You are on page 1of 14

3RD DISTRICT COURT - SALT LAKE

SALT LAKE COUNTY, STATE OF UTAH

STATE OF UTAH vs. MELVIN SHAWN ROWLAND


CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________
CHARGES
Charge 1 - 76-4-401 - ENTICING A MINOR OVER THE INTERNET 2nd
Degree Felony
Offense Date: September 17, 2003
Plea: March 15, 2004 Guilty
Disposition: March 15, 2004 {Guilty Plea}

CURRENT ASSIGNED JUDGE


RANDALL SKANCHY

PARTIES
Defendant - MELVIN SHAWN ROWLAND
Represented by: LISA J REMAL
Plaintiff - STATE OF UTAH
Represented by: PAUL G AMANN
Bondsman - BREAK OUT BAIL BONDS INC

DEFENDANT INFORMATION
Defendant Name: MELVIN SHAWN ROWLAND
Offense tracking number: 13997077
Date of Birth: May 12, 1981
Jail Booking Number: 0324246
Law Enforcement Agency: ATTORNEY GENERAL
LEA Case Number:
Prosecuting Agency: SALT LAKE COUNTY
Agency Case Number:
Sheriff Office Number: 0275287

ACCOUNT SUMMARY
PAPER BOND TOTALS Posted: 10,000.00
Forfeited: 0.00
Exonerated: 10,000.00
Balance: 0.00
NONMONETARY BOND DETAIL - TYPE: Surety
Posted By: {BREAK OUT BAIL BONDS, LLC} (#4040)
Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:49 Page 1

Page 1 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________
Posted: 10,000.00
Forfeited: 0.00
Exonerated: 10,000.00
Balance: 0.00

CASE NOTE
ATTORNEY GENERAL
PROCEEDINGS
09-23-03 Note: CASE FILED BY ATTY GENERALS OFFICE WARRANT ACTIVE
09-23-03 Judge SHEILA K MCCLEVE assigned.
09-23-03 Notice - WARRANT for Case 031906408 ID 5731789
09-23-03 Warrant ordered on: September 23, 2003 Warrant Num: 981112215
Bail Allowed
Bail amount: 50000.00
09-23-03 Warrant issued on: September 23, 2003 Warrant Num: 981112215
Bail Allowed
Bail amount: 50000.00
Judge: SHEILA K MCCLEVE
Issue reason: Based on the probable cause statement
09-23-03 Case filed
09-23-03 Filed: From an Information
09-26-03 INITIAL APPEARANCE scheduled on September 29, 2003 at 09:00 AM
with Judge ARR.
09-26-03 Warrant recalled on: September 26, 2003 Warrant num: 981112215
Recall reason: Defendant was booked
09-26-03 Note: Clerk notified Paul Amann of AG's office of initial
appearance date on Monday, 9/29.
09-29-03 Filed: Affidavit of Indigency - Approved by Judge Atherton.
09-29-03 Minute Entry - Minutes for Appointment of Counsel
Judge: JUDITH S ATHERTON
PRESENT
Clerk: lorip
Prosecutor: LEMCKE, HOWARD R
Defendant Present

Video
Tape Number: 37 Tape Count: 930

INITIAL APPEARANCE
Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:49 Page 2

Page 2 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________

The Information is read.


Advised of charges and penalties.
APPOINTMENT OF COUNSEL

Court finds the defendant indigent and appoints Salt Lake Legal
Defenders to represent the defendant.

Appointed Counsel:

Name: Salt Lake Legal Defenders


Address: 424 East 500 South Suite #101
City: Salt Lake City UT 84111
Phone: 532-5444

ROLL CALL is scheduled.


Date: 10/09/2003
Time: 02:00 p.m.
Location: To Be Determined
Third District Court
450 South State
Salt Lake City, UT 84111
Before Judge: ANN BOYDEN
09-29-03 ROLL CALL scheduled on October 09, 2003 at 02:00 PM with Judge
BOYDEN.
09-30-03 Note: Bail remain - To complete PTS/ Dr. Decaria evaluation.
10-08-03 Filed: Appearance of COunsel
10-08-03 Filed: Formal Request for Discovery
10-08-03 Filed: Notice of Bond Hearing
10-09-03 Filed: Notice of Bond Hearing
10-09-03 Filed: Formal Request for Discovery
10-09-03 Filed: Appearance of Counsel
10-09-03 ROLL CALL scheduled on October 21, 2003 at 02:00 PM with Judge
BURTON.
10-09-03 Minute Entry - Minutes for Roll Call
Judge: ANN BOYDEN
PRESENT
Clerk: terryb
Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:50 Page 3

Page 3 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________
Prosecutor: PAUL G. AMANN
Defendant Present
Defendant's Attorney(s): LISA J. REMAL

Video
Tape Count: 4.43

HEARING

Bail reduction is denied. May readdress at next hearing. New


charges is being filed. Roll call continued to 10/21.
ROLL CALL.
Date: 10/21/2003
Time: 02:00 p.m.
Location: To Be Determined
Third District Court
450 South State
Salt Lake City, UT 84111
Before Judge: MICHAEL K. BURTON
10-21-03 ROLL CALL scheduled on October 28, 2003 at 02:00 PM with Judge
BOHLING.
10-21-03 Minute Entry - Minutes for Roll Call
Judge: JOSEPH C. FRATTO
PRESENT
Clerk: terryb
Prosecutor: PAUL AMANN
Defendant Present
Defendant's Attorney(s): LISA J. REMAL

Video
Tape Count: 2.44

HEARING

Roll call continued to 10/28 to consolidate with other case.


ROLL CALL.
Date: 10/28/2003
Time: 02:00 p.m.
Location: To Be Determined
Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:50 Page 4

Page 4 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________
Third District Court
450 South State
Salt Lake City, UT 84111
Before Judge: WILLIAM B BOHLING
10-28-03 Preliminary Hearing scheduled on December 02, 2003 at 09:00 AM
in THIRD FLOOR - S35 with Judge DEVER.
10-28-03 Minute Entry - Minutes for Roll Call
Judge: WILLIAM B BOHLING
PRESENT
Clerk: terryb
Prosecutor: PAUL G AMANN
Defendant Present
Defendant's Attorney(s): LISA J. REMAL

Video
Tape Count: off record

HEARING

COUNT: off record


Court Orders Case set for Preliminary Hearing
PRELIMINARY HEARING is scheduled.
Date: 12/02/2003
Time: 09:00 a.m.
Location: Third Floor - S35
Before Judge: DEVER, L A
11-10-03 Filed: Letter from Krystal Wilbur
12-02-03 Minute Entry - Minutes for Preliminary Hearing
Judge: L A DEVER
PRESENT
Clerk: rhondam
Reporter: GREEN, TEENA
Prosecutor: AMANN, PAUL G
Defendant Present
Defendant's Attorney(s): REMAL, LISA J.

Video
Tape Number: 1 Tape Count: 10:34-12:40

Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:50 Page 5

Page 5 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________
HEARING

Exclusionary rule is invoked.


11:02 Witness is cross-examined.
10:37 Eric Anderson is sworn and testifies (WVC Police
Department). States exhibit 1 is offered and received.
11:34 Rachel McCready is sworn and testifies.
11:46 Court is in recess.
11:56 Court is back in session. Witness resumes the stand.
Witness identifies the defendant. Court finds probable cause.
Court grants bail reduced to 10,000.00 each on both cases.
Defendant may be released to Pretrial Services under the condition
that defendant is to have no internet access. Surrender computer.
Defendant is to have no contact with females under the age
of 18. Defendant is not to be allowed out after dark, only to
return directly home after work. Court requests a ankle monitor.
CASE BOUNDOVER

Defendant waived preliminary hearing, State consenting thereto.


This case is bound over. An Arraignment hearing has been set on
12/15/03 at 9:00 AM in courtroom S41 before Judge SHEILA K.
MCCLEVE.
12-02-03 Note: Case Bound Over
12-02-03 ARRAIGNMENT scheduled on December 15, 2003 at 09:00 AM in
FOURTH FLOOR-S41 with Judge MCCLEVE.
12-02-03 Note: PRELIMINARY HEARING minutes modified.
12-02-03 Filed: Exhibit List
12-04-03 Filed order: Order Reducing Bail and Requiring Pretrial
Services Supervision
Judge L A DEVER
Signed December 04, 2003
12-15-03 SCHEDULING CONF scheduled on January 12, 2004 at 09:00 AM in
FOURTH FLOOR-S41 with Judge MCCLEVE.
12-15-03 Minute Entry - Minutes for Arraignment
Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
PRESENT
Clerk: lauraj
Prosecutor: AMANN, PAUL G
Defendant Present
Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:50 Page 6

Page 6 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________
Defendant's Attorney(s): REMAL, LISA J.

Video
Tape Number: 12/15/03 Tape Count: 9:11:19

ARRAIGNMENT

The Information is read.


Defendant is arraigned.
DEFT PLED NOT GUILTY. ATD WILL FILE MOTION BY THE FIRST WEEK OF
JANUARY. SET FOR SCHEDULING CONFERENCE 1/12/04 AT 9AM. THE COURT
WILL SET FOR MOTION HEARING AT THAT TIME.
SCHEDULING CONF is scheduled.
Date: 01/12/2004
Time: 09:00 a.m.
Location: Fourth Floor - S41
Third District Court
450 South State
SLC, UT 84114-1860
Before Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
12-15-03 Filed: Supervised Release Agreement
12-24-03 Note: BREAK-OUT BOND #4040 FOR $10,000.00 WAS POSTED 12/09/03.
12-24-03 Bond Account created Total Due: 10000.00
12-24-03 Bond Posted Non-Monetary Bond: 10,000.00
01-09-04 Filed: electronic monitoring contract
01-12-04 Minute Entry - Minutes for SCHEDULING CONFERENCE
Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
PRESENT
Clerk: lauraj
Prosecutor: AMANN, PAUL G
Defendant Present
Defendant's Attorney(s): REMAL, LISA J.

Video
Tape Number: 1/12/04 Tape Count: 9:24:59

HEARING

MOTION FILED ON CASE # 031906925. C/O SET FOR MOTION HEARING


Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:51 Page 7

Page 7 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________
2/13/04 AT 2PM WITH THAT CASE.
MOTION HEARING is scheduled.
Date: 02/13/2004
Time: 02:00 p.m.
Location: Fourth Floor - S41
Third District Court
450 South State
SLC, UT 84114-1860
Before Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
01-12-04 MOTION HEARING scheduled on February 13, 2004 at 02:00 PM in
FOURTH FLOOR-S41 with Judge MCCLEVE.
01-26-04 Filed: Motion in Limine to Suppress Evidence of Other Alleged
Criminal Conduct
01-26-04 Filed: Memorandum in Support of Defendant's Motion in Limine to
Suppress Evidence of Other Alleged Criminal Conduct
02-13-04 SCHEDULING CONF scheduled on March 01, 2004 at 09:00 AM in
FOURTH FLOOR-S41 with Judge MCCLEVE.
02-13-04 Minute Entry - Minutes for MOTION HEARING
Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
PRESENT
Clerk: lauraj
Reporter: YOUNG, BRAD
Prosecutor: AMANN, PAUL G
Defendant Present
Defendant's Attorney(s): REMAL, LISA J.

CAT/CIC
Tape Number: 2/13/04 Tape Count: 2:09:18

HEARING

THIS CASE IS TO TAG ALONG TO CASE #031906925 FOR THE MOTION


HEARING.
C/O ATD TO PREPARE AMENDED RELEASE ORDER THAT ON ELECTRONIC
MONITOR TO INCLUDE TO & FROM SCHOOL AND WORK. DEFT MUST HAVE ONE
SET DAY PER WEEK TO MEET WITH HIS SUPERVISOR
TO GO OVER HIS WORK SCHEDULE. ABSOLUTELY NO INTERNET ACCESS. C/O
SET FOR SCHEDULING CONFERENCE 3/1/04 AT 9AM.
SCHEDULING CONF is scheduled.
Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:51 Page 8

Page 8 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________
Date: 03/01/2004
Time: 09:00 a.m.
Location: Fourth Floor - S41
Third District Court
450 South State
SLC, UT 84114-1860
Before Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
02-13-04 Note: MOTION HEARING minutes modified.
03-01-04 SCHEDULING CONF scheduled on March 15, 2004 at 09:00 AM in
FOURTH FLOOR-S41 with Judge MCCLEVE.
03-01-04 Minute Entry - Minutes for SCHEDULING CONFERENCE
Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
PRESENT
Clerk: lauraj
Prosecutor: AMANN, PAUL G
Defendant Present
Defendant's Attorney(s): REMAL, LISA J.

Video
Tape Number: 3/1/04 Tape Count: 10:33:30

HEARING

THERE IS ONGOING NEGOTIATION, COURT GRANTS ATD'S MOTION TO


CONTINUE SCHEDULING CONFERENCE TO 3/15/04 AT 9AM.
SCHEDULING CONF is scheduled.
Date: 03/15/2004
Time: 09:00 a.m.
Location: Fourth Floor - S41
Third District Court
450 South State
SLC, UT 84114-1860
Before Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
03-05-04 Filed: AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT OF REQUEST FOR REVOCATION - DEFT
NEVER ATTENDED WEEKLY VENTNOR CLASS
03-05-04 Filed: REQUEST FOR REVOCATION OF SUPERVISED RELEASE AND ORDER
FOR REVOCATION
03-09-04 Filed order: Request for Revocation of Supervised Release and
Order for Revocation
Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:51 Page 9

Page 9 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________
Judge SHEILA K MCCLEVE
Signed March 09, 2004
03-09-04 Notice - WARRANT for Case 031906408 ID 5882315
03-09-04 Warrant ordered on: March 09, 2004 Warrant Num: 981122166 Bail
Allowed
Bail amount: 50000.00
03-09-04 Warrant issued on: March 09, 2004 Warrant Num: 981122166 Bail
Allowed
Bail amount: 50000.00
Judge: SHEILA K MCCLEVE
Issue reason: The defendant failed to comply with the
Court's order.
03-15-04 SENTENCING scheduled on May 03, 2004 at 09:00 AM in FOURTH
FLOOR-S41 with Judge MCCLEVE.
03-15-04 Minute Entry - Minutes for Change of Plea
Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
PRESENT
Clerk: lauraj
Prosecutor: AMANN, PAUL G
Defendant Present
Defendant's Attorney(s): ANDERSON, PATRICK L

Video
Tape Number: 3/15/04 Tape Count: 11:37:12

CHANGE OF PLEA

The Information is read.


Court advises defendant of rights and penalties.
A pre-sentence investigation was ordered.
The Judge orders Adult Probation & Parole to prepare a Pre-sentence
report.
Change of Plea Note
DEFT PLED TO COUNT 1 AS CHARGED. C/O SET FOR SENTENCING 5/3/04 AT
9AM.
C/O BW RECALLED AND DEFT MUST COMPLY WITH ALL CONDITIONS SET BY
PTS: NO CONTACT WITH ANYONE UNDER 18, NO TRAVELING EXCEPT TO WORK
& SCHOOL & TREATMENT, ATTEND VETNOR GROUP, NO INTERNET.
SENTENCING is scheduled.
Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:51 Page 10

Page 10 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________
Date: 05/03/2004
Time: 09:00 a.m.
Location: Fourth Floor - S41
Third District Court
450 South State
SLC, UT 84114-1860
Before Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
03-15-04 Warrant recalled on: March 15, 2004 Warrant num: 981122166
Recall reason: Court ordered recall
03-15-04 Note: CHANGE OF PLEA minutes modified.
03-15-04 Filed: STATEMENT OF DEFENDANT IN SUPPORT OF GUILTY PLEA AND
CERTIFICATE OF COUNSEL
04-16-04 Filed: MAXIMUM CORRECTIONAL SERVICES - AFFIDAVIT - DEFT HAS
VIOLATED THE ELECTRONIC MONITORING CONDITIONS. REFERED TO
JUDGE.
04-23-04 Filed: AFFIDAVIT
04-23-04 Filed: Certificate of Service
04-28-04 Filed: LETTER FROM RALPH BOHN
04-29-04 Filed: Maximus Special Report
05-03-04 SENTENCING scheduled on June 21, 2004 at 09:00 AM in FOURTH
FLOOR-S41 with Judge MCCLEVE.
05-03-04 Minute Entry - Minutes for SENTENCING
Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
PRESENT
Clerk: lauraj
Prosecutor: AMANN, PAUL G
Defendant Present
Defendant's Attorney(s): REMAL, LISA J

Video
Tape Number: 5/3/04 Tape Count: 12:01:58

HEARING

DEFT TO COMPLETE PSYCHO SEXUAL EVALUATION. THE COURT FINDS THE


DEFT IS IN VIOLATION OF THE PRE-TRIAL RELEASE/ELECTRONIC
MONITORING, REVOKED PTS RELEASE AND DEFT IS PLACED ON
CUSTODY. SENTENCING RESET TO 6/21/04 AT 9AM.
SENTENCING.
Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:51 Page 11

Page 11 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________
Date: 06/21/2004
Time: 09:00 a.m.
Location: Fourth Floor - S41
Third District Court
450 South State
SLC, UT 84114-1860
Before Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
06-21-04 Minute Entry - Minutes for SENTENCING
Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
PRESENT
Clerk: lauraj
Prosecutor: AMANN, PAUL G
Defendant Present
Defendant's Attorney(s): REMAL, LISA J

Video
Tape Number: 6/21/04 Tape Count: 9:18:34

HEARING

DUE TO THE PSYCHOSEXUAL EVALUTION IS NOT COMPLETE, C/O SENTENCING


RESET FOR 7/12/04 AT 9AM.
SENTENCING.
Date: 07/12/2004
Time: 09:00 a.m.
Location: Fourth Floor - S41
Third District Court
450 South State
SLC, UT 84114-1860
Before Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
06-21-04 SENTENCING scheduled on July 12, 2004 at 09:00 AM in FOURTH
FLOOR-S41 with Judge MCCLEVE.
07-12-04 Minute Entry - Minutes for SENTENCING
Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
PRESENT
Clerk: micheldb
Prosecutor: AMANN, PAUL G
Defendant Present
Defendant's Attorney(s): REMAL, LISA J
Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:52 Page 12

Page 12 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________

Video
Tape Number: 7/12/04 Tape Count: 10:46:33

HEARING

TAPE: 7/12/04 COUNT: 10:46:33

The court and counsels received the psychosexual evaluation this


morning. ATD requests a one week continuance of the sentencing so
that she may review the report.
SENTENCING.
Date: 07/19/2004
Time: 09:00 a.m.
Location: Fourth Floor - S41
Third District Court
450 South State
SLC, UT 84114-1860
Before Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
07-13-04 SENTENCING scheduled on July 19, 2004 at 09:00 AM in FOURTH
FLOOR-S41 with Judge MCCLEVE.
07-19-04 Bond Exonerated -10,000.00
07-19-04 Minute Entry - Minutes for SENTENCE, JUDGMENT, COMMITME
Judge: SHEILA K. MCCLEVE
PRESENT
Clerk: lauraj
Prosecutor: AMANN, PAUL G
Defendant Present
Defendant's Attorney(s): REMAL, LISA J

Video
Tape Number: 7/19/04 Tape Count: 10:34:38

SENTENCE PRISON
Based on the defendant's conviction of ENTICING A MINOR OVER THE
INTERNET a 2nd Degree Felony, the defendant is sentenced to an
indeterminate term of not less than one year nor more than fifteen
years in the Utah State Prison.

Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:53 Page 13

Page 13 of 14
CASE NUMBER 031906408 State Felony
________________________________________________________________________________
COMMITMENT is to begin immediately.

To the SALT LAKE County Sheriff: The defendant is remanded to your


custody for transportation to the Utah State Prison where the
defendant will be confined.

SENTENCE PRISON CONCURRENT/CONSECUTIVE NOTE


COURT IMPOSED 1-15 YEAR PRISON, CONCURRENT WITH CASE #031906925,
CREDIT FOR TIME SERVED.

Credit is granted for time served.


08-26-09 Notice - EVIDNOTC for Case 031906408 ID 12368314
I certify that on _______________ I destroyed the following
exhibits which had been received by the court in this matter:

1-LARGE ENVELOPE

_________________________
JAMES STOKER
EXHIBITS MANAGER

08-26-09 Note: EVIDENCE In accordance to Rule 4-206(4)(b) The retention


has been met. All remaining evidence has been destroyed.
Nothing remains.
01-03-10 Judge TIMOTHY R HANSON assigned.
01-05-10 Judge ROYAL I HANSEN assigned.
02-21-11 Judge RANDALL SKANCHY assigned.

Printed: 10/22/18 23:28:53 Page 14 (last)

Page 14 of 14

You might also like