Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: T he paper presents an analytical study of the helicopter rotor v ibratory load reduction design
optimizatio n w ith aeroelastic stability constr aints. T he composite ro to r blade is modeled by beam type fi
nite elements, and warping deformation is taken into consideration for 2 dimension analysis, while the
one dimension nonlinear differential equat ions of blade motion are formulated v ia Hamilton s principle.
T he rotor hub vibr ator y loads is chosen as the objective function, while r otor blade sectio n construction
parameter, composite material ply structure and blade tip swept ang le as t he design variables, and au
torotation inertia, natural frequency and aeroelastic stabilit y as the constraints. A 3 bladed rotor is de
signed, as an ex ample, based on the vibrator y hub load reduction optimization process w ith sw ept tip an
gle and composite mater ial. T he calculating results show a 24. 9% 33% reduction of 3/ rev hub loads in
comparison w ith the base line rotor.
Key words: v ibration reduction optimization; aer oelastic constraint; co mposite rotor blade desig n
带气弹稳 定性约束 的复 合 材料 浆叶 减 振优 化设 计. 郭 俊 贤, 向 锦武. 中国 航 空学 报 ( 英 文版 ) ,
2004, 17( 3) : 152- 158.
摘 要: 研究以降低直升机旋翼激振 力为目 标的复 合材料桨 叶结构 动力学 减振优 化设计, 分析 了
桨叶结构特性及桨尖后掠角等参数对 N 次/ 转旋翼 桨毂振 动载荷 的 影响。在 建立的桨 叶二维 结
构特性有限元分析方程中, 计入了桨 叶剖面 翘曲变 形的影响, 并 利用哈 密尔顿 原理推导 了旋翼 桨
叶的一维非线性运动微分方程。以桨毂交变载荷为目标函数, 直接以复 合材料桨叶 典型剖面 构造
节点数据、
铺层设计参数和桨尖后掠角等为设计变量 , 引入桨叶挥 舞惯量、固有频率 和气弹稳 定性
约束, 进行旋翼的动力学优化设计, 并结合 3 片桨叶旋翼的设计 进行了算例 分析, 优化结果使 3 次
/ 转的桨毂载荷降低了 24. 9% ~ 33% 。
关键词: 减振优化设计; 气弹约束; 复合材料旋翼桨叶设计
文章编号: 1000 9361( 2004) 03 0152 07 中图分类号: V212. 4 文献标识码: A
As one of the major vibrat ion sources, the he aerodynam ic paramet ers ( such as blade platform,
licopter rotor has gained severe att entions for a long pre tw ist law, and t ip shape, etc. ) , as well as t he
time in f oreig n researches, and a lot of efforts had ply angle of com posit e lay ups in blade cross sect ion
been g iven t o achieve helicopter vibrat ion reduct ion struct ures, were used as design variables in opt i
by decreasing the vibratory loads f rom t he rot or. m izations[ 1] . How ever, the blade struct ural models
T he design optimizat ions mainly f ocused on rot or adopt ed in these researches w ere aw fully simplified
blade dynamic charact eristics ( including natural even in the lat est reference paper [ 2] , and for t he
frequency and mode shape) , rot or hub vibrat ory sake of easy opt imizat ion process, a simple tw o box
load ( especially N / rev load) and hub vibrat ion lev beam sect ion model was chosen as the opt im izing
el. T he rotor blade w eight , autorot at ion inert ia composit e blade, w hich w as act ually much differ
and aeroelast ic stabilit y w ere usually selected as op ent f rom the real designed blades, so as t o lead to a
t imizat ion object ive funct ions or constraints, while result that would be far from t he real helicopt er sit
blade mass and/ or st if fness span w ise dist ribut ions, uat ion.
R eceived dat e: 2003 07 10; R evision received dat e: 2003 12 08
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. http://www.cnki.net
A ugust 2004 Composit e Rotor Blade D esign O pt imizat ion f or V ibration R educt ion wit h Aeroelast ic Const raints # 153 #
U p t ill now, only a few ref erences w ere re ^j nr , ^k nr ) and show n coordinat es e Hr ( ^i r , ^j r , ^k r ) are
port ed w ith composite blade sect ion ply structures shown in Fig 1.
( including ply angle as well as ot her ply shape pa
ramet ers) as desig n variables, and meanw hile t he
N / rev hub vibratory load as object ive funct ion,
w it h aeroelast ic stabilit y const raint s. T his paper
presents, in accord w it h t he above descriptions, t he
eff ort of structural opt imization of composite rot or
blade w it h C spar and D shape t orsion box sect ion
to minimize t he N / rev vibrat ory hub load. T he F ig 1 Coor dinates of rotor system
typical blade cross section w ith out of plane w arp ( footnotes r! and nr! stand for rotating
ing is included in the blade model. T he blade sec and non rotating, r espectively)
t ion st ructural parameters are calculat ed wit h 2D 1. 1 Blade structural analysis
F EM , and t he nonlinear equat ions of blade mot ion Arbitrary cross sect ional shape and anisot ropic
are derived using Hamilt on s principle for aeroelas composit e mat erial behavior are considered in blade
[ 3 5]
t ic analysis . A 3 blade rotor is considered for struct ural 2D FEM analysis[ 3 5] . T he displacement
optimizat ion desig n w ith 3/ rev vibrat ory hub vert i of any point in the cross sect ion can be w rit ten as
cal shear force as object ive funct ion, and blade dy w 0+ y x - x y + gz
namic frequency, aeroelast ic st ability and autorota u= u0- y z + gx ( 1)
t ion inertia as constrains, while blade cross sect ion v0+ x z + gy
composit e ply parameter and tip sw ept ang le as de T
where u = w is t he displacement of
u v
sign variables. A reduct ion of 24. 9% 33% in 3/ T
any point in section, s 0 = w 0 u 0 v 0 is t he
rev vert ical hub shear can be obt ained f rom opt i translat ion of one section as a w hole, 0 =
m ization in comparison w ith the init ial design as for T
z x y is angular displacement, and g =
baseline rotor model. T
gz gx gy is the elast ic displacement, while
1 Blade Structural M odel and Formulation g x and gy are t he w arpings in t he sect ion and g z is
of Equations of M ot ion the w arping out of the section ( plane) . According
T he rotor blade is described as an elastic beam to t he relat ionship of stress displacement, the fol
w it h const ant rotating speed . A main current low ing is obt ained,
part and a t ip part are divided on t he blade, and an w∀0 + y ∀x - x ∀y + g∀z
ang le is used to def ine the tip sw eep. T he basic ∀ gz
s
u∀0 - y- y ∀z + g∀x +
hypot heses used are list ed in t he f ollow ing : ∀x
( 1 ) For 2D structural propert y analysis: ∀g z
v∀0 + + x ∀z + g∀y +
z
∀y
w hole blade section movement w ith addit ional 3D
!= ∀gx ( 2)
w arping, ex pressed in displacement;
∀x
( 2) F or one dimension aeroelast ic analysis:
∀gy
blade wit h a nonlinear moderate def lect ion, rig id ∀y
cross sect ion, isolated homogeneous rot at ing beam; ∀gy ∀gx
+
( 3) Blade w ith non unif orm mass and st if fness ∀x ∀y
dist ribut ions, nonlinear tw ist and sm all precone; And then, based on minimum potent ial energ y
( 4) Blade w ith litt le torsion deformat ion, and principle, t he equilibrium equat ion w it h it s condi
chord lengt h far less than blade radius. t ions of t he sect ion can be derived. F rom one of t he
T he rot or non rotating coordinat es e H ( ^i nr , specif ic solut ion t o the equat ions t he inverse of t he
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. http://www.cnki.net
# 154 # GU O Jun x ian, X IAN G Jin w u CJA
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. http://www.cnki.net
A ugust 2004 Composit e Rotor Blade D esign O pt imizat ion f or V ibration R educt ion wit h Aeroelast ic Const raints # 155 #
w here F and M st and f or the hub force and mo optimizat ion is performed for 3/ rev hub loads at ad
ment , w ith f oot not es x , y and z , to t he six com vancing ratio )= 0. 3 in level flig ht .
ponents; w hile K F , K M , K 1 , K 2 and K 3 are T hree cases are conducted for opt imizat ion
w eight ed factors. from t he init ial design:
( 2) Const raints ( 1) T he st ruct ural parameters such as cross
∋ Frequency (i : the f irst m t h mode fre sect ional propert ies, ply st ruct ure and generalized
quencies w ill meet t he limits as f ollow ing: weig ht are used f or design variables to minimize t he
(i 3/ rev hub loads;
gi , U ( D ) = - 1 ( 0
(i, U ( 2) T he blade t ip sw eep param eters are used
i = 1, 2, ), m ( 16) for desig n variables to minimize the 3/ rev hub
(i loads;
g i, L( D ) = 1- ( 0
(i , L ( 3 ) Based on t he opt im ization of the f irst
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. http://www.cnki.net
# 156 # GU O Jun x ian, X IAN G Jin w u CJA
case, the blade t ip sw eep parameters are used for Table 3 Comparison of initial design and optimized
design variables, t o minimize t he 3/ rev loads, and result ( blade design variables)
In case 1, the opt imizat ion of blade mass and Fig 3 3/ rev optimized hub vertical shear for ces
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. http://www.cnki.net
A ugust 2004 Composit e Rotor Blade D esign O pt imizat ion f or V ibration R educt ion wit h Aeroelast ic Const raints # 157 #
References
[ 1] 向锦武, 郭俊贤, 张晓谷. 直升机减振 的旋翼桨 叶优化设 计
Fig 7 Compar ison o f blade lead lag st iffness 研究综述[ J ] . 北 京航 空航 天大 学学 报, 2001, 27 ( 1) : 32 -
35.
X iang J W , Guo J X, Zhang X G . A n overview of rotor blade
opt imum design f or helicopt er vibration reduction [ J ] . Journal
of Beijing U niversit y of A eronaut ics and Ast ronautics, 2001,
27( 1) : 32- 35. ( in chinese)
[ 2] Y uan K A , Friedmann P P. St ruct ural opt imizat ion f or vibrat o
ry loads reduction of composite helicopt er rotor blades wit h ad
vanced geomet ry tips[ J] . Journal of AHS , 1998, 43( 3) : 246
- 256.
[ 3] K osmat ka J B. S truct ural dynamic modeling of advanced com
posit e propell ers by t he FEM [ D] . Los Angeles : U niversit y of
Californ ia, 1986.
Fig 8 Effect of tip swept angle on hub vertical shear [ 4] G iavot t o V , Borri M , M ant egazza P, et al . A nisot ropic beam
t heory an d applications[ J ] . Comput ers and St ructures, 1983,
16( 1 4) : 403- 413.
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. http://www.cnki.net
# 158 # GU O Jun x ian, X IAN G Jin w u CJA
[ 5] R ef ield L W. Design analysis met hodology for composit e rot or XIANG Jin wu Born in A pril 1964, a
blades[ J] . A IAA J, 1982, 20( 5) : 693- 699. professor of A ircraft Design at Beijing U
[ 6] G anguli R , Chopra I. Aeroelast ic opt imizat ion of an advanced niversity of Aeronautics and Astronau
geomet ry helicopt er rot or[ J ] . Journal of AHS , 1996, 42 ( 1 ) :
tics. He received B. Sc. and Ph. D. in
18- 28.
A ircraft Design fr om N anjing U niversity
[ 7] G anguli R , Chopra I. A eroelast ic opt im ization of a helicopter
of A ero nautics and Astronautics in 1984
rotor to reduce vibration an d dynamic st resses [ J ] . Journal of
and 1993, respectively , an M . E. in En
A ircraf t, 1996, 12( 4) : 808- 815.
[ 8] A delman H M , M antay W R. Int egrat ed mult idisciplinary de
g ineering M echanics from Northwestern Poly technical U ni
sign opt imization of rot orcraft [ J] . Journal of Aircraft , 1991, 28 versity in 1990, and a in A ircraft Design from N anjing U ni
( 1) : 22- 28. versity of Aeronautics and Astronautics in 1993. Dr . Xiang
Biographies: joined the facult y at Beijing U niversity of Aeronaut ics and
GUO Jun xian Bo rn in August 1966, a Astronautics in 1995, wher e he has been activ ely invo lved in
senior engineer of helicopter at Chinese teaching and resear ch. He has been wor king on problems as
Helicopter Design and Development In sociated w ith aircraft design and aeromechanics of heli
stitute. He r eceived a B. Sc. in Eng ineer copters. He is an author o f over 60 papers and has wo n 6
ing M echanics from No rthw ester n Poly times award for promotion of science and techno logy from the
technical U niversit y in 1989, a M . E. in state and various ministries.
air craft desig n from Beijing U niversity of
A eronautics and Astronautics( BU AA) in 2000. He is now a
Ph. D. Candidate of BU AA . His r esearch interests include
helicopter design and composite structural desig n. He is an
author of over 10 papers and has won 3 times award from the
state and various ministries.
© 1994-2010 China Academic Journal Electronic Publishing House. Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. http://www.cnki.net