You are on page 1of 6

Based on the research “Politics of Aegyo:

Discursive and Affective Patterns of Embodied


Cuteness in South Korea.”

This research was funded by Underwood


International College through “2015 UIC
Research Project- Korea (URP-Korea).” For
further inquiries, contact UIC Academic Advisor
Sol-A Yu (solasola@yonsei.ac.kr) or refer to
UIC official website (http://uic.yonsei.ac.kr).
cover image: Kwon Eun Bean, Producer 101, MNet, 2016
Publisher I Jin-bae Chung mnettv.interest.me/produce101/main.dbp
Editorial Director I Michael Kim
Research Advisors I Aljosa Puzar

Politics of Aegyo
Sol-A Yu
Author I Sehee Eom (UD ‘12)
Yewon Hong (UD ‘12)
Graphic Designer I Sehee Eom

Discursive and Affective Patterns of


Embodied Cuteness in South Korea
2 Politics of Aegyo Politics of Aegyo 3

WHAT IS
KEY RESEARCH POINTS

01 Similar concepts of
02 How can aegyo be
03 What does this tell

AEGYO?
aegyo exist across seen as “Korean,” us about the posi-
East Asian regions, what in relation to varous Korean- tionality of women in Korean
similarities/differences do they specific concpets, and how society in general, and what
have with aegyo? What does is it tied it to the various implications does it have
this imply about each culture? structural chcaracteristics of for the future of feminism in
Korean society? Korean society?
    DISCOVERING & DEFINING AEGYO                                     

THE DEFINITON OF AEGYO

Aegyo is a complex articu- 0 2 4 6 8 10 12


lation of behaviors, linguistic
forms (word-choice, grammar CUTE PHYSICAL APPEARANCE 10.63

and intonation), gestures, nar-


10.17
ratives and fashions aiming SINCERE AFFECTION

to deliver childish cuteness,


INNOCENCE 9.4
frequently observed among
Korean women and occa- NUNCHI 9.28
Hyeri, Girls Day MV “Hello Bubble,” 2015 sionally and non-dominantly
in young men. It includes CHILDISH OR SPECIAL LANGUAGE, GRAMMAR 8.53
aspects ranging from directly
WHY AEGYO? embodied features, such as CUTENESS/AEGYO OF ANIMALS 8.33
voice and gestures, to those
Hyeri, a female idol celeb- little study done in the aca- but also in non-personal indirectly helping or under- RESEMBLANCE TO AEGYO OF CELEBRITIES 7.62
rity, gained her popularity demic field about aegyo, realms, such as work envi- pinning the articulation of
through her performance of unlike other Korean-specific ronment, and even between female cuteness, including EMPATHY (BEING NICE TO EVERYONE) 7.44

aegyo in one of Korea’s reality cultural concepts, such as strangers having casual con- objects, narratives and more.
SUBMISSIVENESS (POLITENESS)
show programs. Her aegyo jeong, nunchi and chemyon. versations, not to mention its There are many verbal and 7.24

was marketed in various tele- Our goal was to find out how popularity in Korea’s popular vocal aspects of aegyo, gen-
PRETENDING (GASIK) 7.04
vision programs, advertise- aegyo operates within the cul- culture and idol culture. Aegyo erally characterized by high-
ments, even emoticons for tural context of South Korea, interacts with Korea’s complex pitched, nasal voice accom- SEXUAL NUANCE 6.9
chat-room apps. We were and what implications it has societal structure layered with panied by abnormal pronunci-
intrigued by the strong, mixed for feminism and female “soft neo-Confucianism, hyper-cap- ation or grammatically incor- OTHER 3.44
responses to her aegyo from power” in the future of Korea. italism, post-colonialism and rect sentence structure, often
different groups of people and many more. Aegyo, thus, is accompanied by a childish
went on to speculate the spe- Aegyo is a cultural phe- not only another social skill for expression. There is no sin-
cific cultural phenomenon. nomenon that constructs the South Koreans but it is some- gular definition or description of aegyo or behavior that What makes aegyo aegyo?
everyday lives of Koreans and thing that directly represents is classified as aegyo, but being adorable and cute is
Once the topic caught our influences how they behave in South Korean hierarchical the common factor of anything that is considered to We asked survey responders to pick 5 of
attention, we realized how different situations and rela- order, gender roles and indi- be aegyo. The graph shows what survey responders the most important factors in aegyo, and
aegyo was deeply rooted tionships. It is widely per- rect power disparity. picked and ranked as the most important factor for a to rank them according to imporanc. This is
in South Korea’s complex formed not just among family certain behavior to be aegyo. the graphic representation of the result.
society. Yet there was very members, friends and lovers,
AEGYO
INSIDE &
KOREAN AEGYO

OUTSIDE
Korean brand of
winsomeness distinguishes
WOMEN SKILLFUL AT AEGYO AND HER NUNCHI. SHE: itself from its counterparts
60 as it inevitably interacts with
Korea’s complex societal
50
structure layered with neo-
    KOREAN AEGYO                                    40 Confucianism, hyper-
30 capitalism, post-colonialism
and other Korea’s cultural
AEGYO IN OTHER CULTURES 20
concepts, such as jeong, han,
10 chemyon and nunch i. Even
0 though aegyo operates by
Similar concepts of aegyo
NEITHER/IT IS NOT BOTH, DEPENDING
putting oneself in the position
exist in other countries in HAS NUNCHI DOES NOT HAVE
of the immature child, it should
the East Asian region. All NUNCHI RELEVANT ON THE SITUATION
not be understood as random
the performances of female MALE FEMALE bursts of emotion. There are
winsomeness in different
strict social rules governing
East-Asian cultures seem to DOES AEGYO CONTRIBUTE TO THE CULTURE OF 'JEONG' IN the use of aegyo , for both the
share some similarities: cute
KOREAN SOCIETY OR COMMUNITY? (E.G. FAMILY, NATION ETC) person performing aegyo and
and childish yet potentially
the person on the receiving
sexual invitation for attention 80
end. Therefore aegyo cannot
and protection from others.
60 be discussed outside the
In Chinese culture, there is
context of Korean society,
sajiao (撒娇), which literally 40 and various Korea-specific
means “throwing tantrum
from “My Sunshine,” Croton Media, 2015 (China). concepts. What is considered
like a young child.” Sajiao 20
In this scene, Zhao Mosheng is asking her husband to be acceptable about aegyo
is often characterized by
to go outside with her during their trip together. 0 exists within the system due
tantrums and public pouting
YES NO IT IS IRRELEVANT BOTH, DEPENDING to the constant regulation
which resembles that of
ON THE SITUATION and censorship by the rules
a spoiled child, possibly
of nunchi . Most of our survey
putting young women in a MALE FEMALE responders and interlocutors
position of immature child
agreed that nunchi was
that needs male guidance
essential for performing aegyo
and supervision. The Japanese counterpart of
successfully. In another question, more than 40% of responders
Korean aegyo could be found in the concept of
said that aegyo , in some way, contributes to jeong, or collectivism
amae (甘え), which describes a set of behaviors
in Korea. Both results show how performed and mediatized aegyo
that indicate one’s desire to be loved and cared
coexists with traditional values, confirming the need to analyze
by others. Women with amae tendencies will
the concept not only comparatively and transnationally but also
depend on others, such as their superiors at
in relation to other local Korean concepts, both traditional and
work, desiring attention and protection from
recent.
them in exchange for nuanced submission.

from “Ties of Shooting Stars,” TBS, 2008 (Japan). Shizuna is listening attentively
to her older brother, who is trying to help her out through a rough situation. examples of Korean Celebrities performing aegyo, from top to bottom:
Yuju, Gfriend official twieet, 2015. twitter.com/gfrdofficial; Sunny, Girl’
s Generation MV “Oh Oh Oh Oh,” 2010; Suzy, Bean Pole Advertisement,
2015, blog.samsungfashion.com/beanpole; Yura, Girls Day MV “Female
President,” 2013; IU, KangHeart, SBS, 2012, tv.sbs.co.kr/kangheart
6 Politics of Aegyo Politics of Aegyo 7

SURVEY &
mood, atmosphere and situa-
tion, whereas Korean aegyo Performing and Receiving Aegyo:
is more about onomatopoeic
words and sounds. COMFORTABLE RECEIVING AEGYO FROM: WOULD BE ABLE TO AEGYO TO:

INTERVIEW
WHEN DO YOU USE
CELEBRITY
AEGYO?
SUBORDINATE/JUNIORS
F: I think aegyo is a great
tool when communicat- SUPERIOR/BOSS/SENIORS
    RESEARCHING AEGYO                                    ing with the elderly. When
you talk softly, they will per- FRIEND/COLLEAGUE
ceive you as polite, likable. So
95% The research mostly relies on ethnographic data, but also
employs data from the non-ethnographic sources to support
aegyo makes it easier to com-
municate with older people,
LOVER

responded aegyo is and broaden our findings. There were interlocutors from differ- because communicating with FAMILY

good for women at ent ethnographic backgrounds, participating in in-depth, non- them is totally different from
structured interviews. To back this up, two different surveys talking to your peers. 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
least in some situations
were created, one with 14 questions focusing on the relation
of aegyo and Korean society and the other with 6 questions But then I believe aegyo works
0% directed towards finding out the perception of aegyo on an indi- way better for opposite sex WOMENT SKILLFUL AT AEGYO AND VERTICAL SOCIAL
responded female vidual level. A total of 144 and 56 people, respectively, partici- than for the elderly. It is so MOBILITY (SUCCESS IN PROFESSIONAL AND PRIVATE LIFE)
pated in the two surveys. All the interviews and survey ques- obvious! It’s almost like asking
aegyo was bad for tions aimed to explore similarities and differences of aegyo to why heterosexuals like oppo- 80
men. other types of performed cuteness in other nations, what aspect site sex and homosexuals like 60
of it is specifically Korean, and what the position of female per- the same sex. Aegyo is one of 40
formers are, showing how aegyo could be understood by differ- the charms people can have
70% ent members of society. Some interesting answers and findings and I think it can be sexual.
20

said aegyo was are introduced to give a better understanding of the nature of 0

important or very aegyo, which our study focused on. Random alpahabets were HOW DO YOU THINK FOR- GENERALLY GENERALLY BOTH, BETTER IN

PRIVATE,
BETTER IN AEGYO IS NOT

PROFESSIONAL, RELEVANT FOR


assigned to each interlocutors. EIGNERS WILL THINK OF BETTER WORSE DEPENDING ON
important in romantic ONE’S SUCCESS
AEGYO? SITUATION WORSE IN WORSE IN

relationships PROFESSIONAL PRIVATE IN LIFE

INTERVIEW E: Foreigners will not get the MALE FEMALE TOTAL


feeling of the aegyo as we do,
WHAT IS YOUR EXPLANA- of someone, so in that case but of course they will have
TION OR UNDERSTANDING I was doing aegyo to foreign their own type of aegyo. The lot of aegyo. She has a strong her crying like a baby because
You OF KOREAN AEGYO? tourists visiting the guest- foreigners will like Korean opinion, and when things are someone rejected her opinion.
need house while I was working style of aegyo, too, though not done according to her will,
nunchi J: Aegyo would be a certain there. They were an old they may not understand it she will be very angry. Once WHY DO MEN/WOMEN LIKE
to know type of cuteness. For couple, and after I was really as we do. Foreigners cannot we were deciding on which AEGYO?
when to deploy example, if someone made a nice to them, smiling and really get the same feeling color our group T-shirt should
aegyo gun, then mistake, he/she could lessen stuff, they were very happy, from (Korean) aegyo as we be. It wasn’t even an important D: So aegyo would be mostly
you have to the tension by acting cute and even asked me to visit them do. topic. I guess she didn’t like between lovers or by women
pretend nothing making the others forget their later… I think Korean aegyo the color that everyone liked, who want some attention or to
happened to keep anger or negative feelings. is different from “aegyo” CAN YOU GIVE US A POSI- she wanted a pastel color. be liked. This is the purpose.
your chemyon. Aegyo also has an element of from other countries. I don’t TIVE EXAMPLE OF USING She started to talk like a baby, But men like women with
humor and playfulness. know how to do aegyo in AEGYO? transforming her complaints aegyo because women can
-interlocutor a English. I also watched lots of into something that resembles hide their purpose. They can
F: I think aegyo includes being Chinese TV series, but then K: I know a girl from a school aegyo. She threw a tantrum hide their purpose and use
nice, smiling and taking care their aegyo was more about activities I once did. She has a in the end. I also remember aegyo as an instinct to make
examples of cutified and infantilized
8 Politics of Aegyo I m a g e sP
, olitics f t tA
f r o m L e of R i g h t9
o egyo : Egg
Feelings, Charlotte Mei, 2015, www.
themselves liked. The purpose bunwigi (ambience) is differ- sweet, cheery, but not nec- F: I remember this instagram . com / p /6 kdq D q A sx G; K im
Woobin, Monkey3 Star Morning Call
is underneath their actions. ent if we have women at work. essarily positive. There is a meme that went viral
- aegyo ver, 2013; Lip-tint, mirukeu-
So they can achieve their If the woman is friendly and personality with lots of aegyo few months ago in senpai , 2015, mirukeu - senpai . tumblr .
purpose without disappointing has aegyo then the bunwigi and personality without lots of Facebook. It says com; And God Created Woman,
the opposite party. Wanting becomes lighter. It is helpful aegyo. Even if someone who “Dear women without US H a r p e r ’ s B a z a a r , 2010, w w w .
to be liked by others is like to the women herself if she does not have aegyo watches aegyo: if you read harpersbazaar . com , P uss in B oots ,

an instinct. Women instinc- has a lot of aegyo. The evalu- lots of YouTube videos teach- this phrase 10 times Shrek, PDI/Dreamworks, 2001
tively know what can get them ation of colleagues would be ing him/her how to perform per day then you
liked by men. I think that is an different. If she is even good aegyo, he/she would not be will be able to have
instinct. What man would be at her work, there would be able to do it. aegyo!” and it was
able to resist aegyo? a synergy. That is what my “Gishingggungggotto”
workplace wants from female DO YOU FEEL LIKE THERE (기싱꿍꼬또). I
The reason only some women workers. IS A PRESSURE TO thought it was funny
like aegyo has much to do with PERFORM AEGYO? and somewhat weird.
age. If you are a peer, or in WHAT IS A “GOOD” AEGYO? Why would someone
the same age group, you may K: One of my uncles directly need to practice
be disgusted by it. But as you E: It would depend on whether told my dad that I have no aegyo and for what?
get experience and get older, there is a purpose or not. It aegyo and that I am not
then you can just see aegyo would differ according to the daughter-like. Of course they
as cute. Because you have situation. If there is too much would hate it if my younger
become more relaxed. Simply, aegyo in the workplace, it brother does aegyo because
it means that one performing would be frowned upon. But it he is a boy. Anyway, instead
aegyo is not your competitor would be better received if it of doing cute stuff, I spoke
anymore. is done between lovers, or to few English sentences to
family members. Like I said, I please them, especially my
HAVE YOU EVER WIT- think the difference is whether dad. I think my dad really
NESSED AEGYO IN YOUR you have a purpose or not. liked it, showing off how smart
WORKPLACE? and capable his daughter is,
CAN SOMEONE HAVE instead of me acting cute in OBSERVATIONS I shouldn’t talk to him because She complimented her boss
C: In the workplace, I haven’t NATURAL AEGYO? front of everyone. So it was as he is scary), and performed (her eyes wide open, blinking
seen men acting like this. For if I am his pikkachu! He would An observation on a infantile gestures (e.g. sticking too frequently), that he looks
men, it is just being friendly. D: Girls with aegyo and girls demand me to show off some female employee of a her lips out to indicate she is “dandy.” He did not under-
We do have women in the without aegyo is a difference skill I learned, and I would Korean company shows not satisfied). All these seem- stand the word so he asked
workplace even though we of nature. It is a personality do it. So I did something else how aegyo is used to one’s ingly childlike behaviors dilute her to repeat it. She under-
have mostly men, and the difference. It is about being instead of doing aegyo. advantage, in various situ- her aggressiveness and allow stood it as him wanting to
ations. When she said rude her to freely insult people. hear her compliment him
things, she would employ an She breaks down the realm once more. She laughed
aegyo-like tone and style of of private and professional and touched his shoulder
speech. She freed herself by using aegyo, and brings and said, “Oh, so you want
from social responsibility of people who were in her public to hear it once more?” He
being polite by positioning realm into her (imaginary) politely replied that he didn’t
herself as a carefree child, private circle. understand the word. She
so someone who would criti- explained what “dandy” meant
cize her rudeness will imme- Another example shows and laughed frivolously, but
diately receive negative com- a case when aegyo did not then was immediately baffled
ments from others for taking work, as the one trying to because he did not show the
something to be unneces- use aegyo was not sensi- expected response. He then
sarily serious when she was tive enough to her social replied that he thought she
just being playful. She inten- surroundings. A girl, aged is overreacting. He seemed
tionally made her voice high- twenty two, who often uses truly puzzled by her remark.
pitched, generated uncon- aegyo in the office environ- She was visibly embarrassed,
trollable laughter, used infan- ment and her personal life, stopped laughing and every-
tile vocabularies or logic (e.g. tried to use aegyo to her boss. thing got awkward.
RedVelvet MV “Dumb Dumb”
10 Politics of Aegyo Politics of Aegyo 11

CONCLUSION
LAST COMMENT When we first decided to start a research on aegyo ,
we encountered a range of reactions, mostly disbelief.
Many thought it was ridiculous, thinking aegyo was not
serious enough to be studied, not to mention our seeming
ineligibility to understand such subject since we “just don’
    IN SUMMARY                            t have aegyo .” Over past several months, we couldn’t
master the art of winsomeness, unfortunately. However,
OUR FINDINGS we were able to analyze it through more than one
dimension, adding depth to the concept that was often
1. AEGYO IN DIFFERENT of female sexuality is also communities as a womanly disregarded despite its strong influence over everyday
CULTURES a characteristic most vividly virtue. As aegyo is mostly lives of Koreans. We now know aegyo is not a mere
displayed in aegyo , possibly expected from younger people social skill or some popular trend but a reflection on South
Most of the survey leading people to differentiate or people of lower social Korea’s landscape of power imbalance between gender,
responders and interviewees aegyo from performed positions, such expectations age and social status. We truly hope that our research
acknowledged the existence corporeal cuteness in other for women as well relegate contributed to the understanding of Korean culture and
of female performance of cultures, such as amae women to the position unequal possibly other similar social phenomena of different areas
cuteness in other parts in which sexuality is not to for whom the aegyo is in the world.
of the world, confirming consciously expressed. The performed. The project allowed us to take initial steps to conduct
that winsomeness is not a specificity of aegyo is further At the same time, aegyo is, real academic research, and we are grateful that UIC
unique cultural phenomenon supported by responses from paradoxically, also considered gave us the opportunity. We also learned about each
to Korean society. Many people who understood it to be an expression of female other as friends and as research partners. Sometimes it
responders answered that in relation to Korea’s other playfulness and free choice. was harder than we imagined, but in the end we do not
foreigners could easily identify culturally specific concepts, Comments and responses regret participating in the project as a team.
with aegyo , or that there was in this case mainly nunchi generally viewed aegyo We thank Professor Puzar who always helped us
aegyo in foreign countries as and chemyon , and others. as voluntary enactment on throughout the entire process of research. We believe
well. We discovered aegyo is Nunchi confines aegyo to the women’s part, claiming that that without him the paper would have been half-cooked,
a phenomenon comparable boundaries of established it facilitates uncomfortable missing many crucial parts. We also thank Professor Yu,
to Chinese, Japanese cultural values and does not situations, which is in stark who patiently guided us through the formats and rules
and broader phenomena permit aegyo to be genuinely contrast to the request for of the research, and all the other professors and faculty
of cutified and charming infantile in nature, while aegyo to be “genuine”. There members who made our research possible.
behaviors. Interestingly, while saving one’s social face, or were few responses that Lastly we thank every interlocutor and survey
acknowledging the presence chemyon , is the ultimate goal addressed the uncomfortable participant who helped us build our precious sets of data.
of similar winsomeness to be achieved by performing compromises women are We were able to earn great insight to the topic through
in other cultures, many of aegyo . Aegyo is, therefore, forced to take when they survey responses and personal accounts from our friends,
interviewees still believed that entangled with other Korean perform aegyo , and instead Lookbook, Hottiewood, 2016 family members, and people unknown to us, stretching
the specificity of aegyo and cultural concepts and can be many focused on the positive shophottiewood.com way beyond student population and beyond circle of
its position in Korean culture. understood as exclusively feedbacks of aegyo or friends and acquaintances.
Korean. pleasurable experience of
2. WHAT MAKES AEGYO receiving or being exposed
KOREAN 3. IMPLICATIONS ON THE to aegyo . This brings us to ABOUT AUTHORS Yewon Hong
POSITIONALITY OF WOMEN the question of paradox of Yonsei University
Many failed to identify female agency and “free” Underwood International College
aegyo in non-Korean context, Most important part of choice with regards to aegyo Comparative Literature and
for instance having a hard the research is certainly the of South Korea. It is important Culture, Class of 12
time depicting or defining it in “politics” of aegyo and the to see how this all-pervading dalihong@naver.com
foreign languages. During the position of this phenomenon practice of self-infantilization 010-8847-4823
Sehee Eom
surveys and interviews, aegyo in the lives of Korean women, affects what people imagine
Yonsei University
was often characterized by and more indirectly, men. as “Korean women,” or any
Underwood International College
its style of speech, something Most agreed aegyo is “good” idealized female image that
Political Science and International
that cannot be easily for women, and is frequently is being propagated in the
Relations, Class of 12
translated or fathomed in expected from young society of unequal power
jbnd12@gmail.com
other languages. Infantilization women in various types of distribution.
010-5317-6769

You might also like