Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/250072477
CITATIONS READS
24 3,315
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Eunsoo Choi on 30 March 2015.
This paper introduces a new steel-jacketing method for reinforced by Harajli and Dagher (2008) to be significant characteristics
concrete (RC) columns using external pressure. Experimental tests for seismic rehabilitation. Increased stiffness reduces the
of concrete cylinders and RC columns are performed to assess the fundamental period of the structure and increases the applied
effectiveness of the proposed method. Single- and double-layered seismic load. The FRP jackets are probably preferred in
jackets are introduced. The newly jacketed cylinders show good
practice due to the aforementioned benefits (Pantelides et al.
results in terms of increasing the compressive strength and
ductility compared to plain cylinders. The double-layered jackets 2004; Pantelides et al. 2007). The price of FRP jackets,
are estimated to show equal performance to that of a single steel however, is generally higher than that of concrete or steel
jacket having the same thickness as the double-layered jacket. Four jackets. Also, FRP jackets use adhesives such as epoxy to
columns are prepared and two of them are confined by steel jackets attach themselves to the concrete surface. The adhesive has
with external pressure; one is a single-layered jacket and the other been proven to reduce the effectiveness of jackets on
is a double-layered jacket. The proposed steel-jacketing method concrete cylinders because it generates a thin gap between
increases the ductility of lap-spliced RC columns. The double- the concrete and the jacket (Choi et al. 2009).
layered jacketed column produces more ductile behavior than the This study proposes a new steel-jacketing method that
single-layered jacketed column. uses the external application of lateral pressure to attach steel
jackets on the surface of columns. The proposed method
Keywords: external pressure; grouting; reinforced concrete columns;
seismic retrofit; steel jacket. does not require the application of grout between the steel
jackets and the concrete surface to attach them together.
INTRODUCTION Compressive tests of concrete cylinders and a bending test of
In South Korea, many reinforced concrete (RC) bridge RC columns confined by steel jackets were conducted
piers were constructed using lap splicing with starter bars following the application of the proposed method to assess
projecting above the foundation before the seismic design the effectiveness of the technique.
code of the Korea highway bridge design specification
(KHBDS) enacted in 1992. Even after the implementation of RESEARCH SIGNIFICANCE
the KHBDS, some bridges were constructed with the lap- The objective of this study is to propose a new steel-
spliced connections because their designs had been jacketing method for RC columns without grouting. The
completed before the implementation (Chung et al. 2008). It method is not expected to produce the composite behavior
is known that spliced reinforcement with short splice lengths between steel jackets and concrete in the conventional
and inadequate confinement in the critical region, including methods and thus can solve the problem of increasing the
the base of bridge piers, can allow splitting bond failure that lateral stiffness of steel jacketed columns. The new method
leads to stiffness degradation, loss of energy dissipation also offers the following advantages: 1) no increase in the
capacity, and low deformation capacity (Harajli 2008; cross section of RC columns; 2) no use of an adhesive, such
Chung et al. 2004). Since the first steel-jacketing method as epoxy; and 3) allows for installation of steel jackets at any
(Chai et al. 1991) as a seismic retrofitting technique was position of a column (bottom, middle, or top).
introduced, external confinements of steel and fiber-
reinforced polymer (FRP) have been recognized as a very CONCRETE CYLINDERS TEST AND RESULTS
effective means to improve the performance of the lap- Twelve concrete cylinders of 150 x 300 mm (Φ x H; 6 x
spliced region of RC columns. Each of the existing external 12 in.) were fabricated with a design strength of 24 MPa
jacketing methods has strong and weak points. Concrete and (3.48 ksi). A steel jacket and lateral strip bands were used to
steel jackets are very effective for improving the ductility of confine a cylinder, as shown in Fig. 1(a). The dimensions of
bond failure at lap-spliced points. It is inconvenient, each jacket were 290 mm (11.4 in.) in height and 480 mm
however, to install such jackets on RC columns because (18.9 in.) in width. The height of the steel jacket was less
doing so requires using scaffolds and allowing for the curing than that of the concrete cylinders, which guaranteed that no
of the concrete in concrete jackets or for curing the grout compressive force would be transferred to the steel jackets.
between the steel and the concrete when using steel jackets. The width of the jacket was larger than the perimeter of the
Additionally, concrete jackets increase the sectional area of cylinder by 10 mm (0.394 in.) to allow the jacket to wrap
a column; and steel jackets produce sectional discontinuity
because they are installed only around critical sections of a
column. FRP jackets have several advantages over steel and ACI Structural Journal, V. 107, No. 6, November-December 2010.
MS No. S-2008-239.R7 received April 7, 2009, and reviewed under Institute publication
concrete jackets: 1) ease of installation; 2) no increment of policies. Copyright © 2010, American Concrete Institute. All rights reserved, including the
the cross section of RC columns; and 3) no increment of the making of copies unless permission is obtained from the copyright proprietors. Pertinent
discussion including author’s closure, if any, will be published in the September-October
flexural or shear stiffness of the structure, which were found 2011 ACI Structural Journal if the discussion is received by May 1, 2011.
of flexure and axial compression. This can be attributed to respectively. Once these cracks formed, a slight bulge of
the relatively large stress at a large drift ratio, which leads to the steel jackets was observed when the lateral drift
the buckling and eventually fracture of the reinforcement increased up to the drift ratio of 3.0% and 5.0% for Specimen
and hence core concrete crushing. For the jacketed columns, RC-N-SP50-UB1 and Specimen RC-N-SP50-UB2, respectively.
as shown in Fig. 5(c) and (d), first flexural cracks were The bulge in the steel jackets, however, did not seem to affect the
generally observed at the drift ratio of 0.5% and initiated at failure of the columns.
the location above the height of steel jackets. Then, most
flexural cracks seemed to propagate toward the inside of the Lateral load-drift response
steel jackets and thus were not visible. A relatively small Figures 6 and 7 show the applied shear force versus
amount of the flexural cracks were observed in the jacketed drift ratio response of the column specimens and the
specimens compared to the unjacketed specimens, when the envelopes of the hysteretic curves. In Fig. 8(b), Specimen
steel jackets were removed from the specimens after RC-N-SP00-NUB developed an initial flexural crack at
completing the test. In particular, flexural cracks were not 0.5% drift and the reinforcing bar was yielded at 1.0% drift;
even fully developed in Specimen RC-N-SP50-UB2 (the the yield was assessed from the strain of a section of a
double-layered jacket). Accordingly, the propagation of these reinforcing bar measured at the bottom of the column. At the
cracks does not seem to be severe enough to reach the failure drift ratio of 1.0%, the measured strain was 5.523 × 10–3,
of the columns. which is 3.6 times the yield strain of the reinforcements.
The observation of the column test results also indicates After the drift ratio of 4%, at which the cover concrete was
that the failure of the jacketed columns was initiated by the crushed and the reinforcements were exposed, the load-
flexural cracks developed at the column-footing interface. carrying capacity of the column decreased until the drift ratio
The flexural cracks that occurred at the position were first of 6.0%. Specimen RC-N-SP00-NUB showed an abrupt
formed at the drift ratio of 2.0% and 1.5% for Specimen softening behavior out of line with the behavior of
RC-N-SP50-UB1 and Specimen RC-N-SP50-UB2, comparing to the other specimens. The cause of the behavior
for Specimen RC-N-SP50-NUB, 79.5 and –56.5 kN NUB. The average values of displacement ductility for the
(17.87 and –12.70 kips) for Specimen RC-N-SP00-NUB, jacketed columns were 4.87 and 5.65 for 1.0 and 2.0 mm
73.5 and –77.5 kN (16.52 and 17.42 kips) for Specimen RC- (0.0394 and 0.07874 in.) jackets; the ductility of Specimen
N-SP50-UB1, and 73.5 and –81.3 kN (16.52 and –18.28 kips) for RC-N-SP50-UB2 is close to that of Specimen RC-N-SP00-
Specimen RC-N-SP50-UB2, respectively. The jacketed specimens NUB (μ = 5.86). The aforementioned results indicate that the
showed similar failure loads. proposed steel-jacketing method can enhance the
displacement ductility of the lap-spliced columns. Also, the
Displacement ductility performance of the double-layered jacket is better by 14.7%
Based on the envelopes as shown in Fig. 9, the ultimate than that of the single-layered jacket. Thus, the double-
and the yield displacements are assessed, as arranged in layered jacket was proven to be more effective for the
Table 2. The ultimate displacement Δu was defined as the jacketing of RC columns as well as for concrete cylinders.
lesser of the measured displacements between when
longitudinal or confinement steel exceeds its fracture state Strains of longitudinal reinforcements
and when the strength on the descending branch of the force- In addition to the global behavior of the specimens, the
displacement envelope curve becomes less than 0.85Vmax. local behavior at the critical region was investigated by
The yield displacement Δy was defined as the displacement measuring the strains of reinforcements of the specimens and
of the crossing point of the following two lines: the straight analyzing the characteristics of the failure of the specimens.
line that passes through the origin and 0.75Vmax of the Strain gauges on longitudinal reinforcements were placed at
envelope curve and the line that passes Vmax on the envelope 200 mm (7.874 in.) above the base of the specimens. The
curve parallel to the x-axis. The results of displacement gauges were attached at the front side of the actuator and
ductility μ = Δ/Δy are listed in Table 2. The ultimate farthest away from the center of the cross section. Figure 6
displacements of Specimens RC-N-SP50-UB1 and RC-N-SP50- shows the load-strain relationships for each specimen. The
UB2 were 1.77 and 2.03 times that of Specimen RC-N-SP50- pushing and pulling action produced tensile or reversed