Professional Documents
Culture Documents
—
New York, November 4, 1966
So,
So they were preparing just to satisfy the demigod Indra, because he was
supposed to... Not supposed. Actually he supplies rains sufficiently. Wit-
hout rains you cannot have successful agriculture. So they were preparing
that sacrifice. So this preparation was being observed by Kṛṣṇa and Balarā-
ma. Kṛṣṇa is the youngest, and Balarāma is the eldest. Balarāma is son
of Rohiṇī, and Kṛṣṇa is son of Devakī. Both these ladies, Rohiṇī and Devakī,
they were wives of Vasudeva, Kṛṣṇa's father. So Balarāma was born
of Rohiṇī, and Kṛṣṇawas born of Devakī. Devakī-nandana-gopāla. So Deva-
kī-nandana. So They were not very... There was not much difference of
Their age, say one year or two years, like that. So Balarāma was eldest brot-
her. They were playing together, and this is an incidence when Balarā-
ma was about eight years old and Kṛṣṇa was about seven years old. So, bha-
gavān tatraiva baladevena saṁyutaḥ. Bhagavān, the Supreme Personality of
Godhead, Kṛṣṇa, along with Baladeva, His elder brother, apaśyan, "saw."
What is that "saw"? Nivasan gopaindra-yāga-kṛtodyamān: "All the cow-
herds men, including His father, they were preparing for sacrifice of Indra-
yajña." Indra-yajña.
Tad abhijño 'pi. This very word is used here, that "He knew everyt-
hing," Bhagavān. Because Bhagavān means He must know everything, past,
present future. There is no lack of knowledge. I have several times descri-
bed before you. Bhagavān means He is full of all opulences, and there are
six opulences: riches, strength, fame, beauty, knowledge, and renunciation.
So Bhagavāncannot be in lack of knowledge. He must know everything.
That is Bhagavān. So therefore it is said that "What is the use of asking His
father what they were going to do? He knew everything." But it is specifi-
cally mentioned, atad abhijño'pi. Although He knew it, because He was pla-
ying the part of a boy, and the father knew that "Kṛṣṇa is my son..." They
did not recognize Him that He is Personality of Godhead. They knew, "Oh,
He is my ordinary son." Tadabhijño'pi bhagavān sarvātmā. Sarvāt-
mā means one who is situated in everyone's heart. Sarvātmā sarva-
darśanaḥ. Sarva-darśanaḥ means one who can see everything past, present,
and future. Still, praśrāyavantaḥ, "Just like an obedient son, submissive
son," apṛcchad vṛddhān nanda-puro-gamān, "the elderly persons of His fat-
her's friends and associates, with very humbleness, He inquired." He inqui-
red. And what is that inquiry?
"My dear father, I very respectfully and humbly I am inquiring. What is this
arrangement? Why you are busy in making some sacrificial ceremony, and
what is the reason, and what is the result?" Kiṁ phalaṁ: "What is the result
of doing this?" Kiṁ phalaṁ kasya ca uddeśaḥ: "By whom... Whom you are
trying to satisfy?" Kena vā sādhyate: "And what is the purpose of this sacri-
fice? So I cannot understand. Will you kindly explain to Me?" Etad brū-
hi mahān kāmo:"I am very much anxious. Kindly explain to me." Etad ma-
hān kāmo mahyaṁśuśruṣave pitaḥ: "Oh, I am your most obedient son, so
you kindly explain to Me." This question was posed.
na hi gopyaṁ hi sādhūnāṁ
kṛtyaṁ sarvātmanām iha
asya-svapara-dṛṣṭināṁ
amitro-dāsastad viṣām
jñātvājñātvā ca karmāṇi
jano 'yam anutiṣṭhanti
viduṣaḥ karma-siddhiḥ syāt
tathā na viduṣo bhavet
This is the only religious principle, and everyone will have all his desires ful-
filled by this chanting." So the brāhmaṇas, those who are priestly class, they
thought that "If people take to this only chanting, then what about our chur-
ches and mosque and temples? They will not come." So they lodged a com-
plaint to the magistrate that "This is not Hindu religion. He has discovered
something in His own fertile brain, so we do not recognize it." So this com-
plaint was lodged before the magistrate, and the magistrate took step, first
of all warned Him that "Don't chant Hare Kṛṣṇa." Then, when He did not
care, then sent some constables, and the drums were broken. Then Caitan-
yaMahāprabhu started civil disobedience movement. So He did not care for
the magistrate. He started saṅkīrtana throughout the whole city of Nabad-
wip. Then they approached the magistrate's house. Just the other day there
was a procession in your city. So this civil disobedience movement was star-
ted first by Caitanya Mahāprabhu. Now, there was some compromising talk
with the magistrate, and in that talk the Caitanya Mahāprabhu first questio-
ned. Because he was Mohammedan, Caitanya Mahāprabhu said that "In
your religion there is killing of father and mother. What sort of religion this
is?" The Kazi replied, "How do you say that we are killing our father and...?"
"Yes. You are killing your mother. Cow gives you milk, delivers milk. You
drink the milk, and you kill the cow. Therefore you are killing your mother."
So the Kazi replied that "In your Vedic literature also, I have seen. There is
cow sacrifice." So Caitanya Mahāprabhu replied, "That is not cow sacrifice.
That is rejuvenation of cow. Old cows were sacrificed in the fire, and again a
new life was given by the Vedic mantra. But because there is lack of such ex-
pert brāhmaṇas to chant that mantra, therefore cow sacrifice in this age is
forbidden."
So when the things are not practical, that becomes a forbidden. If you ac-
tually get the result by some spiritual or religious rituals, performance, then
it is very good. Otherwise it is superstition. Lord Caitanya's opinion is that
because all these Vedic injunctions, sacrifices, they are not possible to be
performed in this age... They are very difficult. There is no expert leader to
perform all these ceremonies and rituals. Therefore, take to
this Hare Kṛṣṇa. Take to this. There is no need of rituals. There is no need
of expenses. Simply God has given you tongue, and God has given you ear.
Just go on chanting: Hare Kṛṣṇa, Hare Kṛṣṇa, Kṛṣṇa Kṛṣṇa, Hare Hare/ Ha-
re Rāma, Hare Rāma, Rāma Rāma, Hare Hare, and it will fulfill your spiri-
tual advancement. Similarly, Kṛṣṇa said, jñātvā ajñātvā ca karmāṇi jano
'yam anutiṣṭhanti:"Generally, mass of people, they are ignorant. They per-
form some religious rituals knowingly or unknowingly as a matter of su-
perstition or custom." So, viduṣa karma-siddhiḥ syāt. But one who is intelli-
gent, he should know that "By this sacrifice, I must get the re-
sult." Viduṣo karma-siddhiḥ syāt tathā na viduṣo bhavet: "And those who
are fools, they, simply by superstition, they do it."
So Kṛṣṇa did not recommend that you should do something under su-
perstition. No. You must do it for practical result. This dogmatism, fanati-
cism—"Oh, why I shall chant Hare Kṛṣṇa? I am Christian. I am Jews"—this
is fanaticism. If you find actually ecstasy by chanting Hare Kṛṣṇa, why
should you not? Why should you not? "No. I am Jew." "I am Christian." "I
am Muhammadan." Well, it is transcendental vibration from the spiritual
platform. Your Muhammadism, Christianism, Hinduisim, Buddhism, this
is skin disease. This is... Because you have got some particular body at parti-
cular circumstances, therefore you claim like that. But actually we are all
spirit soul, and this sound vibration is from the spirit soul. It will appeal to
everyone. See the effect. Then don't be fanaticist. Don't be, I mean to say,
sectarian. So Kṛṣṇawants that, that simply by custom, one should not follow
the rituals. One should see the effect.
He says, "My dear boy, water is very essential because without rains we can-
not have any produce. Therefore... This rain is controlled by Bhagavān In-
dra. The heavenly king Indra, he controls the megha." Megha means cloud.
He is the master of the cloud. He can send cloud, and he can stop cloud. He
is representative of God, so he has got the po-
wer. Te 'bhivarṣanti bhūtānāṁprīṇanam: "So when he allows this raining,
people become satisfied. They get their produce."
tac cheṣeṇopajīvanti
tri-varga-phala-hetve
puṁsāṁ puruṣa-kāraṇāṁ
parjanyaḥ phala-bhāvanaḥ
"Now, this water is so important that it will produce grains and we shall li-
ve. And for perfection of our life we must first live. So this is very important
thing, so we have to satisfy Indra."
He says, "My dear boy, we should not give up this paramparā." Parampara-
means coming from disciplic succession or from generation. My father did
it, my father's fathers did it. So every religious ceremony, and according to
Vedic rituals, they are from paramparā, family or society-wise or commu-
nity-wise. In every country there is. So he says that "This paramparā, this
successive generation, we have been doing this, and we should not give it
up." He understood the Kṛṣṇa's purpose, that "He is asking. He is very inte-
lligent boy, so He is asking me all these questions just to forbid me." That
He's just... "Like father like son." The father was also intelligent.
So, ya evaṁ visṛjed dharmam. Dharmam means one must execute. That
is dharma. Just like to become hungry, it is my religion. This is called reli-
gion. We should know what is the meaning of religion. Religion means
which we cannot separate from myself. The religion which you can change,
that is not religion. Suppose I am Hindu; I become Christian. So neither
this Hinduism is religion or Christian is religion. It is a dictionary, English
dictionary, word. But dharma, according to Sanskrit word, dharma does not
mean that which you can change. I have several times explained this
fact. Dharma cannot be changed. Therefore we must find out what is
our dharma, what is our religion. Which we are professing, that "Christia-
nity is my religion," "Hinduism, my religion," that is not religion. That is
faith. Religion is different. Religion you cannot change. You cannot change.
That is the meaning of religion. Here it is said that ya evaṁ visṛjed dhar-
mam. Dharmam means you cannot change.
So pāraṁ paryāgataṁ naraḥ, kāmāt, kāmāt lobhāt. Now, religion someti-
mes, when it is taken as faith, they have changed. How they have chan-
ged? Kāmāt.For some gain. Just like in India formerly Christian religion
was preached, giving some facilities. And generally we see that Christian
priests who go to foreign countries... I have seen. They offer some hospital
facilities, some economic facilities. The poor men, they supply clothing and
education. So those who are poor, they become captivated, and they... They
have practically no religion. Anyway, they are facing the economic pro-
blems. So kāmāt. Kāmātmeans for some gain. For some gain, kā-
māt, and lobhāt... Lobhāt means by some greediness. And bhayāt. Bha-
yāt means out of fear. And dveṣāt. Dveṣātmeans out of enviousness. For all
these things one should not give up his faith or religion.
So, asti ced īśvaraḥ kaścit: "Supposing there is some God..." "There is so-
me God." Just see. A God is preaching atheism. He is God Himself, and He
says, "Supposing if there is some God." "Supposing if there is some
God," kaścitphala-rūpy anya-karmaṇām, "and He gives the result of your
work." The karma-mimāṁsā philosophers, they accept God in this way,
"Suppose there is God and He is to give us the result. So He is obliged. If we
do nice work, He is obliged. So what is the use of flattering God? Let us do
our duty nicely. Then He will be obliged." So Kṛṣṇa is following that argu-
ment. Asti ced īśvaraḥkaścit phala-rūpy anya-karmaṇām, kartāraṁ bhaja-
te so 'pi: "He also worships the worker. The worker has not to worship God.
Because God gives you good result out of your good work; therefore, becau-
se you are doing good work, therefore God is worshiping you." Just see the
argument. He says, kartāraṁbhajate so 'pi na hy akartuḥ prabhur: "And
one who does not do good work, even God does not like him. So there is no
necessity of worshiping this heavenly god or any god, so let us have our
duty done nicely. That will fetch us the desired result."
Oh,
svabhāva-tantro hi janaḥ
svabhāvam anuvartate
svabhāva-stham idaṁ sarvaṁ
sa-devāsura-mānuṣam
"Everyone is acting according to the modes of nature he has acquired, so
whatever nature we have acquired..." His purpose is that "By nature we are
mercantile people." Because His father was maintaining cows, so he is con-
sidered a mercantile man. Vaiśya-karma svabhāva-jam. Kṛṣi-go-rakṣya-
vāṇijyaṁ vaiśya-karma svabhāva-jam [Bg. 18.44]. So He is giving stress
that "Let us perform our duty as mercantile men honestly, and that will
bring us result. Why should we go to worship these demigods?"
Now, here is a point, that Kṛṣṇa does not approve the worship of demi-
gods. That is also stated in the Bhagavad-gītā. Kāmais tais tair hṛta-jñā-
na yajanty anya-devataḥ: [Bg. 7.20] "Those who are out of intelligence, they
simply worship the demigods." In the Bhagavad-gītā or in the Bhāgava-
ta, anywhere, worship of demigods is not very much recommended. So here
also the same thing, that svabhāva-tantro hi janaḥ: "Everyone is carried by
the modes of nature." Svabhāvam anuvartate: "And he cannot surpass the
spell of the modes of nature." Svabhāvam anuvartante, svabhā-
vas tam idaṁ sarvam: "Everyone is under the control of the nature he has
acquired." And sa-devāsura mānusaḥ. Sa-devāsura. "Always, either he is
man or superman or animal, everyone is being controlled by the modes of
nature."
"Therefore you don't bother yourself about worshiping this god or that god,
demigod. You just be faithful to your work, and then that will give you good
result." Añjasā yena varteta tad evāsya hi daivatam.
ājīvaikataraṁ bhāvaṁ
yas tv anyam upajīvati
na tasmād vindate kṣemaṁ
jārān nāry asatī yathā
Now, this is a very important question. Nāry asatī. Asatī. Asatī means
not chaste, not chaste woman. Just like... In India, of course, it is very strict,
that the woman is not to give up her husband and acquaint herself with any
other man. This example is given that "An unchaste woman gives up her
own husband and makes friendship with others; similarly, one who gives
up his own profession and takes other profession, he is also similarly un-
chaste." Unchaste. Nāry asatī yathā. Varteta brāhmaṇo vipra rājan-
ya rakṣayā bhuvaḥ:"Therefore one should not deviate from his professional
duties, just like the brāhmaṇas..." Brahman..., varte-
ta brāhmaṇo vipraḥ: "Those who are brāhmaṇa, they should stick to their
principle of life, simply spiritual culture." Rājanya rakṣayā bhuvaḥ: "And
those who are kṣatriyas, they should stick to their protecting the citizen."
The kingly order, royal order, their duty is to give protection to the... They
should not simply collect tax. The kṣatriyas, this king is allowed to collect
tax because he is supposed to give all protection to the people. So therefore
it is said, rājanya rakṣayā bhuvaḥ. Rājanya means the royal order stick to
his principle, how to give protection to the people. Similarly, vaiśyas tu vār-
tayā jīvet śūdras tu dvīja-sevayā: "Similarly, these mercantile, they should
live on their trade, and those who are śūdra, those who are laborer class,
they should serve all these three classes." That is the rules.
Now,
kṛṣi-vāṇijya-go-rakṣā
kusīdaṁ tūryam ucyate
vārtā catur-vidhā tatra
vayaṁ go-vṛttayo 'niśam
"Now, according to scripture, we are vaiśya, and we should live not in the
brahminical way or kṣatriya's way or śūdra's way, but we should live just li-
ke vaiśyas; and we are actually agriculturists, and we are actually protecting
cows. Therefore we are vaiśyas. Our duty is to stick to our, faithfully stick to
our business, stick to our work. What is the use of worshiping this god or
that god?"
"So therefore we are not going to the city. We are inhabitants of this village.
So it is better to worship this land, this land, this land, Govardhana." Becau-
se Kṛṣṇa was herding His cows on the Govardhana Hill, so indirectly He
hinted that "We should worship this Govardhana Hill, and that is our duty."
So it is a long story, three, four chapters. Of course, it will take some ti-
me. I don't think you can give us so much time. The net, the result is that
when Kṛṣṇa talked like this, then His father agreed not to perform the sacri-
fice. Because all the inhabitants of Vraja, Vṛndāvana, they are so much fond
of Kṛṣṇa, whatever Kṛṣṇa will say, they will accept. So although Kṛṣṇa was a
boy, He implored his father and other elderly gentlemen present there that
"There is no need of performing this sacrifice." So they stopped sacrifice. As
a result of this stopping, Indra became very much angry, and there was to-
rrents of rain, incessant rain, and very vehemently. So the whole village and
whole tract of land comprising the Vrajabhūmi, they became overflooded.
And the cows and the animals and the people became too much afflicted. So
they had no other source. They approached Kṛṣṇa, "Protect us. Kṛṣṇa, pro-
tect us." So at that time Kṛṣṇa said, "Yes, I will give you protection." So He
was, although a boy of six or seven years old, He lifted that hill. That is...
We are... If any time you go to India you will see the hill. It is not less than
at least five, six miles area, very big hill. That hill was lifted by Him, and He
kept that hill in His hand for seven days. And then everything was cleared.
Then Indra prayed Him.
So there are many things after this. So today Kṛṣṇa lifted this hill; there-
fore His name is Giridhārī. Giridhārī means who held the hill. Giri means
the hill, and dhārī means one who holds up. So today is that, is the annual
ceremony of today, this Govardhana-pūjā. So we follow that principle. Be-
cause we are devotees of Kṛṣṇa, we are trying to follow His instruction. So
at noontime we shall perform that pūjā, and you are invited to take prasā-
dam. I think prasādam will be ready by eleven o'clock, and you will kindly
participate in taking prasādam. (end)