Greg Russell, Richard Green and Chris Rumpf Presentation outline
Legislation Referral process Assessment considerations Problems arising from development Agency requirements Some interesting examples Legislation
Water Act 1912 (NSW)
– Licence required to access groundwater (Part 5) Water Management Act 2000 (NSW) – Access licence and approvals required (Part 3) Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) – Referral of Development Application to NSW Government agencies for assessment where licence or permit required (Part 4) – Referral of Major Project Application to NSW Government agencies for conditions of approval (Part 3A) Protection of the Environment Operations Act 1997 (NSW) Contaminated Land Management Act 1997 (NSW) Referral process – how it is meant to work Development application lodged with local council Council identifies need for authorisation(s) and refers application with documentation to relevant agency under s.91 of the EP&A Act 1979 (NSW) Branches within agency with jurisdiction over specified project activities prepare combined response back to council with General Terms of Approval (GTAs) Council incorporates GTAs into development consent conditions Development proceeds in accordance with conditions of consent Referral process – where it goes wrong
Council does not identify need for authorisation(s) and
development proceeds without appropriate conditions of consent Development application does not identify presence of groundwater, council does not refer proposal and development proceeds without appropriate conditions of consent Excavation commences, groundwater inflows are found to be significant and contractors attempt to obtain a temporary construction dewatering licence at short notice without any assessment at critical stage of construction Assessment considerations Volume of groundwater to be extracted Permeability of subsurface materials Magnitude of groundwater level lowering Potential for groundwater dependent ecosystems in the vicinity of the site Ambient quality of groundwater (e.g. saline or aggressive water) Presence of actual acid sulphate soils or potential acid sulphate soils Presence of contaminated groundwater beneath the site and in the surrounding area Problems arising from development Fluctuating water table not taken into account – raised groundwater levels flow into basement areas through unsealed joints and crevices Acid sulphate soils not taken into account – impacts on waterways, receiving environments and associated species Contaminated groundwater not taken into account – potential environmental and human health risks Effects of water table lowering not taken into account – damage to neighbouring buildings and major infrastructure Agency requirements Tanked basement construction required in highly permeable ground where excavation requires shallow water table to be lowered to make working environment safe Licence for temporary construction dewatering required to be applied for and obtained from the NSW Office of Water prior to excavation commencing Monitoring required throughout dewatering period and for a short period after pumping ceases Licence is valid for defined period, after which time pumping is unauthorised Proponent required to report results to the NSW Office of Water at the expiry of the licence What happens when it goes wrong…
…some interesting examples
Building settlement damage Eastern Distributor (2001) – Recessed parkway construction through sand beds – Shallow depth to groundwater required extensive dewatering – Significant internal and external structural damage to nearby buildings – Commission of Inquiry determined damage resulted from vibration, dewatering or a combination of both – Road authority required to pay for restoration SOURCE: COMMISSION OF INQUIRY 2001 Development company bankrupt Northern Beaches (2010) – Water-filled excavation adjacent to residential properties – Development company bankrupt, unable to continue work at site – Cessation of dewatering allowed the basement excavation to recharge from shallow groundwater – Pumping to make safe would need top be continuous and ongoing to counter recharge SOURCE: CHANNEL 7 NEWS BULLETIN Basement inundation (external cause) Paddington (2010) – Water main fracture in ageing distribution system beneath suburban street – Mains water pipe ruptured, flooding surrounding area – Inundation of basement car park beneath neighbouring building – Water damage to parked cars on street and in basement – Repair costs and insurance costs likely to be substantial
SOURCE: CHANNEL 7 NEWS BULLETIN
Contaminated groundwater ingress Canberra (1977) – Centre Cinema patrons complained of hydrocarbon fumes in the building – Worker attempted to install extraction fans in lift shaft – An explosion caused by the use of welding equipment killed the worker – Cinema was out of commission for months – Numerous boreholes drilled to identify source and prevent further explosions – During the installation of new storage tanks at a nearby petrol station 30,000 litres of petroleum was ‘lost’ SOURCE: SMITH 1998 Contaminated groundwater ingress Banksmeadow (2005) – Contaminated groundwater seepage identified by fumes in hotel cellar – Cracks in the wall of the cellar allowed contaminated seepage to flow across the floor – Hotel employees exposed to cancer- causing chemicals and hydrogen sulphide fumes – WorkCover NSW arranged sealing of hole and clean up measures