels.
The factory then holds the de-molded pieces for
two weeks unitl it is inspected and approved for
delivery.
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 244
Yacht House
Richard Horden | United Kingdom | 1983 | Single-family residential
Prefab Score
67
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
Plan
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
Assembly Process
Units of Prefabrication: Steel tensions members
and the interior wall modules.
Assembly Detail
Precedents • 246
4
(+)
123
use use
residential infrastructure
3
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
2
temporary
1 123
custom
standard
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
DETERMINANTS
and the entryway on the other. The units are
equipped with a boiler, mechanical ventilation and
electrical heating. Spacebox units are made of
the same high-grade light weight composites that
are used in shipbuilding and aircraft
manufacturing.
Source: http://mocoloco.com/archives/000821.
DEPLOYMENT
php
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 250
Bluff Homes
Vetter Denk | Milwaukee, WI USA | 2009 | Single Family Townhomes
Prefab Score
65
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
Methodology:
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 252
Precast Concrete Segmental Bridge
Prefab Score
65
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
DETERMINANTS
600 dwellings in the three large housing blocks
bring up the average density)
Source: http://urbantheorywest8amsterdam.
blogspot.com/
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 258
Pinchin Street Studios
Urban Space Management, Ltd | London, UK | 2007 | Container Housing
Prefab Score
64
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
Source: http://londonwall.blogspot.com/2009/11/
DETERMINANTS
pinchin-street-studios-by-urban-space.html
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 260
Keetwonen
Tempohousing | Amsterdam, The Netherlands | 2006 | Housing
Prefab Score
63
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
CONTEXT
and each unit contains their own bedroom, living
room, bathroom, kitchen, and balcony. The
Keetwonen complex also contains office space,
super markets, a sports area and a cafe for the
students. Each unit is brought to the site and
stacked through the use of a crane. Originally the
project was meant to only stay on site for 5 years,
PRECEDENTS
but the relocation has been postponed until 2016.
The units can be easily moved to a different
location to create the massive container city
through the use of cranes and trucks for
transport.
Precedents • 262
Park Row Terrace Houses
Vetter Denk | Milwaukee, WI USA | 2005 | Multi-family Row Houses
Prefab Score
63
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
DETERMINANTS
Precast Concrete Panels and Hollowcore Planks
were the main units of prefabrication. The
concrete panels were designed to not only act as
sheer walls in this project but act as the fire walls
between each unit.
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 264
Hong Kong & Shanghai Bank
Norman Foster & Associates | Hong Kong, China | 2007 | Skyscraper
Prefab Score
61
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
DETERMINANTS
ules were fabricated in Japan and stacked and
attached to the superstructure. This allowed for
on-site construction to progress quickly and
increase turn-over time. However, the complexity
of the design and coordination process between
multiple practitioners invariably delayed the con-
struction process despite its proposed design.
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 266
Hong Kong & Shanghai Bank
Norman Foster & Associates | Hong Kong, China | 2007 | Skyscraper
The steel superstructure was fabricated in
London, England and shipped innternation-
ally by sea. This pieces arrived as six mod-
ules that were assembled by crane into four
sets of “mast” super-columns. These were
then fitted with truss hangers that suspend
the floor components.
DETERMINANTS
are completed after the truss hangers have
been put in place.
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 268
Hong Kong & Shanghai Bank
Norman Foster & Associates | Hong Kong, China | 2007 | Skyscraper
The structural innovation of Hong Kong
Bank has allowed the plan to benefit from an
externally loaded core that services an inte-
rior column-free space. The open floor plan
is also divided by movable partitions that
can re-configure the spatial organization of
the plan for future use capacity. This adapt-
able re-use concept has also been imple-
mented in section where double height
stories create spaces for sustainable social
interaction and circulatiory functions that
are separate yet complimentary to the office
floors.
INTRODUCTION
The steel supertructure was coposed of two
modules for the column masts and four
modules for the truss system. These pieces
were assembled by crane; a structural pin
system fastened the pieces together. The
benefits of the superstructure are evident in
DETERMINANTS
its ability to provide 33.5 meter spans
between columns. This allows a greater
flexibility of floor space that is unprece-
dented in contemporary construction.
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 270
Habitat ‘67
Moshe Safdie | Montreal, Canada | 1967 | Multi-family residential
Prefab Score
58
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
Fenestration
(-)
permanent
temporary 2 X 4 Interior Wall Assembly
custom
standard
Floor Assembly
Units of Prefabrication: With the exception of
bathroom cores and millwork, all the residential
units were pre-fabricated on-site and lifted into
place by crane. “B”
Exploded Axon
Precedents • 272
Construction Photo
INTRODUCTION
DETERMINANTS
DEPLOYMENT
Section
CONTEXT
Bridging Units and Terraces
View from across the Saint Lawrence River
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 274
Elemental
Alejandro Aravena | Santiago, Chile | 2001 | Low-income Housing
Prefab Score
49
on-site/off-site ratio
(+)
use use
residential infrastructure
degree of prefabrication
(-)
permanent
temporary
custom
standard
DETERMINANTS
structural frame that arrives on flatbed. A crane
and assembly crew construct the prefab frame.
The structure is then completed with site-cast
concrete block for the facade. The design allows
for residents to expand their homes as necessary
into each interstitial unit space.
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 276
Elemental
Alejandro Aravena | Santiago, Chile | 2001 | Low-income Housing
The project goal for Elemental was to replace
existing slum dwellings in Santiago, Chile. The
design vision considered the needs of the
displaced families by focusing on an expedited
building delivery system. The answer was to use
a durable prefabricated concrete frame that could
be assembled within hours. The building structure
is completed with site-cast concrete block that
adds an aesthetic appeal to the facade.
Crane type
Transport of Precast Concrete Panels Crane Assembly Plan Kit of Precast Parts
INTRODUCTION
DETERMINANTS
Area for expansion
Prefabricated unit
hvv
DEPLOYMENT
CONTEXT
PRECEDENTS
Precedents • 278
Precedents
Sources
System3
1. Bergdoll, Barry and Peter Christensen. Home Delivery: Fabricating the Modern Dwelling. New York: The Museum of Modern Art, 2008.
Citizen M
1. Bergdoll, Barry and Peter Christensen. Home Delivery: Fabricating the Modern Dwelling. New York: The Museum of Modern Art, 2008.
Pierson Court
2. Chen, Aric. Teaching Tools. Metropolis Magazine, July 25, 2007. http://www.metropolismag.com/story/20070725/teaching-tools
Melrose II
1. www.scottsystem.com/informers/Beauty_in_the_Bronx.pdf
2. www.pathnet.org/si.asp?id=2652
3.campaign=en&utm_source=en-hana-us-sk-gm&utm_medium=ha&utm_term=maps
Metastadt-Bausystem
1. Bergdoll, Barry and Peter Christensen. Home Delivery: Fabricating the Modern Dwelling. New York: The Museum of Modern Art, 2008.
2. Anssen, M., ‘Interview mit dem Metastadt-Architekten Richard J. Dietrich : Man hätte uns nicht in Richtung Wulfen treiben dürfen’, Bauwelt, 79, 1988, pp.
1990-95.
3. Janssen, M., ‘Metastadt, Wulfen : Eine Studentin von heute über eine Utopie von gestern’, Bauwelt, 79, 1988, pp. 1990-91.
INTRODUCTION
Kim & Sill
1. http://www.architektenprofsill.de/flash/starter1280.htm
DETERMINANTS
2. http://www.detail.de/rw_5_Archive_En_HoleArtikel_1513_Artikel.htm
3. “Housing and commercial block in rathenow” Detail Magazine. Vol. 38. No. 5. Pg. 808-812. 1998
4. http://myweb.wit.edu/kiml1/590fall05/web-content/terry.pdf
Drop House
Kim House
DEPLOYMENT
1. Bergdoll, Barry and Peter Christensen. Home Delivery: Fabricating the Modern Dwelling. New York: The Museum of Modern Art, 2008.
1. http://www.onesmallproject.com/pagescontributors/contributorparejo.html
2. http://www.recetasurbanas.net/indexphp?idioma=ENG&REF=1&ID=0003
Nomadic Museum:
1. http://www.burohappold.com/BH/PRJ_BLD_nomadic_museum.aspx
CONTEXT
2. http://nymag.com/nymetro/arts/architecture/11077/
1. Bergdoll, Barry and Peter Christensen. Home Delivery: Fabricating the Modern Dwelling. New York: The Museum of Modern Art, 2008.
Puma City:
PRECEDENTS
“1. Adapting Prefabricated Industrial Systems into Innovative Architecture” by Jesse Cabrera & Daniel Ottochian
2. http://www.boston.com/lifestyle/fashion/articles/2009/04/23/a_portable_city_visits_fan_pier/
1. http://uk.westfield.com/stratfordcity/studio-east/studio-east-dining/
Precedents • 280
Precedents
Sources
Nomiya Restaurant
1. http://plusmood.com/2009/09/nomiya-temporary-rooftop-restaurant-pascal-grasso-laurent-grasso/
2. http://www.dezeen.com/2009/09/11/nomiya-temporary-restaurant-by-pascal-grasso/
1. http://www.pci.org/pdf/publications/journal/1999/January-February/JL-99-JANUARY-FEBRUARY-3.pdf
2. http://www.pci.org/pdf/publications/ascent/2000/summer/AS-00SU-3.PDF
Rue De Meaux
1. http://www.housingprototypes.org/project?File_No=FRA006
1. http://lifewithoutbuildings.net/2005/08/life without-books-green-house.html
2. http://www.kortekniestuhlmacher.nl/
Rucksack Housing
1. http://www.convertiblecity.de/projekte_proje kt02_en.html
Box Office:
Loft House
1. www.aisslinger.de
2. www.loftcube.net
Moduli 225
1. Bergdoll, Barry and Peter Christensen. Home Delivery: Fabricating the Modern Dwelling. New York: The Museum of Modern Art, 2008.
Rastipuisto
1. http://www.jouleconsultingengineers.co.uk/presnew.htm
Saterininne
DETERMINANTS
1. http://www.scribd.com/doc/18765509/the-art-of-precast-concrete-colour-texture-expression
Yacht House
1. Bergdoll, Barry and Peter Christensen. Home Delivery: Fabricating the Modern Dwelling. New York: The Museum of Modern Art, 2008.
Baukasten
1. Bergdoll, Barry and Peter Christensen. Home Delivery: Fabricating the Modern Dwelling. New York: The Museum of Modern Art, 2008.
Spacebox
DEPLOYMENT
1. www.mocoloco.com/archives/000821.php
2. www.spaceboxusa.com/
Bluff Homes
1. http://www.thebluffhomes.com/
CONTEXT
http://www.pci.org/pdf/publications/journal/1980/July-August/JL-80-JULY-AUGUST-9.pdf
2. http://www.metamere.com/images/segmentalbridgeunderconstruction4.jpg
3. http://www.mtc.ca.gov/images/ta02-0307/skyway.jpg
4. http://www.gautrain.co.za/web_images/_2S22gQ.jpg
5. http://www.djc.com/stories/images/20090716/DSCN1968_big.jpg
PRECEDENTS
Parasite Prefab
1. www.calderflower.com.au
Parcel 12 & 18
1. http://urbantheorywest8amsterdam.blogspot.com/
Precedents • 282
Precedents
Sources
1. http://www.containercity.com/pinchin-street-studios.html
2. http://londonwall.blogspot.com/2009/11/pinchin-street-studios-by-urban-space.html
Keetwonen:
1. http://www.tempohousing.com/projects/keetwonen.html
2. http://www.inhabitat.com/2007/08/24/prefab-friday-keetwonen-container-student-housing/
1. www.vetterdenk.com/work.php
1. Ford, Edward R. “The Details of Modern Architecture” Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2003.
2.The_Hongkong_and_Shanghai_Banking_Corporation
3. http://www.urbain-trop-urbain.fr/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/Fiche-hong-kong-bank-de-Foster.pdf
4. http://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/29554/52723412.pdf?sequence=1
5. http://isites.harvard.edu/fs/docs/icb.topic32894.files/7-4_Hongkong.pdf
Habitat ‘67
1. Bergdoll, Barry and Peter Christensen. Home Delivery: Fabricating the Modern Dwelling. New York: The Museum of Modern Art, 2008.
Elemental
1. http://www.archdaily.com/10775/quinta-monroy-elemental/
2. http://www.elementalchile.cl/
3. www.acleanbreak.org
Precedents • 284