Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Oxford University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Social Forces.
http://www.jstor.org
in the interview situation was therefore crucial for sets the conditions for the success of individual
the elicitation of unthreatened responses. Also, musicians.3Each orchestra is known and perceived
care was taken throughout the entire study to as the receptacle of rather well-defined status and
insure against the researcherbecoming associated financial rewards. Since the major symphony
in any way with any arm of management: no orchestras, let us say the top 15 or 20, are geo-
one in any such position was interviewed or con- graphically distributed throughout the country,
tacted for any purpose whatever, other than to from Boston to Los Angeles and Minneapolis to
gain initial permission to attend concerts and New Orleans, realization of career expectations
rehearsals.It is felt that whatever loss has ensued almost invariably means considerable geographic
from this procedure has been more than com- mobility. No musician who identifies himself as a
pensated for by the richness of the material full-time professional symphony musician can
gathered from the musicians. achieve his occupational aspirations apart from
movement up and into orchestras at or near the
THE MOBILE WORLD OF THE SYMPHONY MUSICIAN top rank, depending to a limited extent on the
From the perspective of the professional specific position in the orchestra. There is little
symphony musician, his occupational world may be ambiguity concerning the jobs that will satisfy
thought of as an array of symphony orchestras in his reward and status ambitions.
major cities, each of which is the bearer of a rela- The prestigious character of the orchestra is not,
tively stable quantum of prestige, and the entire however, the sole factor involved in the musician's
array ranged on a status hierarchy roughly corre- mobility decisions. For instance, images of con-
sponding to (1) the relative wage scale, and (2) ductors and even of section principals (section
the length of the "season," the top orchestras leaders, or 1st chairs) sometimes become significant
having the highest wages and the longest season. for such decisions. A 1st violin player had this
At the top of this hierarchy stand such organiza- to say:
tions as the orchestras of Boston, New York, and
As far as symphoniesare concernedI'm better off
Philadelphia, celebrated as the finest in the world.
here. I couldhave gone to K [namesa somewhatmore
At the base are found a great proliferation of prestigiousorchestra]last year on viola. The salary
"civic" and semi-professional orchestras in which is a little better than here, but I can't stomach the
musicians perform for little or no pay. The playing conductor.
of symphonic music is for these musicians an
avocation at best, and more often, a form of Also, values originating outside the orchestra or
creative leisure. In the middle ranges it is possible the whole system of orchestras (home town,
to distinguish several groupings on the basis of health, etc.) are sometimes related to musician's
prestige. Of the orchestra studied 70 members mobility decisions, but we need not concern our-
were asked to rank in order the 10 best symphonies selves with these.
in the United States. There was remarkable con- More important than such idiosyncrasies is the
sensus on the order: the orchestras of Boston, fact that, not only the orchestra as a unit, but also
New York, and Philadelphia were ranked 1-2-3 specific positions within it, are ranged on a scale
by 90 percent of the respondents. Immediately of status. The principal chairs (in the case of
below these, three more orchestras were grouped,
and below these, three more. In all, 21 orchestras 3The higher up in the hierarchy the more permanent
becomes the organization. The yearly rate of member-
were named but the top 6 were mentioned by 96
ship turnover would provide an index of permanency.
percent of the respondents, and the top 10 by 47
Though at the time of the study the personnel records
percent. The orchestra upon which this paper is of other orchestras were not available for inspection, it
based was one of those immediately below the is probably safe to assert that any significant shift in
top three. this rate would be accompanied by a shift in the pres-
It is within this system that demands for ma- tige of the orchestra relative to other orchestras. This
terial and status rewards are realized: its structure is because the relative permanence of an orchestra is an
index of the degree to which values are satisfied.
ductor is a topic appropriate for extended treatment. Theoretically, orchestras offering greater value satis-
Unfortunately, space will not permit a digression suffi- factions, i.e. material and status rewards, will also be
cient to comprehend adequately the many facets of the "better" in terms of aesthetic "efficiency," or perform-
position. ance norms.
string sections) and the chairs of "lst men" (in put his best men in back so [they] could watch the
the case of winds) top this scale. Incumbents of poorones.It's moredifficultto play [sittingin the back
these positions are paid roughly double the salaries of the sectionbecausethe conductoris furtheraway].
of others (section men). Therefore, within each
In response to the same question an older 2nd
organizationrewardsand status are to some extent
violin player had this to say:
at least formally available for the fulfillment of
mobility demands. The internal status system of Not particularly.I sit midway. I've sat back and
the orchestra is by no means unconnected with forth. I preferto sit in the middleof things. I've not
career-furthering chances of movement through tried for extra responsibilityor askedfor extra money.
the larger system. Experience gained in such jobs I think I'm capableof my job...... I'm older now and
as assistant concertmaster, and to a lesser extent, not ambitiousany more. I never was much. Actually
assistant principal positions, may weigh heavily there's no "aheadedness"to it. There's very little
differencein moneyexceptfor the actualprincipals.
in conductors' personnel replacement decisions.
A man who had played 2nd stand, 1st violins A somewhat abused and buffetted cello player
would probably merit slightly greater considera- expresses the ultimate rationalization.
tion than one off the last stand,4 or one from the
2nd violin section, other things being equal (which I feel my position is somethinglike the 1st cellist,
they practically never are). beingas I sort of pull the sectionalongfromthe rear.
Despite many denials, position in the section
Some mention should be made here of the possi-
is an important source of job satisfaction and
bility of leaving the system and finding career
status deprivation. Though no systematic evidence
satisfactions in related spheres. Specifically,
is available to demonstrate this point there are a
enumeration of soloist6 status, chamber groups
number of considerations that bear immediately
(primarily string quartets), a few opera and ballet
upon it. The mere fact that chances for outside
orchestras, and the popular music field exhausts
jobbing are directly dependent on position injects
such avenues. For the string player, opportunities
a purely economic aspect that poorly paid
in the popular field are few, and the real chances
musicians could hardly ignore.5 Also, if one takes
of becoming a soloist or full-time member of a
the trouble to observe carefully he may sometimes
quartet that pays its own way are fewer. There
detect a nonchalantly calculated, subtly surrepti-
are probably no more than 10 string players suc-
tious competition in the edging forward of chairs.
cessfully making a living as soloists in the United
And a few violinists in the back of the section
States. For wind players, on the other hand, the
confess that being thus displayed before audiences
situation is different. There are always jobs avail-
of thousands is a status-effacing experience. But
able and most symphony wind players augment
perhaps the best indicator of the status meaning
their incomes substantially by playing in popular
of section position is gleaned through the fre-
orcllestras, jazz bands, combos, etc. Of course,
quently inventive rationalizations enunciated by
these opportunities vary somewhat according to
status-deprived musicians. Here, a 1st violinist
the demand for different wind instruments.
who was 10th of 16 in the section elaborates on
In terms of the scope of employment oppor-
his promotion chances.
tunities, then, the strings and winds find them-
Q. Do you expectto get aheadin this orchestra? selves in significantly different situations. The
A. There is no point in it. As much is expectedof string player experiences a relatively great "job
you no matterwhereyou sit. He [the conductor]might confinement" while the wind man has the vast
field of popular music in which he can work.
4A stand is composed of two players. There were 8 While there are other important dimensions on
stands in the 1st violin section of the orchestra studied; which the experience of string and wind players
thus, 16 players. differ,7 it is this one of job confinement which
6 Hiring of string players for whatever outside jobs
are to be had is effected through a long-time member 6 This term as used here means a self-employed,
of the orchestra who acts as a one-man employment entrepreneuring free agent, not to the 1st men of the
agency for establishments or individuals who wish to wind sections, who are also referred to as soloists. Such
hire. The basis for selection is universalistic: he starts names as Menuhin, Heifetz, Serkin, and Rubinstein
with the players at the front of the sections and works come immediately to mind.
toward the back until the supply of jobs is exhausted. 7 The most prominent of these is visibility by both
must be kept primarily in mind as the context in must be filled. The manifest function of this prac-
which we shall examine the dynamics of occupa- tice is to control the "informal" features of a rela-
tional identification and aspiration as they shift tionship that is, nominally at least, one of authority
over the course of a career and have consequences -in this fashion the potentially disorganizing
for other facets of the musician's work life.8 Our effects of formerly egalitarian relationships are
main concern will therefore be with the string circumvented; but its significance extends beyond
players, who constitute about 70 percent of any this-it also has the latent consequence of en-
symphony orchestra. couraging and increasing inter-orchestra mobility.
The fact that, in the orchestra studied, 5 of 14
MOBILITY MECHANISMS principals and 1st men were up from the ranks
In orderfor men to make claims on higher status is probably primarily reflective of a poorly
positions there must be modes of selection to get developed authority system at the level of princi-
them in these positions. Positions are distributed pals and 1st men, for the conductor exercises
as opportunities for rewards and perquisites by many leadership functions that in other orchestras
conductors who select through auditions9 the are delegated to section leaders. Unfortunately,
best players for the jobs. Several features of this no comparative data from other orchestras were
mechanism are of importance. available on this point.
First of all, the top orchestras generally make a The fact that being selected for better jobs is
practice of hiring only men under the age of 35. rare for musicians over 35 means that their career
This means that for the vast majority of musicians changes are effectively settled by that age; thus
success must come early if it is to come at all. If they must move fast. The criteria of principal and
a man has not attained a high status position by 1st man selection, taken together with the prestige
the time he is 35, or at the latest, 40, it is almost grading of orchestras described earlier, means that
certain that he will never attain it. the musician's potential career opportunities are
A second factor of importance, which con- structured in the following ways: (1) a limited
tributes greatly to the geographic mobility of the range within the orchestra, up to but probably not
musician, is the principle in accordance with which including the 1st chair jobs; (2) positions in higher
principals and 1st men are selected. Replacements ranking orchestras, with certain exceptions-
of principals and 1st men are seldom made from section principals would seldom accept section
sections within the orchestra in which the position jobs in higher ranked orchestras; (3) in some
cases, higher status positions in lower ranked
colleague and concert hall audiences. Since most wind orchestras-this almost always would mean a
players are soloists, in the sense of playing a great many section man accepting a principalship or soloist
passages with the rest of the orchestra as a background, job in the lower rankedorchestra. Since the number
the condition for a "performance anxiety" is built into of orchestras that at any given time are relevant
their jobs. While string players need only "blend" with for a musician's mobility chances is never large,
the rest of the section (and it is therefore practically knowledge of potential openings tends to be en-
impossible to ascertain whether they are playing well cyclopedic, though this varies by the size of the
or badly, indeed, whether they are playing at all), a aspirant's section. Whereas trumpet sections
great many of the sounds produced by the wind player
usually have five or six men, 1st and 2nd violin
are audible to all, and these of course, include his
sections taken together normally have at least five
mistakes.
8 The perquisites of a position are by no means in-
times as many. Mobile musicians will probably
considerable. For instance, the 1st men and section know the approximate ages, professional history,
principals monopolized most of the better teaching and ability of most of the incumbents of what,
opportunities in the area, bringing them an income of from their perspective, are desirable jobs, and
substantial proportions. perhaps even in some cases whether there is an
9 The audition is a test of competence everyone must
inclination to quit, and the character of relations
pass prior to admission into the orchestra. It is usually
with the conductor. Thus, each musician is, in a
administered by the conductor (occasionally by the
concertmaster), and is, for most, fraught with anxiety. sense, his own employment agency, compiling an
Some argue that it is not a true test of ability to play inventory of probable and possible jobs. Such
in a symphony orchestra, i.e to "blend" in with the knowledge serves the function of preparing the
total sound. musician for opportunities that "come like a
flash, are there for a moment, and then are gone." -and thus outward from the community he is, at
The careerof the symphony musician is not one of the moment, in, but not of-his social life is
steady advancement through a series of finely typically restricted to a culture flourishing on the
graded positions with predictable promotions periphery of his work life, a culture participated
based mainly on presentation of credentials of in by others like himself, stopping for a year or two,
service and tenure, but rather, one of watchfully then going on. Extreme involvement with
awaiting the opportunity that may appear but colleagues off, as well as on the job, means that the
once in a lifetime. musician's professional identity, developed over
long years of training, is constantly being but-
OCCUPATIONAL IDENTIFICATION, ASPIRATION, AND tressed and reinforced, holding to a minimum the
THE CAREER possibilities of pursuit, or even consideration, of
Extraordinarilylong training periods and intense other possible ways of life.
study produce musicians whose occupational This intense occupational identification so char-
identification is of the strongest sort. A complex of acteristic of the young symphony musician, taken
factors accounts for this. together with the reward features of the system-
The training of the musician, particularly the which, in orchestras roughly below the top 10
string musician, begins at an early age in the form practically fail to provide even a subsistence level
of private lessons (usually) and long practice ses- of existence'0-tend to inculcate in him the strong-
sions. Some musicians actually begin their training est aspirations. Now we do not wish to assert as an
at the age of 3 or 4. The fact that intense training empirical generalization that either the level or the
begins so early means two things: (1) that other strength of aspiration necessarily co-varies with
experiences, particularly work experiences, are the strength of occupational identification; only
considerably circumscribed,and (2) such an early that in the case of the symphony musician, strong
investment of time, money, and effort typically occupational identification, conjoined with the
creates a firm basis for a strong occupational com- pattern of rewardand status distribution, produces
mitment while the potential professional is yet a high aspirations of considerable intensity (at
child. Consequently, other identities have little least in the early work years)."i Let us look now at
chance to develop. And it is not by chance that the dynamics of occupational aspiration and
those who remain in the profession have such long identification over the course of the career char-
histories of study. Competence on stringed instru- acterized by great job confinement.
ments particularly depends on years of arduous The highest aspiration a string musician can
practice: one cannot begin late and hope for have is to some day become a self-employed soloist.
success. This ambition was expressed by many young
Isolation from other occupational experiences, violinists particularly,'2 in the subject orchestra
toward which the musician is predisposed by early of the study. For any young man roughly between
training, is perpetuated by two institutional 25 and 30, to be a player in the orchestra means
features characteristic of his late youth and early that at this point in his career he is successful.
adulthood: (1) the conservatory, and (2) his
10In the orchestra studied the weekly base pay (set
great social and geographic mobility. Of the
musicians interviewed, 77 percent attended at by union contract was over $100 per week, with the
possibility of individual bargaining with management
least one conservatory, and many attended two or
for $5 or $10 more. Therefore no one could make over
more. Periods of attendance ranged up to 14 years.
about $3200 in one year, because the season lasted
The curriculum of a music conservatory is not through only a portion of it.
calculated to give the student a rounded education. 11The strength of an aspiration and the level aspired
It is clear that he is there for one purpose-to to are obviously not the same thing. Neither are they
become a polished musician. This means that necessarily in constant relation. A son of a laborer may
opportunities to develop knowledge of and interest aspire strongly to the rather modest occupational
in other areas of endeavor tend to remain minimal. status of, say, barber, while the aspiration of a middle-
class child for attainment of a much higher occupational
Then, as a young man just on the job market, the
status may be of considerably less strength.
tyro professional must maximize a potential for 12 Other than violinists and pianists there are hardly
mobility. Since his career orientation forces him to any instrumentalists making a living in the concert
face upward toward better jobs in other orchestras hall as soloists.
Ambitions of such musicians are typically big: This is typical of the older strings: many want to
a 24-year old 2nd violin player had the following get out. Some have tried; few have succeeded.
to say. The years complete the process of effacement of
the occupational identity. As the player grows
This is the beginningof my careerand what I would older, into and beyond the 50's, his talent begins
like to do eventuallyis to be on my own and becomea to erode and his value to the organization dimin-
soloist. ishes, particularly in terms of his future potential.
A number of string players (and a few of the winds)
Such men, in their first professional experiences, report having been "pushed back" in the section.
are intensely motivated toward unrealistically Here, a 54-year old 2nd violinist who had once
high goals. This strong motivation is in part the played in the 1st violins comments.
product of success experience in moving through
relatively low echelon orchestras up to a point Q. Whatare someof thingsyou like best aboutbeing
where, for most, a personal plateau is reached. The a musician?
orchestra studied was such a plateau for many.
After a few years without noticeable progress, A. I don't like any part of it. As a matter of fact,
all the time I've had severalexperiencesin the business
aspirations tend to become scaled down. In the
world,but they failed and I had to come back. But as
following exerpt from an interview, a 32-year old
a professionalmusicianI've never liked it.... The
violin player expresses the inner struggle typical firstchanceto get out I will. I still am looking.
of string players beginning to sense that their (later)
career aspirations may never be realized.
... by the time you reachan age whereyou should
My problemis that I alwayshave ambitionto be a be independentit's just the opposite.As you growolder
soloist,but that's yourideal point of view. You always you get less desirable,less valuable.It's not like other
have to makeadjustmentsto live life or you driveyour-
things.....
self to destruction.You have to keep your ideal and
makeadjustments.I wantedto be a soloistbut I know The material and status rewards offered the
now there is not enoughspace for that. So I chose the symphony musician, particularly the string play-
orchestraand I'm pretty happy about playing in it.
ers, in the circumscribed world of symphonic
But I have ambitionsto become a soloist some day.
Playing in the orchestrais just as valuablebecauseof music are structured such that only a relatively
the experience,and is of more value musically,but few jobs, those in top orchestras plus a number of
when I play a solo I think it counts more because I section principalships and 1st man jobs, can
have all the responsibilityon me. I have to ... do my satisfy the demands created by years of study and
best to become a first-rateplayer. In the orchestra an idealized self-image. When the aspirations
you can do all those things but you can't reach that emerging from these factors fail in fulfillment they
level to get that reward.You can get some satisfaction begin to erode, and before too long the idealized
playing in the orchestra:you can see the standardof occupational identity upon which they are in good
a solo piece is higher.You can hear yourself-you are part founded becomes, over the years, progressively
more of an individual.You have it difficultand more
more rent and torn, in many cases ultimately
to give than in the orchestra.
undergoing near-complete effacement."3
In later years the process of persistent thwarting For the young musician, bringing to the job an
of aspirations often touches the musician's very idealization of the musician's role and a sense of
identity as a talented and schooled artist perform- personal musical integrity, contact with such dis-
ing the work he esteems, making great music come illusioned older musicians can be a rather bewilder-
alive in the concert hall. A 47-year old 1st violin ing experience, and in some cases was the fountain-
player quite well-placed in the section answers: head of considerable hostility directed toward
them: such encounters scarcely engender con-
Q. Whatdo you expectto be doing5 yearsfromnow? firmation of the artistic image of the symphony
musician. A 27-year old cello player says:
A. That's a hard question.If I can still be playing
I'll be playingin an orchestra.If I can get decentcom- 13 Note certainparallelswith the automobileworker
mercialworkthe yearroundI'd ratherdo that.... I've as presentedin Ely Chinoy, AutomobileWorkersand
done cabaretwork. I'd ratherplay in any cabaretin the AmericanDream(New York: Doubledayand Co.,
the countrythan the symphonyorchestra. 1955).
mobile young. The result, in the orchestra here man, "characters," and "queers"-he wants no
studied, was a fairly well-developed schism created part of them. The older men, on the other hand,
from factors outlined earlier. The younger are apt to be defined by the younger as defectors
musicians, living in quasi-bohemian style become, from artistic and professional values. And this
in the eyes of the settled, community-involved they find incomprehensible.