Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT: Laboratory investigations were carried out on a. residual lateriti~ soil t~eated with qUic~lime (up
to 8% by weight of dry soil) in order to evaluate the effect of lime conten~, cunng penod~ ~d compactlve ef~ort
on the permeability of lateritic soil-lime mixtures prepared at various maximum dry de":sltles and correspo~ding
optimum moisture contents. The permeability of uncured specimens (standard Proctor) mcreased to a maximum
at 4% lime content and decreased with increasing lime content. Specimens compacted at the energy of the West
African Standard had coefficients of permeability that decreased with increasing lime content. .For the cu~ed
condition, the permeability of all the lime-treated specimens compacted at the two energy levels mcreased With
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by Monash University on 03/18/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
curing age up to 14 days and decreased with curing age beyond 14 days.
INTRODUCTION clay particle structure. Many soils compacted drier than OMC
had more random particle orientations and a larger average
Addition of lime to a soil tends to improve its properties as pore size than when compacted wetter than OMC, where ~e
a result of soil-lime reactions. The advantage of this property particles had a more parallel arrangement. The larger the in-
has been utilized mostly for road subgrade stabilization dividual pores for any given total pore area, the greater ~e
("Lime" 1990; Locat et al. 1990; Hammond 1992), although flow would be, since permeability varies as a power functIOn
increasing use is being made of lime stabilization for bulk fill of pore size.
operations, embankments, and cutting slope repai~ ~n~ as a The effect of lime on soil permeability is still not clear.
bearing stratum for lightly loaded foundatIOns. This IS m .ad- Fossberg (1969) reported a decrease of as much as two orders
dition to lime slurry pressure injection, lime columns, and hme of magnitude in the coefficient of permeability with increasing
piles for ground improvement (Rog~rs ~d Bruce 1991; R.og- lime content, and found the decrease to be in direct proportion
ers and Glendinning 1994). Two mam different results of hme to the lime content and curing time. He based his conclusions
action are usually believed to occur in soil-lime mixes. The mainly on the results of consolidometer tests. The samples
first, quick action, occurs immediately on addition of lime and were compacted 1 h after mixing the soil and lime. Townsend
is believed to be due to cation exchange and flocculation. The and Klym (1966), on the other hand, reported a substantial
second reaction, aggregation, which is time-dependent (days
increase in the coefficient of permeability of heavy clay soils
to years), is rather slow. It is attributed to the pozzolanic re- (from 2 X 10- 8 cmls to 4 X 10- 6 cmls). The samples were
actions with formation of cementation compounds (Webb compacted 24 h after mixing the soil and lime and were cured
1992; Rogers and Lee 1994; Narasimha Rao and Rajasekaran as long as 19 weeks, with most of the increase in permeability
1996).
occurring during the first four weeks. The increase in the co-
Lateritic soils, which are defined by the ISSMFE Progress
efficient of permeability was explained in terms of the addi-
Report ("Peculiarities" 1985) as soils belonging to .horizo~ A tional flocculation that occurred during the elapsed time after
or B of well-drained profiles developed under humid trOPiCal mixing prior to compaction. Hunter (1988) explained the in-
climates with clay fraction constituted essentially of the kao-
crease in permeability of lime-treated clay as due to the siltlike
linite group and of iron or aluminium hydrated oxides, can be
mechanical properties imparted on the natural soil.
economically stabilized with lime (Ola 1975). The soil-lime
Lateritic soils are normally utilized as base for road con-
mixture so produced can be used as subbase or base courses
struction and are generally regarded as good foundation ma-
in roads. Moreover, the climate in Nigeria favors this type of
stabilization. terial because they are virtually nonswelling. However, the use
of the material is dependent on the degree of permeability,
One of the most important points taken into consideration
which determines whether the proposed road foundation is
in soil mechanics is the effect of water on the geotechnical
suitable for use. This study offered a good opportunity to in-
properties of soils. Permeability has not been studied as ex-
vestigate the effects of lime content, curing period, and com-
tensively as the other major soil engineering properties like
pactive effort on the coefficient of permeability of lime-treated
strength and compressibility. However, in recent times a sub-
lateritic soil specimens obtained from mixtures prepared at
stantial amount of work has been carried out by various re-
searchers [Ola (1983), Finno et al. (1996), Yin et al. (1996), their maximum dry densities and corresponding optimum
moisture contents.
Nuik and Singh (1997), and others] on permeability.
In his study of the permeability of compacted clay. Mitchell JUSTIFICATION FOR STUDY
(1976) found that the permeability of compacted clay samples
on the dry side of optimum moisture content (OMC) for stan- Quite a large amount of research has been conducted on the
dard compaction was many times higher than on the wet side. effect of lime on the strength properties of soils in the last two
The reason for this phenomenon was explained in terms of decades, but permeability has received far less attention. How-
ever, these researches were mostly carried out on temperate-
'Sr. Lect.. Dept. of Civ. Engrg.• Ahmadu Bello Univ., Zaria, Kaduna zone soils, which are significantly different from tropical re-
State, Nigeria. sidual soils. Unlike the sedimentary soils of temperate zones,
Note. Discussion open until March I, 1999. To extend the closing date the soil deposits generally referred to as lateritic soil have been
one month, a written request must be filed with the ASCE Manager of
Journals. The manuscript for this paper was submitted for review and
known to possess complex macro- and microfabric (Da Fon-
possible publication on September 2, 1997. This paper is part of the toura 1985), texture, and structure (Melfi 1985) due to their
Journal of Transportation Engineering. Vol. 124, No.5, Septemberl morphological features. The response of lateritic soils to sta-
October, 1998. ©ASCE. ISSN 0733-947X198/0005-0465-0469/$8.00 + bilization using different additives also relates significantly to
$.50 per page. Paper No. 16546. the genetic (morphological, physical, chemical, and minera-
JOURNAL OF TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING 1 SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 1998/465
Permeability Tests
The compaction mold with the specimen in it was used as ------ Stan. Proctor
part of the permeameter in order to eliminate disturbance of - + - - West African SIan.
the specimens on extrusion from the molds. The falling head
test was adopted for the investigation. The first step in carrying
out the permeability test was to saturate the specimen in the
mold. The saturation process involved placing the perme-
ameter in a small water container. A transparent plastic hose
12 -1-------\------+-------+------
was connected between the opening at the top of the cell cap
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by Monash University on 03/18/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
2 4 6 8
and an electric suction pump. The function of the suction Lime Content, %
pump was to accelerate the saturation of the specimen by elim- FIG. 3. Variation of OMC of li'eated Lateritic 5011 with Lime
inating entrapped air in the voids as much as possible before Content
"sucking" water in order to saturate it. The permeability tests
were performed in accordance with BS 1377 ("Methods" soil. Sodium hexametaphosphate, which is considered most
1990). and the coefficients of permeability reported are the effective as dispersant for these lateritic soils (Gidigasu and
average of five tests per specimen performed on three speci- Kuma 1987) was used in the sedimentation analysis. The over-
mens for any given parameter. all geotechnical index properties of the soil show that it can
be classified under the A-7-6 subgroup of the AASHTO Soil
TEST RESULTS AND ANALYSIS
Classification System (Standard 1986) and CL in the Unified
Identification of Soil Soil Classification System ("Soil" 1993). It is a reddish
brown, well graded soil with a relatively high plasticity of 20%
Table 1 summarizes the geotechnical index properties of the and clay content of not more than 12%.
natural soil. Fig. 1 shows the particle size distribution of the
100 Compaction Characteristics
The effects of lime content on the maximum dry density
80 (MDD) and OMC of lateritic soil for the two compactive ef-
forts are shown in Figs. 2 and 3. respectively. The MDD de-
70
creased with increase in lime content. The decrease in MDD
with increasing lime content conforms with the usual trend
and is in agreement with Ladd et al. (1960) as well as Marks
and Haliburton (1970). The decrease resulted from the floc-
culation and agglomeration of clay particles. caused by the
cation exchange reaction, leading to corresponding decreases
in dry densities (Lees et al. 1982).
The decrease in OMC for the soil-lime mixtures at the en-
10
ergy of the standard Proctor for low lime contents is in agree-
ment with Ladd et al. (1960) as well as Marks and Haliburton
0+-----;-----+----+------1 (1970). When lime dissociates in the presence of water into
0.001 0.01 0.1
Particle size, mm
10 calcium and hydroxyl ions. either of two situations arises. The
calcium ions either replace cations of other elements present
FI,G. 1. Particle Size Distribution of Natural 5011 at the exchange sites in the soil. or the calcium ions are ab-
1.11
sorbed by the soil if there are other unattached anions. apart
from hydroxyl ions. on the soil surface. The decrease in OMC
I
was due to a cation exchange reaction. which caused floccu-
'")1.88
I--~'~
west
-+- Afrtc8n . . .
lation of clay particles. It has been reported (Millard 1993)
that when lime is added to soil the calcium ions replace the
C sodium ions in the clay fraction until the latter becomes sat-
Q
~1.82
urated with calcium and the pH rises to more than 12. The
~
conversion from sodium to calcium ions produced a marked
i reduction in the apparent plasticity of the soil. But the poz-
Q
~1.7s zolanic reaction of lime with clay fraction of the soil is re-
Q ported (Ola 1978) to cause an increase of OMC noticed at
5
E
higher lime contents. At the energy level of the West African
1 1 74
.
Standard. the OMC increased with increasing lime content in
conformity with reported cases.
~2500 T
..-< 1 P - Standard Proctor ., 3.00E·OS
~
~OOO j
I
WA - West Aflican Standard
"5
f; I ~2.5OE.OS
~ x~x ~
+6~.%===>.-:: i
r / -------- 7 days (P)
1!1000V;/~
500
--+-- 28 days (P) '0
--<>--- 7 days ryvA)
1i 1.5OE-Q5
'0
'tl 1./'/
- x - 14 days ryvA)
~ 1.00e-QS
Co)
CIl x
c ------- 28 days ryvA)
'E
8c 500 S.ooe-Qll
::::>
O.OOE+OO
Downloaded from ascelibrary.org by Monash University on 03/18/13. Copyright ASCE. For personal use only; all rights reserved.
o j-.'~~~l'-I~~---jl~~~-+-~~- 0 2 4 e e
Lime Content, %
o 2 4 8 8
Lime Content, %
FIG. 5. Variation of Coefficient of Permeability of Uncured
FIG. 4. Variation of UCS of Treated lateritic Soli with Lime Treated lateritic Soli with Lime Content
Content
1.00E+02
P - Standard Proctor
14, and 28 days, respectively. The improvement in strength of WA - West Aflican Standard
8% lime content. Millard, R. S. (1993). "Cement and lime stabilization." Road building
The permeability of all the cured lime-treated specimens in the tropics. State-of-the-art review, Vol. 9, Transportation Research
prepared at the two energy levels considered increased with Laboratory, 183-185.
curing age up to 14 days and decreased up to the maximum Mitchell, J. K. (1976). Fundamentals of soil behaviour. John Wiley &
Sons, Inc., New York, N.Y.
28-day curing period considered. Specimens compacted at the Nandy, R. M., and Handy R. L. (1977). "Simple field controls for soil-
energy levels of the standard Proctor and West African Stan- lime construction." Civ. Engrg., ASCE, 60-66.
dard showed peak permeabilities at 4 and 6% lime contents, Narasimha Rao, S., and Rajasekaran, G. (1996). "Reaction products
respectively. Recorded permeability values increased from formed in lime-stabilized marine clays." J. Geotech. Engrg., ASCE,
3.38 X 10-' and 2.29 X 10- 6 cm/s for uncured specimens to 122(5), 329-336.
Nuik, T. R., and Singh, S. S. (1997). "Permeability of flowable slurry
2.1 X 10- 3 and 1.0 X 10- 4 cm/s, respectively, at 14 days' materials containing foundry sand and fly ash." J. Geotech. and
curing period and decreased to 1.9 X 10-4 and 4.0 X 10-' Geoenvir. Engrg., ASCE, 123(5), 446-452.
cm/s, respectively, at 28 days' curing period. O'Flaherty, C. A. (1974). Highway engineering. Vol. 2, Edward Arnold,
London, U.K.
Ola, S. A. (1975). "Stabilization of Nigerian lateritic oils with cement,
APPENDIX. REFERENCES bitumen and lime." Proc. 6th Regional Conj. for Africa on Soil Mech.
and Found. Engrg., Vol. I, 145-152.
Akintola, F. A. (1982). "Geology and geomorphology." Nigeria in maps, Ola, S. A. (1978). "Geotechnical properties and behaviour of some sta-
R. M. Babour, ed., Hodder and Stoughton, London, U.K. bilized Nigerian lateritic soils." Q.J. Engrg. Geol., London, U.K., 11,
Areola, O. (1982). "Soils." Nigeria in maps, R. M. Babour, ed., Hodder 145-160.
and Stoughton, London, U.K. Ola, S. A. (1983). "Permeability of some compacted Nigerian soils."
Da Fontoura, S. A. (1985). "Shear strength of undisturbed tropical lat- Tropical soils of Nigeria in engineering practice, S. A. Ola, Ed., A. A.
eritic soils." ISSMFE Progress Rep. (1982/85), Committee on Tropical Balkema, The Netherlands, Rotterdam, 155 -171.
Soils, International Society of Soil Mechanics and Foundations Engi- "Peculiarities of geotechnical behaviour of tropical lateritic and saprolitic
neering,47-66. soils." (1985). ISSMFE Progress Rep. (1982/1985), Committee on
Finno, R. J., Chung, K. Y., Yin, J., and Feldkamp, J. R. (1996). "Coef- Tropical Soils, International Society of Soil Mechanics and Founda-
ficient of permeability from AC electroosmosis experiments. II: Re- tions Engineering.
sults." J. Geotech. Engrg., ASCE, 122(5), 355-364. Rogers, C. D. F., and Bruce, C. J. (1991). "Slope stabilization using
Fossberg, P. E. (1969). "Some fundamental engineering properties of lime." Proc. Int. Conf. on Slope Stability Engrg., Institution of Civil
lime-stabilized clay." Hwy. Res. Rec. 236, Highway Research Board, Engineering, London, U.K.
Washington, D.C., 19-26. Rogers, C. D. F., and Glendinning, S. (1994). "Deep-slope stabilization
Gidigasu, M. D. (1980). "Variability of geotechnical properties of using lime piles." Transp. Res. Rec. 1440, Transportation Research
subgrade soils in a residual profile over phylite." Proc. 7th Regional Board, Washington, D.C., 63-70.
Conf. for Africa on Soil Mech. and Found. Engrg., Vol. 1,95-104. Rogers, C. D. F., and Lee, S. J. (1994). "Drained shear strength of lime-
Gidigasu, M. D. (1988). "Potential application of engineering pedology clay mixes." Transp. Res. Rec. 1440, Transportation Research Board,
in shallow foundation engineering on tropical residual soils." Proc. Washington, D.C., 53-62.
2nd Int. Conf. on Geomechanics in Tropical Soils, Vol. I, 17-24. "Soil and rock; dimension stone; geosynthetics." (1993). Annual book
Gidigasu, M. D., and Kuma, D. O. K. (1987). "Engineering significance of ASTM standards, ASTM, Philadelphia, Pa.
of laterization and profile development processes." Proc. 9th Regional
Standard specifications for transportation materials and methods ofsam-
pling and testing. (1986). 14th Ed., American Association of State
Conf. for Africa on Soil Mech. and Found. Engrg., Vol. 1,3-20.
Highway and Transportation Officials, Washington, D.C.
Gidigasu, M. D., and Yeboa, S. L. (1972). "The significance of pretesting
Townsend, D. L., and Klym, T. W. (1966). "Durability of lime stabilized
preparations in evaluating index properties of lateritic materials." Hwy. soils." Hwy. Res. Rec. 139, Highway Research Board, Washington,
Res. Rec. 405, Highway Research Board, Washington, D.C., 105-106. D.C., 25-41.
Hammond, A. A. (1992). "Manufacture and use of lime and pozzolana Vaughan, P. R. (1985). "Mechanical and hydraulic properties of in situ
cements in Africa." Lime and other alternative cements, Neville Hill, residual soils." Proc. 1st Int. Conf. on Geomechanics in Tropical and
Stafford Holmes, and David Mather, eds., Intermediate Technology Saprolitic Soils, Vol. 3, 1-33.
Publications, London, U.K., 35-46. Webb, D. J. T. (1992). "Lime stabilized soil blocks for Third World
Hunter, D. (1988). "Lime-induced heave in sulfate-bearing clay soils." housing." Lime and other alternative cements, Neville Hill, Stafford
J. Geotech. Engrg., ASCE, 114(2), 150-167. Holmes, and David Mather, eds., Intermediate Technology
Ladd, C. C., Moh, Z. C., and Lambe, T. W. (1960). "Recent soil-lime Publications, London, U.K., 246-257.
research at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology." Presented at Yin, J., Finno, R. J., Feldkamp, J. R., and Chung, K. Y. (1996). "Coef-
39th Annual Meeting, Highway Research Board, Washington, D.C. ficient of permeability from AC electroosmosis experiments. I: The-
Lees, G., Abdelkader, M. P., and Hamdani, S. K. (1982). "Effect of clay ory." J. Geotech. Engrg., ASCE, 122(5),346-354.