Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Seven models for conceptualizing positive mental health are reviewed: mental health as above normal, epitomized by a DSM-IV’s Global
Assessment of Functioning (GAF) score of over 80; mental health as the presence of multiple human strengths rather than the absence
of weaknesses; mental health conceptualized as maturity; mental health as the dominance of positive emotions; mental health as high
socio-emotional intelligence; mental health as subjective well-being; mental health as resilience. Safeguards for the study of mental
health are suggested, including the need to define mental health in terms that are culturally sensitive and inclusive, and the need to
empirically and longitudinally validate criteria for mental health.
Key words: Positive mental health, maturity, resilience, coping mechanisms, subjective well-being, emotional intelligence, positive emotions
The great epidemiological studies of to define mental health may appear pa- healthy in some cultures, but that does
the past half century have focused upon rochial to those from other countries. not mean that the tolerated behavior is
who was mentally ill and not who was Thus, the commentaries on this paper mentally healthy. Until recently, Por-
well. Mental illness, after all, is a condi- will be particularly important. tugal did not recognize alcoholism as
tion that can be defined reliably, and its The second precaution is to keep an illness, but that did not reduce the
limits are relatively clear. Until recently, in mind that “average” is not healthy. contribution of alcoholism to mortal-
only the Sterling County Studies by A. Community surveys always mix in the ity in Lisbon. The best way to enrich
Leighton (1) came close to defining pos- healthy with the prevalent amount of our understanding of what constitutes
itive mental health operationally. In ad- psychopathology. In the case of red mental health is to study a variety of
dition, it has been argued that achieving blood count, or thyroid function, the healthy populations from different per-
above average mental or physical health middle of the bell curve is healthy. In the spectives, in different cultures and for a
is not the province of medicine, but of case of eyesight, only the upper end of long period of time.
education. the bell curve is healthy; and in the case This paper will contrast seven differ-
Early in the past century, internists of cholesterol and bilirubin only the low ent empirical models of mental health.
began studying physiology at high al- end of the curve is healthy. First, mental health can be conceptu-
titude and devise measures of positive A third precaution is to make clear alized as above normal, as epitomized
physical health for athletes, pilots, and whether one is discussing trait or state. by a DSM-IV’s Global Assessment of
finally astronauts. In 1929-30, at the Longitudinal study is particularly im- Functioning (GAF, 6) score of over 80.
University of California at Berkeley, the portant. A world-class soccer player Second, it can be regarded as the pres-
Institute of Human Development was temporarily sidelined with a sprained ence of multiple human strengths rather
founded by H. Jones, N. Bayley and J. ankle (state) is probably healthier than a than the absence of weaknesses. Third,
McFarlane (2,3). Originally created to type 1 diabetic (trait) with a temporarily it can be conceptualized as maturity.
study healthy child development, the normal blood sugar. Fourth, it can be seen as the dominance
Institute was to provide a seminal influ- Finally, mental health needs to be of positive emotions. Fifth, it can be
ence on E. Erikson’s model of healthy seen in context. Sickle cell trait is un- conceptualized as high socio-emotional
adult development. In the late 1930s, A. healthy in Paris, but not in central Af- intelligence. Sixth, it can be viewed as
Bock, an internist trained in high alti- rica where malaria is endemic. In the subjective well-being. Seventh, it can be
tude physiology and interested in posi- 1940s, paranoid personalities made very conceptualized as resilience.
tive physical health, began the Study of poor submariners but excellent airplane To avoid quibbling over which traits
Adult Development at the Harvard Uni- spotters. Punctuality and competitive- characterize mental health, it is help-
versity (4,5). This was designed as an in- ness are seen as healthy in some com- ful to adopt the analogy of a decathlon
terdisciplinary study of both mental and munities, but not in others. champion. What constitutes a “track
physical health. Moreover, if mental health is “good”, star”? A decathlon star must possess
Like physical fitness, positive mental what is it good for? The self or the so- muscle strength, speed, endurance,
health is too important to be ignored, ciety? For “fitting in” or for creativ- grace and competitive grit, although the
but its definition is not easy. Several pre- ity? In defining mental health, biology combinations may vary. Amongst de-
cautions are necessary. First, in defining usually trumps anthropology. Cultural cathlon champions, the general defini-
mental health, cross-cultural differences anthropology teaches us that almost tion will not differ from nation to nation,
must be kept in mind. My own efforts every form of behavior is considered or century to century. The salience of a
93
95
97
99