You are on page 1of 12

NEWSLETTER

of
The American Musical Instrument Society
Volume 37, No.2 Summer 2008

AMIS in Calgary
What’s the difference between a mu- time, any desired musical expression should Perhaps even more dazzling were
sical instrument and an electrical appli- be reproducible, the performing technique Buchla’s Lightning Wands, virtual drum-
ance? This is not a joke, at least for or- should be somehow intuitive, and the tech- sticks that draw symphonic (or any oth-
ganologists. But AMIS members had nique should have a gestural coherence. er) music from thin air (no drums are
good fun pondering the ques- involved). The programmable
tion during the thirty-seventh wands are synthesizer control-
annual meeting, hosted by the lers that interact with infrared
Cantos Music Foundation in light beams. Both of these Bu-
Calgary, Alberta, May 28 to chla-developed devices preserve
June 1, 2008. the shaman-like mystique of the
Andrew Mosker, executive performer, while opening a door
director of the foundation, wel- to a thought-provoking future.
comed the sixty-odd registrants It’s shocking to realize that
with a talk about the Cantos col- generations of electrical and
lection. Begun in 1997 with pia- even electronic musical instru-
nos and organs, it opened a new ments have already appeared,
and unusual collecting stream in flourished, and in many cases
2000: early electro-mechanical died of obsolescence. Among
instruments, synthesizers, and the fifteen papers presented,
historic recording equipment. Robert Eliason traced the life
The collection includes about of the Synclavier Digital Audio
400 instruments, of which about System, 1976-92, while Mat-
150 are electronic; the core of the thew Hill explored the business
collection dates from the 1920s activities of the inventor Benja-
through the 1980s, Mosker said. min Miessner, who was an early
Mark Goldstein, a San Fran- licenser of musical instrument
cisco-based percussionist and technologies.
software developer offered his AMIS members get up close to the Ahrend organ Hammers and plectra were
perspective on the dividing line at the University of Calgary (C.B.) not forsaken; several perfor-
between musical instruments and mances showed the depth and
other sound-generating or recording de- On paper, these issues seem dry range of the Cantos Foundation’s early
vices. Among his requirements for an in- and cerebral. But Goldstein quickly put keyboard holdings. Gordon Rumson
strument: it should generate sounds in real his ideas to work in a concert, demon- demonstrated the Duplex Coupler pia-
strating the possibilities of two inge- no of Emanuel Moór; the two contigu-
IN THIS ISSUE nious devices. The Marimba Lumina, ous keyboards eased technical prob-
developed by a team including Don lems for any pianist quixotic enough to
Annual Meeting at Calgary 1 Buchla and Goldstein, uses a seemingly take the instrument seriously. Few did,
President’s Message 3 conventional mallet technique. But the and working exemplars like this one
Editor’s Note 4 “bars” of this instrument are discrete are rare. Rumson later used a spinet by
Awards 4 electronic fields, programmable ad li- Logan and Stewart (Edinburgh, 1777)
Business Meeting Minutes 5 bitum. In the hands of a virtuoso like for a salon recital, moving to a piano
Book Reviews 6 Goldstein, the Marimba Lumina can by Louis Dulcken II (Munich, 1791)
Familiar Words about a Piano shade off from conventional marimba for the sound effects-filled “Battle of
Manufacturer 9 sounds, through stretched pitches and Prague” by Frantisek Kotzwara. He
Images of Calgary 11 timbres, into a sound world of infinite shared the program with two remark-
Photo Credits 11
possibilities. able young pianists, Alexander Ma-

AMIS - Volume 37, No.2


likov and Jan Lisiecki, who performed reminiscences and short presentations.
American Musical
Beethoven, Liszt, and Mendelssohn on Deborah Check Reeves moderated a
Instrument Society
a grand piano by Bösendorfer (Vienna, panel discussion of “Education’s Role
Newsletter ca. 1857). in the Musical Instrument Museum.”
Dwight Newton, Editor
Friday afternoon was spent at the Sunni Fass and Jennifer Post gave a
James B. Kopp, Review Editor
University of Calgary, listening to a progress report on the Musical Instru-
magnificent pipe organ built in 2006 ment Museum, now under development
The Newsletter is published in spring,
by Jürgen Ahrend Orgelbau, Leer, Ger- in Phoenix.
summer, and fall for members of the
many. With a tonal design and specifica- During the concluding banquet, the
American Musical Instrument Society
tions that are consistent with 17th century Curt Sachs Award was presented post-
(AMIS). News items, photographs,
North German organs that Ahrend reno- humously to William Waterhouse, the
and short articles or announcements
vated following World War II, this beau- Frances Densmore Award to Patrizio
are invited, as well as any other infor-
tiful new instrument was ably played Barbieri, and the Frederick R. Selch
mation of interest to AMIS members.
and described by Neil Cockburn, Cantos Award (for best student paper) to Eu-
Contributions for the Newsletter and Music Foundation Organ Scholar. genia Mitroulia, for “The Saxotromba:
correspondence concerning its content Several papers examined keyboard Fact or Fiction.”
should be sen t, preferably as Micro- topics. Using high-speed video imag- Mitroulia was one of six student at-
soft Word attachments to: ing, Stephen Birkett and Anne Beetem- tendees recognized as recipients of the
Dwight Newton Acker demonstrated that components William E. Gribbon Memorial Award
University of Kentucky School of Music of both historical and modern piano ac- for Student Travel; others were Mat-
105 Fine Arts Building tions undergo unintended (and hitherto thew Courtney, Panagiotis Poulopou-
Lexington, KY 40506-0022 undetected) vibrations, which probably los, Ioana Sherman, Clinton Spell, and
Phone: 859-257-1808 account for some of the elusive differ- Hannes Vereecke. Charles Mould took
Email: dwight.newton@uky.edu ences in “feel” that players experience. advantage of the gathering to present
Address changes, dues payments, re- Pedro Bento summarized the acoustical the Galpin Society’s Anthony Baines
quests for back issues of AMIS pub- constraints imposed by the shortest few Award (for lifetime achievement) to
lications, and requests for information strings of harpsichords, and examined Herbert Heyde.
on membership should be sent to: the strategies makers used in coping Laurence Libin announced the re-
American Musical Instrument Society with them. sults of the silent auction, then goaded
389 Main Street, Suite 202 Ken Eschete described a reversible a cheerful crowd of banqueters into live
Malden, MA 02148 felt-replacement technique that he de- bidding on big-ticket goods and servic-
Email: amis@guildassoc.com vised to conserve an 1854 Erard grand es. Proceeds from the sale will help fund
Phone: 781-397-8870 piano used in demonstration concerts at future Gribbon awards.
Fax: 781-397-8887 the Smithsonian Institution. Panagiotis  Jim Kopp
Poulopoulos examined various “piano-
AMIS BOARD OF GOVERNORS key” mechanisms that were applied dur- Show and Tell in
President: Stewart A. Carter ing the mid-eighteenth century to wire-
(2007–09) strung “English guitars.” Calgary
Vice President: Darcy Kuronen A bus excursion to nearby Banff al- This conference marked the revival
(2007–09) lowed attendees to experience at close of the “Show and Tell” session, courtesy
Secretary: Deborah Check Reeves hand the majesty of the snow-capped of Doug Koeppe, who volunteered to or-
(2008–09) Canadian Rockies. Students from the ganize and moderate it. It was the first
Treasurer: Joanne Kopp 2008 Banff International Jazz Workshop such session since the 2000 meeting in
(2008–09) used electronic instruments borrowed Lisle, Illinois. With the conference be-
Board of Governors from the Cantos Foundation collection ing in Canada, however, questions arose
Niles Eldredge (2006–09) in an after-lunch concert. The return trip as to the feasibility of bringing valuable
Sabine K. Klaus (2006–09) included a stop at the Calgary home of musical instruments through customs.
James B. Kopp (2006–09) the Audities Foundation, comprising Thus few people responded to Doug’s
Mary Oleskiewicz (2006–09) more than 150 electronic musical in- request for proposals. But by the time of
Douglas F. Koeppe (2007–10) struments spanning seventy years. The the meeting four presentations had been
Brenda Neece (2007–10) guiding force is David Kean, a collector arranged, though only one included live
Susan E. Thompson (2007–10) who also has ties to the Cantos Founda- instruments.
Beth Bullard (2008–11) tion collection. Carolyn Bryant presented a history
Jayson Dobney (2008–11) Douglas Koeppe moderated a panel of Show and Tell itself. A revered AMIS
Edward L. Kottick (2008–11) on the topic of private instrument collect- tradition, the first show and tell session
Maria Rose (2008–11) ing, past and present. He also introduced listed in a program was at the 1982 meet-
a Show and Tell session that included ing at Oberlin and was moderated by

 AMIS - Volume 37, No.2



William Gribbon. Her talk sparked some high standard. During the various events event possible. Darcy Kuronen, Pro-
reminiscences about previous show and people of different interests and profes- gram Chair, arranged an outstand-
tell events. sions, including students, researchers, ing conference for us, with excellent
Al Rice showed photographs of the academics, collectors, musicians and concerts, panel discussions, a trip to
only known American-made bassoon- instrument makers, were exchanging in- Banff, and papers on topics ranging
shaped alto clarinet, which he attributes formation, asking questions, and making from musical instruments at the late-
to Catlin (or the Catlin school) ca. 1810– useful comments and suggestions. sixteenth-century court of Landgrave
20. Rice originally learned of this instru- I had the chance to meet in person Mortiz von Hesse to electronic instru-
ment from Bob Eliason, who brought it and talk to people that had sent me infor- ments in the Cantos Collection. And
to the 1994 meeting in Elkhart, Indiana, mation via e-mail and attend some very the Cantos Music Foundation staff—
for appraisal (it was not then part of interesting and inspiring presentations. Andrew Mosker (Executive Director
show and tell). In fact, a few participants were interested of Cantos), Isobel Weldon Hogue,
John Hall, a piano collector and in my project and a couple of them have Jesse Moffat, Anne Phillips, Ingrid
historian who previously worked at the already sent me important new material Kincel, and John Leimseider—bent
Cantos Foundation, presented an over- for my research. Furthermore, I had the over backwards to make this confer-
view of the Canadian piano and organ in- chance to meet postgraduate students ence one we will long remember.
dustry. Makers he has researched include and researchers from various institu- Second, at the Annual Business
American-born John C. Fox, who set up tions, among them E. Peppers, P. Bento, Meeting, we recognized the invalu-
a piano factory in Kingston, Ontario, in M. Hill and E. Mitroulia (who won the able contributions of our outgoing of-
the early 1860s, and George M. Weber, award for best student paper), all friends ficers and Board members—Carolyn
who worked in New York City, Kingston and colleagues from the University of Bryant (Secretary), Marlowe Sigal
Ontario, and Chicago. Edinburgh, presenting their work and (Treasurer), Albert Rice, and Susanne
The final presentation was given by discussing their projects. Skyrm—people who have served the
veteran show-and-teller Lloyd Farrar, The staff of the Cantos Music Society exceptionally well, and over a
the only one to bring actual instruments. Foundation were friendly and helpful, considerable period of time.
He showed, described, and demonstrated answering a lot of questions regarding In addition to the fine papers and
American-made fifes in different lengths the instruments and the collection, and concerts presented in Calgary, I was
and also discussed a presentation fife, providing useful information about the pleased to attend two very stimulating
long attributed to E.G. Wright, that he city in general. The programme was panel discussions, “Education’s Role in
believes—based on its dimensions—to quite tight but everyone made an effort the Musical Instrument Museum” and
have been made by Walter Crosby. to keep things working on time and in “Private Wind Instrument Collecting,”
It is hoped that this description will order. I particularly enjoyed the concerts both of which were very well attended.
encourage others to think of instruments and the auction after the banquet. Law- I also enjoyed the return of “Show and
to bring to next year’s conference in Ann rence Libin did his best trying to raise Tell,” a feature of many earlier AMIS
Arbor (21–24 May 2009) to continue the funds for the next Gribbon competitors, meetings. These events lent consider-
tradition of Show and Tell. managing to be effective and humorous able variety to our program.
 Carolyn Bryant at the same time! Our 2009 annual conference will
As a Gribbon competitor I received be on the campus of the University of
A STUDENT Perspective funding for most of my expenses, and I Michigan, May 21-24. See the Call
would like to thank AMIS for offering for Papers below for details.
My name is Panagiotis Poulopou- me this great opportunity. Following the Also in 2009, AMIS will partici-
los and I am a PhD student at Edinburgh experience of this meeting I will surely pate in a conference in Italy in Sep-
University doing research on the English try to participate in the next AMIS meet- tember 2009, organized by CIMCIM
guitar under the supervision of Dr. D. ing in Michigan next year. (Comité International des Musées et
Martin and Prof A. Myers. Last May I  Panagiotis Poulopoulos Collections d’Instruments de Mu-
participated in the 37th annual meeting Edinburgh University sique), with the American Musical In-
of the AMIS in Calgary presenting the strument Society, The Historic Brass
paper “The piano-key mechanism of the Society, and the Galpin Society as
English guitar.” PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE co-sponsors. The principal sessions
This was the first time I participated I have now completed my first year of the conference will take place in
in an AMIS conference and I can say that as President of AMIS, and I have con- Rome, 7-11 September, with a “pre-
it was in total a very good experience. cluded that the Society’s greatest asset conference” in Milan 5-6 September
The whole atmosphere during the meet- is its people (no big surprise here!). and a “post-conference” in Naples
ing was quite casual and relaxed, enabling Our thirty-seventh annual meeting in 12-13 September. AMIS and Galpin
the creative interaction among the partici- Calgary, May 28-June 1, brought this will host a joint session on 10 Sep-
pants. The papers covered a wide variety home in a big way. First, there were tember, with Arnold Myers and my-
of topics and the presentations were of a the people who made this wonderful self as coordinators. Details will be

AMIS - Volume 37, No.2 



posted on the CIMCIM website in due missions are accepted will be notified This year we will be publishing our
course (http://www.music.ed.ac.uk/ by January 15, 2009. Their abstracts Membership Directory online (to be ac-
euchmi/cimcim/). The official call for will also be placed on the Society’s cessed by password). This will allow us
papers will not be announced before website (http://www.amis.org), where to save in printing and postage, and it also
November 15, 2008, but I encourage information about all aspects of the allows us to update it more often at vir-
AMIS members to contact me soon with conference will be made available. For tually no cost. The directory will be pub-
suggestions for presentations. further information, contact program lished as a PDF document that you can
 Stewart Carter chair Stewart Carter (at the address easily print if you require or prefer a hard
listed above) or local arrangements copy. We will be providing you with pass-
Call for Papers chair Christopher Dempsey, Universi- word access information. I recommend
ty of Michigan, School of Music, The- you download and save the directory to
38th Annual AMIS Meeting atre & Dance, E.V. Moore Building, your local computer rather than routinely
Stearns Collection 1100 Baits Dr., Ann Arbor, MI 48109- opening it from the website. A printed
2085 (e-mail: cdempsey@umich.edu). copy of the directory will be made avail-
of Musical Instruments Douglas Koeppe will again moder- able this first year at no charge to those
University of Michigan ate “Show and Tell,” where members can who request it, but it is hoped that most
School of Music, make informal presentations or demon- will find the electronic edition sufficient
Theatre & Dance strations using instruments from their per- to their needs.
Ann Arbor, Michigan sonal collections and/or discuss research We in academia are sometimes re-
in progress. He can be contacted at sistant to change. The ephemeral nature
May 21 to 24, 2009
512-847-1673 or koeppe1@verizon.net. of electronic ones and zeros is perhaps
The University of Michigan School William E. Gribbon Awards for Stu- disconcerting to those of us who are
of Music and the Stearns Collection of dent Travel to the annual meeting are concerned about the archival storage and
Musical Instruments will host the 38th available. These awards include a one- retrieval of digital information. A book
annual meeting of the American Musical year student membership in the Soci- or journal will always remain in some
Instrument Society from May 21 to 24, ety and substantial financial support for library somewhere and will always be
2009. The Program Committee for the travel and lodging. Applications should readable. Digital information is not so
meeting, which includes Stewart Carter be addressed to Emily Peppers, Cultural tangible and substantial as a book.
(chair), Darcy Kuronen, and Christopher Collections Audit Assistant, Edinburgh But the other side of that coin is that
Dempsey (ex-officio), welcomes propos- University Library, 3F1 10 Royal Park electronic forms of information storage
als for papers, lecture-demonstrations, Terrace, Edinburgh EH8 8JD Scotland and retrieval have revolutionized what
performances, and panel discussions on a or e.peppers@ed.ac.uk. See the AMIS we can know about a subject. Not long
broad range of topics relating to the his- website for further details. ago it may have been a challenge to find
tory, design, use, care, and acoustics of historical information about, or images
musical instruments from all cultures and Editor’s Note of, an obscure musical instrument. The
time periods. Presenters are especially en- exponential growth of readily available
couraged to submit proposals that relate Pictures and reports from Calgary information is having a huge impact on
to the Stearns Collection (http://www. indicate a fine time was had by all. I re- scholarship and learning. I think this is a
stearns.music). Individual presentations gret I was not able to attend, but several good thing.
should typically be limited to 20 minutes capable representatives have contributed So the challenge is to move care-
(followed by time for questions and dis- reports of the meeting in this issue of the fully, but with determination, away from
cussion), but requests for longer presenta- Newsletter. a technology of sharing information that
tions will be considered. As we look forward to another year humans have relied upon with success for
Please send a typed abstract (up of engagement in this curious obsession, centuries and towards an uncertain future
to 250 words), accompanied by a brief we must be vigilant to the future. Our technology that has really only just be-
biography (up to 75 words), and a list volatile times are filled with trials and gun. The risks seem great, but the rewards
of required audio-visual equipment, by tribulations. Oil prices don’t only affect will also be great if we approach it as an
December 15, 2008, to Stewart Carter, the price of gas at the pump, they affect opportunity rather than a threat.
Department of Music, Wake Forest Uni- everything we do. Printing and postage  Dwight Newton
versity, Winston-Salem, NC 27109; or costs continue to rise and transportation to
email: carter@wfu.edu. conferences is becoming more difficult. Curt Sachs Award
The specified language of the ab- Technology provides a lot of good
stracts and presentations is English, and solutions to sharing information. We can The late William Waterhouse, author
papers should be delivered in person at and will be taking more advantage of of The New Langwill Index of Musical
the meeting by the author. All submis- that in the coming year and the years be- Wind-Instrument Makers and Inventors,
sions will be considered by the Program yond. We have a solid website and email posthumously received the Curt Sachs
Committee, and applicants whose sub- discussion list. Award of the American Musical Instru-

 AMIS - Volume 37, No.2



ment Society on May 31, 2008, during statements, and interviews with surviv- Thursday, May 29, 2008, by President
the society’s meeting in Calgary, Alber- ing exponents of the trade. The four hun- Stewart Carter in the Discovery Room of
ta. Waterhouse, born in London in 1931, dred years covered in the article embrace the Cantos Music Foundation in Calgary,
died in Florence on November 5, 2007. much of the history of the violin, viol, Alberta, Canada.
Before preparing this fundamental lute, guitar, and harp families. The minutes of the June 29, 2007
revision of the pioneering work by Lyn- Barbieri teaches musical and ap- Annual Business Meeting were read.
desay G. Langwill, Waterhouse served as plied acoustics at the University of Lec- Motion to approve was made by Cynthia
principal bassoonist in the London Sym- ce, Italy, and the history of organ build- Hoover, was seconded, and approved.
phony Orchestra and as co-principal bas- ing at the Pontificia Università Gregori- Secretary Carolyn Bryant an-
soonist in the BBC Symphony Orches- ana in Rome. He has published a book nounced the following new members of
tra. He was also an important collector on musical temperament and more than the Board of Governors: Jayson Dobney,
of historical bassoons; his collection was eighty articles on music theory, acous- Maria Rose, and Beth Bullard. Elected
documented in The Proud Bassoon, the tics, organology, and music printing. He for a second term was Ed Kottick. Sec-
catalog of an exhibition mounted in 1983 graduated in electronic engineering from retary Bryant announced that member-
at the Edinburgh University Collection Rome University I in 1966. ships have dropped below 500, a low not
of Historical Musical Instruments. The Frances Densmore Award, giv- reached for a number of years.
A committee of AMIS members, en at two-year intervals for the most sig- Treasurer Marlowe Sigal reported
headed by Lloyd Farrar, made important nificant article in English on an organo- that AMIS’s net worth is approximately
contributions to The New Langwill Index, logical topic, is named for the pioneer- $228,000. He reported that there has been
which was published in London by Tony ing ethnographer who recorded musical minimal negative effect on the invest-
Bingham in 1993. Waterhouse also wrote practices of Native Americans on wax ments due to the downward trend in the
articles on the bassoon and related topics cylinders and in important books. stock market. Treasurer Sigal was also
in the 1980 and 2001 editions of The New very happy to announce two important
Grove Dictionary of Music and Musi- FREDERICK SELCH grants made to AMIS. The first, of $6500,
cians, as well as Bassoon, a volume in the was given to support the William E. Grib-
series of Yehudi Menuhin Music Guides. AWARD bon Memorial Award for Student Travel
He published many articles, reviews, The Frederick R. Selch Award, es- and was made through the Cantos Foun-
translations, and editions of music. tablished in 2005, is presented in recog- dation. The second grant, of $5000, was
The Curt Sachs Award is given an- nition of the most outstanding student given to support the Annual Meeting and
nually for important contributions in the paper at the Society’s annual meeting. was made by the Target Corporation.
field of organology. The award is named in honor of Selch, President Carter thanked outgoing
a longtime AMIS member and former Board of Governors members Susanne
Frances Densmore president of the Society (1977-81). Skyrm and Al Rice and made special
Seven students, representing five dif- citation of outgoing Secretary Carolyn
Award ferent countries, presented papers at Bryant and Treasurer Marlowe Sigal. He
Patrizio Barbieri, a trained engineer our recent conference in Calgary. All of welcomed their replacements, Deborah
who turned his attention to the study of them were excellent, and the selection Check Reeves and Joanne Kopp, respec-
musical instruments, has received the committee—Janet Page, Albert Rice, tively.
Frances Densmore Award of the Ameri- and Stewart Carter—faced a very diffi- The Journal of the American Mu-
can Musical Instrument Society for his cult decision. The winner for 2008 was sical Instrument Society editor, Janet
article on the making of musical instru- Eugenia Mitroulia, for her paper “The Page, reported that the 2007 volume was
ment strings in Italy. The award was Saxotromba: Fact or Fiction.” Eugenia, out and the 2008 volume is under con-
announced at the society’s meeting in a Ph.D. candidate at the University of struction. Three articles have been ac-
Calgary on May 31, 2008. Barbieri’s Edinburgh, offered an insightful view of cepted, and reviews editor Jim Kopp has
“Roman and Neapolitan Gut Strings the distinction between the saxhorn and solicited nine reviews. Page expects the
1550-1950” was published in the Galpin the saxotromba—a distinction that was new volume to be out before the end of
Society Journal in 2006. not always consistent, even in the mind the year. She invited the general mem-
Barbieri’s findings are of immediate of Adolphe Sax himself. bership to submit articles, either long or
interest to players of bowed and plucked short, and communications.
instruments. He traced changes in de- Annual Business President Carter reported that the new
sign, in manufacturing processes, and on-line membership directory will be up for
in the requirements of performers over Meeting a trial run by early September. This directory
the centuries, addressing agricultural will be updated regularly, will be available
May 29, 2008
sources, scaling, overspinning, trueness, only to AMIS members via a password-pro-
and tension. He drew on Latin- and Ital- The Annual Business Meeting of tected area of the society’s website. A print
ian-language archives, published histo- the American Musical Instrument So- version will be supplied free-of-charge for
ries, trade advertisements, performers’ ciety was called to order at 1:15 PM on the first year if requested.

AMIS - Volume 37, No.2 



tions Prize Committee
will be chaired by Niles
Eldredge, with Darryl
Martin and Beth Bullard.
The committee to
choose next year’s recipi-
ents of the Gribbon Me-
morial Awards for Student
Travel consists of Em-
ily Peppers (chair), Mary
Oleskiewicz, and Al Rice.
Members are requested to
encourage any graduate
or undergraduate students
who might be interested
The AMIS board considers Janet Page’s report on the Journal (L-R: Doug Koeppe, Debbie Reeves, Susanne in this award to submit an
Skyrm, Joanne Kopp, Jim Kopp, Janet Page, Al Rice, Marlowe Sigal) (C.B.) application (details on the
AMIS website).
Christopher Dempsey invited the Ioana Sherman, Hannes Vereecke, Eu-
general membership to Ann Arbor for genia Mitroulia, Matthew Courtney, News of Members
the 2009 Annual Meeting to be held Panagiotis Poulopoulos, and Clinton
at the Stearns Collection. The dates Spell. Lloyd Farrar provided a brief Carolyn Bryant has been appoint-
of the meeting are May 21-24, 2009. history of the namesake of the award, ed as a contributing editor in charge
The Stearns Collection was founded in William Gribbon. of articles about musical instruments
1899 and contains 2500 instruments. Laurence Libin called for items to and instrument makers for The Grove
The last time the Annual Meeting be auctioned with all proceeds donated Dictionary of American Music, sec-
was held in Ann Arbor was 1974 and to the Gribbon fund. ond edition.  The original four-volume
the last time AMIS visited the collec- President Carter called for new edition appeared in 1986; the revi-
tion was in 1983 in conjunction with business, and none was announced. sion will expand to six volumes and is
the Annual Meeting being held at the The meeting was concluded at 1:40 PM. scheduled to be published by Oxford
Henry Ford Museum. President Carter Respectfully submitted, University Press in 2011. Carolyn has
announced a December 15 due date for  Deborah Check Reeves, Secretary already been in touch with a number
a call for papers, Carter chairing the of AMIS members about potential ar-
Program Committee. A 2010 meeting ticles, and is interested in hearing from
in Washington, DC, is being discussed Committee others about their areas of expertise
with Carol Lynn Ward-Bamford of the Appointments in musical instruments in America
Library of Congress. (cfbryant@boo.net).
President Carter announced a joint President Stewart Carter has an-
meeting of CIMCIM with several other nounced committee appointments for Clarinet
organizations, including the Historic 2008–09, including the nominating
Brass Society, the Galpin Society, and committee and two prize committees. conference
AMIS. This meeting will occur over Members are welcome to suggest can- The Stiftung Kloster Michael-
several days in three different cities in didates for the Board of Governors, or stein–Music Institute for Performance
Italy in September of 2009. The dates to suggest potential awardees for the Practice presents its 29th Symposium
that will feature activities by Galpin and Sachs Award (for contributions to the on Musical Instrument Building: “His-
AMIS will be September 7-11, 2009, in goals of the society) or the Bessaraboff tory, construction and repertoire of
Rome. Prize (for most significant book in Eng- clarinet instruments,” Michaelstein,
President Carter thanked mem- lish published during 2006–07). Please October 24 to 26, 2008. The three-day
bers of the Gribbon Award for Student submit any suggestions to the chair of conference will include papers and
Travel Committee. The committee was the appropriate committee. performances on clarinet, chalumeau,
chaired by Arian Sheets and included The Nominating Committee con- basset horn, and related instruments.
Mary Oleskiewicz and Emily Peppers. sists of Sabine Klaus (chair), Douglas A special exhibition with 40 clarinets
Six Gribbon scholars were awarded Koeppe, and Jayson Dobney. The Curt from the collection of Eric Hoeprich
grants that allowed them to travel to the Sachs Award Committee consists of will be featured.
2008 Annual Meeting. The following Harrison Powley (chair), Ed Kottick For more information, see:
were introduced to the membership: and Mary Oleskiewicz. The Publica- http://www.kloster-michaelstein.de

 AMIS - Volume 37, No.2


BOOK Romanticism.  (A password within the


book provides access to clarifying musi-
cal examples at the publisher’s website.)
ments defeats the purpose of making pe-
riod instruments. A woodwind’s tuning
and voicing can never be perfect, hence

REVIEWS Haynes’ Modernism has seamless le-


gato, continuous vibrato, long-line phras-
ing, unyielding tempos, and rigid fidelity
makers must adopt compromises to cre-
ate functional instruments. The compro-
mises extant in a historical instrument
Bruce Haynes. The End of Early Mu- to the printed score. While appropriate can tell us what was important or trivial
sic. Oxford University Press, 2007. for the works of Stravinsky, Boulez, and to its maker and thus to the players and
284 pages:  17 musical exx. ISBN 978- other mid- to late twentieth-century com- audiences of that era. Haynes perfectly
0-19-518987-2. $35 (hardbound). posers, Modernism is inimical to Period sums up the challenges facing modern
performance. Applying Modernist style to makers: “To comprehend the purposes of
In The End of Early Music, Bruce Rhetorical music results in what Haynes such apparent mistakes often takes years
Haynes calls to action all performers and punningly calls “strait style,” in which of playing, combined with reflection. If
artisans who make their living in early the performer eschews the freedoms and we ‘correct’ them, we may inadvertently
music. Unlike his Elegant Oboe (2001) improvisations of Rhetorical style, thus eliminate differences between the pres-
and History of Performing Pitch (2002), placing himself in a musical straitjacket ent and the past the way nineteenth-cen-
this book is not a synthesis of musico- and missing the point of Period perfor- tury editors used to bowdlerize out the
logical and historical research; rather mance. cross-relations in Purcell” (159).
it comprises “reflections on the present Chapter 8, “Ways of Copying the Haynes calls for scrupulously exact
state of the historically inspired perfor- Past,” contrasts three approaches to copying of historical woodwinds, “warts
mance (HIP) movement … from the copying artworks, including period in- and all.” The performer, with practice
point of view of someone who has been struments: Emulation, Replication and and study, must accept “flaws” as es-
involved with it since the early 1960s” Imitation.  Emulation is “copying with sential attributes of the instruments. This
(vii). improvement or enhancement,” the pro- laudable attitude is a little unwieldy.
cess undertaken by Mendelssohn for Today’s audiences grew up in Modernist
Bach, by Wagner for Beethoven, and by times and demand that performers play
Mozart for Handel. This was the guiding relatively close to equal temperament.
principle of period instrument making un- The Period performer must be able to
til the 1970s; consider Dolmetsch’s large- make a living; historical accuracy in
holed recorders, Pleyel’s steel-framed tuning will be one of the places where
harpsichords and Moeck’s two-keyed woodwind makers must compromise.
oboes built with a modern bore, pitched I take exception to a few of
at A-440, and played with modern reeds. Haynes’ claims.  He quibbles over mu-
As an outgrowth of “Darwinian” attitudes sicians’ modes of dress and concert
towards early music, Emulation led to deportment.  He contends that “the oboe
“copies” of early instruments which fit used in symphony orchestras today ...
the experience of Modern players. has changed less since [1881] than the
A “humbler mind set” (140) pro- hautboy changed in any twenty-year pe-
motes the exact Replication of period riod during the eighteenth century” (29
instruments, played with historically ap- and 231, endnote 46). Such a claim ad-
propriate reeds, at original pitches, from dresses body morphology and key work
original notation. This laudable goal has without considering the bore and tone
yet to be reached—our reeds don’t fully holes. In fact, the sound of the sympho-
meet the demands of a period oboe. But ny orchestra has changed appreciably in
Haynes views Replication as having fos- my own concert-going lifetime of only
Haynes gives a fascinating insight tered popular acceptance of “authentic- thirty-five years, largely because modern
into the modern HIP movement and its ity” in early music, thus allowing the instruments really are modern; they are
countercultural roots.  He identifies three truest understanding of original practice louder, less nuanced in timbre and often
relevant performing styles: Romantic, and intent. played at sharper pitch than those of just
Modern, and Period. Romantic style, Imitation embraces “style-copy- a generation ago.  
current until the early twentieth century, ing,” which seeks to create the result of These quibbles aside, Haynes pow-
was characterized by sentimentalism, a particular style or instrument but not erfully demonstrates the cultural validity
“portamentos, fluctuating tempos, and every fine detail.  To Haynes, “style- of early music and the need for scholars
unrelenting earnestness” (33). This mu- copying is what most Period musicians and instrument makers to continually
tated after World War I into Modernism, do in performing.”  He argues compel- refer back to original sources. The End
which Haynes considers a reaction to lingly that “correcting” historical instru- of Early Music repeatedly confronts the

AMIS - Volume 37, No.2 



unspoken assumptions and biases behind beautiful original condition, with three evidence for several problems that ap-
“early music” making; anyone reading brass keys. Simple but elegant lines at- pear to have arisen during the design and
this book with an open mind will come test to its early date (ca.1750), as does its construction of this new instrumental
away hearing different things in early E key, located at the back and operated type. The seventh key, for F-sharp, was
music, and will be richer for the insight. by the thumb. The profile resembles that perhaps removed before the instrument
Who should read this book?  Any of earlier instruments such as recorders left the workshop or shortly thereafter.
student, maker or performer who wishes and primitive clarinets. The swelling in After removal of the problematic key,
to transcend mere technique and to un- which the E key is mounted has two F the area was neatly cleaned and covered
derstand the function and philosophy of holes, one closed with a removable plug with leather along with the rest of the
period instruments.   for playing with the right hand below the curved, segmented body.
 Robert Howe left. With the plug moved to the other F Basset horns by Theodor Lotz and F.
hole, the instrument can be played with G. A. Kirst are beautiful examples of the
Frank P. Bär. Verzeichnis der Eu- the hand positions reversed. Stamped high era of graceful form and function,
ropäischen Musikinstrumente im Ger- “IP,” a mark not yet associated with any ending around 1800. In them the body,
manischen Nationalmuseum Nürnberg, known maker, the clarinet can be attrib- formerly curved, becomes angled, with
Band 6: Liebesklarinetten/Bassetthörn- uted on stylistic grounds to South Ger- a “knee,” usually made of ivory. These
er/Bassklarinetten/Metallklarinetten: many or the Alps. It is one of the earliest early basset horns extended the compass
Beschreibender Katalog. Wilhelmshav- clarinets d’amour known of the instruments from written E down to
en: Florian Nötzel Verlag, 2006. 294 C, but without any intervening tones. Not
pp.: 265 black-and-white photographs until the second quarter of the nineteenth
(including 17 x-rays), 18 line drawings, century were the semitones made avail-
37 graphs, and 12 diagrams. ISBN: 3- able. One anonymous basset horn in the
7959-0823-X. €128 (cloth). catalog, from the very end of that period,
  descends to low B-flat. Its mechanism is
This superbly well-organized and so complex (and ingenious) that the key-
lavishly illustrated volume presents vi- work diagram is necessary to understand
sual and textual descriptions of thirty- it. Curiously, this instrument reverts to the
three instruments of the clarinet family earlier, angled body and box design.
made in some twenty-five locations in One bass clarinet catches the eye
South Germany and Austria, from the for its key work: the “Bimbonifon,”
middle of the eighteenth to the beginning produced by the Bimboni family be-
of the twentieth centuries. Three sopra- tween 1845 and 1850. Anyone familiar
no metal clarinets are included, but the with the family of sarrusophones (coni-
majority are larger sizes: seven clarinets cally bored metal instruments invented
d’amour, one tenor clarinet, sixteen bas- ca.1855 by the French bandmaster Sar-
set horns, and six bass clarinets, requir- rus) must wonder about possible influ-
ing the maker to bring widely separated ence from the metal Bimbonifon (the
tone holes under the convenient control first half of its bore cylindrical and the
of the player’s fingers. Most are jewels second half conical). The bridging of
of esthetic beauty. For those who appre- The basset horns (all in F but for one key work between the two main vertical
ciate amazingly complex mechanisms, in G), dating from the 1770s to ca.1850, body sections is strikingly similar. (This
several of the basset horns (most in F) present a wide range of esthetic types. arrangement also makes one think of
and bass clarinets (in B-flat) can provide The earliest have curved bodies covered the contra-alto and contrabass clarinets
endless hours of fascinating study. in leather, fitted to be played with either developed by the Le Blanc Company of
Graphs display the results of so- hand above. During the later “golden Paris in the twentieth century.) Unfortu-
phisticated measurements of inside age” of classical basset horns, a “box” nately, the Bimbonifon is in poorer con-
diameters of most instruments. Mean- near the bell housed a double-reversing dition than most of the other clarinets in
while, twelve schematic diagrams of bore to achieve a longer sounding length this catalog.
key work−variations on a model devel- and extend the compass of the instru- Also of note are two other bass clar-
oped by Herbert Heyde in Historische ment. Still later models were straight, inets. One, made in modern style by Buf-
Musikinstrumente im Bachhaus Eisen- lacking the box. fet-Crampon ca.1850, shows the obvious
ach (1976)−aid the reader in compre- The earliest of these basset horns, influence of the saxophone family, pat-
hending the more complex key systems, by Anton and Michael Mayrhofer of ented by Adolphe Sax in 1846. Another,
such as those of the deeper clarinets. Passau, dates from the 1770s. It origi- made by Heckel of Biebrich in the early
The earliest instrument included is nally had seven keys of sheet brass with twentieth century, is an elegant straight
an anonymous clarinet d’amour in G, in octagonal flaps. The author discusses model. This historically important bass

 AMIS - Volume 37, No.2



of the clarinet family is seldom described The article praises McCammon’s factory was situated in northern Albany
with such clarity and detail. factory in glowing terms that seem espe- at the southern end of a block bounded
This volume, the third by the author cially appropriate to its modern facilities by Broadway on the west, North Ferry
in a series of catalogs of instruments in and equipment, but they have a famil- Street on the south (the main front-
the Nuremberg museum, contains 275 iar ring to a reader conversant with the age of the building), and an unnamed
notes on the text, a bibliography of 73 genre of “piano-factory visit” articles of street on the east. This location is not
reference and source works, and indexes the 19th century. In fact, most of the text mentioned in the article of 1854 in
of makers, cities of origin, and inventory was taken verbatim (and pieced together Godey’s Lady’s Book—the corner of
numbers in this volume. It also includes not very skillfully) from the extensive State Street and Pearl Street, given in
cumulative indexes listing similar infor- description of Boardman & Gray’s fac- this source, must have been the address
mation for all three volumes. tory published almost a quarter-century of the company’s warerooms—but it
A few typographical slips and mi- earlier in Godey’s Lady’s Book (January is identified in the newspaper article
nor weaknesses in order of presenta- and February, 1854): 5–13 and 101–107 cited above, in Albany city directories,
tion of some information hardly detract (this article was reprinted in this News- and in the Map of the City of Albany
in a work of this scale. This splendid letter 31, no. 2 [Summer 2002]: 5–10; (Albany: Sprague & Co.; New York:
volume will not disappoint any serious and no. 3 [Fall 2002]: 8–20). The out- M. Dripps, 1857). Since the same loca-
student, researcher, collector or curator dated source must have been too irre- tion is given for William McCammon’s
interested in the lower members of the sistible to John C. Freund, editor of The new, enlarged factory, it is clear that he
clarinet family.  Music Trade Review, and probably also built it on the ruins of the old build-
 Douglas Koeppe to Edward McCammon, who may have ing. Thus, the reference in 1878 to his
needed to supply appropriate verbiage to “selecting a site” seems somewhat dis-
Freund and most likely had a copy of the ingenuous.
If you are interested in reviewing old article conveniently at hand. At any In the following transcription of
a book or a CD for the Newsletter, rate, whoever was responsible for recy- the article of 1878, text taken directly
please contact review editor Jim Kopp cling the text, the extent of this practice from the 1854 article is presented in
at J2Kopp@aol.com. shown in the present example should boldface type. The earlier article ends
serve to make readers wary of informa- with a description of Boardman &
tion found in the trade-journal literature. Gray’s “Dolce Campana Attachment,”
Within the large blocks of copied which allowed players to obtain “hun-
Familiar Words material, the article of 1878 includes dreds of beautiful effects” by causing
about a Piano changes of several items that clearly weights to bear down in varying de-
reflect the current situation. Thus, the grees on the bridge, modulating the
Manufacturer new factory had a front on three streets vibration of the soundboard. In place
of 513 feet (i.e., the sum of the lengths of the reference to this evidently out-
While assembling materials for of all three sides), and its main building moded device, the 1878 article ends
the paper I presented on 19th-century is described as fronting on three streets with information—not included in
American piano factories at the 2007 363 feet; while in 1854 the fronts were the following transcription—about
AMIS meeting in New Haven, I inadver- upwards of 320 feet and 208 feet, respec- the “patent insulated iron rim” (which
tently overlooked an article entitled “A tively. Likewise, the size of the (possibly was already featured in advertisements
Visit to the Factory of E. McCammon in new) steam engine in 1878 was given of Boardman, Gray & Co. as early as
Albany,” published in The Music Trade as fifty horsepower, compared with the 1860). Also not given here is the text
Review (April 15, 1878): 236–237. As old engine, which was reported as hav- of a document dated 1862, attesting to
seen in the transcription given below, ing forty horsepower. It is interesting McCammon’s legitimacy as the suc-
this article identifies the proprietor as that each article states that the engine cessor to Boardman, Gray & Co.
Edward McCammon, the son of William in question had been designed by Wil-  William E. Hettrick
McCammon, who bought the business liam McCammon, who had overseen its
of Boardman, Gray & Co. in 1861. What construction. (The article of 1854 adds Transcription from The Music Trade
the article does not reveal is that the el- that McCammon was currently in charge Review:
der McCammon’s being “almost imme- of the Chicago Waterworks.) In addi- A Visit to the Factory of
diately . . . compelled to extend the fa- tion, while the 1878 article identifies the E. McCammon in Albany
cilities which had been sufficient for his same McCammon as the one who super- By the courteous invitation of Mr.
predecessors” was the result of the fire vises the manufacturer’s department and E. McCammon, we paid a visit to his
that destroyed almost all of Boardman & “gives his time personally to the busi- factory in Albany last week. Mr. Mc-
Gray’s plant at the same address in 1860 ness,” in 1854 it was James A. Gray Cammon was anxious to convince us
(reported in The New-York Times, Sep- who carried out these tasks. by personal observation that the pianos
tember 18, 1860). The old Boardman, Gray & Co. which bore his name were all made on

AMIS - Volume 37, No.2 



the premises owned by him, and were of planing boards or planks of any The business of this house, of
constructed of the very best material thickness three feet wide; two circu- which Edward McCammon is the pres-
and by the most skilled workmen of the lar saws; one gig saw, for sawing fan- ent proprietor, was founded in 1835 by
old house of Boardman & Gray, whose cy scroll work; a “half lapping ma- Boardman & Gray, who achieved con-
only legitimate successor, if we under- chine” for cutting the bottom frame siderable distinction by the superior
stand the matter rightly, is Mr. McCam- work together. One band saw, turning excellence of their instruments. They
mon. We must confess that we were lathes, and several other machines, continued in the business for some
most favorably impressed by the order all in full operation, more noise than years, and were finally succeeded by
and completeness of Mr. McCammon’s music. Mr. William McCammon, who, after
factory, and heartily endorse his almost The lumber, after being cut to a number of years of unqualified suc-
modest claims to consideration. the length required, by the large cess, retired full of honors and years,
The manufactory is situated cor- cross-cut saw in the cellar, is brought the first of last year, in favor of his son,
ner Broadway and North Ferry streets, into this machine room and sawed Mr. Edward McCammon, the present
Albany, N.Y., occupying the end of and planed to the different forms proprietor. Mr. Edward McCammon
a block, presenting a front on three and shapes required for use, and is has been brought up to the business,
streets, of 513 feet, the main building then ready for the drying rooms. and is thoroughly conversant with all
of which, fronting on three streets In this machine room, which is a the details, from the selection of mate-
363 feet, is built of brick, four stories very large one, the “bottoms” for the rial to the sale of the finished instru-
high, above a high basement story, cases are made and finished, ready for ment. Mr. Wm. McCammon succeeded
devoted exclusively to machinery the case maker to build his case upon. Boardman & Gray in 1861, and almost
driven by a fifty-horse power engine. The next room is the “case-mak- immediately was compelled to extend
Every improvement and convenience ing” department; and here we find the facilities which had been sufficient
is attached to make the entire per- piano-forte cases in all stages of for his predecessors. Selecting a site,
fect, and in going through the prem- progress; the materials for some just he planned and built the elegant and
ises one is attracted by the compre- gathered together, and others fin- substantial building now occupied by
hensiveness of the whole concern. ished or finishing; some of the plain- his son as a manufactory.
The drying-rooms, of which there est styles, and others of the most The establishment employs some
are three in the establishment, hold, elaborate carved work, and orna- one hundred hands, and the number
when full, 150,000 feet lumber, and mental designs. We will now follow of the last piano made was 12,096,
are kept at a temperature of about the case to the room where the work- their capacity being thirty instru-
100° Fahrenheit, by means of steam men are employed in putting in the ments per week.
from the boiler through pipes. sounding board and iron frames. For the convenience of himself
The engine, of fifty-horse power, The case, while in this depart- and his patrons, Mr. Edward McCam-
was built at the machine works of ment, receives all its strings, which are mon has had the wires of the Western
Messrs. Townsend, of Albany, from of the finest tempered steel wire, fin- Union Telegraph Company brought
the plans and under the superinten- ished and polished in the best manner. into his office, and customers can now
dence of Mr. Wm. McCammon. Mr. McCammon makes his own send in their orders from any part of
In the same room is the boiler, of “keys” and actions. the United States and Canada free of
the locomotive tubular pattern, large Action-Making Machine, Etc. expense, and thus insure prompt at-
enough not only to furnish steam for He uses the principle which is tention to their orders. The excellent
the engine, but also for heating the termed the French Grand Action, reputation made by Mr. Wm. McCam-
entire factory, and furnishing heat with many improvements, added mon will be fully sustained by his
for all things requisite in the build- by himself. He considers it more son, and we predict for the McCam-
ing. Water for supplying the boiler powerful than the “Boston or Semi- mon piano, under the efficient man-
is contained in a large cistern under Grand,” as it will repeat with much agement of Mr. Edward McCammon,
the centre of the yard, holding some greater rapidity and precision than still greater success in the future than
26,000 gallons, supplied from the any other, and is far more elastic un- it has achieved in the past.
roofs of the buildings. der the manipulation of the fingers.
Passing to the next room, we find The manufacturer’s department AMIS-L
workmen employed in preparing the is under the immediate supervision
iron plates used inside the pianos, of Mr. Wm. McCammon who gives
from the rough state, as they come his time personally to the business. AMIS-L is the free email list for
from the furnace. He selects and purchases all the ma- AMIS and Galpin Society members
Machine Shop terials used in the establishment. No only. For complete information on sub-
In the machine shop are two piano-forte is permitted to leave the scribing to the list, see the website at:
of “Daniel’s Patented Planing ma- concern until it has been submitted http://www.amis.org/amis-l.
chines,” of the largest size, capable to his careful inspection.

10 AMIS - Volume 37, No.2



IMAGES OF CALGARY 2008
Photo Credits: A.H. = Aurelia Hartenberger, C.B. = Carolyn Bryant, P.P. = Panagiotis Poulopoulos, J.K. = Jim Kopp

Trying out an Ondes Martinot at Audities Foundation (C.B.) Pedro Bento plugging in (J.K.)

Tony Bingham, John Leimseider, Debbie Reeves Lloyd Farrar and fifes at the Geoffrey Burgess, oboe (A.H.)
at Audities Foundation (P.P.) Show and Tell session (A.H.)

Group photo of Calgary attendees (A.H.)


AMIS - Volume 37, No.2 11

IMAGES OF CALGARY 2008

John Leimseider, electronics technician for Cantos Foundation, with some


of the Audities Foundation’s instruments. (C.B.)

2008 Gribbon Awardees


Neil Cockburn playing the Ahrend Organ (C.B.) Matthew Courtney, Clinton Spell, Eugenia Mitroulia, Ioana Sherman,
Panagiotis Poulopoulos, Hannes Vereecke (A.H.)

Jim Kopp tries out the Marimba Lumina at the Mark Goldstein and Andrew Mosker (A.H.)
Audities Foundation (C.B.)

12 AMIS - Volume 37, No.2

You might also like