Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Christine Natasya
In total, there are c.34% of Indonesian population who smoke cigarettes, and c.94%
+6221 515 1140 (ext. 233) of these smokers consume clove-flavored kreteks, or cigarettes made of tobacco
natasya@miraeasset.co.id and cloves. Speaking of the kretek industry itself, the hand-rolled cigarettes
currently hold 20% of the market share, lower than the machine-made full-flavored
cigarettes which hold 38% and machine-made cigarettes (SKM) with low tar nicotine
which command 39%. The rest is insignificant, with non-kretek or white cigarettes
holding only 6% of the total market share. It is clearly evident that the machine-
made (SKM) type of cigarettes has gained market shares over the past 5 years,
rising from a total 65% in 2012 to 77% at present. The majority of the rising market
share is attributed to the full-flavored segment, which has increased by 10%p from
28% in 2012 to 38% in 2017. Given Indonesia’s high preference for clove cigarettes
(kretek), we believe the country will continue to put up a natural barrier for white
cigarettes (those composed of tobacco only) to gain market share. In addition,
global players have tried to launch clove cigarette on their own, which turned out to
be unsuccessful. Back in 1984, before acquiring HMSP, Philip Morris had tried to
enter the clove cigarette market, which did not end up successful as Indonesian
smokers still preferred locally produced clove cigarettes.
PLEASE SEE ANALYST CERTIFICATIONS AND IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES & DISCLAIMERS IN APPENDIX 1 AT THE END OF REPORT.
November 20, 2017 Tobacco
C O N T E N T S
HM Sampoerna (HMSP) 28
HM Sampoerna 29
Company background 29
HMSP’s key brand families 31
Management team 36
Competitive advantage 39
3Q17 Performance review 46
Financial Forecast 49
Valuations 51
HM Sampoerna (HMSP IJ/ Hold/ TP: IDR4,310) 52
Private consumption
Government spending
Investments
32% Inventories
54%
Statistical discrepancy
Non-profit institutions
7% spending
Net exports
Source: Bloomberg, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Research Source: The Tobacco Atlas, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Research
In Indonesia, tobacco industry is considered one of the largest industries, given the
high domestic cigarette consumption, especially among Indonesian men.
According to data from the Ministry of Agriculture, buying cigarettes makes up the
third largest expenditure of Indonesians in their daily expenses, which indicates a
buoyant demand for cigarettes. The habit of smoking has eventually shaped the
culture and lifestyle of Indonesian consumers.
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
It is estimated that around 95% of Indonesian smokers are male, leaving their
female counterparts measuring up to only c.5%. These figures may be related to
the presumption that consuming cigarettes for women is less socially acceptable in
Indonesia.
100mn
Estimated no of smokers
120
97
100
80
60
40
20
0
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 F 2025 F
Speaking of the kretek industry itself, the hand-rolled cigarettes (sigaret kretek
tangan/SKT) currently hold 17% of the market (Figure 6), lower than the machine-
made full-flavored cigarettes (sigaret kretek mesin/SKM) which hold 39% and
machine-made cigarettes (SKM) with low tar nicotine which command 39%. The rest
is insignificant, with non-kretek or white cigarettes representing only 5% of the
total market.
It is clearly evident that the machine-made (SKM) cigarettes have continued to gain
market share over the past 5 years, rising from 65% in 2012 to 77.6% at present.
This rising market share is mostly attributed to the full-flavored segment,
increasing by 11%p from 28% in 2012 to 39% in 2017.
Figure 5. Cigarette market share (2012) Figure 6. Current market share (as of 2016)
7%
5%
37% 39%
Machine made kretek Machine made kretek
(SKM)- LTN (SKM)- LTN
Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Research Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Research
30
25
20
15
10
0
HMSP GGRM Djarum RMBA Nojorono Others
HMSP was established by Liem Seeng Tee, a Chinese immigrant who began his
business by producing and selling hand-rolled kretek cigarettes at his home in
Surabaya in 1913. His small business was among the first to manufacture and
market kretek cigarettes under the brand Dji Sam Soe.
Gudang Garam was initially founded by Surya Wonowidjojo in Kediri, East Java in
1958. In 1979, the company’s first cigarette manufacturing machines were installed.
The company has been listed on the Indonesian Stock Exchange (IDX) since 1990.
GGRM produces a wide range of kretek cigarettes, including low-tar-low-nicotine
variants (which are widely known to be light and mild), and traditional hand-rolled
kretek cigarettes. The company stands out with its machine-rolled full-flavor brand,
GG Surya.
Djarum is the third largest cigarette company in Indonesia, founded by Oei Wie
Gwan of the Hartono family in Kudus, Central Java, in 1951. Djarum’s leading
brands include LA lights, Djarum Super, Djarum Super Mild, Djarum Coklat, and
Djarum 76.
Djarum Coklat
Djarum Splash
Tobacco was first introduced to Asia in 1575, when the Spanish brought it to the
Philippines. It first stepped on the land of Java (Indonesia) in 1601, brought by
Portuguese traders. Therefore, the word tembakau (tembako in Javanese, and
tobacco in English) is phonologically closer to the Portuguese word tumbaco.
Cigarettes in Indonesia were initially home-produced; they were rolled and
wrapped in dried cornhusk, banana, or palm leaves. They were later called kelobot
(husk) in Javanese or strootje in Dutch. After a while, the strootjes made a
comeback by mixing tobacco with clove buds.
Although in the seventeenth century cloves were already mixed with tobacco, clove
cigarettes did not turn into a merchandise success before the 20th century. The
first person taking a step in that direction was a man residing in Kudus (Central
Java), who popularized clove cigarettes among his friends around 1870. The man
had the idea to mix tobacco with cloves and started to sell the hand-rolled
cigarettes. The new product was called rokok cengkeh, also known as kretek
(clove cigarettes). The word kretek itself is an onomatopoetic term for the crackling
sound of burning cloves. After his death in 1880, several other Kudus inhabitants
started to produce their own clove cigarettes, which at that time were wrapped in
cornhusk. The new product gradually gained popularity outside Kudus. It started
off from a home industry which employed hand-operated rollers, while the
factories performed the activities of collecting, controlling, packing, and
distributing the product. Kretek industry was initially dominated by the Javanese,
most of whom were Muslims living in Kudus and the surrounding regions. Later on,
several Chinese entrepreneurs were attracted to enter the kretek industry and soon
gained competitive advantage at an early stage of development. Indonesian
Chinese entrepreneurs that have played an important role in the history of kretek
industry are from the largest kretek companies, such as Djarum, Bentoel, Gudang
Garam (GGRM), Sampoerna (HMSP).
Before 1968, kretek cigarettes were rolled by hand, and only after 1968 did kretek
industry start using machines. At that time, three smaller companies located in Solo
and Kudus, including Bentoel, one of the prevailing brand leaders, began to
mechanize their production. Most of the larger enterprises which began producing
cigarettes with machines in the 1970s and 1980s were Djarum (1976), GGRM (1979),
and HMSP (1983). Currently, kretek cigarettes are either hand-rolled or machine-
rolled and wrapped like conventional cigarettes in cornhusks or in white, black, or
brown paper. In addition, they are manufactured both with and without filters. At
present, clove-typed or kretek cigarettes, made of tobacco and cloves and blended
with other flavors, are apparently the most popular tobacco products in Indonesia.
Rokok Klobot Kretek (KLB) - cornhusk paper that are made by hand
Given Indonesia’s high preference for clove cigarettes (kretek), we believe the
country will continue to put up a natural barrier for white cigarettes, the ones
composed of tobacco only, to penetrate the market at a higher rate. As of 2016,
cloves cigarettes accounted for more than 80% of HMSP sales, and GGRM had no
white cigarettes in their product line up (100% kretek). In addition, global players
have tried to launch clove cigarettes on their own, but their attempts failed. Back in
1984 before acquiring HMSP, Philip Morris had tried to enter the market with their
own clove cigarettes, which did not end up successful as Indonesian smokers still
preferred locally produced clove cigarettes.
Figure 13. HMSP’s revenue breakdown Figure 14. GGRM’s revenue breakdown
Export Machine-made
1% clove cigarettes
9%
Source: Company data, Bloomberg, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Research Source: Company data, Bloomberg, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Research
2 Mild cigarettes contain the lowest level of tar and nicotine content compared to clove cigarettes, and this is well controlled /
guaranteed by the manufacturer, becoming the selling points of these products in the name of health issues (according to
some research, tar and nicotine are usually related to cancer diseases).
3 Mild cigarettes have c.14-15mg of tar and 5mg of nicotine. Because of its lower tar and nicotine content, compared to kretek,
mild cigarettes are associated with the word light, for instances, LA Light and Marlboro Light.
4 The light content of tar and nicotine is made possible through: (a) a further processing of tobacco before finely chopped into
powder structure; and (b) the use of filter technology by wrapping the end of cigarette sticks with foam in order to filter out
the nicotine and tar (research has proven this to be effective).
5 White cigarettes are cigarettes that contain only tobacco, while clove cigarettes are cigarettes containing both tobacco and
cloves.
6 Kretek cigarettes have about 20mg of tar and 4-5mg of nicotine. The tar and nicotine content is larger than that of mild
cigarettes, so kretek cigarettes are said to have even worse effects on people’s health than regular cigarettes due to its higher
percentage of tar and nicotine. An example of kretek cigarettes brands is Dji Sam Soe (owned by HMSP).
7 Kretek cigarettes are made with a blend of tobacco, cloves and other flavors. The word kretek itself is an onomatopoetic term
for the crackling sound of burning cloves.
Source: Internet, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Research
We believe street vendors and warung are key distribution channels for tobacco
manufacturers as cigarettes volume growth largely comes from single cigarettes
sold by street vendors to individual buyers who tend to purchase cigarettes per
stick rather than per pack.
Source: Various internet sources, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research Source: Various internet sources, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research
The government has also put regulations in place affecting the tobacco industry,
such as increasing the number of smoke-free areas, imposing a time limit on TV
cigarette advertisements, and hiking cigarette excise taxes which are widely known
as cigarettes’ excise duty ribbons that comprise of: 1) excise tax; 2) cigarettes tax
(10% of excise tax); and 3) VAT. For the VAT calculation, Indonesia uses banderol
price (suggested retail price from government’s regulation (Peraturan Menteri
Keuangan/PMK)) as the reference price. In some cases, the actual retail price for a
pack of cigarette might be lower than the banderol price (eg: GGRM’s Surya Pro
Mild is priced lower than its banderol price), which we believe is a strategy in order
to increase its sales volume. Note that Surya Pro Mild’s price is still within the
maximum 15% discount of the minimum retail price. Cigarettes are only subject to
a one-time VAT at the producer level, and the current rate is 9.1% of the banderol
price (suggested retail price).
We believe the government has, to some extent, achieved one of its goals, given
the declining volume growth in the industry in the recent years. In 2016, the
volume growth in Indonesia’s cigarette industry was stagnant at 1% YoY. Moreover,
in 2017, Philip Morris International estimated the country’s cigarette volume to
decline by around 3% YoY. On a separate note, for 2018, the government also
forecasts industry sales volume to decline by 3% YoY. We expect muted growth
next year, as we believe the pre-election year would drive up consumer demand,
especially cigarettes.
(Bn Sticks)
Cigarettes sales volume (L) Volume growth (R)
316 3%
314
2%
312
310
1%
308
306 0%
304
-1%
302
300
-2%
298 -3%
296 -3%
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017F 2018 F
Figure 18. Tax as % of state revenue Figure 19. Cigarette tax as % of total excise tax revenue
(IDRtr) State revenue (L) Tax as % of state revenue (R) (IDRtr) Excise tax revenue (IDRtr)
2,000 88% 180 %Cigarette tax revenue to total tax revenue 96.4%
1,800 86% 155
160 96.2%
96.1%
1,600 84% 140 96.0% 96.0%
1,400
82% 120 95.8%
1,200
80% 100 95 95.6%
1,000 95.5%
78% 80 95.4%
800 95% 95.3% 95.4%
76% 60 95.2%
600
400 74% 40 95.0%
- 70% - 94.6%
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017F 2018F 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017F 2018F
Source: Ministry of Finance, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research Source: Ministry of Finance, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research
Figure 20. % of excise tax to total tax revenue Figure 21. Gov’t revenue generated mostly from tax
(IDRtr)
12% % excise tax to total tax revenue Excise tax revenue (L) Other tax revenue (L) % Excise to total tax revenue (R)
- 9%
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017F 2018F
Source: Ministry of Finance, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research Source: Ministry of Finance, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research
In the 1970s, the tax system was modified based on: 1) production volume; 2)
cigarette type (hand-rolled kretek, machine-made kretek, or machine-made white
cigarettes); and 3) price, with the highest tax rates corresponding to companies
with the highest production volume. We believe that hand-rolled products and
companies with smaller scale production levels have consistently enjoyed the most
favorable tax rates and that smaller cigarette producers enjoyed higher margins
due to less excise tax paid compared to bigger players.
The excise taxes for machine-made, hand-rolled and white cigarettes have
increased by an average of 10% (see Figure 27). Nevertheless, the excise tax
increase for hand-rolled cigarettes has remained relatively low than that of the
machine-rolled cigarettes and white cigarettes in the past three years (Figure 23).
The lower excise tax increase for hand-rolled cigarettes is most likely because the
hand-rolled segment is already contracting, whereas the machine-made cigarettes
volume is still growing. In addition, we believe the government continues to favor
the smaller and hand-rolled cigarette factories since they are more labor-intensive.
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Government's retail Banderol
Type of cigarettes Group Production group (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK
price (HJE) Tier
203/ 2008) 181/2009) 190/2010) 167/2011) 179/2012) 179/2012) 205/2014) 198/2015) 147/2016) 010/2017)
(sticks) (IDR/stick) IDR IDR IDR IDR IDR IDR IDR IDR IDR IDR
A 290 310 325 355 375 375 415 480 530 590
I >3bn 1,120 B 280 300 315 345 480
355 355 415
C 260 280 295 325
Machine rolled
895 A 210 230 245 270 285 285 305 340 365 385
II Not more than 3bn B 175 195 210 300 335 370
715-895 235 245 245 265
C 135 155 170
A 290 310 325
I >3bn 1,130 B 230 275 295 365 380 380 425 495 555 625
C 185 225 245
White cigarettes
935 A 170 200 215 235 245 245 270 255 330 370
II Not more than 3bn B 135 165 175 190 290 355
640-935 195 195 220
C 80 105 110 125
1,260 A 200 215 235 255 275 275 290 320 345 365
I >2bn B 150 165 180 245 265 290
890-1260 195 205 205 220
C 130 145 155
A 90 105 110 125 130 130 140 155 165
>50mn but not more
Hand rolled II 470 B 80 95 100 115 120 120 140 155 180
than 2bn 125
C 75 90 90 105 110 110
>50mn but not more
III A A 40 65 65 75 80 80 85 90 100
than 350mn 400 100
III B Not more than 50mn B 80 80 80
No of layers 19 19 19 15 13 13 13 12 12 10
Source: Ministry of Finance, Customs and Excise Tax Office, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research
Type of cigarettes 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014* 2015 2016 2017 2018
Government's retail Banderol
Group Production group (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK (PMK
price (HJE) Tier
203/ 2008) 181/2009) 190/2010) 167/2011) 179/2012) 179/2012) 205/2014) 198/2015) 147/2016) 010/2017)
(sticks) (IDR/stick)
Machine rolled I >3bn A 7% 5% 9% 6% 0% 11% 16% 10% 11.3%
1,120 B 7% 5% 10% 3% 0% 17%
(SKM) C 8% 5% 10% 9%
II Not more than 3bn 895 A 10% 7% 10% 6% 0% 7% 11% 7% 5.5%
B 11% 8% 13% 12% 10%
715-895 12% 4% 0% 8%
C 15% 10%
White cigarettes I >3bn A 7% 5%
1,130 B 20% 7% 12% 4% 0% 12% 16% 12% 12.6%
(SPM) C 22% 9%
II Not more than 3bn 935 A 18% 8% 9% 4% 0% 29% 12%
B 22% 6% 9% 3% 0% 13% 16% 14% 22%
640-935
C 31% 5% 14%
Hand rolled I >2bn 1,260 A 8% 9% 9% 8% 0% 5% 10% 8% 5.8%
B 10% 9% 8% 5% 0% 11% 8% 9%
890-1260 7%
C 12% 7% 26%
(SKT) II >50mn but not more A 17% 5% 14% 4% 0% 8% 11% 6%
9%
than 2bn 470 B 19% 5% 15% 4% 0% 12% 11%
4%
C 20% 0% 17% 5% 0%
>50mn but not more
III A A 63% 0% 15% 7% 0% 6% 6% 11% 0%
than 350mn 400
III B Not more than 50mn B 0% 0%
Simple average 17% 6% 12% 5% 10%* 9% 11% 11% 10%
Source: Ministry of Finance, Customs and Excise Tax Office, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research
Tax revenue is expected to move up in parallel with the state budget growth;
hence, higher excise tax every year is deemed to be normal as the government also
needs to increase their state revenue. However, we view higher taxes for high-end
cigarettes as a double-edged sword for the government, as they would incentivize
the growth of illicit cigarette market as some smokers turn to cheaper illegal
cigarettes given the tax rate gap between high-end and low-end cigarette are
pretty huge. Therefore, in five years ahead, the government has been proposing to
cut the number of excise tax layers into five, from previously nineteen (in the past
eight years), in order to close in the gap of the cigarette tax rates, which inevitably
has forced the number of smaller players in the industry to increase prices and lose
competitiveness against the bigger players. We have seen government’s
advancement to simplify the tax structure. For 2018F, the government has reduced
the excise tax layers further into 10 from 12 in 2017.
The highest excise tax is applicable to white cigarette (SPM) at 12.6%, which we
believe will hurt SPM cigarette volume further. As of 9M17, total industry’s white
cigarette volume has already dropped by 16% YoY with HMSP’s SPM volume
declining by 25%YoY. On the other hand, government is supporting the SKT
segment by setting the lowest excise tax increase of a mere 5.8% YoY for the
highest tier of hand-rolled (SKT) cigarettes. Furthermore, the highest tier of
machine-rolled (SKM) cigarette segment which increases by 11.3% YoY (Figure 23)
will likely lead to a flat volume growth next year.
Figure 24. Cigarette tax revenue in 2018 draft state budget Figure 25. Tax as % of GDP
(IDRtr) Cigarettes tax revenue (L) Cigarettes tax revenue growth (R) (IDRtr) Total tax revenue (IDRtr) tax as % of GDP
1,400 12.5%
160 16% 12.0%
1,200
140 14% 11.4% 11.5%
120 12% 1,000
10.6% 11.0%
100 10% 800 10.4% 10.5%
80 6.9% 8%
600 10.0%
60 6%
9.5%
40 4%
400
9.0%
20 0.5% 2% 200
8.5%
- 0%
LKPP 2012 LKPP 2013 LKPP 2014 LKPP 2015 LKPP 2016 APBNP 2017 RAPBN 2018 - 8.0%
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Source: Ministry of Finance, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research Source: Ministry of Finance, Bloomberg, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research
5%
0%
-1.6%
-3.1%
-5%
-10% -4.7%
-15%
-16.4%
-20%
-25%
1Q16 1H16 9M16 FY16 1Q17 1H17 9M17
In addition, the increased cigarette excise tax is actually normal as it usually hovers
at 8-12% YoY. Thus, its recent change to an incremental excise tax scheme indicates
the government’s support for the consolidation in the industry. In our view, the
number of illicit cigarettes traders in Indonesia has become one of the
government’s reasons to aggressively raise the excise tax. Hence, we believe that
cigarette tax increase can limit the number of illicit cigarette companies since,
assuming they are selling at the same price, consumers would prefer buying bigger
cigarette brands.
16%
Excise tax hike average
14%
12%
10%
8%
6%
4%
2%
0%
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018F
Source: Ministry of Finance, Customs and Excise Tax Office, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research
As the excise tax makes up c.70% of cigarette companies’ cost of revenue, the
expectation of 10% excise tax growth should hurt companies’ cost of sales, as well
as their margin (assuming that tobacco and clove prices will remain the same next
year). However, in order for those cigarette companies to retain their margins, we
expect that cigarette companies need to raise ASP by c.8% in 2018F to compensate
for the excise tax increase.
We see that Indonesia’s excise tariff as % of government retail price has been
volatile. However, although the increase in tax rates between the year of 2015 and
2017 was quite significant, the excise tariff as a percentage of the government
retail prices went down. We believe this is mainly due to the fact that, in absolute
terms, Indonesia’s cigarette manufacturer has been able to overcome the excise
tax hike, as the price increase was larger than the tax increase, which in turn
diminished the effect of the excise tariff hike.
Nevertheless, Indonesia has presently been capping its tobacco excise tariff rate
as % of government retail price at 57% according to PMK No146/PMK.010/2017.
The tobacco tax as % of government retail price is much lower than the WHO
benchmark, set at 75%. Therefore, we believe that at the current level, Indonesia’s
tobacco industry seems to have a better taxation scheme, compared to the
neighboring countries, such as Vietnam and Malaysia.
Excise tariff as % of Gov’t retail price 43.9% 47.0% 49.2% 53.8% 56.1% 56.1% 51.9% 48.0% 47.3% 52.7%
(HJE) on machine-rolled cigarettes
Source: Peraturan Menteri Keuangan, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research estimates
80%
70%
60% 57.5%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Along with the excise tax, the government also increased the 2018F minimum retail
price (HJE) by 3.7% for hand-rolled cigarettes to IDR1,260/stick and by 9.7% for
white cigarettes to IDR1,130/stick. Meanwhile, the minimum retail price for
machine-rolled (SKM) cigarettes is flat at Rp1,120/stick (figure 29). The government
also stated that new brands’ minimum retail price should not be lower than the
existing brands owned by the cigarettes manufacturers. Furthermore, the
regulation now only allows for price discount within 15% of the minimum retail
price suggested by government. We believe this new regulation should benefit big
cigarettes players and bring disadvantages to smaller players which sell cigarettes
at discounted prices. In addition to that, the simplified excise tax brackets should
benefit the bigger players. The government has planned to simplify the excise tax
layers from 10 layers in 2018 to 5 layers in 2021.
1,400
1,200
1,000
800
600
400
200
-
Machine-rolled cigarettes White cigarettes Hand-rolled cigarettes
While there are 181 countries that have signed the treaty by 2016, Indonesia is
among the few that have not done so. This is not surprising since the president,
Jokowi, wants to protect the livelihood of tobacco farmers and cigarettes industry’s
labors.
We believe that the smaller number of tax layers would close in the wide price gaps
among cigarette brands as smaller players will have to increase their average
selling prices (ASPs) and thereby lose their competitive pricing over the bigger
companies. We also believe that the lesser number of layers will impel the
government to control the emergence of smaller cigarette companies. Indeed,
according to the Director General of Customs, the number of tobacco factories has
decreased from 4,198 in 2006 to only 713 in 2015.
5,000
Number of tobacco factories
4,500 4,198
4,000
3,500
3,000
2,500
2,000
1,500
1,000 713
500
-
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Following the excise duty ribbons (comprising of more than 70% of cigarettes
companies’ COGS) as the second largest components of cost of revenue for those
cigarettes companies are tobacco (c.10-11% of total COGS) and cloves (4-5% of total
COGS).
Figure 31. HMSP’s COGS breakdown as of 2016 Figure 32. GGRM’s COGS breakdown as of 2016
Tobacco
Tobacco
Cloves
Cloves
Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
Almost all cloves are locally sourced. On the contrary, due to lack of supply, tobacco
leaves are mostly imported, with an exception to GGRM, which sources most of its
tobacco leaves locally. The company stated that they want to source everything
locally to maintain their costs in Rupiah base. In addition, the company believes
that buying tobacco locally would support the livelihood of local tobacco farmers
who are mostly kretek smokers.
40
160,000
35
140,000
30
25 120,000
20 100,000
15 80,000
10
60,000
5
40,000
-
20,000
-
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Source: Kata Data News and Research, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Source: Ministry of Agriculture, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
We predict the volatility of raw material prices (tobacco and clove) to also be a
threat to cigarette companies, although less significant compared to the excise
given the smaller composition to the total cost of goods sold (COGS). Nonetheless,
in our view, cigarette companies will gradually pass on this cost increase to the
consumers. We also believe that HMSP has a greater import component compared
to GGRM, provided the global supply chain from Phillip Morris.
Furthermore, the prices of cloves are typically believed to be more volatile than
tobacco leaves as big cigarette companies normally purchase tobacco leaves in
bulk to support their raw material continuity since demands may spike up
suddenly, given the harvesting season which is only yearly. Tobacco leaves can be
stored for nine months to up to three years. Currently, tobacco leaves can only be
found in five main regions, namely Bojonegoro, Lombok, Temanggung, Jember and
Paiton (East Java).
On the contrary, cloves are available throughout Indonesia that its harvesting
months are spread within a year. Therefore, unlike the tobacco leaves, big cigarette
companies do not normally keep cloves up until three years (usually c.9month -14
months).
We believe big cigarette companies now safeguard ample clove reserves, owing to
their bad experiences in 2011. Currently, cigarettes companies keep their inventory
of raw materials (tobacco and cloves) as a buffer in the event of significant
increases in tobacco and clove prices. As of 2016, GGRM kept 782 days of raw
material inventory, while HMSP kept 446 days of raw material inventory.
900
782
800
700
600
500 458
400
300
200
100
0
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
In addition, Indonesia has numerous growth drivers in this sector, such as its
favorable demographic profile (50.8% of the population are in the age range of 24-
54), low real cigarette prices, vast population, rising household income, low excise
tax as percentage of cigarettes’ retail price, as well as high pricing power of the big
players holding the market share of the tobacco industry.
Source: United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Research
25
20
15
10
0
2007 2010 2013 2016
HM Sampoerna (HMSP)
Hefty valuation
OP (18F, IDRbn) 17,396 Solid balance sheet- small debt and manageable capex going forward
Consensus OP 18F, IDRbn) 18,187
Since 2015 (the year when the company did a rights issue to comply with the free
EPS Growth (18F, %) 8.1 float requirement), HMSP’s debt has been very small as the company boosted up its
Market EPS Growth (18F, %) 16.6
cash ever since the rights issue. In addition, although the company has greater
P/E (18F, x) 34.3
Market P/E (18F, x) 28.9 financial stability, the company requires only minimal capex ahead as their current
Market Cap (IDRbn) 496,678.2 capacity can fulfill the market demand for cigarettes. The company only needs
Shares Outstanding (mn) 116,318.1 capex of c.IDR1.1-IDR1.2tr per year for repair and maintenance. Thus, we believe
Free Float (%) 7.5 HMSP will have a positive free cash flow going forward, given our assumption that
Foreign Ownership (%) 2.1 its capital expenditure as percentage of sales will just be stable.
Beta (12M) 1.2
52-Week High 4,340 Diversified products to cater to all segments of target market
52-Week Low 3,350
(%) 1M (%) 1M Currently, HMSP sells machine-rolled mild cigarettes (SKM mild) with three market
Absolute 4.9 5.9 8.5 segments, such as A mild for the premium market, U mild for the middle market,
Relative 3.1 -0.2 -8.1 and Magnum Mild for the mid- to low-end market. Meanwhile, for the machine-
rolled full flavor (SKM FF), HMSP has three market segments, such as Dji Sam Soe
(D-1yr=100) JCI HMSP Magnum Filter 12 for the premium market, Marlboro Filter Black for the middle
125 market and U Bold for the mid- to low-end market.
115
105 Initiate with a Hold call (TP: IDR 4,310/share)
95
85 We initiate our coverage on HMSP with a hold rating and a target price of
11/16
12/16
1/17
1/17
2/17
3/17
3/17
4/17
5/17
5/17
6/17
7/17
7/17
8/17
9/17
10/17
10/17
11/17
IDR3,410/share, which was derived by using a 2018F target multiple of 38x. We like
HMSP on the back of its strong position in the cigarette market, despite its recent
declining market share. Nevertheless, its premium valuation and declining market
share of its flagship brands, which we believe has higher margins, such as
Sampoerna A and Sampoerna U (SKM Mild), lead to our hold recommendation. In
addition, HMSP’s SKM FF brands (U Bold and Marlboro Filter black) might
deteriorate the company’s margins.
HM Sampoerna
Company background
Hanjaya Mandala Sampoerna (HMSP) is a top-listed tobacco company that
manufactures and distributes cigarettes in Indonesia. The company is a subsidiary
of PT Philip Morris Indonesia and an affiliate company of Philip Morris International
Inc, the world’s leading international tobacco company. Other than machine-made
cigarettes (SKM), HMSP also produces hand-rolled cigarettes (SKT) and distributes
the product of PT Philip Morris Indonesian (PMID), Marlboro, in Indonesia.
Currently, HMSP leads the industry by holding 33.1% of the total cigarette market
share as of 3Q17. Machine-made cigarettes contribute to the majority of HMSP
total revenue (>60% of HMSP’s revenue) with mild segment contributing more than
the machine-made full-flavor, followed by hand-rolled cigarettes at 20%, and white
cigarettes at 15%. Meanwhile, HMSP’s export market contributes insignificantly to
the company’s revenue at less than 1% of HMSP’s consolidated revenue.
Figure 38. Market share of cigarette companies Figure 39. Revenue breakdown (IDRbn)
Machine made clove cigarettes (SKM)
(%) Market share (%) IDRbn Hand rolled clove cigarettes (SKT)
35 White Cigarettes (SPM)
80,000 Others
Export
30 70,000
25 60,000
50,000
20
40,000
15
30,000
10
20,000
5 10,000
0 0
HMSP GGRM Djarum RMBA Nojorono Others 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 F 2018 F
Source: Company data, Nielsen, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Research Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Research
Figure 40. HMSP’s revenue breakdown Figure 41. HMSP’s quarterly volume sales by segment
Export bn sticks White Hand-rolled Machine-made
Others
White Cigarettes (SPM)
Hand rolled clove cigarettes (SKT) 30
Machine made clove cigarettes (SKM)
28
100%
26
90% 2.7
24
80% 3.5 3.1
20% 22
70%
5.3
60% 20
4.7 4.8
50% 18
40%
16
30% 64%
14 18.3
20% 16.7 17.0
10% 12
0% 10
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 1Q15 3Q15 1Q16 3Q16 1Q17 3Q17
Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Research Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Research
HMSP was established by Liem Seeng Tee, a Chinese immigrant who began his
business by producing and selling hand-rolled kretek cigarettes at his home in
Surabaya in 1913. His small business was among the first to manufacture and
market kretek cigarettes under the brand Dji Sam Soe. In 1959, HMSP’s operation
was then passed on to the second generation of the family, Aga Sampoerna, who
focused on the production of SKT (hand-rolled cigarettes). The company turned into
a public company in 1990.
The company produces some of the best-known kretek (clove) cigarette brand
families, such as Sampoerna A, Sampoerna Kretek, Sampoerna U, and Dji Sam Soe,
which is considered the legendary “King of Kretek.” Given the success of its
business, HMSP drew the interest of PT Philip Morris Indonesia, which has acquired
the majority of ownership of HMSP in May 2005.
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 F 2018 F
Dji Sam Soe is the first SKT brand produced by Handel Maatschappij Liem Seeng
Tee, which later became Hanjaya Mandala Sampoerna.
Dji Sam Soe has both variants of SKT and SKM brands. Dji Sam Soe is positioned as
a premium kretek brand in Indonesia and continues to be the leader in the SKT
segment. Dji Sam Soe’s SKM segments are Dji Sam Soe Filter, Dji Sam Soe Magnum
Filter, and Dji Sam Soe Magnum Blue (launched in early 2014), while Dji Sam Soe
SKT’s segments include Dji Sam Soe Kretek and Dji Sam Soe Super Premium.
Sampoerna’s SKT products, namely Dji Sam Soe (established since 1913) and
Sampoerna Kretek, are still manufactured by hand today in 5 Sampoerna's
manufacturing facilities and 38 facilities that belong to the third party’s operators
throughout Java.
Marlboro, one of the biggest international brands in the market, was launched in
1984 in Indonesia by PMID and is distributed by Sampoerna. Marlboro currently
has five variants, namely Marlboro Red, Marlboro Lights, Marlboro Black Menthol,
Marlboro Lights Menthol, and Marlboro Ice Blast.
HMSP has successfully retained its leading position in 2016. The company, however,
continued to witness stronger competition from the second player, a local company
named Gudang Garam (GGRM). Although HMSP keeps launching several new
product variants, the company has continued to focus on the performance of its
machine-rolled kretek (SKM) brands. The company presented a considerable threat
to some other leading players through its established distribution network and
solid tie-ups with various retail vendors around the Indonesian archipelago.
Management team
Board of Directors
He is a Lebanese citizen, born in Beirut on July 10, 1969. Andre Dahan has served as
a Sampoerna’s Director since April 18, 2013. He joined Philip Morris Switzerland in
2003, progressing through several key positions in marketing at PMI affiliates in
Poland, Hungary, the Czech Republic and Russia, as well as building 16 years of
experience in the industry. He earned his Master’s Degree in Business
Administration from Institut d’Etudes Politiques de Paris, Paris, France, and his
Bachelor of Arts Degree in International Economics from L’université Paris-
Sorbonne, Paris, France. He was reappointed Sampoerna’s Director of Marketing at
the AGMS on April 27, 2015.
He is a U. S. citizen, born in Colorado on October 19, 1971. Troy J. Modlin has served
as a Sampoerna’s Director of Corporate Affairs, appointed at the EGMS, since
September 18, 2015. He joined PMI in 2005 in Switzerland as a Manager and was
later appointed Director of Government Affairs before assuming the Director of
Corporate Affairs position in Hong Kong and Bangkok. He has 10 years of
experience in the industry. He earned his Bachelor of Science Degree in Business
Administration from the University of Colorado in Boulder, Denver, USA, and a
Master’s Degree in International Management from the University of Denver,
Daniels College of Business, USA.
He is a German citizen, born in Heidelberg on May 12, 1968. Michael Sandritter has
served as a Sampoerna’s Director since May 9, 2014. He joined PMI in 1994 and
assumed several key roles in Finance at PMI’s Operations Center in Lausanne,
Switzerland, and at PMI’s affiliates in Hungary and Germany. He was reappointed
Director of Finance at the AGMS held on April 27, 2015. He holds a Diploma in
Business Administration from the University of Cooperative Education, Mannheim,
Germany.
He is an Indonesian citizen, born in Semarang on June 29, 1974. The Ivan Cahyadi
was appointed Sampoerna’s Director of Sales at the AGMS of the Company held on
April 27, 2016. He joined Sampoerna in 1996 as a Sales Trainee. Over his 20 years of
experience with the Company, he has progressed through a number of positions in
Sampoerna and PMI’s affiliates in Malaysia. He received a Bachelor Degree in
Economics from Universitas Surabaya in 1996.
Board of Commissioners
He is an Australian citizen, born in Liverpool on January 18, 1954. John Gledhill has
served as Sampoerna’s President Commissioner since July 18, 2012. He joined PMI
in 1983 and progressed through various senior roles in sales, marketing, and
general management at a number of PMI affiliates, including serving as President
Director of Sampoerna during the period of 2009-2012. John Gledhill was
reappointed Sampoerna’s President Commissioner at the AGMS held on April 27,
2015. He holds a Higher National Certificate in Business Studies from Liverpool
Polytechnic and completed the International Executive Program INSEAD, France, in
1999.
She is an Indonesian citizen, born in Malang on February 25, 1950. Niken Kristiawan
Rachmad has served as Sampoerna’s Commissioner since January 1, 2011. She
joined Sampoerna in 1998 as the Head of Corporate Communications and later
assumed the positions of Communications Director and Corporate Affairs Advisor.
She was reappointed Sampoerna’s Commissioner at the AGMS held on April 27,
2015. She earned a Bachelor of Science Degree from Universitas Gadjah Mada,
Yogjakarta.
He is a Malaysian citizen, born in Selangor on July 3, 1946. Goh Kok Ho has served
as an Independent Commissioner since April 27, 2012, formerly holding several key
positions at PMI affiliates until 2001. He was reappointed Independent
Commissioner at the AGMS held on April 27, 2015. He obtained his Bachelor of Arts
Degree in Economics from the University of Malaya.
Competitive advantage
Solid balance sheet- small debt and manageable capex going forward
Since 2015 (the year when the company did a rights issue to comply with the free
float requirement), HMSP’s debt has been very small as the company boosted up its
cash ever since the rights issue. In addition, although the company has greater
financial stability, the company requires only minimal capex ahead as their current
capacity can fulfill market demand on cigarettes. The company only needs capex of
c.IDR1.1-IDR1.2tr per year for repair and maintenance. Thus, we believe HMSP will
have a positive free cash flow going forward, given our assumption that its capital
expenditure as percentage of sales will just be stable. To note, in 2015, the
company paid all their excise tax payable and charged it as an expense in the profit
and loss statement, turning its free cash flow to a minus state.
25% 25%
20%
20% 15%
10%
15% 5%
0%
10% -5%
-10%
5% -15%
-20%
0% -25%
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017F 2018F 2019F 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017F 2018F 2019F
Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
Figure 53. HMSP’s stable capex as % of sales to boost free cash flow
IDRbn Cash (L) Free cash flow (L) Capex as % of sales (R)
20,000 2.5%
15,000 2.0%
10,000 1.5%
5,000 1.0%
- 0.5%
(5,000) 0.0%
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 F 2018 F 2019 F
Currently, HMSP sells machine-rolled mild cigarettes (SKM mild) with three market
segments, such as A mild for the premium market, U mild for the middle market,
and Magnum Mild for the mid- to low-end market. Meanwhile, for the machine-
rolled full flavor (SKM FF), HMSP has three market segments, such as Dji Sam Soe
Magnum Filter 12 for the premium market, Marlboro Filter Black for the middle
market and U Bold for the mid- to low-end market. In addition, HMSP also
distributes white cigarettes under different brands, such as Marlboro Red,
Marlboro Ice Blast, Marlboro Lights, Marlboro Black Menthol, and Marlboro Lights
Menthol. Since the company only acts as a distributor for the white cigarettes, the
profitability of Marlboro in HMSP is lower than PMI US.
A Mild
Retail price = IDR21,290 Marlboro Filter Black
Retail price = IDR21,500
Magnum Filter
Retail price = IDR16400
U Mild
Retail price = IDR16,767
Magnum Mild
U Bold
Retail price = IDR13,083
Retail price = IDR12,600
White cigarettes
Marlboro Red 25,700
Marlboro Ice Blast 27,600
Marlboro Lights 26,500
Marlboro Black Menthol 25,500
Marlboro Lights Menthol 23,190
Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
Figure 56. HMSP as the market leader in the industry Figure 57. HMSP’s overall market share
32%
18.6
31%
21.2
30%
1Q13
2Q13
3Q13
4Q13
1Q14
2Q14
3Q14
4Q14
1Q15
2Q15
3Q15
4Q15
1Q16
2Q16
3Q16
4Q16
1Q17
2Q17
3Q17
Source: Nielsen, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research Source: PMI US, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
Firstly, although HMSP is the pioneer in the SKM mild segment (SKM LTLN), the
competition within the segment is getting tougher, given the emergence of
products from competitors. HMSP launched their first SKM mild in 1989 with the
brand Sampoerna A. Meanwhile, GGRM has just started producing their SKM mild
in 2002. We believe the recent decline in the HMSP’s SKM Mild (LTLN) market share
is due to the competition that comes from cheaper products in the market,
especially brands under GGRM Surya Pro Mild which are priced at below that of
HMSP’s A Mild. As we believe, in order for HMSP to be able to survive in the market,
the company has been introducing new SKM mild brands into the market. For
instance, HMSP launched Avolution 20 (SKM Mild) at the end of 2015.
Nonetheless, we view that HMSP’s SKM mild segment is recently losing consumers’
appetite as full flavor or mid-tar segment has gained their attention. HMSP’s A Mild
and U Mild have recently seen declining audience shares, which we believe is due to
consumers’ growing appetite for mid-tar cigarette segment that has a similar
pricing (c.IDR21,000/pack), such as GG Surya and Djarum Super.
Figure 58. HMSP’s mild cigarette Figure 59. HMSP’s mild cigarette (newer brand)
Source: Internet, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research Source: Internet, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
Secondly, we believe the company is also aware of the emergence of SKM mid-tar
segments which have gained consumers’ attention recently, especially from
GGRM’s Surya Professional. Thus, HMSP also rebranded their Magnum Blue brand
into Magnum Mild. Magnum Blue, initially launched in 2014, did not sell as good as
Magnum Filter, which is more towards the SKM FF segment. Magnum Mild was
rebranded in the middle of this year, priced at around IDR12,500-IDR13,000 in the
supermarkets, much lower than Surya Pro’s price per pack. In addition, the
company’s Dji Sam Soe portfolio products are seen to be declining; thus, we believe
the company aims to strengthen their portfolio by rebranding their Magnum Blue
to Dji Sam Soe Magnum Mild with hopes to regain market share. At the current
price, Magnum Mild is now catering to the needs of mid- to lower-income smokers
compared to previously when it was targeted at middle- to upper-income smokers.
Our ground checks confirmed that consumers feel the current price is reasonable
compared to Magnum Blue. Nonetheless, Dji Sam Soe Magnum Mild is priced at
c.25% below the government’s suggested price. Therefore, according to the latest
PMK regulation, HMSP needs to raise its Magnum Mild price as the government
now only allows 15% of maximum discount from the minimum retail price (HJE)
which may impede consumers’ preference as the pricing will be similar to U Mild
which has experienced a declining sales volume, in our view. According to HMSP,
the company needs to raise its Magnum Mild price by March 2018F.
Figure 60. HMSP’s SKM Mid tar Figure 61. HMSP’s SKM FF
Source: Internet, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research Source: Internet, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
Thirdly, we believe HMSP is also aware of the fact that SKM FF has always been the
favorite among Indonesian smokers. Therefore, the company launched a new SKM
full-flavored segment in February 2015, such as U Bold. According to the company,
only one year after the launch of U Bold, distribution was expanded to reach 55
cities across the country and has managed to improve its market share after
several months of launching the products. HMSP’s U Bold is priced at 30% of
discount from GGRM’s GG Surya, which is also SKM Mild.
Figure 62. HMSP’s quarterly volume sales Figure 63. HMSP’s quarterly volume sales by segment
Source: PMI US, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research Source: PMI US, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
Figure 64. Sampoerna A’s market share Figure 65. Sampoerna U’s market share
15.5% 6.0%
15.0% 5.5%
14.5% 5.0%
14.0% 4.5%
4.4%
13.0% 3.5%
12.5% 3.0%
1Q13 3Q13 1Q14 3Q14 1Q15 3Q15 1Q16 3Q16 1Q17 3Q17 1Q13 3Q13 1Q14 3Q14 1Q15 3Q15 1Q16 3Q16 1Q17 3Q17
Source: PMI US, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research Source: PMI US, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
Figure 66. Dji Sam Soe’s market share Figure 67. HMSP’s market share from other brand segments
8.5% 10.0%
8%
8.0% 9.5%
7.5% 9.0%
7.0% 8.5%
6.5% 8.0%
8%
6.0% 7.5%
5.5% 7.0%
2Q14 4Q14 2Q15 4Q15 2Q16 4Q16 2Q17 1Q14 3Q14 1Q15 3Q15 1Q16 3Q16 1Q17 3Q17
Source: PMI US, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research Source: PMI US, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
Figure 68. HMSP’s overall market share Figure 69. Sales volume contribution to revenue (%)
40%
32%
67% 68% 70%
30%
31%
20%
30% 10%
0%
1Q15 3Q15 1Q16 3Q16 1Q17 3Q17
Source: PMI US, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research Source: Company data, PMI US, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
Financial Forecast
Revenue growth mainly supported by higher ASPs
We forecast HMSP’s revenue to grow by 5% and 8% YoY in 2017F and 2018F
respectively. Our revenue forecast is basically supported by higher average selling
price (ASP) assumption to offset the higher excise tax per segment. As to our
volume assumptions, however, we forecast lower volume for white cigarettes at 8%
and 6% YoY in 2017F and 2018F, mainly on the back of weaker preference among
Indonesian smokers. In addition, white cigarettes will see the highest increase in
excise tax per stick in 2018F, which is 12.6%. Indeed, HMSP’s 9M17 white cigarettes’
(SPM) volume has declined by 25% YoY. Meanwhile, for hand-rolled cigarettes (SKT)
segment, we forecast a decline by 3% for 2017F and 2018F along with the
downward trend of the company’s SKT sales revenue contribution to total revenue.
We expect HMSP’s SKT segment contribution to total revenue to slightly decline to
19% next year. On the other hand, we still believe in SKM segment as SKM FF and
mid tar products are now favored by smokers. We project a slightly higher volume
of SKM segment by 1% for 2018F, as we also expect the consumption to slightly
recover next year. In addition to that, we believe SKM FF and mid tar segments
have a better chance to increase their ASP next year, especially for Magnum Filter
Black as it is gaining volume and still priced very low compared to its closest
counterparts.
IDRbn
IDRbn Gross profit (L) Gross margin (R)
30,000 30%
120,000
29%
25,000
100,000 28%
27%
20,000
80,000
26%
Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
On the other hand, we project a stable bottom line margin, mainly supported by
the company’s ability to book net interest income as the company has ample cash
reserves as well as a flat capital expenditure for the company going forward. Given
ample cash and minimal capex going forward, we expect the company’s payout
ratio to be stable at a high rate of 100% going forward.
Figure 72. Gross profit forecast Figure 73. Bottom line forecast
IDRbn
IDRbn Net profit Net profit margin
16,000 16%
30,000
14,000
15%
25,000 12,000
14%
20,000 10,000
8,000 13%
15,000
6,000
10,000 12%
4,000
5,000 11%
2,000
0 - 10%
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 F 2018 F 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 F2018 F
Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia research
14,000 130%
10,000
110%
8,000 100%
100%
100% 100%
98%
6,000
90%
4,000
84%
2,000 80%
- 70%
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 F 2018 F
Valuations
We initiate our coverage on HMSP with a hold rating and a target price of
IDR4,310/share, which was derived by using a target multiple of 2018F of 36x.
We like HMSP on the back of its strong position in the cigarette market, despite its
recent declining market share. Nevertheless, its premium valuation, structurally
declining market share and tight competition in the market lead to our hold
recommendation on the company. HMSP’s flagship brands, Sampoerna A and
Sampoerna U (SKM Mild), which we believe have higher margins compared to their
latest launched products, remain under pressure in the 3Q17 as they booked lower
market shares. In addition, HMSP’s SKM FF brands (U Bold and Marlboro Filter
black) might deteriorate the company’s margins.
Currently, HMSP is trading at 34.3x forward PE, still lower than its average 5-year +1
standard deviation at 35.7x.
40
+2 Std Dev
+1 Std Dev
35
Avg PER
30
-1 Std Dev
25 -2 Std Dev
20
01/13 01/14 01/15 01/16 01/17
Gudang Garam was initially founded by Surya Wonowidjojo in Kediri, East Java
in 1958. In 1979, the company’s first cigarette manufacturing machines were
installed. The company has been listed on IDX since 1990. GGRM produces a
(Initiate) Trading Buy wide range of kretek cigarettes, including low-tar-low-nicotine variants, widely
known as light and mild, as well as traditional hand-rolled kretek.
Target Price (12M, IDR) 91,000
Expect a double-digit topline growth for 2018F
Share Price (11/17/17, IDR) 77,975 We expect GGRM to book 10.5% YoY growth in its topline in 2018F, mainly on the
back of higher average selling price (ASP) of c.8%, which we believe should be
Expected Return 16.7% sufficient to offset higher excise tax and other raw material price increases in the
cost of goods sold. We forecast flattish volume growth for GGRM’s SKT segment
OP (18F, IDRbn) 12,292 and 1% volume growth for GGRM’s SKM segment as the company sees more
Consensus OP 18F, IDRbn) 12,218 potentials in the SKM full-flavor segment.
EPS Growth (18F, %) 14.8 Robust free cash flow, expect higher dividend per share
Market EPS Growth (17F, %) 16.6
P/E (18F, x) 17.8 We expect GGRM to book robust free cash flow going forward as the company sees
Market P/E (18F, x) 28.9 less capex burden compared to five years ago (2011-2015). In addition, given lesser
Market Cap (IDRbn) 154,744.8 capex going forward, we estimate a stable payout ratio at 75% (similar to 2017F),
Shares Outstanding (mn) 1,924.1 and expect higher dividend per share going forward.
Free Float (%) 23.8
Full-flavored cigarettes as the winner
Foreign Ownership (%) 81.4
Beta (12M) 1.2 As GGRM’s product mix is still dominated by machine-made (SKM) full-flavored
52-Week High 83,100 cigarettes, we believe the company is well positioned to embrace the growing
52-Week Low 60,025 machine-made full-flavored segment; its well-received brand image among
smokers should support its growth agenda. According to Nielsen, the industry’s
(%) 1M 6M 12M
machine-made (SKM) FF market share has grown from 28% in 2012 to 38% today.
Absolute 20.9 5.9 23.8
Indeed, GGRM saw an increase in its SKM FF volume contribution. In 2013, GGRM
Relative 19.2 -0.2 7.3
SKM FF products’ contribution to total volume was 74%. Currently, the figure has
(D-1yr=100) JCI GGRM
amplified to 77%.
125
Initiate with a Trading Buy call (TP: IDR 91,000/share)
115
We initiate our coverage on GGRM with a trading buy rating and a target price of
105
95
85 IDR91,000/share, which was derived using DCF with a 7-year life span. Our WACC
assumption of 9.5% is derived from the following assumptions: Risk free (Rf) rate of
11/16
12/16
1/17
1/17
2/17
3/17
3/17
4/17
5/17
5/17
6/17
7/17
7/17
8/17
9/17
10/17
10/17
11/17
6.5%, market risk premium (MRP) of 5%, terminal growth rate of 3%, and equity
beta of 0.9x. GGRM is currently trading near -1std deviation at 22x forward P/E, 13%
discount from HMSP which is trading at 19.5x. We are taken with GGRM as the
company is projected to register higher free cash flow, stable margins, and benefits
from higher selling price due to lesser competition in the market.
Gudang Garam
Company Background
Gudang Garam was initially founded by Surya Wonowidjojo in Kediri, East Java in
1958. In 1979, the company’s first cigarette manufacturing machines were installed.
The company has been listed on IDX since 1990.
Figure 77. GGRM’s revenue breakdown Figure 78. GGRM’s sales volume breakdown
Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research
GGRM is currently operating two production facilities at two main sites, each having
its own primary and secondary kretek manufacturing operations. The first site is in
Kediri, where the company was founded (Gudang Garam headquarters). The
second site is located in Gempol, East Java (50 km away from Surabaya).
GGRM is also operating an in-house printing facility and five major operating
subsidiaries, such as:
• Surya Air and Galaxy Prime Ltd providing non-scheduled air transport
services
Management team
Board of Directors
Mr Heru Budiman was appointed Director in 2000. He joined the company in 1990
with responsibilities for Treasury and Investor Relations and was appointed
Corporate Secretary in 1996. His background includes senior management
positions at international and leading national banks. He holds a Bachelor Degree
in English from Satya Wacana University. He is currently a Commissioner of PT
Graha Surya Media and PT Surya Abadi Semesta. He is also serving as President
Director of PT Surya Madistrindo.
She was appointed Director in 2015 with responsibility for SKM production at Kediri.
She formerly served as Deputy Director of Production at Gempol in 2014-2015 and,
prior to this, was the Head of LTN (low tar nicotine) production in 2013-2014. She
joined the company in 2012, working in the Technical Division. Previously she
worked in automotive manufacturing at Bosch in Germany. She is a graduate from
the Technical University of Berlin. She is also serving as a Director of PT Bukit
Dhoho Indah.
He joined the company in 2012 and was appointed Director with responsibility for
printing operations of cigarette packaging. From 2008-2012, he served as Director
at PT Cipta Kretek Nusantara and PT Karyadibya Mahardhika. Prior to that, he
worked at PT Surya Zig Zag, during which he served as the General Manager and
Management Representative. He was appointed Independent Director in 2014. He
holds a Bachelor Degree in Chemical Engineering from Institut Teknologi Sepuluh
Nopember, Surabaya.
Board of Commissioners
She was appointed President Commissioner of the company in June 2009. She has
been a Commissioner since 1983. She is related to Susilo Wonowidjojo, the
President Director and is affiliated to the company’s shareholders. Concurrently,
she is serving as President Commissioner of PT Suryamitra Kusuma as well as
Commissioner of PT Suryaduta Investama, PT Surya Wisata, and PT Taman
Sriwedari. She is also the President Director of PT Surya Pamenang and PT Surya
Zig Zag.
Competitive advantage
GGRM has been maintaining average payout ratio of c.36% over the past 10 years.
The company had spent c.IDR18.4tr for capex throughout 2011-2015 to replace
machineries, build new production machinery, refurbish factories as well as
establishing modern warehouses, which clearly explains why its dividend payout
ratio was very low during those years (c.35%). Going forward, we believe GGRM will
maintain its capex low as the current plants’ capacities are able to cater to demands
from consumers.
Last year, GGRM increased its payout ratio to 78%, with dividend per share
increasing by 225% on a YoY basis from IDR800/share to IDR2,600/share in 2016.
The company confirmed that this year, they will spend the same amount of
dividend per share at IDR2,600, which translates into 75% of dividend payout ratio.
Although GGRM’s recent plan of land acquisition worth IDR850bn with a total area
of 2.68m² to construct an airport in Kediri is a key concern to the capex going
forward, we judge the amount to be insignificant. Hence, we believe the company
will still be able to maintain its low capex over the years ahead. Furthermore, even
if the company were to proceed with the airport construction (which we assume to
be at c.IDR1.5tr-IDR2tr), we expect the total lost to be spread across a span of 3-4
years. All in all the financial burden is estimated at IDRIDR400bn-IDR700bn/ year,
which would still be low at c.2% of sales compared to the previous years’ 6.3% of
sales (assuming GGRM does not spend hefty capex on production capacity plant in
the next several years).
6,000 12%
5,000 10%
4,000 8%
3,000 6%
2,000 4%
1,000 2%
- 0%
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 F 2018 F 2019 F 2020 F
Since GGRM no longer spends hefty amount of capex going forward and is still
going to maintain its bank borrowing amount, (maintaining good relationships with
the banks), we assume the company will still be able to maintain stable dividend
payout ratio at the current rate going forward. With the current low interest rate in
the market, we favor the company’s initiative of using debt to finance their
expansion as it will generally be cheaper than the cost of equity. Based on our
calculation, any increase of 25%p in GGRM’s payout ratio should also increase the
company’s return on equity (ROE) by 100bps.
Figure 85. GGRM’s dividend per share and payout ratio Figure 86. GGRM’s gearing and net gearing
(IDR/share) Dividend per share Dividend Payout ratio Gross Gearing Net Gearing
3,000 90%
60%
78% 75% 80%
50% 51% 51%
2,500
70% 50%
2,000 60%
40%
50%
1,500
40% 30%
1,000 30%
20%
20%
500
10% 10%
- 0%
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 F2018 F 0%
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 F 2018 F
Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research
In addition to that, we have regard for the company’s diversification into a premium
price cigarette in the SKM FF. GGRM’s first premium product, launched in 2013
under the brand GG Surya Exclusive, invited good market responses. We expect
warm reception from the market to continue and GGRM to enhance its market
share in SKM FF.
According to our discussion with the company’s investor relation team, GGRM’s
SKM mid-tar segment, Surya Professional (Surya Pro), has been recording higher
sales volume growth due to its ability to sell at a cheaper price compared to other
cigarettes in the similar type in the industry, such as LA Bold and Dunhill Kretek
Filter (SKM mid-tar).
Compared to LA Bold and Dunhill Kretek Filter, both of which are in the mid-tar
segment (tar level of 18-25mg), Surya Pro is priced at a more competitive price.
Based on our channel check, Surya Professional red is priced at IDR16,200, while
Dunhill Kretek Filter and LA Bold are priced at IDR17,900 and IDR20,600,
respectively.
GGRM is currently trading at 17.8x 2018F P/E, at relatively much cheaper compared
to its counterpart, HMSP, which is trading at 34.3x 2018F P/E. We believe the
company’s discounted valuation as compared to HMSP is merely due to its less
visible capex. The company has not disclosed its plan for expansion in the near
term as it is yet to plan for the launching of new products. However, their plan to
construct an airport in Kediri, as well as expanding to air transportation business
under Surya Air label (GGRM has established a 100% owned subsidiary, PT Surya
Air), remains a key concern for investors.
Nevertheless, we believe that should GGRM spend a high capex in the future, it will
translate into a strong revenue generation. As evident, the company was successful
in selling and promoting GG Mild products (launched in April 2013). Meanwhile, we
believe GGRM valuation is currently very attractive given the expectation of strong
full flavor sales volume, as well as less competition in the cigarettes industry post
recent regulation on PMK that specifies minimum cigarette retail selling prices at
the maximum discount of 15% from government’s suggested retail price (HJE). We
view this as an advantage for big players, including GGRM, as we believe its market
share will be maintained going forward.
(x) GGRM
HMSP
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
-
1/4/2013 1/4/2014 1/4/2015 1/4/2016 1/4/2017
Financial forecast
Expect double-digit topline growth for 2018F
We expect GGRM to book 10.5% YoY topline growth in 2018F, chiefly on the back of
higher average selling price (ASP) of c.8% to offset the higher excise tax and other
raw material price increases in the cost of goods sold. We forecast flattish volume
growth for GGRM’s SKT segment and 1% volume growth for GGRM’s SKM segment
as the company sees more potentials in the SKM full-flavor segment. As full-
flavored segment has a lower tobacco cost compared to SKT, we expect the
segment will stabilize GGRM’s gross margin going forward. GGRM has higher
inventory compared to HMSP in order to secure a large amount of tobacco (due to
ageing process) and cloves (due to fluctuating prices). Thus, we believe the
company is able to overcome fluctuating raw material prices.
Figure 89. Revenue forecast Figure 90. Stable gross margin forecast
IDRbn Revenue growth IDRbn Gross profit (L) Gross profit margin (R)
100,000 20%
25,000 23%
90,000 18%
20,000 4% 5,000
18%
10,000 2%
0 0% - 17%
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 F 2018 F 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 F 2018 F
Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research
We expect GGRM to book a robust free cash flow going forward as the company
needs less capex compared to five years ago (2011-2015). In addition, given a lesser
capex going forward, we estimate a stable payout ratio going forward at 75%
(similar to 2017F), and expect higher dividend per share going forward.
Figure 91. Free cash flow and capex as % of sales Figure 92. Dividend and payout ratio
IDRbn Free Cash Flow (L) Capex as % of sales (R) IDRbn Dividend (L) Dividend per share (L)
8,000 12% Payout ratio (R)
7,000 90%
6,000 10% 78% 75%
75% 75% 80%
6,000
70%
4,000 8% 5,000
60%
4,000 50%
2,000 6%
3,000 40%
- 4% 30%
2,000
20%
(2,000) 2% 1,000
10%
- 0%
(4,000) 0% 2011 2013 2015 2017 F 2019 F
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 F 2018 F
Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research Source: Company data, Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research
Valuations
We initiate our coverage on GGRM with a trading buy rating and a target price of
IDR91,000/share, which was derived using DCF with a 7-year life span. Our WACC
assumption of 9.5% is derived from the following assumptions: Risk free (Rf) rate of
6.5%, market risk premium (MRP) of 5%, terminal growth rate of 3%, and equity
beta of 0.9x.
GGRM is currently trading at slightly above its 5-year average P/E at 17.8x forward
P/E, 48% discount from HMSP which is trading at 34.3x. We are taken with GGRM as
the company is projected to register higher free cash flow, stable margins, and
benefits from lesser competition from smaller players in the market given the
company’s strong position in the SKM FF segment.
24
22 +2 Std Dev
20
+1 Std Dev
18
Avg PER
16
-1 Std Dev
14
12 -2 Std Dev
10
01/13 01/14 01/15 01/16 01/17
APPENDIX 1
Disclosures
As of the publication date, PT Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia, and/or its affiliates do not have any special interest with the subject company and do not own
1% or more of the subject company's shares outstanding.
Analyst Certification
Opinions expressed in this publication about the subject securities and companies accurately reflect the personal views of the Analysts primarily responsible
for this report. Except as otherwise specified herein, the Analysts have not received any compensation or any other benefits from the subject companies in
the past 12 months and have not been promised the same in connection with this report. No part of the compensation of the Analysts was, is, or will be
directly or indirectly related to the specific recommendations or views contained in this report but, like all employees of PT Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia
Indonesia, the Analysts receive compensation that is impacted by overall firm profitability, which includes revenues from, among other business units, the
institutional equities, investment banking, proprietary trading and private client division. At the time of publication of this report, the Analysts do not know
or have reason to know of any actual, material conflict of interest of the Analyst or PT Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Indonesia except as otherwise stated
herein.
Disclaimers
This report is published by PT Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Indonesia (“Daewoo”), a broker-dealer registered in the Republic of Indonesia and a member
of the Indonesia Exchange. Information and opinions contained herein have been compiled from sources believed to be reliable and in good faith, but such
information has not been independently verified and Daewoo makes no guarantee, representation or warranty, express or implied, as to the fairness,
accuracy, completeness or correctness of the information and opinions contained herein or of any translation into English from the Bahasa Indonesia. If this
report is an English translation of a report prepared in the Indonesian language, the original Indonesian language report may have been made available to
investors in advance of this report. Daewoo, its affiliates and their directors, officers, employees and agents do not accept any liability for any loss arising
from the use hereof. This report is for general information purposes only and it is not and should not be construed as an offer or a solicitation of an offer to
effect transactions in any securities or other financial instruments. The intended recipients of this report are sophisticated institutional investors who have
substantial knowledge of the local business environment, its common practices, laws and accounting principles and no person whose receipt or use of this
report would violate any laws and regulations or subject Daewoo and its affiliates to registration or licensing requirements in any jurisdiction should receive
or make any use hereof. Information and opinions contained herein are subject to change without notice and no part of this document may be copied or
reproduced in any manner or form or redistributed or published, in whole or in part, without the prior written consent of Daewoo. Daewoo, its affiliates and
their directors, officers, employees and agents may have long or short positions in any of the subject securities at any time and may make a purchase or sale,
or offer to make a purchase or sale, of any such securities or other financial instruments from time to time in the open market or otherwise, in each case
either as principals or agents. Daewoo and its affiliates may have had, or may be expecting to enter into, business relationships with the subject companies to
provide investment banking, market-making or other financial services as are permitted under applicable laws and regulations. The price and value of the
investments referred to in this report and the income from them may go down as well as up, and investors may realize losses on any investments. Past
performance is not a guide to future performance. Future returns are not guaranteed, and a loss of original capital may occur.
71
Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research
November 20, 2017 Tobacco
Distribution
United Kingdom: This report is being distributed by Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia (Europe) Ltd. in the United Kingdom only to (i) investment
professionals falling within Article 19(5) of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Financial Promotion) Order 2005 (the “Order”), and (ii) high net
worth companies and other persons to whom it may lawfully be communicated, falling within Article 49(2)(A) to (E) of the Order (all such persons together
being referred to as “Relevant Persons”). This report is directed only at Relevant Persons. Any person who is not a Relevant Person should not act or rely on
this report or any of its contents.
United States: This report is distributed in the U.S. by Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia (America) Inc., a member of FINRA/SIPC, and is only intended for
major institutional investors as defined in Rule 15a-6(b)(4) under the U.S. Securities Exchange Act of 1934. All U.S. persons that receive this document by
their acceptance thereof represent and warrant that they are a major institutional investor and have not received this report under any express or implied
understanding that they will direct commission income to Daewoo or its affiliates. Any U.S. recipient of this document wishing to effect a transaction in any
securities discussed herein should contact and place orders with Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia (America) Inc., which accepts responsibility for the
contents of this report in the U.S. The securities described in this report may not have been registered under the U.S. Securities Act of 1933, as amended,
and, in such case, may not be offered or sold in the U.S. or to U.S. persons absent registration or an applicable exemption from the registration requirements.
Hong Kong: This document has been approved for distribution in Hong Kong by Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia (Hong Kong) Ltd., which is regulated by
the Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission. The contents of this report have not been reviewed by any regulatory authority in Hong Kong. This
report is for distribution only to professional investors within the meaning of Part I of Schedule 1 to the Securities and Futures Ordinance of Hong Kong (Cap.
571, Laws of Hong Kong) and any rules made thereunder and may not be redistributed in whole or in part in Hong Kong to any person.
All Other Jurisdictions: Customers in all other countries who wish to effect a transaction in any securities referenced in this report should contact Daewoo or
its affiliates only if distribution to or use by such customer of this report would not violate applicable laws and regulations and not subject Daewoo and its
affiliates to any registration or licensing requirement within such jurisdiction.
Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia (America) Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia (Europe) Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia (Singapore)
Inc. Ltd. Pte. Ltd.
320 Park Avenue, 31st Floor. 41st Floor, Tower 42 Six Battery Road #11-01
New York, NY 10022 25 Old Broad Street Singapore, 049909
London EC2N 1HQ
United States United Kingdom
Tel: 1-212-407-1000 Tel: 44-20-7982-8000 Tel: 65-6671-9845
72
Mirae Asset Sekuritas Indonesia Research