Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A RTIC
of theInternalBodin ATP
InquiryFigure9.15:ls theBotation
Synthase Responsible forATPSynthesis?
for ReadingThisArticle
Guiding Questions
A. AbouttheArticle
1. What is the name of the first authorof this researchteam?
2. Most of the authorsof this paper work in major researchlaboratoriesin what nation?What is the name of the author af-
filiated with the Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory in the United States?
3 . What is the nameof thej ournalin which this article was published?This paperwas publishedin what month and yearI
1-l Inquiry in Action: Interpreting Scientific Papers
l. This research was supported in part by grants from what organization? (See Acknowledgements, p. a68.)
5. The afticle's abstract(p. 465, first paragraph,in bold print) summarizesthe major contributions of the study.Write the
one sentencefrom the abstractthat statesthe basic concept for which the study provides direct evidence.
hydrolysis
luciferase
photon
9. The researchersmanipulated a single subunit of the AIP synthasecomplex, the y (gamma) subunit' Prior to this study,
what aspectof the y subunitin Fl reversalhad not yet beentested?
Article 3: Inquiry Figure 9.15
10. One end of the Fl test complex was attachedto a glassslide by modifying two cysteineamino acidsof one end of the
complex. The other end of the F1 test complex, the y end, was attachedto a magnetic bead using a specific attachment
protein (streptavidin).Examine the experimental setupin Figure | (p. 466).Although the drawing in Figure 1a is not to
scale,which is the larger element, the Fl protein complex or the magnetic bead?How did the investigatorsmanipulate
this systemto causethe y end of the complex to rotate?
11. The investigatorsnoted that during ATP hydrolysis,the complex rotated in one direction.What reactiondid they hy-
pothesizewould occur if the complexwas rotatedin the oppositedirection?
13. Figure 3a showsthe numberof photonsdetectedwith respectto rotation of the y-subunitof the ATP synthase.N, S, and
H refer to what three rotation states?In Figure 3a, the relative number of photons detectedis highest at which type of
rotation-N. S. or H?
14. In the control experimentsgraphed in Figure 3b, the broken lines show the lowest number of photons detected.What
was different aboutthoseexperimentsto producesuch low numbers?Why did this omissionserveas a control for the
experiment?
16 Inquirl- in Action: Interpreting ScientificPapers
letters to nature
.,,olumeof medium per active F1 molecule had to be small' the magnets were tumed off' AlP-driven rotation resumed'
First, we tried to reduce the volume by making microdroplets in Si'nthesiswas shown in the ADP-luciferase medium by accumu-
oii (Fig. 2a). Figure 2b shows data fiom a 4 x 4 array of droplets in iating chemiluminescence photons over a series of 5-min intervals
one chimber. The beadsin droplets were rotated at 10Hz alternately in wfrich the magnetic field was rotated at 10Hz in either direction
for 5 min each in the direction of hydrolysis (anticlockwise when or tumed off. all seriesproduced the expectedpattern (Fig' 3a):
viewed from top irl Fig. 1a) and synthesis(clockwise)' As seenin higher photon counts during ciockwise rotation (S, synthesis) than
Fig. 2b, 14 out of 16 droplet cuwes showedthe M-shaped pattem of cluling anticlockwiserotation (H, hydrolysis) or no rotation (N)'
photon counts exPectedfor the sequenceofrotation direction when This graph compiles ali data taken in consecutive experiments
ihe overall decline was taken into account. The decline was due to (aUoui half of the experiments failed at some point, for exainple
the gradual disappearanceof the aqueous phase into oii: although during chamber preparation or because of a large focus drift, and
we iaturated the oil with water before the experiment, droplets did nJt produce data)' Mechanical synthesisin the flat chamber was
tended to shrink crver time. For random photon counts, the reproducible, although variation among data rvas stiil large'
probability of observing a sianting M shape is 8 '. The probability We note that irl most curves shown in Fig. 3a including the total
ofobserving14ormore M shapesoutof 16is 2 x 10-11.The dataset counts, counts during anticlockwise rotation (H) are higher than
shown in Fig. 2b thus strongly indicates mechanical synthesis' Th-e those at no rotation (N). This is due to the presenceof F1 at the
experiment is extremely difficult (at most a ferv beads rotate in each ceiling of the chamber as stated above' For these upside-down F1
droplet), however, and we have obtained only a few more data sets mole.-.,I.s, anticlockwise bead rotation will drive ATP s1'nthesis'
that contained severalM-shaped patterns. Indeed, when we flipped the chamber upside down after obtaining
We thus tried to increase the number of rotating beads in an the unbrokenblue ii"e in Fig. 3a' the count Patternwasreversed,as
ordinary obserwation chamber (Fig. 1c) by infusing a concentrated shown by the broken blue line. Another reason for the higher counts
solution ofbeads carrying F1.To aliow F1 to rotate in the proper durilg anticlockwise rotation was that luciferase did not consume
direction, we derivatized only the bottom surface of the chamber a1lof ihe newly synthesizedAIP in 5 min: as shown by the unbroken
with nickel nitrilo-triacetic acid (Ni2+-NTA), which would specifi- lines in Fig. 3b, the luminescence at no rotation lvas high after ATP
cally bind the $-histidines. In control experiments done in 4mM synthesis it the arrows. Luminescence decay after AIP mixing was
AIP (no ADP) and without magnets,we found in the fieid of view of sirown to involve a comPonent with a lifetime of about 3 min (see
1.0x 105pmt us many as 480 | 70 F1 molecules rotating anti- Supplementary Information). Thking aii of the above points into
clockwise at the bottom {three chambers). However, the high aciount, we consider that mechanical synthesis has been conclu-
density of beads resulted in nonspecific binding to the ceiling, sively demonstrated.
where 100 + 20 beads rotated clockvrise (as viewed from above the Figure 4 shows the effect of rotary speed on the efficiency of
chamber). We also tested in the AIP medium rvhether forced ATP synthesis. The synthesis rate apparently saturated above 3 Hz
(fig. +U). This was becauselarger beadsor bead aggregatesfailed to
rotation by external magnets would damage F1. After confirming
AlP-<lriven rotation, we turned on the magrets and applied several rotite at high speeds,as confirmed by direct obserwation (uncou-
bursts of hundreds of revolutions at l0 Hz in both directions'When pling betwJen magnet and bead rotations)' Calibration of the
i'-i
Magn€tie bead
$lrertavidjn *: i:
Gal}i1lcompiex i, j.
li:_lis,
boMaonet d
%8
g6pp16._=-.--i1-";''n:-
ffi
Ob je ctivele n s._| I
-F- I
1
I
l'ij. lffase
r.i"* E+
._-> Frce€ssing
system
Ph+tcncounlingcaFr€ra;ncoalinghouse
Figu re1 Exp erin r ent als et - up' a, Bas ic des ign' The s t r u c t u r e s o {F 1 a n d s t r e p t a v i d i n a r e N i 2 *- N T A v l a s a p p | i e d o n | y t o th e b o tto m su a ce '
fromref.2landrcL22.respectively.Thebeadisnottoscaleandtheorientationof ontheceiling.d,Topvlewofthernagnets
isunknown.
streptavidin b, Sideview of the system.
optical c, Observation chamDer.
NATURE VOL427 29 IANUARY 2004 twnaturc'com/Earure
@2004 NaturePublishingGrouP
1E Inquiry in,\cfion : Interpreting Scientific Papers
letters to nature
Sample d.oF,ets i\ergi't 3 um. dJanelH 30 Fml
otr oa:te'ned area coated 4,th P'i, ' NTA 20Sx103
30
o
*zs 150
o
n
Er o tr
q E
100e
E 15 G
b
b10
E 50
z-
b ?sF
0
E 150
's bss
s
+
6 rcO 30
E E
*zs
d
a
Ezo
g
0
E1s
Figure2 Rotationalsynthesisinmicrodroplets. chamber
a, Observation 0nthesilanized
h {n
bottom coverglass,4 x 4 spotsseparatedby-50 pmandmeasuring 20-30pmujere ts t f#[."*;;;:
E
derivatizedwithNi2+NTA, whichrendered thespotshydrophilic,Anoillayer witha
z- : ;i-:=i:EES;lt ,
thicknessof .'3mmwasplacedontop Usingaglassmicropipette,weformedadroplet c
thesolutionwithonecontaining N H SH S H N S H S H N ]
of - 1pl conlainingF, oneachspotandthenreplaced
beads, ADP, phosphate andthe chemiiuminescencesystem b,Simultaneous observation
Thickmagenta
of 16 droplets, curvewithopencircles ihesumofallunbroken Figure3 Rotational
represenls synthesis in a flatchamber. Eachsymbol shows thenumber of
cuTvest errorbarsrepresent + 2q whereo istheexpected s d, forphotonstatlstics photonsdetectedover5mininanimageareaof 7,8x 104pm2 N,norotation;H,10-Hz
(square rooi0f thetotalcount).Thebrokencurveat thebottom represents a controlin rotationinthehydrolysis direction (forF1onthebottom ofthechamber); S,10 Hzrotation
whichanareaoutside wasimaged.
thedroplets SeeSupplementary Informationfor inthesynthesis direction. a, Results from12chambers, distinguishedbydifferent
details. colours. Broken bluecurve repfesents results
obtainedafterthechamber gtvingrisetothe
unbroken blue curve was flipped upside do\.n. Thickmagenta curuewith open circles
represents thesumof allunbroken curves;err0rbarsrepresent + 4o (>99,99%
confidence). Forclarity, somecun/es havebeen shifted withint 1,000counts
verlically
photon-to-ATP ratio (seeSupplementaryInformation) indicated a b, Control experiments. Unbroken curves showresults without
either orwith
rotation
ivnthesis rate of about five molecules of ATP per second under imposed clockwise rotation forsynthesis at 10 Hz(arrows).Broken curuesshow
rotation at 3Hz, as compared with the nine molecules of AIP per experiments carried outasina exceptthat phosphate wasomitted fromthemedium. The
second expectedfor the one AIP molecule per 120' schemeu. counts inihebroken curves arelowin comparison to theothers because phosphate
Although Fig. 4 represents our best data so far and variation tended toincrease thebackground, apparently byincreasingthepodion ofluciferaseihat
arnong chambers is large (Fig. 3a), we anticipate that the coupling reacted ATP
v,rith extremely slowly $ee Supplementary Information)
between mechanical rotation of the 1-subunit and chemical syn-
thesis is tight, at least at 1ow speeds.The significant synthesisat low
speeds (Fig. 4), which were much lower than the maximal rotary
speed of 130H2 of this motor during AIP hydrolysisr3,merits Information). If F1, or the motor enzyme myosin, is mixed with
attention. Becausethe slow rotation was at a constant speed,it is high concentrationsofADP and phosphatein the absenceofATR
likely that chemical reactions were at quasi-equilibrium at all angles' some AIP is spontaneously formed on the enzyme without input of
Rotation by ATP hydrolysis can also be made slow and at a constant energvlt-tu. This, however, is a dead-end reaction and the AIP that
speed by attaching a long actin filament to the 1-subunit8, again has been formed is not availabie in the medium: releaseof the tightly
suggestingquasi-equilibrium. The implication is that ATP slmthesis bound ATP requires an external supply of energyt'lt.
in-F1 proceeds as a straightforward reversal of the hydrolysis Here we have demonstratedrepetitivesynthesisby F1 (-10'ATP
reaction, tracking the same reaction pathway in the opposite molecules in 5min), leading to aPpearanceof the product in the
direction. On that pathway, both hydrolysis and slnthesis reactions medium. To our knowledge, this is the first accomplishinent of
are controlled by one mechanical handie' the rotary angle of the
rotary artificial chemical s1'nthesisby a vectorial force (although nature
1-subunit. The situation contrasts with the more complex presumably has been doing this for millions of years)' Pressure
motor of bacterial flageila, where rotational directions can be
could also shift a chemical equilibrium by actirg on substrates(and
switched without reversing the proton motive forcetn.
solvent); however, in our experiments the chemical equilibrium
AIP synthesis is a chemical reaction that is energetically uphill,
per seis on the side of almost complete hydrolysis, and a force on a
requiring 80-100 pN nm ofenergy under physiologicalconditions'?'
In the experiments shown here, contaminant AIP amounted to poilt remote &om substrates counters the hydrolysis reaction and
to the point offavouring s1'nthesis'Because
about I irM, impiying that roughly 30 pN nm of fiee energy was pushes the equilibrium
needed per molecule of ATP synthesized (see Supplementary r.vestill have to rely on nature's nanomachine, the F1 motor' our
theoretical predictionst'le should be our next task' The key is to enaSv of AIP binding to myosin Biotleu Biophys Res'Contuut 57' 7og
716 ( ra74)
obtair magnetic beads that are small and uniform in size' n 18, MmnheqH.G.,Schenck,H &Goody,R s SynrhesisofATPfiomADPmdinorgmicphosPhateat
(1974)
the myosin-subftagment I adive site Ezf, / Biachetu 48,287 295
slnthm N|tu|e 396' 279-282
19. Wang" H. & Ostel G Energy bansductiol in the F1 flotor ofAlP
Methods f1998).
is not irfuenced by subsitution
Materials 20. Oishi, N. & Sugi, H Ift riho AIP dePendent F anin sliding on myosin
(199'1)
I210C or removal ofbound nucleotid,e Biochitu BioPhys''4caa 1185' 346-349
A mutant q3031 subcomplex (comprising Cl93S o , Histo-S-, and S107C' I1-AlPase with
subunits; ;eierred to Fr in this paper), derived ftom the themophilic Bacillro strain 2L Menz, R. L, Wa.lker I E & Lsliq A G w' Strudue of bovine mitochondrial
^/ "s (ref 8) Streptavidin-coated nucleotide bound to all tluee catallti. sitsr inplicaions for tie nechoism of rotary catalysis Cell
PS3, wro biotinylated at the only cl'steineson the 1 subunit
magnetic beads (Seradln; nominally 0 7 pm) were lighdy centifuged to remove large 106,331-341 (2001).
R E shdural studis of the
beais and aggregates(but elimination nas incomplete) Biotinylated Ft
(400PM) w6 22. Freitag S., Tiong I L, K1umb, L, SbFos' P S & StenkmP'
(1997)
(N-morpholino)propanesulphonic streptavidin binding looP Ptoz;n S.j. 6' 1157-1166
ircrb"t"d-ithb""ds(-50pM)inbufferA(50mM3
with buffer
acid/KOH, 20 mM KrSOa 4 mM MgSOa, pH 7'6) for 10 min at 23 "C, wmhed
Kikkoman Co We
A, md concentrated with a magnet. Luciferaser2was a kind gift from Supplementary Inft rmaton accompmies the Paper on www'natrlre'Gfln/nature'
(App)ied
purified ADP (K-salt; Sigma) as described'oon a Poros HQIL coiumn
Photonia KK who
Biosystems). Acknowledgements We thmt T. Hayakawa md T' Hiruma of Hmmatsu
for the idea of using
allowed H.I. to work on this project for more than 6 learsj S Brenrer
chamber
0bservation microdropletsi M. Sugai for initial work; M. Shio, menbers ofthe
fomer CREST Team 1l and the
Mizuoo' K Suzuki' S Llchiyama
Forthechambershominlig. Ic,a32/.24mm2coverglasswasfunctionalizedbyasilane curent Kirosita and Yosh'ida labomtorie for help and advice; I
reacted first with and H N'fiyaiima for the magneic
coupling agent with m SH group (TSL 83801GE Toshiba Silicone)'and and Y. Mizuguchi for the photon-counting system; C Gosse
i paallel
ro rril maleimide Cr-NTe-1oojindo) and then with i0 mM NiCl, Two tweas; K. Abe and K. Rikukawa for nicroscopy; S Murakami for lucifercq and H' Umsaw
-g of Lumirror polyester film (TORAY) were placed on the covergis' and a
strips and M. Fukatsu for labomtory management. This rvork was supPofied
in Part by Gnnts-in-Aid
top to form a
t8 x ts mmz cot"rglus coated with hexamethyldisilazanewas placed on from the MinistryofEduetion, Cultue, SPo{is, Science andTqlhrologyof lapan' and Bunoughs
Ar (buftbr A
flow chmber. We inft*d -soo plt t1-conjugated magnetic beads in buffer Wellcome Fund (R.Y).
3 mgml-1 bovine serum albumin (BSA)) md incubated the chamber tbr
containing
10 pM
:O min at"z:'C. efter infusing buffer A: severaltimes, buffer A containing competingfinancial
1
BSA' together CompetingIntefestsstatsnent The authorsdedre that they haveno
luciferase, 1 mM luciferin, i0 mM K2Poa, 200 pM ADP and 1 5 mg ml
eventuallysere 1tr1erss.
with a small number of 3-pm DlnabeadsM-280 beads(Dynal) thatwould
upper coverglas
as spacers,wx infused. The spacerstrips were arefully removed.md rhe
the spacerbeads' Conespondence ud requsts for malerialsshouldbe addrssed to H I
*^ p."rrud ao reduce the chmber height to -3 pm, as determined by
(hiiloh@hpk.trc-net.cojP).
The chmter wc then sealed with wu and subjected to observation'