Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Vol: 24 No. 10
Monthly October 2018
INSIGHT
“Pakistan will continue its unconditional and full support for the people of Jammu and Kashmir
and we will make all out efforts at every level to resolve the issue according to the resolutions of
United Nations. The resolution of conflict of Jammu and Kashmir is essential to have an
enduring relationship between Pakistan and India. Denying the Kashmiris the right to self-
determination is condemnable and international community should play its role in the
resolution of the issue.”
“The unresolved Kashmir dispute poses a great threat to peace and stability in the region. Peace
can never be established in South Asia unless the issue of Kashmir is resolved in accordance with
the UN resolutions. It is India that in plain sight operates state terrorism in Jammu and Kashmir
and it is a matter of great concern that humanity is being crushed and human rights are being
violated all across India.”
Security Advisor, John Bolton, in President and High Indian Foreign Minister, Sushma
Washington and discussed Representative of the European Swaraj’s speech termed it as a
bilateral ties and regional Union on Foreign Affairs and pack of lies, deceit, arrogance
situation. During their meeting, Security Policy; Yousuf Bin and persistent denial of the
Shah Mehmood Qureshi and Alawi bin Abdullah, Foreign ground realities in Kashmir. He
Mike Pompeo deliberated upon Minister of Oman; Adel bin said that it was due to the
the bilateral issues and matters Ahmed Al-Jubeir, Foreign arrogant mindset that India
pertaining to regional security. Minister of the Kingdom of Saudi preferred to be in denial mode
The Pakistan Foreign Minister Arabia; Taro Kono, Minister for since the tragedy of Kashmir was
said that peace in South Asia - a Foreign Affairs of Japan; Wang born in 1947. He said that India
common goal of both the US and Yi, State Councillor and Foreign claimed to be the largest democ-
Pakistan - would remain elusive Minister of China and racy of the world having a multi-
until all disputes - including the Mohammed bin Abdulrahman cultural society and a fast-
core issue of Kashmir - were Al-Thani, Foreign Minister of growing economic hub but had
resolved. Qatar and highlighted the plight no courage to accept the bare and
Shah Mehmood Qureshi during of the people of occupied internationally-recognised
his visit to the US met various Kashmir. These dignitaries Kashmir dispute only because it
world leaders and apprised them assured Shah Mehmood Qureshi believed that it could crush the
of the Indian brutalities in strong support to the legitimate Kashmiris’ legitimate liberation
occupied Kashmir. struggle with its
He also urged them military might.
to play their role in Senior APHC
the peaceful resolu- l e a d e r ,
tion of the Kashmir Muhammad
dispute. Ashraf Sehrai, in
The Pakistan foreign his statement
minister addressing hailing Shah
a distinguished M e h m o o d
gathering of busi- Qureshi’s address
ness leaders, think at the United
tank analysts and Nations General
media persons Assembly said
convened by that Pakistani
Atlantic Council Foreign Minister
spoke at length cause of the Kashmiri people. had boldly highlighted at the
about Pakistan’s proactive On the other hand, Hurriyat international forum the need for
engagement with neighbouring leaders hailed the Foreign resolution of the Kashmir
countries seeking peace and Minister of Pakistan, Shah dispute. He said that the
stability in South Asia. Mehmood Qureshi, for coura- lingering dispute was a bone of
Shah Mehmood Qureshi also geously highlighting the
held meetings with Ambassador contention between the two
Kashmir dispute in his address at nuclear powers in South Asia,
Zalmay Khalilzad, named as the the United Nations General
US Special Envoy for Pakistan and India.
Assembly. The Chairman of Jammu and
Afghanistan who was flanked by The Chairman of All Parties
Ambassador Alice Wells, the US Kashmir Salvation Movement,
Hurriyat Conference, Syed Ali
Principal Deputy Assistant Zafar Akbar Butt, in a statement
Gilani, in a statement issued in
Secretary of State for South and also welcomed the address of
Srinagar said that Shah
Central Asian Affairs; Sheikh Shah Mehmood Qurershi. He
Mehmood Qureshi’s address
Abdullah bin Ziyad, Foreign also hailed the UN Secretary
had once again proved that
Minister of the UAE; Sameh Pakistan was a friend and well- General, Antonio Guterres, for
Hassan Shoukry, Foreign wisher of the people of Jammu expressing concern over the
Minister of the Arab Republic of and Kashmir. The APHC prevailing grim situation in
Egypt; Federica Mogherini, Vice Chairman while reacting to the occupied Kashmir.
Ahmed Bakhshi, and a pellet- pellets on protesters by Indian Hira Nagar jails in Jammu region.
blinded youth, Suhail Ahmed troops during a cordon and search September 27: Indian troops
Tramboo, under draconian law, operation in Shirmal area of killed four youth during cordon
Public Safety Act, and shifted Shopian. and search operations in Srinagar,
them to Kathua Jail in Jammu. The occupation authorities Budgam and Islamabad areas.
September 19: A woman, Rifat booked two youth, Firdous The troops also killed a non-
Jan, died due to heart attack when Ahmed and Aadil Hussain, under Kashmiri, Umesh, in Kupwara.
Indian troops barged into her draconian law, Public Safety Act, Over 30 youth were injured after
house and ruthlessly thrashed and lodged them at Kot Bhalwal they were hit by the pellets fired
and arrested her brother, Jail in Jammu. by the troops on protesters in
Hidayatullah, in front of her at September 23: The troops during Budgam and Srinagar areas.
Ashmuji in Kulgam. cordon and search operations Indian police arrested five youth
More than 50 mourners were killed two youth in Tangdhar area from Baramulla and Islamabad
injured after Indian police used of Kupwara district and another districts.
brute force on Muharram in Tral area of Pulwama. September 28: The occupation
processions in Srinagar. Several youth were injured when authorities disallowed people to
September 20: Indian troops the troops fired bullets and pellets offer Friday prayers at Jamia
killed two youth during a cordon on protesters in Tral. Masjid in Srinagar and put
and search operation Hurriyat le aders,
at Shukbabun-Sumlar Syed Ali Gilani,
in Bandipore. Mirwaiz Umar
Indian police arrested F a r o o q a n d
two youth during Muhammad Yasin
house raids in Malik, under house
Saidpora-Bala area of arrest or in custody.
Shopian district. Indian police
Many mourners arrested three youth
sustained injuries in Islamabad and
after Indian police
Pulwama areas.
subjected the
The authorities
M u h a r r a m
booked Hurriyet
processions to brute
leaders, Shabbir
force in Srinagar.
Ahmed Dar, Ghulam
September 21: Indian troops September 24: Indian troops
killed three more youth during during continued military
Ahmed Gulzar, Peer Ghulam
continued cordon and search operation killed three more youth Mohi-ud-Din and Advocate
operation at Shukbabun-Sumlar in Tangdhar. Hussain Ahmed, under black
in Bandipore. September 25: The troops killed law, Public Safety Act, and
The occupation authorities two youth during a cordon and lodged them at Kot Bhalwal Jail
imposed restrictions in Srinagar search operation at Tujjar Sharif in in Jammu.
to prevent people from taking out Sopore. September 29: Several people
Aashura processions. The Indian police arrested several were injured after Indian forces’
authorities also disallowed Hurriyat leaders and activists personnel fired pellets and
congregational Friday prayers at including Ghulam Ahmad teargas shells on protesters in
historic Jamia Masjid and Gulzar, Nisar Hussain Rathar, Redwani area of Kulgam.
detained Syed Ali Gilani and Muhammad Yasin Attai and Syed September 30: Indian troops
Mirwaiz Umar Farooq at their Imtiaz Haider in Srinagar. ruthlessly beat up and injured
residences. September 26: The occupation over three dozen people during a
Scores of mourners were injured authorities booked four youth, cordon and search operation at
after Indian police used brute Gowhar Hassan Parray, Ishfaq Kareemabad in Pulwama. The
force on Aashura processions in Ahmed Parray, Aijaz Ahmed Mir troops also arrested two dozen
Srinagar. and Bilal Ahmed Parray, under youth, damaged many residential
September 22: At least six people black law, Public Safety Act, and houses and disgraced several
were injured due to the firing of shifted them to Kot Bhalwal and women in the area.
who were forced to live with to self-determination of the UN chief, Antonio Guterres’
arbitrary arrest, imprisonment, people of the territory and its remarks. He appealed to the UN
torture and killings in their resolution must be sought to play its role in the peaceful
everyday lives. within the parameters of that settlement of the Kashmir
Syed Ali Gilani, Mirwaiz Umar definition as well. They said that dispute for ensuring durable
Farooq and Muhammad Yasin this facet of the dispute could peace in South Asia. He said that
Malik in their letter pointed out only be addressed if the people tripartite dialogue involving
that the Indian forces continued of Jammu and Kashmir were Pakistan, India and the genuine
to shower pellets and bullets permitted to represent their case Kashmiri leadership was the
indiscriminately on the and asked Antonio Guterres to best way to resolve the lingering
unarmed civilian population. champion their right to be heard Kashmir dispute.
According to reports, they said, on the dispute as the primary Earlier on September 13, the
more than 16,000 people in party to it. United Nations Secretary
Kashmir suffered serious The Chairman of International General listed India among
injuries by pellets while Forum for Justice and Human several countries in his report
hundreds have been rendered Rights, Muhammad Ahsan that details an alarming level of
permanently harsh reprisals and
blinded and 14 intimidation against
percent of these those who cooperate
victims were below with the UN on
the age of 15. They human rights issues.
recalled as how the The ninth annual
campaign of report of the UN
suppression Secretary General
through daily detailed the level of
cordon and search retaliation against
operations (CASOs) human rights
has become a defenders on a
permanent feature country-by-country
of the Indian basis, including
occupation. They Untoo, in a letter addressed to allegations of killing,
said, during these operations, the UN General Secretary said torture, arbitrary arrests, and
the forces’ personnel assault that for the past almost three public stigmatisation
residents and damage their decades now, occupied campaigns, which also target
properties. They said that a war- Kashmir had experienced an victims of rights abuse. The
like situation existed in ugly cycle of repression report documents allegations of
Islamabad, Bandipora, followed by an explosion of reprisals and intimidation in 38
Baramulla, Kulgam, Pulwama violence in the form of countries, some of which are
and Shopian districts. The unprecedented human rights members of the UN Human
leaders also attached some violations at the hands of Indian Rights Council.
pictures with the letter to forces’ personnel. The cases of Kartik Murukutla, a
highlight the enormity of the He pointed out that unabated member of the Jammu and
atrocities committed by the human rights abuses were the Kashmir Coalition of Civil
Indian forces on the people of benchmark of Indian Society, and Khurram Parvez,
occupied Kashmir. occupation over Kashmir where Chairperson of the Asian
The resistance leaders through people see the UN as the only Federation Against Involuntary
the letter informed the UN chief ray of hope. Disappearances and
that Jammu and Kashmir was The Chairman of Jammu and Programme Coordinator of
not a territorial dispute between Kashmir Salvation Movement Jammu and Kashmir Coalition
India and Pakistan but (JKSM), Zafar Akbar Butt, in a of Civil Society, were
primarily a question of the right statement also welcomed the mentioned in the report.
Syed Faiz Naqshbandi stated Kingdom and Ronald Barnes The Chairman of South Asia
that the resistance leaders in from Alaska criticised the world Centre for Peace and Human
occupied Kashmir have been community for turning a blind Rights (SACFPHR), Professor
under detention without eye to the grim situation in Nazir Ahmed Shawl, on the
reprieve whilst the internet occupied Kashmir, stating that occasion stressed that the
services have been clamped ignoring Indian oppression in Kashmir dispute, recognised by
down, epitomising the Indian the territory is a criminal silence. the United Nations, needed to be
attitude to peaceful political The roundtable was held next to addressed in accordance with the
dissent. the famous broken chair, will of the Kashmiri people.
Michael Rosenbaum, a student in representing anti-mines The UN Legal Representative for
Geneva, expressed his admira- campaign, in the United Nations Resource Centre for Palestine
tion and support for the Squire in which a large number Residency and Refugee Rights,
Kashmiris’ cause for the right to of people from media commu- Rania Madi, shared her concern
self-determination, sharing his nity participated. about numerous causes still
own family’s experience of On September 23, the searching for the right to self-
political activism resulting in International Human Rights determination.
exile from Russia. Association of American Barrister Stuart Stevens of
Yasir Ahmed, General Secretary Minorities (IHRAAM) in Holborn Chambers observed
of Kashmir Youth Alliance collaboration with International that the world is no longer
(KYA), vowed that governed by justice but
the sacrifices of the by domination of
people of occupied economic interests,
Kashmir particularly creating victims out of
those youth who anyone who wants self-
have suffered at the determination, and to
hands of brutal change this phenome-
Indian occupational non, political will of all
forces would not go stakeholder must exist.
waste. The Chairman of
Zubair Awan, Kashmir Youth
Chairmain KYA, Assembly, Zubair
pledged that young Awan, commented that
Kashmiri diaspora collective responsibility
would raise the issue of Kashmir Council for Human Rights by the world community can
on every platform available and (ICHR) conducted an event ensure the right to self-
create a new generation of “Obstacles to right to self- determination for the people of
activists to lobby the Kashmir determination”. Kashmir.
cause. Barrister Abdul Majeed Tramboo The special guest at the event was
Kashmiri representative, of IHRAAM, chairing the event, a noted lawyer and human rights
Shamim Shawl, in her address remarked that civil society and activist, Advocate Deepika Singh
highlighted the violence against NGOs have been vocal since the Rajawat, the counsel repre-
women and children perpetrated inception of the UN Human senting the parents of eight-year-
by the Indian forces and other Rights Council (UNHRC) to old Aasifa Bano, who was raped
Government functionaries. She ensure that the right to self- and brutally murdered in Kathua
raised the issue of 8-year-old girl determination is brought back on area of occupied Kashmir. She
Asaifa Bano who was gang- its agenda. He posed the ques- stressed if one actually wishes to
raped and brutally murdered tion of obstacles and the methods work on the protection of human
and the BJP politicians attempted to remove them, asking if there rights, he/she must work from
to save the culprits. was a way to successfully the heart with passion, putting
Chaudhry Parvaiz Ashraf, influence the UNHRC to return everything at stake; that is when
former AJK minister, Sardar the right to self-determination you become a true human rights
Mahmood Iqbal of Belgium, Raja back on its agenda and put in activist, otherwise it is only for
Sikandar Khan of United action. show.
OCTOBER 2018 27
Chronology
Shalimar Bagh
Shalimar Bagh, the celebrated on the lake shore, it is connected (public audience hall). In this
royal garden in Srinagar, is to the Dal Lake by a long canal, hall, a small black marble throne
considered to be the finest and the formal approach to the was installed over the waterfall.
Mughal-style garden. It is garden is through this canal. It The emperor during his stay in
located on the northeast side of can now also be reached from the Kashmir held his daily court
famous Dal Lake, approximately road that runs around the lake. here.
fifteen kilometers away from the The Shalimar Bagh is an adapta- The second terrace garden along
center of Srinagar. It was built by tion of the formal Persian chahar the axial canal, slightly broader,
the Mughal Emperor Jahangir in bagh, traditionally uniform in has two shallow terraces. The
1619 for his wife, Nur Jahan. He shape, with a water source in its Diwan-i-Khas (the hall of private
was so fascinated with the center and four radiating streams audience), which was accessible
garden that he called it Farah that divide the garden into four only to the noblemen or guests of
Bakhsh (the delightful) and "one sections. It adapts the chahar the court, now derelict, is in its
of the sights of centre. However, the carved
Kashmir." stone bases and a fine
platform surrounded by
The Shalimar Bagh was fountains are still seen.
constructed not merely The royal bathrooms are
as garden but it also located on the north-west
served as the summer boundary of this enclo-
residence of the sure.
Mughals. The water In the third terrace, the
canals and fountains axial water channel flows
cover a major area of the through the Zenana
garden and the gurgling (harem) garden, which is
sound of soothing water flanked by the Diwan-i-
canals, lovely fountains, Khas and chinar trees. At
vibrant flowers and the the entrance to this
old architecture make this bagh to the mountainous terrace, there are two small
garden a wonderful place to topography by emphasizing the pavilions or guard rooms (built
spend a fine sunny day. central water channel; the in Kashmiri-style on stone
In 1630, on the orders of Shah secondary channels are mini- platform) that is the restricted
Jahan, the local Kashmiri mized or removed from the
and controlled entry zone of the
governor, Zafar Khan, extended design, and the source of water
royal harem.
shifts from the center of the
the garden under the name of The Shalimar Bagh is well known
garden to its highest point. Thus
Faiz Bakhsh (the bountiful). for its chini khanas, or niches,
the central water canal of the
Under Pathan and Sikh gover- behind garden waterfalls. These
garden (Shah Nahar) forms its
nors, Shalimar was treated as a niches, which once held oil
main axis, uniting the three
pleasure resort, and during the lamps, now hold pots of flowers,
terraces with their regularly
reign of Ranjit Singh, European placed fountains and chinar so that their colours will be
visitors were housed in its (sycamore) tree-lined vistas. reflected behind the flowing
marble pavilion. The Maharaja Beginning at the top of the water. Presently, the garden is a
Hari Singh had installed electric garden, the canal runs through public park.
lights in the garden. each of the baradaris (pavilions) The best time to visit Shalimar
Covering an area of approxi- in the garden. Bagh is during autumn and
mately 12.4 hectares, the garden Within the Shalimar Bagh, there spring season (September-
is rectangular in shape. It is are three terraces with different October and mid-February till
oriented northeast to southwest, functions and level of privacy. mid-April) when Chinar trees
with the highest point located The first terrace is a public change their colours from green
along the northeast side. garden or the outer garden to orange and yellow, giving a
Although it is not located directly ending in the Diwan-e-Aam warm glow to the garden.
“We do not seek to go behind the United Nations Commission for India and Pakistan
(UNCIP) resolutions, or to ignore the vital elements of principle contained in them .…
We have always adhered to the UNCIP resolutions …. We cannot be a party to the
reversal of previous decisions taken by the United Nations Commission with the
agreement of the parties.”