You are on page 1of 48

PAGE DE COUVERTURE

The French against


the crisis of democracy:
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
French perceptions of Franco-American relations
and populism

An Ifop survey on behalf of Le Sursaut and the


Fondation pour l’innovation politique

FD/JPD/SS No. 115814


Ifop contacts:
Frédéric Dabi / Jean-Philippe Dubrulle / Sébastien Sibaï
Opinion and Business Strategies Division
TEL: +33 (0)1 45 84 14 44
firstname.lastname@ifop.com
SEPTEMBER 2018

September 2018
The French against the crisis
of democracy:
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
Between the fear of globalization, rejection of immigration, rise of Islamism and populism, in
a context of upheaval in the world’s order, relations between Europe and the United States are
suffering through the most important crisis in their history.

The weakening of the transatlantic relationship, multilateralism, NATO, as well as the divisions
within the European Union are all the more threatening as they manifest themselves into a context
of the rise of competing models, the first of which are Russia and China.

In 2016, in a context already marked by Islamist attacks, the refugee crisis and the populist
upsurge, AJC Europe and the Foundation for Political Innovation organized a day of reflection to
draw attention to the erosion of the democratic world. Today, we reiterate the event, two years
after the election of Donald Trump, while the refugee crisis continues to have an impact throughout
Europe, favoring notably new populist breakthroughs.

To support the second edition of the Sursaut, we asked the polling institute Ifop to carry out
an opinion survey in order to understand the public’s view of Franco-American relations and of
the future of democracies (the survey was conducted in France with a sample of 1,007 people,
interviewed from the 10th to the 11th of September 2018).

Main takeaways
The Franco-German friendship is perceived as stronger than ever,
and Putin’s Russia worries twice the number of French people than
Trump’s America does.
More than ever, Germany is viewed by the French as “an ally or a safe partner country” (89%)
compared to 61% for the United Kingdom and 44% for the United States. The French’s judgement
of Germany has not been this favorable since 1994.

It should be noted that despite a lower level of confidence, the image of the United Kingdom, more
than a year after Brexit, has improved significantly (61%) compared to 2017 (46%).
A positive judgment of the US has nonetheless risen by six percentage points since March of 2017
(38%).

Finally, in the case of non-European powers, the French have most confidence in India (41%),
ahead of China (32%) and finally Russia (22%), which comes last.
The French do not confuse Trump with Americans.
While a significant proportion of French people still consider the United States as a partner (44%),
judgments made on the policies of the American President elicit wide disapproval (80%). Similarly,
our survey reveals that 83% of French people have a poor opinion of Donald Trump as president,
a number which has increased by eight points since the day after his election (75%).

The United States is firstly considered an ally in the fight against Islamist terrorism (74%). To go
up against Russia, barely more than one in two French people (51%) qualify the United States as
an ally, and 49% consider the country an “opponent”! In general, to ensure the security of NATO
member countries, 50% of French people look to the United States as an ally, and 50% as an
opponent.
In terms of economic growth, the French are massively (78%) watching the United States as an
“adversary”, both in regards to France (78%) as well as to the European Union as a whole (81%).
It is about the fight against global warming that the French are the most numerous to consider the
United States as an adversary.

While the French severely judge the President of the United States, they do not confuse him with
the American people. In fact, 75% of those surveyed consider that Donald Trump is a president
who does not represent the image of Americans. This confirms the friendship that a very broad
majority of French respondents (79%) say they feel for Americans. Similarly, the French remain
above all convinced of the need to preserve the relationship between Europe and the United
States: they are 82% to judge the preservation of this relationship as important in the years to
come.

Fragile democracy: migration crisis and populist upsurge.


According to the survey, by comparing the current situation to that of a few years ago, democracy
appears more fragile in the United States (64%) than in the EU as a whole (56%), and even less
so in France (52%). A large minority (38%) also consider the German democracy as more fragile.

According to respondents, 32% of French people cite that the rise of populism and protest votes
in Europe can be explained by immigration, followed by the 23% that cited degradations of living
conditions - purchasing power, housing, social insurance, etc., the 12% that cited problems
regarding the security of individuals and property - incivility, delinquency, criminality, 13% that
cited the integration of those with foreign origins, unemployment (9%), the feeling of social
decommissioning (7%) and corruption (4%).

The French believe that those most responsible for the rise in populism in Europe are first and
foremost national governments (47%), far ahead of the European Union (33%). The idea that the
media could be responsible for poorly informing us is shared by only 20% of respondents.
Contents

- 1 - Methodology
- 2 - Study results Contents
- A - The French and the United States
Perceived reliability of various allies or partners
Approval of US policy
Perceptions of Franco-American cooperation on various issues
Donald Trump’s approval rating among the French
Perceived degree of similarity between Donald Trump and Americans in general
-1- Methodology .................................................................................................................................................................................... 1
Perceived importance of maintaining relations between Europe and the United States
-2- Study results.....................................................................................................................................................................................
Benevolence towards Americans 4
- A - The French and the United States............................................................................................................................ 5
- B - The rise of populism
Perceived
Perceivedreliability various allies
strength of democracy or partners
in various countries ..................................................................................................... 6
Approval of US policy................................................................................................................................................................ 14
Causes of the rise of populism in Europe
The most responsible
Perceptions authority for
of Franco-American the rise of populism
cooperation on various in Europe
issues.............................................................. 16
Donald Trump’s approval rating among the French........................................................................................... 24
Perceived degree of similarity between Donald Trump and Americans in general.................... 26
Perceived importance of maintaining relations between Europe and the United States ..... 28
Goodwill towards Americans............................................................................................................................................... 30

- B - The rise of populism............................................................................................................................................................ 32


Perceived strength of democracy in various countries.................................................................................... 33
Causes of the rise of populism in Europe................................................................................................................... 38
The authority most responsible for the rise in populism............................................................................... 41

4
-- 1 --

Methodology
Methodology

5
2

Methodology
This document presents the results of a study conducted by Ifop. It is fully compliant
with scientific ethical principles of polling. Its findings reflect the state of public
opinion at the time that it was conducted and should not be regarded as a prediction.

Ifop’s express consent is required for any full or partial publication.

Study conducted by Ifop on behalf of Le Sursaut


and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique

Sample The survey was conducted with 1,007 people,


constituting a representative sample of the French population
aged 18 years and above.

Methodology Sample representativeness was ensured by


quota sampling (by respondents’ sex, age and occupation)
following stratification by region and municipality size.

Collection method Interviews were conducted online by a


self-administered questionnaire between the 10th and 11th of
September 2018.

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
3

Note regarding margins of error


Using statistical theory, it is possible to measure the uncertainty of each result in
a survey. This uncertainty is Note expressed
regardingas a confidence
margins of error interval either side of the
observed value in which the real value has a determined probability of occurring.
This uncertainty,
Using commonly
statistical theory, referred
it is possible to as
to measure thethe ‘marginof of
uncertainty error’
each resultvaries depending
in a survey. This on
sample size isand
uncertainty the observed
expressed percentage,
as a confidence asside
interval either shown
of thein the table
observed valuebelow:
in which the real
value has a determined probability of occurring. This uncertainty, commonly referred to as the
‘margin of error’ varies depending on sample size and the observed percentage, as shown in the
table below:

95% CONFIDENCE INTERVAL

If the observed percentage is …


Sample size 5 or 95% 10 or 90% 20 or 80% 30 or 70% 40 or 60% 50%

100 4.4 6.0 8.0 9.2 9.8 10.0


200 3.1 4.2 5.7 6.5 6.9 7.1
300 2.5 3.5 4.6 5.3 5.7 5.8
400 2.2 3.0 4.0 4.6 4.9 5.0
500 1.9 2.7 3.6 4.1 4.4 4.5
600 1.8 2.4 3.3 3.7 4.0 4.1
700 1.6 2.3 3.0 3.5 3.7 3.8
800 1.5 2.1 2.8 3.2 3.5 3.5
900 1.4 2.0 2.6 3.0 3.2 3.3
1000 1.4 1.8 2.5 2.8 3.0 3.1
2000 1.0 1.3 1.8 2.1 2.2 2.2
3000 0.8 1.1 1.4 1.6 1.8 1.8
4000 0.7 0.9 1.3 1.5 1.6 1.6
5000 0.6 0.8 1.1 1.3 1.4 1.4
6000 0.6 0.8 1.1 1.3 1.4 1.4
8000 0.5 0.7 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.1
10000 0.4 0.6 0.8 0.9 0.9 1.0

Example reading of the table: in a sample of 1,000 people, if the measured percentage is 10%, the
Example
margin ofreading of The
error is 1.8. thereal
table: in a sample
percentage of 1,000
is therefore people,
between if the
8.2% and measured percentage
11.8%.
is 10%, the margin of error is 1.8. The real percentage is therefore between 8.2% and
11.8%.

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
-2-

Study results
-2-

Study results

8
-A-

The French and- the


A - United States

The French and the United States

9
6

Perceived reliability of various allies or partners

Question: Please indicate whether you consider each of the following


countries to be a very reliable, mostly reliable, mostly unreliable
or very unreliable ally or partner for France.

- Summary Table – “TOTAL reliable” –

All All All All All French


French French French French people
people people people people September
May June May March 2018
1994 2004 2014 2017

(%) (%) (%) (%) (%)


• Germany………………………………. 65 82 82 81 89
• United Kingdom…………………… 65 63 68 46 61
• United States……………………….. 70 55 77 38 44
• India…………………………………….. 41
• China……………………………………. 32
• Russia…………………………………... 13 38 12 18 22

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
10
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
7

Perceived reliability of various allies or partners

Question: Please indicate whether you consider each of the following


countries to be a very reliable, mostly reliable, mostly unreliable
or very unreliable ally or partner for France.

TOTAL Very Mostly TOTAL Mostly Very TOTAL


Reliable Reliable Reliable Unreliable Unreliable unreliable

(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)

• Germany……………….. 89 35 54 11 9 2 100
• United Kingdom…….. 61 13 48 39 31 8 100
• United States…………. 44 9 35 56 40 16 100
• India………………………. 41 2 39 59 47 12 100
• China……………………… 32 3 29 68 51 17 100
• Russia……………………. 22 4 18 78 50 28 100

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
11
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
8

Perceived reliability of various allies or partners


Germany
TOTAL Very Mostly TOTAL Mostly Very
Reliable Reliable Reliable Unreliable Unreliable unreliable

(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)


ALTOGETHER 89 35 54 11 9 2
SEX
Male 90 40 50 10 8 2
Female 87 30 57 13 10 3

AGE
Under 35 90 34 56 10 7 3
18-24 91 37 54 9 5 4
25-34 89 31 58 11 9 2
35 and above 88 35 53 12 10 2
35-49 87 35 52 13 9 4
50-64 88 38 50 12 11 1
65 and above 89 33 56 11 9 2

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 90 31 59 10 9 1
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 88 36 52 12 9 3
Paris metropolitan area 86 35 51 14 11 3

REGION
Paris region
Outside Paris region 86 34 52 14 11 3
Northeast 89 35 54 11 9 2
Northwest 88 33 55 12 10 2
Southwest 92 39 53 8 7 1
Southeast 87 29 58 13 10 3
89 36 53 11 8 3
APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve
Disapprove 67 22 45 33 26 7
59 10 49 41 32 9
DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE
FRENCH
Positive opinion
Negative opinion 66 18 48 34 28 6
60 12 48 40 31 9
GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS
Yes 65 14 51 35 28 7
No 49 11 38 51 39 12

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
12
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
9

Perceived reliability of various allies or partners


United Kingdom

TOTAL Very Mostly TOTAL Mostly Very


Reliable Reliable Reliable Unreliable Unreliable unreliable

(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)


ALTOGETHER 61 13 48 39 31 8
SEX
Male 62 14 48 38 28 10
Female 60 11 49 40 33 7

AGE
Under 35 69 18 51 31 24 7
18-24 74 18 56 26 22 4
25-34 67 18 49 33 25 8
35 and above 58 11 47 42 33 9
35-49 68 15 53 32 23 9
50-64 57 9 48 43 33 10
65 and above 47 9 38 53 46 7

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 61 9 52 39 30 9
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 60 14 46 40 31 9
Paris metropolitan area 67 16 51 33 28 5

REGION
Paris region 66 16 50 34 28 6
Outside Paris region 60 12 48 40 31 9
Northeast 58 12 46 42 31 11
Northwest 65 14 51 35 27 8
Southwest 57 14 43 43 30 13
Southeast 58 11 47 42 36 6

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 67 22 45 33 26 7
Disapprove 59 10 49 41 32 9

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 66 18 48 34 28 6
Negative opinion 60 12 48 40 31 9

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 65 14 51 35 28 7
No 49 11 38 31 39 12

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
13
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
10

Perceived reliability of various allies or partners


United States
TOTAL Very Mostly TOTAL Mostly Very
Reliable Reliable Reliable Unreliable Unreliable unreliable

(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)


ALTOGETHER 44 9 35 56 40 16
SEX
Male 49 13 36 51 39 12
Female 40 6 34 60 40 20

AGE
Under 35 52 11 41 48 31 17
18-24 52 10 42 48 26 22
25-34 50 11 39 50 35 15
35 and above 42 8 34 58 43 15
35-49 47 10 37 53 38 15
50-64 40 7 33 60 45 15
65 and above 38 8 30 62 46 16

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 41 6 35 59 42 17
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 45 10 35 55 39 16
Paris metropolitan area 45 9 36 55 40 15

REGION
Paris region 44 10 34 56 39 17
Outside Paris region 44 9 35 56 40 16
Northeast 46 10 36 54 39 15
Northwest 42 7 35 58 44 14
Southwest 41 10 31 59 36 23
Southeast 46 9 37 54 39 15

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 76 26 50 24 18 6
Disapprove 36 5 31 64 45 19

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 76 24 52 24 20 4
Negative opinion 38 6 32 62 44 18

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 47 10 37 53 39 14
No 34 6 28 66 43 23

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
14
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
11

Perceived reliability of various allies or partners


India
TOTAL Very Mostly TOTAL Mostly Very
Reliable Reliable Reliable Unreliable Unreliable unreliable

(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)


ALTOGETHER 41 2 39 59 47 12
SEX
Male 46 3 43 54 44 10
Female 36 1 35 64 50 14

AGE
Under 35 39 4 35 61 50 11
18-24 44 7 37 56 44 12
25-34 36 2 34 64 54 10
35 and above 42 2 40 58 45 13
35-49 36 3 33 64 50 14
50-64 45 1 44 55 41 14
65 and above 44 1 43 56 46 10

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 36 2 34 64 50 14
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 43 3 40 57 47 10
Paris metropolitan area 43 1 42 57 41 16

REGION
Paris region 41 1 40 59 42 17
Outside Paris region 41 3 38 59 48 11
Northeast 38 1 37 62 51 11
Northwest 43 2 41 57 47 10
Southwest 37 6 31 63 50 13
Southeast 43 3 40 57 45 12

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 37 5 32 63 46 17
Disapprove 42 2 40 58 47 11

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 42 4 38 58 43 15
Negative opinion 41 2 39 59 47 12

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 43 2 41 57 47 10
No 32 3 29 68 48 20

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
15
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
12

Perceived reliability of various allies or partners


China
Perceived reliability of various allies or partners
TOTAL Very Mostly TOTAL Mostly Very
China
Reliable Reliable Reliable Unreliable Unreliable unreliable

TOTAL Very Mostly TOTAL Mostly Very


(%)
Reliable (%)
Reliable (%)
Reliable (%)
Unreliable (%)
Unreliable (%)
unreliable
ALTOGETHER 32 3 29 68 51 17
SEX
Male 37
(%) 5
(%) 32
(%) (%)
63 48
(%) 15
(%)
Female
ALTOGETHER 29
32 2
3 27
29 71
68 52
51 19
17
SEX
AGE
Male 37 5 32 63 48 15
Under
Female35 37
29 6
2 31
27 63
71 48
52 15
19
18-24 39 7 32 61 43 18
25-34
AGE 36 5 31 64 50 14
35 and35
Under above 31
37 2
6 29
31 69
63 51
48 18
15
35-49
18-24 32
39 5
7 27
32 68
61 48
43 20
18
50-64
25-34 34
36 2
5 32
31 66
64 48
50 18
14
65 and above
35 above 28
31 2- 28
29 72
69 58
51 14
18
35-49 32 5 27 68 48 20
URBAN UNIT SIZE
50-64 34 2 32 66 48 18
Rural
65 andmunicipalities
above 29
28 2- 27
28 71
72 51
58 20
14
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 35 4 31 65 49 16
Paris metropolitan
URBAN UNIT SIZE area 31 3 28 69 53 16
Rural municipalities 29 2 27 71 51 20
REGION
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 35 4 31 65 49 16
region
Paris metropolitan area 30
31 3 27
28 70
69 53 17
16
Outside Paris region 33 3 30 67 50 17
Northeast
REGION 29 2 27 71 55 16
Northwest
Paris region 36
30 4
3 32
27 64
70 47
53 17
Southwest
Outside Paris region 29
33 4
3 25
30 71
67 49
50 22
17
Southeast
Northeast 36
29 3
2 33
27 64
71 49
55 15
16
Northwest 36 4 32 64 47 17
APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Southwest 29 4 25 71 49 22
Approve
Southeast 34
36 7
3 27
33 66
64 48
49 18
15
Disapprove 32 2 30 68 51 17
APPROVAL OF US POLICY
DONALD
Approve TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE 34 7 27 66 48 18
FRENCH
Disapprove 32 2 30 68 51 17
Positive opinion 38 10 28 62 47 15
Negative opinion
DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE 32 2 30 68 51 17
FRENCH
GOODWILL
Positive TOWARDS AMERICANS
opinion 38 10 28 62 47 15
Yes
Negative opinion 34
32 3
2 31
30 66
68 50
51 16
17
No 28 3 25 72 51 21
GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS
Yes 34 3 31 66 50 16
(*)
No Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results
28 should
3 be interpreted
25 cautiously
72 due to the21low
51
numbers
(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

16l’innovation politique
AJC Europe and the Fondation pour
The French against the crisis of democracy:
Immigration, Populism, Trump,
16 Europe...
September 2018
13

Perceived reliability of various allies or partners


Perceived reliability of Russia
various allies or partners
Russia
TOTAL
Reliable
Very
Reliable
Mostly
Reliable
TOTAL Mostly
Unreliable Unreliable
Very
unreliable

TOTAL Very Mostly TOTAL Mostly Very


Reliable
(%) Reliable
(%) Reliable
(%) Unreliable
(%) Unreliable
(%) unreliable
(%)
ALTOGETHER 22 4 18 78 50 28
SEX
Male (%)
27 (%)
5 (%)
22 (%)
73 (%)
48 (%)
25
ALTOGETHER
Female 22
17 4
2 18
15 78
83 50
52 28
31
SEX
Male
AGE 27 5 22 73 48 25
Female
Under 35 17
26 2
6 15
20 83
74 52
44 31
30
18-24 20 4 16 80 50 30
AGE
25-34 31 8 23 69 40 29
Under
35 and35
above 26
21 6
3 20
18 74
79 44
51 30
28
18-24
35-49 20
21 4
3 16
18 80
79 50
51 30
28
25-34
50-64 31
20 8
3 23
17 69
80 40
50 29
30
35 and above
65 and above 21
21 3
2 18
19 79
79 51
55 28
24
35-49 21 3 18 79 51 28
50-64 20 3 17 80 50 30
65 and above
URBAN UNIT SIZE 21 2 19 79 55 24
Rural municipalities 21 4 17 79 50 29
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 22 4 18 78 50 28
URBAN UNIT SIZE area
Paris metropolitan 26 3 23 74 46 28
Rural municipalities 21 4 17 79 50 29
Urban
REGION municipalities outside the Paris region 22 4 18 78 50 28
Paris
Paris metropolitan
region area 26
25 3
3 23
22 74
75 46
46 28
29
Outside Paris region 22 4 18 78 50 28
REGION
Northeast 23 2 21 77 51 26
Paris region
Northwest 25
20 3
3 22
17 75
80 46
50 29
30
Outside
SouthwestParis region 22
20 4
7 18
13 78
80 50
49 28
31
Northeast
Southeast 23
22 2
4 21
18 77
78 51
51 26
27
Northwest 20 3 17 80 50 30
Southwest
APPROVAL OF US POLICY 20 7 13 80 49 31
Southeast
Approve 22
46 4
10 18
36 78
54 51
38 27
16
Disapprove 16 2 14 84 53 31
APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve
DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE 46 10 36 54 38 16
Disapprove
FRENCH 16 2 14 84 53 31
Positive opinion 50 10 40 50 37 13
DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE
Negative opinion 16 2 14 84 52 32
FRENCH
Positive
GOODWILL opinion
TOWARDS AMERICANS 50 10 40 50 37 13
Negative opinion
Yes 16
23 2
3 14
20 84
77 52
50 32
27
No 18 4 14 82 50 32
GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS
Yes 23 3 20 77 50 27
No 18 4 14 82 50 32

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers
(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


17 of democracy:
The French against the crisis
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
17
September 2018
14

Approval of US policy

Question: In general, do you approve or disapprove of US policy?

All French people


September 2018
(%)
TOTAL Approve 20
• Completely approve………………………. 3
• Mostly approve…………………………….. 17
TOTAL disapprove 80
• Mostly disapprove………………………… 44
• Completely disapprove…………………. 36
TOTAL 100

18l’innovation politique
AJC Europe and the Fondation pour
The French against the crisis of democracy:
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
15

Approval of US policy

TOTAL Completely Mostly TOTAL Mostly Completely


Approve approve approve disapprove disapprove disapprove

(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)


ALTOGETHER 20 3 17 80 44 36
SEX
Male 24 5 19 76 41 35
Female 18 2 16 82 46 36

AGE
Under 35 27 5 22 73 42 31
18-24 26 7 19 74 41 33
25-34 28 4 24 72 42 30
35 and above 19 3 16 81 44 37
35-49 22 5 17 78 46 32
50-64 18 2 16 82 43 39
65 and above 15 2 13 85 43 42

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 22 2 20 78 45 33
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 19 4 15 81 43 38
Paris metropolitan area 25 3 22 75 43 32

REGION
Paris region 25 4 21 75 41 34
Outside Paris region 20 3 17 80 44 36
Northeast 21 5 16 79 47 32
Northwest 17 1 16 83 46 37
Southwest 22 3 19 78 45 33
Southeast 20 4 16 80 39 41

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 86 16 70 14 13 1
Negative opinion 7 1 6 93 50 43

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 22 4 18 78 44 34
No 17 1 16 83 41 42

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
19
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
16

Perceptions of Franco-American cooperation on various


issues

Question: With regard to the following issues, would you say that the United
States is mostly an ally or opponent of France?

Mostly Mostly an TOTAL


an ally opponent
(%) (%) (%)
• Fighting Islamist terrorism………………………. 74 26 100
• Facing up to Russia………………………………….. 51 49 100
• Facing up to China…………………………………… 51 49 100
• Security of NATO member countries……….. 50 50 100
• Encouraging French economic growth…..... 22 78 100
• Encouraging European economic growth… 19 81 100
• Tackling climate change…………………………… 12 88 100

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


20 of democracy:
The French against the crisis
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
17

Perceptions
Perceptions of of Franco-American
Franco-American cooperation
cooperation on various
on various issues
Fighting Islamist
issues terrorism
Fighting Islamist terrorism

Mostly allies country Mostly opponent


country

(%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 74 26
SEX
Male 80 20
Female 69 31

AGE
Under 35 72 28
18-24 67 33
25-34 76 24
35 and above 75 25
35-49 78 22
50-64 68 32
65 and above 81 19

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 77 23
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 75 25
Paris metropolitan area 70 30

REGION
Paris region 70 30
Outside Paris region 76 24
Northeast 73 27
Northwest 76 24
Southwest 75 25
Southeast 78 22

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 86 14
Disapprove 72 28

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 84 16
Negative opinion 73 27

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 78 22
No 62 38

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
21
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
18

Perceptions of Franco-American
Perceptions cooperation
of Franco-American on various
cooperation issues
on various
Facing up to Russia
issues
Facing up to Russia
Mostly allies country Mostly opponent
country

(%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 51 49
SEX
Male 59 41
Female 44 56

AGE
Under 35 53 47
18-24 54 46
25-34 52 48
35 and above 51 49
35-49 60 40
50-64 44 56
65 and above 49 51

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 55 45
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 49 51
Paris metropolitan area 54 46

REGION
Paris region 55 45
Outside Paris region 51 49
Northeast 45 55
Northwest 56 44
Southwest 48 52
Southeast 52 48

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 72 28
Disapprove 46 54

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 72 28
Negative opinion 47 53

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 54 46
No 43 57

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
Immigration, Populism, Trump,
22 Europe...
September 2018
19

Perceptions
Perceptions of of Franco-American
Franco-American cooperation
cooperation on various
on various issues
Facingissues
up to China
Facing up to China
Mostly an ally country Mostly an opponent
country

(%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 51 49
SEX
Male 57 43
Female 46 54

AGE
Under 35 58 42
18-24 60 40
25-34 57 43
35 and above 49 51
35-49 55 45
50-64 45 55
65 and above 46 54

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 51 49
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 52 48
Paris metropolitan area 50 50

REGION
Paris region 48 52
Outside Paris region 52 48
Northeast 50 50
Northwest 54 46
Southwest 45 55
Southeast 56 44

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 76 24
Disapprove 45 55

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 78 22
Negative opinion 46 54

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 54 46
No 41 59

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
23
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
20

Perceptions
Perceptions of Franco-American
of Franco-American cooperation
cooperation on various
on various issues
The security of NATO
issuesmember states
The security of NATO member states

Mostly allies country Mostly opponent


country

(%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 50 50
SEX
Male 58 42
Female 43 57

AGE
Under 35 50 50
18-24 48 52
25-34 51 49
35 and above 50 50
35-49 52 48
50-64 46 54
65 and above 53 47

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 47 53
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 50 50
Paris metropolitan area 55 45

REGION
Paris region 55 45
Outside Paris region 49 51
Northeast 50 50
Northwest 46 54
Southwest 44 56
Southeast 52 48

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 73 27
Disapprove 44 56

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 73 27
Negative opinion 45 55

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 51 49
No 45 55

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
24
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
21

Perceptions
Perceptionsof of
Franco-American cooperation
Franco-American on various
cooperation issues
on various
Encouraging French economic growth
issues
Encouraging French economic growth
Mostly allies country Mostly opponent
country

(%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 22 78
SEX
Male 18 82
Female 26 74

AGE
Under 35 34 66
18-24 36 64
25-34 32 68
35 and above 18 82
35-49 22 78
50-64 17 83
65 and above 13 87

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 18 82
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 23 77
Paris metropolitan area 25 75

REGION
Paris region 24 76
Outside Paris region 22 78
Northeast 21 79
Northwest 24 76
Southwest 18 82
Southeast 22 78

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 48 52
Disapprove 15 85

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 45 55
Negative opinion 17 83

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 22 78
No 22 78

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
25
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
22

Perceptions
Perceptions of Franco-American
of Franco-American cooperation
cooperation on various
on various issues
Encouraging European economic growth
issues
Encouraging European economic growth
Mostly allies country Mostly opponent
country

(%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 19 81
SEX
Male 15 85
Female 22 78

AGE
Under 35 28 72
18-24 29 71
25-34 28 72
35 and above 15 85
35-49 21 79
50-64 13 87
65 and above 10 90

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 17 83
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 20 80
Paris metropolitan area 19 81

REGION
Paris region 19 81
Outside Paris region 19 81
Northeast 25 75
Northwest 13 87
Southwest 16 84
Southeast 19 81

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 42 58
Disapprove 13 87

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 41 59
Negative opinion 14 86

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 19 81
No 18 82

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
26
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
23

Perceptions
Perceptions of of Franco-American
Franco-American cooperation
cooperation on various
on various issues
Tackling climate
issues change
Tackling climate change
Mostly allies country Mostly opponent
country

(%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 12 88
SEX
Male 11 89
Female 12 88

AGE
Under 35 18 82
18-24 18 82
25-34 18 82
35 and above 9 91
35-49 13 87
50-64 8 92
65 and above 6 94

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 10 90
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 12 88
Paris metropolitan area 13 87

REGION
Paris region 12 88
Outside Paris region 12 88
Northeast 13 87
Northwest 9 91
Southwest 7 93
Southeast 14 86

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 28 72
Disapprove 7 93

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 33 67
Negative opinion 7 93

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 11 89
No 14 86

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
27
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
24

Donald Trump’s approval rating among the French

Question: Would you say that you personally have a positive or negative
opinion of Donald Trump as US president?

All French All French All French


people people people
May 2016 November 2016 September
Before Donald After Donald 2018
Trump’s election Trump’s election

(%) (%) (%)


TOTAL Positive opinion……………. 11 13 17
• Very positive opinion……… 3 3 3
• Mostly positive opinion…. 8 10 14
TOTAL Negative opinion…………… 80 75 83
• Mostly negative opinion… 22 32 29
• Very negative opinion……. 58 43 54
• Don’t know……………………. 9 12 -
TOTAL……………………………………… 100 100 100

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
28
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
25

Donald Trump’s approval rating among the French


Donald Trump’s approval rating among the French
TOTAL Very Mostly TOTAL Mostly Very
Positive Positive positive Negative Negative negative
opinion
TOTAL opinion
Very opinion
Mostly opinion
TOTAL opinion
Mostly opinion
Very
Positive Positive positive Negative Negative negative
opinion opinion opinion opinion opinion opinion
(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 17 3 14 83 29 54
SEXALTOGETHER (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)
SEX
ALTOGETHER 21
17 4
3 17
14 79
83 28
29 51
54
Male
SEXALTOGETHER 13 1 12 87 30 57
Female
SEX 21 4 17 79 28 51
Male 13 1 12 87 30 57
AGE
Female 20 4 16 80 28 52
Under 35 21 5 16 79 25 54
18-24
AGE 19
20 3
4 16
16 81
80 31
28 50
52
25-34
Under 35 16
21 2
5 14
16 84
79 29
25 55
54
35 and above
18-24 19
19 4
3 15
16 81
81 28
31 53
50
35-49
25-34 17
16 2
2 15
14 83
84 28
29 55
55
50-64
35 and above 11
19 1
4 10
15 89
81 32
28 57
53
65 and above
35-49 17 2 15 83 28 55
50-64 11 1 10 89 32 57
URBAN UNIT SIZE
65 and above
Rural municipalities 15 1 14 85 30 55
Urban
URBANmunicipalities
UNIT SIZE outside the Paris region 16 3 13 84 29 55
Paris metropolitan
Rural municipalitiesarea 22
15 3
1 19
14 78
85 28
30 50
55
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 16 3 13 84 29 55
REGION
Paris metropolitan area 22 3 19 78 28 50
Paris region 21 3 18 79 27 52
Outside
REGION Paris region 16 2 14 84 29 55
Northeast
Paris region 18
21 4
3 14
18 82
79 33
27 49
52
Northwest
Outside Paris region 13
16 1
2 12
14 87
84 30
29 57
55
Southwest
Northeast 16
18 1
4 15
14 84
82 25
33 59
49
Southeast
Northwest 18
13 3
1 15
12 82
87 27
30 55
57
Southwest 16 1 15 84 25 59
APPROVAL
Southeast OF US POLICY 18 3 15 82 27 55
Approve 71 12 59 29 23 6
Disapprove
APPROVAL OF US POLICY 3 - 3 97 30 67
Approve 71 12 59 29 23 6
GOODWILL
Disapprove TOWARDS AMERICANS 3 - 3 97 30 67
Yes 18 3 15 82 28 54
No
GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS 11 - 11 89 32 57
Yes 18 3 15 82 28 54
No 11 - 11 89 32 57

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers
(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour


29l’innovation politique
The French against the crisis of democracy:
29
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
26

Perceived degree of similarity between Donald Trump and


Americans in general

Question: In your opinion, is Donald Trump a president who is …?

All French people


September 2018
(%)
• Unlike most Americans and they are unlike Donald Trump…… 75
• Like most Americans and they are like Donald Trump………….. 25
TOTAL 100

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
30
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
27

Perceived degree of similarity between Donald Trump and


Americans in general
Perceived degree of similarity between
Unlike most
Americans and they
Donald Trump and
Like most Americans
and they are like

Americans in general
are unlike Donald
Trump
Donald Trump

Unlike most Like most Americans


(%)and they
Americans (%)are like
and they
ALTOGETHER 75 Donald
are unlike Donald25Trump
SEX Trump
Male 69 31
Female 80
(%) 20
(%)
ALTOGETHER 75 25
AGE
SEX
Under
Male 35 74
69 26
31
18-24
Female 73
80 27
20
25-34 75 25
35
AGEand above 75 25
35-49
Under 35 73
74 27
26
50-64
18-24 71
73 29
27
65 and above
25-34 81
75 19
25
35 and above 75 25
URBAN
35-49 UNIT SIZE 73 27
Rural
50-64municipalities 78
71 22
29
Urban
65 andmunicipalities
above outside the Paris region 74
81 26
19
Paris metropolitan area 73 27
URBAN UNIT SIZE
REGION
Rural municipalities 78 22
Paris
Urbanregion
municipalities outside the Paris region 75
74 25
26
Outside Paris region
Paris metropolitan area 75
73 25
27
Northeast 73 27
Northwest
REGION 77 23
Southwest
Paris region 72
75 28
25
Southeast
Outside Paris region 75 25
Northeast 73 27
APPROVAL
Northwest OF US POLICY 77 23
Approve
Southwest 49
72 51
28
Disapprove
Southeast 82
75 18
25

DONALD
APPROVAL TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE
OF US POLICY
FRENCH
Approve 49 51
Positive opinion
Disapprove 40
82 60
18
Negative opinion 82 18
DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE
GOODWILL
FRENCH TOWARDS AMERICANS
Yes
Positive opinion 79
40 21
60
No
Negative opinion 59
82 41
18

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 79 21
(*)Sample No
lower than 40 individuals: these results should be
59
interpreted cautiously
41
due to the low
numbers

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
31
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018

31
28

Perceived importance of maintaining relations between


Europe and the United States

Question: Some people believe that relations between Europe and Donald
Trump’s United States are currently in serious crisis. Do you think
it is important or not important to maintain these relations in
future years?

All French people


September 2018
(%)
TOTAL Important 82
• Very important……………………………… 29
• Quite important……………………………. 53
TOTAL Not important……………………………….. 18
• Not very important……………………….. 13
• Not at all important………………………. 5
TOTAL 100

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
32
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
29

Perceived importance of maintaining relations between


Europe and the United States
TOTAL Very Quite TOTAL Not Not very Not at all
Important important important important important important

(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)


ALTOGETHER 82 29 53 18 13 5
SEX
Male 84 35 49 16 11 5
Female 80 23 57 20 15 5

AGE
Under 35 76 24 52 24 17 7
18-24 74 28 46 26 18 8
25-34 78 21 57 22 16 6
35 and above 84 31 53 16 12 4
35-49 80 30 50 20 14 6
50-64 84 30 54 16 11 5
65 and above 88 33 55 12 10 2

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 81 26 55 19 15 4
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 82 29 53 18 13 5
Paris metropolitan area 82 31 51 18 13 5

REGION
Paris region 82 31 51 18 13 5
Outside Paris region 82 28 54 18 13 5
Northeast 82 30 52 18 13 5
Northwest 79 27 52 21 16 5
Southwest 85 30 55 15 14 1
Southeast 83 27 56 17 10 7

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 89 36 53 11 9 2
Disapprove 80 27 53 20 14 6

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 93 35 58 7 7 -
Negative opinion 79 27 52 21 15 6

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 85 33 52 15 11 4
No 68 11 57 32 22 10

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
33
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
30

Goodwill towards Americans

Question: Regardless of Donald Trump, would you say that you feel
benevolent towards Americans?

All French people


September 2018
(%)
• Mostly yes……………………………………………………………………… 79
• Mostly no……………………………………………………………………… 21
TOTAL 100

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
34
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
31

Goodwill towards Americans


Mostly yes Mostly no

(%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 79 21
SEX
Male 79 21
Female 79 21

AGE
Under 35 74 26
18-24 72 28
25-34 75 25
35 and above 81 19
35-49 77 23
50-64 79 21
65 and above 87 13

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 79 21
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 81 19
Paris metropolitan area 73 27

REGION
Paris region 73 27
Outside Paris region 80 20
Northeast 78 22
Northwest 79 21
Southwest 86 14
Southeast 81 19

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 83 17
Disapprove 78 22

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 86 14
Negative opinion 78 22

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
35
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
-B-
The rise-ofB populism
-

The rise of populism

36
33

Perceived strength of democracy in various countries

Question: Compared to the situation several years ago, would you say that
democracy is weaker, stronger, or neither weaker nor stronger in
each of the following countries or territorial units?

Weaker Stronger Neither TOTAL


weaker nor
stronger
(%) (%) (%) (%)
• United States………. 64 12 24 100
• European Union as a 56 13 31 100
whole………………..
• France………………… 52 13 35 100
• Germany……………. 38 26 36 100

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
37
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
34

Perceived strength of democracy in various countries


United States

Weaker Stronger Neither


weaker nor
stronger
(%) (%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 64 12 24
SEX
Male 63 13 24
Female 66 11 23

AGE
Under 35 52 21 27
18-24 58 23 19
25-34 49 19 32
35 and above 69 9 22
35-49 64 12 24
50-64 74 8 18
65 and above 67 7 26

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 64 10 26
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 66 12 22
Paris metropolitan area 61 15 24

REGION
Paris region 63 13 24
Outside Paris region 65 12 23
Northeast 64 13 23
Northwest 62 11 27
Southwest 71 7 22
Southeast 65 14 21

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 37 36 27
Disapprove 71 6 23

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 30 43 27
Negative opinion 71 6 23

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 65 12 23
No 60 13 27

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
38
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
35

Perceived strength of democracy in various countries


European Union as a whole

Weaker Stronger Neither


weaker nor
stronger
(%) (%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 56 13 31
SEX
Male 59 13 28
Female 54 13 33

AGE
Under 35 45 21 34
18-24 42 22 36
25-34 47 20 33
35 and above 61 10 29
35-49 53 14 33
50-64 64 9 27
65 and above 65 7 28

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 55 13 32
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 55 14 31
Paris metropolitan area 65 10 25

REGION
Paris region 64 10 26
Outside Paris region 55 14 31
Northeast 52 14 34
Northwest 52 15 33
Southwest 62 15 23
Southeast 56 13 31

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 58 22 20
Disapprove 56 11 33

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 56 24 20
Negative opinion 56 11 33

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 57 13 30
No 54 15 31

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
39
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
36

Perceived strength of democracy in various countries


France
Weaker Stronger Neither
weaker nor
stronger
(%) (%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 52 13 35
SEX
Male 51 14 35
Female 52 13 35

AGE
Under 35 46 18 36
18-24 49 17 34
25-34 45 18 37
35 and above 54 12 34
35-49 51 14 35
50-64 57 11 32
65 and above 52 10 38

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 54 12 34
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 51 14 35
Paris metropolitan area 51 12 37

REGION
Paris region 52 11 37
Outside Paris region 52 14 34
Northeast 53 13 34
Northwest 52 13 35
Southwest 58 12 30
Southeast 48 16 36

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 59 20 21
Disapprove 50 12 38

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 58 23 19
Negative opinion 50 12 38

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 50 14 36
No 56 13 31

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
40
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
37

Perceived strength of democracy in various countries


Germany
Weaker Stronger Neither
weaker nor
stronger
(%) (%) (%)
ALTOGETHER 38 26 36
SEX
Male 43 23 34
Female 33 28 39

AGE
Under 35 29 30 41
18-24 26 26 48
25-34 31 33 36
35 and above 41 24 35
35-49 37 23 40
50-64 41 28 31
65 and above 46 20 34

URBAN UNIT SIZE


Rural municipalities 36 25 39
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 38 27 35
Paris metropolitan area 40 24 36

REGION
Paris region 39 24 37
Outside Paris region 38 26 36
Northeast 40 27 33
Northwest 34 28 38
Southwest 42 25 33
Southeast 37 24 39

APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Approve 41 37 22
Disapprove 37 23 40

DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE


FRENCH
Positive opinion 43 37 20
Negative opinion 37 23 40

GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS


Yes 37 27 36
No 41 22 37

(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
41
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
38

Causes of the rise of populism in Europe

Question: In your opinion, which of the following issues is the most likely
explanation for the rise of populism and protest voting in Europe?
Please rank your answers first and second.

First choice All references

(%) (%)
• Immigration……………………………………. 32 45
• Decline in living conditions (purchasing 23 42
power, housing, social insurance,
etc.)…………………………………………………
• Security issues affecting people and 12 32
property (antisocial behaviour,
delinquency, crime, etc.)…………………
• Problems with integration of people of 13 28
foreign origin…………………………………..
• Unemployment……………………………….. 9 25
• Perceived decline in social status……. 7 16
• Corruption………………………………………. 4 10
• TOTAL 100 (*)

(*) Total exceeds 100 since respondents were able to give two answers

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
42
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
39

Causes of the rise of populism in Europe


Causes of the rise Firstofchoicepopulism in Europe
Immigration Decline in Security Problems Unemploym Perceived Corruption
living First choice
Immigration Decline in Security Problems Unemploym Perceived Corruption
living issues
issues with
with ent
ent decline
decline in
in
conditions affecting
conditions integration
affecting integration social status social status
Immigration Decline in Security Problems Unemploym Perceived Corruption
(purchasing
(purchasing people and
people of people of
living issuesand of people
with of ent decline in
power,
power, property
property foreign
foreign
conditions affecting integration social status
housing,
housing, (antisocial
(antisocial origin
origin of
(purchasing people and of people
social
social behaviour,
behaviour,
power, property foreign
insurance,
insurance, delinquency
delinquency
housing, (antisocial origin
etc.)
etc.) crime,
crime, etc.)
etc.)
social behaviour,
insurance, delinquency
etc.) crime, etc.)
(%)
(%) (%)
(%) (%)
(%) (%)
(%) (%)
(%) (%)
(%) (%)
(%)
ALTOGETHER
ALTOGETHER 32
32 23
23 13
13 12
12 9
9 7
7 4
4
SEX
SEX (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)
Male
Male 36
36 18
18 16
16 11
11 8
8 7
7 4
4
ALTOGETHER 32 23 13 12 9 7 4
Female
Female 29
29 26
26 10
10 13
13 11
11 7
7 4
4
SEX
Male 36 18 16 11 8 7 4
AGE
AGE
Female 29 26 10 13 11 7 4
Under
Under 35
35 25
25 23
23 10
10 13
13 14
14 10
10 5
5
18-24
18-24 28
28 22
22 8
8 12
12 15
15 11
11 4
4
AGE
25-34
25-34 24
24 23
23 11
11 14
14 13
13 9
9 6
6
Under 35 25 23 10 13 14 10 5
35
35 and
and above
above 35
35 22
22 14
14 12
12 7
7 6
6 4
4
18-24 28 22 8 12 15 11 4
35-49
35-49 22
22 28
28 15
15 15
15 9
9 6
6 5
5
25-34 24 23 11 14 13 9 6
50-64
50-64 36
36 20
20 11
11 13
13 9
9 7
7 4
4
35 and above 35 22 14 12 7 6 4
65
65 and
and above
above 49
49 18
18 16
16 8
8 4
4 5
5 -
35-49 22 28 15 15 9 6 5-
50-64 36 20 11 13 9 7 4
65 and above 49 18 16 8 4 5 -
URBAN
URBAN UNIT
UNIT SIZE
SIZE
Rural
Rural municipalities
municipalities 36
36 24
24 9
9 14
14 7
7 7
7 3
3
Urban
Urban municipalities 32 22 13 12 10 7 4
URBANmunicipalities
UNIT SIZE 32 22 13 12 10 7 4
outside
outside the
the Paris
Paris region
region
Rural municipalities 36 24 9 14 7 7 3
Paris
Paris metropolitan
metropolitan area
area 28
28 23
23 15
15 11
11 9
9 8
8 6
6
Urban municipalities 32 22 13 12 10 7 4
outside the Paris region
REGION
REGION
Paris metropolitan area 28 23 15 11 9 8 6
Paris
Paris region
region
Outside
Outside Paris
Paris region
region 29
29 22
22 14
14 13
13 9
9 8
8 5
5
REGION
Northeast
Northeast 33
33 23
23 12
12 12
12 9
9 7
7 4
4
Paris region
Northwest
Northwest 29
29 22
22 15
15 13
13 12
12 5
5 4
4
Outside Paris region 29 22 14 13 9 8 5
Southwest
Southwest 37
37 27
27 9
9 11
11 7
7 6
6 3
3
Northeast 33 23 12 12 9 7 4
Southeast
Southeast 31
31 24
24 13
13 8
8 7
7 10
10 7
7
Northwest 29 22 15 13 12 5 4
34
34 19
19 13
13 15
15 9
9 7
7 3
3
Southwest 37 27 9 11 7 6 3
APPROVAL
APPROVAL OF
OF US
US
Southeast 31 24 13 8 7 10 7
POLICY
POLICY 34 19 13 15 9 7 3
Approve
Approve 38
38 14
14 15
15 11
11 10
10 6
6 6
6
APPROVAL OF US
Disapprove
Disapprove 31
31 24
24 12
12 13
13 9
9 7
7 4
4
POLICY
Approve 38 14 15 11 10 6 6
DONALD
DONALD TRUMP’S
TRUMP’S
Disapprove 31 24 12 13 9 7 4
POPULARITY
POPULARITY AMONG AMONG
THE
THE FRENCH
FRENCH TRUMP’S
DONALD
Positive
Positive opinion
opinion AMONG 42
42 13
13 17
17 10
10 8
8 6
6 4
4
POPULARITY
Negative
Negative opinion
opinion 31
31 24
24 12
12 13
13 9
9 7
7 4
4
THE FRENCH
Positive opinion 42 13 17 10 8 6 4
GOODWILL
GOODWILL
Negative opinion 31 24 12 13 9 7 4
TOWARDS
TOWARDS AMERICANS
AMERICANS
Yes
Yes 33
33 23
23 14
14 13
13 7
7 6
6 4
4
GOODWILL
No
No 31
31 21
21 10
10 10
10 15
15 9
9 4
4
TOWARDS AMERICANS
Yes 33 23 14 13 7 6 4
No 31 21 10 10 15 9 4

(*)
(*) Sample
Sample lower
lower than
than 40
40 individuals:
individuals: these
these results
results should
should be
be interpreted
interpreted cautiously
cautiously due
due to
to the
the low
low
numbers
numbers
(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers

43
AJC Europe and the Fondation pour
43l’innovation politique
The French against the crisis of democracy:
43
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
40

Causes of the rise of populism in Europe


Causes of theAll references
rise of populism in Europe
Immigration Decline in Security Problems Unemploym Perceived Corruption
Immigration
living
living All
Decline in
conditions
references
Security
issues
issues
affecting
Problems
with
with
integration
Unemploym
ent
ent
Perceived
decline
decline in
in
social status
Corruption

Immigration conditions
Decline in affecting
Security integration
Problems Unemploym social status
Perceived Corruption
(purchasing
(purchasing people
people and of
of people of
living issuesand people
with of ent decline in
power,
power, property
property foreign
foreign
conditions affecting integration social status
housing,
housing, (antisocial
(antisocial origin
origin of
(purchasing people and of people
social
social behaviour,
behaviour,
power, property foreign
insurance,
insurance, delinquency
delinquency
housing, (antisocial origin
etc.)
etc.) crime,
crime, etc.)
etc.)
social behaviour,
insurance, delinquency
etc.) crime, etc.)
(%)
(%) (%)
(%) (%)
(%) (%)
(%) (%)
(%) (%)
(%) (%)
(%)
ALTOGETHER
ALTOGETHER 45
45 42
42 32
32 28
28 25
25 16
16 10
10
SEX
SEX (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)
Male
Male 50
50 36
36 29
29 35
35 23
23 17
17 10
ALTOGETHER 45 42 32 28 25 16 10
Female
Female 41
41 48
48 36
36 22
22 27
27 16
16 11
11
SEX
Male 50 36 29 35 23 17 10
AGE
AGE
Female 41 48 36 22 27 16 11
Under
Under 35
35 40
40 42
42 29
29 21
21 34
34 20
20 14
14
18-24
18-24 40
40 40
40 27
27 21
21 36
36 20
20 16
16
AGE
25-34
25-34 39
39 43
43 31
31 21
21 33
33 20
20 13
13
Under 35 40 42 29 34 14
35
35 and
and above
above 47
47 42
42 33
33 31
31 22
22 15
15 9
9
18-24 40 40 27 21 36 20 16
35-49
35-49 36
36 49
49 33
33 26
26 27
27 19
19 11
11
25-34 39 43 31 21 33 20 13
50-64
50-64 48
48 42
42 33
33 31
31 22
22 14
14 10
10
35 and above 47 15 9
65
65 and
and above
above 60
60 34
34 35
35 36
36 16
16 12
12 6
6
35-49 36 49 33 26 27 19 11
50-64 48 42 33 31 22 14 10
65 and above 60 34 35 36 16 12 6
URBAN
URBAN UNIT
UNIT SIZE
SIZE
Rural
Rural municipalities
municipalities 46
46 48
48 36
36 23
23 24
24 16
16 8
8
Urban
Urban municipalities 46 40 31 30 26 16 11
URBANmunicipalities
UNIT SIZE 46 40 31 30 26 16 11
outside
outside the
the Paris
Paris region
region
Rural municipalities 46 48 36 23 24 16 8
Paris
Paris metropolitan
metropolitan area
area 41
41 42
42 34
34 29
29 23
23 17
17 14
14
Urban municipalities 46 40 31 30 26 16 11
outside the Paris region
REGION
REGION
Paris metropolitan area 41 42 34 29 23 17 14
Paris
Paris region
region 43
43 43
43 34
34 28
28 22
22 18
18 13
13
Outside
Outside Paris region 46 42 32 28 26 16 10
REGION Paris region 46 42 32 28 26 16 10
Northeast
Northeast 46
46 37
37 34
34 28
28 29
29 16
16 10
10
Paris region 43 43 22 18 13
Northwest
Northwest 51
51 46
46 29
29 24
24 24
24 16
16 10
10
Outside Paris region 46 42 32 28 26
Southwest
Southwest 38
38 50
50 33
33 31
31 22
22 16
16 10
10
Northeast 46 37 34 28 29
Southeast
Southeast 45
45 40
40 32
32 31
31 26
26 16
16 10
10
Northwest 51 46 29 24 24
Southwest 38 50 33 31 22 16 10
APPROVAL
APPROVAL OF
OF US
US
Southeast 45 40 32 31 26 16 10
POLICY
POLICY
Approve
Approve 56
56 30
30 35
35 30
30 21
21 15
15 14
14
APPROVAL OF US
Disapprove
Disapprove 43
43 46
46 32
32 28
28 26
26 17
17 9
9
POLICY
Approve 56 30 35 30 21 15 14
DONALD
DONALD TRUMP’S
TRUMP’S
Disapprove 43 46 32 28 26 17 9
POPULARITY
POPULARITY AMONG AMONG
THE
THE FRENCH
FRENCH TRUMP’S
DONALD
Positive
Positive opinion
opinion AMONG 58
58 29
29 32
32 35
35 19
19 13
13 14
14
POPULARITY
Negative
Negative opinion
opinion 43
43 45
45 32
32 27
27 26
26 17
17 10
10
THE FRENCH
Positive opinion 58 29 32 35 19 13 14
GOODWILL
GOODWILL
Negative opinion 43 45 32 27 26 17 10
TOWARDS
TOWARDS AMERICANS
AMERICANS
Yes
Yes 45
45 42
42 35
35 29
29 23
23 16
16 10
10
GOODWILL
No
No 46
46 41
41 21
21 24
24 35
35 19
19 13
13
TOWARDS AMERICANS
Yes 45 42 35 29 23 16 10
No 46 41 21 24 35 19 13

(*)
(*) Sample
Sample lower
lower than
than 40
40 individuals:
individuals: these
these results
results should
should be
be interpreted
interpreted cautiously
cautiously due
due to
to the
the low
low
numbers
numbers
(*) Sample lower than 40 individuals: these results should be interpreted cautiously due to the low
numbers
44
AJC Europe and the Fondation pour
44l’innovation politique
The French against the crisis of democracy:
44
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
41

The authority most responsible for the rise in populism


in Europe

Question: Which of the various powers below would you say is most
responsible for the rise of populism and protest voting in Europe?

All French people


September 2018
(%)
• National governments, which are insufficiently effective at 47
solving their citizens’ problems…………………………………………
• The European Union, which is insufficiently effective at 33
solving Europeans’ problems……………………………………………
• The media, which misinforms us and does not tell us what is 20
really happening……………………………………………………………….
TOTAL 100

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
45
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
September 2018
42 The authority most responsible for the rise in populism
in Europe
National The European The media, which

The authority most responsible for the rise in populismgovernments,


which are
Union, which is
insufficiently
misinforms us
and does not tell
The authority most responsible
in Europefor the rise in populism
insufficiently
effective at
effective at
solving
us what is really
happening
in Europe solving their
National
The media, which
citizens’
Europeans’
Theproblem
European
governments,
problems Union, which is misinforms us
National The European The media, which
which are insufficiently and does not tell
governments, Union, which is misinforms us
insufficiently
(%)are effective
(%) at us what
(%)isnot
really
which insufficiently and does tell
effective at solving happening
insufficiently effective at us what is really
solving their Europeans’
effective at solving happening
citizens’ problem
solving their Europeans’
problems
citizens’ problem
problems
(%) (%) (%)
(%) (%) (%)

ALTOGETHER 47 33 20
SEX
Male 48 34 18
Female 47 32 21

AGE
ALTOGETHER
Under 35 47
44 33
26 20
30
SEX
18-24 40 20 40
ALTOGETHER 47 33 20
Male
25-34 48
46 34
31 18
23
SEX
Female
35 and above 47
49 32
35 21
16
Male 48 34 18
35-49
Female 54
47 27
32 19
21
AGE
50-64 51 33 16
Under
65 and 35
above 44
39 26
48 30
13
AGE
18-24 40 20 40
Under 35 44 26 30
25-34 UNIT SIZE
URBAN 46 31 23
16
18-24 40 20 40
35 and above
Rural 49 35 16
25-34municipalities 47
46 37
31 21
23
35-49 municipalities outside the Paris region
Urban 54
48 27
31 19
21
35 and above 49 35 16
50-64
Paris metropolitan area 51
46 33
33 16
35-49 54 27 19
65 and above 39 48 13
50-64 51 33 16
REGION
65 and above 39 48 13
URBAN
Paris UNIT SIZE
region 49 31 16
20
Rural municipalities
Outside Paris SIZE
region 47
47 37
33 21
20
URBAN UNIT 16
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region
Northeast 48
44 31
37 21
19
Rural municipalities 47 37 21
Paris metropolitan area
Northwest 46
50 33
31 19
Urban municipalities outside the Paris region 48 31 21
Southwest
Paris metropolitan area 48
46 35
33 17
REGION
Southeast 47 31 22
Paris region 49 31 20
REGION
Outside Paris
APPROVAL region 47 33 20
Paris regionOF US POLICY 49 31 20
Northeast
Approve 44
38 37
36 19
26
Outside Paris region 47 33 20
Northwest
Disapprove 50
50 31
32 19
18
Northeast 44 37 19
Southwest 48 35 17
Northwest 50 31 19
Southeast
DONALD 47 31 22
Southwest TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE 48 35 17
FRENCH
Southeast 47 31 22
APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Positive opinion 37 35 28
Approve opinion
Negative 38
50 36
32 26
18
APPROVAL OF US POLICY
Disapprove 50 32 18
Approve 38 36 26
GOODWILL
Disapprove TOWARDS AMERICANS 50 32 18
DONALD
Yes TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE 47 34 19
FRENCH
No 48 30 22
DONALD TRUMP’S POPULARITY AMONG THE
Positive opinion 37 35 28
FRENCH
Negative opinion 50 32 18
Positive opinion 37 35 28
Negative opinion 50 32 18
GOODWILL TOWARDS AMERICANS
(*) SampleYes
lower than
GOODWILL
No
TOWARDS40 individuals:
AMERICANS these results 47
should
48
34
be interpreted
30
19
cautiously
22
due to the low
Yes 47 34 19
numbers No 48 30 22

46

AJC Europe and the Fondation pour l’innovation politique


The French against the crisis of democracy:
46
Immigration, Populism, Trump, Europe...
46
September 2018

You might also like